Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / The Man Machiavelli Based 'The Prince' On—Cesare Borgia's Rise and Fall
Transcript
- 0:00Beat Cesare Borgia, the Pope's son whose ruthless power plays
- 0:04became the model for Machiavelli's Prince.
- 0:08All that and more. Stay tuned.
- 0:30Welcome back to Hidden Forces in History.
- 0:33I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan Slate, the CEO of Commander
- 0:36Brand. We help our clients to appear on
- 0:39some of the biggest podcasts in the world.
- 0:43Check us out via the link in the description.
- 0:46And now our story. The Borgias aren't Italian,
- 0:51they're Spanish. The family name is originally
- 0:55Borgia, a minor nobility from Valencia.
- 0:58They're ambitious, clever, and completely shut out of power in
- 1:02Spain, where the great aristocratic families have
- 1:05locked down every position of influence.
- 1:10So they do what ambitious outsiders have done throughout
- 1:13history. They go where the opportunities
- 1:16are. And in the 15th century, the
- 1:18biggest opportunity in Europe is the Catholic Church.
- 1:23And here's why. The Catholic Church is perfect
- 1:26for ambitious families. It's the only institution in
- 1:29Europe where birth doesn't completely determine your
- 1:33ceiling. Yes, noble connections do help.
- 1:37But unlike kingship, which passes through bloodlines,
- 1:41church positions can theoretically be earned through
- 1:44talent, education and political skill, or bought.
- 1:49The first Borgia to do it big is Alfonso de Borgia.
- 1:52He's a lawyer, a diplomat and a skilled administrator.
- 1:56He works for the King of Aragon, impresses the right people, and
- 2:00in 1444 becomes a cardinal. In 1455, he becomes Pope
- 2:05Calixtus the Third. This is the breakthrough.
- 2:10Once you have a family member as Pope, you can instill relatives
- 2:14throughout the church hierarchy. Nepotism isn't accepted in
- 2:18Renaissance Italy. It's expected.
- 2:21It's how power works. Calixtus immediately promotes
- 2:25his nephew Rodrigo Borgia, making him a cardinal at age
- 2:302525 years old. No significant theological
- 2:35training, no reputation for piety, just family connection.
- 2:41But Rodrigo is brilliant. He's charismatic, ruthless and
- 2:46pragmatic. He understands something crucial
- 2:49about the Renaissance Church. It's not a religious institution
- 2:55that happens to have political power.
- 2:58It's a political institution that uses religion as a tool.
- 3:03From 1456 to 1492, which is 36 years, Rodrigo Borgia builds the
- 3:09most efficient corruption machine in Europe.
- 3:12His official position is vice chancellor of the Catholic
- 3:15Church. Think of it as the Vatican's
- 3:18chief operating officer. He manages the administrative
- 3:22bureaucracy, controls appointments and overseas the
- 3:27legal system. And he monetizes everything.
- 3:32The sale of offices, every position in the church hierarchy
- 3:35is for sale. Want to be a Bishop?
- 3:37Well, that'll cost you a cardinal higher price.
- 3:42Rodrigo doesn't just sell positions.
- 3:45He creates A secondary market, taking cuts when offices are
- 3:49resold or inherited. By 1492, he's accumulated more
- 3:54wealth than any cardinal in history.
- 3:58His palace in Rome is more luxurious than most Royal
- 4:01Courts. He owns vast estates across
- 4:04Italy and Spain. The mistresses and bastards.
- 4:08Rodrigo doesn't even pretend to be celibate.
- 4:12He has a long term relationship with Venoza de Cotenay, a Roman
- 4:17noble woman with whom he has at least four children.
- 4:21Cesare, born in 1475. Juan, born in 1476.
- 4:26Lucrezia in 1480. Joffrey in 1481.
- 4:30Later he'll take another mistress, Julia Fernace.
- 4:35She's beautiful. She's called Julia Labella, who
- 4:39is 30 years younger than him. Her brother will later become
- 4:43Pope Paul the Third, partly because of Rodrigo's patronage.
- 4:48This isn't scandal in a modern sense.
- 4:50Everyone knows about it. Other Cardinals have mistresses
- 4:54and children, but Rodrigo is exceptional in how he openly
- 4:59flaunts it, and he aggressively promotes his illegitimate
- 5:03children. The political network.
- 5:06Rodrigo builds alliances with every major power in Italy,
- 5:10Milan, Venice, Naples, Florence, and he lends money to kings.
- 5:15He brokers treaties. He makes himself indispensable.
- 5:19By 1492, when Pope Innocent the 8th dies, Rodrigo Borgia is the
- 5:23most powerful cardinal in Rome. But he's also 61 years old.
- 5:28If he's going to become Pope, it has to be now.
- 5:32So what does he do? Well, he does what he does best.
- 5:35He buys it. August 14, 9223 Cardinals enter
- 5:41the conclave to elect a new Pope.
- 5:44The favorite is Cardinal Giuliano della Rovre, Learned,
- 5:48experienced, genuinely pious by Renaissance standards.
- 5:54He'll later become Pope Julius the 2nd and Commission
- 5:57Michelangelo to paint the Sistine Chapel ceiling.
- 6:01But Della Rovare has a problem. He's not as rich as Rodrigo
- 6:06Borgia. What happens next is described
- 6:09in detail by multiple contemporary sources, including
- 6:13the Mantuan ambassador and various Cardinals own accounts.
- 6:19Rodrigo makes specific offers to specific Cardinals.
- 6:22Cardinal Escenia Schwarza the key vote.
- 6:25Rodrigo promises him the position of Vice Chancellor,
- 6:29which is Rodrigo's current job, plus the Borge of palace in Rome
- 6:34and 4000 gold ducats in cash. Swartz accepts.
- 6:38To Cardinal Arsini, he promised multiple church offices and
- 6:41estates. To Cardinal Colonna, he promised
- 6:45the strategic fortress of Subiaco and the Abbey of Subiaco
- 6:49worth enormous revenues. As for the Venetian Cardinals,
- 6:54he promised lucrative positions in the Papal States.
- 6:58Contemporary sources claim Rodrigo spent over 100,000
- 7:02ducats buying the papacy, which is roughly equivalent to 20 to
- 7:07$30 million. Today, on August 11th, after 4
- 7:10ballots, Rodrigo Borgia received the necessary 2/3 majority.
- 7:16He becomes Pope Alexander the 6th.
- 7:19The reaction across Europe is immediate horror.
- 7:23The Florentine preacher Savonarola calls it an
- 7:26abomination. The French ambassador writes
- 7:29that the papacy has been sold to the highest bidder.
- 7:33Even by the standards of Renaissance corruption, this is
- 7:36exceptional. But Alexander doesn't care about
- 7:40appearances. He cares about power.
- 7:43And now he has it. Alexander's first act as Pope is
- 7:49to turn the Vatican into a family enterprise.
- 7:53His son Cesare Borgia is made a cardinal at age 18, 18 years
- 7:57old, and he has no theological training, no pastoral
- 8:02experience. He's a warrior and a politician,
- 8:06not a priest. But Alexander needs Cesare in
- 8:09the church hierarchy to control the College of Cardinals and
- 8:14eventually succeed him as Pope. This is the plan.
- 8:19Create a Borgia dynasty that controls the papacy across
- 8:22generations. His older son Juan is made Duke
- 8:25of Gandhia and given command of the papal armies.
- 8:29Alexander showers him with titles, land and money, clearly
- 8:34favoring Juan as his secular heir, while Cesare is meant for
- 8:38the church. This creates immediate tension.
- 8:43Cesare does not want to be a cardinal, he wants to be a
- 8:46warrior Prince like his brother. The rivalry between them will
- 8:51have deadly consequences. His daughter Lucrezia becomes a
- 8:56political pawn at age 13. She's married to Giovanni
- 9:00Swartza, the Lord of Picero, to cement an alliance with Milan.
- 9:05But here's where the Borgia dynasty gets genuinely
- 9:10disturbing. Alexander is obsessively close
- 9:14to Lucrezia. Contemporary sources describe
- 9:17him as unable to be separated from her, keeping her at the
- 9:21Vatican, consulting with her on political matters, and
- 9:25displaying physical affection that makes observers a bit
- 9:29uncomfortable. Later, enemies will accuse
- 9:32Alexander and Cesare of incest with Lucrezia.
- 9:36Are these accusations true? Well, probably not.
- 9:39They're mostly propaganda from the Borgia's enemies.
- 9:44But the fact that the accusations are believable tells
- 9:47you everything about the family's reputation.
- 9:51Alexander has turned the papacy into a Renaissance court, with
- 9:55himself as absolute monarch and his children as Princess and
- 9:59princesses, and an entire apparatus of the Catholic Church
- 10:03as their personal property. And then the murders begin.
- 10:10Before we get to the next part of the story, subscribe, leave a
- 10:13like and a comment. What are your thoughts so far?
- 10:17Are the Borgias the most dangerous family in history?
- 10:21OK, let's get back to the video. June 14th, 1497.
- 10:28Rome. Hope.
- 10:29Alexander's favorite son, Juan Borgia, Duke of Gandhia, attends
- 10:33a dinner party at his mother Venutsa's house.
- 10:37Also present are his brother Cesare.
- 10:39Around midnight, Juan leaves the party on horseback with a
- 10:44mysterious masked companion. He tells his servants that he
- 10:48has business to attend to. He's never seen alive again.
- 10:52The next morning, a timber merchant reports seeing a body
- 10:56thrown into the Tiber during the night.
- 11:00Papal guards drag the river and find Juan's corpse stabbed 9
- 11:04times, his throat cut, and still wearing his expensive clothes
- 11:09and jewelry. This isn't robbery.
- 11:12This is assassination. Pope Alexander is devastated.
- 11:17Contemporary accounts describe him as weeping uncontrollably,
- 11:22refusing to eat for days and threatening to abdicate.
- 11:26Juan was his favorite, his secular heir, the son who
- 11:30supported to build the Borges dynasty's temporal power.
- 11:35The investigation goes nowhere. No one is ever charged.
- 11:40But everyone in Rome knows who did it.
- 11:43Cesare. And here's the motive.
- 11:46Juan has everything Cesare wants.
- 11:49Military command, secular titles, their father's love.
- 11:54Meanwhile, Cesare is trapped in the church, wearing cardinal's
- 11:58robes when he wants to wear armor.
- 12:01Multiple contemporary sources, including the Venetian
- 12:05ambassador, report that Cesare and Juan had a violent rivalry,
- 12:10that they competed for their father's attention and for the
- 12:14same woman, possibly Sasha of Aragon, their brother Joffrey's
- 12:18wife. The night of the murder, they
- 12:21were seen leaving a party together.
- 12:24Cesare is never formally accused.
- 12:27He's a cardinal and the Pope's son.
- 12:30But from this moment forward, everyone knows.
- 12:33Cross Cesare Borgia and you die. Alexander eventually accepts
- 12:38that his favorite son is dead and that his other son probably
- 12:43killed him, and he makes a calculation.
- 12:47Better one living son with power than two dead sons and no
- 12:51dynasty. He gives Cesare everything Juan
- 12:54had and more. August 1498 Cesare Borgia does
- 13:00something unprecedented in church history.
- 13:03He resigns as a cardinal. No one has ever voluntarily
- 13:08given up the cardinal it. It's a lifetime appointment and
- 13:12one of the most powerful positions in Christendom.
- 13:16But Cesare doesn't want spiritual power.
- 13:19He wants an army. Pope Alexander immediately
- 13:22legitimizes the transition. He petitions the king of France
- 13:26for a secular title for his son in exchange for supporting the
- 13:31French claim. In Italy, Cesare becomes Duke of
- 13:35Valentinois. Illinois Valentino, as the
- 13:38Italians call him. Now he's free to do what he was
- 13:41born for, conquest. Alexander's plan is brilliant
- 13:46and ruthless. Use the papacy, spiritual
- 13:49authority and financial resources to carve out a secular
- 13:53Kingdom for Cesare in central Italy.
- 13:56The target? The Romagna, a patchwork of
- 13:59small city states nominally under papal control but actually
- 14:03ruled by independent Lords. Over the next four years, Cesare
- 14:07becomes the most feared military commander in Italy.
- 14:12As for the method, Cesare doesn't just conquer, he
- 14:15terrorizes. His signature move is to take a
- 14:18city through siege or treachery, execute the previous ruler in a
- 14:22spectacular public manner, install absolute control, and
- 14:27then move to the next target. Faenza falls after an 8 month
- 14:31siege, and Cesare personally supervises the torture and
- 14:35execution of the city's young Lord Astoria, the third
- 14:39Manfrede, whose body is later found in the Tiber.
- 14:44Urbino falls through betrayal and treasury, pretends to be an
- 14:48ally, then suddenly occupies the city while the Duke is away.
- 14:52The Duke flees into exile and dies shortly after, possibly
- 14:56poisoned. Camarino.
- 14:58Pezzero. Remini, Sasana 1 by 1.
- 15:01The cities of the Romagna fall to Cesare's combination of
- 15:05military force and political treachery and manipulation.
- 15:11The Senegalia Massacre on December 31st 15-O2 Cesare's
- 15:16most infamous act. Several of his own condottieri,
- 15:20which are mercenary commanders, have been plotting against him.
- 15:24The Orsini and the Vitelli families worried that Cesare is
- 15:28becoming too powerful. They think they negotiated a
- 15:32truce and meet Cesare at Senegalia to discuss terms.
- 15:37It's a trap. Cesare invites them into the
- 15:40palace for negotiations. Once inside, his guard seized
- 15:44them that night. Cesare personally supervises
- 15:48their execution. Vitilazzo Vitelli and Alvarado
- 15:52de Fermo are strangled with a cord.
- 15:55The others are killed. Over the following days, the
- 15:59massacre sends shock waves through Italy.
- 16:02The message is clear. Betraying Cesare Borgia means
- 16:07death, and he'll smile at you while planning your murder.
- 16:15A young Florentine diplomat named Niccolo Machiavelli is
- 16:19sent to observe Cesare's court in 15 O 2 to 15 O3.
- 16:24He watches Cesare operate the careful planning, the ruthless
- 16:28execution, the ability to appear merciful while being utterly
- 16:33brutal. Years later, Machiavelli will
- 16:36write The Prince, and Borgia will be his primary model for
- 16:40the ideal ruler. Someone who understands that
- 16:43power requires both the cunning of a fox and the strength of a
- 16:46lion. Someone willing to do evil when
- 16:49necessary, but skilled enough to make it look like justice.
- 16:54By 15-O3, Cesare controls a Kingdom stretching across
- 16:58central Italy. He's 28 years old.
- 17:01He has his own army, his own state, and his own court.
- 17:05The Borgia dynasty seems unstoppable.
- 17:08And then in August 15, O3 everything collapses in a single
- 17:12week. August 5th, 15 O 3A villa
- 17:19outside Rome. Pope Alexander the 6th and
- 17:22Cesare Borgia attend a dinner party hosted by Cardinal Adriano
- 17:27Castelli. It's Castellesi.
- 17:32I'm going to do it again. Hope.
- 17:38Alexander the 6th and Cesare Borgia attended dinner hosted by
- 17:42Cardinal Adriano Castelesi. It's a summer in Rome, brutally
- 17:48hot and disease season, when wealthy Romans flee to their
- 17:52country estates. During or shortly after dinner,
- 17:56both Alexander and Cesare become violently I'll.
- 17:59Within days, Pope Alexander the 6th is dead.
- 18:03He's 72 years old, and his body decomposes so rapidly in the
- 18:08August heat that it swells grotesquely, turns black and has
- 18:12to be forced into a coffin by workers holding clothes over
- 18:15their faces. Cesare survives, but barely.
- 18:20He's bedridden for weeks, delirious with fever, his skin
- 18:24peeling off in sheets. Well, what happened?
- 18:28The official story is malaria. August in Rome is peak malaria
- 18:33season, and both men have been working outdoors in the heat.
- 18:37The rumor that spreads immediately across Europe?
- 18:41Poison. Specifically, the rumor claims
- 18:44that Alexander and Cesare had planned to poison Cardinal
- 18:48Castellesi to seize his wealth, but the poisoned wine was served
- 18:53to them by mistake. Is it true?
- 18:56Almost certainly not. The story is too perfect, too
- 19:00poetically, just the poisoners poisoned by their own weapon.
- 19:05It's the kind of story people want to believe.
- 19:09But is it the truth? Modern historians think malaria
- 19:13is the most likely cause, but the fact is that the poison
- 19:16story is immediately believable. Tells you everything about
- 19:21Borgia reputation by 15 O3. Everyone in Europe thinks
- 19:25they're capable of anything. The borscht has become legendary
- 19:29for a poison called la cantarella, supposedly a white
- 19:34powder made from arsenic that could be slipped into wine or
- 19:37food, causing symptoms that looked like natural illness.
- 19:43Did this poison actually exist? Well, it's possible arsenic
- 19:48poisoning was known in Renaissance Italy.
- 19:51Did the Borgias use it systematically?
- 19:54Well, that's harder to prove, but several suspicious deaths
- 19:58surrounding the Borgia papacy. Pardon Michelle.
- 20:02In 15, O3 dies suddenly after dinner with Alexander, leaving
- 20:07his wealth to the Pope. Cardinal Orsini, also in 15 O3,
- 20:12dies in papal custody after being arrested by Cesare Alfonso
- 20:17of Aragon in 1500, Lucretia's second husband.
- 20:20Is attacked by assassins, survived, and then strangled in
- 20:23his sick bed, possibly by Cesare's orders.
- 20:28Whether or not the Borges actually poison people, they
- 20:30certainly benefited from the fear that they might.
- 20:36Pope Alexander's death destroys everything Cesare has built.
- 20:40But here's the problem. Cesare's entire power base
- 20:44depends on his father being Pope.
- 20:47The papal armies, the papal treasury, the political
- 20:50alliances, all of it flows from Alexander's position.
- 20:55With Alexander dead, Cesare is just another Italian warlord
- 21:00with enemies everywhere. The College of Cardinals elects
- 21:05A compromise candidate, Pope Pius the Third, who dies after
- 21:1026 days, possibly the shortest papal reign in history.
- 21:15Then they elect Cesare's worst enemy, Giuliano della Rovare,
- 21:20who becomes Pope Julius the Second.
- 21:23If you remember Della Rovare from earlier, he's the cardinal
- 21:26who lost to Rodrigo Borgia in the 1492 conclave.
- 21:31He's been waiting for 11 years for revenge.
- 21:34Julius immediately moves against Cesare.
- 21:37The papal armies are withdrawn from the Romagna.
- 21:41Cesare's enemies, the Orsinian, The Kelowna, the dispossessed
- 21:45warlords, all come back for vengeance.
- 21:48Within months, Cesare loses everything.
- 21:52His fortresses fall, his allies abandoned him, he's arrested,
- 21:57imprisoned, and eventually exiled to Spain.
- 22:01In 15 O 7, at the age of 31, Cesare dies in a minor skirmish
- 22:06in Navarre, fighting as a mercenary for his
- 22:08brother-in-law. The man who once controlled
- 22:11central Italy dies in a meaningless battle, his body
- 22:15stripped and left on the battlefield.
- 22:18Lucrezia survives barely After three marriages and used as a
- 22:23political pawn, she's finally married to Alfonso Deste, Duke
- 22:28of Ferrara in 15 O1. Unlike her father and brother,
- 22:32Lucrezia seems to have genuinely tried to escape the bourge of
- 22:35reputation in Ferrara. She becomes a patron of the arts
- 22:39and learning. She supports poets and artists
- 22:43and by all accounts becomes a respected Duchess.
- 22:47She dies in 15-19 at the age of 39 from complications of
- 22:51childbirth. Her final letters suggest a
- 22:54woman exhausted by life, seeking religious consolation.
- 22:59The accusations of incest and poisoning follow her to her
- 23:02grave, but modern historians genuinely conclude she was more
- 23:07of a victim than a villain. A woman uses a political tool by
- 23:11her father and brother. By 15 O 7, the Borgia family is
- 23:16finished as a political force. Their enemies systematically
- 23:20erase them from history. Literally.
- 23:23Julius the Second has Borgia emblems chiseled off of
- 23:26buildings. Borgia appointments are
- 23:29reversed. The family name becomes
- 23:32synonymous with corruption. But here's the dark irony.
- 23:38The Borgias didn't invent Vatican corruption, they just
- 23:41perfected it. Simony, which is the buying of
- 23:43church offices, Nepotism, mistresses, illegitimate
- 23:48children, political manipulation.
- 23:51Well, all of this existed before the Borgias and continued after
- 23:55them. the Renaissance papacy was structurally corrupt.
- 24:01The Borgias real crime wasn't being corrupt, it was being too
- 24:05obvious about their corruption. Too successful, too threatening
- 24:09to the established Italian families who have been playing
- 24:12the same game for centuries. So what does the Borgia story
- 24:25actually teach us about how corruption works at the highest
- 24:28level? Well, first is that corruption
- 24:31thrives in institutions that claim moral authority.
- 24:34The Catholic Church in the Renaissance had enormous
- 24:37spiritual legitimacy. People believed and genuinely
- 24:41believed that the Pope was Christ's representative on
- 24:45earth, that Cardinals were Princess of the Church, and that
- 24:49the sacraments were pathways to salvation.
- 24:53That spiritual authority created cover for financial and
- 24:57political corruption. Who's going to challenge the
- 25:02Pope's appointments when he claims divine guidance?
- 25:07Who's going to audit the Vatican's finances when it's
- 25:10supposedly doing God's work? This pattern repeats throughout
- 25:15history. Institutions that claim to serve
- 25:18the highest purposes religion, democracy, human rights, public
- 25:23health, often become vehicles for private enrichment precisely
- 25:28because their moral claims make scrutiny seem illegitimate.
- 25:34The second is that corruption becomes systematic when everyone
- 25:38participates. The Borgias didn't corrupt the
- 25:40church. They entered an already corrupt
- 25:43system and played the game better than anyone else.
- 25:47Cardinals have been buying offices, keeping mistresses and
- 25:51enriching their family for decades.
- 25:54The difference was that the Borgias were outsiders, Spanish
- 25:59upstarts who threatened the Italian families who have been
- 26:02running the corruption race for generations.
- 26:06And that, ultimately, is their unforgivable sin in the eyes of
- 26:10history. Not just that they were corrupt,
- 26:14but that they made their corruption impossible to ignore.
- 26:19From the scandal soaked papacy it's a straight line to
- 26:23Savonarola's bonfires in Florence, the rise of reformers
- 26:27like Erasmus and eventually Martin Luther nailing his 95
- 26:32thesises to a church door in 1517 denouncing the indulgent
- 26:37selling Pope's who lived like Princess.
- 26:41The Borgias didn't just stay in the Vatican, they helped to
- 26:44break the medieval church. Whether you hear modern
- 26:49scandals, financial crimes, abuse, cover ups, or when you
- 26:59hear modern scandals, financial crimes, abuse, cover ups,
- 27:03political manipulation, remember the template is old.
- 27:08A family from Spain once walked into the Vatican, bought the
- 27:12keys to the Kingdom and use them to see how far power could go
- 27:17before the world would push back.
- 27:20Their story isn't just Renaissance gossip, it's a
- 27:23warning. This is hidden forces in
- 27:26history. I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate, and
- 27:29please like this video, leave a comment, and smash that
- 27:34subscribe button if you want more hidden forces in history.