Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / “Getting Started In Open Source Research” with Sofia Santos
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to a Bellingcat Discord server
- 0:04stage talk titled Getting Started in Open Source
- 0:07Research. This week we were joined on stage by
- 0:10OSINT analyst Sophia Santos. Sophia works at
- 0:14the Center for Information Resilience, an independent
- 0:16non -profit social enterprise dedicated to exposing
- 0:20human rights abuses and war crimes, countering
- 0:23disinformation and combating online behavior
- 0:26harmful to women and minorities. During the talk,
- 0:29she walked us through her route into open source
- 0:31research and shared some invaluable tips on how
- 0:34to focus your efforts in order to gain a job
- 0:37in the industry. You can find all the links mentioned
- 0:40in the talk in the description of this podcast.
- 0:44The talk was hosted by me, Charlotte Ma, on Wednesday
- 0:46the 5th of June in the Bellycat Discord server.
- 0:51It's worth mentioning that during the course
- 0:52of the podcast, there was some explicit language
- 0:55used. Welcome to this week's Bellingcat Stage
- 1:01Talk. This week, we're joined by Sophia Santos,
- 1:05an OSINT expert and longtime Bellingcat Discord
- 1:08member who currently works as an analyst at the
- 1:11Center for Information Resilience. Sophia is
- 1:13also the owner and author of the blog website,
- 1:17grailix .com. Grailix is a useful resource for
- 1:20those looking to practice open source research
- 1:23skill sets. Sophia posts regular exercises challenging
- 1:27strangers to have a go at the puzzles. You can
- 1:30then find the answers in helpful guide videos.
- 1:33Sophia also writes and records video tutorials
- 1:35for basic research skills, teaching you how to
- 1:38do geolocation, for example, to even knowing
- 1:40how to embrace your own mistakes. Today, Sophia
- 1:43is here to share some advice for people who are
- 1:45new to the industry and want to get involved.
- 1:47We'll be discussing routes into research and
- 1:50what traps to avoid. And yes, you'll get a chance
- 1:53to ask your questions too. As we talk, please
- 1:56put your questions in the chat and I'll ask them
- 1:58as we move into the Q &A section. Sofia, it's
- 2:02your turn. Please take the mic and I'll pop back
- 2:05in in a little bit to ask you some questions.
- 2:08Thank you. Okay, so hello everyone. My name is
- 2:11Sofia. I am Portuguese. and I work for the Center
- 2:14for Information Resilience as DOC and team lead
- 2:17on one of their many, many projects. I investigate
- 2:21human rights violations, security incidents,
- 2:24armed conflict and terrorist activity, among
- 2:26many other exciting things. I focus on a very
- 2:30specific area of the globe, which shall remain
- 2:33unidentified for security reasons. Sorry about
- 2:35that. In addition to working on my own investigations,
- 2:39I also lead the extremely talented OSINT team
- 2:42within that project. Right. So how did I get
- 2:45you to OSINT in the first place? I hope you're
- 2:47ready for this because I'm not sure if I am.
- 2:50So the story begins in the late 90s, early 2000s,
- 2:54the early stages of the internet. Like any cool
- 2:57teenager at the time, I was spending a lot of
- 3:00my free time online. The internet was this amazing
- 3:03new thing. But the internet from 20 odd years
- 3:06ago was very different from what we have now.
- 3:09Security was almost non -existent, which was
- 3:11very good or very bad, depending on what you're
- 3:14trying to do. Things were less connected and
- 3:16information was hard to find and even harder
- 3:19to piece together. So everything felt scattered
- 3:22and unorganized if that makes sense. It was,
- 3:25however, a very exciting time to be a teenager.
- 3:27I talked to a lot of people, I met a few, I learned
- 3:31loads of new things and I was having a blast.
- 3:35Unfortunately, this was also the time that I
- 3:37met a person who later became my stalker. So
- 3:40I'm not sure what I did to trigger his obsession
- 3:43or if I did anything at all, but he remained
- 3:46a continuous presence in my life for about five
- 3:48years. He knew where I lived, he knew my friends,
- 3:52he knew my family, and he held a gun to my head.
- 3:55And I was too young to know how to handle it,
- 3:57so I tried telling my friends, but no one really
- 3:59believed me because he was a very charming person.
- 4:02They thought he was, you know, I was perhaps
- 4:04overreacting or misunderstanding his good intentions,
- 4:08but his intentions were not good and I knew that.
- 4:12So I did what I had to do, you know, I cut everyone
- 4:14off and I stayed indoors for almost two years.
- 4:17You know, I just, that's what I had to do to
- 4:19survive. And because I was a minor, sometimes
- 4:22I was still forced to leave the house to do things
- 4:24with my family, you know, like everyone else.
- 4:27But in general, for those two first years, the
- 4:29internet became the only safe way for me to interact
- 4:32with the outside world. But it wasn't completely
- 4:35safe because my stalker also knew how to find
- 4:38me online. So over time, I figured that the best
- 4:41way to keep myself safe was to first be very
- 4:44good at hiding my online presence and second,
- 4:47to track down his movements. Because if I knew
- 4:50where he was going to be or what he was planning
- 4:52to do before he found out what I was doing, I
- 4:55could avoid him and stay safe. So the hunter
- 4:58becomes the hunted. And that's how I got myself
- 5:01into OSINT without realizing. I became very good
- 5:05at finding information, tracking movements, analyzing
- 5:07patterns, and making informed decisions based
- 5:10on that data. At that time, I did not know it
- 5:13was OSINT, of course. I was just trying to stay
- 5:15alive. Eventually, those two first years went
- 5:18by. I started getting confident enough. I left
- 5:21the house, I enrolled in uni, and as soon as
- 5:23I completed my degree, I was out. I left my country.
- 5:27I moved a lot, lived in many countries, maintained
- 5:29a very low online presence, you know, just in
- 5:32case. I had many jobs. I did a lot of very cool
- 5:35things, but nothing to do with computers, nothing
- 5:38to do with security, nothing to do with open
- 5:40source investigation. I was kind of a hermit,
- 5:42honestly. I went from mostly living online those
- 5:45first two years to barely being online the moment
- 5:48I left my country. In fact, I lived in a few
- 5:51areas of the globe with none or very limited
- 5:54internet access for a while, but that was fine
- 5:56because I was safe. And that was my life for
- 5:59a very long time. But the story obviously doesn't
- 6:03end here, does it? So we're going to fast forward
- 6:07a lot to three years ago, more or less. We're
- 6:10in the middle of the pandemic, there's lockdowns
- 6:13and there's boredom. I was so bored and somehow
- 6:18I found myself stuck at home again. But this
- 6:20time it wasn't just me, it was all of us, so
- 6:22it's fine. The world outside was a bit scary
- 6:25again for a completely different reason this
- 6:28time. And so during my boredom, I once again
- 6:31had to resort to go online to experience the
- 6:33world. We all did it in this time. But what I
- 6:36was yet to find out is that my experiences with
- 6:39my stalker 20 years earlier had conditioned how
- 6:42I interacted with the internet because during
- 6:45those First years online, I almost obsessively
- 6:49explored gathered info and analyzed everything
- 6:52because the internet was a tool that allowed
- 6:55me to feel in control of my life, but I had to
- 6:58have full control of that tool. So during lockdown,
- 7:01I got really, really into ethical hacking because
- 7:04it was something I had already done back in the
- 7:07day. Although I'm not even going to pretend that
- 7:10what I was doing back in the early 2000s was
- 7:12ethical. It was most definitely not ethical.
- 7:15I was just a bit naughty then. But that's fine.
- 7:17I did what I had to do. However, whilst looking
- 7:21into ethical hacking this time, I came across
- 7:24the concept of OSINT and everything felt very
- 7:27familiar. I had done this before and I loved
- 7:30it because like I said, it gave me a sense of
- 7:32control. So I started exploring more about this
- 7:35new found concept and got absolutely hooked on
- 7:39geolocation specifically. I was fascinated and
- 7:42terrified by how much information you could get
- 7:46from a single image, which is why my camera is
- 7:48off. I'm sorry about that. I'm not giving you
- 7:50that data. And I enjoyed solving geolocation
- 7:54and hosting challenges online and then reading
- 7:56people's walkthroughs. I also felt there were
- 7:59not that many around. So I decided to create
- 8:02a blog and start writing my own walkthroughs
- 8:05so other people could also learn. I had written
- 8:07about eight of them when one day I was on Twitter
- 8:11and I saw Nina, the then vice president for the
- 8:14Center for Information Resilience, asking for
- 8:16volunteers to help geolocate and verify data
- 8:19showing the Russian military buildup by the Ukrainian
- 8:21border. This was the 23rd February 2022, the
- 8:26day before the full -scale invasion. The tweet
- 8:28said they were looking for people with Ukrainian
- 8:31and Russian language skills and women and I thought
- 8:34to myself I cannot speak any language but I am
- 8:37a woman so fuck it I'm doing this so I sent an
- 8:40email to CR with a short message offering my
- 8:43services a link to my LinkedIn to prove I was
- 8:46a real person and a woman that's the only thing
- 8:48I get a head going for me at a time and a link
- 8:51to my blog to show I was at least capable of
- 8:53geolocating stuff I was full of undeserving confidence.
- 8:57That's just how I live life anyway. So somehow
- 8:59they replied, they got me in and I started working
- 9:02through the already massive database of the Eyes
- 9:05on Russia project. I did this for about two days.
- 9:08On my third day, I was offered a full -time position
- 9:11as an OSINT analyst working on a different project.
- 9:14So I'm still on that same project now, but over
- 9:17the past two and a half years, I rose up to be
- 9:19the OSINT team lead. So for the first year, however,
- 9:22I worked on the two projects at the same time,
- 9:25my full -time paid job and then my free time
- 9:28on the Eyes on Russia project as a volunteer.
- 9:31So I was doing eight hours a day on my normal
- 9:33one, plus a minimum of three hours each evening
- 9:36and four weekends on the Eyes on Russia project
- 9:38from the moment I woke up to the moment I went
- 9:40to bed. It was intense. It was very, very intense.
- 9:44So I went from casually geolocating random pictures
- 9:48online to verify data from a warzone to then
- 9:51get hired as a no -scene analyst in a matter
- 9:53of three days. And to give you an even better
- 9:56sense of perspective on the timeline of these
- 9:59events, I had done my first geolocation ever
- 10:02two months before I got a job offer. And I feel
- 10:06like I was possibly on the right place at the
- 10:09right time with the right set of skills. I'm
- 10:11not even going to pretend I was some sort of
- 10:13prodigy. It was most definitely a combination
- 10:15of luck, lots of confidence and a lot of dedication.
- 10:20So during my first year as an official hosting
- 10:22analyst, I kept writing geolocation walkthroughs
- 10:25and tutorials on my blog. Honestly, I have no
- 10:28idea how I even found time for that. I probably
- 10:30wasn't sleeping much, but I was having lots of
- 10:32fun, so it's fine. I started getting people messaging
- 10:34me, asking how to get into OSINT, how do you
- 10:37start, how do you learn, how to do all these
- 10:39cool things. And I kept answering them because
- 10:41I just answer everyone, which is very bad. But
- 10:43anyway, I kept telling people to just go for
- 10:46it, explore the internet, find images, analyze
- 10:49them, notice the details, connect dots. Everything
- 10:52made sense in my head because that's how I always
- 10:55interacted with the internet. I observed everything.
- 10:58I analyzed everything. I had to, wasn't it? I
- 11:01didn't even know how to do it in any other way.
- 11:04But I felt people weren't really understanding
- 11:06what I was trying to convey and just do it wasn't
- 11:10enough. And I wasn't sure how to explain it better
- 11:13because it was just so obvious to me. So now
- 11:16I look back, I understand that this was due to
- 11:19how I learned how to interact with the internet
- 11:21back in the early 2000s when I had a stalker.
- 11:24Most people didn't go through that. So the internet
- 11:27was a completely different space for them. They
- 11:29interacted with it in a more casual, relaxed
- 11:32way, which if I'm honest, I kind of envy. The
- 11:35internet was a battleground for me. It was not
- 11:37a place to relax. So, like I said, I kept answering
- 11:41people, working on both projects, a lot, and
- 11:44creating content. And by the end of that first
- 11:47year, I was completely and utterly burned down.
- 11:51I was physically and mentally done. I was a complete
- 11:55wreck. But by then, the Eyes on Russia project
- 11:58was well established, had funding, wasn't relying
- 12:00on volunteers. So I decided I had to step back.
- 12:03I need a break. I couldn't do it anymore. And
- 12:06that's how I found myself with a lot of free
- 12:08time that I hadn't even realized existed. And
- 12:11because I still kept getting messages from people
- 12:14wanting to learn about OSINT, I thought to myself,
- 12:16you know what? Let me show you what I mean. Because
- 12:19just to explore the internet advice was clearly
- 12:22not enough. I now had the free time to do it,
- 12:25so I did. You know, fuck sleep, right? Who needs
- 12:26to sleep anyway? So in January, 2023, I created
- 12:31my first five exercises and released them on
- 12:34my website in short succession. They all have
- 12:37the exact same format. They start with a very
- 12:40small briefing, providing some basic context.
- 12:43Then there's some initial data to analyze. This
- 12:45can be a photo, a video, a link, or just text.
- 12:49Then you get a small list of tasks to complete
- 12:51at that rate based on difficulty level. People
- 12:54can solve the tasks however they want it. None
- 12:57of them are impossible, but they do vary a lot
- 12:59in difficulty. I mark them as either easy, medium
- 13:02or hard and separate them by beginner or expert
- 13:05level. So you can choose to start with tasks
- 13:08that I deem easy for beginners, for example,
- 13:10and work your way up until you're comfortable
- 13:12enough to start tackling the ones that are harder,
- 13:15or you could just jump straight to the more challenging
- 13:17ones aimed at the experts. You call whatever
- 13:20floats your boat, really. The exercises are all
- 13:23centered on the three main skills I believe are
- 13:26fundamental for someone to become a good hosting
- 13:28analyst. How to find data, how to verify data
- 13:31and how to analyze data. Everything on my website
- 13:35is free. I don't even have ads. I hate ads. None
- 13:37of the exercises requires people to use any paid
- 13:40tools or spend any money on anything. It's just
- 13:43using your brain and open source data. That's
- 13:46it. So within the first 24 hours of publishing
- 13:49and exercise, I released a full video walkthrough
- 13:51on my YouTube channel showing how I solved all
- 13:54tasks. I feel like when you're a beginner watching
- 13:57someone do it in front of you, step by step is
- 14:00extremely helpful. So I show everything, no cuts,
- 14:03apart from when I swear too much and I think
- 14:05to myself, well, let me just edit this one out.
- 14:07But the most important thing for me in my videos
- 14:10is just I explain why I'm doing things. It's
- 14:13not just a click here, then there, and voila,
- 14:15you get the answer. I narrate out loud what is
- 14:18going on in my head, which is a very dangerous
- 14:20thing sometimes, but it's also very helpful.
- 14:22So if people tried and failed to solve a task,
- 14:25they can watch me do it and then try to replicate.
- 14:28Afterwards, when they're faced with a similar
- 14:30situation, they'll know what to do. I also urge
- 14:33people to write walkthroughs explaining how they
- 14:37solve the challenges. I then link them on the
- 14:40corresponding exercise page so others can read
- 14:42and learn alternative methods. Because there's
- 14:44never just one way to do things, I'm not like
- 14:47the ultimate OSINT person there's many people
- 14:49to learn from. And because people still kept
- 14:52messaging me, I created a frequently asked questions
- 14:55page on my website with some guidelines on how
- 14:57to get into OSINT as a career. In the past years,
- 15:01I have advised many people on what to do to break
- 15:03into the field. Some of them I'm very, very proud
- 15:06to report already work as OSINT analysts, so
- 15:08well done for them. So what is my general advice?
- 15:12First thing you need to do is to figure out exactly
- 15:15what you would like to do, because OSINT is an
- 15:17umbrella term to refer to intelligence obtained
- 15:20through open source. It can be used on a number
- 15:23of fields such as human rights, like I do, cybersecurity,
- 15:27private investigation, journalism, etc. And the
- 15:31skills required can be very different from each
- 15:33other. You'll be working with open source data,
- 15:35but using different methods for different goals.
- 15:38Once you have decided what type of OSINT you're
- 15:41drawn to, I suggest finding organizations or
- 15:44people who work in that field and see what they
- 15:46are doing. Many will have public profiles and
- 15:49you can see what sort of things they discuss,
- 15:51they share and they gauge with. This will enable
- 15:54you to understand what skills they possess and
- 15:57what skills you should aim to develop. Then you
- 15:59can start working on those skills. I think my
- 16:02exercises are a good resource once you get to
- 16:04this stage, especially if you're someone who
- 16:06needs a bit of structure in their learning. I
- 16:09still think that the best way to learn Austin
- 16:11skills is just to observe and analyze everything,
- 16:14but having some structured tasks might be quite
- 16:17useful as well. And that's why I created them.
- 16:19So explore the exercises. I would advise if you
- 16:22are a beginner to start with the easy ones. Don't
- 16:25try to be a hero and go for the hard tasks as
- 16:28you may end up frustrated. It's best to build
- 16:30up the skills and the confidence alongside them.
- 16:33You don't need to prove anything to anyone. This
- 16:35is not a race. Once you get to a point where
- 16:38you're capable of solving the tasks without any
- 16:40help, whether they're easy or hard ones, write
- 16:43about it. Create a blog, a website, a Twitter
- 16:46thread, whatever floats your boat. Learning to
- 16:48transfer your thoughts into words is extremely
- 16:51helpful in this field of work. A great OSINT
- 16:53analyst has to be able to write great reports
- 16:56and you don't need to just write exercise walkthroughs.
- 16:59You can write about anything you want. It's a
- 17:01matter of showcasing what you're capable of.
- 17:04That's what you'll want to do. You want to advertise
- 17:07your skills. However, there is quite a difference
- 17:10between writing a walkthrough and writing an
- 17:13OSINT report and I want to highlight this. On
- 17:16a walkthrough, the goal is to explain your process,
- 17:18how you solve the challenge, how you unveil identities,
- 17:21how are you geolocating something. The aim is
- 17:24to explain your thought process step by step
- 17:26from beginning to end. On the other hand, in
- 17:29an OSINT report, the focus is on the intelligence
- 17:32behind it. What does it all mean? Yes, you got
- 17:36the answers, you unveil identities, you geolocated
- 17:38everything and so what? How does that information
- 17:41help you, the client or the public? What conclusions
- 17:44can you draw from it and what measures can potentially
- 17:47be taken based on this intelligence? So this
- 17:50second type of report is obviously a bit hard
- 17:53to master. It requires the analyst to take a
- 17:55step back and see the bigger picture after spending
- 17:58possibly a considerable amount of time analyzing
- 18:01the small details of it all. So for beginners,
- 18:05Wanting to start doing research, I would suggest
- 18:08starting with just explaining simple things.
- 18:11Write about how you geolocated something, how
- 18:13you verified an image that turned out to be old,
- 18:15misleading, or plain old propaganda. Then you
- 18:18start adding more complexity to it all. That
- 18:21is also something I aim to do with my exercises
- 18:23when preparing them. especially the ones aimed
- 18:27at beginners, the first question will always
- 18:29be the easiest one. Afterwards, I request something
- 18:32a bit more challenging to force people to keep
- 18:34exploring instead of just stopping there. On
- 18:37the other hand, the hard tasks, especially the
- 18:39ones aimed at experts, will throw you immediately
- 18:42in the deep end. Often you just have one task
- 18:44and you need to be able to figure out where and
- 18:46how to start, where to move from there and how
- 18:49to keep going until you reach your goal. That
- 18:51is not an easy task for beginners, not that's
- 18:54impossible. It's just a lot harder because the
- 18:57OSINT mindset is still developing, but you'll
- 18:59get there. It's fine. Don't rush it. So once
- 19:01you're comfortable writing about your OSINT investigations,
- 19:04you can start sharing them online in whatever
- 19:07platform of your choice. The goal is to be seen.
- 19:09Remember, people like me will find people like
- 19:12you. If you're writing about something that I'm
- 19:14monitoring, I will find you. That sounds very
- 19:17creepy. Not to say that you should just sit and
- 19:20wait, definitely not. But if you keep on producing
- 19:23good content, people will notice. And that's
- 19:26especially true if that content is very niche
- 19:28and no one else is investigating it. You shouldn't
- 19:31pick something based on what you think will look
- 19:33good or how much intention you'll get from it.
- 19:36Go for something that's close to your heart,
- 19:38something that drives you, the sort of topic
- 19:40that you just cannot stay away from. Because
- 19:44it's very clear to me when I'm reading or reviewing
- 19:46OSINT reports if the investigation was something
- 19:49the analyst deeply cared about, or it was something
- 19:52they were just writing because they were assigned
- 19:54to that topic, you can feel someone's passion
- 19:57shining through their writing. As a team lead,
- 20:00I always try to match analysts with their favorite
- 20:02topics because it's a huge difference in the
- 20:04quality of their work. You cannot feign passion.
- 20:08Once you find what drives you and start investigating
- 20:11and writing about it, start looking for collaborations
- 20:14with other like -minded people working on similar
- 20:17things. I know that the Bellingcat Discord server
- 20:20is great for that. I actually often advise people
- 20:22to come here, share their ideas, their work,
- 20:25their progress, and see if they can find others
- 20:27to collaborate with. Because when you're starting,
- 20:30your goal is to build a good OSINT portfolio,
- 20:33especially if you have no background in a field
- 20:36related to OSINT. At this point, your CV will
- 20:39be relevant. Your new website, your blog, your
- 20:42social media account, they will be your new CV,
- 20:45your skills portfolio. It will show prospective
- 20:48employees what you can do, how dedicated you
- 20:51are and your writing skills. And this will all
- 20:55be public. It's your evidence. So it's your job
- 20:57to make it as brilliant as possible. And yes,
- 21:00and I get asked this many, many times, you can
- 21:03absolutely get a job in Austin with zero professional
- 21:05experience in this field. I know many truly amazing
- 21:09analysts who seem to have come from nowhere,
- 21:11a bit like me. No experience, no background knowledge,
- 21:14just pure passion and dedication. They always,
- 21:17always stand out. They're honestly the best professionals
- 21:20I work with. Nothing matches their drive to learn
- 21:23and improve. So find your passion and go for
- 21:26it. I hope this was helpful. Thank you for listening.
- 21:29Up to you, Charlie. Thank you so much, Xavier,
- 21:33for such a clear and... friendly explanation
- 21:37of how to get into this kind of industry and
- 21:41for explaining the different types of things
- 21:43you can do with these skill sets as well. Stephanie
- 21:45in the chat said, thank you for sharing a personal
- 21:48situation, a terribly good way to learn about
- 21:51OBSEC and how to spot traces on the internet.
- 21:55I also shared, sorry, go ahead. Sorry. No, I
- 21:59was going to say that You know, it's one of these
- 22:02things that I thought for a while whether or
- 22:04not I wanted to reveal that information, but
- 22:06I thought I cannot explain how I got into OSINT
- 22:10without explaining why I had to go into OSINT,
- 22:13if it makes sense. So that's it. It's out now.
- 22:17Yeah. So many people in the chat are saying,
- 22:19Mina says, this was amazing. Thank you. Shucky
- 22:22Ducky, which I love the name, says, so helpful
- 22:24and encouraging. Thank you. Biggie Cheese says,
- 22:28this was definitely the clearest and most friendly
- 22:30advice I've gotten for getting into OSINT, so
- 22:32thank you. While you were talking, I also put
- 22:34some links in the chat, which I'll share with
- 22:38the podcast recording as well, which is the link
- 22:41to your organization Center for Information Resilience,
- 22:46the link to Bellingcat's coverage of the Eye
- 22:50of Russia. project that you worked on, and also
- 22:55a link to a recent Bellingcat report where we
- 22:58listed seven deadly sins of bad open source research.
- 23:02Because as you mentioned, when you're writing
- 23:03up those initial conclusions, when you're first
- 23:06writing up those reports, it's really, really
- 23:09important to make sure that you're checking your
- 23:11own work and making sure that you're staying
- 23:14accurate to kind of what you found and not kind
- 23:16of making assumptions. Because that tends to
- 23:19be something that we see a lot of people who
- 23:23are getting into OSINT do, because they're excited
- 23:27by the information they've found. But sometimes
- 23:30you can kind of jump to conclusions without realizing
- 23:34that you've kind of made that jump. So I just
- 23:37wanted to flag that as well. I wanted to ask
- 23:44while people are putting their questions in the
- 23:46chat, I wanted to ask why you feel people should
- 23:50train in open source techniques in comparison
- 23:52to training in coding language or perhaps even
- 23:58just traditional journalism. Why did you feel
- 24:02like open source research was the way forward
- 24:05for you and why do you think it's such an attractive
- 24:09kind of set of skills for employers and also
- 24:12for people in general. I think OSIN kind of employs
- 24:17these basic skills of challenging what is being
- 24:20said to you on a very fundamental level. And
- 24:24in a world full of misinformation, disinformation,
- 24:30propaganda, those are very valuable skills in
- 24:32all. I mean, you can be just a student writing
- 24:35your thesis, but it's useful to check that. to
- 24:38check that the information you're getting is
- 24:40from a reputable source, for example. So I found
- 24:43that it's just a very fundamental skill to have
- 24:50in anything. I think that, obviously, learning
- 24:53coding, for example, is useful. I would say that
- 24:57most authentic analysts I work with do not know
- 25:00coding. I feel like it's interesting that It's
- 25:06sometimes useful because I know some of it, just
- 25:09a bit, but I know enough to read, for example,
- 25:14the HTML code of website or read the code and
- 25:17figure out what this is supposed to be doing.
- 25:19But I think on my line of work, it's mostly to
- 25:23analyze things like the HTML. For example, I
- 25:27have an exercise on that specifically. on, you'd
- 25:31have like three links to articles and these are
- 25:35articles that were published in countries that
- 25:37do not use the Gregorian calendar. So it's a
- 25:40bit of a challenge. If you're writing an Austin
- 25:42report and you want to say on this date, this
- 25:45was published, but you do not know the date,
- 25:47then it's one of those things. You can just go
- 25:50to the HTML. I'm kind of spoiling it a bit now.
- 25:53You can just go and it'll give you some information.
- 25:56So You know, it's, it's useful to have some basic
- 25:59knowledge. I don't think it's very, um, you know,
- 26:02it's not fundamental, but it's, you know, it's
- 26:04useful anyway. Hope that makes sense. Definitely.
- 26:08Definitely makes sense. Yeah. I always surprised
- 26:10actually how much, uh, coding comes up in conversations,
- 26:14but how, how many researchers don't need it.
- 26:16And I just posted a link in the chat to, uh,
- 26:19one of our more recent videos where we were,
- 26:23uh, Agnes from our team. who's on our tech team,
- 26:26who definitely knows how to code, was talking
- 26:29you through how to use Jupyter Notebooks and
- 26:31Google collab as well, which is a way of using
- 26:34open source research tools without knowing coding
- 26:37language, which can be useful for people as well.
- 26:41We have so many questions coming, floating in
- 26:44now. Lumos asks, thank you. Can you tell us more
- 26:47about how you felt in your first role in the
- 26:50Eyes on Russia project? How did you feel when
- 26:53you first got involved with that? Oh, okay. Okay.
- 26:58So that was overwhelming. That was insane overwhelming
- 27:01because I went from being, you know, just geolocating
- 27:04cool pictures I found online to now, my job was
- 27:09mostly to geolocate because we had a massive
- 27:11database by then. And, you know, there's so much
- 27:15content coming that had to be verified, geolocated,
- 27:19you know, added to the map eventually. So it
- 27:22was very overwhelming. It was definitely a trial
- 27:26by fire, if that makes sense. But yeah, there's
- 27:31some good aspects of it because I definitely
- 27:34learned a lot of it. And there were some bad
- 27:37aspects of it because I was forced to experience
- 27:40things that I was most definitely not ready to
- 27:43be experienced if that makes sense. And I'll
- 27:45tell you a story. So, you know, the two databases,
- 27:49so I have my normal job and the Eyes on Russia
- 27:51project, and both of them have a database. And
- 27:56the database is where we collect all the information
- 27:59that we want to archive. So everything that's
- 28:01photos, videos, you know, any audio goes there,
- 28:04gets archived. So it's not lost. If it gets deleted
- 28:06from the online, you know, social media, then
- 28:09it's just archived. And so all entries have a
- 28:14rating. on violence level and this rating varies
- 28:18from one to five being one everything's fine
- 28:20there's nothing horrendous on this picture two
- 28:24you might see some threats verbal threats or
- 28:26something like that maybe some damage on three
- 28:29you're going to see maybe some beating perhaps
- 28:32blood bruises some sort of aggression on four
- 28:36you're going to see a body and on five that body
- 28:38is going to be in a very bad condition so I thought,
- 28:42you know what, I'm going to be very sensible
- 28:44on my normal job. And I am just going to look
- 28:48at the ones and the twos. I'm not taking care
- 28:50of anything else until I'm comfortable enough
- 28:52to move up and then more, you know, horrible
- 28:55content. And that was great. I was, I was so
- 28:58good. I was so proud of myself. I was like, Oh
- 29:00yeah, I can, I'm going to be so good at this.
- 29:02And then I go to the Eyes on Russia project and
- 29:05this was during the weekend. And I was going
- 29:09through the database again. I was just clicking,
- 29:11geolocating, clicking, geolocating. And there
- 29:14was something that felt wrong. I'm not sure if
- 29:17wrong is the word because suddenly there were
- 29:20dozens of links entered on the database and there
- 29:23was nothing else. They didn't have a rating.
- 29:25They didn't have description, didn't have category.
- 29:28And it felt like someone just had to dump all
- 29:32these things because something very big had happened
- 29:35and there was just like the need to quickly archive
- 29:37this. So, you know, I completely understand it
- 29:40had to be done. And I was alone. I was completely
- 29:44alone on that day on that database, because it
- 29:46was probably like a Sunday and I was just working
- 29:48because why wouldn't I? And I just start clicking
- 29:51and I start geolocating and I start clicking
- 29:53and I start geolocating. And at the time, I didn't
- 29:56realize how much that was affecting me because
- 29:59I'm not going to describe what I was watching,
- 30:01obviously, but it was something that happened
- 30:03that had a lot of civilian casualties. It was
- 30:10something that made international news everywhere.
- 30:12It was a very bad incident and it was covered
- 30:15everywhere. I was the first person, well, technically
- 30:19the second after whoever put those links there.
- 30:22go through all of it and I was looking frame
- 30:24by frame, video by video, picture by picture
- 30:27and it was very, very bad. And when I finally
- 30:31stopped, it was time to go to bed and I was like,
- 30:35I am done. I realized how much that had affected
- 30:38me and I had a completely breakdown, completely.
- 30:42It was horrible. It was such an enormous thing
- 30:46to experience. And I feel like that was something
- 30:50that I was not prepared to deal with. And now
- 30:53obviously there's been a lot of policies put
- 30:55into place and also I know when to stop. But
- 31:01I think there's something that when I think of
- 31:04the Eyes on Russia project at the beginning,
- 31:06that is what I think about that trauma that I
- 31:10had to deal with. Well, I tell it, not like I
- 31:13had to, I just did it anyway. So there you go.
- 31:16Lot of information. I was just like sharing everything
- 31:18now. Next question. Yeah, I mean, we talk about
- 31:22it a lot in these stage talks, actually, keeping
- 31:25yourself mentally healthy and mentally sane when
- 31:30viewing these things. And especially if you're
- 31:31thinking about going into a niche that involves
- 31:34human rights or conflict, you need to kind of
- 31:39be aware that this kind of material might come
- 31:43across your plate and how to deal with it. I'll
- 31:47share a few resources in the chat as well. Meryl's
- 31:51already done it. My colleague Meryl's just shared
- 31:54a guide for mental health hygiene in the chat.
- 31:58It's really, really important that you kind of
- 32:03keep that. in the forefront of your mind. And
- 32:05there's some really useful tools online as well
- 32:07that can help kind of obscure some of the image
- 32:11for you while you're looking at different parts
- 32:13of the image, for example, or mute the sound,
- 32:16which can also be highly triggering. But we've
- 32:19got a lot of other stage talks on our sound card
- 32:22that you can listen back to, specifically on
- 32:24mental health while doing open source research.
- 32:28We have so many questions. So if you don't mind,
- 32:30I'll keep going. Bishti has asked, and I hope
- 32:35I've pronounced that right, Bishti has asked,
- 32:38how do you pick images for your geolocation challenges?
- 32:43How do you select them? Okay. So there's many
- 32:47ways I do that depending. So the first thing
- 32:50is that when I come up with exercise ideas, I
- 32:53base based on specific skills I want to talk
- 32:56about. So my goal is always to have an educational
- 32:59side of it. So then I think of something and
- 33:03for example, it could be, I want to do a geolocation
- 33:07that just requires satellite image. You cannot
- 33:09use Google street view. You cannot use anything
- 33:12like that. That's it. Like the first one, my
- 33:15first exercise is like that. So in that case,
- 33:18honestly, I would just go to a random place on
- 33:21the map and I was like, this is a good one. And
- 33:24then I, you know, try to find the name of whatever
- 33:26next village nearby is. And then I start using
- 33:30keywords about that village could be the name
- 33:33of the village. And the first one would be the
- 33:35name of the village. It could be, I'll try to
- 33:38find geotagged content like on YouTube. And then
- 33:42I'll like do a screenshot of someone or a location
- 33:46somewhere. Sometimes if I want to be a bit more
- 33:50challenging, I have one where it's the It was
- 33:53a photo of a military aircraft from the U .S.
- 33:59And so I went to the U .S. State Department.
- 34:02I think I'm not sure if it was that one or not.
- 34:04And I just tried to find something that just
- 34:06said undisclosed location. So I would just put
- 34:08that in brackets and disclose location, not brackets,
- 34:11sorry, quotation marks. And I just see, let's
- 34:14see what kind of photos are undisclosed. Well,
- 34:16until I come to them, then it will be disclosed.
- 34:19and so on. So it really varies. Sometimes my
- 34:22focus is on the area. So I have a very specific
- 34:25area. I try to have as many areas of the globe
- 34:29as possible. So I don't want it to be too centered
- 34:31on Europe, too centered on the US, too centered
- 34:33on Russia. I want everything because all countries
- 34:37have their issues. And it's interesting to just
- 34:40look at them, especially when you have no idea
- 34:42what's going on them. And sometimes that happens
- 34:44to me. I'll be like, let me just come up with
- 34:47a random country and see what's happening there.
- 34:50And then I'll go and check pictures from the
- 34:52news and so on. So it's a bit chaotic. It's a
- 34:56bit random because I feel like adding that randomness
- 35:00creates an extra challenge that I enjoy because
- 35:03I also need to solve them in the first place,
- 35:05isn't it? Yeah. I think it's great that you're
- 35:08thinking about trying to cover different areas
- 35:10of the world as well, particularly as when you're
- 35:13first starting into your location, you might
- 35:15not be aware of the limitations to some regions
- 35:20of the world in terms of satellite mapping and
- 35:23image access. I also want to shout out that your
- 35:26colleague, Bender and Strick, also does a really
- 35:28great YouTube series as well called Bender Brown,
- 35:32which also showcases a lot of useful tips and
- 35:36tricks for open source researchers, so also worth
- 35:39checking that out. as well as Sophia's fantastic
- 35:43exercises. CR has asked, excited to try these
- 35:47challenges. When it comes to a portfolio, is
- 35:50there an ideal format that seems to be most popular,
- 35:54blog posts versus a plain site? I get it depends
- 35:57on your audience too, but what would you advise?
- 36:01How would you advise creating your portfolio?
- 36:04What would you make it look like? That's a tough
- 36:06question because I am not involved in any hiring
- 36:09so I'm not sure what other people are looking
- 36:12at. I feel like I tend to prefer blog entries.
- 36:18It could be on a website. You can just have a
- 36:21blog on your own or sometimes people put on LinkedIn
- 36:25as a post. I'm not sure how you call that. I
- 36:30tend to not prefer, I don't enjoy too much Twitter
- 36:34threads. I find it very hard to read them, if
- 36:37it makes sense. And they're also very focused
- 36:39on the images. And I think when you're writing,
- 36:42you want to be explaining things. So limiting
- 36:45the character is not ideal. So I think blog posts,
- 36:49I would say they're the best thing because you
- 36:52can make them as big or as small. You can make
- 36:54a series if you want to. So they give you, you
- 36:57know, a lot of allowances. You can do whatever
- 36:59you want, you know, once you have it, it's yours.
- 37:02So I think those are quite good. At least that's
- 37:04what I've been using and that's what I see other
- 37:06people using. And I think they, they're quite,
- 37:09you know, they're very nice. Thank you. Moving
- 37:11swiftly on. Bishti has also asked another question
- 37:14about limiting yourself while writing reports,
- 37:17because often people tend to find themselves
- 37:21writing too much. How long or short should intelligence
- 37:26reports be? And then CR has added on top of that,
- 37:29is there a good place to ask for feedback when
- 37:32you do write such a report? Where did you go
- 37:36in the early days for feedback on some of your
- 37:39early reports? Okay, so yeah, how long? Okay,
- 37:42I feel like that is a problem that all us internalists
- 37:45have because we just know so much when investigating
- 37:48something, you know everything, you know all
- 37:49the details and you want to explain all the tiny
- 37:52details. And most of the times, the reader does
- 37:55not care about the details. They just want the
- 37:58information. They wanted the digested information.
- 38:02So I would say in terms of number of pages, if
- 38:07that makes sense, I would say two. Two is how,
- 38:10well, to be fair, I tend to aim at two and end
- 38:13up with four anyway. But that's pictures, so
- 38:16that's fine. I can do that. But yeah, just try
- 38:19to keep it as clear as possible. What you usually
- 38:21do is that you'll explain things and then you
- 38:24link to the sources. So you don't have to, you
- 38:26know, describe everything. You can just say,
- 38:28oh, this is what, you know, there's a photo that
- 38:31showed this and then you just link to that photo
- 38:33without having to, you know, put everything on
- 38:36it. If people want more information, they can
- 38:38click the link and then, you know, get, you know,
- 38:41the information of where you got that information,
- 38:43that source and so on. So I would say keep it
- 38:47short -ish and that's mostly because you want
- 38:50to make sure that the people will keep on reading
- 38:52until halfway through because otherwise they'll
- 38:55just... Most people that will read your reports
- 38:59are probably going to be people that do not have
- 39:02much time to read too much information. So they
- 39:06want intelligence, that's it. They don't want
- 39:07how you got it. They don't want to learn about
- 39:11all the steps and that tiny detail and that video
- 39:13and then you found this person and then you did
- 39:15this thing. They don't care about any of that.
- 39:17They want intelligence. If you're writing a blog
- 39:20post and you want to showcase your skills, then
- 39:23definitely explain how you got there because
- 39:25when someone like a prospective employee is looking
- 39:28at it, they want to see that you're capable of
- 39:31making those steps and do this analysis. and
- 39:34find these identities, do you locate these things?
- 39:37So these are skills that you'll be looking for.
- 39:39But in terms of the reader, that's why I explain
- 39:42the difference between an oath and report and
- 39:45a walkthrough. They're quite different things.
- 39:47I'm sure there was a second and a third question,
- 39:49but I didn't write it down. Yeah, the second
- 39:52question actually relates to the question I was
- 39:54going to ask now. A lot of people are asking
- 39:57where they can find examples of good practice
- 40:00reports and where they can get feedback on their
- 40:04reports. Have you got any tips on that? Okay.
- 40:10So good practice reports. Well, there are many
- 40:13reports being written online. Bellinghat has
- 40:16reports or articles. I'm not sure how you describe
- 40:19it. You know, they are there. CR has, there's
- 40:22a few projects that publish reports, the High
- 40:25Zone Russia project, the Afghan witness project,
- 40:28the Myanmar witness project. So all of them have
- 40:30reports and then you can read and see more or
- 40:34less what style they are. And I guess you can
- 40:36guide yourself through with that. In terms of
- 40:39feedback, that is harder because obviously when
- 40:41you're working, you'll have someone to give feedback.
- 40:44I'm the person that gives feedback to other people.
- 40:46when you're not working, then that's obviously
- 40:50makes it harder. I usually, I would suggest getting
- 40:54other hosting people to read your articles because
- 40:57I feel like I have that problem at work as well.
- 41:00Cause I review everyone's reports, but who's
- 41:02reviewing mine, right? Like, you know, who watches
- 41:04the watchman. So I tend to ask other analysts
- 41:08who's like, can you look at my own reports? Which
- 41:10I hate. I hate when people commenting on it.
- 41:12I'm like, no, it was perfect. What are you doing?
- 41:14But no, sometimes it's not perfect and I need
- 41:16to change it. So it's always good to have an
- 41:19extra pair of eyes and it doesn't even have to
- 41:21be an awesome person. You can just give it to
- 41:23your mom or dad and be like, if you were to read
- 41:25this, do you understand? Because Again, there's
- 41:29different types of OSINT, and if your article
- 41:32is for public, it could be anyone. Anyone could
- 41:36just pick it up and read it and it needs to be
- 41:38understandable. People will be reading it and
- 41:40you're like, what do you mean by this? I've never
- 41:42heard this concept before because it could be
- 41:44something that everyone knows in OSINT, but out
- 41:47of OSINT, no one knows about it. So it's very
- 41:49useful to have extra pair of eyes from all walks
- 41:53of life, not just OSINT. That's it. That would
- 41:57make sense. Definitely, and I would just like
- 42:00to plug that in the Bellingcat Discord server,
- 42:03we have channels like publication preparation,
- 42:08cries for help, show your work, where you can
- 42:12kind of ask for that kind of last checks or help
- 42:17with those kinds of things as well. I'm not encouraging
- 42:20you to all post all of your 60 page works. in
- 42:25the channels, but asking people for help there
- 42:28is definitely encouraged. So please do reach
- 42:31out. So Tansa has asked a very common question
- 42:35that Bellingcat often face, actually, which is
- 42:37without cyber security expertise, how do you
- 42:40protect yourself while researching potentially
- 42:43dangerous topics or organizations? Any advice
- 42:48on that? So, yes, I do understand that. Like
- 42:52in my case, I feel like I kind of learned that
- 42:54the hard way before cybersecurity was even a
- 42:57topic I knew about. So it's hard for me to understand.
- 43:00I feel like there's a few ways to protect yourself,
- 43:03obviously. I feel like people as well exaggerate
- 43:08how much protection they need. Sometimes, the
- 43:11keyword being sometimes, because I see people
- 43:14like you need a virtual machine with whatever
- 43:19super exciting operating system and some crazy
- 43:24tools. And if you're just going to check Twitter,
- 43:27you don't need that. That's a bit too much, isn't
- 43:29it? If then you're going to, for example, investigate...
- 43:34extremist terrorist, you know, extremist organization
- 43:36propaganda, and you need to get into this very
- 43:39specific channels, which I shall not name, then
- 43:43definitely, you definitely need some sort of
- 43:45protection because you just never know what's
- 43:47going to happen. So there's a few things. that
- 43:49if you are going to go into places that will
- 43:53possibly get you on a list, you should definitely
- 43:55do. So things like you have a burner phone and
- 43:58you have a burner SIM card. And I have that just
- 44:01like an old phone that I don't use anymore. Cleaned
- 44:03everything. Everything just reset. Buy a SIM
- 44:06card from like for 20 P from eBay. It's not associated
- 44:10with me in any way. And that is just used to
- 44:13register. on websites that require. So like,
- 44:17for example, Facebook, they need your phone number.
- 44:19That's my phone number now. They need a new email.
- 44:21I'll create a new email. So I'll have a browser
- 44:24that's my working browser and nothing on that
- 44:27browser can connect to me in any way whatsoever.
- 44:31And, you know, that gets cleaned all the time.
- 44:34If I click, you know, close the browser, everything
- 44:36gets purged and everything has to be logged in
- 44:39again. So there's a few basic things. I don't
- 44:43think people need to go overboard again if they're
- 44:45doing investigation that just requires social
- 44:48media, geolocations, analyzing pictures. But
- 44:52if you do then get into more deeper rabbit holes,
- 44:57then definitely you need to read into how to
- 45:00stay safe. But you don't need a cybersecurity
- 45:02course. just some basic knowledge. And also once
- 45:06you start getting into OSINT and you can see
- 45:08how much information you can get from very specific
- 45:11things like, you know, in photo, then you start
- 45:14getting very careful about what you post online.
- 45:17And also I would suggest every so often just
- 45:20do OSINT on you, see how much you can find about
- 45:23yourself, anything that you left behind, a blog
- 45:26post, some social media profile that you forgot
- 45:29existed, go back, purge everything, delete everything,
- 45:33and that's it. It doesn't require too much, I
- 45:36think. Have you ever worked on a dark or deep
- 45:41web OSINT? Somebody in the chat is asking a question
- 45:44about that. No, I don't do that. There are a
- 45:50few members of my team that do that, but that
- 45:52is not my department, so I do not do that now.
- 45:56Great. Thank you so much for that really important
- 46:00advice. And yeah, just making sure that you're
- 46:02using kind of research profiles when you're searching
- 46:05anybody on social media as well is really important.
- 46:08Keeping it away from your personal profiles as
- 46:11much as possible. Stephanie asked a really interesting
- 46:14question. How can you tell the difference between
- 46:17passion and work and thinking about your sleep
- 46:19and about trauma and also the large number of
- 46:22people who are looking for a job in open source
- 46:24research? because they love investigating and
- 46:26analyzing this or that field. And of the recruiters
- 46:31who ask, what are your salary expectations as
- 46:33a junior? So how do you tell the difference between
- 46:36passion and work? Okay. I think for me, it's
- 46:41very clear at the end of the day is like 6 p
- 46:43.m. I'm done for the day. Do I walk away from
- 46:47it or do I just open another tab and I'm looking
- 46:49at something else? So that is the difference
- 46:51for me. If I just keep on going, it doesn't matter
- 46:54if it's weekend. It doesn't matter if it's, you
- 46:57know, 6 a .m. and I'm like, you know what I should
- 46:59do? I should look at that location. I should
- 47:02look at that picture. I need to solve that. I
- 47:05feel like that is passion. If you're just doing
- 47:07it because you have to, then that's a job. And,
- 47:11you know, it's fine. Sometimes you can have one
- 47:12without the other. But, you know, when you have
- 47:15them combined, that's just heaven. I love it.
- 47:20As we're running out of time, we've only got
- 47:2210 minutes left. So please put your final questions
- 47:24in the chat now. Shuky Ducky actually asked a
- 47:28question that I wanted to ask as well, which
- 47:30is based on your experience and observations.
- 47:34Sophia, what areas or topics do you think are
- 47:35currently undeserved or in high demand for open
- 47:38source researchers? Oh, God, that is a very hard
- 47:42question. I don't know. That is my answer. I
- 47:47just do not know because I feel like Whenever
- 47:49I go and I want to look at some random country
- 47:54for an idea for an exercise, I just come across
- 47:59so much that I had no idea what was going on
- 48:02there. And that's always a surprise to me. I
- 48:04was just like, oh, well, I had never come across
- 48:06this. I didn't know there was an issue going
- 48:09on in this country or this region of the world.
- 48:12And I feel like Maybe the best way is to find
- 48:16something, like I said, that's close to your
- 48:18heart. Maybe it could be, you know, where you
- 48:20live or where you're from, could be different
- 48:23things. Something that, you know, when you go
- 48:26to Twitter or when you go to Facebook or whatever,
- 48:29the things that you just keep on checking, you
- 48:31keep on Googling, you keep on wanting to know
- 48:33more about it. Because again, like I said, when
- 48:36I was speaking, it's best to do something that
- 48:39drives you than to try to find something that
- 48:43you feel will get attention or is not getting
- 48:46enough attention, just find something that you
- 48:49want to do. Yeah, passion is definitely important
- 48:53because you're going to be staring at the same
- 48:55piece of information or the same set of information
- 48:57for a while. But a lot of people fall into things
- 49:04that are familiar to them as well. So covering
- 49:07countries, for example, where they speak the
- 49:09language, where they're familiar with the landscape,
- 49:12because it's often easier for geolocation purposes,
- 49:16at least. Zal Dastix earlier asked, if you're
- 49:21doing that kind of thing, if you're kind of falling
- 49:23into familiar territory for yourself, how do
- 49:26you avoid getting your biases in the way. How
- 49:32do you investigate something and make sure that
- 49:35you're not harming anybody with biases when doing
- 49:38open source reporting? It's very hard because
- 49:42I do investigate the same area of the globe every
- 49:45single day, but I also do as part of a team.
- 49:49So, you know, we all keep each other in check,
- 49:53if that makes sense. And sometimes I'll write
- 49:54something and be like, no, no, that's wrong.
- 49:56Kind of like, damn it. So I think it's always
- 50:00best if you can collaborate with other people
- 50:02because they do provide a different perspective
- 50:07than yours. And I feel like that is also so valuable.
- 50:11And most of my, sorry, most of my reports, I
- 50:15do them alone. I write them alone. But, you know,
- 50:17it's just so important to have that someone else
- 50:20to just come in and look at it. So, like I said,
- 50:24the Bellingcat server is a good one. So you can
- 50:27go and it's divided in like topics, isn't it?
- 50:29And you can go and see what other people are
- 50:31talking about because maybe, yeah, you are stuck
- 50:33in our biases. And also, I would suggest, like
- 50:38I said, I have a different browser for work.
- 50:41So that browser. It gets purged every day, like
- 50:45all cookies go, everything. So it kind of resets.
- 50:49So anything that I was looking for or looking
- 50:51around the previous day is no longer impacting,
- 50:54hopefully, my results. And I think that's important
- 50:57to just get the clear slate, you know, because
- 51:00we get a lot, you know, search engines and platforms
- 51:06try to track what you like and try to give you
- 51:09more of that. So my suggestion, just don't give
- 51:12them that. Just purge everything. Just like give
- 51:14me the clean slate and let's see what you got.
- 51:17Exactly. Algorithms try to box you in and this
- 51:20can sometimes leave you blind. I wanted to ask,
- 51:24is there any tools that you found more useful
- 51:26when you were a beginner that you now perhaps
- 51:30no longer use as an expert or any that have become
- 51:33a staple as part of your research that you think
- 51:37are worth shouting out? So the short answer is
- 51:42no. I feel like tools come and go and I tend
- 51:45to not get attached to them too much because
- 51:47you just never know. Next time I'm going to search
- 51:49for it, they're just gone. It's however, something
- 51:52I see a lot in the online hosting community.
- 51:54They just need to find and collect hosting tools
- 51:57for everything. There's list of this and top
- 52:00five and top 10 tools for whatever. And I'm sure
- 52:03some of them are very useful, but I tend to not
- 52:05just bother with any of them. I like to stick
- 52:08to the basics and try to use search engines to
- 52:10find information. You have Google Yandex Bing
- 52:13Maps alongside Google Earth Pro for satellite
- 52:17imagery, because I spend a lot of my time looking
- 52:19at photos and videos and noticing the tiny details
- 52:22of it all. So it's mostly what I do. I also feel
- 52:25like the most important thing about any tools
- 52:29is to master them, to learn in depth what they
- 52:32can or cannot do because That's it. You learn
- 52:37how to do things that most people probably don't
- 52:40know about. I'll give a quick example. I did
- 52:44a geolocation that I wrote about a while ago.
- 52:46I think it was last year. It was at a time where
- 52:50a Wagner convoy was heading to Moscow. It was
- 52:53a big thing and everyone was just in a big brouhaha.
- 52:57There was a video of excavators digging a road.
- 53:01I apparently was to stop this convoy from reaching
- 53:05Moscow and I was tasked to find this geolocation
- 53:08thing. What I used at the time was that I went
- 53:12to Google Maps and I knew more or less the area
- 53:15that they were heading in a specific direction.
- 53:19They were heading towards Moscow. I knew where
- 53:21they were before, so I kind of had a more general
- 53:24idea and I was looking for big roads because
- 53:26there were tanks and stuff, they needed space.
- 53:28And I end up using the traffic option on Google
- 53:33Maps, which is not used that often. So people
- 53:36will use it if they need to navigate, for example,
- 53:38and they want to see how much traffic is in a
- 53:40specific area. But because when I saw that video,
- 53:44I saw that when the excavators were digging the
- 53:47road, there was a queue of cars forming behind
- 53:49them. So I thought, if I put this live thing
- 53:54that shows the traffic of this area, I would
- 53:59say that the red bits is where the traffic is
- 54:02forming. That's where this likely to play. So
- 54:05I went straight to that area, check Google street
- 54:08view because apparently they did have it, which
- 54:10was great. And I just relocated. So that's what
- 54:13I mean. Like, you know, everyone knows how to
- 54:15use Google maps, but not everyone will know how
- 54:17to use this very specific. option of Google Maps.
- 54:21And so I would suggest people to just play with
- 54:24everything, click everything. I'm always clicking
- 54:25everything. And I keep up with any changes to
- 54:29this. So I follow things about Google News and
- 54:32Maps. So whenever anything is introduced or removed,
- 54:36I'm aware of it and I can just make sure that
- 54:39I can either use it or stop using and find an
- 54:43alternative. So it's less about the tools and
- 54:45more about your expertise in using them. That's
- 54:49really, really good advice. Just on that topic
- 54:53then, as we're wrapping up, what kind of barriers
- 54:56should people expect to face when trying to get
- 55:00into this industry and trying to get into open
- 55:02source research? And how might you advise they
- 55:06overcome them? I think that there's a few barriers
- 55:10in terms of skills, obviously. So if you're investigating
- 55:14something, like I said, I applied for the Eyes
- 55:17on Russia project and they wanted someone who
- 55:19spoke the language. That's the barrier for me
- 55:22specifically. Language is definitely a very high
- 55:27demand skill. But I think the biggest barrier
- 55:31that I see nowadays is that there's so many organizations
- 55:35hiring based on CV and that is not how you get
- 55:37the talent. The talent is not coming from the
- 55:40CV. At most, you'll get someone that can write
- 55:42CVs very well. The talent are the people that
- 55:45dedicate and do things. And I feel like that
- 55:50is an overall thing. But I think the problem
- 55:53is if you have a small organization, then it's
- 55:57likely that the people that will be doing the
- 55:58hiring will be people that know about OSINT.
- 56:01If you have a big organization, chances are the
- 56:04people hiring are the people that are like HR
- 56:06or something like that or management. And those
- 56:09will be looking at CV because they don't know
- 56:11what skills they need. And I feel like that is
- 56:13a problem in any organization, in any industries,
- 56:17not just this one. But I think in OSINT specifically,
- 56:21the best, absolutely the best analyst I ever
- 56:24worked with. were people that didn't have the
- 56:28ideal CV. They didn't have anything to do with
- 56:31OSINT. And I feel like if they were looking at
- 56:34their CV at the beginning, they would not have
- 56:36a job. No one even looked at my CV. I never sent
- 56:38my CV to anyone. They were just like, hey, yeah,
- 56:40you can join in. And that's it. So I was happy
- 56:44for that. I'm very happy for that. But I feel
- 56:46like we need to let more people in. based on
- 56:51the skills rather than what they have done so
- 56:54far. Absolutely. Absolutely. I cannot agree more.
- 57:00And that's part of the reason why I was so desperate
- 57:03to chat to you today. And thank you so, so much
- 57:07for today's talk. It's been fascinating. We've
- 57:10learned a few things. We've learned not to depend
- 57:14on tools, practice, practice, practice, identify
- 57:18your niche, identify your passion, and that the
- 57:21industry needs to recognize all the hard people
- 57:24working out there on these kinds of things. So
- 57:26thank you so much, Sophia, for a fantastic talk.
- 57:30Is there any other resources that you want to
- 57:33kind of highlight quickly other than your own
- 57:35fantastic website? Yes. Yes, I want that. Yes,
- 57:39I'm very excited about that. Okay. So one of
- 57:41the things that I've told already is that I ask
- 57:44people to, when they solve my exercises and when
- 57:48they write walkthroughs to please give me the
- 57:51links. And so then I put them on my page. So,
- 57:55you know, like on my page, each exercise has
- 57:58a page and on them, I will list everyone that
- 58:02has written a walkthrough. And I feel like that
- 58:06is a gold mine of knowledge. I love reading those
- 58:10walkthroughs because very often they come from
- 58:12people that have no experience in OSINT and somehow
- 58:16they're thinking, they're using methods, they
- 58:18use strategy that would never occur to me. And
- 58:22it's brilliant. And I'll get people from all
- 58:24walks of life, people from all sides of this
- 58:27planet, all corners. And they just solve the
- 58:31exact same thing that I've done and many others
- 58:33have done, but they use the technique that no
- 58:36one else has used. And I think this is just brilliant.
- 58:39I absolutely invite people to read other people's
- 58:42work. And some of them are honestly, they're
- 58:46just their raw talent. And I keep telling them
- 58:49and I am always so sad when sometimes they message
- 58:53me and they're like here's my walkthrough please
- 58:55don't publish I'm not comfortable I'm not confident
- 58:57enough and I read it and it's like the most brilliant
- 58:59piece of work and I was like why wouldn't I publish
- 59:03this is brilliant please keep writing please
- 59:05if you ever change your mind just let me know
- 59:06I want to publish this you should be very proud
- 59:09of it and that's it that's a good resource. Fantastic
- 59:13so Safiya wants to know if you've tried her exercises
- 59:17and please do get in touch. All right. Thank
- 59:20you, everybody, for listening. I'm going to end
- 59:22the recording here. But thank you so much for
- 59:24your time today. And in two weeks time, we'll
- 59:27be back with another stage talk. My colleague
- 59:30Meryl will be presenting it. Thank you so much,
- 59:32everybody. Thank you. Bye bye. Thank you for
- 59:38listening to the stage talk. If you'd like to
- 59:41catch a stage talk live where you can ask the
- 59:43guest questions, join the Bellingcat Discord
- 59:46server by visiting www .discord .gg slash Bellingcat.
- 59:53The music you've heard is titled Dawn by Newer
- 59:56Self and is courtesy of Artlist.