Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Philosophers in the Driver's Seat
Transcript
- 0:10Imagine Friedrich Nature, the philosopher of raw power, test
- 0:14driving a completely silent 2024 electric vehicle.
- 0:19I mean, he would absolutely hate it.
- 0:20Welcome to today's deep Dive. Yeah, he really would.
- 0:23It's such a fun thought experiment.
- 0:24Exactly. And looking through the stack of
- 0:27sources you shared with us, from, you know, historical
- 0:29philosophical text to modern EV engineering breakdowns, we're
- 0:33taking on a really fascinating mission today.
- 0:35We are playing a fantasy game. Right.
- 0:37Like what happens if we put the greatest historical philosophers
- 0:40in the driver seat of a modern EV?
- 0:43For you, the listener, it sounds kind of absurd, but it actually
- 0:46reveals a ton. Yeah, giving these thinkers the
- 0:48keys reveals exactly how their ancient theories map perfectly
- 0:52onto the features of today's technology.
- 0:55It really exposes the core mechanics of how they viewed the
- 0:58world. We aren't just looking at what
- 1:00they thought, but, well, seeing those world views translated
- 1:03into torque, batteries and motors.
- 1:05So I want to start off with the Epicurus.
- 1:07Going through the notes on his worldview I kept thinking, is
- 1:09driving an EV basically like putting noise cancelling
- 1:12headphones on your soul? Oh wow, that is actually a
- 1:14brilliant way to frame it. I mean people often misinterpret
- 1:17Epicurus as a guy who just loved lavish banquets and excess.
- 1:22Right, the whole Epicurean Delight stereotype.
- 1:24Exactly. But his actual philosophy was
- 1:27centered on eliminating stress and pain to achieve, you know,
- 1:30anorexia. That's the total absence of
- 1:32disturbance. OK, so he valued what the
- 1:35sources call catastomatic pleasure.
- 1:38Meaning what exactly? Like a baseline level of joy.
- 1:41Yeah, think of it as the pleasure of a stable, anxiety
- 1:44Free State. You aren't chasing a high, you
- 1:47are simply existing without friction.
- 1:49Makes sense. Now compare that to a standard
- 1:51combustion engine. It is literally thousands of
- 1:54controlled explosions per minute.
- 1:55Right. The engine is vibrating, the
- 1:57gears are grinding. You have to constantly shift to
- 2:00avoid stalling. Exactly.
- 2:02Philosophically, a gas car is basically a machine that
- 2:04generates mechanical anxiety. So the EV motor, which is just
- 2:08this smooth, silent, magnetic glide, perfectly embodies
- 2:12catastomatic pleasure. He's just floating down the road
- 2:15in total peace. Precisely.
- 2:17But you know, Epicurus is all about curating his own internal
- 2:20peace. If we look at someone who
- 2:22aggressively rejected the outside world altogether.
- 2:25Like who? Well, someone like Diogenes the
- 2:28cynic. The motivation shifts entirely
- 2:31with him. Wait, I have to stop you there.
- 2:33Diogenes hated society. I mean he lived in a literal
- 2:36barrel in the street. Yeah, the guy was intense.
- 2:39He threw away his only wooden bowl because he saw a child
- 2:42drinking out of his hands. You're telling me he would care
- 2:45about a complex high tech EV? That makes zero sense.
- 2:49I know it sounds totally contradictory until you look at
- 2:51his core obsession, which is a tarky absolute self-sufficiency.
- 2:55OK. So he despised depending on any
- 2:57external system. Exactly.
- 2:59To him, relying on society was a form of slavery.
- 3:02And think about what driving a gas car means.
- 3:04You are permanently tethered to the global geopolitical oil
- 3:07grid. You need the gas station, the
- 3:09supply chains, all the refineries.
- 3:10Right, but an EV changes the equation.
- 3:13If Diogenes can, say, bolt a solar panel to the roof of his
- 3:17barrel and charge his EV using just the sun, he severs that
- 3:21tether. Oh wow.
- 3:22He achieves technological. Yes, he is generating his own
- 3:27fuel independently, completely off the grid.
- 3:30He'd gladly roll silently past gas stations, just mocking the
- 3:34drivers as slaves to the price per barrel.
- 3:36That is such a great image, but I mean, Diogenes solves the
- 3:41problem by retreating from society entirely.
- 3:43What if you can't live in a barrel, right?
- 3:44Yeah. What if you have to share a
- 3:46crowded city with millions of others?
- 3:49That requires a completely different framework.
- 3:51Which brings us to Immanuel Kant.
- 3:54Kant believed in pure rationality and universal rules.
- 3:57Right, his famous categorical imperative, basically arguing
- 4:00that you should only take actions that make sense if
- 4:03everyone in the world did them simultaneously.
- 4:06Spot on. So if everyone in a dense
- 4:08metropolis drives a car pumping out toxic exhaust, the air
- 4:12becomes unbreathable. The environment literally
- 4:14destroys the people in it. It creates A logical
- 4:17contradiction which I know Kant couldn't stand.
- 4:19Yeah, he hated that, but there's a deeper mechanical alignment
- 4:23here too. Combustion engines are
- 4:25incredibly inefficient. They lose about 80% of their
- 4:28energy as wasted heat and friction.
- 4:30Right, whereas an electric motor uses almost all of this energy
- 4:33for pure forward motion. Exactly.
- 4:36For Kant, this thermodynamic efficiency isn't just an
- 4:39engineering feat, it's the ultimate triumph of practical
- 4:42reason. It is energy used rationally,
- 4:45without waste, in a way that works as a universal law.
- 4:49I could definitely see Kant nodding approvingly at the
- 4:52thermal efficiency, but let's circle back to that opening
- 4:54thought about Nietzsche. Yes, the ultimate hater.
- 4:58Kant loves the logic, Epicurus loves the piece.
- 5:02But why does Nietzsche despise the EV?
- 5:05Because to Nietzsche, engineering a car to be
- 5:07perfectly silent, safe, and emission free is a a too human
- 5:13attempt to anesthetize danger. Right.
- 5:15He championed the Dionysian spirit, embracing the chaotic,
- 5:18brutal and sometimes dangerous nature of reality.
- 5:20Exactly. So a combustion engine which, as
- 5:22you said earlier, is literally powered by thousands of
- 5:25contained explosions appeals to him.
- 5:27It is the perfect physical metaphor for his philosophy,
- 5:30isn't it? It really is.
- 5:32The engine harnesses violent explosions to overcome physical
- 5:35resistance. It taps into the will to power,
- 5:37the drive to overcome struggle and achieve greatness.
- 5:40And an EV just removes the struggle.
- 5:42Right. It removes the roar and the
- 5:44mechanical resistance to Nietzsche.
- 5:46Making the drive effortless makes it weak.
- 5:49Wow. Let's pause this fantasy game
- 5:51for a second and let you, the listener, think about it.
- 5:54Which of these philosophical rationales resonates most with
- 5:57you? Are you chasing Epicurus's quiet
- 6:00peace or Diogenes's solar powered independence?
- 6:04Oregon maybe Kant's universal efficiency or Nietzsche's raw,
- 6:07unfiltered mechanical rumble. We want to thank you so much for
- 6:10taking this ride with us and for your time today.
- 6:12Yes, thanks for joining our deep dive.
- 6:14But before you go, consider this If our choice of transportation
- 6:18subconsciously reveals the ancient logic we follow, what do
- 6:21the rest of our everyday technological choices say about
- 6:25the unspoken philosophies governing our lives?