Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / The Hidden Risks of High ROE Explained
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. Our mission here is pretty
- 0:03simple, really. We take a stack of financial
- 0:05sources. You know, the kind that are
- 0:07dense with numbers and jargon. And we try to boil them down.
- 0:10Exactly distill them into the genuine actionable insights you
- 0:14need to well to instantly upgrade your understanding.
- 0:18And today we are tackling one of the most fundamental questions
- 0:21in all of corporate finance. How do you truly identify the
- 0:26engine of a company's long term profitability?
- 0:29We're looking past the simple stuff like revenue or net
- 0:32income, right? We're focusing on the metrics
- 0:34that legendary value investors prefer.
- 0:37We want to know, is this company genuinely successful, or does it
- 0:43just look successful on the surface?
- 0:44That is the core question. We're doing a deep dive into the
- 0:47difference between just simple profit and what some of these
- 0:50sources call efficient profit. And to do that, we're going to
- 0:53focus on three concepts, 3 numbers that are super
- 0:56interconnected. You have to check them against
- 0:58each other, return on equity, return on assets and the
- 1:01critical check on corporate borrowing.
- 1:03Otherwise known as leverage. Exactly.
- 1:06Leverage. You know, it's true that a lot
- 1:08of new investors, they get obsessed with quarterly
- 1:10earnings. But if you look at the track
- 1:12records, people like Warren Buffett, the emphasis is placed
- 1:16so heavily on just one metric to start return on equity Roe.
- 1:22OK, so let's unpack that. Roe is, I guess, the simplest
- 1:25way to measure how effectively management is using your money.
- 1:29The shareholders money, yes. It's the company's net income
- 1:32divided by shareholders equity. So if a company can consistently
- 1:36deliver an Roe above what say 15 or 20%?
- 1:39That's a great benchmark. It suggests it's generating
- 1:41fantastic returns relative to the owner's capital.
- 1:44But you said consistently? And that consistency is the
- 1:46absolute key. The sources we analyze, they all
- 1:50highlight that a high Roe number by itself, it only gives you a
- 1:54starting point. It's not the whole story.
- 1:56Not at all. The real secret to creating
- 1:58compounding wealth isn't just the profit you make this year,
- 2:01it's what you choose to do with that profit next year and the
- 2:05year after that. OK.
- 2:06So Segment 1 is all about understanding this idea, the
- 2:09compounding machine and the sources use this really this
- 2:14very relatable analogy. They call it the AMU Milk Tea
- 2:17shop. So let's imagine we launched
- 2:19this shop. Our initial investment, our
- 2:21shareholder equity is 1,000,000. After one year of just fantastic
- 2:25sales, our net income is 200,000.
- 2:28Perfect. That gives us a starting Roe of
- 2:3120%. Simple math.
- 2:32Right now, this is where the divergent happens.
- 2:36This is the fork in the road where you separate static
- 2:39businesses from, you know, exponential growth machines.
- 2:42OK, so let's track 2 parallel universes.
- 2:45Company A and Company B both start with that 20% Roe.
- 2:49OK, Company A decides it's doing great and distributes that
- 2:53entire 200,000 profit as cash dividends to the owners.
- 2:56So company A shareholder equity stays at 1,000,000.
- 2:59Right, it doesn't grow. So it's income next year,
- 3:01assuming the business doesn't really change is still 200,000.
- 3:04The owners got a nice cash payout which is great.
- 3:07But 10 years from now? 10 years from now, Company A is
- 3:10still a $1 million equity company earning 200 grand a
- 3:13year. It's stable, sure, but it's
- 3:15fundamentally static. It hasn't grown at all.
- 3:18But Company B takes a different path.
- 3:20The crucial step? They retain that 200,000 profit.
- 3:23No dividends. No dividends.
- 3:25They immediately reinvest that cash.
- 3:27Maybe they open a second milk tea shop or upgrade all their
- 3:30equipment. So by retaining that profit,
- 3:32company BS equity grows in year 2, their shareholder equity is
- 3:37now 1.2 million. OK.
- 3:40And crucially, if business keeps its competitive advantage, its
- 3:43efficiency, that 20% Roe Year 2's income won't just be
- 3:48200,000. It'll be 20% of the new larger
- 3:51base. Exactly 20% of 1.2 million,
- 3:54which is 240,000. So wait.
- 3:56We didn't just grow by 20,000, we grew off the new profit base.
- 4:00That means our equity just keeps expanding.
- 4:02And the 20% you earn the next year is calculated related on an
- 4:05even larger number. That's the definition of
- 4:07compounding at the corporate level.
- 4:09That's the engine. High Roe plus a high retention
- 4:12rate. But this this brings us straight
- 4:15to the big trap, right? Something the sources call the
- 4:18reinvestment pitfall. Yes, because if compounding was
- 4:21just about holding on to cash, every CEO would just stop paying
- 4:25dividends and we'd all be rich. Why doesn't that happen?
- 4:29Because holding on to the cash means management has to
- 4:31consistently prove two things. One that they can find new
- 4:36projects that yield that same high return.
- 4:38And two. And two, that they have the
- 4:40integrity to just walk away from bad projects.
- 4:42Exactly right. Imagine Company B keeps the
- 4:45200,000, but the new location they open is just terrible.
- 4:50It only yields a 5% return. So while the original capital
- 4:53was earning 20%, this new money is dragging the average way
- 4:57down. Management succeeded in holding
- 4:59on to the money, but they actually destroyed its value in
- 5:02the process. This is where that whole
- 5:03discussion around a business Moat, you know, Buffett's term
- 5:06for competitive advantage, become so important.
- 5:09It's essential, the sources argue, that the best investment
- 5:12targets they have to have both an extremely strong Moat.
- 5:15To protect the high returns from competitors.
- 5:18Right. And abroad reinvestment space,
- 5:20they need somewhere to put the money.
- 5:22To ensure that every dollar they keep can be put to work at that
- 5:25same high protected rate. And if those opportunities dry
- 5:28up, if there's nowhere good to reinvest, a disciplined company
- 5:32should start paying dividends. Because that signals they're
- 5:35protecting the shareholder from that reinvestment pitfall.
- 5:37Exactly. They're basically saying we
- 5:39can't get 20% on this cash anymore, so you take it.
- 5:42That makes perfect sense. So the decision to retain cash
- 5:45isn't just a financial choice, it's a strategic vote of
- 5:49confidence by management in their own ability to keep that
- 5:52edge. OK.
- 5:54That gives us a really clear picture of how value is created
- 5:57over time. But wait, how do we know if that
- 6:00beautiful high Roe we just calculated is, you know, the
- 6:04result of a genuinely fantastic business or if it's just built
- 6:08on quicksand? That brings us to Segment 2.
- 6:11Yeah, whose money is actually driving that profit?
- 6:14This is where we have to shift from the income statement, how
- 6:18much money was made, to the balance sheet.
- 6:20How the company is financed. Exactly.
- 6:22We need to understand the relationship between what the
- 6:24company owns and who provided the cash to buy it.
- 6:27So let's define the three components, maybe using our
- 6:30small business analogy again. First, we have assets, right?
- 6:34This is the list of everything the business uses.
- 6:36The tables, the lemons, the juicers in the shop.
- 6:38It's the total resources the business controls.
- 6:41Then you have liabilities. This is the borrowed money.
- 6:44The company's obligations, a bank loan, or maybe money we
- 6:48borrowed from our fictitious neighbor Old Wang to buy that
- 6:51new juicer. And finally, shareholders
- 6:54equity. This is our money, the owner's
- 6:56money, what we truly put in or what we retained over time.
- 7:00And the fundamental accounting formula is that assets always
- 7:03equal liabilities plus equity. Everything the business has must
- 7:07be paid for, either by borrowing or by the owners.
- 7:10Simple as that. And understanding that simple
- 7:12formula lets us define two very distinct return metrics.
- 7:16The difference is well, it's often confusing, but it's
- 7:19absolutely critical for you as an investor.
- 7:21The first one is ROA or return on assets.
- 7:24You calculate this by dividing that income by total assets.
- 7:28What is this number truly telling us?
- 7:31ROA is basically management's efficiency report card.
- 7:35It measures the fundamental quality of the business itself,
- 7:38independent of how it's financed.
- 7:40OK. So if your ROA is say 8%, it
- 7:43means that every dollar of resources, whether you borrowed
- 7:46it or you own it, is yielding 8 cents in profit?
- 7:49And the sources say that if a business can't get an ROA above
- 7:525%, the whole thing might just be too much work for too little
- 7:56return. Or that management is misusing
- 7:58the funds. It's just not an efficient
- 8:00operation. So ROA is the hard truth about
- 8:03the business's operating quality.
- 8:05But we as shareholders, we're more interested in ROA return on
- 8:08equity. That's our personal return.
- 8:10And this is where the magic of leverage comes into the picture.
- 8:13Amplification. Yes, let's use a quick
- 8:15calculation. Stick with our lemonade stand.
- 8:17Total assets are 100, Net income is 10.
- 8:20OK. So the fundamental efficiency,
- 8:21the ROA is a decent 10%. Correct.
- 8:23Now let's look at the financing in scenario one, maybe we paid
- 8:27for all 100 in assets with our own equity, so.
- 8:30Roe is 10 / 110% ROA equals Roe. Easy.
- 8:37But in scenario 2, suppose we only put in 50 of equity and we
- 8:43borrowed the other 50 from the bank so. 50 in liabilities,
- 8:46right? Our net income is still 10, but
- 8:48now the denominator for our ROV calculation is only 5010.
- 8:52Divided by 50, right? Wait, the ROV suddenly jumps to
- 8:5520%? Exactly.
- 8:56The shareholders successfully used borrowed money leverage to
- 9:00amplify their personal returns. We doubled our return without
- 9:04changing the fundamental operating efficiency of the
- 9:06business one bit, that's why. We look at Roe, but we have to
- 9:09understand what's actually driving it precisely.
- 9:11And that. Amplification, which looks like
- 9:13such a sweet deal, brings us right to Segment 3, the danger
- 9:16of high debt, because that magic candy can become financial
- 9:20poison really, really fast and to.
- 9:22Check that to scrutinize the leverage, we use the long term
- 9:25debt to equity ratio D to E. This is the.
- 9:27Risk barometer it is. It simply measures borrowed
- 9:30money versus the owner's money. Ade of 0.5 means you borrowed
- 9:34$0.50 for every dollar you put in.
- 9:35That's usually pretty healthy, but the.
- 9:37Sources. They warn about this Wall Street
- 9:40game of extreme financial engineering.
- 9:42Oh. Yeah, where?
- 9:43They push this ratio to the absolute limit just to make the
- 9:46ROV look phenomenal. Let's use the extreme example.
- 9:49Company C right, 100 in total assets, but a massive 99 of that
- 9:53is liabilities, borrowed money and only $1.00 is shareholder
- 9:58equity. So a.
- 9:59Debt to equity ratio of 99. Insane.
- 10:03Now, if Company C manages to earn just $1.00 in profit, a
- 10:08really modest 1% ROA, what does their ROA look like?
- 10:12It's. $1.00 of net income divided by $1.00 of equity
- 10:15Their. ROA looks like 100%.
- 10:17What a. Perfect number to an.
- 10:19Investor who is only looking at ROA and nothing else.
- 10:21This company appears to be the ultimate growth stock.
- 10:24It looks like instant wealth creation, but it's a.
- 10:26Total House of Cards. It's built on borrowed
- 10:28resources, and this is what the. Sources mean by poison, not
- 10:30candy. It is.
- 10:32We've seen this happen countless times in history.
- 10:34If interest rates rise just a little bit, or if the business
- 10:37has a modest downturn, they sell 5% fewer units than they
- 10:41expected. What happens?
- 10:43The company. Instantly loses the ability to
- 10:45service or pay back that massive $99.00 in debt and when that.
- 10:48Company collapses the shareholders $1.00 investment is
- 10:51the very first thing that gets completely wiped out.
- 10:54It goes to zero. So the lesson?
- 10:55Here is that Roe is just too easily manipulated upward by
- 10:59debt. The real difference between a
- 11:01good company and a dangerous one lies in that ROA number.
- 11:04Absolutely. The final synthesis for you, the
- 11:07listener, is this. A high Roe coupled with a low
- 11:12ROA suggests a company is fundamentally inefficient but
- 11:15just drowning in debt. That's.
- 11:17A huge red flag. A massive.
- 11:19Red flag. The ideal sustainable company is
- 11:21one that has a healthy ROA, you know, 10% or more, combined with
- 11:25an excellent Roe, maybe 15 to 20%, but driven by.
- 11:28Moderate debt, not reckless borrowing that.
- 11:31Is the definition of a company with a true sustainable
- 11:34competitive Moat and real financial discipline and the.
- 11:37Distinction checking Roe against both the DE ratio and the
- 11:40underlying ROA. That is how you separate a true
- 11:44compounding machine from a financial gamble you.
- 11:46Can't. You just cannot look at any
- 11:49single financial number in isolation and hope to succeed
- 11:52long term. The numbers have to tell a
- 11:55coherence story about efficiency, leverage and that
- 11:59reinvestment capacity we talked about and.
- 12:01Here is a final provocative thought for you to consider and
- 12:03it circles right back to our first segment on reinvestment.
- 12:06OK. If you see a high ROA company
- 12:09that has traditionally retained almost all of its earnings to
- 12:12fuel growth, our Company B, and then it suddenly reduces its
- 12:16retention rate and starts paying out massive dividends, what does
- 12:20that signal to you? It sounds like management might
- 12:24be telling the market, without actually saying it, that the
- 12:27great growth opportunities are gone the high.
- 12:29Return reinvestment space they once enjoyed.
- 12:31It's drying. Up.
- 12:32They're saying the Moat is shrinking.
- 12:34They are. Essentially telling
- 12:35shareholders, we don't believe we can earn 20% on this cash
- 12:38anymore. So here you take it back.
- 12:40That's a deep dive for you to Mull over as you analyze your
- 12:44next potential investment. Thank.
- 12:46You for joining us for this deep dive into the financial engine
- 12:49of corporate profitability. You know, if you want to track
- 12:51total market temperature, you can search and download the iOS
- 12:55app Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 12:57It actually provides daily updates based on this kind of
- 13:00deep financial analysis and a. Quick disclaimer All analysis is
- 13:04based on publicly available sources and may be subject to
- 13:07revisions or differing interpretations.
- 13:09The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 13:12constitute investment advice. Please conduct your own due
- 13:16diligence before making any investment decisions and.
- 13:19To access our full archive of deep dives on topics just like
- 13:22this, or to get access to more advanced content and tools, we
- 13:26encourage you to join the Deep Value Club membership or
- 13:29subscribe to us on Apple or Spotify Podcasts.
- 13:32The channel is deep value investing.
- 13:34We'll catch you on the next deep dive.