Latest / And Now For Something Completely Machinima / S6 E245 The Horror of Classic Fallout: When the Vault Becomes the Threat (Oct 2026)
Transcript
- Ricky Grove 01:00 Hello, everybody. Welcome to and now for something completely machinima, the podcast about machinima, real-time video, and sundry topics. I'm here with my pals Tracy Harwood, Phil Rice, and Damian Valentine. Hello, everyone. Tracy Harwood 01:17 Hello. Ricky Grove 01:18 This week we've got a very interesting pick by Phil Rice. Phil, why don't you tell us about it? Phil Rice 01:26 Yeah, the the algorithm delivered this one up to me a little while back, and I'm a big fan of Fallout, so that's what attracted me to start watching. But I liked the format. This is. It's done basically. It's called Fallout Horror, or let me see what it's actually the actual title. The horror, the horror of classic Fallout, and the creator's name is Lando, and that's basically what he does. As far as I can tell, that's what he does on his channel, is these documentary style dives into video game lore, or or in some cases the history of how the game was made, which is which is a lot of what the the this Fallout themed one covers is the origins of the game from you know the it basically started as a kind of a after-hours side project of developers working for someone else on something else, and then it became, of course, this this bigger-than-life franchise that it is now. So I found it very interesting. It's there. There are some things in it that he had to correct, which is probably stock and trade for solo documentary filmmakers, right? If you have a team, then someone will catch these things. But the one that made me first kind of wrinkle my forehead is only because of the benefit, I guess, of age, but he he cited Cormac McCarthy's *The Road* as an influence for the the world of *Fallout* which that that doesn't timeline doesn't quite add up. The road the road the road came considerably after the original *Fallout* did, and he ends up correcting that. I think it's in the pinned comment, and each of his documentaries. There's something, there are things, little things like that, where he got something wrong. But for me, it doesn't detract from the the enjoyment of it at all. And it kind of, I'm a more recent comer to Fallout, mainly Fallout Four. I dabbled with Fallout Three. This gets back to kind of the roots of that story. Some of you have probably seen the the Amazon TV show as well, which kind of takes it in a slightly different direction, plays with things in a different way, so it was interesting to see this origin world and what it really looked like. And it it seems like that the original Fallout there was much more emphasis on the horror side of things than there was on the. It's kind of a mix of horror and humor nowadays, and that really shows itself in the TV show. I think that it's kind of there's kind of a zaniness to it, but it's dark still, right? Well, the original as this digs into and how that evolves from there, a lot more emphasis on the dark horror side of it, and I just I just found that interesting. Found his presentation well done and engaging, and and was wondering what you guys thought of it. Ricky Grove 04:43 Is there a specific genre for this type of documentary, game documentary? Is it is there a word or a phrase that describes it? Phil Rice 04:53 Not one that I know of, Ricky Grove 04:54 because there's been quite a few. I've seen several on. YouTube, where they, where a a gamer slash filmmaker will take a favorite game and go back on its origins and roots, and and and maybe even put some interviews in and things like that, like a personal essay on on on a game. Some of them suffer from nostalgia, where they see the game with a sort of rosy lens, whereas it maybe not was not like that. I didn't get that feeling from this documentary at all. Yeah, Phil Rice 05:33 me neither. Ricky Grove 05:34 I thought the guy was very realistic and straightforward, and I appreciated that that he saw the horror elements in it. I think many games were from early game history were affected by horror because that was during a horror boom at the time, and I think the market was really supporting horror. So you'll find a lot of those early games emphasize the horror side of it, but I really enjoyed it. I learned a lot about a game. I haven't. I've actually tried to play it, but I never really finished it. I don't know why. Probably because my restless mind, I move on to something else, you know. Before, but I really found it interesting, and and the bigger thing is, it made me want to play it again, go back and look at that world because I've always been impressed with games that create a world. The gameplay is secondary to me in a way because I almost see them like novels. They, I want to be inside of this. That's why Elden Ring is so impactful for me because it has this world that is just so filled with strangeness and interest and newness and nature and beauty and ugliness, and it's fascinating to be able to move around in that world, to be inside of it, so to speak. So I thought it was a great pick, and and I enjoyed it very much. Damien Valentine 07:05 I I'm going to say it's like very similar to Ricky. I'll start off with I did try and play this game as well when it got released, and I never finished it. I liked what I saw, but and and this documentary kind of touches on it. You have a very strict countdown of how quickly you can finish it? If you fail, then you lose the game. And it took me half that time just to find the first town to visit. And then I kept playing, and I kept dying a lot. And I thought, you know, I'm not actually. I like this game. I like the world that it's portraying, but I'm not enjoying that element of it because how do you possibly finish it if half the time takes? And I didn't really go all over the place. I just kind of went in a straight line, and I ran down half the game's time limit. I thought, well, how can you possibly finish this if that's done? So, I played it a few times, but always came to the same conclusion. So this was very interesting to see what I missed out on, and like Ricky, it did kind of make me think, well, maybe I should give it another go now. I'm a bit older, and maybe. or patience for this these kind of things. Ricky Grove 08:26 I don't know. Some I I play games slowly as well, and I think it's a mistake for them initially to have put a time limit on. But because there are always going to be players who stop and go, "Wow, look at that! That's pretty cool. Five minutes later, they go. Oh shit! I've got a time limit. I gotta, I gotta get back into the game. Yeah, they don't make allowances for that sort of play, and I think that's a mistake. Damien Valentine 08:49 Yeah, maybe this one that I Phil Rice 08:51 think. One I think they've corrected, by the way, on the subsequent chapters. Fallout Three, Fallout Four, is very open world, and you can, you could put the main quest off forever if you want to, and just Damien Valentine 09:04 yeah, Phil Rice 09:05 live in that world. So yeah, they they seem to have learned from that. That was a pretty unforgiving element to the original. Damien Valentine 09:12 Yeah, I think there should be a difficulty option. So if you want that the tension of having a limited amount of time, you've got that. But if you just want to smart away, yeah, if you want the the experience of just going out and exploring this world they've created, let them turn off the timer or set a very long timer, so you're not under constant pressure. Ricky Grove 09:31 That's a smart way to deal with it. Damien Valentine 09:33 Yeah, because I've played other games where there's been a time timer to it, but it's not been so restrictive that you can't enjoy the game because you're constantly thinking I can't do anything other than very quickly focus on completing the main storyline, because I like to explore the games. And if there's a photo mode, I'll often pause the game and spend ages playing around with the photo mode. You know. Taking the pictures. Obviously, this is long before photo mode existed, but I like to be able to explore and look at things and look at all the effort that went into designing the game and building the world, finding details that you only find if you're looking for it, and they help make the world feel more alive. So even if you're just walking through and you don't pay attention, it's just there. I mean, if you look at the background behind this, this is from Cyberpunk, and there's a window and there's smoke out the window. Unless you stop and pay attention, you probably don't even notice it's there. But it makes the world feel alive, and the screens you can stop and see those screens and the advertising products that are part of the game world, and you know, there's like there's Ricky Grove 10:45 a word for that. It's called verisimilitude. Damien Valentine 10:49 Okay. Yeah, but yeah, I appreciate all of that. So anyway, this documentary taught me a lot about the game. It showed me things I missed, and of course, I never played the second game because I thought, well, I didn't really finish the first one, so I'm not going to play the second one. I played the third one because I knew that it was a completely different development team, so it was a way to get back into that world, and it wouldn't necessarily be the same. And I did watch some of the TV show, which I enjoyed, but was it because I was going through a lot of health problems? That kind of horror wasn't really something I was in the right mindset for at the time. I need to go back and watch it. So Ricky Grove 11:31 yeah, I did Damien Valentine 11:31 like it. I kind of appreciate again the effort that went into to bringing that gay car to life in a TV show. Yeah, Ricky Grove 11:38 yeah, yeah, Damien Valentine 11:39 yeah. Anyway, this is a really good documentary about the Fallout game, so I kind of have to look at check out his channel to see what else he's covered and maybe some games that I have actually played and know more about. Phil Rice 11:50 Actually, one of the other games that that he covered in similar fashion is Red Dead Redemption Two, focusing less on the making of it and more of just on all the lore built into that game. The only reason I didn't pick that is because we've done a decent amount of Red Dead Redemption, but there's very little Fallout, so I thought this would be unique in that regard. But it's worth watching as well if you enjoyed this. It's Damien Valentine 12:14 worth giving it a shout out just like that. Tracy Harwood 12:17 Yeah, yeah. Do you know I love this. I've never played these games. I Phil Rice 12:22 thought you might. Tracy Harwood 12:23 I really liked what he's done with this. I'd call it a kind of docu essay, maybe. I don't know. It is an essay. It's more of an essay, I think, than a documentary. And I mean, I've done quite a detailed analysis of it. If you bear with me, Ricky Grove 12:42 Always. Tracy Harwood 12:42 Okay. Well, I mean, the first thing that I thought struck me really was the the particular image that you associate with Fallout, and it's and it's really easy to recognize it, which is that kind of cheerful advertising and the kind of the retro styling and this kind of power armor that you sort of recognize with it, and I think what interests me about the way that this has been done is how Lando kind of moves our attention towards the anxiety underneath all that familiarity, and through this 12 minutes of essay, he does that so well. Obviously, it's you know assembled from kind of gameplay. He's got in there some animated dialog scenes, some cinematic material, and kind of other imagery which he's used to sort of supplement what he's presenting. I'm assuming it's not all from the game. I think the film making kind of happens through juxtaposition of all those connecting images, and I think that's what gives us kind of plenty to discuss, really. Even though it's not kind of a fictional short, but more of a sort of explanation of the story and its impacts as a as a game, really. I think the structure of it is really accessible. We start with this kind of original games development, the move into choice and consequence. We encounter the master, and then broaden out towards things like nuclear anxiety and corporate control, and the visual design, and then the soundtrack. I think all of those things he's got something really interesting to say about. I think the progression through that is one of its strengths as a as an essay. I think it begins with a with a game that we can examine and gradually opens up to these much larger questions about about the world. Really, that the the that the game imagines, the horror becomes much more interesting when it moves beyond these kind of grotesque creatures. I mean, the the vault, as I. Understood. It was supposed to offer protection, but once, as is portrayed here, protection becomes a mechanism for controlling and experimenting on people. That sort of reassuring architecture becomes frightening in its own right, and I think that's the point. The film has something kind of more substantial to say it connects fear with institutions with you know with advertising and the and the sale of security and those ideas really give it its imagery a kind of a purpose beyond reminding us of these kind of memorable enemies I guess visually, I think the essay binds its different materials together with really distressing framing. The you know the sort of the scratches, the scan lines, the color treatments. You know they they they are the things that hold all the different things. You know they give it a sense of a time period, and it's clearly not from the same time period. We kind of see the game's interfaces, the close-ups of of the characters and whatnot, the desert landscapes, the propaganda, the nuclear destruction, all have this sort of same kind of common treatment, my reading is that it makes the essay resemble a kind of a damaged record, effectively, I suppose, of a damaged world. And there's a kind of a relationship between the subject and the presentation. We're looking at the remnants, and the images themselves appear kind of worn. I think that's a really clever device, but I'd also question that decision actually, because applying the same treatment to everything can make the different sources feel equally historical or equally authentic. I guess a game scene and an external illustration may belong together emotionally, but they actually have very different evidential values. So for me, that's kind of an interesting tension in this video essay form. I think the editing can sort of establish the persuasive connection. Actually, though, before we've even really had time to sort of ask whether it establishes a fact or one. So I guess I don't know what your thoughts are about the the visual treatment, but that was something that kind of struck me immediately. Perhaps come back to that in a minute. The master sequence, I think, is particularly useful as as an example of kind of letting the source material carry carry the argument. I mean, Lando introduces the character and gives the space to the original dialog, I suppose, about unity and and the the removal of difference. Tracy Harwood 18:01 My interpretation is that the frightening thing is the combination of these physical grotesqueness and and a kind of rationale for it. I mean, this being has a theory of how to repair humanity, and the solution requires humanity to surrender its differences. That gives the sequence political dimension as well. I think as well as well as this kind of bodily one. The language is promising survival. The character's appearance kind of makes the cost of that promise fairly visible. I think one prominent commentator said the original, or he reads original Fallout as approaching cosmic horror. They describe the accumulating threat, the cult's references to the master, and the eventual encounter with something grotesque and overwhelming. I think that's actually quite a productive reading of it. It directs us towards the process of discovery, and the the rumors and incomplete knowledge can kind of prepare an encounter long before a creature appears on the screen, and I think that's that's portrayed really well in this. And I guess it's a you know it's a question that we come back to quite a lot in some of the films that we review. Is it necessary for there to be a monster for us to feel fear, I suppose. I think the ending gives Lando's argument another strong example. The protagonist saves the vault and is then excluded from it. The journey has changed the person who was sent out, and home can no longer accommodate them, and for me, that's that's more affecting than a than a straightforward victory. Actually, it makes survival carry a loss. The place you protected does not necessarily remain a place where you can belong. I'd push back on that. Essays sort of broader tendency towards hopelessness, though, because I think the narration sometimes presents humanity's return to its worst behavior as inevitable. I think that's quite a strong interpretation, and I think really I would have liked more room for the tension between the claim and the game's possibilities for choice to come through. I think there's also a distinction between the first two games being made. Lando does acknowledge the Fallout Two becomes more eccentric and comic. I'd have welcomed a little more sort of exploration of how that shift changes the horror, rather than allowing sort of classic fallout to become this sort of one largely unified mood, and then there's a section on early computer imagery, which I think is especially relevant to machinima. Around the seven and a half minute mark, the essay discusses the uncanny quality of the games and the way technological limitations leave gaps for the imagination, I really like that idea. An image can be detailed enough to suggest a living face, and still strange enough to resist that impression. I think the original animated dialog heads. I think they they offer a very different encounter from a sort of a modern character moving smoothly through a fully rendered scene. And Lando also discusses the physical clay models behind those faces. I think the yeah I think the precise production you know and the and the and the narration that that you know it's claiming to sort of make a really kind of well, they're they're just very interesting. I think the the connection between the physical making and the digital character imagery is really kind of useful subject for us to sort of think about in terms of what he's what he's saying about how this plays out, I think there's a broader creative question, which is really whether realism always serves the scene, and sometimes the incomplete or awkward image gives a viewer much more room to imagine something disturbing, and that's again something that we've talked about a lot. These are things that he's sort of alluding to in his narration, and then the soundtrack section is another really substantial part of the argument that he's making. He credits Mark Morgan and describes an environment of sort of sirens and metal and water and drums and kind of coded signals, and he treats these sounds as traces of the world that disappeared. I think what interests me is the suggestion that atmosphere can carry history. Tracy Harwood 22:52 A landscape doesn't need to explain every event if its sounds gives us a sense of what has happened there, and I think, I think that's that that discussion, that sort of commentary, really kind of reflects a lot of the things that we talk about as well in terms of the use of sound design. I mean, I suppose really overall, I think, you know, I think it's a really engaging piece of interpretive filmmaking. It gives us a clear route through the material and draws our attention really to the relationship between horror and the institutional control that he's referring to, and also visual uncertainty that's being portrayed, and the and the soundscape and the the way that that has been designed to portray what what's kind of going on. I I actually think the strongest lesson for Machina is what selection can do. I think existing footage becomes new work because the filmmaker is really deciding what we should notice and how those details should relate to each other. The reservation, of course, is at the same persuasive power. Simply, you know, can it can it just complicate the history of it? Possibly, I'd say that's probably what we're seeing in some of this. I guess you know, from this, you'd certainly have a have a think about having another go at this, as you've both, you know, all of you've said. Really, does it inspire you to want to sort of play it? It actually inspires me to want to go and explore it, actually, because I think it's the way it's portraying what's what's going on is worthy of spending some time just sort of being immersed in it and having a a think about Damien Valentine 24:49 it, but not too much time because otherwise you die. Tracy Harwood 24:51 Well, indeed. But then, you know, because I don't play the games, it doesn't really come to me in that way. But yeah, I mean, I really enjoyed thinking. About what it what it was what it was doing, what it was portraying, and how it was working as a as a story, and whether it actually reflects very closely how how you might experience the game. Ultimately, I'm not that sure about, if I'm honest. But it's certainly interesting to sort of see how it's been put together as as a narrative arc and a and a reflective essay of clearly Lando's experience of it. So yeah, that's my thoughts about it. Ricky Grove 25:30 Great insight as usual. One Phil Rice 25:32 of the things that it got me thinking about too was you know a lot of the really all of the anxiety of the game is rooted in it. There's kind of a foreknowledge, a prerequisite that's implied there, which is you understand Tracy Harwood 25:52 the Phil Rice 25:52 Cold War nuclear threat, Tracy Harwood 25:55 which we Phil Rice 25:55 all grew up under, right? We know that. It's it's fascinating to me how Fallout continues to apparently resonate with a generation that's come into gaming that's both that's of this millennium, you know that like has no direct knowledge of that whatsoever. Only their parents do. They have no understanding of. There's still nuclear fears, right? But it's not running drills at your school to crawl under your desk kind of stuff, you know. I mean, it was palpable. Yeah, that real sense that yeah, the end is coming, right? And so this plays on that in a similar way to how that the comic book series, The Watchmen, is built on that and takes a similar approach. It basically creates an alternate history that essentially explores what if this went really wrong. You know, those kinds of stories are are fascinating to me because it's it's. I mean, we've we've talked so many times on the show that science fiction is really the ideal realm to explore those kind of scary what ifs, but in a way that feels relatively safe, you know. And so I feel like that that part of what that team who put this world together originally were reacting to was, you know, if they they made this in '97, so they probably started developing it. Maybe they came up with the ideas '94, '95, and you know, grew in that time. So the the Cold War is still like in right there, big and living memory. Yes, yes. So, and I think for people old enough to be paying attention in that immediate post Cold War era, it was pretty clear that the the the the threat, the looming threat of nukes and what would come after that, if anything, had not gone away at all, you know, because the weapons were still there, and if anything, now we weren't certain who had them, you know. So, and the whole mutually assured destruction thing that amazingly we were leaning on for well, that's why it won't happen. Now that's not there, right? So in some ways it got scarier, and they were tapping into that. But and yet the I don't feel like that that that sense of how big and real that threat is can possibly be understood by a very young generation. Let's say born post born post 2000. I don't think there's any way that they can really get that, but this still resonates. So it almost like that there's that those deeper themes that you you called attention to, Tracy, of the the distrust of institutions. I mean, my goodness, that's at a boiling point right now. Speaker 2 29:03 Yeah, Phil Rice 29:03 almost globally, definitely all throughout the West. This sense of we can't trust our governments is like through the roof. You know, that's implicit in this, and the TV show calls a lot more attention to this than the original story did. In the TV show, the villain is not a government. The villain is a corporation. The corporation was behind the whole thing. The whole thing was planned. The vaults were never about security. They were sold to these oligarchs, with the understanding that these are your test labs, and we're going to get people to pay. Tracy Harwood 29:41 Yeah, Phil Rice 29:42 be your guinea pigs. You know, it's just amazing, and it's all attributed to this kind of looming sense of corporate evil. And yes, it got out of hand, and now no one's at the controls. But that's who started all of this, right? So that's the villain. Now that is an idea of a villain. That the younger generation they do relate to; those feelings are real. There is this real sense of some of these big corporations, and frankly, that you know, OpenAI's CEO doesn't really help them in that regard because he's creepy and weird, and and you know, Zuckerberg people speculate he's an android. He's so weird, and Elon Musk, of course. So there's all this real sense of these are basically supervillain archetypes running these things that give the impression that they're more powerful than countries were. You know, Tracy Harwood 30:37 well they are. Phil Rice 30:37 And and this game, the ideas underneath this game basically survived that transition from you can really only get this if you know know the Cold War and those fears to nah it's it still adapts you know so it's yeah it really got me thinking about a lot of that stuff I I enjoyed it I'm glad that you guys did too Damien Valentine 30:59 I'd like to add something to that as well is because so the the threat of the Cold War is obviously long gone now, but you turn on the news, and there's almost certainly some kind of global event happening, and it's usually a big disaster. It's a war, or terrorism, or disease, or something, and you're just constantly bombarded by these global disasters, and it's been like that for years. Like sometimes even feels like apocalyptic level events, and you. So the war threat's gone, but people are growing up now. The current generation, they're going to have that experience. So when they play Fallout, that's what's going through their mind. So it's different threats, but it's still there, looming over them. And the way that the news works now is 24/7. Unless you just turn off the news and don't look at it at all, you're constantly going to be aware that bad things are happening all the time. And part of it is because bad news sells. You're not going to get headlines. This wonderful thing's just happened because no one will read that. They want the they want the disasters and the bad news and all of that. Because well, also Ricky Grove 32:13 also less thoughtful people will assume that that's what the world is, and will forget that there's a whole other aspect to it that's not being reported. Damien Valentine 32:23 Yeah, yeah, Phil Rice 32:24 and it doesn't help too that even what would have once been thought of as regional conflicts are dressed up and portrayed as if they have Tracy Harwood 32:35 yes, indeed, Phil Rice 32:36 global consequences. Right, and you must weigh in on what you feel about the two sides of this regional conflict. You must, and how you weigh in on that determines who you are as a person. Right? It's just it's this whole in in in marketing they they talk about funnels, right? And you're ultimately trying to drive things one way. And yeah, the the the bifurcation. of us as as people has it's a funnel system, and you you're forced. You must make a public statement. I say must, but of course you don't have to. But the the pressure is you must weigh in. You must have an opinion. You can't you can't say it doesn't affect me, or I just don't really care either way. You can't do that. They will force you into one of the funnels if you do, right? Even Damien Valentine 33:28 if you've never even heard of the place that conference happening before it started. Speaker 3 33:32 Yeah, yeah, Phil Rice 33:33 and you're right. It all comes down to what what you mentioned, Damian. That that that's what sells. That's what keeps eyeballs where they want them, and so yeah. And the younger generation, I think, gets that maybe better than we Ricky Grove 33:46 do. Yeah, I'd like to point out that we chose a machinima, which was a documentary about a move, a game that was made in '97, and have talked about the themes of it. And here we are talking about contemporary history and ideas in politics, so something worked in that. That's quite a compliment Phil Rice 34:07 to the film. Yeah, I agree. Yeah, isn't that? I agree. Tracy Harwood 34:10 Indeed. Phil Rice 34:10 Yeah. So anyway, yeah, we hope to see more of of Logan's work if he's still indeed. Tracy Harwood 34:16 There's Ricky Grove 34:17 a link to the movie. You can watch it and to his channel, if you have ideas, if you think we're just out of our minds with our thoughts and completely wrong-headed, upbred us at talk at completely machinima.com. Thank you, Damian and Phil, Tracy, and myself, Ricky Grove. We'll be back next week with a very interesting choice, which I'm looking forward to talking about. So that's it. Check out completelymicchinima.com for more info and our show notes, and we'll see you next time. Damien Valentine 34:54 Bye.