Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing an Employee Who Always Says I Know
Transcript
- Lucas: So you give a team member a piece of feedback — something straightforward, like "hey, next time you send that report, could you include the regional breakdown?" — and they look you in the eye and say, "I know." Luna: Ah, the classic. And then they keep sending the report without the breakdown. You're thinking, okay, if you knew, why didn't you do it? Lucas: Right. That phrase — "I know" — it's one of the most common but frustrating responses a manager gets. And it's not always malicious. It can mean a few different things. Today we're going to unpack that single phrase and give you some scripts for the next time you hear it. Luna: Good. Because my first instinct is usually to get annoyed, and I know that's not helpful. Lucas: Yeah, totally. And annoyance is natural. But the best managers pause and ask: what's underneath the "I know"? There are at least three distinct possibilities. First, the employee genuinely does know but hasn't internalized it as a priority. Second, they don't actually know but are afraid to admit it. Third, they're using it as a conversational shut-down — like, "I know, stop talking." Luna: That third one is the hardest. How do you even begin to address that without escalating? Lucas: Let's start with the first one, because it's the most fixable. Say a developer on your team — let's call her Priya — always says "I know" when you mention code review comments. She's senior, she knows the codebase. But the behavior doesn't change. So you might say, "I hear you know that, and I believe you do. But I'm noticing the output still has the same issue. Help me understand the gap." Luna: That's good. It's not accusatory. It's saying, I see a disconnect between your knowledge and your action — let's solve it together. Lucas: Exactly. Often the gap is a lack of systems or habits, not a lack of knowledge. Priya might need a checklist or a template. Or she might be overwhelmed and skipping steps. The "I know" is her way of saying, "I'm aware, but I'm choosing to do something else." Luna: Okay, what about the second type — the one who doesn't actually know but says they do? Lucas: That's the fear-driven one. Maybe a junior analyst named Marcus. You ask if he understands the new financial model, and he says "I know" — but he really doesn't. He's afraid looking incompetent will hurt his standing. The best move there is to depersonalize the knowledge. You can say, "This model trips up a lot of people. Let's walk through it together — I want to make sure we're on the same page." Luna: That takes the pressure off. You're giving him permission to not know. Lucas: Right. And you can follow up with a specific question. Instead of "Do you get it?" — which invites a yes — ask "What's the first step you'd take if you were building this from scratch?" That tests understanding without putting them on the spot. Luna: And the third type — the shutdown. What do you do when it feels like a power move? Lucas: That's the trickiest. If someone is saying "I know" to end the conversation, you need to address the pattern directly, but with curiosity. In a one-on-one, you might say, "I've noticed that when I bring up certain topics, you respond with 'I know.' I want to make sure I'm not overwhelming you with things you already have covered. Could we try a different approach?" Luna: That puts the ball in their court. You're not accusing them of being rude; you're offering to adapt. Lucas: And if they're genuinely shutting down, they might open up about feeling micromanaged or being bored. That's useful information. But if they continue the pattern, you may need to be more direct: "When you say 'I know,' I'm not sure if the message has landed. Can you tell me in your own words what you're taking away from this?" Luna: I like that. It's a gentle accountability check. And it works for all three types, really. Lucas: One thing I want to emphasize — don't let "I know" become a habit in your team culture. If one person does it and no one calls it out, others may adopt it. You want a culture where people feel safe saying "I'm not sure" or "Can you show me again?" Luna: That reminds me: I heard a story about a manager who actually banned the phrase "I know" from one-on-ones. He told his team, "Instead, say 'I recall' or 'I've seen that' — because saying 'I know' closes the door, but saying 'I recall' invites a conversation." Lucas: That's a smart linguistic hack. It shifts from certainty to curiosity. And we could all use a little more curiosity in our feedback conversations. Look, speaking of keeping conversations open — we're able to have these honest, detailed conversations on this show because we don't run any ads. No sponsor breaks, no pre-rolls, no mid-rolls. And that's a choice we make deliberately, because we want this to be a resource you can trust, not a marketing vehicle. Luna: Yeah, and the way that stays sustainable is through listener support. If you've ever found yourself using a tactic from one of our episodes — or even just nodding along — and you want to help keep the show ad-free, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: And every contribution genuinely helps us keep putting out episodes like this one. Back to managing the "I know" — there's one more scenario I want to cover. What if the person saying "I know" is actually your peer or even someone more senior? Luna: Oh, that's a whole different dynamic. If it's someone you can't formally manage, the approach has to change. Lucas: Exactly. With a peer, you might say, "I hear that you know this, and I respect your experience. I'm coming at it from a different angle — can I share what I'm seeing?" That frames it as collaboration, not correction. With a senior person, you might ask a question that invites them to teach you: "I know you're familiar with this process. Could you walk me through how you approach it? I want to make sure I'm not missing anything." Luna: That's disarming. You're acknowledging their expertise while subtly opening the door for a deeper conversation. Lucas: Here's another technique: use the phrase "for the record." Say, "For the record, I know you know this, but I want to make sure we're aligned — can we quickly review the steps?" It acknowledges their knowledge while still getting the confirmation you need. Luna: That's a nice buffer. It makes it less about them not knowing and more about team alignment. Lucas: And finally, if you're the one who says "I know" too often — and I've caught myself doing it — try replacing it with something like "I've seen that" or "I'm familiar with that approach." It keeps the conversation open rather than shutting it down. Luna: Self-awareness is key. If you model that behavior as a manager, your team will follow. Lucas: Let's recap the three types: the genuine knower who needs a system, the fearful pretender who needs safety, and the shuts-down who needs a direct but curious conversation. And the universal tool: ask them to paraphrase in their own words. Luna: That's a solid toolkit. I think the takeaway is that "I know" is rarely just about knowledge. It's about emotion, culture, and communication style. Lucas: Exactly. And as a manager, your job isn't to judge the phrase — it's to understand what's behind it. Thanks for listening, and we'll see you next week.