Latest / Crypto Coin Show / Can Cross-Border Global Payments be completely Private? w/ Payy Network | Blockchain Interviews
Transcript
- 0:00I'm Ashen Addison from the Crypto Coin Show, and today on Blockchain Interviews,
- 0:04we have Sid Gandhi, the CEO of pay. Sid Welcome to the show
- 0:07and thanks for taking the time. Cool. Excited to be here, definitely.
- 0:12I'm excited to dive into the privacy aspect of blockchain. I feel like
- 0:16it's becoming ever more important to know about it. We'd love to start,
- 0:20first of all with a little bit on yourself and business blockchain privacy, your
- 0:24background, how that led you to founding pay, then we can dive into
- 0:27all the details. Yeah. Cool. I guess my crypto journey started in
- 0:32twenty twelve. I read the Bitcoin white Paper, got really excited about the
- 0:37possibilities of decentralized financial networks. We kind of followed the variety of different trends
- 0:45and cool things that have been built since then. Early in twenty twenty two,
- 0:51my co founder and I got really excited about building infrastructure to solve the
- 0:55scalability, cost and privacy problems that we're still in crypto that we felt were
- 1:00like kind of keeping crypto from mass adoption. So we started poly based Labs.
- 1:07We built a bunch of cool stuff Since then, we built poll based
- 1:10database, which was a decentralized database used by over four thousand developers. We
- 1:15built ZK bench which was a ZK frameworks benchmarking tool. It's probably the top
- 1:22most used benchmarking tool today. We looked at risk zeroly, we looked at
- 1:26Noir, we looked at Polygon Midem, and we benchmarked those in a way
- 1:32that's repeatable by anyone. That's all open source. And we also built polly
- 1:37lang, which was a which is a typescript to ZK bytecode compiler, and
- 1:42so if you know how to write typescript or JavaScript, it's really easy to
- 1:45write ZK circuits with that. What we started working on at the end of
- 1:49last year was a consumer application because we really felt strongly that like there's been
- 1:56a lot of advancements in ZK in privacy from an infrastructure perspective, but really
- 2:01getting that into people's hands has been a huge challenge. If you ask people
- 2:07like do they use privacy tech and crypto today, the answers usually know or
- 2:12we've tried, but it's like really hard and there's a bunch of examples out
- 2:15there. You know, either it's like really expensive on gas, it's really
- 2:19slow, you have to take a bunch of different steps to wrap and unwrap
- 2:22and shield and unshield, and we said, can we actually simplify that for
- 2:25people and build something that is private, is self custodial, is decentralized,
- 2:32but feels like, you know, just another app that's really easy to use
- 2:36on your phone. Wow. Very cool. I'm excited to hear more about
- 2:40that because I have personally tried some different privacy networks privacy coins and yeah,
- 2:46you're right, there's always extra steps or it's just you know, way too
- 2:50much effort for the value that you're trying to get. So how exactly has
- 2:54your team sort of lowered those barriers to entry with pay network to allow more
- 3:00people to have access to these privacy functionalities. Yeah, there's basically three main
- 3:05areas that we've worked on to improve that experience. The first one is the
- 3:09privacy itself. And so what does privacy mean? So on pay network and
- 3:15in the pay wallet, privacy means your sender, the receiver, the token,
- 3:21and the amount. Those are all completely private and only stored on the
- 3:24user's device and they're encrypted and backed up. Now, what gets sent to
- 3:30the network every time you make a transaction is a ZK proof and a hash,
- 3:35and that's all handled automatically in a self custodial way. The second main
- 3:39area is kind of abstracting away all those like really crypto things about doing crypto
- 3:46payments, so things like addresses, keys, seed phrases, tokens, gas
- 3:53fees or gas tokens. We've abstracted all that away from the user. So
- 3:59what you see in pay wallet is your USDC balance, and to send a
- 4:03payment, you generate an ephemeral wallet, which is just like generating a link.
- 4:09So you just type in I want to send five dollars. You hit
- 4:11next, the app automatically generates an ephemeral wallet, stores that five dollars in
- 4:15that wallet, and then generates a link. And then you can send that
- 4:18link to anyone. So we pull up like the share sheet. You can
- 4:21send it the I message or telegram or signal, and when the receiver gets
- 4:28that link, they can just click that link, and if they don't have
- 4:30paywallet, it'll prompt them to download it. If they do, it'll open
- 4:33directly in pay wallet and it'll just allow them to redeem into their balance.
- 4:40And so we've kind of like you don't have to think about like what chain
- 4:44you're on and wrapping and un wrapping in any of that, it's all kind
- 4:46of done for you. And the last part is that the ramps on and
- 4:51off, whether through fiat or existing crypto networks, have to be really seamless
- 4:58and they have to be really fast. And so what we've done is we've
- 5:02integrated a variety of different ramps. So right now we have Robinhood connect,
- 5:09we have Coinbase, we have Binance, we have other exchanges. You can
- 5:14obviously deposit funds using a deposit wallet address we give you, so that's available
- 5:19on Polygon right now. That will be available on Ethereum and other EVM chained
- 5:24as well. And then the last thing we're enabling is direct fiat ramps,
- 5:29so you'll be able to connect your bank account obviously, like you can purchase
- 5:33crypto through your credit card, but all of that is seamless and fast and
- 5:39lands within a couple of minutes into your pay wallet automatically without you having to
- 5:44go through extra strap steps like bridging or swapping or wrapping, So we can
- 5:48kind of do all of that for you. Wow, that's really cool,
- 5:53and I feel like the fiat on an off ramp is of course very important,
- 5:57especially for people the ninety nine percent that they they're looking for a better
- 6:00alternative to the traditional systems to send money across border payments of the transfer wise
- 6:09or going to the ATM, and there's so many fees, but that's all
- 6:13they know. And when you add too many technological steps, it's like,
- 6:16I don't want to do it through the app. But if you can really
- 6:19lower those barriers to entry, I feel like that's a multi billion dollar market
- 6:25that crypto has yet to sort of break into. Yeah, very cool.
- 6:31And with the wallet, So the z there you mentioned at the beginning,
- 6:39able the ZK technology, the privacy technology, all that people don't really need
- 6:43to understand the technicalities behind it. Is there a way that you can you
- 6:50can explain the benefits to the people that why this is needed or how it
- 6:56benefits them besides the fact that you know, if you're a person you're looking
- 7:00at the blockchain exploring and you're like, okay, there's less information. But
- 7:03if you're coming from the Western Union world, is that stuff really important to
- 7:11them as well? Yeah, it's kind of funny because I think a lot
- 7:15of people don't realize when they come from trad five to crypto that all of
- 7:18the transactions they're doing are fully public forever. And yeah, if you're coming
- 7:25from Western Union and you know someone gives you a crypto payments app, you
- 7:29know there's dozens of crypto payments apps now that I'll use stable coin, and
- 7:32you know they're built on Base or Arbitrum or Polygon or whatever. Most people
- 7:39don't realize that those are fully public. And if you pay out a store
- 7:43with crypto, which is obviously still really hard even fifteen years on from bitcoin.
- 7:47If you pay at a store with crypto and you walk out of that
- 7:50store, everyone knows that what like that person that walked out, what their
- 7:55on chain activity has been, so how much money you have on their you
- 7:58know, what DeFi protocols do you use? What NFTs you own? And
- 8:01I think a lot of people think that by using like ephemeral wallets and multiple
- 8:07different addresses that that kind of keeps you private. Turns out over the last
- 8:13like six to seven years, all the blockchain analysis firms, so if you
- 8:18think about chain analysis, Arkham Intelligence TRM labs, they've all been doing tremendous
- 8:26work to allow people to discover connections between different wallets, and they use that,
- 8:33they use behavioral analysis, they use big data, they use AI,
- 8:35and today the technology is so good that they're able to do clustering analysis around
- 8:43times of day and location and all these different signals that they have and bring
- 8:46all that together. It turns out pseudonomy is pretty much dead unless you're really
- 8:54really really good at it and you use vp A NS and you uh,
- 8:56you know, you kind of remember to shuffle around your wallets and you don't
- 9:00use the same centralized exchange DEPOSITI address every time. Like it's really hard to
- 9:05actually maintain proper privacy in crypto. All of this to say, the regular
- 9:11consumer today probably doesn't understand this, but I would say in the medium term,
- 9:18like Crypto's going to have a Cambridge Analytica type moment where some kind of
- 9:24inflection point happens, just like with Facebook and Cambrage Analytica, Like no one
- 9:28really cared about putting all their stuff on Facebook, right, Like remember,
- 9:31and we used to just put everything every personal like thing on Facebook, right
- 9:35relationship status Like wow, that was a big thing. And then we all
- 9:41realized that was being used by random companies to do data analysis and being shared.
- 9:46And so I think crypto's gonna end up having the same thing. We
- 9:50see the very beginnings of this, right. Google recently started indexing bitcoin transactions.
- 9:56I think this was last month, and so now you can go and
- 10:00type in a big cooin address and you can see the balance, and you
- 10:01can see transactions, and obviously you can see where that's going. Google is
- 10:05going to use that for that advertising product, and that's just that's obvious.
- 10:11And now you see like Stripe accepting USDC on a couple of different blockchains,
- 10:16Like every time you make a Stripe payment, now that's going to be public
- 10:18for anyone in view, and they can try to use different techniques to get
- 10:22around that, but at the end of the day, it's it's not going
- 10:26to work on a public network. No, it's it's a great point.
- 10:30And I feel like we're already seeing a lot of privacy related news of crackdowns,
- 10:35more so in the news recently of technology. Perhaps there's a lot of
- 10:41people that are they're doing nothing wrong, they're just looking for a technology that
- 10:45is going to protect their personal information. And then there's the Samurai wallet news
- 10:50or other privacy technology that also could be abused by illicit actors. I feel
- 10:56like any technology could be abused, you know Google's it could be abused by
- 11:01illicit actors. What do you think about what's happening in the news towards the
- 11:07perspective of privacy technology. Are they trying to portray that it's bad or that
- 11:11it could be used for both bad and good. Yeah, privacy has had
- 11:16a lot of regulatory challenges, I think all the way. If you go
- 11:20back to z cash, which was basically a progression of bitcoin into a private
- 11:24network, it was a first popular privacy protocols still exists today obviously, but
- 11:31has gotten in tons of trouble. A bunch of exchanges have delisted it now
- 11:33it's really hard to use. After that, we had Monaro. Then in
- 11:39most recent times we had Aztec Connect that got shut down. We had rail
- 11:43Gun, which is like nice but it's really really, really hard to use
- 11:46and very expensive. We had Tornado Cash, of course, and now we
- 11:52have a couple of new privacy protocols Aztec their final version hopefully Alio, you
- 11:58know, whenever they can them out of testnet or whatever they're working on.
- 12:03I think when we looked at each of these, what we looked at was
- 12:09not absolute privacy, but how much privacy we could give users while still maintaining
- 12:16a service that you wouldn't get shut down. And through that we've actually solved
- 12:22the privacy compliance trade off really cleverly with this thing we call ZK compliance.
- 12:28Now, traditionally, in compliance, what happens you have a regulator or you
- 12:33have an exchange that wants to apply a set of rules to a bunch of
- 12:37transactions to say whether you're a good person or not. Right, have you
- 12:41interacted with any OFAX sanctioned wallets? Have you traded with any other risky protocols
- 12:48or risky wallets, etc. Now to do that, what they do is
- 12:50they take all of the data which is available publicly on chain, and they
- 12:54take your address, and then they run their rules over that, and then
- 12:58they get their answer and then either they allow you to off ramp or not,
- 13:01or you know, they come and try to find you for doing bad
- 13:05things or not. We've completely flipped the model. In our model, you
- 13:13have the data, right, So I mentioned before that all the transaction metadata
- 13:16is actually the user owns it on their device. Now what you can do
- 13:20is actually take someone else's rule set. That rule set could be as simple
- 13:24as have you interacted with anyone on the o fac SDN list. You can
- 13:30run that rule set as a function on your own device and then you can
- 13:33send back a proof to whoever needs that. Now, that's something that hasn't
- 13:39been done before. It's similar to the privacy pools concept that got popular last
- 13:43year earlier this year, but we've actually implemented that all the way and we've
- 13:50made it programmable, and we're starting to work with a couple of different partners
- 13:54on the exchange side so that they can implement these kind of frameworks into their
- 14:01off ramping and so they won't have to delist, you know, a privacy
- 14:05protocol just because some you know, some government agency tells them to. They're
- 14:09able to actually prove that the users off ramping from that protocol are actually clean
- 14:16or or a buy by a certain set of rules. M Yeah, that's
- 14:18great to hear. The ZK technology is really beautiful in being able to prove
- 14:24something without showing too much information. So it's really cool. I'm curious in
- 14:28the in the pay wallet, when you're sending a value, are you using
- 14:35a stable coin? Is there and is there actually also a privacy coin that
- 14:41the pay wallet has created or can you send any currency? How exactly does
- 14:43that work? Yeah, So today we allow us d C to be on
- 14:50ramped into the pay network and so that's a traditional like lock and mint bridge
- 14:54that we've deployed, and so you lock your usd C on the public network
- 15:01and it's minted as wrapped USDC on pay. We are planning on adding other
- 15:07tokens as well, starting with stable coins and then expanding into others. We
- 15:11do not have our own privacy token or anything like that. We find those
- 15:16to be very unusable. I mean, who wants to accept you know,
- 15:20Zech or manarrow right, like, no one, And so we think stable
- 15:28coins are the way to go here. Now. The reason we've done that
- 15:33is because pay is currently the key use cases only for payments. We are
- 15:39planning on adding future use cases, whether that's being able to earn interest invest
- 15:43things like that, but that's coming in the future. Yeah. No,
- 15:48that's great to hear. And I think the payments problem worldwide is a big
- 15:54issue to solve in the first place. So I feel like you have a
- 15:56lot on your hands, and you know a lot of the people who are
- 16:02trying to send money uh to different countries or overseas back to their family.
- 16:06They're in a lot of different countries. Are there any restrictions or is it
- 16:11available to most of the people, you know, the popular countries that are
- 16:15seeing remittances to back to their families. Yeah, so pay is available in
- 16:22any country that has App Store or Google Play available in those countries. So
- 16:27if you can download an app, you can you can use pay now.
- 16:32Pay is self custodial, which means it's it's kind of like meta mask or
- 16:37trust wallet or or coin based wallet. We don't custody any of the funds,
- 16:42and it's fully built on the decentralized pay network that rolls up to EVM
- 16:48chains, and so yes, anyone in any country that can download an app
- 16:52can use pay now. The real challenge is around how you on and off
- 16:57ramp FIAT and so currently we allow kind of like I was mentioning before,
- 17:03we allow on an off rent being through exchanges. So that's really easy.
- 17:08Most countries around the world have an exchange, So you connect your bank account
- 17:12to the exchange or whatever method domestic payment method you have. You on ramp
- 17:18funds, you buy USDC and then you send it over to pay. We're
- 17:22actually gonna be bundling that those ramps directly into pay so you actually can skip
- 17:27skip that exchange step and then that will make it actually even easier for folks
- 17:33to send money from one country to another. That's great, And you know
- 17:38you hinted at some other functionality in the future looking towards the roadmap in terms
- 17:45of the privacy side and the payment side. Is there any more that needs
- 17:48to be done? You know, there's still so many people that are yet
- 17:53to onboard or is it just aware of this technology exists? Hey, we
- 17:57need more people to start using it to reap the benefits. Yeah, I
- 18:02mean pay is in main net, right So the network is in main net.
- 18:06It's it's been audited. The ZK circuits as well as smart contracts,
- 18:11the bridge and the roll up contracts have been audited and it's ready to use
- 18:15and we have about we have a couple of thousand users already using pay now.
- 18:21The pay wallet is in beta right now. What that means is it's
- 18:26using real us d C. But there's still a few features we want to
- 18:30add into pay wallet to make it more usable, like the on and off
- 18:32ramps, improve some of the UX you know, small things like that and
- 18:37so that's why we haven't you know, fully gone into customer acquisition mode just
- 18:42yet and so that will be like later this summer and so, but I
- 18:48would suggest, like if you're if you use crypto payments today, if you
- 18:52use us DC to pay people, pay Wallet is probably the easiest payments app
- 18:57in crypto today. You can go from downloading the app to paying someone within
- 19:03like five seconds. As long as your app downloads is fast. There's no
- 19:07like setup, there's no you know, additional work that needs to be done.
- 19:11In fact, if you go to pay dot link p a y y
- 19:15dot link right now, you can actually try out what I just said and
- 19:21see for yourself that it's insanely fast, very cool. Sid I'm definitely gonna
- 19:25check it out. I'll put that link in the show notes and also just
- 19:29a link to the apps if people want to download it. This is something
- 19:32that I think is very needed, and not just for people that are already
- 19:34in crypto that are looking to pay easily, but the people that aren't aren't
- 19:38yet and we need an app like this to go viral so that people can
- 19:44understand the benefits of you know, moving crypto instead of FIA and how they're
- 19:49really getting ripped off from transferring feat, especially internationally, and I think this
- 19:55is something that could do very well. So I'm looking forward to following up
- 20:00as this continues to grow. I would love to have you back on the
- 20:02show and discuss more around that privacy and just how people need easy payments.
- 20:10Yeah, definitely awesome. Thank you so much, sir,