Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Siege of Montgisard 1177: The Boy King Baldwin's Triumph
Transcript
- Lucas: If you've been stepping into history with us episode by episode, you'll remember Saladin as a master strategist who united Syria and crushed the crusaders at Hattin in 1187. But he wasn't invincible. A decade earlier, in November 1177, a teenage king with leprosy handed him one of the worst defeats of his career at a place called Montgisard. Luna: Wait — leprosy? King Baldwin IV, right? Lucas: Exactly. Baldwin IV was only sixteen in 1177, and he was already showing signs of the disease that would eventually kill him. But in that moment, he led a Frankish army that caught Saladin completely off guard. To understand how, we need to rewind a little. In the summer of 1177, Saladin launched a major invasion from Egypt into the Kingdom of Jerusalem. Lucas: His plan was straightforward: march up the coast, besiege the fortress of Darum, then hit Ascalon and Jerusalem. He had around 26,000 men, according to the Muslim chronicler Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani. The Franks were badly outnumbered. Baldwin's forces at Ascalon numbered barely 500 knights and a few thousand infantry. Luna: So how did he win? Lucas: First, Saladin made a tactical error. He let his army spread out while foraging, assuming the Franks were too weak to attack. But Baldwin, advised by Raynald de Châtillon — the same guy who later triggered the war by raiding caravans — decided to strike. On November 25, the Franks marched out of Ascalon and caught Saladin's army near the village of Montgisard, about fifty kilometers south of Jaffa. Lucas: The crusader chronicler William of Tyre describes Baldwin riding at the head of his troops, carrying a reliquary of the True Cross. The sight of a leper king leading a charge — it must have been electrifying. They hit Saladin's vanguard so hard that the Muslim lines broke. Saladin himself nearly got killed. He escaped by mounting a swift camel and fleeing toward the coast, leaving his baggage and many of his men behind. Luna: Ibn al-Athir calls it a disaster for the Muslims. What does he say exactly? Lucas: Ibn al-Athir writes that Saladin's army was 'scattered like dust' and that the sultan barely made it to safety. He lost thousands of men, including his personal secretary and several commanders. The Franks captured enormous booty. For Saladin, it was a humiliating lesson in hubris. He had underestimated the Frankish will to fight, even when they were outnumbered. Luna: So what was the aftermath? Did Baldwin follow up on the victory? Lucas: He tried, but he didn't have the resources to press deep into Egyptian territory. The crusaders celebrated — they saw it as divine intervention. But the victory was fleeting. Saladin retreated to Cairo, regrouped, and within a year launched a new campaign. The real significance of Montgisard is that it showed Saladin the vulnerability of overextended supply lines. He learned from that mistake. Lucas: In later campaigns, he would keep his army compact, use fortified supply depots, and never let the Franks catch him in a disorganized march. That lesson paid off at Hattin in 1187. So Montgisard was a crusader victory that actually made Saladin a better general. It's a classic case of defeat teaching more than victory. Luna: It's interesting that the battle isn't as famous as Hattin, but it shaped how Saladin fought later. Lucas: Exactly. And speaking of shaping the show — we can do these deep dives because of a handful of listeners who chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No ads, no corporate stuff, just people who want to keep this kind of history going. It really makes a difference. Luna: Yeah, it's a small group, but it's what keeps us ad-free. Lucas: So back to Montgisard — one detail I love is that the Franks built a chapel on the site afterward, dedicated to Saint Catherine, because the battle happened on her feast day. That chapel still stands today, though it's been rebuilt. It's a tangible reminder of that moment when a leper king defied the odds. Luna: I've heard there's a legend that Saint George appeared on the battlefield — is that true? Lucas: That's from later sources, especially the English chronicler Roger of Wendover. He claims that Saint George led the Frankish charge. But contemporary accounts like William of Tyre don't mention it. William emphasizes the True Cross and Baldwin's personal bravery. Still, the legend stuck, and it reflects how the crusaders framed their victory as a miracle. Lucas: For Saladin, though, it was a bitter lesson. His biographer Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad records that the sultan often recalled Montgisard as a moment of overconfidence. He realized that the Franks were not just barbarians — they had their own warrior ethos. That respect shaped his later diplomacy, like the truce he made with Richard the Lionheart in 1192. Luna: So Montgisard was almost a turning point in Saladin's development as a leader. Lucas: Absolutely. He went into that battle expecting an easy walkover and came out humbled. Afterward, he spent years building a coalition, strengthening his logistics, and learning to read his enemy's moves. Without Montgisard, Hattin might have turned out very differently. Lucas: One last thing: the battlefield itself. It's near modern-day Gezer, in central Israel. Archaeologists haven't found much from the battle, but the terrain — a narrow plain between hills — explains why the Frankish cavalry charge was so devastating. They had room to build momentum, and Saladin's troops had no place to run. Luna: It sounds like a textbook ambush. Lucas: It was. And it's a reminder that even the greatest generals have bad days. For Baldwin IV, it was his finest hour. For Saladin, it was the harsh education that made him a legend.