Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / J.J. McCullough: The "privatization" conversation in Canadian health care
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. This is Van Color. Welcome back to This is Van Color.
- 0:24Universal public healthcare is part of our Canadian identity. However, as Canadians
- 0:29face emergency room shutdowns, long wait times, and healthcare staffing shortages some of
- 0:34the worst among OECD countries, more Canadians, including the government of BC,
- 0:39are actually turning to private healthcare, including outside of our own country. And
- 0:44yet we can't say the p word privatization, even when other countries have shown
- 0:50that universal, publicly funded healthcare with private competition is possible. Returning to the
- 0:56show to discuss he's a YouTuber based here in Vancouver with nearly a million and
- 1:00subscribers. He is JJ McCullough, JJ. Hello, thank you for returning
- 1:04to the show. Thanks for having me back. Always a pleasure. So
- 1:07I feel like we're in a bit of a paradox here in Canada. More
- 1:10and more Canadians are turning to privatized healthcare out of country, out of province.
- 1:14The government of BC is sending cancer patients to Bellingham effectively to know have
- 1:19private healthcare in terms of their cancer treatments. Bill Mooreneau has said that this
- 1:26spending for healthcare is unsustainable. So we are spending more on healthcare. We
- 1:30are kind of leaning towards privatization. The healthcare system is failing, and yet
- 1:34it's kind of taboo to say maybe we should privatize some healthcare. Well,
- 1:38I mean, I think it's worth sort of getting into the precise definitions of
- 1:42these terms, because I do think one of our current problems is that we
- 1:45throw a round these terms a little too lucy goosey, and they contribute to
- 1:48a climate of public ignorance, which then makes it very difficult to do the
- 1:51things that need to be done. So privatization is when you take something that
- 1:55is being done by the government and you instead you turn it into a private
- 2:00operation. You know, you take a business that is like Petro Canada was
- 2:02privatized. Petro Canada used to be run by the government is now a private
- 2:06company. Right, Nobody is really talking about doing that as far as Canadian
- 2:09healthcare goes. We're not talking about like turning our hospitals into for profit businesses.
- 2:14What we're talking about is and we're also not talking about bringing in private
- 2:17health insurance to cover things that are currently covered by the public plan. What
- 2:22we're doing is we're simply talking about expanding the public plan to cover services provided
- 2:28at existing privately run facilities. Right, so you can go to these privately
- 2:31run facilities which have sort of been existing in the shadows all of these years.
- 2:36But now the governments, you know, on Ontario there's sort of the
- 2:38most advanced on this. The government is simply saying that if you go to
- 2:42a private clinic, the government will pick up the tab via your public health
- 2:46insurance card or program or whatever. And that is very different than privatization.
- 2:52It's merely talking about private delivery covered by public insurance. But again it's like
- 2:59these distinctions I feel are frustratingly not known, and the public is not literate
- 3:04enough in this kind of language of private delivery versus public coverage, and that
- 3:07just contributes to a climate in which anything that has the word private associated with
- 3:12it in any way becomes demonized as American style and all this. Yeah,
- 3:15and I think that's a great point, because well, we're almost in this
- 3:17binary right. There's like, in our mind, there's the Canadian style of
- 3:21healthcare and there's American style of healthcare. However, we're ignorance of the fact
- 3:25that there are many European countries, certainly other countries around the world that have
- 3:30different models of delivering healthcare. Sweden is a great example where they do have
- 3:34public universal healthcare, but they also have private competition and in their public healthcare,
- 3:38if you're not able to get a test within certain days or certain treatment
- 3:43within a certain time period as a Swedish resident, you can go to private
- 3:46clinics and effectively, as you said, the government gets built for it.
- 3:52You're not paying for it out of pocket. And there's even rules around healthcare
- 3:54workers perhaps having to work a certain amount in the public sector before they can
- 4:00start billing in the quote unquote private sector. Why are we so stuck in
- 4:04this binary of American system versus Canadian system? And why aren't we opening our
- 4:10horizons or broadening our horizons to other forms of healthcare Because our whole conception,
- 4:15our whole national identity is just based drowne shallow anti Americanism. Right. So
- 4:19it's like, and it's worth noting that our whole idema pretty much, I
- 4:23would say. So it's very difficult to find something that Canadians are proud of,
- 4:26or that Canadians even identify as an identifiably or important Canadian thing that doesn't
- 4:30have some dimension of anti Americanism to it, you know. But it's worth
- 4:33noting that because of this pervasive cult of anti Americanism as so centered to our
- 4:38identity, we don't even like honestly understand how the American system works. Like,
- 4:41I agree, the American system is definitely at one extreme end of the
- 4:44spectrum based on OCD nations. But at the same time, like every American
- 4:47is not whipping out their credit card every time they have to get you know,
- 4:50some stitches or their brain removed or whatever. Right, it's like Americans
- 4:55have insurance. Americans happen to have private insurance. We generally have publican insurance.
- 5:00But even then, it's also worth noting that most Canadians also have some
- 5:02form of private insurance too, right when it comes to covering all of the
- 5:05things that are not covered by the medical plan, And we also have private
- 5:09insurance to cover the dentist. You know, I just went to the dentist
- 5:11yesterday, and you know, I have to pay within my Blue Cross,
- 5:14which I pay into. Right, So it's like we have the capacity to
- 5:17sort of like understand these sort of nuances because in many ways we're already lived
- 5:21them. Because there's already large segments of the insurance and healthcare system in this
- 5:26country that's already privately run. But because we're so obsessed with anti Americanism,
- 5:30and because you know, we've we've allowed, like they do polls on this
- 5:33and Canadians are more priorate of the healthcare system than the flag or the constitution
- 5:38or democracy or anything. And that's not healthy. But you know, it's
- 5:41certainly not healthy when healthcare is failing. And I think we also have to
- 5:44recognize that healthcare is one of those areas whereas technology progresses, things actually get
- 5:49more expensive. Usually as technology progresses, things get cheaper, but healthcare is
- 5:54one of those fields that just with machinery and technology and even manpower, things
- 5:58do get more EXPANSI I feel like the Canadian identity is kind of still a
- 6:03work in progress. You know, we've certainly shed certain things, adopted new
- 6:06things. You know, when it comes to multiculturalism, why isn't this something
- 6:11that is malleable, Like why are we so attached to this even as the
- 6:15healthcare system itself is failing, even as you know, provincial governments are using
- 6:19and relying on privatized healthcare. I think it's because that the American system is
- 6:24still seen as being worse. And I think that frankly, like Americans themselves
- 6:29and sort of the deficiencies of the American healthcare system is a much larger part
- 6:31of the American political conversation than it used to be. So like, if
- 6:34you're a Canadian who consumes a lot of American news, as most Canadians do,
- 6:39you are constantly bombarded with stories about how horrible and terrible the American healthcare
- 6:43system is, you know, despite Obamacare, despite in many ways the system
- 6:46having made a lot of progress, and you know, it's over, like
- 6:48ninety percent of Americans now have sufficient healthcare coverage by their own admission, right,
- 6:53We're still constantly told that the system in America is bad, it's terrible,
- 6:56it's hellish, blah blah blah blah blah. And again, like nobody's
- 6:59talking about adopting that system. But as long as that binary, which is
- 7:01again like the quintessential binary that defines Canadian identity, as long as that is
- 7:05perceived to exist, then I think Canadians, you know, middle class Canadians,
- 7:10will shrug their shoulders and say, like, our system might have its
- 7:12problems, but at least it's better than America. So as a result,
- 7:15I often wonder if the only way that this will change is if the American
- 7:17system changes, Right like, if some days some like AOC becomes president and
- 7:23she introduces like, you know, Medicare for all or whatever, and then
- 7:26that kind of takes the issue off the table, and then you know,
- 7:28we're kind of more at an equal playing field, and so we can look
- 7:30more honestly at our own system really quickly. Is there a political space for
- 7:34a party to actually introduce some of these reforms or will any party that reduce
- 7:40that introduces or even suggests some of these reforms, will they just be stereotyped
- 7:45as you know, you're introducing American style broken healthcarees? Yes, they will
- 7:47be. Okay, So there's no space to talk about it. There's no
- 7:50space to do it publicly. I think that there is space to do it
- 7:54secretly, which is that right? I mean our NDP government is doing it
- 7:57secretly and they're getting you know, fine by I ought to offer doing sure
- 8:01our transfer payments are getting reduced because we're doing too much of this, But
- 8:03we're doing it in the shadows, and so it doesn't really seem to be
- 8:05sticking to the NDP government of this province the way it is to Premier Forward,
- 8:09who's done it publicly. Yeah. So are we going to get canceled
- 8:13for having this conversation? Yeah? Probably, JJ A pleasure. I hope
- 8:16to see you a lot more of you as the season continues, So thanks
- 8:20so much for your time tonight. Always a pleasure. Folks. Find him
- 8:22on YouTube to learn about countries, culture and Canada. A fan favorite of
- 8:26yours. I know he is JJ McCullough and as I said, since he
- 8:30is such a fan favorite, expect to see more of JJ more often.
- 8:33Right here on This is Van Color. Now up next. Are we allowed
- 8:37to call our political leaders hot? Probably not? But what if we sing
- 8:41about it? Angela Valiant is here and has always. She brought her Uka
- 8:45Lele and I promise you won't want to miss in memory