The Man in the Bag: Secrets That Bought a Body at the Quarry

True Nightmare Stories · Jul 8, 2026 · 19m

The Man in the Bag: Secrets That Bought a Body at the Quarry

The water turned red when seven teenagers pulled a heavy black plastic bag marked US from the bottom of Wayne Fleet Quarry and found a man weighed with concrete garden stones. A Dartmouth-trained physician, federally employed and once accepted to Oxford, had been living as "John" in a rented room and was shot once behind the right ear - but which of his two lives cost him his life?

In this episode, we lay out the facts of the case from the quarry recovery to the two houses tied to the victim and the young man connected to the dying…