Latest / Consumerpedia / 21 - Auto Glass Class: How to Get Repairs and Replacements
Transcript
- 0:02You're driving along when a pebble kicked up by the vehicle
- 0:04in front of you, hits the windshield and cracks it.
- 0:07Chances are that Little Rock, just created a costly headache
- 0:10for you down the road. You could be looking at 800 to
- 0:141500 dollars or more depending on your ride to replace that
- 0:17windshield. I'm her Weiss bomb the consumer,
- 0:20man, a contributing editor at checkbook.
- 0:22Dot-org, welcome to Consumer pedia at checkbook.
- 0:25Dot-org, where the nonprofit that helps consumers select
- 0:28Services avoid. Ville and save money because we
- 0:31don't accept any advertising or take money from any business.
- 0:34We recommend you can rely on checkbook, dot-org to be
- 0:37completely independent and objective.
- 0:40Now, here's the host of consumer pedia America's consumer expert
- 0:44the consumer man, herb Weiss pom.
- 0:47These days a windshield, is more than a big piece of glass.
- 0:50There's a lot of Technology embedded in it, or located
- 0:52behind it sensors. That feed data to software
- 0:55controlling, automatic wipers, Lane departure, warnings
- 0:58adaptive, cruise control. Advanced steering and braking
- 1:01systems, no matter how big or small the job, you want it done
- 1:05quickly. And for a fair price in this
- 1:08episode of consumer pedia checkbooks executive editor,
- 1:11Kevin Bressler explains, how to choose a good shop.
- 1:14How to decide about that replacement?
- 1:15Windshield original manufacturer, or third-party?
- 1:19And how to deal with the insurance companies?
- 1:21Yours or the other drivers. Hey Kevin.
- 1:23Hey herb, so why is repair work on auto glass?
- 1:27So, darn expensive. It's glass.
- 1:29Crying out loud. Yeah.
- 1:30I mean it's astonishingly expensive, right?
- 1:33While most Vehicles, the side and like the rear windows, they
- 1:36cost a hundred fifty to four hundred dollars or so to replace
- 1:39windshield replacement. These days for many models can
- 1:42run anywhere from $800 to $1000. And for, for some popular cars,
- 1:47I mean, they're like fifteen hundred dollars or more to
- 1:50replace the windshields. One of our researchers was
- 1:53talking to one shop getting prices and he's mostly a mobile
- 1:57operator, will they come to you to replace windshield?
- 2:00Olds and she has time for to do that and he said under no way
- 2:03I'm putting a two thousand dollar, windshield on my truck
- 2:06and driving it to you gotta bring your car in here.
- 2:08Right well the reason is that for many late model cars when
- 2:13you look through your windshield there's a lot of devices looking
- 2:15to they pack a lot of Technology either end of the windshields or
- 2:20right behind the windshields, you know, sensors and radar that
- 2:24feed into software that controls your automatic wipers or Lane
- 2:28departure warnings and Cruz Control adaptive steering and
- 2:31braking the radar and other devices and cameras that are
- 2:34helping. You avoid collisions there,
- 2:36right into the windshields embedded into the windshields
- 2:39are right behind them. And so when you replace or
- 2:42remove the windshields, these gadgets they have to be tested
- 2:45and recalibrated it just takes, you know, often a test drive and
- 2:50these checks can add an hour to what used to be a simple task of
- 2:54taking out one windshield and put it in another.
- 2:56Now, it's a much bigger job and the parts that they're using.
- 3:00The windshields themselves are often a lot more expensive.
- 3:02Also then based on what you said, should we skip the
- 3:05companies that say they'll come and change the glass in the
- 3:07parking lot while you're at work?
- 3:09No, I think it's fine to do that.
- 3:11I think that no matter what the, you need to make sure that if
- 3:14there's any kind of recalibration needed that, the
- 3:17company can do that often what we found when our undercover
- 3:20Shoppers were shopping for prices, for windshield
- 3:23Replacements, some shops would tell us.
- 3:25Well, I can replace the windshield but then you're going
- 3:28to have to take the car to a dealer or Different place to
- 3:30have the calibration work done. You don't want that, right?
- 3:34You want one stop shopping. You want to make sure that the
- 3:37place that's doing the work can do all the work and the reason
- 3:40is that, if there's a problem, then there's no finger-pointing.
- 3:43If you got the windshield done one place and then the
- 3:45calibration work done in another place.
- 3:48Well, what if things aren't working well, one shot May blame
- 3:51the other place and then you're just caught in the middle here.
- 3:53It's better to deal with one place.
- 3:55If there's a problem then you know where to go to get it, put
- 3:57right? What about repairing?
- 3:59The windshield. Than replacing the whole thing.
- 4:01You know, there are these companies have put this stuff in
- 4:03and puts it back together again. What about that?
- 4:05Yeah, so the good news is that shops and the kind of the
- 4:08windshield manufacturers have gotten way better at repairs,
- 4:13the modern windshields. They're essentially made with
- 4:15layers of glass, sandwiching a layer of vinyl and they're
- 4:19designed so that the glass breaks into cracks rather than
- 4:23shattering into us. And so if there's a crack on one
- 4:27of those layers, it can be filled, they inject this.
- 4:29Like this polymer in there and then they smooth it out Once the
- 4:33polymer is set. And so repairs are possible.
- 4:36Even for pretty large areas of damage larger than you might
- 4:39expect. As long as the chips of
- 4:41penetrate an angle and it's, you know, kind of made this clean
- 4:45break, and the glass and it's shallow.
- 4:48It can usually be repaired if you're not sure if the repair is
- 4:52possible, then just ask them to inspect it and let you know,
- 4:56small repairs are really inexpensive, I mean, you know,
- 4:59like you Fifty to a hundred bucks to make a small repairs.
- 5:02Opposed to eight hundred dollars or more for a new windshield
- 5:05replacement. But the trick is this you have
- 5:07to get repairs done as soon as possible if you don't rein and
- 5:11dirt and wind and stuff. We'll get into that damage stuff
- 5:15and it will make the crack worse and worse and, and once the
- 5:18crack is too big or it's in your line of vision or something like
- 5:22that, repairs are impossible. I've made this mistake a few
- 5:26times. I had a little small Ding, and
- 5:28then I drove around too long. And the little chip turned into
- 5:31a big crack and then you get the idea eight hundred dollars
- 5:34later. I had to get a new windshield
- 5:35and I would assume that Ding also reduces the Integrity that
- 5:38window, which is designed to protect you.
- 5:40If something's coming your direction.
- 5:41Exactly. And in states where they still
- 5:43do safety inspections every year, cars or every other year,
- 5:46they won't pass your car. If you have a big crack running
- 5:49across your windshield, so you can put it off for only so long
- 5:53before you can have to get this stuff fixed either for safety
- 5:55reasons, or because they just won't, they won't improve your
- 5:57car anymore. Can shops repair other one.
- 5:59Only cars it just the windshields.
- 6:01Well yeah, maybe the other windows, they're not made of the
- 6:05same kind of sandwich materials as windshields, they're usually
- 6:10tempered glass and that strengthens the glass and
- 6:13ensures it'll break up into very small pieces.
- 6:15So unlike the windshields were, they don't want it breaking into
- 6:18a bunch of pieces and your lap and your face for side windows.
- 6:22They do want it to break up into little bitty pellets as opposed
- 6:25to shards. If there's little small chips,
- 6:29they might be able To repair them instead of replacing them
- 6:31but know that, you know, replacing side and rear windows,
- 6:34it's usually a lot less expensive than having to replace
- 6:36windshields. And so most folks, they just
- 6:38stopped for replacing the glass itself.
- 6:40So checkbook has shopped the shops and we have ratings.
- 6:43Tell us what we learned. And how do you use that
- 6:45information to choose a show? We have ratings of shops for
- 6:48quality of work. Definitely check out those
- 6:51ratings before selecting a company.
- 6:52I think it's also worth looking at our price comparisons of
- 6:56local shops are undercover Shoppers collected pricing for
- 6:59several types. Replacements and for repair for
- 7:02typical cars and found really big differences.
- 7:04So for example, among shops here are I live in the Washington
- 7:07area. We got prices ranging from $410
- 7:11to six hundred and seventy-five dollars to replace the
- 7:13windshield on a Ford Fusion using OEM original manufacturer
- 7:18parts. We found prices ranging from
- 7:20eight hundred and seventy-five dollars to 1882 dollars.
- 7:25That's a difference of more than a thousand dollars to replace
- 7:29the windshield. Hold on a 2021, Honda Odyssey
- 7:32van. And again using the exact same
- 7:35parts and including recalibration of the Vans
- 7:38systems just huge price differences from shop to shop
- 7:41for the exact same work. So what if the damage was caused
- 7:44by someone else and the insurance companies paying for
- 7:47the fix, if the damage was caused by someone else and their
- 7:50insurance company is paying for the fix start by checking with
- 7:53that. Ensure some have price
- 7:54agreements in place with networks of shops, and it just
- 7:57might be a lot easier for you to go to one of their Prove shops
- 8:00to get the work done as opposed to, you know, having to take
- 8:03your car from place to place on your own.
- 8:05That way. You know, that just all the
- 8:07costs are being taken care of. Right.
- 8:09The shops going to replace the windshield or do whatever work
- 8:11needs to be done and you're not going to be left on the hook for
- 8:13some kind of overage between what the insurance company is
- 8:15willing to pay and what the shop charges.
- 8:17So when you get the estimate, you'll need to decide whether
- 8:20the replacement windshield was made by the vehicles
- 8:22manufacturer or some other company will talk to Kevin about
- 8:26that. Next, you're listening to
- 8:27Consumer pedia powered by. Checkbook, dot-org consumer PDF,
- 8:32fast facts. The first cars didn't have
- 8:35windshields Oldsmobile made them a standard feature.
- 8:38In 1915 today. Windshield damage is the most
- 8:42common type of auto insurance. Claim, the windshield glass on
- 8:45most cars weighs between 20 and 30 pounds checkbook.
- 8:48Subscribers can access radians and evaluations for auto glass
- 8:51shops auto, body shops, and auto mechanics.
- 8:54And these seven Metro areas, Boston, Chicago Philadelphia
- 8:58Seattle, San Disco, Minneapolis st.
- 9:01Paul, and Washington. D.c. if you live in one of these
- 9:04cities and haven't joined checkbook, yet check us out.
- 9:07Get a free 30-day subscription to all our ratings by going to
- 9:09check book. Dot org, slash consumer pedia.
- 9:13You know when checkbook gives advice about repair work at auto
- 9:16body shops. We talk about two different
- 9:18kinds of Parts, the original equipment manufacturer or OEM
- 9:22parts or aftermarket parts made by a third party company.
- 9:25Kevin, is this something we need to worry about when we deal with
- 9:28Auto Glass? It it is the good news is that
- 9:31all automotive glass. It must meet certain, you know,
- 9:34Federal Motor Vehicle Safety route standards, right?
- 9:37But as with Auto Body repairs, you often get the choice between
- 9:42glass, that's original equipment, manufacturer, OEM
- 9:45parts parts that were originally designed and manufactured.
- 9:49When the car was assembled versus other parts.
- 9:52Aftermarket parts made by third-party companies that were
- 9:56made to fit that car, but weren't part of that original
- 9:59kind of Mine process manufacturing process.
- 10:02I think it definitely makes sense, to ask shops about their
- 10:05experience, with either type for your car, and let you know what
- 10:09they think, OEM parts cost more but in general, most shops,
- 10:14prefer them. But some shops may be able to
- 10:16tell, you know, we work with this aftermarket part all the
- 10:18time, and it's fine. It really is.
- 10:20It does vary considerably from car to car, but having said that
- 10:24most of the shops we spoke with overwhelmingly prefer to use OEM
- 10:28parts and it's not just, Just because they cost more.
- 10:31It's because they fit better and because it's easier to
- 10:33recalibrate everything and make it work.
- 10:35Then the aftermarket ones. And we've actually gotten the
- 10:38point where a lot of vehicle manufacturers are urging
- 10:41customers to get OEM windshield Replacements versus aftermarket.
- 10:45There's a conflict of interest there right there, making the
- 10:48windshields themselves or have a partner that's doing it for them
- 10:51and therefore there's a profit motive to a manufacturing
- 10:54automaker saying hey use OEM Parts.
- 10:57But I think especially in the case of windshields Just too
- 11:00much evidence out there in terms of our discussions with shops
- 11:03and everything else I've read about.
- 11:04It says that OEM is probably a better idea, especially for
- 11:08windshield Replacements in after-market, should you assume
- 11:10that if a shop can replace the glass?
- 11:13It can also calibrate it. No.
- 11:14And so this is a problem we had when we were doing our test
- 11:17shopping, that some shops, especially for some makes and
- 11:20models of cars, doing that recalibration work was just too
- 11:23complicated for them and so they were willing to replace the
- 11:26windshield but they were saying we were going to have to take
- 11:28the car to a dealership. Ship to have the recalibration
- 11:31work done and then some dealerships.
- 11:32We contacted said, well yeah, we're not able actually able to
- 11:34do the recalibration work here. You're going to take it to this
- 11:37auto glass place because they have more expertise and better
- 11:40equipment for this. It was bizarre really.
- 11:43When we were doing this work at, you know, how for some cars,
- 11:45especially cars with really complicated systems, how much
- 11:49trouble it was going to be for us to get just a windshield
- 11:52replacement done me, one little pebble is created this massive
- 11:55problem, basically, for a lot of drivers these days because of
- 11:58this recalibration, You as we mentioned before, it is vastly
- 12:02preferable to have all the work done, the replacement and the
- 12:06calibration work done by the same shop.
- 12:08So do ask in advance who's going to do that work.
- 12:11Make sure it's all being done by the same shop.
- 12:13I digress a little bit here but it's clear that Parts aren't
- 12:17simple anymore. Mean, even a bumper is not a
- 12:19bumper. It's got all the safety stuff in
- 12:20it. Right now, you can't just have
- 12:22anybody slap a bumper on? I mean, that's where we are with
- 12:24automobiles right now. These are rolling safety devices
- 12:27as well as Transportation lat. Of sensors.
- 12:30I mean there are sensors everywhere in cars these days
- 12:32and the materials are cars, are made with.
- 12:34It used to be the Bodywork was all sheet metal.
- 12:37And that's not at all the case anymore.
- 12:38A lot of cars. They the outside skin is made of
- 12:41plastic, a lot of aluminum, is used some cars have Composite
- 12:45Materials. It used to be nice to just bang
- 12:47out dents and if the windshield got nicked, you just replace the
- 12:50thing and sealed it right back up and you're good to go.
- 12:53And and these days, you know, almost every repairers become
- 12:56complicated and unfortunately the one part of your car, The
- 12:59most vulnerable to damage is the windshield.
- 13:02Yet there's a lot of Technology either packed into the
- 13:04windshield or sitting right behind it.
- 13:07That relies on the windshield, and it's created a lot of
- 13:09headaches for drivers having to replace just a windshield.
- 13:12And if you find a shop, you really like and you're about
- 13:15ready to commit, you should probably ask some a time frame
- 13:17because they may have problems with parts because of what's
- 13:20going on now with the supply chain and then mask and what
- 13:22kind of warranty that they provide with us that may vary
- 13:25from shop to shop? You're absolutely right.
- 13:27I mean, ask about a timetable there.
- 13:29Might be delays, especially these days and you might find
- 13:32that you can contact a different shop that can get the work done
- 13:35faster. It's also I think, pretty
- 13:37important ask about warranty details look for one that covers
- 13:41the service life of the vehicle. That's what you're looking for.
- 13:44I make sure that the warranty covers the costs of replacing
- 13:47the glass and the labor involved to do that.
- 13:50The good news is that most shops do give quote-unquote lifetime
- 13:54warranties for windshield and other glass Replacements.
- 13:57So with us were costing so much Does it make sense to add one of
- 14:01those? No deductible glass, coverage
- 14:03Riders to your auto insurance policy.
- 14:04You definitely want to avoid making small claims on your auto
- 14:08insurance policy. If you do your rates, may go up
- 14:11and some states, they can easily drop you for just making one
- 14:15little claim. But, think about it this way,
- 14:18let like, even if your windshields and expensive
- 14:20replacement, $700 $800 or more, if your deductible is $500,
- 14:25that's not a claim you're probably going to want to make
- 14:28because you're only going to save.
- 14:29Two or three hundred dollars once you've paid your deductible
- 14:32and then you may be on the hook for a big premium increase down
- 14:35the road, especially when you renew your policy.
- 14:38So know that though, a lot of insurers they offer no
- 14:41deductible glass coverage, and that sounds sensible, right?
- 14:45Like I might have this problem and if I don't have to pay a
- 14:47deductible for repairs, it might make sense to have that coverage
- 14:50because I don't have to worry about these.
- 14:51You little claim ahead and make that claim and get my windshield
- 14:54replaced, but it's often just not a good by the added policy
- 14:58feature. If it's Three or four only cost
- 15:01forty or fifty dollars more a year than sure.
- 15:03You can go ahead and get it. Especially if you know your
- 15:05windshield is going to be expensive to replace, but most
- 15:08companies they charge a lot more than that and it just makes it a
- 15:11bad by you're just increasing your premium costs.
- 15:15And you know also that you know even though they might not
- 15:17charge you a deductible, if you have a claim for glass
- 15:20replacement, that doesn't mean they won't jack up your rates.
- 15:23It doesn't mean in some states. They may not drop you later on
- 15:27for having made that claim their promise to you.
- 15:29Is only that they're not going to charge you a deductible.
- 15:31If you have a claim, they're not promising not to Skyrocket.
- 15:35Your rate for doing so well. As you said, a little Pebble,
- 15:38can cause a lot of headache, but you got to know what you're
- 15:40doing because you could have more problems down the road if
- 15:42you don't do it right? That's right.
- 15:43And they, I every time I hear a pebble, hit my windshield, these
- 15:46days I just shot her Holly looking at very carefully,
- 15:48right? Because just so expensive to
- 15:50have this work done for something, that doesn't seem
- 15:53like it should be so expensive, it really is these days.
- 15:56Great advice Kevin. Thank you, as always thank you.
- 15:59Well, That's it. For this episode of consumer
- 16:01pedia, you can subscribe to us on Apple or Google podcasts
- 16:04Spotify, Stitcher, or wherever you listen to your podcast.
- 16:08That way you won't miss an episode.
- 16:10Remember we release new ones, every other Thursday, another
- 16:13way you can support this show is to follow us on consumer, pedia
- 16:17on Facebook and Instagram and at my consumer pedia on Twitter.
- 16:22I'm her, why Spong? Thanks for listening consumer.
- 16:24Pedia is a public service of checkbook, dot-org.
- 16:27We're a unique nonprofit that empowers you the consumer to
- 16:30save money and make smarter choices from auto repair shops
- 16:34to doctors plumbers to vets, you can count on checkbook, dot-org
- 16:37to help you find the best services, and avoid the worst
- 16:40local ratings are unbiased and accurate.
- 16:43If you live in, or around these Seven Cities and haven't joined
- 16:46checkbook. Yet check this out, Boston,
- 16:48Chicago Philadelphia Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis st.
- 16:53Paul and Washington DC to get your free 30-day subscription.
- 16:57Go to check book dot org slash Consumer, PDF consumer pedia
- 17:02empowering consumers to save money and make smarter choices.