Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP194: The Lipstick Killer
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Tanya and I'm Talia, and we are Crimes and Consequences,
- 0:18a true crime podcast. Ay Tanya, Hi Talia. Welcome back everybody
- 0:38to this week's episode of Crimes and Consequences. This is an oldie goodie.
- 0:45Yes, you may have heard of them as the lipstick Killer. I have
- 0:49never heard of this one. Really, yeah, it seems like there's probably
- 0:53a few lipstick killers there probably, Well, this is about William George Harron's
- 0:59I'm a give you a little background. Okay, okay, I'm ready before
- 1:02I do, though, everybody knows hit the like subscribe, follow love,
- 1:07need more, button, need more, whatever it is on your favorite app.
- 1:12And with that, we're going to dive into this. All right,
- 1:15let's do it. See. I kind of like the older ones that because
- 1:19there's I don't know what the word is, but there's something interesting about killers
- 1:26that aren't in our time, Like it just shows that there were killers.
- 1:29Yeah, like throughout time. Probably there's weirdos everywhere at anytime, anytime in
- 1:36our in our human existence. Okay, so let me tell you about William
- 1:40George Harrens. He was born in nineteen twenty eight, he was on the
- 1:44eve of the Great Depression, and he was raised in Evans, still in
- 1:49Illinois. He came from a poverty stricken home and his parents they argued all
- 1:56the time. They had no money. Yeah, I know, they probably
- 1:59just were yeah, yeah, fuck, I know. At the age of
- 2:02elemon, William claims to have witnessed a couple will say making love. Oh
- 2:07no, that's a nice term. Yeah. When he told his mother,
- 2:14she would tell him that all sex was dirty and he would get a disease.
- 2:20Did he ever tried it as a result. One time, when he
- 2:24was a little older, he was kissing a girlfriend and he just burst into
- 2:29tears and started vomiting right in front of her, voiting because it's dirty.
- 2:34It's dirty, and it's you're gonna get a disease. It's gross. Gross.
- 2:38As a child, he was pretty quiet and he spent most of his
- 2:42time alone. When he became a teen, he just took to the streets
- 2:46in search of what we'll call cheap entertainment. Are you being nice? And
- 2:52unfortunately that included petty theft. He was just kind of what's the word,
- 2:59a little hoodlum? Yeah, yeah, so it's an old term, right,
- 3:02he's a hoodlum. When he was twelve, he worked at a grocer
- 3:07store, so he actually had a legit job. One day, he accidentally
- 3:09short changed himself, so the register was a little off and I think he
- 3:14had to pay for it. Oh shit, Yeah, he was messed up
- 3:17on the whole change to someone. So he ended up stealing a single dollar
- 3:24bill from an apartment by reaching through the crack in a chain door. And
- 3:30he's twelve, and after that it all went downhill. Yeah. He soon
- 3:35graduated to stealing larger amounts of money and then later personal items from people.
- 3:42That's so creepy. Eventually William had himself a small collection of stolen items that
- 3:47ranged from the expensive to the more mundane. He had things like cameras,
- 3:53cocktail shakers. Oh they're probably like sterling silver or something, guns gone,
- 4:00yeah, and even handkerchiefs. You why, why do you want someone's handkerchief?
- 4:05It's the thrill that I told you. That was his form of entertainment.
- 4:12Then he really began like taking robbing home. Seriously. He would look
- 4:16for apartments that forgot to lock their doors. He would then check to make
- 4:20sure like no one's home and sneak in, and he'd steal anything that had
- 4:26any sort of value. And he's young, so that a lot of things
- 4:30may have seemed like they had value, but most of the time he was
- 4:32hunting for wallets and purses or any cash. At thirteen, he was arrested
- 4:39for breaking into a local building's basement and when he was arrested, he was
- 4:43carrying a loaded gun. Oh shit, it's not a good start. No,
- 4:47So the police ended up searching the heron's home and that revealed more weapons
- 4:51hidden in a refrigerator. Come on, now, nobody found it. And
- 4:58I don't know. Maybe they I had to come on, they're poor as
- 5:00hell. Maybe he's in a bag looked like meat and dashed in the produce
- 5:06store behind some cucumbers or something, and they also found some in the loft
- 5:13they had the attic. William admitted to a string of burglaries. He's like,
- 5:16yeah, I did it, and he was sent to what I believe
- 5:19is called the balt School of Wayward Boys. Wayward change the name. Nobody
- 5:27wants to be like, yeah, I go to that Wayward Boys school.
- 5:29Where school you go to, I know, something different? But he was
- 5:33there for several months. He claimed that he stole mostly for fun and it
- 5:39was a way to release tension. Okay. He described it as a hobby
- 5:44for him, something to do while his parents were busy fighting with each other.
- 5:48Yeah, okay, blame the parents. They're so they're busy fighting.
- 5:51What else could I do? What else could I do? I couldn't just
- 5:55go out and like play baseball with my friends. No, I needed to
- 5:58go rap. I got to release this tension. I got to release his
- 6:00tension. Not long after he was released from the Wayward Boys School, he
- 6:04was arrested again. Oh no, This time he was sentenced to three years
- 6:10at what I believe is called Saint Bede's Academy, and that was operated by
- 6:13benedictin Monksh Yeah during this time and sent to a nunnery right. Yes.
- 6:19Yes. During his time at the school, he stood out because he was
- 6:24really an exceptional student. He was very smart. He was released when he
- 6:28was sixteen, and he had such good test scores that he was able to
- 6:32enroll at the University of Chicago. Really, yeah, he's sixteen, He's
- 6:36wasting his life. Now he's not. He's going to school. Okay,
- 6:40he was wasting his life met with the months before he got sentenced to live
- 6:46with the monks. Yeah, now we know what to do with our kids.
- 6:49While the school proved to be good from academically, it didn't really hell
- 6:56with his what we'll call bad streak. In other words, he was still
- 7:00stealing. Yeah, he's getting his thrills. He's still getting his thrills.
- 7:03As a matter of fact, he was seventeen years old when he was at
- 7:06the University of Chicago and he got arrested again. Oh shit, Well,
- 7:11yam can't stay out of trouble, no, because he likes the thrillsoutely.
- 7:16On June twenty six, now we're in nineteen forty six, he was robbing
- 7:20an apartment when he was spotted by another neighbor who called the police. Police
- 7:26fired after William pulled out a gun. Oh no, yeah, and they
- 7:30managed to fire off two shots. But it was a hit over his head
- 7:35and there was a nearby flower pot. Oh, and it broke and it
- 7:40ended up rendering him unconscious. So the flower pot fell on I guess that's
- 7:46kind of crazy. It's like in a movie that happened to me once.
- 7:48Actually, well, no one was shooting a gun, but I was sitting
- 7:50on my parents' deck and flower pot fell and hit me right. Yeah,
- 7:56that explains a lot, now I understand. It hurt like a son of
- 8:01a bed. Let me just tell you long term effects. But I didn't
- 8:05fall unconscious, so I must have knocked his ass. Real guid. He
- 8:09was arrested and taken to the Cook County Jail in Illinois. At first he
- 8:13was just a thief. They didn't know that he would end up being the
- 8:18lipstick killer. Let's take a look back some shall we. Let's do that.
- 8:26Three terrible murders took place just five months earlier, between June of nineteen
- 8:33forty five in January of nineteen forty six, so that's an eight month span.
- 8:39Chicago was on the alert, but the rest of the country was as
- 8:41well. So let me tell you about the first one. It's June fifth,
- 8:45nineteen forty five, forty three year old Josephine Ross, who was three
- 8:50times divorced. She was unemployed. She lived with her daughters Mary, Jane,
- 8:54Jacqueline, and I don't know where her other daughter is. They lived
- 9:00in Kenwood Avenue apartments in the Edgewood District, which is located in Chicago's North
- 9:07Side. Her body was discovered at one thirty that afternoon when Jacqueline came home.
- 9:13She usually she went to work and she would come home for lunch.
- 9:16She found the apartment she lived in with her mom turned upside down. The
- 9:20drawers were pulled out, chairs were knocked over, and newspapers were unfurled across
- 9:26the floor. She ran to her mother's bedroom and then she saw something she
- 9:31would never forget. Josephine was sprawled across to her bed. Her throat was
- 9:37gashed many times and there were multiple stabbings. Her head was wrapped in a
- 9:43dress. Blood was spewed across the room. It was on the walls,
- 9:48the drapes, the furniture, It soaked the mattress, and there was an
- 9:54adjoining room several articles of women's clothing in undergarments. They lean this pool of
- 10:01bloody water in the bathtop. Oh that's weird. The only thing missing from
- 10:07the house was some change. Really, no fingerprints were found, only dark
- 10:15hairs that were in Josephine's hands. Who was clutching these dark hairs that indicated
- 10:20to authorities that she was struggling with this intruder who eventually killed her, so
- 10:28she ripped his hair out. Josephine had a fiance, but he had an
- 10:33alibi. They questioned all her former ex husbands because she had three right and
- 10:37her former boyfriends, and they all had alibis, so the police had no
- 10:41suspects. There was a witness who saw a man loitering around the apartments and
- 10:46running from the scene, and he had a dark complexion and he was wearing
- 10:50a white sweater and dark pants, but they weren't able to locate them.
- 10:56Next, we have this honorably discharged from the US Navy named Francis Brown.
- 11:01Francis Brown was petite, brown haired, and demure. She lived in room
- 11:07six one one at the Pine Crest apartment building on Pine Grove Avenue, not
- 11:13far from where Josephine Ross had lived, and she was home alone on the
- 11:18evening of December tenth, nineteen forty five. She arrived a little late.
- 11:22It was about nine thirty. Francis was told by a desk clerk, because
- 11:26remember she's running a room, that a man had entered the foyer earlier asking
- 11:33for her. When the man was informed that she was out, the man
- 11:37left. According to the clerk, Francis seemed to have been expecting the caller
- 11:43the person the man there. Her nude body was discovered the following morning by
- 11:48Martha Ingalls. She was a housemaid, curious s twoy francis radio was playing
- 11:56really loud at nine am and why her door was a jar. Martha peeked
- 12:01into room six one one and she found Francis's bed splattered with blood and a
- 12:07trail leading to the bathroom. Oh. She found Frances stretched over the bathtub,
- 12:16her head wrapped in her pajamas, a butcher knife rammed into her neck,
- 12:22and a bullet hole in her skull. Oh my gosh. No valuables
- 12:26were taken, but there was a message written in lipstick on the wall of
- 12:33her apartment and it read as follows quote for Heaven's sake, catch me before
- 12:41I kill more. I can't control myself. Wow. I feel like we've
- 12:45had that before. And one of our Patrion episodes we had a killer yea
- 12:52uh huh, and he's like, I'm not going to stop and it was
- 12:54on a mirror and I think I did. It was something like the title
- 12:58had to do with mirror or something. Yeah. Yeah, we've done so
- 13:01many guys, I know un together at some time. I mean, I
- 13:03remember it, but I don't remember the name. Please found a bloody fingerprint
- 13:07smudged on the door jam of the entrance, and an earlier witness, his
- 13:13name was George Weinberg, came forward to report that he did hear a gunshot
- 13:16at like four am. And additionally, of course there's that night clerk.
- 13:20She'd been stationed in the lobby of the building. She reported a nervous man.
- 13:24He was about thirty five forty years old. She thought he wade maybe
- 13:28one hundred and forty pounds. He got off the elevator, fumbled for the
- 13:33door to the street, and he left. Now next, we have a
- 13:37beautiful six year old named Susanne Degnan. She went to bed Sunday evening and
- 13:43this is January sixth, nineteen forty six. She spent the whole day earlier
- 13:46with her family. She went to bed. Her parents were Jim and Helen
- 13:50and they had a happy family. They lived at Thorndale and Kenmore in the
- 13:54Edgewater district. They had two daughters, Susanne and Betty. They shared a
- 14:01huge, huge turn of the sentry kind of home. They shared it with
- 14:05another family, one of those big homes. They occupied the first floor,
- 14:09and then the people named the Flynn's had the upstairs floor. During the night,
- 14:16the only sounds that household heard were the momentary barking of the Flynn's dogs,
- 14:20which wasn't unusual. I mean, I have dogs, they barget flies,
- 14:26and they heard some men talking in the street. Cecilia Flynn thought one
- 14:30of the men had said something like, this is the best looking building around.
- 14:35Helen, Susanne and Betty's mom at one point sat up in bad She
- 14:39woke her husband up. She explained she thought she'd heard Susanne crying. The
- 14:46couple listened for a few minutes and then they hear anything, so they went
- 14:50back to sleep. So it's the morning. Now it's January seventh. Jim
- 14:54Dad went to wake up his daughter's for school. He thought it was odd
- 14:58that Susanne's door was closed, since she was afraid of the dark and she
- 15:01always kept her door open. So he peeks inside her bedroom and her window
- 15:07is fully raised. The curtains were blowing just like you see in the movie.
- 15:11Yeah, the cold breeze, and Suzanne was nowhere to be seen.
- 15:16She couldn't be found. The rust of the family gets up. They're looking
- 15:20everywhere. They're in the looking in the closets, they looked on the fire
- 15:24escape. They woke up the Flints and asked them if they could search their
- 15:28part of the home. And that's when they began to panic because Suzanne was
- 15:33not in the house. And she's six and she's taken from a window.
- 15:39Right. That's brazen, right, because in the nature of this crime,
- 15:45we have a child that's disappeared. The police department dug into this case with
- 15:50fervor. There was a new police commissioner's name was John Prendaghast, and he
- 15:54became personally involved like this meant something. The Degnan apartment, according to this
- 16:03author, her name is Dolors Kennedy, she wrote this book, was immediately
- 16:07quote filled with police from the area, eager to resolve the disappearance of Suzanne
- 16:15Degnan. On the floor of Suzanne's bedroom, they found what they thought was
- 16:21a discarded tissue. But it wasn't, Tanya, Oh was it? It
- 16:26was a ransom note? Oh shit, really a ransom note. It was
- 16:30probably blown from the bed because the window was open in the wind and it
- 16:36read quote get twenty thousand ready in weight and weight is spelled wrong for word?
- 16:42Do not notify FPI or police bills in fives and tents. Yeah,
- 16:48that's a lot of five sutents. On the backside was a warning burned this
- 16:55for her safety. Oh that's ominous, dude. You can't even spell weight,
- 16:59right. You think you're going to get away with nappy? Bring it
- 17:02for ransom and don't don't notify the police. Oops, already did that.
- 17:06Who's not going to notify the pol? They always notify the police. Come
- 17:08on. Exactly outside the apartment, police found a seven foot ladder that,
- 17:14when held upright, reached to the sill of the girl's window. Oh godamn
- 17:18it did say she was on the first floor, But that's fine. The
- 17:22ladder, police learned, had been stolen from a nursery several blocks away.
- 17:27Investigators spread throughout the ear They're searching, they're asking questions, They're hoping to
- 17:32find a witness or something. There was an anonymous call that suggested they search
- 17:38the local sewers. Shit the sewers. Oh shit, But before I tell
- 17:45you more, I'm gonna take a quick break. That evening detective Lee O'Rourke
- 17:52and Harry Benois did just that. They searched the sewers, noticing that a
- 17:59sewer her cover a nearby Wilthrop Avenue looked misplaced. They flashed their light into
- 18:06the well. It's not really a well, it's a sewer, yeah,
- 18:10and they found what looked like the head of a golden haired dow No,
- 18:17it wasn't a doll's head. Before that evening ended the rest of Suzanne because
- 18:23it was just her head. Oh shit. Her legs and torso were found
- 18:29scattered in the debris of other sewers. Are you kidding me? Her arms
- 18:33weren't found for several weeks. Oh my god, who fucking does that?
- 18:37Well, we know, but it looks like Jesus Christ. A basement washtub
- 18:44below one of the apartments off of Wilthrop Avenue proved to be the place of
- 18:48dismemberment. So he brought her into an apartment like a laundry room, right,
- 18:56and he just cut her up? What the fuck? Like, what
- 18:59the fuck is that? Yah? Yeah? And it's like, how are
- 19:02you not worried that someone's gonna walk? Yeah? They found blood, pieces
- 19:06of human flesh, and blond hairs in the dream. Oh poor little Susianne.
- 19:12I don't know what the fuck is sex? What a matter of people?
- 19:18I hate people do. Chicago's greatest manhunt and perhaps one of the most
- 19:23intensive ever conducted in the nation at the time it was on. Yeah,
- 19:29police had the task of trying to pluck the killer out of a city of
- 19:33four million. It's a long time ago, guys. Yeah, this isn't
- 19:37like DNA, And yeah, I really feel for cops back that it had
- 19:41to because I can't even imagine. They worked around the clock. This is
- 19:45a quote from an author, Lucy Freeman. They worked around the clock,
- 19:49often driving their own cars and using their own time a police work day and
- 19:53night. They questioning potential suspects. They interviewed more than eight hundred people.
- 19:59They gave lie detect her tests to one hundred and seventy geez. The crime
- 20:03Laboratory compared seven thousand sets of handwriting with a ransom note. Can you imagine
- 20:11the tedious job that was. Now, we have computers to put it in
- 20:14and see, but these people had to do it all manual. The police
- 20:18received over five thousand, two hundred and fifty tips from all over the world,
- 20:23and they investigated three thousand, one hundred and fifty three of them.
- 20:27Geez police believed the kidnapper slash killer must have driven a car the few blocks
- 20:33to the place of dismemberment, so Suzanne had been put in a car.
- 20:38She was seventy four pounds and carrying her through the streets would have probably caused
- 20:42too much attention. But I don't know. With him, I don't either.
- 20:47These streets weren't empty. Even in the late hours, there were still
- 20:51people. Witnesses had seen a woman in the vicinity carrying a large bundle in
- 20:56both her arms. Near the Degnen home, she got into what seemed to
- 21:00be an awaiting automobile where a balding man sat behind the wheel. Another witness
- 21:04he was a seresman on Furlow he saw a large, dark man carrying a
- 21:10shopping bag, but the couple and the man with the bag they were never
- 21:14identified. The author I talked about, Dolores Kennedy said quote. The most
- 21:18promising suspects were arrested, and upon those arrest State's Attorney William J. Towey
- 21:23and Chief of Detectives Walter G. Storms would tell the press that this time
- 21:30they had found the killer. Inevitably the suspect would end up passing a lie
- 21:33detector test or I have an alibi, and police were forced to admit that
- 21:37the fingerprints that they did have didn't match, so they were basically leading the
- 21:44public un to believe all we got him this time, and then it would
- 21:47just fall Yeah, a janitor. Sixty five year old Hector Berber was arrested
- 21:52on suspicion. So they actually arrived at he worked in the apartment building where
- 21:57the Degnans lived, and the sink where Suzanne was believed to be dismembered.
- 22:03That was in an area that he frequented a lot, and the grimy state
- 22:11of the ransom note because it was dirty, suggested it could be a janitor.
- 22:15Really, if janitors have dirty hands. Okay, okay, don't you
- 22:22think that's a stretch. That's a big stretch. That's a big stretch.
- 22:26The police were so confident that they told the press, quote, this is
- 22:30the man. Oh, despite the discrepancies between his profile and the one that
- 22:37they had developed originally, which stated that the killer had skills of a surgeon.
- 22:41Oh oh yeah, that's right, because she wasn't dismembered, or was
- 22:47at least a butcher. They just felt confident he was the one because the
- 22:51notes dirty and janitors, I guess are dirty. I guess all the janitors
- 22:55obviously never looked dirty. All right, right, he doesn't go home and
- 22:57wash his hands. Come on, he was an older and you know he's
- 23:02sixty five. I guess as the elderly. It doesn't seem so old to
- 23:04me. He was beaten by the police. Oh no, under questioning for
- 23:08forty eight hours. Damn. He suffered injuries, including a separated shoulder,
- 23:15oh out of him, and he still didn't confess. Yeah. Wow.
- 23:19He got a lawyer through the janitor union, and he was released on a
- 23:25writ of habeas corpus. You know what he had to say about this experience
- 23:30said quote, Oh, they hang me up. They blindfolded me. I
- 23:33can't put up my arms, they're still sore. They had handcuffs on me
- 23:37for hours and hours. They threw me in the cell again. I was
- 23:40blindfolded. They handcuffed my hands behind my back and pulled me up on bars
- 23:45until my toes touched the floor. I know, eat, I go to
- 23:51hospital. Oh I'm so sick anymore, and I would have ended up confessing
- 23:56to anything Oh that's some human violation right there. Fucking shitty, that's how
- 24:02they did it back in the day. Though. Yeah, he's lucky he
- 24:06held his ground right because he need be hanged. Probably probably he ended up
- 24:11spending ten days in the hospital. Oh shit, what it's a long time,
- 24:15so longed in. You can't do that shit, not anymore. No,
- 24:19not they do. But it was determined that Hector, sorry, couldn't
- 24:25write English well enough to even by the crude standards of a ransom note for
- 24:32him to have written it like he couldn't read or write. He sued the
- 24:36Chicago Police Department. He sued for fifteen thousand, and you know what the
- 24:40judge did, what gave him twenty wow wow, which would be a lot
- 24:45of money today less what a ransom note was for was for twenty grand Oh
- 24:51well he didn't write it, yeah, exactly. Five thousand dollars of the
- 24:56twenty thousand awarded to Hector was given to his wife, as the police had
- 25:00tried to pressure her to implicate her husband in the murder. They were laying
- 25:07on the pressure, fucking ing as winner turned into springs. Her time is
- 25:11going by. Yeah, police had their theories, they had lots of them,
- 25:15but they had no concrete leads. The ransom note had been sent to
- 25:18the FBI laboratories, and I told you there were fingerprints that were found.
- 25:25Most of the prints belonged to the family members and the policemen who handled it,
- 25:29because he's back then his hands were dirty, No, just kidding,
- 25:32Yeah, who knows whose hands were dirty? But a few smudged prints hadn't
- 25:37been identified. Thomas Laffey, the Chicago Police Department's expert, spent a lot
- 25:42of time trying to match them with thousands and thousands of files, but he
- 25:48couldn't. That had to be frustrating as all hell. Right, at some
- 25:52point you're like, guys get blurry, and you're like yeah, they're like,
- 25:56oh, I can't look at any more fingerprints. They also, I'm
- 25:59sure they all start to look the same. Right. The search seemed impossible,
- 26:03But then something changed. A college student named none other than William Harrins
- 26:08turned up out of nowhere, and the spotlight of suspicion was turned on him
- 26:14with full force. So now I'm going to go back over the night he
- 26:19was caught, which I did talk to you about earlier. Remember the flower
- 26:25Oh yeah, yes, so he's about eighteen. Now it's June twenty six,
- 26:30nineteen forty six. William was arrested on attempted burglary charges because someone saw
- 26:37him breaking into an apartment and he fled and the buildings janitor nice pursued him,
- 26:41blocked his path out of the building. Up. Yeah, hello hero,
- 26:47janitor, Hero not dirty hands. William, though, ended up pointing
- 26:51the gun he was carrying the old janitor and said, quote, let me
- 26:56get out, or I'll let you have it in the guts. Oh okay,
- 27:00go ahead. Then surface police go the doors right there. Yes,
- 27:06I will not block. The janitor stopped chasing him. Yeah, William made
- 27:10his way to this nearby building. He was Lena lay low, but someone
- 27:14spotted him and they called the police, and I described it a little bit
- 27:18before. But two officers closed in from two different directions, and William was
- 27:22trapped brandishing a revolver. He points the barrel at one of the officers.
- 27:29Now, one of the reports say that he pulled the trigger and the gun
- 27:33misfired. The police stay he pulled it twice in a misfired. William's versions
- 27:37a little bit different. He said he was just basically bluffing with a gun
- 27:42and the cops charged after him. A scuffle resulted and it ended only when
- 27:48an off duty police officer dropped three flower pots on William's head, so they
- 27:56had fired after Adam. One of the flower pats fell down, and then
- 28:02the officer threw some nice at his head. At least two nice because they
- 28:07are total three that he said. According to William, you remember drifting into
- 28:11consciousness only when he was being questioned. The police had it taken him to
- 28:18Bridewell Hospital, which is right by the Cook County Jail. He says policemen
- 28:22were threatening him. They were pushing him, they probably were, and then
- 28:26punching him. Yes, given what we know, they probably were. And
- 28:30they were jabbing him in the body and he felt his hands being pushed onto
- 28:34an inkpat. Oh, they're getting his finger pricked. He would know because
- 28:40he's been arresting quite a few rights. He claims he was drifting in and
- 28:44out of consciousness, and then the questioning became more intense. They were demanding
- 28:48to know how he did it, to say how he did it, and
- 28:52that they knew he did it. At one point, someone allegedly punched him
- 28:56in the testicles, causing him to near vomit. They also burned him with
- 29:02ether. Really, m, how do you burn someone with either poor ether?
- 29:07Oh? Okay, let's liquid like alcohol? Yeah, I think I
- 29:11think right. Thought it was like, Oh, I guess it is like
- 29:14chloroform or whatever. They did it wow allegedly yeah. William later said he
- 29:19was interrogated around the clock for six consecutive days, being beaten and abused by
- 29:26police, and he was not allowed to eat or drink in six days.
- 29:30Yes, I don't know if I believe that. I wasn't allowed to see
- 29:33his parents for four days, and he was also refusing an opportunity to have
- 29:37a lawyer for all those six days. Now I would normally say I don't
- 29:41believe it, but given what we know about one janitor, yeah, I
- 29:45don't know. I don't know. So this gets even crazier too. Psychiatrists
- 29:51doctor Haynes and Roy Rinker gave him sodium pentathal truth serm. Okay, they
- 29:57didn't have a warrant, his parents didn't consent. But he's eighteen, so,
- 30:03oh he's not quite eighteen, that's why. And then on the truth
- 30:07serum he was interrogated for three hours. Oh, they were going to get
- 30:11this guy under the influence of the drug. The authorities claimed, William spoke
- 30:15of an alternate personality named George Merman. Okay, okay, and it was
- 30:21George Merman that committed the murders. William claimed that he recalled little of the
- 30:26drug induced interrogation, which is probably fucking true. I mean, I don't
- 30:30know. I've never had truth serum. Please. No, I've had a
- 30:33lot. I've had a lot of things, but I haven't had that.
- 30:37It might be fun I don't know. What William actually said is in dispute
- 30:41as the original transcripts disappeared. We shouldn't laugh. It's not funny. If
- 30:51it wasn't true, it'd be funny. Yeah. Right, on his fifth
- 30:52day and custody, William was given a lumbar puncture. Oh without anesthesia.
- 31:00Oh no, it's like a spinal tap. Oh, this is making me
- 31:03like moments later, I don't I don't even know why. He was driven
- 31:07to police headquarters for a polygraph test. They tried for a few minutes to
- 31:11administer the test, but he was in such obvious pain that the test had
- 31:15to be rescheduled. Why would they give him a lumber it's a spinal tap.
- 31:22I don't know. I don't know either. Well, it was nineteen
- 31:23forty six. They were doing all kinds where they were just making sure he
- 31:26was healthy, giving him a physical. Sure, we'll go with that.
- 31:32Eventually, the polygraph was administered and authorities announced that the results were inconclusive.
- 31:38On July second, nineteen forty six, he was transferred to the Cook County
- 31:41Jail, where he was placed in the infirmary to recover from his injuries.
- 31:48His various injuries. Police things seems so wrong about william claims that he was
- 31:56taking the rap for George. Psychologist explained that it's a time that William made
- 32:00up his duo personality like normal children make up imaginary friends. He did it
- 32:07to keep his diabolical deeds separate from the person he is, you know,
- 32:10like was me, it was George. It was the evil too, yeah,
- 32:17Sullia. He tried to portray himself as the average son student. He
- 32:23dated nice girls, and he went to church. But then authorities were skeptical
- 32:30of William's claims and suspected that he was laying the groundwork for an insanity But
- 32:37the confession earned widespread publicity with the press transforming Merman to murder man, George
- 32:45Merman, George to murder murder man. Oh that's clever. So handwriting analysis
- 32:52did not definitively link William's handwriting to the lipstick message really lipsticks, I remember,
- 33:00right with lipstick? I don't know if it is in my handwriting,
- 33:02right, I don't know. Please claim that the fingerprints, though matched a
- 33:07print discovered in the scene of Francis Brown's murder. It was first reported as
- 33:12a bloody smudge, remember, but now it's a last fingerprint match. Furthermore,
- 33:19a fingerprint of the small left finger was allegedly connected to William on the
- 33:23ransom note. There were nine points of comparison at the time. Williams supporters
- 33:29pointed out the FBI handbook regarding fingerprint identification and it required twelve points of comparison
- 33:37to have a positive match, but nine's close enough. Later, Chief of
- 33:43Detectives Walter Storms confirmed that the bloody smudge left on the door jam as I
- 33:46said, was Williams. Police did searches of William's home without a warrant,
- 33:53and he lived in the college dorms too, and they found other items that
- 33:58got a lot of publicity. They found a scrap book containing pictures of Nazi
- 34:02officials that belonged to a war veteran named Harry Gold. And he got it
- 34:08when he burglarized Harry Gold, which was the same night Suzanne Dagnim was killed.
- 34:16Gold lived by the dagnanms. Oh, so that puts William in the
- 34:21area. Yeah. In addition, the police found in William's possession a stolen
- 34:25copy of Psychopathia Sexual Sexualists. I'm not sure how to say it. Yeah,
- 34:32I yep, okay, And it was stolen. The press focused on
- 34:37it and started to depict this young burglar as a real life mister Hyde.
- 34:40The police also found a stolen medical kit among his possessions. They announced that
- 34:46the medical instruments couldn't be linked to the murders because there was no trace of
- 34:51biological material like blood, skin, and hair. But it was a big
- 34:53sensation that they found some medical kind. He probably just stole them. There
- 35:00was no biological material of anybody found on William well, of course, and
- 35:07on any of his clothes. The medical tools were too small to really be
- 35:12used for any real dissection. Please believe that William actually used the medical tools
- 35:17because they were tiny to alter war bonds he stole. I I don't know
- 35:24how you do that, but okay, apparently he could do that. Back
- 35:28then, a gun was found in his possession and they linked that to the
- 35:31shooting. A cult police positive revolver had been stolen in a burglary at the
- 35:38apartment of some guy named Guy on December third, nineteen forty five. Two
- 35:45nights later, bullet went through the closed eighth floor apartment where Marian Caldwell lived
- 35:51and it wounded her. William had that gun in his possession, so now
- 35:53we know he has a god and he is shot somebody. According to the
- 35:59Chicago Police Department, the bullet that injured Marian was linked through ballistics. A
- 36:05man named George I can't pronounce his last name, so I'm not going to
- 36:07He was an active soldier made a statement the day after the murder of Suzanne
- 36:12that he saw this figure walking in the direction of the Degnan's residence with a
- 36:15shopping bag. Remember I mentioned that He said he was about five feet five
- 36:21nine inches, saw way to hunt him, seventy pounds, about thirty five
- 36:23years old, and he was wearing a fedora and a dark overcoat. But
- 36:28it was too dark for George to make out the facial features. When the
- 36:32police showed him a photo of William on July eleventh, he couldn't identify him.
- 36:37Okay, so we don't really have anything linking him to the murder.
- 36:43Just days later, on July sixteenth, during a hearing, George, who
- 36:46couldn't identify him on the eleventh, pointed at William and said, quote,
- 36:51that's the man I saw, okay, and he made a positive identification.
- 36:55This sounds a little shady to me. No, no, no. The
- 37:00Chicago press stated that this solidified the case against William. I mean, now
- 37:05we have an eye, which right, and that helped him get his indictment.
- 37:10A little spoiler alert That testimony was later discredited. Oh all right,
- 37:16so my shadiness alert. Yes, it's true. It was later discredited.
- 37:21A radio newscast reported on the Chicago Tribune scoop of the confession which William heard
- 37:28in his cell. A radio newscast reported on the Chicago Tribune scoop of the
- 37:34confession which William heard in his cell. He was incredulous, stating quote,
- 37:39I didn't confess to anybody, Honestly, my god, what are they going
- 37:43to pin on me next Williams lawyers pressured him to take a plea bargain.
- 37:47That's probably a smart because at this point they're just there to the deal,
- 37:53which was a topic behind closed door meetings. As we know, stated that
- 37:59william would serve one life sentence if he confessed to the murders of Josephine Ross,
- 38:04Francis Brown, and Suzanne Tegnan. And let's not forget that he did
- 38:08shoot somebody else, but that's just a footnote except to her. Yeah,
- 38:15right. With the help of his lawyers, they began drafting a confession using
- 38:20the Chicago Tribune article as a guide quote. As it turned out, the
- 38:24Tribune article was very helpful as it provided me with a lot of details I
- 38:29didn't know. My attorneys rarely changed anything out right, but I couldn't tell
- 38:34by their faces if I had made a mistake, or they would say,
- 38:37now, Bill, is that what really happened that way? Then I would
- 38:42change my story because obviously it went against what was known in the Tribune.
- 38:46So he had to do a confession. And then this article. Yes,
- 38:52because he made a confession and it went against what the Tribune said, So
- 38:58he changed his confession to match the newspaper, this all sounds really, really
- 39:04shady. Both William and his parents signed a confession. The parties agreed to
- 39:08the date of July thirtieth for William to make his official court confession. On
- 39:13that date, the defense went to the prosecutor's office, where there were several
- 39:16reporters. They were gathered around to ask William questions, and the prosecutor himself
- 39:22made a speech. William looked bewildered and gave a noncommittal answer to report his
- 39:28questions. He later blamed the prosecutor, saying, quote, it was the
- 39:34prosecutor himself. After assembling all the officials, including attorneys and policemen, he
- 39:38began a preamble about how long everyone had waited to get a confession from me,
- 39:44but at last the truth was going to be told. He kept emphasizing
- 39:47the word truth, and I asked him if he really wanted the truth.
- 39:52He assured me that he did. Now the prosecutor made a big deal about
- 39:55hearing the truth. Now I was forced to lie to save myself. It
- 40:00made me angry, so I told him the truth and everyone got really upset.
- 40:07Yeah, because I feel like what he told them isn't what they wanted
- 40:10to hear, so the prosket withdrew the previous agreement sentence of one life term
- 40:16with a few minor charges, and changed to three terms to run consecutively and
- 40:23threaten William with the death penalty. You want to go to trial. Yeah,
- 40:28you want to go to a trial because if you do and you loose,
- 40:30I'm gonna kill you. Yeah. They threatened to charge him with a
- 40:34murder of someone named a Stealcaree, even though William was attending the Gobalt School
- 40:37for Wayward Boys in Indiana at the time. William's own attorneys were really angry
- 40:44at their client for the plea bargain. The Chicago Tribunes headline ride quote mute
- 40:52heron's faces trial killer spurns mother's fervent plea to talk. Prosecutor announced that he
- 41:00would press ahead to try William with the deaths of Susanne and Francis. William
- 41:07agreed with a new plea agreement. So William publicly confessed in the prosecutor's office,
- 41:13and he talked, answered questions. He even re enacted parts of the
- 41:16murderer. He did. Yes that he confessed too. One of the police
- 41:22officers that was really nice. To him before changed his opinion on William and
- 41:27believed he was culpable when he heard how familiar William was with victim Francis Brown's
- 41:34apartment the way he described it and re enacted the murderer. William says he
- 41:39just confessed to save his life. I don't know, I don't know.
- 41:43In his confession, William stated that he disposed of the hunting knife, which
- 41:46he had used to cut up Susanne, on an elevated subway track near the
- 41:52scene of the murder. The police never searched the track, so he could
- 41:58have it's probably still sitting there. When the reporters heard about this, they
- 42:01inquired to the trek crew if they'd found a knife. They had found a
- 42:06knife on the tracks, and they kept it in a storage room, So
- 42:12these reporters were like, fuck, yeah, we got a story here.
- 42:15The reporters determined that the knife belonged to Guy Roderick, which I told you
- 42:20he'd stolen from a guy named Guy. Oh yeah, yeah. What he
- 42:22had stolen before was the Colt police twenty two caliber gun, which was found
- 42:29in William's possession on July thirty first. He positively identified the knife as his
- 42:35William acknowledged that he threw the knife there from the train, claiming he didn't
- 42:39want his mother to see it. Okay, okay. He took full responsibility
- 42:44for the three murders. In August seventh of nineteen forty six, as I
- 42:47said, the prosecution had him reenact the crime previously if some of the victims.
- 42:53He re enacted the crime of Suzanne's in public again in front of the
- 43:00press. So that's two he re enacted, because one was Francis's murder.
- 43:04On September fourth, William's parents and the victims families attending the Chief Justice,
- 43:09Justice Ward presided and William admitted his guilt on burglary and murder charges. That
- 43:16night, William tried to hang himself and his south. He timed it to
- 43:22coincide with the shift change of the prison guards, but he was discovered before
- 43:25he died. Apparently he was just realized he's so fucked. Yeah. Regarding
- 43:30the murders, he said, quote, everyone plead I was guilty. If
- 43:34I weren't alive, I thought I could avoid being a judge guilty by the
- 43:37law and thereby gained some victory. But I wasn't successful even at that.
- 43:42Before I walked out into the courtroom. My counsel told me to just enter
- 43:45the plea of guilty and keep my mouth shot. Afterwards, I didn't even
- 43:49have a trial. Well, that's what happens because you took and took a
- 43:52deal out. I'm just staying, don't cry about not having a trial and
- 43:58when you're taking a plea deal. On September fifth, after further evidence was
- 44:01written into the record and the prosecution and defense made some closing statements for the
- 44:07sentencing, he was sentenced to three life terms. He was transferred to Statesville
- 44:12Prison from the Cook County Jail. Sheriff Michael McAuley asked William if Susanne suffered
- 44:20when she was killed, and William answered, quote, I can't tell you
- 44:22if she suffered. I didn't kill her. Tell mister Dagnan to please look
- 44:27after his other daughter because whoever killed Susanne is still out there. Stop it,
- 44:31dude. Soon after all this arrest and stuff, his parents and younger
- 44:38brother changed their last names to Hell. His parents divorced. Can you blame
- 44:45him? No? So he was housed at Stateville Prison and Julia, Illinois,
- 44:50where he learned several trades, including television and radio repair. He became
- 44:54the first prisoner in Illinois history to earn a four year college degree. On
- 44:59February six, nineteen seventy two, got a Bachelor's of Arts. He also
- 45:02aided other prisoners educational progress by helping them earn their GEDs, and he became
- 45:09what is commonly known as a jailhouse lawyer. In nineteen seventy five, he
- 45:15was transferred to a minimum security correctional center in Vienna, Illinois, and then
- 45:22he was transferred to another minimum security in nineteen ninety eight. He resided in
- 45:25the hospital work because he suffered from diabetes and I left him with some swollen
- 45:30legs and limited eyesight. He ended up being confined to a wheelchair. He
- 45:36tried really hard to get clemency, but he died in twenty twelve with the
- 45:40age of eighty three. Oh damn, he spent all that time. So
- 45:45let me tell you what's happened as far as the case goes and the things
- 45:50of his innocence. The first person that really supported his innocence besides his family
- 45:54or friends was Josephine Ross's daughter Mary Jane. She just didn't believe he did
- 46:02it. Really, there were twenty nine inconsistencies with William's confession and the facts
- 46:09of the crime. Oh, that's not good. Twenty nine. He actually
- 46:14had two polygraph exams. Both were declared inconclusive. However, in looking back
- 46:21at them now, it seems as if most people believe that he passed them.
- 46:28Really, as far as handwriting evidence goes, that's been examined even by
- 46:34the FBI, and they concluded that the two messages, one was in lipstick
- 46:37and one was at ransom note didn't match each other with the handwriting and they
- 46:42didn't match williams. Oh damn that fingerprint evidence the door jam that's with a
- 46:49smudge. Now, no, doesn't really remember the only nine out of twelve
- 46:53points. Yeah, that's not enough they've decided. And I was talking about
- 47:00the confession, like the twenty nine and consistencies. We know, we know
- 47:05that a lot of people are wrongly convicted on false confession. And as I
- 47:12said, some of the details they didn't match right. And since they beat
- 47:15up Hector the janitor, and they did that to him, he was only
- 47:20like seventeen year old boy. He may have caved and just confessed so they
- 47:24would stop doing what they were doing. I don't know, there's a lot
- 47:28of people that believe he's innocent because he was just a thief. Yeah,
- 47:32but then there's a gun he shot at that woman and it matched. So
- 47:37I don't know. But there were other suspects, yeah, and you know
- 47:42about them. Yeah. One was Richard Russell Thomas. He was a male
- 47:45nurse. He sometimes posed as a surgeon. Oh. He wasn't from Chicago,
- 47:52though he lived in Phoenix, Arizona. However, he was in Chicago
- 47:55when Suzanne was murdered, and he had been imprisoned for Arizona for molesting one
- 48:01of his daughters. So yeah, he had previously been convicted of extortion,
- 48:08so that kind of goes with the ransom note, right, and his handwriting
- 48:14was said to be quote very similar to that of the ransom note. He
- 48:19and he also even confessed to killing Susanne. He confessed, but then he
- 48:23recanted it after William was arrested. He's like, oh wait, never was
- 48:27signed. Yeah, He's like, I didn't William did, Yeah, so
- 48:31maybe someone else did it. I don't know for Susanne at least, right,
- 48:36because he just said they said that the lipstick didn't match. I don't
- 48:40know, But then what are the odds of all that happening, because I
- 48:43was thinking too when you were telling me about these victims. It seems kind
- 48:46of strange that he kills a six year old and then he kills like two
- 48:49grown women, right right, Like killers don't usually vary up their victims and
- 48:53going through like the window and kidnapping. That's taking her and kidnapping and remembering
- 49:00versus. Yeah, exactly right. The other one's like, oh, slit
- 49:04her throat and whatever. So I don't know. This is making me feel
- 49:07kind of uneasy. There might have been two killers. Yeah, it might
- 49:09have been. I don't know. I don't know, but we'll never know.
- 49:13I'll never know because William got convicted of it and he served till he
- 49:16was eighty three years old. Yeah that's a long ass time. Maybe he
- 49:21killed some of them, Yeah, maybe he did. Who knows? I
- 49:22don't. I don't either, But that's the story of William Harrons. Harrons.
- 49:29So I want to thank you guys all take the time, listen to
- 49:30us, reach out to us by email, contact at crumbs Consequence dot com,
- 49:35and let us know did he do it? Yeah? What do you
- 49:37think? I don't know. I don't know. Either. I'd like to.
- 49:42I'd like to say, oh, yeah, I'm glad the asshole's burning
- 49:44in hid but I don't know. Sure, I mean, I can't.
- 49:46I can't say that. I know, right, I don't like that.
- 49:50I don't either. I'd like to be able to say some of the horrible
- 49:52human being. Yeah, I don't know if he was, I don't know.
- 49:55Okay, all right, and you want to do the close, sure
- 50:00I can do that. You can find us on social media at Facebook and
- 50:06Instagram and at Hardcore True Crime. Sorry fucked that all up, but you
- 50:09get what I mean. And then if you would like to join our Patreon
- 50:14where you get an extra weekly episode and you can get this episode early release
- 50:21and add free, go to Patreon dot com slash TNT Crimes. You can
- 50:27also find it information about it on our website, Crimes and Consequences dot com.
- 50:31Or you can subscribe through your Apple podcast app if that's the way you
- 50:36listen, and you will have access to so many episodes. So if you
- 50:40can't get enough of us, do what you can't tell? We've done so
- 50:44many, so many, so many, so any time to go home?
- 50:47It is until our next episode. Don't kill each other by