Latest / Arroe Collins Like It's Live / Con Men, Call Centers And Rogue Doctors Elizabeth Chamblee Burch's The Pain Brokers
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: It was a vision that came to me in twenty
- 0:01twelve to create a podcast network. Twenty twelve, it's twenty
- 0:06twenty six. Now look how many years it took to
- 0:09put together your power of choice. That's what aero dot
- 0:13net is, a r r OE dot net, nineteen different
- 0:17podcasts and growing. Like vocal dfrag, we always ask questions,
- 0:22but do you ever question the answers. This is a
- 0:25serious question with some really fun results. Vocal dfrag on
- 0:29aero dot net a r r o e dot net.
- 0:33Enjoy your exploration. Hello, and good morning party people. Hi Aero,
- 0:39how are you fantastic? Listen to your voice? Man? Man,
- 0:42how did you get so in tuned so early on
- 0:44a Monday?
- 0:46Speaker 2: I get up early. I have a lot of coffee.
- 0:48Speaker 1: See that's what it's all about. That's the secret, isn't it.
- 0:51These people that sleep in man, you know at what
- 0:53they need to do is wake up at six o'clock
- 0:55in the morning and grab your book.
- 0:57Speaker 2: Oh I appreciate that. Yeah, I hope that's right.
- 1:00Speaker 1: Well, don't you think your book is a great way
- 1:02to start off your day? Either that or or a
- 1:04moment in your day where you can say I need
- 1:06to cut myself off from the from the the rigamaru
- 1:09of the social media as well as the headlines, and
- 1:12I need to just listen to somebody who has a message,
- 1:15and that's that's you.
- 1:17Speaker 2: Absolutely yeah.
- 1:19Speaker 3: I mean it's it's hard to turn off to social
- 1:21media in the mornings or even in the afternoons. But
- 1:25I'm thrilled to have written this book and I'm super
- 1:27excited to talk with you about it.
- 1:29Speaker 1: Well, I'm excited to find out how you even came
- 1:31up with this title, because you know the title of
- 1:33a book, that's where everybody goes to judge the author.
- 1:36Oh and then you got to go through the editor first.
- 1:37As I go, hope, please, I just need the journey
- 1:40to get it out there.
- 1:42Speaker 2: Yeah, it's so true.
- 1:43Speaker 3: And you know, the pain Brokers was not actually the
- 1:46original title of this book, as you can well imagine.
- 1:49So I had actually started off with the Body Shop,
- 1:54but my publishers were worried that people would get confused,
- 1:57is it about automobiles?
- 1:59Speaker 2: Is it about cosmetic?
- 2:01Speaker 3: So we settled on the pain Brokers, and I think
- 2:03they were absolutely right.
- 2:04Speaker 2: I think it conveys the message really well.
- 2:06Speaker 1: See it's moments like that that really does remind me
- 2:09of of kind of like what Mark Twain used to say,
- 2:11is that that we want to break it down, break
- 2:12it down, break it down, and simplify everything, that we
- 2:14might as well just go back to just going uggug
- 2:16and they would know what we're saying, right.
- 2:21Speaker 3: Yeah, I can't understand that, Yeah, but you know it does.
- 2:25It brings it in line with some of these great
- 2:27works by Patricrad and Keith Empire of Pain and Barry
- 2:31Meyer Painkiller, which are both about the opioid epidemic. And
- 2:35this isn't about the opioid epidemic, but it is about
- 2:38another mass to it, like the opioid epidemic.
- 2:41Speaker 1: So to have that honesty in this world where you're
- 2:44supposed to be going, oh, I'm going to look this
- 2:45other way. You did not, Elizabeth, look the other way
- 2:48on this subject.
- 2:50Speaker 2: No, I looked straight at it.
- 2:51Speaker 3: And I've been writing about this for I mean, as
- 2:54an academic for twenty some odd years. But as will
- 2:58not surprise you at all, nobody really cares about what
- 3:00academics say. So I wanted to talk about this to
- 3:03a larger audience, and I went back to school and
- 3:07got an MFA in Narrative nonfiction and wrote this book
- 3:10along the way so that I could tell these stories
- 3:12in a way that would really resonate with people.
- 3:14Speaker 1: See I see that as being a soundtrack to your life,
- 3:16because A you're not getting that time back, and B
- 3:19when people say, what were you doing, Well, here's what
- 3:21I was doing and look at the effects.
- 3:24Speaker 3: That's right, that's right. You know, I think, you know,
- 3:27scholars play an important role. And the difficulty in this
- 3:32world that I write in is that the key stakeholders,
- 3:35the people you're trying to convince to change, all have
- 3:37a vested interest in the status quo. So if I
- 3:40really wanted to create some sort of change in this world,
- 3:43then I needed for the general public to understand why
- 3:46this is so problematic.
- 3:47Speaker 1: So what was it like for you to fit inside
- 3:50the bookstore? Because we're talking about a book that's easily
- 3:53a public service style book, but at the same time
- 3:55it's a thriller. Where does that end up at Barnes
- 3:58and Noble?
- 4:00Speaker 2: You know, that's a good question.
- 4:01Speaker 3: I've only seen it at the Barnes and Noble here
- 4:03in town, and it was, you know, on the front
- 4:06because I was a local author. But you know, I
- 4:08think it's it's somewhere in maybe history. It's not quite
- 4:13current events because it happened a couple of years ago,
- 4:15although very much of this is happening still today, so
- 4:18it could be current events. It's also true crime, so
- 4:22you know, it's it'll be interesting to see where it
- 4:25lands on the bookshelves.
- 4:26Speaker 1: Yeah, because I mean my experience with that when when
- 4:28I went in there and found it in my first
- 4:30book in what's called New Age Religion, I went, what, well, no, no, no,
- 4:36that's no no, and they wouldn't change it out of there.
- 4:39I said, oh god, I guess I have to work
- 4:41with this now.
- 4:42Speaker 3: Right right, Yeah, I mean, it'll be interesting to see
- 4:46where it lands. It's it's hard for these kinds of
- 4:49narrative nonfiction books to really find a home because they're
- 4:53not memoirs, they're not biographies. They're kind of history but
- 4:57not quite history. And and so it's there, they're a
- 4:59little bit of misfits in the bookstores.
- 5:02Speaker 1: This is the style of book my wife wants to
- 5:04read because she wants to have that experience of, oh
- 5:06my god, this could really happen. I mean, that's what
- 5:09she loves in a story like this, because it comes
- 5:11with history. It gives her a chance to take a
- 5:13break to go look something up that it might look
- 5:16just like it or it is just like it. Because
- 5:18I mean, you're talking about Sharon, Barbara and Jerry here,
- 5:20three women who have been targeted, manipulated and violated. Now
- 5:25you have the attention of the people. There's your true crime.
- 5:29Speaker 3: That's right, that's right, and this is you know, it's
- 5:31something this happened in the past. It involved Pelvic mesh
- 5:36and some cold calls to jar and Sherry, Sharon and
- 5:39Barb telling them that they had a ticking time bomb
- 5:42in them that they had to have it taken out immediately.
- 5:46And you know, the callers had all of the information
- 5:49that you would normally expect to raise your red flag.
- 5:53So you know, they're not asking for information about their
- 5:57birthdays or their implant dates. They already have all that
- 5:59information available at their fingertips through a data breach in India,
- 6:03and so it sounded very legitimate.
- 6:06Speaker 1: You know we're talking about You woke me up in
- 6:09the way that I'm so tired of getting these phone
- 6:11calls because and I work with con artists all the time,
- 6:15because one of my favorite things to do in life
- 6:17is to do jobs that people don't want to do.
- 6:19And so one day I decided, I'm going to go
- 6:22work at a grocery store because I saw it on TV.
- 6:24These two old guys at a grocery store, and they
- 6:26look like that they're community connected. And so when I
- 6:29sit here and I read about con men and call
- 6:31centers and rogue doctors, I'm going I live this every
- 6:35day because they're coming through my store.
- 6:38Speaker 2: Yep.
- 6:39Speaker 3: Yeah, and they're coming through people's lives. You know, there
- 6:42was an opportunity to there was, you know, hundreds of
- 6:46thousands of women who started suing over this product. And
- 6:50the lawyers and the doctors and the middlemen realized that
- 6:54they were sitting on a gold mine and if only
- 6:56they could convince women to have the product removed, that
- 6:59it would increase the value of the settlement for them
- 7:01and not necessarily for the women. And so the machine
- 7:05started to grind, grind up.
- 7:09Speaker 1: Doesn't this open up the door for people to say,
- 7:11I knew it only because when it comes to America's
- 7:14lawsuit factory. When I had my heart attack at forty seven,
- 7:17I accused my doctor of faking it because they were
- 7:19just looking for business. And even more recently, when another
- 7:22doctor told me, well, I need you to lose weight
- 7:24to get your cholesterol down, and I do it, he says, oh,
- 7:27there must be a bigger problem. And I'm going, what
- 7:29are you doing here? And then I come across you
- 7:32here America's lawsuit factory. I'm going, oh, my god, am
- 7:36I a victim? And are we victims? Just like Sharon
- 7:39Barbara and Jerry Well.
- 7:41Speaker 2: I mean, that's the big question.
- 7:43Speaker 3: And I think a lot of this was based on
- 7:45trust or lack of you know, maybe trust that shouldn't
- 7:49have been placed in these doctors. I know one of
- 7:52the reasons that so many women got exploited, and this
- 7:55was the doctors were very dismissive of their pelvic pain.
- 7:59So they would go and talk to their doctors and say,
- 8:01you know, something's wrong, something's poking me, something's terrible happening,
- 8:05and the doctors would just sort of wave their hands
- 8:07and say, everything looks fine to us. And so when
- 8:10these callers called and said, well, you know, doctors don't understand.
- 8:14They're not on the cutting edge of this. There are
- 8:16only a few doctors in the country who can do this.
- 8:18We'll set up an appointment to fly you down to
- 8:20see them.
- 8:21Speaker 2: It resonated with a lot of these.
- 8:23Speaker 1: People, Please do not move. There's more with Elizabeth Chamblee
- 8:27Birch coming up next. The name of your new book,
- 8:32The pain Brokers. Elizabeth Chamblee Birch, you went through two
- 8:36hundred and nine thousand pages of evidence. I don't know
- 8:40how you do it, but the thing is is that
- 8:42I respect you for doing it because I thought I
- 8:44was a research pig, and then when I find out
- 8:47about this from you, I'm going I want to be
- 8:49like Elizabeth. I want to have that courage and that
- 8:52confidence to say there's a story here and we're going
- 8:55to find it.
- 8:56Speaker 3: Well, it is digging for that needle in a haystack,
- 8:59and you have these like wonderful you know, just when
- 9:02you get so discouraged and you're like, oh, there's nothing
- 9:05that I can find, then you find that thing that
- 9:07you weren't supposed to find, and it's just these amazing
- 9:11aha moments that happened along the way that keep you going,
- 9:14and you know, you feel a little bit like a detective.
- 9:16Speaker 2: It's really wonderful.
- 9:17Speaker 1: But isn't this con job also involving lawyers as well?
- 9:21Because how many times have we seen those commercials on TV.
- 9:24If you've had the hernia mesh, you could be in trouble.
- 9:28Now I'm going, well, why am I going to the
- 9:30doctor if the doctor says you got to do it?
- 9:32And these guys are saying, well, you're going to screw
- 9:34up if you do it. I mean you're caught right
- 9:35in the middle of the quarter of walk and don't walk.
- 9:39Speaker 2: Yeah, you really are.
- 9:40Speaker 3: And so much of it falls on us as consumers
- 9:43to try to do the research to figure out is
- 9:46this the right thing for me? You know, lawyers were
- 9:49very much involved in this as well, and there was
- 9:52a kind of a loophole in Washington, d C. It
- 9:55started because lobbyists, I think, wanted to go on the
- 10:00cloak of privilege with lawyers.
- 10:02Speaker 2: But in DC you can start a law firm.
- 10:05Speaker 3: With non lawyer partners as long as you have a
- 10:08single DC lawyer who's willing to be your front man.
- 10:11And so there was a call center that created a
- 10:14partnership with a DC law firm and instead of selling
- 10:20these quote unquote leads for clients, was actually able to
- 10:25get in on the contingency fees.
- 10:28Speaker 1: Oh, Elizabeth, you have woken up the bear here because
- 10:32I'll tell you what it's happened to my wife and I.
- 10:34And you're right about the you know, those call centers
- 10:37in the way that it just seems like when doctors
- 10:39see something that they that needs to be looked at,
- 10:41why are we getting phone calls from four and five
- 10:43different businesses? I mean to go get an MRI. There
- 10:46must have been seven or eight phone calls for people saying,
- 10:48I can get you in, I can get you in.
- 10:50I'm going, is there anybody here that that that has
- 10:52actually worked with me or talked with me? I mean,
- 10:55you you're such an eye opening situation here with the
- 10:57pain brokers.
- 10:59Speaker 3: It is, and you know, the troubling part about it
- 11:02was all these sort of side scams that I found
- 11:04as I was going along.
- 11:06Speaker 2: You know, you have these.
- 11:07Speaker 3: Chiropractic clinics that are trying to you know, have lawyers
- 11:11in house next door to the chiropractor and send their
- 11:14you know, car accident victim over and some of them
- 11:17are subjected to unnecessary surgeries to do the same sort
- 11:20of thing. But you know, you have to pick the
- 11:22story that you can tell and that you can write
- 11:24about in a coherent way. And it's it's really disturbing
- 11:28how much of this continues to go on?
- 11:30Speaker 1: Are we a weak people? Because and the reason why
- 11:32I bring that up is because I was always I
- 11:34was angry when my parents ended up at the doctor,
- 11:37like almost every day of the week. I'm going, what
- 11:38are you doing? And are we weak? Or is it
- 11:42that we just want to feel better?
- 11:45Speaker 3: You know, I think people just want to feel better,
- 11:47and you know, they don't always have the education, and
- 11:51so we trust people who are educated and who are
- 11:54supposed to be acting on our behalf. And there are
- 11:58wonderful doctors out there, are wonderful lawyers out there who
- 12:01are very much trying to do good in the world.
- 12:03And so you know, the key is finding the right
- 12:06group of doctors and lawyers who can help you instead
- 12:08of bringing you additional pain.
- 12:12Speaker 1: So, as a creative person, as the published author and
- 12:15somebody who's connected to a publishing company, how do you
- 12:18get somebody like chat GPT to get you on their
- 12:21list when it comes because you know people are going
- 12:23there to get answers, And how do we get the
- 12:25pain brokers up there? How are you guys working on that?
- 12:30Speaker 2: You mean, how are we getting it out into the world?
- 12:32Speaker 1: Because I mean, because when I go to chat GPT,
- 12:35I want answers and so and I think I think
- 12:37the pain Brokers is an answer. But it's like, Okay,
- 12:40we can put it up on TikTok, but where's everybody going.
- 12:42And obviously everybody's going to chat GPT because they want
- 12:45to put advertising on it now, They're not going to
- 12:46do it if the people aren't there. And so it's like,
- 12:48how do we get Elizabeth out there to where there
- 12:52is something that we can choose from.
- 12:55Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, you know, that's the real challenge, is
- 12:57to try to break through the noise of things that
- 12:59are going on every day. It's one of the reasons
- 13:01I was so excited to talk with you is because
- 13:03you know, you want people to be able to hear
- 13:05about it.
- 13:06Speaker 2: You want to get it out into the world.
- 13:09Speaker 3: You want it to be part of the rhythms of
- 13:10the daily life and to come up for people in
- 13:13their searches and to come up as a reliable source
- 13:16of information. But it is, I mean, it is a
- 13:19real challenge to break through everything that's going on horribly
- 13:24in the world and to try to get people to
- 13:25focus on this for a minute.
- 13:27Speaker 1: Well, my fear has always been the moments after we've
- 13:30all dealt with a doctor Christopher, because we've all had
- 13:34a doctor Christopher.
- 13:36Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, you all have these. It's it's this trusting
- 13:40of your gut. And I think, you know, part of
- 13:42the situation that these women found themselves in is that
- 13:45they were flown, you know, thousands of miles to a
- 13:49kind of an eerie twilight zone chiropractic outpatient clinic in
- 13:53South Florida, and then they were you know, kind of
- 13:57sucked into the machine at that point. So it's like,
- 14:00you know, can you stop and say, no, this doesn't
- 14:03feel right to me, I'm backing out of this. And
- 14:06I think a lot of the women didn't feel like
- 14:08they could do that at that point.
- 14:10Speaker 1: Oh. I had a rotator cuff doctor get so pissed
- 14:13off at me inside the office because he wanted to
- 14:16do the surgery. And I said, no, you're wrong. If
- 14:18this is my body, I know what I feel, I'm
- 14:20going to go with what I feel. And he literally,
- 14:23in lettering, big letters, in his own handwriting, said do
- 14:26not invite this patient back here again.
- 14:28Speaker 2: Wow. Wow.
- 14:29Speaker 3: I mean, you know, it is very much about trusting
- 14:32your instincts, about standing up for yourself, you know, just
- 14:36about listening to your gut and saying this isn't right,
- 14:39this isn't what I want to do for my body.
- 14:41Speaker 1: How are you going to change the world now? In
- 14:42other words, is your book is out, do you go
- 14:44on a speaking engagement? How are you are Do you
- 14:46go out and teaching some of these universities that that
- 14:49are part of not only the educational field of lawyers,
- 14:52but doctors as well.
- 14:55Speaker 2: Absolutely.
- 14:56Speaker 3: You know, it's interesting that we've had the first few
- 14:58events for the Pain Brokers last week, since the book
- 15:01has been out in the world for just less than
- 15:03a week now, and I've already been contacted by our
- 15:06med school. We have a brand new med school here
- 15:08at the University of Georgia that's just starting up, and
- 15:11you know, thinking about ways that we can partner with
- 15:13them to talk about ethics and the medical profession. I
- 15:17of course teach a third of our incoming class at
- 15:19the University of Georgia School of Law to talk to
- 15:22them about turts and civil procedure, and then I teach
- 15:25advanced mass Torts and complex litigation. And then my hope
- 15:30is that they go out into the world. You know,
- 15:31a lot of them are clerking for judges and working
- 15:34in these big law firms, and you know, between that
- 15:37and talking with the public, I hope that we can
- 15:39slowly start to tip the scales.
- 15:41Speaker 1: God, I would love to see you at you and
- 15:43CC or even even Queen's College or for that matter,
- 15:46CPCC with their world and how they're changing people on
- 15:49the community level. You know, you get into the soul
- 15:51of where the community is and all of a sudden, Elizabeth,
- 15:53you're changing people's lives.
- 15:56Speaker 2: Well. Absolutely.
- 15:56Speaker 3: And I'll be up at Davidson at Main Street Books
- 15:59in February. I don't know, that's a little bit of
- 16:01a hike for me, for you, Yeah, from Charlotte.
- 16:04Speaker 1: It's just up forty five. It's not that big of
- 16:06a hike.
- 16:08Speaker 2: Yeah, So I'm excited about that.
- 16:09Speaker 3: I'm talking with the director of writing at Davidson who's
- 16:13also a professor in gender studies, and you know, it's
- 16:16open to the public. We'd love to have people there,
- 16:18particularly from around the Charlotte area, and just really excited
- 16:22to get this book out there. You know, I'm not
- 16:24doing a ton of in person, but if people invite me,
- 16:27I'm happy to come. And if people are doing book clubs.
- 16:30I'm happy to pop in over Zoom just to kind
- 16:33of do a quick Q and A if people have questions.
- 16:35Speaker 1: Do me a favor. When you go to Davidson, that
- 16:37is the home of Steph Curry, You've got to go
- 16:39see you, I know, Oh my god, go see what
- 16:42that man has done to that campus and how it
- 16:44inspires everything beyond today.
- 16:48Speaker 2: I can't wait. I'm excited.
- 16:50Speaker 3: I went and toured Davidson when I was an undergrad
- 16:53or thinking about going to school. That was a long
- 16:56long time ago, so I'm sure it's changed a whole
- 16:58lot since then.
- 16:59Speaker 1: Well I don't know how you guys would even pay
- 17:00attention if you were in class with Lake Norman up there,
- 17:02because there's just way too much going on when it
- 17:04comes to mother nature.
- 17:06Speaker 2: I bet, I bet. Yeah.
- 17:08Speaker 3: I didn't end up going to Davidson, but it was
- 17:10a beautiful campus and the people were there were just lovely.
- 17:13Speaker 2: So I'm excited to have a chance to go back.
- 17:16Speaker 1: Where can people go to find out more about you?
- 17:19And how can we keep this conversation growing? This cannot
- 17:21be a oh January twenty twenty six kind of a conversation.
- 17:26Speaker 3: No, I hope it'll start, you know, spark beginning of
- 17:29a movement. So my website is my long and convoluted
- 17:33name at www dot Elizabeth Shamblyccha m bl e E
- 17:39birch bu rch dot com. But if you just google
- 17:42The Pain Brokers, I'll come up. It's probably easier to remember.
- 17:45And I'm on Instagram and you know all the social
- 17:49media that's out there these days trying to get out
- 17:51and talk about the book and how it affects everyone.
- 17:54Speaker 1: See, I'm shocked that you're not doing a radio show
- 17:56doing this because I mean, it worked for doctor Lore,
- 17:58it worked for all these other people that would get
- 18:01on there and play the music. But then you could
- 18:03sit there and say, now here's something we're going to
- 18:04talk about today. Blah blah blah blah blah. You've just
- 18:07got that type of personality where it's like that was
- 18:10a beautiful song, but now, how can we incorporate something
- 18:12into your day.
- 18:14Speaker 2: I love that. I love that idea.
- 18:16Speaker 3: Maybe I can I can do that for you know,
- 18:18the Pain Broker's two point zero. But for now I'm
- 18:21just excited to leave that to you and to talk
- 18:23to you about it.
- 18:24Speaker 1: Wow, well you've got to come back to this show
- 18:26anytime in the future. Twenty minutes with you is not enough.
- 18:31Speaker 2: Well, I would love that. I'd love to come back.
- 18:33Speaker 3: There's you know, there's so much to this story and
- 18:36there's so much to mask towarts. I mean, you know,
- 18:39right now, the GLP one litigation is just gearing up.
- 18:42All the people who are finding out that we go
- 18:44via nozimpic isn't the dream that they hoped it might be,
- 18:47or beginning to sue. There's three thousand of those lawsuits
- 18:51and two hundred and fifty more being fouled every month.
- 18:53Speaker 2: So you know, I'm worried about what's going to happen there.
- 18:56Speaker 1: You're scaring the Butjbi's out of that one because, in
- 18:58all honesty, so that I could keep my life in
- 19:00order when it comes to diabetes. I'm the one that
- 19:03gives my wife her ozimpic every week. Yeah, and then
- 19:06you and then I read about this inside the book
- 19:08and I'm going, oh, for the love of Pete, Oh
- 19:11what's going on? What do I need to watch?
- 19:14Speaker 2: Yeah, And you know, it can be a wonderful drug
- 19:17for many people.
- 19:17Speaker 3: It's just that there are occasional side effects, and you know,
- 19:20there's these questions.
- 19:22Speaker 2: Like we think about you know, you think back.
- 19:23Speaker 3: To Finn Finn, which was a massive disaster, but it was,
- 19:29you know, a hugely popular drug and it was alleged
- 19:33to have caused enlarge heart valves and the people who
- 19:37used it, and then the you know, the pain brokers
- 19:39came in and there were vans outside of hotels with
- 19:43echo cardiograms in them, and people lined up to have
- 19:47their echo cardiograms read within a minute to decide if
- 19:51they were potential plaintiffs in a lawsuit.
- 19:53Speaker 1: Oh my god, So you have got the courage to
- 19:57march right through this dang mountain, and because I'm sure
- 20:00there are people that are standing in your way saying, Elizabeth,
- 20:02don't go there, but I have to.
- 20:05Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, I mean these are stories that nobody really
- 20:08wants told. So I'm not the most popular person in
- 20:12the room, but i am excited to tell the stories.
- 20:15And they're important and they're important for people to hear.
- 20:17So I'm grateful for the chance to do that. Wow.
- 20:21Speaker 1: Well, once again, please come back to the show anytime
- 20:23in the future. The door is always going to be
- 20:25open for you.
- 20:26Speaker 3: Well, I'm so grateful to you, Ero, thanks so much
- 20:28for having me on.
- 20:29Speaker 1: Will you be brilliant today?
- 20:31Speaker 2: Okay, all right, you do the same. Thank you so much.