Latest / Gemenskap Series: Building intentional student communities / Why Students Really Drop Out (Not Grades)
Transcript
- 00:00:01:09 - 00:00:33:10 Anna Hi and welcome to Gemenskap Series, the show exploring the art and science of building student communities that matter. We bring together housing directors, residential operators and student affairs experts to talk about what it really takes to create spaces where students feel seen, supported and like they truly belong. If you care about the moments, decisions, and people that define an exceptional student experience, you are in the right place. 00:00:33:12 - 00:00:35:00 Anna All right. Hello and. 00:00:35:00 - 00:01:12:18 Anna Welcome to another episode of Gemenskap Series. And with me here today I have Elsy Ayoub, assistant director of student retention and programs at the University of Miami. And I think, Elsy, you've been doing some really great work at the University of Miami overseeing your program, GPA, founding or co-founding GPA, and even teaching in the first years direction seminar. And we're going to get all philosophical about education and dive into your career and the work you're doing. 00:01:12:21 - 00:01:45:12 Anna However, before we kind of get into that, I always like to know who I am talking to. Even though I, I know you're a little bit better, but make sure that the audience knows a little bit more about you and and also about me, because not everyone knows me either. And and and from my end, I just have to say, one thing that really stands out with you is how you see every individual for who they are and have, like a truly altruistic motive of helping them succeed in life. 00:01:45:12 - 00:01:53:23 Anna I have been so inspired by by this and and welcome to the podcast. I'm so excited to have you here. 00:01:54:00 - 00:01:57:02 Elsy Thank you Anna. Thank you for having me. 00:01:57:04 - 00:02:16:05 Anna Yeah. So before we go into, as I said, all of the different topics we're going to discuss, can you tell us just a little bit about kind of one moment throughout your college life that you remember a little bit extra or was a little bit better? 00:02:16:06 - 00:02:43:22 Elsy Yes. It's actually full of special moments for me. But when I think of your question, I think less of a particular event and more of a feeling like waking up in the morning, walking through the trees, really being excited about what I'm going to learn today. Like, you know, when you're just early in your 20s, you're still full of energy. 00:02:43:23 - 00:03:18:00 Elsy You want to explore the world, and then, you know, more importantly, you're really studying something you're passionate about. It's this feeling in the morning. I can't wait to know what this day holds for me. And more importantly, I also remember walking into classes and that moment when a professor, for instance, would recognize something in me that I have not recognized in myself, whether through a presentation or a little question or a comment, or even the way I would enter class, or I would leave. 00:03:18:01 - 00:03:32:00 Elsy And that was always partial. That has always been powerful. And that's what I remember the most. And that's what stands out to me when you say a special memory, it's more about the feeling. 00:03:32:02 - 00:03:55:18 Anna Yeah, I love to hear that. That was the experience you had throughout your college and that you were excited about waking up, going to class, studying, whatever you were studying. And I think more and more it's less common that I hear this from people. And why do you think that was like, why did you have that feeling? How did you make that happen for yourself? 00:03:55:19 - 00:04:18:14 Elsy Yeah, there were a couple of things. I think number one, I always like to ask the question, what is the goal in anything? I believe I entered university having the goal that I wanted to establish good connections, and I wanted to get to discover myself like that was the goal from the get go. I wasn't even very determined to be in a certain major. 00:04:18:16 - 00:05:00:07 Elsy I was like, let's see what this adventure is even about. Of course, I chose a very good, affluent university, but as I say that I chose the environment before I chose the university, and I allowed myself to explore. And actually something that might be surprising, and it's actually something that I often share with my students, especially when I'm handling those tough conversations, when they're not sure about whether this is the place for them, or even whether that's what they wanted out of life, I tell them I had a moment after studying, after being a pre-med student for two years, when I thought I was getting it, like I was living the life, you know, I 00:05:00:07 - 00:05:25:20 Elsy was enjoying it. I was going, but I was going to become a medical doctor. I had all those nice dreams that look nice on papers. Right? And then halfway through my second year, something happened when I had an elective course that I needed to fill. And then somehow, by the grace of God, I say all of the easy elective courses were taken and I'm like, oh my God, I have to take this this semester. 00:05:25:20 - 00:05:45:15 Elsy What do I do? So I sit with my advisor and then then my advisor goes, if you can't take this category or that category, you have one choice. I said, what's the choice? It's like you go and you take a course in education and that's going to count for both requirements. He goes, it's going to count as a math and science, which is what you want is ten. 00:05:45:18 - 00:06:10:09 Elsy And it's also going to count, as, you know, the sociology, whatever that other requirement we were trying to satisfy on, like whatever I go, it was, I still remember the name of the course, the add to 12, which is education for the school order the school and the orders in the social system. It was a very complex course and I'm like, I'm not sure I understand the title. 00:06:10:09 - 00:06:28:22 Elsy I don't know if I'm going to understand anything in the course. And I go, I ask around, they're like, no, don't take this course. Absolutely not. You're not allowed to do anything. You're going to have to look through newspapers. The professor is so ancient as they describe the professor. I'm like, I guess I'm going to take it anyways. 00:06:28:22 - 00:06:54:16 Elsy I take the course. And I fell in love forever with this idea, this fascinating idea of how you can change societies, basically just through the power of human development. And I had this crazy moment, you know, that gut feeling when you're like, oh my God, I love this so much. I thought I loved med school and I'm doing so well. 00:06:54:16 - 00:07:37:23 Elsy But now I thought I just found something that I fell in love with, and that was a different feeling. And that was that. And the rest is history. And I transferred second year through and I never looked back and it was just amazing. So I think that had to do with me. So to answer your question, me allowing myself to discover what I was even passionate about and move from something I deeply loved into something I recognized I could be of purpose with, that has allowed me to gain the best out of my college experience, before I even think of anything else. 00:07:38:00 - 00:08:02:20 Anna That is such a beautiful, rich story that you are, that you are sharing truly, and how a lot of times when we're in a moment we cannot really touch. All of the pieces together about like, how did we where are we going? But then when you look back, they fit so perfectly altogether. And and I can tell you, like when I was in college, I had the same feeling. 00:08:02:20 - 00:08:35:21 Anna I was excited about what I was doing. And for me, it comes from a little bit of a different space. I've always had the golden ambition to like Mondays because I knew if I liked Mondays, I filled my weeks with something that I enjoyed doing, something I was passionate about, and my choice for college was to do a double masters, one in engineering physics, because I loved physics and I loved math, and the second one in education and the decide, and you're like, who is crazy like this? 00:08:35:21 - 00:09:09:15 Anna Doing these two wild worlds and combining them. But really, I loved every step of that journey. Now, when I look back, one of the biggest values I got is what you kind of were going into open for the experience of exploring yourself, getting to no other people, experiencing new things. I think this is one of the most valuable things and most memorable about my college experience, but I learned it after the five years you knew it going it. 00:09:09:17 - 00:09:35:19 Elsy I think so, I think so, and to tell you the truth, one of the greatest takeaways I have gotten to learn from this experience is this idea that you discover your passion in the doing, in the making. Passion is not something that you discover on a retreat somewhere, or when you discover when you've taken a break from life. 00:09:35:19 - 00:10:00:07 Elsy It's actually something that you discover in the making, in the domain. And that's very important. And that's what I hope every young person today listening to this conversation takes away. It's it's okay if you still don't know what you're doing. I don't think anyone in any way in the early 20s knew what they were doing. So it's okay. 00:10:00:13 - 00:10:21:18 Elsy Just allow yourself to experiment and be open to asking those questions with curiosity. Where is life taking me? What is this asking of me to do? My favorite question is I always tell my students, when you are in a situation, no matter if it's good or bad, and to me, everything is good. Everything is good. Always say it's good, everything is a gift. 00:10:21:18 - 00:10:44:03 Elsy And I tell them, ask the question what is life trying to show me? What is life trying to show me through this? What if? What is life trying to show me? If I took this course by mistake and then I loved it more than I'm supposed to, as life trying to show me if I'm repeating those calculus and pre-med courses and the chem, the organic cam. 00:10:44:03 - 00:11:09:01 Elsy And I'm trying and I'm trying and something's just not clicking. What is life trying to show me? If I found joy in something I didn't even expect it was going to bring me that that much joy? Or what is life trying to show me? If I'm trying to connect with someone and that connection is not neutral, right? So all of these things, life is always giving us feedback. 00:11:09:03 - 00:11:18:14 Elsy And magic happens when we slow down a little bit and just allow ourselves to get curious, get curious. 00:11:18:16 - 00:11:40:15 Anna I think it is so, so important and I can identify again myself in this trying trial and error a lot of different things. That is how you actually discover your passion. And when I came out of it, I was like, so what have I been doing on my free time outside of my studies? Actually, I've always been building organizations and helping people develop outside of my study. 00:11:40:15 - 00:12:01:11 Anna So all my free time and I realized, actually, I need to work with this. So this is why I've even been working in that space and why I have been building companies or running different initiatives to try and change things, because this is when I get the most kind of passion and joy in my life. But, I mean, you've decided to stay in that space for for quite some time. 00:12:01:11 - 00:12:23:09 Anna And I think you've also been asking yourself a deceptively simple but very profound question around like, how can a man be different? And I am very interested in like, what has made you stay for such a long time? And have you found an answer to that question? 00:12:23:11 - 00:12:27:06 Elsy What's the question? 00:12:27:08 - 00:12:30:23 Anna Can be different and what needs to change, you know? 00:12:31:00 - 00:13:08:06 Elsy Yeah. Can education be a different actually. And what has driven me for a great deal of my career, especially pursuing a career in education, which is a sector that has a lot of questions and is greatly connected and works with the greatest resources there is time and money, right, interchangeably. And so the question that I have held dear to my heart throughout is a question that seems simple, but it's not that simple. 00:13:08:06 - 00:13:50:00 Elsy It's this idea of what happens when we stop designing education around the average student, and instead design education around the whole person in front of us. And that is a question that I kind of like had early on. And I believe my privilege in getting exposed and in studying both the American and the Scandinavian models in education, the American, the systems, the best practices, the orientation, and then the Scandinavian, the sustainability. 00:13:50:01 - 00:14:14:21 Elsy You know, where the heart meets the head have allowed me earlier on to realize that success is not about giving people information, and it's not either about telling them what to do. Success is really about providing the conditions in which human capacity can emerge and in which human beings can discover their own capacities. 00:14:15:01 - 00:14:49:06 Anna Yeah. And I have to say, I can only agree, and I have asked the exact same question. Actually, it it was what drove me to stop teaching because I was frustrated a little bit. I was working in a system where we were teaching for the average, and I was very new in, in the space, in the field. And when you were new in the space, it's overwhelming because you have a lot of students and there are a lot of things you have to learn, understand how you're doing them, and you have a very limited amount of time. 00:14:49:08 - 00:15:15:04 Anna And and I was like, I don't feel like I can change this from, from the inside. And this is the reason that I'm even building a company and a startup, which is a crazy journey to be on. And then I was called Kohli. But I want to ask you, so how do you then actually change that design pattern from designing for the average person, which maybe feels like the easy way out? 00:15:15:04 - 00:15:19:12 Anna And why are we not doing it to a larger extent? 00:15:19:14 - 00:15:52:22 Elsy Why are we not doing it? I think it takes courage to question, and it takes courage to know that the GPA is important, but it is one performance. It's the one indicator in which we measure performance. Let me put it that way. But then as I say, that there's something beyond the GPA and the GPA does not tell me if the student is experiencing their life in a certain way. 00:15:52:22 - 00:16:17:22 Elsy It tells me if they're able to perform. And that's one important metric. Of course. You come here, you finish what you start. I begin every class. I finish every class with this, even when students are at my office, you know, we're trying to solve something. I say, listen, you came here to finish what you start. But then, as I say that, I want to make sure that you know that you, who you are matters. 00:16:18:00 - 00:16:39:20 Elsy And what you do matters. What you came here, what you came here to do matters, and how you do it. How you experience your world as you're getting to discover your world really matters. Because that's also what you take with you moving on. That's what you take with you when nobody's looking. That's how you learn to talk to yourself. 00:16:39:22 - 00:16:59:11 Elsy You know, talk to yourself when no one's listening. And that's how you learn. What do I do when life hits hard? Because the chances are life's going to hit hard. Maybe every day. And then what do we do with it? That becomes a bigger, deeper question. So coming back to your question, I think it's very important to always start with a question. 00:16:59:13 - 00:17:06:01 Elsy And it's very important to teach our generation to ask relevant questions. And that's. 00:17:06:01 - 00:17:28:18 Anna Is yeah, that is truly a skill. And I think going back to this idea that the GPA is one metric, right, of of what we're trying to to see and change and achieve in the educational space. If you see education as an instrument to transform a society, and I think we share actually a little bit of you a similar view on this. 00:17:28:20 - 00:17:55:22 Anna And I mean, you have worked with the two programs, GPA, GPA at the University of Miami, but you've also through these programs. And I know this because I spoke to you earlier, seen that the main reason that students drop out is not always academic. So it's not always tied to this metric that we look at. So. 00:17:56:00 - 00:18:09:16 Anna So much to kind of judge success. And if we're going in the right direction, what we're doing and what are you actually hearing in those with the drawer conversations that doesn't really show up and that GPA metric? 00:18:09:17 - 00:18:45:17 Elsy Yes. I hear a lot about this idea that belonging is not a feeling that we give students. It's an ecosystem. It's not an event. It's not an event. I feel I belong here, I don't belong here. It's actually an establishment of an ecosystem that allows a student to feel and beyond welcomed. Here I'm actually seen if there's a very big difference between being visible and being seen. 00:18:45:21 - 00:19:17:18 Elsy Being visible is like, I'm here, out there, they notice me being seen is really realizing I can find myself. I can mirror myself in this community and I have the relationship, the relational trust in the community and belonging does not mean everyone likes me, but it simply means I have this trust that allows me to move with ease through both the ups and the downs. 00:19:17:18 - 00:19:49:21 Elsy And it also means that if something goes wrong, I know where to go. I knew, I know who is my person, and that's our establishment or our version of what we call the success team. Like the moment the student is onboarded, they are supported with a group. When I talk about ecosystem, it's it's this establishment that only architecture students know about or only engineering students know about, or only med students, or only law students or only business students. 00:19:49:22 - 00:20:14:16 Elsy You know what it takes not just to be successful, but what it takes to get the best out of it. And, you know, so we have the academic advisors, we have success advocates, we have transitional guides who basically just transition and onboard the students. Throughout the first couple of months, we have counselors. We have a group that basically is there appointed for the students. 00:20:14:16 - 00:20:45:03 Elsy So in such a way, we're not just looking at data, but we're also creating reference points. So when something happens, the student knows where to go. They know how to seek advice. They know that they're not alone. And it's very important because loneliness, I think, is real. It's important to know that you can be alone. That's normal. But to be lonely I have experienced is not easy. 00:20:45:03 - 00:21:11:10 Elsy When you're a 20 year old, when you're sitting out there thinking that a grade of an F is a verdict, you know it's something that you can't change. I think this is where support hits in. You know, from your world of view. You failed yourself. And I was there. I was once there when I thought like, failing. A class says a lot about who I am. 00:21:11:10 - 00:21:36:20 Elsy I could have gotten stuck there, but instead I had mentors who supported me, who supported me in opening up my perspective into asking the right questions. Again, what is this trying to tell me? Who am I going to support myself with? Who am I changing with? Not just who I hang out with, but the way I organize my time, my schedule, the way I choose, what's important and what's a priority. 00:21:36:21 - 00:22:06:05 Elsy Right? Because that means all the difference. And when you're supported and you realize you're not going through this alone. And that's the other thing that I do a lot in GPA eight, which is the intervention of intensive programs like you're in the ICU, you're struggling, and we're going to take care of you. The first thing I do in the student orientations, I sit in front of 100 of students and I say, listen, I'm here to normalize challenges, and I'm here to tell you it's not going to be easy, but it's going to be worth it. 00:22:06:05 - 00:22:33:06 Elsy And we're here together because I want you to look in a in a room. I want you to look around and see and raise your hand and tell me who is here, because it's been hard to find their way in the first semester. Who's in here? And I tell them, I start by saying, listen, you are here. At least that you made me the chances that you are sitting in this room that you even get accepted in the first place is what, like 10%? 00:22:33:08 - 00:23:14:23 Elsy So you came here. I believe in you, and I know you came here for a reason, and I'm not here to question you. I'm here to take your hand and ask the questions that are relevant and support you. I'm here to help you ask the question, are you playing to your strengths? Ask the question, is this where you want to be five years from now and ask the question, are your results reflecting your effort or are they reflecting a bigger indicator or a bigger issue that we need to sit across and discuss and get curious about? 00:23:15:00 - 00:23:16:05 Elsy So just. 00:23:16:07 - 00:24:02:04 Anna State yeah, yeah. No, of course. And and I want to go back to this idea of belonging as an ecosystem. It's not just about belonging, right. Or someone seeing you. And it's about being part of that whole ecosystem and actually interacting with each other and influencing with each other. And actually, it's the whole point. I'm calling this podcast series because in my opinion, the word you mean scope is in capturing what we are trying to say, what the word belonging a lot of times, but much more in this kind of idea of a little bit like an ecosystem where individuals feel seen and like they are developed to the extent that they also start to 00:24:02:04 - 00:24:19:00 Anna give back. So they start interact again with this community and this group that they exist inside of. And that is, I think, what we're trying a lot of times to achieve when we say we want students to below, we want students to belong. It's not just for them to stay, it's for them to to be there and be successful. 00:24:19:00 - 00:24:47:14 Anna And it takes more than just feeling like I can identify it with this group, and it doesn't end at that moment. And at that time, and I think we're maybe following a little bit short thinking that that is the only a job that we have. And, and then it's, it's very interesting. And the part you're saying of like, how are you actually seeing an individual and I think. 00:24:47:16 - 00:25:14:11 Anna Sometimes I get scared when we talk a little too much about like procedures. And this is the plan. And this is two in the interaction. And every single individual is different. And I think we don't talk about differentiation enough. How are you differentiating the way you're communicating or the question that you are asking to your student and or the way you play to their strengths, the way you play to their challenges, the environment that they are in, the background that they have. 00:25:14:12 - 00:25:47:09 Anna We need to take all of these things into account. Whenever we are supporting a student and trying to develop someone, it really starts in that understanding for for another individual, I think. And, and yeah, but how are you building that understanding for an individual? You'll have hundreds and hundreds of students kind of in front of you. If, if someone was listening to this and they were like, okay, okay, I want to start contributing and building up this ecosystem, I don't only want to be kind of building belonging. 00:25:47:09 - 00:25:50:14 Anna Where would you tell them to start? 00:25:50:16 - 00:26:21:07 Elsy I would say, I'm going to tell you where we would always start. I'm going to give you some secrets there. I would always start in changing attention and changing what we put attention on. Meaning. When I want to change a program, I start by changing the questions because soon enough in the institutions are questions. Determine our values and our values, determine what we optimize and what we focus on. 00:26:21:07 - 00:26:52:05 Elsy So if all I'm looking at is GPA, number of credits, attendance and these are all important. But if that's all I'm looking at retention graduation rates, then I think we're selling ourselves too short. And instead we've been more and more looking at ways in which we can really get to how a student is experiencing their life, knowing that that's what they take with them. 00:26:52:05 - 00:27:04:19 Elsy And so we look at student capacities. This is when the game of shifting from skills to capacities get to really play. 00:27:04:21 - 00:27:41:10 Elsy You know, a skill is what you graduate with. That's a skill. Capacity is what you actually take with you. So if you ask me, what's the simple way to describe capacity to the average person? The capacity is really the ability to meet what comes next. And in a world where the the world is always changing fast, no curriculum is going to be able to meet or predict what the world is going to be like five years from now, ten years from now. 00:27:41:10 - 00:28:04:18 Elsy And no curriculum is therefore capable of preparing our students in the way we would want or hope. And anyone who tells you, hey, take this course, drop from this college, forget about this degree and come and take this. I would question if that is even the way, because today it's not about what you do, but it's about how you do it. 00:28:04:18 - 00:28:33:22 Elsy So coming back to capacity building, this is when I spent a lot of time researching and studying in my work. What does it mean to develop what we call the forces? And what we found is that no matter what field you're in, no matter what you choose to study, no matter what you choose to do in the world, of what type of business you get into, you want to have developed for you to be successful, you want to have developed for capacities. 00:28:33:22 - 00:29:12:15 Elsy We call them the four seeds. And the first one is critical thinking. You want to be able to critically think. The second one is collaboration collaborate. The third one is to be able to communicate. So communication and the last one is creativity. And to the extent that we're able to practice those four capacities that are constantly ever evolving and the way we teach ourselves and our students to learn how to learn, it is to this extent that they're going to be able to be successful no matter what the world looks like, no matter if they choose to pivot or do something else. 00:29:12:15 - 00:29:39:20 Elsy And no matter what they do with the decree, the degree is just a start point. It's not the end. And in a world that's always changing, information is important. But how you learn to use information has become even more important. And so that is about the capacities, and that is about how we're constantly evolving and how we're constantly meeting the demands of the world, really. 00:29:39:20 - 00:29:43:20 Elsy And in a world where. 00:29:43:22 - 00:30:12:00 Elsy You know, I have just fast paced, fast tracked what we even imagined, what what was possible. Thanks to AI, we're able to look at the data, we're able to track metrics, and we're able to look at behavior achievement. We're able to classify, you know, low, medium, high risk, and we're able to provide interventions accordingly. But that's just one part of the game. 00:30:12:00 - 00:30:40:18 Elsy AI is fascinating at pattern recognition just pattern recognizing. Right. But then what AI cannot yet do. And I think what AI is here to help us do more of is a human connection, is this ability to establish the relationship, to look someone in the eye and say, you're struggling, tell me more, and here's what I learned. And that comes more from my special ed background. 00:30:40:19 - 00:31:05:00 Elsy You know, I learned that diagnoses is a beautiful tool, but it should only be treated as a tool. Through diagnosis. We get to say we get to tell the student. Speaking of differentiation, because you asked me about differentiation, we get to tell the student or even the parents, and those are very hard conversations. You know, here's what I learn. 00:31:05:02 - 00:31:29:05 Elsy Here's what I learned about you through this assessment or a series of assessment. And here's what I think we can do for. Here's what I recommend we do right here. So it's almost like here are the options. And here are some of the choices right. So we don't treat diagnoses as the end I have to not. 00:31:29:06 - 00:32:06:12 Anna Have to comment on on the way you're phrasing yourself. And I think we forget a lot of times how important our words are and how big impact they have. And you phrase yourself as here is what I learned about you through these assessments. And I think too many times we're treating diagnosis and different assessments as you are or you have, and it's the way you're phrasing yourself is a much more constructive way for supporting an individual to develop, and you're providing them different ways on how they can do it. 00:32:06:12 - 00:32:48:23 Anna And I just think too many times we forget how powerful our word is when it comes to changing people and their behavior and their own mental representation of who they are, which is exactly what we're doing in education. Yes, we teach a lot of knowledge as well, but we forget that a lot of the teaching happens outside of the classroom, which is why we're focusing actually a lot with colleague on the residential experience of what you're learning there, which is a lot of times where you're building that capacity of yours and all of those adjacent skills that you are going to need in life after college. 00:32:49:00 - 00:32:55:03 Anna And so I just have to the way you're phrasing yourself, that is phenomenal. 00:32:55:08 - 00:33:21:09 Elsy Thank you. I always tell my team, my students, myself included, words create worlds. So the way we communicate and the way we think about something is just as important as what this something is, because it paves the way. And we always want to be thinking about pathways. We always want to be opening pathways, and we always want to be starting with floors, not ceilings. 00:33:21:13 - 00:33:46:07 Elsy Start with a doable start with the things that we know are handy, and let's challenge those. If you come and tell me you know I'm not meant for this, I'm going to challenge that. I'm going to ask you to think of three examples when you have not been successful. And I'm going to also ask you to think of three examples where you have been successful at that very thing that you're saying it's not for you. 00:33:46:07 - 00:34:09:12 Elsy And then from there, I'm just going to challenge those assumptions, those limited beliefs. And if we decide, after really looking at both sides, that this is for me, that's not for me, I'm going to go with whatever you decide, because I'm always going to trust Molly's going to trust your needs and your wants. And this is very important. 00:34:09:12 - 00:34:27:04 Elsy And that happens when we ask the question instead of asking the question, what is wrong with the students? Instead of asking that question, what is wrong with the student? Ask the question of what does the student need in order for their capacity to emerge? That's a very different question. 00:34:27:06 - 00:34:28:18 Anna It shifts. 00:34:28:20 - 00:35:10:15 Elsy It shifts the players and it shifts the table from this is who you are, and this is how you're going to live with this for the rest of your life. And I cannot tell you how many times we've had success stories. And that's what motivates me every day of just students who became amazingly successful just because someone believed in them, and just because they were given the support that they needed instead of, you know, just closing the door right when you when you ask about which that ecosystem looks like, I think ecosystem is this idea that every single thing matters. 00:35:10:15 - 00:35:33:23 Elsy And it's like this domino effect where one thing changes the other one, and then everything is connected, right? And it's both hopeful, but it's also alerting in the sense of our work really matters. And what we do with it matters even more. Yeah. 00:35:34:00 - 00:35:56:18 Anna Due to kind of some everything up. And if you had to pick kind of one practice that you feel like has been the most impactful in the work you're doing to not only make students belong, but be part of that ecosystem and supporting them on their journey to to success. What is that one practice you could teach someone who was listening? 00:35:56:19 - 00:36:09:13 Elsy The practice would always have to do with the mismatch between how the student is experiencing their world, and. 00:36:09:15 - 00:36:47:13 Elsy All the possibilities that could be made possible through our support and through our guidance. And I'm always there to support a student in whatever reality they're coming with. But I'm also there to challenge their limiting beliefs. And if we were to think of capacities, I would always, for instance, when it comes to critical thinking, if a student says something and instead of me just expecting one simple answer, I would just ask them, what make what makes you think that way? 00:36:47:15 - 00:37:16:00 Elsy That that is very indicative. They will often tell you about their internal world and how they're experiencing that. And a lot of the times our students are revolutionary on the outside, but not on the inside. And I always invite students and I say, try to be revolutionary on the inside and just static on the outside, because as long as you're revolutionary on the inside, you will always have this pursuit for what's next, right? 00:37:16:00 - 00:37:47:18 Elsy And that pursuit is going to be aligned with who you are instead of what others want of you. And at the same time, when we're communicating with students, I'm not just looking at presentations, I'm looking at their capacity to agree to disagree. I'm looking at their capacity to negotiate. I'm looking at their capacity to work with people who are different than, than than them and just have their needs heard and expressed. 00:37:47:22 - 00:37:58:20 Elsy If I'm looking at perhaps creativity, I love the type of questions that have no one answer. 00:37:58:22 - 00:38:20:17 Elsy And that is often indicative, like the way a student phrases themselves is a lot has has a lot to do with how they're experiencing their world. And I would slow that down. I would always have them as much as possible. Move from awareness. I would ask questions that bring awareness to a certain situation into acceptance, accepting what is. 00:38:20:17 - 00:38:47:03 Elsy I'm not here to fight what is. And you know, the moment we resist reality, the moment we resist resistance is the moment it has a lot of grip on us. So instead we accept what's there. Like if there's fear, we accept the fear. If there's failure, we accept the failure. And I tell the students it's allowed to be here, it's in the back seat, but it doesn't get to drive the car knowing that it's fair. 00:38:47:04 - 00:39:15:10 Elsy How can we learn to be with that energy without having it define our identity or anything about even the institution? Right. And this is when there's a pivot. And this is because you also mentioned that your your background combines engineering with education. This is a design thinking approach to problem solving, right? Which is an engineering framework in which we teach students to problem solve. 00:39:15:10 - 00:39:40:05 Elsy And if you ask me what's at the heart of that methodology? And it's such a good, best practice for our success team, always, it's two things, basically, number one, the capacity to pivot. So and to fail to fail forward. I always tell students, fail fast and forward. Our team were allowed to fail. Even if we're launching a program, I say it does not matter if we realize it's not working because we're going to be tracking it and we're going to pivot. 00:39:40:06 - 00:40:07:23 Elsy So fail fast and forward fail before the failure becomes catastrophic. Basically because failure is feedback. And this is the next point, right, about design thinking. Every step of the way is feedback. It's always giving us feedback. As long as we slow down, we take the feedback seriously. And that basically inspires the next step. So from that perspective, we have failure policy, which says you can fail as long as you fail fast and forwards and there is no failure. 00:40:07:23 - 00:40:16:04 Elsy If you think about it from that perspective, every opportunity defines the next step. And that's the beauty of the work we do. 00:40:16:06 - 00:40:38:10 Anna And I think, I think if I can summarize that in my own words, it's about supporting students and also shifting their perspective of that failure says something about them to that it is something external that they actually can affect with the actions that they're doing, and it's not their person. And it takes time to learn that, yes, it really does. 00:40:38:11 - 00:41:15:06 Anna And you need to have people like you who are reminding you that that is a fact, that you can mentor around your own kind of values, personality types, habits and things like this and the way you interact with others and yourself. So I think it's so important, supporting individuals in general to to make that shift. And, and, and I think with that, we, I think we could have three more podcast episodes, to be honest on, on this topic. 00:41:15:08 - 00:41:36:15 Anna Just the idea of an ecosystem building, building that to make students thrive. And it's not only about belonging. We get a little bit to focus on that one and how we're building capacity in our students. Maybe that is one of the more important jobs that we have as educators and as people working with human development. And I. 00:41:36:16 - 00:41:48:17 Elsy Think that gap closing, closing that gap between, well, what is student actually is and what the system can measure, closing that gap, striving to close that gap I think summarizes. 00:41:48:21 - 00:41:50:03 Anna So important. 00:41:50:05 - 00:41:51:13 Elsy Yeah. 00:41:51:15 - 00:41:59:00 Anna Elsy, thank you so much for being here, for taking the time and sharing your practice and your experience. 00:41:59:01 - 00:42:01:00 Elsy Thank you. Anna. It's my pleasure. 00:42:01:00 - 00:42:19:14 Anna Yeah. And for all of you listeners, I really appreciate that you were here once again and listening to Eumenes Cup series, and I look forward to seeing you in the next episode. LC thank you so much and take care everyone. 00:42:19:16 - 00:42:20:16 Elsy Thank you.