Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Transphobic dating and faking Indigenous identity
Transcript
- 0:00Can you repeat what you just said, Rebecca before I started recording. So
- 0:06I was looking at No, No, I want to hear you gotta start
- 0:09with that sentence you just said. It always starts with dick or something.
- 0:13It starts with dick. Really, it's all about Dick. It all goes
- 0:16back to Dick. You have the audience intrigued, now, please elaborate.
- 0:21So I was looking at the course outline for my sex therapist certification and I
- 0:29was surprised to see how much time. And this is obviously like not the
- 0:34whole course, but I was like, oh, man, we're starting with
- 0:36dick. Wow, like with everything that we know about female sexuality and female
- 0:42bodies, and I want to focus on female bodies. I was like,
- 0:46man, we're going to be talking about Dick a lot, and that's going
- 0:49to be triggering for me and I'm going to have to like chill and just
- 0:53think about Dick. And I'm amazed at how much time gets spent on male
- 0:59erection dysfunction disorder or whatever you want to call it. When half of American
- 1:04women are having orgasms, switch is way more important to me. Yeah,
- 1:10yeah, we'll talk more about dick. As I learned, I mean it
- 1:11is it like seventy percent of the time about dick or is it fished?
- 1:17I don't know yet. I mean it was just the course description for one
- 1:19of the eight modules, so I just need to chill out. But I
- 1:23was also like, I guess, I was like shocked of like, oh,
- 1:27right, this is sex therapy. And for a lot of people,
- 1:32when I say sex therapy, most people think I'm going to be working with
- 1:34heterosexual couples, and I have to explain, like, that may be other
- 1:38people's focus, but that's not going to be my work. And you have
- 1:42the luxury of saying that because your late career and when you start working with
- 1:49clients, you can actually determine that. For a lot of people starting their
- 1:53career, they don't have that luxury usually because they have to take whoever is
- 1:59going to come to them. And I had this very sweet moment with my
- 2:01dad where he was asking me why I was doing this, and I was
- 2:05explaining, you know, dad, this is the last twenty years of my
- 2:07career and this is how I want to spend it. And my octagenarian father
- 2:13said, oh wow, that went so fast. It's like, oh my
- 2:16god, you've watched my whole life. I'm talking about the last twenty years
- 2:22of my career. Yeah, it is weird because in traditional sense and the
- 2:28traditional sense in ten years, we're basically of retiring age, you know,
- 2:32of the old days. I don't think that many people retire in their early
- 2:37sixties these days, and particularly therapists, professors, podcasters don't retire. I
- 2:42can't retire, So you better keep this up right, speaking of dicks,
- 2:46and so I'll talk about dicks a lot if I can make if I keeps
- 2:52my career going, I'll focus my whole career. I'll just talk about dick
- 2:55all day long. I mean, there's a lot of erectile dysfunction in the
- 3:00world, and I think it's on the rise. But I'm bumped and we're
- 3:06gonna have so much fun. Okay, So along those lines, Okay,
- 3:10there's an email that I asked if you wanted to tackle and you said,
- 3:17I think, quote, why the fuck not? It's all about dick anyways.
- 3:22So anonymous patron she wrote in and says, Hi, Kirk, and
- 3:25I was hoping to ask Rebecca this question as well. I am a heterosexual
- 3:30assist gender woman who has bisexual tendencies or maybe I guess that makes me queer
- 3:36question mark. I am not completely confident with labels or terminology around my sexuality.
- 3:42By the way, recently I had a date with a cisgendered This persusss
- 3:46cisgendered, but it's cisg pan sexual woman. So what's your definition of pan
- 3:53sexual, Rebecca. They are attracted to all genders pan meeting, all right,
- 4:01because if you say bisexual, that is referring to the binary, of
- 4:05course, so pan sexual. Recently I had a date with a cisgender pan
- 4:11sexual woman who told me she is annoyed by bisexual people who won't date transgender
- 4:16people. Her statement caught me off guard because it seemed like a litmus test,
- 4:21as if she was fielding my attitudes on the topic. Right, so
- 4:28just chiming in litmus test, I think, meaning that it wasn't actually on
- 4:31the table. I mean, I think that's a question of like, are
- 4:33you one of us? Like, so you think that anonymous patron might be
- 4:39reading that correctly? Yeah, perhaps going back to the email, perhaps out
- 4:44of naivete I struggled and said, that makes sense, But honestly, I
- 4:47so this is back to her thinking. But honestly, I had never thought
- 4:51about it before the date ended on a flat note, and I was still
- 4:56thinking about our question, feeling a little confused. Afterwards, with some thought,
- 5:00I realized I wouldn't date someone trans. It seems so unfamiliar to me,
- 5:04particularly because trans is such a big part of one's identity. Just chiming
- 5:11in here, What do you think about that thus far? Well, I
- 5:15think because I know where we're going. You know, attraction is a complicated
- 5:19thing. Some people base their sexual attraction on people's minds or all kinds of
- 5:28aspects of people. For some people, it's really a body attraction issue.
- 5:33And I know this is loaded, but I personally think that has to be
- 5:38okay that someone's like I, you know, there are certain aspects of a
- 5:43body that I want to be attracted to. I just spent the evening live
- 5:48streaming with Sylvia o'ste for more. We're doing these very funny two old queers
- 5:53futero experiences on Instagram, and we were doing a reading for her friend who's
- 6:00really into who's gay, who's really into men who are bearers and the way
- 6:04that gay men talk about the body that they are attracted to and how much
- 6:10they want a certain body You know it's not. And I think straight men
- 6:16too, actually spend a lot of time thinking about the body that they are
- 6:20attracted to. I think women are given less permission to be really honest about
- 6:26the body that they are attracted to. But I don't think if you really
- 6:30need a certain body to feel sexual, you're not doing anyone any favors by
- 6:36thinking, you know, politically, I have to be attracted to all bodies.
- 6:41That's just not how desire works. What's your Instagram again? Our text
- 6:50and if you want, it's very funny, but there's this whole we just
- 6:54talk about bear men for a really really long time. And one of the
- 6:58things apparently, so who's gravitating towards dicks? I guess it's me, but
- 7:02Honey Bouquet, which is spelled Honeybucket, that's her drag name, was saying
- 7:08I want a height weight proportionate man, a man who's over six feet tall
- 7:14and over three hundred pounds. And I was like, oh right, there's
- 7:16a whole different definition of bodies that is attractive. When you're you know what
- 7:23a bear is? Should we define that? So bears are what would be
- 7:29considered in the straight culture, very large, heavy set, gay men who
- 7:34tend to be hairy. Hotters are skinny men who are hairy. But you
- 7:41know, in queer culture, especially in male queer culture, there is so
- 7:45much definition of the bodies that are attractive and what you are looking for physically.
- 7:50Yeah so, and there's all these weekends you can go to bear weekends
- 7:55which are just about finding the spending time with the body that you are attracted
- 7:59to. Yeah So, given my sense of the progression to where this question
- 8:07comes from, this is just my observation from outside the community, is that
- 8:11in the beginning, so to speak, you had a very simplistic understanding of
- 8:18gender and also of trans people. And I would hear about scenarios where say
- 8:26you had a straight CIS guy who met a woman at a bar and then
- 8:33you know, was very attracted to her and liked her personality and thought she
- 8:37was beautiful and thought she was hot, and then later found out that she's
- 8:41trans trans woman, and then all bets are off for this guy, right
- 8:46well, and it could end violently. I mean, there are so many
- 8:50stories where people find that a violent offense that they were somehow absolutely and you
- 8:54know, there's just the only way for the man to preserve his toxic masculinity,
- 8:58which is to go overboard with a masculine response, which is murder and
- 9:03violence, which is wonderful. So he will be very upset, and you
- 9:11know, and there's a lot of manifestations of that. You might have conversations
- 9:16among sis heterosexual people that might say, or really any sexuality person who would
- 9:24say, well, sure she looks attractive, but no, that's disgusting.
- 9:31I would never I would, even though I'm attracted to everything I'm seeing and
- 9:35the personality is exactly what the sort of thing I'm looking for, just the
- 9:39fact that she's trans, it's just a no go. And and when you
- 9:46ask these people why, they would say, well, it's just disgusting.
- 9:50You know. They just think trans is disgusting, which is fucking ridiculous,
- 9:54right, And so they will just flat out discriminate on that level. And
- 10:01then of course just general trans discrimination, which is from my sense, much
- 10:07more of a foundational problem for trans people than dating, right because a lot
- 10:15talking employment discrimination, housing, plus like trans people don't they're not trying to
- 10:20trick people into dating them, you know what I mean that there's enough people
- 10:26to go around, and so but when it comes to this kind of view.
- 10:31It's hurtful, it's harmful, it's transphobic. So that we can point
- 10:37at and say, well, at least open your mind up a little bit,
- 10:41because it's possible that if you just weren't indoctrinated or somehow re educated yourself
- 10:48not to be anti trans, you might actually be very attracted to this person,
- 10:52and you're limiting yourself based on prejudice. You know, it would be
- 10:56the same as if someone was and doctor needed heavily into a racist culture like
- 11:03at the United States, and hadn't deprogrammed themselves and just said like, I'm
- 11:05not going to date a black person, or I'm not going to date an
- 11:09Asian person or something, you know, just just because it's like, even
- 11:11though I'm very attracted to that person, gross, black people are gross.
- 11:16You know, it's immoral, it's short sighted, it it's wrong. So
- 11:20then there's this backlash against that, which is of course understandable and justified.
- 11:28And then you have heading into the current phase that we're in in our culture,
- 11:33and you have people that are starting to open up and things are starting
- 11:37to change slightly slowly, and you still have some people that are saying what
- 11:43you're saying Rebecca, which is that, of course, transphobia is wrong and
- 11:48short sighted and limits everybody, including the transphobia individual. But for people with
- 11:54their attraction, it's hard to change that exactly, and you could be open
- 12:01to all kinds of bodies. So did you watch One Mississippi, the Tig
- 12:03Nataro show, her stand up special, No, it's her, it's a
- 12:09several Yeah I did what. It's a it's a sitcom. Yeah, yeah,
- 12:13I love that show. Yeah, so there's this. So she is
- 12:18heavily pursuing a woman who views herself as straight in the show, and their
- 12:24wives in real life and she so Tigs right. So Tig in real life
- 12:31is married to an actress who is on this show, and they play different
- 12:37characters. Tig plays like a radio host if I remember right, and her
- 12:41actual wife is playing a woman that she works with. I think, yeah,
- 12:46she's very attracted to and is pursuing and is straight and is straight,
- 12:50and the woman has a lot of problems imagining being in a gay relationship and
- 12:56wasn't in real life her wife living as straight before, I think, so,
- 13:01I always kind of their actual beginning. Yeah, So in the show
- 13:07the PURSUITI asks, well, what kind of bodies are you attracted to?
- 13:13And Tig says, you know, I've been with men and I've been with
- 13:16women. And there's this beautiful line where she says, you know, are
- 13:20those saggy breasts or a saggy ball sack? And it's just kind of this
- 13:24very different way of looking at bodies and thinking about bodies. So is there
- 13:31a chance that you would get with a body that you're unfamiliar with and find
- 13:35ways to find it attractive? Maybe? And Tig, due to breast cancer,
- 13:41has had a full radical mastectomy and did not have reconstructive surgery. So
- 13:48you know, I mean she has a body that would be not gendered as
- 13:52female, like she doesn't you know, she doesn't have breasts, Like what
- 13:54does that mean? So there's all kinds of bodies out there. But we
- 14:00were choking to get back to the topic to sure you know, is one
- 14:05of the reasons that this woman doesn't want to be with a transgender man is
- 14:09that they assume that this person won't have a penis and they can't have traditional
- 14:16vaginal penis penetrative sex. And is that a priority for this person, right?
- 14:22Yeah, A lot of it has to do with Have you actually tried
- 14:26it on for size so to speak, you know, not actually being with
- 14:30someone physically, although if that were, if you're able to do that and
- 14:33you want to do that, then that is a worthy way to find out,
- 14:37right, But at the very least, investigating the indoctrination and the propaganda
- 14:41that you've internalized to really sift through if if you're limiting yourself at the very
- 14:48least, and again, you could be giving into the transphobia. And it's
- 14:54something that each individual is on their own path around. And I don't think
- 14:58outsiders should shame people, and in my experience, trans people don't shame people
- 15:03for that. You know. Can you identify someone on Twitter that does that
- 15:07sort of thing? Sure? But you know, every trans person I know,
- 15:11and all the famous trans people I know, would never attack someone because
- 15:16of their preferences regarding this thing. You know, they'll say, if you
- 15:20don't want to be with me, I don't want to be with you.
- 15:22Yeah, you know, don't harm, no foul. But you might want
- 15:26to think about your internalization just for your own sake, because you might be
- 15:31missing out on things. You know, your soulmate might actually be passed over
- 15:35because of whatever prejudice, whether it's race or sexuality or class or trans or
- 15:43gender or whatever. You know, like you might want to investigate that,
- 15:48but I'm not going to shame you or yell at you for having your current
- 15:50preferences that kind of thing. And I recently had a friend who went on
- 15:54a disaster date and they could not press seed sexually what they had kind of
- 16:03been promised sexually. The person could not deliver day of what does this mean?
- 16:11They were expecting to get topped sexually and the person who said that they
- 16:17could be a top could not be a top. So it wasn't an anatomy
- 16:19issue. It was a behavior energy issue. Yeah, And We've had many
- 16:26long conversations about it, and it was really interesting because you know, I
- 16:32mean, people promise all sorts of things, right, but can they deliver
- 16:37and be honest about what they can actually? So is the implication this top
- 16:42layer was trying to entice the person and was lying or was convincing themselves of
- 16:52something I was convincing themselves, and then when the time came, could not
- 16:57deliver the goods. Couldn't deliver it the goods. Huh does that happen?
- 17:03I guess so huh yeah, yeah, but you know, I mean this
- 17:07intimacy is so intense, right, I mean, you get in the you
- 17:12get in the spot, and you know, does your desire align with your
- 17:18fantasies, align with what the other person wants? Like you know, we're
- 17:22kind of in this scary soup, and you know, in queer relationships it
- 17:29gets so much more complicated because there's many more variables or presumed variables than you
- 17:37know in a strait disbodied experience. So is it fair for this anonymous patron
- 17:44who is bisexual to have someone judge her for saying that she doesn't want to
- 17:52date a trans person. I mean, we live in the most judgy time
- 17:56that I've ever lived in, So she might get judged, but I would
- 18:00so much rather she'd be honest with herself and say this isn't a fit for
- 18:04me. That would be great, because so much better than to set someone's
- 18:11expectations up that intimacy is coming and for her to know that she just can't.
- 18:17We don't want her in that you know, top failure position where she
- 18:22gets into the situation and she's like, oh I can't there's no physical attraction
- 18:26here, I can't do it. Yeah, yeah, I think it's related
- 18:30to another phenomenon that I absolutely will get behind. That's related to the dating
- 18:37scenario that I laid out earlier. That, of course, for a lot
- 18:41of people, if not the majority of Americans and certainly majority of people around
- 18:45the world, don't recognize that trans people exist at all. Great, right,
- 18:48they wouldn't know it if I've had that experience where somebody has told me
- 18:52they're a transman and I was like, yeah, I could spot you at
- 18:56one hundred feet Derek, really I pass in the straight world, And I
- 18:59was like really, wow, Okay, Well, not only that, but
- 19:04that if they knew, whether passing or not, that someone was trans,
- 19:10they'd say, oh, well you're you're not a real woman that kind of
- 19:14thing, or you're not a real man whatever, And that notion is of
- 19:19course abhorrent and silly and really unscientific. And when you have people from that
- 19:27side of things will say, as a heterosexual man, of course I wouldn't
- 19:32date a trans woman because that's not a woman, that's a man. So
- 19:36that is wrong and abhorrent and transphobic at it at its most base level,
- 19:42not that they have to date the person, but that they're just denying that
- 19:47trans people exist at all, right, or denying that a trans woman is
- 19:51a woman. And for people like anonymous patron that later goes on in the
- 19:56email and says that she thinks of herself as as an ally, I don't
- 20:00know that, but you know, she says she promotes pronouns and', she
- 20:06promotes gender neutral bathrooms and gender firming care safe spaces, she wants to protect
- 20:11trans people, and she supports policies that support trans people. You know,
- 20:17for someone like that that is on the right side of history, do we
- 20:22lump this anonymous patron in with that guy I said earlier that would say that
- 20:27trans people aren't really trans, a trans woman is a woman, you know
- 20:30what I mean? Do I feel like Twitter will lump those two people together.
- 20:34Yeah, I mean there's so much more nuance here in terms of do
- 20:41I want someone to support trans rights? Yes? Do I need someone to
- 20:47be sexually attracted to every single human on the planet? No? Are Yeah?
- 20:52I mean I see it as really really different. And I think,
- 20:57you know, we kind of talking about why aren't people attracted to trans bodies?
- 21:04And that gets very complicated, And also what I just said, you
- 21:08may think you're not attracted to trans bodies, but you know, have you
- 21:12ever been with a trans body? Yeah? And the thing that I would
- 21:17say to people that I have to clients is to just try it on for
- 21:22you know, like if you're dating and you're in the shoes, Well,
- 21:26I guess I'll just speak directly to you, anonymous patron. In your mind
- 21:30if you want to, don't do it. If you don't want to,
- 21:33but if you want to and it's comfortable in your mind, just try it
- 21:38on for size. And what comes up for you is it not getting my
- 21:44engine going? And if it's not getting your engine going, then maybe look
- 21:48at why. And this is for your sake, because again, you might
- 21:52be limiting yourself. And if you go down that road voluntarily with comfort,
- 21:59and I'm just exploring, you might find that further down the road there's some
- 22:04flexibility there, but maybe not sort of like anonymous patron, I don't know,
- 22:08but I'm guessing a similar thing happened with bisexuality. But that one's kind
- 22:15of hard because in some cultural pockets there isn't as much homophobia as there is
- 22:19transphobia. Yeah, and so you might find it fairly easy to try on
- 22:26same sex, sexuality, it might be easier, and so at the very
- 22:33least just try and over size and at the end of that road if it
- 22:37And you know, I've done this work with people in a variety of areas,
- 22:41and I've found that for some people they will say, you know what,
- 22:47I think I was giving into the propaganda and there's a lot of discomfort
- 22:52around just this topic in general because of all the things I've internalized and also
- 22:57kind of the landscape. And actually, if I just shed that, then
- 23:03I find that I'm actually more open and wanting to be with these sorts of
- 23:08people internally. And then they start to have experiences with those sorts of people
- 23:15and find that it's absolutely their thing or maybe it's a secondary thing, whereas
- 23:19for other people they will find that at the end of the road, even
- 23:25maybe having experiences with these sorts of people, that they're like, yeah,
- 23:29no, i think I've shed myself of the propaganda and I'm not opposed to
- 23:34it, but I've tried it on in my mind and I've even dabbled it
- 23:37in person and found that it's just not and I'm talking about across the board,
- 23:41right, I'm talking about not just charge, talking about experimenting and sexuality
- 23:45in general, Like you know, I mean, we're talking about adding in
- 23:48sex storys. We're talking about dildo's instead of dicks, or fingers instead of
- 23:52dicks, or like all of these things that it like do don't get talked
- 23:56about a ton, but are equally valid and pleasurable forms of sexuality and intercourse.
- 24:04And I'm thinking, have you seen Monster Ball, the documentary about the
- 24:10basketball for guys in wheelchairs and twenty years ago. Yeah, and there's a
- 24:15whole section in there about penetrative sex and how important it is for folks to
- 24:21still be having that and how they do it. And actually kind of the
- 24:25modern dildo movement, the modern silicon and dildo movement was I think they were
- 24:30called scorpio and it was invented by a Vietnam vet who wanted men who'd lost
- 24:38the ability to have penetrative sex to still be able to give that to their
- 24:41partner. And so, you know, there's lots of people who are having
- 24:48sex that you may not think that we don't the sex that we don't show
- 24:53in mainstream media, there's you know, it's there's quite a range, wide
- 24:59range to do it, and there's quite a wide range of how to pleasure
- 25:03your partner and be pleasured by your partner, and so this similar scenario happened
- 25:11to me. It didn't happen to me, but a friend of mine wrote
- 25:12me, who's CISHT woman, and said I was out on a date with
- 25:18someone before they came out to me as a transman. And I was like,
- 25:22huh, And they were kind of shocked, like they should have told
- 25:26me sooner. But I was like, you know, people have different levels
- 25:29of comfort of when they're going to tell somebody, and it was interesting.
- 25:33They were really shocked at I wasn't that shocked. Yeah, so in a
- 25:41perfect world there would be no transphobia. Well, and the body that you
- 25:45think you're going to get, like I was just intu loom and there was
- 25:49this heavy I was unexpected, but heavy duty cis male bodybuilding culture going on.
- 25:55A lot of the men were like bulked up. So this is Mexico.
- 25:57I was in Mexico. Yeah, and you know, I don't in
- 26:00Seattle. You don't see that a lot because it's like not warm enough to
- 26:03kind of like be out, you know U. Plus it's you know a
- 26:07bunch of computer nerds, grunge music skinny wafy, you know, more crossfits,
- 26:18less like big bodies on top. Yeah, so I you know,
- 26:22I'm seeing all these bodies so I don't usually see. And then I immediately
- 26:27I think of, like talk about erect ole this function. I'm like,
- 26:30well, if he's taking a lot of steroids, you know, it's probably
- 26:34not having the best sex of his life right now, like he's big on
- 26:38top, but like, well, who knows. I mean we don't know,
- 26:42but it could be a factor. I just hadn't. I'm just flashing
- 26:48on being in like the Oxo, which is equivalent to the seven eleven,
- 26:52and just you know, somebody shirtless and like so buffed that I can't believe
- 26:56it. You don't like it, I mean it's their body. No,
- 27:02it was just like weird, like I just you know, I don't ever
- 27:04see it. Yeah, I mean it's I'm not into it either, but
- 27:07you know it was sach to their own. Yeah, it was surprising.
- 27:11I wasn't expecting that culture there. Yeah. The way that at least I
- 27:15had either invented or you had primed me to invent was that Tullum Mexico.
- 27:22Was this really relaxing hippie getaway or something, but you ended up experiencing something
- 27:27different. It sounds like, yeah, so is that what you thought it
- 27:30was going to be. I it advertises itself as like a very holistic place
- 27:37to be what I e. Hippie hippie. It is very expensive. Yeah,
- 27:44And in Tuloom I did not see like a single to Molly Kart.
- 27:48Like it was just like, oh, this is this is for the American
- 27:52market. This is for the Instagram market for sure. And it was very
- 27:59strange. I will say, we led this beautiful retreat at this beautiful set
- 28:03of haciendas. They were like three full houses. Led the retreat. I
- 28:07co led the retreat with Drea Bloom. How many people came to the retreat.
- 28:11There was five folks came. They were great group. And this is
- 28:15four white again. This is Drea's therapist Utero. So Drea led journaling prompts
- 28:22and all she does. I mean, she's kind of magical. So she
- 28:25did her thing in the morning. I led collages in the afternoon. And
- 28:30we also because we were in the jungle, we're doing all kinds of botanical
- 28:33prints with watercolor and watercolor paper and photographic that really simple photographic paper that just
- 28:41turns from blue to white. Yeah, I love that stuff. So we
- 28:45were having this magical time and then is it za. So four of them
- 28:51go to Cheats or maybe all five of them on their own went to Chia,
- 28:55go to like one of the great spiritual pyramid sites on the planet,
- 29:00and then we like get to make taro with them the next day, and
- 29:03they are so kind of on another plane, having seen, you know,
- 29:08one of the seven great wonders of the world. So that part was really
- 29:12neat to get to be in clearly a spiritual center of the world. And
- 29:19then I got to do an underwater photo shoot. Do I tell you about
- 29:22this? Yeah? So, so note is a it's featured in the second
- 29:29Black Panther movie, which is like these water pools that are like potentially portals
- 29:33to other dimensions and they're all over to Loom. And when I was researching
- 29:41stuff to do, you know, I didn't need to take another atv rite
- 29:45or a zip line or like, I was just looking for something really unique.
- 29:49And because of my history, you know, getting photographs of me is
- 29:53a thing. And I now have so much more understanding for your wife Stacy
- 29:59and her modeling career because I did an hour and a half of an underwater
- 30:03photo shoot. Oh, you were the subject. Yes, it was the
- 30:07most exhausting. Yeah, physically demanding, especially underwater for crying over. Yeah.
- 30:11So there's two. There's the main photographer and then the assistant. And
- 30:17assistant spent the first twenty minutes with me just training me how to let all
- 30:21the air out of my lungs, how to go underwater, and how to
- 30:25not puff out my cheeks, which is really hard, like it goes against
- 30:30everything your body wants to do totally. And then once you're underwater, she
- 30:34spent another fifteen minutes with me teaching me how to pose, so it's like,
- 30:38you know, put your arms out, turn your head the other direction,
- 30:41make your legs look like a flamingo. Okay, did you keep your
- 30:45eyes open? She no, but it was my shoulder hurt for like two
- 30:52days afterwards because I had just like been in this ridiculous position. But there's
- 30:57gonna be these amazing PHONEO is me underwater? Did you enjoy the experience?
- 31:03It was very intense, and an hour and a half, I was like,
- 31:06how long have I been in the water, Like I can't do this
- 31:07much longer. Yeah, that's a lot Yeah, my body was just so
- 31:11physically exhausted, thinking, I mean an hour and a half. Yeah,
- 31:15I got out of the water. I like consumed a protein bar in like
- 31:18two bites. It was just it was a lot, and you've been given.
- 31:23So I was thinking about how on America's Next Top Model, somebody cries
- 31:26every episode, and like, I understood why because you're just giving constant feedback.
- 31:32Do this, do this, do this. You almost got that right,
- 31:33Okay, so now do everything you just did and do this. Yeah,
- 31:37And I was like, I'm really fucking tired. Yeah. It's like
- 31:41ballet dancing or something, because you have to always look beautiful and natural and
- 31:48relaxed while every single muscle in your body is doing something that you never knew
- 31:56you could actually do with that muscle, you know, and hold it while
- 32:00your faces relaxed. But probably Yeah, and it's like an hour and a
- 32:09half. Yeah, and you're exhausted. Yeah, Stacy, I mean,
- 32:14I don't know if she's ever done underwater, but yeah, she'll be modeling
- 32:17for eight hours straight. And I'm so much. I always have admired her,
- 32:23but now I admire her at a completely different level. Yeah, she'll
- 32:28have me model for photos sometimes like we'll do our Christmas card or we'll well,
- 32:35when she first started studying photography, she would have me be a subject
- 32:39so that she could practice, and literally, like three minutes in, I'd
- 32:45be like, okay, are we done, because she would have already taken
- 32:47like ten pictures and she'd be like, oh, honey, no, we
- 32:52were not even started. I'm just getting the flash right. And I'm like,
- 32:58okay, well another five minute, Like how long does it take to
- 33:00take a couple of pictures? Like, because to me, you know,
- 33:04you take thirty seconds and it's to dial it in just right. You take
- 33:07a picture to do like the picture that you're looking for. Yeah, just
- 33:12And that was just me often just sitting in a chair, let alone,
- 33:15like contorting my body and having a very natural, attractive facial expression. Well,
- 33:22and in the sonote photo shooting. Now that I look at her other
- 33:25work of other people, I can see like, oh, I was in
- 33:29that exact same spot, doing that exact same post. Like she knows exactly
- 33:34what she wants and exactly what looks good. And she is a task master,
- 33:38which means this is why I was attracted to doing this in the first
- 33:40place. Her photos are exquisite. But to get there, man, it's
- 33:46yeah, I've watched Stacy and actually because she started doing portraits and other kinds
- 33:52of things. And the real magic comes in when she has families with little
- 33:59kids that are rambunctious, and she has these certain scouted locations like the Japanese
- 34:07gardens or some park, because you got to find a good place with a
- 34:13number of different backgrounds and the lighting is good and there's not a lot of
- 34:16public people in the background, you know, to interfere. You don't want
- 34:21to bother others. So it's kind of a delicate balance. And then that
- 34:24was the other thing. I was in the sonote at eight am, right
- 34:28because other people can be there, you know, later on. And also,
- 34:31like the real magic comes in with her ability to coax people into providing
- 34:38a good picture because she has to please everybody. She's got to please both
- 34:45parents and all three kids and maybe a dog, and she has to get
- 34:50them all to look at her at the same time to take the photograph.
- 34:53She's got to keep them all smiling, she's got to keep them in a
- 34:57good mood. She has to be very light and fun. And also people
- 35:02are insecure. They most people are like, I think I look like shit
- 35:07in pictures, right, so she has to massage he goes. It's it's
- 35:12a masterclass in psychological manipulation because the subjects want a good picture and they don't
- 35:21know what it takes. And you know, you might have like a child
- 35:22melting down. You might have mom that is like my hair looks like shit.
- 35:28You know. I you know, I gained weight because I had kids,
- 35:30goddamn it, you know. And and you got dad that's like another
- 35:35picture, and a dog that's getting you know, she and she's a The
- 35:39ninety percent of her skill is just people. Is just managing that all those
- 35:45personalities for like the two hours that it takes to take these photos. And
- 35:51then you see the photos once she gets them back, and everyone looks relaxed
- 35:54and fine, but it's but I've been there in person, and I'm like,
- 35:59how is she gonna get a picture out of this? This is a
- 36:01disaster. Like the kid is crying half the time. The dad is like
- 36:06clearly not into this. What's happening. The parents seem to be kind of
- 36:10going through like pre divorce fighting right now. That's like subtle, I don't
- 36:15know. But then you look at the picture, and you know everyone's beaming
- 36:17and smiling and looking into the camera. And sometimes she has to take two
- 36:22or three photos and like photoshop one of the kid's eyes because he blinked in
- 36:25that moment. But you know it ends up looking real great. Well.
- 36:29And in this scenario, it was the photographer and an assistant, and the
- 36:32assistant is like not only she's trying to keep me not being exhausted, so
- 36:37like I'm holding onto a floaty. She's like pulling me around the sone on
- 36:42a floaty. And she didn't have a boat. No, you didn't have
- 36:45a boat. No, no boat. No you're in the ocean. No
- 36:51I'm not in the ocean. I'm in a sone, which is like a
- 36:53gorgeous watering hole. There's like half cave, bats flying over my head,
- 36:59mangrove everywhere. I am in a so still water, still water, fresh
- 37:04water. So tune into Instagram, y'all to see that photo. Let's take
- 37:07a break, we get back more stuff to talk about. What you say,
- 37:10yes or back from the break? So I forgot the mic. We
- 37:19were chatty. I have another email. So militier patron Julia from Vancouver,
- 37:23Canada. She says, I live in Canada, and in the past few
- 37:28years there have been a few high profile cases of famous people who were revealed
- 37:32to have been faking their Indigenous ancestry. Have you heard of this sort of
- 37:37thing? Yes. Of note, one was a former judge and another was
- 37:40an esteemed professor. They both accepted awards and accolades that were supposed to be
- 37:46reserved for those with Indigenous ancestry. After investigations, it was found that these
- 37:51individuals had been fraudulent about their identity. Their ancestry could be traced back to
- 37:57European settlers only, and there was no connection whatever to Indigenous people or Indigenous
- 38:02communities. They have been accepting awards and positions in Canada that they would not
- 38:07have gotten otherwise. More recently, an investigation of the folk singer Buffy Saint
- 38:14Marie came to light. She has received multiple music awards, some of which
- 38:19were intended explicitly for Indigenous artists. The themes of her music revolve around exploring
- 38:24her identity as an Indigenous person adopted into a white family, and she even
- 38:30wrote children's books from the perspective of an Indigenous child. She claimed that she
- 38:36was born on a reserve in Saskatchewan, Canada, and then adopted by Caucasian
- 38:40parents who lived in Massachusetts. She grew up in a middle class neighborhood in
- 38:45Massachusetts and then supposedly wanted to explore her Indigenous roots as an adult. However,
- 38:50birth records show that she was actually born to the same parents who claimed
- 38:53adopted her. Her family is of English and Italian descent, she is Caucasian.
- 39:00She seemingly grew up with no connection whatsoever to Indigenous communities, and there's
- 39:05no record of her supposed adoption. Some family members have said that they have
- 39:08received threatening letters from her lawyers to not come forward about the truth about her
- 39:14background. As a Caucasian individual, she and several other prominent individuals have built
- 39:20their entire careers and identities on lies, and have stolen positions and awards that
- 39:23were supposed to be reserved for a marginalized and highly oppressed community in Canada.
- 39:28These individuals also seem to follow the same pattern. They speak in interviews about
- 39:31the discrimination and prejudice that they experienced as Indigenous people, and even make up
- 39:37elaborate stories about what it was like to live on a reserve, even though
- 39:45none of them ever had the experience of living on reserve and seemed to be
- 39:49fabricating stories about experiences with oppression. Could you please speak to the psychology of
- 39:53these people who built their entire career and identity on lies and the set,
- 40:00Rebecca answer, why would they do this? Why? I mean, there
- 40:06is something, there is a level of attention that they want that they assume
- 40:12can only be gotten by having an identity that they don't have. And that,
- 40:20first off, that makes me really sad that they would spend so much
- 40:23work creating a story about themselves that wasn't true. I mean so to me,
- 40:29that speaks inherently the low self esteem that who they are isn't enough,
- 40:36and that these issues that they wish that they could explore they feel that they
- 40:39can't explore with what is their actual identity. I mean, you hear this
- 40:45a lot that like, I'm a white person, I don't have any culture,
- 40:49and it's like, oh, honey, like you better work for it,
- 40:51you better find out what it is. But yeah, I was and
- 40:55I was shocked that the Buffy Saint Marie story, I mean, this has
- 41:01been her whole quote brand for sixty years. Yeah, it wasn't a judge
- 41:09that just happened to occasionally discuss their indigenous ancestry. It was an artist that
- 41:19was centered around being an indigenous person, right, isn't that true? Yes?
- 41:23Yeah, like when people thought of her this, oh, she's an
- 41:25indigenous singer yea and sings about indigenous things and talks about indigenous things and other
- 41:32things, of course. But yeah, So I have thought about this a
- 41:38lot because as a person that has a distant Japanese ancestry myself, meaning that
- 41:47if my parents told me I wasn't Japanese, if they just told me I
- 41:51was white with like some like nonstandard white features, you know, white ethnic
- 41:58as my friends and call ourselves yeah, swarthy, then I wouldn't know any
- 42:05different. I mean, there's I mean, there wouldn't have been that much
- 42:08in my family that would have to be excized culturally for there to be no
- 42:13markers of Japanese culture, because my ancestors came over a undred twenty years ago,
- 42:17and over time you just start to assimilate or blend in or discard because
- 42:24you want to fit in or whatever. And so I can kind of relate
- 42:30to this on some level. But why would you claim an identity that you
- 42:34didn't have, right, so I think that it is. You know,
- 42:37there's a spectrum. Here. On one end of the spectrum you have con
- 42:42artists and liars who know they're lying, and maybe over time they start to
- 42:45believe their lives, but they start out absolutely intending on pulling one over on
- 42:52people like We recently re ran an episode about Tanya Head, who claimed to
- 42:55have been in the towers when they were hit by the hijackers and became president
- 43:04of the Survivors who Were in the Building Association and was perhaps the most famous
- 43:09survivor of the event. She claimed I think her husband died in the building,
- 43:15and not only was she in the building, but she was above the
- 43:19impact that she was one of the few people that actually survived. After that
- 43:22happened, and years and years later, like ten years later something, someone
- 43:29was doing a retrospective of a ten year anniversary, I think the New York
- 43:31Times, and a journalist just on a very surface level started to investigate,
- 43:37and the entire story fell apart. She wasn't even in New York at the
- 43:42time. She was in because she's Spanish. She was in Spain. She
- 43:46didn't have a husband that died, she didn't even work in that she never
- 43:51worked in the World Trade Center. There's just so many lies that were easily
- 43:57detected. And for Tanya Head, it looks like, given the whole scenario
- 44:04that she knew she was lying, she intended to lie. She has a
- 44:07pattern of lying. There's evidence of that as well. And you know,
- 44:10psychopathic liars will psychopathically lie. So that's on one end of the spectrum.
- 44:15The other end of the spectrum is people that were misled. Stacy, my
- 44:20wife was told for her entire life that she had a Native American in her
- 44:25history, in her ancestry, and what she found out with her DNA was
- 44:30that she has black in her history. And there's a well understood historical phenomenon
- 44:37of people that don't present. You know, you imagine you're half something,
- 44:43you're not entirely white. And because being black is worse than being Native,
- 44:49is she Appalachian? Her this branch comes from like Kansas, Missouri, Arkansas,
- 44:57or so those whole pockets of the country where this is. It's a
- 45:00huge phenomena. People would claim to be Native when in fact they knew they
- 45:05were black. But it was a lot worse to be of black ancestry than
- 45:09to be of Native ancestry, and so of course, even though you know
- 45:15it's a lie, you're going to tell your kids because you don't want them
- 45:19to slip with the truth because it could be bad for them. And then
- 45:22you know, after a couple of generations, there's no one alive anymore that
- 45:25remembers the truth, and it just gets passed down. And how would you
- 45:28know? There are many people who are misled for various reasons. Someone they
- 45:34have an aunt that just forgot because believe me, Another aspect I've learned is
- 45:39that genealogy up until DNA results could be found out fairly cheaply, is all
- 45:45word of mouth. It's all just like Grandpa. The shock that I had
- 45:50when I did my DNA, it was like, oh my god, the
- 45:52family story was true. When I got it back and I was ninety eight
- 45:55point six percent Ashkenaziq, I was like, oh my god, the tribe
- 46:00did stay together from the fifteen hundreds. Like how that part blew me away?
- 46:04Right, because it just seems so unbelievable that that story could actually be
- 46:08true, because you would think if that's what you're being told, you're like,
- 46:13well, I mean, there's got to be a great great grandma that
- 46:15got absorbed into the family that wasn't Askenazi, so you know, one hundred
- 46:21percent, come on, that's probably not likely. So so on one end
- 46:24you have the psychopathic flyers, and the other end you have the people who
- 46:28are just completely misled. For myself by white side, I was always told
- 46:32that my mom was Swedish, at least mainly Swedish. When I looked into
- 46:37the genealogy, my mom was only a fourth Swedish, but her three fourths
- 46:43is sort of a mismash of English, Scottish, Irish. And also,
- 46:50those people go back to the seventeen sixteen hundreds, and there's no records of
- 46:53those people, so we don't really or there's very little records, so we
- 46:58don't really know. What we remember is that the recent immigrants were the Swedish
- 47:01who came over in the eighteen hundreds, and we have enough, you know,
- 47:06memory of those people. So my mom just always said she was Swedish.
- 47:09So for a long time, I said I was half Japanese half Swedish.
- 47:14Was I am I a psychopathic liar because I was saying I was half
- 47:16Swedish even though I'm only at an eighth Swedish. You know, there.
- 47:21So there's a lot of people walking around my wife. I'm pretty sure I
- 47:24know she would walk around when it you know, she wouldn't get awards for
- 47:29being native, but when it came up, you know, she might mention
- 47:34it. So in between though, is I think where the vast majority of
- 47:38these kind of cases are, like like Saint Marie and you know, is
- 47:45it wouldn't it be? Is this an identity that she wanted and so she
- 47:50just took Was it a fantasy? Was it something that she stepped into and
- 47:54it really worked for her and she kept going right? And there are there
- 48:00are tribes too who do not do DNA testing. This is another thing too,
- 48:05is that the idea of who belongs in the tribe. Some tribes don't
- 48:09do DNA testing and view it as very cultural about who is part of the
- 48:14tribe. So I don't know if that was her story, if she got
- 48:16accepted into a group, or if she just decided that this was her story
- 48:21at tempoint. Well I actually looked into her story kind of and there's some
- 48:27details kind of along those lines. But to demonstrate this, since this is
- 48:30a psychology podcast, I want to really walk people through because when you hear
- 48:35these news headlines. It is very tempting, and I see people do this
- 48:38when they watch reality TV as well. It's very tempting to draw this very
- 48:44damning conclusion. And maybe there is a damning conclusion, but it's not as
- 48:49simple as it was with say, for example, Tanya Head, who clearly
- 48:53just made this up to get attention and then dug herself into a hole and
- 48:59might have thought, I shouldn't have lied about this because I'm going to get
- 49:01caught. I was just trying to lie to get attention for a month.
- 49:06But now I'm president of the association, you know. Anyway, so I
- 49:09think that there there's a pathway. Let me kind of describe it. So
- 49:13in the beginning, and I don't know, but it's possible that they might
- 49:16have known they were spinning the truth and or they were maybe misinformed in the
- 49:21beginning. You know, you have someone that assumed they were of native ancestry.
- 49:27You know, people have said that about me in my life. They
- 49:30especially when I was younger, they would they would say, oh, you're
- 49:34you're Indian or you're Native American and say that you just thought it'd be easier
- 49:39to go along with it, and so you just say yep, you know,
- 49:44and you don't get an award or anything. You're just like, sure,
- 49:46that's I am that because you just don't want to explain things or whatever.
- 49:51Or it's a job application and you're young and you're desperately trying to get
- 49:55a position and you're just thinking, I haven't all the jobs have me down.
- 50:00What if I just check this one box because some people think I look
- 50:02Native American? What if I check this box, would I get the job?
- 50:07And you just vow to yourself that I'll check this box and I'll never
- 50:10talk about it again because I don't want to get into this lie. Or
- 50:15a person has spotty early childhood memories like Saint Marie. I think might have
- 50:22had you know, trauma, being taken away from your parents or something else,
- 50:27and the family doesn't really remember the details, and so as an individual,
- 50:31you're always searching for the answer. And you hear a similar story about
- 50:36an Indigenous person who was stripped away from their family, and you think,
- 50:38huh, maybe that's what happened to me. You know, you start having
- 50:43these questions. Years go by, nothing happens. Then a gig comes along
- 50:46that's only for Indigenous people and you're like, well, I do remember thinking
- 50:52that it was possible that I might be of indigenous ancestry. You never know,
- 50:57So what if I just I do pass people sometimes? What if I
- 51:01put on this feather earring and just pasted And you know, in this moment,
- 51:07they you know, they know they're lying, and they have a tendency
- 51:09to do FIBs like this anyway, but they're not committing to creating a whole
- 51:14career around this. You know, they don't wake up one day and go
- 51:16like I'm gonna I'm going to trick the world. It's just like this little,
- 51:21this little slippery slope and they take the gig and they find that,
- 51:27oh my god, people treat you so differently at this festival that is for
- 51:31this sort of thing. I'm welcomed in this community. People are complimenting me
- 51:36as a musician just trying to get a gig. No one cares about me,
- 51:40but as an Indigenous person getting it who's a musician. Suddenly like I'm
- 51:45the center of attention, like this isn't so bad. And then you know,
- 51:49you sprinkle in. I think what you're getting at Earlier about white guilt,
- 51:52there's a lot of white guilt, and for good reasons. You know,
- 51:58white people feel bad about their history and their ancestors having oppressed a lot
- 52:04of people their own privilege, and an easy out is to start to convince
- 52:10yourself that maybe you're not entirely of the oppressive class. And so there's a
- 52:15lot of incentive, you know, to say, well, I did have
- 52:20an ant once that I seem to remember once saying that maybe we have Nate,
- 52:23so you know, we were native. Also, as you were getting
- 52:25at of white people saying that they don't have culture, they definitely have culture.
- 52:30They just swim in the mainstream culture, which is white culture. You
- 52:32know, at Antioch, we would talk about everyone's culture, would go around
- 52:37the room, and there's a lot of white people at antiok and a lot
- 52:42of white people at the beginning of the graduate school would say, well,
- 52:45I'm just white. I don't have culture. So we'd have a long talk
- 52:49about that. You know, like Japanese people in Japan don't think of themselves
- 52:53as as ethnic or having culture. They just think of themselves as being the
- 53:00quote unquote normal, you know, but if they come to the United States,
- 53:04then they're like, oh, or if we go there, you know
- 53:06what I mean, it's like when you're swimming in it, you're swimming in
- 53:08it. You know. American culture, American white culture isn't like the default.
- 53:13It's sort of like thinking your accent is to admit that this is your
- 53:17culture. Right. Well, also it's hard to know because you've never been
- 53:22educated or you've never been in a position where you have to contrast your culture.
- 53:24You know, Like for myself being Japanese American, growing up, I
- 53:30was constantly aware of the fact that, oh, there's this thing called culture
- 53:34because at home, these are things that I go to white people. So
- 53:37houses is complete different anyway, So after a while, some of these folks
- 53:42might start actually believing that they're indigenous ancestry. Because denial is a powerful thing.
- 53:49You know. You have people that drink all day every day and say,
- 53:52I'm not an alcoholic. What are you talking about. I could stop
- 53:54at any time. It's normal to drink. I'm just drinking, you know,
- 53:58I had a hard day, and they believe it. You come up
- 54:00to a light detector test, they believe it. And when it comes to
- 54:02this sort of thing, since there's not an obvious contradiction to this, you
- 54:07know, day in and day out, there's so many reasons to believe it.
- 54:10To people believe in QAnon shit, people believe that the Earth is flat.
- 54:15It's not a stretch to imagine that someone over time would start to actually
- 54:20believe one hundred percent that they actually have an ancestry that they do. And
- 54:24we're talking about social engagement system too. So if you're getting positive feedback about
- 54:30this aspect of yourself, it's hard to let go of. Yeah, because
- 54:37if you remove this, who are you left with? You know, it's
- 54:40like that kind of shadow self of like, oh, I'd have to look
- 54:45at the part that I have been denying, yeah, all this time.
- 54:49Yeah, and I my true identity, so to speak, is someone that
- 54:53I don't like because those are the people that oppressed my wait, my people
- 54:59or the you know, it gets very easy and very there's a lot of
- 55:02hues said to Rachel Dole as all comes to mind. Do you remember her?
- 55:06Yes, I was actually going to bring this up. She just got
- 55:08fired for having an only fans, right, what do you think about that?
- 55:13I mean, she's going to make a living. She's a teacher's aid,
- 55:15I believe, and someone out at her as having an only fans and
- 55:21then she was fired, So she wasn't advertising her only fans, She wasn't
- 55:25telling people at the school she had an only fans. She was just doing
- 55:30a side gig. But if a journalist could figure out it was her,
- 55:35I'm guessing that she must have been showing her face. That must be part
- 55:38of her kind of shtick. Is like you can see Rachel Dole is all
- 55:43the famous person. You can see her naked or something. You know,
- 55:47And to be clear, only fans isn't always naked pictures or sexual acts.
- 55:52It can be all sorts of things, but typically it's something along those lines.
- 55:54But yeah, do you think that that's like, I mean, you
- 55:59know, as a pro sex work person, this has happened before, only
- 56:02dvance this would happen too, is that someone would get outed as a sex
- 56:06worker and lose their job. I mean, I think it's really unfortunate.
- 56:08It doesn't impact their work with children, but I do think it shows that
- 56:15you know, once you've set, once you've put yourself in a position of
- 56:20being a quote liar or you know, people track you. And this is
- 56:25happening to the vander Pump guy Tom Tom. Is that you know there was
- 56:30an article in the New York Times this the other day, like it's the
- 56:34best reality TV show ever and he's completely ruined his life. Like, you
- 56:37know, once you're kind of viewed in the public eye is a certain thing.
- 56:42It's hard to unwind that story. Yeah. I just watched a whole
- 56:45interview with him, and a year later he's he hasn't grown in the least
- 56:51at least from the evidence, which is really unfortunate for him. But do
- 56:55you think a school should fire someone over that? I would hope not,
- 56:59but it's it's very, very common. Yeah, there's a case in the
- 57:04Berkeley Public School District which you would think would be very accepting of. A
- 57:08woman was outed as a social worker, I mean as a social worker,
- 57:12as a sex worker, that's kind of a social work. It is kind
- 57:15she really presented herself as like offering a human service, and she lost her
- 57:22job as a teacher. Yeah. Yeah, on the surface, for me,
- 57:28it's like what about the children? And you're like, as long as
- 57:31you're not letting your kids go online to wherever they want to go, then
- 57:37it's behind a paywall, so they're not going to grow up. Plus what
- 57:43on the off chance that kids accidentally hopefully because hopefully they're not, like they
- 57:49don't have free access to like internet porn. Let's just say someone gets their
- 57:54hand on a picture of teacher's aide who's who is naked, and they start
- 58:00sharing the picture. Is it the end of the world? You know what
- 58:02I mean, it's what's bad is that you have a system that has children
- 58:07being exposed to pornography in general. You know, seeing a naked body isn't
- 58:13gonna erode a child's mind. You know, there's a lot of other things
- 58:17that are more destructive, most namely sex negativity in general. You know,
- 58:22body shaming in general. Right, the body is disgusting, you know,
- 58:25like kind of So that's my first reaction, But then I don't know.
- 58:30My second reaction is just like Rachel does, all what are you doing?
- 58:31Like you're working in a school and you have an only fans, Like,
- 58:35there's a lot of other jobs. I'm guessing that it wouldn't be as as
- 58:39a sex We look at Rachel's psychology, I mean, she posts as black
- 58:45to for employment, for attention. She really felt like that was her identity.
- 58:52Yeah, she tanned or used makeup to make her skin. She's a
- 58:57blonde eyed, she's a blond eyed. She's a blue eye, a blue
- 59:00eyed, blonde white person, like just white white. If you see early
- 59:05pictures of her as a teen, she's a blonde, blue eyed white girl.
- 59:08You see these pictures of her when she's essentially black facing, She's permed
- 59:14her hair, she's dyed her hair. She has very fairly dark skin compared
- 59:20to her probably natural skin, I don't know, but it looks very tan
- 59:22and makeup or something. And in Spokane, Washington, by the way,
- 59:27and becomes THEAACP chapter president out there, the regional president. Did you know
- 59:32that? Yes, And she was a professor of Africana studies at Eastern Washington
- 59:37University. And then when she was caught, she just said, well,
- 59:43I identify as black. Another person that posed as another white person, by
- 59:49the way. I mean, that's another thing about the black people or Asians.
- 59:53You have white people that are claiming to be of a marginalized identity and
- 1:00:00becoming major spokespeople and leaders. I mean, it doesn't get more colonizing than
- 1:00:07that, right, It's just another example of a long history of white people
- 1:00:10just invading every fucking aspect, including marginalized groups. It's like you invade our
- 1:00:16country you kill us, you take our children away from us, and then
- 1:00:22you dress up in our clothes and claim to be us, and then go
- 1:00:25on stage and get our awards and sing quote unquote our songs and claim you
- 1:00:31are the leader of us within us. You know, in the past,
- 1:00:36you would just come in and said, I'm your white saver. Now you're
- 1:00:38saying you're one of us. Like, just leave us alone. You've already
- 1:00:43marginalized us. Let us be marginalized. Don't come into our marginalized corner.
- 1:00:49You know, it's it's well and you get to come in and take it
- 1:00:52off. I mean, that's the thing. I mean, the thing about
- 1:00:53Buffy Saint Marie is that she never took it off, you know. I
- 1:00:58mean she's now in her eighties and claim this identity for an entire lifetime.
- 1:01:02I mean, how is she what is she saying back? Well, so
- 1:01:07there's been a lot of back and forth that I've heard reporting of, and
- 1:01:14you know, at first denials, then once the evidence became pretty clear,
- 1:01:21her and I don't know, maybe her spokes to people I can't remember.
- 1:01:23I didn't. I'm a little foggy in the details because a while since I
- 1:01:27read all this, But kind of like Rachel Dolezolo, where it's just like,
- 1:01:30well, I am this and it doesn't matter what my history is.
- 1:01:35Also, there's some I guess, debatable points about the truth of the matter.
- 1:01:40You know, what exactly did happen and didn't happen in terms of adoption
- 1:01:44this kind of thing. According to a news article that I read, the
- 1:01:47descendants of the Native American the First Nation, the Indigenous People are defending Buffy,
- 1:01:54Saint Marie saying in a statement quote, we claim her as a member
- 1:01:59of our family, and all of our family members are from the pia Pot
- 1:02:02First Nation. I don't know how to pronounce that papot to us. That
- 1:02:07holds far more weight than any paper documentation or colonial record keeping ever. Could
- 1:02:13Hey, did she live the life? Yeah, it's hard to know what
- 1:02:15they mean by that, because they could mean, well, we believe her,
- 1:02:19or they could mean, well, we don't know. It's possible that
- 1:02:23she isn't actually DNA wise of our people, but we claim her as one
- 1:02:29of our people, which I can see because you know, for I don't
- 1:02:34know, fifty years, you have this figure that you love, that fights
- 1:02:38for you, that makes you feel better, that gives you someone to rally
- 1:02:44around. You know, she's not the only one, of course, but
- 1:02:45you know, one of the figures. And what is the meaning of life?
- 1:02:51Is it matter where she comes from? You know, it's a philosophical
- 1:02:53question, right, So you know, I don't I don't blame the Indigenous
- 1:02:59people for just saying, look, we still claim her and that's that.
- 1:03:04And I'm sure it's not all of those individuals, but at least the spokespeople,
- 1:03:08that's what they're saying. So would you say it's at its base it's
- 1:03:13a low self esteem issue? Yeah, it could be. It could be
- 1:03:16a con artist thing as well. You know, it's sort of like Bob
- 1:03:21Dylan. There was this persona that he had that he was this rough and
- 1:03:27tumble traveler of the American South with his six string strap to his back and
- 1:03:34you know, just going from down to town, you know, and it's
- 1:03:37like, oh, he's from Minnesota. Yeah, he's a nice Jewish boy
- 1:03:39from Minnesota and grew up middle class and yeah when did Jewish summer camp with
- 1:03:44my mom. Oh, really funny and had a regular little Bobby Zimmerman.
- 1:03:49Yeah, is that like Rachel Dole as all? It's not a good thing
- 1:03:52now, I just want to say off the top, my thing is don't
- 1:03:55lie. Yeah, it's it's easy not to lie, but it's I mean,
- 1:03:59we're also telling stories of it's it's hard not to lie, right,
- 1:04:03Like, there are personas that we could take on that could make things easier.
- 1:04:12And you know, I could definitely see it in being straight. It
- 1:04:15would be so much easier for me to be straight. When I see the
- 1:04:21straight women in my life and the stability that they have, it looks really
- 1:04:27attractive. Is that an identity that I can pull off for very long?
- 1:04:31No? But do I want the I mean, this is flip. Do
- 1:04:34I want the trappings of that privilege? Yes? I'm trying to think so
- 1:04:42like an identity like in the disability community. You know, I have several
- 1:04:46invisible disabilities. Am I gonna identify as disabled in order to I don't know
- 1:04:54get certain things like that's really triggering for me. So I'm just trying to
- 1:04:59imagine the slippery slo get what what would you get? I don't know.
- 1:05:02I think I'm not a very good person to do this with because well,
- 1:05:08you work for yourself, right, And is this like a parking placard?
- 1:05:14Baby? I don't know. I'm just trying to imagine things that I would
- 1:05:16lie about in order to get ahead. Well, is it, oh,
- 1:05:19what you would lie about. Yeah, but you're saying what you would emphasize
- 1:05:24right out of truth, but maybe not out of a sincere, absolute need.
- 1:05:30Yeah, that's what you're saying. Yeah. Yeah, But I'm trying
- 1:05:32to think of if there's any clients that I've worked with whose lives were built
- 1:05:39on a lie. Yeah. I can think of someone, and she had
- 1:05:44all kinds. She could be kind of judgmental of other people who she felt
- 1:05:47like they were living a lie, and I would have to bring it up,
- 1:05:50like, actually, your marriage is a lie. But it was interesting
- 1:05:56how often she would forget and how mad she would get at other people.
- 1:05:59Yeah, denial and then projection. Yeah. Like kind of a related thing
- 1:06:04for me in my life is I've been in scenarios at the university where there
- 1:06:11would be a question of racial oppression, white supremacy, and there would be
- 1:06:19a lot of different measures in place, one of which would be to have
- 1:06:24a lot of discussions about as professors, what should we be doing different or
- 1:06:29how do we feel about it? And sometimes they would break us up into
- 1:06:34two groups. There'd be a white group and then a person of color group
- 1:06:39BIPOD group, and I would be in the BIPOD group because I'm half Asian,
- 1:06:43and a part of me was like, well, yeah, Asians are
- 1:06:46oppressed. I'm half white though, and I'm also for generation and also Japanese
- 1:06:51people are bastards and racist against Chinese and Koreans and Vietnamese, and so I'm
- 1:06:59the victim. I don't know, Well that's funny. So Jewish folks in
- 1:07:03those situations are often like, there needs to be a third group. We
- 1:07:08were just considered white in the last fifty years. Really we're not white.
- 1:07:13I don't know if you've seen that scenario. Yeah, go down, and
- 1:07:15they're like, no, Jewish people, you have to be with the white
- 1:07:17people, and the Jews are like, our experience has been so different than
- 1:07:20your average white person. Yeah, but then like has it so? Yeah?
- 1:07:27And I have a friend who's half Asian half Japanese who was in a
- 1:07:30scenario like this, and she was actually told to go with the white people,
- 1:07:34and she was like, well, I kind of get that, but
- 1:07:38I'm not entirely white, so can't I maybe go back and forth between two
- 1:07:44I don't know, like it for half people as always, we're like maybe
- 1:07:47maybe for Jewish people as well. It's just like that, you know,
- 1:07:49because we don't fit into like the darker skin lighter skin phenomenon than you know,
- 1:07:56paradigm. It's like, we don't know what to do with you,
- 1:07:58so we'll just forget you exist and make you conform to one side of yourself
- 1:08:02anyway. So you know, I'd be in this bipod group and I'd be
- 1:08:09thinking, I don't know, but I'd rather be over here than in the
- 1:08:13white group because we're over here talking about oh yeah, you know, those
- 1:08:17white people, And if I was in the white group, i'd be I'd
- 1:08:23get labeled as well, you know, and that wasn't the purpose of these
- 1:08:28affinity groups, I think, is what they're called. But for myself,
- 1:08:32I didn't push back. I didn't raise my hand, I didn't say I
- 1:08:36don't know if this is the right configuration for this. I'm not saying I'm
- 1:08:42not oppressed and haven't experienced racism, because I have, but I'm probably not
- 1:08:47in the same category as for myself. Are there Asians that are you know,
- 1:08:53like there are Asians in Seattle that I think are being targeted by a
- 1:08:57lot of hate crimes, particularly in South Seattle. My anecdotal experience, Yeah,
- 1:09:01yeah, and it really bad. Actually, right, So I'm not
- 1:09:04saying Asians aren't, but as a half Asian, pretty white passing person,
- 1:09:11as a as a man, as as tall as I'm tall, I'm very
- 1:09:15educated. I you know, I have so much privilege and somehow like I'm
- 1:09:21but I didn't, I didn't push back. So I think that there's that
- 1:09:25kind of thing too. I'm not lying, But if I was in a
- 1:09:29tight spot and I had a tendency to lie maybe slightly, am I capable
- 1:09:33of going down that road? I guess? So I think that we should
- 1:09:41definitely call these people out, but at the same time, we shouldn't tell
- 1:09:45Indigenous people you can't claim her, you know what I mean? Yeah,
- 1:09:47I mean there's such a specific scenario and what she's given to that community is
- 1:09:53so huge, But I yeah, what is identity? I mean? Another
- 1:09:58really interesting example is Carol Channing, the famous singer for Me, a huge
- 1:10:02star in the seventies, famous for musical theater, very very entertaining. She
- 1:10:09lived into her nineties and was beloved even then, and she started to disclose
- 1:10:15at the end of her life that she was a quarterblack, and how she'd
- 1:10:17made it through Hollywood she passed all these years, right, we didn't know
- 1:10:23until the very very end. And you know, I mean there's stuff about
- 1:10:26identity in our culture that is so huge. Could Carol Channing have been famous
- 1:10:31in the sixties and seventies if folks knew she was a quarterblack? Probably not
- 1:10:35right, Yeah, Bruno Mars, I don't know. But a lot of
- 1:10:41people anecdotally, I'll ask people, what is his race? What's this?
- 1:10:45If this city? People say, well, he's black? Right, he's
- 1:10:48half fucking Asian. Right, he's half Filipino, half Jewish, half Puerto
- 1:10:54Rican. Well that's three halves, three halves, but he's half Filipino and
- 1:10:59the other half. Yeah, he's a quarter Jewish, a quarter okay,
- 1:11:02Puerto Rican. But he's half Asian and he's no black. Yeah, you
- 1:11:05know, I don't fault people, but the way he codes is a black
- 1:11:10person. And I don't know Bruno Mars and his thing, and maybe he
- 1:11:16is a lot more vocal and will set the record straight about his ancestry.
- 1:11:21But in the United States, if you're a half Asian, quarter Jewish,
- 1:11:27quarter Puerto Rican, artist. You are not going to get the attention then
- 1:11:30if you are a black artist, because Asians are not associated with R and
- 1:11:35B or soul music or dance music. You know, Asians are associated with
- 1:11:40Chinese food and karate. So I don't know what Bruno Mars is doing exactly.
- 1:11:45I don't know. I'm not saying he's lying or anything, but you
- 1:11:47know, you gotta do what you gotta do. It's just a reflection of
- 1:11:50our fucked up society, right. Yeah. I have some psychologist that on
- 1:11:57merch for you. I got you two shirts. Nice. It occurred to
- 1:12:02me that the co hosts don't have don't have merch. You don't have to
- 1:12:06wear it if you don't want to. I mean, of course I'll wear
- 1:12:09it. But there's a oh take care of you, take care of yourself
- 1:12:12shirt, and then a Psychology and Seattle shirt and a Psychology and Seattle mug.
- 1:12:15Oh my god, I'm like surrounded by merch. Yeah, look at
- 1:12:19that. You're I'm branded. You're part of the team, You're part of
- 1:12:24the brand. This is one of the greatest gifts of my life to be
- 1:12:27part of this team. I feel lucky every day. Really. Oh yeah,
- 1:12:31yeah, I mean I get to people are like, oh, what
- 1:12:32do you do? And one of the things I say is, I'm a
- 1:12:35monthly guest and a wildly popular internet Yes, you're a co host. I'm
- 1:12:39a co host, an employee. I'm a monthly co host on a wildly
- 1:12:44popular, internationally known podcast. I mean, whose life story is that?
- 1:12:47Like, that's not that's pretty. You know, I feel very blessed to
- 1:12:50be in this well scenario. We're blessed to have you. I'm blessed to
- 1:12:55have you as a friend, and I always look forward to you coming over
- 1:13:00and I took a shower for you. That's how much I want to impress
- 1:13:04you. It's uh, it's always fun, it's always interesting. There's always
- 1:13:12a lot of banter. You know, you and I as podcasters have you
- 1:13:16know, each of the co hosts is a different kind of energy obviously really
- 1:13:19different, and for you and me, it always feels the most like a
- 1:13:24conversation, most like hanging out. Like I mean, I think of like
- 1:13:28we used to go out to lunch and have this exact same experience and now
- 1:13:30we record it and that's really funny and like very much modern life. Like
- 1:13:35I just yeah, I mean, I have the same experience, Like I'm
- 1:13:38going to hang out with one of my besties. We'll talk about really provocative
- 1:13:42stuff. We'll record it, and then we'll put it out to the universe.
- 1:13:45Like that's kind of cool, you know. And I'm fifty three,
- 1:13:47Like this is not like I'm getting to participate in modern life. I'm not
- 1:13:54playing Sadoko, I'm not doing pick a ball, but I am podcasting.
- 1:13:58Like, and we got it. We got to say that we figured out
- 1:14:00what this creepy noise was. H it was correct. We're gonna take a
- 1:14:04picture of it right now. It was the lightsaber that you made at Disneyland.
- 1:14:13Yep, that was the creepy noise. It was not in the heating
- 1:14:15event as originally. I've been dealing with this noise for years, ever since
- 1:14:20I guess for three years or two years, ever since I got that lightsaber.
- 1:14:25And it's like a ventriloquist because the lightsabers to my left when I'm at
- 1:14:29my desk, it always sounded like it was coming from directly behind me.
- 1:14:32Well, it's a very strange noise. It's like a rare noise. And
- 1:14:35I was, you know, tearing apart my shelf every six months when that
- 1:14:42noise happened. The time it happened with you, it was starting to happen
- 1:14:45more often because it's a battery indication. Then it's low, which is kind
- 1:14:50of a noise. Just like, how about how if it just turns off?
- 1:14:55Don't take a picture of no I'm taking I'm trying to take a picture
- 1:14:58of me. Oh waste the lightsaber. Oh okay, you're doing a selfie.
- 1:15:02And I also tore apart my wall heater because when it went off with
- 1:15:08you, I figured it must be the wall heater. And by the way,
- 1:15:10the wall heater is not close. It's it's the it's in the ballpark.
- 1:15:15But why was I so sure it was the wall heater. Yeah,
- 1:15:17I tore that whole thing apart, and I'm I'm like, there's no battery
- 1:15:21in this thing. It has a dedicated supply. This is horrible. And
- 1:15:25by the way, it's like, the supply to the wall heater is two
- 1:15:29forty And for you elect trick people out there, you know, like,
- 1:15:32that's not a fun thing to mess around with. I didn't even hit the
- 1:15:34breaker, but once I figured it out, I went online and discovered that
- 1:15:41there are a lot of people in that situation where they're like, oh my
- 1:15:44god, I heard this noise going off. Because normally when something tells you
- 1:15:47the battery is going dead, it goes like bee beep right, or a
- 1:15:51light will blink or something. It won't just every six months, just god
- 1:15:56forbid, your lightsaber doesn't act when you need it to. That's the thing,
- 1:16:00Like it's just a fucking toy. Like if the batteries die out and
- 1:16:04I didn't know, it's not the end of the world. It's like it's
- 1:16:09programmed in to like bug you come on, Yeah, I can't think of
- 1:16:13a I have a lot of things in this room that are battery powered,
- 1:16:15and that's the only one that's annoying like that, Well is it because it
- 1:16:18was so expensive? I think an engineer didn't ask the question about, well,
- 1:16:26I could do this, but should I do it? That's the question,
- 1:16:30you know, Like engineers, they can do all sorts of shit,
- 1:16:32you know, like we could change the Google Maps interface, we could change
- 1:16:39the way Facebook interacts, we could change the UI. Have all sorts of
- 1:16:43things, but should we So I have this happen. I got a new
- 1:16:46I've had many for travel to watch movies when I was traveling and it was
- 1:16:51great. But I thought, oh, this will be fun. If I'm
- 1:16:56having a video conversation with someone, I can have this bigger screen. I
- 1:16:59can see there face so much bigger. But what the Or when I'm podcasting
- 1:17:02with Sylvia, I could use it with her. But there's a super annoying
- 1:17:08feature that the camera in the thing decides what it should be focusing on,
- 1:17:15so you can't position yourself. The camera zooms in on your face, so
- 1:17:18it's assuming that you're moving around willy nilly and the camera should decide. But
- 1:17:25it's super annoying because if you're talking to someone and you move, you get
- 1:17:29this weird like like it's this weird AI camera thing. So I had to
- 1:17:33spend like a very long time going through all the settings learning how to shut
- 1:17:40that off because I was like, I don't need you to frame the shot.
- 1:17:43I'm very experienced at this. I know what I want the shot to
- 1:17:45look like. It's like my car. It's constantly telling me to slam on
- 1:17:50the brakes. There's this beeping at you and the red light and the stream
- 1:17:56wheel will start to shave oh shit, and it'll start to slightly tap the
- 1:17:59brakes for me. Oh god, to it thinks I'm about to slam headlong
- 1:18:03into a car in the opposite lane. And I'm just driving down Aurora and
- 1:18:09I'm not swerving. There's nothing that's happening, but the computer somehow thinks regularly
- 1:18:15that I'm gonna slam and it's it's like, there's no option, and I've
- 1:18:18looked to turn that feature off. It's you can only turn down the sensitivity
- 1:18:23and it's still too sensitive. Eli on we should ask about this because Eli
- 1:18:29also informed me that if your car suddenly surges, that information gets recorded,
- 1:18:32right and that they so this is a great story. ELI had to inform
- 1:18:38somebody that someone else was driving the car and the car had been in an
- 1:18:42accident and repaired without the driver of the car knowing. A family member had
- 1:18:46done this, and they were like, how do you know? And they're
- 1:18:48like, cause we can see this report online from your card. Your car
- 1:18:53surged at this point there was an accident, and the person was like what
- 1:18:59They were like, this is all we recorded, sir. I'm sorry I
- 1:19:00have to inform you. I just you can do it, but should you
- 1:19:08do it? Well? On that note, you can and should take care
- 1:19:14of yourself because because you know what. On my way here, the cherry
- 1:19:16blossoms for blooming, and I thought, oh my god, it's spring.
- 1:19:20There's five Mondays until the officials start a spring, so by the time this
- 1:19:26podcast airs, there'll be one Monday hanging there. Everybody