Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / Repositioning Co-Teaching: A Deeper Dive with Blue Engine
Transcript
- 0:00Hi,
- 0:01this is Aurora from the Educating All Learners Alliance.
- 0:04And today we're talking with Jessie Brunken and Tiffany Galloway for a deeper dive with Blue Engine.
- 0:10Blue Engine is an organization that supports schools and districts to improve academic outcomes for all students,
- 0:16specifically,
- 0:17students with disabilities and emergent Multilingual learners who disproportionately identify as black and brown by supporting systems with core instruction and inclusion setting.
- 0:28Joining us today is Blue Engine's Ceo Jessi Brunken.
- 0:31She's been with Blue Engines for 10 years where she leads on a range of roles on the program and comes to this work through the classroom and secondary math inclusion.
- 0:40We're also joined by Tiffany Galloway,
- 0:43the VP of learning design and impact at Blue Engine.
- 0:46Tiffany is a veteran inclusive education practitioner with over 15 years of experience and comes to this work from a deep background in special education pedagogy and practice.
- 0:56Having served as a classroom teacher and instructional coach,
- 0:59school leader and district administrator.
- 1:01On today's episode,
- 1:02we're going to discuss the gaps in our current public education system specifically when it comes to meeting the needs of diverse learners and how this disproportionately impacts the felt educational experience of students who are historically marginalized.
- 1:16There are several levers to address this issue and co teaching is one of them.
- 1:21Thank you so much for joining me today and welcome to the podcast.
- 1:25So let's dive right in.
- 1:28So as we know,
- 1:29Jessi was on our five minutes with series and today she's back with Tiffany to talk about the current practices in our education system when it comes to meeting the needs of students of color with disabilities,
- 1:41how co teaching can address some of these current barriers.
- 1:45So this work is very closely tied with the work that I do with Ela and the educating All Learners Alliance.
- 1:51But when speaking with new folks,
- 1:53I always like to jump in with,
- 1:54you know,
- 1:54what's your personal connection to this conversation?
- 1:57Why is this important to you?
- 2:00I love that question,
- 2:01Aurora,
- 2:01we love to talk about the why at Blue Engine so many connections for me to this work.
- 2:08But I think on a personal level,
- 2:10what stands out the most to me is I actually identify as being part of the one and five.
- 2:16And that actually wouldn't become clear to me until my adult life.
- 2:21And so I spent a lot of time like thinking back to my K 12 and college experience.
- 2:27And what stands out the most to me is actually a feeling,
- 2:31the feeling of anxiety that I often had um in classroom spaces um that I became really good at hiding and the feeling of just really struggling but wanting so badly to be successful.
- 2:47And I often don't talk about this actually because when I do bring it up,
- 2:50people's is usually,
- 2:52but look how you turned out.
- 2:53So it's fine,
- 2:55it feels really invalidating.
- 2:57Um But I'm trying to use my voice around this a little bit more.
- 3:00And for so long,
- 3:01I believed it was normal to feel an immense amount of anxiety.
- 3:06And so I show up to this work and think about this on a daily basis just knowing that if we do our job as well at Blue Engine,
- 3:13what it means is that greater numbers of students feel like what is normal is being themselves and having the support that allows them to feel comfortable and successful and challenged,
- 3:24of course,
- 3:25in classroom settings,
- 3:26but having teachers who believe it's their job to see and know and support them.
- 3:32And then on a professional level,
- 3:33as you mentioned,
- 3:34I was a middle school math inclusion teacher in the South Bronx earlier in my career.
- 3:38And that's where I first saw the compounding effects of race and socioeconomic status on neurodiversity and disability.
- 3:47I taught in a school where the average teacher tenure was probably about 3 to 4 years and almost everyone had been alternatively certified.
- 3:55I was as well.
- 3:56And one of the impacts of that of having such an unexperienced underprepared teaching workforce was that we truly didn't know in many cases what to do with neuro diversity.
- 4:09And it meant that kids who should have been included in the general education setting were often segregated and put into self contained environments because teachers put up their hands and said,
- 4:20I,
- 4:20I don't know what to do.
- 4:20It must mean they need something different,
- 4:22they need,
- 4:23you know,
- 4:23more,
- 4:24more help is kind of what we,
- 4:26what we would say.
- 4:27And so,
- 4:28you know,
- 4:28I am just here on a mission every day because of both my personal and professional experience.
- 4:33I often say that some of the manifestations of a DH D for me are my superpower.
- 4:38I have endless amounts of energy,
- 4:40urgency,
- 4:41enthusiasm around this um And feel grateful to put that to work here.
- 4:45And I work alongside people like Tiffany who I learn from every day.
- 4:49So I'm eager to share her personal why as well.
- 4:53Yeah.
- 4:53Oh my goodness,
- 4:54so much of what uh Jessi shared so keenly resonates with me,
- 4:59with my own personal and professional experiences.
- 5:02So much of my um my many intersections of my identity informs why I do this work.
- 5:07And perhaps more importantly,
- 5:09how I go about doing this work similar to Jessi.
- 5:12Um I grew up in the inner city of Boston,
- 5:15a city well known for its challenges with diversity equity and inclusion in the predominantly black neighborhood of Dorchester was very conscientious to say that in a non Bostonian way.
- 5:26So uh throughout my K 12 experience though I attended Boston public schools and can like distinctly recall grappling with some really harsh truths about my own educational experience uh within my family education was centered as like this critical lever to access like the ever elusive American dream,
- 5:48so not dissimilar from other kids in my neighborhood.
- 5:51However,
- 5:51my parents would heavily emphasize the importance of me going to school,
- 5:55getting good grades and getting out if you will right Uh To experience the things that they were unable to experience due to a range of issues which can largely be attributed to systemic and structural oppression.
- 6:08More on that.
- 6:10Uh another combo for another day for sure.
- 6:13And so I had this image and this mantra that was consistently at play in my head.
- 6:18Uh When I engaged with school one being like be the best,
- 6:21right?
- 6:22You gotta be the best always which I internalized as like be perfect,
- 6:27right?
- 6:27Like be the best means be perfect.
- 6:29And then then the secondary point is like this idea of like anything short of the best will reduce your chances of quote unquote making it,
- 6:36right?
- 6:37So you talk about pressure,
- 6:38right?
- 6:38That's a lot of pressure for your entire K 12 experience.
- 6:42And similar to Jessi again,
- 6:43like what I learned as I navigated schooling,
- 6:45I found it to be equally as important,
- 6:47if not more important than the content was the task about like internalizing how to actually hide how to flow under the radar,
- 6:57how to build a bank of coping mechanisms to make school work for me and to meet the approval of like my folks,
- 7:05right?
- 7:05Because what I would learn later in life in my mid thirties,
- 7:09like Jessi is that I sit squarely with my people,
- 7:12the one in five of,
- 7:14one in five people in this country that are diagnosed with learning and attention issues.
- 7:18Again,
- 7:18like in my mid thirties,
- 7:19I was diagnosed with a DH D and I couldn't help but think about like how my schooling experiences may or may not have looked differently for me,
- 7:28right?
- 7:28Um Growing up in the nineties,
- 7:30early two thousands,
- 7:31for me,
- 7:32there wasn't this notion of like including kiddos who were different.
- 7:36So if that was publicized,
- 7:38then when I have not been tracked into,
- 7:40you know,
- 7:40more prestigious or advanced work classes or A P classes and things of that nature.
- 7:47If I am honest,
- 7:48I am not sure that the learning environment honestly,
- 7:51really super designed well to address learner complexities at that time.
- 7:55And then professionally,
- 7:56I'm connected to this work because I spent the better part of my career advocating for inclusive learning environments uh similar to Jessi.
- 8:04I recall at the beginning of my career,
- 8:06I was 1/6 grade,
- 8:07self-contained reading teacher in South Fulton County in Atlanta.
- 8:11I was alternatively certified and my classroom consisted of students whose demographics have historically been marginalized.
- 8:19So those are those uh students who are newcomers,
- 8:23Multilingual learners.
- 8:24A lot of Black and Latinx students uh and students with disabilities,
- 8:28um specifically learning and behavior girl disorders and so much of uh of my class,
- 8:33many of those sixth graders spent a substantial amount of their time with me outside of the general education environment.
- 8:40And I can't but think about like why this actually needed to be the case.
- 8:43Like they're in sixth grade and they're in a reading class and it needs to be away from their counterparts most of the day and most of the week.
- 8:52And it honestly is something I still grapple with to this day and it submits why I show up in this work in the way that I do.
- 9:00Yeah,
- 9:00thank you both so much for sharing that.
- 9:02There's a lot of research that points to educational inequity for students of color,
- 9:07students from low income backgrounds,
- 9:08students with disabilities.
- 9:10And we also know that when we're talking about special education and inclusion,
- 9:15a lot of schools and a lot of districts are doing it right now.
- 9:18So why do we have to have this conversation explicitly?
- 9:22You know,
- 9:23isn't inclusive education happening already.
- 9:26Most districts have adopted an inclusion model where students with disabilities are taught alongside their peers.
- 9:32There's actually a report that's produced by NCLD on significant disproportionality in special education and it found that only a third of black students with disabilities spend that much time in the general education setting as compared to 55% of white students.
- 9:48Right.
- 9:49Additionally,
- 9:49in a report also produced by NCLD on helping educators unlock the power of students who learn differently.
- 9:57They highlighted the huge disparities in achievement for 4th and 8th graders with disabilities.
- 10:02They found that 91% of fourth graders and 96% of eighth graders with learning disabilities are not proficient in math.
- 10:11Right.
- 10:11So 91% and 96% of our students are not proficient in math.
- 10:18Similarly,
- 10:19when we think about reading,
- 10:2197% of fourth graders and 96% of eighth graders with learning disabilities are not proficient in reading.
- 10:29And so we see a compounded effect on students with disabilities of color,
- 10:34specifically black students with disabilities have a gap of about 20 points on nape scores between their white peers and black students with IEPs are four times as likely to be suspended as compared to their white counterparts.
- 10:47So if we're thinking about the original question posed is inclusive education already happening,
- 10:52we have to dismantle this notion that just because kids with disabilities are integrated into the general education environment,
- 10:59it does not necessarily mean that they are receiving inclusive education at Blue Engine.
- 11:04We know this and we know this very,
- 11:05very well.
- 11:06We work with partners from various parts of the country,
- 11:09New York,
- 11:10L A,
- 11:10New Orleans,
- 11:11DC and Massachusetts,
- 11:13shameless plug who are also all grappling with the same notion,
- 11:17right?
- 11:18How do we create and support learning environments that are places where all kids are able to thrive.
- 11:25We work with educators at all levels of the system.
- 11:28So that's in the classroom,
- 11:29at the school level and at the district level to address this issue.
- 11:32And I like to think that we're making some strides like towards actualizing that vision,
- 11:37Jessi.
- 11:37I'd love to know what you think here.
- 11:39You've been here.
- 11:40Veteran with Blue Engine.
- 11:43Yeah.
- 11:43What I thought of when I was listening,
- 11:46I mean,
- 11:47I loved all the data.
- 11:49I feel they were a very data driven organization.
- 11:51But what I thought about when I heard you saying,
- 11:54citing all the research shift was like if I go like all the way back to like 22 year old me learning to teach,
- 12:00there was this saying that a lot of us learned like if students didn't learn it,
- 12:05you didn't teach.
- 12:06It is really simple,
- 12:08but it stuck with me today.
- 12:09So regardless of what people think is happening,
- 12:13let's look at the outcomes,
- 12:14it's not happening,
- 12:16it's not happening.
- 12:17And I think a lot of it is because inclusion is so much bigger than just integrating students into a learning environment.
- 12:26And if we haven't intentionally made those changes to the environment,
- 12:31to the supports we put in place to how we're using the human capital,
- 12:35which is,
- 12:36you know,
- 12:36where we often focus in we,
- 12:38what we see is like self contained happening in the general education setting because you have your content,
- 12:43teacher teaching kids without IEPs and you have your special educator teaching like that's,
- 12:47that's not inclusion,
- 12:49that that's self contained is happening in,
- 12:51in four different walls.
- 12:53And so I,
- 12:54I just go back to that saying and then it's,
- 12:57you know,
- 12:57what,
- 12:57what else is alarming is if 50% of our general education teachers nationally tell us that they don't believe students with disabilities can be successful with grade level rigor.
- 13:10Our classrooms are not included of spaces.
- 13:13So it's not happening.
- 13:14And what's funny about what Tiffany said around like hypothetically if we interviewed 10 system leaders,
- 13:21well,
- 13:21she's interviewed 20 this year.
- 13:22And so it's not hypothetical.
- 13:24There are different responses.
- 13:27Our leaders of special education are frustrated because they're feeling like they don't have an equal voice at the table and they know how important this work is.
- 13:35And so,
- 13:36yeah.
- 13:36No,
- 13:37it's not.
- 13:37Um but,
- 13:38but I think our work proves that it can with intentionality.
- 13:42Yeah,
- 13:43I mean,
- 13:44we know that there are many different definitions of inclusion and many di different definitions of what is an inclusive space or an inclusive classroom,
- 13:53which kind of lends to the question of like,
- 13:56what would we need,
- 13:58what enabling conditions like,
- 14:00what would we need to have present to really kind of,
- 14:03you know,
- 14:04bring this vision,
- 14:05bring everybody kind of on board to the same vision or to,
- 14:09to help address these gaps right,
- 14:11you know,
- 14:1150% of teachers,
- 14:13like you said,
- 14:13like,
- 14:14don't believe that special education students can achieve it at great little rigor.
- 14:18So we're familiar with the conditions or familiar with kind of what's happening now,
- 14:24what do you believe we need in our system in order to,
- 14:27you know,
- 14:28start to impact change or address some of this?
- 14:31Yeah,
- 14:32I'm actually low key giddy about this and Jessi will tell you this.
- 14:35this is actually one of my most favorite things to talk about in the discussion of inclusion or inclusive practices.
- 14:41This idea of enabling conditions,
- 14:44I think we have to go back to this mental model of inclusion being a place like versus a systemic approach,
- 14:49right,
- 14:50in order,
- 14:51right.
- 14:53Right there,
- 14:54that's some of like the implicit sort of like ingrained,
- 14:57you know,
- 14:57ways of thinking,
- 14:58right?
- 14:59I mean,
- 14:59I've been an educator and been doing this work and I still do sometimes think of it as like it's a,
- 15:04it's a physical thing to the inclusion classroom.
- 15:07There you go.
- 15:09Yeah,
- 15:10you're exactly right.
- 15:11So like in order to have like a school or a classroom environment that is actually inclusive and prepared to attend to the various learning needs of every learner.
- 15:21Like not even just the ones that are have identified disabilities or are learning English as a new language,
- 15:27the system around that classroom,
- 15:30the school or district actually has to work together very,
- 15:33very well to produce that.
- 15:35Um it's incredibly difficult however,
- 15:37to dismantle a mental model when uh general educators receive like little to no training or what it means to support diverse learners and hold those limiting beliefs about themselves as educators and of the students who are in their classroom.
- 15:51Right?
- 15:52So Jessi uh alluded to like the 50% of our educators not believing that students with IEPs or with disabilities are able to access grade level content and rigor there's also this belief of like whether or not me as the spec as the general educator feels well prepared to even get you to that place and I'll,
- 16:12I'll pepper in some more data points.
- 16:13Again,
- 16:14NCLD is one of my favorite organizations and they also um again,
- 16:17conducted a study on understanding teacher mindsets and found that at least 17% of the teachers that they surveyed felt very well prepared to teach students with mild and moderate learning disabilities.
- 16:30We elevated a little bit earlier that like 70% of students with disabilities um are served through special education in the general education setting.
- 16:39Um So if 70% of those kiddos are included right in the inclusion environment,
- 16:45uh but only 17% of teachers actually feel even well prepared to teach them that signals to me like a gap in the conditions that are in place to actualize inclusive education.
- 16:57So for me,
- 16:58the the this current reality makes it incredibly challenging to adopt change.
- 17:02Our teachers are facilitating instruction um with students for students with disabilities.
- 17:07Um c
- 17:15Right?
- 17:16Like so uh how do I teach a kiddo in my sixth grade math class who has dyscalculia,
- 17:21which is a math disability or how do I teach a kiddo in my class who has an auditory processing disorder or deficit?
- 17:29And my primary mode of facilitating is through talking at kids,
- 17:33right?
- 17:33School leaders.
- 17:34Uh I think there's also a gap in school leaders who are knowledgeable about knowledgeable about special education um or can even support their teachers in this area.
- 17:44I think about school leaders being situated as like the instructional lead of the building.
- 17:50And if we're tasking teachers with the responsibility of being able to teach to all but not building up the professional development or the support around the teacher,
- 17:59like your leader doesn't have it.
- 18:00Uh We're hiring instructional coaches and they're mostly content specific or content focused and don't have that expertise or,
- 18:07or ability to flex the muscle in teaching towards learner variability who provides that training or support for teachers to do their job well or meet that moment to say it more succinctly.
- 18:18I think there's a few enabling conditions that I think are absolutely critical to kind of start as a jumping post for for having this conversation about inclusive education.
- 18:27I think it begins with like inclusive investment and that's from a range of stakeholders,
- 18:31not just in the building that's looping in parents,
- 18:33right?
- 18:34We talk about there's when we talk about special education and I like what Jessi mentioned earlier of like we see special education as something that is so unique and special and different.
- 18:45My favorite phrase is the Ruan,
- 18:47you guys remember that was a Crayola color seru colored unicorn.
- 18:50We see special education as the thing that somebody else with this magical wand is gonna come in and do and fix.
- 18:56And so we also have this mental model that that means it has to be away from the general education environment.
- 19:03So when we talk about inclusive investment,
- 19:04we have to also bring parents along uh in this belief that inclusion is also important.
- 19:10I think there's also a critical need to,
- 19:13to have a visioning um that start,
- 19:15that starts at the top at the district level and it's communicated as a priority and not an initiative,
- 19:20right?
- 19:20There's a difference.
- 19:21So a lot of times we see like we have an inclusion initiative and it's a two-year pilot that we're gonna try in three schools here and four schools there.
- 19:28And it isn't really like steeped in this idea or the culture of the district.
- 19:33When you have a vision,
- 19:33you also have to have goals for it,
- 19:35right?
- 19:35You have to like we what we measure what is saying,
- 19:39I forget the name of the saying but it talks about like the importance of us setting goals and like holding ourselves accountable to things that we say are important.
- 19:46Um And I think we need to have those districts need to have those in place.
- 19:49Schools need to have those in place.
- 19:51There's also this very real tension between strategic staffing and budgeting and funding.
- 19:56I would love to be able to wave wave a magic wand and give everyone infinite number of teachers with infinite amount of time for planning.
- 20:03That's not the case.
- 20:04So like your districts have to plan for that,
- 20:06they have to account for that in their funding and their staffing models IEP alignment.
- 20:11And then lastly like district data systems that are in place to inform the practice and let us know what's working well and where um and in order to shift that behavior that we're gonna have to really be honest with ourselves as professionals and as a system.
- 20:25Um if we actually have the skills,
- 20:27mindsets and knowledge to adopt the behaviors that create change.
- 20:31Yeah.
- 20:32Aurora, you're getting a taste of what it's like to be in space every day with Tiffany and me like we,
- 20:37it's a lot of taking so much control from me as like a a talkative extrovert not to jump in and be like,
- 20:46yeah.
- 20:46Yeah.
- 20:47Yeah.
- 20:47Yeah.
- 20:48No,
- 20:48totally.
- 20:49Totally.
- 20:50It's all really,
- 20:50really resonating with me.
- 20:51But yeah,
- 20:52I mean,
- 20:52just to give us some of your like your take on it.
- 20:55No,
- 20:55I,
- 20:56I mean,
- 20:56Tiffany and I talk about this stuff all the time.
- 20:58So everything she said times 100 I will just zoom us out and like,
- 21:03remind us sometimes when,
- 21:06you know,
- 21:06we're having a hard day at Blue Engine or I'm having a hard day or the team,
- 21:09like,
- 21:10like why is it so hard?
- 21:12It shouldn't be this hard.
- 21:14We have to remind ourselves that our public education system was one designed for a solo teacher.
- 21:23So when we're talking about co teaching,
- 21:25like it,
- 21:25it square around like,
- 21:27was it set up that way?
- 21:28Our system was also designed at a time when not all students had the right to education.
- 21:35And so there's so much legacy in the,
- 21:38in the way that that things were initially set up that we're still trying to untangle.
- 21:44So when things are hard,
- 21:45you have to ask yourself like,
- 21:47what are the mental models that play?
- 21:49What are the policies?
- 21:50What are the incentives because the system is working the way it was,
- 21:54it's supposed to,
- 21:55right?
- 21:56It doesn't mean it's right or it's equitable but it's working the way it's set up.
- 22:00So we're in there are there incentives policies,
- 22:04mental models that are leading to,
- 22:06to the disparity and outcomes that,
- 22:08that,
- 22:09you know,
- 22:09we've been talking about.
- 22:10And so three things that I'll say that I think a lot about I I lead our partnership development work.
- 22:16I talk to system leaders all the time that system wide vision and expectations that Tiff mentioned is really important.
- 22:24If you talk to a school leader,
- 22:26they'll tell you,
- 22:27I'm just trying to figure this out for myself.
- 22:29Like no one's telling me how to do this.
- 22:31OK.
- 22:31So number one,
- 22:33number two structures at a school level have to um support inclusive practices.
- 22:40We silo our support of educators,
- 22:44right?
- 22:44We departmentalize so that,
- 22:47you know,
- 22:48our,
- 22:48our learning specialists and our content specialists are not engaging in shared professional learning.
- 22:54We silo and you know,
- 22:57the support and accountability for uh affect effective teacher collaboration is missing,
- 23:03right?
- 23:03I was observed and evaluated as a solo teacher even though I was co teaching,
- 23:08I never got feedback on how to collaborate when it went well when it goes well,
- 23:13often say,
- 23:13wow,
- 23:13it's so lucky those two teachers jive instead of saying this is part of the job description,
- 23:19this is the professional expectation because our students deserve it.
- 23:23Like it's a you don't get to say,
- 23:25you know,
- 23:26you don't,
- 23:27you don't like this person or you know,
- 23:28you don't want to do that.
- 23:29You're like that is part of the job.
- 23:31And so we have mental models that we need to unpack and it shouldn't be happen.
- 23:36Stand.
- 23:36But the the the last thing I'll say is like being a part of a really effective inclusion team can change the experience fundamentally of teaching like we are our teacher workforce is young,
- 23:48they're tired and so there are a lot of positive benefits for teachers as well that I think don't get talked about enough.
- 23:55Yeah,
- 23:56I mean,
- 23:56you're already kind of leading me to my,
- 23:59to my next train of thought,
- 24:00which is this idea of the structure and model that our,
- 24:05you know,
- 24:05our current American public school system exists and is not designed to address the needs of all learners.
- 24:12So when we look a little bit further back,
- 24:14maybe when you know that the date ages or data,
- 24:17but maybe when we were coming up in school,
- 24:19you know,
- 24:20the model was a single educator and a class of 30 kids and that was the way it went.
- 24:24And then,
- 24:25you know,
- 24:25we go a little bit,
- 24:26we've evolved a little bit past that where now co teaching is,
- 24:31is an expectation,
- 24:33but at least in my experience and I'm sure many people listening can relate co teaching.
- 24:38Like you said,
- 24:38Jessi is like,
- 24:40throw these two teachers together and cote figure it out.
- 24:44You too,
- 24:45you know,
- 24:45you're cotes now there's,
- 24:47there's like very little kind of like preparation around there,
- 24:51which is what uh uh an organization like Blue Engine,
- 24:55which is why I'm so glad that we're talking to you folks today.
- 24:58You know,
- 24:59that's what,
- 25:00that's your goal,
- 25:01you support this,
- 25:02you know,
- 25:02uh implementation of effective collaboration and co teaching.
- 25:07So I want to also help our listeners understand and help me understand too,
- 25:11what are some of the barriers to,
- 25:13to good and effective co teaching?
- 25:15Right?
- 25:16We know what it looks like when it,
- 25:17when the teachers are jiving and it's going great.
- 25:20But what is in our way,
- 25:22what,
- 25:22what are the barriers that,
- 25:23that are not allowing us to fully like realize this vision?
- 25:27Yeah,
- 25:29so many barriers.
- 25:30Um I spoke to some of them,
- 25:31I'm gonna start at the highest level which is um sometimes we don't even get to engage in a dialogue about that question,
- 25:38Aurora because we,
- 25:40we get some pushback.
- 25:41So I want to address that first and then I want to talk a little bit more about like some of the barriers that like we really have uh the control of.
- 25:49So,
- 25:49first of all,
- 25:50if we're all on the same page that this 1 to 30 teacher model,
- 25:55the way that we're currently living out inclusion in a lot of spaces is still creating disproportionality.
- 26:03You know,
- 26:03students of color are more likely to be identified for special education at higher rates,
- 26:07more likely to be suspended um or expelled than their white peers,
- 26:12more likely to be placed in restrictive environments.
- 26:14You know,
- 26:15this is our current reality and we're,
- 26:16we're on track to perpetuate that if we don't slow down to reconsider that we need a new path forward.
- 26:22And I bring that up when you ask the about barriers to co teaching because one of the things that comes up before even talking about how co teaching can be improved is,
- 26:31you know,
- 26:31we often get told,
- 26:33well,
- 26:33I can't afford that for every classroom or I can't afford that for every school in my district.
- 26:38So,
- 26:39like,
- 26:39I can't talk about co teaching right now.
- 26:42And so before we get into like bars on co teaching,
- 26:45I just want to talk about equity for a minute.
- 26:47I,
- 26:48you know,
- 26:49my response to that is,
- 26:50it makes sense.
- 26:51I have a limited budget at Blue Engine too.
- 26:53Where are we putting our resources?
- 26:54Like resources are not infinite.
- 26:56And so if you do have resources,
- 26:59I want to talk about,
- 27:00you know,
- 27:01equity means that people get what they need,
- 27:04not everyone gets the same thing.
- 27:06And so if you do have,
- 27:07have the ability to do this somewhere,
- 27:10let's go back to that disproportionality and put those co teaching resources where they are most needed based on the data that is loud and clear.
- 27:20So if you can't do it everywhere,
- 27:22it doesn't mean that you can't do some of it in service of educational equity.
- 27:26And,
- 27:27you know,
- 27:27I'm gonna let Tiffany speak a little bit more about the barriers and specifically what we've learned about them and why our programming is designed to address that because,
- 27:37you know,
- 27:37we,
- 27:37we,
- 27:38we have services designed to ensure that um student achievement is being accelerated through effective co teaching.
- 27:45Um And we believe that all Cotes should be well prepared to universally design instruction that's accessible to all students,
- 27:53but to talk a little bit more about the specific barriers.
- 27:56Yeah,
- 27:56thanks Jessi.
- 27:57I think this also builds on the question that we were talking about earlier in terms of a new link conditions.
- 28:02So I think it's kind of goes really,
- 28:04really well hand in hand together.
- 28:06There's like a combination of issues related to mindset preparedness training and and the reality,
- 28:12staffing time and resources like are all barriers like we can align and agree up there.
- 28:18But at like as in a learning organization,
- 28:20we're positioning ourselves uh to meet classrooms,
- 28:23schools and systems exactly where they are,
- 28:25where they are at.
- 28:27Um And for some,
- 28:29they are already implementing a co teaching model and need to effectively support both teachers to implement that model effectively.
- 28:36Uh some are contemplating using a,
- 28:39a co teaching model and just need some support in developing some of the enabling conditions to make it uh truly an an effective situation.
- 28:47Um And then there are others that are just like incredibly unfamiliar or have like major barriers to implementing co teaching,
- 28:54giving their current structure,
- 28:55right?
- 28:56So we support with ways to increase the collaboration amongst all the educators in the building.
- 29:02Um And then ensuring all teachers have the skill set to support uh diverse learners.
- 29:07In our case,
- 29:08that Blue Engine,
- 29:08we focus on supporting again classes and school systems and implementing co teaching and we work across a range of school models,
- 29:15all with a single focus on evolving their current approach to inclusion uh specifically for students of color and emerging um language learners.
- 29:24So through our work,
- 29:25uh we've come to learn that there that there are a few uh barriers that rise to the top first being mindsets,
- 29:32right?
- 29:32So,
- 29:33developing mindsets that all teachers are responsible uh for uh their various learning needs in the classroom.
- 29:40So it's not my kids,
- 29:41your kids,
- 29:42all of our kids,
- 29:43the skills and training that I alluded to before uh develop the knowledge and the skills and educator.
- 29:48So they feel like they have the true ability to adapt instruction and working in collaboration with others to meet the various learning needs of kids in their classroom and ensuring that they're not reducing uh the rigor while doing so,
- 30:01right?
- 30:01There's this constant tension of balancing access with rigor.
- 30:05And then lastly,
- 30:06we support in the ways of life thinking about school leader development because I pointed to this earlier,
- 30:11it's,
- 30:11it's really critical um if not the school leader,
- 30:14but also an instructional lead at the building can support the,
- 30:17the teachers or the other instructional aids in the building around what it means to support students or with disabilities or with learning differences as well.
- 30:27Um So school leader development is an absolutely critical level um to understand how to promote and sustain inclusive practice.
- 30:34Yeah.
- 30:34Thank you both so much.
- 30:36For that.
- 30:36I mean,
- 30:36that's one of the great things about working with different organizations with different areas of expertise and look at things through a different lens,
- 30:43right?
- 30:44Which is something that I love about Blue Engine is that you're looking at,
- 30:47you know,
- 30:47co teaching and affect models through the lens of,
- 30:50let's talk about race,
- 30:51power and privilege.
- 30:52Let's talk about,
- 30:53you know,
- 30:53barriers and ways to move forward,
- 30:56which is,
- 30:56you know,
- 30:57sort of where I always kind of like to see our conversation.
- 31:00We've talked a lot about the barriers,
- 31:03the issues and,
- 31:05you know,
- 31:05we all know things that are going on right now in the world of education.
- 31:08There's,
- 31:08there's so many conversations and topics about the struggles,
- 31:12the challenges.
- 31:13So with all of that going on,
- 31:16why now,
- 31:17why is now the right time to push forward and,
- 31:21and move forward and,
- 31:23you know,
- 31:23bring special education to the forefront,
- 31:25you know,
- 31:25how do we move forward and,
- 31:27and why,
- 31:28why now it should have always been now,
- 31:33like the,
- 31:33now,
- 31:34you know,
- 31:35last week,
- 31:36one month ago when you're like now is the time it's always been the time.
- 31:39But let,
- 31:40let's do it.
- 31:41Oh,
- 31:41aurora.
- 31:42So one of the things that,
- 31:45that I,
- 31:45I wholeheartedly believe,
- 31:48and I feel like Tiffany is always saying it for the people in the back,
- 31:52but like diversity is the norm.
- 31:56Yeah.
- 31:56Right.
- 31:56And um I,
- 31:58and I experienced that through my own,
- 32:01you know,
- 32:03understanding of what it means to be the one in five though not having a formal,
- 32:08I formally diagnosed,
- 32:10you know,
- 32:10learning disability like diversity is the norm.
- 32:13And I feel like people are more ready for that conversation coming out of interrupted schooling with the pandemic.
- 32:20And acknowledging that um students are in such different places though many students always have been,
- 32:25it just feels like there's an openness to that conversation and there's an openness to the idea that we are all,
- 32:34we all need to be prepared,
- 32:36more prepared than we've ever been as educators to be able to meet the unique learning needs of students.
- 32:42So even though I've always felt like now is the time now is really the time because we're ready for it.
- 32:46And you know,
- 32:47we are all special educators,
- 32:49we need to be,
- 32:50if we believe that diversity is the norm,
- 32:52we all need to see ourselves in that way.
- 32:54All students are our students.
- 32:56We're all special educators,
- 32:57we all need to know the content and that's what I believe and the proof is in the pudding.
- 33:01And I wish,
- 33:02you know,
- 33:02this is a,
- 33:03I wish I could show you examples of the incredible work our partners are doing,
- 33:06but they are the living proof of what happens when this goes.
- 33:09Well,
- 33:10Tiffany can speak to some of the the results that our partners are having when they focus on this work.
- 33:16Um But that is why I feel so strongly.
- 33:19Now is the time.
- 33:20Um Now is the time Jeff?
- 33:22What do you think?
- 33:24Yeah,
- 33:24this is,
- 33:25thanks so much.
- 33:26I,
- 33:26I really appreciate this conversation that we've been having.
- 33:29Uh It made me think back a couple weeks ago,
- 33:32maybe end of January or so.
- 33:33Now I um I spoke at a conference on race,
- 33:37power and privilege in special education and I shared with the group that I was facilitating with something that I think is so fitting here.
- 33:43If the question is like,
- 33:44why this and why now I think I want folks to listening to consider this.
- 33:49Uh in 1954 the United States Supreme Court in Brown V Board of Education found that separate facilities are inherently unequal,
- 33:58right?
- 33:59So this landmark case is regarded as like the pivotal point in the American public education system and it led to the integration of schools nationwide and it was deemed like and,
- 34:09and in that,
- 34:10it was deemed that the separation of students on the basis of race as unconstitutional uh what was not protected.
- 34:16However,
- 34:17in that ruling was the separation of students on the basis of disability,
- 34:21right?
- 34:21And so we think about that in 1954.
- 34:25So blacks and,
- 34:25and since then,
- 34:26black students have been overrepresented in special education since then,
- 34:31right?
- 34:32And in the office of in the US Office of Civil Rights first started to sample school districts in around 1968.
- 34:39There's over literally 50 years of documented persistent disparity and inequity perpetuated against students who lay at the intersection of race and ability.
- 34:49So for question is like,
- 34:50why now?
- 34:51Like it's,
- 34:51it's way past time to center this work.
- 34:53It like the time is absolutely now it was 1954.
- 34:57That was,
- 34:58that was 1954.
- 35:00And then,
- 35:00and then the OCR started to collect the data on it in 1968.
- 35:04So there's like we have data since 1968 that like atrocities have been perpetuated against like by black and brown bodies um who live at the intersection of race and disability for well over 50 years.
- 35:17So I I I've always like astounded by that data point.
- 35:22And,
- 35:22and,
- 35:22and so when we think about like,
- 35:23how,
- 35:25why is it important?
- 35:26Why now I think some,
- 35:27when I look at the work of our partners,
- 35:29I'm always like blown away like Blue Engine.
- 35:31We've been chipping away at this and we have so many positive um data points to,
- 35:37to,
- 35:37to,
- 35:37to rely on 92% of teachers after working with Blue Engine agree that all of their students can understand challenging concepts compared to 50% percent of that uh of teachers nationally,
- 35:50right?
- 35:50So we talked about those 50% of teachers earlier feeling prepared,
- 35:5492% which I think is absolutely incredible of the teachers after working with Blue Engine say this 82% of Blue Engine teachers report that they feel confident in their ability to,
- 36:04to teach diverse learners.
- 36:05Right earlier,
- 36:06I mentioned that only 17% of teachers surveyed by NCLD felt this 82%.
- 36:12I'm gonna say that again for the people in the bag,
- 36:1482% of teachers who work with engine coaches,
- 36:17believe this on the last data point,
- 36:19I'll leave you with this like this idea.
- 36:20Like 92% of the teachers who work with us report feeling confident in their ability to differentiate instruction to reach students at different levels in their classroom.
- 36:30And so I think like the proof is in the pudding and that that like this is possible,
- 36:34we can change the time,
- 36:35we can cultivate mindsets,
- 36:36we can give you the skill sets and the knowledge to be able to do this.
- 36:39Well,
- 36:39I think there just has to be a paired sense of urgency all around for sure.
- 36:43Yeah,
- 36:43I really like that.
- 36:44I do that.
- 36:45Can I jump in to give a shout out here?
- 36:47Shout out,
- 36:49I look at data all the time.
- 36:50I'm so deeply proud of that data,
- 36:52but just like shout out all day long to the teachers who under like extraordinary circumstances are still showing up every day,
- 37:01pushing their own mindsets and and shifting practice and service of students.
- 37:05So shout out to our teachers to the Blue Engine coaches.
- 37:08I think we have some great people on that.
- 37:12The best,
- 37:13the best.
- 37:14Thank you.
- 37:15Because that is,
- 37:16I mean,
- 37:16the the numbers are astounding.
- 37:19I mean,
- 37:19it,
- 37:19it goes to show that the effort is there,
- 37:22the will or the desire is there,
- 37:25right?
- 37:25The will is there the,
- 37:26you know,
- 37:27people don't,
- 37:27people don't become teachers and enter this profession to do a bad job.
- 37:33I think that there's sometimes this national kind of narrative.
- 37:37Sometimes there's like this weird kind of vibe of like teachers are doing a bad job because they're XYZ.
- 37:44And I think that it shows that you don't go into this,
- 37:47this field to because you don't care.
- 37:50Absolutely.
- 37:51But the system is,
- 37:53is often stacked against you as a student,
- 37:56as a teacher,
- 37:57as a parent,
- 37:58as an administrator.
- 38:00So,
- 38:00you know,
- 38:00this,
- 38:01this conversation today is just a small kind of,
- 38:05you know,
- 38:05peek into like the the world of,
- 38:09of addressing.
- 38:10But addressing this disparity,
- 38:11I think at least talking about it or listening to to it is a,
- 38:14is a great kind of first that at least and the work that y'all are doing at at Blue Engine is,
- 38:21is just incredible.
- 38:22So it's wonderful to have you as partners.
- 38:25So before we go,
- 38:28if somebody's listening and they're like,
- 38:29wow,
- 38:29Blue Engine,
- 38:30that sounds amazing.
- 38:31I want to be part of that 92% or I want my,
- 38:34my school to be part of that 92%.
- 38:36Um What can people do to get involved,
- 38:39stay involved,
- 38:40connect with y'all?
- 38:41Yeah.
- 38:42Follow us on linkedin.
- 38:43That's where we share our primary vehicle for sharing content.
- 38:47But reach out to us,
- 38:49connect with me on linkedin.
- 38:50Connect with Tiff at linkedin.
- 38:52You can find us easily there,
- 38:54email me,
- 38:55email Tiff Jessi at blue engine dot org.
- 38:57Tiffany at blue engine dot org.
- 38:58Or if it's easier to remember,
- 39:00partnerships at Blue engine dot org will also get you a conversation with someone um as well,
- 39:07but we are excited to connect with others to learn what's working in other spaces.
- 39:12So even if folks aren't thinking about,
- 39:15you know,
- 39:15engaging in that way,
- 39:17uh We,
- 39:17we,
- 39:18I think I said this last time we vary.
- 39:19We are an organization that is all about teams and collaboration.
- 39:23Like we want to team and we want to collaborate complex,
- 39:26you know,
- 39:27problems need complex solutions.
- 39:30So please reach out to us,
- 39:32get connected.
- 39:34Yeah,
- 39:34and then I'll just plug for our website if folks wanted to go over there and like just read on the excellent things that we have going on in our models.
- 39:41You can go to Blue Engine dot org.
- 39:44Awesome.
- 39:45Thank you so much,
- 39:46Jessi.
- 39:47Thank you so much Tiffany for joining us today.
- 39:49This was really a fantastic opportunity to talk and pick your brains a little bit.
- 39:53Absolutely.
- 39:54Thank you so much for having us.
- 39:56Thanks Aurora.
- 39:59That's it for us today,
- 40:00folks.
- 40:01Thank you to Jessi Brunken and Tiffany Galloway from Blue Engine.
- 40:04I'm Aurora from EALA and this was a Deeper Dive with Blue Engine.