Latest / Falcon Forward / State Farm’s Commission Cuts: Why Independent Agents Still Win
Transcript
- Peter Brecht: All right, welcome to Falcon Forward. I did get an email from YouTube and Spotify saying that we have finally published more podcast episodes than 90% ⁓ of podcasts out there. So ⁓ congratulations, Mike. We're we're doing okay. ⁓ that it really ⁓ it it is a very low bar. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Pretty well bar. Peter Brecht: but anyways, ⁓ as with insurance, there's always something new coming up. There's always something to learn. So we have endless things to talk about, ⁓ which is both good and bad for people listening, I guess. But ⁓ today we're talking about State Farm. We're just gonna jump into it. We've got a lot going on today outside of this, but we wanted to to get an episode out and just ⁓ share some news. So what's going on with State Farm? Mike Tanghe: Yeah, ⁓ so to your point, ⁓ You know, if you're looking for it, insurance is always in the new I mean, everything from the Middle East conflict, you know, why are these ships slow to start moving again? It's insurance companies saying, you know, hey, if we're gonna be on the hook for a multi potentially, you know, hundreds of millions of dollars exposure, ⁓ we'd to know some things are in place before we do that. And certainly the if you've been following that closely, the the back and forth and different differing opinions being said on on each side of of things ⁓ gives pause. So insurance really drives that you look around and see. and ⁓ we ⁓ take have a very vested interest in what's going on in the insurance world and and ⁓ even though things don't necessarily directly impact us, like ⁓ the Wall Street Journal just had come up with an article on State Farm, which we'll go into a little bit more detail. ⁓ it's still quite interesting to ⁓ for us to follow that just to see because peripherally it does Touch us here at Falcon West, ⁓ which we'll go into again in greater detail. But ⁓ yeah. ⁓ should we talk a little bit about State Farm and their comp plan changes? Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Let's do it. ⁓ I'm I'm curious. I read some stuff, but ⁓ probably not gonna have the same in depth ⁓ analysis as Mike, so Mike Tanghe: Yeah. so State Farm, I think started over over a hundred years, I think it's 104 years ago ⁓ was when they started. they nineteen thousand agents that sell just state farm products. So we here at Falcon West cannot sell state farm, we're not a a state farm appointed ⁓ agent. those who are, so those nineteen thousand ⁓ only can sell state farm products, so they cannot sell ⁓ other people's products. State Farm, the largest insurer of personal auto, the largest insurer of homes across the country. So I mean this is a massive, massive organization on it. And you know, of course there are commercials, there's there are tag lines, all that. Very well-known company on it. ⁓ so what has changed for them in the past years? State Farm's model is to sell through these agents. and you know, those agents will have their shingle up in whatever town or community that they live in, they're active in that community. and their model. that's a expensive model to do so when you're selling has become a very commoditized product, which is personal ⁓ auto insurance and to some degree home insurance, although people haven't figured that out as well. ⁓ on the auto insurance. know who who's the competition for State Farm? That would be companies like a Geico or a Progressive that is spending you know massive amounts on marketing, but then also even more massive amounts on technology and automation and trying to really ⁓ much can they squeeze the costs of that product down? So you have State Farm, which is you know, this I'll call it more of a legacy company that has 19,000 agents out there, ⁓ then you Have these companies like a progressive will sell through independent agents, that they don't necessarily have to support. It's you know, if we sell it, ⁓ so we are a progressive appointed agent along with you tens of thousands of other people out there. But progressive ⁓ also sells ⁓ direct ⁓ to the consumer, ⁓ so bypasses the agent. and you know progressive, I think over half their premiums are sold direct where they're not ⁓ in involving an agent. So what does that do for progressive? That obviously keeps their costs lower and that they don't have to pay an agent ⁓ in that transaction. and so for something like auto insurance, again, that in my opinion is very commoditized. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: For the mass market purchaser, that model has worked for progressive. And so they've seen their market share steadily climb, and State Farm has seen theirs eroded over the years. So, you know, questionable. ⁓ And I don't know anything about the CEO of State Farm. ⁓ I know if he rose through the ranks as a salesperson. I do know though, having both been a salesperson ⁓ and then also led salespeople, you know, a tough way to go out and sell more products is to tell your existing salesforce. That you're going to cut their compensation. that generally doesn't ⁓ bring out a whole lot of goodwill or ⁓ boost morale amongst the troops ⁓ and stuff. Not saying that things didn't need to change ⁓ with their company, but again, a pretty tough way to approach it. And you know, time will tell if the their ⁓ CEO is still in his job in a couple years or not. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Right. One thing I was thinking about is are is state farm banking on the fact that a lot of these state farm agents have put their entire livelihood behind building their agencies that, yeah, okay, we're gonna lead with the bad news, we're cutting your commissions, but then trusting that sticky factor of you've already put your entire life into this and you're just gonna take a you know, take a hit because you you can't you don't wanna lose the whole thing. You'd rather just take Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: less than than you know, I don't know if they're kind of thinking through that, but that seems to be the strategy. And I have a friend who works for Allstate and, you know, very similar model. ⁓ they've changed, you know, commission structures and, you know, hey, you gotta s you know, sell this many products to each client and or you don't get your bonus. I mean, there's so many things that go on in the back end too, but that, you know, the general public doesn't think about. But I'm wondering if they th if they thought through that and that was kind of the approach. That that'd be my that's my guess, but it's not a very Fun one. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, no, in in and great guess. And you know, one of the things we can do is kind of speculate on what was the motivation or what is ⁓ the the logic on it. I ⁓ my opinion, I think you'd be better but a hundred percent there be you know, you're if you're a state farm agent, you don't have a lot of options other than ⁓ your agency to State Farm, ⁓ 'cause they are independent contractors ⁓ on it, and then ⁓ attempting to restart ⁓ somewhere else. And I have friends who who who've done that ⁓ both Peter Brecht: Yeah. Mike Tanghe: farmers agents, state farm agents that have come over to the independent side. It's obviously that's a very long-term play, right? So if you're in your 60s, you know, would you do something like that? Probably not. in your 50s, yeah, much more likely. And certainly if you're a younger person, I think I think you'll see a lot more of those folks be like, hey, I don't want to, you know, ⁓ and even to think about, like, you know, if you hadn't if you were banking on something like this, hopefully the people that are closer to retirement age you know, will change their their direction. But ⁓ hopefully it's not, you know th they're not gonna be penniless on this. ⁓ which no Peter Brecht: Yeah. Well and also, I mean, it changes the value of your book of business and your business. So if you're gonna go sell your book to another state farm agent, which is the only person you could sell it to, the value that you know goes down along with the commissions too, I'd imagine. So I it's that's that's just not a that's a very difficult thing to look at if if if your legacy is tied up in in something like that. But I I ⁓ and and I'd I I'm I'm Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Yeah. Peter Brecht: Curious, I mean, from your perspective, like you know, you've been doing this for a long time. I am why did you not why did you choose the independent model versus state farm? I think that's something I'm curious about because it to me it'd be a no brainer. Like I get to sell more than one product, I get to have more carrier relationships, I get that versatility for my client versus state farm. Like what what's the value for state farm, right? I I do think must be the network or something like that. I don't know. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, you know, what they would sell would be their exclusivity. Like other people can't access our products. so that would be the selling model ⁓ of it. And I started my career working for a direct writer. ⁓ so it was it was a different company, federated insurance. They have a bit more of a business focus than they do the personal focus that a state farm does. but in ⁓ when was brand new in the industry and you know, new zero, and you know, was twenty-two years old, it was that was a actually a great start because they tried. trained you, here is our product. Here is everything you need to know about our product. Here's the people who will buy our product. Here's how you reach those people in their product. And that was all great for someone who is 22. didn't have a network built up. I didn't know people that were were potential buyers. When I later made this switch, so when I was in my you know eight years of professional experience, my friends had been starting companies and and you know I I had a bit more of a track record under my belt where I could go into business owners ⁓ Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: talk to them on a more equal level. I want to be hobbled by that, okay, because State Farm will only write you know what what is in their appetite. And if you met someone who's like, hey Mike, I think you're the greatest person in the world and I want you to write all my insurance and I have this massive portfolio of products and which is how I've built my business, which is through those relationships. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: If you're a state farm or federated and that business doesn't fall into what their category is, you gotta be like, hey, I'm really sorry. You know, I really enjoy getting to know you, and you have a great business and you're super successful, but I can't work with you because you don't f check fall into this box. So for me, that's the biggest reason of why not to go that route. because we will we can find options for literally any type of business that's out there. Peter Brecht: Yeah. Gotcha. Mike Tanghe: But the selling point would be is you know for that exclusivity. And in certain towns and stuff like that, where you know, if you're more of that main street small town business, ⁓ you know, having that that that state farm model, especially you can take over for someone else, it's kind of the just this proven thing, ⁓ it no surprise ⁓ it be that hey, eventually that that type of model is gonna go away, just like other ⁓ in town, you know, the the the the dry goods store or something like that, you know, they they That's not a sure ticket when you have Walmart opening up, you know, a a massive center that's way less costs ⁓ across town. That's a the equivalent of what we're seeing here is the mass ones kind of kicking out that and people can kind of lament it. Is it sad? ⁓ you know, I think that's just change, which is inevitable. Peter Brecht: Yeah. ⁓ I know we have a few minutes left here to s wrap this up, but ⁓ is there anything else that you want to touch on with this state farm change? Mike Tanghe: Yeah, you know so a couple things on it. So one, to me, it's a continual race to the commoditizing of certain types of products, which I think auto insurance can fall into that category. and it's really you you you're segmenting a market. So you in my opinion, there's three types of ⁓ of of people out there of consumers ⁓ on it. So you have those who want just the cheapest product possible with as little human interaction as possible. in the Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: That I think is who a progressive is appealing to. And I think what State Farm is trying to pivot towards is how can we employ, and as part of this article, they talked about how they now have an AI assistant that's when you have an auto claim. So you're complete you're you're not interacting with a human. So ⁓ if you're very neatly f fill into all these boxes, then that's kind of cool, because you can do it at any time you want, and the company doesn't have to staff for that. ⁓ ⁓ To me, that's not not a a viable model and frankly not anything I would enjoy. So that's kind of segment one. That's that customer. We're not targeting those customers. That's not someone that that ⁓ 'cause we wanna have a human interaction and we're not gonna sell you the absolute cheapest product. We'll sell you the right product at a good value, but we're not gonna just say, Here's your lowest premium, good luck ⁓ on that. There's also a subset of customers that value human interaction, so they don't want to necessarily buy everything online. But ⁓ them, it's what give me just the lowest cost, lowest cost, lowest costs. ⁓ again, that's not a customer for us because they're not valuing, ⁓ here's how insurance should work for you. Here's what it can protect, what you've built. ⁓ And then there's ⁓ smallest segment of the market, but this is the one that we're pursuing, are those who value the human interaction, but then also value what the Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: They're buying value that they need to make sure that they have the right insurance product in place so that if something unlucky happens to them, that it's not going to change their lifestyle ⁓ it. And those are the clients that that we're pursuing. ⁓ those are ⁓ not impacted, you know. Yes, they want to see efficiency and they want to see, you know, they don't like to waste time and all that, ⁓ at the end of the day, they want to be able to ⁓ up the phone, call you, and talk through that situation with them. And ⁓ I get it, there's a much, much bigger market out there in those other two. Categories, ⁓ that's great. That's who Progressive and State Farm will kind of chase themselves, in my opinion, a race to the bottom on. Well, at the same time, there is a market out there that does value what we provide and will continue to serve those clients and look for new ways that we can help them, we can be more efficient. Certainly, we're not sitting here saying, ⁓ we're always going to do things the same old way. Far from it. But at the of the day, we want to make sure that we're available to talk to people and talk them through their. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: unique situation and to make sure that what they're buying they understand and that it appropriately ⁓ matches the risks that they have ⁓ with their in unique situation. Peter Brecht: Hundred percent. Awesome. Well, hey guys, we're gonna wrap it up here. Mike and I have a strong nine thirty that we gotta jump off to. But thanks for listening to the podcast. We look forward to being here next week. ⁓ hoping to bring on some guests here in the next couple of weeks too, so you can hear some other voices besides me and Mike. So ⁓ have a great week and we'll see you again soon.