Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / BREAKING: Alabama FIve-Star Quarterback Signee Julian Sayin Transferring To Ohio State
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman.
- 0:04Here as always with Tom or Tom. How is it going? Yeah?
- 0:12You always say here is always with Tom Moore, But man, it
- 0:15feels like it really is like always. It feels like we're doing a breaking
- 0:20news podcast about every sixty to ninety minutes or so at this point. Here
- 0:26we are in the off season. Uh huh, off season, Tony?
- 0:30Remember remember when the off season was the thing? Hey, Tony, guess
- 0:32what. There's more news for Ohio State football. Yeah, there is more
- 0:37news as Alabama incoming freshman quarterback Julian's Saying is transferring to Ohio State, saying
- 0:44was the top quarterback in the twenty twenty four class. I'll give you all
- 0:49of the recruiting service rankings here. He was number one in the A quarterback
- 0:54for ON three, the number seven player overall. Twenty four seven Sports had
- 0:58him as the number three quarterback, the number twenty one player overall, ESPN
- 1:00had him as the number one quarterback, number three player overall, Rivals had
- 1:06him as is the number two quarterback, the number four player overall, and
- 1:08everybody but twenty four to seven had him as the number one player from California's
- 1:11from Carlsbad, California. And I think anytime you can get the number one
- 1:15player in California, you should probably go and do it, even if it
- 1:19takes him going to another school first, as it did with Julian Saying.
- 1:23And we've seen the incredible fallout from Nick Saban's retirement, and you probably listen
- 1:30to other shows that we've talked about the Caleb downs transfer and commitment to Ohio
- 1:34State referred back to that one. But Tom, this is is this unnecessary?
- 1:42Is what unnecessary? Bringing in Julian saying or doing a podcast Julian saying
- 1:49it all, this all feels necessary kind of whatever the question is, it
- 1:52feels necessary? This is I mean, you mentioned the national recruiting rankings.
- 1:57That is as consensus a top of the kind of guy as you're going to
- 2:01find. On top of that, he was the Gatoraded Player of the Year
- 2:05in the state of California, which is a whole separate evaluation process. He
- 2:08was also the MVP of the Elite eleven Finals last year, which is a
- 2:13whole separate evaluation process. At some point, you know you're going to have
- 2:17the you know, reasonable minds can disagree kind of conversation, especially about evaluating
- 2:22high school football players. This is one where everybody is kind of tony,
- 2:28if you will pardon the pun, saying the same thing. It is all
- 2:32the recruiting services Elite eleven gatored player of the Year that tells me he can
- 2:38do the camp thing, has the arm, can make all the throws,
- 2:42but also it's translating to the field and also it's projectable because all the I
- 2:46mean, that's it, Like that's the whole package. There's there is not
- 2:51some other element of evaluation that you you know, that is out there that
- 2:55it's like, well, but they're not talking about this, like no,
- 2:58that's it. That's that's the whole. Yeah, it is impressive the overall
- 3:01opinion on him. And it's not like he's put up huge numbers. This
- 3:07is guy in his three years starting as a quarterback high school through four twenty
- 3:12four hundred and forty seven yards as a senior, and the most he threw
- 3:15four was as a sophomore twenty seven hundred and sixty nine yards, So like
- 3:19between twenty three hundred and twenty hundred yards is what he's done as a senior
- 3:23through twenty four touchdowns and just one interception. He's six foot one, one
- 3:28ninety five. The thing that people talk about him is just the feel for
- 3:30the game, the ball placement, the easy throws, Like you watch him
- 3:35and you don't see this gigantic arm or anything. But because I think,
- 3:39because he makes it look pretty easy. He can also run some. You
- 3:44know, he's not just He's certainly not just a statute pocket passer. Like
- 3:46I said, he's sixty one one ninety five, so probably grew up having
- 3:50to run a little bit, being a maybe not the biggest quarterback maybe on
- 3:54the I can't even say the smaller side, but necessary to run and then
- 3:58he will run when but has been a prodigy basically everywhere he's gone. Committed
- 4:06to Alabama I think November of twenty twenty two, Ohio State wasn't really in
- 4:15on him because they had a commitment from Dylan Roola, so they just,
- 4:18you know, we're gonna ride with Dylan Roola. Dylan Rayola decommits December seventeenth,
- 4:25I think, twenty twenty two, and one month later, Ohio State
- 4:29offers Julian Saying and saying had already been committed to Alabama, for a couple
- 4:33of months. You know, Ohio State had to try, didn't necessarily obviously,
- 4:38maybe went somewhere. He was happy to receive the offer, but he
- 4:40stayed at Alabama. Ohio State then goes out offers Aaron Noland in the spring.
- 4:45They get a commitment from him, so they're done. But then Nick
- 4:49Saban goes and retires, and you have Julian saying knocking on your door,
- 4:55and you have to be like, well, we're in the business of getting
- 5:00as much talent as possible in our room, but you also need to talk
- 5:05to the room about it, don't you. Well, you do have to
- 5:09talk to the room about it. And this is kind of one of the
- 5:13new realities of college football is you can have someone who just signed with Alabama
- 5:19a month ago, like it was December twentieth, so it was, you
- 5:24know, just about a month ago, and then he's in the portal and
- 5:29then you have the opportunity to add someone before National Dining Day even happens.
- 5:33This is you know, he's already signed in this class and you have an
- 5:35opportunity to now add him to your class for the class of twenty twenty four.
- 5:41I think you obviously have to have conversations with your guys about it.
- 5:45But the goal here for Ryan Day and the Buckeyes is the best possible team
- 5:53on the field. That's the goal. And this is you know, every
- 5:58position, you're competing with the best guys in the country at your position group.
- 6:01You know this is Brian Hartline is not thinking, well, do I
- 6:04want to bring in one more good wide receiver? He just goes and gets
- 6:06another good wide receiver. Tim Walton is not thinking, do I want to
- 6:13bring in another five star corner? I boy, I'm not sure it might
- 6:15hurt people's feelings like you bring in another five star corner. And those places,
- 6:18those positions are a little different because you're playing one quarterback for the most
- 6:21part, and you know you're playing more than one corner, more than one
- 6:24wide receiver, but you're trying to stack the most talent that you possibly can.
- 6:30Too many good quarterbacks in a room that sounds like a problem. You
- 6:34can make that sound like a problem. That's not actually a problem. That's
- 6:36that's a good thing. And you don't expect guys to come in and start
- 6:41their first year, and you don't want your guys to have to come in
- 6:44and start their first year. So come in, get developed, and then
- 6:47see where things go from there. I you know, we'll see how this
- 6:50you know what kind of impact this has in the quarterback room. But you
- 6:54know, when you have the opportunity to bring in a player like this,
- 6:58you bring in a player like this. Yeah, Malie Hartford is safety very
- 7:02encouraging, impressive freshman year, true freshman to be out there in the spots
- 7:08that he was obviously a very bright future. You don't need to ask twice.
- 7:12If you have the opportunity to bring in a Kale Downs, you bring
- 7:15in a Kale Downs. There's a lot of talent in that Ohio State quarterback
- 7:18room. Now there's just a little more talent in that the Ohio State quarterback
- 7:21room. Well even real quickly, the conversation with Malie Cartford and Caleb Downs.
- 7:28Having Caleb Downs on this roster is going to make Millie Cartford a better
- 7:30player. That is from playing with him, watching him, just competing with
- 7:36him. And the same goes for the quarterback situation. I do wonder as
- 7:42a staff talked it over, the offensive staff talked it over, then you
- 7:46could I'm just imagining, like you have Brian day, Bill O'Brien, Brian
- 7:51Hartline, maybe Corey Dennis all saying hey, Air, we need to talk
- 7:57to you. This is what we're thinking. What do you think? And
- 8:01a eighteen nineteen year old quarterback with those four guys just kind of maybe like
- 8:09not putting pressure on you, But you don't want to say at that moment,
- 8:13I don't want to compete. You know, at that moment, you're
- 8:15probably like, I don't care who you bring in, bring in whoever you
- 8:18want, because I'm going to compete. And that may be like that would
- 8:22in theory like a reaction to that kind of meaning, or that just may
- 8:24be who you are. And at quarterback, that's what they want to see
- 8:28and whatever the situation is, coaches love to see how their quarterbacks react to
- 8:37tough situations on the field, off the field. It all is data that
- 8:41they use. And this is one more And do you want to be the
- 8:46guy who they're like Coaches convinced say hey, we're thinking of doing this.
- 8:50How do you feel about it? And the quarterback is like, no,
- 8:54I don't think you should do that. That would you know, I it
- 8:56would have to be a conversation where you know, you'd be like, well,
- 9:00you told me you weren't going Like if there is a specific lie told,
- 9:03this is not I don't. This is no lie. This is a
- 9:07situation where they brought in Aaron Noland. They didn't say we're not gonna get
- 9:09anybody or you know, you're you know, this is the entire circumstance has
- 9:15changed. So you have this opportunity. And it's also an opportunity for air
- 9:20Nolan. Again, it's more competition. It is, you know, a
- 9:24challenge, and with the quarterback competition that there's gonna be so many quarterback competitions
- 9:33this year. Tom, you got the top of the line, you've got
- 9:35the the young part of the line. And I guarantee Tom, they're gonna
- 9:41be splitting up the two practice sessions with the quarterbacks and the offenses again where
- 9:46they're just going, going, going, they may need three I'm just gonna
- 9:50say that now. But they've got enough fields for it. But I also
- 9:54think you do what your quarterbacks on the roster year and quarterbacks, I think
- 9:56air Nolan is saying, yeah, go ahead and bring this whatever. I
- 10:00don't care, I'm going to compete. I think that is also a good
- 10:03thing. Well, I don't think you get to the point where airon Noland
- 10:09is where you were one of the top quarterback prospects in the country, and
- 10:11you know, he was ranked all the way down as what like the number
- 10:15fifth, number five, number four kind of prospect in the country at quarterback.
- 10:18You know, he's not exactly any kind of a slouch either, And
- 10:22you don't get to that point to be that kind of quarterback at you know,
- 10:28playing in Georgia and kind of big, big school Georgia football. You
- 10:31don't get to be that at that point if you're just kind of scared to
- 10:35compete. That's you. You are not scared to compete if you're competing at
- 10:39that level because you've always been the best guy wherever you've been playing. So
- 10:43yeah, I don't I don't think this is something that should be immediately chasing
- 10:46air Nolan into the portal or anything like that. And he doesn't actually have
- 10:50the option to go in the portal yet. He would have to wait until
- 10:52at least after spring ball to do that. And that's true of anyone who
- 10:56on the Ohaistate roster unless they have graduated, with which none of their quarter
- 11:00have. So this is this is all a little bit of a theoretical conversation
- 11:03right now. But yeah, if you're the you know, if you are
- 11:07a quarterback who's now been on campus for two weeks, what do you what
- 11:09are you going to say? Like, no, no, thank you,
- 11:11I respectfully decline your offer. And you know, this is like the UN
- 11:15Security Council where I can I can vote no and that makes the means that
- 11:18doesn't happen. That's that's not how it works. So you know this is
- 11:22I very much doubt that er Noland, you know, approached Brian Day during
- 11:28the recruiting process and said so hypothetically, if Nick Saban retires and then Julian
- 11:33Saying goes in the portal, would then would you be interested in him?
- 11:37Like, I don't think that's probably how that how that played out. But
- 11:41again, if you can bring in this kind of talent, you do it.
- 11:43And there is a track record of guys who you go through the year
- 11:50or two with Ryan Day at Ohio State, you learn from him, and
- 11:54then if you don't win the starting job, then maybe you transfer if you're
- 11:58a year or two in. I mean, this was the Joe Burrow story
- 12:03leaving Ohio State when he was not sure he was going to be win the
- 12:07starting job against Dwayne Haskins. When yours came to Ohio State for a year,
- 12:11it was pretty apparent that c. J. Stroud was going to be
- 12:13the starter for another year after that, and so then he transferred to Texas
- 12:16and he's done just fine with himself. So you know, coming to Ohio
- 12:20State for a year, two years, whatever you learn, you fight for
- 12:26the position when the you know when there's a positional battle, and then you
- 12:30see where it goes from there. I don't I don't think there's any reason
- 12:33you'd need to immediately hit the portal if you're ar Nolan. Yeah, and
- 12:37and it will be an interesting watch this spring when you have Will Howard,
- 12:41Devin Brown, Lincoln Keenholes, Jillian's saying Aaron Noland at this point, I
- 12:48would expect Will Howard and Devin Brown to be competing for the starting job,
- 12:52and then the three youngsters a little bit off on their own, but getting
- 12:56as many reps as possible because this day and age now, you do need
- 13:01to get guys reps in order to make them feel like they have a chance
- 13:03or that they are engaged, and you need to keep them engaged and also
- 13:07continue to improve so that they have an opportunity to compete. So, boy,
- 13:13it has been an interesting January, and it was going to be.
- 13:16It's gonna be a fascinating March and April, and we will be here for
- 13:20all of it. As you know. You can find us at the Buckey
- 13:24Huddle dot com. We will be talking about this for a while longer.
- 13:28You can find us on the message board the Huddle message board there, have
- 13:31become a member, join up. A ton of stuff going on there,
- 13:33a ton of discussions about all of these new editions, and even though all
- 13:37of this is happening, people are still like, I want more, I
- 13:39want more, give me more, I need more portal players. And who
- 13:43knows. There is still plenty of time for some of these coaching changes to
- 13:46shake some things out. But there should be enough. You should you should
- 13:50have enough by now. You should be satisfied with what you've got. But
- 13:54you can also find us at YouTube dot com slash Bucke Huddle. If you
- 13:58have not yet liked this video, if you're watching, please do. We
- 14:00would appreciate that, and of course, at the bell to be notified when
- 14:03we do any more emergency Instant Reaction live shows because this will not be the
- 14:09last one, so thank you all for tuning in and we'll talk to you guys later