Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E003: Macro Masterclass with Lyn Alden
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company. On Ramp's multi institution
- 0:35Custody is a segregated institutional grade vault
- 0:38requiring two of three institutions at any point in
- 0:41time to sign once a client's unique permissions have been met
- 0:45at on RAMP We understand that your Bitcoin journey is a multi
- 0:48generational pursuit catalyzed by the ideals of perseverance,
- 0:52aspiration and legacy. That's why we're proud to
- 0:55introduce on RAMP Heritage, a suite of private client services
- 0:59dedicated to ensuring your Bitcoin legacy is preserved and
- 1:02passed on, embodying the true essence of wealth that goes
- 1:06beyond mere numbers. If you would like to learn more,
- 1:08please schedule a consultation. As we prepare for the Bitcoin
- 1:11having and the next wave of global adoption of this nascent
- 1:15and growing asset class, we are halving all annual maintenance
- 1:18fees for clients that secure their wealth before the next
- 1:21Bitcoin epoch. Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an
- 1:26international asset. We are spending like drunken
- 1:29sailors. Bitcoin is the only economic
- 1:32entity where the supply is unaffected by the demand.
- 1:38If you want to preserve your wealth, you have to convert that
- 1:41currency into an asset that's scarce, desirable, portable,
- 1:46durable, and maintainable. Hello, my name is Andy Edstrom
- 1:56and I'm so excited to welcome you to the third episode of
- 2:00Scarce Assets, a show that examined scarcity, the most
- 2:03fundamental driver of economics and markets, and the scarcest
- 2:07asset of all, which is Bitcoin. Today, I'm very happy to be here
- 2:11with my Co host Jesse Myers and our guest, the brilliant Lynn
- 2:14Alden. Now I have the pleasure of
- 2:16saying a few things about Lynn. Just like our first two guests
- 2:20on scarce assets, Lynn is a professional innovator both in
- 2:23Bitcoin and outside of Bitcoin. She's an entrepreneur and an
- 2:27investor and an exceptional macro analyst.
- 2:31Now this gives her a unique and valuable view into all asset
- 2:34classes as well as into the global monetary system.
- 2:38Her book, Broken Money is honestly the best finance book
- 2:42I've read in a long time, and that includes both traditional
- 2:45finance books and Bitcoin books. And I'm also confident to say
- 2:49that it's probably the single best book I've read on the
- 2:51monetary system. And I've read quite a few of
- 2:54those. So the title is Broken Money,
- 2:56and I personally got a lot out of it and I highly recommend it.
- 3:00And lastly, I'm just going to say that I've listened to
- 3:03thousands of podcasts myself, and Lynn is consistently both
- 3:06entertaining and professional. I'll just add an anecdote here
- 3:09quickly, which is in late 2020 I had the privilege of appearing
- 3:13with Lynn on the Swan Signal podcast, then hosted by the
- 3:16great Brady Swenson and now the great Sam Callahan.
- 3:20And about 10 minutes into the interview, my 4 year old bombed
- 3:23into the room and took the conversation off the rails for a
- 3:26moment. But Lynn was totally
- 3:27unflappable. She both took it in stride and
- 3:31also did not have small children running around through her
- 3:33frame. Who knows, maybe she will
- 3:35someday. But in the meantime, she's
- 3:37always been both a true professional and very kind to
- 3:39me, and I'm absolutely delighted to have her here with us today.
- 3:43So Lynn, how are you? I'm great.
- 3:46Thanks for having me and Congrats on your new podcast.
- 3:48Excited to see where it goes? Thank you very much.
- 3:52Really appreciate you joining us.
- 3:54Let's just dive right in to Broken Money, your book.
- 3:59One of my favorite parts of the book is chapters you devote to
- 4:04examples of money creation and what the implications are for
- 4:09the money and credit system and also for inflation.
- 4:12So I want to ask you if you'd be willing to touch on maybe a
- 4:15couple of archetypal examples of what some people might call
- 4:20money printing and talk about what they mean for inflation or
- 4:24for the monetary system overall. Sure.
- 4:28And like a a consistent theme that I touch on in broken money
- 4:30is idea. That money is like a Ledger that
- 4:32people either agree to use or some cases forced to use or
- 4:36using a Ledger either in the literal form or the abstract
- 4:40form. And so the big questions to ask
- 4:42are who can censor transactions and who can create more of those
- 4:46units or in some rare cases who can destroy those units in a
- 4:49centralized way. And so, you know, you can kind
- 4:53of think of that as two main things.
- 4:54There's commodity money itself, right?
- 4:56So we have a lot of known examples of those.
- 4:58We have grains, we have obviously gold and silver.
- 5:01In later years, we have shells. There's all matter of different
- 5:07types of money that people can use.
- 5:08One of the examples that I like is the tobacco example in early
- 5:13United States before they were actually a country, just the
- 5:16early colonies. And the reason is it was kind of
- 5:19like the gold standard but accelerated.
- 5:21So like all the flaws of money all kind of happened within a
- 5:24pretty short time period because it was, it was less sound.
- 5:27And so we kind of ran through the full gambit of all the
- 5:31problems and and frictions that people find with money.
- 5:33And so, you know, when they get to the colonies, there's not a
- 5:36lot of species, there's not a lot of coinage.
- 5:39And so they're kind of gravitating towards other types
- 5:42of money, especially for kind of everyday transactions.
- 5:45On one hand, they turned to the shell money of of the, you know,
- 5:49the indigenous people. And they kind of used that money
- 5:52without the ceremony that was normally attached to that type
- 5:55of money by the natives themselves.
- 5:57But they, they just kind of used it for its scarcity purpose.
- 6:00And then they also turned to using tobacco as money, which
- 6:03was a major cash crop. And what's notable about tobacco
- 6:07is obviously it's you know you get a lot of value per kind of
- 6:11mass and weight relative to other crops.
- 6:13It's a it's a cash crop in that sense and it was it has globally
- 6:18desirable crop and so they start kind of making that into money.
- 6:22They say, OK, well here's it's legal tender.
- 6:24We're going to use this along with things like wampum, you
- 6:27know, the the shell money and. But then all the natural things
- 6:31start happening, right. So if if tobacco is money, it
- 6:35means more people are holding it it for reasons in addition to
- 6:39its utility value. And so it's kind of overvalued.
- 6:42It's like more valuable than you'd expected to be based on
- 6:45its utility alone. And so there's a really strong
- 6:48desire to plant more of it because it's it's overvalued.
- 6:51And so people start planning more of it and you start to get
- 6:53tobacco price inflation. And then so then the authority
- 6:57is like no, no, wait, we have to put restrictions on who can plan
- 7:00it, right. And so then they have, you know,
- 7:03if you're it's kind of the the classic, if you're close to the
- 7:06source of power, you know you're one of the privileged groups
- 7:08that can plan it. Otherwise you can't.
- 7:10Then there's like bootleg tobacco planting because it's
- 7:15it's still profitable to try to plan it.
- 7:16Obviously there's more risks and then there's problems of
- 7:19fungibility. So not all tobacco is the same.
- 7:22It's different ages, different types, different quality.
- 7:25And so then they said, OK, well, instead of using tobacco
- 7:27directly, we're going to abstract it.
- 7:29Everybody's going to put their tobacco to warehouse and
- 7:31professionals will grade it and it will have tobacco receipts.
- 7:35And now you have both tobacco that's not really scarce, but
- 7:38you're still using this money. It's got lack of fungibility,
- 7:42but you're so now you're abstracting it.
- 7:44So you have like really counterparty risk on top of an
- 7:46unsound money and eventually the system became so untenable and
- 7:50that the economy's developed enough that they had more
- 7:53species to work with. So they they abandoned that
- 7:55system. And in parallel similar thing
- 7:57happened with the shell money. So you know, the shell money was
- 8:00very valuable to the natives. It was very hard to make.
- 8:04You know, it's it's got inherent scarcity to it and it has the
- 8:06good properties of money. It's portable, it's long lasting
- 8:09and has all those attributes. But as soon as you add metal
- 8:13tooling and other kind of sophisticated techniques of
- 8:17gathering shells and then polishing and drilling them and
- 8:20making them into their final form, they could basically
- 8:23devalue the money. They could inflate the supply
- 8:26more readily than was normally the case.
- 8:29And so a similar along with the lines of tobacco, they inflated
- 8:34it until it was not really useful money anymore and they
- 8:36had to gravitate towards stronger types of monies.
- 8:39So there's all, there's all sorts of examples like that, but
- 8:41I find those interesting because they're well documented compared
- 8:45to many other types of monies. And there was all kind of all
- 8:48the problems kind of unfolded over an accelerated pace because
- 8:51you had like a clash of cultures and you had a kind of a unique
- 8:54example of a fairly developed civilization but in a new
- 8:58environment. So they were kind of cut off
- 8:59from there, you know, more developed core and so you had
- 9:03kind of the clash of older money systems, new money systems all
- 9:07kind of coming together. Well, it sounds to me like the
- 9:10tobacco monetary standard just went up in smoke in a relatively
- 9:15short period of time there. He was sitting on that for a
- 9:17while. Been saving that one up.
- 9:21OK, well, let's talk a little about another one of the key
- 9:25insights I thought from your book which relates to monetary
- 9:28velocity. I have to say I did not
- 9:32understand this concept until I read your book or really I
- 9:36hadn't understand, understood how impactful or important it
- 9:40could be, especially as it relates to velocity of other
- 9:44standard monies monetary standards whether it be gold or
- 9:47Fiat. Would you mind enlightening us a
- 9:50little bit more on this Velocity issue and and the technology
- 9:54related to it? Well, so velocity has multiple
- 9:56different definitions. You know, the kind of the
- 9:58classic definition is is, you know, you compare GDP to the
- 10:02money supply and see what that multiple is.
- 10:04So velocity is kind of that filler variable, but in the
- 10:07broader sense, it's basically how how easily money moves.
- 10:10And that has a technological component to it.
- 10:13And one thing I described in the book is that for in the
- 10:15development of money, there's basically 2 technological paths
- 10:18that are happening simultaneously.
- 10:19One is what we're actually using as money itself, which we just
- 10:23touched on. For example, if our technology
- 10:25is too good for shells, we can't use shells anymore.
- 10:28We have to use something that even our new technology can't
- 10:30make more of quickly, like gold, for example.
- 10:32So you kind of move up the hardness scale in terms of
- 10:35different types of of commodity money.
- 10:37That's that's one technical path.
- 10:39But the other technical path could basically be described as
- 10:42analog encryption or various technologies that overlay on top
- 10:47of those monies and allow the ownership of it to move around
- 10:50more quickly. Because when you're moving and
- 10:53transporting commodity money, especially, you know, gold bars
- 10:56and things like that, both the transport of it securely and
- 11:00then the auditing of it down to its core, these are time
- 11:03consuming, inefficient, expensive processes.
- 11:06And so going back, you know, literally hundreds and in many
- 11:09cases thousands of years, there's various types of proto
- 11:13bankers kind of before the modern banking establishments
- 11:16and early bankers, they were trying to find ways to make this
- 11:19more efficient. And so going back to, you know,
- 11:23ancient Egypt, for example, there'd be papyrus bills of
- 11:25exchange. And there's also early examples
- 11:28along the Silk Road in like Central Asia and a lot of things
- 11:32that we don't really consider technology today were all ways
- 11:35to make the transfer of of money is quicker and more efficient.
- 11:40So coinage for example is one of the classic monetary
- 11:43technologies. You put them in the standard
- 11:45units with various anti forgery techniques or anti shaving
- 11:48techniques on the metal itself to make that exchange more
- 11:51rapid. There's also the the invention
- 11:54of paper and then the invention of book binding and then the
- 11:57invention of you know different types of inks and then you have
- 12:00analog encryption. So for example if if I give gold
- 12:03to a merchant and that merchant signs a piece of paper that I
- 12:07can then transfer to another city and exchange for at a
- 12:11different merchant for gold, again, obviously those merchants
- 12:14in their network have to have some sort of anti forgery
- 12:16technology on top of it to to make sure that it people can't
- 12:20just copy those paper receipts and just redeem gold that they
- 12:23never put in. And so you have the development
- 12:25of this various kind of anti forgery encryption techniques in
- 12:30the analog sense. Then things like the printing
- 12:32press which you know again is today is not new technology.
- 12:36But back then that was a big deal.
- 12:37I mean the complex paper instruments that are
- 12:40standardized and and complex became cheaper to do and so that
- 12:45that expanded the number of things you can do with paper
- 12:48like widespread usage of banknotes and things like that.
- 12:52So there was that that technological path over top of
- 12:55the of the commodity money angle.
- 12:57And these were kind of developing along the
- 12:59simultaneous lines. And then when you get into the
- 13:01modern era, you get even further developments.
- 13:04And I I contend, for example, that the Telegraph was an
- 13:08enormous stepwise change in the speed of money globally.
- 13:12So prior to that, there's virtually no way to send
- 13:16information faster than matter, right.
- 13:18So even with complex banking and Ledger systems, those Ledger's
- 13:23still only moved at the speed of people, right?
- 13:25So foot horses, ships, you know, with rare low bandwidth
- 13:29exceptions of like fire signals in the night.
- 13:32You can't, you can't send information long distances
- 13:34quickly, faster than ship. But what made the Telegraph so
- 13:38interesting is that now you could send higher bandwidth
- 13:41information around the world very quickly.
- 13:44And for the first time in thousands and thousands of years
- 13:47in human history, we had this big gap between how quickly we
- 13:51could transfer information versus how quickly we were still
- 13:53confined to transferring matter. And the, you know, that had, I
- 13:58think most historians when they focus on that, they focus on the
- 14:00geopolitical implications. But there's a pretty
- 14:02straightforward monetary implication which I don't see
- 14:05discussed that often and why I chose to emphasize it so much,
- 14:08which is that information transferring information allows
- 14:11you to make transactions, but especially in a low bandwidth
- 14:15setting like that and it does not allow you to make
- 14:17settlements. And so the, the gulf between
- 14:20settlement, the transactions and settlements became larger than
- 14:22ever. So prior to then there were
- 14:25still somewhat of a gap. So there's various paper
- 14:27instruments I I mentioned you know, they basically increased
- 14:30the gap between transaction speed and settlement speed, but
- 14:32it was still like a manageable size.
- 14:35But this just completely blew open the, the, the scale and the
- 14:39speed of those two things. And what I would argue is that
- 14:43basically we had a century and a half of just extreme levels of
- 14:46financial centralization and most of that was to bridge that
- 14:50gap between those transaction speeds and those settlement
- 14:53speeds basically because you had to rely on some sort of trusted
- 14:55entity in in the middle until we we basically just dropped the
- 15:00idea of settlement altogether. We just dropped the idea of
- 15:03using any sort of underlying gold and the Ledger itself
- 15:06became the settlement. And you know, going to the the
- 15:10modern era, what makes Bitcoin so interesting is that finally
- 15:14technology and bandwidth globally came together enough
- 15:18that we could do digital settlement, not just digital
- 15:20transactions. And that really could not have
- 15:23occurred much earlier than it happened, right?
- 15:26I mean you had obviously the development of the Internet.
- 15:28You had to have not just low bandwidth Internet, but fairly
- 15:30high bandwidth Internet, pretty globally accessible.
- 15:34Then you had to have pretty advanced encryption techniques.
- 15:37Some of them were only invented, you know, less than a decade
- 15:39before Bitcoin came out. And so as these things come came
- 15:43together, we got the emergence of Bitcoin which is digital
- 15:46settlement. And so that's like what I
- 15:49describe as closing that 150 year gap between transactions
- 15:53and settlements. And the kind of the take away
- 15:56point is how much technology influences who controls money,
- 16:01right. So, you know, if you go back
- 16:03centuries, the idea of surveilling every transaction is
- 16:07like science fiction, whereas now it's, it's almost like
- 16:10people say why, Why wouldn't government surveil every
- 16:12transaction, right. It seems normal.
- 16:15And if you, if you kind of question it, it's almost like
- 16:17you're the weird one. You're like, well, what are you
- 16:19up to then if you don't want every transaction being
- 16:21surveilled? And so basically the, the
- 16:23technology, the speed, all these things are heavily influenced by
- 16:27technology. Even though a lot of monetary
- 16:30history books focus on human decisions, which I you know
- 16:33they're they're relevant for certain times and certain areas.
- 16:36But that link between technology and money and how fast it allows
- 16:40money to move and who controls it, I I think is something that
- 16:43was generally under explored and why I emphasize you so much.
- 16:47That's that's incredible. I I have to confess, I had not
- 16:51yet read Broken Money and I will now be reading it after getting
- 16:55this little teaser. Incredible.
- 16:58But I have to, I have to ask this question of So Linda, does
- 17:01that mean that you view central banking and Fiat money as a
- 17:07necessary stop gap, a transition era that was bound to happen as
- 17:11a result of this technology gap? Yeah, I would use the word
- 17:15inevitable more so than necessary.
- 17:18One of the themes that kind of indirectly comes up in the book
- 17:20is the idea of kind of technological determinism, which
- 17:24is that when certain orders of events happen, one kind of leads
- 17:29to the other. And so if we use another
- 17:31example, if we were to rerun this human history 100 times,
- 17:36either 99 or 100 times, the bicycle would be invented before
- 17:40the automobile and before the airplane, right?
- 17:42Because one kind of leads ones like a necessary but
- 17:45insufficient part of the next one, right?
- 17:47So something really weird would have to happen to invent the
- 17:50airplane before you have something like a bicycle or
- 17:53something like a car. And the same thing is kind of
- 17:56true with money, which is that we kind of saw the emergence of
- 18:00pretty common paths, right? So first there was proto banking
- 18:04that's kind of it's like channel like banking in the modern
- 18:07context. It's almost like lightning came
- 18:09before Bitcoin in the sense that you know you'd have these
- 18:12bankers that are basically they they have direct connections
- 18:15with other merchants in other cities and they can allow for
- 18:18the transporting of money pretty quickly.
- 18:20It's more about actually transferring money than credit
- 18:23even though it relies on credit to make that transfer.
- 18:26And then you had the development of of you know more free banking
- 18:28type of arrangements. But the problem is that when all
- 18:33the gold kind of gets put into a couple different hubs, like a
- 18:36couple different major banks, the governments know where all
- 18:39the gold is now, right? Instead of being diffused
- 18:41throughout the population, it's it's in certain hubs and there's
- 18:45ledgers built on top of those hubs that allow people to
- 18:47transfer the ownership of it more readily.
- 18:50That was basically, for example, the whole point of, you know,
- 18:53banking in those Italian city states is that they'd have the
- 18:56gold in one spot and you'd have a Venetian merchant and an Arab
- 19:00merchant. And they could just go to their
- 19:02go to the banker and say, well, OK, we transferred these spices
- 19:05and now we're going to just transfer these Ledger entry for
- 19:08for who owns this amount of gold.
- 19:10And the gold would still just kind of be sitting in the same
- 19:12vault. And the problem is that that all
- 19:15coalesces and governments know where it is.
- 19:19And so they can say, well, OK, now every every bank has to put
- 19:22all or some of their gold into this big central vault.
- 19:25And then also you have the constant tendency towards
- 19:28duration mismatching. So there's all these debates
- 19:30around fractional reserve or full reserve banking.
- 19:33I prefer to kind of describe it as either full either duration
- 19:38matched or duration mismatched banking, which is basically your
- 19:41your, your liabilities are you're making promises that you
- 19:45only probabilistically can keep. So you have this kind of
- 19:49ultimately unsound arrangement that leads to kind of cascading
- 19:53crises. And then one of the solutions
- 19:56for those is central banking. But then it comes it's almost
- 19:58like a deal with the devil in the sense that it it fixed over
- 20:01your immediately problem but then it further over decades
- 20:05further centralizes the system. So one of the things I argue is
- 20:08the fact that. You know, gold failed almost
- 20:11everywhere. At the same time, you know,
- 20:13other than Switzerland and a few others, it, it pretty much all
- 20:15failed at the same time. And the fact that we look around
- 20:18today, there's no countries on a gold standard like not one.
- 20:22There's no country that does for their banking, even though it's
- 20:26just inherently more stable of a system.
- 20:28It's just the incentives did not work that way.
- 20:31I generally argue that the the, the, the, the path, the
- 20:33technology that was available so strongly tilt incentives towards
- 20:38some directions that you know 99 or 100 times out of 100 it leads
- 20:42towards those directions at least until another technology
- 20:46comes along that swings those incentives back in another
- 20:49direction. Right.
- 20:50So for you know a century you'd have sound money advocates or
- 20:54Austrian economist proponents saying how things should be and
- 20:58just kind of getting ignored, right.
- 21:00They they're they're kind of making arguments about and it's
- 21:02just kind of nation states were like that's cool and they just
- 21:05ignored them. Whereas I kind of view Bitcoin
- 21:09as the first tool that actually gives them the the burden of
- 21:12power, right? That they that things now a
- 21:15little bit kind of tilt the scales back in their favor to
- 21:18some extent. So yeah, I, I I kind of view a
- 21:20lot of it as even though there were human decisions that can be
- 21:24described as some cases ethical, some cases unethical, and they
- 21:28can affect the timing of certain things.
- 21:30When you generally see the whole world move in a direction for a
- 21:33period of time, it's it's usually the case that technology
- 21:36has kind of strongly tilted the scales in that favor, at least
- 21:39at least for that era. Yeah, I want to, I want to under
- 21:43score that that's another major point that you make in the book,
- 21:46which is governments or other organizations can react or
- 21:51attempt to react or they can attempt to impose restrictions
- 21:55or rules. But it's really hard to argue
- 21:59with the fundamentals of technology and when a new
- 22:01technology that's better along multiple parameters comes along
- 22:06very difficult to to contain it. So I would you mentioned you
- 22:13mentioned duration mismatch. So I'm going to take us to one
- 22:18of my other questions which is this is the scarce assets show.
- 22:23So let's talk about an asset that most listeners probably
- 22:26don't consider to be very scarce and that's U.S., government
- 22:30bonds, 10 year and longer maturities.
- 22:34My hypothesis, let's just say, is that this asset may be very
- 22:40scarce this year and that's because it's an election year.
- 22:43Then I think the Fed and the Treasury want to keep the long
- 22:46end of the curve down to keep asset prices up and that could
- 22:51mean either more QE or it could be a mix shift, an additional
- 22:55mix shift let's say by the Treasury in favor of shorter
- 22:59maturities rather than longer. Do you have any thoughts on this
- 23:04and and what's going to happen with the with the bond mix
- 23:07likely in the next year or two? Well, so one thing that's
- 23:10interesting is that the entire reverse repo facility basically
- 23:13represents excess demand for T-bills beyond the amount that
- 23:17is available. And so and that that's a market
- 23:20that I've been following pretty closely throughout my just kind
- 23:23of macro career. So for example back in 2019 we
- 23:27had the opposite, we had a repo spike and we had the Fed engage
- 23:30in repo activities and that was partially just because there
- 23:33were too many T-bills, relatively available liquidity
- 23:36to absorb those T-bills. But after all the QE that
- 23:40happened during the during the pandemic stimulus and lockdowns
- 23:44and all that, you had this build up of excess cash that wanted to
- 23:48be in T-bills. And so they set up all the
- 23:50reverse repo facilities and things like that to ensure that
- 23:53T bill yields don't get driven below their the lower bound of
- 23:57their interest rate targets. And so as long as that pool of
- 24:02capital exists, policy makers specifically at the Treasury
- 24:06have the option to tilt duration towards the shorter end to try
- 24:10to meet that excessive demand for T-bills and relieve the
- 24:14potentially insufficient demand for longer dated securities.
- 24:18And so we we've seen kind of a gamification of that in the past
- 24:23year or more. And one of the kind of the
- 24:26dilemmas you face as the Treasury is you know you're
- 24:29you're trying to issue debt. I mean you're not the the
- 24:31Treasury's not the one that determines what the deficits
- 24:34are, right, that that's mostly Congress and the president and
- 24:37all that kind of comes together. But you're as the Treasury, it's
- 24:40your job to figure out what types of bonds to issue to, to
- 24:44meet those demands. And if you go back long enough,
- 24:47that wasn't always the case. It used to be that Congress
- 24:49would basically authorize every type of of bond to pay for every
- 24:53type of debt. And eventually they said, OK,
- 24:56that's the micromanagement is getting too silly there because
- 24:59the the whole apparatus is getting too big.
- 25:02And so they said, OK, well, we'll just set a limit.
- 25:04Here's a debt ceiling. And the Treasury can go out and
- 25:07figure the details of what bonds to issue and what durations and
- 25:11any sort of parameters they want to do.
- 25:13And so the Treasury has this job of meeting this very large
- 25:17deficit and they have different parameters that they're trying
- 25:20to meet. So one is obviously they want to
- 25:22have the lowest cost available to the government.
- 25:24That's that's a big variable, right.
- 25:26So if there's a different part to the Treasury curve, you can
- 25:29potentially save some money by issuing debt on the on the
- 25:32cheaper part of the curve, but it has other consequences.
- 25:36Another big one is obviously liquidity.
- 25:37If you don't want to cause a liquidity problem, you can issue
- 25:43bonds on the more expensive part of the curve, but that is more
- 25:46conducive to liquidity and asset prices and things like that.
- 25:49So basically the treasury of the past year or more has erred on
- 25:53the side of issuing among the more expensive parts of debt,
- 25:58which is short duration debt in an environment of an inverted
- 26:01yield curve, right. So it's the most expensive part
- 26:03of the yield curve, but it's the least negative for liquidity and
- 26:08in many cases can be positive for liquidity because they're
- 26:11sucking money out of the reverse repos rather than elsewhere and
- 26:14spending that back into the economy.
- 26:17So I do think that they're going to probably keep tilting towards
- 26:21the short end of the curve until the reverse repo facility is
- 26:23used up. Some of this is non linear.
- 26:26So. So I think 1 error that market
- 26:29participants make sometimes is they extrapolate, here's what
- 26:32happened the last quarter or two.
- 26:33So here's what's likely to happen the next quarter or two,
- 26:36whereas when you look at the four quarters of the, the fiscal
- 26:39year, for example, tax quarter is very different than other
- 26:43quarters, right, because you have this influx of revenue and
- 26:46you have different different spending patterns, right.
- 26:49So what what happens in any, any given quarter is not necessarily
- 26:52the same that happens next quarter.
- 26:53So I think that the next couple quarters are maybe less extreme
- 26:58than we've seen over the past couple quarters where if you if
- 27:01you just analyze like annualize the last two quarters, you get
- 27:05to a pretty silly number, whereas that's not really how it
- 27:08works in in the calendar year. And so I do think that some of
- 27:11this will become less extreme over the next, call it five
- 27:15months or so, but that structurally those same problems
- 27:18are there. So I think we've already seen
- 27:21kind of the maybe the most shocking part of the transition
- 27:23where they thought a lot of these coupons were going to
- 27:26happen. It was, it was kind of a shock
- 27:27announcement of how tilted towards bills it was.
- 27:31We'll see what happens, you know kind of quarter by quarter
- 27:34including shortly here to see what the specific kind of you
- 27:41know, long for short is going to be.
- 27:43But I do think that the, the Treasury is managing liquidity
- 27:46above most other variables. And if you look at, for example,
- 27:52you know, bank reserves in the system, they kind of hit their
- 27:55bottom right around that banking crisis of nearly a year ago and
- 28:00they've been flat up ever since. That was kind of the line in the
- 28:02sand for where they wanted to go.
- 28:05And so ever since then they they've pretty much been
- 28:08managing around liquidity. And so I think that's probably
- 28:10going to continue at least until the reverse facility's drained,
- 28:14perhaps later this year. Yeah, that's that.
- 28:18Is that still in a few months or that it was on a tremendous
- 28:20drawdown rate that last I looked was targeting like end of March
- 28:24for it to be depleted, but it's probably slowed since then?
- 28:28So, so far it's not slowed that much but I do think it could
- 28:31slow around tax season as we get closer to to tax season, we're
- 28:34now kind of entering tax season and that's what I mean by those
- 28:37non linear effects. So the shortage is, I'm not sure
- 28:40because you know tax season could surprise the upside or
- 28:44downside. Sometimes it comes in a little
- 28:47bit, you know hot or cold I think in large part because
- 28:52asset prices have been pretty good lately.
- 28:55Tax season will probably be pretty solid all us being equal,
- 28:59which is why I think it might slow a little bit.
- 29:02And and there are well known well known analysts and
- 29:04investors that are more explicitly calling for a
- 29:08slowdown of the drain rate of the reverse repo facility.
- 29:13I have maybe less conviction than them, but I I do err
- 29:15towards that likely being the outcome which is that the the
- 29:19very sharp rate we've seen over the past six months or so, I do
- 29:22expect that to slow. So I wouldn't necessarily take
- 29:25what we've seen over the past quarter or two and just apply it
- 29:28straight toward you know kind of the end of this quarter, early
- 29:30next quarter. I do think we'll see a little
- 29:33bit of bumpiness, you know, as as we kind of get closer to tax
- 29:36season. Yeah, go ahead now.
- 29:38I think that's a great framing. And you know, Lynn, you're
- 29:41always careful to have a view but to acknowledge that there's
- 29:45uncertainty, you know, around or there's risk around maybe the
- 29:49base case expectation. I'll just throw in one little
- 29:52anecdote. So my father who's also my
- 29:54business partner learned a hard lesson.
- 29:57This was decades ago. I mean I think this was early in
- 30:00his investment career and he took a position on long
- 30:04treasuries and the Treasury stopped issuing for a period of
- 30:09time. I think it was the 30 year or
- 30:11maybe it was the they had been issuing a 20 year but 20.
- 30:14Year, yeah. The 20 year was not issued for
- 30:16quite a while. That's what it was.
- 30:17See you of course you knew, you knew the correct answer.
- 30:21So yeah, so they stopped issuing 20 year bonds.
- 30:24Well, you you can guess. You can guess that price moved
- 30:27because all of a sudden it became a very scarce asset and
- 30:30he was unfortunately on the wrong side of that trade.
- 30:32So it was a, it was a painful lesson for him, but just a
- 30:36reminder that it's hard to be certain about what's coming.
- 30:39Nevertheless, we do our best and you do a great job of it.
- 30:44I think I just jump. In the way I approach it, like
- 30:47it is how I work on a lot of things, whether it's writing my
- 30:49book or drawing a picture. It's kind of like I I have an
- 30:52outline, a base outline of where I expect things should go, and
- 30:56that's a fairly high conviction outline.
- 30:58If I'm setting out to do something like write a book, do
- 31:01a picture, or make a macro call, if I'm bothering to do it, it's
- 31:05usually cuz I have a conviction about that.
- 31:07So the outline is generally pretty high conviction, but then
- 31:10as you over time you actually move towards completion of that
- 31:13work, you fill in details and you keep adding more and more
- 31:16details. So maybe start with the book
- 31:18outline and you start adding kind of more chapter outlines
- 31:23and things like that. And then you start actually
- 31:24writing the chapters until you actually form the whole book.
- 31:27And with the macro view, I'm kind of doing the same thing
- 31:30where I'm, I'm taking pretty broad strokes and I have this
- 31:32kind of high conviction view on kind of the the overall
- 31:35structure of the direction of where we head on certain things.
- 31:38But that has to be updated quarter by quarter by quarter as
- 31:41new information comes in as as kind of probabilities become
- 31:45certain or air towards One Direction to the other.
- 31:48That then allows you to see a little bit further into the fog
- 31:52of war to to you know fill in the next view a little bit.
- 31:55So that's kind of how I think about predictions, which is that
- 31:58you know, predictions are obviously very hard and just the
- 32:01the main thing is try to avoid being completely offsides, have
- 32:05a view but then be be pretty quick to update that view as as
- 32:09new information comes in. Sorry to interject there.
- 32:11No, that's good. That's helpful.
- 32:12So Speaking of peering into the fog of the near future, I think
- 32:17I saw a certain senator from Massachusetts call publicly for
- 32:22the Fed to cut rates. Of course, the Fed is not a
- 32:27political body, of course. Any thoughts, Any thoughts on
- 32:32rates this year? You know, are they kind of
- 32:34crucial to your outlook or are they not as important?
- 32:39So I'm, I'm, Matt. I'm like monitoring the reverse
- 32:43repo facility and the rate of QT to be a little bit more
- 32:46important than the rates themselves, partially because
- 32:50the rates themselves weirdly have a dual aspect.
- 32:53So they are tightening to some parts of the economy, but as a
- 32:56point I've been making is they're actually stimulating
- 32:58other parts of the economy. And that's really only the case
- 33:01when you have public debt to GDP this high, right, Right.
- 33:04So back in the Volcker era when you had 30% debt to GDP, the
- 33:08higher the rates go, it's mostly just depressing the economy.
- 33:11It's mostly an anti inflationary, anti credit
- 33:15creation effect, which is why Volcker did it.
- 33:18But the problem is when you try to repeat that when you now have
- 33:21130% debt to GDP just for round numbers, on one hand you, you
- 33:26are having the same effect of you know pushing down on
- 33:30interest rate sensitive sectors of the economy, right.
- 33:33So commercial real estates, small business, bank lending,
- 33:37you know, residential real estate turnover, things like
- 33:41that, that all that all effects is similar.
- 33:44On the other hand, you're completely blowing out the
- 33:47fiscal deficit which is stimulating parts of the economy
- 33:49that are not as interest rate sensitive or not interest rate
- 33:53sensitive at all. And so if you're if you're on
- 33:55the receiving side of those deficits one way or another, if
- 33:58anything, your propensity spend is now higher and so that effect
- 34:03is more muted. Whereas liquidity is still
- 34:05pretty much liquidity. So QT is generally still not
- 34:09good for asset prices unless it's being countered by
- 34:11something else like for example the draining of the reverse repo
- 34:14facility. So I've been, I've been paying a
- 34:16little bit more attention to the balance sheet more so than the
- 34:20rates. Another factor worth pointing
- 34:22out is that as as inflation has cooled down to varying degrees,
- 34:30a, a flat interest rate profile results in widening real rates,
- 34:35right. So if if they just hold interest
- 34:37rates flat and interest rates are declining, that means
- 34:40they're increasing real rates. And so they actually have a
- 34:43capacity to mildly reduce rates while still remaining, at, say
- 34:48the positive real rate level that they had, you know, some
- 34:51some months ago. So that might be a that might be
- 34:54a path that they approach. They might, they might trim
- 34:56rates, for example. But say that they're just kind
- 34:59of maintaining the level of hawkishness that they're already
- 35:03at. They're actually not really
- 35:04viewing it as less hawkish. All right.
- 35:06I think that's one way of looking at it.
- 35:08Of course, you could get the inverse effect.
- 35:09If you get some sort of energy shortage or some sort of
- 35:13inflationary reacceleration, then simply holding rates flat
- 35:18might become more dovish over time because now interest rates
- 35:21are increased. I mean, now inflation's
- 35:23increasing and real rates are reducing.
- 35:27And so I I do think that they're going to air, you know, less
- 35:30hawkish this year. I, I, you know, I think they've
- 35:32been signalling that pretty clearly.
- 35:35I do think, you know, while the Fed tries not to be immediately
- 35:38political, right. So when we think about
- 35:41separation of central banking and the executive branch, it's
- 35:44mostly in the acute sense. So, so that, for example that a,
- 35:47a president can't just call the head of the Central Bank six
- 35:50weeks before an election and say I'm going to fire you unless you
- 35:53raise rates right. There's there's certain
- 35:55separations of powers that make that sort of acute or obvious.
- 36:00You know, interaction not not really possible.
- 36:03But when things get bad enough or when things get structural
- 36:07enough, there is integration between them.
- 36:09So the obvious examples during World War 2, that was the most
- 36:12direct example of basically the central bank being entirely
- 36:15captured by the Treasury because they viewed it as they viewed it
- 36:18as a national emergency, not to. And in the in the more recent
- 36:22sense, you know Fed officials generally are almost by
- 36:27definition pro establishment. They generally favor
- 36:30establishment candidates. It might not be as acutely but
- 36:35it they, you know to the extent that they can put their thumb on
- 36:37one side or the other, that's kind of the the direction
- 36:39they're going to point in. So I I do think that they have a
- 36:43fairly significant incentive not to have an acute recession this
- 36:46year. It doesn't mean you can't have a
- 36:48slowdown, doesn't mean you can't have sector specific weakness,
- 36:53but I think that they're going to probably do their best not to
- 36:55have some sort of full blown, you know, whole labor cycle
- 36:59acute recession if they can help it.
- 37:01Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 37:04exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 37:06about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 37:10allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 37:14We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 37:18Yeah I definitely agree with the with that take the powers that
- 37:21be will try to keep the train on the tracks at least at least for
- 37:25a bit. Well, let's let's get more
- 37:28specific maybe on on portfolio construction and I'm not gonna
- 37:32ask you to give away your secret sauce.
- 37:35You have an excellent subscription service which is
- 37:37also quite reasonably priced where I know you make specific,
- 37:40you know picks on securities. But maybe could you talk more
- 37:43generally about your framework at the moment and also working
- 37:49into that, I think six or seven months ago when we did that
- 37:53panel that you were kind enough to appear on and give us your
- 37:57view on this, you had a framework which included sort of
- 38:00a macro asset class which is basically scarce assets.
- 38:04I don't remember if you called it that specifically, but I'm
- 38:07wondering if you're still thinking in terms of having
- 38:11significant exposure to, generally speaking, scarce
- 38:14assets which are different from, I don't know, equities or real
- 38:18estate? I do, yes.
- 38:20And so, you know, over the past 40 years, especially in the
- 38:23United States, there's been this kind of structural tilt towards
- 38:28disinflation. SO4 decades of declining
- 38:30structural inflation, 40 years of declining interest rates.
- 38:34And therefore both stocks and bonds were very good performers.
- 38:39They had you know partially thanks to those reductions in in
- 38:43interest rates. You had higher equity multiples
- 38:46that made sense relative to interest rates over time and
- 38:50that's kind of a virtuous cycle for as long as it lasts until
- 38:53you hit zero and and stay at 0 for a while at least.
- 38:57And so we had this kind of 40 year period where owning stocks
- 39:00and bonds together made a lot of sense.
- 39:03When you look at longer data sets or more multi country data
- 39:07sets, we are not just picking the best equity market in the
- 39:10world of the reserve currency country right.
- 39:12If you're if you have a a a more global view or a view that does
- 39:16not just include that kind of 40 year dissipationary regime.
- 39:20Generally more diversified portfolios hold up better than
- 39:23the stock bond portfolio. So it could be as simple as
- 39:26adding say a gold slice historically, right?
- 39:28So instead of saying 6% stock, 40% bond, if you said 60%
- 39:32stocks, 30% bonds, 10% gold. There are decades where neither
- 39:36stocks nor bonds do particularly well.
- 39:38But gold does. Amazing, right?
- 39:40So the 1970s and the 2000s would be examples of that.
- 39:44Those tend to be the more inflationary decades, all else
- 39:47being equal, they tend to be weaker dollar decades.
- 39:50So where the dollar index rolls over, you get international
- 39:53equity outperformance, you get commodity outperformance, you
- 39:55get gold outperformance relative to U.S. stocks and bonds.
- 40:00And so I think especially in this kind of era of fiscal
- 40:04dominance where we're no longer in that kind of 40 year
- 40:07structural disinflation, monetary dominance cycle, I
- 40:11generally think that having that.
- 40:14That inflationary segment in a portfolio is useful.
- 40:17So that can include, you know, I like to describe it either as
- 40:20real estate in some context, but more more specifically it's kind
- 40:23of commodities, commodity producers and hard monies and
- 40:28and so for example that can include energy, right.
- 40:31If you if you map energy prices to inflation, energy prices are
- 40:35kind of like a high beta version of inflation.
- 40:38If you're trying to hedge inflation, one of the best ways
- 40:40to do it historically is is having long exposure to various
- 40:43energy assets. And then hard monies have a more
- 40:47complicated relationship to inflation because they're more
- 40:50specifically about currency debasement.
- 40:53But overall they they kind of protect you from similar types
- 40:56of decades, decades where neither stocks nor bonds do
- 40:59particularly well. We could call them
- 41:01stagflationary decades, we could call them weaker dollar, higher
- 41:04inflation, higher international decades.
- 41:08There's different flavors of these types of decades.
- 41:10But in general, those things that have been under invested in
- 41:13during the disinflationary cycle and they potentially are the
- 41:17causes of the next inflationary cycle that like they're the
- 41:20things that have become scarce, they tend to go up when other
- 41:24things don't. And we've seen in recent years
- 41:27that you know during you know, kind of years where both stocks
- 41:31and bonds do poorly, it's those energy and commodities and more
- 41:34inflationary assets that do well.
- 41:36And so I actually think that one of the best ways that someone
- 41:37can hedge their portfolio that otherwise consists of, say,
- 41:42stocks and bonds would be to own some of those, like energy
- 41:45producers for example, right. Because they're more likely to
- 41:48have a decent year when those other assets have a a poor year.
- 41:51Maybe not every time they have a poor year, but especially if
- 41:54that is caused by some sort of energy spike or inflation spike,
- 41:58that thing can specifically increase those prices while
- 42:02putting downward pressure on either either bond prices,
- 42:06meaning higher bond yields or you know, lower equity
- 42:10valuations due to higher discount rates and things like
- 42:13that. So I do think that's really
- 42:15important. And then having that scarce
- 42:17asset slice, that hard money slice, you know in in older eras
- 42:22that would be gold. Now it could be Bitcoin or it
- 42:24could be a hybrid of gold in Bitcoin, depending on that
- 42:27investor's view, their age, their volatility tolerance, how
- 42:30much they've researched those, you know, two types of assets
- 42:33for example. But I do think that it if we do
- 42:36enter a more sustained period of a more stagflationary type of
- 42:41environment, which doesn't have to be extreme, it doesn't have
- 42:43to be like the 70s. It could be like the 2000s, for
- 42:46example. It could be like the 1940s,
- 42:48which is a decade that I use a lot as an analogue that not many
- 42:53other analysts do. I think it's now it's becoming
- 42:55more common. But that's if you go back to, if
- 42:58you want a third example, the 2000s, the 1970s and the 40s,
- 43:01that'd be another one. I do think that most research
- 43:05shows, you know there's the Dragon portfolio for example by
- 43:09I think Chris Cole, he put that for some years ago.
- 43:12He kind of modelled out 100 years and said what kind of
- 43:15portfolio would do well over that longer cycle, not just this
- 43:1840 year cycle. There's also portfolios called
- 43:21it the permanent portfolio or other things like that.
- 43:23They kind of model these longer time frames and they generally
- 43:26show that you're having something other than just stocks
- 43:28and bonds. It tends to be very helpful,
- 43:30could be gold, could be real estate, could be energy
- 43:34producers, could be Bitcoin. Obviously all three of us here
- 43:38are are pretty bullish on Bitcoin and so that that would
- 43:41probably be our our slice of choice in that segment.
- 43:44But yeah, there are a handful of other ones that can that can
- 43:46serve a somewhat similar role. Yeah.
- 43:49That's really helpful. And one of the things I struggle
- 43:51with personally as an asset allocator is within that
- 43:55scarcity bucket. It seems to me that some of
- 43:58those assets, maybe including energy, are more macro or growth
- 44:03driven and then others maybe like gold or less so.
- 44:07And so I wonder, you know, does it make sense to get more clever
- 44:12and slice it between the scarce assets that do well when yes,
- 44:17there's inflation but also there's decent economic growth
- 44:21versus yes, there's inflation but not so great economic growth
- 44:25in terms of a stagflationary type of environment.
- 44:28I confess I'm I I'm trying to get better at that at further
- 44:33segmenting the growth versus not growth in that bucket and and
- 44:37I'm wondering how you think about it.
- 44:39I think that partially depends on your conviction as an
- 44:41investor. You know, they're investors that
- 44:43are really tuned into the energy markets.
- 44:44They're investors that are really, you know, they spent
- 44:461000 hours looking into Bitcoin, for example, and they're going
- 44:49to have different comfort levels.
- 44:51You know, someone that might want to have a 10% Bitcoin slice
- 44:54of portfolio would be considered very aggressive to someone else
- 44:58who's not not as bullish on Bitcoin or high as high
- 45:01conviction bullish on Bitcoin. And they might think 1 to 3%
- 45:04makes more sense for them, for example.
- 45:07And so partially depends on how many things an investor wants to
- 45:10monitor, how many, how how much they care about smoothing out
- 45:14volatility year by year or their particular propensity to trade.
- 45:20So do they think one year they want to position for this year
- 45:23and then position for next year and then position for the next
- 45:25year after that? Or are they saying this is what
- 45:27I want to hold for this decade and maybe rebound to it from
- 45:30time to time or somewhere in between those outcomes.
- 45:34And so for example what I put forth as a as a portfolio idea
- 45:38to clients airs towards that more diversified view because
- 45:42the last thing I want to do is you know have a A7 year old
- 45:46investor put 20% of their net worth and Bitcoin because they
- 45:51read my work and My Portfolio says that for example.
- 45:53And then they're they're caught off guard and they sell at A at
- 45:56a weak point because it's more volatile than they expected,
- 45:58right. So what I do in my personal
- 46:00account might be a little bit more aggressive say on the
- 46:02Bitcoin side of things whereas I, you know I own decent of
- 46:05Bitcoin, I invest in Bitcoin venture.
- 46:09So I pretty high exposure to Bitcoin that I would not
- 46:12necessarily recommend to people as like a starting point and
- 46:16instead I kind of default towards that more diversified
- 46:20view. I guess if I had to pick two, it
- 46:23would be Bitcoin and energy stocks.
- 46:26Whereas gold is the one that's arguably losing market share to
- 46:31Bitcoin. Whereas energy is important, you
- 46:34know, in in any era as long as the valuations and balance
- 46:38sheets and other things like that are are appropriate.
- 46:42So I I really think it comes down to what an individual
- 46:44investor's comfortable with. So I don't, I don't know if
- 46:47there's a right answer other than to say that naturally I
- 46:50expect over the next decade, unless something goes terribly
- 46:54wrong, Bitcoin to outperform gold, but but probably with more
- 46:58volatility along the way. I like that Take.
- 47:02Yeah, that's a very interesting wrinkle You include there too
- 47:04that that energy stocks might be your #2 because I think that
- 47:10sort of suggests there's enough conviction on your side about
- 47:13Bitcoin that it might shift into the historical role that gold,
- 47:17gold has played and and and eclipse it in terms of role
- 47:21there. But overall it's it's it's
- 47:23wonderful to to hear that you're thinking about this in the very
- 47:27similar way to how Andy is thinking about it.
- 47:29And I think you know the the spirit of the show came from
- 47:34Andy wanting to have a a podcast for wealth managers that talks
- 47:41about how you know for 40 years the 6040 portfolio has been a
- 47:46winning strategy and as a result of that wealth managers are not
- 47:49really thinking about scarce assets.
- 47:52So it's been 6040 zero and looking ahead Andy thinks I
- 47:57think and it sounds like you think that should be different.
- 48:01Yeah, I I think so. And and really the, the one
- 48:03decade in, the exception there was the 2000s, right?
- 48:06So that's when you had gold, have a big run up, energy have a
- 48:09big run up U.S. stocks, they pretty much just got back to
- 48:13their.com highs, especially in inflation adjusted terms, right.
- 48:18So is it not a bad decade, but it wasn't a booming decade for
- 48:21stocks. Real estate was the the, the
- 48:23area that was more booming until it wasn't, but that was one of
- 48:26those kind of scarce asset decades as well.
- 48:30But it was small enough in the grand scheme of things that you
- 48:34could almost just ignore that decade and just keep riding the
- 48:366040, which is what a lot of people did.
- 48:39And I think that the question is, could we go into a longer
- 48:42period where that's not really the case, like a, a longer
- 48:45version of the 2000s. And I I do think that's
- 48:48certainly possible and that's an environment where you'd want to
- 48:51own those other types of assets. We've seen for example, you
- 48:54know, we take for granted that the Usus stocks always go up.
- 48:57First of all, it's not always the case.
- 48:59There are long stretches where especially in inflation adjusted
- 49:02terms, stocks don't go up for 15 years or more.
- 49:05And then two, when you look globally, that happens a lot
- 49:09more frequently. I mean Japan goes 30 years
- 49:11without new highs or Europe goes 20 years without new highs.
- 49:16These things happen on a regular basis, especially when you start
- 49:19with very high equity valuations.
- 49:22A lot of foreign capital pushed into your area.
- 49:24So in the late 80s it was Japan. Everybody was like, OK, Japan
- 49:27has taken the world, we all want to own Japan.
- 49:30Their market cap to GDP became very kind of imbalanced in the
- 49:36late 90s, early 2000s, the creation of the euro.
- 49:40It was very optimistic time for Europe.
- 49:42There was quite a bit of capital pushed into Europe, you know,
- 49:45not to the extremes of Japan, but you know, fairly high
- 49:48starting evaluations and high expectations which then were not
- 49:51met. And so you had 40 years, 20
- 49:54years of not not very good on average European equity
- 49:57performance. And right now, I would argue
- 49:59that the the, you know, U.S. equity valuations are quite
- 50:02expensive. They, it's not new.
- 50:04I mean they've been expensive in the past five years and they've
- 50:06only gotten more expensive. Pretty much the percentage of
- 50:11global capital that could be in the US, a lot of it is in the
- 50:15US, right. So there's not necessarily a ton
- 50:17of capital just sitting there that could decide to come into
- 50:20the US A lot of it's already in the US And so should some of
- 50:23these virtuous cycles start going the other way as they they
- 50:26have done in the past in certain decades, so the 70s or the 2000s
- 50:30or maybe more structurally at some point in the future you
- 50:33could have a shift where the US equity market, you know, maybe
- 50:36doesn't crash, but maybe it just under whelms for 1015 years or
- 50:41more and being in other assets are where it's at.
- 50:46And it could be that those assets go up in price, for
- 50:48example, maybe Bitcoin captures market share and adds A0 to its
- 50:52price for example. Or it could be that you one
- 50:56reason I like energy stocks for example is that they pay good
- 50:58dividends, they have good balance sheets.
- 51:01And so you know some small price gains combined with just ongoing
- 51:06income can make up for like a a flat decade in in equities for
- 51:10example that that don't pay much dividends.
- 51:13And so it's either in terms of outperformance in that sense or
- 51:16the absolute kind of total return that you can get from
- 51:20erring towards scarcer assets or or or another another way of
- 51:23putting it is under owned assets that are also scarce that
- 51:27they're, you know even scarce assets can be a problem if
- 51:30they're over owned like gold was in the, you know the late 2000s
- 51:35decade, you know going into 2011 for example, gold was very over
- 51:39owned. And so even though they didn't
- 51:41make a ton more gold since then they made a decent amount but
- 51:44not a ton, gold went nowhere for a decade because pretty much all
- 51:48the marginal capital that wanted gold was into it.
- 51:52So basically the combination of something that's scarce and
- 51:55historically under owned or under owned relative to
- 51:58potential is, is what I try to look for.
- 52:02So Speaking of opportunities in perhaps under owned assets,
- 52:08you're a general partner at Ego Death Capital, which means you
- 52:12are allocating funds into areas of the Bitcoin ecosystem, which
- 52:19I think we would probably all agree is still under owned,
- 52:22although the recent ETF launch is helping in that regard, what
- 52:27are you most interested in? Are there areas of level twos
- 52:32built on Bitcoin? Are there certain categories of
- 52:36business models that are most interesting to you right now?
- 52:39What what's What's got you fired up and interested in spending
- 52:42time in terms of sectors within Bitcoin?
- 52:45So we're fairly agnostic just because the, you know the
- 52:49Bitcoin start up scene is still relatively small overall and so
- 52:54kind of having a a pretty broadview to go anywhere within
- 52:56that makes sense. Personally, and as a fun but
- 53:00especially speaking for myself, I I tend to like utility over
- 53:03speculation. So even though there could be a
- 53:06big market for speculation, I I prefer to, you know, I have
- 53:11higher conviction on things that I expect to be around longer
- 53:14utility things, things that solve a problem rather than just
- 53:17kind of increase another Ave. for speculation.
- 53:21So I think a big theme over the past several decades, there's
- 53:24been more and more financialization and the there's
- 53:28like a global arbitrage, right. So when you have 160 different
- 53:31currencies and some of them float against each other and
- 53:33pegs break and there's all these different equity markets, all
- 53:36these different real estate markets.
- 53:38If you're a financier, you have you have like this whole
- 53:41playground of options to like short one thing and go into
- 53:43another thing. And when you look at the the
- 53:46crypto scene, it's kind of like the end stage of that, like it's
- 53:50kind of the the pinnacle of financialize everything and
- 53:53speculate on everything. Bitcoin is in some ways the
- 53:56reversal of that. It's basically saying that it
- 53:58with the reintroduction of a sound boring good money, it
- 54:04actually can de financialize certain things, you know, not
- 54:07to, not not to an extreme sense, but it can it can reverse that
- 54:10trend towards ever more financialization and arbitrage.
- 54:16And so I I tend to err towards things that are solving for
- 54:19utility, right. So for example I generally like
- 54:23things that that help scale Bitcoin or that help make it
- 54:26more private. For example, that's one reason
- 54:29I've been interested in the the broad field of Charmaine E Cash.
- 54:33There's not just one company building on it, there's
- 54:35multiple. And what they did was they took
- 54:3840 year old technology that never really found a home on
- 54:42dollars like they originally tried to do it.
- 54:44But instead they kind of realized that Bitcoin is
- 54:46arguably a much better money to put that technology onto.
- 54:49And that's both a scaling method.
- 54:51It makes fees cheaper, it improves privacy.
- 54:54So even if you can afford base layer Bitcoin, you might still
- 54:58want to use E cash for for example, your daily spending
- 55:01wallet and and things like that. So it kind of accompanies
- 55:05lightning, it accompanies these other systems and allows Bitcoin
- 55:08to scale and be more customizable.
- 55:10So I find that a very interesting area.
- 55:13I think that Lightning infrastructure is, is still a
- 55:16growing era area. A lot of people have been
- 55:19critical of lightning lately. But it's interesting.
- 55:21If you look at for example the River report from later, late
- 55:25last year, we see that even though public capacity has been
- 55:29stagnant, the number of Bitcoin payments and the overall volume
- 55:33of Bitcoin payments has continued to increase in large
- 55:35part because the network keeps getting more and more efficient.
- 55:39And so anything that makes lightning easier to use and it
- 55:43solves some of the well known problems of Lightning I think is
- 55:46a market opportunity. I think DLCS are interesting.
- 55:50You know they kind of blend utility and speculation because
- 55:55you know they can enable things for example like on chain
- 55:57derivatives and things like that.
- 55:59But of course those those also have utility use cases.
- 56:02And so I I think there's multiple areas that are
- 56:05interesting, but basically anything that kind of emerges
- 56:08from concept and starts to get momentum and scaling I think is
- 56:12useful. I think a final thing I would
- 56:15put on it is that when I analyze Bitcoin, I try to take into
- 56:19account timing, right. So I think that one thing you
- 56:23have to be careful of as Bitcoin bowls that are then operating a
- 56:27fund is, you know, we, we might think, OK, the whole world
- 56:31should be doing this. Why is it not doing this yet?
- 56:33Whereas I think we have to have a more realistic sense of timing
- 56:37and therefore say, OK, this might look like this in 10
- 56:41years, but it might not be a good investment for five years.
- 56:44So maybe it's early for this one area even though I think that's
- 56:47where the puck's going. And you either have to avoid
- 56:50that area for now or if you go in that area, the founders of
- 56:55those companies should take into account that this is a, you
- 56:58know, this is still a while away and so you want to have, you
- 57:01want to build conservatively, you want to have long runways,
- 57:04you don't want to build a business expecting everyone's
- 57:06going to use it next year. You have, you have kind of that
- 57:08long term term plan. Yeah, the history of
- 57:12entrepreneurship in Bitcoin and probably all sectors is is many.
- 57:17Many died on the vine. Many were too early, too early.
- 57:22I I do think we're Bitcoin is like the there's so many cases.
- 57:27Every new startup that's at the bleeding edge of something in
- 57:31Bitcoin falls into the like the Gartner Tech Hype Cycle Classic
- 57:36framework of like everyone sees the potential and thinks it's
- 57:39going to change the world, and then you go through the long
- 57:41through of disillusionment before it actually changes the
- 57:43world. That's true of every feature of
- 57:45Bitcoin. It's kind of like how everything
- 57:48from the.com bubble end up becoming a reality, but like a
- 57:51decade later. Yeah.
- 57:52So all the, all the, if anything, a lot of those
- 57:55valuations that were extreme at the time, some of those
- 57:58companies went on to make new all time highs at reasonable
- 58:02valuations 1015 years later. And it's just that, yeah, the
- 58:06whole sentiment for what was going to happen got way ahead of
- 58:08itself. And I think that that happens
- 58:10time to time in Bitcoin. And you know, one of the skills
- 58:14of a founder in this space or any space, any sort of tech
- 58:17startup founder, one of the skills they have to know is kind
- 58:22of like a race car driver, like when to accelerate and when to
- 58:25slow down. So like when you're going around
- 58:26a turn, you know you want to break at the right time, you
- 58:29want to conserve everything you have, but then you want to know
- 58:31when to when to gun it, when to just go for it and pass someone.
- 58:35And so there's mistakes that founders can make where they're
- 58:39overly aggressive, overly optimistic, they burn through
- 58:41cash too much and then they, you know, they they burn out too
- 58:44quickly. They they, they, the market did
- 58:46not meet their their vision as fast as they did.
- 58:50On the other hand you don't want to be so conservative that you
- 58:53don't push when you really should and therefore you miss an
- 58:56opportunity and get get past. And so part of the things I try
- 59:00to do especially with my view of economics is is to some extent
- 59:04help founders as as no one's perfect.
- 59:08But as you try to navigate questions of of when to when to
- 59:12be conservative and when to OK this is the time pushing hard
- 59:16raise capital and and and deploy it right.
- 59:18So that's it's just one of the overall tricky things of of
- 59:21building something that's that's new and innovative.
- 59:25Well, that makes complete sense. Lynn, maybe I'll close on what I
- 59:29suspect will be a bullish note for Bitcoin.
- 59:32Any comments you want to make on either this year or the next
- 59:35couple years? I know you generally don't like
- 59:37to make, you know, one week, one month type of predictions, but
- 59:41what do you what are you seeing, Let's say 2024-2025 for Bitcoin?
- 59:46I've I've been giving like a two year view, more than a one year
- 59:49view. It's like higher conviction in
- 59:52that period because almost anything happened in one year,
- 59:56whereas 2 years I I think the, the directions matter more, The
- 1:00:00structural directions are kind of harder to not go a certain
- 1:00:04way. And so I do expect that within
- 1:00:06the next two years, we'll probably have another pro, pro
- 1:00:09liquidity cycle. So we've we've been in this kind
- 1:00:12of period of stagnant liquidity, so stronger dollar quantitative
- 1:00:16tightening, partially offset by all these treasury actions we've
- 1:00:19been talking about you know draining the reverse repo
- 1:00:21facility, things like that. But I do think that within the
- 1:00:23next two years we'll probably have another significant up leg
- 1:00:26in liquidity and one of one of the strongest correlations with
- 1:00:30Bitcoin is liquidity, especially global broad liquidity measures.
- 1:00:35So I do think that that will be a tailwind for Bitcoin.
- 1:00:39I think the halving will be a a tailwind for Bitcoin.
- 1:00:42You know, one thing I argue is that the the halving, the timing
- 1:00:46is not always perfect for for Bitcoin bull runs.
- 1:00:48If anything liquidity correlates with that stronger than the
- 1:00:50halving. But the halving is certainly
- 1:00:52still a a factor, especially for magnitude, especially for
- 1:00:55helping reach higher highs and higher lows as it goes through
- 1:00:59these cycles. So the fact that the halving is
- 1:01:01coming up I think is bullish. I think the washout of a lot of
- 1:01:05the excesses of the past cycle is mostly done, which kind of
- 1:01:09just sets the floor for Bitcoin. And I also look at the huddle
- 1:01:15wave, for lack of a better word, there's and there's there's more
- 1:01:18sophisticated ways to measure too, like looking at addresses
- 1:01:21that mostly accumulate Bitcoin and and rarely sell Bitcoin and
- 1:01:25kind of looking at their percentage relative to the
- 1:01:27whole. But different ways of looking at
- 1:01:28it is roughly the question of has there been a distribution
- 1:01:32cycle yet? So generally, stronger hands in
- 1:01:35Bitcoin tend to sell somewhat into strength.
- 1:01:39So if Bitcoin goes up 5X or 10X, some of those addresses tend to
- 1:01:43be trimming their holdings. You know, maybe it's because
- 1:01:46they're rebalancing. Maybe it's because they now can
- 1:01:50consume something that they couldn't consume before.
- 1:01:52You know, they want to buy the house that they couldn't buy
- 1:01:55before, and so they're selling some Bitcoin to do it.
- 1:01:58Generally when you see a significant amount of that
- 1:01:59distribution and a lot of new investors coming in, that's when
- 1:02:03you're maybe getting closer to a top in the cycle and that's not
- 1:02:07really started yet in this cycle.
- 1:02:09So even though we're off the the lows by about double or more,
- 1:02:14there's not really been that distribution cycle yet.
- 1:02:16And so far that's very clean compared to prior this stage in
- 1:02:21the bull market like an early bull market environment where
- 1:02:24price is off the lows, sentiments improving, it's not
- 1:02:28really dead anymore, but there's also been virtually no
- 1:02:31conviction, no like reason for those like strongly held coins
- 1:02:35to go back onto the market. And so I think that most of the
- 1:02:39catalysts still point toward pretty good two year returns in
- 1:02:44my expectation and really that you know the longer I go out,
- 1:02:48you know the the higher conviction I can be.
- 1:02:50So I might be very uncertain for the next six months, pretty high
- 1:02:54conviction for the next 24 months and obviously higher
- 1:02:58conviction would say A5 year view.
- 1:03:00Well, Jesse has not started selling any coins yet, so we
- 1:03:04know that the the Huddle Wave is is still intact.
- 1:03:07Of course, Jesse never sells any coins, so made too.
- 1:03:10Bullish Lynn Always too bullish? Yeah, last last last cycle I
- 1:03:15sold one Bitcoin, but I use it to buy Bitcoin miners, so I
- 1:03:18don't really count that one. And so I I'm I'm kind of the
- 1:03:20same way. Still Bitcoin exposure, you
- 1:03:23added some leverage on top of, on top of your Bitcoin position.
- 1:03:27Well, Lynn, this has been phenomenal conversation.
- 1:03:30Thank you so much. Is are there any parting
- 1:03:33thoughts or anywhere you want to send people online to learn more
- 1:03:36about what you're up to? So people can check out broken
- 1:03:39money wherever books are sold. They can also check out Lynn
- 1:03:42alden.com. Overall, I think that you know
- 1:03:45this is it's just a very dynamic environment.
- 1:03:48I described some decades as being macro heavy and other
- 1:03:51decades as not being particularly macro heavy.
- 1:03:54And I think this is a very macro heavy decade where things like
- 1:03:59liquidity, things like geopolitics, these can impact
- 1:04:04asset prices more than in a decade.
- 1:04:06That's not macro heavy and they tend to feed on each other,
- 1:04:10right. So one thing I point out for
- 1:04:12example, is that sovereign debt crisis are likely to lead to war
- 1:04:17and war is likely to lead to sovereign debt crises.
- 1:04:19So you kind of get that vicious cycle and and the same is true
- 1:04:24like you know, peace can lead to disinflation and disinflation
- 1:04:28can lead to peace because things are kind of when when orders
- 1:04:31present it tends to lead to more order until of course something
- 1:04:35changes it. And so because we're in this,
- 1:04:37this macro heavy decade with high public debts and like usual
- 1:04:42liquidity situations and now kind of a breakout of
- 1:04:44geopolitical conflict, the things tend to add together.
- 1:04:48So surprises are usually towards more macro not less macro.
- 1:04:53And so that's that's just my overall kind of framework for
- 1:04:55this decade is to kind of expect the unexpected, stay humble and
- 1:05:01and like I said kind of have a have a a sketch of where things
- 1:05:05I think things are going but then be very quick to adjust
- 1:05:09that as time goes by. So, for example, I've been using
- 1:05:11the 1940s as well as other, you know, analogues to to help me
- 1:05:16construct a a a mental framework or what this can look like.
- 1:05:20But of course, no one can see the future.
- 1:05:21I mean, I don't know what what countries will be in war a year
- 1:05:24from now. They're not in a war now, what
- 1:05:26wars might end or, you know, what might have happened with
- 1:05:29country XYZ or surprise assassinations or this happened
- 1:05:34or, you know who all that stuff has to be kind of adjusted to
- 1:05:38over time. And so I think that just stay
- 1:05:40humble, have an outlook and then it just just keep adjusting to
- 1:05:44new information. Well, I agree completely.
- 1:05:47I'm very bullish on macro this decade as well, which means I
- 1:05:51think you're going to be adding a lot of value to a lot of
- 1:05:53clients portfolios. You'll have plenty to do.
- 1:05:57So thank you again. Really appreciate it.
- 1:05:59Hope to do this again with you sometime in the future And on
- 1:06:03behalf of our audience at Scarce Assets, Thank you and have a
- 1:06:08good one. Sounds good, and good luck on
- 1:06:10your podcast. Thank you.
- 1:06:11Thank you.