Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 09/10/26 EPISODE 023: BOTTLE BREAKDOWN - OLD CASSIDY 2025 RELEASE BY RARE CHARACTER
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: You also haven't been pumping up ⁓ Glenn Kerrens with the three two three logo on there. They're sale. Feel free there's gotta be a way to have a link below kind of. Feel free to mention them. There is a link. In every post, there's a link in there. There's a link below. Yeah. All right, guys. Welcome back into the another episode on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. And this week we're doing ⁓ a bottle breakdown. A bottle I picked up, I believe, towards the end of 2025. It's just been sitting on the shelf. Figured Damn it, it's about time we tasted it and see if it's any good and worth chasing on 2026 when they come out. So ⁓ and we're talking about the ⁓ Old Cassidy 2025 release ⁓ from Rare Character. Comes out at 123 proof. And ⁓ I thought I'd give a little details about what is old Cassidy, a little bit about Rare Character, ⁓ who produces it. And before we get it ⁓ t start talking, let's pop this thing. That way you guys can not but just be sitting there listening to I you were say we should warn the viewers that we've been filming all day and kind of get a little loose in here. By the way, there's a link below if you like these Glenn Kairens that we have here with the three through three bourbon library logo on them. Absolutely. If you want to get a get those or they're for sale. We haven't broken one yet. Not yet. Let's see if this pops, see if it's any good. ⁓ I like that. That works. Tight. John Carlo, that's for you. ⁓ look at that color. You can see the color right in the bottom. Looks even better in the 323 Glen. Absolutely. The Glen Karen makes it look so much sharper. Thank you. Perfect. All right. So let's dive in here. So this ⁓ this old Cassidy, what is it, right? I you know, when it dropped last year, I think I maybe I wasn't aware of what what it was. ⁓ but if you're looking for a historic heritage brand ⁓ from the eighteen hundreds, you won't find it here. Okay. Okay. Old Cassidy Bourbon is actually a brand new ultra premium release ⁓ in the modern whiskey world, heavily tied to the independent bottling movement that has taken ⁓ the bourbon community by storm. So here's a quick history of how this cult classic bottle came to be. So Old Cassidy is curated and released by Rare Character Whiskey, an independent purveyor of co founded I'm gonna mess this name up by Pete Nevog Nevoglosky and Bob Lamoy. ⁓ independent bottling, ⁓ a concept borrowed from the Scotch world involves hunting down exceptional mature barrels hidden away in rick houses of various establishments, distilleries, aging them further, and then blending or bottling them under a unique label. So before it became white a widely known product, Old Cassidy started as an incredibly exclusive project. The single barrel origins. Rare Character initially dropped Old Cassidy. As two hyper limited single barrel offerings. One was was a collaboration with a prominent whiskey pitch picker, Frank Dobbins III, and the other was an exclusive release done in tandem with Unicorn Auctions. In 2025, this is the 2025 release. So recognizing that there was a massive hype and demand generated by those early barrels, Rare Character transitioned old Cassidy into a highly anticipated annual vintage release. So this is the first release of its you know, now hopefully for the foreseeable future once-a-year release coming out. ⁓ so what makes old Cassidy Cassidy historically interesting to Bourbon Geeks is its composition. It is designed to showcase the absolute peak of rare characters' curated stash. The blend features a heavy base of 18-year-old aged Kentucky straight bourbon, which is then married with a slightly younger, more robust barrels, estimated to be around eight to ten years old. To inject vibrancy and balance out the heavy oak funk and of the older liquid. This comes out at 123 proof, and because old character relies on sourcing and blending unique parcels of whiskey, the flavor profile of Old Cassidy will shift slightly with every annual release, turning it into a living timeline of rare Kentucky barrels. The official release of Old Cassidy Bourbon by Rare Character stands out because it be behaves like a dense, rich dessert in a glass. Shit, now I gotta smell this thing. You better smell it. It's good. Yeah, they're not wrong. ⁓ my goodness. I gotta shut up. We'll get to the end of this and ⁓ taste this. 123 proof. I was expecting very different aromas coming off of it. So ⁓ counterbalanced by heavy oak. Because it uses a heavily aged eighteen year old Kentucky bourbon as its structural anchor, it carries an immense amount of dusty barrel character that helps cut through the sweetness. Reviewers and And the creators themselves frequently describe the overall pro profile as tasting remarkably like black cherry Manhattan cocktail. despite being a straight, uncocktailed bourbon, ported a massive cast strength of 123 proof. So, ⁓ I'm gonna I wanna taste it before I before I read the notes that they say I should taste. Yeah, you probably should. I think you're gonna have your own strong opinions. ⁓ That that dark brown sugar. What do you what'd you g I know you guys have been into it a little bit more than I have? What what are your thoughts so far on nose and palate? Yep. Molasses. Like little like a lot of that. Mm-hmm. Hundred percent. Almost got peanut. Like shelled peanuts. Like a bean profile peanuts. More like a like that. Almost when you're at the ballpark and you're eating that dusty the dust from the peanut. Got it. Okay. Okay. That's at first that's what I got. Which was interesting. So I wrote it down. I'm like, I'm getting that peanut. Yeah, I got that molasses you noted. That's definitely there. Dense molasses. Nice fruit, dark fruits in there. Cherry or something. ⁓ Yeah, like maybe like drink's a little warmer than the other one we just had, which is only Point four proofs lower. Yep. This drinks a lot warmer, right? It's not a bad thing. That's a good thing. Not a bad thing, but it is a little hotter on the on the finish. Where that eighteen year old Barton juice that we just had was a little softer. That drink agreed much lower than its actual program. This one drinks 123 pounds. That's correct. Not not saying that's a bad thing. Not a bad thing. I actually like it. But this is so sweet. So dessert forward. Correct. Yeah. Correct. Yeah, the palette's got caramel toffee, maybe like a peanut brittle type note in there with that nuttiness that you're saying. Vanilla. Yeah. And then f finish for me is that warmth is like cinnamon clove. Mm-hmm. Absolutely cinnamon clove. Long finish. Huge finish. Yeah, that's it's early July and we're enjoying the heck out of this, and all I'm thinking about is a cold winter day. Sitting outside by a fire. Like this is this is what I would want. So warm you up pour. Yeah, so warm you up pour in the middle of winter, Christmas right time. You're outside in the woods on a campfire. That I mean this would just that would elevate this experience. I'm with you. I d I'm just continuing I'm in love with the color. I just keep staring at it. Yeah. I love what a bourbon's got a great depth to it. This has it. 100%. Yeah, this is this is this is excellent. So now Ronnie, the question I have is is it because I'm getting more used to this because we've been drinking a lot of bourbon? Because at 123 proof, this is this is warm, but I'm not I'm still not getting that burn down in my stomach. No. No. No, no. Yeah, I think definitely warm. ⁓ I've I to me this drinks a little bit warmer than some other very similar proofs. I don't know. That could be the younger whiskey that's blended in with it, right? Well not that long ago. We've had some corn forward ethanol smelling and tasting that just burn. Yeah, this is not that at all. No, no, no, no. I'm definitely not an ethanol burn or alcohol y type flavor to it at all. ⁓ they did a great job. It's a deep spice burn, which is different than an ethanol astringency. Yeah. Just a deep cinnamon. Like when you taste something that's Got a ton of cinnamon in it. Bunch of cinnamon for me. Yeah. I'm still getting that peanut. Yeah. For some reason. I don't disagree with you. You're on the money. I wouldn't pick that up personally, but I'm not disagreeing with you when you say it. Yeah, that peanut brittle that Roddy mentioned is right there. And that nose has got this creaminess to it though too, doesn't it? Mm-hmm. That so does the pour. The pour is coats your mouth. I love that like vanilla pudding type sweetness on the nose that that you get on some of these bearings. Got a huge flavor profile. It just builds. Yeah. So I come from the cooking world, as some of you may know. And you build flavor, right? You start with a base and you keep building. And I can tell that from this portion, it's just build flavor. Something keeps coming out every time I take a sip. I was gonna say we keep talking about the power of suggestion and you keep talking about that baseball that ⁓ unshelled peanut dust kind of smell. And the ⁓ that's that's in the back of my mind. But the more I'm diving into this, I'm I'm getting pistachio. ⁓ On the palate or the nose? On the nose. I'm getting pistachio on the nose, but probably because he's suggesting that nuttiness. Perhaps. And you're talking about vanilla pudding and my brain just went to like pistachio pudding. I don't know why. I'm thinking of green jello pistachio pudding and all of a sudden I'm like, that's what I smell in here. You I smell that vanilla pudding. I smell that jello pudding. I smell that pistachio in here. It's a good pour. It is a good pour. It's really good. So what they say we should taste and smell. ⁓ so the nose, they say deep, dark aromas lead the way, creme brulee, charred oak spice, dark brown sugar, an intense wave of sweet purple fruits, like stewed plums and black cherry. So so far nothing that we said. Fair enough, right? I think I said cherry, maybe. I don't know, I can't remember. ⁓ the palette, it hits very dense, velvety and mouth coating texture. Up front, you get the classic rich dessert layers, butterscotch, toffee, and cinnamon-spiced graham crackers. ⁓ as the sip sits on your tongue, the older wood takes over and hit hints of pipe tobacco, leather, and cocoa. Finish, long, warm and oily. The heat is incredibly well integrated for a 120 proof. It leaves lingering notes of dark chocolate covered almonds. There you go. There's your nuttiness. There it is. Toasted oak. And ⁓ and ⁓ fading, slightly tangy dark fruit leather note. Okay. And as a side note, it says how to drink it on here, which is kind of interesting. Because it's bottled uncut and unfiltered, it's highly recommended that you try your first few sips neat to experience the full density of the math fill. Afterwards, add just two or three drops of distilled water to help cut down the initial alcohol heat and bloom. The softer fruit and vanilla profiles. Do we still have that bottle of Tennessee water? It's right behind you. Anybody interested in it? I sure would. I've tried. I only need like one drop though. Yeah. Very little left. Drink everything so far. Or from Kentucky not Tennessee. Kentucky, okay. Kentucky water. ⁓ two. I'll take two. Boop. Thank you. And you wanted one? Yeah, I got a little bit more less. Perfect. I'm out. He couldn't wait for this. Pour yourself a little bit more with Giancarlo. Him and my wife have Now the question is how old is that ⁓ Kentucky water? This usually doesn't have I've got well, yeah, I've got two liters of it, but that's ⁓ okay. I'm thinking this is the same bottle we've been tripping out of for three years. It is. But I mean it's sealed. So should be good. ⁓ It's like a fruit, like immediately on the nose I got like this juicy fruit bubblegum. Yeah, one one drip in my cup changed it. ⁓ yeah. Like the fruit just pops on the nose. Yes, very, very light fruit though. We were talking about dark fruits earlier and dark, dark, dark, and all of a sudden it's like a light fruit. Yeah. You're saying bubblish and bubblegum, and I'm going, I I I I kind of get it. Juicy fruit. Juicy fruit, yeah. I'm gonna be honest with you, this tastes so much better with two drops of water in it. I thought it was pretty good before. Or because it just softens it releases flavors. The flavors, I think it amplifies the flavors. The heat dissipates just a little bit, still there. But the fruit definitely pops up. Yeah. It's a great suggestion of more vanilla and more soft fruit. It does. It it opens up that profile just enough. Big time, yeah. It allows more of that that fruitiness that we're noting. ⁓ yeah, it didn't really temper the the heat. No. I thought the heat was fine. Yeah. As it was. So I actually had less left in my glass and that one drop you put in, I think it did drop the heat. Just a little bit. I'm agreeing with everybody, but everything opening up. The only difference for me was the heat dropped as well mine. Okay. Okay. Hey. No, I to be honest with you, I don't think it's probably been at least a year that I've added drops of water to a bourbon. So like I know you mentioned it on one of the last times we filmed, like, I gotta bring that little jar up here so that we can have it just in case. Came in handy on this episode. I forgot that I had mentioned it. I thought I was bringing up something new today. No, you brought ⁓ you think you brought it up last time. Repeating myself. Well, Pablo and Peter doing some special things at rare character with some of these special This is crazy. Lines that they're now introducing or in some cases reintroducing. So I think there's a lot of rare character like single barrel picks out there. Some are great, some are misses. Like it just depends on who's picking that barrel, right? ⁓ but their their core line are like the Brookhill, this, Pride of Pride ⁓ Sanderson County, Commander's Club, like some of their limited releases, they do a phenomenal job on. Yeah. And I think that's worth a chase. 100%. Delicious. Delicious. That's an instant buy if you see it. Absolutely. Yeah. My my ad was gonna be there's a lot of bourbons, like regular Woodfords and stuff like that. Well, I'll still put a big rock in there and let that rock kind of melt down. Yeah. To me, my advice on this would be get a little nugget ice machine. 'Cause we're doing really small pours here for tasting. If somebody's put to do a real pour at home. We're putting two drops in here. Yeah. If they dropped a couple of nuggets of ice in there just to get that temperature down, just to get that dilution down a little bit, I think that nugget ice would be the answer to this. Cut it just a little bit. It it made the world a difference. I like it even more. Interesting. Well listen, I ⁓ unfortunately passed on buying a second bottle of this because I was like, I don't know if this is gonna be that good. What were these? Three hundred bucks? Yeah. I think they're about three hundred bucks. ⁓ I'm gonna have to keep my eyes out for a 2026 release version. And hopefully it's just as good. Maybe they may be able to still find a 2025 out there if you look hard. ⁓ but yeah, from from me, I think it's an absolute buy. If you see an old Cassidy, again, it's not a shelter bottle, it's an expensive bottle. They're usually on lottery. Sometimes they're hard to find. But if you haven't tried it and you're wondering about it, and that's a product ⁓ price that doesn't scare you off. I think you should grab it. Absolutely. Absolutely. You'd be happy to have that on your shelf, I guarantee you. Perfect. Well, thank you guys for tasting it with me. It's certified a good bottle. We'll see you very soon on another episode of the 323 Bourbon Library. Cheers. Cheers. Cheers.