Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 150 - Knut Svanholm: Democracy Leads to Totalitarianism
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 150 of the Free Cities podcast. What a lovely round number
- 0:38brought to you as always by our wonderful sponsors of the show Veritas Villages.
- 0:44Veritas Villages are freedom-oriented, energy-self-sufficient, luxury communities
- 0:50in Latin America designed for people who want to enjoy peace of mind and real freedom in these
- 0:57uncertain times. You can live amongst like-minded neighbours in communities that use Bitcoin,
- 1:05and you can buy your property with Bitcoin as well. www.veritasvillages.com forward slash free
- 1:13cities. It's in the show notes, as I'm sure you know. And to remind you once more, Patrick,
- 1:20the founder of Veritas Villages, will be speaking at the Free Cities Conference in Prague
- 1:26in just a few weeks freecitiesconference.com you cannot miss that one i'm getting actually
- 1:33genuinely excited now can't wait to be there loads of great speakers all listed on the website now
- 1:40and more coming it's just the place to be if you're in the free cities movement be there or
- 1:46be square as they say right today's show and it's a returning guest knut svanholm you may know him
- 1:54quite well. I certainly do. And I'm going to go straight to my AI for the summary. Tim interviews
- 2:01Knutts von Holm, who shares a distinctive perspective on Bitcoin, its culture and security.
- 2:08They discuss Bitcoin's alignment with natural law, property rights and peaceful trade,
- 2:14as well as its potential to promote honest money, deflation and increased purchasing power.
- 2:20The conversation touches on personal responsibility, critiques of democracy and historical examples of limited government societies.
- 2:30Svonholm presents Bitcoin as a tool for individual freedom and economic empowerment.
- 2:36That's it, he sure does.
- 2:38And my two sats that I will add, he also defines the most red pill of red pills.
- 2:45As the title suggests, yes, we challenge the unchallengeable idea that democracy is the pinnacle of human governance technology.
- 2:57See you soon in the gulags, guys.
- 2:59We're saying the unsayable.
- 3:01Talking of gulags, I'm observing what's happening in the world and the powers that be
- 3:07really have started ramping up the privacy invasion slash digital ID thing in the last
- 3:15couple of weeks. I don't know whether you've noticed it yourselves. It all seems to be
- 3:19happening in lockstep. Alarm bells are ringing. Remember, it's never what they say it's about.
- 3:26It's hard not to see this as preparation for something big in the future. My bet
- 3:32would be on monetary reset at some point, probably in the 2030s.
- 3:39That's a bit of a wild prediction, I know.
- 3:42Anyway, wrapping your head around decentralized networks
- 3:46is never more important than it is now.
- 3:49And I'm going to say this again.
- 3:51Don't forget, start using decentralized privacy tools now.
- 3:56Start making them part of your day-to-day life.
- 3:59Start using decentralized money now.
- 4:01start using it on a daily basis start living in a parallel world whenever you can
- 4:07start now so that it becomes second nature that would be my advice
- 4:13right rant over subscribers on fountain my beautiful subscribers many thanks to you all
- 4:23i'm going to give you all a little mention here nicholas cousin vinnie shadrach silas thornbrook
- 4:29set in stone a n t c b there's an n pub there i think it's christopher albanese i don't know
- 4:38why it's not showing up bullish mike matthias tim guess what guys i published a new bonus
- 4:46episode a couple of days ago if you haven't seen it already you have access to that now
- 4:52It's another massive conversation, this time with a Bitcoin slash Erbit developer by the name of Jake Hamilton.
- 5:01It's basically me talking with a gigabrain for nearly four hours about literally everything from technology to religion to psychedelics to basically the future of mankind.
- 5:13and if you add that to the four hours of bonus episodes i recorded with gg
- 5:20in your brain can thank me later anyway please subscribe for these private episodes and more on
- 5:27fountain.fm you get the bonus episodes you get early access to some other episodes you also get
- 5:37a guaranteed readout of your comments like this one from subscriber.
- 5:44Bob John.
- 5:45Bob says, I love, and he's talking here about the episode with VIT,
- 5:51the president of Liberland.
- 5:53That was last week's episode.
- 5:54I love the spirit of Liberland and what they've accomplished.
- 5:59Thanks for asking tough questions about the shit coin.
- 6:02He's talking about that's BTC maximalist speak for their own coin that they have, which isn't Bitcoin.
- 6:10I think they would be able to bring in higher quality peeps if they dropped their own coin.
- 6:16It's a personal barrier for me.
- 6:18That may well be true, Bob.
- 6:20It's hard to say.
- 6:22I certainly agree that Bitcoin maximalists, Bitcoiners would take Lieberland slightly more seriously if they didn't issue their own coin.
- 6:32however that's the route they have decided to go down or vit he's he talks about it in the podcast
- 6:40actually he's quite resolute about his ideas about economics and also the fact that they have quite
- 6:47a large treasury in bitcoin as well listen to the episode if you'd like to draw your own conclusion
- 6:53to that debate right let's get into this grab your copy of the bitcoin white paper make a small prayer
- 7:00to the gods of Bitcoin maximalism. It's time to speak to Knut. Once you're in your calm state,
- 7:07you know what to do. Sit back, relax and enjoy my conversation with Knut Svonholm.
- 7:14now what were we just talking about before we went on air and i said oh let's talk about that
- 7:31on the pod um yeah well first of all thank you for having me on again tim like the last time around
- 7:37we did the longest pod ever done in my life like more than four hours it was it was epic yeah i did
- 7:43get your full backstory though and stuff which we obviously don't need to go to now no no everyone
- 7:47knows that now yes everyone knows it after after the two million views the the previous one did
- 7:54yes of course i saw actually i have seen other people talk to you about
- 7:58seafaring and all that kind of stuff i hadn't spotted that one before but now it seems to be
- 8:03one of your go-to uh topics well it's not voluntarily though other people want me to
- 8:11talk about well it's almost like in the bitcoin world it's like bitcoin and yeah isn't it bitcoin
- 8:16and seafaring great right let's do it what what can we what what conclusions can we draw from
- 8:22bitcoin and see no but the thing about that my background like um my whole um public bitcoiner
- 8:29career if you can call it that you can definitely call it it's it started here uh baltic hannah
- 8:35Badger in 2019. And back then I thought like, I do not come from computing or like systems
- 8:45engineering or and I do not know anything about economics really like I haven't studied that.
- 8:52So I thought my seafaring background would be to my detriment. But the opposite was true,
- 8:57because I had a perspective that no one else had because I had a different background.
- 9:01So I think that's one of the things that Bitcoin does.
- 9:05It makes people...
- 9:08You can be appreciated for your unique perspective.
- 9:12I believe that over the course of a lifetime,
- 9:15your path becomes more and more unique because no one else has it And the older you are the more unique your path is And there value in that And you can sort of look back on dreary boring episodes
- 9:31of your life and realize that there's actually something of value to be extracted from that.
- 9:36It's not like I believe in some greater purpose or anything like that. It's just like, maybe
- 9:41wasn't all waste maybe maybe you wouldn't have been where you are now if all those things hadn't
- 9:48happened leading up to something always and there's there's power in that and like finding
- 9:53stuff from your past that you thought was useless but it can actually be valuable i do remember a
- 10:01time in the bitcoin world when there weren't any celebrities other than people like possibly adam
- 10:07back and a few people like that now andreas antonopoulos yes andreas definitely andreas
- 10:13ironically andreas isn't as well known really anymore but i think most people i know from back
- 10:19in the day or say the the 2017 people yeah were were basically turned on by and and and and
- 10:26antonopoulos probably when he went on rogan the first time i think yeah and uh he was like the
- 10:32only one doing this like traveling to conferences and stuff and in 2019 here he had just released
- 10:39his mastering ethereum book and like uh and 2019 everyone was uh very much in slay your heroes mode
- 10:49we were proud that we slayed our heroes uh and whenever someone stepped out of line and started
- 10:54shitcoining or anything they were immediately called out uh and rightfully so like that's one
- 11:00aspect of the community that i really loved is like that no one's safe here it doesn't matter
- 11:05your credentials if you if you bullshit you're out so like we're not going to respect you anymore
- 11:11uh and what what happened there was um so so we were slaying all our heroes except andreas it's
- 11:19like he had plot armor yeah so so so i started poking people on the shoulder and they're like
- 11:26why is no one saying anything about Andreas?
- 11:28He obviously took a bag of shit coins
- 11:29and is now shilling this Ethereum bullshit.
- 11:33But no one dared to call him out on it.
- 11:35And then eventually people did.
- 11:37And I think Andreas sort of,
- 11:41I guess he was bored with his,
- 11:44well, fed up with his path.
- 11:46And he sort of went into the shadows and started,
- 11:50I mean, he blocked me.
- 11:52What is he doing now though?
- 11:54I think he's doing the same thing as he always was, just on a smaller scale.
- 11:58And he doesn't get the whole maximalism Austrian economics angle, really.
- 12:05Really?
- 12:06He spoke like an Austrian economist when he used to talk about Bitcoin.
- 12:10A lot of it, yeah.
- 12:13I mean, you could argue he's one, well, not anymore, but he was the most valuable brand in Bitcoin at one point.
- 12:22Absolutely.
- 12:22And like if Andreas, if you're seeing this and if you want to unblock me, please feel free to do so.
- 12:29Because on the whole, like I try to judge people on their, like everyone's a human being, right?
- 12:36And we have goods and bads.
- 12:39And if Andreas is still definitely tilted more towards the good side than the bad side for me.
- 12:45So I think.
- 12:46I'd say, I would say he's a hero of mine.
- 12:48He basically completely changed my life.
- 12:52I would not, I mean, I already knew about Bitcoin prior to that, but he, I'd heard about it.
- 13:00It didn't mean anything to me.
- 13:01I watched him on the internet and the penny dropped with me, literally looking at that
- 13:07guy's face.
- 13:08And I would imagine that happened to a hell of a lot of people because he had a very good
- 13:11way of, he was very eloquent about it.
- 13:15Very good public speaker.
- 13:16Excellent.
- 13:17But when you think how long ago it was as well, it's taken, like nowadays we get very
- 13:21used to being able to talk quite authoritatively about the bitcoin but he was he he got it deeply
- 13:28all the way back yeah ahead of the curve which is why it was so uh disappointing when he started
- 13:37shitcoining like still like ethereum to me um is an obvious scam 70 pre-mine uh it reached its peak
- 13:49in 2017 and then there was a slight run-up in 2021 when they changed their narrative from world
- 13:56computer to ultrasound money or whatever the fuck and it never got to 50 percent of the peak in 2017
- 14:04in fiat terms it did it did but if you're measuring in fiat you're using the wrong
- 14:10denominator and you you don't detect that you're being ripped off if you denominate in bitcoin it
- 14:15never went to 50 of its initial hype so the rug pull had already happened like there was never a
- 14:21flippening it was a scam through and through and i don't think andreas is willing to admit that but
- 14:27i mean i shouldn't speak for him i like i said he's still definitely a net benefit and he had
- 14:33some of the best clips about bitcoin out there are from him so i've all the respect for that
- 14:38but i'm still going to call out the bad stuff and chilling ethereum is crap any idea why
- 14:44um um like as a as a was he i don't know whether he was particularly technologically
- 14:53minded or not but he was so do you do you think well he must have he had a background in computer
- 15:00science so maybe he did think the theorem was revolutionary or a natural progression or
- 15:06something i don't know yeah but but still i mean the information is false regardless of your
- 15:16intention with it sort of like is it malice or just uh bad thinking i don't know but the message
- 15:25is wrong and it's like that's what social media is for like someone's wrong on the internet i'm
- 15:31going to point it out but then again if he wrote a book about how to program on ethereum in a way
- 15:37it's neutral i mean it's like i know you know i i don't think there's any chance that he didn't get
- 15:42paid to do that of course it is okay yeah but and i'm almost certainly he needed to get paid as well
- 15:48i mean if you think back as well i've heard many people say that he did spend i mean he obviously
- 15:54had a fair bit of bitcoin because it was hard not to back then but i think he spent it all because
- 15:58it wasn't really valuable. Absolutely, because he financed his own. And then there was a
- 16:02hashtag thank you Andreas thing where he
- 16:06collected like 13 bitcoins or something. Really? With people just donating
- 16:10to him because they liked him. Recently? No, it's
- 16:14like five years back. I was going to say, 13 bitcoins. Probably even more.
- 16:17Yeah. Well, it wasn't as much back then, of course.
- 16:22I mean, the thing Andreas did for me on a personal level
- 16:25is just, I looked at this guy
- 16:28and he's flying around the world
- 16:29teaching people about Bitcoin
- 16:32and seems to have this fantastic life
- 16:35where you can just go wherever you want
- 16:37and make money off of telling people the truth.
- 16:42And I looked at it as like,
- 16:45maybe I could do that.
- 16:47That was very much an inspiration.
- 16:50I probably wouldn't be doing what I'm doing now
- 16:52if it wasn't for that.
- 16:54Do you know what?
- 16:54I've got a feeling.
- 16:55I wear this Bitcoin pin whenever I go and I've worn it for a long time.
- 17:00I've got a feeling he gave me that idea because he said in a small way, it's nice to, it's
- 17:06probably not so good these days, but back then it's nice to signal to people that you're
- 17:10a Bitcoiner because if you run into someone on a plane, like I still get it to this day.
- 17:14If they spot the sign, they're like, hey, things are different now.
- 17:17I like the subtler ones.
- 17:19I suggest the everything divided thing is better to every Bitcoiner knows it.
- 17:25And it's not signaling to bad guys that you're a Bitcoin.
- 17:28And talking of bad guys, you know Elena.
- 17:33Oh, yeah.
- 17:33She's not a bad guy.
- 17:35No, she's not a bad guy.
- 17:36But did you see her talk this year?
- 17:38No, I missed that one.
- 17:40But I'm catching it in Helsinki next weekend.
- 17:43Do you know what it's about?
- 17:44Yeah, about the security stuff.
- 17:46Yeah.
- 17:46And that was a real eye-opener.
- 17:48She showed for the first sort of like 15 minutes of the talk behind her, she had flashing news articles constantly for ages, probably about over 300 of them, of people that have been kidnapped and had their Bitcoin stolen in some shape or form from all around the world.
- 18:06Yeah, I have a slightly controversial view on all of that.
- 18:14Everyone's a FUD salesman.
- 18:16the guy who sold you this water bottle sold you the fud of not being able to quench your thirst
- 18:24if you didn't buy his bottle of water so and in bitcoin like there's levels of fud salesmanery
- 18:31i guess uh but in bitcoin is very common like you need this steel plate you need this hardware
- 18:38wallet you need this security course or whatever Like everyone selling this And of course it a good thing We should take care of how to secure our bitcoins
- 18:54We should do all the measures.
- 18:57We should know what to do when there's a kidnapper in your house.
- 19:00Panic buttons.
- 19:00All of this stuff is good stuff.
- 19:02Hardware wallets.
- 19:04You should definitely take control of your own keys.
- 19:06You should probably do multi-sig and have your keys in different countries and all of this stuff.
- 19:12It's all good.
- 19:14But still, and here's the but.
- 19:17But everyone's trying to sell you FUD.
- 19:20And I refuse to let fear dictate my actions.
- 19:25If I walked around being afraid all the time, then I wouldn't do anything.
- 19:32You just can't live like that.
- 19:34And we need people to be courageous and stand up for what they believe and to show other people it's not dangerous to talk about this stuff.
- 19:42Like there's that side of the coin too.
- 19:45And I mean, at the end of the day, it's easier to steal other things than Bitcoin if the Bitcoins are stored properly.
- 19:54Because I do this shtick all the time.
- 19:57But if I point a gun at your head and say, Timmy, Timmy, give me all your Bitcoins.
- 20:04You can give me any amount of Bitcoin, and I have no way of knowing if that was all you had or not.
- 20:10You may have given me 0.1% of your Bitcoin.
- 20:15I have no clue.
- 20:16And that's true for every single human being on Earth right now.
- 20:20There is no way of actually knowing how many Bitcoins they have.
- 20:24Theoretically, everyone on Earth could control every single one of the keys,
- 20:28and everyone could have all of the 21 million Bitcoin, right?
- 20:32if you take this to the extreme.
- 20:34So in the future,
- 20:36when an attacker
- 20:37wants to steal something
- 20:40from you, regardless of
- 20:42it's an attacker in the public or the private
- 20:44sector,
- 20:46they want to take your house, they want to take your money,
- 20:48they want to kidnap your kids
- 20:50and put them in school, whatever
- 20:52it is,
- 20:53it's going to be harder because
- 20:56they can do all the
- 20:58other stuff, but taking your Bitcoin
- 20:59is not worth the attack.
- 21:02It shifts the profitability calculation
- 21:07that the attacker has to do
- 21:08because it's way harder to take the Bitcoin
- 21:10than to take anything else.
- 21:12So it's more profitable for the attacker
- 21:17to instead of attacking you,
- 21:19providing something of value back
- 21:21and trading with you.
- 21:24And this is like the very basis of what this is.
- 21:27the way I see it, and this is straight out of Misesian logic,
- 21:34humans have two ways of resolving conflict.
- 21:39One is communication and the other is violence.
- 21:42I can either talk to you and resolve the conflict because conflict only arises
- 21:47when there's a scarce good or a scarce service.
- 21:51so the the hoppian argument and like the i think this is derived from the rothbardian argument is
- 21:59that even in heaven uh where a theoretical heaven where you have an abundance of all goods
- 22:05i uh two bodies cannot take up the same spot at the same time so if i want to stand over there
- 22:12in heaven right next to saint pete or something quantum physics say the opposite to that
- 22:18two things can be in the different places yeah but only very very small things
- 22:24anyway not a human body so there's a potential conflict there but we only have conflict over
- 22:31scarce resources and therefore all communication is really at the very deepest philosophical level
- 22:39aimed at resolving conflict which and from that uh first principles thought you can derive that
- 22:47well, science can't derive an ought from an is,
- 22:51but I would say that we can derive an ought not.
- 22:54And that ought not is don't steal.
- 22:56Don't violate other people's property.
- 22:58And what is property?
- 23:00Like the first obvious property is your own body.
- 23:03If I say that human beings control their own bodies,
- 23:07therefore they own their own bodies,
- 23:09you can argue against that.
- 23:10But in doing so, you prove my point.
- 23:13Because you have to control your body to be able to argue.
- 23:17So where does the body end?
- 23:20Well, that's where homesteading comes in.
- 23:22If I take something in nature, from first principles, I am the rightful owner of that thing.
- 23:32If all communication is aimed at resolving conflict, you have to talk to me and convince me that that stick that you picked up is not mine, but it's yours.
- 23:42so if we if we want peaceful interactions you can you are not allowed to take the stick
- 23:49like this is natural law law that is discovered rather than invented by human beings so this is
- 23:56the difference between lawful and legal and i think if more and more people viewed their like
- 24:04morals and their ethics from a lawful perspective and instead of following whatever law someone came
- 24:10up with just followed natural law, respected property rights and said, this is rightfully
- 24:15mine, this is rightfully yours, and called out bad actors for what they actually are,
- 24:20everything would be better.
- 24:21And Bitcoin sort of allows this because of this, the profitability of violence model.
- 24:27In the long run, Bitcoin is peace.
- 24:31It leads to fewer and fewer violent, less and less aggression.
- 24:37This is the non-aggression principle.
- 24:39Bitcoin is the manifestation of the non-aggression principle in real life.
- 24:44So yeah, we're in a period where there's a lot of confusion,
- 24:47and a lot of people think that they can kidnap someone and cut their middle finger off
- 24:52and take all their Bitcoins.
- 24:55But it's not a very profitable thing to do.
- 24:58It's very risky, and you have no idea of knowing if you actually got the Bitcoin or not.
- 25:04And in fact, Lena talked about an incident where someone was robbed of $6,000 worth.
- 25:09And I think they were killed.
- 25:11So I think that underestimates the vigor with which some people will try and steal from others.
- 25:17No, no.
- 25:17I'm not denying that there are bad people out there.
- 25:20But if they kill you, no one gets the Bitcoin.
- 25:23What happens then is that the remaining sats become even more scarce.
- 25:28Therefore, every other Bitcoiner in the world now has more purchasing power, more political influence, more power in general.
- 25:41So they can only make the system stronger by attacking us.
- 25:46This is the perfect defense mechanism.
- 25:49You just mentioned John Locke's ideas about property then, didn't you?
- 25:53Lockean law.
- 25:54Yeah, I think John Locke was onto this as well.
- 25:58No, but you just said something.
- 25:59I think I've written down.
- 26:00No, Hopper.
- 26:01I said Hans Hermann Hopper.
- 26:02I thought you, but you said the same thing.
- 26:05If you have, because when I think of homesteading, I think of John Locke and I think of the 160 acres that you're allowed.
- 26:12If you add, that's kind of how it formed into a law in the States that you were allowed to claim 160 acres if you added your labor to the land and you blah, blah, blah, all this kind of stuff.
- 26:22Do you think Lockean law, do you think that law, the idea that if you grab something natural, add your value to it or add your work to it, it becomes property?
- 26:33Do you think that's a natural law?
- 26:35Yes, I do.
- 26:36So it's a real natural occurring law.
- 26:39It's important here to remember that in a perfect world, everyone would have respected that from the beginning and we would have no wars and everything would be better for everyone forever.
- 26:50But we're not living in that world.
- 26:51We're living in a world where every single product is the product of both violent and nonviolent interactions.
- 26:58So this water bottle, for instance, the free market and division of labor and price signals more than anything,
- 27:06made it possible for people to print this piece of plastic to turn oil from the ground into a well-functioning bottle that doesn't weigh too much so it can be easily transported.
- 27:19have you seen the lid though it doesn't yeah so there's also violent interactions one of them is
- 27:25this fucking bullshit where the eu prevents us from removing the cork they don't prevent you mate
- 27:31no no you can rip it off but but but the thing is they did force everyone involved to to change
- 27:38their fucking factory to make this thing this way instead that one's got a bit of added technology
- 27:43look it's got two layers on it look there's a bit the bit around the bottom it's kind of like
- 27:48No, but the point here that I'm trying to make is that at the end of the day, that is an added cost to the manufacturer.
- 27:56And it's so retarded I can't put it on again.
- 27:59And who pays for that Everyone does Yes every day Everyone And there VAT added to it That is a violent interaction That is not consensual We forced to pay it
- 28:12So like...
- 28:14Well, you're not forced to buy it, I suppose, are you?
- 28:17No, you're not forced to buy it.
- 28:18And that's the thing.
- 28:20The free market is such a strong force for good in the world
- 28:23so that despite all the government bullshit
- 28:26and despite the EU being completely retarded,
- 28:29it still provides us with uh more and more of an abundance of stuff do you think they'll ever
- 28:37backtrack on that thing just out of interest because it's so universally disliked isn't it
- 28:42have you ever met anyone who thinks it's a good idea no but i don't mingle with eu bureaucrats like
- 28:47yeah but do you think they'll listen to the public and go do you know what i mean i don't
- 28:52i don't ever recall seeing lids all over the floor either beforehand did you we didn't have
- 28:57a lid infestation did we no no it's so retarded but that meme is uh is absolutely true like america
- 29:07innovates china replicates the eu regulates yes yeah and so lockheon law is naturally occurring
- 29:15so that idea that property is derived from your the addition of your work to it is it would
- 29:23would arise everywhere any if if we if you arrive on an island with nobody else on it and then i
- 29:30wouldn't i'm too unfamiliar with john locke um for this like i i derived this from mises rothbard
- 29:38and hopper like to me locke's biggest contribution to mankind is the separation church and state
- 29:43like that's where he was really influential but like
- 29:47I'm trying to separate the last religion
- 29:51democracy
- 29:53from people
- 29:55separate the state from everything
- 29:58so
- 29:59yeah
- 30:02so where was I
- 30:04we're living in a world where everything is a mixture
- 30:06and all the land
- 30:08in the world is already claimed by someone
- 30:11and it has been for
- 30:12generations and it's been
- 30:14traded like someone
- 30:16bought a house or bought a piece of land. Manhattan was sold for what was this like
- 30:20$10,000 300 years ago or something. But it has also been taken by force. So we live in
- 30:27a mixture, everything's a mixture of violent and nonviolent interactions. So the only way
- 30:33to decide now who owns what is if we want to go forward into the future peacefully.
- 30:41And by we, I mean anyone who's willing to do this kind of thought experiment and actually live out what they believe to be true.
- 30:51Then if I say this water bottle is mine, I have to argue for why it is.
- 30:56And I'll say because you gave it to me, it's mine.
- 31:00You could probably convince me to give it back.
- 31:05It would probably be harder to convince me to give it back if I bought it myself.
- 31:09But there we are.
- 31:10If we want to peacefully resolve the conflict, we need to communicate.
- 31:14We need language.
- 31:15It's the only way.
- 31:18And that's how I view this whole thing.
- 31:22You can have the ball, by the way.
- 31:24Bitcoin is nothing but communication.
- 31:26It's an agreement on a fixed set of rules.
- 31:30And the reason we agree on this specific set of rules is that it's more expensive to break the rules than to just follow them,
- 31:37which allows us to have a monetary system with a fixed supply that we all store in our heads.
- 31:49I believe all the Bitcoins are within the Bitcoiner because the Bitcoins are not the UTXO on the blockchain.
- 31:59It's the private key or access to the private key.
- 32:02It's the ability to move them that is actually giving you the superpower.
- 32:05and that is always in someone's head it's always a secret kept from someone else
- 32:10which means that we now have um a way to check ourselves check our privilege when it comes to
- 32:19communication we we we can do absolute free market economy we just have to agree on this
- 32:27set of rules and the more people that do the the better it becomes uh and number goes up that is
- 32:32which is really just purchasing power go up and you can see how fooled you've been by the fiat
- 32:38system. Gold did not have a fixed supply. Gold had a stock to flow ratio that was in line with
- 32:44the progress of everything else. That's why prices were stable in gold. But stable prices is an
- 32:50illusion. I love to ask the simplest questions. So the simplest question I know is like,
- 32:57to describe all this is
- 33:00when human beings practice doing something,
- 33:03do they usually get better or worse
- 33:04at the thing they're practicing doing?
- 33:08So if I practice playing Beethoven's Fifth or something,
- 33:11do I get better or worse at it?
- 33:13I hope you get better.
- 33:14Yeah.
- 33:14Most people get better when they practice doing something.
- 33:17The follow-up question is,
- 33:18so why aren't all prices dropping forever?
- 33:22Because that's what they would do
- 33:25if we had honest money.
- 33:27And if you're using Bitcoin as your denominator, you can see the world through that lens.
- 33:32And you see how absolutely awesome that is.
- 33:34Everything is getting cheaper forever.
- 33:36It's fantastic.
- 33:38And once you get above a certain hurdle or a threshold, you don't need to work another day in your life if you don't wish to.
- 33:43I think a lot of people who aren't Bitcoiners would listen to what you said and would say,
- 33:49that's all very well, but prices won't come down forever because you're going through a monetization phase and blah, blah, blah, and all that kind of stuff.
- 33:57Okay, but then they should do this hypothetical thought experiment.
- 34:00So let's say there is no more fiat.
- 34:03Everything is running on Bitcoin.
- 34:05Therefore, it stops going up.
- 34:07Well, the pie can still grow larger.
- 34:12There can still be more products, cheaper products.
- 34:14People will still practice doing stuff, including designing water bottles with caps that you can screw off.
- 34:22And it will get cheaper and better over time.
- 34:24There's no reason that it would ever stop.
- 34:26Maybe it will flatten out, but the flattening out is way off in the future.
- 34:32The flattening out is after everything is on Bitcoin.
- 34:36And we don't know how much it will flatten out.
- 34:40I suspect that it will not flatten out at all because you add AI and robotics and all of this,
- 34:47we get so much better at an increasing pace at doing absolutely everything.
- 34:52like just remember coordinating uh where you're gonna meet somewhere else someone else before
- 34:59mobile phones and like how did you navigate before google maps like nowadays i can i can get an uber
- 35:08within two minutes in every single big city in the world it's it's amazing like why aren't people
- 35:14appreciating these things like it's it's so good uh and if you denominate that in bitcoin it's even
- 35:21more magic because everything is dropping in price forever something i thought about the following
- 35:26the ai trend into the future is that it will do away with money altogether won't it because
- 35:33the marginal cost of things will will all trend to zero and there'll be a point where the production
- 35:40of new things won't cost anything anything and the production of anything new because there'll be
- 35:47But the flaw there is that it will never actually reach zero.
- 35:52And if it did, no one would produce anything.
- 35:54But, I mean, AI would be doing it.
- 35:56But why?
- 35:59AI is...
- 36:00So here's the thing.
- 36:02Why I don't believe in general intelligence AI.
- 36:07Humans do things because we feel uneasy.
- 36:11So we're somewhat uneasy.
- 36:13This is the praxeology.
- 36:14This is the basics of praxeology.
- 36:16So we envision a future in which we've used some means to reach a certain end.
- 36:23For instance, right now, I'm foreseeing a future where I've used language to explain this concept to, well, not you, but our listeners, because you already know this stuff.
- 36:35So I feel slightly uneasy that I haven't gotten to the end of the sentence yet.
- 36:41So therefore, I keep on talking to reach that end.
- 36:46An AI would never feel that uneasiness and could never make a decision on its own.
- 36:51It's always a slave to someone.
- 36:54It will never, it will never skynet.
- 36:58Well, yeah, but what about, but this is a thought experiment then.
- 37:02I'm thinking, what is that uneasiness, right?
- 37:04In a human being, if you track back uneasiness as far as you can, it might be the fear of death.
- 37:12No, it's a selfish gene.
- 37:13at the end of the day it's just your genes
- 37:16trying to survive
- 37:16to survive? yeah
- 37:18but AIs want to survive as well
- 37:20I think there's been examples of them wanting to survive already
- 37:24yeah yeah yeah
- 37:25but
- 37:25every organ
- 37:30wants to survive.
- 37:32That's like
- 37:33the most basic property
- 37:35of anything living is that
- 37:37they want to reproduce and survive.
- 37:39That's the basics
- 37:42of evolution.
- 37:43The things that have that property
- 37:45are the things that will survive.
- 37:49But the AI
- 37:51where was I going
- 37:54with this?
- 37:55The thing
- 37:58that separates human beings
- 37:59from other creatures and other plants or animals or whatever,
- 38:04is that we do things deliberately out of free will.
- 38:10And we can get into the whole free will rabbit hole.
- 38:13I love the Hitchens quote about it.
- 38:15Of course, I have free will.
- 38:16I have no choice but to have it.
- 38:19And I think, objectively speaking, you cannot have free will
- 38:23because the neuron firing off will have to precede any decision.
- 38:28so what made the neuron fire off
- 38:31it was not your consciousness
- 38:33because that comes with a lag
- 38:34so objectively we possibly can't have it
- 38:37but the thing is that doesn't matter to praxeology
- 38:39because subjectively
- 38:40we have to have free will
- 38:42we cannot argue that we don't
- 38:45without running into a logical contradiction
- 38:47if I say to you that
- 38:49you don't have any free will
- 38:52I do so by my own volition
- 38:54so I have free will
- 38:56I cannot do that without
- 38:58showing you the opposite.
- 39:02Everything's futile if we don't
- 39:04argue from a perspective of we have
- 39:06free will, then everything is
- 39:08pointless.
- 39:09We can't do anything about arguing
- 39:12about it anyway because we would just
- 39:14automatically... The paradox
- 39:16is unsolvable.
- 39:17Just don't go there. It's just going to drive you mad.
- 39:23I believe
- 39:24to a certain extent... And there are
- 39:26theories that
- 39:27in quantum physics,
- 39:30particles can be entangled.
- 39:33Right? And some people
- 39:34misinterpret this because it's not like
- 39:36this thing is influencing that.
- 39:38It's more like if I
- 39:40write on a piece of paper.
- 39:45Is that your phone?
- 39:46No.
- 39:48My God, I just switched it off.
- 39:52Sorry.
- 39:52sorry about that i did i did switch it off right in the middle of a hey it's off
- 40:02that's yeah that's weird my phone just rang and it was on there was no internet connection
- 40:09joe rogan would have done exactly the same tim don't worry about it yeah yeah sorry
- 40:13so entangled yeah so it's more like uh the the particles are entangled in the sense that if i
- 40:21write the word spadoinkle on a piece of paper and I rip the paper apart and I have the sp part,
- 40:29I put that in one envelope and I put the doinkle part in another envelope and I send,
- 40:35randomly send one of the letters to Australia. Whenever someone opens that letter in Australia,
- 40:40I immediately know what the other letter says without even opening it. So that's how
- 40:45particles are entangled. It's more like if you have the information about this, you also
- 40:50automatically have the information about that.
- 40:53And particles have been shown,
- 40:57I'm no expert in this by any stretch of the imagination,
- 41:01but to be able to be entangled across time,
- 41:04so backwards in time.
- 41:06That could theoretically explain free will.
- 41:09If the neuron can fire off and you can make the decision
- 41:13and that can influence the decision,
- 41:15Terminator style,
- 41:17a couple of microseconds backwards in time,
- 41:19then maybe there's a way to have objective free will.
- 41:23But if time is what it seems like it is,
- 41:28and it goes in one direction only,
- 41:30then we cannot have free will.
- 41:31One way I've always thought of it is that time exists
- 41:38and your path through time is you have free will over.
- 41:44But when you change between paths,
- 41:48as in say say imagine this is your life and you're you've got all these options of things these are
- 41:54intentions that you take and when you move one lane into this intention you inherit the history
- 42:00of that or you know yeah that ties into the multiverse thing which is by the way the only
- 42:07theory that actually works when it comes to quantum mechanics the particle really does take
- 42:14all the paths between a and b and and when you measure it you reveal what timeline or what
- 42:21part of the multiverse you happen to be in it's about your intent it's about your attention so
- 42:27this is why the dichotomy between subjective and objective might be entirely false and this is to
- 42:33is david hume that talked about this a lot i think uh but um that we all all we can do is
- 42:40all our information is through our senses.
- 42:42So we don't know to which extent the mind creates reality.
- 42:48But we know that it does it to some extent.
- 42:50The only thing you can actually prove is Descartes.
- 42:53I think therefore I am.
- 42:54Or rather, the updated version is even more correct.
- 42:57I think therefore some thinking is going on somewhere.
- 43:00You can't really prove anything but that.
- 43:02That doesn't sound as good, though.
- 43:04No, it's not really...
- 43:06It's not memeable.
- 43:08what's the word i'm looking for it's not the
- 43:11desirable axiom for anything really so you have to pick your axioms and you have to to like how do
- 43:22i know that what i know is actually true and i love the austrian um model for thinking like uh
- 43:31you can actually deductively reason yourself to positions by simply acknowledging that some
- 43:37statements run into logical contradictions and therefore they cannot be true. And it's
- 43:43not simple semantics. It's actually true that you own your own body because you cannot argue
- 43:48against it. Anyway, we need some kind of framework like that to be thinking about human beings
- 43:57and our actions at all. We have to presuppose free will and we have to start from some axiom.
- 44:04So, yeah, this is deep.
- 44:08Yeah, I'm going to change it up a notch because I think this is quite fascinating.
- 44:13And I want to go back to the beginning of our conversation where we were talking about Andreas and Bitcoin celebrities and stuff.
- 44:24I see your name there.
- 44:26That name is – well, that's only because that gives me a chance to plug one of my bonus episodes, but I'll do that later.
- 44:32Yeah.
- 44:32it is fascinating like i began saying i remember this world of bitcoiners before there were
- 44:40celebrity bitcoin celebrities and i've i think you're we're not celebrities well you know what
- 44:46i mean it's a bitcoin we're recognized within our own bubble yeah i know but but i can almost
- 44:50remember the exact time it started happening and it was the conference in america after the pandemic
- 44:57when when i when people started realizing holy shit the last couple of years people have been
- 45:04locked away watching videos of me or you you know of some you know and suddenly they walk into a room
- 45:11full of 10 000 people and everyone knows their name and i had that experience in miami that year
- 45:16like uh i came to miami and people started recognizing me on the street at miami beach
- 45:23is a completely surreal experience for a schmuck like me.
- 45:27I know, but it is interesting.
- 45:29And it's because when we were walking here from the venue,
- 45:32you were talking about something that I find quite interesting,
- 45:37which is that you've lost count of how many appearances you've had to do this.
- 45:41Yeah, I reached my Dunbar's number of experiences.
- 45:44Like, it's all a mess.
- 45:46Like, I can't remember where I was and what I was doing.
- 45:49Like, I do too many.
- 45:50And what do you think about that?
- 45:51What do you think about that?
- 45:52like think about it think about cypherpunks and bitcoin and this and what do you think about the
- 45:57fact that you know now you do book signings now you kind of got to go on stage like 200 times a
- 46:05year and say something about bitcoin i know it's it's a really interesting phenomenon well luke and
- 46:11i have a a thing we want to live by when we do our stuff together that my co-host for the show
- 46:18and the co-author for Inverse of Clown World.
- 46:20We do a lot of shit together, have our publishing house and whatnot.
- 46:25Anyway, in anything we do, we have the saying,
- 46:28feet on the ground, head in the clouds.
- 46:30Because you need both.
- 46:32You need to stay grounded.
- 46:33You need to still...
- 46:36I know of authors that think it's tedious and like,
- 46:42oh, I'm going to have to sign books again.
- 46:44It's so boring.
- 46:45What they have forgotten is that the guy on the other side of the table buying the book and wanting your signature this is a true moment for them they looked forward to seeing you and you have one of
- 46:58the most the best problems in the world to have it's it's you you think it's uh tedious and boring
- 47:07to be appreciated by others like who gets to do that it's just so never lose your footing like i'm
- 47:15I'm stoked every time still that someone wants my signature.
- 47:20It's just bizarre to me.
- 47:21Like, holy shit.
- 47:23And I can pat myself on the back and say, like, you did something good here.
- 47:27I think, like, this is working.
- 47:29So I try to always remember where I came from and always remember it's the stay humble thing.
- 47:36And I'm obviously the most humble bitcoiner ever.
- 47:40In the history of Bitcoin.
- 47:41I have the platinum status humbleness.
- 47:44anyway uh but but also you need your head in the clouds because you you need to uh realize that
- 47:53if you're not believing in yourself no one else is going to believe in you either
- 47:57so you can actually do way more with your life than it seems at first glance do you think that
- 48:06you wanted this like do you think because if you think about it you did absolutely i mean when i
- 48:12grew up and in my teens and stuff i wanted to be a rock star and like fortune and fame like of
- 48:17course that had a a role in it but going but the older i got it's more like i want my work to be
- 48:25recognized not my person and it's very much like that now like it's the uh josh homie of queens of
- 48:32the stone age uh expressed it nicely once he said that like when someone writes a good song they
- 48:38tend to forget that it's the song that's beautiful not them and it's like the metaphor used was like
- 48:44if a fisherman catches a beautiful fish it's the fish that is beautiful not the fisherman
- 48:49so you're and so i try to approach work that way like i try to make the books the best i can
- 48:57and the pod the best i can and try to be myself and like but
- 49:01not take myself too seriously but also uh allowed myself to to be proud of what i do and you can't
- 49:11be proud of it if you're not proud of it so like you better put your best effort into it has anyone
- 49:15ever tried to slay you as in slay the heroes yeah i've been called a hypocrite on several occasions
- 49:22for instance last time was because we have bitbox as a um a sponsor and bitbox is an old hardware
- 49:31wallet and i made some tweet about i'm not gonna attend conferences or stuff where there are shit
- 49:36coin apologists and i'm gonna be harsher against shit coinery and someone pointed out that well you
- 49:42have a shit coiner sponsor but like that this is a hardware wallet that has been around since
- 49:48forever and they're very much bitcoin focused they just still have those services i think it's
- 49:53different with a company that has its legacy back in when bitcoin maximalism wasn't even a thing
- 49:58and companies that turn shit coinery afterwards
- 50:02or companies that are deliberately confusing people.
- 50:06Like Coinbase, for instance.
- 50:08Brian Armstrong never says Bitcoin.
- 50:09He says crypto all the time.
- 50:11And it's like because he makes money doing that.
- 50:14But it's dishonest.
- 50:15So, like, I mean, to a certain extent,
- 50:20I think everyone's a hypocrite,
- 50:22but you sort of have to pick your battles.
- 50:24And unfortunately, everyone still needs fiat income to survive in the world we're living in.
- 50:32And every time I use fiat, I am aware that I'm stealing from my children and I'm participating in a crime, basically, by using fiat.
- 50:41I'm using money that someone has the ability to counterfeit at will and that I'm enabling that criminal every time I use it.
- 50:51But I'm very aware of that.
- 50:53And I try to be aware of when I'm being hypocritical and try to be as truthful as possible.
- 51:00And I don't want to keep secrets from people.
- 51:04What's your thoughts on that?
- 51:05Do you agree with this?
- 51:08Would you take a bag of shit coins?
- 51:11Would it depend on the size of the bag?
- 51:13No, I wouldn't.
- 51:15But I think if you live by the sword, you die by the sword.
- 51:18I don't go around saying, oh, you shouldn't shitcoin.
- 51:22I'm more like you can do whatever you want.
- 51:25And if you live by the fork, you die by the fork.
- 51:27But, yeah, are you saying I'm overweight?
- 51:29No, no, I'm thinking of hard forks.
- 51:32But, for example, I would love more sponsors on this show.
- 51:36And I had the option to have a sponsor.
- 51:39But, and I can't even say who they were because it would, I just don't want to.
- 51:44But it was something I decided not to go with because I thought it was not on brand and it's to do with crypto.
- 51:53So in that sense, yes.
- 51:55But I think probably if you analysed everything I do, like I have people on it, like a lot of the people in the Free Cities world has a spectrum of people in it.
- 52:06And you do get, like I went to Zuzalu, which was a pop-up city in Montenegro.
- 52:12Vitalik paid for the whole thing.
- 52:14Vitalik was there. It was a weird experience seeing him in real life. He's a strange guy. He's not my kind of person at all. And I don't mind that. I tried to actually get him on the show, but he wouldn't come. And I wasn't going to gotcha him. I don't care. I really enjoy talking to people and getting to the bottom of everything.
- 52:32but but um a lot of the people in the free cities movement especially the people in the longevity
- 52:38space and people who are creating you know pop up this and new cities belagi you know there's a lot
- 52:45of people on that side of the spectrum that don't have a problem with it they see it as a technology
- 52:49that they're they're just working with and so i'm shit coining in that sense because i'm giving them
- 52:55a platform but but i don't care i i i believe i really do believe in in people listening to
- 53:02opinions and making their own money.
- 53:04There is a
- 53:05balance to be struck there.
- 53:08Because platforming
- 53:10dishonest people,
- 53:12it's not something I want to do.
- 53:14And sometimes
- 53:14in hindsight realize that they were not
- 53:18playing a straight game.
- 53:20But for instance,
- 53:21you have to weigh the potential
- 53:24good against the
- 53:25already detected bad.
- 53:27For instance, I disagree with
- 53:30Bitcoin Magazine about a lot of things.
- 53:32And I think they're into some dodgy stuff.
- 53:35Regardless of that, I'm good friends with one of the editors.
- 53:40And he wanted to publish two chapters of my Praxeology book in Bacor magazine.
- 53:44So I let him.
- 53:45Because I get more eyes on it.
- 53:47The ideas in there are sound.
- 53:49And if that can help people, then that's good.
- 53:54But this is a tricky thing.
- 53:57The guilt by association thing seems like a very left-winger thing.
- 54:03Yeah, I agree.
- 54:04And I think people should, if they get burned, and of course no one should bail them out, they should take responsibility for their own actions.
- 54:13But I really don't want to help scammers scam people.
- 54:18I still want to call a scammer a scammer.
- 54:21But there's a balance to be struck for sure.
- 54:23um i'm about to plug a bonus episode now because it's it's interesting and relative to this i don't
- 54:30know whether you know on fountain now they do i i host on fountain and fountain allow you to do
- 54:35bonus episodes and stuff great i started doing them but i started yeah i started digging out
- 54:40old episodes of things i've done with bitcoin is in the past that never actually in the past that
- 54:46never got published because i was i was making a film once about proof of work years ago just
- 54:51which the pandemic just annihilated and i'd done lots and lots of interviews with really
- 54:56interesting bitcoiners yeah and one of them was with gg oh yeah never been never been heard before
- 55:02really but except by me and him it's four hours of us talking so i started putting so i i chopped
- 55:07it into two and i put one out a few weeks ago and the second one i i listened to it back the other
- 55:12night it's actually the first time i've listened to it since we spoke it oh and it's hilarious
- 55:16because do you know what was happening at that time is breed love had just done the um big cloud
- 55:22thing yeah yeah and gg is hilarious he's he's the funniest motherfucker on the planet yeah yeah i
- 55:28know and we were talking about it and it brought back all these kind of sweet memories i mean you
- 55:33know i i i've always been a little bit skeptical of robert breed love for that reason nothing else
- 55:40once again you know separate you can separate people into different categories like they can be
- 55:47they can do this but they can also do that you know great painters can be ourselves you know
- 55:52yeah but but it's very funny like oh yeah exactly but it's very funny listening to us talk about it
- 55:59because i forgot about that whole world of of and this was the time when the the celebrity the cult
- 56:06of celebrity.
- 56:06Like you said,
- 56:07we were all slaying.
- 56:08I had gotten to know Breedlove pretty well by then and I was disappointed as fuck that he did that But then I think like and some people just cut him out completely and slayed him
- 56:22I think he somewhat redeemed himself by just putting out great content for a while.
- 56:27But it's like some people just, once in a while, they do this really dodgy thing
- 56:31and everyone's like, oh my God, why the fuck did he do that?
- 56:34and if they can just make up for it with enough good stuff then that's it's some somewhat
- 56:41forgivable like i believe in second chances i don't believe in third chances so i'll say that
- 56:46that's a that's a very common trust people once yeah and yeah yeah when people show you who they
- 56:53really are we believe them and all of that but i do believe there's a power in forgiveness too
- 56:59and that people can change.
- 57:00And if you can and if you think it's appropriate,
- 57:05you should give people a second chance,
- 57:07but you should never give them a third chance.
- 57:09The thing is, though, I doubt, in this case, Robert Breedlove needs any forgiveness.
- 57:16I doubt he's looking for forgiveness.
- 57:18If it was me and I did that, I wouldn't care if Knut thought he was going to forgive me.
- 57:24No, no, no.
- 57:24He probably doesn't.
- 57:25he did uh he did make an apology of about it quite close to when it happened like it was really i
- 57:35think that's what we were talking about it was pretty passive aggressive though it was it wasn't
- 57:39really an apology it was sort of doubling down yeah so that was like yeah and then he disappeared
- 57:45for a while and then he came back doing great content so like yeah i'm i'm willing to like
- 57:50forget about that funny thing is i i haven't listened i don't think i've listened i should
- 57:56go back to is he still doing the what is money show yeah he is and he's got eric stacks on now
- 58:01like as he's uh they're doing stuff together and sometimes it's just eric and sometimes it's just
- 58:06rob and i went to miami like a month ago and uh i was really going to naples and then to canada but
- 58:13but i stopped by breedlove's house in in miami and and did a pod with eric uh the cannabis farmer
- 58:19if you know about him.
- 58:21The guy that always wears a hat.
- 58:22Yeah.
- 58:22Yeah, great guy.
- 58:25Yeah, I don't know where he popped up at somewhere
- 58:27in the last couple of years.
- 58:29All right.
- 58:30And how was that?
- 58:31It was great.
- 58:32I had been up for 20 hours at the time
- 58:34because I'd been traveling.
- 58:37Prague was just before that.
- 58:38And I said goodbye to my family and traveled for 20 hours.
- 58:42So, but talking about phases,
- 58:46like the the the kind of the the bitcoin movement goes through and you've got that time when you had
- 58:53all these celebrities appearing and then everyone got slayed and then the and what i feel like now
- 59:00there's there's there's a couple of things happening which also kind of seem to be in
- 59:06conflict with each other on the one hand you've got this absolute joy and excitement about the
- 59:11price and about the amount of legitimizing things that are happening and this is incredible but then
- 59:17on the other end of the spectrum the real world is getting really shitty and and you would imagine
- 59:23that this is these two are obviously related it's like that scene in the big short like
- 59:27just don't fucking dance so so but i feel like i'm currently feeling two emotions at the same time
- 59:37literally like pure dread and i mean in the form of like you know say the latest one in the uk the
- 59:44online safety bill it's horrible yeah all this stuff but also the fact that a lot of bitcoiners
- 59:51are getting rich and now they're starting to realize right i'd like to do something with my
- 59:55money and now they're going oh how do i spend it without doing xyz because i believe in this and i
- 1:00:03don't believe that you know and that's that seems to be this kind of reality check happening that
- 1:00:11that is like yeah it's you know it's real it's real like a lot of bitcoiners are trying to now
- 1:00:18do things in real life it's gone beyond you know it used to be a movement it was a cypherpunk thing
- 1:00:23then it was kind of like oh we're getting a bit rich and now it's like right it's not enough to
- 1:00:27just be a bitcoiner i've got to do something yeah you know but i was going to use my stack but now
- 1:00:33oh i'm going to get capital gains taxed or i'm going to get a kyc yeah but that only applies if
- 1:00:39you actually receive fiat money in a bank account like if you exchange your bitcoin for cash somewhere
- 1:00:46or if you buy something from someone with your sets no one's going to care like the the only
- 1:00:53triggers for all this tax stuff is if you actually touch the banking system. So I would say that's a
- 1:01:00problem with the banking system and not a problem with Bitcoin. And it's also a problem with people
- 1:01:04not having the courage to not give a fuck about what these self-proclaimed leaders tell them is
- 1:01:09correct. Like, yeah, you should take care so that you don't end up in trouble and some public
- 1:01:15criminal takes 30% of your money. But then don't use their services. Like, don't use the banks.
- 1:01:23So if we want this to be an actual opt-out option, we need to start using it.
- 1:01:29And when you're doing all the conferencing, you see it happening because everyone's using Bitcoin and no one's giving a fuck.
- 1:01:35And because it's way more convenient, it's way better in every single sense, and everyone's just using Bitcoin.
- 1:01:43And we need to make that happen in the real world too.
- 1:01:47And I'm using the word we too much.
- 1:01:49I don't really believe in that word.
- 1:01:50But I think it sort of implies a collectivist thing.
- 1:01:56Who am I to say what other people should do?
- 1:01:59That kind of thing.
- 1:02:00I don't take it.
- 1:02:00But anyway.
- 1:02:02It's more warming than that.
- 1:02:03Yeah.
- 1:02:04I wish that people were more courageous and dared to bite the hand that obviously doesn't feed them and stop caring about stuff.
- 1:02:17And to me, the things are happening in the UK, and I think there's something like 30 arrests for social media posts per day or something.
- 1:02:27It's insane now.
- 1:02:29Why isn't there the biggest uprising ever against that?
- 1:02:33George Orwell was born in the UK, and this is worse than anything he ever imagined.
- 1:02:40It's insane.
- 1:02:42Do you know what?
- 1:02:42That just reminded me.
- 1:02:43I wrote down this quote this morning and I was going to bring it up with one of my former guests, but it's very it would fit right in now because it's it's George Orwell wrote this.
- 1:02:56hayek's thesis is that socialism inevitably leads to despotism and that the nazis were able to
- 1:03:05succeed because socialists had already done most of the work for them especially the intellectual
- 1:03:12work of weakening the desire for liberty yeah and the the hardest pill to swallow
- 1:03:18is that democracy is socialism.
- 1:03:23Democracy leads to totalitarianism.
- 1:03:26It's the most taboo thing to ever critique,
- 1:03:29but it's based on majority rule
- 1:03:32and based on that some people are allowed
- 1:03:37to steal stuff from other people without their consent.
- 1:03:41And I just think it's immoral through and through,
- 1:03:44and I think it always leads to more and more theft,
- 1:03:49more and more totalitarianism.
- 1:03:51Once an institution is in place,
- 1:03:53it's going to fight for its own survival,
- 1:03:56like every other living being.
- 1:04:00All governments need to extract more and more over time,
- 1:04:03and you see this cycle playing out over and over again
- 1:04:06until there's a revolution and a reset,
- 1:04:09and then we go back to somewhat more respected property rights.
- 1:04:13But all the horrors of the 20th century with the world wars, we haven't fixed the core problem yet, the money printing.
- 1:04:24It's what financed both wars and what led to both wars.
- 1:04:29In a way, the first world war is still ongoing and the bad guys won.
- 1:04:33They're still stealing our stuff.
- 1:04:35They're still doing whatever they want to us.
- 1:04:37That's the thing we have to resist.
- 1:04:40like uh i'm totally there by the way i'm radicalized fully 100 anarcho-capitalist
- 1:04:48i think government is a net bad and we would be better off without it and i think you can
- 1:04:54reason yourself to that position without needing any evidence it's an a priori deductible
- 1:05:01knowledge that everyone could who just sat down and thunk could like reason themselves into
- 1:05:09Does it ever solve itself though, other than cyclically?
- 1:05:14It solves itself individually.
- 1:05:18Like individuals do find ways to navigate around it.
- 1:05:21And the more individuals that do that, the better off we are.
- 1:05:25The more we can separate ourselves from the state on an individual level the better it gets But this is not something that can be solved democratically It cannot be solved from within the system you have to take matters in you to your own hands you have to follow your heart
- 1:05:42and your balls and fuck off it's the only way democracy leads to totalitarianism i think i'm
- 1:05:52gonna have to call the episode this that's a really bold i like the way you described it as
- 1:05:55well as the ultimate red pill yeah there's the hopper book uh democracy the god that failed yes
- 1:06:01But there's also a newer book, I don't remember its name, but it was released just a couple of years ago, that Andre from Free Madeira recommended about how democracy is flawed.
- 1:06:16I mean…
- 1:06:16All forms of democracy? What about direct democracy and all this kind of stuff?
- 1:06:20you know pirate there are grades grades of of it of course uh and a a democracy in which only
- 1:06:28property owners uh get to vote about their stuff is obviously better than a democracy where everyone
- 1:06:36gets to vote uh but but still i think we would do better without it a popularity contest that's
- 1:06:44not at all give anyone any other any more natural right to take my stuff or anyone else's for that
- 1:06:51matter it's it's it's not natural and it's something we can and will do without at some
- 1:06:58point i i believe bitcoin fixes this if we allow it to but it's all so you think in a bitcoin future
- 1:07:06we won't trend towards this outcome because if you think about it on an individual level it's
- 1:07:13easy for you to decide i'm not going to steal someone's stuff but as you get more and more
- 1:07:17collective it becomes no but this is this is this is the flawed thinking like we have to stop using
- 1:07:25the word we because it implies that we ought to do something together and it's much more important
- 1:07:32that people do this individually if you don't take matters into your own hands and if you don't
- 1:07:36reclaim the driver's seat of your life no one else is going to do it for you if you outsource that to
- 1:07:42groupthink thing, then you end up in the same dilemma as you were in the first place.
- 1:07:47That's the whole we thing.
- 1:07:50That's the collectivist trap.
- 1:07:52That's what leads to democracy, which then leads to totalitarianism.
- 1:07:56Of course, different governmental models have their own flaws, like a monarchy is not flawless,
- 1:08:04a dictatorship is absolutely not flawless.
- 1:08:06But thinking that we solve all problems by just being democratic is just naive and ignorant.
- 1:08:15We've been taught, like we've been spoon fed this propaganda from public service media outlets and 12 years of mandatory schooling.
- 1:08:25Where we've been taught that a belief in democracy is just as vital and important and true as one plus one equals two.
- 1:08:33Which is absolutely not.
- 1:08:35It's an opinion that the people that hold the opinion are more often than not people who live off of others and just take stuff violently from them.
- 1:08:49I think it's mind-blowing that the entire world is sort of brainwashed into this mode of thinking that this is the only way.
- 1:08:57I absolutely don't think it is.
- 1:08:59I think respecting property rights is the absolute most crucial thing for that is peace in my mind.
- 1:09:04i i i'm a relative um newcomer to that idea though i've spent most of my life believing that
- 1:09:13and so it's so did i i'm a big like 40 years deeply about as many things as i can yeah but
- 1:09:19that just shows you you said you can't understand why it's such a prevalent idea and no it's
- 1:09:25everywhere but but it is and we've both fallen for it in the past so so and i think i know why
- 1:09:32I mean, on face value, it seems really fair, doesn't it?
- 1:09:36Yeah, but only if you...
- 1:09:38It's superficial to think it is, though.
- 1:09:41Of course, yeah.
- 1:09:42I know now that in reality, even, I mean, we've just gone through an election
- 1:09:47where I think the guys who won got in on 20% of the total number of people
- 1:09:54in the country's votes, which is...
- 1:09:57So obviously that's broken.
- 1:09:58but people looked at that and kind of went oh well uh not many people came out to vote
- 1:10:03so be it like no one they don't get a shit wrong you know do you know how often they have elections
- 1:10:10in china they never do they have them every morning sorry this is the kind of stuff that
- 1:10:22gives you a bad reputation okay sorry about that but um but no i mean it's it's a very it is it is
- 1:10:32the ultimate red pill in this day and age if you are a thinking person yeah i see people constantly
- 1:10:38arguing over politics but never stopping to think that it's the politics that's the problem
- 1:10:45no you know what i mean and never seeing the connection between the monetary system and
- 1:10:49politics never seeing how the monetary monetary policy is what makes the cancer grow so fast and
- 1:10:55so large like all the good stuff originated from a time where taxes were way lower
- 1:11:03they're higher than they have ever been in all all of the western world at least and it's just
- 1:11:10it's just growing larger and like my home country sweden that now supposedly has a right-wing
- 1:11:17government they didn't cut any spending they just changed some stuff like the not there's not a
- 1:11:24single party that wants to reduce the size of the state apparatus so which means to me means that
- 1:11:30it's going to eat everything at some point what about mille what do you think of mille he seems
- 1:11:35to be doing that right i think he's uh entertaining and i love that he exists and i love that he
- 1:11:41quotes Rothbard all the time but I
- 1:11:43urge any
- 1:11:44self-respecting
- 1:11:46anarcho-capitalist
- 1:11:49to watch Hoppe talk about
- 1:11:51Milley and how much of his
- 1:11:53politics that are really not
- 1:11:55that libertarian. Well Hoppe
- 1:11:56has commented on it. Yeah.
- 1:11:58And he views Milley as some
- 1:12:00a bit of a clown
- 1:12:03that he says one thing but does
- 1:12:05another. I mean the state is
- 1:12:07still very much present in Argentina
- 1:12:08and he took out a big loan
- 1:12:11to finance the central bank once again to strengthen the pesos.
- 1:12:14The peso is a bit better than before,
- 1:12:16but it's really not walking the walk the entire 21 miles.
- 1:12:25But of course, I love that he exists.
- 1:12:27I think he's enormously entertaining.
- 1:12:30To me, politicians are –
- 1:12:32I can say I like a politician more than another,
- 1:12:36but I don't like any politicians.
- 1:12:38And I think comparing Miele to any politician in the UK is like, yeah, sure, I'd rather have the flu than testicle cancer.
- 1:12:50Like, so he's the lesser of two evils, absolutely.
- 1:12:54And he's going to change the country for the better.
- 1:12:58But he's still not an anarcho-capitalist, really, in my opinion.
- 1:13:04think he i mean he he claims to be at least but do you think he's just that's as good as he can do
- 1:13:11within the framework of the well there's some truth to that that these reforms are hard and
- 1:13:16he has to play the game to a certain extent but yeah uh we are yet to see where where where the
- 1:13:26melee experiment ends up and uh yeah i'm giving willing to give him the benefit of the doubt for
- 1:13:31a while but and i think he's definitely better than any alternative so do we have any examples
- 1:13:38in history that are particularly inspiring in in apart from revolutions bloody revolutions
- 1:13:46what are the what are the good examples of of governments getting smaller for want of a better
- 1:13:54word? Hong Kong? In what sense? Hong Kong was very free for 50 years when it belonged to the UK,
- 1:14:08but was a free trade zone. And they had almost no taxes and was very laissez-faire. And it went from
- 1:14:16a village in the countryside to skyscrapers everywhere. That's a good example.
- 1:14:22I wasn't looking for that kind of example, but I mean like governments voting themselves smaller and solving the problem.
- 1:14:29But no, but let's stick to Hong Kong because you've basically just described a free city.
- 1:14:34Yeah, in a way it was a free city.
- 1:14:37Of course not 100% free, but what is?
- 1:14:40But I mean a place run by merchants with very small political moves.
- 1:14:48All the Hansa cities, some of the most beautiful cities around Northern Europe, all the beautiful buildings and everything were built during a time where merchants,
- 1:15:00gave very few fucks about what the kings thought about them.
- 1:15:04And it's a testament to how good things can get
- 1:15:07when you get that kind of trade going.
- 1:15:10Venice also.
- 1:15:11Venice, yeah.
- 1:15:12The most successful city in the world.
- 1:15:13Amsterdam.
- 1:15:14Yeah.
- 1:15:15But no, I agree with you.
- 1:15:17I agree that the places –
- 1:15:20I mean, Dubai is doing the same thing at the moment.
- 1:15:22It's traders going there to trade,
- 1:15:25not really to go there and vote on who does what.
- 1:15:28Yeah, but good and bad. I mean, Dubai is still totalitarian in some senses.
- 1:15:36But the reason Europeans are moving to Dubai more than Dubaians are moving to Europe is that when you actually watch people's actions, you can see that they enjoy property rights more than they enjoy free speech because they're moving in that direction.
- 1:15:56so uh yeah you can't say anything you want about the sheik or whatever in in dubai
- 1:16:01i've got a thought experiment for you um i want to hear what you would say if say you had um you
- 1:16:10had a totalitarian this is something we discuss in the movement quite a lot you have a totalitarian
- 1:16:16totalitarian government that wants to start a free city in their in their country because it's
- 1:16:23freer inside the city like a version of um dubai when it was when it was before dubai was dubai
- 1:16:32isn't that what prosper is sort of or um well i wouldn't call not at the time i wouldn't have
- 1:16:38called um honduras a totalitarian place say say somewhere like um well no the here's an example
- 1:16:46the example would be dubai had sharia law for example and it created a small pocket inside of
- 1:16:53dubai which allowed common law and as a result western businesses could move in because they
- 1:16:59the financial district that worked on common law now imagine it's a pretty totalitarian country
- 1:17:05but the the the ruler wants some kind of reform so he creates a little oasis of more freedom than
- 1:17:13totalitarianism so not not not complete freedom is that a good or a bad thing well it's with always
- 1:17:20with a caveat though right because it's his personal experiment and he can rug you at any
- 1:17:25time okay but still it's still is it still something you would pursue or not pursue how
- 1:17:31well like say because in this movement we're like my my my opinion would be look is it better than
- 1:17:37is is is life inside there better than life outside of there if it is probably do it do it
- 1:17:42you know regardless of what you think is going to happen the whole vote with your feet thing
- 1:17:47It's absolutely a thing, and it's going to drive out the freer countries, and the more Bitcoin-friendly countries are going to attract better brains.
- 1:18:00It's a brain drain thing, and the more the government gives to passivity, the more it's going to attract passive.
- 1:18:09I mean, you get what you pay for.
- 1:18:12So that's definitely a thing.
- 1:18:14but I think it's equally important
- 1:18:16if you can't move with your feet
- 1:18:18and if you don't want to
- 1:18:20it's very important that you stay where you are
- 1:18:22and take the fight
- 1:18:23as soon as you think the situation
- 1:18:26is hopeless
- 1:18:27they've won
- 1:18:29never lose hope
- 1:18:31optimism to me
- 1:18:34and this is in the revised version
- 1:18:36of the Praxeology book
- 1:18:37in a chapter called What About the Roads
- 1:18:39if you look at the movie
- 1:18:43The Shawshank Redemption
- 1:18:44You know the famous prison movie, right?
- 1:18:46Andy.
- 1:18:46Love it.
- 1:18:47Andy Dufresne is the protagonist and his best friend Red, played by Morgan Freeman.
- 1:18:53And then you have a character called Brooks Shields, who's 90 years old and gets released from the prison when he's 90.
- 1:19:01And he spends two weeks outside and then he hangs himself.
- 1:19:05And he does so because he's being completely institutionalized.
- 1:19:08institutionalized. In the prison, he knew the rules and he gets his three free meals per day.
- 1:19:13He knows his bedtime. The outside world was terrifying to him because he had been
- 1:19:19indoctrinated to think that hope was a dangerous thing. And this is what Red tells Andy in the
- 1:19:25movie, that hope is dangerous because all it will bring you is misery because there is no hope.
- 1:19:31this is really the gist of the movie
- 1:19:34so what Andy does
- 1:19:37he has this entire career
- 1:19:38within the prison and does
- 1:19:40favors for the prison warden who then
- 1:19:43later rugs him and is really mean
- 1:19:45to him and he's just stuck in there forever
- 1:19:47it seems but every day
- 1:19:48he's been doing the low time preference thing
- 1:19:50and taking a spoon and digging
- 1:19:53out a big tunnel in the wall
- 1:19:54behind a poster in his cell
- 1:19:56and he finally after 10 years
- 1:19:59or something he escapes and he's a free
- 1:20:01man and he moves to Mexico and enjoys life. And by his actions, he's showing Red that hope is never
- 1:20:09futile. It is the rational choice. Because you could either die fighting to be a free man,
- 1:20:17or you can die a prisoner. But the catch is that you're going to die anyway,
- 1:20:23so you might as well live as if hope exists.
- 1:20:29So by that logic, it is a first principle rational choice
- 1:20:33to not allow the metaphorical Shawshank walls to be real.
- 1:20:40So no matter what laws your government put up around you,
- 1:20:44the rational choice is to have hope and not give a fuck about them.
- 1:20:48Give them a middle finger, either if you're staying where you are
- 1:20:51or if you're voting with your feet or if you become a fully-fledged Bitcoiner,
- 1:20:55do something to emancipate yourself.
- 1:20:59We can't do this collectively.
- 1:21:01It's up to each and every one of us.
- 1:21:03They can still extort the people who don't.
- 1:21:06It's tragic, but there's no such thing as fairness
- 1:21:11as long as people are allowed to use violence to get what they want.
- 1:21:17So you might as well live as if the prison walls, metaphorical prison walls don't exist.
- 1:21:23And I think that's the message I want to deliver to people.
- 1:21:28Hope is a rational choice.
- 1:21:30Hope is what – yeah.
- 1:21:36Struggling to find the last sentence here, but like, yeah, Spanoinkel, end of rant.
- 1:21:43Victor Frankl and Man's Search for Meaning.
- 1:21:46what was the hope component in that i'm just i did he unaware as in you know like man's search
- 1:21:53for meaning uh as in you know not finding freedom in the most unfree situations you can like you know
- 1:22:00he was in a he was in a concentration camp oh yeah yeah yeah completely how does hope come into that
- 1:22:06equation there because it's it's interesting that freedom i was thinking about whether there was a
- 1:22:12connection between freedom and hope yeah there is what is it i mean hope is a hope for more freedom
- 1:22:18always like they could you could hope in your case but it might not be in someone else's case
- 1:22:24well what would you hope for rather than freedom children i don't know uh getting married you know
- 1:22:30what i mean or is it am i not going deep enough uh i mean we me currently yes in my life and in
- 1:22:38the stage of my life, the number one topic that I think about is freedom in all its shapes
- 1:22:46and forms.
- 1:22:47That's kind of on my mind.
- 1:22:49There's an Austrian definition of freedom, and it's the sphere in which, let me see if
- 1:22:53I can remember this correctly, the sphere in which you are able to choose between different
- 1:23:00modes of action.
- 1:23:01and those what limits that sphere can be external things like governments or nature
- 1:23:10or it can be internal that your psychology prevents you from taking certain paths and you need to like
- 1:23:16grow up and think outside the box and change your life if you if you want more freedom you
- 1:23:22have to be willing to give up some of your beliefs maybe or some of your like
- 1:23:27i think i mean victor frankel well the conclusion i drew is that your true freedom is in your action
- 1:23:38the way you relate to the thing that's happening to you so someone can lock you in a cell
- 1:23:44and throw the key away but they can't choose the way you exactly appreciate they can't take your
- 1:23:53thoughts yeah i mean but they might in the future who knows technologically i don't know thought
- 1:23:59extractor in your ears no but then they're i mean i wouldn't be surprised if in our lifetime you
- 1:24:07could point a little device at someone brain and get a sense of what they thinking and that and that just phase one of of the technology technological art we on i don know i i i have a more
- 1:24:22pessimistic if you will like a view of technology like we we hear that ai is going to change
- 1:24:29everything and we hear that virtual reality has supposedly been a thing that is just around the
- 1:24:36corner now for 30 years and all of this stuff like i think um yeah there is technological
- 1:24:44progress but it more often than not it's not what we think it is like most ai is being used to
- 1:24:52generate internet slop nowadays and just fake tiktok videos and whatnot no one really asked
- 1:24:58or no one really needs.
- 1:25:01So in a way, I think the...
- 1:25:07I don't really like thinking about potential things
- 1:25:12like quantum resistance in Bitcoin, for instance.
- 1:25:16There's a fear that quantum computers will break everything.
- 1:25:21Worry about that when these things are actually here.
- 1:25:24A lot of that is just things to put on the front cover
- 1:25:28of a popular science magazine, and it's not actually a thing.
- 1:25:32But aren't most people thinking,
- 1:25:34especially in the case of AI or quantum computing,
- 1:25:38when it happens, it's going to happen quite suddenly or not?
- 1:25:44Well, who knows?
- 1:25:45And you say when it happens, like it's a given, but it's not.
- 1:25:49The thing is, in Bitcoin, first of all,
- 1:25:55quantum computing can't break SHA256.
- 1:25:58It can break some other algorithms involved in Bitcoin,
- 1:26:01from what I know.
- 1:26:03I'm not an expert here either.
- 1:26:06It can't break SHA256?
- 1:26:09No.
- 1:26:09I thought it was just a guessing game, though.
- 1:26:12That's about compute, right?
- 1:26:14Yeah.
- 1:26:15I wouldn't be able to go deeper into that
- 1:26:18because I don't know the reasons.
- 1:26:20This is like, from what I've heard,
- 1:26:24someone who i respect and know and i've forgotten whom so don't fucking clip this and turn it into
- 1:26:30quotes because i'm making another point really yeah don't don't verify trust
- 1:26:36anyway my point is that if if quantum computing breaks uh a lot of security algorithms that the
- 1:26:46banks are much more fucked than bitcoin is because we have at least 10 minutes to fix the problem
- 1:26:51at least we have 10 minutes to fix the problem they don't so we have more problems than that
- 1:26:57like nuka or launch codes and stuff um i let's talk a little bit i i i'm unfortunately i know
- 1:27:05we can't go for four hours today because um oh no is coming quite soon but we've we've got a bit
- 1:27:13of time left can i just take a leak before we go yeah sure sure and true rogan style
- 1:27:18um we were this was a this was what i was going to say was continuing on from our discussion about
- 1:27:28sort of personalities in bitcoin is you end up being able to monetize it and that's good
- 1:27:36because you need to make a job you have a job and this that and the other and blah blah blah and
- 1:27:40one of the biggest things that people struggle with myself included is trying to work and live
- 1:27:48in this world when you come from a completely different world and i've still not i have kind
- 1:27:53of nailed it i suppose i i mean i am in it full time now but it's still not a very super successful
- 1:28:00business and things like that and i think a lot of people now bitcoiners you're the same
- 1:28:04doing all kinds of stuff you've got uh education arm to your but a bow to your sorry arrow to your
- 1:28:13quiver now right and things like that um what how what is it and how does it work and and what do you
- 1:28:19know what what is you're just teaching are you teaching who you're teaching bitcoin to yeah so
- 1:28:24so uh i've been luke and i have been doing the um uh bitcoin infinity show for a little over two
- 1:28:32years oh we're running up on three years i think yeah we started did you start before me i'm i'm
- 1:28:39What episode are you on?
- 1:28:40What number?
- 1:28:42Do you do weekly or more than weekly?
- 1:28:45We do weekly.
- 1:28:47We have in the past done like two per week at certain points.
- 1:28:52Because I can always look at mine.
- 1:28:53Because I put one episode out on a Friday.
- 1:28:55I can look and I can see how long I've been going.
- 1:28:57But I need to look.
- 1:28:59I'm 142 weeks now.
- 1:29:01Yeah.
- 1:29:03We've promised ourselves to do at least 210 episodes.
- 1:29:07I think we're around 160 and something.
- 1:29:10So next spring we'll be at 210
- 1:29:12and we'll revaluate the whole thing
- 1:29:14if it's worth doing or not.
- 1:29:16But right now I think it would be worth doing
- 1:29:19even if I didn't have sponsors
- 1:29:21because I just love talking to people
- 1:29:23and getting to know people with interesting ideas.
- 1:29:28Exactly.
- 1:29:29But the new thing, the educational thing
- 1:29:31is the Bitcoin Infinity Academy.
- 1:29:33So there's a geyser fund for that.
- 1:29:35This is where I do the shilling, I guess.
- 1:29:37geyser.fund slash project slash infinity and you'll find a couple of different membership tiers
- 1:29:44where you can join the discussions and stuff but the the show is called the bitcoin infinity academy
- 1:29:49it's basically uh we're taking a chapter from each and every one of my books per week and
- 1:29:56reading that and discussing the ideas in that specific chapter um is that online that's online
- 1:30:03Yeah, so it's on YouTube and Fountain and all of these.
- 1:30:06But I mean, when you discuss them, do you discuss them with the students or whatever?
- 1:30:12Yeah, so if you join one of these courses, you can participate in the episode.
- 1:30:18Like people participate by chatting with us as we record the episode.
- 1:30:24So they're not actually on camera or anything like that, but they can be in a live chat while we record the episode.
- 1:30:30Safe Dean did that during the pandemic.
- 1:30:31That's how I met a lot of Bitcoins.
- 1:30:33Oh, really?
- 1:30:33first time yeah well i was in one of his courses like way back when yeah i did the first one yeah
- 1:30:39and with prince he did it um pretty young from the three cities he did it there was a few people
- 1:30:44and he started recording episodes of a podcast with us all there yeah so and you and a number
- 1:30:50of times you know it was a really interesting it's the same thing yeah it's very similar uh
- 1:30:55because there's only there are only so many ways you can do this but it has also led to a very
- 1:31:01you mentioned Giacomo and
- 1:31:03we now have a very good collaboration
- 1:31:06with the Plan B network
- 1:31:07and to me it's a dream come true
- 1:31:10to work with Giacomo
- 1:31:11I've known him for almost 10 years now
- 1:31:13and he's like
- 1:31:14one of those people where I'm very proud
- 1:31:17to call myself his friend
- 1:31:19like Gigi you mentioned before
- 1:31:21and like
- 1:31:21these are great
- 1:31:24thinkers and great educators
- 1:31:27and I just love being able to work with them
- 1:31:29So the other thing I'm doing with Plan B is that I was a guest star lecturer for the Plan B Business School and gave a lecture about praxeology this spring.
- 1:31:40And then I was there for a week in Logano in July here.
- 1:31:46They take the top 21 students in the world from the online course, and they get to spend a week in Logano, lectures every day for six days, full days.
- 1:31:58and then a big ceremony afterwards where they get an official paper.
- 1:32:05And most of the students from previous years have all gotten jobs in Bitcoin
- 1:32:10or have their own Bitcoin business afterwards.
- 1:32:12I was going to ask that.
- 1:32:13Anyone who went on to great things?
- 1:32:16It's like kind of an incubator, is it?
- 1:32:18Yeah, I wouldn't know any specific names, but it's definitely an incubator.
- 1:32:23And I mean, I love the students that were there.
- 1:32:26they were very alert and very eager to learn stuff.
- 1:32:31And how do they find them?
- 1:32:34Well, people join from all over the world.
- 1:32:36They join this online course, and then there's some tests and stuff.
- 1:32:41Giacomo can probably tell you more about the details later,
- 1:32:45but the best ones get to do this summer school thing.
- 1:32:48And what do you think of Locarno?
- 1:32:50There's something going on there, isn't there?
- 1:32:52I love it.
- 1:32:52I mean, what they're doing with the Plan B network and the Plan B hub, so it's a four-story building in the middle of the city that is just gorgeous and very modern design of the thing.
- 1:33:10And there's a lot of co-working spaces within the building.
- 1:33:15There's a gym in the basement and there's a big hall where you can give lectures and there's a podcasting room and whatnot.
- 1:33:22Bitcoin is moving there but is it the kind of place is it turning into a bit of a hub Somewhat I think But Lugano is very expensive It very Swiss for lack of a better word
- 1:33:40It's like Italy, but it works.
- 1:33:44So the cost of living is pretty high there.
- 1:33:47But then again, Bitcoin fixes this too, as we know.
- 1:33:54Have you got – I mean, so you're one of those people that has voted with your feet and you've moved somewhere.
- 1:34:01You don't have to say where, but –
- 1:34:02I moved to Spain.
- 1:34:03Yes.
- 1:34:04But the reason – the biggest reason for moving to Spain is that we already had a holiday home there.
- 1:34:10So we just moved down to that.
- 1:34:11now we bought another house and like sold the house in sweden and sold the house in
- 1:34:15spain and bought bought a bigger one in spain but uh and it was not for political reasons or
- 1:34:21anything like that have you is it something you think about going forward in the future you know
- 1:34:25where it seems to be on a lot of people's minds spain was never i never viewed it as a final
- 1:34:32destination it's like a first like getting my family on board with the idea that we might move
- 1:34:37in the future.
- 1:34:40Spain seems like it goes first step.
- 1:34:43And I mean,
- 1:34:44the bureaucracy in Spain
- 1:34:46is just completely horrible.
- 1:34:48And it's very socialistic
- 1:34:50and very retarded.
- 1:34:52But as a Bitcoiner,
- 1:34:54you sort of can be under the radar
- 1:34:56pretty easily there.
- 1:34:57I mean, I have no Bitcoin business
- 1:34:59in Spain whatsoever.
- 1:35:04So that's all in an Estonian company.
- 1:35:07uh,
- 1:35:08Luke and I have together.
- 1:35:09We started up a company in Estonia,
- 1:35:12so where we can do all the legit Bitcoin things.
- 1:35:16Uh,
- 1:35:16but Spain,
- 1:35:17other than that,
- 1:35:18it's,
- 1:35:19um,
- 1:35:19other than the horrible bureaucracy is,
- 1:35:22it's very relaxed and good place to live.
- 1:35:25Do you have,
- 1:35:25uh,
- 1:35:26any insight into the good places around the world where the people are moving to as,
- 1:35:33of late as in,
- 1:35:35especially Bitcoiners?
- 1:35:36Cause it's one of those things.
- 1:35:37It's,
- 1:35:37It's on everyone's mind.
- 1:35:39And one of the great attributes of Bitcoin is that you can travel with your wealth, which makes voting with your feet easier.
- 1:35:48So I know everyone talks about it and everyone has their favorite spots, Paraguay, Uruguay, I don't know, Mexico.
- 1:35:54I visited El Salvador for the first time this spring.
- 1:35:58And I was positively surprised by it because a lot of Bitcoiners have said like, oh, it's fake.
- 1:36:03You can't pay with Bitcoin in very many places and stuff.
- 1:36:07But I went into it thinking that that was the case and I could pay with Bitcoin almost everywhere.
- 1:36:12So I was happy with it.
- 1:36:14What's your view on the current politics that are politicking there?
- 1:36:19I mean, I just saw recently that it turns out they weren't stacking sats.
- 1:36:22They were just moving stuff around.
- 1:36:23Yeah, Bukele is a double-sided coin for sure.
- 1:36:26And he just changed the constitution so that he can stay for longer.
- 1:36:32I don't necessarily view that as bad because he's very popular.
- 1:36:35And as I explained before, democracy is not optimal.
- 1:36:40A benevolent dictator is probably better than a democracy for a country like El Salvador.
- 1:36:46So I don't particularly mind that.
- 1:36:51But yeah, it's like with all politics.
- 1:36:56It's grades of hell.
- 1:36:57i i think people have pointed out as well that there have been plenty of terrible leaders who
- 1:37:06began life very well liked especially in that part of the world as well yeah yeah so you know
- 1:37:12i don't know do you think in a place like el salvador um bitcoin can win or bitcoin has won
- 1:37:21if you're saying it's being used.
- 1:37:22So as a result, it's won.
- 1:37:27Because before, you can't stop the train,
- 1:37:29and now people are using it,
- 1:37:31and in the end, it defends the government, let's say.
- 1:37:35Yeah, it does.
- 1:37:37The snowball has just started to roll down the hill,
- 1:37:40and it's infecting the neighboring countries.
- 1:37:43Costa Rica has a giant Bitcoin scene now,
- 1:37:45like the Satoshi Lake or whatever it's called over there.
- 1:37:50Bitcoin Lake.
- 1:37:51Yeah, or Bitcoin Jungle.
- 1:37:53Oh, that's it.
- 1:37:54Bitcoin Jungle is the name.
- 1:37:56So these things are happening.
- 1:37:59And it's not only El Sonte anymore.
- 1:38:01There's another smaller town in El Salvador called Berlin, up in the mountains,
- 1:38:06that is basically a Bitcoin circular economy.
- 1:38:09Do you think that's how it happens, through circular economies?
- 1:38:13I don't believe in circular economies because I think everything's interconnected.
- 1:38:17Okay.
- 1:38:17So I don't particularly like the term because we're all connected, all human beings, whether we'd like to or not.
- 1:38:26It's like the Kevin Bacon numbers on IMDb, if you know about those.
- 1:38:31There was an experiment in one of the American universities.
- 1:38:36So they took a random actor that had been working with a lot of other actors, in this case Kevin Bacon.
- 1:38:43and they wanted to see the degrees of separation between the furthest they could go and the
- 1:38:50furthest they could go from Kevin Bacon.
- 1:38:52Like if you're Kevin Bacon, you have Kevin Bacon number zero.
- 1:38:55If you've been in a movie with Kevin Bacon, you have Kevin Bacon number one.
- 1:38:58If you've been in a movie with someone that has been in a movie with Kevin Bacon, you
- 1:39:03have Kevin Bacon number two and so on and so forth.
- 1:39:06And the furthest away from two people they could find on the entire internet movie database
- 1:39:10was seven people.
- 1:39:11and that's some you know extra in a bollywood movie that no one saw
- 1:39:17so and and i know what that is like like think about the connections you have if
- 1:39:26you've talked to giacomo um he's talked to like almost everyone like you're talking to me now i
- 1:39:34have talked to michael saylor several times uh he's talked to basically everyone that's
- 1:39:40Like we're super connected.
- 1:39:44Saylor has talked to Donald Trump.
- 1:39:46Like he has talked to almost everyone.
- 1:39:48So the same thing with economies is what I'm saying.
- 1:39:51Like everyone's decision influences everyone else's decision, which is also, by the way, why I don't like the term economic node.
- 1:39:59But we don't need to go down that rabbit hole.
- 1:40:04Something I'm even more allergic to than circular economies is money in circulation.
- 1:40:09Money is never in circulation.
- 1:40:11It always belongs to a certain person, and then it changes hands.
- 1:40:15It's not in circulation.
- 1:40:17It's a very Keynesian thing to say that.
- 1:40:19Talking of Trump and the US, what's your opinion on what's going on over there?
- 1:40:26Never attribute to 4D chess, which can be explained by retardation.
- 1:40:34That's my opinion.
- 1:40:35Hopeful about what's happening there, though?
- 1:40:37I know that's good and bad.
- 1:40:41I think tariffs are horribly stupid and just makes life worse for everyone involved.
- 1:40:47Like all taxes.
- 1:40:50Nothing making tariffs any better than any other tax.
- 1:40:53They happen really quickly, though, tariffs, don't they?
- 1:40:55They just come like that, and all of a sudden, you can go out of business.
- 1:40:59And all of a sudden, all the prices go up in the US because now they have to charge more.
- 1:41:03And it's not going to make any American less fat or less lazy or less costly to employ.
- 1:41:11That's not how it works.
- 1:41:14Anyway.
- 1:41:16What about the Bitcoin stuff?
- 1:41:18The Bitcoin stuff, I mean, ask yourself, what's better for Bitcoin, a pro-Bitcoin politician or an anti-Bitcoin politician?
- 1:41:26And that's a real dilemma because if we allow a politician to dictate what a node is and them saying you're allowed to run a node, then that's not freedom.
- 1:41:40That's not Bitcoin.
- 1:41:41So I think in countries where it's harder to use Bitcoin, people will do their homework more.
- 1:41:48So that's the irony of it.
- 1:41:49What I do know from insider information from a handful of Bitcoin companies that I'm advising, I know that they see the election of Trump as less risk.
- 1:42:06So they've started to do more stuff and not asking for permission, which is great.
- 1:42:10you can start a wallet service or whatever in the US
- 1:42:15and not give it two shits about what the EU thinks about it
- 1:42:19and just launch it everywhere
- 1:42:20because you can now put it on Google or Apple Play Store
- 1:42:26and if not that, then just put it somewhere else
- 1:42:31and put a link somewhere
- 1:42:32and at least the Trump administration is not going to give a shit about that and not try to put you put you in jail for for innovating right last question because uh we one hour 40 i got to go um quick overview geopolitical future ahead um because it something
- 1:42:56you probably think about it i do what do you think what do you think the future looks like
- 1:43:01from here you know europe versus south america versus america versus whatever you know like what
- 1:43:09what do you think is happening here because bitcoin has been massively legitimized it's
- 1:43:14unbelievable really the kind of news you hear and currently even four years ago would have blown your
- 1:43:21mind it would have been the biggest thing that ever happened and now people don't really give a
- 1:43:25shit at all so so so something big is happening in this world but legitimized like all right you
- 1:43:32know what i mean i i not your keys not your coins still applies so like i see what sailor is doing
- 1:43:40for instance with this treasury company uh and uh how he's constructed this machinery on top of a
- 1:43:49Like there's this metaphor with a pond and there's a waterfall and the engineer observes the waterfall and then puts dynamos and uses, harnesses the energy.
- 1:44:03It's gears, isn't it?
- 1:44:04Someone showed me.
- 1:44:05Yeah, gears.
- 1:44:06Explained it as gears.
- 1:44:07Yeah, exactly.
- 1:44:08And that might actually be 4D chess and not Ritter Edition, by the way.
- 1:44:12But still, from what I know, MicroStrategy has all their coins with Coinbase.
- 1:44:20So it's like you're trusting someone to trust someone with your coins.
- 1:44:24It's two stages of separation.
- 1:44:27And at the end of the day, whoever controls the keys is the actual owner of the Bitcoin.
- 1:44:37So this is going deeper again.
- 1:44:40ownership is your legal relationship with a a thing so i think we've done this experiment before
- 1:44:48here here's your cup uh i'm i am now in possession of it belongs to the airbnb yeah okay then
- 1:44:55well this water i actually did buy this cup though yeah because i didn't like your glasses
- 1:44:59okay so i am now in possession of your glasses you still own them so you can say can i have my
- 1:45:07glasses back please and i can give them back or i can say fuck you tim i'm taking your glasses and
- 1:45:11you can't see where where i went because you can't see anything without your glasses that's the
- 1:45:16difference between ownership and possession you cannot own nor possess possess a bitcoin
- 1:45:21all you all you're doing is keeping a secret from someone that's that's it we we can act as if we
- 1:45:30own them but we don't actually own them it's just a fucking number can you own it's not on them
- 1:45:35Can you own anything in existence?
- 1:45:38Absolutely.
- 1:45:39But you cannot own information.
- 1:45:42This is about why copyright laws and patent laws are so insanely stupid because they don't – like if you write something on that piece of paper and I read it, we both have that information.
- 1:45:57So I didn't steal anything from you by copying it from you.
- 1:46:01the the only reason you create artificial scarcity by copyright laws and patent laws and saying that
- 1:46:08you cannot have this information this is my recipe for a goulash or whatever can i just can i just
- 1:46:14before you go on because i i've never had this one answered well before i come so so my my
- 1:46:22former life i was a photographer for a living and copyright was quite important in in photography
- 1:46:29and i'll tell you why because for and you can just probably say to me all right it was a crap
- 1:46:35business model but the business model was that you would spend some money so i would i would
- 1:46:41prove i would work to create an image which i would then sell the right to use yeah does that
- 1:46:49work is that is that okay copyright no right and this is this is the reason like it creates
- 1:46:57artificial scarcity where there shouldn't be any and that leads to resource misallocation at some
- 1:47:02point so the way i see it the 20th century was the anomaly because before the 20th century
- 1:47:10century there wasn't really mass production of anything so it's only during the 20th century
- 1:47:14that you can mass produce stuff and sell copies of books movies music photographs whatever you
- 1:47:23But they were digital.
- 1:47:25Yeah, but still.
- 1:47:27So all these copyright laws were written during a time where that made sense, sort of, for people who didn't think right.
- 1:47:37It was a physical thing.
- 1:47:39This is my CD or whatever.
- 1:47:42And then you get into the internet era where all of a sudden it's shown to the world that all the information can and should be copied.
- 1:47:49And what's mine is yours, really.
- 1:47:50We can share everything that's in the informational realm and no one loses.
- 1:47:56And then you sell a service on top of that.
- 1:47:58So, for instance, a Spotify subscription is really just the service is cataloging for you so that you don't have to put files into a certain folder.
- 1:48:12That's all they're doing.
- 1:48:13It's like categorizing and making it easy for you to find the correct song at the correct point.
- 1:48:19but but the the information itself is infinitely copyable so so bitcoin is the first thing that
- 1:48:26doesn't have that property that is in the informational realm so all of a sudden you
- 1:48:31have a thing that uh everything in it can be copied but the the thing that makes the thing
- 1:48:38powerful cannot be copied and that is the secret you keep from someone else and if you if you're
- 1:48:44good at keeping that secret you act as if you actually own the thing so in that sense it's the
- 1:48:50only ownable thing but at the end of the day it's just some guy knowing something that other people
- 1:48:56other people don't and leading back to the sailor thing because i want to i need to stress this point
- 1:49:01who actually owns micro strategies bitcoin is not michael sailor it's not brian armstrong
- 1:49:08it's some guy at coinbase or or or three out of five guys with coinbase or something and at any
- 1:49:17point in time they can take all those bitcoins and fuck off and i am looking forward to that day so
- 1:49:25much especially when it comes to government-owned bitcoins or all this institutional crap like
- 1:49:30imagine the last scene of fight club where all the skyscrapers break down and they're the pixie
- 1:49:35song comes on and it's just blown off his face and he finally gets the girl even though he's insane
- 1:49:39that's what i'm looking forward to that's what i want bitcoin to do like
- 1:49:45level the playing field for everyone a corporation it's just a bunch of people
- 1:49:51it's not real a business it's just a bunch of people a business on a bitcoin standard can just
- 1:49:57be a telegram chat it can be anything like and you you can do all your business without anyone
- 1:50:03else being even able to extract, to expropriate value from it.
- 1:50:10You can just do things like the joker, you know, you can just do things.
- 1:50:14And it's so powerful when you admit that that is already the case and we're already living
- 1:50:20in that world.
- 1:50:21The future is already here, just not evenly dispersed.
- 1:50:24Like, that's so true.
- 1:50:25Like, that's one thing I want Bitcoiners to think about more.
- 1:50:32it's just a fucking secret
- 1:50:34it's just a number
- 1:50:36you know a number
- 1:50:38and you believe
- 1:50:40it's improbable that anyone
- 1:50:42else knows the number you know
- 1:50:44and therefore you can act as if you
- 1:50:46owned the number
- 1:50:47I'm gonna
- 1:50:50have to leave it there, I had a number of
- 1:50:52questions but I
- 1:50:53quite like leaving it with that vision
- 1:50:56from the end of Fight Club
- 1:50:57it's
- 1:50:58and all the things
- 1:51:02yeah right let's
- 1:51:03let's leave it there
- 1:51:04yeah that's a Cartman version
- 1:51:08I love that
- 1:51:11thanks mate it's been a pleasure again
- 1:51:13thank you Timmy
- 1:51:14enjoyed it again I feel
- 1:51:16philosophized well and truly
- 1:51:18right back at you
- 1:51:19and yeah and see you at the next one
- 1:51:22probably you'll be at all the conferences
- 1:51:24I go to I would imagine
- 1:51:25yeah
- 1:51:28hopefully
- 1:51:29maybe not all
- 1:51:30but
- 1:51:30trying to cut down
- 1:51:31on conferences
- 1:51:32but it's so hard
- 1:51:33I love it too much
- 1:51:35take it easy
- 1:51:35thank you very much
- 1:51:36thank you
- 1:51:36cheers