Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Prosecuting Employment Tax Fraud and Alien Harboring Together: HSI and IRS Join Forces
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Prosecuting Employment Tax Fraud and
- 0:06Alien Harboring Together, HSI and IRS Joint Forces.
- 0:11I'm Philipp Behring, chair of the BHBA tax law
- 0:14section. The tax law section is sponsored by
- 0:17Hochmann, Salk and Torscher Perez PC. The Hochmann,
- 0:21Salk and Torscher Perez PC advantage is experience,
- 0:24an eye for innovation and a genuine dedication
- 0:26to clients, their families and their business.
- 0:29In addition to their national practice in civil
- 0:31and criminal tax controversies and related litigation
- 0:35in federal and state courts, the firm is also
- 0:38active and successful in handling white collar
- 0:40defense. Today I'm delighted to introduce our
- 0:43speakers, Professor John Lentz -Weiss and Evan
- 0:47Davis. Professor Weiss teaches and co -directs
- 0:51the USC Gold School of Law Immigration Clinic.
- 0:55and teaches the immigration detention and appellate
- 0:58clinic and the legal profession courses. As co
- 1:02-director of the immigration clinic, Professor
- 1:05Weiss oversees the Immigrant Legal Assistance
- 1:08Center, which provides free legal assistance
- 1:11to USC students, faculty, staff, and their family
- 1:14in connection with immigration related issues.
- 1:18Professor Weiss was a trial attorney for six
- 1:21years at the Los Angeles County Public Defender
- 1:23and Alternate Public Defender. and alternate
- 1:26public defender handling misdemeanor and felony
- 1:28cases in downtown Los Angeles and Compton. Prior
- 1:32to joining USC Gould, Professor Weiss was a senior
- 1:35associate at Archer & Norris PLC. Evan Davis
- 1:39is principal at Hochmann Salk & Toscha Press.
- 1:42Before joining the firm in 2016, Evan spent nearly
- 1:4620 years with the US Department of Justice. He
- 1:50was first a civil trial attorney with DOJ's tax
- 1:53division. then an assistant US attorney in the
- 1:57CD California's tax division handling civil and
- 2:01criminal tax cases and finally a criminal AUSA
- 2:05and the USAOs major fraud section handling white
- 2:09collar, tax and other fraud cases through jury
- 2:13trial and appeal. He serves as bankruptcy fraud
- 2:16coordinator, financial institution fraud coordinator,
- 2:19securities fraud coordinator and now with all
- 2:22of that let's get started. Well, thank you very
- 2:27much, Philip. And thank you, Professor, for joining
- 2:32me for this presentation. We probably have a
- 2:37group of listeners who are a combination of immigration
- 2:43attorneys and tax attorneys. We're going to try
- 2:45to give you information that's applicable to
- 2:49both. This is Definitely feeling like a new era
- 2:55for tax lawyers. We'll see what happens with
- 2:59the IRS in the coming days, but the tax division
- 3:02and the Justice Department, for example, has
- 3:05been disbanded and the attorneys have been spread
- 3:09out between the civil and criminal divisions
- 3:11of the Justice Department. There have been big
- 3:14changes at the IRS, including based on personnel.
- 3:19But one area that has not lost that many folks
- 3:23is criminal and IRS criminal investigation, and
- 3:26they definitely continue to be busy. And one
- 3:31of the areas that they're busy is the focus of
- 3:34today's presentation, which is on how the IRS
- 3:37and Homeland Security have joined forces, which
- 3:42is not actually a new thing as we will talk about.
- 3:46But first, I would like to turn to the professor
- 3:50and have her talk about some of the changes that
- 3:54we've seen that might be interesting and relevant
- 3:59to the presentation today when it comes to immigration
- 4:04law. Well, thank you for including me in this
- 4:08presentation. And I thought maybe I would just
- 4:13start off with presenting a little bit about
- 4:15the climate that we're working in, this kind
- 4:18of new aggressive enforcement climate. I would
- 4:21say generally, now is not the time to try pushing
- 4:25the envelope when it comes to immigration laws,
- 4:29obviously, and employers who are related to that.
- 4:33We have several kind of new executive actions
- 4:37that have really targeted that had prioritized
- 4:43immigration enforcement, that have shifted resources,
- 4:46that have shifted policy, reinterpreted statutes.
- 4:51I mean, an extreme example is reinterpreting
- 4:53the 14th Amendment of the Constitution as an
- 4:57enforcement, the birthright citizenship. So we've
- 5:00got this really kind of enforcement -oriented
- 5:02agencies. We also have what we call force multipliers.
- 5:08As Evan pointed out, the cooperation between
- 5:13IRS and Homeland Security's investigation isn't
- 5:16anything new. But we have IRS agents that are
- 5:19actually being deputized to enforce immigration
- 5:23law. And we've had resources shifted, for example,
- 5:28from firearms, tobacco, and alcohol to immigration
- 5:33enforcement. We also have state governments that
- 5:37are state local law enforcement being deputized
- 5:40to engage in immigration enforcement. So we call
- 5:42them force multipliers because it really increases
- 5:45the ability of enforcement beyond the Department
- 5:48of Homeland Security. We still have the kind
- 5:53of I -9 audits, focuses on workplaces, but we're
- 5:58seeing kind of bigger raids, so to speak, bigger
- 6:02enforcement operations. And I'll talk a little
- 6:04bit about the Hyundai mega plant in Georgia.
- 6:09There's policy shifts. I mentioned one of them
- 6:12is The US attorney, Pam Bondi, in February of
- 6:172025 issued a memo saying we're prioritizing
- 6:20immigration related crime and criminally charging
- 6:23companies. And we may see a shift. I will say
- 6:26we haven't really seen it yet, this kind of increased
- 6:29attacks on employers. But the memo talks about
- 6:34this shift from maybe punishing with fines to
- 6:38more draconian punishments. for immigration -related
- 6:41offenses, criminal offenses. And then we have
- 6:45kind of unprecedented cooperation between Department
- 6:50of Homeland Security and IRS when it comes to
- 6:52sharing private taxpayer information, people
- 6:54who have their ITN numbers and using that information
- 7:01for people who are reporting and paying taxes
- 7:03to try and locate their places of residence as
- 7:06a result of enforcement law. Many people who
- 7:10aren't eligible for social securities and who
- 7:13are undocumented may still be paying their taxes
- 7:15under their ITNs. So that is kind of a big enforcement.
- 7:22And then I would say, too, just we're going to
- 7:24see the use of AI to look at employment records,
- 7:29to detect tax crimes and harboring. We'll see
- 7:34overall increased scrutiny by the government.
- 7:38And then another part that I'll talk about a
- 7:41little bit is how we're seeing the termination
- 7:44of lawful statuses, which affects people's ability
- 7:48to work, which affects employers' compliance
- 7:52with the law. And I'll talk more about that.
- 7:55So we're in a situation where it's kind of all
- 7:59hands on deck with immigration enforcement, and
- 8:00that's going to draw more scrutiny on employers
- 8:03as well. Go ahead. This is just a slide to give
- 8:10you an idea of how many people are having these.
- 8:16you know, tax filings and undocumented tax filers.
- 8:23And so, you know, the sharing of information
- 8:26between the IRS and DHS is really going to be
- 8:29used as a tool to go after people's information
- 8:32to find where they are if they're undocumented.
- 8:35Well, and I know that you talked about ITINs.
- 8:39The idea behind, for those who are not familiar
- 8:42with it, the idea behind an ITIN is you do have
- 8:45people working in the United States who may not
- 8:49be allowed to work here or don't have a social
- 8:54security number, for example, and basically the
- 8:59government wanted a system by which folks like
- 9:03that who are earning money, whether they're allowed
- 9:06to or not, are reporting it and paying tax on
- 9:10it. So they came up with this ITIN, the Individual
- 9:14Tax Identification Number, and the whole idea
- 9:19was to increase compliance for the people who
- 9:24are operating perhaps in the shadows and perhaps
- 9:29in anticipation of a later test. when the government
- 9:33decides who can become a U .S. citizen, one of
- 9:38the tests was, were you paying taxes all along?
- 9:42So the ITIN was set up for that reason. Professor,
- 9:47we didn't talk about this before, but it just
- 9:50is kind of a natural question based on what you
- 9:52said earlier. Is that gonna come back to bite
- 9:56people? Is that something that lawyers are gonna
- 9:59be hearing? should I or should I be worrying
- 10:02about my employees reporting ITIN information?
- 10:07Because is that just going to be shipped over
- 10:10to Homeland Security and ICE? And that's just
- 10:14a much easier way of finding people who are not
- 10:17here lawfully. Yeah, I think it really kind of
- 10:22it has this negative policy implication of decentivizing
- 10:26people from complying or paying taxes under the
- 10:31ITIN because that information can be used to
- 10:35locate and remove them from the country. And
- 10:38I think that those individuals are in a rock
- 10:40and a hard place because, as you point out, when
- 10:43it comes to certain immigration applications
- 10:47for status, One of the things that are looked
- 10:50at is good moral character. And one of those
- 10:55things that are looked at are, did you pay your
- 10:58taxes when you were supposed to? And so that
- 11:01would be something that would be a good thing.
- 11:05But now I think people are really hesitating
- 11:07about whether they should give their information
- 11:09and do that because it's going to be used to
- 11:12track them down. And I think just with the background
- 11:14of what you see on the news with the aggressive
- 11:16enforcement, I think people are scared too. Well,
- 11:21so let's move to the tax side of things first,
- 11:25and then we'll talk about some of the immigration
- 11:28crimes that can come into play. What statutes
- 11:34are at issue in the cases that we're expecting,
- 11:38right? The professor indicated we haven't really
- 11:41seen an increase. We are gonna actually talk
- 11:43about some very recent cases from 2025. as well
- 11:47as some historical cases in a bit. But what statutes
- 11:52can be brought to bear to address at least the
- 11:58tax side of these immigration and tax cases?
- 12:04Setting the table, the standard situation in
- 12:07which you will see a nexus between a tax crime
- 12:12and an immigration crime, primarily is in an
- 12:16employment situation. It's not generally the
- 12:19standard individual income tax return situation,
- 12:24although you can see that coming to bear just
- 12:27if someone had overstayed a visa, had been deported
- 12:32at some point previously, is coming back into
- 12:34the country, you might get a... an illegal reentry
- 12:39charge, but really this presentation is more
- 12:42about what lawyers who are either advising businesses
- 12:48or lawyers who have a business person who comes
- 12:52into them and they're either under investigation
- 12:55have been charged. So what are the statutes on
- 12:58the criminal tax side that we're looking at?
- 13:02Well, the first statute, which is one that even
- 13:07criminal tax lawyers don't run across that much,
- 13:11is 26, that's the tax code, U .S. Code, Section
- 13:167202, which is the willful failure to collect
- 13:19or pay over tax. This is a common employment
- 13:23tax charge, although employment tax charges have
- 13:28waxed and waned over the years. I remember when
- 13:31I was in AUSA, We started doing more of them
- 13:35and then it seemed like we were doing less of
- 13:38them. During my last nine years when I've been
- 13:41in private practice, it seems like this became
- 13:44a focus doing criminal employment tax cases.
- 13:51Section 7202, in essence, is the criminal analog
- 13:55of the civil penalty case against employers who
- 14:03fail to pay over, who collect but fail to pay
- 14:06over tax. So often these employers are collecting
- 14:12tax from employees who, some of whom in this
- 14:16situation may not be here lawfully or may not
- 14:19lawfully be permitted to work, but they don't
- 14:23then send the money over to the government. for
- 14:26example, or they intentionally fail to collect
- 14:29tax, which might be a more common situation in
- 14:33the immigration context, where they may be paying
- 14:39employees without taking any money. There is
- 14:44a statute available for that, which is 7202.
- 14:487201 is the standard tax evasion case. It is
- 14:57quite a broad section. It can basically encompass
- 15:01a one -person conspiracy, if you want to call
- 15:04it that, where an individual, in this case it
- 15:08could be an employer, evades either the assessment
- 15:14or the payment of tax. In this situation, it's
- 15:17most likely that the IRS would be looking to
- 15:21investigate evasion of assessment. And it wouldn't
- 15:24necessarily be the assessment of income tax,
- 15:28although that could be part of it. It would be
- 15:31the evasion of employment tax. But if you think
- 15:35about it, if you're not reporting the wages to
- 15:40begin with, you're obviously not going to be
- 15:43paying or reporting employment tax obligations.
- 15:47But you're also causing, in essence, the employee.
- 15:52not to report or feel like they don't have to
- 15:55report their income. And there can be an income
- 15:58tax angle to it as well. Keep in mind, tax evasion
- 16:02doesn't just include evading your own income
- 16:05tax. If you are assisting someone else to evade
- 16:09their income tax, then this statute also can
- 16:13apply. You also have a willful failure to file
- 16:21return supply information or pay tax, which is
- 16:24a misdemeanor. This is available as well. I've
- 16:30already described the 7202 situation. So this
- 16:35is in case you are negotiating with a prosecutor,
- 16:43generally you start out by saying, This case
- 16:45should be a civil case. So I don't know why you
- 16:47guys are prosecuting my poor client. And then
- 16:50you move to, well, at very least it's a misdemeanor.
- 16:53So just keep in mind that there are misdemeanors
- 16:55available. The tax division of the Justice Department,
- 17:00when it existed, generally did not like misdemeanors.
- 17:03Who knows whether that's going to change under
- 17:06a new administration when you have people whose
- 17:09life does not revolve around tax. supervising
- 17:14folks who are primarily doing tax work. It remains
- 17:19to be seen whether you're going to have the same
- 17:23ethos when it comes to protecting the tax code
- 17:27and protecting the taxpayers when you have diffused
- 17:31the tax division into civil and criminal divisions.
- 17:35But as of now, at least, the tax division has
- 17:39not been too happy with misdemeanors. So 72061
- 17:43and 72062 are the false tax returns and false
- 17:49statements charges. 72061 is just filing a false
- 17:54tax return for yourself. That could be a false
- 17:59employment tax return or individual income tax
- 18:03return. But there's also the aiding or assisting.
- 18:07And this can come into play in a situation where
- 18:11you have an employer and an employee who is off
- 18:14the books or not fully on the books, for example.
- 18:20And all you need to do for 72062, in addition
- 18:24to obviously having the requisite intent, is
- 18:28to basically create some sort of a document.
- 18:32And it doesn't have to be an official document.
- 18:35It could be pretty much any document that aids
- 18:39or assists another person in the preparation
- 18:43or presentation of a false document. You also
- 18:50have 7207, another misdemeanor, which is basically
- 18:54a false return or other document. This is really,
- 18:58again, more of a negotiating tactic. You don't
- 19:01see the government charging this that often on
- 19:04its own, it's really more in a resolution context.
- 19:08And then you have a very broad statute, which
- 19:11is section 7212, which is a catch -all. And in
- 19:17fact, courts have expressed some concern about
- 19:21how broad the statute is. In essence, anything
- 19:24that is done that makes the IRS's job harder,
- 19:29could be considered a 72 -12 count. So you could
- 19:36see how that would come up in terms of paying
- 19:39employees under the table. It also can come up
- 19:43in a situation of an audit, which is something
- 19:46that we will talk about at some point today as
- 19:50well. When you're representing an employer, you
- 19:55need to make sure that the employer doesn't make
- 19:58the situation worse in the audit by providing
- 20:02false information. And this is a count that in
- 20:08the context of an audit, the IRS loves to investigate
- 20:11and the Department of Justice loves to bring.
- 20:15So now what about on the immigration crime side?
- 20:19What criminal statutes are we looking at? And
- 20:23what do the penalties look like? So what I'll
- 20:29be talking about mostly today is this concept
- 20:31of harboring, because it's so broad. There was,
- 20:36and I'll just kind of as an aside, there's no
- 20:42legal definition for harboring. So the courts
- 20:45have been tasked with interpreting what that
- 20:47means. And circuits don't completely agree. I'll
- 20:53be talking more about employment and some of
- 20:56the other kind of sheltering aspects of harboring.
- 20:59But I did want to mention that there was a Supreme
- 21:02Court ruling in 2024 in State versus Hanson that
- 21:06challenged this statute, this idea of bringing
- 21:12or attempting to bring, and then an aiding and
- 21:15abetting kind of facilitating that person to
- 21:19come unlawfully. And it was challenged on a First
- 21:23Amendment basis that the statute was too broad.
- 21:26And the Supreme Court in a seven to two decision
- 21:30authored by Justice Coney Barrett said that,
- 21:35you know, we're talking about the criminal use
- 21:38of the words and not the kind of colloquial use
- 21:42that would be broad. So I open with that example
- 21:46because that's really the most recent kind of
- 21:49challenges to this statute that we've seen, and
- 21:52it's been on a First Amendment basis for the
- 21:55language. So there is a lot of criticism in the
- 21:58immigration scholarship about how this statute
- 22:03is so broad and isn't clear, and courts are left
- 22:07to interpret, and that Congress really should
- 22:10be considering revisions. So regarding kind of,
- 22:15well, then what is harboring? The short answer
- 22:20is that employing somebody who is unauthorized
- 22:25to work without more is not going to lead to
- 22:29harboring charges. Most of the harboring cases
- 22:33require some kind of act to avoid detection.
- 22:41And so, for example, in one of the cases an employer
- 22:48who was an agency that had employed people to
- 22:53do custodial work had provided false identifications
- 22:58for background checks to clean government buildings.
- 23:02So that was really, there were harboring charges
- 23:05that were successfully pressed in that case because
- 23:07that required also like trying to avoid detection
- 23:10by providing these false documentation, false
- 23:13documents. Okay, so the basic elements of the
- 23:20harboring is that there is knowledge that there
- 23:24is an immigrant who is present in violation of
- 23:26immigration law, so either entered or remained
- 23:28in violation of law. And then the defendant in
- 23:33this case would conceal, harbor, or shelter the
- 23:36immigrant in the United States. Again, it's very
- 23:38broad language. And then that person also has
- 23:42to take some additional action to substantially
- 23:47facilitate somebody being in the US in violation
- 23:51of the law. So in the Ninth Circuit, which is
- 23:54where we are, generally harboring could be sheltering
- 24:00individuals, but it gets a little bit thornier
- 24:04regarding whether or not harboring is a specific
- 24:07intent crime. And in the Ninth Circuit, they've
- 24:08held that So sheltering and knowingly sheltering
- 24:12an undocumented individual could fall under the
- 24:16harboring statute, but there has to be this intent,
- 24:19a specific intent to kind of further that presence
- 24:23in violation of immigration law. So we still
- 24:25have, you know, for example, renting an apartment
- 24:29to someone who is undocumented would not fall
- 24:31under harboring. So I'm going to, you know, maybe
- 24:36give examples of cases where there has been found
- 24:42not to be harboring. And many of these cases
- 24:47involve some sort of attempt by the defendant
- 24:50to evade federal agents or sheltering individuals
- 24:57and transporting individuals as part of their
- 25:01employment. An example of harboring, there was
- 25:06a case where a restaurant owner required federal
- 25:11agents to obtain a warrant before coming into
- 25:15the restaurant. While the enforcement agents
- 25:20were getting the warrant, the owner of the restaurant
- 25:23facilitated the undocumented workers there to
- 25:27leave. to pretend that they were customers to
- 25:31leave undetected, and then transported them to
- 25:34another location. So it was that dual thing.
- 25:37Just exercising your rights and requesting a
- 25:39warrant. This is an older case. That wouldn't
- 25:43be harboring. But then that additional action
- 25:45of really intentionally attempting to obstruct
- 25:49the federal agents from enforcing immigration
- 25:52law. Another example was an employer at a scrap
- 25:59metal yard who was also lodging workers at a
- 26:05warehouse and transporting them back and forth
- 26:08and advising them how to avoid detection. Also
- 26:11not reporting tax, engaging in the kind of tax
- 26:15offenses that Evan Davis had just described.
- 26:20In the Ninth Circuit, there's a fairly broad
- 26:23interpretation. So like I said, just sheltering
- 26:28could fall within the harboring statute. But
- 26:33because it's a specific intent crime, most cases
- 26:36have required that there's something about wanting
- 26:40to facilitate that unlawful presence as part
- 26:43of that sheltering. Another major element of
- 26:47the harboring cases is the knowledge or reckless
- 26:51disregard of the fact that the person's unauthorized.
- 26:54Many defenses to kind of the unlawful employment
- 26:58statutes and immigration by the employers is,
- 27:01well, I didn't know. I was asked for the information
- 27:05to, you know, the employment records, and I didn't
- 27:09know that they did not belong to that person
- 27:11or that they weren't part. So that's and that
- 27:13has been kind of a design of our employment authorization
- 27:19program since it was established under Reagan
- 27:23in the ERCA, the Immigration Reform and Accountability
- 27:28Act. And so there is a, and some of, many of
- 27:38you might know the E -Verify system, which The
- 27:42information that the employer enters about their
- 27:45employee is then compared to records in the Department
- 27:47of Homeland Security and the IRS. That is not
- 27:51a nationwide mandated system. Some states, I
- 27:56think about 22 states now require employers to
- 27:59use E -Verify. California is not one of them.
- 28:04But federal contractors have to use it. Institutions
- 28:08that accept federal funds, for example, many
- 28:10universities have to use e -Verify if they're
- 28:12accepting federal funds. So that's one way that
- 28:15there's this kind of additional verification
- 28:17step, but it's not required by the statute. So
- 28:24knowledge or reckless disregard, if you should
- 28:26have known, if the circumstantial evidence would
- 28:28have shown that. And then the other element is
- 28:33whether or not that defendant for the individual
- 28:37acted for commercial advantage or private financial
- 28:40gain. And this really doesn't require the government
- 28:47prove that you have exchanged or received something
- 28:50of value, received money or something of value.
- 28:54It just has to be for this commercial advantage.
- 28:57So it's a lot more broad. If that is the case,
- 29:02then the maximum penalties are fines, right,
- 29:05or up to five years for each unauthorized immigrant
- 29:11that is being harbored under, you know, is prosecuted.
- 29:16Sorry, it's 10 years. If there's no commercial
- 29:19advantage, it's five years. So it's a 10 year
- 29:21maximum. And then there's other kind of increased
- 29:25penalties if the harboring resulted in great
- 29:29bodily injury or jeopardized the life of an individual,
- 29:32then that's up to 20 years. So historically,
- 29:36I think there's been a lot of fines, except for
- 29:37really egregious cases where there has been a
- 29:42link to workplace violations. A lot of these
- 29:47kinds of prosecutions are resulting from investigations
- 29:51into complaints or workplace violations and then
- 29:57from there these harboring charges are usually
- 30:01brought. Let's see, what else can I say? Okay,
- 30:11so I guess maybe I'll stop there and we can talk
- 30:15about some current cases. Let's do it. Why don't
- 30:24I start with an old case, which is one of the
- 30:27reasons why I'm doing the presentation, because
- 30:29this was my case, along with a handful of other
- 30:34prosecutors. Interestingly, the defense included
- 30:38my current law firm, so it all kind of went full
- 30:41circle in that regard. But this was a case involving
- 30:47a gentleman named George Torres. who was charged
- 30:52with RICO murder, with honest services, fraud,
- 30:58basically public corruption, tax crimes, which
- 31:04included failing to pay employment tax, and as
- 31:10well as harboring, which the professor was just
- 31:17describing. It was basically four cases in one,
- 31:22but it's a pretty rare case. I and the professor
- 31:28were looking for examples dating back basically
- 31:33as far as we could, just looking for press releases
- 31:37and similar things to try to find out how many
- 31:40of these things came up. At least in the Central
- 31:43District of California, very few examples, and
- 31:48even nationwide when we did that search as well,
- 31:52there are very few examples of cases involving
- 31:56criminal charges for harboring that also included
- 32:00the, in this case, section 7202, the willful
- 32:06failure to collect taxes that I mentioned before.
- 32:10This case involved, as I mentioned, RICO murder,
- 32:14the the allegations that the jury found and later
- 32:17dismissed involved, in essence, killing some
- 32:22people who made threats or killed people who
- 32:25worked at his grocery stores. But the aspects
- 32:31of the case that are relevant to today involved
- 32:35paying known workers who were here illegally
- 32:42under the table and at the same time, providing
- 32:48housing for them, which is something that the
- 32:53professor mentioned earlier about, well, if you're
- 32:56just a landlord providing housing to someone
- 32:59who you know is not supposed to be here, that's
- 33:02not gonna get charged. But in the instance of
- 33:06an employer who is paying someone under the table
- 33:10and at the same time, finding a location for
- 33:15all of those workers to live, that was the focus
- 33:20of the employment tax and immigration aspects
- 33:25of the case. So that got me, I guess, interested
- 33:30in the area. And I remember doing a presentation
- 33:34a few years later about how these cases can work
- 33:38and how easy it is to prosecute. but notwithstanding
- 33:44that the IRS was talking about doing the cases,
- 33:47I really didn't see any more in the additional,
- 33:52let's see, I think this was 2009, so the additional
- 33:57seven years that I worked for the office, I don't
- 34:00think I saw more of them, as I said, as easy
- 34:04as they were. There are task forces that you
- 34:09have Homeland Security and the IRS on. This goes
- 34:12back a lot of years. But their focus usually
- 34:17is on organized crime and drug cases, not cases
- 34:22like this. Well, the Torres case was an example.
- 34:25This came out of a task force that involved local
- 34:30as well as federal agents. And there was, as
- 34:34I described, this kind of gang and violence aspect
- 34:39to it. So in essence, the tax and the immigration
- 34:43charges were really just along for the ride with
- 34:47the more serious charges. But that's just not
- 34:51terribly common. So cases really weren't coming
- 34:55up that often. But we see examples, and Professor,
- 35:02I forget which ones you're going to be talking
- 35:04about, but We found an example in 2011 in Pittsburgh
- 35:09where there was an alien harboring money laundering
- 35:13case. So a couple of years after the one that
- 35:15I prosecuted here in LA. By the way, all of the
- 35:19full press releases and the indictment for Torres
- 35:23is in the materials. And it was a kind of a standard
- 35:27case in Pittsburgh where you see hospitality
- 35:31industry workers being paid under the table,
- 35:37harboring for commercial gain, money laundering,
- 35:39et cetera. So there are kind of few and far between
- 35:43until 2022 and the Biden administration. And
- 35:49I don't know whether it was President Biden,
- 35:52whether it was the attorney general, whether
- 35:55it was the commissioner of the IRS or someone
- 36:00else. But it seems like starting in 2022, the
- 36:04IRS got interested in these cases again, involving
- 36:08harboring as well as employment tax. And Professor,
- 36:12what are your thoughts? I mean, I know politically
- 36:15what people have said about the last administration
- 36:18and immigration, but at least if you look at
- 36:21the volume of cases involving tax as well as
- 36:26harboring charges, it seems like the upswing
- 36:30started during the last administration. I would
- 36:35agree with you. I think that our former President
- 36:40Biden's position on immigration being open borders
- 36:43policy is exaggerated on one side, that there
- 36:48was aggressive enforcement under that administration
- 36:52as well, maybe not to the degree that we're seeing
- 36:57currently. but definitely carrying into the Biden
- 37:01administration from the first Trump administration
- 37:03a lot of policies and kind of focus on the issue
- 37:07of unlawful immigration. I mean, one thing is
- 37:11these kinds of statutes I think are going to
- 37:14be used more to make examples of people and to
- 37:18kind of overall deter unlawful immigration for
- 37:24economic purposes so that employers and employees
- 37:28will be facing harsher consequences. I think
- 37:31that's kind of part of the increased attention
- 37:36here, which I think was part of Biden's administration
- 37:39as well. We'll just scroll through. We have October
- 37:442024, December 2024, another case. March 2025
- 37:50is Morgantown, West Virginia case. Now, those
- 37:58of us who do these cases, and I know the professor
- 38:01used to be a defense counsel, it's very difficult
- 38:05to put together a federal tax and immigration
- 38:08case within two months. This is two months after
- 38:11the inauguration. So this is very likely a case
- 38:16that had been going on for a year or more. I
- 38:20mean, my experience with the IRS is two, three
- 38:22years is not uncommon from start of a criminal
- 38:26investigation to charges. But it would be light
- 38:31speed if this was actually started under the
- 38:33new administration. So this is really an indicator
- 38:35of something that happened beforehand. Professor,
- 38:39I know you wanted to talk about the Charleroi
- 38:42staffing case too. I would say that with this,
- 38:48you know, we have this kind of Operation Take
- 38:50Back America was the name of the operation. And
- 38:53I think that this is one of the cases under that
- 38:56operation. So I don't think it was just for the
- 38:58Charleroi case or Charleroi, I guess, or my French
- 39:03accent is struggling. But this is a case where
- 39:09it wasn't just not reporting, employing unauthorized
- 39:16immigrants and not, in this case, it was a staffing
- 39:21agency that wasn't reporting about, I think only
- 39:2610 % of the business were people who were able
- 39:30to work. And so there were tax, crimes being
- 39:34committed and not reporting all of the employees
- 39:38that were working there with the housing and
- 39:42transporting. And so you had immigrants who were
- 39:46being housed at a hotel by the agency and transported
- 39:51to their workplaces in addition to the agency
- 39:53not reporting those unauthorized immigrants.
- 39:59for tax purposes. And so in that case, there
- 40:03was a sentence that did include imprisonment.
- 40:06It was 30 months of imprisonment as well as,
- 40:09I looked up, I think that it was like, you know,
- 40:12over $3 .5 million in fines as well. But that,
- 40:17in that case, I can't, oh yeah, so that was over
- 40:21the summer in 2025. I don't know if you have
- 40:23anything to add to that. I don't think so, other
- 40:27than it's possible there are a handful of cases
- 40:30that we never heard about because the IRS tends
- 40:33to issue press releases when they receive a sentence
- 40:37that they're proud of. But that having been said,
- 40:42I would expect the cases that they're bringing
- 40:44in this area to receive substantial prison sentences
- 40:49because you have the overlay of immigration.
- 40:53And I think the professor, what she does in her
- 40:55day job when she's not helping us out, is it
- 40:59seems to be much more focused on the workers
- 41:03in the situation than the employers. So often,
- 41:08I suspect you're seeing that the workers are
- 41:10very poorly treated because if they're basically
- 41:14probably stuck in a hotel, they're probably told
- 41:16they can't go anywhere. and they're just shuttled
- 41:20back and forth almost like prisoners. So that's
- 41:25the sort of thing as a judge that the judge would
- 41:29be concerned about. Now, some of the cases that
- 41:32we've handled recently that involve employment
- 41:36tax that arguably could have included a harboring
- 41:41charge if the right agency had been added to
- 41:45the case. those employers treated their workers
- 41:50just fine. So it wasn't something that necessarily
- 41:55a court would have been concerned about. But
- 41:58when you hear, in addition to breaking the law,
- 42:01you're also abusing workers, that's the sort
- 42:05of thing that can generate some longer sentences.
- 42:09And I think here's another couple of slides that
- 42:13I think you added about the Chinese money laundering
- 42:17and then we'll talk about the the Iowa raid Yeah,
- 42:21I mean, I think this is just another example
- 42:24of You know targeted kind of cooperative investigation
- 42:29And maybe to highlight the difference between
- 42:34a track trafficking offense and a harboring offense
- 42:37because harboring covers a lot more than trafficking
- 42:40but you know, there is kind of some overlap in
- 42:44certain cases. One of the, you know, related
- 42:51to some of these aspects are undocumented workers
- 42:57who are victims of trafficking. That could be
- 43:00a way for them to obtain legal status in the
- 43:05US. And so sometimes there's this overlap between
- 43:11the poor treatment and between possibly getting
- 43:15legal status, which is just something to keep
- 43:18in mind. And that's if they cooperate with an
- 43:21investigation and that's if they help with a
- 43:24prosecution. So sometimes these cases get to
- 43:29the attention of the authorities because they
- 43:32are based on complaints by the employees themselves,
- 43:36even though the employees are undocumented and
- 43:38not working with authorization. I wanted to talk
- 43:42about this case because this was a big raid in
- 43:492008 on a meatpacking. There's a lot of focus
- 43:52on meatpacking raids. It was kind of this really
- 43:59organized immigration enforcement and employment
- 44:03enforcement. And I think about 389 workers, which
- 44:07composed, I want to say half, if not more than
- 44:13half of the post -Ville population. And they
- 44:17were unauthorized workers that were arrested.
- 44:21And the investigation started with complaints
- 44:25against workplace practices by the CEO. The CEO
- 44:30was not charged with harboring. The CEO was eventually
- 44:33convicted on a bank fraud and I think some other
- 44:38workplace violation crimes, but not harboring.
- 44:45But what happened in this case that's interesting
- 44:48is outside on a field, they had set up a judge,
- 44:57a criminal judge, immigration judge, and so they
- 45:01had public defenders, they had prosecutors on
- 45:04a field, and they were offering these kind of
- 45:06in mass detail pleas. So they were charging people
- 45:11with providing false documentation or identity
- 45:14theft related charges as criminal. misdemeanors
- 45:18and saying, we'll give you time served, we won't
- 45:22require any sort of imprisonment, but you have
- 45:26to accept deportation as part of your plea. And
- 45:28so it was really, I think that this is a model
- 45:32that might be used again, but where you're looking
- 45:35at kind of this intersection between enforcement
- 45:39and, you know, enforcement and workplace. issues
- 45:45with hiring people who are undocumented. In this
- 45:48case, there were no harboring charges, but I
- 45:51wanted to point it out at this kind of concerted
- 45:53effort where you have federal and local judges
- 45:56and prosecutors working together to secure a
- 45:59plea that affects immigration enforcement. Thank
- 46:05you. So if you're like us, or at least our firm,
- 46:14we We're sometimes called on in advance to advise
- 46:19employers frequently, though we're kind of the
- 46:21cleanup crew where something has happened and
- 46:24we're dealing with it in an audit or once charges
- 46:28have already been brought. But to the extent
- 46:34that employers are going to come in and say,
- 46:36look, I'm running a contracting business and
- 46:42I do employ a number of people who are undocumented
- 46:47here. What should I do? And my immediate reaction
- 46:54is, well, I'm a lawyer. I've got to tell you
- 46:56to comply with the law. One of the things that
- 47:01I would tell employers is, I know that you're
- 47:09concerned that you will no longer be viable,
- 47:12you'll no longer be competitive. We've had a
- 47:16number of clients who've unfortunately been prosecuted
- 47:19for employment tax crimes, and they've cleaned
- 47:25everything up, they've gone back into business,
- 47:27and they remain competitive. So you do want to
- 47:31give your clients some light when you're telling
- 47:36them, no, you've got to get your... get everything
- 47:41straight. But I know you were talking about E
- 47:47-Verify earlier. What sort of things should employers
- 47:51be looking to do to comply with the law if they're
- 47:54concerned that the jig might be up and they want
- 47:57to come clean? I mean, I think I agree with you.
- 48:02You've just got to comply. E -Verify, that is
- 48:09a way to make sure someone stays in status. So
- 48:15one of the things that we're seeing is, for example,
- 48:20if you are familiar with TPS, temporary protected
- 48:23status, this administration has terminated or
- 48:26not renewed a lot of temporary protected statuses
- 48:30that people have. I think that there's approximately,
- 48:36I have it here in my notes. something that, you
- 48:39know, tens of thousands of people who had lawful
- 48:43status and the ability to work that no longer
- 48:46have it because their designation has ended.
- 48:49So Venezuelans, Haitians, there's been parole
- 48:53programs that were started by the Biden administration
- 48:56that were terminated by this administration.
- 48:59So someone may have obtained a Social Security.
- 49:02number may have been authorized to work and their
- 49:05statuses may have been abruptly ended by this
- 49:07administration. And so employers may have a valid
- 49:11social security number that no longer authorizes
- 49:14that person to work. So that's one of the pitfalls.
- 49:19DACA is another, you know, that could end and
- 49:22that would result in... you know, about 400 ,000
- 49:25people who were authorized to work to not be
- 49:27able to work. So that's one thing that's going
- 49:29to complicate compliance is just staying up with
- 49:32all of the different lawful statuses that authorize
- 49:35people to work that have been abruptly ended.
- 49:38And those people are no longer authorized. And
- 49:40now you're in a situation where you're not complying
- 49:43today when you were complying yesterday. E -Verify
- 49:46seeks to help with that. I think that, you know,
- 49:51that comes down to best practices. Maybe, you
- 49:54know, you, Evan, would be able to speak to that
- 49:57better than I would. Yeah, well, I'd like to
- 50:00turn for the last 10 minutes or so to the nuts
- 50:04and bolts of what it's like to deal with this
- 50:07on the civil and criminal side. Those of us on
- 50:12the tax side, at least, are most likely to face
- 50:15this in a civil audit. And you might think, well,
- 50:19what does that have to do with Homeland Security?
- 50:23Keep in mind the past administration, the past
- 50:28IRS commissioner. I shouldn't say the last IRS
- 50:30commissioner or two commissioners ago because
- 50:32of course we went through a half dozen or seven
- 50:35or whatever the number is this year. But when
- 50:39Chuck Reddick was the commissioner, he emphasized
- 50:43having more cases sent from the civil side to
- 50:48the criminal side of the IRS. And that included
- 50:51employment tax cases. And that may be one of
- 50:54the reasons why, because he was commissioner
- 50:57between 2018 and I think 2022, that may be one
- 51:02of the reasons why we saw the increase in cases
- 51:07involving both Homeland Security charges as well
- 51:11as tax charges. in the latter part of that period,
- 51:142022, 23, 24, et cetera. Danny Werfel was the
- 51:20commissioner after that. I have no reason to
- 51:22think that he shut down that program. So the
- 51:25folks that are working at the IRS have been trained,
- 51:28if they're on the civil side, to be on the lookout
- 51:31for good cases. So one thing that we've seen
- 51:37repeatedly that could be an error in a civil
- 51:40case civil audit is to try to hoodwink the auditor
- 51:48or distract them, not provide information, because
- 51:56I don't want to say it always happens, but what
- 51:59can happen is they'll figure it out on their
- 52:02own. One of the things the IRS has done recently
- 52:06is go after a lot of check cashers, both civilly
- 52:09and criminally. and they squeeze the check cashers
- 52:13to get information about, okay, who's coming
- 52:17in and cashing a lot of checks. If you're a contractor
- 52:22cashing a lot of checks, that feels odd to the
- 52:26IRS because contractors who have checks normally
- 52:29also have bank accounts. And why are you cashing
- 52:33checks? Well, the IRS jumps to the conclusion,
- 52:36which could be accurate. that you're doing it
- 52:39so you can pay people in cash. And that's one
- 52:45way that the IRS has identified a number of contractors
- 52:49to audit or even potentially prosecute. So the
- 52:55IRS may have information that you don't know
- 52:58about, number one. They have other ways of getting
- 53:01information. But number two, a thorough IRS auditor
- 53:05is probably going to figure this out. So generally,
- 53:09the best practice is to get out ahead of it,
- 53:12to go in and say, you know what, there are problems.
- 53:14Start using the passive voice, you know, that
- 53:17mistakes were made, as opposed to identifying
- 53:20your client as the one who made them, and try
- 53:24to get out ahead of it. Put a basically a bow
- 53:28on top of it, get a CPA, forensic CPA to basically
- 53:32do the work. Go in and say, well, we found some
- 53:36errors. And for the year that's at issue here,
- 53:42here are the computations. Some attorneys even
- 53:46say, and I've gone back a year because I know
- 53:49that's exactly what you're gonna do or two years.
- 53:53And we've already done that for you as well.
- 53:55And we've already amended those tax returns for
- 53:58the years that you haven't yet picked up, but
- 54:00would if you figured out what was going on. Most
- 54:03revenue agents will just say, I'm gonna walk
- 54:05away. Thank you so much. You've made my job so
- 54:08easy. We've had some criminal cases where even
- 54:13if the lawyer was trying to do that, the client
- 54:16may not have provided all of the information
- 54:18upfront. The lawyer rushes in, for example, trying
- 54:22to get in before the agent puts too much time
- 54:26in. So there's a good reason to rush in. But
- 54:29unfortunately, the information that they give
- 54:32is incomplete. The IRS agent then figures something
- 54:35out. It's missing. Oh, you said you were fixing
- 54:37the problem and didn't. And they use that as
- 54:41a reason to send it up to IRSCI, which in this
- 54:45instance, the IRS has changed its approach to
- 54:49what cases are important criminally as a consequence
- 54:53of the new administration. Anything that you
- 54:56can say is tied to immigration. is something
- 55:00that will get kudos, and it will be considered
- 55:06as something that should be at the front of the
- 55:08line for charging. So if you have a regular employment
- 55:12tax case with no immigration in it, and you have
- 55:17an identical employment tax case that also has
- 55:21an immigration angle, which one do you think
- 55:23is gonna be charged at this point? Well, it's
- 55:25gonna be the second one. the IRS has been told
- 55:29to start working even more closely with Homeland
- 55:32Security. So those are the cases that will be
- 55:36worked. Homeland Security and IRS, they don't
- 55:41necessarily do a lot of cases historically together,
- 55:44other than on these task forces. But one thing
- 55:48that Homeland Security will learn, just like
- 55:51the FBI has learned, is that the IRS has perhaps
- 55:55the best financial investigators in the government.
- 55:58So if they're investigating an immigration crime,
- 56:02whether it be harboring or transporting folks
- 56:07into the US, it's going to be more likely you're
- 56:11going to see the IRS involved in those cases
- 56:14as well, because they add something. As a prosecutor,
- 56:19it was often easy to get a tax charge where perhaps
- 56:23the bigger crime or the initial reason that an
- 56:26individual is under investigation was harder.
- 56:31Frequently, if you're paying people in cash,
- 56:33you've often got a second set of books. And the
- 56:38IRS will often know about that, either initially
- 56:41because there's a whistleblower, which is another
- 56:44reason why you shouldn't withhold information
- 56:46from the government. They might be sitting on
- 56:48a whistleblower complaint. or through an audit,
- 56:52or they will come in and do a search warrant
- 56:55or subpoena, grand jury subpoena or a summons
- 56:59if it's an administrative criminal case. So how
- 57:03are you gonna handle a case that does go criminal?
- 57:06Well, this is the flavor of the day. This is
- 57:09a case that the IRS and Homeland Security is
- 57:12gonna want to get a big press release on. So
- 57:15you need to be aware of that when you're negotiating.
- 57:20the people who are paying attention may be in
- 57:23Washington D .C. instead of just the local U
- 57:26.S. attorney's office, for example. So they are
- 57:30frequently going to want more out of the case
- 57:33because they're trying, as the professor mentioned
- 57:36earlier, they're trying to send a message to
- 57:40employers. This has obviously been what the current
- 57:42administration has done across, I'm not saying
- 57:46anything that's I think controversial, they are
- 57:49trying to get messages out in a variety of ways,
- 57:53and one of which is through criminal prosecutions.
- 57:57So how do you handle a criminal case, a criminal
- 58:01investigation in this area, knowing that it's
- 58:04a priority? Well, keep in mind, you're probably
- 58:08representing an individual. Proving that the
- 58:12individual actually knew all of these things
- 58:15were going on, is not always the easiest thing
- 58:17in the world. In a civil audit, you don't have
- 58:20to worry about that. But in a criminal case,
- 58:24absolutely, you should be focusing on the individual
- 58:28that you're representing as opposed to this collective
- 58:31entity. I will point out if the government does
- 58:35end up charging the entity criminally, which
- 58:37does happen, particularly in cases like this
- 58:40where you're involving an employer. The government
- 58:44still has to prove that someone knew that they
- 58:47were committing a crime. They don't just add,
- 58:50someone knew this, someone knew that, someone
- 58:52intended this, someone intended that. To get
- 58:55a criminal case to stick against an entity, the
- 58:58government needs to demonstrate, again, beyond
- 59:01a reasonable doubt, that someone acting on behalf
- 59:04of the entity, in essence, held all of the necessary
- 59:09elements. So focus on whoever you represent or
- 59:14whatever you represent, because these cases,
- 59:17as politically charged as they are, you might
- 59:20find that the cases also are not being investigated
- 59:25the same way. We're seeing, obviously, a lot
- 59:28of attrition. Is that going to both in the U
- 59:32.S. Attorney's offices as well as at the IRS
- 59:34and perhaps Homeland Security? So if those things
- 59:39are happening, it's still a standard criminal
- 59:41case. just work at the same way. So I know we're
- 59:45coming to an end and I know, Professor, if you
- 59:48have any closing comments, feel free and then
- 59:51we can always hear from Philip. Just to sum up,
- 59:57say that this Hyundai raid, the investigation
- 1:00:01and the material that was used were time cards,
- 1:00:06employment records, and photos and camera. And
- 1:00:10so that highlights this was a very, I think,
- 1:00:14politically charged raid as well. And these were
- 1:00:16individuals who were on short -term visas and
- 1:00:18were going beyond that. So just another example
- 1:00:21of the scrutiny of the employer records that
- 1:00:24are being used in these enforcement operations.
- 1:00:33Okay, looks like Philip's not here. It was nice
- 1:00:36of him to introduce us. I know that there are
- 1:00:38additional panels coming up that he would have
- 1:00:41liked to have mentioned if he'd been able to
- 1:00:44make it. But regardless, thank you so much to
- 1:00:47the Beverly Hills Bar Association. Obviously,
- 1:00:49thank you, Professor. learned quite a bit from
- 1:00:54dealing with you. Likewise. I learned a lot from
- 1:00:56you, so thank you. And we appreciate everyone
- 1:00:59joining us for this. So thank you very much and
- 1:01:04have a good day.