Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep9: GRD009 - 72(t) Payments, Yes or No?
Transcript
- 0:00INTRO: Hi, I'm Ed Slott and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you the saver so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that each week.
- 0:16Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular retirement strategy
- 0:21or topic with the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip a.
- 0:30Winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want to argue.
- 0:33And both of us will have to argue in favor of our respective positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner.
- 0:43You a more informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of
- 0:47each side of the debate to your own personal situation, to decide
- 0:50what's best for you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the great retirement debate.
- 1:02Ed Slott: Welcome back everyone to the great retirement debate.
- 1:05I'm Ed Slott, along with Jeff Levine.
- 1:08How you doing today, Jeff?
- 1:09Jeff Levine: I'm good.
- 1:09Ed.
- 1:10I, I warmed up today.
- 1:11I feel like I'm in peak form.
- 1:12I spent the last few hours arguing with my three year old.
- 1:16So you're in trouble today.
- 1:17There's no, no better.
- 1:20No better protagonist or antagonist than a three year old.
- 1:23Ed Slott: Did was the problem.
- 1:25He said, roth IRA.
- 1:26And you said, absolutely not.
- 1:28Jeff Levine: That's right.
- 1:28Well, you know, ed, my children I've taught them well, they knew how to roll
- 1:32over before they knew how to roll over.
- 1:34That's uh, that's very, we start young in this house.
- 1:38And, and I've got one for us today.
- 1:39And, you know, we talk a lot about those who've saved and who've kind
- 1:42of reached a peak and pinnacle of retirement, and what should they do.
- 1:45Let's talk about someone who maybe, uh, is, has fallen on a little bit
- 1:49harder times or has retired early any one of these where they may need
- 1:53to access money in their retirement account prior to 59 and a half.
- 1:57Let's say the traditional age at which distributions from retirement accounts
- 2:01are no longer subject to a penalty.
- 2:03And one of the ways in which you can do so is so-called 72 T distributions
- 2:08named after the tax code under which effectively they're authorized.
- 2:12So 72 T sometimes you'll hear these referred to as SEPs or so SEPs.
- 2:17Short for a series of substantially equal periodic payments, but at the
- 2:21end of the day effectively, what it is, it's a manufactured way to access
- 2:25money in a retirement account via payments over time that, uh, will
- 2:31just allow you to avoid the penalty.
- 2:33No, no, you don't get outta tax.
- 2:35You still have to pay the tax.
- 2:36Everybody has to pay tax, right.
- 2:38But no 10% penalty.
- 2:39So, and we gotta flip a coin.
- 2:41Uh, you could flip today.
- 2:42I will take, I will take heads, since you always take heads, I'm taking heads.
- 2:48Ed Slott: All right.
- 2:49Let me do an actual coin tails it is.
- 2:55Tails,
- 2:55Jeff Levine: all right.
- 2:55So you get to pick, would you like to argue that you should use 72 T or that
- 3:00you should avoid them like the plague.
- 3:02Ed Slott: Uh, I will go avoid them like the plague, although I
- 3:05really don't totally believe that because there are uses for them,
- 3:08but that's where you'll come in.
- 3:10Jeff Levine: That's right.
- 3:10That's the, if you go, if you do start to do that, ed, we don't have a show.
- 3:13We have to debate.
- 3:14You have one side.
- 3:15I have the other, that's the way this works.
- 3:17Ed Slott: I say no to 72 T and a lot of financial advisors won't like to hear
- 3:21that, because we get questions on that.
- 3:23Both from consumers and financial advisors, who, who, as Jeff said, really
- 3:28need to tap in to their retirement savings and the last thing they wanna do is get
- 3:33hit with a 10% penalty because they're withdrawing before age 59 and a half.
- 3:37Jeff Levine: Right.
- 3:37And the, and the, and the 72 T distributions allow them to do that.
- 3:41So why, why so against them ed?
- 3:43Ed Slott: Because I don't like commitments.
- 3:45All right.
- 3:45Uh, to the, let me explain,
- 3:47Jeff Levine: I'm sending this podcast to your wife with a little note.
- 3:50Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 3:50Right.
- 3:51That's exactly where I'm going with this actually.
- 3:54Uh, the, the rules are so strict and unforgiving, you
- 3:59know, the, the rules generally
- 4:01Jeff Levine: Are you're talking about marriage or are we back on 72 T?
- 4:03Ed Slott: Oh no.
- 4:03We're back on 72 T.
- 4:05Yeah, they've applied to both.
- 4:07It, it's a very similar, you're going to see you're gonna come
- 4:09out on my side at the end.
- 4:11Uh, it's very similar, but in general, the rules, the tax rules surrounding
- 4:16retirement accounts are not only among the most complex in the tax code.
- 4:20But often rigid and unforgiving as this one is yes.
- 4:25The tax code allows you to access your money.
- 4:27If you need it before, let's say retirement age dictated by the tax code,
- 4:33age 59 and a half, without that dreaded 10% penalty for withdrawing early.
- 4:38To me, the 10% penalty is throwing money away.
- 4:42It's a deal breaker, but if you use these so-called 72 T schedules, you
- 4:47can get money out, you pay the tax, as Jeff said, without the penalty.
- 4:52So right away you might say, well, why would you be against that?
- 4:55Because to do that, you have to create as the name, the official name, a series
- 5:00of substantially equal periodic payment says you have to stay on a payment plan.
- 5:06And here's where the commitment comes in.
- 5:09You have to commit to that payment plan without changes for the longer of age of
- 5:15five for the longer of five years or until you reach age 59 and a half years old.
- 5:22Now let's say you're doing this at 40 years old.
- 5:25You'd have to stick to that commitment for 19 and a half years.
- 5:29Most marriages don't last that long.
- 5:31And here's the thing let's say you were great.
- 5:34You did it every, every year.
- 5:36You came up with the right number and you're going to need software to do
- 5:39this in most cases and the help of a financial advisor, because you don't wanna
- 5:44break the plan, go off the commitment.
- 5:46Because let's say, in my example, you're doing okay.
- 5:49You know, you started at 40 and you did it perfectly took
- 5:52the right amount every year.
- 5:54You're 15, 16, 17 years into this.
- 5:57And then for some reason you go off the wagon, you make a change with
- 6:02the tax law coils of modification.
- 6:04Even if you take more, that's where I see a lot of mistakes.
- 6:07People figure, oh, I'll take more.
- 6:09IRS will love me because I'm paying more tax.
- 6:12No, then you've broken the 72 T schedule.
- 6:16And here's what happens.
- 6:17This is a horror show of a penalty.
- 6:20The 10% penalty is then triggered.
- 6:24Retroactively for all of those back years undoing the very thing you were
- 6:29trying to avoid plus interest at a time when you may need the money the most,
- 6:35Jeff Levine: Well, you just made a good point, Ed.
- 6:36You need the money the most, you, you, you need the money.
- 6:41So it's going to have to come from somewhere and chances are, if you're
- 6:44thinking about a 72 T schedule that you've already exhausted
- 6:49your after tax savings, right?
- 6:50Your regular emergency fund is gone.
- 6:52You probably don't even have Roth IRA dollars because as we know the
- 6:55contributions, there can come out tax and penalty free at any time.
- 6:59So you're probably stuck between a rock and a hard place and you need money.
- 7:03And if you need money from an IRA, There is no hardship
- 7:08exception to the 10% penalty.
- 7:10Now, one of the most common misconceptions that we run across, and Ed, I'm sure
- 7:13you've seen it hundreds of times over the course of your career is
- 7:16people thinking that because they've fallen on tough times, they can
- 7:20get money into their, out of their retirement account without a, without
- 7:23a penalty you've seen that I'm sure.
- 7:25Right?
- 7:25Ed Slott: Right.
- 7:26Have I seen that?
- 7:26We teach that in all our advisor training programs, it seems like every.
- 7:31A couple of times a year, maybe more, we see an actual court case where somebody
- 7:35went to tax court and pleaded with the judges that said, but I needed the money.
- 7:39I lost my job.
- 7:41Uh, I have financial hardship.
- 7:42Shouldn't I be able to access my retirement account, not tax free, tax
- 7:46you always pay, but shouldn't, shouldn't I be relieved of the 10% penalty.
- 7:50And in every one of those cases, not almost everyone in every
- 7:54one of those cases, the judge has always seemed simpathetic.
- 7:59You've seen some of the, uh, the court rulings where they'll
- 8:02say, no, we agree with you.
- 8:03It's a tough thing, but we didn't write the tax code, the tax code
- 8:07lists certain exceptions for the 10% penalty and financial
- 8:12hardship is just not one of them.
- 8:14Now, some people might be watching this or listening to it, uh, or this
- 8:19program and saying, wait a minute, you might even be a financial advisor.
- 8:22Say, Ed, I don't know if you're right.
- 8:24There is a financial hardship penalty, exception.
- 8:27For 401k plans!
- 8:29No, there isn't.
- 8:30What they're talking about there, just for your own knowledge, 401k plans
- 8:35have a financial hardship exception, but that only allow allows you access
- 8:40to those funds, where you otherwise wouldn't be, wouldn't have that access.
- 8:44Jeff Levine: That's right.
- 8:45You have the privilege of paying tax and a penalty.
- 8:48If you're under 59 and a half, yes.
- 8:49Yes of using your own money.
- 8:51That's what a hardship exception is.
- 8:52And you said that there's this, uh, you, you said you, you, when talking about
- 8:57these cases that you just mentioned, you referenced the fact that the judges
- 9:00often say there's an enumerated list of, of exceptions to the 10% penalty
- 9:05and hardship is not one of them.
- 9:06Well, let's talk about some of them death.
- 9:09That's not good.
- 9:10Right?
- 9:11You can't use your own money if you're not here.
- 9:13Ed Slott: The ultimate hardship, but not on you!
- 9:16Jeff Levine: Disability.
- 9:18Certainly not something that you're going to create.
- 9:20If it doesn't already exist, right?
- 9:23Uh, education.
- 9:24Well, if you're not using it for education, It doesn't apply.
- 9:29A birth of a child.
- 9:30If you haven't had a child or adopted a child within the
- 9:33last year, it doesn't apply.
- 9:34They're very narrow exceptions, right?
- 9:37They're, they're very specific case scenarios for all of these or for almost
- 9:42all, except the 72 T, the 72 T exception is effectively the great equalizer
- 9:49to say it doesn't matter who you are.
- 9:51It doesn't matter why you need the money.
- 9:53You need it for diapers.
- 9:54Fine.
- 9:55You need it for, uh, you know, uh, uh, rent.
- 9:58Fine.
- 9:59Do you need it because you want to go on a vacation around the world.
- 10:02That's okay, too.
- 10:03So unlike any other exception, you are effectively able to manufacture
- 10:08your own excuse to tap into your retirement funds for any reason.
- 10:13Yes.
- 10:13There are other restrictions you talk about, but that restriction comes with
- 10:17the flexibility of being able to use these dollars for any reason, for any purpose
- 10:22and no other exception really offers that.
- 10:26Unless you find yourself in an unfortunate position, like being
- 10:30disabled already or being dead already, your beneficiary could use the money
- 10:35for any reason without a penalty.
- 10:37But certainly we wouldn't create a scenario where someone dies or
- 10:40becomes disabled just to allow penalty free access to dollars.
- 10:44Outside of that, all the other exceptions effectively that would apply
- 10:49are, uh, expense driven exceptions.
- 10:52Ed Slott: They're all targeted to certain uses and you're right.
- 10:55You could use that money for anything you want.
- 10:58You talked about a need, you don't even have to have a need.
- 11:00I know some people that use it just to create a flow of income
- 11:04to maybe invest in other vehicles.
- 11:06Some people use it to pay insurance premiums.
- 11:09And there are reasons I I'll take your side if somebody's maybe
- 11:13closer to 59 and a half, maybe.
- 11:15And I have used it in this case where I had somebody who was 55
- 11:19years old, they left their job.
- 11:21Most of their money was in their retirement account.
- 11:23They wanted to start enjoying it.
- 11:25And that would be the reason you would use it.
- 11:27So we created this schedule form, but you still have to monitor the schedule,
- 11:32you know, it's so easy to fall off the schedule to break the commitment.
- 11:37That's what worries me most about these things.
- 11:39They have to be monitored.
- 11:41You have to have the exact amount.
- 11:44Jeff Levine: You know, Ed, speaking of the amount, there's, there's actually new
- 11:48information just as of earlier this year.
- 11:50Ed Slott: That's right.
- 11:50Jeff Levine: That makes me feel even better about using the 72
- 11:55T schedules than ever before.
- 11:57At least not, maybe not ever before, but at least in recent history.
- 12:00One of the ways in which you calculate this, or one of the
- 12:03inputs in the calculation, there are technically three ways that the
- 12:07IRS is approved to calculate this.
- 12:09One is using what they call the required minimum distribution method, which is
- 12:13a lot like regular required minimum distributions for those, once they
- 12:17reach 72, the problem is it produces a really small distribution amount.
- 12:23The other two ways of going about calculating the amounts you can
- 12:27take out are the annuitization and amortization methods and you
- 12:30don't have to know what those are.
- 12:31If you're listening, candidly, most CPAs don't even know what they are.
- 12:34They just open up their calculator and plug in the interest rate.
- 12:37But that's the input, right?
- 12:39Is there's an in there's an interest rate that has to be used.
- 12:42That's set by the IRS.
- 12:44And that helps to effectively dictate the maximum amount that you can take
- 12:49out of your IRA without a penalty.
- 12:51So it's not just, when we talk about creating a series of substantially
- 12:55equal periodic payments, we're not just saying, come up with a number, whatever
- 12:58suits you and take the same amount.
- 13:00The IRS has, uh, very precise procedures for this.
- 13:04And one of the things the IRS did earlier this year is it announced that
- 13:07at a minimum you can use a 5% interest rate for your calculations when you
- 13:14go about running these, these numbers.
- 13:16And at least for years, we have seen interest rates incredibly
- 13:20low in the one to 2% range.
- 13:23Yeah.
- 13:24Thereby reducing the amount that people could take out
- 13:26of their retirement accounts.
- 13:27Now using a 5% interest rate, all you need to know today is that there's a
- 13:32lot larger distribution you could take.
- 13:35So you have the ability to get more penalty, free dollars out of your IRA.
- 13:39Again, for any reason, whatever serves your purpose, then you have
- 13:44at any point in recent history.
- 13:46Ed Slott: That's true.
- 13:47You could get a larger payment and that's the key strategy.
- 13:50If you are going to use the 72 T payment plan, most people want to, uh, get the
- 13:56largest payment, but I would add on top of that, the best strategy for this
- 14:00is to create the largest payment using the smallest amount of your retirement
- 14:06savings to get the most out of the least.
- 14:09And maybe a better strategy if you're going to go this way is to isolate one
- 14:13retirement account and just use that one.
- 14:16So the other funds you have in other retirement accounts are not
- 14:20committed and don't get hurt if you fall off the schedule on that.
- 14:25Jeff Levine: Yeah.
- 14:25So essentially Ed, right?
- 14:26If you have a million dollars or so here in an account, but you find you
- 14:30can get the amount you need to last you through 59 and a half with only $600,000.
- 14:35Calculating that 72 T distribution, before you start the payments split the
- 14:41account, put 600,000 in one account, do the 72 T distribution there.
- 14:46Put 400,000 in the other account.
- 14:48And effectively, that means that if something goes wrong, you
- 14:51have an emergency, there's a leaky roof, something like that.
- 14:54You can still access the $400,000 in the account.
- 14:57You've peeled away without breaking the schedule and triggering all
- 15:01those back taxes and or oh, back penalties that Ed was talking
- 15:04about earlier, along with interest.
- 15:06Now, obviously some people will find themselves in a situation where.
- 15:11Where they don't, they don't have enough, right.
- 15:13They, they need $500,000 to calculate the payment they really
- 15:16need, but they only have 400,000.
- 15:18Well, you can't get blood from a stone, so you're not gonna be able to calculate
- 15:22that payment even there, Ed, uh, I often suggest that, uh, people still
- 15:28take a little bit aside, you know, if you needed 500, but you only have 400.
- 15:33A lot of times, I'll say put 20 aside in another account.
- 15:36And even though that does slightly reduce your payment, uh, it, it does like you're
- 15:40still not, you're getting even less than what you needed and it's still not enough.
- 15:45It does mean that if you have some sort of emergency, you still have
- 15:48this other account in which to access.
- 15:50And even if you took the whole 20,000 out, in my example, you would
- 15:54have a $2,000 penalty because you'd have the 10% penalty on top of the
- 15:58income tax, but you wouldn't have the penalty on all the back distribution.
- 16:03Ed Slott: Right, the retroactive.
- 16:04What I don't like about it, the buildup at the worst possible time.
- 16:09I understand, like you said, most people need the money and that's
- 16:12another reason the schedule doesn't work, especially the younger you
- 16:16are, the smaller the payments are.
- 16:19So it may not be enough to, to fill the need it's based on
- 16:23life expectancy, these payments.
- 16:25So the younger you are, even if you are in your fifties the payments,
- 16:28unless you have a very large IRA are not going to be enough.
- 16:32And if you have a very large IRA, you probably don't have a problem.
- 16:37So you may be better off if you have a one time need.
- 16:40And I, I hate to even say that this, if you have a one time need, maybe it's
- 16:45better to take the hit and the penalty.
- 16:47I hate to paying the penalty because it's just money down the drain, but
- 16:51it might be a better one time fix then having to get stuck with a commitment
- 16:57where you may end up paying that penalty anyway, if you can't stay
- 17:00on the schedule for all those years.
- 17:03Jeff Levine: Well, I think.
- 17:05We've covered a good cross section here of some of the pros and cons, but let's just
- 17:10say you let's just take a step back Ed and think of someone in this situation who's
- 17:16trying to figure out what they can do or, uh, you know, they're in need for funds.
- 17:20I think we both agree that, uh, whether you set up the 72 T schedule or you
- 17:26pay the penalty, the first thing you most likely should do in, in,
- 17:30again, not all, but most situations is look for other sources of dollars.
- 17:34Ed Slott: Oh, absolutely.
- 17:35I mean, we we're assuming, and you made that assumption up front,
- 17:38that everything else is gone.
- 17:39There are no, this is the last resort.
- 17:42I believe this should be the last resort.
- 17:45Jeff Levine: What about someone who says, I don't want debt.
- 17:47I, you know, I own my home, but I, I don't wanna take a home equity loan.
- 17:52Would you oftentimes look for something like that before
- 17:54going into a 72 T discount?
- 17:55Ed Slott: A reverse mortgage!
- 17:57Jeff Levine: Yeah.
- 17:57Okay.
- 17:58I, I, I don't necessarily disagree.
- 18:00I mean, there's where if you can't get.
- 18:03To, uh, you know, to a, to dollars in other accounts, cause they don't exist
- 18:07in your choices, an IRA distribution and setting up a 72 T schedule or
- 18:11perhaps, you know, tapping other assets.
- 18:13I mean a home is an asset and if you have equity in that asset, uh,
- 18:17oftentimes that can be a, a less expensive, certainly don't need to keep
- 18:20the home equity line in place until your 59 and a half or until five years.
- 18:25So you have some more flexibility.
- 18:27Ed Slott: Your age is a big factor.
- 18:28If you're close to 59 and a half, it may just be a stop gap measure
- 18:32until you're over the threshold where a penalty no longer applies.
- 18:36Jeff Levine: That's a great point.
- 18:38You're only looking there, you know, if you start a 72 T distribution of 58,
- 18:42you've gotta keep that until you're 63.
- 18:44If you, uh, start just taking a distribution at 60, uh, 58, you've
- 18:49only got a year and a half to go until you've got the ability to take all
- 18:53those penalty free distributions again.
- 18:55So absolutely.
- 18:56That's a great point.
- 18:57But Ed, in summing up some of our key pros and cons of the day.
- 19:01Uh, I think some of the key cons you mentioned, and, and probably the single
- 19:05biggest issue with 72 T distributions is the fact that they are, uh, a long
- 19:10and rigid schedule at the very least we're talking about five years, but
- 19:14in many cases it's a decade plus of commitment that you have to stick
- 19:19to and get it right for a long time.
- 19:21And the other challenge with these distributions is that you don't get
- 19:24to make the amounts up yourself.
- 19:26You have to stick to a calculation and that's limiting the dollars that you can
- 19:30take out at any one time on the pros Ed, we said that, uh, one of the biggest pros
- 19:36relative to all the other exceptions that are available is that you can effectively
- 19:40manufacture this one for yourself.
- 19:42It doesn't require some sort of nasty event, like a death
- 19:45or disability to happen first.
- 19:47It doesn't require that you spend the dollars on certain things such
- 19:50as education or home purchase, etc., as other exceptions do.
- 19:54So this one is just if you want the dollars and you adhere to
- 19:58the schedule, you can do whatever you want with those dollars.
- 20:00And because of a change in the way that payments are calculated
- 20:05with a new IRS interest rate set earlier this year, a minimum
- 20:09interest rate, uh, that can be used.
- 20:12There's an ability to take more dollars out of retirement accounts,
- 20:15penalty free using this method that at any time in recent history, anything
- 20:20else you'd add to, to those as key takeaways for our listeners today?
- 20:23Ed Slott: The concept in all 72 is if you're going to do it, get the
- 20:28largest payment, using the least amount of retirement accounts, if you can.
- 20:33But I know Jeff, when you close up this program, you are, as you
- 20:36always say, use a financial advisor.
- 20:39This is one I would not try at home alone.
- 20:43Jeff Levine: I don't think I'd even try this one at home alone.
- 20:46I think if I ever need one of these and hopefully I don't, I'm coming to you, Ed.
- 20:50Ed Slott: And I'm going to some computer program and I'm gonna print
- 20:53it out like I used to do for my clients and check it off each time to make
- 20:56sure they made the exact payment.
- 20:58And even then sometimes they make the wrong payment.
- 21:01Jeff Levine: Mistakes happen and, and that's why you need a professional.
- 21:04And, and that's why, and that's also why, while there are two sides to
- 21:07every coin, Ed, life and retirement decisions, when they're this big,
- 21:11can't be left up to that coin flip.
- 21:13So one thing you and I always agree on is when these big decisions occur.
- 21:18Anytime there's, uh, a life changing decision or just a decision with
- 21:22significant financial consequences.
- 21:24It's best to talk through the decision with a knowledgeable financial
- 21:27advisor or a tax professional so that you can weigh the pros and cons of
- 21:30those decisions against your own set of specific goals and objectives.
- 21:36Now, if you'd like to continue the discussion with Ed or I we'd
- 21:38love to hear from you, you can reach out to us on social media.
- 21:41You can reach Ed on Twitter @TheSlottReport.
- 21:44Again, that's the @TheSlottReport and you can reach me on Twitter @CPAPlanner.
- 21:48Again, that's @CPAPlanner.
- 21:50Let us know what you think of 72 T distributions.
- 21:53Do you like them.
- 21:54Do you not?
- 21:54Have you used them before, uh, any specific set of pros or cons, uh,
- 21:59that you thought we missed or should have spent more time on, or you have a
- 22:02topic for a future debate for Ed and I.
- 22:04We'd love to hear from you until then Ed, as always.
- 22:08It's been fun.
- 22:09Ed Slott: All right, sounds good.
- 22:10Jeff, we'll see you on the next episode of the great retirement debate.
- 22:16OUTRO: Jeffrey Levine is chief planning officer for Buckingham wealth partners.
- 22:19This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 22:23not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal or tax advice.
- 22:26Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information,
- 22:29which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 22:32Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's accuracy and
- 22:35completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 22:36The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 22:40and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham wealth partners.