Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Direct Listings to Go Public
Transcript
- Lucas: So a question we keep hearing from founders and investors alike: if you don't need to raise new capital, why go through the traditional IPO song and dance? That's the direct listing argument in a nutshell, and it's a conversation that's gotten a lot louder in the last couple of years. Luna: And it's not just a theoretical debate anymore. We've seen real success stories — Spotify, Slack, Palantir. Each one took a slightly different path, but the core idea is the same. Lucas: Exactly. The traditional IPO — you hire a syndicate of banks, they underwrite the offering, they set a price, they allocate shares to institutional clients, and on day one the stock pops. The company raises capital, but it also leaves a lot of money on the table, and the banks take a hefty cut — typically around three to seven percent of the proceeds. Luna: Right. And that pop is essentially a signal that the banks underpriced the deal. The company could have gotten a higher price, but the banks want to make sure their clients get a good first-day return. Lucas: Spotify in 2018 said, no thanks. They did a direct listing on the New York Stock Exchange. No underwriters, no lockup, no price-setting by banks. Instead, existing shareholders — employees, early investors — simply sold their shares directly to the public at whatever price the market determined. The opening price was based on buy and sell orders, not a banker's estimate. Luna: And it worked. Spotify saved millions in underwriting fees. The stock opened at about $132 and traded up from there. No pop in the traditional sense, but no dilution either. The company itself didn't issue new shares — it was purely a secondary sale. Lucas: That's the key distinction. A direct listing is a liquidity event for existing shareholders, not a capital-raising event for the company. So it only makes sense if the company doesn't need the cash. Spotify was cash-flow positive. Slack was well-funded. Palantir had plenty of venture money. Luna: But that limits the universe. Most companies that go public need the capital to grow. So why is the direct listing gaining traction? Lucas: Because the model has evolved. In 2020, the SEC approved a new type of direct listing that allows companies to raise primary capital at the same time. That's what Palantir used in 2020. They sold about $560 million in new shares alongside the direct listing. So now you can have your cake and eat it too — lower costs, no underpricing, and fresh capital. Luna: And there's another benefit: no lockup period. In a traditional IPO, insiders are typically locked up for 180 days. In a direct listing, they can sell immediately. That changes the dynamics for early employees who want liquidity sooner. Lucas: It also changes the risk profile for the company. With no lockup, there's no artificial supply constraint. The market finds its equilibrium faster. Some argue that reduces volatility, though the data is mixed. But it definitely changes the post ipo playbook. Luna: So where are we now? Are we seeing more companies choose direct listings? Lucas: It's still a small slice of the overall IPO market. In 2025, about 12 percent of US tech IPOs were direct listings, up from maybe 5 percent a few years earlier. But the trend is meaningful. And with the SEC signaling more flexibility, I expect it to grow. Luna: And it's not just tech. We've seen companies in other sectors explore it. The model is spreading. Lucas: Look, the traditional IPO isn't going away. For companies that need marketing, analyst coverage, and a big capital injection, the banks still add value. But for well-known, well-capitalized companies, the direct listing is a compelling alternative. And it forces the banks to compete on fees and services. Luna: Speaking of which, this is a good place to mention something about how we operate this show. We deliberately don't run ads. No sponsors, no commercial breaks. And that's a choice we make because we want these conversations to be as direct and useful as possible. Lucas: Exactly. If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, and you want to support that choice, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to keep this ad-free. No pressure, just if it matters to you. Luna: Yeah, it's a simple model. And it keeps us focused on the substance. So back to direct listings — what's the biggest misconception you hear? Lucas: That direct listings are riskier. Actually, the risk profile is different. In an IPO, the banks set a price and guarantee a sale. If the market drops, the banks eat the loss. In a direct listing, there's no backstop. If there isn't enough demand, the stock could open lower. But in practice, companies that choose direct listings are usually well-known and have strong demand. Spotify, Slack — they didn't have trouble finding buyers. Luna: And the data shows that direct listing stocks don't underperform IPOs over the long term. In fact, some studies suggest they outperform, possibly because the pricing is more efficient. Lucas: Right. And there's the cost angle. A traditional IPO for a $1 billion deal might cost $30 million to $50 million in fees. A direct listing might cost a few million — legal, accounting, exchange fees. That's a huge saving. Luna: So who's the ideal candidate for a direct listing today? Lucas: A company that's well-known, has a strong brand, doesn't need a ton of new capital — or at least can raise it alongside the listing — and wants to give its employees and early investors immediate liquidity. Think of a company like Airbnb, if it had gone public a few years later when it was profitable. Or Stripe, if it ever decides to go public. Luna: And the market environment matters. Look at the ARK Innovation ETF — it's up six percent in the last five days. That's a sign of risk appetite. When markets are hot, direct listings tend to do well because there's plenty of demand. But in a downturn, the lack of a price backstop can be scary. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why we haven't seen a flood of direct listings in the last two years. The 2022 bear market scared a lot of companies. But now, with the market recovering — the S&P 500 is up, tech stocks are strong — we might see more companies test the waters. Luna: What about the role of the exchange? NYSE and Nasdaq both support direct listings now. Does that matter? Lucas: It matters a lot. Competition between exchanges has driven innovation. The NYSE pioneered the direct listing with Spotify. Nasdaq followed with its own version. Now both offer it. That gives companies more options, and it puts pressure on fees. Luna: So what's the bottom line for a founder listening to this? Should they consider a direct listing? Lucas: If you're a well-known company with a strong balance sheet and you don't need the marketing support of a traditional underwriter, absolutely. But if you're a smaller company that needs analyst coverage and a stable debut, the traditional IPO still has a role. The beauty is, now you have a choice. Luna: And that choice is only going to get more common. As more companies succeed with direct listings, the stigma fades. Lucas: I think we'll look back at the 2020s as the decade when direct listings went mainstream. The IPO market is being disrupted by its own innovation. And that's a healthy thing. Luna: Agreed. Next time, we'll dig into SPACs — the other big alternative. But for now, thanks for listening. Lucas: And if you found this useful, you know where to find us. Fexingo Business. We'll be back tomorrow.