Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Steven Crowder Abuses Wife (Allegedly)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deservan listeners, A lot of you have been asking that a react
- 0:03to the video of Stephen Crowder verbally abusing his wife. So full disclosure,
- 0:09I had never heard of him until y'all started emailing me about this, and
- 0:13so I thought I would watch the Young Turks on YouTube provide at least an
- 0:17introduction for me and maybe for some of you. So let's watch their coverage.
- 0:22They're going to introduce this, I think right wing commentator Stephen Crowder,
- 0:25who seems to be as toxic as he is publicly in private. Okay,
- 0:32So I'm learning that he is a right wing commentator in private with people like
- 0:38his wife, with people like his pregnant wife. Disturbing video was a tame
- 0:43obtained by journalist Yasha Ali, and it reveals that the commentator Stephen Crowder is
- 0:50berating his wife. And this apparently is one instance up. Okay, so
- 0:54we're learning that someone sent a journalist a video of the two of them.
- 0:58I believe of what we found out was many and this one clip. It's
- 1:02from June of twenty twenty one, and his wife Hillary is eight months pregnant.
- 1:06This is um after a week where Stephen Crowder announced that he and his
- 1:10wife were getting a divorce. Okay, So I'm trying to catalog all the
- 1:14details that this is in twenty twenty one, June of twenty twenty one,
- 1:18and the video was taken then, and this was around the time that they
- 1:22were getting a divorce. Okay. I found the video on Yasher Ali's sub
- 1:27stack. Let's watch that. Obviously this carries with it trigger warning. Seriously,
- 1:33I don't know what we're going to see, but I'm going to guess
- 1:36that it could trigger some of you and your PTSD. So don't watch this
- 1:38if you think you're going to be triggered by it and harmed. Are you
- 1:42a boundary? Are you a boundary? Nod aoundary? You're not taking a
- 1:49car. So this is in the middle of the conversation, so I'm having
- 1:53a hard time understanding. Maybe we'll get some context, but he's saying he's
- 1:57drawing a boundary. I'm also guessing that the video was leaked by her because
- 2:02this is thus a security camera that they have it at their home, looks
- 2:07like two years ago, in twenty twenty one, and maybe she leaked it
- 2:10as a way to try to out him or something. I don't know I
- 2:14drew a boundary. I drew a boundary. No, No, you just
- 2:17did. You just did a boundary. You were not taking a car.
- 2:23That's because if you refused to do wife with things, then I will vote
- 2:28the grocery at stakes one Pellis Mikeril, I know it's I've been a couple
- 2:36therapists for twenty five years, so I am very familiar with couples who are
- 2:42fighting verbally with each other. And this has the tone and the look of
- 2:46that. I'm guessing there was a ramp up to this. Each person,
- 2:50or at least one person, was being hurt or something. I don't know,
- 2:53but it sounds like he's saying, you can't take the car because you're
- 3:00not doing your wifely things. I don't know what that means. It certainly
- 3:04doesn't sound like a good indication. I don't know. I'm going to take
- 3:07a guess and say that a lot of people don't like this Stephen Crowder individual.
- 3:12But I'm trying to reserve judgment until I see something that indicates that I
- 3:15should be judging something. I'm about. First, how are you respecting?
- 3:25Okay, how do you respect men? All? Right? Now? If
- 3:30this was a couple that I was working with, and I've heard statements like
- 3:35this in session before. Usually I would stop where the conversation is going and
- 3:38I would focus on him, and I would say, when you say respect
- 3:42men, what exactly are you trying to get at? And we might explore
- 3:46sexism and misogyny, we might explore what he is trying to get at.
- 3:51Usually, when men are doing this, it's because they're hurt deep down.
- 3:54It doesn't mean you have to have sympathy for them. It's a triangulation.
- 3:58You've heard me talk about triangulation. When there is conflict between two people,
- 4:01the lower the differentiation level, meaning the lower the maturity, the lower the
- 4:06emotional intelligence, that kind of thing, lower the coping skills, the couple
- 4:11or one person will triangulate a third element. So you might triangulate a friend
- 4:16by saying, hey, you can't believe what my husband did, or you
- 4:19might triangulate society. That's what he's doing. He is saying there is this
- 4:24rule in society. I think this is what he's getting at that says you
- 4:29must respect men because you're a woman, you're lesser. And so I don't
- 4:33know how to deal with this conflict. I've tried to deal with it.
- 4:38I don't know how to deal with it, or I'm guessing because you usually
- 4:42you don't triangulate third elements, especially in this way, unless you feel like
- 4:46you have no idea what you're doing and you're at your wits end, so
- 4:49to speak. And so he is pulling in society and saying I have society
- 4:55on my side. Everyone agrees, and maybe even she has agreed in the
- 4:59past. I don't. I don't know her politics. He is trying to
- 5:01pull that in as a try, as an attempt to win the argument to
- 5:05get her. I'm guessing to say something like, well, yeah, I
- 5:10guess you're right that women are lesser and men are superior, and I need
- 5:14to respect men. So okay, you win, which, of course I
- 5:18don't think is going to work. And more generally speaking, in a couple
- 5:23of conflicts, we will do this. You've done this, I've done this,
- 5:26We've all done this. When we get into these kinds of conversations,
- 5:30everyone's trying to win, and when everyone's trying to win, everyone loses about
- 5:36how do you respecting you? I don't, So you're not thinking up you
- 5:51are not I will ask them. He's saying you are not taking the car.
- 5:57It's just hard to know what the context he is but the way it
- 6:00looks is that he is controlling her. He's saying that she wants to go
- 6:04somewhere, it looks like, and he's saying you can't take the car.
- 6:09I don't know. There's so many question marks. Certainly his tone is in
- 6:14the direction of verbal abuse. There's indications of abuse. It could be much
- 6:17worse than it looks, honestly, But if I were to take a guess,
- 6:21I would say that there was an escalation in the fight, and he
- 6:25could be all to blame for that. I don't know. But there's a
- 6:29ramp up to this and he is in his way, and I again,
- 6:33I've treated lots of couples with this kind of toxicity. In his very twisted
- 6:38way, I'm guessing he's trying to make up with her, meaning that he's
- 6:44trying to establish some kind of closeness, some kind of indication that she won't
- 6:47leave him. And the fact that she wants to leave the house, maybe
- 6:50because she has to run an errand, or maybe because she wants to get
- 6:54away from him. I don't know. He perceives this as a rejection or
- 7:00potential loss of some kind, and he's getting desperate abusive people. In my
- 7:03experience, and I've treated many perpetrators who were court mandated because they broke a
- 7:09law. They were sentenced in a court of law that they had committed a
- 7:12crime, and they were mandated to come to my group, a group that
- 7:15I was running with other colleagues, and I learned firsthand the mindset of abuse
- 7:23of people, particularly abuse of men, and I learned over time that although
- 7:28it was a very twisted set of behaviors, very abusive, criminal, upsetting,
- 7:32destructive group of behaviors, at the foundation of it all, they were
- 7:36actually trying to retain closeness, which is bizarre when you think about the behavior,
- 7:42but that's usually the case. So I don't know, but that's just
- 7:45my guess is that he, in a very twisted way, doesn't want her
- 7:48to leave because, you know, if his inner child, so to speak,
- 7:51could talk, I'm guessing that child would say something like, I'm really
- 7:57hurt by everything that's been happening lately, and I'm worried about our relationship and
- 8:01it's been rough lately, and if you leave, I'm going to be very
- 8:05sad and worried. So, can you please not leave? You are nine?
- 8:13I will ask would so? Then she's like, well, then I'll
- 8:20ask him to pick me up. So it sounds like she's meeting up with
- 8:24someone. And then he says, is that a threat? It looks like
- 8:28he doesn't want her to leave and prisoning her in his house. That's what
- 8:33it looks like. I don't mean, man, no, you're not thing.
- 8:39You are nine. I will ask would you? Okay, Stephen,
- 8:48I can't feeling some constraints, see like I can't see it. Listen to
- 8:54listen, do you want to walk out right now? Listen to me.
- 8:56I can't go to Jim, I can't go to my parents. I can't
- 9:00call my friends. I can't. I can't be home. You're gonna take
- 9:03the car and leave me here? Just thinking he's made me. Oh,
- 9:07he's saying, taken uber because I don't want you to take our one car,
- 9:13because I don't want to be boxed in. Because I don't understand what
- 9:16they're talking about. It is maybe y'all know. I don't know. There's
- 9:22just a certain Okay, I'll just keep watching. What do you need me
- 9:26to pick up? I'll get it. I'll be back from the back.
- 9:28Nope, that doesn't work either, or you'll be back from your back.
- 9:33I understand the diffence between one might be set to the setting and you back
- 9:43the only way out of it. Yeah, there's so many questions, but
- 9:48there's words in here like respecting men, and the only way out of this
- 9:54is discipline and respect. She is trying. The tone of her voice,
- 10:01the way she's talking. I'm going to take a guess and say that she's
- 10:05being nice and accommodating and he is not. There's so many questions. I
- 10:09take it from me as someone who has had couples come into my office in
- 10:13the middle of a conversation like this, and I have the opportunity to drill
- 10:18down on these issues, at least for that session, maybe even for months
- 10:22in the future. We can really drill down on the details, and I
- 10:26can understand where people are coming from. So take it from me that just
- 10:31seeing this clip, I don't know if we know anything. Maybe it'll escalate
- 10:35here. Certainly the things that he said thus far raise some major red flags
- 10:41the tone here, but I don't know that. When we saw the Amaranth
- 10:46video that was so much more apparent. Plus the audio quality was better,
- 10:50So there's that. But the Amaranth videos longer, there was much more detail
- 10:56that one. You could absolutely say some things, but I don't know.
- 11:00This one's harder to decipher. You only at annas because you can't have any
- 11:07Yes. There you go, you throw your hand, you give us,
- 11:13you give up so easily. I just said, the only we have this
- 11:15is discipline, respect you We are okay. So she's saying we're at an
- 11:18impasse, and I again, I see this through my lens, which is
- 11:24typically couples coming to me asking for help. Couples don't come to me asking
- 11:28me. Well, sometimes they do ask asking me to determine who's right and
- 11:33who's wrong, but that's not often very helpful. I mean, sometimes we
- 11:37can talk about, well, you know, in this instance, I think
- 11:39you're the one that's a little more in the wrong. But we can't start
- 11:43off like that because I'll alienate that individual and they won't ever come back.
- 11:48So I have to start more general and we have to talk about what's going
- 11:52to help. And so that's my job. That's what I'm trained to do,
- 11:56that's what my clinical skills are in. I'm not tryin to watch a
- 12:01security camera in the middle of a fight and understand what's happening. But again,
- 12:09it doesn't look good for him. And I wonder if, because he's
- 12:11a right wing pundit, if this has become a bigger story. I've received
- 12:18so many requests to watch this, and yeah, maybe it'll escalate, so
- 12:22maybe I need to know. But anyway, my point is is that she
- 12:26is starting to say it, we're at an impasse, and I think the
- 12:31message, either intended or unintended to him, is I'm done, meaning that
- 12:37there's no use in continuing to have this conversation. And I'm guessing, given
- 12:45the tone of this, that she has run into this many many times.
- 12:48She's had many conversations with him along these lines and has learned that it's just
- 12:54best to cut your losses and get out of the conversation. She says,
- 12:58we're at an impact. I'll rewind it because he says some very quintessential things
- 13:03that I've seen in my office before, or her described in my office.
- 13:05You know, they'll talk about a fight they had the night before, and
- 13:09the things he's saying is, oh, so you're just going to give up.
- 13:11That is a signal that he doesn't want her to leave, and he
- 13:16doesn't want her to give up. He wants to stay in this relationship.
- 13:18He's trying, it's not working, and he's not listening. And his message
- 13:24is respect and discipline, and you need to understand that you're subservient to me.
- 13:31You can't do what you want. I mean, that seems to be
- 13:33the messaging from him, which shouldn't surprise us given his politics. Right,
- 13:37So I want to be clear, I'm not justifying it. I'm not even
- 13:41coming close to justifying it. I am condemning it one hundred percent. And
- 13:46if we're going to understand, as I need to understand in order to treat
- 13:48people, I need to understand where it generates from. Sometimes it generates from
- 13:52psychopathy or what the Internet will call sociopath but psychopathy, sociopathy, antisocial lack
- 14:01of empathy does exist in the world, and there's a small percentage of individuals
- 14:05that have that problem, but usually that's not the case. Usually where this
- 14:11abusive behavior comes from is because it was learned, it was taught to them,
- 14:15and the individual is having a really hard time establishing attachment security, and
- 14:20so they resort to abusive tactics to retain or to obtain attachment security, but
- 14:28it's fake, right, because when someone is dominated and coerced into being close
- 14:33to you, it's not actual closeness. They're just terrified of leaving you.
- 14:37And then the individual who's abusive continues to feel aggravated because they're not getting the
- 14:43closeness they're seeking, but they're just shooting themselves in the foot. Meanwhile,
- 14:46they're abusing everyone around them. And so what I do with these individuals as
- 14:50I try to teach them all this and help them, and it's not easy,
- 14:54but I try to point them in a direction where they can actually get
- 14:58their needs met. And then when they actually do that, I don't need
- 15:00to resort to what they were taught when they were young to engage in abusive
- 15:05misogynistic behavior. And it takes time, but I've done it many many times
- 15:09and it works. So that's what I see. I don't know if that's
- 15:15what is happening, but anyway, so I think she has run into this
- 15:18a lot, and she's trying to get away, but she's staying around.
- 15:24So I'm guessing that she's worried that if she just walks off, because I
- 15:28think that's what she wants to do, because I think she literally has somewhere
- 15:31to go that it will escalate for him and he will become worse. And
- 15:37so that's what it looks like. It looks like she is thinking in her
- 15:39mind, Okay, there's no sense in continuing this because he's dug in and
- 15:45he's putting me down. I want to get away, but if I just
- 15:48bolt when he's like this, when I get back, it could be a
- 15:52hundred times worse. The only automa because you can't have any Yeah, there
- 16:03you go, you throw your hand, you give us, so give up
- 16:07so easily. So what we saw this with Amareth in that video, and
- 16:12I've seen it many times clinically and personally, but there's this weird flip flopping
- 16:18that abusive people will exhibit. And with the Amareth video is it was much
- 16:23more apparent because we had much more data. But I think we just saw
- 16:26it a little bit here where he's like, well, fine, if you
- 16:29can't have any discipline a respect, then we're at an impass. And then
- 16:32she agrees. She says, well, then I guess we're at an impasse
- 16:36because what I'm not gonna be it I'm not going to be submissive to you
- 16:40I'm not gonna give in to you all the time. And then she's like,
- 16:42well, I guess I'm at it him impass and then he flip flops
- 16:47to you give up so easily. It's weird. Now. It can have
- 16:49a gaslighting effect, it can have a crazy making effect. But where the
- 16:53individuals coming from is they're they're doing whatever they can in their way to a
- 16:59stash control because they equate control and power and getting someone to be submissive with
- 17:06attachment security. They are desperate to get to that place. You might even,
- 17:11and I've done this before with abusive people, I will actually in the
- 17:15office establish actual closeness where they're not in power and control, and because of
- 17:21their upbringing and their life, they actually don't perceive it as closeness at first
- 17:26because it looks so foreign to them throughout their life, perhaps modeled in their
- 17:30own parents' behavior. The only time there was ever any aunt emotional closeness or
- 17:34security, even though there's it's just a shred of it and it's fake anyway,
- 17:38was when someone was dominating another person and the other person was being submissive.
- 17:42So the goal of the conversation is that it doesn't matter how you get
- 17:47there, you're just trying to oppose. You're trying to break the other person
- 17:51down. You don't even need to have a coherent argument. That's why this
- 17:55from the outside and maybe from the inside if you're her I think your name
- 17:57is Hilary, that will perceive this flip flopping and you will even maybe bring
- 18:03it up to the abusive person. You're like, wait, didn't you just
- 18:06say? But the abusive person is not interested in having a rational conversation.
- 18:10They're only interested in power and control. That's all they're looking for. And
- 18:15when you finally give up the power to the other person and you submit,
- 18:18then they can relax and then they will maybe even warm up to you.
- 18:22So it has this training effect on the abused individual that you know, just
- 18:27submit because if the sooner you get it over with the better, The sooner
- 18:32you can get rid of the abuse, the better. So just do whatever
- 18:34you need to do to get rid of the abuse. And that just means
- 18:37you just submit, even though in your mind you might not be really submitting.
- 18:41You rinse and repeat that over time. Eventually you start to convince yourself
- 18:44you are submissive, You are stupid, You don't have a good way of
- 18:48judging reality because the abusive person has beaten that into your skull. So I
- 18:53think we're seeing some of that dynamic here. We're at an inte. So
- 19:00he says, the only way out of this is discipline and respect. I
- 19:04don't know what he means by that. I'm guessing it means you will do
- 19:07what I say, and just the body language too. He's just like sitting
- 19:11down and she's trying to get away, but she keeps coming back, and
- 19:15so he's saying, the only way out of it is discipline and respect,
- 19:18and if you can't do it, then we're at an impass. He says
- 19:22he might even be using her word that she has used against him in the
- 19:26in previous conversations. I don't know what just has that look to it.
- 19:30And then watch what she says, Well, then I guess we're at an
- 19:32impass. And then he flip flops and says, but hey, you know,
- 19:36you're giving up so easily. The only way out of the only out
- 19:47we're at ante because you can't have any discipline. Yeah, there you go,
- 19:52You throw your head, You give up so native, you give up
- 19:56so easily, And the nefarious nature of being victimized by someone like This is
- 20:03that you believe that you're dealing with someone that's rational, that if you just
- 20:08convince them of your point of view or your feelings, then the abusive person
- 20:15will say, oh, you know what, maybe, or they'll be influenced,
- 20:18you know, with other people, non abusive people. That's often how
- 20:21it works. Not always, but that often is at least possible. To
- 20:25the abusive person, nothing is possible. You cannot convince them. The only
- 20:30thing, like I said, that will get them to shut up is if
- 20:33you submit, and you have to do it very noticeably, and you have
- 20:37to do it very convincingly. That will that's the only thing that will get
- 20:41them to stop arguing with you. Typically, so we saw that in the
- 20:44Amaranth video very much. So I think that's what we're seeing. You know,
- 20:47she's stopping and said, no, no, no, I don't give
- 20:48up that that's not me. And if I were a little birdie on her
- 20:52shoulder, if I understand the situation correctly, which God knows, I would
- 20:56say, you're wasting your breath. You're trying to argue with them, You're
- 21:00trying to make your point, but he's just using words. And that's important.
- 21:03If you're ever being victimized by someone like this currently or past or future.
- 21:08You have to really drill into your head that there's no convincing them until
- 21:14the perpetrator gets treatment and really starts to work on their issues, and that
- 21:18can take years, by the way. Until that happens, there's no convincing
- 21:22them. There's no point in trying to convince them. In fact, often
- 21:25to the abusive person, they'll take you arguing with them as opposed to you
- 21:30having an impass and getting in your car and driving away. They would rather
- 21:33have you there and have a conversation with you, even though it's very contentious,
- 21:38than to lose you, because their attachment and security is so great that
- 21:41they would rather have some of you, even though you're fighting, than to
- 21:45have not none of you, meaning that you are driving away and potentially leaving
- 21:51them in your mind and in your body. Oh yeah, this is a
- 21:53discipline respect, you know. We are added right, I love you?
- 22:03Okay. So we're seeing more here that she's saying your abuse is sick,
- 22:10all right. That gives me some indication that this has been going on for
- 22:14a while, that she either knows from her own experience and education and awareness,
- 22:19or she's talked with other people who have said that's abusive. What you're
- 22:23telling me, what your husband is doing, that's abusive. I don't know,
- 22:26but she has the resolve to say this in order to say this.
- 22:30I'm guessing this has been going on for years, maybe even since the beginning
- 22:33of their relationship, and so that's what it tells me. And then he's
- 22:38saying, watch it, that's a threat. Right, discipline. He's talked
- 22:42about respect, Tell me about your disrespect of men? His body language,
- 22:48the flip flopping him saying watch it, Watch what, buddy? What is
- 22:53it? Now? Is he physically abusive? I wouldn't be surprised. I
- 22:56don't know what the allegations are, but and I'm pretty sure that doesn't happen
- 23:00in a video like this, because I've just heard that it was a verbal
- 23:03abuse example. But let's rewind this and really break it down. I just
- 23:07the only we had this discipline, respect, an investment. No, we
- 23:10are at a right. I love you? Right? She says, Okay,
- 23:15I love you, And that's another sign that she's a victim because she's
- 23:19trying to get away. I'm thinking, so I wouldn't be surprised if in
- 23:25the beginning of their relationship, when he would do this sort of thing,
- 23:27she would give in and submit. And this is a very common story that
- 23:33at first she was confused. She thought, well, maybe it was my
- 23:37fault, maybe he's just in a bad mood. Then over time it might
- 23:40have become worse, and then she became more confused, like is there something
- 23:45wrong with him, there's something wrong with me? I don't know, And
- 23:48then ways of trying to deal with it, ways of trying to manage it.
- 23:51Maybe if I did this, Maybe if we had a kid it would
- 23:55help, Maybe if we took a vacation, a lot of accommodation, a
- 23:59lot of problem solving, a lot of searching for an answer. And then
- 24:03eventually she gets support. She is starting to hear from other people. Might
- 24:08have even had other recordings that she reviewed, maybe showed other people I don't
- 24:12know, and said like what do you think about this? And they're like,
- 24:15that's abusive, and then she's like, really is that? Well?
- 24:18What is that? But no, maybe maybe because she's she married him for
- 24:22a reason, right, because she loved him and she wanted to be in
- 24:25a relationship with him. So that's a hard pill to swallow, right,
- 24:26to realize that you're married to an abusive person. The father of your child
- 24:32or children is an abusive person, and what do you do about that?
- 24:34It's hard to cope with, right, So maybe some negotiation on her mind.
- 24:40Eventually, though, she lands on he's abusive, Okay, I need
- 24:44to talk with him about it. And I'm guessing that this is not the
- 24:47first time that she has brought it up with him, maybe even when he's
- 24:51in a good mood. She's like, Hey, we need to talk about
- 24:52we need to go to a couple of therapy or I don't know, And
- 24:55I'm just gonna say a guess and say they didn't go over with him.
- 24:57And so then we get to this point I think they divorce. Around this
- 25:03time, she's starting to want to leave him, and she is wanting to
- 25:07take the car out. I can't. I don't know the context. And
- 25:10then the conversation is escalating and she knows all the signs. She's been over
- 25:14it in her mind many times of Yeah, this is how it starts.
- 25:18These are the things that he says, This is the typical way in which
- 25:22he tries to gain control. This is the only way out of the conversation.
- 25:26So what's my next step. Well, I'm not going to take it
- 25:29anymore, because because I've tried so many other things in the past to try
- 25:33to stop it, to try to convince him, or to try to manage
- 25:37it, it just gets worse over time. I'm completely powerless over the situation,
- 25:41so i can protect myself, and I've maybe talked with other people and
- 25:44they've said, you know, you just leave, just get out or whatever.
- 25:47And so she is having this conversation with him. She's about to leave,
- 25:52but she knows that it's going to hurt him and it's going to make
- 25:56him angry, and she's worried about what he will do in that situation,
- 26:00which is normal to be worried because even without the threat, even if he's
- 26:04never said I'm going to kill you or I'm going to do this or that,
- 26:07when you see someone that adamant and that locked in on needing power and
- 26:11control and that volatile, it's natural for victims to have some ideas about what
- 26:18they might be capable of. Right it doesn't take much of an imagination to
- 26:23start to think about murder. Or he's a public figure, he could speak
- 26:27out against her and ruin her or some or sue her who knows, So
- 26:32you start to worry about that. Maybe he's even done things like that.
- 26:36I don't know. So then you're thinking, well, I need to draw
- 26:37a boundary. But I need him to at least not be too angry.
- 26:41How can I manage that? So in the midst of this very difficult conversation,
- 26:45she starts to say, I love you, Okay, I love you,
- 26:48you know I do, I think, as a way to try to
- 26:52soften it because she wants to leave maybe the relationship also, but she also
- 26:57doesn't want him to seek retribution against her. That's often the case. Now
- 27:03I don't know, I'm speculating. I'm inserting a lot of thoughts into her
- 27:06head. It's possible that she just had an upwelling of love for him in
- 27:08that moment, which I'm guessing is not true. I'm guessing this is a
- 27:11strategy that she has discipline, respectation. No, we are out of right.
- 27:18I love you, right, and it precedes this next thing. Your
- 27:26abuse is sick. I love you, but your abuse is sick. I
- 27:30think because she was planning on saying your abuse is sick, but then she
- 27:33thought, well, I need to soft the blow with this, right,
- 27:37up front, because I know from previous experience that if I just tell him
- 27:41this, he's really going to lose it, And so he likes it when
- 27:45I am because it is a bit of a submissive love in the midst of
- 27:48all this, because he's certainly not being very affectionate. I love you,
- 27:52I love you, I love you, I love you. It's a little
- 27:53bit of a submissive statement, maybe because she knows that's what he's looking for.
- 27:57But she also follows it with your abusive. Watch it sick, watch
- 28:03it, fucking watch it, more threats, watch it just a I'm laughing
- 28:15because I don't know what else to do. It's awful. Watch what,
- 28:18Watch what I'm gonna I'm gonna take a guess and say that she knows what
- 28:21he's threatening. The dog seems to be alerted this. But anyway, so
- 28:26she's now saying, I'm gonna let that go, I think, because she's
- 28:30like I could say something to that. I could say, like that's some
- 28:33serious, bs, but I'm gonna let that go because I need to go
- 28:37somewhere, I think. And she says, I need some space. Fucking
- 28:41watch it, and I need some space. You need to just suck at
- 28:48Okay, I love you so again. She I think knows that if she
- 28:53says those kinds of things, it'll calm him down because it has the feeling
- 28:59of submissive, right. I mean, it also could just could be that
- 29:02she does love him and is trying to soothe him a little bit. It's
- 29:04not a bad thing in the midst of an argument to say, hey,
- 29:07you know, I love you. But even if there's no abuse happening,
- 29:11So it could be something. I don't know. I don't want to see
- 29:15things through a particular lens. But so she's trying to get away right now,
- 29:18and I think she's worried that if she just bolts that he'll escalate and
- 29:22when she gets back it'll be really terrible. She's like, don't do anything
- 29:26while I'm gone, and I need some space. We need to just stuck
- 29:30a MAKA. I love you, I love you getty much. I don't
- 29:37love that's the big book. I've never received you love from you. There's
- 29:40no rationalizing with someone like this. She's saying some pretty important things that she
- 29:45wants space, that she loves him, but she wants some space, and
- 29:48they're at an impasse, and he just ignores it because he's not in power
- 29:53yet, he's not in control. We saw this with Amaranth in that video
- 29:57as well. Amaranth, if you don't remember, was a woman that creates
- 30:03content on the Internet, and she recorded a conversation on the phone with her
- 30:07husband, I believe, who was extensively being verribly abusive allegedly, and this
- 30:12video we're seeing a similar tactic. If you remember from the Amaranth video.
- 30:15Once the abusive husband started to realize that he was really starting to lose control
- 30:22of his wife, then he started to resort to a softer tactic. And
- 30:27I think that's what we're seeing now because she's saying some pretty definitive things I
- 30:32love you, but I need some space and I'm leaving. And then he
- 30:36says, well, I don't love you because you've never shown me any kind
- 30:40of love. So I interpret that as a softer version of his power and
- 30:45control tactic because it's trying to pull on her heartstrings. It probably has worked
- 30:49in the past where she would be like, oh, what are you talking
- 30:52about? No? I love you and what no? No, and he's
- 30:56trying to Now that also could be a more vulnerable statement, can actually be
- 31:00I wouldn't be surprised if he actually feels that way right now, he thinks
- 31:04he's opening up at this point. Instead of talking about respect and men are
- 31:08being superior, he's like, you've never loved me. By implication, he
- 31:12is hurt that she's never loved him. Now. I doubt that that's true,
- 31:17but he, given his attachment and security, given his upbringing, he
- 31:22might actually feel that way. And that's where a lot of his vindictiveness might
- 31:26actually generate from. Is this very sure feeling that she has never loved him
- 31:32in But it's often a transference or a displacement from his childhood where someone didn't
- 31:37give him enough love, one of his parents or something like that. But
- 31:41it is interesting, Yes, So I think he's changing his tactic to try
- 31:45to get hurt. He he can't control her if she disengages, he can't
- 31:51control her if she leaves. He has to try anything possible to at least
- 31:56keep the connection going, keep the conversation going, and then if she gives
- 32:00in here, which I wouldn't recommend, then eventually he'll start to engage in
- 32:05the more aggressive power and control conversation. But there's this dip right now because
- 32:09he's like, oh, actually she's going to leave a better try, different,
- 32:14more softer tactic. We need to Okay, I love you, I
- 32:20love you getty much. I don't love. That's the big book I've never
- 32:24received you love. And the fact is when I don't look, I need
- 32:27an ABCD no. But I love you one okay, Okay, put on
- 32:35some gloves. I'm not sure what that means, but yeah, it's interesting
- 32:38because it happened pretty quickly. I don't I'm always interpreting things, so I
- 32:43don't know if I'm right. But I think even in that little series of
- 32:46sentences, he starts off more vulnerable in it, with a different tact,
- 32:51but then transitions very quickly back into the discipline talk and the respect talk.
- 32:57That's not fair. It's not fair, and it's distintend pelory. You're right
- 33:00written become someone dan a life. Yeah, it's more rhetoric regarding superiority of
- 33:14men and that women have a duty to be submissive or to do with their
- 33:21husband. Says I can't know that for sure, it certainly sounds that way.
- 33:23I mean, we're not hearing him lay out his bullet points regarding what
- 33:27he means by this. I believe in his right wing commentary, he does
- 33:30go into those sorts of things. Whenever I talk with men like this,
- 33:34I will ask them to give me the bullet points because with sexism, often
- 33:39it's just the surface statements. There's a lot of you know, you'll hear
- 33:44politicians will use these kinds of phrases, right, like traditional family values.
- 33:49And then when you actually ask the politician, what do you mean by that?
- 33:52What are you actually saying? What are you trying to communicate? Because
- 33:57if you hear enough right wingers act invoke that phrase, you suspect and maybe
- 34:02know that what they really mean is make America great again, or we need
- 34:07to have where women are submissive, where everyone has their role, where men
- 34:13are in control, and men appeared to have self esteem because they were in
- 34:19control of everything and everyone respected them. That's what they are actually saying,
- 34:24and they're communicating through because traditional family values, that could be a lot of
- 34:29things. That could be a lot of really wonderful things. It could actually
- 34:31be a lot of horrible things. Right. So you'll hear these phrases and
- 34:36I'll drill down with these individuals, be like, Okay, tell me what
- 34:37you mean, and you'll see them squirm because they know they're not supposed to
- 34:43believe or say what they want to say in support of that topic sentence,
- 34:47so they will squirm around it and say other kinds of things. And I'll
- 34:52say, like, well, then, why don't you just say that?
- 34:54Why are you using this vague phrase that could be interpreted a lot of so
- 35:00he's using that phraseology. What he, I think really wants to say is
- 35:04you are a woman and I'm a man, and you need to be submissive
- 35:07to me because that is the natural order of things, because that's what me
- 35:12and all my misogynistic men have established. Haven't you read the newsletter that you
- 35:16are an idiot and I'm superior, I'm smarter, I'm better, I have
- 35:22a divine right to have everyone worship me all the time. Don't you understand
- 35:27that you're right written become someone dan and day out a wife no matter the
- 35:37life. I'm not going I'm going to be more. Signs that she has
- 35:44been down the shroad many many times. She's talked with her support system,
- 35:47maybe a therapist, and she uses words like impass I'm not going to engage,
- 35:53I'm going to go And I was worried she was going to engage because
- 35:58he had stopped up her and she was listening, and he was lecturing her
- 36:01about listen to me. He says, listen, listen to me, and
- 36:06he starts to ramble and lecture. It definitely has that abusive lecture tone to
- 36:10it right where he's just telling her how it is and not having a conversation.
- 36:15And she's been down this road many times where I'm just going to take
- 36:19a guess where he will have a three hour lecture that he will subject her
- 36:24to, where he's talking about all the things that just randomly come to his
- 36:29head. Again, it's not the content of the lecture. It's I am
- 36:32yammering and being aggressive and speaking to you from authority, and you are listening.
- 36:38That makes me feel okay because power equals attachment and security, and if
- 36:44I don't have power over you, it's a very scary, very threatening world
- 36:49to me, and I'm terrified. I'm a very terrified little boy. And
- 36:52the only way I can have any kind of happiness in life or safety is
- 36:57if you're totally under my control. Anyway, So she says, I'm not
- 37:00going to engage because I'm thinking she's been down this road so many times,
- 37:04and she resolved in her mind, she's like, I'm not going to do
- 37:06that. I'm not going to listen to him lecture to me like he always
- 37:08does. I'm gonna go. I'll get textsolutely, I'll Gettin. But then
- 37:14as she's leaving, she has to accommodate because she's terrified that if she doesn't
- 37:19calm him down, then it'll be even worse physical abuse. I don't know,
- 37:22but she stops. She's like, yeah, text me what you need
- 37:25and we're good. I'll still do what I can, but I am leaving,
- 37:30which I don't blame her for. You know, I'm role playing it
- 37:32in a way that might appear mocking. It is. She's in an impossible
- 37:37situation. There are several evils that she has to pick the lesser of,
- 37:40and she's trying to figure out how to get out of the house, maybe
- 37:45even divorce him in a way that causes the least amount of harm and abuse
- 37:51to her. I'm gonna go, I'll get textsolutely, I'll GETTIN. I
- 38:00I love you, I'm committed to you. Right. She's doing everything she
- 38:05can. She's trying to draw boundary. I'm not going to be abused anymore.
- 38:08I'm not going to engage right an impass. I've been here before,
- 38:12and I don't want you to escalate this. I don't want you to use
- 38:16this as an excuse to abuse me even more. I'm taking a big leap
- 38:21right now that I have haven't done in the past. I'm just walking out
- 38:24and you know, hey, we're still on the same page. I'm still
- 38:27gonna help you out, and I love you. I'm committed to you.
- 38:30So I wonder what that statement is where she's saying I'm committed to you.
- 38:34That seems to be like maybe she intuits that if he is under the impression
- 38:38that she's going to leave him in the marriage, then he'll really escalate or
- 38:43something. So she's trying to reassure him I'm committed to you, I'm not
- 38:46going to divorce you, and I'm not. I'm not you're not committed to
- 38:58anything, so put on gloves. I'm not sure it is that some sort
- 39:01of housework thing. What she's waiting for is for him to be like fine,
- 39:06go or okay, see you later, or I'll textulate it, you
- 39:08know, just some some indication that as she's leaving, he's not going to
- 39:13escalate, or that it's less likely but he's not going to give that up.
- 39:16He knows that that is power. He knows that's what she's looking for.
- 39:20At least he into its. And so he tries another thing. Okay,
- 39:23we're you gonna put on this glove. It's probably some sort of chore
- 39:25at the house. So are you gonna put on the gloves? Are you
- 39:29at least going to do that? Because in his mind, he's like,
- 39:32that's I'm trying whatever I can to keep this conversation going so that I can
- 39:37continue to yammer and lecture her, because it's worked in the past when I
- 39:40did that, and I saw that when I was a kid, it worked
- 39:43with my parents or wherever this was modeled him. And so that's my only
- 39:46road to happiness. That's the only road for our relationship to actually be salvaged.
- 39:51I'm desperate for that. I'm terrified. This is driven by terror,
- 39:54make no mistake about it. They don't look afraid, but they are terrified,
- 39:59and when are terrified, they will do a lot of different things.
- 40:01So we don't have to have sympathy for that. I don't have any sympathy
- 40:05for it. You can be terrified, you can't be abusive, come on,
- 40:08so he is trying whatever you can at so I think he's he's saying,
- 40:13hey, okay, what about this chore thing? And then she'll she'll
- 40:15stay for that, right, and then then I can continue to badger her
- 40:19and then maybe we can get back there. But if she leaves that,
- 40:22I'm really scared of that. I'm not I'm not You're not committed to anything?
- 40:28And then he uses her word committed because she just said, look,
- 40:31I'm committed to you, and then he says, look, you're not committed
- 40:35anything, grasping whatever he can. It's abusive, it's annoying, it's coercive,
- 40:42it's disrespectful. Isn't interesting that he keeps talking about respect and he's the
- 40:45one being disrespectful. You just said I love you, committed to walk the
- 40:50dogs front bus. So again he's using her words, trying to use anything
- 40:58he can to get her to stay, to control her. And he's talking
- 41:02about gloves and walking the dogs. So maybe the gloves have something to do
- 41:06with walking the dogs? Are you committing? And isn't it interesting you could
- 41:13drop parallel with Amaranth as well that Amaranth's husband appeared to be using the dogs
- 41:19as a triangulated third to control Amaranth, And maybe he's doing that too because
- 41:24he knows, I'm guessing that she loves the dog and or dogs and will
- 41:30do anything for them, and so he's like, hey, you know you're
- 41:34committed. You need to do this, You need to stay here so I
- 41:36can continue to lecture you, and thinking that's what's happening because he knows that
- 41:42she will have a hard time refusing her care of the dogs. I'm good
- 41:49dogs. Are you committing enough to get the medication of blocks? Oh?
- 41:54Medication? So I wonder if the gloves has to do with because sometimes when
- 42:00you administer medication to a dog, either you know, from behind or on
- 42:05the ear, you you know, the medication will go through the skin,
- 42:07and so you can't have the medication go through your skin, so you wear
- 42:12gloves as you're administering. It was that what he's talking about? I don't
- 42:15know, okay, And then I believe Yeah, sure. Ali included the
- 42:17following as the crowder's head inside, Stephen gets angry and angrier, and,
- 42:22by his own admissions, screams, I will f you up at his pregnant
- 42:25wife Hillary, who then flees their home. I will f you up.
- 42:30Yeah, So the watch it lines that he was saying and his tonality and
- 42:36his badgering, and then we hear this statement we I don't know if we're
- 42:40going to see that, but it sounds like we're not going to. That
- 42:44indicates potentially a pattern of abuse and an indication of a pattern of physical abuse.
- 42:54Okay, that's the end. Yeah, the amaranth footed which was much
- 43:00easier to analyze for me, there's a lot of questions here. Certainly there
- 43:06seems to be some indication of a pattern of abuse from him. But as
- 43:09someone who does this kind of work, not only treatment wise, but I
- 43:13also used to work as a forensic psychologist, and I know enough to say
- 43:17that there's often a lot of details that you can't tell from a video like
- 43:22this. So I can't tell I can't make a strong assertion from what's happening
- 43:27here. So maybe we can see some follow up journalism around this. Arguing
- 43:37with his wife that she should go pick up groceries but she can't use his
- 43:40car. That what is her respect for the man? Like, what does
- 43:45she think about men? Oh? So she wanted to go get groceries and
- 43:52he wasn't letting her use his car. I don't know that points in the
- 43:54direction who knows that she doesn't have a car and he controls her by not
- 44:00allowing her to have her own car. I guess I don't know. That's
- 44:04just a speculation. There's a lot of other explanations. She could have a
- 44:07car, her cars in the shop or something. Okay, So some piece
- 44:10of context there is that she, he says, put on gloves and this
- 44:15is because he was asking her to give medicine to the dogs, and she
- 44:20was asking him to do that that task because she's afraid the dog medicine might
- 44:23be toxic to her as a pregnant person. Oh okay, Well, I'm
- 44:29glad that context was given. I mean, I don't know the credibility of
- 44:31that claim, but that certainly fits with the data. No, it's it's
- 44:37we have to make light of this because it's so egregious and disgusting. But
- 44:40I want to tell you more because Mondale hinted at it like it does feel
- 44:45although Hillary alleges otherwise that there might be some physical abuse, because Yashar Ali
- 44:52reports from his newsletter. Okay, so according to the journalist, they're saying
- 44:57that Hillary has stated that Stephen Crowder was not physically abusive to her, That's
- 45:01what it sounded like. And if that's true, Yeah, it's hard to
- 45:06know. Could a victim say to the public that they're not being victimized as
- 45:12a way to try to manage the victimizer the abusive person. Sure that happens
- 45:16all the time, probably more times than not, honestly, so it's possible.
- 45:21But from what we saw, you know, I could see a scenario
- 45:24where he wasn't physically abusive, or he did put hands on but she doesn't
- 45:29categorize it as physical abuse. I don't know, but we don't need physical
- 45:35abuse to justify labeling someone as an abusive individual. Verbal abuse emotional abuse is
- 45:42rough. Some people will say, having partners or parents who abuse them in
- 45:47various ways verbally, emotionally, physically, they will report, sometimes not always,
- 45:52that the physical abuse was the least of their worries, because to be
- 45:55hit or beat was painful and rough, but at least you knew the parameters,
- 46:00You knew when it was going to end, you knew how bad it
- 46:04would typically get, and you would just take your lumps. It wasn't great,
- 46:07but it would be over at some point. But the verbal and emotional
- 46:09abuse gets under your skin and it's just unrelenting, and it starts to brainwash
- 46:15you, starts to make you feel like you're worthless. Of course, the
- 46:17physical abuse will make you feel worthless as well, but the ongoing verbal and
- 46:22emotional abuse, if you've ever been through it, you know that that can
- 46:24be extremely destructive, potentially for the rest of your life. You might need
- 46:29a lifetime of therapy to recover halfway from verbal and emotional abuse, and really
- 46:35all types of abuse. But my point is is that we don't need to
- 46:37and I feel like society does this. Sometimes it's like, well, he's
- 46:39got to be physically abusive, right, Hillary sounds like she came forward and
- 46:44said that she wasn't. And then we're like, well, but no one
- 46:45acts like that if they're not physically abusive. And plus I want to hate
- 46:49the guy, so I want to believe that he's physically abusive. You could
- 46:52still hate him for the verbal abuse and emotional abuse. You can absolutely dislike
- 46:57and judge someone and cancel someone. I pose for verbal and emotional abuse.
- 47:01It's not just verbal and just emotional abuse. It is unrelenting, it is
- 47:07damaging, it is not okay, it will break someone down, and if
- 47:12you've ever been through it, you know how horrible it is. I believe
- 47:15it's substack, which is where this is reported, saying moments later off camera.
- 47:20After this argument, Stephen Crowder, by his admission, would lose control
- 47:23and scream its pregnant wife in a threatening tone, I will f you up,
- 47:28which is what led his wife to flee the home. However, neither
- 47:31Hillary nor Stephen is contending that there was physical abuse in their marriage or sexual
- 47:36infidelity, and an audiophiles and text messages I reviewed, Stephen Crowder admits to
- 47:39some of his faults, which include a volcanic temper. Sorry, yeah.
- 47:45Abusive people will sometimes claim that they have an anger management problem or a temper,
- 47:51and usually they will admit to that when they feel like they can't get
- 47:54out of it and they have to admit to something. But that's not the
- 47:58way we frame it in our industry. In fact, I would assess people
- 48:02when they would come in having been committed of a crime of domestic violence intimate
- 48:07partner violence, and we would actually find that a small minority would qualify for
- 48:12what we would call having a temper or an anger management problem, meaning that
- 48:16they didn't have the personality traits and the belief system that upheld an abusive behavior.
- 48:24In other words, there were two groups of people. There were people
- 48:28that would come in and we would say, yes, you need to go
- 48:30through the abusive perpetrator treatment, but a small group would be like, well,
- 48:35actually you don't need that, you need anger management. So for the
- 48:38individuals that we would flag for abusive perpetrator treatment, these individuals had a personality
- 48:45such that they actually believed that abuse was okay. They had a belief system
- 48:52that said, often it was men that I was treating. They had a
- 48:54belief system that men were superior, and men were better and women were inferior,
- 49:00and it was okay for men under certain circumstances to beat their wives.
- 49:04So that's in their personality, it's in their bones. They believe that to
- 49:08be true. And they also have a personality such that they have high reactivity.
- 49:13Often, these abusive individuals, they don't necessarily have a bad temper outside
- 49:19of their marriage, at work, and in other situations, they're calm and
- 49:22cool as a cucumber. But when it comes to attachments, that's when they
- 49:25engage in the abusive behavior. Whereas a small minority of people would come into
- 49:30us having been convicted of abusing their partner, and we would find that they
- 49:35didn't have that belief system, and they didn't have a pervasive personality trait or
- 49:38a set of traits that resulted in them being violent with their attachment with their
- 49:43partners. And so these individuals tended to have anger regulation problems in every circumstance
- 49:50at work, with friends, with their partner, every while they're driving on
- 49:54the street. They did have an emotional regulation problem. Sometimes it was PTSD.
- 49:59Honestly, so they didn't have to be re educated. The people that
- 50:02would go through the domestic violence treatment we had to re educate them. To
- 50:07use a term of brainwash, we would have to unbrainwash them. We would
- 50:10have to change their personalities. The foundation of the way they looked at the
- 50:15world, the foundation of how they approached attachments, the foundation of how they
- 50:19saw themselves and men and women, all of that had to be unlearned,
- 50:23and then they had to relearn a new thing that takes a lot of time
- 50:27and a lot of convincing. Whereas someone going through the Anger manager of program,
- 50:30they didn't need that, they didn't need that re education. They didn't
- 50:34need that unbrainwashing. It's like for the perpetrators, it was like trying to
- 50:37extract someone from a cult. They had been brainwashed into this way of thinking
- 50:42and it took a lot of time for them to change their paradigm. The
- 50:45anger management folks, they didn't need that. They needed Ptstree treatment or emotional
- 50:51regulation skills, and that would usually help. So for a lot of abusive
- 50:53people, when they're trying to minimize their abusive behavior and mindset, they will
- 50:59deny the fact that they have a personality trait or they've been brainwashed into a
- 51:04misogynistic point of view, and they will say, yeah, I just have
- 51:06an anger problem. But look, his family has spoken out about this,
- 51:12and the reason, in my opinion, that they've been speaking out about this
- 51:15is because Stephen Crowder had the audacity to openly talk about their divorce on his
- 51:20program in a way. Okay, so it sounds like they did get divorced,
- 51:23and he talked openly about the divorce, probably critical of Hillary. Ay.
- 51:30That made it sound like there was no reason that his wife was seeking
- 51:34said divorce, right, and that it should you know, for some reason,
- 51:37she just wants out of it. And now we're flirting with I don't
- 51:40know if you could call a defamation legally, but we're flirting with, for
- 51:44sure, a disparaging of character when he could have chosen to say nothing at
- 51:49all. So Hillary's family spoke out to Yashi Ali, this journalist and said,
- 51:52quote, the truth is that Hillary spent years hiding Steven's mentally and emotionally
- 51:57abusive behavior from her friends and family while she attempted to say their marriage.
- 52:00She was the one who was asking to work on their relationship to keep the
- 52:02marriage intact for their unborn children. Okay, So the family of Hillary made
- 52:08a statement to the journalist that they're saying that Hillary spent years hiding Stevens mentally
- 52:15and emotionally abusive behavior from friends and family while she attempted to save their marriage.
- 52:22Yeah, it's a very common story, and it fits with the narrative
- 52:25that I was saying earlier that as she was starting to say we're at an
- 52:29impasse or I'm not going to engage, I'm guessing that when she got to
- 52:34that point, she actually did start to talk with other people. I don't
- 52:37know, or she just knew from her own wisdom that it wasn't safe or
- 52:42it wasn't advisable to engage with him when he's being abusive, And so it
- 52:46fits with my narrative as well. When I was a very typical story,
- 52:51as you know how I depicted how in the beginning, I was wondering if
- 52:54she's like, well, maybe it's me. Maybe he's just in a bad
- 52:57mood, maybe he stressed out from work. I can manage it. I
- 53:00don't want to out him to other people. I don't want to concern my
- 53:04family and friends. Maybe it's my fault. That's usually the mode that victims
- 53:08will go through in the beginning, maybe even for their entire lives. But
- 53:13then eventually, hopefully they can emerge out of that, get support, start
- 53:16talking, and then either get treatment or leave their relationship. In June twenty
- 53:22twenty one, Steve left their home to pursue elective surgery. Hillary urged him
- 53:25to get the help he needed to address his abuse, with the hope that
- 53:29their marriage could be saved and they could peacefully live together as a family.
- 53:32Instead, Stephen refused to do so and chose not to be with his wife
- 53:37during the birth of their twin children. There's more after the birth, which
- 53:44I guess he eventually got to he bought a townhouse, left their home permanently.
- 53:49Hillary was unaware that Stephen had hired a divorce attorney and asked his assistant
- 53:53to cut Hillary off financially. Their significant documentation substantiating these facts. Yeah,
- 54:00so, financial abuse is a well known phenomenon. When someone is abusive,
- 54:06they often will use whatever they can, and if they can use the finances
- 54:12as a way of abusing or controlling or getting back at someone, then they
- 54:16often will. He's alleged that women who are under the thumb of a strong
- 54:22male just stay at home, are happy, they love serving their husbands.
- 54:27Here he is in November of twenty twenty one, just months after this one
- 54:31particular fight on his show. Every issue that you complain about women legitimately,
- 54:38and I am empathetic towards you. I have a white woman wife, just
- 54:42to be clear, hashtag white woman. I have a wife who's a stay
- 54:45at home mom now and she used to be a professional. So I have
- 54:49some experience with this living with a woman and what it is that she has
- 54:52valued and where she has found herself happier. Take pride in your job,
- 54:57absolutely, but take pride in being a mother. Too, take pride and
- 55:00being a wife too. Do you not want your husband to take pride and
- 55:04so verbatim? In my view, you could say that there's nothing problematic with
- 55:08those kinds of statements. Like for me, as a husband, I can
- 55:13say I take pride in being a husband. I take pride in my role
- 55:16in my marriage. I take pride in knowing that I'm working on my marriage,
- 55:22trying to make it better, giving my wife the benefit of the doubt,
- 55:25doing a lot of things to try to make our marriage better. I
- 55:29take pride in that, and I would hope that my wife would do the
- 55:31same. I would hope that my wife. I can't even say it out
- 55:37loud because it's usually associated with what he is trying to say, what he's
- 55:42communicating, but I would hope that my wife would also try at our marriage.
- 55:45Let's just say that, but that's not what he's saying. What he's
- 55:51saying is I would hope that women would return to the way they used to
- 55:57be, or at least the way we think that you used to be,
- 55:59which is the natural order of things. This is the central feature for a
- 56:04lot of conservatives, is to bring us back to the past because they think
- 56:07that where we're headed and where we are now is this, you know,
- 56:10den of sin and horribleness. So this is usually the tagline for them.
- 56:16You know, fifty years ago they would just say it outright. They would
- 56:21say women need to be barefoot in the kitchen because that's the natural order of
- 56:24things. They have learned. The misogynists and the conservatives and folks like this
- 56:30will they know that they can't say that because even among other right wingers they
- 56:35will say, well, that's going too far, so they will tone it
- 56:38down. But the message is the same. They mean the same thing,
- 56:43but they use different words for it. This is true with racism. Fifty
- 56:45years ago, they would just say black people are stupid and criminals. Everyone
- 56:51understands that. Today they will say things like thugs who will loot stores,
- 56:57or they'll use things like urban as stand in for black people or inner city,
- 57:01well, you know, the inner city, they're all stupid and criminals.
- 57:05We all know that they're using words that code words that everyone understands what
- 57:08they're referring to. But they're evading a direct link to racism. But it's
- 57:15clear that they're being racist. Right, So this is the phraseology of the
- 57:20modern sexist where she has found herself happier. Take pride in your job,
- 57:24absolutely, but take pride and being a mother too. Take pride and being
- 57:29a wife too. Do you not want your husband to take pride and being
- 57:31a good husband, being a faithful husband, being a loving husband. But
- 57:35of course, if you ask his wife, she would say if what do
- 57:39you okay, what do you mean by pride? And this is These are
- 57:42the debates I would get into with misogynists in my office. I'd say,
- 57:45Okay, let's not use the word pride. What do you mean by pride?
- 57:49Tell me the bullet points? What would indicate pride? I'm guessing he
- 57:52would say, like, well, you're dedicated to your spouse. You will
- 57:58do what you can to make them happy. Say okay, yeah, that
- 58:00sounds good. So that's what you're wanting her to do. Yes, that's
- 58:04what I want her to do. Okay, are you doing that for her?
- 58:07Is that also part of the taking pride in one's marriage? Because I'm
- 58:13guessing the wife would say, I have bent over backwards for a long time
- 58:17to make him happy. I have put myself aside many many times. One
- 58:22could argue I'd do it every day. He never does that. Okay,
- 58:28So if we're talking about both people having but the language that now I don't,
- 58:31I can't say that because it's it's evasive language. So verbatim. Wise,
- 58:38there's nothing wrong with what he's saying. Like I was saying earlier,
- 58:40I take pride in being a husband. I hope my wife takes. When
- 58:44I say it out loud, it sounds sexist when I say it about my
- 58:49wife. When I say about myself, it doesn't say so. I'm not
- 58:51even gonna say it. I just hope we both are dedicated to our relationship.
- 58:53I hope we both try to make this thing work. Even that sounds
- 58:57sexist because it's sort of in line with anyway. But everyone knows, especially
- 59:00his audience, given all the things, all the rhetoric that he says,
- 59:05that what he's saying is, I would hope that women would serve their husbands
- 59:09like the natural order of things, like the things the way things used to
- 59:14be, because that's the way things should be. She should be getting me
- 59:16a beer from the fridge, and when I arrive at home, she should
- 59:20run to me and kiss me. And when I'm upset, she should listen
- 59:22to me, lecture to her for three hours and your job. Absolutely,
- 59:27but take pride and being a mother too. Take pride and being a wife
- 59:29too. Do you not want your husband to take pride and being a good
- 59:31husband, being a faithful husband, being a loving husband, the qualities that
- 59:36you admire in a man. Take pride and being a wife and a mother,
- 59:38not just a career. You can take pride in either or, but
- 59:42generally speaking, not both. You can't have it all, okay, you
- 59:47can't take what you can't take pride in work and your family and your husband
- 59:54like you can't, so will you work so? Well? Yeah, yeah,
- 1:00:02it's twisted. I'm looking for logic where there obviously is done. But
- 1:00:10take pride and being a mother too. Take pride and being a wife too.
- 1:00:14Do you not want your husband to take pride and being a good husband,
- 1:00:16being a faithful husband, being a loving husband, the qualities that you
- 1:00:20admire in a man. Take pride and being a wife and a mother,
- 1:00:22not just a career. You can take pride in either or, but generally
- 1:00:25speaking not both. Yeah. Yeah, the twisted, the twisted logic,
- 1:00:34it makes zero sense. You can't take and again that word pride doesn't sound
- 1:00:40bad. This whole rhetorical exercise is a stand in for she needs to serve
- 1:00:47me. Bottom line, she doesn't even need to serve my kids. She
- 1:00:51needs to serve me because I need her to do whatever I say, because
- 1:00:54I only feel safe when she is submissive to me. You can't have it
- 1:01:00all. I can't say what I want to say without this entire all.
- 1:01:07Right, Well that doesn't for that episode of psychology and seattle. Everyone out
- 1:01:10there, please take care of yourself because you deserve it, You really, really do