Latest / Portfolio Talks / Ep 16 : The Real Cost of AUM
Transcript
- Vishal Gill, CFP: Welcome, welcome everyone, to another episode of Portfolio Talks. Today we're gonna be talking to those of you who are scared every single time you hear the word AUM or assets under management. Is it good? Is it bad? Is it horrible? Is it great? It really depends who you are and what you're looking to achieve. So today our intent is to dispel AUM. it's not all doom and gloom, which if you jump on LinkedIn for five minutes, you'll probably see 14 different articles talking about how bad AUM is. But depending what you're looking for, it might be great for you. So we're going talk about that today. Who is it for? Who's it not for? And why should you choose one over the other? As always, feel free to share, subscribe, and It really helps us bump up on that front. And without further ado, let's jump into an episode of Portfolio Talks, A-U-M, and the real cost of it. All right, we're back. Episode, I don't even remember what number it is. I think it's episode seven, seventeen, could be 40, who knows? We're having a blast, so you you lose track when you're having fun. but we really want to chat about AUM, and I think it's so appropriate as the year winds down because most of you have been busy in your profession, so you don't really meet with your advisor all that much until close to the year end because personal taxes are coming around the corner, or maybe your corporate year end is right about now. or you just have time to finally open up those statements and take a look and see the state of affairs and what's going on. So we felt it's very appropriate to talk about AUM. there's a conversation that comes up every single time. because we are a flat fee financial planning firm. so it's a question that comes to us when we first meet with clients. They're like, I hate AUM. And we always ask why. And more times than not, they don't even know. They're just like, I just, I don't know, I read that I should never be with AUM. and then some of the clients, as we talked to them, were like, you know what? I think you actually would be better served with an AUM model. And some of them are great for us and and some don't really know and they migrate back and forth between the two. So what we want to do is chat about that. Tyson has a unique experience with this because he has a robust amount of experience in different buckets in the financial world. he is the youngest looking guy. I think he looks half my age, but he has double my wisdom. So I don't know if it's a good thing or a bad thing, but we're gonna talk about that and kind of all the nuances around. the AUM model. So before we jump into that episode, Tyson, anything you want to let the listeners know but before we jump into the the meat and potatoes of it. Tyson Nagasaka: No, I I don't think so. It's it's a way that the industry's operated for a very, very long time. There's a reason for it. there's a time and a place for it. And then the alternatives that we're gonna talk about, I think if they're done well and you're the right type of person to do that, it could work for you. So you know, we're open to to everything that's out there, but you wanna know the pros and cons, like everything that we talk about. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And I think for starters, people ask sometimes, why why was AUM the norm? what I would say is, you know, my opinion might not be the exact right opinion, but it's just kind of what I've seen and and my interpretation of it. AUM truthfully is the best way to scale up a firm because you have guaranteed revenue coming in. it's it's a good way to grow. So if you look at the banking worlds, they have excuse me, they have Banks, they have buildings, they have a lot of staff, they have a lot of overhead. In order to do that, you need AUM. And if you take that to independent firms, there's independent firms who add a lot of value to their specific clients. If look at family office style firms, we will have a small size firm that really just niches in, you know, 20 to 25 families. And they're gonna be a certain amount of net worth and they're gonna charge the AUM model, and that allows them to hire staff to do. Everything. They'll have their in-house accountant, in-house lawyers, they'll have you know, concierge, employees, and and all that kind of stuff. So depending what you want to do, AUM is the best way to scale up. And banks like to see the AUM because of guaranteed revenue coming in in order for them to lend you money to then continue to scale. So that's why AUM is kind of the norm. There's so many different ways that people charge in our industry. when I first entered the industry, it was really just the two. It was either AUM or you do commissions. And that's basically it. What I mostly noticed at that time was if it was AUM, all the advice, understandably, would be to retain the assets that are magic in the investment portfolio. So they would point people towards leveraging instead of withdrawing from their investment portfolio. and everything that you every problem that you had always equated to investing more money or leaving your money invested, hence why the banks also make a lot of money on the loans and the debts. On the flip side, the commission side. was every single question you had equated to a new insurance policy. You want to invest for home, just do it through whole life. You want to do XYZ save your kids, another insurance policy. You want to take care of your parents, another insurance policy on yourself. So all this kind of stuff was always always that was the only way that you can get paid. Now there's so many different ways. There's people that charge hourly, there's people that charge flat fee, there's hybrid models, there's AUM models, and none of them truthfully are wrong. It really just depends on what you're getting out of it. It's the same thing when I go to get my car fixed. there's different mechanics that charge different prices. It just depends how much do I want to pay versus the quality that I'm getting. And I think that's the same decision we make in everything that we consume, everything that we buy. So without further ado, Tyson, why don't we jump into what the fee actually is? So people hear AUM, but they don't really know what the fee is or how does that work? registered, non registered, corporate, personal. Let's talk about it. What is the fee and how does that work? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, so what most people w think about when they're thinking about fees for investments, it comes from the mutual fund world just because that was the biggest sector of the most amount of clients that have invested the most amount of money in Canada through banks, through investment firms that are national or some of them are regional, through credit unions. Most people were using mutual funds. And then over the last like 10 to 15 years, it's been a big push for ETFs. ETFs have basically become the new mutual fund. some of them are lower cost, some of them are not. but what the fee refers to is usually the advisor fee portion of the fee that is charged. Now, traditionally, mutual funds you'd be paying two to two and a half, sometimes more. and the advisor would get about one percent of that. Now Since about twenty sixteen to twenty twenty, firms have been starting to convert to a model where the advisor fee and the fund fee, the investment fee, are starting to become unbundled. And that has a lot to do with regulations and clarity of like how am I paying fees? Who am I paying them to? How does that work? so the one percent that a lot of people see, that's the advisor fee. That's usually not the investment fund or the investment management fee. So all in you might be paying one and a half to two percent. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And depending on what you're looking to invest in, the complexity of the underlying investments, that's gonna dictate what the let's just say the institutional fee to keep it simple. if it's just basic index funds at ETFs, it'll be on a cheaper rate, maybe a zero point two. If it's more private funds, you know, maybe a zero point eight or or one percent, whatever that ends up being. It's what you're paying to get, what's the underlying investment. and that's what that fee is gonna be. And then the one percent Tyson's referring to. How much you're paying for your advisor. And again, the question isn't so much about the one percent fee, it's more so what are you getting out of that one percent? so deductions is one thing that comes up often. Like, is this fee deductible or is it or is it not? So this is for the one percent advisor fee. Yeah, it's one percent, but can I deduct it against my taxes? How does that work? Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. So one of the good things about having an advisor that has fees that are unbundled when you can clearly demonstrate the advisor fee portion and you have non-registered investment accounts or you have corporate investment accounts, that 1% fee becomes deductible. because you can show that you're getting some level of management and advice from an advisor, that fee is something that you are paying for advice. You can deduct that. And so you you're not paying one percent at the end of the day. You might be paying 0.6, you might be paying 0.5, depending on how aggressive your accountant is and how you are able to kind of mark that down. that is one advantage of having an advisor that charges an unbundled fee is the clarity, but also the deductibility. Now, on registered accounts, R R SPs, RESPs, tax-free savings accounts, CRA doesn't like you to deduct those fees. If your accountant does do that, that could be putting you in some Dark gray areas and you don't want to be audited. Vishal Gill, CFP: Dark, dark, dark gray. so definitely don't want to be in there. and I I think this is one of those things that your accountant probably already knows and is doing the deduction on the non-registered. You just want to double check. but it's it's less about is that fee actually getting deducted? It's more about you understanding that it's not just the one percent where your net cost is, let's say 0.6%. So is that 0.6%, the same argument, is that 0.6% worth the advice that you're getting? so it's not one percent if it's non-reg, if it's TFSA, FHSA, R R S P. those ones, there is no capital loss harvesting that can happen. There's no, it's pretty simple with your registered accounts. It's more so about the tax advantage aspects of of those accounts, of those portfolios. so that is what it is, but it's the non-reg because there's a lot more things that you can do with the non-reg ones. and that's where you can start to get those deductions and and bring your fee down from 1% to let's say a 0.6. we're gonna talk about this later, but actually I'll think I'll just bump it up in the agenda here. So you kind of talked about the bundled and unbundled fees. So when people look at their statements, and it's an exercise we do every time we onboard new clients is we ask them before we tell them how much they're paying, how much are you paying in in fees? And some of them, even the ones that try to find out when they look at their statements, especially those that come from the bank. So we won't say any specific bank names, but a lot of our MDs, DDS, ODs, they'll get into those relationships. at a university because the line of credit and then from there they just open up their investment accounts and they end up just being there because it's convenient, everything's in one spot, one login. However, when they start to get to a higher net worth and want to migrate out and they ask what's going on with my fees, they open those statements and they have no clue what's going on, can't find it anywhere. one of them a couple weeks ago was like I hit control F and tried to find fees, E Rs, AU, I'm not gonna find anything. I don't know what's going on. so what do your statements not tell you specifically with the banks for the most part? And there's some other institutions out there too, I'm sure, but for the banks for the most part, what do they not see in their in their statements when it comes to fees? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I don't think they see simplicity. so what a lot of companies have taken to is they have to follow the rules set by the regulator. So they are over disclosing, right? They're breaking the fees down into a lot of small chunks versus saying the percentage of fee that you're paying, they're gonna say you're paying it fifty dollars a month for fifty dollars a year for statements. You're paying X amount of dollars for the bank administration, you're paying X amount. For the advisor, and they're gonna break it down into a lot of chunks. And sometimes we see account fees, you might see nominee fees if you're a nominee versus a client name. So the account type will dictate how fees are done. And I think that over disclosure of the fees is making it more confusing, especially when you start looking at a spectrum of months that are out there. The other thing that happens is we see on a lot of statements from some companies is they only disclose the fees on your February statement. So February is not the end of a quarter, it's also not the end of a year, but at the end of your February statements for your banks and most investment companies, is you're gonna see a fee that's on there. And every company chooses how they're gonna display that fee, and they might also choose the time range. in which they are are allocating this fee. So it's not always an apples to apples comparison. Sometimes it does take a lot of reading and like comprehension of how are they trying to explain this fee. And the more the regulators try to flatten the marketplace and make it more transparent, the more confusing it comes, not just for clients, but also the advisors. Vishal Gill, CFP: Absolutely. So moving on to the fee. So let's say it's we won't talk about the deductive fee, we'll just one percent to keep it simple. So let's say you're doing that one percent. people talk about oftentimes the compounding effects of the one percent. so compounding works both ways. Compounding, we talk about the advantages of compounding. So starting your investments early because you know, eight percent on 200k is worth more than eight percent on 160k, and that just keeps happening over and over and over again. The rule of 72. however, when it comes to compounding working against you, when it comes to the fee, it's like that 1%. So every dollar that's not invested in your portfolio is costing you the compounding growth. So if you have you know, 1% on a million dollars, let's say $10,000 is not invested, that $10,000 is compounding against you as far as a missed opportunity cost. so how do you feel about that? argument when it comes to people like well the investment shouldn't have any cost at all is that equate to other types of investments I think we have we talked about this offline but we have different opinions on there are different examples of this sorry when it comes to the compounding against so first question would be anything to do with the math on the compounding effects of the fees and then alternatively the second part of that question would be is that just for investments or is that kind of common ticket for entry for any type of investment? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. Okay. So Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, okay. Tyson Nagasaka: it it it is absolutely common, depending on or an on any type of investment, there is some sort of a cost in order to invest there. but we do see these arguments on online a lot, especially from financial coaches who are very much arm's length away from doing actual advisor work or investment management work or dealing with clients when they're in the worst possible situations. the one percent advisory fee Yes, it sounds like it's compounding, it's working negatively against you, but your statements almost across the board for all banks, investment companies, institutions, they're reporting your net of fees returns. So that means after the fees are deducted, after all the costs are stripped out, if your statement says you earn nine percent, that's nine percent after all the fees and costs and everything have come off the top. so you get an idea of what are you doing. Outside of any fee, reporting fee cost, all that kind stuff. Now, the the sidebar to that is if you were to do this on your own, a lot of people get in their own way making decisions about the wrong time. They might choose good investments, but they don't always have the best entry method or exit method from a position. and The there's danger in that. So we'll cover DIY in another section. We'll just stay on the fees. You're getting getting access to hopefully really good quality, curated portfolios. That's what the fee pays for. The example that I use when people are really dissuaded or against paying fees is if you took $500,000 and invested in the portfolio, it grew, it does whatever. But if you also took that $500,000 and bought a rental property, And it grew by 10%. And in 30 years, it's worth $2.5 million. Very common example for Vancouver. We have people now who have real estate they bought in the 90s. It's worth $2.5 million now. Along the way, there's costs associated with maintaining that investment property. There's property taxes, there's maintenance, there's appliances that go down, there's tradespeople you need to fix stuff, there's windows that get broken and you need to fix and replace. There's all kinds of costs associated with it. They're just not called investment fees when you're investing in businesses or real estate or in other areas. So in securities investing, there are fees associated, but it's probably the most transparent industry about how the fees are conducted and charged to you. And I I guess people don't like the transparency or because you can see it, you have something to to target. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, a hundred percent. And and that's not even to mention like the the Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, a hundred percent. Vishal Gill, CFP: realtor side of it. So let's say you do have the investment property. it's worth X amount of dollars. That's great. You can't really do anything with it. the the paper value is irrelevant until you tap into it via a HELOC or you take a loan against it. And there's transaction fees for that. So those are you know, account fees, E R fees, whatever you want to call it, AUM fees. you got tap into that. So you gotta pay money to the lender. That that broker is going to charge you a fee. you're also gonna have to pay the conveyancing work. perhaps you have to get your place reappraised. there's all those fees that go into it. And those are one time large transaction fees. But if you break that out, you know, what is that as a percentage on the growth that you were earning? And another layer of that is when you eventually want to sell that property, then you have realtor fees. And realtor fees is a hot topic. Because people are very against realtor fees. They're like they get paid way too much for what they do and blah, blah, blah. However, when you ask them, okay, well, why don't you DIY that? it's the same kind of premise, like, okay, well, I don't to pay investment fees, I'll just DIY it. Okay, well, we don't like realtor fees, why don't you DIY that as well? Like, well, there's too much risk. Like, you know, what if I don't get the best asset price? what if I make a mistake and whatever? And that's the same argument for. investment fees and the AUM side of it. So again, it's just to show that's not so much the fee is what you're getting out of the fee. And I think that's the real problem that people have. and we have the conversation all the time, even with other advisors, when we do go to other events, we we tend not to go to too many different industry events. We we prefer to golf as opposed to going to industry events. But when we do go to them, we talk to advisors and they have the same thing all people are so against like AUM fees. And my argument is always the same. Well, for the clients that we see, I don't think they're against AUM fees. They just have no clue what you even offer them for what they're paying. Tyson Nagasaka: Yes. Vishal Gill, CFP: and I think that's their problem. Like that's the advisor's fault. That is your fault of why you're losing clients. Is if someone were to tell me, hey, Vishall, you're paying $10,000 in fees, but you know, this is what you're getting, this, this, this, or even if you don't tell me, if I see it with frequent meetings, frequent reachos, anytime I have a problem, you're solving it in a in a well thought out way, I would have no problems with that because. Another part of this argument that I think we'll just add the DIY side into it is we see catastrophic mistakes that people make with their investments when they come to us. and even just this last year, I think there were four examples that we had when we first onboard the client and they always have some kind of issue for the most part. there's a pain point that makes people want to switch advisors or hire an advisor, of course. but when it came to the DIY, these four examples. were one of the types I'll let you talk about, but I had two that were one was just holding all the wrong investments inside their TFSA. so they were bleeding money on on withholding tax and things like that. Not the end of the world, but it's not really that efficient, whereas you could hold different investments and we wanted to fix it. So you know we did that afterwards. But this would have stayed the exact same compound over over several years and it would have equated to way more than what an AUM fee would have had. had she just hired someone right off the bat to help her with it and it was an AUM advisor, that problem I would hope that it would never happen, but who knows? But I would assume that that problem would have happened. And then that one percent fee that they were paying, assuming it's one percent, would have been significantly cheaper than than her losses that she would take in the T FSAs. Another example was cross border. We have cross border clients. you know, one of them he was on the RESPs for his children. that's a problem. There's another one where he had a different client had a TFSA. So it's not the end of the world on the Canadian side, but the TFSA doesn't shield you as a dual citizen from the IRS. So that's another problem. So there's lot of inefficiencies, a lot of mistakes that are happening in the DIY investors. And it's not that they're dumb. It's not that they have no idea what's going on. A lot of these people are more than smart enough to DIY it. It's a bandwidth problem. They don't have enough time to do all the research constantly about all these issues, and life is ever changing. So you built yourself Tyson Nagasaka: Yes. Vishal Gill, CFP: a DIY plan two years ago. It's not relevant anymore now. but those are some examples of what it's actually costing you on the DIY side. Tyson, I'm sure you have some other examples too. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, we we've seen some terrible self directed choices over the last couple of years. And a lot of them are it's like they're investing based on vibes versus based on investment fundamentals, looking at the company, thinking about what model they're gonna use to evaluate. And I don't expect regular people to do this because As advisors, we rely on portfolio managers to do a lot of these calculations. But they're buying things based on a name associated, a brand, or a trend that's happening. So big one that we saw over COVID was Peloton. Everyone was working at home, everyone was getting these Peloton bikes. They thought it was going to be fantastic. And there were some fund managers out of the States that have very, very popular ETF. They went full bore on some of these companies that did very well during. COVID and coming out of COVID, they lost up to 90% of their fund value. And clients were still holding this because they didn't know how to exit, when to exit, and they're holding on, hoping it's going to come back. But in some of these portfolios that we looked at and we analyzed, it's like, hey, your one position, in order for it to come back to an amount where you can trade and not have a loss, that particular security needs to do 400% return. So how how long are we gonna hold this? And so you have to make strat you have to make strategic and sometimes very gut-wrenching tactical decisions of cut off the loss, let's have the money that's remaining go into something that's gonna earn you eight, ten, twelve percent, whatever. Let's let's move in the positive direction. But we have seen more and more and more horror stories. And I think the trend and it's not it's kind of not in our outline for today. But sports gambling, sports betting is eating away at people's investment behavior. And it's a trend that's happening where I saw a study years ago and I don't know if this is still true. But for every dollar that's spent on sports gambling, it takes away about two dollars from retirement savings. and so I'd like to see an updated one. I haven't found one yet that makes sense. But I think the theme is right. Is sports gambling and the way people are investing is very much like gambling and they're looking for a win. And when we look at their statements over the last year or two years, if you could see the behavior that's happening, very concerning. So your advisor, one of the things that they help with is behavioral finance, is getting you on a simplified, very calm but positive direction heading strategy. And we work forward to build savings. And I think that your advisor team should be doing that for you. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yep, absolutely. so before we flip over to who AUM is good for, which is our next topic, I would just kind of end that point where what we've seen is people are less against AUM and more so confused of the value of AUM. And that is really the advisor's fault, is you are not providing enough value to justify how much you're charging. And that would also be the same argument if you're a flat fee advisor or if you're charging hourly. if you're like, I'm charging 700 bucks an hour and you're just doing basic stuff that they can DI themselves, why would I pay you 700 bucks an hour? So I think the argument is the same for all of them. we've seen less resistance from AUM as you can move away from the bank. So if people are gonna pay the same one percent, would I pay you one percent for a basic? I was about to say the bank's name, a basic bank portfolio or they're Tyson Nagasaka: Like balance fund, yeah. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, or their private private wealth one that's more or less the same thing. or, you know, could you take that same one percent fee and flip over to a private wealth fund that's separate from the banks that has access to different things, innovative things, and you know, should you buy Peloton or GameStop or any of that stuff, they'll kind of make all those decisions for you. So all you gotta worry about is doing your deposits that are gonna keep you on track to hit those goals. And then you can have some money on the side to do sports gambling or whatever you want to do. so there's no one specific mathematical approach in my opinion of what makes the most sense, you're paying fees no matter what, whether you are paying AUM fees, whether you're paying fat flat fee fees, whether you're paying hourly fees, and whether you're DIYing it and paying mistake fees, which you most likely are. And every single client that we've seen that that comes to us afterwards, it this ends up being the most expensive. So we tell them like, you know, if have, you know, friends and family that are against Starting with an advisor, just tell them to pick whatever advisor model makes the most sense for them. it's not, you know, we're not here to tell you that flat fee planners are the only ones you should ever work with, and you know, we're the best, and you know, ego beat our chest and say this and that or the other. It really depends what you're looking for, and just find the advisor that makes the most sense for you because that mistake fee is the most expensive one that we've seen. And any one of those fees, AUM hourly flat mistakes. is all compounding against you because money that is otherwise out of your portfolio and it's the same thing for your spending habits. So all this stuff is all money that's compounding against you. But people are okay with you know my Cactus Club or my traveling that's compounding against me. They're okay with that trade off because what they get out of it. So they would be also okay with how much they're paying for the fees as long as they're getting what they want out of it. So moving on to who AUM fee advisors are okay for. what are your thoughts? is there anyone that's specifically good for AUM versus anything else, or can they more or less get it from everyone? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. I I I think I think there's a place for it for most Canadians. and you touched on a bunch of the things that w where this lift really comes in into place. number one, the people, especially the the clients that we deal with, they're super smart, they're very academic, they're very accomplished, but their challenge is bandwidth. They have they might work sixty, eighty, hundred hours a week, they have kids, they have a household to maintain, they have a spouse. They have stuff going on. They don't have time to research their investments. How does it fit with their strategy? Should it be exiting? Should it be buying more? so bandwidth is one of their first constraints. And so hiring a team around them is really a smart idea. And they should be adding value. they should be adding layering strategies that make sense for you. And we say this in a lot of our presentations. It's not that. We're gonna do these steps for you, tax-free savings account, FHSA, life insurance, budget, where it's really order of operations. You're gonna prioritize and you're gonna execute on the right things in the right order so it's efficient for the client and they're not being overwhelmed. And they're also not confusing things that are happening as you start to layer on, because they have the ability to do all of these things doesn't mean that you should. All right. An example of that is. When we go and talk to our med students that are graduating, we're going to talk to them about RSPs, but they're likely not going to contribute to RSPs for the first few years because they have student tuition credits. Then after that, they're likely going to incorporate. And then they got to figure out how they're going to pay themselves. They might not even have RSP contribution room. so we'll talk about it, but we'll tell them that when it's appropriate, we're going to implement that strategy. That's something that an advisor does. We're not even getting paid for that, but that's. A level of advice and organization that we bring that tells them the order of operations. And then on the flip side, what happens if you've had a very successful life? You've built this huge portfolio and now you're getting closer to the exit, right? You want some estate planning. Why? Because you don't want half or 60% of your estate to go to the CRA. You'd rather disperse it to the appropriate parties, family members, charities, your financial planning team. will help you lay the groundwork to do that efficiently so that there's off ramps for your finances that you've been successful with. And your fee pays for part of that advice and all of the work that they do behind the scenes, the research and picking out the appropriate partners and which path that you're gonna do. So it all comes into to play. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And you know that that's really well said. And I think the big thing that stands out to me with what you mentioned, which is the last part. And this is what we see a lot is people are almost scared of spending their money and they just defer, defer, defer. And we made a different episode about this is you know, is your tax plan to just defer, or do you actually have a tax plan? And for most people, it's just deferment, is their entire plan. The problem with that is it just traps a lot of your wealth inside your corp. All of you listening are either incorporated or you're gonna be incorporated very shortly. and then your money's just stuck in your corporation. And for you to pull any of the money, you're almost terrified because you I gotta pay tax on this, it's gonna put me in a high marginal tax rate, or I don't have enough personal savings on the personal side. So I have to take more of it out from the court to pay my tax. man, that's like less money that's compounding against me because that's money that's not in my portfolio. You know how how much is enough? And that is really a plan built backwards from what your goals you're trying to accomplish. What you don't want to do is be a prisoner to your own money. It's your money. Freaking spend it. enjoy it. the problem is you don't have a plan to do so. So that kind of brings us into us, our pitch. I I guess if you're gonna say in the episode side. So we are a flat fee planning firm. Tys, before I kick it to you and then I'll I'll add on at the end of it. I re remember myself, like when I first started in the industry, I mentioned this in the beginning of the episode. There was two ways to charge. There was the AUM side or there was a commission side. I didn't love either one of them. So I started doing the hourly side. And I remember in the very beginning, almost every advisor that I knew that was in, my area, besides Tyson, thought it was like crazy. why are you doing hourly? That doesn't make any sense. and it sucked. Like doing hourly sucked for me because I hated tracking my time. I kept forgetting to I was not working on a file. I like, man, I gotta track my time. and I always think about that when I talk to my friends and our lawyers, and I just laugh. I like, I don't know how you guys do it. Honestly, like That was the hardest part for me when I was doing the hourly side is tracking my time. It was such a tedious thing to do. and I just I just would never ever do that again. So we did flat fee instead. But you know, flat fee is an alternative. So it's one of the ways that you can charge or or find an advisor and to help you, you know, what is flat fee and and you know, why does that fit really well? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, for a lot of our clientele that we're seeing now, they're coming out of med school and they're told they're drilled into them in med school, find a flat fee advisor. And I think this comes from a place where the past experience that the faculty have had is AUM advisors, whether that was with a traditional investment company or is with a bank. Is they're giving you conflicted advice because they don't want their assets on your management to decrease when you spend your money. so a good advisor will always remind you it's your money. I'm gonna give you advice, but you're gonna do with it what you want. If you need to take it out, you have liquidity in your portfolio, you can use it, it's your money. good decisions, bad decisions, it's your money. Okay. But flat fee, we take a very consulting point of view where we're gonna look at the whole picture. We're gonna look at cash flow and budgeting and all of the pillars of financial planning on the personal and on the corporate side. because of things like tax integration, you can't have a partial picture and expect to have a full plan for everything that's happening, which is really where the flat fee model comes in. We act as a consultant, it is updated annually because as soon as you print a financial plan, I've been around long enough where we used to print financial plans, put them in a leather binder and give them to somebody. And as soon as you print it, it's out of date. Because they have sold their house, they've bought new cars, they've had a child, they've gotten divorced. Man, we've got a lot of divorcee clients. Grey divorce too. so as soon as you print the financial plan, it's out of date. But it does give you a really, really good base plan in order for us to ablib the next steps that are happening. Because the plan needs to be flexible enough to adapt to life, because life has a tremendous sense of humor and it will never follow the plan that we make, but we will make really, really good foundations so that we can flex and go on to the next steps that bring themselves up. So flat fee, that's kinda like what we do and what we bring to the table. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, absolutely. I think the biggest thing is that there is no conflicts of interest. and that's how it's built. Is regardless what advice you need to make your future goals a reality and build a plan to do that, you're good. You get you get the the advice to to get you there in the most efficient way possible. And to Dyson's point, yeah, there's always changes that happen. Like I perfect example, I was delivering a financial plan to a client last night. wasn't printed though. That's what's on online. but it was funny because we built the plan version one was two months ago, just prior to them having a kid. And there's already changes because we we booked again to help implement because again it's a flat fee firm. What our our firm does we don't just give you a plan that's like 80 pages, good luck, calls if anything goes wrong. we also do a state of the affairs. So what what out of here is the most valuable things to start changing and implementing? Let's stage one, then stage two, then stage three. And we help you along the way. We meet through advisors, your accountants, your lawyers, everyone else involved that needs to be involved to get this up to the finish line. We take care of all that as well. but this client, we chatted last night and and and he's like, Yeah, honestly, I'm just kind of they're gonna see less patients during the I'm still gonna work the same five days, but I'm gonna see less patients during the day. So I'm not doing my charting and stuff at home. because now he's like, Man, having a kid is freaking awesome. It's like, yeah, it's it's unreal. so know what that equates to is about a sixteen percent reduction in income. And that's the question. Hey, how how is that going to change the plans? What the trade-offs? and we just kind of ran through it and we're like, okay, cool, we'll just ramp up a little bit of the risk on your investment portfolio. So instead of being super conservative, you'll be a little bit more on the balance side. And that's cool. That's it. Or you can fund this goal a little bit less or you can retire a little bit later or whatever that ends up being. And in reality That 60% loss probably isn't going to be indefinite. That's going to change again in a couple of years. So there's always changes that are happening in the plan. And this way your plan is always up to date and it's a flat fee. So all your stuff is included in there as well. So what I do find to kind of close off is it's less about what type of fee that you're paying and just kind of what you're getting out of it instead. Because if you're a good financial planner financial planning firm, more or less your costs are gonna be basically the same. If someone's AUM, So what the client would pay you A cumulatively over their career versus what they could pay flat fee versus what they can pay the hourly, if you're getting what you should get out of it, it's probably gonna be more or less the same because there's a cost to service those clients at a at a high level. if you're someone who has very, very basic needs, so you're not, you know, a very high net worth client, you're midwealth or or whatever, you just need DIY, then that's okay. You can DIY into, but there's a cost to that as well, which is the advice you're not getting. the the cost of mistakes and all that is also compounding against you. So more or less your costs will always the same. It's more important to figure out what value you're getting from that firm, who you connect with, who you just resonate with. one thing our clients always laugh about, they're like, it's weird, but we actually look forward to our financial planning means because we like chopping it up and so do we. We love chit chatting it. and just, you know, we're not very, very serious. As you can tell I had basketball other and I haven't even moved my basketball from from my recording studio. Sometimes you see golf calls back here, sometimes we just random messes. So we don't take ourselves overly serious. but that that works. And that's our clients that that connect with us, and we're those we connected with those clients as well. and it was funny actually, Tyson, I forgot to tell you this, but one of the audience members they ended up coming into a client, but they were trying to be like, Yeah, you guys seem like So professional and it's a it's a good flow on your episodes. And I started laughing. I was like, we chat probably three minutes before we start recording. We're like, all right, what do you want to talk about? Cool. Let's jump into it. We have a rough idea, but we just hang around each each other a lot. So it's funny, like when we hear your when I hear your point of view on stuff, like it's just it's nice because it's the first time I'm hearing it on this topic. And I'm like, Yeah, okay, cool. And sometimes it's a good conversation for us to have. and you guys are all here live for it, which is always nice. So appreciate the feedback on the on the episodes and it's good that's We come across very professional and very streamlined ISIN, so take that for what it's worth. Tyson Nagasaka: That's awesome. Vishal Gill, CFP: in ending, you know, this is a little bit of a quicker episode than our other ones, but anything to add on the very end of you know, what should people take away from this or or any kind of next test for them? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I I think some of the big takeaways are when you work with a professional advisor team, they should be able to coordinate stuff on your behalf to make sure that the strategy, the idea, the implementation are done, the order of operations are done. All right. I think we said in a in a previous episode, but you know, one of the examples is when we talk to families, we find out what's going on and you find out, you know, one of the children is is got a disability. And he's like, whoa, are you guys getting the disability tax credit? no, what is that? Go through the application process. Well, we can't do all of it, but we can lead them to start the application process. You could do that now through your My CRA portal online. And then it pushes it to your family doctor. Your family doctor signs off. CRA will give you the disability tax credit. But some of the families that we've talked to, they already were getting the tax credit that they hadn't opened RESP or RDSP yet, the registered disability savings plan yet. If you've been receiving the tax credit and you haven't started the account, you can actually reclaim or are some of the past contribution room as well as some of the grants. And so it could be a lot of money in grant money sitting there for you. That is really the value of an advisor, is seeing the playing field for more than the topic that we're looking at, but actually what's happening in your whole life and finding areas to essentially find money. There are programs that are available to you. Are you taking advantage of this? This is a good tax break for you. Make sure you save your receipts so you write this off. Those little sidebar conversations add so much value. And like we don't, we typically don't track the dollar value that we bring. but it's thousands and thousands of dollars of value. If somebody's gonna choose to be DIY and do it yourself and they're determined to do that, because there's so many, there's so many places where you can do that now, whether that's wealth simple or quest trade or e-trade or whatever platform you're gonna use. I highly recommend the first investment that you do is the consumer version of the Canadian Securities course. It's about 700 bucks. Huge investment in your investment knowledge. you can still make mistakes, but at least when you look backwards and you do an autopsy, you can understand where you made the mistakes because you've had a little bit of training and you have some knowledge at your fingertips. So that would be my recommendation. If you want to do it yourself, the first investment you should make is in. your education and do the Canadian Securities course. We do not have a discount code link in bel in the comments below, but maybe we should get one. Vishal Gill, CFP: No doubt, no doubt. amazing. Well, we'll leave you all with that. hope this helped clarify the AUM side. There really is a fee that you're paying no matter what. It's either flat fee, hourly, AUM, or in mistakes. All that is compounding against you because less money that you're investing. So all things are really equal at the end of the day. It's more so, you know, what are you really getting out of it? And I think that's the real question is what should you demand out of your relationship with your financial advisor? And just what's out there. and that's like the last thing you could do is, you know, as this year winds down and if if you don't even meet with your advisor, I think that that's telling on its own. but if you do meet your advisor, it's one of those things that you can kind of gauge of like w what am I really getting out of this relationship versus what else is out there? and of course, if you want to hire a new financial planning firm, we're open for business. you can also access our booking calendar in our show notes. I'm pretty sure it's there. If not, you can find a social media portfolio planning or wherever, visit our website. but it's a Good time at the end the year to get a state of the fairs, look at your statements, look at your fees, look at, what's going on. And if you want 2027 to be different than 2026, make some changes. And hopefully this was some information to arm you with doing so. So with that being said, we'll see you guys on the next episode of Portfolio Talks.