Latest / Investor Exchange / Doubt Looms Over China Environmental Resources Group’s Future In 2025 Annual Results

Transcript

Doubt Looms Over China Environmental Resources Group’s Future In 2025 Annual Results · Investor Exchange

• 0:02
  Time for another Investor Exchange podcast. Here are your hosts, Matt and Sally.
• 0:07
  Welcome back to the Deep Dive. We're jumping straight in today looking at the
• 0:11
  annual results for China Environmental Resources Group Limited.
• 0:14
  That's CERGLE for the year ending June 30, 2025.
• 0:19
  And our mission really is to figure out what seems like a, well,
• 0:23
  financial paradox. If you just glance at the headlines, their loss actually
• 0:27
  got smaller by almost 40 percent, which sounds pretty good, right?
• 0:31
  It sounds great on the surface, absolutely.
• 0:32
  But then you dig a little deeper, look at their actual businesses,
• 0:34
  and uh-oh, revenue is just collapsing. So we need to ask, what's actually propping this company up?
• 0:40
  And are there some operational disasters being hidden by accounting moves?
• 0:45
  It really is a fascinating case study. Financial reporting versus,
• 0:48
  let's say, operational reality.
• 0:50
  And the operational pain, well, it's hard to miss.
• 0:54
  Total revenue just fell off a cloud, dropped, what was it, 26.6%?
• 0:58
  Yeah, a huge drop. From HK $82.8 million down to HK $60.7 million,
• 1:05
  I mean, normally a contraction like that, you'd expect the bottom line to get much, much worse.
• 1:09
  But here's the twist for you, the listener.
• 1:12
  The net loss shrank significantly from a really bad HK $72.1 million loss last
• 1:19
  year down to HK $42.9 million this year.
• 1:22
  So it feels like we're looking at a company that, well, struggled to sell its
• 1:26
  products, but somehow managed its accounts very effectively.
• 1:29
  We need to find those non-cash levers, you know, the things that made the P&L look less bad.
• 1:33
  Let's try and unpack that. So the loss per share basically halved,
• 1:37
  went from 16 Hong Kong cents down to 8 cents.
• 1:39
  Now that signals to the market that maybe things are getting better,
• 1:42
  maybe stabilizing, but you're saying this stability might be,
• 1:44
  well, a bit of an illusion.
• 1:46
  Largely, yes. It's not about operational wins here. So what was the biggest
• 1:48
  single factor, the non-operational thing that really helped that bottom line
• 1:52
  look better? Okay, so this wasn't about selling more tires or recycling more metal.
• 1:56
  This was fundamentally an accounting reprieve.
• 1:58
  The single biggest swing factor, it was how they valued their standing timber,
• 2:03
  their biological assets. Ah, the trees.
• 2:06
  Exactly. The technical term is the loss arising from changes in fair value,
• 2:10
  less cost to sell of biological assets. That number just plummeted.
• 2:15
  It was roughly HK $38.6 million in write-downs in 2024, this year.
• 2:21
  Only HK 5.37 million dollars.
• 2:24
  No hold on so that's a difference of about HK 33 million dollars in losses that
• 2:29
  just disappeared from the statement year on year.
• 2:32
  Vanished is a good word for it yes it didn't reflect better operations.
• 2:36
  So the company didn't suddenly become brilliant at selling stuff they just didn't
• 2:39
  have to write down the value of their trees as much as they did the year before
• 2:42
  it was a less bad loss not really a good result.
• 2:45
  Precisely that single adjustment it accounts for most of the improvement you
• 2:48
  see in the net loss figure.
• 2:49
  Now, to be fair, they did find some savings elsewhere that helped contain the
• 2:53
  damage a bit. Like where?
• 2:54
  Well, administrative and operating expenses were cut quite a bit from HK $40.9
• 2:58
  million down to HK $35.7 million.
• 3:02
  And finance costs also dropped slightly from HK $6.8 million to HK $5.9 million.
• 3:07
  So some genuine cost control was happening.
• 3:09
  Okay. So the biological assets gave them that huge accounting break and they
• 3:13
  tighten their belts internally.
• 3:14
  But I also noticed something kind of strange with their investments seemed like
• 3:18
  a big game from a really small portfolio.
• 3:20
  Oh, you pick up on that. Yeah. Yes, that was another unexpected twist.
• 3:23
  Their net game on fair value changes in investments actually shot up.
• 3:28
  It went from HK $1.59 million last year to HK $5.67 million this year.
• 3:34
  Wow. But here's the kicker.
• 3:36
  Their total investment portfolio, the actual assets they hold,
• 3:39
  it shrank to almost nothing, just HK $140,000.
• 3:43
  So how do you get a nearly HK $6 million gain from only HK $140,000 in assets?
• 3:49
  It strongly suggests they got, well, very lucky on maybe one or two specific
• 3:53
  trades or holdings just before they effectively wound down that activity.
• 3:56
  It's a nice gain, but it's from a non-core area they seem to be exiting.
• 3:59
  A lucky break, you could say. A lucky break? Sure.
• 4:02
  But you can't run a company on lucky breaks forever, especially when revenue
• 4:05
  is down almost 27 percent.
• 4:07
  So, OK, the accounting department did well, maybe got lucky.
• 4:11
  But what about the people actually selling things?
• 4:14
  If the P&L was saved by spreadsheets, where did the customers go?
• 4:18
  Which business segments are really dragging things down operationally? Right.
• 4:22
  So there are two main areas facing, frankly, catastrophic structural problems.
• 4:26
  And both are heavily exposed to what's happening in the greater China economy.
• 4:29
  First, the motor and motor accessories business. Revenue there fell sharply
• 4:32
  from HK $63.7 million down to HK $48.7 million.
• 4:37
  What's driving that decline? It seems to be consumer confidence,
• 4:41
  particularly in Hong Kong and Taiwan.
• 4:43
  People are putting off car maintenance or when they do buy tires,
• 4:46
  they're trading down. They're choosing cheaper, lower tier brands.
• 4:49
  And Sergal's main supplier is Pirelli, a premium brand. Pirelli just doesn't
• 4:54
  make those budget tires. There's a fascinating global link here, too.
• 4:58
  Geopolitical tensions think Red Sea, Gulf of Aden, they're disrupting shipping from Europe.
• 5:04
  Directly impacts their ability to get those premium Pirelli tires,
• 5:08
  especially the specialized ones needed for things like racing events. That's incredible.
• 5:12
  Global shipping snarls hitting local tire sales in Hong Kong and Taiwan.
• 5:16
  Okay, now what about the part of the business that actually has environmental
• 5:20
  resources in the name? The metal recycling side. How did that do?
• 5:23
  Oh, the metal recycle business numbers are, well, they're almost hard to look at.
• 5:27
  Revenue just plummeted from HK $9.8 million last year, all the way down to HK
• 5:32
  $2.8 million this year. Yikes.
• 5:34
  What happened there? It's deeply tied into China's broader industrial situation.
• 5:38
  You've got massive overcapacity in China's steel sector, which has crushed scrap steel prices.
• 5:44
  Yeah. At the same time, internal demand, you know, for infrastructure,
• 5:48
  building projects, that's softened dramatically.
• 5:50
  Plus, the huge state-owned steel giants, they dominate the market.
• 5:54
  And they're apparently not relying much on scrap metal as a primary input source right now.
• 6:00
  So the group has pretty much admitted defeat locally. They're slowing down efforts
• 6:03
  in China and actually exploring shifting focus to, quote, lower risk countries.
• 6:08
  That's a huge signal they can't compete effectively in the PRC market anymore.
• 6:12
  Wow. So it really sounds like they're retreating on those two big fronts, motors and metals.
• 6:17
  Did any of their smaller ventures offer any kind of, I don't know,
• 6:20
  stability? I think you mentioned money lending and maybe a hotel lease.
• 6:23
  Yeah, those were the niche areas. They did provide a tiny bit of stability.
• 6:26
  The money lending interest income actually went up slightly from around HK307K to HK368K.
• 6:33
  And their hotel leasing business, which is in Nepal, that was stable too.
• 6:37
  Revenue edged up just a little from HK4.78 million dollars to HK4.92 million dollars.
• 6:43
  Okay, so not bleeding cash, but definitely not enough to offset the millions
• 6:47
  lost in the main segments. Exactly.
• 6:49
  They aren't liabilities, but they're certainly not saviors here.
• 6:52
  Right. Now let's circle back to those biological assets, the timber.
• 6:56
  We know the loss calculation looked better because the write-down wasn't as severe this year.
• 7:00
  But what about the actual trees, the physical asset value? Did that go up or down?
• 7:05
  That's a great question. The underlying fair value of the standing timber actually
• 7:09
  dropped slightly overall.
• 7:11
  It went from HK $190.9 million down to HK $189.0 million.
• 7:17
  Oh. But didn't the trees grow? Yes, that's the interesting part.
• 7:21
  The actual volume of timber increased slightly, about 0.23 percent just from natural growth.
• 7:26
  But that growth was wiped out, and then some, by two market factors.
• 7:31
  First, the market price for popular timber fell by about 3 percent.
• 7:34
  And second, the renminbi weakened against the Hong Kong dollar.
• 7:37
  Reducing the translated value.
• 7:39
  So the asset value is actually eroding despite natural growth,
• 7:41
  and they haven't harvested anything for two years. Correct.
• 7:45
  No harvesting for two consecutive years. They're essentially just holding on
• 7:49
  to this green asset, which leads to a really important potential shift in strategy.
• 7:53
  Since they're not logging, the report mentions they're now exploring how to
• 7:57
  capitalize on carbon credits from the plantation.
• 8:00
  Ah, so pivot from selling timber as a commodity to maybe selling its environmental benefit.
• 8:05
  Potentially, yes. It could be a way to derive value if the timber market itself isn't attractive.
• 8:10
  A necessary pivot, perhaps. A necessary pivot indeed.
• 8:14
  But look, the P&L might have looked less bad due to accounting,
• 8:17
  but the real state of the company's health, that seems to be screaming from
• 8:21
  the balance sheet, especially liquidity. You mentioned cash earlier. Yes.
• 8:25
  And this is where things look quite alarming. The balance sheet is flashing
• 8:28
  bright red warning lights.
• 8:30
  If the P&L improvement was somewhat masked, the liquidity issues are stark.
• 8:34
  Cash and cash equivalents just cratered from HK $22.8 million at the end of
• 8:38
  last year down to just HK $1.92 million as of June 30, 2025.
• 8:43
  Under HK $2 million in cash.
• 8:46
  For a company this size? It's incredibly low. And this connects directly to
• 8:50
  the most serious warnings in the report.
• 8:52
  The group had that net loss we discussed, HK $40.3 million in the P&L,
• 8:57
  and it had an operating cash outflow of HK $9.6 million, meaning day-to-day
• 9:03
  operations burn through cash. But here's the most critical part.
• 9:06
  As of the balance sheet date, June 30, 2025, they had net current liabilities
• 9:11
  of approximately HK $28.7 million. Okay, for the listener who might not be deep
• 9:16
  into finance, what does net current liabilities really mean in plain English?
• 9:20
  It means their short-term debts, the money they owe and have to pay within the
• 9:23
  next 12 months, are significantly larger than their short-term assets,
• 9:26
  like cash, receivables, inventory.
• 9:29
  They owe HK $28.27 million more in the near term than they have readily available
• 9:33
  assets to cover it. That sounds preterious. It is.
• 9:35
  And the auditors explicitly state that this combination, the loss,
• 9:39
  the cash outflow, and the net current liabilities, indicates a material uncertainty
• 9:44
  which may cast significant doubt on the group's ability to continue as a going concern.
• 9:49
  That phrase, going concern, is the most serious flag an auditor can raise.
• 9:54
  It questions if the company can realistically survive the next year.
• 9:58
  That's about as serious as it gets. So what are the directors actually doing
• 10:03
  about this? How are they planning to keep the lights on and pay those bills?
• 10:07
  They outlined a three-pronged approach to try and manage this liquidity crisis.
• 10:10
  First, and this is absolutely crucial, the executive director,
• 10:13
  who also happens to be the chairman, the CEO, and a major shareholder,
• 10:17
  has personally undertaken to provide adequate funds to meet the group's liabilities
• 10:21
  as they fall due for the next 12 months.
• 10:23
  So the CEO is basically putting his personal wealth on the line to backstop the company.
• 10:28
  That's what the undertaking implies, yes. It's their immediate lifeline.
• 10:32
  Second, they mentioned they have an undrawn banking facility of HK $20 million
• 10:36
  they can tap into if needed.
• 10:38
  And third, they're sticking to those cost-saving measures we saw reflected in
• 10:43
  the reduced admin expenses.
• 10:44
  Okay, that personal guarantee is huge. But it does make you wonder if that's
• 10:48
  a sustainable long-term fix or just,
• 10:50
  you know, buying time while the core businesses continue to struggle.
• 10:53
  Now, speaking of unexpected financial events, while they're scrambling for cash,
• 10:57
  let's talk about that property sale that fell through. It sounds like a bit of a silver lining.
• 11:01
  It was certainly an unexpected and probably very welcome cash injection.
• 11:06
  They had agreed to sell an investment property in the PRC. The sale fell apart
• 11:10
  because the buyer failed to complete the transaction. And the deposit.
• 11:14
  Because the buyer defaulted, Suragol was legally entitled to forfeit the deposit,
• 11:18
  which amounted to HK $11.8 million.
• 11:21
  It just kept it as liquidated damages. Wow. So someone else's failure to buy
• 11:26
  netted them nearly HK $12 million in cash. That's unbelievable.
• 11:31
  Talk about a non-operational lifeline helping with that cash crunch.
• 11:34
  Absolutely. a very significant one-off event.
• 11:36
  It doesn't fix the underlying business issues, but it certainly helped the cash
• 11:40
  balance at a critical time. What else is going on with their property holdings?
• 11:43
  Any other notable points there?
• 11:46
  Well, they continued to see fair value losses on their other investment properties,
• 11:50
  about HK $15.68 million this year. That's a recurring theme.
• 11:56
  And interestingly, to try to boost the value or competitiveness of their car
• 12:00
  parking spaces in Hong Kong, they're exploring installing electric vehicle charging facilities.
• 12:04
  Trying to modernize those assets a bit. Seems like it.
• 12:08
  And just touching on other balance sheet points, their gearing ratio,
• 12:11
  which measures debt relative to equity, actually improves slightly from 20.2%
• 12:16
  down to 17.9%, likely helped by the reduced overall debt.
• 12:20
  And as you'd expect with severe cost cutting, the employee headcount was slashed
• 12:25
  dramatically from 44 employees down to 31.
• 12:28
  That's nearly a 30% reduction in workforce. A major cut. definitely signals financial distress.
• 12:33
  Okay, let's pivot now to the bigger picture, the final segment.
• 12:37
  The macro environment. These internal problems aren't happening in a vacuum, right?
• 12:42
  What does the outlook look like for the key markets they operate in,
• 12:45
  according to the sources?
• 12:47
  Yeah, the external environment doesn't look particularly friendly,
• 12:50
  unfortunately. For the USA, the projections point towards an economic slowdown heading into 2026.
• 12:55
  Things like slowing job growth, maybe inflation kicked up by tariffs.
• 12:58
  The report mentions a fairly high probability, 35-40% of a severe recession there. And U.S.
• 13:03
  Health impacts global trade, global sentiment. Okay, what about closer to their
• 13:07
  core operations, China and Hong Kong? The PRC outlook is mixed.
• 13:11
  The IMS is forecasting moderate growth, maybe around 4.8%,
• 13:16
  But, and this is a big but, it's really being hampered by the ongoing property
• 13:20
  sector crisis, high debt levels across the economy, and the potential threat
• 13:24
  of more U.S. tariffs or trade friction.
• 13:26
  So growth, but with significant headwinds.
• 13:28
  And Hong Kong itself, projected solid GDP growth, maybe 2-3%,
• 13:32
  but is seen as very vulnerable.
• 13:35
  Vulnerable to external risks, like U.S. policy shifts or a weak U.S.
• 13:39
  Dollar, and also internal factors, like changing consumer spending habits within the city.
• 13:44
  So a pretty challenging external picture overall. Slowdown in the U.S.,
• 13:47
  headwinds in China, vulnerability in Hong Kong.
• 13:49
  How does the group say they plan to navigate all this uncertainty,
• 13:53
  given their internal issues, too?
• 13:55
  Their stated strategy seems to be one of, well, cautious defense and maybe some
• 13:59
  tentative diversification.
• 14:00
  They explicitly mentioned exploring the motor tires business in new countries.
• 14:04
  That looks like an attempt to reduce their heavy reliance on the struggling
• 14:07
  greater China market. Spreading the risk a bit.
• 14:09
  Exactly. And for the biological assets, the timber, they're continuing to work
• 14:13
  prudently, focusing on economic viability, which might mean not harvesting and
• 14:18
  seriously looking into those carbon market opportunities we talked about.
• 14:21
  It feels very much like survival mode combined with trying to pivot strategically where possible.
• 14:26
  OK, so let's try to synthesize all of this. If you had to boil down the entire
• 14:30
  financial story of Sergal for the year ended June 2025, what's the absolute
• 14:36
  essential takeaway for you, the listener? I think the essential takeaway is this.
• 14:40
  Sergal did manage to report a significantly smaller loss in 2025,
• 14:43
  but that improvement came primarily from non-cash factors, especially that much
• 14:48
  smaller write-down on their biological assets, and from some really aggressive
• 14:52
  internal cost-cutting.
• 14:54
  They also got bailed out, frankly, by some lucky investment gains in that huge
• 14:58
  forfeited property deposit.
• 14:59
  But underneath that improved bottom line. The core story is one of accelerating
• 15:04
  operational collapse in their two main revenue-generating businesses,
• 15:08
  motor accessories and metal recycling.
• 15:10
  And those collapses are tied directly to difficult geopolitics,
• 15:13
  disrupted supply chains, and seriously weak consumer confidence in their key markets.
• 15:17
  It really is the perfect example of why you have to read beyond the headline
• 15:21
  numbers in a financial report, isn't it?
• 15:23
  So given those huge net current liabilities, that dramatic drop in cash,
• 15:28
  and the heavy reliance on the CEO's personal financial guarantee,
• 15:31
  here's a final thought for you to chew on.
• 15:33
  How sustainable is this? how much longer can non-cash gains,
• 15:36
  accounting adjustments, and one-off windfalls mask what looks like a crumbling
• 15:40
  operational foundation?
• 15:42
  This is a case where the shrinking loss tells a far, far less complete and maybe
• 15:46
  less honest story than the shrinking revenue.
• 15:49
  You always, always have to ask where the numbers came from.