Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Noncompetes Across State Lines: Choice of Law in a Remote Workforce
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, I'm Belinda McCauley, CEO of the Beverly
- 0:06Hills Bar Association, and I'm delighted to be
- 0:09here today to introduce our speaker, the Honorable
- 0:11David S. Cunningham III. Judge Cunningham is
- 0:14a retired judge now in neutral with jams drawing
- 0:17on a distinguished legal and judicial career
- 0:19spanning more than four decades He served as
- 0:22supervising judge of the LA Superior Court's
- 0:25complex litigation program presiding over complex
- 0:28civil litigation mass torts class actions family
- 0:31law and probate matters and Earlier built a trial
- 0:34and civil litigation practice in both the public
- 0:36and private sectors beginning his career in the
- 0:39DOJ's civil rights division working on voting
- 0:41rights cases and later serving as president of
- 0:44the L .A. Police Commission during a pivotal
- 0:46era of institutional reform. Known for his impartiality,
- 0:51practical insight, and efficient respectful handling
- 0:54of complex legal and factual disputes, Judge
- 0:56Cunningham now serves as a mediator, arbitrator,
- 0:59and neutral evaluator. evaluator across a wide
- 1:03range of civil matters. Joining him today as
- 1:06moderator is Reggie Joseph, practice development
- 1:09manager at Jams. Reggie, I will happily turn
- 1:12the Zoom floor over to you. Thank you so much,
- 1:15Belinda, and thank you everybody for joining
- 1:17us and joining me in the honor of David Cunningham.
- 1:21I will get us started. Judge Cunningham, before
- 1:25we get into it, if you want to talk a little
- 1:27bit more about your background, just briefly
- 1:29and your practice and ADR at Jams really quickly.
- 1:34Well, certainly, I think what's most relevant
- 1:35to everyone is the class action work that we
- 1:38do here at Jams, at least at this stage. Certainly,
- 1:41we do a lot of dispute resolution as it relates
- 1:44to both employment related and commercial litigation.
- 1:48While I note that a significant portion of our
- 1:52arbitration and mediation work focuses on employment,
- 1:55it also focuses on business disputes. So I think
- 1:58this remote workers and the non -compete choice
- 2:01of law question actually has both a labor component
- 2:04to it and a business aspect to it in that it
- 2:07can arise in the context of business dissolutions
- 2:10as well. And not merely for waging our employees,
- 2:14but also for salary -exempt employees. In fact,
- 2:18these issues become particularly relevant for
- 2:20that class of employees, particularly in the
- 2:22context of when you have professional organizations
- 2:25or LLCs or other types of businesses that get
- 2:28sold that retain and have goodwill. So that's
- 2:31what our discussion is going to be about because
- 2:33one of the things we also recognize in today's
- 2:36commerce the state lines are not really where
- 2:40the work ends. In fact, now that we're in the
- 2:42digital age, the state lines are far more amorphous
- 2:47than they once were. And we'll get into why that
- 2:49matters. Perfect. And thank you, Judge. And just
- 2:52really quickly, before I share my screen with
- 2:54your PowerPoint, you mentioned it a little bit.
- 2:57But I mean, the article in today's topic is really
- 2:59important. I mean, we have a lot of people working
- 3:02hybrid and remote. Just talk a little bit about
- 3:03what the impetus of this article and this talk
- 3:06is and why it was important to you. Well, one
- 3:08of the things that struck me is I was trying
- 3:11to determine how I could be a thought leader
- 3:14in certain topics. I read from the Bureau of
- 3:17Labor Statistics, than an unbelievable close
- 3:19to 25 % of the labor force now works remotely.
- 3:24And it's a growing number of people. So it really
- 3:28is something that is not only contemporary, but
- 3:31it's also something that is expanding in terms
- 3:33of scale. And I think many of you will touch
- 3:36on these issues in your practice. Perfect. And
- 3:39I am going to share my screen now. And we will
- 3:42get started, Judge. All right, the genesis of
- 3:45our discussion today is based on the article
- 3:48that I wrote back in July published in the Daily
- 3:50Journal around mid -July that talks about workforce
- 3:54non -competes and primarily the issue of Charter
- 3:56Law at Battlefield. Next slide, please. Now,
- 4:03California has adopted a public policy that basically
- 4:07says employee non -compete agreements are per
- 4:11se invalid. The other states, and in the past,
- 4:15there's been a debate as to whether or not in
- 4:17the common law, you use the rule of reasonableness.
- 4:20What's the distinction? Under a public policy
- 4:23initiative that says employee non -compete agreements
- 4:26are unenforceable per se, you would think that's
- 4:29the end of the analysis. In the context of the
- 4:31reasonable analysis, you really have to get into
- 4:34the factual analysis of it to determine whether
- 4:37or not a non -compete heat provision is enforceable.
- 4:43But the old question basically had been, is this
- 4:46restriction reasonable? In fact, as you'll see,
- 4:50as the case law has developed and California
- 4:53has adopted certain statutes, the question really
- 4:56is changing now to which state gets to decide.
- 5:01Next slide, please. So I want to start out with
- 5:03a hypothetical. Let's say that you've got an
- 5:06employee, and this employee is basically working
- 5:11from home in California on their computer for
- 5:15a Massachusetts employer, we won't necessarily
- 5:19state what the industry is at this point, that
- 5:22has New York customers and they're incorporated
- 5:25in Delaware. So that gives you an idea of the
- 5:28scope of the question and that's the hypothetical
- 5:30we'll be working on that we'll move to later.
- 5:33Basically in the context of the type of work,
- 5:36some of the facts that you'll be looking at is
- 5:39where does the employee live and work, where
- 5:43is the employee managed and where are their tasks,
- 5:47where is the relevant market, and then ultimately,
- 5:51where is the home or some of the primary activities
- 5:54of the employer. Next slide, please. Now, a non
- 6:03-compete agreement restrains post -employment
- 6:07competition. So the idea is that you are restricting
- 6:11a person's ability to one, in the work context,
- 6:15join a competitor, two, to go out and take your
- 6:19information and business that they've learned
- 6:21from their employer and start a competing business,
- 6:24or ultimately to perform certain defined competitive
- 6:28activities, certain outreaches to other types
- 6:30of clients, or to provide certain activity to
- 6:33them. So if you would turn to our handout, Reggie.
- 6:39because merely because you have a handout page
- 6:41two, if you could. And ladies and gentlemen,
- 6:44there is a handout that's been posted. Rather
- 6:47than post the citations and some of the case
- 6:50law in the PowerPoints, my preference would be
- 6:54just to use the PowerPoints as a talking point.
- 6:57But if you look at the handout, they will give
- 6:59you the detail. And I wanted to direct you to
- 7:02page two and. Starting on page two, we talk about
- 7:06what are some of the exceptions to the non -complete,
- 7:09non -compete provisions. One is if you have sale
- 7:12of a business goodwill. So you have business
- 7:16and professions code section 16601, which allows
- 7:20non -compete agreements concerning the sale of
- 7:22business. The non -compete agreement for employees
- 7:25can apply if there's an exception in the dissolution
- 7:28of a partnership. And then ultimately you should
- 7:30be aware that another exception would be in the
- 7:33context of a limited liability company members.
- 7:36There's a distinction as to whether or not it's
- 7:38member managed, whether or not you have a managing
- 7:41member or general members, and the fiduciary
- 7:43duties that arise that are statutory in that
- 7:46context. Next slide, please. The idea, next slide.
- 7:55Slide five. So the idea is, You are attempting
- 7:59to protect the assets of the business, but you
- 8:03do not want to limit employee mobility. So what
- 8:07are the types of things that you actually are
- 8:09seeking to protect? One would be trade secrets,
- 8:13the other would be goodwill, and the other would
- 8:16be the investments that a business has made.
- 8:18If you can turn to the handout, page eight, Reggie.
- 8:29And ladies and gentlemen, if you can read along
- 8:31with us, I would direct you specifically starting
- 8:35on page eight through page nine of the handout
- 8:38where we talk about in greater detail what are
- 8:41some of the particular statutory exceptions and
- 8:44also the trade secret protection exception. It
- 8:47is in great detail. It's a separate statute that
- 8:50is civil code section 3426 to 3426 .211, and
- 8:57it operates in the context of certain employment
- 8:59contracts, addressing trade secrets. That is
- 9:03the method in which you can independently protect
- 9:07your certain business assets. So in the context
- 9:09of a non -compete employee provision, you may
- 9:13also want to have a separate trade secret agreement
- 9:16or agreement that protects your proprietary interests.
- 9:20You want to make sure that they are distinct
- 9:22because ultimately you may have a problem if
- 9:24you're trying to enforce an integrated agreement
- 9:27that would include a non -compete provision for
- 9:30an employee. Let's move to the next statute,
- 9:38slide six. Now, you will discover that because
- 9:42California has the per se rule, most other states
- 9:46are looking at enforcing a reasonableness standard,
- 9:50but there is a move to at least limit the extent
- 9:54and application of non -compete employment agreements.
- 9:57Originally, the feds got involved and the FTC
- 10:01had originally adopted a rule that sought to
- 10:03have a national ban on non -compete employee
- 10:07agreements. And indeed, the FTC in 2024 adopted
- 10:11such a rule, but then it was challenged in court
- 10:14and ultimately the FTC removed its national ban
- 10:20on non -compete agreements, and now it has to
- 10:23be analyzed by state law. So you cannot assume
- 10:26that there is any federal immunity, and the FTC
- 10:29rule no longer is applicable. Next slide, please.
- 10:35So I just wanted to take a moment to talk about
- 10:38what the states are doing in this context, because
- 10:40I do think it's important for you to know that
- 10:43the non -compete rules are changing. that it
- 10:46varies from state to state. There does not appear
- 10:50that there will be a long -term national perspective.
- 10:54So you wanna look at what the states are doing
- 10:56and we'll talk about California in a moment because
- 10:59California basically has a broad band. There
- 11:03are also other states that have statutory limitations
- 11:06including the state of California that we'll
- 11:08talk about as it has changed its non -compete
- 11:11rules and making it a separate cause of action
- 11:15if you do have, you attempt to enforce a non
- 11:20-compete employment provision in the state of
- 11:22California. Problems arise when you have businesses
- 11:25that are operating throughout the United States.
- 11:28Ultimately, there's certain limits in terms of
- 11:31notice, the role that you play, and the industry
- 11:33that it's in from a state -to -state perspective.
- 11:37And when states look at reasonableness, they
- 11:39look at the interest that you're protecting,
- 11:42the duration of the non -compete, the scope,
- 11:45and the territorial limitations. Now some of
- 11:48the states are currently, you've got California
- 11:52that adopt the per se rule. You've got several
- 11:56states that had pending litigation, which I talked
- 11:58about in my article. One was New York. New York
- 12:01had SB 335, which basically set up an antitrust
- 12:05violation and market situations where there's
- 12:08only one buyer for the buyer to enact a non -compete.
- 12:12Apparently that was not adopted. New York had
- 12:15HB 1381, but apparently that has also not been
- 12:19adopted. South Carolina has a bill pending to
- 12:22try to restrict non -competes. Washington will
- 12:26go into that has some standards that they've
- 12:29adopted. That's the state of Washington. Other
- 12:31states look at and regulate non -competes. based
- 12:35upon the particular industry. For example, I
- 12:38looked at Missouri, where they have legislation
- 12:41pending that would limit non -competes of physicians
- 12:43working at certain types of facilities owned
- 12:46by a non -profit corporation. Also, Missouri
- 12:51is attempting to completely ban non -complete
- 12:54agreements as they apply to physicians. So there's
- 12:57also a focus on the health care industry and
- 13:00certain types of professions. Throughout the
- 13:03state, I won't go into great detail, but all
- 13:06of the various states are looking at changing
- 13:08from the reasonableness standard to some form
- 13:11of regulation based on the industry type and
- 13:15certain notices that you have and whether or
- 13:17not it's a key employee. Let's move to the next
- 13:20slide. Slide number eight. Gotcha, Judge. Okay.
- 13:30Now, I wanted to focus more on California and
- 13:33Texas. And to some extent, Washington, I have
- 13:37listed for you what are some of the statutes
- 13:39that have been enacted in California. California
- 13:42adopted a stronger anti -enforcement and notice
- 13:45rules in AB 699 and AB 1076. Those have since
- 13:51been codified, and we have discussions about
- 13:54that in the handout. In addition, could you turn
- 13:57to the handout that analyzes the distinction
- 14:01between California and Texas law? Texas is focusing
- 14:07more on limits for physicians and certain specified
- 14:10healthcare practitioners. The handout that you
- 14:13have gives you a distinction between what California
- 14:16is doing, which you can read basically the effective
- 14:20date of the new California law adopting the per
- 14:22se rule, some of the overall changes, how it's
- 14:25distinguished, some of the geographic limitations.
- 14:29It also compares what Texas is doing as compared
- 14:32to California. And then Washington also, Washington
- 14:36state this year is considering HB 155, which
- 14:41is also a broader ban, which is anticipated to
- 14:44become effective. Can you go back to slide number
- 14:48five, number eight, go back to slide eight. Got
- 14:51you. Washington states, if HB 155 does get enacted.
- 14:57it's intended to operate as a per se rule similar
- 15:01to California commencing in 2027. But in California,
- 15:07non -compete agreements restricting post -employment
- 15:11contact are generally void, but they are not,
- 15:16they are voidable, but they are not void ab initio.
- 15:19They're merely voidable and unenforceable. Next
- 15:22slide. And if you look at the case law, particularly
- 15:27the Edwards case, which went into great detail
- 15:30in outlining that narrowing a non -compete agreement
- 15:37to certain jurisdictions or certain duration,
- 15:40ultimately California rejected that. And it indicated
- 15:44that narrow is not enough. Section 16 ,600 Subdivision
- 15:51B, the business and profession code requires
- 15:54a broad reading in accordance with the California
- 15:57Supreme Court of Edwards case. In the handout,
- 16:00it goes into detail as to how we get there. Turn
- 16:03to our next slide, slide 10. So what happens
- 16:10if you're an employer and you want to enforce
- 16:15a non -compete agreement. And you have the circumstance
- 16:21go back to, we have an employee that's in California,
- 16:25working for a business out of Massachusetts,
- 16:28where most of their customers are in New York.
- 16:31The business is incorporated in Delaware, claims
- 16:35that Delaware is their home state. So what law
- 16:39applies? And if you had, for example, a Massachusetts
- 16:43non -compete provision against an employee, but
- 16:46the employee finds themselves suing in California
- 16:50isn't enforceable. Well, what do we look at?
- 16:54First, you look at the reach. When and where
- 16:58was the document signed that does not necessarily
- 17:01save a void contract per se? So the fact that
- 17:05the employee signed the non -compete provision
- 17:08that's included in California even though that
- 17:11may cause create a cause of action, we can talk
- 17:13about that. Ultimately, that's not the end of
- 17:16the analysis. The analysis then turns to the
- 17:19conduct through the entering or attempt to enforce
- 17:22can violate the state statute in California.
- 17:25So if you're attempting to enforce it in California,
- 17:28you may very well get a court that would say,
- 17:31well, you're entitled to attorney's fees, you're
- 17:34entitled to damages. This is an unenforceable
- 17:36agreement. That's where the issue of choice of
- 17:39law becomes important. And then ultimately, on
- 17:42the remedial side, are you seeking an injunction?
- 17:45Is the employer trying to enjoin the employee
- 17:47from engaging in further activities? How do you
- 17:50establish actual damages? And you want to look
- 17:53at prevailing worker fees. So ultimately, you're
- 17:56looking at what are your remedies in the context
- 17:59of enforcement and which provision applies and
- 18:02what state law applies. Next provision. Enter.
- 18:07Labor Code, Section 925, which limits mandatory
- 18:14form and choice of law terms. So basically, Section
- 18:2216600 .58 addresses contracts void under the
- 18:29chapter, regardless of the signing location or
- 18:32time. It addresses enforcement even if signing
- 18:36and employment were outside California. It prohibits
- 18:39covered provisions and employer or prospective
- 18:42employer contracts. And most importantly, it
- 18:45creates a civil violation. So this becomes critical
- 18:49in that context. Section 925 protects a defined
- 18:58California relationship. So who? The employee
- 19:02primarily resides and works in California. when
- 19:04we're talking about Labor Code Section 925, which
- 19:07creates the civil violation. Terms required is
- 19:11a condition of employment that forces the California
- 19:14claims out of state or deny California substantive
- 19:16provisions. And when you enter into or was modified
- 19:21or extended for contracts after January the 1st
- 19:25of 2017. Let's move to the next statute. Next
- 19:39slide. I'm on 12 now. What's the governing law
- 19:45and forum that answer different questions? Now,
- 19:48section 925, the council exception does not settle
- 19:54the non -compete enforceability. Typically, what
- 19:57a party would state is that as 925, labor code
- 20:01section 925 could potentially create a cause
- 20:03of action for even having a non -compete employee
- 20:08provision, the question becomes if the employee
- 20:11was represented by counsel in negotiating that
- 20:14agreement then actual individual legal representation
- 20:17in negotiating the form or the governing law
- 20:20may be a mitigating factor. What it does not
- 20:24establish is that exception alone does not make
- 20:27a non -compete enforceable. So arguably even
- 20:31if you come in and you're the employer you're
- 20:33attempting to defend a non -compete employee
- 20:37provision. It isn't really enough under Section
- 20:39925 to say, look, the employee was represented
- 20:44by counsel, and they knowingly negotiated this
- 20:46provision. The court looks at greater detail
- 20:49to determine if there is an exception in that
- 20:51context. Move to the next slide. There we go.
- 21:00Slide 13. Yeah, we got you. So the question becomes,
- 21:06which substantive law actually applies? And where
- 21:11will the dispute be heard? Now, typically, you
- 21:15state a choice, a chosen form may apply another
- 21:19jurisdiction's substantive law. And that arises
- 21:22when you look at determining what is the better
- 21:25choice of law. The question becomes, if in our
- 21:29hypothetical, are you going to wind up applying
- 21:32Massachusetts law? Are you going to wind up applying
- 21:34California law. Are you going to wind up if you
- 21:37do have a non -compete provision which may violate
- 21:40the per se rule? Has the employer potentially
- 21:44created some via some potential violation of
- 21:47the statute? And the question becomes what's
- 21:50the appropriate form? Next statute, next slide.
- 21:59So and you identify the form, you identify the
- 22:03applicable conflicts framework and by that which
- 22:07analysis are you going to use? You test the chosen
- 22:11law's connection to the relationship, and without
- 22:14an effective chosen law clause, you examine the
- 22:17forum's default law. So you first determine,
- 22:20is there a selection for choice of law? If there
- 22:23is not, then you look to see how the particular
- 22:26state analyzes, which is a choice of law analysis.
- 22:30You will look at competing fundamental policies,
- 22:32and you look at the state interest. So what does
- 22:35that mean? in a practical context. Next slide.
- 22:41It certainly means that physical location is
- 22:45not the same as competitive impact. The employee
- 22:49location may be where they live, there may be
- 22:53some travel involved, there may be some relocation
- 22:56involved for purposes of their work. However,
- 22:59the analysis focuses on the location of competitive
- 23:04conduct and where the alleged injury could occur.
- 23:07So you're looking at when you're determining
- 23:10choice of law, where are the customers? Where
- 23:13is the primary market? Where is the data being
- 23:16used? And more importantly, where is the alleged
- 23:20injury? Next slide, please. The seminal case
- 23:26on form selection and choice of law in this non
- 23:33-compete context is the Draft King's decision.
- 23:36If you'll turn to the handout page nine, please.
- 23:47Now, the Draft King decision basically comes
- 23:50out of the Fifth Circuit. In that case involved,
- 23:54Draft King sued a former employee who took a
- 23:58job basically arguing that the new provision
- 24:01violated a non -compete agreement containing
- 24:04a Massachusetts choice of law provision. So now
- 24:07we've got a Massachusetts choice of law provision.
- 24:11The district court sided with the employer, deeming
- 24:15the non -compete enforceable under Massachusetts
- 24:19law and issuing a preliminary injunction against
- 24:22the employee. The employee appealed and argued
- 24:28that California law was to govern because the
- 24:32non -compete enforceability and that the injunction
- 24:35should exclude California. His argument in California
- 24:39is that the employee apparently had moved to
- 24:42California. Ultimately, in going through the
- 24:45analysis, the court determined, first circuit,
- 24:49that Massachusetts law governs because diversity
- 24:52jurisdiction existed over the breach of contract
- 24:56non -compete claim. Massachusetts was the forum
- 24:59where draft kings and the plaintiff set the rules
- 25:03for deciding which state's law determines the
- 25:06outcome. So the court looked at their initial
- 25:08choice, but it went further. It determined that
- 25:12the materially greater interest, looking at the
- 25:15policies between California versus Massachusetts,
- 25:19the court focused on whether California had a
- 25:22material greater interest in Massachusetts. And
- 25:24here's where it gets interesting and where the
- 25:26analysis about conflict of law becomes important.
- 25:30The employee argued that a previous decision
- 25:34called the Oxford decision had approved his claim.
- 25:37And in that case, the court held that California
- 25:39had a materially greater interest because the
- 25:42employee, and this is the point I'm making, executed
- 25:45and performed the contract in California and
- 25:48the alleged breach occurred there. So the court
- 25:52looked at the injury, the court looked at where
- 25:56the employee lived, and then looked at where
- 26:00the contract was performed and then ultimately
- 26:03determined that the harm occurred there. But
- 26:07in the Draft King's case, the First Circuit took
- 26:10a different approach. They found basically that
- 26:14the employee had worked in New Jersey, had worked
- 26:20in New York, had only minimal contacts in California,
- 26:23though he had traveled there a few times for
- 26:26his work. So you can get arguments that I performed
- 26:28some of my work in a different state. but he
- 26:30was not residing in California, nor did the breach
- 26:34occur there. And there was no evidence that he
- 26:37performed any work for the employer in California.
- 26:41Question, would that have made a difference?
- 26:43And then the court analyzed where the harm actually
- 26:46would have occurred, and it determined that the
- 26:49primary harm would have occurred in Massachusetts
- 26:51and not California. So ultimately, the court
- 26:55made the determination that the appropriate jurisdiction,
- 27:00despite the argument that the parties had chosen
- 27:03California law, or at least that the parties
- 27:06were arguing that California might be the appropriate
- 27:08forum that Massachusetts law should govern. So
- 27:12next slide, please. Can you go back to the original
- 27:17slide? Okay. So ultimately, the reasoning in
- 27:21that case is that California's interest was not
- 27:24shown to be materially greater. from the employer
- 27:28perspective, if you have an employee that is
- 27:31asserting, labor code section 925, asserting
- 27:35that now we have a violation because you have
- 27:38a non -compete clause, which may or may not be
- 27:43reasonable, but you're arguing as a California
- 27:45employee that is per se violation, you could
- 27:49find that ultimately California law may not apply.
- 27:53Even though the statute says in and of itself
- 27:56the California law should apply. The court still
- 27:59may not even in California enforce California
- 28:02law based upon the choice of form questions.
- 28:05So that's the issue that you need to be aware
- 28:07of and understand that it's a fact -specific
- 28:10application and you want to look at the facts.
- 28:14Next slide. The other question because well frequently
- 28:20you in a form selection choice of law context
- 28:24you want to know who should get to the courtroom
- 28:27first. So a farm raise can raise costs even before
- 28:32merits are reached. So you may find that, oh,
- 28:34if you're the employee and you're going to be
- 28:36the plaintiff, you want to rush to your California
- 28:38courts. You want to be able to establish the
- 28:40facts that show California applies because now
- 28:42you can rely on labor code section 925. If you
- 28:46are the employer, you will say, hey, wait a minute.
- 28:50Despite the language of the statute, let's look
- 28:52at the case law, which says this is still affect
- 28:55specific analysis when you're trying to determine
- 28:58which state law actually applies and it may be
- 29:01that Massachusetts or another state has a greater
- 29:05material interest than California and therefore
- 29:09that's how you avoid the liability under labor
- 29:11code section 925 and of course what's at risk
- 29:15well from the employee perspective they want
- 29:18a declaration that the restraint is void from
- 29:22the employer's perspective They want enforcement
- 29:25and emergency injunctive relief. The point that
- 29:28we know is determining the form and the substance
- 29:31of law becomes important because the legal fees
- 29:34for even a form dispute, emergency relief, and
- 29:38parallel proceedings can get quite costly. Now,
- 29:43next step, next slide. So if you're negotiating
- 29:50these contracts or you have a potential action,
- 29:54your employer assessment begins with what is
- 29:56the real business risk. So you need to pinpoint
- 30:00what is the specific information or relationship
- 30:04that's at risk. Is it a trade secret? Is it proprietary
- 30:08information? Is this in the context of the sale
- 30:12of a business? Do you have goodwill that's at
- 30:15issue? Do you have an LLC that's at issue? So
- 30:19all of a sudden, rather than running in and saying,
- 30:21aha, we have a violation, of the non -compete
- 30:26employment provision under California law and
- 30:28the per se rule. Here my attorney's fees, here's
- 30:31the violation. That's not the end of the analysis.
- 30:34Next you have to determine the applicable law
- 30:36from the worker's actual locations. So you need
- 30:39to determine, is this an employee that's working
- 30:43digitally? What is the source of the information?
- 30:48Where is the employer located? And more importantly,
- 30:52where's your market located? In today's world,
- 30:56it could be ubiquitous. And then the next question
- 30:59is, where is the majority of the harm? So that's
- 31:02the arguments that have to be addressed before
- 31:06you get to the question of labor code section
- 31:08925, liability. And then review the terms when
- 31:12the role or authorized work site changes. So
- 31:17one of the caveats that certainly in drafting
- 31:20these decisions or thinking about litigation
- 31:22in this context, is you have an employee that's
- 31:24being relocated or that's being moved. You may
- 31:28want to revisit this issue to make certain from
- 31:30the employee's perspective that you're getting
- 31:32the outcome that you see. Next slide. An employee
- 31:39review should also proceed any transition if
- 31:43you are being moved. You should get every agreement,
- 31:47look at its negotiation history. map out your
- 31:51old role, your new role, the work site, and more
- 31:54importantly, customer overlap. And then finally,
- 31:58assess filing data and solicitation risks before
- 32:02acting, meaning that you really do need to determine
- 32:05is the California rule going to apply or not.
- 32:11You shouldn't equate unenforceable restraint
- 32:14with permission to take data. Next slide. So
- 32:21the question becomes, your challenge here is
- 32:25creating agreements or a litigation strategy
- 32:31that doesn't create an outright work ban. If
- 32:36you do create a work ban, you probably want to
- 32:40tie it to specific, separately negotiated agreements.
- 32:45One topic would be confidentiality. Define what
- 32:49the protected information is precisely. With
- 32:52respect to trade secrets, remember that you have
- 32:55a separate trade secret law. You want to go through
- 32:59compliance of that and arguably have a separate
- 33:01set of controls and protocols for trade secrets.
- 33:05Then with respect to inventions, tailor assignment
- 33:09terms to applicable law. Be specific about in
- 33:14terms of access to proprietary information and
- 33:17who can get it and how it's distributed and identify
- 33:20whether or not a person is a key employee or
- 33:23not. I think that that's ultimately critical
- 33:25because a customer non -solicitation agreement
- 33:28is not going to automatically be valid in California
- 33:32law and it is not a substitute. So that puts
- 33:39us with if you have a business today, for example,
- 33:44that's working in the AI area and computer technology,
- 33:51dealing with the internet, data harvesting. You
- 33:55are basically dealing with a business that the
- 33:58state limitations are primarily non -existent
- 34:02or not of critical importance. So you want to
- 34:06make sure that you are protecting your information,
- 34:08that you're not running a file of any of the
- 34:10state laws. But ultimately, if you find that
- 34:14you've got older agreements, You've got issues
- 34:19about whether or not you've complied with the
- 34:21notice requirements in the California law that
- 34:24has adopted the per se rule, which if you look
- 34:27in our handout, it lays out that once California
- 34:32adopted the per se rule in 2023, it laid out
- 34:37that an employee non -compete agreement restricting
- 34:41post -employment conduct, not only are they voidable
- 34:45and unenforceable, it also required certain notices
- 34:49once that the act was adopted. It indicated that
- 34:53you had to notify employees if you had a non
- 34:56-compete agreement that it would potentially
- 34:59not be enforceable. So there are some provisions
- 35:02in there that require you to take certain actions
- 35:05as an employer. Next slide, please. If you find
- 35:12yourself in a dispute, It's our position that
- 35:15certainly I believe that early mediation can
- 35:18help you to narrow what the real dispute is in
- 35:22that context. So you want to focus on information
- 35:25and we're here to help you in that context. What
- 35:28data must be returned or protected and ultimately
- 35:33what duties and contracts create the immediate
- 35:36conflict. during the transition. Those are the
- 35:39things that we want to look at and then process
- 35:42what verification and dispute procedure will
- 35:44work. So with that ultimately looking at the
- 35:47agreements that you have, looking to determine
- 35:50the form selection clauses and whether or not
- 35:52they're enforceable and ultimately if not enforceable
- 35:57what would be the appropriate substantive law
- 36:00and then ultimately what is the status of it.
- 36:03Next slide please. Arbitration certainly doesn't
- 36:08erase the choice of law issue, but there is a
- 36:12benefit in that ultimately you have a private
- 36:16forum and a more focused process. So certainly
- 36:20as you go through the process of transition,
- 36:22as you go through, you'll have trade secrets
- 36:24that may be involved. You may have proprietary
- 36:27information that you do not want to have out
- 36:30in the ether available to the general public.
- 36:32So that's one option way arbitration may assist
- 36:36Ultimately, while it doesn't erase the choice
- 36:39of law issues, it certainly can help to preserve
- 36:41some confidentiality as you're going through
- 36:44that process, particularly if you have proprietary
- 36:47information that's at issue. And then you have
- 36:50the continuing questions about what's the scope
- 36:53of the choice of law clause? Where are you going
- 36:57to be seated? What is the governing law? And
- 36:59also whether or not you're entitled to interim
- 37:01relief, which ultimately the arbitrator can grant
- 37:05depending upon the terms of the arbitration agreement.
- 37:08Next slide, please. The bottom line is precision
- 37:14is the practical answer. So you want to map out
- 37:18the people, the dates, where they work, customers,
- 37:23and what is the potential harm. On testing the
- 37:26restraint, you want to look at which form have
- 37:29been selected. What would be potential statues
- 37:33there because they are changing and what is the
- 37:35governing law? And then ultimately you can use
- 37:38tailored protection by considering early ADR.
- 37:43Next slide. I've attached for you what are some
- 37:47of the core authorities for follow up purposes.
- 37:52Certainly the handout goes into greater detail
- 37:55and giving you some of the specific provisions
- 37:57of which you should be aware some of the notice
- 37:59requirements. and certainly what are the consequences
- 38:03for violating the non -compete employment provisions
- 38:06in California. Also, we have the case study of
- 38:09the Draft Kings case. It is very helpful because
- 38:12it explains in great detail how the courts determine
- 38:16choice of law and certainly what would be an
- 38:19appropriate outcome in that context. And then
- 38:22ultimately, some legislative updates because
- 38:24there is a lot of activity going on in this context.
- 38:29I want to go back to our hypothetical. And this
- 38:33is a point where I want to invite you to begin
- 38:37to think about that. And I'd raise this question.
- 38:41Going back to our hypothetical where we talked
- 38:43about you've got a remote worker in California
- 38:49who lives there. You've got the employer that's
- 38:53in Massachusetts. The specific customers that
- 38:57this particular employee is servicing. is in
- 39:02New York, and the business is ultimately incorporated
- 39:06and has as its home, Delaware. So if you have
- 39:11that situation, we have an employee works, they
- 39:14say that they're a data entry person working
- 39:21from home. Ultimately, they come in, they have
- 39:25an action against their employer. This is in
- 39:29the context of perhaps a business dispute per
- 39:31se. They're not selling the business, or there's
- 39:34not a sale of goodwill, or there's not a dissolution.
- 39:37Which fact would you investigate first in that
- 39:40four -state hypothetical? What do you think would
- 39:42be the most important place to begin? I want
- 39:46you to think about that for a moment. Next slide.
- 39:54Next slide, please. So does moving to California
- 39:59defeat the non -compete? For example, let's say
- 40:05that the worker in my hypothetical was working
- 40:10in Missouri instead of California. And they decide
- 40:14to move to California. And they come into court
- 40:17and they say, aha, California's got a percent
- 40:19rule. I should win. The answer is not automatically.
- 40:24And the why, the form, conflict rule, the timing,
- 40:29the state interest will still matter. So what
- 40:33about a debt does a Delaware clause in the analysis?
- 40:38For example, what if the agreement says our site
- 40:44and it's going to be controlled by Delaware law
- 40:47and as a consequence, I am free not to have California
- 40:54law apply. Next slide. Next slide, please. The
- 41:03answer is no. A selected law can face connection
- 41:08public policy, and statutory challenges. Again,
- 41:12going back to the Draft Kings case, there's a
- 41:15question as to whether or not California law
- 41:17had been selected in that Massachusetts context.
- 41:20And while the court looked at an earlier case
- 41:23with a concluded California law applies, in that
- 41:27context, it determined, no, we need to look a
- 41:29little bit more closely at the public policy
- 41:31and what are certain statutory challenges, and
- 41:34determined that, no, the clause selected by the
- 41:38parties did not automatically determine the outcome.
- 41:43What about does negotiating counsel make a restraint
- 41:47valid? So for example, the mere fact that an
- 41:52employee had counsel present with them when they
- 41:55were negotiating the employment agreement. Does
- 41:58that make a difference? No. Next slide. Not by
- 42:05itself. because Labor Code section 925 exception
- 42:10concerns the state's form and law protections.
- 42:13It does not necessarily make the restraint valid.
- 42:18You still have to make a determination as to
- 42:21what is the substantive law that applies. And
- 42:23here's the twist, because the statute says, doesn't
- 42:28matter what state you're from. If you're in California,
- 42:32the California law would apply, but that actually
- 42:34is not the end of the analysis. Can we use a
- 42:38customer non -solicit instead? And by that, could
- 42:43you simply narrow an agreement to state, you
- 42:47cannot solicit from my client? The answer is,
- 42:56next slide. No, not as an automatic California
- 43:00workaround. Of course, examine whether the provision
- 43:03restrains lawful work. So the question isn't,
- 43:09you can use a customer non -solicit instead.
- 43:12And you say, I'm not saying that you can't compete.
- 43:15I just am very limited in saying that you cannot
- 43:18compete by pursuing certain customers. That is
- 43:22still viewed as a non -compete agreement. And
- 43:25the court's going to look at, is it limiting
- 43:27your right to work? Because again, remember that
- 43:29the theory behind this is to allow for employee
- 43:33mobility. then a question becomes, well, who
- 43:39should file first? Should the employee file first?
- 43:43Should the employer file first? That really depends.
- 43:48Next slide. Got to do it? I think, and the answer
- 43:54to that is depends, because filing first is not
- 43:56a complete strategy. Again, you've got to look
- 44:00at the jurisdiction. You've got to look at if
- 44:03you need to have emergency relief and what's
- 44:05the reason for the emergency relief? Ergo, that's
- 44:08why you look to, are you looking at a sale of
- 44:10business? Are you looking at parties that have
- 44:12some form of an LLC or some form of a partnership
- 44:15connection? Or you're looking at whether or not
- 44:20there's some form of an exception which would
- 44:26take it out of the per se rule. Can mediation
- 44:34resolve a conflict? the law has not settled.
- 44:38Good question. It can resolve the business dispute,
- 44:43but we cannot rewrite the mandatory laws. It
- 44:46would be helpful if the parties can agree on
- 44:49lawful data protection and transition steps ahead
- 44:52of time. That's one of the guidance that we would
- 44:55like to be able to offer you in that context,
- 44:58which is basically to help you get to a resolution
- 45:01of the business dispute in that context. as opposed
- 45:06to limiting the ability of an employee to move
- 45:09to another state or to engage in lawful work
- 45:13that may be with the competitor. So that's sort
- 45:16of the overview that we've covered in the context
- 45:20of the article on remote workers and non -competes.
- 45:23I wanted to open this up now to questions. I
- 45:29have given you the handouts that go into greater
- 45:32detail about the specific law that applies. It
- 45:35also lays out both the per se rule, the reasonableness
- 45:38standard, some case law in that context, and
- 45:41also the exceptions as it relates to sales of
- 45:44businesses and even partial sales of businesses
- 45:47and how non -complete agreements would not be
- 45:50enforceable in that context. Judge, I just got
- 45:54one question that came in, and I will read it
- 45:57to you. Have you ever done non -binding findings
- 46:01of fact and non -binding conclusions of law as
- 46:04part of a mediation with a view that the parties
- 46:07can use those in court on cross motions for MSJ
- 46:12in court? I have not done that. That primarily
- 46:21because we would view arbitration of less mediation
- 46:25certainly as confidential in the context of arbitration.
- 46:30The idea is that you're in arbitration because
- 46:33in these employment contracts, quite frankly,
- 46:36a lot of times they arise on new businesses and
- 46:40particularly in the. I want to say the high tech
- 46:46business. For example, what's going on in Northern
- 46:50California with the tech business, the media
- 46:57business, the things that are going on along
- 46:59those lines where it's developing a number of
- 47:03new businesses. So I think that the shown answer
- 47:06is no. I avoid from listing those findings. I
- 47:11think those protections are more appropriately
- 47:13provided in the context of the agreements. Perfect.
- 47:16I think the follow -up was, have you ever done
- 47:17a consent award to set up an appeal? A consent
- 47:24award in the context of an arbitration? I certainly
- 47:29created consent judgments in the context of as
- 47:31a judge. But a consent arbitration where it is
- 47:36publicly used, where the findings are used, I'm
- 47:39unfamiliar with that. Got it. And then I have,
- 47:42does this analysis apply to other issues that
- 47:45may be involved in the dispute in addition to
- 47:47non -compete? Read that question again. It just
- 47:52says, does this analysis apply to other issues
- 47:55that may be involved in the dispute in addition
- 47:57to non -compete? Well, I'm uncertain what you
- 48:01mean by other disputes. The per se rule and the
- 48:06reasonableness standard really relate to enjoining
- 48:10a person from engaging in certain business activities
- 48:13that would compete with their prior employer
- 48:16or that would be a competitor. And it does vary
- 48:20from state to state. And in those states, it
- 48:23varies from industry to industry. California,
- 48:26because we've adopted the per se rule, doesn't
- 48:29necessarily drill down on an industry to industry
- 48:31basis. And I think that's one of the big distinctions.
- 48:34What it does is it looks at the type of transaction
- 48:37and it looks at the relationship of the employee
- 48:42to the employer. For example, a good example
- 48:45would be I think the The primary case that we
- 48:49refer to, it's the Edwards case, involved an
- 48:55accounting firm and Arthur Anderson. And that
- 48:59gives you an example of, and in that context,
- 49:02the Supreme Court, the California Supreme Court
- 49:03ultimately said that a narrow restraint exception
- 49:07simply would not apply. And they invoked in a
- 49:10per se rule. And that was the basis for confirming
- 49:13that per se rule that was in the Edwards decision.
- 49:16Perfect. Next, when examining where major harm
- 49:20occurred for a choice of law, does this analysis,
- 49:24does this analyze the harm done to the employer
- 49:27by violating non -compete or the harm done to
- 49:30an employee by being unable to freely accept
- 49:33work or both? It's a balancing test. So the question
- 49:38becomes, what are you protecting for the employer?
- 49:42That's why trade secrets as a separate group
- 49:45may be critical. So it's not tied to the non
- 49:48-compete, but rather you're establishing that
- 49:51it's data and information and inventions and
- 49:57patents and things of that nature where a entity
- 50:01has invested significant money and proprietary
- 50:04information, and that needs to be protected.
- 50:06And quite frankly, there should be a separate
- 50:09agreement protecting that and disclosing that
- 50:11in the context of employment. I think that makes
- 50:13your position stronger. So my argument would
- 50:15be, if you want to talk about the harm, it is
- 50:19a balancing in that you're looking at what interests
- 50:21are you protecting for the business. If you're
- 50:24looking at the employee, you want to protect
- 50:26the employee's mobility. If you're talking about
- 50:29a good example would be the customer non -solicit.
- 50:33And see, well, that's just a narrow definition,
- 50:36but that's not enough. That's the reason why
- 50:38a customer non -solicit agreement is not sufficient
- 50:42for purposes of Labor Code Section 925. Because
- 50:45ultimately, what that non -solicit agreement
- 50:48does is it limits the mobility of the employee.
- 50:52And the employee could argue within that. prevents
- 50:54me from pursuing lawful work. In the context
- 50:57of the Edwards case, it was about an employee,
- 51:00an accountant who worked for Arthur Anderson.
- 51:03And the exclusion was you can't contact any of
- 51:05Arthur Anderson's clients to provide accounting
- 51:08services. And the court ultimately said, look,
- 51:10if you can provide them for a better price and
- 51:12you believe you can provide better services than
- 51:14Arthur Anderson, that should be. part of our
- 51:18open market society approach, and you should
- 51:21be able to compete. So it's a balancing test
- 51:24that the courts have to review. And I would argue
- 51:27if you're on the employer side, that to the extent
- 51:30you can have separate agreements or specify what
- 51:33the proprietary information is that you're protecting
- 51:35the better, even if you just categorize it, that's
- 51:37important. Perfect. The next question relates
- 51:41to arbitration. Can you, using AAA rules for
- 51:47JAMS arbitration, Rans, can you use the AAA rules
- 51:50in there? And then, I don't know if you want
- 51:53to take that one first, but the second one is,
- 51:54would you accept a case delegating injunctive
- 51:57relief into your ARB award? Second question,
- 52:02yes. Because obviously one of the key remedies
- 52:07is whether or not the person is able to work.
- 52:10whether or not they're able to take certain data,
- 52:12whether or not you want to enjoin their going
- 52:16to a competitor, whether or not you want to enjoin
- 52:18them starting a startup business right across
- 52:20the street while they're also trying to take
- 52:22your clients. Then you also want to look to see
- 52:24if there's any connection between the parties,
- 52:26if they were via partners, or they're engaged
- 52:29in a similar business, what work has been done
- 52:32to develop goodwill. So I think when the Act
- 52:35was established, and the argument was that we're
- 52:38now creating a separate civil violation for having
- 52:41a non -compete employment provision in a contract,
- 52:47that that creates civil violations. But I think
- 52:50there are a number of exceptions, and people
- 52:52need to recognize that. So it's a public policy
- 52:55which gets you away from the analysis of enforcing
- 52:59the agreement. But I think when you're talking
- 53:02about potential violation, I think you do have
- 53:05certain defenses there in terms of, in the context
- 53:08of, what are you protecting? Perfect. I think
- 53:12they added contempt power as well. So I was like,
- 53:15would you accept that KTL getting injunctive
- 53:17relief to your ARB award and contempt power too?
- 53:20I think it's critical in order to enforce your
- 53:22rulings, yes. Perfect, perfect. Do you at least
- 53:30say name to the art? Well, I can answer that.
- 53:33No. JAMS is not charged specifically being named
- 53:35in an arbitration clause. And we can help you.
- 53:37If anyone wants to talk about that after, we
- 53:38can definitely do that. And also, I think there
- 53:42was a question too about, yes, JAMS does administer
- 53:44matters with AAA rules up to the parties decide
- 53:47which we can do that. And that's all I have unless
- 53:51anybody has any other questions as well. That's
- 54:01what I have. Chat here. I think that's all the
- 54:07questions I have, Judge. All right. Well, thank
- 54:10you. And it looks like we're almost at the 5
- 54:13o 'clock hour. So I think this worked out well.
- 54:16It's been a pleasure to address each of you.
- 54:19I would just remind you that the handouts go
- 54:23into greater detail. I think they're also most
- 54:26helpful. And I would urge you to certainly get
- 54:28them. and review them if you need them for purposes
- 54:31of citation and also the actual briefing of the
- 54:34cases that contained within the outline. My view
- 54:38was rather include all of that in the PowerPoint
- 54:41presentation that I think ultimately you would
- 54:43benefit from just having the actual handout.
- 54:45So that was my purpose. Perfect. Thank you, Judge.
- 54:50And thank you, everybody, for joining us today.
- 54:55If you have any questions or further questions,
- 54:58you can reach out to the Beverly Hills Bar and
- 54:59they'll put you in touch with us. And we can
- 55:00make sure that any further questions get answered.
- 55:03And if you have any questions about jams as well
- 55:05or Judge Cunningham, please let us know. Thank
- 55:07you. Thank you, everybody.