Latest / The Piano Maven with Jed Distler / Benjamin Grosvenor's Chopin Sonatas Nos. 2 & 3
Transcript
- 0:08This is Jed Disler and welcome to The Piano Maven,
- 0:11your friendly podcast guide to piano recordings.
- 0:15Consider taking out a paid subscription to The
- 0:18Piano Maven, and you can find a link to do so
- 0:21in our episode description. Paid subscribers
- 0:25help keep this podcast afloat, so I really appreciate
- 0:29your support. Somehow... I missed the boat when
- 0:34Benjamin Grosvenor's Decca release featuring
- 0:37Chopin's second and third sonatas pulled into
- 0:42the dock back in May of 2025. I never got around
- 0:47to hearing it until recently, although several
- 0:50subscribers have been pushing me to talk about
- 0:53it. So finally, I did settle down to listen to
- 0:57this disc, and I have to tell you, I was mostly
- 1:01impressed, not all the way throughout this release.
- 1:05But I would venture to say that Benjamin Grosvenor's
- 1:10recording of the second sonata, the Funeral March
- 1:12sonata, may well be my new modern -day reference
- 1:17version, with all due respect to people like
- 1:20Nelson Freire, Marc -André Hamelin, Janina Fielkowska,
- 1:25Hélène Grimaud, and... Others that I'm forgetting
- 1:29to mention, of course. Benjamin Grosvenor totally
- 1:32gets the first movement's agitato qualities without
- 1:37pushing the music into hysteric extremes or...
- 1:41faking emotion. And the scherzo is a model of
- 1:46textual clarity. And all of the pianist's inflections
- 1:50of tempo and phrasing enhance rather than obliterate
- 1:55the music's expressive unrest. And I like how
- 1:59Grosvenor sometimes desynchronizes his hands
- 2:02to clarify contrapuntal textures. And he does
- 2:06this without out -sounding mannered or contrived
- 2:10or trying to evoke the spirit of dead pianists.
- 2:15And I also love this pianist's carefully scaled
- 2:19dynamic game plan in the funeral march and how
- 2:24in the trio section he shapes the melodic line
- 2:28with tiny breath pauses and hesitations. It's
- 2:32almost like an aria. my goodness, what fluency
- 2:37and absolute synchronicity between the hands
- 2:40and the finale's unison runs. I mean, the colors,
- 2:45the harmonic pointing, this is just a wonderful
- 2:48performance. As a whole, the interpretation doesn't
- 2:52probe into dangerous corners. And, you know,
- 2:57maybe I've heard more chillingly. desolate funeral
- 3:01march movements, certainly from a pianist like
- 3:05Alexander Gajiev, whose 2021 Chopin competition
- 3:09performance remains one of the most mesmerizing
- 3:13I've ever heard. But Benjamin Grosvenor's highly
- 3:17detailed and deeply felt second sonata, I think,
- 3:22is built to last. It's a marvelous recording.
- 3:25His B minor sonata, the sonata number three,
- 3:29is almost on the same level. It's a marvelous
- 3:33interpretation in and of itself, although I do
- 3:38have to say that there is stronger catalog competition
- 3:41for excellent versions of this work. For some
- 3:46reason, there seem to be more great B minor sonatas
- 3:50in the catalog than B flat minor sonatas, at
- 3:53least that's my opinion. For some listeners,
- 3:57grosvenor may come across as a little too forthright
- 4:00or cruel or even perfunctory in the first movement
- 4:06where He really does project the allegro directive
- 4:10well, but somehow he avoids the composer's maestoso
- 4:15marking. If you want maestoso with a capital
- 4:19M, with all of its rhetorical implications, then
- 4:23you have to go to pianists like Claudio Orao,
- 4:26or maybe the very broadly paced Emil Gilels on
- 4:30Deutsche Grammophon. I would wish for a little
- 4:34more tenderness and lyricism in the second subject
- 4:38than what Grosvenor is willing to offer. But
- 4:42his balancing of the gnarly counterpoint in the
- 4:46development section is like watching a game of
- 4:49three -dimensional chess played by somebody like,
- 4:52oh, I don't know, maybe Bobby Fischer in his
- 4:56prime. The scherzo is really fantastic. It's
- 5:00very fleet and effortless and intelligently voiced.
- 5:04And the transition into the B major trio section
- 5:08just takes your breath away. And also in the
- 5:11trio, Grosvenor doesn't lean on the top line
- 5:15and ignore everything else. He really voices
- 5:18the counterpoint in the trio so that you hear
- 5:21all of the lines independently and interacting
- 5:25really. Interestingly, I was looking at the original
- 5:30review of this disc in Gramophone by my colleague
- 5:34David Fanning. He was not so keen on the Largo
- 5:38movement. He said that the slow movement central
- 5:42section in particular was a little too notey,
- 5:46a little too severe of countenance. I rather
- 5:51disagree because I hear more flexibility in pulse.
- 5:55And I hear the triplet sequences in the right
- 5:58hand take on a really imaginative, melodic trajectory
- 6:04that really propels the music over the bar lines.
- 6:08And this is a movement that can so easily die
- 6:11on the vine. In Benjamin Grosvenor's hands, it
- 6:15really moves and takes interesting shape. The
- 6:19finale has great character and dramatic contrast,
- 6:23and the climaxes are full -bodied. And the quiet
- 6:27decorative writing is amazingly lithe and supple
- 6:31and very intelligently contoured. There are other
- 6:35works on this disc. There's a beautiful Berceuse.
- 6:40although it's not quite so magical and ethereal
- 6:43and otherworldly as, I guess, that classic Murray
- 6:50Pariah recording or the old Solomon recording
- 6:53on 78s. In Grosvenor's hands, the first ballade
- 6:58is more about music than virtuosity for its own
- 7:02sake. And this is especially true in the coda,
- 7:05where the pianist focuses on the cross -rhythmic
- 7:09phrasings. I mean, he's mastered the notes to
- 7:12the point where he doesn't have to show off or
- 7:15prove anything. He just makes music. I am a little
- 7:19disappointed with the F minor Nocturne, Op. 55
- 7:23No. 1. The performance strikes me as a little
- 7:27bit square and literal. I mean, the tempos are
- 7:30ideal, but I rather miss the bel canto sensibility
- 7:35and the really authentic agitato qualities in
- 7:40the central section that distinguishes how Vladimir
- 7:44Horowitz played this piece. My thoughts haven't
- 7:47quite crystallized about how Grosvenor plays
- 7:51that fantastic nocturne in E -flat, Op. 55, No.
- 7:562, you know, the one that Ignaz Friedman made
- 7:58famous in his legendary 1936 recording. On one
- 8:04hand... Grosvenor's finger independence transforms
- 8:07the complex textures into something much more
- 8:11horizontal than vertical, as if the piano had
- 8:16morphed into being a string quartet. And it always
- 8:21seems that Grosvenor is searching for something
- 8:23and trying to establish dialogues between the
- 8:27voices. But on the other hand, the performance
- 8:30seems to hit a lot of dead spots where a line
- 8:34or a phrase tends to peter out before arriving
- 8:38at its final destination. Or there are indifferent
- 8:42resolutions or matter -of -fact resolutions of
- 8:48a cadence. Or there's a climax that's dynamically
- 8:52miscalculated. I mean... I find this performance
- 8:56to be more exploratory than specific. It's not
- 9:00uninteresting, but somehow, to my ears, it just
- 9:05doesn't gel. I don't know. But you really do
- 9:08need this release for the sonatas, especially
- 9:12the Funeral March sonata. This is Jed Disler,
- 9:16and you've been listening to The Piano Maven,
- 9:18your friendly podcast guide to piano recordings.
- 9:22Thank you for tuning in and I look forward to
- 9:24being with you for our next episode.