Latest / Come Sit With Us: Friendship, Community & Real Conversations / The Promise You Keep When They Can't: Grief, Loyalty & Letting Go | Come Sit With Us
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of loneliness that settles in when you realize you are the only one still holding onto a promise neither of you can keep anymore. It’s not anger, exactly; it’s just this quiet, hollow ache of remembering who you were together before the silence took over. I want to talk about promises today. Not the big, wedding vows or the blood-oath type of promises we make to our children. I’m talking about the small, casual promises we weave into the fabric of our friendships. The ones that feel so easy at the time because they’re rooted in hope. "We’ll go to Italy next spring." "You’ll come to my birthday dinner." "Let’s start that book club." For years, these phrases were the glue that held us together. They were tiny threads of future-tense intimacy that said, essentially, 'I see you in my life, and I believe we will still be there for each other.' But lately, I’ve been thinking about what happens when one person stays while the other… well, when the other person stops being able to show up. Maybe it’s illness. Maybe it’s a move across the ocean. Maybe it’s just the slow, grinding drift of life that pulls two people in opposite directions until the distance feels insurmountable. And suddenly, that promise becomes a ghost. It haunts you. You find yourself checking your calendar for dates that will never happen. You catch yourself rehearsing conversations you’ll never have. And you wonder if keeping the promise alive is an act of love, or if it’s just stubbornness dressed up as loyalty. I remember a friend, let’s call her Elena. We had promised to run a half-marathon together. It was going to be our thing. Every Sunday morning, for six months, we would lace up our shoes, complain about the cold, and jog through the park. It wasn’t about the running; it was about the ritual. It was about showing up for each other in sweatpants and messy buns. Then, Elena got pregnant. And then she got busy. And then the baby got sick. And then, slowly, the Saturday runs stopped. At first, I understood. Pregnancy is exhausting. New motherhood is a full-time job that comes with no sleep. I didn’t push. I didn’t say, 'Hey, what about our race?' I waited. I thought that by waiting, I was being a good friend. I was honoring the promise. But here’s the truth that took me too long to admit: waiting became a form of control. By holding onto that promise, I was keeping her tied to a version of herself that no longer existed. I was mourning the runner she used to be, while she was trying to survive the mother she had become. And in doing so, I made her feel guilty for not being able to keep her word. I made her feel like she was failing me, when really, she was just living her life. That guilt? It’s heavy. It’s heavier than any physical weight we could lift in the gym. And it pushes people away. It creates a wall where there should be a bridge. So how do we distinguish between loyalty and attachment? Loyalty is standing by someone in their pain. It’s bringing soup when they’re sick. It’s listening when they’re overwhelmed. It’s saying, 'I’m here.' Attachment is insisting on a future that isn’t happening. It’s demanding that they remain who they were, rather than allowing them to become who they are. This is hard, especially for women who are often socialized to be the keepers of relationships. We are taught that friendship is work. That if we stop working at it, it will fall apart. So we work harder. We send more texts. We plan more trips. We hold tighter. But sometimes, holding tighter is the very thing that breaks the bond. I think about another friend, Sarah. She moved away three years ago. We had promised to visit each other every year. For the first two years, we tried. But the third year, the cost of flights, the timing of our vacations, the energy required to coordinate—it all felt like too much. I almost canceled. I almost said, 'Well, you didn’t keep your part, so I’m letting go.' But then I realized something. The promise wasn’t the problem. My expectation of what the promise looked like was the problem. The promise was meant to be a connection, not a contract. And contracts require equal participation. When one side checks out, the contract is void. But the connection? That can still exist, if we change the terms. This is where it gets tender. Rewriting the terms of a friendship requires vulnerability. It requires admitting that things have changed. It requires saying, 'I miss our runs, but I know you can’t run right now. So instead of waiting for you to run, let’s just sit on the porch and drink coffee. Or let’s video chat once a month. Or let’s just text when we see something funny.' It’s a lowering of expectations, yes, but it’s also a raising of presence. We stop looking at the horizon, waiting for a future event, and start looking at the ground beneath our feet, appreciating the present moment. I did this with Elena. I stopped asking about the marathon. I stopped mentioning the race date. Instead, I sent her pictures of my own lonely morning jogs. I told her, 'I ran today. It was cold. I missed you.' And she replied, 'I wish I could have been there. I’m so sorry I’m not.' And we both cried a little. But then we laughed. And we talked about the baby. And we talked about nothing. And for the first time in months, we felt close. Not because we were fulfilling a promise, but because we were acknowledging the loss. We were grieving the runner together. And in that grief, we found a new way to be friends. A quieter way. A softer way. But a real way. Releasing a promise doesn’t mean releasing the person. It means releasing the demand. It means saying, 'I value you, even if you can’t give me what I asked for.' This is incredibly difficult for many of us. We equate compliance with care. We think that if someone loves us, they will do what we ask. But love is not transactional. Friendship is not a business deal. When we cling to promises, we are often clinging to our own fear of irrelevance. We are afraid that if we aren’t needed, if we aren’t relied upon for specific plans, then we don’t matter. But you matter. You matter even if you are just a listener. You matter even if you are just a text sender. You matter even if you are silent. Your worth is not tied to your utility. Your friendship is not defined by its productivity. So, take a breath. Look at the promises you are keeping. Are they serving the relationship, or are they serving your ego? Are they bringing you closer, or are they building a wall? If it’s the latter, it might be time to gently, lovingly, put them down. You don’t have to announce it. You don’t have to make a drama out of it. Just stop mentioning it. Stop planning for it. Stop waiting. And see what happens. Sometimes, when we stop pushing, the other person finally has space to breathe. And maybe, just maybe, they will reach out. Not because they have to, but because they want to. And that changes everything. There is a profound intimacy in accepting someone as they are, not as we wish them to be. It’s the difference between loving a photograph and loving a person. The photograph is static. It’s perfect. It’s frozen in time. But the person is messy. They are changing. They are tired. They are human. When we accept the fluidity of friendship, we allow it to evolve. We allow it to be less frequent, but more meaningful. We allow it to be quieter, but deeper. I’ve learned that some of my most cherished connections are the ones where we don’t talk every week. Where we don’t have grand plans. Where we just know, deep in our bones, that we are each other’s safe harbor. That kind of trust doesn’t require promises. It requires presence. It requires the courage to sit in the discomfort of uncertainty. To say, 'I don’t know what’s next. I don’t know if we’ll ever run together again. But I know I care about you. And that’s enough for now.' That’s enough. It has to be. Because life is unpredictable. People change. Circumstances shift. The only constant is our willingness to meet each other where we are, not where we were. So, let go of the ghost. Let go of the plan. Let go of the 'shoulds.' And just be here. With yourself. With your friends. In this moment. It’s not as exciting as the future we dreamed of. But it’s real. And it’s yours. Thank you for sitting with me today. I hope you’re giving yourself permission to release what no longer serves you. Until next time, be gentle with your heart. I’m rooting for you.