Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Will Jeremiah Smith Be An Immediate Starter For The Buckeyes?
Transcript
- 0:01Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:05here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going well, Tony,
- 0:13I'm looking ahead at the listener questions for this episode and realizing this episode's going
- 0:17to air in about two days, which is plenty of time for us to
- 0:22already be wrong about some of these questions in here, which is great.
- 0:29Lui. You know, we love to be wrong, not that we're ever
- 0:31wrong, but hypothetically if we were at some point in the distant distant future
- 0:35to be wrong, you know we love that. So well, on with
- 0:40the show, Tony, I'll let you take this first one from Matt Omar
- 0:44Underscore Austin eight val you Buck, I had all remember Tony does l J
- 0:48flip. Dominic McKinley, five star defense tack, five star defensive tackle out
- 0:54of Louisiana did not sign on signing day. Dominic McKinley the number six defensive
- 0:59lineman in the class according to the twenty four to seven composite. There are
- 1:06obviously some conversations going on, and I think we talked about that on signing
- 1:10day. Mark Gibler talked about that as well. But it has been tome
- 1:15twenty one years or so. Twenty years or so since Ohio State signed a
- 1:22defensive lineman out of Louisiana. Nater Abdallah was a two and three or two
- 1:26thousand and five class somewhere in there. So it's been a while and they
- 1:32don't even necessarily go into Louisiana all that often. Jay R. Brown,
- 1:38does that count as going into Louisiana. He was in Louisiana for a spell,
- 1:42but then, of course he's no longer in Ohio State anyway, so
- 1:45I don't know that that one really counts. We've talked about how on the
- 1:51show a couple of days ago. Ohio State they're fine with their defensive line
- 1:53numbers, according to Ryan Day, so why would they even want to crowd
- 1:57the room with another five star defensive tackle. But I'm never going to side
- 2:04on the side of Ohio State's definitely going to get this five star defensive linement
- 2:08from the South. If I have an option A to say there's no chance
- 2:14and an option to be to say, hey, I like their chances,
- 2:15I'm gonna generally side with option A on the five star defensive tackle out of
- 2:20the South. Yeah, that's one of those position groups where a lot of
- 2:23the best players in the nation are in the South, so you have to
- 2:27go into the South. But it is a real uphill battle. Recruiting out
- 2:30of Louisiana in general is hard because there's a real draw to LSU for the
- 2:36in state kids. But also Alabama's right there, Texas at AA and m's
- 2:39right there. You get all those other schools right down there. And if
- 2:44you want to get out of the SEC, well, you know, you've
- 2:46got clumbson. You've got Florida State. You know, Georgia's right there in
- 2:51terms of you know, being much closer to Louisiana than Ohio is. There's
- 2:54just a lot of there's a lot of other options. That's just a very
- 2:59tough area to part guys out of because Louisiana is you know, Georgia is
- 3:04a area, especially like the Atlanta area, where you get a lot of
- 3:07transplants where you know, a lot of people who live in Atlanta are not
- 3:12from Atlanta. And you know, if you grew up in Ohio and then
- 3:15your family moved to Atlanta, or even your parents grew up in Ohio and
- 3:19moved to Atlanta, maybe you have more you know, more likelihood to have
- 3:23some affinity for Ohio State in particular, like Garrett Wilson, for example,
- 3:28that was a Texas guy, but you know, his family was from Ohio
- 3:30and then moved to Texas and then he so he had this affinity for Ohio
- 3:34State and then comes back. That's not necessarily as true in Louisiana and Mississippi
- 3:42and Alabama as it is in places like Georgia or Florida. So I think
- 3:46that's I am always going to bet against Ohio State pulling someone out of Louisiana.
- 3:52You know, they tried attack at Curtis a year ago and he ended
- 3:54up going to USC. Now he's back in the portal, so maybe they
- 3:58get him, you know, potentially in the portal this year. That's at
- 4:00least a possibility. I would not bet on Dominic McKinley. If I'm going
- 4:05to bet on them landing a guy in the defensive line recruiting class for twenty
- 4:12twenty four during the early signing period, which will already be done by the
- 4:15time you hear this, I would bet on Dominic Kirks rather than Dominic McKinley.
- 4:18But that's you know, neither one of those is a sure thing.
- 4:23Neither one of those is a definitely not. But I think they're more likely
- 4:27to end up with Kirks than McKinley. Next one from Matt Buckeye sixty seven
- 4:30to thirty one. Any idea how well Jeremiah Smith and Aaron Nolan know each
- 4:34other? What do you think of the idea of these two roomy together?
- 4:38Join them from them, join them from the hip on day one? Erin
- 4:42Nolan from Georgia, Jeremiah Smith from South Florida. So they may know each
- 4:47other from camps and you know, all star games and visits at Ohio State.
- 4:53But I don't you know, this is not you know, to Kyle
- 4:56McCord and Marvin Harrison who played high school foota together or anything like that.
- 5:00So you know, Tony, you know me. I am always up for
- 5:04a good Hey, did you know the quarterback and the wide receiver our roommates,
- 5:09Tony? Did you know that Dwayne Haskins and Austin Mack our roommates?
- 5:13Did you have any idea? Have you heard anything about that? Yep?
- 5:15I remember that. I remember that. I wonder Tom if maybe Aaron Noland
- 5:20and Jeremiah Smith will be roommates in San Antonio when they're both playing in the
- 5:25All American Bowl later in a couple of weeks. And maybe that's a question
- 5:30that Kevin new And and Mark Gibler can ask when they're down there, say,
- 5:33hey, are you guys roommate yet? Who you're rooming with? And
- 5:36just get really nosy about all of these questions like what's your address? Why?
- 5:40Why do you want to know my address? And stuff like that.
- 5:43So I some of those things that I like, the big brother thing that
- 5:48the Ohio State does, but the rooming thing that they do as well.
- 5:55They've got such nice apartments. Now, these dorms, they're ridiculous. I
- 5:58think you can put four people in there legitimately, unlike when you put four
- 6:01in a place illegitimately back in back in the day, like in the towers,
- 6:06where there shouldn't be sixteen people in here. There should only be like
- 6:12four. No, no, no, no, it's fine. Just the
- 6:15beds go up to the walls. It's fine. There's enough room for everybody.
- 6:19But yeah, I'm all for getting those two to get acquainted with each
- 6:26other, and you do. We're gonna have to add, We're gonna have
- 6:29to add, mister business to the official logo and the description on this podcast
- 6:32at some point soon if he continues guest hosting. He said, he's been
- 6:35on here more than Kevin Well. This is his first appearance in this show.
- 6:40Tom Well, I know, but and yeah, if we've gone two
- 6:44shows in a row, he's on quite a few. Plus he looks better
- 6:47in a bow tie than Kevin. More professionals he does there. You go
- 6:50very very much professional, but you want your quarterback to be rooming with these
- 6:56guys, not just rooming, but on the field, on the practice field,
- 7:00after hours, get the key to the to the woody, that sort
- 7:03of thing where they're just always working. And I would expect that to continue
- 7:08with this the way Ryan Day talks about Aaron Nolan saying that he is going
- 7:11to be the leader of this team. So I'm not going to doubt the
- 7:14guy that knows quarterbacks about his quarterback well. And what's interesting is the way
- 7:19they do rooming. You talked about it a little bit with the Big Brothers
- 7:23and all that kind of stuff, but the way they do rooming during camp
- 7:25a lot of times is you'll have guys from the offensive side of the ball
- 7:29rooming with someone from the defensive side of the bawl or you'll have you know,
- 7:32maybe that's the case for bowls, where the whole point is you have
- 7:36people who don't just get to know the people in their room or on their
- 7:41side of the ball. The whole team gets to know each other, and
- 7:43then you end up with what cade Stover and Tommy Eikenberg and Steel Chambers.
- 7:49I think we're all roommates this year, and you know, I go back
- 7:54a couple of years and it was like a bunch of the tight ends I
- 7:57think live together, but like tight end and an offensive lineman and someone on
- 8:01the defensive side of the ball. Like the whole point is that you're trying
- 8:05to get so you don't get clicky on the team that you get guys who
- 8:07are friends with people all you know, all different position groups, different sides
- 8:11of the ball, that kind of stuff. So you know that it's sort
- 8:15of they're sort of strategic in the way that they do that as well.
- 8:18So we'll see, we will, we will. I'm sure at some point
- 8:20ask Aaron Noland, hey, who are you living with next? Up from
- 8:26at Bucky Hustle six? Will the NCAA go lighter on Michigan if Hardball leaves.
- 8:31So that's an interesting question. And you know, obviously that would mitigate
- 8:39the head coach penalties. I don't you know, I think you're likely to
- 8:46see assuming that they feel that they've proven their case and the you know,
- 8:50initial notice valegations that went out this week involving the COVID stuff, and then
- 8:54whenever the notice of allegations goes out for all the stuff that came out this
- 8:58fall, all with the Connor stallions and the sign stealing and all of the
- 9:01associated other stuff. You know, you're you're you are as a head coach
- 9:07looking at a probably pretty significant penalty for two separate major infractions cases going on
- 9:15simultaneously. That's you know, that's something that's going to come down probably fairly
- 9:20hard on the head coach. That's probably why you're hearing his name floated for
- 9:26you know, the San Diego Chargers shop right now sort of beat the posse
- 9:30out of town. Basically, I don't know that that's you know, I
- 9:33don't know the NCAA is going to look at that and go, well,
- 9:37as long as Jim Harbaugh's gone, everything else is fine. I think you're
- 9:39still you know, whoever the new head coach is obviously isn't going to have
- 9:45the suspension like poured it over to him. But I think you're still looking
- 9:50at if, you know, if there are other coaches on the staff who
- 9:52get suspensions or show causes or whatever, or you've got scholarship restrictions. I
- 9:58don't I don't think I buy the idea that this is like, well,
- 10:01if Jim Harble, you know, this is all a secret vendetta against Jim
- 10:05Harball, Like, I don't think that's actually what's going on here. So
- 10:09I don't think it's going to materially impact, you know that if there's a
- 10:13scholarship production number. I don't think that changes the scholarship production number if Jim
- 10:18Harball is no longer the head coach. Yeah, especially if he just walks
- 10:22away like there's there's no punishment given to him. But even if he was
- 10:28still there, the punishment would be your show cause, you know, and
- 10:33that doesn't have anything to do with the scholarship production. The lack of institutional
- 10:37control, it's not a lack of head coach control, it's lack of institutional
- 10:41control. So there's still the whole administrative aspect of this that goes beyond the
- 10:46head coach, and you know, the scholarship production, the whatever vacated things
- 10:54that they're going to have, Like that's all in addition to anything that would
- 10:58happen to Harbaugh. Think back to Ohio State when they essentially fired Jim Tressel
- 11:05and did they get did that go easier on did the NCAA go easier on
- 11:11them for that? They still still got docked a you know, the postseason,
- 11:18and I don't expect to. I don't expect any postseason bans any longer.
- 11:26I think maybe the NCAA is hoping, like the punishment should ban you
- 11:30from the postseason themselves, like that sort of thing, like we're not going
- 11:33to limit you your eligibility for it, but hopefully these twenty scholarships that you
- 11:39no longer have will make you a seven and five program rather than a ten
- 11:45to two program, that sort of thing, because I don't really see them
- 11:48trying to impact any type of television product anymore. Yeah, this is all
- 11:56kind of new where postseason bands have been. I mean, I'm trying to
- 12:00remember the last team they got a postseason ban. It's been a year or
- 12:03two at least, and it you know it feels like they they're sort of
- 12:09like gradual trends in the punishments are And you know, I'm not expecting twenty
- 12:16scholarship you know, a twenty scholarship production, like I don't remember what the
- 12:18Penn State situation was. I don't think you're going to see quite that much,
- 12:22but I think you're going to probably see scholarship productions. You're probably going
- 12:28to see some coaching penalties. You know. Obviously I'm not expecting a TV
- 12:33ban like that's that's one of those things that I think that the only thing
- 12:35I can say with one hundred competence, and they're not going to get a
- 12:37TV ban. That's that's just not a thing that they're going to issue against
- 12:41anyone. Anymore postseason penalties. Yeah, I mean that that might be a
- 12:50just hit them hard enough in other areas that it sort of works itself out
- 12:54as a functional postseason ban without being a postseason dan. Yeah, it's so
- 13:00fascinating to me how different this conversation is compared to where it was when Jim
- 13:05Tressel was you know, when Jim Tressel was the guy in the NC double
- 13:09as Crosshairs and you know, accused of the same thing that Jim Harbaugh is,
- 13:13which is lying to the NC Double A. And this is just the
- 13:18first thing for Jim Harbaugh. And they haven't the NC DOUBLEA hasn't officially ruled
- 13:22that he did it yet, but it's in the notice of allegations. And
- 13:24you know, that was a thing that got Jim Tressel fired, got Ohio
- 13:28State a one year bowl band, and you know that's just you know,
- 13:33act one of this Michigan thing. Well, and it's funny when I say
- 13:37postseason band, I I wasn't even thinking bulls. I'm just thinking playoffs.
- 13:43So that might be where where things are now in terms of what actually counts
- 13:50as the postseason. And to me, I guess playoffs is postseason. But
- 13:54as long as well you got to remember then the NC Double A doesn't actually
- 13:58have oversight over the call football playoffs, so they can't specifically say college football
- 14:03playoff band. They would have to say postseason ban, which you know,
- 14:07I mean, this is one of the many areas in which the NCAA governance
- 14:11is like, what, why, who drew this up this way? And
- 14:13the answer is, well, no, and it just kind of worked out
- 14:16that way. Yeah, And we know the committee says they're not going to
- 14:18hold anybody ineligible as long as they're eligible. So as long as the NCAA
- 14:22is saying they're eligible and conferences are saying they're eligible, they're going to be
- 14:26eligible. So yeah, but that is all new, and it has been
- 14:31a while since we've seen any like big time postseason ban from anybody, and
- 14:37I guess I'll be surprised if I see it again. But this is also
- 14:41a very very unique and serious charge. Absolutely, and again I think it's
- 14:48worth reiterating the thing that os You got hit for twelve years ago, that's
- 14:54Act one for Michigan, that's, you know, and also the stuff that
- 14:58os You got hit for the you know, the the underlying charges that led
- 15:01to the Jim Trestle led to the NCAA thing. All that stuff's legal now,
- 15:05which is crazy to think about. And so you know, we'll see
- 15:11where this all goes. We'll see where Jim Harbaugh goes. But no,
- 15:16I don't you know, I think I think this is only just beginning.
- 15:18This process that's probably going to drag out for another year or more. Next
- 15:24one for Matt Bucky Hustle six. How many more players do you think enter
- 15:28the portal for Ohio State. You know, I think you've we kind of
- 15:31had a rough list, and a lot of the names off of that list
- 15:35are gone. I think what may impact guys moving forward is who leaves who
- 15:45comes back. You know, if you're a guy at a position and you
- 15:48think, I've got a clear path to the playing field, Now what wants
- 15:52these guys who I think are going to leave for the NFL leave for the
- 15:54NFL. If those guys come back, maybe the path to the playing field
- 15:58isn't so clear, and then maybe you think about leaving. You know,
- 16:03you may have you may have sort of followed, you know, fall off
- 16:04effects from guys making NFL decisions that you you know, you weren't expecting them
- 16:10to make. So that's where I'd maybe expected so. And you know,
- 16:15there are other guys who may end up deciding to go after the bowl game.
- 16:18But I don't I don't think you're going to see another how many guys
- 16:22have left now twelve or something like that. I don't think you're going to
- 16:26see another wave of guys like that, But you may see another handful three,
- 16:30four, you know, something something like that. Is that's them reasonable?
- 16:34Yeah, I think that's reasonable. And you know, I still have
- 16:38on my list like six guys that you know i'd put on my preliminary expected
- 16:44list. But some of that is some of those are do I want to
- 16:48come back from my sixth year type of thing, or do I want to
- 16:51do somewhere else for my sixth year type of thing. But also we're going
- 16:53to see stuff in after the spring as well. If somebody, say on
- 16:57the offensive line, hitting their third year, still has not moved past the
- 17:03third team, they may hit the road and go find some place to play,
- 17:07or somebody that is graduating in the spring that sort of thing, like
- 17:11I'm just staying for to get my degree. Then I'll be hitting the road
- 17:15and I can go wherever I want, that sort of thing. Not that
- 17:17they couldn't anyways, but there is still some timeframe issues going on here.
- 17:22I did expect when we had that flurry when everybody was hitting, and I
- 17:26think I asked both you and Kevin at that point like give me, like
- 17:30I set the over under it, like two and a half more names,
- 17:33and I don't think we had any further names other than maybe maybe Kyle McCord
- 17:37after that one, which was not necessarily the one that everybody was expecting.
- 17:41But yeah, I'm still I three four something like that would not surprise me.
- 17:45Like I said, I still got like six names here, and you
- 17:48know I could I could pull off, you know, two to four more
- 17:52others, just depending on how spring goes. Is there are a bunch of
- 17:55guys that entering their third and fourth year who have not really played, ye
- 17:59played yet, and you've got fifteen freshmen hitting spring ball. And if they
- 18:07how quickly they move past or stay even with somebody, or for some guys,
- 18:11it doesn't take long to see like, oh, that guy's better than
- 18:15you know. I wasn't that good when I was that young, and I'm
- 18:18probably not that good right now. And so the writing is big, big
- 18:25bold letters for a lot of these guys come you know, like April fifteenth.
- 18:29Yeah, we have come to call that the spring awakening, where you
- 18:33know, you're it's like you're driving in the You're driving in the middle lane,
- 18:36and you've got people passing you on both sides, and it's like,
- 18:38m I might this might not be the highway for me. That's that's sort
- 18:42of where the left lanes are passing only by the way, if you're that's
- 18:48a whole separate lecture. Anyway, transfer out of the left lane if you're
- 18:52driving slowly. Next one from at fun under square magnets. Jeremiah Smith is
- 18:56an immediate starter, right Tom? I don't, Hey boy, this is
- 19:03the question. We did not talk about this on the last show or the
- 19:07previous to the last show, but we did say he other than Jeremi Smith,
- 19:12he would be the first freshman to get a start, implying that we
- 19:15expect Jeremiah Smith to be the first freshman to get a start. One of
- 19:18the things that I was talking with Mark and Kevin about while on a live
- 19:23stream while you were on campus was that I wouldn't be surprised if Jeremi Smith
- 19:30becomes the fourth true freshman with thirty receptions for Buckeye, you know his freshman
- 19:34year. Mark said he would be surprised if he doesn't become that fourth guy.
- 19:40So, Tom, I'll go ahead and flip this to you. I
- 19:42don't think he is an immediate starter, but where do you stand on that
- 19:45part? And also the thirty reception mark? But I also think he's an
- 19:52eventual starter, maybe a spot starter at some point. I just it's a
- 19:56lot to put on a guy. Yeah, I think it's a lot to
- 19:59put on a guy that you're a day one starter. I'm not saying no.
- 20:03And some of this made to depend on stuff like does a Mecca Abuka
- 20:07comeback, because if a Mecca Abuka comes back, one of the three starting
- 20:10positions is spoken for, and I think another one of the starting positions is
- 20:15spoken for with Carnell Tait, So you know, then you're going against all
- 20:18of the other very talented receivers in that receiver room for that third starting spot.
- 20:23So you know, I think my expectation would be he's not a day
- 20:26one starter. If you're asking me to set the over under on number of
- 20:30starts for Jeremiah Smith in twenty twenty four and you're setting the over under at
- 20:36zero point five, I'm probably taking the over. I'm almost certainly taking the
- 20:40over. But I don't know, you know, someone's going to get hurt
- 20:42at some point, and I think he's in the top he's certainly in the
- 20:48top five entering, you know, entering the season. Certainly he maybe he's
- 20:52in the top four. I don't think it's realistic to think he's in the
- 20:56top three unless and mecha a booka leaves and then know then I'm then I'm
- 21:00bumping the over under on the UH on the number of starts and the projected
- 21:04first start date. I'm bumping that up quite a bit. But I don't
- 21:08think it's reasonable to expect him to start day one just because that's really you
- 21:12really haven't I mean, have you ever seen that an Ohio State receiver starting
- 21:17day one game one of his true freshman season. I'm just thinking back like
- 21:19Chris Lave No, Garrett Wilson, No, Jackson's with the jig, but
- 21:22no, David Boston, No, maybe Ted Gin. I'm not sure about
- 21:30Chris Carter ted Gett at two thousand and four, like I can go and
- 21:34actually pull yeah, I mean it's that, It's just yeah, you can.
- 21:38You can pull that one up. While I'm thinking about the thirty catch
- 21:41thing, but I think I think if he's healthy, he's hitting the thirty
- 21:45catches next year would be my expectation. But you know, they're they're even
- 21:51that is you know, I think everyone's kind of going, well, of
- 21:53course he got thirty, he'd get thirty catches. You know, why wouldn't
- 21:56he get thirty catches? There's no scenario in which he doesn't get thirty catches
- 21:59if he's healthy. Julian Clemming had twenty six catches this year. Colonel Tate,
- 22:03who everyone is looking at, is like, man, this is a
- 22:06you know, likely a more or less sure thing to start next year.
- 22:11Colonel Tate seventeen catches two hundred and sixty yards, so you know you're looking
- 22:15for him to do double essentially what Carnel Tate did this year. I think
- 22:18he will. Marvin Harrison sixty seven catches, Kate's over forty one, and
- 22:22Mecha Abuka thirty five this year. Those are the only guys with thirty catches
- 22:26this year. So that's that's the kind of company we're talking about. And
- 22:30I do think he gets it this year. But some of that depends on
- 22:34doesn't make a booka come back. Some of that depends on Kate Stiver come
- 22:38back. But yeah, I you know, we try very hard to not
- 22:42overly gas up the true freshman before anyone has actually seen them on the field
- 22:48at a college level in person. But it feels like Tony if someone was
- 22:52going to get to thirty catches as a true freshman receiver. Jeremiah Smith is
- 22:56probably the guy who you would think would do it. Yeah, I'm not
- 23:00going to bet against that. And to answer my own question about Ted Gin,
- 23:06he did not start any of the first three games in two thousand and
- 23:10four. That's all the further I've gone and looked. Do you know,
- 23:14Tom, can you tell me the two starting receivers in two thousand and four
- 23:21to open the season against Cincinnati, Go boy, two starting receivers to open
- 23:27the season against Cincinnati. Well, by the end of the year it was
- 23:33Gin and Anthony Gonzalez. And two thousand and four, was it Santonio Holmes.
- 23:44I'll tell you what those are the three guys I'm going to say started
- 23:47the Michigan games, Antonio Holmes, Ted ginn and Anthony Gonzalez. It did
- 23:52any of them start the first game of the two thousand and four season,
- 23:56Yeah, san Antonio Holmes did. He was joined by Roy Hall. Okay,
- 24:00okay, yeah, I was. I think Roy Hall was. So
- 24:04the second game of the season featured Bam Childress in the starting lineup. The
- 24:10second spring game, Yes, that's yeah, that's that's you know I mean,
- 24:15And that's Ted gin was an otherworldly talent and that was not an Ohio
- 24:19State room that was as deep or as talented as this Ohio State room,
- 24:25not by a long shot. I mean, Santonio Holmes is Santonio Holmes.
- 24:27He wasn't like finished products Santonio Holmes at the start of the two thousand and
- 24:30four season. But you know, future Super Bowl MVP Santonio Holmes could play
- 24:34a little football, So you know he's in that conversation. But you know,
- 24:38I don't I don't think Bam Childress is getting a start in the twenty
- 24:41twenty four Bluck guys. I think Hall is getting a start for the twenty
- 24:44twenty four bluck guys. So you know, Ted gin the bar is pretty
- 24:48high to be, you know, in terms of athleticism, explosive and his
- 24:52playmaking ability, all that kind of stuff for Ted Ginn. And he didn't
- 24:56start over those guys. So I just I until you until we can find
- 25:00a true freshman who definitely started and you know, is in a relevant era
- 25:04like Chris Carter. Like, I'm sorry, the Earl Bruce teams are not
- 25:08a great analog for the Ryan Day teams at Ohio State. So unless there's
- 25:14someone I'm not thinking of who's done it more recently than that. I think
- 25:18I'm going to I think I'm going to just sort of always default to know
- 25:22until I see someone make it happen. Well, I amloading. I am
- 25:26loading the first box score from the nineteen eighty four season very slowly because this
- 25:30is probably a heavy, heavy PDF to see if Chris Carter was in the
- 25:34starting lineup a handwritten pdf, I would guess too. Yeah, it's like
- 25:40everything is filled out and almost there. Tom Now I just have to scroll
- 25:45and look to see if they put in the starting lineups, and boy,
- 25:48this is oh, here we go. Let's see Ohio State offense split ends
- 25:55Jay Holland, Doug Smith, Carter, Chris so no, so he did
- 26:02not start. He was a second. He was a second split end to
- 26:03go in because so, there you go. He not even he started day
- 26:08one at Ohio State. All right, next time for Matt fun Undersquare Magnets
- 26:15rank j t Amecca, and Henderson in order of the most important to return.
- 26:19So this is an interesting question because these are three guys that I think
- 26:23we have both sort of heard are more likely to return than you might have
- 26:29thought at the beginning of the season. And boyd I think I mean all
- 26:37three of them would be massive for Ohio State to get back. I think
- 26:42I'm gonna put travy On Henderson at the top of that list, just because
- 26:48if he doesn't come back, then you're looking at three running backs in that
- 26:52running back room, two of whom are freshmen. So I think that's probably
- 26:56my answer for the number one most important there. But I don't, you
- 27:03know, I mean, I think this is actually a pretty close Even with
- 27:07that, I think this is a pretty close decision in terms of, you
- 27:11know, the impact that the other two guys could have on this team as
- 27:12well. I'm with you, because you look at you have to look at
- 27:18the rest of the room as well, And that's why I think my ranking
- 27:22goes Henderson a mecca JT. Touey Moolowow, which is strange, like the
- 27:30wide receiver room is deep, the you know, running backs are a diamond
- 27:34dozen. J T. Twoey Molowow is a difference maker, So why would
- 27:37he be last? And it's like, well, there are other defensive ends,
- 27:41and you when you've are when you're already losing, assuming Marvin Harrison and
- 27:45Julian Fleming and Xavier Johnson, you want somebody back in that receiver room.
- 27:52So having a Mecca back would be huge, and they can build around him
- 27:57and move around him and decide different ways to use him and use him as
- 28:00a focal point of the offense as well. And I'm with you, you
- 28:04don't want to go into a season with three running backs and so because if
- 28:07you do, you've got to go to the portal. And now now you're
- 28:11looking for a starter. Now you're looking for a tray sermon. And doing
- 28:15that at the portal age is kind of dangerous because you may be losing somebody.
- 28:19So now now you need two running backs out of the portal, and
- 28:23there aren't two good running backs in the portal that are going to both come
- 28:26and join you. So I think, overall, just for the the smoothness
- 28:33of the season, I'm going to go Henderson one, Abuka two and two
- 28:38Bolowow three, which seems counterintuitive. It does seem counterintuitive, and I think
- 28:45you're also I think it's also worth noting that I think number one is pretty
- 28:49clear cut to me, just because of the depth in the room. Two
- 28:55in three. I think you could make a pretty compelling argument either way,
- 28:59and I think it would be huge to get any or all of those guys
- 29:02back. And if they do get all three of those guys back, boy,
- 29:04that changes I think a lot of the conversation around this team. And
- 29:07you're going to have a new quarterback, and so having a returning wide receiver,
- 29:11a proven wide receiver who has been really, really good when he's been
- 29:15healthy, that's going to really you know, that takes a lot of the
- 29:18pressure off of Carnel Tate who hasn't had to start yet, and Jeremiah Smith
- 29:22who han't steped foot on campus yet, and you know, the whole the
- 29:26whole rest of that wide receiver room. I think there there's very very talented
- 29:29receivers in that room, but they're all young and unproven, and having you
- 29:33know, a veteran coming back I think makes a big, big difference in
- 29:37that room. So I think I will co sign your answer there. But
- 29:41it is you know, this is not a you know, one huge gap,
- 29:45two huge gap three kind of situation. They are all very important.
- 29:51I think the only the only thing that's a clear decision to me is number
- 29:55one, and that's Henderson, and that's just based on the rest of the
- 29:57depth chart. Last one time, should Lincoln keenholes get any meaningful snaps in
- 30:02the Cotton Bowl. If the coaching staff thinks he's ready, Absolutely, he
- 30:08should get meaningful snaps in the Cotton Bowl. We'll see if the coaching staff
- 30:12thinks he's ready, because again, this is a guy who showed up in
- 30:15the summer, who played just a little bit during the course of the year.
- 30:19It sounds like they've been happy with how the quarterbacks have looked during Bowl
- 30:23prep, and so that's all good. Let's if if I'm if I'm Ryan
- 30:32Day, I think I'm giving Lincoln Keyholes a drive at some point just to
- 30:37i mean, get more reps on film, get him more experience, because
- 30:41yeah, it matters if you win this game. But does it really matter
- 30:44if you win this game? Is that is that the primary goal here?
- 30:47Is is the ultimate goal here to win the twenty twenty three Cotton Bowl and
- 30:49to bring the twenty twenty three Cotton Bowl trophy back to Columbus. I submit
- 30:53that it is not. I would submit that the ultimate goal for this game
- 30:57should be to get Ohio State in the best possible position to win as many
- 31:02football games in twenty twenty four as they possibly can. I know they want
- 31:06to win the twenty twenty three Cotton Bawl. I know they've got, you
- 31:08know, potentially a lot of guys coming back who want to end the season
- 31:11right, and it changes the narrative around the team a little bit, not
- 31:15entirely, but a little bit if you win this game. But the ultimate
- 31:18goal is to make yourself as good as you can heading into spring ball,
- 31:22heading into winter workouts, all that kind of stuff. So if they feel
- 31:26that Lincoln Keenholes is ready to step on that kind of a stage, because
- 31:30he's so far only played you know, last five minutes against Michigan State kind
- 31:33of situations, if they feel he's ready to step on that stage, absolutely
- 31:41give give him a shot. Just like you, you know, treat it.
- 31:42Treat it like the first game against Indiana, the second game against Youngstown
- 31:45State. You wanted to win those games too, but also you wanted to
- 31:51figure out who your quarterback is. I think the process of figuring out who
- 31:53your twenty twenty four quarterback is has already started this month. Yeah, and
- 31:59we've talked about this all month long, that he should play some in the
- 32:02in the Cotton Bowl. But Ryan Day on signing day said, this is
- 32:07Devin Brown's game and when I asked if Lincoln Keyholds was going to play,
- 32:10he's like, well, if there's an opportunity, meaning if it's a forty
- 32:14two to fourteen game in the fourth quarter, is how I kind of took
- 32:16that. So I, you know, I think you should play, like
- 32:21I said, give them and drive, see what happens, and not just
- 32:22see what happens. Given drive, so he has a drive, it's like,
- 32:25oh, let's just see what happens. Like, No, this is
- 32:28an opportunity where it's not going to impact really anything because it's not like you're
- 32:36trying to get all of these guys to come back for this game. You're
- 32:37trying to get all of these guys to come back for next year. So
- 32:40there is focus on next year already happening this year. So I think it's
- 32:45okay to carry that into the Cotton Bowl at this point. Based on what
- 32:50Day said on Wednesday, I guess I'll be surprised that if Keyholtz actually gets
- 32:55much time, unless it's a blowout one way or the other, which would
- 33:00maybe also surprise me equally. Yeah, I'm not expecting this to be a
- 33:04huge blowout one way or the other. And you know, I Yeah.
- 33:07I heard him say that, and I thought, yeah, I mean,
- 33:10I think that maybe tells me where they think keen Holes is in terms of
- 33:15preparedness right now, because I think they also recognize that this is a little
- 33:21bit of a forward looking game to a certain degree, But how much of
- 33:25this is also personal management? Where if Devin Brown comes out and looks just
- 33:30okay, and Lincoln keen Holes that comes out and gets has two great drives,
- 33:34well, you know, does how does that change the conversation around the
- 33:37quarterback position and the likelihood that you have fewer than two of those guys when
- 33:40the season starts next year. I mean, there's that kind of factor as
- 33:45well. So there are factors in here, you know, in terms of
- 33:50how exactly what have they looked like during practice this month that we don't have
- 33:54direct access to. So I'm sure that that's going to be one of the
- 33:59driving factors in this decision. But you know, all things being equal,
- 34:02if if Lincoln Keenhols looks even remotely ready, I would like to see him
- 34:07get some reps because he should be getting reps. Jolannie Thurman should be getting
- 34:13some reps like you should. You should be taking advantage of the opportunity to
- 34:16play some of your younger guys, and you know, let's let's see what
- 34:21it looks like. Let's Malik Hartford should be getting reps in this game.
- 34:23Like that. Let's let's see what you've got there and start to you know,
- 34:29start to build for next year, get some film on these guys,
- 34:30all that kind of stuff. Yeah, I'm with you. That will do
- 34:34it for today. Please go ahead and like this video if you're watching it
- 34:37on YouTube, if you're listening to it on the podcast platform, go ahead
- 34:39and rate and review five stars if you could, we would appreciate that.
- 34:44And as always, find us at buckeyehuddle dot com. If you're not yet,
- 34:46remember now as a fantastic time to join. Check us out there at
- 34:52the end of the huddle message board. All kinds of insight, info,
- 34:55x's and o's, and sometimes some gossip, all things like that, so
- 35:00feel free to find us there. So thank you all for tuning in.
- 35:04Have a wonderful holidays. We will talk to you guys. I don't know
- 35:07the twenty sixth, I suppose of December, if not sooner, So thank
- 35:13you all for tuning in, and we'll talk to you guys later