Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #50: Political Apathy - Why it's Dangerous and How We Can Fix it
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:03I'm your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:05Today, we're gonna talk about political apathy and why it's a problem.
- 0:10How do we measure political apathy?
- 0:13Which citizens tend to be more apathetic?
- 0:15In what ways does political apathy manifest?
- 0:19Why are some voters apathetic?
- 0:21And why does political apathy pose such a threat, including unintentionally contributing
- 0:27to our nation's polarization?
- 0:30All this and more is on tap for today's podcast.
- 0:33But first, today is the fiftieth episode of the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:38Hooray.
- 0:39Shots, shots, shots.
- 0:42Thank you all for being on this journey by contributing your viewership slash listenership
- 0:48and sharing this podcast with others you know, and please continue to do so.
- 0:52And thank you to all the guests I've had on this podcast so far.
- 0:57I think this is an especially good choice to cover for a milestone episode of this podcast.
- 1:03It's a this political apathy is something I have particular concerns about in my work
- 1:10because today's political climate and discourse struggle with polarization and toxicity.
- 1:16But there's another major issue that affects our ability to find real solutions to our
- 1:23nation's problems, and that's political apathy.
- 1:26While there are many people that are too invested to the point where their political
- 1:31views become their identity and any difference in opinion is perceived as an existential
- 1:36threat, There are also people who, for various reasons, choose to rarely or never engage with
- 1:43politics at all.
- 1:45They, a lot of times, just don't care.
- 1:48And this political apathy can unintentionally exacerbate the problems we see today in
- 1:54politics, including polarization.
- 1:57And political apathy is a major concern of mine in my work in politics.
- 2:02In some ways, people are responsible for how much they should be invested in politics.
- 2:08And sometimes the rationale for choosing not to engage with politics is a cop out.
- 2:13I've heard some pretty ridiculous reasons for people saying why they don't vote or otherwise
- 2:19get involved in politics.
- 2:21But there are also understandable reasons for people to or that people have to distance
- 2:29themselves from politics as well.
- 2:31And we need to fully understand said reasons to help fix our political discourse because
- 2:38political apathy unintentionally contributes to a lot of the problems we see today with
- 2:42polarization and toxicity in particular.
- 2:46So today, we're gonna go ahead and dive into all things political apathy and how we can
- 2:54address these problems.
- 2:55So let's go.
- 2:58First of all, need to actually define and measure voter apathy in some way.
- 3:05Divining apathy is I've talked about it in previous episodes when it comes to defining
- 3:11things or the fancy way to describe it in academic terms is operationalize is you you you
- 3:17need to have some idea of a term needs to be sort of somewhat agreed upon to actually define
- 3:24it, to know what we're talking about.
- 3:26I can't quite give you a full on there's no one true definition of apathy.
- 3:33I'm gonna use the phrase politically apathetic or just apathetic to describe this.
- 3:38And and and some political observers may they may call politically apathetic people passive
- 3:45citizens.
- 3:46There's no one true definition.
- 3:48But for our purposes, this is just generally going to describe people who, for one reason or
- 3:53another, do not engage much with politics.
- 3:56Maybe they think politics is boring or unimportant.
- 4:00It's not boring.
- 4:01It's not unimportant, but a lot of people think it is.
- 4:04Or they might otherwise be interested in politics or think it is important, but they
- 4:09feel the political system doesn't work for people like them.
- 4:12They feel it's a waste of their time because they just can't have some sort of impact.
- 4:18And we're gonna get into those reasons some more, but there are several different ways to
- 4:25gauge how much citizens care about politics.
- 4:30And when you're trying to measure it, some of these reasons, it might look like it's apathy
- 4:37where they just don't care, but it may it might be due to other circumstances too.
- 4:42A lot of times, though, it is an indication that voters don't care much or at all.
- 4:47And I'll I'll describe some of these possibilities where it might not actually be a
- 4:51matter of apathy, but it's still functionally is apathy.
- 4:55And a lot of times it is a lack of caring, but it's not really trying to blame people here.
- 5:02To some extent, it is their responsibility to responsibility to care about politics, but
- 5:09there is also, again, some understandable reasons people have for not wanting to engage
- 5:16in politics, and we need to address those.
- 5:18But also want to make clear that there are some levels of apathy.
- 5:25It's not just simply, I care about politics versus I don't care about politics.
- 5:30They might care about only specific parts of politics or only certain elections.
- 5:35They might care just about voting, but they don't otherwise get involved in campaigns or
- 5:42consume a whole lot of political media, or they might do those things, but only for specific
- 5:47elections.
- 5:48Or there could be some life life circumstances that lessen how much somebody cares about a an
- 5:57an election or some other political event at a particular point in time.
- 6:01So some of it can just be a matter of timing as well.
- 6:04So it gets a little bit more complicated, but we're gonna try to make this as simple as
- 6:12possible to understand.
- 6:15So some of the ways that we measure political apathy.
- 6:21One way, probably the most, probably the easiest way to measure it is when we look at
- 6:28voter turnout rates.
- 6:30Lower voter turnout rate suggests that people are more apathetic.
- 6:34People who are apathetic about politics are probably not going to show up to vote.
- 6:40It's the most basic way people can get involved.
- 6:44All you have to do is just go to a polling place as long as you're registered to vote and
- 6:48cast your ballot and then you're done.
- 6:51You technically don't even really need to research anything.
- 6:54Obviously, obviously, you should research things, but you technically don't even need to
- 6:57do that.
- 6:59But you also have different rates of turnout depending on the race.
- 7:03Presidential elections are going to get the highest rates of turnout and then midterms will
- 7:08get less than that.
- 7:09And then odd year elections will get less than that.
- 7:11And then that's not even counting primaries.
- 7:13A lot of local elections have elections in months that are not November.
- 7:19They might be in April or May or June where the election is decided that most voters just care
- 7:26about the presidential election.
- 7:27They think that that's the only one that matters or that's the only one they're actually
- 7:32willing to get invested in, but they don't care about midterms or odd year elections or
- 7:38primaries and so on.
- 7:42And even within the same election, races lower on the ballot will see much fewer votes being
- 7:50cast.
- 7:50This is what we call ballot drop off.
- 7:52So if you have, like, 20 different things that you're voting on, you might vote on the first
- 7:57five, ten, but then the last 10 elections or races that are on the ballot are gonna have a
- 8:06lot fewer people deciding on them even if they voted on things at the top.
- 8:12So and then that's that's typically local races like mayor or city council and also races that
- 8:22are for offices with a specified responsibility like a local judge or a school board might not
- 8:29be seen as important to certain voters.
- 8:32And we'll talk a little bit more about why that might be the case in a little bit.
- 8:37But how might this not be apathy but still mistaken as such?
- 8:41Now, in fairness, when it comes to primaries, some states use what's called a closed primary
- 8:47where independents cannot vote in them and people only people that are registered with
- 8:53that party can vote in that election.
- 8:55So if it's a Republican primary that's closed, only Republicans can vote in it.
- 8:58If it's a Democratic primary that's closed, only Democrats can vote in it.
- 9:01So if third parties don't have a primary, well, too bad they can't vote in that.
- 9:05Independents who have no party at all can't vote in any of those primaries unless it's for
- 9:11a nonpartisan race.
- 9:14So that's not necessarily a matter of not caring.
- 9:18That's a matter of they can't actually vote if we're talking about a primary.
- 9:23There might be extenuating circumstances that might have stopped someone from going to vote
- 9:28even if they were otherwise going to.
- 9:31Maybe they experienced a severe health episode or negative health episode.
- 9:39Maybe they they got in the hospital, and they weren't actually able to cast a ballot for some
- 9:44reason.
- 9:46Maybe they had a lack of mode of transportation to get to a polling place.
- 9:50That is something that some people experience, especially in more rural areas.
- 9:55They might want to vote, but are otherwise prevented from doing so, not because of
- 10:01physical health problems, but maybe they're not a US citizen or they are in some cases, if
- 10:08you're a convicted felon or an ex felon who has not had their ability to vote reinstated, you
- 10:15can't vote either.
- 10:16Now that's a whole other topic of discussion.
- 10:19Not gonna get into that.
- 10:21But whether that's right or wrong, those people cannot go to vote because they haven't had
- 10:28their right to vote reinstated.
- 10:30Another way to measure voter apathy or political apathy is that there are oftentimes
- 10:37low rates of other forms of political participation beyond voting.
- 10:43People who are apathetic are not likely to participate in politics beyond voting.
- 10:47It might already be a chore for them to even go to vote, but not gonna expect them to get
- 10:55involved in other ways, like, for example, volunteering for campaigns by going door to
- 11:02door, knocking on people's doors, and and telling them about, hey, vote for this person
- 11:06because of x y z reasons or doing phone banking for that candidate.
- 11:11A whole bunch of other ways that you can get involved.
- 11:13Maybe you're not involved with a specific campaign, but you could be doing other civics
- 11:17oriented functions like teaching people about what's coming up in the election or going to
- 11:23town halls.
- 11:24People who are apathetic are probably not doing those things.
- 11:27Nonpartisan groups with different reasons for getting involved, like trying to bridge
- 11:32political divides.
- 11:34People who are apathetic, probably not doing that either.
- 11:37Now if they're not participating in politics beyond voting, may there might be some reasons
- 11:44why that's not actually apathy, but it looks like apathy.
- 11:47Maybe people want to get involved, but the actual opportunities are limited or they don't
- 11:55believe that groups or people where opportunities are available are worth that
- 12:00effort.
- 12:01Maybe they see some of these candidates that are running for some sort of local office.
- 12:07They look at all of them.
- 12:07They're like, I don't like any of these people.
- 12:09I don't want to get involved.
- 12:10I mean, I want to get involved, but I don't like these people that are doing it.
- 12:14Not a matter of apathy.
- 12:16It's it's just that what they see they do not like, or they don't know about the
- 12:22opportunities to get involved in politics because they haven't heard about them.
- 12:26Maybe they just haven't been educated about them.
- 12:28Maybe their capacity to receive this information is limited.
- 12:33Maybe they have poor Internet connection.
- 12:36Broadband connections are, especially in rural areas, not the best.
- 12:42Maybe don't see it on TV.
- 12:43Maybe they don't receive mailers.
- 12:46Who who knows?
- 12:47But in any case, generally speaking, if they're not getting involved in politics beyond voting,
- 12:53there there's probably a certain level of apathy there.
- 12:57Another way to measure voter apathy is by looking at rates of political media
- 13:03consumption.
- 13:04People who are apathetic are likely not consuming much political media, if at all.
- 13:09So TV, radio, internet, particularly social media.
- 13:14And if they do consume political media, it's probably only going to be around the time of an
- 13:19election.
- 13:20So one, two, three months before an election, maybe then they'll start to pay a little bit of
- 13:26attention, but they don't really care all that much.
- 13:29Now, this might not actually be apathy in some cases.
- 13:33Some people might just be wary and distrusting of political media and just don't know where to
- 13:38get quality information.
- 13:40So they just tune a lot of things out.
- 13:42Their access to this quality info may be limited.
- 13:45Maybe they lack good internet connection or there's no major newspaper that services them
- 13:51or even a smaller newspaper that might not be available, especially as news play newspapers
- 13:58have declined in prominence over the past couple decades in particular.
- 14:03Or they may want to consume political media, but they also have so many other interests that
- 14:09they get pulled in all these other directions and thus have little time for political info.
- 14:13But generally speaking, a lot of times it is a matter of apathy when people do not consume any
- 14:19sort of political media and it doesn't have to be Fox News and CNN and MSNBC and all that.
- 14:24It could be actually trying to research what's going on in politics at that time or going on
- 14:32to actually educational forms like or websites like Ballotapedia, for example.
- 14:39So it a lot of times it is just a matter of being apathetic.
- 14:45Another way we can measure political apathy is by measuring the levels of knowledge about
- 14:53politics.
- 14:55People who are apathetic are likely to be much less knowledgeable about politics.
- 15:01They might not even know basic information like what are the three branches of government,
- 15:06executive, legislative, and judicial, and then what they do.
- 15:10Executive enforces laws, legislative rights laws, judicial branch interprets laws.
- 15:15They might not know who our prominent political figures are.
- 15:19They might not know who their local congressperson is or their state legislator.
- 15:25And if you ever watched, like, for example, if you ever watched the tonight show with when Jay
- 15:30Leno was still hosting it, he had this segment called jaywalking, and you could see how little
- 15:36some of those people knew about politics.
- 15:39Now some of that probably wasn't real, but those kinds of people do exist in real life.
- 15:45And and some of those people are going to be legit where they just really don't know
- 15:50anything that's going on or know very little about political history.
- 15:57Now how might this not be apathy but mistaken as such?
- 16:01Maybe these people do want to know more about politics, but they just don't know where to
- 16:04start.
- 16:05Maybe they didn't have a good civics curriculum where they grew up, and post school civics
- 16:12programs are just basically nonexistent or of poor quality.
- 16:16A lot of times we don't really focus on I mean, there's a lot that's made about civics
- 16:21curricula in schools, which is good.
- 16:24We should care about those.
- 16:26But a lot of times, we don't think hard enough about what comes after school.
- 16:32So sometimes called continuing education or adult education.
- 16:36We don't oftentimes focus enough on civics in that regard.
- 16:42So maybe these people do want to know more, but they just don't know where to start.
- 16:47And then some people, a lot of people grossly overestimate how much they know about politics,
- 16:53but they but they do care about it.
- 16:54They just think they know more than they actually do.
- 16:57And it turns out if they actually take a test, they don't really know a whole lot about it,
- 17:02but they still might care.
- 17:03But generally speaking, though, a lot of people who are lacking in knowledge about politics are
- 17:09just apathetic about politics.
- 17:13And then one more way we'll talk about, and these are not all necessarily all the ways that
- 17:18apathy can be measured, but there's some of the big ways is we can look at polling questions.
- 17:23You'd might be able to gauge the apathy of voters directly or indirectly through polling
- 17:28questions.
- 17:29Probably not going to just say, hey, are you apathetic about politics?
- 17:32That's probably not a good polling question, but you have to be wary though because people's
- 17:38reporting of their involvement or interest in politics can be overstated.
- 17:44They might not actually care about politics, but they often care about how other people
- 17:49perceive their involvement in politics.
- 17:53And we have what we call a social desirability bias, which is sometimes people change their
- 18:02responses to a question on a survey because they're afraid of how they're going to look to
- 18:09the person asking the question.
- 18:11They might be afraid, oh, what if this what if how I answer this comes back to me and people
- 18:15know, even though you're not going to be identified on these surveys, but you might
- 18:19still think the person who was surveying you was going to have a negative opinion about you.
- 18:24So you might change your answer on a question.
- 18:28So when it comes to being involved in politics, there is that whole voting and being involved
- 18:38in politics, but especially when it comes to voting, is treated as a civic duty and
- 18:43responsibility, not just as a right.
- 18:46So when people are being pulled about how involved they are in politics, they might
- 18:52overstate how involved they are.
- 18:55And one particular way that this is seen a lot of times is in public opinion surveys, overall
- 19:03self reporting of people voting tends to be noticeably higher than the actual voter turnout
- 19:08rate in an election.
- 19:10So if you go to a if you poll a specific state about how how many of those voters voted in the
- 19:18previous election, you you'll probably get something like, it's gonna make up some
- 19:23numbers, but just to demonstrate, you might get, like, 70% of people say, oh, yeah.
- 19:27I voted in the last election when really it was more like 55% because of that whole, I don't
- 19:33want people to think that I don't vote because I don't want people looking down on me.
- 19:37So you have that bit of an issue.
- 19:41Now that's not to say that you shouldn't regard what public opinion surveys, what pollings what
- 19:46polling questions say, but it is something to think about and to watch out for.
- 19:51And then for campaigns in particular and not even necessarily campaigns, but these big
- 19:59polling organizations that also are trying to figure out what's gonna happen in election,
- 20:04they have what's called a likely voter.
- 20:07So that's not a specific formula that anybody can employ.
- 20:12It's a proprietary thing.
- 20:13A lot of people, a lot of these organizations have their own formula for determining how
- 20:18likely somebody is to vote.
- 20:21So you're never gonna actually see what that formula is because it's proprietary.
- 20:29So then when it comes to things being proprietary and copyrighted, that's when legal
- 20:36ramifications come in.
- 20:38So it's not an exact it's not an exact science, but oftentimes polls will ask questions along
- 20:44the lines of how excited are you to vote in this election, or how much are you looking
- 20:50forward to this election, or how interested are you in this year's election?
- 20:56So again, people might inflate how eager they are as part of that social desirability bias.
- 21:02They might think, oh, I need to really say say sell to this person.
- 21:05Oh, I'm really excited to to vote even though they really couldn't care less.
- 21:09They just care about how they're being perceived.
- 21:12But there might be people who do legitimately answer how much they are looking forward to
- 21:18voting, but it might just be for that particular moment in time that they were
- 21:24pulled, and then that could change.
- 21:25So if you're pulled two months before an election and some major controversy happened
- 21:31with one of the major candidates.
- 21:33Candidate a said something incredibly stupid and offensive.
- 21:38At that point, you might be fired up and be like, oh, I can't let this person win.
- 21:42I'm gonna make sure that they lose.
- 21:44But then another month rolls around if you you've already forgotten about what they said
- 21:49or or you haven't forgot about what they said, but you've cooled off a bit now and are like,
- 21:56yeah.
- 21:56I I mean, I don't like what he said, but am I really gonna go and vote?
- 22:01Some people have that kind of thing to consider in their in their brain.
- 22:07It's not an exact science, but those are just some ways to at least try to get a sense of how
- 22:13apathetic they are.
- 22:15And those are usually pretty good indications, but you do have to watch out for other
- 22:20extenuating circumstances that actually indicate maybe they're not apathetic, but it
- 22:27just looks like apathy.
- 22:28But a lot of times, it is still apathy.
- 22:31So moving on from how to measure voter apathy.
- 22:37Now let's talk about who exactly tends to be more apathetic because there is a little bit of
- 22:45science to that too.
- 22:47There are certain groups of people, certain kinds of characteristics that you can look at
- 22:52to say, okay, these are, this person's probably going to be more apathetic or at least they're
- 22:57more likely to be apathetic about politics.
- 23:00So if we go back to our measurements we just discussed, voters who tend to be more apathetic
- 23:05tend to be they tend to exhibit traits like voting much less often, if at all.
- 23:12They rarely, if ever, participate in politics beyond voting.
- 23:16They consume little to no political media.
- 23:19And if they do consume it, it's probably only gonna be close to election time.
- 23:23They have low levels of political knowledge, things like that.
- 23:28Now, if we look at other characteristics, we can say, for example, if we look at the
- 23:33partisan leanings of people, we have a a lot of times, have a conception that we call a quote
- 23:42unquote weak democrat or republican and a strong democrat or republican.
- 23:49It's not a value judgment.
- 23:50It's just a description of how closely tied that person feels to that party label.
- 23:56So if they are strongly Democratic or Republican, they care a lot about the fact that
- 24:02they're a Democrat or Republican, and they're probably gonna let you know that they're
- 24:05Democrat or Republican.
- 24:07So when it comes to voter apathy in terms of partisan leanings, usually, the more apathetic
- 24:14people are, quote, unquote, weak Democrats or Republicans or what you might call a, quote,
- 24:20unquote, true independent, where it's not somebody who leans towards one party, but they
- 24:25are really just middle of the road.
- 24:27Those kinds of voters tend to be more apathetic, and that's because they have no
- 24:33strong pull towards a party.
- 24:35So campaign appeals to those party labels aren't effective.
- 24:38They don't excite them.
- 24:39You can't go to them and be like, you gotta be a good democrat.
- 24:43You've gotta be a good republican and turn out for our candidate.
- 24:47Those people are not gonna care about that.
- 24:49And it's a similar thing with ideological leaning.
- 24:51So people who tend to be, quote, unquote, somewhat liberal or conservative versus being
- 24:58strongly liberal or conservative or what we might call a, quote, unquote, true moderate.
- 25:05Similar to party, these appeals to ideological labels don't really have much pull on these
- 25:10kinds of people.
- 25:11They tend to be more apathetic.
- 25:12They don't really have a strong tie to any particular labels.
- 25:17And then if you look at some other social demographics, ones that tend to be more
- 25:22apathetic include younger people, some racial minorities, less educated people, lower income,
- 25:31and some of the reasons for that.
- 25:33And then then get this is not a value judgment on any of those people.
- 25:36This is just trying to describe why some of those people tend to be apathetic.
- 25:40For younger voters, they oftentimes are less mature.
- 25:43Although, believe me, I've seen some older people that are not mature at all, but they
- 25:49also just have less experience with the real world to suggest that they should care more
- 25:54about politics.
- 25:55They don't experience.
- 25:57There's not a lot of experiences that they've had where some sort of policy issues, like,
- 26:05obviously, if they're younger, they're not gonna be getting Social Security.
- 26:09So they're not gonna care.
- 26:10That's one less thing for them to care about or Medicare or any sort of other elderly policies.
- 26:20It's it's probably not gonna have as much of an impact.
- 26:22So there's they're gonna think that there's less reason for them to be involved or or just
- 26:27or just plain they haven't had time to really learn enough about politics, so they don't
- 26:32really think about it a whole whole lot.
- 26:35When it comes to racial minorities, and this can vary considerably because there's obviously
- 26:39a lot of different racial groupings that we can talk about.
- 26:43But for some racial minorities, there is research to suggest that they feel much more
- 26:48represented when they have government officials like congresspeople that have a similar racial
- 26:53background to them.
- 26:54So sometimes that makes them more invested.
- 26:57A lot of times, congress in particular gets chastised for not being democrat
- 27:03demographically representative.
- 27:05And so for some racial minorities, if they don't have somebody if they don't have a whole
- 27:10lot of people from their racial background in office, they oftentimes feel less represented.
- 27:18They don't feel that issues important to them are being talked about.
- 27:24So that sometimes makes them apathetic and just goes, okay.
- 27:27I guess we're just not gonna have anybody that cares about what our racial groupings are going
- 27:32through.
- 27:33Obviously, that's not the case for everybody.
- 27:35And I I realize as a white person how that can how can that can come across.
- 27:41So I'm trying to make sure I say this in a way that hopefully makes sense of what hopefully,
- 27:52what I'm saying makes sense and doesn't come across as anything in particular.
- 27:56But that that is for some racial minorities that is part of the equation.
- 28:03There's also the less educated demographic.
- 28:08They don't know what they don't know.
- 28:10So a lot of times they don't know that they should care about politics or they don't know
- 28:14what the issues are.
- 28:15They don't have a civics background, and a a lot of times, more civically minded people are
- 28:22more invested in politics, and they just have less exposure to political info.
- 28:28So there is that that therefore, people who have lower levels of education tend to be less
- 28:38or they tend to be more politically apathetic.
- 28:41And then when it comes to lower income voters, they, a lot of times, are just so focused on
- 28:47their current economic situation.
- 28:48They're just not even worried about anything else.
- 28:50They're just worried about the next paycheck and being able to feed their families.
- 28:56They oftentimes believe that officials are just there to enrich themselves at voters' expense,
- 29:02and they oftentimes just don't have the fiscal means to influence politics like a lot of these
- 29:09major political donors do or even not even major political donors, but regular political
- 29:13donors, the ones that you don't necessarily hear about as as much, but still make regular
- 29:19contributions to state level campaigns or local level campaigns.
- 29:23Maybe they give, like, $500 regularly or a thousand dollars regularly, not like these mega
- 29:28donors that you often hear about.
- 29:30And, of course, all these demographics can work in tandem to make somebody more or less
- 29:36apathetic as well.
- 29:37Maybe it's a young person who is also a racial minority who is lower income, or maybe it's
- 29:44somebody who is a more educated person that is younger.
- 29:49All these things can can work together to make somebody more more or less politically
- 29:56apathetic.
- 29:57But, of course, people are people individuals have their own reasons for things.
- 30:03So that's not to say that older people can't be politically apathetic.
- 30:07Whiter people can't be politically apathetic, more educated, higher income.
- 30:12But generally speaking with these demographics, these are the demographics that tend to be more
- 30:18politically apathetic.
- 30:20And sometimes the reasons are understandable.
- 30:23Now we know who is apathetic or who tends to be more apathetic.
- 30:27Now we need to think about and talk about why some people are more apathetic and touched on
- 30:35that a little bit already with some of the discussion about who tends to be more
- 30:39apathetic, but let's go into it some more.
- 30:42So when you dive into why people are apathetic, just simply saying, well, why don't you care
- 30:50about politics?
- 30:51You should care.
- 30:52What's wrong with you?
- 30:53That that's for a lot of people, that's not gonna convince them to actually get involved in
- 30:58policy and certainly not to actually educate themselves on what's going on.
- 31:03You need to effectively demonstrate to people why they should care about politics.
- 31:09Otherwise, you can't actually fix political apathy.
- 31:13But before that, we need to know why people don't care about politics in the first place.
- 31:19If you don't know why they don't care about politics, you can't address that specific
- 31:23reason for why they can't or don't care about politics in the first place.
- 31:29So one reason that people are politically apathetic is when it comes to low levels of
- 31:37political efficacy.
- 31:40Now there are two types of political efficacy.
- 31:42We actually had an episode that centered on political efficacy.
- 31:46I wanna say it was episode 28.
- 31:49But there are two types, internal and external.
- 31:53Internal relates to how much people know about politics and how much they think they know
- 32:00about politics.
- 32:01And then external political efficacy refers to how much people can impact politics and how
- 32:08much they think they can impact it.
- 32:10So there can be some discrepancy between how much people think they know about politics and
- 32:14how much they actually know and how much they impact politics and how much they think they
- 32:22impact politics.
- 32:24But generally speaking, those are the two basic groups of political efficacy.
- 32:30And apathetic voters tend to demonstrate low levels of efficacy.
- 32:35They do not know much about politics and or think they don't understand it.
- 32:39Maybe they actually do know about politics, but they perceive that they don't really know.
- 32:45And so they might think, I I don't think I should get involved because I don't really
- 32:49understand all this stuff.
- 32:50And politics is very complicated.
- 32:51It's complicated for all of us.
- 32:53Just like even for me, just because we're involved in politics for a living doesn't mean
- 32:57that we've got we've figured out everything.
- 33:01Of course not.
- 33:02No.
- 33:02Nobody has everything figured out.
- 33:03Doesn't stop some people from acting like they've got everything figured out, but I
- 33:08digress on that point.
- 33:09Or, apathetic voters tend to be tend to have low levels of efficacy because they do not
- 33:17sometimes because they do not have many avenues to affect politics and or think they can't make
- 33:23an impact on politics.
- 33:25Last week, I had talked with two very well educated, well spoken young men, Graham
- 33:33Bernstein and Jacob Kaplan from the Florida student policy forum, and they talked a lot
- 33:38about young people making an impact when it when it comes to legislative advocacy.
- 33:44These are definitely two guys who have high levels of political efficacy, and they want
- 33:49other young people to have that level of political efficacy as well.
- 33:54But it just shows you that divide that some people have when it comes to political efficacy
- 34:01and how much people think they can make a difference because there's a lot of young
- 34:04people that think that they can't affect change, and so they just don't get involved.
- 34:10Even if they'd really like to get involved, they just think it's a waste of time because
- 34:13nobody's gonna listen to them.
- 34:16Another contributor to why some people are apathetic is the difficulty in researching
- 34:22info.
- 34:23And those of us who are involved in politics for a living, we sometimes underestimate the
- 34:28difficulty being informed is for nonpolitical people.
- 34:32Because a lot of times, it is very difficult to find political information, especially when it
- 34:37comes to local level races, like a school board or a mayor.
- 34:43It is often very difficult to find an ample amount of information about what's going on
- 34:48because there's it's just not covered as much.
- 34:52Even for those of us who are trained in research, it can be difficult.
- 34:55And if it's difficult for somebody like me or somebody else who is trained in this kind of
- 34:59thing, if it's difficult for us to find information, it's really hard to expect other
- 35:04people to be able to devote time to trying to find this information either, especially
- 35:09because they are they have their work is in something that's not political, so then they'd
- 35:15have to spend the time to also learn about politics.
- 35:18That's a tough ask for people.
- 35:21And even if you know where to find info, it takes time and effort to find that info,
- 35:27especially when it comes to quality info.
- 35:30There's a lot of bad information out there, a lot of polarized, heavily biased information,
- 35:35which unfortunately is much easier to find than actually quality info.
- 35:40And so that's what partly what makes this bad crappy info circulate so much faster is because
- 35:48it just is so much easier to find and social media algorithms cater to that.
- 35:53Time and effort are finite for everybody, especially when our other interests and the
- 35:59demands of life cut into our attention too.
- 36:01And then I'll I'll use me as an example.
- 36:04Obviously, politics is what I do for a living.
- 36:06I don't like being in focused on politics twenty four seven, though.
- 36:11I have plenty of other interests.
- 36:13I enjoy sports, football, basketball, baseball, hockey.
- 36:17I'm starting to get more back back more into baseball.
- 36:23Video games is another major interest of mine.
- 36:26So those things are cutting into my attention too.
- 36:29And that's to me as somebody who's involved in politics for for a living.
- 36:32Now you're talking to about people who are not involved in politics for a living, having to
- 36:38also cut or put aside some time to get more informed about politics.
- 36:45It's it's again, it's a lot to ask of people.
- 36:48And it also might even cost money to get that information.
- 36:52Like, if you're subscribing to a national newspaper, like, that that has a paywall, like
- 36:56Wall Street Journal or Bloomberg, for example.
- 36:59Well, Bloomberg is not a newspaper, but you get the point.
- 37:02It's a a news source that is a has a paywall.
- 37:06And this contributes to apathy because this difficulty in researching info makes many
- 37:13people just throw up their hands in defeat because it's just like, well, what what's the
- 37:18point of this?
- 37:19I don't know where to find this information.
- 37:20I don't I don't know whether it's good information.
- 37:24What's even the point?
- 37:26They might really want to get involved and and informed, but there's just so many roadblocks
- 37:32to becoming informed.
- 37:34And so people sometimes become apathetic and just like, you know what?
- 37:37I'm not even gonna bother.
- 37:40Another reason that people can be apathetic is just a general disenchantment with politics.
- 37:49And, hey, you know what?
- 37:51Honestly, sometimes it's something I struggle with too.
- 37:53Sometimes I'm just like, oh, gosh.
- 37:56What's the point of of all this?
- 37:58And for a lot of people, they feel the same way, and they're not even involved in politics
- 38:03the way I am or other people are.
- 38:06And this disenchantment can be for a number of reasons.
- 38:09Maybe they just think that politics doesn't and won't ever work for them no matter what they
- 38:15do.
- 38:16Maybe they're turned off by the level of polarization in politics and want to distance
- 38:20themselves from that.
- 38:22Maybe they're flustered at how complicated it all seems and is.
- 38:26Talked about the difficulty in researching info.
- 38:30Maybe they're just so frustrated at trying to figure out who to trust that they just tune it
- 38:34all out.
- 38:35Maybe they say, democrats, no.
- 38:36Thank you.
- 38:37Republicans, please move out of the way.
- 38:40Independents, I don't even know anything about them.
- 38:42They just sometimes are just frustrated that all the all the stimuli that's bombarding them,
- 38:51bombarding their brains all the time, and they just go, you know what?
- 38:54Just gonna cut this out.
- 38:56What what's even the point of all this?
- 38:58It's just too much stuff to take in.
- 39:00Whatever the reason, disillusionment leads many people to become apathetic.
- 39:04If you're disillusioned, you're just gonna say, I don't care, which is what apathy is.
- 39:10You don't care.
- 39:11It's not that they want to be apathetic.
- 39:14In fact, many of them don't want to be apathetic.
- 39:16It's just the disillusionment, the disenchantment is sometimes just too much.
- 39:23Another reason that people can be apathetic, politically apathetic, is they don't think that
- 39:30politics affects them, especially when you get to the more esoteric local level offices.
- 39:36For example, some people do not care about school boards because they do not have kids,
- 39:41and they have been far removed from schooling themselves.
- 39:47They might have moved somewhere that they didn't grow up in, so they didn't grow up in
- 39:50that educational system, and so they just they don't get involved in it.
- 39:53Maybe they maybe because they just don't think it's appropriate for them to because they don't
- 39:57really know what's going on.
- 39:58But some people just are like, oh, I don't have kids.
- 40:01Why am I even gonna bother with the school board?
- 40:03Some people care about the higher levels of government, but they don't think the lower
- 40:08level stuff matters.
- 40:09And so they participate much more in those federal level or maybe even state level races,
- 40:14but they don't participate in the local level.
- 40:16And then state level has less participation than federal level.
- 40:20And they all they they they might think that the federal government handles a lot more
- 40:25things than it actually does.
- 40:26Some people will request that the president, whoever it is, do something that they have
- 40:32absolutely no power over.
- 40:34And even if even if they could do something about it, there's a billion other things that
- 40:39are taking that president's attention that they're really not gonna be worried about that
- 40:43local matter anyways.
- 40:46But as crazy as I may sound to some of us, there are some people, including registered
- 40:50voters, who just don't think politics at all are that important, not because of
- 40:57disenchantment or frustration or anything like that.
- 41:01They just do not care, do not want to care, and do not think they should care.
- 41:07And if they don't think politics matters, obviously, they're likely to be more apathetic.
- 41:13I mean, that probably goes without saying.
- 41:16But they if if somebody doesn't think something affects them, they're they're not gonna really
- 41:24worry about it more than likely.
- 41:27Another reason that some people are apathetic is that they perceive a lack of representation
- 41:33in government, and there are various ways that people don't think politicians represent them.
- 41:39I mentioned earlier, for some racial minorities, they often don't think elected
- 41:43officials look out for them or their communities and in part because they don't see
- 41:48as many people that look like them.
- 41:51Some people might think more along ideological or partisan lines where they think that
- 41:56politicians are too liberal or conservative.
- 42:00Even if they are also liberal liberal or conservative voters, they might think that some
- 42:05politicians are just too far out there, and they're like, you know what?
- 42:08I'm I'm I'm not I'm not that far there.
- 42:11I'm not I'm just not gonna bother with them.
- 42:14And it's the same thing with partisanship.
- 42:16Some people may be Democrat or Republican, but they think somebody who's the all the people
- 42:21that are in office are like, oh, I'm not that republican.
- 42:23I'm not that democratic.
- 42:25So they might not they they might be apathetic about government that way.
- 42:31And then younger people often perceive politics as being just old people.
- 42:36And yes, government does much more skew older and people that regularly vote tend to be
- 42:42older.
- 42:44So younger people often just see these politicians as just not caring about younger
- 42:49people's issues at all.
- 42:50You might hear them actually say that policy is just a bunch of old white guys, which is not
- 42:55true, but there is a skew to that in the representation of government.
- 43:02So apathetic people often think that politicians don't represent them and thus
- 43:08aren't going to get invested in politics.
- 43:10Oh, this person doesn't represent me, so why am I even gonna bother?
- 43:13They'll they'll a lot of times think.
- 43:15The whole point of elected officials are that they are supposed to represent you to some
- 43:22extent.
- 43:22Now to what extent they shouldn't be representing you and how much they should be
- 43:27doing specifically what you want, that's that's up for debate.
- 43:30That's a whole other can of worms.
- 43:31But in any case, people in office are supposed to represent you to some extent.
- 43:38And then the last piece we'll cover for the reasons why voters are apathetic is that
- 43:47they're not being surrounded by other civically minded individuals.
- 43:52A lot of political scholarship focuses on the role of family, friends, peers in political
- 43:59socialization, which just refers to the development of political opinions, values, and
- 44:04beliefs over your lifetime.
- 44:07And these social influences can and often do have a monumental impact on your sense of civic
- 44:13duty and your general political views, especially when you filter it through social
- 44:18media.
- 44:19And even though those are technically not your peers or a lot of times you just see somebody
- 44:24online, these as much as I hate this term influencers can take the role of peers even
- 44:32when they aren't actually peers, especially these very biased one-sided influencers that
- 44:40just think they know everything about what's going on and that you need to think like them.
- 44:45Otherwise, you're you're goofball.
- 44:47You're dumb.
- 44:49But I digress on that point.
- 44:51But you also see these influences of civic mindedness or a lack of civic mindedness
- 44:58through through peer pressure and social desirability bias, again, from polling, group
- 45:05think, following trends.
- 45:07We are even those of us who like to think that we're not so susceptible to peer pressure,
- 45:15we're social creatures.
- 45:16We all are susceptible to some extent to social pressures.
- 45:21But apathetic people or politically apathetic people tend to have not many, if any, people
- 45:30around them that do care about politics that are civic minded.
- 45:33So there's nobody to really reinforce to them the fact that they should care about politics
- 45:39because, like, oh, well, my friends and my family didn't tell me how important it was to
- 45:44be involved in politics.
- 45:46My friends don't really care about politics.
- 45:48The people I see don't really get involved in politics, so why should I?
- 45:53That's the logic for a lot of people.
- 45:55Now it's all well and good to talk about how to measure voter or political apathy and why
- 46:03people are apathetic.
- 46:05But why is political apathy such a problem?
- 46:09And for some people that might seem like a a question that answers itself, like, well, yeah,
- 46:16what do you mean why is it a problem?
- 46:18Why wouldn't it be a problem?
- 46:20If you want people to not be apathetic, you have to demonstrate to them why they shouldn't
- 46:26be apathetic, why they should care.
- 46:28So you need to also demonstrate not only the benefits of of them getting involved in
- 46:35politics in some fashion or at least being informed, but also demonstrate the consequences
- 46:42of being apathetic.
- 46:44Because these concerns about political apathy have been around for a long, long time.
- 46:49It's not a new phenomenon.
- 46:51In fact, when I was doing research for some of my notes, I found news articles, academic
- 46:56journals, and so on from 5100, January ago that talk about political apathy.
- 47:05And the founding fathers writings also demonstrated this worry about political apathy.
- 47:09They didn't necessarily use that specific word apathy, but they talked about it in their
- 47:14writings on what it means to be a good citizen and the importance of an informed electorate.
- 47:21You see it a little bit in the or a lot rather in the Federalist papers, which were written
- 47:27predominantly by Alexander Hamilton and James Madison.
- 47:31But part of the reason why you need to demonstrate to people why they should care
- 47:36about politics is the need to demonstrate why their apathy is actually a problem, not just
- 47:43for them, but for other people, including those who do care about politics.
- 47:49Then you can really start fixing the problem of political apathy, but it can be a struggle to
- 47:55get past this roadblock and convincing them.
- 47:58And if it wasn't so much of a problem, well, we would already have figured out the solution.
- 48:03But few of the reasons why political apathy is a problem is, a, it leads to a generally more
- 48:11uninformed public.
- 48:12You know, there's that very cliche knowledge is power, but it is very true in the context of
- 48:18politics.
- 48:19When you are knowledgeable about what's going on, you can make a big impact on what's going
- 48:24on in politics.
- 48:26You can't affect change if you don't know what is wrong and how to even start going about
- 48:32fixing it.
- 48:33To fix it, you have to know who your elected officials are, how the government is
- 48:37structured, who the leaders in government are that can have the most impact on policy and
- 48:44legislation, so on and so forth.
- 48:47And also, civic knowledge has been shown academically and practically to have positive
- 48:53effects on democracy, the responsiveness of government, accountability in government.
- 48:58We need an informed public and not even just from the fact of from a standpoint of healthy
- 49:08politics, healthy democracy.
- 49:10Just it's just good to just be more knowledgeable about stuff in general, even just
- 49:14to have something to talk about with people.
- 49:16Another reason why political apathy is a problem is that it affects the people who do
- 49:22care about politics in a negative fashion too.
- 49:24Now some of these people who care about politics, it's not always healthy.
- 49:29Some of them are they care too much about politics, and they get way too amped up.
- 49:34But if too many people of a particular group, whether it's geographic, like a town or a
- 49:40county or a state, demographic, so any of these social characteristics like age, for example,
- 49:48political groups, etcetera, If too many people of that group do not care about politics and
- 49:56don't participate in politics in any way or at least at very low rates, they're not going to
- 50:02be listened to by government officials.
- 50:05Government officials have no incentive to listen to them because they're not they're not
- 50:08even voting, much less getting active in campaigns and advocacy.
- 50:14And then the people in those groups who do care about politics will have their voice drowned
- 50:18out as well because their compatriots are not participating either.
- 50:24So then people can get frustrated not only with politicians, but people in their cohorts too.
- 50:33And if politicians think not enough people care, they're going to push the boundaries of
- 50:38what they think they can get away with.
- 50:40It's it's a human nature problem.
- 50:43When we think that there's no accountability, no reprisal for something, we tend to push the
- 50:50boundaries of what we think we can get away with.
- 50:54And so this leads to government that is unresponsive except to those who benefit those
- 51:01elected officials.
- 51:03People who donate a ton of money, who vote regularly.
- 51:07They're just gonna listen to those people.
- 51:09So apathy leads to a lack of accountability from politicians.
- 51:15And then the third big reason I'm gonna talk about here for why political apathy is a
- 51:22problem is that political apathy unintentionally contributes to polarization,
- 51:27and polarization is a very serious issue we have right now.
- 51:31Now sometimes it can be inflated to seem like it's bigger than it is and that it's it's
- 51:36insurmountable.
- 51:36It's not insurmountable.
- 51:38It's gonna be very difficult to get past it, but we can get past it.
- 51:43But apathy contributes to polarization because polarized people are anything but apathetic.
- 51:53In fact, they care too much just like we said earlier.
- 51:56They perceive politics as a constant existential crisis, and they are much less
- 52:02willing to hold their own side accountable for anything.
- 52:06And so it heightens this tribalism that we often see in politics.
- 52:10But less polarized people tend to be more apathetic and thus less involved in politics.
- 52:18They vote less often, especially in non presidential elections, and they don't
- 52:23participate in politics much beyond voting if they do at all.
- 52:27And so more and more, it just becomes polarized people being active in politics, and that makes
- 52:34polarization seem more pervasive than it actually is because polarized views are mostly
- 52:40being represented.
- 52:41The people who want to affect positive change, but are not so heavily one-sided, their voice
- 52:48is getting drowned out.
- 52:49And so these polarized views become more influential, benefiting only a small number of
- 52:54people, which makes government less responsive, less accountable, less representative.
- 53:01And it makes our politics overall become more hostile, which drives more people away, which
- 53:08makes more people apathetic, and the cycle continues.
- 53:11It becomes this self fulfilling prophecy of polarization.
- 53:17So too many people being apathetic and not caring actually can heighten, can augment the
- 53:25reasons that people were apathetic in the first place, thinking that government doesn't work
- 53:29for them, thinking the polarization is too much and so they're just not even gonna bother, not
- 53:35being informed about politics.
- 53:38Those are only gonna become worse if you are apathetic.
- 53:44So how do we address this voter apathy, this overall political apathy?
- 53:53Because you can't just tell people that they should care.
- 53:57We need to effectively demonstrate why they should and how they can.
- 54:01And there's no one size fits all approach as people have different reasons for being
- 54:06apathetic.
- 54:07So you need to target people differently if you're trying to make them not apathetic, make
- 54:12them actually care.
- 54:14Obviously, it's not an easy thing to solve because if it was, we'd have figured out how to
- 54:19address it by now.
- 54:21Now, some people, no matter what you do, they're just gonna continue to be apathetic.
- 54:27And you know what?
- 54:28That's okay to have at least a few people be apathetic because that's not reasonable to
- 54:34expect everyone to care.
- 54:36You can't just you're never gonna have a 100% participation, and there are some people that
- 54:42arguably shouldn't be participating anyways.
- 54:45But we do need a lot more people to care and in a healthy manner because some people, again,
- 54:50they care too much.
- 54:53To some extent, people and we said this earlier.
- 54:57People have a responsibility to to care about politics themselves.
- 55:00They have a duty to make themselves care.
- 55:04But there are also understandable reasons for why people have just given up on politics.
- 55:09So simply just blaming people for not caring is not only sometimes unhelpful, but the blame is
- 55:16sometimes misplaced.
- 55:18And I I I used to believe a lot more in this, the whole, like, if you don't vote, you don't
- 55:24have the right to complain.
- 55:25I used to think a lot like that.
- 55:27Now there is a little bit to some extent where some people just wanna complain for the sake of
- 55:31complaining.
- 55:32They don't actually want to fix something.
- 55:34In that case, yeah, I don't wanna hear it.
- 55:37But just because people don't participate doesn't necessarily mean that they shouldn't
- 55:44complain.
- 55:45You have to know why exactly they're not participating.
- 55:49And sometimes this blaming is not only unhelpful, but it's sometimes misplacing the
- 55:55blame.
- 55:55So we first need to address the underlying reasons why people are politically apathetic.
- 56:04So is the reason for this apathy a matter of knowledge and civic understanding?
- 56:08So do they have low political efficacy?
- 56:12Is there not a good civics curriculum where they went to school?
- 56:16Is there a lack of a post school civics curriculum for adult education?
- 56:21Is researching politics too onerous for one reason or another?
- 56:27How you tackle apathy based on a matter of knowledge and civic understanding might be
- 56:34different than if the reason for the apathy is an emotional issue.
- 56:38Maybe they're just frustrated, angry, and fearful about politics to the point that
- 56:42they're just like, well, this.
- 56:44I don't I don't care about this.
- 56:45This is this is dumb.
- 56:47Why am I gonna get involved in it?
- 56:50So how you tackle it from an emotional standpoint is different.
- 56:53And then maybe it's also a sociological issue.
- 56:57So they maybe they don't have people around them that care about politics and know how to
- 57:03get involved, and maybe their parents didn't properly socialize them, politically socialize
- 57:08them.
- 57:10So is it a matter of knowledge?
- 57:13Is it an emotional issue?
- 57:14Is it a sociological issue?
- 57:16Is it a different issue entirely?
- 57:17How we tackle each of those reasons, it it requires a bit of a different touch.
- 57:25And then once we do that, we need to actually tackle the root causes of political apathy,
- 57:34such as improving civics curricula in school and beyond, Or maybe we need to make political
- 57:41information much easier to find.
- 57:43And groups like Ballotpedia, for example, Pew Research Center, a lot of times need to just
- 57:52make people more aware of that information.
- 57:55Hopefully, they'll also come to this podcast as well.
- 57:59You also need to make people feel more representative in represented in politics.
- 58:06Too often, get excluded from the table.
- 58:10So is it younger people that feel excluded, racial minorities, less educated, lower income,
- 58:18or is it the flip side?
- 58:19Is it people who are higher income, who are more educated, who are not racial minorities,
- 58:27who are older, do they feel excluded as well?
- 58:30We shouldn't be excluding anybody from the table, but we need to work in any case on
- 58:38making people feel represented too.
- 58:40If they feel represented, they're probably gonna be much less apathetic.
- 58:44They're gonna be more involved.
- 58:47And then simultaneously to actually addressing that underlying or those underlying reasons for
- 58:53political apathy, we must demonstrate why their apathy is unintentionally making things worse
- 58:59and why they should care about those specific things.
- 59:02How apathy leads to a much less responsive and accountable government because they're only
- 59:09listening to the people who are getting most involved, and so they just shut out people who
- 59:16are not paying attention, which means that politicians can further abuse our trust, our
- 59:23taxpayer dollars, our respect for political institutions.
- 59:26They can further manipulate us because if we're apathetic, we're not gonna do anything about
- 59:31it.
- 59:33And then apathy also adds to polarization by letting these polarized views gain undue
- 59:38influence because they're the ones who aren't apathetic, and they drown out other poise other
- 59:44voices that care but are not so polarized.
- 59:48So that further adds to this issue of a lack of representation.
- 59:54So it obviously is a there's a lot here that needs to be done to address political apathy,
- 1:00:02but it is one of our biggest issues, I think, that we have along with this level of excessive
- 1:00:09level of polarization and hostility and toxicity that we see in politics.
- 1:00:15So, obviously, a lot that's a lot easier said than done to address all those things, but
- 1:00:19these are just some beginning steps we need to take to actually address political apathy and
- 1:00:26to address it long term, not just a short term solution, but to actually address it long term
- 1:00:31and to make sure that people have a healthy concern about politics, not get to the point
- 1:00:38where they get angry like we see a lot of times, which is which can happen to any one of
- 1:00:44us.
- 1:00:44We all need to make sure that we don't get too caught up in things too.
- 1:00:50So there is a right balance to strike, and I think we can get there.
- 1:00:55But it'll take a lot of changes to how we do things and not just blaming people for being
- 1:01:02apathetic, but to demonstrate to them why they should care, why they should be less apathetic.
- 1:01:11But that is gonna cover today's podcast episode.
- 1:01:16And once again, thank you all so much for listening.
- 1:01:19Man, 50 episodes.
- 1:01:20I I I really appreciate all of you listening and liking, commenting, sharing, subscribing.
- 1:01:27Please continue to do so so we get another 50.
- 1:01:30Actually, a lot more than 50 is the goal to goal was to keep this going as much as
- 1:01:36possible.
- 1:01:36So as always, thank you all for the support.
- 1:01:40Links in the show notes, my Facebook, LinkedIn, medium profile, where I write about politics
- 1:01:46from time to time as well, matchmaker FM profile if you wanna be a guest on this podcast
- 1:01:51or you want me to be a guest on your podcast, and my educational email course that talks a
- 1:01:58little bit about this whole how do we properly address polarization, how we depolarize our
- 1:02:06political climate, how we unintentionally contribute to the polarization, and how to fix
- 1:02:11those mistakes that we make when trying to depolarize deep local climate.
- 1:02:16But that is gonna do it for today's episode.
- 1:02:18So as always, thank you so much for listening, and until next time, take care.