Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Buffett Indicator 228%; Shiller PE: 40!
Transcript
- 0:00You know, it's, it's a bit like looking at that weather app on
- 0:03your phone, right? The one that never quite gets it
- 0:04right. Yeah, exactly.
- 0:05It confidently says it's sunny out, maybe 75°.
- 0:09But then you look out your living room window and there is
- 0:12a literal tornado tearing up your street.
- 0:14That is a very accurate description of the vibe right
- 0:16now. Because that massive disconnect,
- 0:18you know, between the comfortable data on your screen
- 0:21and the total chaos outside, that is exactly what it feels
- 0:25like to look at the stock market today.
- 0:27It really forces you to question your own sanity be a bit,
- 0:30doesn't it? Oh, 100% because here we are,
- 0:32right? It's May 2026.
- 0:34The S&P 500 is just casually hitting all time highs, yet the
- 0:38daily headlines you are reading are dominated by geopolitical
- 0:43wars, lingering recession fears, and just some frankly bizarre
- 0:48corporate behavior. You look at the broader
- 0:49landscape and the pieces just, they don't seem to fit together
- 0:52at all, right? But to understand the market
- 0:55today, you really have to look past those sensational headlines
- 0:58and just focus relentlessly on the underlying math.
- 1:00And to do exactly that, we have a fantastic stack of sources to
- 1:04unpack today. We really do.
- 1:05We're pulling comprehensive macro analysis and some very
- 1:08specific first quarter earnings breakdowns from Steve Eisman's
- 1:11The Weekly Wrap. Which is always a great read.
- 1:13Oh, always. And we are combining that with
- 1:15some raw real time Friday dashboard data that tracks
- 1:18investor sentiment and market volatility.
- 1:21So we're getting both the fundamentals and the feelings
- 1:23basically. Exactly.
- 1:24The mission here is to look under the hood of this May 2026
- 1:28market. And really figure out how it's
- 1:30shrugging off so much global friction.
- 1:33Like, is this rally built on a solid foundation or is it just
- 1:36pure speculation? OK.
- 1:38Well, it starts with looking at the actual corporate scorecards,
- 1:42right? We have the Q1 earnings data and
- 1:44it's it's almost fully printed. Right, most of the big players
- 1:47are out. Yeah, over 300 of the 500
- 1:49companies in the S&P have reported, and the numbers are
- 1:52just staggering. Wall Street analysts have
- 1:54actually had to steadily revise their revenue estimates upward
- 1:58as the year progressed. OK, let's unpack this, because
- 2:00that feels entirely backward to me.
- 2:02How so? Well, usually analysts start the
- 2:04year highly optimistic, you know, and then they slowly
- 2:07downgrade their expectations as reality sets in.
- 2:10Exactly. Yeah, but the exact opposite is
- 2:12happening here. Back on January 1st, the
- 2:14consensus estimate for S&P revenue growth was about 7.5%.
- 2:20By April first, they had to bump it to 9%, and by May 4th it hit
- 2:2610.5%. And perhaps the most surprising
- 2:29data point here is that all 11 sectors of the S&P actually beat
- 2:35their January 1st revenue estimate.
- 2:37All 11, even the laggards. All of them.
- 2:40And it isn't just a revenue story either.
- 2:42Operating margins, so the actual profitability of these
- 2:44businesses for the next 12 months are currently sitting at
- 2:46an all time high of 20% that's. Wild.
- 2:49Just for context, that number was 16% back in 2023.
- 2:52OK, so the math you are describing points to this
- 2:54booming, incredibly healthy economy.
- 2:57But that brings us to the core paradox.
- 2:59This K shaped economic reality. Everyone talks.
- 3:02About the divert. Yeah, because Zillow is
- 3:05explicitly stating that the housing market is effectively
- 3:07flat, and if you look at the lower end of the economy, the
- 3:10average consumer is heavily constrained.
- 3:13They are definitely struggling. So how on earth can the S&P post
- 3:16record revenues and 20% margins if everyday people are barely
- 3:20scraping by? Well, what's fascinating here is
- 3:22the structural dominance of the index.
- 3:25It's just heavily skewed now. Infotech alone now makes up 35%
- 3:29of the S&P 500. 35%. Yeah.
- 3:32And to put that in perspective, it was only 20% a decade ago,
- 3:35back in 2016 that. Is a massive jump.
- 3:37It is and if if you add in the tech adjacent giants, you know
- 3:41companies like Amazon, Google, Meditech is effectively 50% of
- 3:45the entire index, half the. Pie is just tech.
- 3:47Exactly, and the infotech sector alone just posted a 28.7%
- 3:51revenue growth. OK, so it's less like a group
- 3:54project where one person does the work and more like a massive
- 3:58cargo ship I. Like that analogy?
- 4:00Like the lower end of the economy is essentially a leak in
- 4:03the hull taking on water, but the tech sector is an engine so
- 4:07incredibly powerful that the ship is still setting speed
- 4:10records Despite that leak. That's a perfect way to
- 4:13visualize it, because it really is about the brutal mathematics
- 4:16of percentages. As the lower part of the K
- 4:19shaped economy shrinks in its overall spending, its percentage
- 4:22impact on the S&P 500 also shrinks.
- 4:26Tech has become so overwhelmingly massive that it
- 4:29acts like this mathematical shield.
- 4:31As long as that 50% of the pie continues to report stellar near
- 4:3530% growth numbers, the index as a whole becomes practically
- 4:38immune to the struggles at the lower end consumer.
- 4:41OK, that makes sense. That totally explains the
- 4:43mechanics of the high prices. But it makes me wonder about the
- 4:45psychological side of all this. The sentiment side.
- 4:47Yeah, because we have this real time market dashboard data and
- 4:52there is a massive disconnect between what investors are
- 4:54saying and what they're actually doing with their money.
- 4:57You are looking at the sentiment versus speculation gap.
- 5:00Yes, because if you ask people how they feel about the market,
- 5:03they seem totally level headed. Right, right.
- 5:05The survey date is pretty calm. Exactly.
- 5:07The AAII Investor Sentiment survey, which, you know, just
- 5:10asks individual investors if they're bullish or bearish,
- 5:13shows people are only modestly optimistic.
- 5:16Just kind of lukewarm. Yeah, you've got about 38%
- 5:19bullish, 33% bearish. That's a spread of just five
- 5:22points. Nobody is throwing a parade
- 5:25here. And the bond market agrees.
- 5:26Right. You look at the I see BofA move
- 5:29index, which basically measures how volatile the US Treasury
- 5:32market is. It's often viewed as the bond
- 5:35markets fear gauge. It's sitting at 75 to 85, right?
- 5:37Yep. Which is completely subdued.
- 5:39No panic there at all. So both of those metrics suggest
- 5:42a very rational, cautious market.
- 5:44But then you look at the options market, the daily CBOE equity
- 5:48put call ratio triggered a severe alert in the data.
- 5:51It dropped to roughly 0.46, which is well below its usual
- 5:55threshold. And that's a.
- 5:56Huge red flag. It really is.
- 5:58And just to clarify for you listening at home, a call is
- 6:02basically a bet that the market goes up and a put is insurance
- 6:06against it going down. So a ratio under 0.5 means there
- 6:10is this massive explosion of speculative call buying and a
- 6:14huge drop in people buying insurance.
- 6:16They're just rolling the dice. Exactly, If people are telling
- 6:20surveys they are just modestly optimistic, why are they
- 6:23throwing away their insurance policies to buy lottery tickets?
- 6:26It is a brilliant question question and it really
- 6:28highlights the power of FOMO, you know, the fear of missing
- 6:32out. FOMO is driving the bus.
- 6:33Completely Investors aren't necessarily euphoric about the
- 6:36state of the world. They see the geopolitical
- 6:39tensions. They know the housing market is
- 6:41flat. But the tech rally is so
- 6:43relentless and the math we just talked about is so undeniable,
- 6:46that FOMO is just forcing their hands.
- 6:48They can't just sit there and watch it happen.
- 6:49Exactly. They feel they cannot afford to
- 6:52sit on the sidelines while tech osts almost 29 growth, so they
- 6:56are piling into these seculative bets simply because the cost of
- 7:00missing the upside feels entirely too high.
- 7:04But you know, treating tech as this one big invincible monolith
- 7:07is actually a huge mistake right now, isn't it?
- 7:09Oh absolutely, because looking at Eisman's sector breakdown, AI
- 7:13is creating a brutal internal divide within the tech space
- 7:16itself. It really is.
- 7:18We are seeing a profound split between the companies building
- 7:21the physical infrastructure for AI and the companies writing
- 7:25software. Right, The hardware companies
- 7:27are clearly selling the shovels in this gold rush.
- 7:29And they are making a fortune doing it.
- 7:31The data shows AMD posting a 38% jump in sales.
- 7:34Arista Networks, which builds network switches for AI data
- 7:38centers, saw their earnings per share jump 34%.
- 7:41It's incredible growth. Even industrial companies, the
- 7:43folks physically constructing these data centers like
- 7:45Rockwell, posted a nine percent organic sales growth.
- 7:49They are undeniable winners. But then when you crossover to
- 7:52the software side of tech, the narrative just completely flips.
- 7:57Our sources actually describe it as an AI panic.
- 8:00And this is the part that genuinely broke my brain.
- 8:02Let's look at Palantir. Oh.
- 8:03Delantir is the perfect example. They report an incredible
- 8:06quarter. Earnings per share are up 154%.
- 8:10Commercial revenue is up 133%. Just Absolute Home runs
- 8:15incredible numbers, but their stock is down 22% this year and
- 8:19Shopify is down 30%. Wait.
- 8:22Palantir's revenue is up 133%, but the stock is down 22%.
- 8:27Are investors just assuming AI will make volunteer software
- 8:30obsolete before they can even cash in on these earnings?
- 8:33That perfectly captures the dynamic, Yeah.
- 8:35The prevailing narrative right now is that generative AI will
- 8:38fundamentally disrupt the traditional software as a
- 8:40service model. Because anyone can just code it
- 8:42themselves now. Exactly.
- 8:44Investors are terrified that clients will simply use AI to
- 8:48build their own internal tools rather than paying massive
- 8:52recurring subscription fees to external software vendors.
- 8:55Wow, so even when a company like Palantir proves that narrative
- 9:00wrong with actual phenomenal revenue, the market is so
- 9:03consumed by the fear of future AI disruption that they punish
- 9:07the stock anyway. It's all about the fear of
- 9:10what's next. Right.
- 9:11And frankly, it doesn't help that Palantir is trading at a
- 9:13multiple of 100 times its future earnings.
- 9:16When you are priced for perfection, any narrative fear
- 9:19causes a massive sell off. So public investors are
- 9:22terrified of software, but our sources point out that this
- 9:25software panic is actually creating a very quiet, very
- 9:28dangerous time bomb in the private equity space.
- 9:31Yes, this is a critical piece of the puzzle.
- 9:34Private equity firms like Apollo and KKR have massive exposure
- 9:37here right now. Apollo made a very smart move
- 9:40recently by shifting to daily pricing for its fixed income
- 9:43assets, trying to provide, you know, transparency to a
- 9:46traditionally opaque market. But that doesn't solve the
- 9:48underlying structural issue, does it?
- 9:50Not at all. Walk me through the mechanics of
- 9:51that issue. Like why is a public drop in
- 9:53Shopify or Palantir a threat to a private equity firm?
- 9:56Well, because private equity firms buy companies using
- 10:00massive amounts of debt. Let's say APE Firm bought a
- 10:03private software company two years ago.
- 10:06OK. They valued it based on what
- 10:09similar public companies like Shopify or Palantir were
- 10:11training for at the time. I see where this is.
- 10:14Going right. So if those public equivalents
- 10:16have now seen their valuations slashed by up to 50% due to this
- 10:20AI panic, it implies the private software companies are also
- 10:23worth half of what the PE firm paid for them.
- 10:26And because they use debt to buy them, the bank eventually comes
- 10:28knocking. Precisely when those loans come
- 10:31due, or if the debt needs to be refinanced, the math just no
- 10:34longer works. The collateral has basically
- 10:36evaporated. So what happens to the PE firms?
- 10:39These PE firms are going to face massive collateral calls.
- 10:42It's going to force them to either inject huge amounts of
- 10:45their own cash or simply walk away and default on those
- 10:47companies entirely. That is a wild dynamic.
- 10:50The exact same AI that is making chip makers rich could trigger a
- 10:54massive debt crisis in private equity.
- 10:57It's a double edged sword. But I want to step completely
- 11:00outside the tech bubble for a moment because the rest of the
- 11:02market is dealing with this barrage of chaotic wild card.
- 11:06Yeah. Real world problems.
- 11:07And what the sources show is that this high pressure
- 11:09environment is brutally exposing who the good corporate managers
- 11:13are and who is just making excuses it.
- 11:15Really is a Crucible right now. You cannot hide behind macro
- 11:18trends anymore. Let's look at the geopolitical
- 11:21wild card. We have severe tensions in Iran,
- 11:24with critical infrastructure being attacked in the Strait of
- 11:26Hormuz. Initially, oil prices surged.
- 11:30Which is the standard reaction. Yeah, right.
- 11:32And just as a purely factual market input here, former
- 11:36President Trump stepped into the narrative claiming the war is
- 11:38over while simultaneously threatening to resume bombing if
- 11:41peace deal isn't reached by Thursday.
- 11:43And strictly from a market perspective, commodity traders
- 11:46and algorithms process all of that simply as data points
- 11:50regarding supply risk. Just noise in the machine.
- 11:52Exactly The ultimate result of that diplomatic whiplash was oil
- 11:56prices actually settling back down, with Brent crude declining
- 12:00below $100 a barrel. But the mere existence of that
- 12:03volatility was enough for some companies to use it as a shield.
- 12:07Oh, absolutely. Take Whirlpool.
- 12:09They had an absolute disaster of 1/4.
- 12:12They posted a 56 cent loss. They slashed their forward
- 12:16guidance in half from $6 down to three, and they blamed the war.
- 12:19Right. But then you contrast that with
- 12:21McDonald's. McDonald's navigated the exact
- 12:24same tough global consumer environment, the exact same
- 12:28geopolitical fears, and still posted a 3.8% growth in same
- 12:33store sales. It's a stark contrast.
- 12:35I mean, I have to ask, is the geopolitical situation in the
- 12:38Strait of Hormuz really stopping someone in Ohio from buying a
- 12:41washing machine? Or is this just the corporate
- 12:43equivalent of the dog ate my homework?
- 12:45If we connect this to the bigger picture, it is absolutely the
- 12:48latter. Yeah, we are in a hyper
- 12:50efficient market dominated by those massive tech margins we
- 12:54talked about when you were a legacy company with poor
- 12:57management. Whether you are Whirlpool
- 13:00blaming geopolitics for bad appliance sales or you know a
- 13:03legacy payment company like Feeserv dropping 15% because
- 13:08newer financial tech is just eating your market share, you
- 13:11are being brutally exposed. There's nowhere to hide.
- 13:14The market simply has 0 patience for inefficiency right now.
- 13:17And that brutal punishment of inefficiency isn't just
- 13:19happening in retail or appliances.
- 13:21We're seeing it in the mergers and acquisitions space too.
- 13:23Oh, the GameStop situation, Yeah.
- 13:25GameStop, the original meme stock, made this bizarre bid to
- 13:29buy eBay for $60 billion, which is.
- 13:32Structurally absurd when you look at the mechanic.
- 13:34It makes no sense. EBay is 4 times the size of
- 13:37GameStop. Exactly.
- 13:38The amount of debt GameStop would have to take on to absorb
- 13:41a company 4 times its size is astronomical.
- 13:44It was so mathematically flawed that Michael Bury, the famous
- 13:48investor who had actually touting GameStop previously,
- 13:51liquidated his entire position and the moment he saw the debt
- 13:54levels they were planning to take on he.
- 13:56Just walked away. Yeah, when a company tries to
- 13:58force growth without the underlying math to support it,
- 14:01the market instantly rejects it. It really highlights the danger
- 14:05of mean stock valuations trying to operate in the real world M&A
- 14:10space. You can trade on Internet hype
- 14:12all day long, but you cannot buy a $60 billion company with it.
- 14:16No you cannot. The math just breaks down.
- 14:18But while GameStop is flailing, you have real ruthless corporate
- 14:23warfare happening in logistics. Amazon is aggressively entering
- 14:27FedEx and UPS territory. This.
- 14:29Is a huge shift. They aren't just shipping their
- 14:31own packages anymore, they are opening up their massive freight
- 14:34network to non Amazon sellers and the mechanism here is
- 14:37fascinating. They are basically commoditizing
- 14:39shipping. Which is terrifying for the
- 14:41legacy carriers. A market reaction was
- 14:43instantaneous. FedEx dropped 8%.
- 14:45UPS dropped 9%. Because Amazon is leveraging its
- 14:49insurmountable infrastructure. They have spent decades building
- 14:52a logistics network that no one can replicate, and now they are
- 14:56using it to just crush legacy competitors.
- 14:58It's ruthless. But if you want to talk about
- 15:01raw, unchecked power, the most glaring wild card in our sources
- 15:06is FICO. This one is staggering.
- 15:09FICO, the credit scoring company that basically dictates whether
- 15:12you get a mortgage or a car loan, has hiked its prices by an
- 15:15astonishing 1500% over the last five years.
- 15:19It's hard to even wrap your head around that number.
- 15:20It has sparked an all out war with the credit bureaus.
- 15:24How does a company raise prices by 1500% without losing all its
- 15:28customers? Because they have a monopoly on
- 15:30the standard. Every bank, every lender relies
- 15:33on the FICO score. It's just baked in.
- 15:35Exactly. It is baked into the foundation
- 15:37of the financial system. They can arbitrarily raise
- 15:40prices by 1500% simply because they know their clients have
- 15:44absolutely no alternative. And that ties everything
- 15:46together perfectly, really. Whether it is Amazon crushing
- 15:49Logistix competitors with sheer scale or FICO hiking prices just
- 15:53because they can, we are looking at a market where dominance is
- 15:57rewarded disproportionately. Is the defining theme right now.
- 16:01So let's synthesize all this data for you, the listener.
- 16:04If you are trying to make sense of your portfolio or the nightly
- 16:07news, what is the ultimate take away here?
- 16:09Well the first court take away is acknowledging the valuation
- 16:12reality. By any traditional metric the
- 16:14market is historically expensive right?
- 16:16If you look at the Schiller PE ratio, which essentially
- 16:19measures a stocks current price against 10 years of its earnings
- 16:23to sort of smooth out the noise, it is currently sitting over
- 16:2740.4. For context, the historical
- 16:30average is just 17.8. Furthermore, the market cap to
- 16:33GDP ratio is at 228%. So those numbers usually scream
- 16:38that we are in a massive bubble. I do, yeah, if you were looking
- 16:41at a traditional industrial area economy.
- 16:43But this expensiveness is a mathematical reality of a
- 16:46fundamentally altered market. Because of tech.
- 16:48Exactly one of those margins we talked about earlier, tech
- 16:50companies with their massive growth multiples and 20%
- 16:53operating margins now make up 50% of the pie.
- 16:56The market is expensive because the companies driving it are
- 16:59highly profitable tech monopolies.
- 17:01And that is the crucial value here for you.
- 17:03You have to mentally separate the broader physical economy
- 17:08from the S and T500. They are not the same thing
- 17:10anymore. Not at all.
- 17:11The broader economy is flat, people are struggling to buy
- 17:13houses and companies like Whirlpool are floundering.
- 17:17But the S&P 500 is not the broader economy anymore.
- 17:20It is an AI and tech driven beast.
- 17:23Making sense of this data is really about understanding those
- 17:25structural shifts beneath the daily noise.
- 17:28Which brings us back to that tornado outside your window.
- 17:31The disconnect between the data on your screen and the chaos in
- 17:34the world isn't a glitch, it is the new feature of the system.
- 17:37It's the new normal. It is, but it leaves us with one
- 17:40lingering, slightly terrifying thought for you to ponder.
- 17:44If half of the S&P 500 is entirely dependent on just a
- 17:47handful of tech giants, and companies like FICO can
- 17:49arbitrarily raise prices by 1500% without losing a single
- 17:53ounce of the market position, we have to ask ourselves, are we
- 17:56still investing in a dynamic, competitive free market, or have
- 18:00we simply transitioned into an era governed by untouchable
- 18:02corporate monopolies? IT.
- 18:03Really forces a total reevaluation of what free
- 18:07enterprise even means today. Something for you to chew on
- 18:10until next time. And hey, before we sign off, a
- 18:13quick note for you to access more advanced researches,
- 18:16applications and our latest published personal intelligent
- 18:19multi agent Deep Value Intelligence.
- 18:21Welcome to explore and join the Deep Values dot AI community.
- 18:25And if you want to track total market temperature yourself,
- 18:28welcome to search and download the iOS App Buffett Indicator
- 18:31from the Apple App Store. Absolutely.
- 18:33Finally, a quick disclaimer. All analysis today is based on
- 18:37publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions or
- 18:40differing interpretations. All all contents from this
- 18:42channel is for educational and research purposes only and does
- 18:45not constitute investment advice.
- 18:47Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 18:49decisions. Do your homework.
- 18:51And if you like to access wider topics, including life and
- 18:54investing philosophy, please subscribe to our sister channel,
- 18:56Deep Values. Don't forget to like this video.
- 18:58Much appreciated. Stay curious, keep looking past
- 19:01the headlines, and we will see you next time.