Latest / Wheel Takes / KOD (Ch21-22): Pruey?
Transcript
- 0:17Hello, Hi, and welcome once again to Wheel Takes, a podcast about
- 0:22the Wheel of Time, a series of fantasy novels written by Robert Jordan and
- 0:26completed by Brandon Sanderson. My name is Gus, and I'm sick, and
- 0:30I'm Ali. And I'm Ali, and I'm on first time reader. Yes,
- 0:37I've read the whole thing. I'm doing really well. You're good a
- 0:40first time reader who is on book eleven, chapter twenty three. You're starting
- 0:46twenty three, but you've read through twenty two. That is what I meant.
- 0:50This podcast only contains spoilers for what Ali's already read, and today that's
- 0:53everything up to and including Knife of Dreams chapter twenty two. To make an
- 0:58anchor weep this week. This past weekend, quick fun update, My play
- 1:06happened. It was real fun. I had a great time, and then
- 1:10I woke up this morning with I think these are allergies. I don't think
- 1:14I'm sick. But that's how it happens. Though. Once you have like
- 1:17the stressful event that you're thinking about, it's over all of a sudden,
- 1:21your body's like and now we're going to experience release the crack. So I'm
- 1:23going to sound like this so my bad for that. Uh, alie,
- 1:29you know what, you know what it's time for It's time to thank some
- 1:33patrons amazing because we love them and they're great and I'm trying to figure out
- 1:40where we left off in the patron Thank yous. I believe it was Antonio
- 1:44B. So five more for this week and we're nearly caught up. Thanks
- 1:49for jumping to a high five. Alexander g. Alexander Ge just like a
- 1:55joevial rock. Yeah, you are ground. You are hard to you know
- 2:02shake in terms of your uh, you know, you're You're just somebody who's
- 2:08just solid, you know, uh. And you are also you know,
- 2:14you're great in times when things just get a little rocky. Your love never
- 2:19erodes. It withstands the test of time and the wears and tears of life.
- 2:25And also, I don't care what anyone has said immant about you.
- 2:31You're a great guy. A radio will have liked this and for that we
- 2:36thank you, and thanks for being a part of this community. Thanks for
- 2:38the high five of cleaves of cleaves. I love it of cleaves just like
- 2:46a shiny painting, like a like a glossy no, like a painting,
- 2:53shiny yeah, basically yeah, sure whatever, there could be gloss or just
- 2:59like shiny good happyness. You know, you're not one to frame other people
- 3:07for problems. You take accountability and responsibility for your shit. You know,
- 3:12you're somebody who's You're not just going to brush have a brush with greatness.
- 3:19You will achieve greatness because you're just the kind of person who deserves greatness.
- 3:25And also, oh, I forgot to thank Alexander for being a part of
- 3:30this community. Thanks Alexander, but also oil Bet You're wonderful and for that
- 3:38we thank you. And thanks for being a part of this community. Thanks
- 3:43for the high five. Alissa h Alyssa h just like a helpful art of
- 3:50choke. Choke Uh No, I don't think you have. You're not one
- 3:54to leave people alone when they need you. You are there for them.
- 3:59You are present. You are an exceptional friend under the right in the right
- 4:08environments that you naturally gravitate toward. You know, good people, good vibes.
- 4:15You bloom. Did you know the art chokes of flowers? I did,
- 4:17I've seen them so very cool looking. You bloom in the right circumstances
- 4:24and just have this thirst for life that is admirable and exceptional, and you
- 4:31also make people green with envy at how great you are. And for that
- 4:36we thank you, and thanks for being a part of this community. Thanks
- 4:39for the pint. Riddle Red Coats, Riddle red Coat. I love the
- 4:44fun names. I do too. I love the real names, but I
- 4:47love the fun names. I love all names, all of them, like
- 4:50everyone. Like like when when someone requested that we refer to them exclusively as
- 4:57alarm Alarm sixty nine. Truly, it made my day. It still does
- 5:02every time I think about it. We're going through the backlog and I was
- 5:06like, I can't wait until we get to alarm Arm sixty nine. But
- 5:10for now, Riddle red coats, Riddle red Coats. Just like a venerated
- 5:17glowstick, you have definitely done glowstick, damn it, And I thought so,
- 5:21Just like a venerated cantalope cantalope, I don't think you have. I
- 5:27don't think I've done cantalope. I think I've done honeydew, but not cantalope
- 5:30orange. You glad I didn't make a bad pun. That's ACU second.
- 5:35Sorry, Uh, there's nothing you can't elope. You can elope. You're
- 5:43just someone. When you put your mind to something, you're gonna get it
- 5:46done. You are ripe with potential and possibility, and you also are bursting
- 5:56with enthusiasm and the spice of life. And for that we thank you,
- 6:02and thanks for being a part of this community. And last but not least,
- 6:05for today, thanks for the cup of coffee. Nedra are Nedra?
- 6:10You should not pronounced Nidra. I am not. I don't know anything because
- 6:13I know someone with the name spelled that way who's it's pronounced Nidra. Well,
- 6:16then, Nidra are. I apologize if I mispronounced your name Nidra or
- 6:20Nedra. Just like a splendid horticulturist, you don't bug out when stuff goes
- 6:30wrong. You stay calm, cool and collected all day every day. You've
- 6:34got the way, you've got a way of making everything a net positive and
- 6:43you are flying towards your dreams and you will achieve them. And for that
- 6:48we thank you and thank you for being a part of this community. So
- 6:51thanks everyone, You're all great. Thank you so much. Now, in
- 6:57the interest of me not making awful sinus noises at you for too long,
- 7:01this will we always say this, This will probably be a fairly short episode,
- 7:05and then you look at the timestamp and it's three hours and forty five
- 7:09minutes. However, these two chapters, while they have their sweet moments,
- 7:15I don't know if there's a lot, there's not a ton to like sink
- 7:18our teeth into. Robert Jordan, I know, would disagree, However,
- 7:23Well, I think that's the thing to sink our teeth into. Maybe I
- 7:26don't think the chapter before has a ton. It doesn't. We'll get to
- 7:30the other thing in a minute when we get to it. But first things
- 7:34first, Ali, my dear, where did we leave off? Noh,
- 7:39I have no idea. Oh you know, it was an absolute banger,
- 7:43high water moment. Oh my god, Golden crany crane good. But the
- 7:46fuck that was an incredible chapter, absolute legend. And now we pick it
- 7:51up with chapter twenty one. You're fine, Chapter twenty one. Within the
- 8:00Stone. That's the logo, what is it? It is ah thang and
- 8:05a tear, the ancient symbol of eyes to die. That's the one.
- 8:11Yeah, Ali, do you have notes for chapter twenty one? Okay?
- 8:13I do. Within the Stone ninety once again hates giving money to the poor.
- 8:18She does. I love that that's a weird consistent thing for her.
- 8:24I think it makes a lot of sense. You do, will Wwayne ninety
- 8:28You've probably had to scrimp and save. Yeah, but we're in wartime,
- 8:31I know. But I'm saying it is probably part of her character to be
- 8:35like, you don't know when you might need that, Okay, sure,
- 8:39but like they have and is walking around seeing these people start. It's true.
- 8:46It is also sort of I feel in some ways at odds with her
- 8:50benevolent healing nature, like a little So it's both. I mean, hey,
- 8:56I guess, I guess she is a practical and she's like, we
- 9:01can't just be throwing money everywhere. But I don't know, I just think
- 9:05it's it is funny. It is really funny. It's funny to me.
- 9:09Then specifically she's always mad about it. Yeah, I oh, I love
- 9:13Rand pushing Rand's women, pushing Alana out of his head. Yes, amazing.
- 9:18No notes, Caroline, my girl, fucking legend say that. Did
- 9:26I not say Darlin was going to be king? You did? You haven't
- 9:28had a king? Right? He is gonna be King of Tyr. And
- 9:31there's this really cute scene at the end of this chapter which I really like.
- 9:33And then Rand is like, I don't give a shit about this,
- 9:35fuck you guys, and it makes me laugh every time I read it.
- 9:39I feel like the boys just love to interrupt other people's flirting. Yeah,
- 9:43they love it. That's our favorite activity, pretty much, is that it?
- 9:48Yeah? Alright, Chapter twenty one. If this is your favorite chapter,
- 9:52you're gonna be very disappointed because we're not going to talk about it very
- 9:54much. It's this is meant in the nicest way possible possible. Okay,
- 10:05we just read Golden Crane Rides for Tarmin Guiden. If you read that and
- 10:11then are like, this is your favorite chapter, I'm I'm confused because there
- 10:16are so many bangers. I don't think anyone's gonna be like but I don't
- 10:22even know what they talked about. But Cad Sawayne needing help down from a
- 10:26ledge like, no, Kadswayne's spanking Rand is your favorite chapter? I just
- 10:31listen. There are eight billion people in this world. I can't speak for
- 10:35all of them. So maybe you sitting here and I'm not judging you personally.
- 10:39No, you person who loves this chapter the most because for some reason
- 10:45you love it When Cad Swayne's spanks Rand in the ass. Ye, I'm
- 10:50not definitely so I'm not really pro corporal punishment or the character assassination of my
- 10:56girl. CAD's Yeah, so I uh, you know if this is correct,
- 11:05and this is a history book basically, like it's like Loyal wrote a
- 11:09history. This is like Loyal's book. If I were Randed'd be like,
- 11:13you could have You didn't need to skip any of that. You could could
- 11:16have cut Loyal, Loyal, you could have. It feels no. I
- 11:22would have been like, did you have to include the time I got spanked
- 11:24and then like go into detail about the welt on my ass? But did
- 11:28that need to happen? It feels almost like the first chapter of a book,
- 11:33because there's there's like two paragraphs reminding us of how tevere In this works,
- 11:37and there's like two paragraphs reminding us that the world is disintegrating, and
- 11:41there's like two paragraphs remind establishing or reminding us that there is like strife and
- 11:46tear that we have not really been Party two, but we kind of knew
- 11:48it was happening. And then Rand was like, I should go resolve this
- 11:50because I've been hiding from the forsaken. But now I guess they just know
- 11:54where I am all the time, So fuck it. So I guess I'll
- 11:56just do things now, I suppose so, so we're gonna drop it.
- 12:01I'm gonna sorry. I was trying to take one for the team there and
- 12:05claim that it was my phone. That was sweet of you, and I
- 12:09did not realize that was what you were doing. Well, you're You're good.
- 12:13Don't worry about it. I'm very good at being alive. Rand is
- 12:18on tied Ashar, tide Potashar and tide Potashar, And we're fucking rolling into
- 12:26tear and there's a bunch of birds fucking crash into each other. So the
- 12:30birds crash into each other, Alley, what do you think? Holy shit,
- 12:33birds they crashed into each other. You remember this, here's the thing,
- 12:37A bunch of birds crashed in that. You know that tavern is a
- 12:41thing that happens and sometimes makes odd things happen sometimes happen. Are like bad
- 12:46things turn out to be good, But also you got to remember that even
- 12:48though bad things are going to turn out to be good, it also means
- 12:50that some good things are going to end up being bad. I don't know
- 12:52if we've established this or communicated this at all and Wheel of Time novel before.
- 12:56Loyle definitely wrote this because that is his face for topic and it's going
- 13:01to go into detail about it. Yeah. Robert Jordan is like, I
- 13:03don't know if you noticed that I got a get out of jail free card
- 13:07that now no other writer can use. And everyone hates you mm hmm uh
- 13:11in the best way possible, but also like what the fuck in the best
- 13:16way possible. Men is also like, well, you're gonna die of hunger.
- 13:18You're gonna die of hunger. You're gonna die of hunger. You're having
- 13:22a terrible time. Everybody's having a terrible time. Yeah, it makes sense
- 13:24to me that in the show they made men have a drinking problem. Yeah
- 13:28yeah, yeah. Some men is looking around like and everything sucks, and
- 13:31Loose Thearren is like having a laugh. It makes sense that she would want
- 13:35to be rid of this power. This power sucks. Yeah, Loose Thearron
- 13:39is having a fucking laugh. Riot and Rand is like trying to kind of
- 13:41be semi incognito, pretty incognito. He's kind of given up in cognito.
- 13:48He has six maidens with him. Then you are not incognito. And he
- 13:54learn what incognito means. Oh, and then like there's the steam wagon goes
- 13:58by and there's these two kids who were like, it's called a steam horse,
- 14:01and one of them is like, no idiots called a steam wagon.
- 14:05Ah A right, I did actually enjoy that part. I love this part
- 14:07very well. It's not I shouldn't say. Actually, I enjoyed like ninety
- 14:11nine percent of this book. It doesn't not the spanking party. Yeah yeah,
- 14:16yeah, you understand, yeah, yeah, yeah, but uh but
- 14:20I enjoyed the part where he was like, I don't know, if you
- 14:24know, merchants will be quick to adapt this. They're usually a pretty conservative
- 14:28bunch, and then loose there and laughed in his head. I like that
- 14:31part. Yeah, why why because something has never changed? Industrial revolution?
- 14:37Yeah, where the merchants are going to become the fucking bankers. Yeah.
- 14:43So these two kids are like talking and they disagree on things, and then
- 14:48Randa's like, here, guys, here's seven hundred thousand dollars apiece, just
- 14:50get out of my hair. Elon Musk over here just invented the fucking steam
- 14:54engine. Wouldn't that be you know Ballin has Henry fo It wouldn't be more
- 15:00app metaphor. I mean sure that would have been a more app if we're
- 15:03gonna if we're gonna boot well actually he's well yeah, but in a wheel
- 15:07of time version of that would have been like Henry fived five. Yeah all
- 15:15right. Anyway, Rand is like, here, guys, here is enough
- 15:18gold to be you know, it's Henry Forge Forge Yeah, get it f
- 15:24O U R g A E yeah h at the end, and there's apostrophe
- 15:28after the h in Henry. So Rand gives these kids money and like Olivia
- 15:33is with him because Olivia is always with him, and he thinks the steam
- 15:37wagon is cool and it is, and it is one of those cool,
- 15:39fun little background things in the books. It's like, hey, it's the
- 15:41Industrial Revolution. That's pretty cool. We went from Tudor England to the Industrial
- 15:45Revolution. That's fucking fast, man. Uh. And there's like, you
- 15:48know, you get the hawkers because it's a city and we do the same
- 15:52thing every time. How's tier tier is well? Okay, Robert Jordan invented
- 15:58the steam engine in this book because he was like I need ways to get
- 16:03people places fast now, Like I need I need to skip over some of
- 16:07this travel montage stuff, which is also why gateways exist all of the different
- 16:12fast travel. The steam engine isn't that much faster than a horse. It's
- 16:15just that like one of them can pull fifty wagons. Well, yeah,
- 16:19he's inventing trains essentially useful when the apocalypse is coming and we need to get
- 16:26like armies of people places very quickly, and we might have an isodye with
- 16:30us. Yeah yeah, yeah, No, So how's tear tears sucks?
- 16:34I hate tear tears sucks. You don't want to be like I hate a
- 16:37whole city of people. But like Darlin is like walking into a viper pit
- 16:45of doom. Well, he's kind of under siege in the in the stone,
- 16:48I guess. Well, yeah, because Alenda is that her name?
- 16:51Lendi? Yes, I believe. So, yeah, I'm going to get
- 16:53some things wrong, y'all. I have a lot of brain fog right now.
- 16:57I apologize. No, no one's allowed to have brain fog on this
- 17:02podcast except for me. That's my thing. How dare you? Wow?
- 17:07Okay, so we're both kind of dealing with brains a little bit, A
- 17:11little bit. That's it's going to be a banger app a banger app so
- 17:15so Rand you know, tears sucks and people are fighting all the time and
- 17:19everything kind of sucks. It sucks here second place. To me, he's
- 17:22just walking around looking at all the people, like, damn, that sucks.
- 17:26By the way, did you know the apocalypse is coming? Because Robert
- 17:27Jordan's going to remind us that the apocalypse is coming? Yeah, it's coming
- 17:32in what four books? Four books? Well? Three three three? Okay,
- 17:37so it's coming fourteen yeah, three books of thousands of words. Yes,
- 17:41yes, I you know, I think back sometimes to book seven when
- 17:44rand was going, there's not enough time, there's not enough time, and
- 17:47I said, look at the shelf, my brother in Christ, there's there's
- 17:49some time. There's a little time. I know for him, it's like
- 17:53a month. There's a dude who's like, I'm going to give you want
- 17:56to buy some silkworms? And there's Sean chanon tier two and that's tense and
- 18:00unsettling, and uh have we not made peace with the Jean jan? Is
- 18:06that not what we're here to do yet? And uh uh okay, So
- 18:10that means that like next chapter is going to be because what we're where are
- 18:15we in the book? How far? Okay? So we're still kind of
- 18:18at the midpoints. We're still at the middle still maybe popping off. You
- 18:22continue to assume that Robert Jordan follows a traditional story. I do, and
- 18:26it's stupid every time. It hasn't done that since book five. No Golden
- 18:30Crane rides for time and guide on right on it. That was right on
- 18:33Q. So how dare you so? I'm wondering if they're trying to set
- 18:41up this moment of samarag whatever being like the climax of the book. Are
- 18:48we killing samarag As the climax of the book seems like we need to have
- 18:52the climax be related to rand it almost always is. Mm hmmm, So
- 18:56there's that, or but I don't We're not near the climax. We're not
- 19:02at the climax yet. So are we going to have like forty five pages
- 19:07forty five thousand pages of peace with the Shawn jan but could do? Or
- 19:11maybe we're going to go hang out with someone else. We have barely seen
- 19:14Aguaine, we have barely seen a GWayne. We've barely seen Agwayne. Matt
- 19:21is fighting with tu On. Yeah, they're also I guess falling in love.
- 19:26Paren is gonna make a big pot of tea. I oh, that
- 19:30could be the climax. Could be the climax, So that means we could
- 19:33get samarag Elaine is trying to consolidate power and also figure out what creepy mccreeper
- 19:37hands is up to. Oh yes, yes, yes, yeah, we
- 19:41know what he's up to being creepy. Yeah. So so they go to
- 19:45an end and Rand is like, yo, do you rent by the hour?
- 19:47And the guy is like uh, and Katsawayne is what a question?
- 19:51And Katsawayne is like, don't just shut up, just stop and Rand is
- 19:55like, why is everybody looking at me? Oh my god, because it
- 19:57sounds like you've hired a sex worker. It does, yes, a little
- 20:02bit. I think that's the implication here, right by the hour? Honey,
- 20:06Well, he says, you think that's the implication here. He's like,
- 20:08hey, can I get one room? And he has six six women
- 20:11with him and the guy's like what what? And then he's like, don't
- 20:15worry, I only need it for a little bit. And the guy was
- 20:18like, oh, okay, Yeah, the implication is are you screwing all
- 20:21these women? How So anyway, they get it, Yeah, they get
- 20:26I don't know, you get a room and it's got a view on the
- 20:29Stone Tier and they go up to the to the thing and then the gateway
- 20:33into the Stone of Tiers. So so now we're in the Stone of Tier
- 20:37and there's some guys there and they're like, oh hey, we're still guarding
- 20:40the Heart of the Stone and Rand is like, why Calendar's gone and they're
- 20:42like, well, because you didn't tell us to stop. And I'm like
- 20:47that's fair, uh, and loose theren's yelling and they're like, yo,
- 20:52hey, well we'll take you to Darlin. We might need to like guide
- 20:56you there because the you know, the rooms keep moving uncomfortable. Yeah,
- 21:03so that's happening now because the apocalypse. So last time it was two books
- 21:07ago it was ghosts and now it's renovations. All right, Renovations are the
- 21:11new impending sign of the apocalypse. Just random renovations. The rooms are moving,
- 21:18oh yes, yes, and like all these big buildings things aren't where
- 21:21they should be. That that's just called or apparently being pregnant Elaine. So
- 21:30what I never made bingo for Knife of Dreams. Really you may not have.
- 21:33I don't think that happened. I don't know, huh. I just
- 21:38realized because I was like wondering how my bingo was going. Is not possible.
- 21:42That doesn't seem right. I'll have to go back. I or you
- 21:47just never made a sheet. I might not have ever made a sheet that
- 21:49would be appropriate thing for me to discover today. I did, I did?
- 21:55Did I well? Fuck? Shit? Should fuck? Okay? Fuck?
- 21:59Okay, okay, well I'll make that soon. Probably not today because
- 22:02I feel quite poorly, but soon. Uh. I remember you're reading me
- 22:07this. Yeah, I was like, I must have yeah, okay,
- 22:10okay, I've gotten some of them. Yeah you have. Wait hold on,
- 22:14okay, let me see how many have gotten? Gallad kills aim in
- 22:17Valda. That was one, I know, it was like two seconds in.
- 22:21Yeah, you got, there was one up there earlier. You got.
- 22:26I got Morayne letter reveal, Yeah, I got, I've got.
- 22:30Oh man, I'm not doing very well this this book. No oh oh,
- 22:33yeah, we'll see. No, I'm not. I'm not doing very
- 22:37well this book. I'll do a randomly generated square for this. By the
- 22:40way, I'm not. I've only gotten Tom Moraine letter reveal. Yeah,
- 22:45Moraine revealed to be alive Free Space, the classic, you know, which
- 22:51is problematic gender dynamics. Ye, easily. Just this chapter, Galad kills
- 22:56am in Valda hopefully the classic and that's it. Well, wow, I
- 23:03am not crushing at this book. So Ray goes to Stone. He's like,
- 23:07yo, let's go fucking talk to Darlin because Alana's with him, so
- 23:10I know where he's at. And he goes up and he's like, hey,
- 23:12what up, And Caroline Damadred is there, and everybody's happy. I
- 23:15am. Carolin Damadrud is back. She's my favorite fucking f tier character.
- 23:18She's shown up twice. I'm obsessed with her. She's great. We are
- 23:22both obsessed. Now. She is also aware she is the canonically hottest person
- 23:26in the book. She's wearing min tight pants. Where is it canonical?
- 23:30My brain? Well, Rad looks at her and he's like, I don't
- 23:33know whether I should be hard or hard because because he starts, he's like,
- 23:41well, on the one hand, she looks like Loraine, so I'm
- 23:42going to start doing the list, but on the other hand, oh my
- 23:45god. But on the other hand, I'm going to start humming and thumbing
- 23:48my ear lobe which is loose there and speak for I'm gonna pop the boner.
- 23:52Refusing because did Brandon rEFInd Moraine hot? No? But remember Caroline is
- 23:57a younger, hotter Moraine wearing green? I mean sure, yeah, with
- 24:03a deep voice. I mean yeah, listen, we all love her.
- 24:07She's great. We love a deep voiced woman. So I married one.
- 24:12I know that was my invocation. Yes, So what the fuck happens?
- 24:18Does anything happening? I just read this. Nothing happens. I have a
- 24:22meeting and they're like, oh, yeah, we you know, they're Rand
- 24:26basically like the event of this chapter is what that cat swayin spanks Rand kind
- 24:32of is? Yeah, yeah, it's like Rand is being, she gets
- 24:36annoyed with him, and she spanks him in front of everybody, and everybody
- 24:38like laughs at that. And I was like, that to me would be
- 24:41like the most unprofessional weird hr call yeah call inducing yeah, weirdness, it's
- 24:51weird. It's like Rand is being, you know, and she hates hard
- 24:55enough to give him a welt? Do you know how hard that is to
- 24:57do? Pretty hard? You have to hit something so hard that's like unnecessary.
- 25:04We'raman's there, Thank god, there's there's uh. Rand is like,
- 25:11why the fuck are you here? You're supposed to be in Kyrie anyway.
- 25:12So there's like a bunch of positioning and stuff, and I do you want
- 25:17to get into the nitty gritty nuances of all this. It's basically like there's
- 25:19the rebels, and then there's not and then some people are coming from out
- 25:23of town and Rand doesn't want them to and and like there's and then the
- 25:29end day tries to get the people more food and Darling's like, well it
- 25:33keeps getting taken by Alenda. Yeah, and Rand goes, well, what
- 25:40can you do? Yeah, and I'm like gateways, Yeah, you can
- 25:45do gateways. And then like, I mean, I know channelers are worthy.
- 25:48Whatever, and then at the end of the at the end, oh
- 25:49who gives an actual rats out And then at the end of the it gives
- 25:52an actual rats at the end of the chapter. It's like, hey,
- 25:56but also we've made parlay with the rebels and they're going to stop being rebel
- 26:00if you just make Darlin king and why because that way they can swear fealty
- 26:06to a Tyrann and not to Rand. That is fucking dumb, but whatever.
- 26:10Yeah, So like I'm kind of jumping through all this, do you
- 26:14mind, because like no, yeah, So so so so the the the
- 26:19fuck god what the uh? By the way, when I say that is
- 26:22fucking dumb, I mean of the fucking of course, of course I don't
- 26:26like the tyrants. I think they're as they're very very racist, Like they're
- 26:30not only racist, they're classiest. All of their like leaders were fucking creeps
- 26:37who were like, uh, like cacticing all these women for funsies and being
- 26:42mad that they could be hung for it. Like fuck the tyrants. Yeah,
- 26:45not the regular tyrants, just these rebel ass tyrants. Fuck them.
- 26:52I hate them. If they don't like it, they can leave. They
- 26:55want Darlin to be king and they want their lands back, and then they'll
- 26:59stop rebelling. And Rand is like, what if instead I keel haul them
- 27:02across my fucking balls? And then and then and then kad Suwaine, did
- 27:08you know I just learned how to swear yesterday? And then uh and then
- 27:12Cata Well, well, I I personally, when I learned how to swear,
- 27:17didn't jump to keel haul them across my balls. I don't know,
- 27:22it felt it felt aftter Rand's mental state. Oh that was one of the
- 27:26great I'm stealing that and pretending like I came out that's fine. So Rand,
- 27:32so kad Swayne like she does, I'm gonna count to three, school
- 27:37marm sort of thing, and then she spanks Rand. And then I mean
- 27:41we did once complain that men weren't getting spanked equally to women. I'm not
- 27:45happy that it's happening now. I don't want anyone to want anybody that allowed
- 27:48and we have no one gets spanked. I don't like that. Any thoughts.
- 27:52I don't think anyone does. Like no one I've talked to you is
- 27:55like, oh yeah, I love the spain. Spanking is the high part
- 27:57of the wheel. Any thoughts on any of this. Ally, I mean,
- 28:03it's kind of like, oh, hey, we did it, which
- 28:07is fine. You know, Tyr was the problem we resolved very quickly.
- 28:11Yeah, we resolved that very quickly, which, you know what, good
- 28:14for the apocalypse. But I was pretty surprised at how quickly Tyr came a
- 28:18non entity, mostly because I wanted to spend more time with Caroline. Yeah.
- 28:22I feel like also kind of the thing is going on here is Rand
- 28:25is being listen, we're assholes. We're complaining about the Elaine succession crisis and
- 28:29how long that's taking and listen, I just I can't be happy. Well,
- 28:36but it was more than except that I'm unhappy. It was also where
- 28:38than I forgot this was happening. I did forget this was happening. Yeah,
- 28:44and now we've spent thirty pages resolving it. I did forget this was
- 28:47happening. Yeah. Yeah, Well there's a lot of plot. And I
- 28:49also don't know why Rand's here. Well, because I thought he was trying
- 28:53to make people of ch Why is he in Tier? And he comes here
- 28:56to like get men to take to band our Abin. So this is basically
- 29:03a waypoint on the way to band our Aban. And he comes and he
- 29:07like band our Abin. It's a city where he's gonna go meet with uh?
- 29:11Is it bandar Abin? I don't know, Okay, And then we're
- 29:14gonna get like the Battle of bandar Abin. No, it's where he's gonna
- 29:17go and make peace with the shan Cha. No, but we're gonna get
- 29:19like the Battle of band or Abin between him and Samarn. Did I say
- 29:22bandar Aban? I'm in Arad Demon, But I don't know is Samara gonna
- 29:26die this book? It's Ara Demon, not band our Abon. Bender Abon
- 29:29is a city in arab demon because we need more to name things. Yeah,
- 29:33so Rand literally came here to be like I need more men? Can
- 29:36I have more men? And then on the way there, we resolved the
- 29:38Tyrone Civil War. We just needed to check that off the list. Yeah,
- 29:42and ran, like by the way, Alana resolved the Tyron Civil War.
- 29:45And Rand starts like being fully agro and yelling about how bad of a
- 29:48job everybody did. And that's when Kat Swayn hits him, and it's like,
- 29:51motherfucker, you got exactly what you wanted. Shut up. Oh I'm
- 29:56not for the hitting. Yeah, she didn't have to spank him about it.
- 29:59Well, banking is weird, like leave the booty alone. Yeah,
- 30:03in a professional is Rand being petty and agro about stuff? Absolutely? And
- 30:10that's going through a lot. I a you know, kick in the ass,
- 30:14but like but like a metaphorical A metaphorical kick in the ass, not
- 30:18a like I don't know this banking in the workplace does need to cease.
- 30:22I do believe that, so then I will, you know what, I'm
- 30:26not afraid to say that. So, like Robert, to his credit,
- 30:30is tying up a plotline here by crowning Darlin, king of tears something you
- 30:33had called I did and I was very pretty well. And Caroline goes,
- 30:37and if you are king, it means that Steward and Tear for the Lord
- 30:41Dragon becomes a lesser title. They may even tack on three or four more
- 30:45noble sounding titles to try pushing it down to obscurity. And Darling goes,
- 30:48and would you marry a king? Caroline, I'll accept the crown. If
- 30:52you will, then I'll have to have a crown made. And this is
- 30:56the cute. I fucking love this bit. And men goes, I can
- 31:00tell you how it should look. I want their love story. Yeah.
- 31:03Caroline laughed again and released Darlin's arms, swaying away from him. I'll have
- 31:07to see you in it. Before I could answer that they have men's crown
- 31:10made, and if it makes you look pretty, then perhaps I will consider
- 31:14it. And Rand goes, this is great. I don't fucking care.
- 31:18And I'm like, you shut up, kid. I have been writing for
- 31:19this weirdly. This is the thing that I've fixated on, is Caroline,
- 31:26Damadred, You've fixated that we have fixated Weirdly, this is the fucking thing.
- 31:32It's not the Amayar, it's this, this is the thing that we
- 31:34have fixated for many books. Weirdly, with the Amayar was like, if
- 31:40I'm remembering this correctly, I was like, oh, they're doomsday culting.
- 31:42I die. You met them, you didn't even meet them. Sorry,
- 31:45they have shown up twice and you heard of them the first time and they
- 31:48said this something something, the time of illusions will come to an end.
- 31:51You went, oh, it's Jonestown, yeah, or Heaven's Gate or like
- 31:56the like tons of other cults that are like it's time to wake up up
- 32:00or it's time to meet our God or whatever, and then they die and
- 32:04it's horrible. It's a horrible thing. Yeah. Not a hot take.
- 32:07No, Like Wheel Takes is very lukewarm on the takes lately in that regard.
- 32:14Yes, but like you know, I just we'll get there, we'll
- 32:19get there. Let's let's let's settle let's settle up with Darlin and Caroline.
- 32:22So Darlin and Caroline have a cute moment. Then Rand is like, I
- 32:24don't care. I have to fucking leave. Time is limited, and men
- 32:28and ninety are like, you fucking ass, there'll be a dick and he's
- 32:31like what he is being a here's the thing, Rand is being a dick
- 32:35lately. Oh god, yeah. And I understand that he's going through a
- 32:37lot, and I empathize with that, But I don't think that going through
- 32:45a lot is an excuse to be a dick to people. I really don't.
- 32:49I think that we have to operate with our most generous hearts even when
- 32:53we're going through a lot. Anna Yella's also here. I'm pretty sure where
- 32:59did we see on a Yell last that's Aaron milla Is. No, wait,
- 33:02it was Ilil and Anna Yella? I think with two who almost knifed
- 33:07him in book eight? Was that on a Yella? I think that was
- 33:09an A Yella. Yeah she's here too. Oh she's fake as fucker.
- 33:15I don't like her. I don't like the Tyranns and I never have and
- 33:19I never will. Yeah, okay, she she is. Yeah, she's
- 33:23the one tyrone common people. She's the one who almost knifes him or maybe
- 33:29doesn't, and now she's the tyrons. Yeah. So anyway, then Rand
- 33:32is like, yo, hey Anna Yella Darlin and where him on? Hey?
- 33:37Where am on? You've been here this whole time? Good for you?
- 33:40Asshole. When do we get to charge? He does, yes,
- 33:44he is exactly like that. He's like, you three get a bunch of
- 33:47dudes and we're going to go to Eric Demon And Darlin is like fucking why
- 33:52and Rand goes, Tarman Guidan is coming soon. You are going to Era
- 33:58demand to get ready for Tarman. Okay, and that that's but the Darlin's
- 34:02not going because Darlin just became king. Darlin's also going, why would Darlin
- 34:07go? Darlin has shit to do. He's got starving people in a city
- 34:09I don't know. We're not going to prioritize, okay, peace with the
- 34:13shan Chan or something, so we're gonna let people starve to death. And
- 34:16Rand was like random, Ran, to his credit, was like, oh
- 34:19those little boys that men got attached to check them die. He was like,
- 34:23yo, Darlin, find these two kids and make sure that they're taken
- 34:27care of. And I'm like, that's very noble of you. There are
- 34:30there's a lot of starving people out there. Well and Min makes a little
- 34:35sounds like oh that means they die, and I was like, well,
- 34:37perhaps perhaps I understand a bit is that we can't save everyone, but this
- 34:45is a city of people. Maybe, and I know men's viewings are and
- 34:52perhaps we could make an attempt. I think it's not really peace with a
- 34:54shawan Chan as much as like, hey, we got to bolster armies against
- 34:58the blight, so we're gonna get ready and be entarian. So he's kind
- 35:00of doing this thing, and he does the same thing in the next chapter
- 35:04Robert Jordan does where he's like, we got to start making sacrifices so that
- 35:08we can be ready for Tarman guidance. So like we got to focus on
- 35:10this. Now we've resolved the king thing. Great, we're gonna go do
- 35:14Tarmon Guiden now. But right now, Yeah, he seems to think,
- 35:19so we're three books away. He didn't think so at the time. He
- 35:22was adamant that the next book would be the last one. He was wrong,
- 35:25or were three books away anyway, and hold your horses. That's the
- 35:29end of chapter. We could maybe do a small side quest we had all
- 35:31this time for weavils, we could do it, maybe a small side quest
- 35:36about like trying to get some cows into the city. They do it doesn't
- 35:38work because of Alenda. Yeah, but like they have and they're like,
- 35:43ah, what do you do gateway, Yeah, gateway gateway. So and
- 35:47he's stick car. That's the end of chapter twenty one. Chaff. In
- 36:07twenty two Ali is called podcast is brought to you by Instacart. It might
- 36:09be, but probably is Instacart. It's grocery shopping, but really expensive.
- 36:15It's more expensive. Chafter you should tip them? You should? You should.
- 36:20Chapter twenty two is called to make an anchor weep. That's the logo.
- 36:22What is it? It's Instacart. It's grocery shopping for when you're high.
- 36:29What was this? It's do you give a fuck about this logo?
- 36:35Okay, here's the thing. We'll get there. Hold on, yes,
- 36:38okay, we're there now. When I read this is the event of the
- 36:43chat, this is yeah. There is there anything else to talk about before
- 36:45we get started? No? No, I mean well, I could talk
- 36:47more about Great stump Gate, which is which is continues to rage on Twitter,
- 36:52the debate over whether or not I'm really happy I did this to you,
- 36:54whether or not it's actually and I love that this is a discussion that's
- 36:58taking place over whether or not the Great Stump takes place on a stump or
- 37:01not. You are very much having to defend the fact that you believe that
- 37:05it does not necessarily take See here's the thing. My perspective is the this
- 37:10is this is what I meant when I said this. The great stump refers
- 37:15to the meeting, not the place. Could it be both. It could
- 37:20also happen at a stump. Yes, The Big White Book of Bad Art
- 37:23does suggest that sometimes great tree stumps are used for meetings. What is the
- 37:30Big White Book of Big White Book of Bad Art is also known as the
- 37:36world of Robert Jordan's The Wheel of Time, and it was a It was
- 37:39a third party book that was commissioned by Tour after Book seven was published.
- 37:45I think it is written from an inn world called the Big White Book of
- 37:50Bad Art. It's called the Big White Book of Bad Art because the very
- 37:52talented artists who they commissioned to do art for this were told, you have
- 37:55five days to make like seventy five fucking drawings. Oh that's not enough,
- 38:00it's not enough. So the art in it is fine, but a lot
- 38:02of it is also like very rough and very early drafts and very early sketches
- 38:07that they basically shoehorned into this book. Yeah, yeah, yeah, And
- 38:10some of it's not bad. I mean, it's most called the Big White
- 38:14Book of Bad Art because it's like these poor people were basically put into into
- 38:17crunch to make I just feel like it's mean to the artists to say it's
- 38:22called the Big White Book of Bad Art, whereas I would feel like I
- 38:24should say the Big White Book of Yeah, yeah, you're right, and
- 38:30I feel like it's mean to listen. I'm just that's just the colloquial it's
- 38:35called the Big No. I just get very defensive of art and the arts
- 38:38because you are so mean to No, you're right, the art isn't bad.
- 38:42It's just rushed. I'm not I'm not yelling at anybody. I'm just
- 38:46saying I think the name is when the artists were set up to fail a
- 38:51little. That's true. So anyway, the Big White Book was committed.
- 38:54We have it, we have it. They reprinted it. Yes, yeah
- 38:59you are, because it was published after book eight, and it was I'm
- 39:01allowed to look at something written by Robert Jordan, and it is written from
- 39:07the perspective of an in world historian. And Robert Jordan deliberately didn't answer a
- 39:10lot of questions post to him because he wanted it to maintain an air of
- 39:15mystery. So it gets a bunch of stuff wrong, like explicitly explicitly gets
- 39:20a lot of stuff wrong that is directly contradicted in the books and is kind
- 39:23of viewed as like soft cannon because it's written by someone in world who was
- 39:28writing an in world history. Okay, they did that with like the book
- 39:32The House of the Dragon was based off of Yes, so in that book.
- 39:37Yeah, it suggests that because they say what happens in the show is
- 39:39actual canon and what happens in that book is soft cannon because it was like
- 39:43three five different historians. Yes, yeah, a bunch of masters, like
- 39:46some of whom are not actual historians because they're like according to like so and
- 39:50so on the street. Yeah, so so Robert. So the Big White
- 39:54Book says studdings have big old stumps. Sometimes they have meetings on them.
- 40:00At no point have I ever said, unless I'm wrong. At no point
- 40:05have I ever said the meeting of a great stump does not and can never
- 40:09take place on a stump. If I did say that, my bad,
- 40:15I didn't, I retract that. All I have meant is that the meeting
- 40:22the great stump refers to the meeting of people. The companion the encyclopedia,
- 40:27which I was like, it's something's wrong, but let's be real here was
- 40:30compiled in twenty twelve, thirteen fourteen. I don't know by Maria and the
- 40:36rest of Team Jordan, so I trust it. More says that stumps are
- 40:42the name for the meeting, doesn't mention anything about where they take place,
- 40:45and that great trees are only cut down if they die, and they almost
- 40:51never do so I think it is unlikely, based on this, that every
- 40:57single setting has a great tree stump that has been prepared and set aside for
- 41:01use for a meeting of a stump. I really do think that stump is
- 41:07just like from the political kind of stump speech, and because it's a tree
- 41:10term. Maybe they have them on great tree stumps. Maybe they don't.
- 41:14Y'all are fucking sick of me talking about this, so I'm gonna stop now.
- 41:16But that's that I think. Is that a stump? Okay, I
- 41:22just spell it's okay, it can be. It might be. I've never
- 41:24said it can't might I just I've just really enjoyed everybody going. I'm pretty
- 41:29sure it happens at a stump and you're like, why just gave you all
- 41:31this analysis as to why it Probably that's fine, by the way, it's
- 41:36fine. You can think we don't care. This is why what I'm saying
- 41:38is not. It can there's an objective wrong and an objective. But I
- 41:43do know that if I see Maria at jordan Con, I'm gonna ask her
- 41:45I want to record it deep that's lie. I think she'd be more than
- 41:49happy with that. If I see her jordan Con, I'm gonna say,
- 41:51Maria, can you answer your question for me about the Great stump and about
- 41:54stumps just because I'm curious now, because it's really hard to find a definitive
- 41:58answer. It is. Yeah, it is a lot of really exciting discussion
- 42:01about this. Anyway, going back to make an anchor weep, do you
- 42:06have any notes? No? Okay, So here's the chapter. It's the
- 42:09sea Folk. There's like there's like there's like seven and a half pages of
- 42:15the sea folk thinking about stuff. Yes, And I like Hereene. Herena
- 42:21is a fun character. Herena's cool. Herena is the sea folk that I
- 42:23give the most of a fuck about. Mm hmm. She's fun. Yeah,
- 42:27she's nice. She's got a lot of cool shit going on. I
- 42:31think she was done dirty by the sea folk when they busted her down to
- 42:36get fucked for the bargain. Well, she is prophesied to eventually be mistress
- 42:42of the ships. Well that's where I think it's gonna happen. Yeah.
- 42:44Uh, it just goes to show just because you have a career setback doesn't
- 42:49mean you won't be mistress of the ship. Yeah. Yeah, Yeah.
- 42:51And there's a wind and there everybody's like, holy shit, that's not a
- 42:54normal wind. It's a armin guidance is coming. A wind rows in the
- 42:59Yeah, he keeps doing this stuff where he's like, something strange happens and
- 43:01everybody goes, oh, the apocalypse. And then they continue about their day,
- 43:05which is that's so really like we all thought. I think that when
- 43:10things were that wild that you know, everything would stop, but it kind
- 43:16of just like keeps going in the weirdest way possible. So they go to
- 43:22a meeting of the twelve, the Council of twelve. What are you doing?
- 43:25I was seeing if my hair looked cute. Oh it does looks great.
- 43:29I like it very much. I think it's adorable. So they can't
- 43:32see it. They get a meeting of the Council of twelve and their meeting
- 43:37with Logane, and they have a whole this is fun. Actually forgot about
- 43:39this. They have a whole discussion about gateways on boats. Gateways on boats.
- 43:44Yeah, it's really hard to gateway to a boat. Oh that's right.
- 43:46That's why Sammarog was like stuck. That was your perception anyway. But
- 43:51they have a very hard time gateway onto boats. Well, now I feel
- 43:53like that's actually been proven, and like Logane gateways onto the boat, but
- 43:58he gateways a foot above the boat because otherwise it like cuts a hole in
- 44:00the deck. That would make sense. Yeah, but yeah no, see
- 44:06ha ha. Now you gotta start thinking maybe maybe you could do like tactical
- 44:14naval warfare and if you had somebody invading on a boat, get a chandler
- 44:16to open a bunch of little gateways in the water and just slice through their
- 44:21fucking holes. We were very lucky that you were a good person. This
- 44:23is this is the kind of shit Brandon Sanderson would get into. Probably yeah,
- 44:29oh no, is it the kind of shit that he does? Oh
- 44:30god, yeah, are you kidding me? In a magic system that has
- 44:35some rules. He's gonna fuck with it heavy. It's gonna be listen,
- 44:37a lot of people don't like it. I do anyway. I like when
- 44:42people with things. Yeah, what's wrong with fucking with things? So there's
- 44:45also a bunch of stuff about how like the isidie teacher with them is being
- 44:50cowed and like beaten all the time, or like, you know, why
- 44:52why are we beating people in the workplace or whatever like ankles or something and
- 44:59having a tear rible time. And yeah, anyway, we don't need to
- 45:01live bloom bloom balloom bloom. Yeah, the sea folk need to get their
- 45:07shit together and stop being so terrible at being bosses Sologane. It's very annoying
- 45:13to be like, oh, the sea pirate people who I want more than
- 45:17anything to be awesome are being the worst. Yes why yeah, yeah,
- 45:22I know, I just want them to be fun. Oh wow. Anyway,
- 45:27Logane shows up, I mean Logane shows up and he comes in to
- 45:30have a meeting. He's like, hey, you guys agreed to be the
- 45:32water taxi. I need you to be the water taxi. And they're like
- 45:36Jesus, dude, what a fucking ask. And he's like you said you
- 45:38would be the water taxi. It is the apocalypse, and you did do
- 45:44you kind of agreed to this, so like I need you to be the
- 45:46water They did agree to that, And it's Logane by the way, he's
- 45:51here, and uh wait, when we were on our honeymoon in Santa Burg
- 45:55where there was that little freaking tugboat that was so adorable, what was it
- 45:59called? Oh shit, little something, what was it called. It was
- 46:04this cute little like freaking water taxi boat. They had a little face on
- 46:07it. Oh god, it was so cute. I don't remember. That
- 46:10was a long time ago. Hold on, I'm looking it up. It
- 46:15had a funny name, little Too, little Toot. So, okay,
- 46:17you signed up to be little too. Yeah, so you gotta be a
- 46:21little too. There's a famine and I need you guys to help bring food
- 46:23up. And they're like, god damn, what a fucking thing to ask.
- 46:27And he's like, it's really not that much of a little thing to
- 46:30ask. I forgot about little Too. It's a little face. Gotta be
- 46:31a little too. You look up little toot, Santa Barbara. Yeah,
- 46:35it's got a little face on it, a little too. This episode is
- 46:37going to be called little toot, isn't it. Yeah, it's gonna be
- 46:39called little too. Yeah, all right, so they're a little too.
- 46:43So little toot is supposed to do their little toot and and then a little
- 46:46too. It's like, man, I don't want to do little too,
- 46:49and you know, like get to toot. Yeah, And they're like,
- 46:53hey, but where's the Corymore. We're supposed to have someone with him at
- 46:57all times. And they're like, he's kind of fending off assassination, so
- 47:00we're not really gonna tell you where he is. And they're like, bullshit,
- 47:02this is a violation, and get a little tootin and away. And
- 47:09Logane is like creepy towards Emilia, Saidai, And that's okay, all right?
- 47:16And who is creepy Logane? Why like this? This? This isid?
- 47:24I pours wine for she's completely fucking shattered because she's been being you know,
- 47:29abused by the sea folk for I don't know how long. And she
- 47:32pours wine for Logane and she's shaking like crazy and maybe he does, oh
- 47:37he doesn't. Actually, I don't know. It's not creepy. Sorry.
- 47:38Logane walked over to her and put his hands on hers to steady her.
- 47:42Was he one of those who could not leave others to do their own work?
- 47:44And he goes, you have nothing to fear for me, I said,
- 47:45I it's been a long time since I ate anyone for breakfast. She
- 47:49stared up at him with her mouth hanging open, as though uncertain whether he
- 47:52was making a joke. So, I don't know, he's not actually being
- 47:55creepy. I think he's being like, chill out. Oh, it's kind
- 47:59of hard to tell, like he might be making a joke. I don't
- 48:00think he's being creepy. I think he's being a nice guy in this moment.
- 48:02I can't really tell. I guess you could read it either way.
- 48:06Yeah you could. Yeah, And I mean Logane has not been you know,
- 48:10he also like the best lately. Admittedly, when he shows up,
- 48:15he sees her and he's like, yo, which side of the tower schism
- 48:17are you on? And the sea folk are like, she's on the getting
- 48:21her ass beaten by the sea folks side of the tower schism, So neither
- 48:24fuck you. I don't like the way the sea folk. I don't think
- 48:31it's so unfortunate because I want them to be exciting and they're introduced is a
- 48:37really cool Yeah, I personally really don't enjoy reading about them at this part
- 48:45in the book because all they really do is like hit teachers, and I
- 48:53can't support and like not want to help. And admittedly, no, here's
- 48:59the thing. Yeah, they're going through some fucking shit. They absolutely are.
- 49:02With the fucking the Escape. I skipped over this. They have a
- 49:06whole thing where they talk about the Escape because they were you know, they
- 49:08were based in the fucking West and the sea in the West and a full
- 49:12Shawn chamionships. Yeah, they're going through it, absolut fucko lutely. Why
- 49:15wouldn't you want to help more? You'd think, you know, what,
- 49:20do you want to be? Like, uh, free us. It's from
- 49:22our from this bullshit, it is, we will help with whatever. It
- 49:25is distressing to me that the sea folk in particular are really written to be
- 49:30just like, very selfish and petty, and I just don't like it.
- 49:36You don't like the fact that the canonical black people are written to be selfish
- 49:39and passed. And I know that's not intentional. I know it's not,
- 49:43but it just makes me feel really awkward. It's it makes me feel so
- 49:50uncomfy. Yeah, it does. It makes me feel a little uncomfy.
- 49:54Yeah, and again I know that's not that's not that's not, but it
- 49:58just happens to be how it reads it. Yes, so it makes me
- 50:01uncomfy. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I just here's okay. Now we're
- 50:07at the thing. Now we're at the thing. So so this this this,
- 50:10this woman comes in and is like, yeah, we have literally the
- 50:15worst news ever. The news is genuinely quite upsetting. Okay, yeah,
- 50:20and I did, Okay, here's the thing I did. I was like,
- 50:23that is very sad. Yes, I did think that the news Okay,
- 50:28before before anyone comes for me, I did. I read that and
- 50:32I was like, oh, yeah, that is very sad. The news
- 50:35is you remember the amaiar vaguely because I said that they were going to jonestown
- 50:39themselves. Well they did. Yes, that's it, they did. Yes,
- 50:44that is that is sorry to use jonestown as a verb, no,
- 50:45of course. Yeah, And we're not making the light of jonestown. No.
- 50:47Of course. That was a horrible, horrific thing. And Heaven's Gate
- 50:52was a horrible, horrific thing. And I think that was the inspiration,
- 50:53maybe partially for almost certainly this this stuff, and so I also so get
- 51:00Robert Jordan's emotional attachment to this moment. Yeah. My thought process is,
- 51:07I think Robert Jordan is a brilliant world builder. He has a lot of
- 51:13world building. I think that happens also in his head and in his notes.
- 51:16And I have done this as a writer as well, where like something
- 51:22really means something to me, but it's because you are with it for so
- 51:28long and ruminating over it for so long. Granted, this was like a
- 51:34good moment. It is a good moment, you know, it's it's it's
- 51:37it's well written, it's moving to read about. However, Yeah, and
- 51:40I feel like even moving is the wrong word, because it's like, these
- 51:44are the kinds of consequences to something like this that I think people don't think
- 51:51about until they happen. And so I do think. I think that this
- 51:59is a realistic thing that could happen, right, and I think it's a
- 52:04devastating thing. I think that unfortunately, and I know that Robert Jordan has
- 52:09said some things about the fact that, well, do you want to explain
- 52:14it a little bout? So here's a little context on why. For people
- 52:15who are like casual readers of the book, which most people are, and
- 52:20don't know the context around this. Robert Jordan prior to the release of Book
- 52:24eleven and Ali I talked to Ali about this after she read this. Prior
- 52:29to the release of Book eleven, Robert Jordan reached out to like Dragon Mounts
- 52:32and some other folks and was like, Hey, there's a gasp moment in
- 52:37book eleven that it sheds like new light on the consequences of something from a
- 52:43previous book. And it's it's going to be like, oh my god,
- 52:45that happened moment. It's gonna be like a really big thing. And so
- 52:49there's a lot of speculation as to what that moment would be, and it's
- 52:52this, it's the Amayar culture destroying itself. And is that terrible? Of
- 53:00course it is. That said, when people were confused as to what the
- 53:07moment was, Robert Jordan was surprised. I'll leave it at that. I
- 53:13would I would say he was upset by him. He was, he was
- 53:16pretty he was pretty irritating. And yeah, I have a couple thoughts about
- 53:20it, just from a writing perspective, and obviously he's a wonderful writer and
- 53:25He's an incredible world builder. And I have had many moments in which I
- 53:30am very emotionally invested in what I'm writing and in my head because I spent
- 53:36so much time with it, it it develops this sense of importance that doesn't
- 53:44always translate yeah right, and that can be really upsetting as a writer to
- 53:51have happen because you know in your brain this this is a gasp moment,
- 53:55or this is really wild or whatever, and the person reading it, who
- 54:00unfortunately the victim of this is often Gus for me, is not is like
- 54:06I didn't I didn't see the connections to like this moment remind me who this
- 54:12person is? Right, And you're like, how could you not know how
- 54:15important they are? And then you look back and you realize you haven't necessarily
- 54:19put in the bread crumbs for that. Now here's the thing, and he
- 54:23part of his upset, a part of the expression of his upset. And
- 54:28I, Liz, I've had many outbursts at Gus over you know, him
- 54:34not getting something. And then later I, you know, realized that Gus
- 54:37only says these things to help, right, but or you know, to
- 54:42ask to probe further because you get very attached to your work, and you
- 54:46get very attached to things, and so sometimes it's hard not to like get
- 54:50a little, you know, emotionally invested in the thing you have to be
- 54:54emotionally invested in. But then you put out in the world and you're like,
- 54:58now criticize this thing that's my bab baby. Yeah, especially you know
- 55:00in this case, when you've been telling me my baby is ugly, like
- 55:04you know, when you've been working on it for eighteen plus and it's not
- 55:06even that it's not that a baby is ugly. I was like, oh,
- 55:08wow, you know that's you know, he really went there and that's
- 55:13that's a hard thing to read about. But I think he said, oh,
- 55:19I think it's that people are desensitized to this kind of stuff and that's
- 55:22why it didn't seem like a big deal. Yeah. I believe the specific
- 55:24terminology he used was if if you did not consider this a gas moment,
- 55:30you have my sympathies, which, first of all, okay, small side
- 55:36thing. I think that if a woman writer had said something like that,
- 55:39she would have been crucified. I agree with you. So I do think
- 55:43there is like just I just want to acknowledge for a minute that he has
- 55:47the privileged ability to be upset at the reception of his work in a way
- 55:52that I don't think people of color or women have. Yeah, I would
- 55:57agree with that, and so I just want to acknowledge that absolutely as like
- 56:00a thing where when you read that to me, I was like, whoa,
- 56:04because I understand where those feelings come from. But like, as a
- 56:09woman writer, that would have to be an inside thought for me, right,
- 56:13you know, And so I was kind of like, huh, I
- 56:17think that that is really interesting. But then also as an additional thing,
- 56:23I think because I obviously empathize with how he must feel good. Yeah,
- 56:29Yeah, that's something that was very moving to him, was not necessarily received
- 56:32by everyone he's that was moving. He describes the process of writing this as
- 56:37like he had to put the pen down, he had to get up a
- 56:39few times. And I completely understand that for him, having built this culture
- 56:45and having a really rich understanding of who the Amayr are, what the Amayar
- 56:51do essentially, like from what I remember from the two ish paragraphs we've heard
- 56:59about them, they're this idyllic, pacifistic society that makes porcelain right, and
- 57:05that's beautiful, and it is terrible. It is it's sad. Yeah,
- 57:10it is sad. I was sad. I think that for me, I
- 57:15don't agree that this is an indication of our desensitization to violence. I think
- 57:21that a lot of the time people like to point to things and go,
- 57:23we are desensitized to violence. La da da da da da dah. And
- 57:27I think that is a very generalized assumption to make, because I certainly am
- 57:31not no in a way that I'm like, I wish I were a little
- 57:37bit more because it's hard sometimes for me as a person to get through the
- 57:42day because of how heavy the world can feel sometimes, right like I see
- 57:49a dog that needs help on Instagram and and my day is like about then
- 57:54like following up until I see that that dog has been saved. Yeah,
- 58:00like I need, you know, when these shelters because they're all over crowded
- 58:04right now, or like putting out these you know, please help things,
- 58:07I you know, all that stuff, or hell, like the humanitarian crises
- 58:13that are happening right now. I don't think that the general human response to
- 58:17any of that has been apathy. So regardless of whether or not you think
- 58:24that's true, I think that the majority of the conversation that I have had,
- 58:29at least with the people that I've surrounded myself with, no one feels
- 58:31apathetic toward the cruelty and violence that is happening in the world. Yeah,
- 58:37what's no one that I know and care to associate with. And I'm sure
- 58:43there are people, right of course, But like I think that the general
- 58:49public does not feel this way. So when I read this section, I
- 58:58was saddened, right because death is sad and if I were to fear of
- 59:05that in the real world, Because of course, I have been alive and
- 59:09continue to be alive during some pretty horrific times, right, Like, pretty
- 59:15horrific things have happened while I've been alive that have wrecked me emotionally, and
- 59:17I have not known a single person involved, even remotely involved. Right.
- 59:23But I think we have to keep in mind as writers that part of our
- 59:30job, because these people are fictional, is to make them feel so real
- 59:35that we care about what happens to them even though they're not real. Because
- 59:38the thing where the hurdle we're always overcoming is these people are not real,
- 59:44right, and so we have to flesh them out with flaws and personalities and
- 59:50details, right, that make them feel like people we might know. And
- 59:55that's why people get so impassioned about like book adaptation. They feel real to
- 1:00:02you. They are real to you. They're specific friends in some way only
- 1:00:07only you perceive every every Again, I've said it before, and I've gotten
- 1:00:12into philosophical debates about storytelling, but I think every time you consume, especially
- 1:00:16a book, it's different. Oh yeah, right, my my understanding of
- 1:00:21the book is different from allies, is different from your as a listener.
- 1:00:23Yeah. Well, it's interesting. Your mom and I were on a walk
- 1:00:25today because Gus's parents are residing. Yeah, and we had this whole conversation
- 1:00:29about you know. She was like, we were talking about you know,
- 1:00:32writing versus acting, and how like you were making discoveries about your play the
- 1:00:38morning of the closing performance and which completely changed how certain scenes felt that night.
- 1:00:46Yeah. And she was like, oh, how interesting that, Like
- 1:00:50that is a you know, living, breathing thing all the time. It
- 1:00:52must be different with writing. And I was like, well, in some
- 1:00:54ways yes, And I said that in other ways no, because because every
- 1:01:01time someone interacts with it, it changes. Yeah, And so you know,
- 1:01:06there are perceptions of it and its importance and the moments that happen and
- 1:01:10the relatability of the characters. It is always different. Yeah, and so
- 1:01:15you know, I if I can springboard off with that to give it give
- 1:01:19kind of an example of how artistic interpretation can change how the art is interpreted.
- 1:01:27Even more than that, I would point to a street car name Desire,
- 1:01:31because for those of you who are familiar with Tennessee Williams Work, for
- 1:01:37this you who are not familiar Tennsee Williams Works. Street Name Desire is a
- 1:01:39play about these two sisters, Blanche and Stella. Du bois from the South
- 1:01:45because it's Tennessee, Williams is all the South, and Stella is married to
- 1:01:50this fairly beastly man named Stanley, and Blanche is fairly well to do woman,
- 1:01:54sister of theirs, who comes into town and there's friction. This is
- 1:01:59a short version, and as written, Stanley is basically a gorilla of a
- 1:02:05man. He's just a brute. He's mean, he's loud mouthed, he's
- 1:02:08angry, he yells and he hits stuff, and then Marlon fucking Brando gets
- 1:02:15his hands on it, and he goes, no, he's not. He
- 1:02:17is a monstrous, brutish person, but he is also basically a child.
- 1:02:23He like reduces him in that Stella scene to like basically he's also like way
- 1:02:28pitiable and he's he's you know, in some ways Scott, you can feel
- 1:02:35compassion for him and you you care about him to a certain extent, And
- 1:02:38yeah, he does monstrous, monstrous things, changed how people it forever completely
- 1:02:45reinvented the character for the rest ye ever, because if you do Streetcar with
- 1:02:51Stanley just being a brute, it's unwatchable because he's just terrible. But if
- 1:02:54you do Streetcar the way Brando interpreted it, he's a bad guy, but
- 1:03:00oh he's a horrific he's fucking bad guy, a horrific person. But he's
- 1:03:04so complicated, he's so engrossing and interesting and you just want to know what's
- 1:03:08going on with him and with them that it's Oh and Blanche is like an
- 1:03:15incredibly complex as well. And then Stella becomes, by comparison, incredibly complex
- 1:03:20because she's torn between this man who is is horrible to her but also needs
- 1:03:25her so badly, Yeah, who is helpless without her as it were,
- 1:03:29Yes, and then she has a sister who also needs her so badly,
- 1:03:32and Stella is just caught in this cyclone of need so and she is like
- 1:03:38battered about by these two emotional vampires essentially, and then it becomes a fascinating
- 1:03:45show to watch because eventually one of the emotional vampires essentially consumes the other.
- 1:03:50Yeah, hot take Tennessee Williams pretty good writer. Yeah, because I believe
- 1:03:54that both of them are emotional vampires. I think they're both like contestable,
- 1:04:00contemptible people but also at the same time really damaged in a way where you're
- 1:04:08like, it's hard because it's like, I think this is what really good
- 1:04:13characters do. Is it's like even I mean, this is what I say
- 1:04:16about Rand. Rand does some horrific fucking stuff, but he's a complicated person.
- 1:04:20Yeah, right, And so yeah, people feel very passionately about these
- 1:04:24characters. Is they're like, yes, they do bad things sometimes, but
- 1:04:28like they also are pitiable in so many ways. Yeah, And I think
- 1:04:32that's going back to the ami Are. While I have no doubt that Robert
- 1:04:38Jordan has an enormous wealth of knowledge about the ami Are, for whatever reason,
- 1:04:42he chose not to share most of it with us, And that doesn't
- 1:04:45mean that you can't still feel sympathy and feel bad for them, but it
- 1:04:47does mean that it's not going to necessarily carry the same I mean, how
- 1:04:53many people have died on page that we don't know the names of. Well
- 1:04:56here's the thing, yeah, I think, yeah, yeah, And I
- 1:05:00think here's the thing for me is that when these kinds of large scale tragedies
- 1:05:04happen in real life, right, you know that each one of those people
- 1:05:13was a real person with a family and dreams and you know, just like
- 1:05:20you. And that's what's so fucked up about these like about any tragedy,
- 1:05:25right. But and so when you read about them, and so when I
- 1:05:29read about them and I see them, and I see the manifestations, I
- 1:05:32see how devastated the community is and the family is, and yeah, I
- 1:05:36mean that's that's the overwhelmed for me. And that's the fuck for me.
- 1:05:45And unfortunately, the thing to get over is the fact that we can have
- 1:05:49some separation from fictionalized events because they're fiction and we know their fiction. There's
- 1:05:55a safety in the fiction. Yeah, And so you have to make the
- 1:06:00those people and the things that they go through feel real enough that it feels
- 1:06:06like a human life has been snuffed out when they pass, or that something
- 1:06:12horrific has happened, well, like like I mean to use something that is
- 1:06:15mentioned in this these chapters when rand tries to resuscitate the little girl and Book
- 1:06:20four exactly that to me. Though I did not know that girl, there
- 1:06:27was enough detail about her to make her feel so real. I also think
- 1:06:31that we as a human race, because of the way that we're built,
- 1:06:35right, we have a difficult time with large scale things because it's so big,
- 1:06:43it's so beyond our capacity to really understand what those numbers actually look like
- 1:06:47and mean, right, like what a tragedy of that scale could possibly even
- 1:06:53like we can't contextualize that, we can't conceptualize that at all. It's difficult
- 1:06:59for our rents. So for me, the little girl, that was a
- 1:07:02personal, like very clear moment, and she had there was a details about
- 1:07:08her, like the way that she was dressed. Yeah, she looked like
- 1:07:12she felt real because there was enough detail about her to feel real. And
- 1:07:16I think that I would disagree very gently with Robert Jordan that this is not
- 1:07:21some sign that we are unable to I don't necessarily think it was a failing
- 1:07:28on his part as a writer, because I know for him, because it's
- 1:07:30true for me. When I am writing, these people feel real to me.
- 1:07:34Absolutely, they feel so real to me. I hear them in my
- 1:07:39head well and again like my I see them in my eyes. The thing
- 1:07:43I always go back to is I wrote a play once about imminent famine,
- 1:07:47and I was asked by my mentor at the time, reread it and count
- 1:07:53how many times you mention imminent famine, because to me, the entire play
- 1:07:57was about imminent famine. I mentioned it twice. Yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 1:08:00because in your mind right, because you are engrossed in it. And
- 1:08:04that's why editors and executives do exist. It's to help, hopefully at their
- 1:08:11best right what their intended purpose is. You know, of course there is
- 1:08:16always some friction and some feelings, but their intended purpose is to help the
- 1:08:21writer have an external view of what their work is. And this is why
- 1:08:29you are the first person always that reads my work, you know, because
- 1:08:31you are my first editor always, because you know what my process is and
- 1:08:38you understand stuff. But yes, and you know what you know what the
- 1:08:42scale of my work can be, and what my goals are and all that
- 1:08:45stuff, and you can tell me whether or not that's been accomplished. But
- 1:08:48like I think, I think here it did impact me. I think that
- 1:08:56I am also someone who is very easily impacted. Sure, and I can
- 1:09:01see why he was impacted in such a profound way by this moment, and
- 1:09:08I can understand why there were people who were very impacted by this moment.
- 1:09:12I can also understand and don't think that it is necessarily a moral failing of
- 1:09:18the people that didn't. Does that makes sense? There's a hot nuance to
- 1:09:23that For me. I read this and I went, who oh, that
- 1:09:26sucks. Yeah, And I think that is because you are not, by
- 1:09:30like far from an unfeeling person, right, you are not. I've never
- 1:09:35ever thought to describe you as some sort of like unfeeling cold hearted. Yeah,
- 1:09:43you know, you know, you are very emotionally intelligent and very in
- 1:09:47touch with your feelings. But I think that there may have been more on
- 1:09:57the part of the writer in terms of of how often and how invested we
- 1:10:02were in this group of people. I feel like, unfortunately to have the
- 1:10:10amount of impact that he wanted to have, because it was impactful, but
- 1:10:15I feel like the heart wrenching thing, I think we needed to know some
- 1:10:21of them more than one more than we see, for we see for very
- 1:10:26a very short period of time, and we really don't know learn much about
- 1:10:30I think in order to conceptualize that level of tragedy, because we as a
- 1:10:35specie, we just we shut down a lot of the tides. There's something
- 1:10:41that huge, it's just our brains cannot handle it. Yeah, it's too
- 1:10:44much, it's too much, it's too much. And like obviously there are
- 1:10:48a lot of moments like that where it just becomes too much. And I
- 1:10:54think that in order to make it so that the scope of that is not
- 1:11:00so much that people like you, who are very emotionally intelligent in touch with
- 1:11:02their emotions kind of shut down and go, okay, you know, I
- 1:11:08think we had to know some of them, yeah, and we had to
- 1:11:10like have spent more time with them, honestly. And here's what I'm not
- 1:11:15saying when I'm saying this, Yes, what I'm not saying is kill the
- 1:11:19group of people that are canonically black. I want to make that very very
- 1:11:24clear before I say this. Yes, but in terms of the emotional investment
- 1:11:28and the amount of time we have spent with them, I think that unfortunately
- 1:11:33Indian, Yeah, yeah, you know people of color. Canonically, I
- 1:11:38don't want to be like kill this group, you know, and it's like,
- 1:11:40no, that's not what I'm saying. But what I'm saying is in
- 1:11:42terms of the amount of time and investment and knowledge about this group of people
- 1:11:48that makes them feel fleshed out and real to us, the c Folk are
- 1:11:56are a group that I feel like we've spent enough time with that if something
- 1:12:00like that were to have happened, I think it would have had that emotional
- 1:12:02impact. Well, you were a branch of the a eel An entire the
- 1:12:08whole plan, you know, the ones who ran off, they all some
- 1:12:11of them do, right, Yeah, But I'm like, you know,
- 1:12:15I think that if the entire Shydough then just decided they were done, that's
- 1:12:23well. I think also for people we got to know, granted they weren't
- 1:12:27our favorites, but we still got to know them as complex people. To
- 1:12:30your point about the sea folk, I think that had he chosen to do
- 1:12:35that, the fact that the sea folk are unfortunately really annoying to read about
- 1:12:41would have made it even more upsetting, because it's the kind of thing where
- 1:12:44you're like, oh my god, we have to deal with these people.
- 1:12:45Oh my god, we have to deal with Oh no, no, no,
- 1:12:48no, no no, bring him back? Yeah, not like that,
- 1:12:50not like that? Yeah, right, Yeah, I think yeah,
- 1:12:56I think I understand what he was doing. And I understand also, right
- 1:13:00that he was living at a time where he saw he saw those incredible tragedies
- 1:13:08that this is referencing happened live. Yeah, he was like twenty somethings,
- 1:13:11right, and those So I'm sure that this resonated with him in a very
- 1:13:15personal way reading about those things happening. Yes, he's horrific, right,
- 1:13:19And so I can imagine the amount of emotional investment that he had in those
- 1:13:26things too. I think that, And I understand that in his brain,
- 1:13:30right, he had spent enough time with them in his brain that they felt
- 1:13:33real to him. Yeah, But I think, yeah, I think there
- 1:13:39that because they are fictional, there is a hurdle to overcome of like their
- 1:13:44fictional So this is safe. Yeah, we need to if we're going to
- 1:13:47do this, I think it's got to feel like these were people we knew.
- 1:13:54Yeah, because when these mass tragedies happen, kind of the first thing
- 1:14:00that happens is we learn about those people so that we understand that these were
- 1:14:05people we could know because the numbers on the page. Unfortunately, Like,
- 1:14:10there's reasons why these museums exist and why there are entire accounts on social media
- 1:14:15dedicated to educating people about this, and why we continue to give specific examples
- 1:14:21of people that perish in these tragedies and stuff over and over and over again
- 1:14:27so that we can learn about them and learn about them in a way where
- 1:14:30we're like, we will never do this to each other again, right,
- 1:14:33and we will never participate in this kind of behavior again, Because then it
- 1:14:38feels real numbers on a page do not mean anything to us because we cannot
- 1:14:45in our brains conceptualize that kind of tragedy. We can't until we personalize it.
- 1:14:50And so I just feel like it's not a moral failing of the readers
- 1:14:57that they did not see what he's saw if there are readers who did.
- 1:15:01And you know, I definitely was like, oh, that's upsetting, and
- 1:15:05I can understand why the characters on the page ri upset, But I think
- 1:15:10for the emotional depth of I think partially it's it's the hyping up of like
- 1:15:15I had to walk away from the screen or from the page. Yeah,
- 1:15:19Unfortunately. I don't think didn't self any favors with well because I think then
- 1:15:24calling it a gasp, the what the anticipation was like min dies right well,
- 1:15:29and the other thing was he was like he I believe part of his
- 1:15:33intention with this was to be like, even the victories aren't always victories because
- 1:15:38they died as a result of the cleansing. But unless you paid really close
- 1:15:42attention to one paragraph at the end of Winter's Heart and tied it into this
- 1:15:46two and a half published books later, you will not make that connection.
- 1:15:50Well, I think he did that very effectively with Demai as wells. Yeah,
- 1:15:54you know, I think he did that very effectively. Granted, there
- 1:15:56are some people that I do think misread that situation, but you know,
- 1:16:01I mean we can't you know, spoon feed it to everybody, but you
- 1:16:05know, people are going to, like we said, interpret things how they're
- 1:16:09going to interpret. And can I make a side note, I saw this
- 1:16:12great TikTok that I think encapsulates my feelings about people will be like uugh,
- 1:16:19sometimes you know this chair is just purple. Like English teachers, we don't
- 1:16:25need to and we don't need to get into this analysis because sometimes the chair
- 1:16:29is just purple, and the writers wanted the chair to be purple, and
- 1:16:30that is true, and I think we have said that a few times on
- 1:16:32this podcast, that maybe he just wanted it to be purple. But like,
- 1:16:36what I don't mean by that, and what I think this captured really
- 1:16:41well was what English teachers are trying to teach you, right, because yes,
- 1:16:45oftentimes the chair is just purple, but that might not be true.
- 1:16:50Sometimes the chair is purple to represent royalty, right. Sometimes the chair is
- 1:16:56purple because of the purple flower in the previous because there's a motif happening,
- 1:17:02right. Sometimes the chair is purple because you know, of you know,
- 1:17:09a trauma that keeps getting repeated, right, whatever it is, And the
- 1:17:15point of the analysis is to teach us that sometimes the chair is purple for
- 1:17:19a reason. Yeah, anyway, that's that's a thing for me where I'm
- 1:17:25like, you know, sometimes we joke about like, you know, sometimes
- 1:17:27the chair is just purple, you know, when we're kind of going into
- 1:17:30deep things, but like this is we also are looking at these things in
- 1:17:36a deeper way as well, where like, yeah, sometimes the chairs just
- 1:17:40purple. But in this particular instance, he is clearly trying to say something
- 1:17:43about the broader nature of like there are still victims even in victory. Yeah,
- 1:17:47right, and he has made that point repeatedly. I think that there
- 1:17:53was a small disconnect for making that impactful for more people, because there were
- 1:18:00clearly still some people that missed it. And I think his response, because
- 1:18:03he was emotionally invested, was to get defensive, which is not uncommon.
- 1:18:10As somebody who has worked with many writers, sometimes you need to have a
- 1:18:14fuck you moment. And I get that, right, because like, the
- 1:18:17work's not good if we don't care. But I do think also Robert Jordan
- 1:18:21had the luxury of being able to do this as a white man. Yeah,
- 1:18:26that's true. You know, I do not think that is Female writers
- 1:18:30get to get away with this in the same way where they get defensive and
- 1:18:32upset that people don't see what they're inscially, you're wrong about that, that's
- 1:18:36true. So there's a lot to unpack with that, with what happened with
- 1:18:41this moment. And I'm not saying that Robert Jordan was wrong or bad for
- 1:18:45reacting this way. He's a person with feelings who wrote a scene he really
- 1:18:51liked, he really liked, and some people didn't connect with yeah, and
- 1:18:55he was really like looking forward to seeing how people responded, and they didn't
- 1:18:59respond how he wanted it. That's really fucking hard as an artist when that
- 1:19:02happens, it sucks. It sucks, and I've had it happen, and
- 1:19:05every artist has had it happen, and it sucks, and it's like,
- 1:19:10it's hard not to feel fuck you about it, really really hard. And
- 1:19:14so I'm looking at this, but I promise my most generous heart where I'm
- 1:19:17like he is, you know, I can I can feel from the statement
- 1:19:24that he made about it that you read to me the hurt that he feels.
- 1:19:27And I am like, I have been fucking there right. I'm like,
- 1:19:32it is nice for you as a person that has also, by the
- 1:19:38way, a big, bigger career behind him, because I also don't think
- 1:19:41in early career writer could do this. I'm like, that is it's kind
- 1:19:45of nice for you that you got to have this moment in your career you
- 1:19:48got upset and it didn't really have a lasting consequence for you. Also,
- 1:19:53it reminds me a little bit of There's a forward that Stephen Erickson wrote for
- 1:19:58the tenth anniversary of Gardens of the Moon, which is a horrible introduction to
- 1:20:05Steven Erickson Mal's that book The Fallen, where essentially he says, like people
- 1:20:10told me that this book was too complicated, and I said, maybe you're
- 1:20:13not fucking reading hard enough. Basically, like it comes across as this really
- 1:20:16really pretentious diatribe, almost against publishing, and it's completely out of character and
- 1:20:25out of step with everything else I've ever read the man saying or writing.
- 1:20:30And it feels genuinely like he was mad at his publishers for turning down his
- 1:20:33books for twenty years, so he wrote a little bit of a fuck you
- 1:20:36and then accidentally sent it in to be the foreword. And I don't know,
- 1:20:42man, I just some of some of this reminds me of that a
- 1:20:45little bit, and it's like this, this is this is you had to
- 1:20:46you had to get something out. The thing is that artists are people,
- 1:20:49yep, and have feelings. And I think what I always kind of cringe
- 1:20:56at, which is why I said the thing about the Bad Book of Art
- 1:21:00is because I am an artist. I think about the artist that was really
- 1:21:04excited to get that opportunity and then had to do the best they could with
- 1:21:09a very very limited timeframe, and it's like I have been there too.
- 1:21:14I have been there, and it's hard and it's sad, and it's like
- 1:21:17you want to do such a good job and then to have people then.
- 1:21:20And that's not to say you can't have opinions about art and stuff, but
- 1:21:24there is a certain extent to which I feel like there's a gleefulness at you
- 1:21:30know, at at tearing down Oh god, yeah, artists, and you
- 1:21:34don't got to do that. You don't got to do all that, and
- 1:21:38you nothing is going to connect with everyone, and yeah, so there are
- 1:21:43people out there that I'm sure read that and we're upset and we're moved by
- 1:21:47it. And I think I definitely felt I don't I did not walk away,
- 1:21:54you know. I think I think when I read it, I was
- 1:21:57like, I think there could have been some more time spent with these people
- 1:22:01to flesh them out and really make their absence feel like a whole yeah,
- 1:22:06or befelt frankly, beyond the fact that the sea folk go, oh,
- 1:22:11we need to go do something about that. And that is purely because of
- 1:22:14the safety of fiction, yea. And so the job is to make people
- 1:22:16feel unsafe, yeah, you know that these do feel like real people,
- 1:22:21and like if we don't see them ever again, that is a tragedy.
- 1:22:25Yeah. So, and I think that is like the magic that is that
- 1:22:30is making things is I mean how I got so gleeful because I was like,
- 1:22:35I'm going to watch my husband play pretend the hardest and the best of
- 1:22:40anyone who's ever played pretend in their life. And that's really what we're doing,
- 1:22:44because we're playing pretend really hard in front of people. That's the thing
- 1:22:47too, is you know, we say, you say earlier, oh,
- 1:22:53it could have been the sea folk, and that's not even because it has
- 1:22:56plot significance. It's just because we know them. If the c folk decided
- 1:23:00to do this, and then okay, Rand dispatches the Ilianors or the fucking
- 1:23:06whoever then and but then even if you can pick up the plower let,
- 1:23:12it was like still like, oh my god, that whole those people who
- 1:23:15we have spent books getting to know, they're gone now forever. Yeah,
- 1:23:19And that's the thing is I feel like I feel like that's that would have
- 1:23:26pushed that to what he envisioned. Yeah, I think so for more people.
- 1:23:30Yeah, you know, I feel like then that would have really been
- 1:23:34a gas moment for me. God. Yeah, And that's having the luxury
- 1:23:40right of having distance and having seen the reaction from people. Yeah. Again,
- 1:23:44if if it had not been for Robert Jordan's specific discourse about this online,
- 1:23:49I wouldn't be talking about it. I would I would have been like,
- 1:23:51oh, yeah, this thing that happens anyway, and it was upsetting.
- 1:23:55It is. But I think it's just like there's specifically from the author,
- 1:23:59was so much fur almost there's the wrong word, so much passionate about
- 1:24:05this that I think it really merits a little bit of time to be to
- 1:24:09kind of stop down and examine well and considering. Okay, And here's the
- 1:24:12other thing, is considering everything that he went through because I imagine, and
- 1:24:19I can only use my my empathetic brain, right, I can only use
- 1:24:25my imagination here. But that is, you know, gently what I've signed
- 1:24:30up to do for my career. So I hope I do it well.
- 1:24:34I imagine and I have read that there is a real disconnect with people who
- 1:24:40experience the level of violence that he has experienced in his life right as a
- 1:24:45soldier, with the average everyday citizen that coming home is a surreal experience,
- 1:24:50especially post Vietnam our soldiers. And so I feel like when I when I
- 1:24:58he's spoken about that, Yeah, that there is a very surreal experience there
- 1:25:03that a lot of people had a very difficult time overcoming. He talks about,
- 1:25:08you know, how he had to He talks about that picture that he
- 1:25:11has of a soldier, which is clearly him. Yeah, I think eating
- 1:25:15eating next to his ex bos a dead body, and he says, I
- 1:25:18killed that man and I buried him six feet under a crossroads outside Sygone because
- 1:25:21he couldn't come back exactly. Yeah. And so I imagine too that that
- 1:25:29there does feel that you have a relationship to violence and are affected by violence
- 1:25:34and the mention of violence because you have seen it in a way that other
- 1:25:40people can only imagine and often don't bring themselves to imagine. Yeah. Right,
- 1:25:47So the subject matter is also something very close to him, yes,
- 1:25:51right, in a way that is not that it is not to the average
- 1:25:56citizen, right, Like Vietnam was really the first war or where we actually
- 1:26:00got to see as a general public the results of what war looked like.
- 1:26:06Right, Usually it was like goodbye boys when you get back and hope you're
- 1:26:12not too traumatized, right, And if you are, there is no assistance
- 1:26:16for you, like you know, and so, and we're going to have
- 1:26:19all of these people completely unprepared for how to treat you when you get home.
- 1:26:26So I imagine right that in his mind, the things he sees because
- 1:26:32of the things he has seen, is much much different than the average person
- 1:26:39reading these books, right, who has not seen that level of violence.
- 1:26:43Well, hopefully hopefully you have not seen that level of violence. I would
- 1:26:46hope for you do might as wells for instance, Yes, right, that
- 1:26:50is something that like clearly came from a place, Right, clearly came from
- 1:26:57a deep place in his mind. I like, you know, I read
- 1:27:00to my as well as a particular way. I know a lot of people
- 1:27:03read it differently, but I read it. I read it in a very
- 1:27:06particular, very very distressing way. Yes, And so I think for him,
- 1:27:13the subject matter, too, of a mass tragedy of this kind,
- 1:27:17is a very different thing for him because because in his imagination, his imagination
- 1:27:24is closer to what reality would be. Yeah, you know, yeah,
- 1:27:27and so Yeah, I think I don't necessarily think this was a failure for
- 1:27:31him, And I don't necessarily think this was a failure for the people who
- 1:27:35didn't feel this way. I think that it is what happens in art,
- 1:27:41which is that different life experiences don't always mash Yeah right, Yeah, that
- 1:27:46makes sense to you, makes sense to me, So yeah, I think.
- 1:27:50I mean, it's a really complicated thing making things that other people then
- 1:27:57consume you are you are taking you You are basically flaying yourself alive in front
- 1:28:01of people and then asking them to pour salt on it. Yeah, pretty
- 1:28:04much. It's I had a whole discussion with a friend of mine the other
- 1:28:09day who is going through kind of a crisis of faith with her art.
- 1:28:13Yeah. Right, she's a brilliant actress, And she said to me,
- 1:28:18what are we doing this for? Why are we doing this? It's horrible?
- 1:28:24Because sometimes it does feel horrible, right, making things as much as
- 1:28:28it seems like fun. Like she was like, I was reading interviews of
- 1:28:31Margot Robbie and what she went through to make Barbie and that's a fun movie.
- 1:28:36And she was like, and she went through it, and she was
- 1:28:40like, what is it for? Like, what are we doing this for?
- 1:28:43Why are we sacrificial lambs for other people? Why do we have to
- 1:28:45go through trauma in front of other people, and like, why do we
- 1:28:49have to like reveal ourselves to other people? She had this whole amazing monologue
- 1:28:55to me about it, which I was like, you know, talking to
- 1:28:59artists is always just like damn, they just say things and you're like fuck
- 1:29:03and I and I said to her, it's worth it, and she said,
- 1:29:09no, it's not. And I said, but it is all.
- 1:29:12I said, no, it's not, but it also is. And I
- 1:29:15said, because not to reveal this very personal conversation that I had with a
- 1:29:21friend that they do, I don't think she'll care, and obviously she'll remain
- 1:29:26anonymous. But I said, you know, the point, right, is
- 1:29:32that we are showcasing to people. We are reflecting humanity back to people our
- 1:29:39own right, because we can only really reflect our own back to people,
- 1:29:43and like ask them, like do you feel this way too? And the
- 1:29:46hope and what makes it worth it, right is that we are going through
- 1:29:51this. And I don't mean to sound self important as an artist, because
- 1:29:56obviously we're all going through fucking shit, right, But I'm like, I
- 1:30:00I believe that the arts are a service job, much like any other service
- 1:30:04job. Right, we are trying to do a service for people, hopefully.
- 1:30:11I think if you're doing it for a claim, much like if you're
- 1:30:13doing medicine for a claim or teaching for a claim or anything else worth doing
- 1:30:16for a claim, that you're doing it for the wrong reasons. But I
- 1:30:18was like, but what you were doing it for, right is connection.
- 1:30:24That's the whole fucking point of being alive. Right. You're asking the as
- 1:30:30they say in your play Godless Wilderness, right, what feels sometimes like a
- 1:30:32godless wilderness? Like do you feel this way too? And a lot of
- 1:30:38people go, no, wh's fine, and also fuck you. But what
- 1:30:42we're doing it for is that one person who says, yes, oh my
- 1:30:45god, thank you for seeing me for a second. And I said,
- 1:30:48because that is the fucking point. The fucking point is we are all wandering
- 1:30:51around thinking that we are in this godless wilderness. There was this game that
- 1:30:56we used to play in my theater for young audiences class called pruey oh yeah,
- 1:31:01I kind of remember this where one person was the prue and everyone else
- 1:31:04was wandering around with their eyes closed, and the prue was the only person
- 1:31:10who got to have their eyes open, and they could not move and they
- 1:31:13could not speak and they could only watch, yes, and everyone else was
- 1:31:18wandering around, and if they bumped into another person, they would say Pruey,
- 1:31:25and the other person would gently say Pruey if if they were not the
- 1:31:29PRUEI yeah, and they were meant to say it like I wish you well
- 1:31:34on your journey. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And if you found the
- 1:31:38Prue, you became part of the Prue, became part of the mass of
- 1:31:41the Pruey. And then but you knew you found the Prue because you would
- 1:31:45touch them and they would say nothing, and then you would join hands and
- 1:31:47then you would be silent. You could say nothing, you could not move,
- 1:31:51and you would watch as people like got close to you and then just
- 1:31:56walked right by you, and you would watch as like other people had moments
- 1:32:00of connection, and then you would like hope that they would find you.
- 1:32:03And I feel like that's actually and I just realized this now exactly what making
- 1:32:09art fucking is. Yeah, it is pretty much. And oh wow,
- 1:32:13sorry, this is profound for me. I don't know if anybody else gives
- 1:32:15a shit, but great, I'm here asking Pruey, right, and maybe
- 1:32:18other people will respond with Pruey pop off. But yeah, I feel like
- 1:32:24that's how it feels sometimes to be alive. Yeah, sure is. You're
- 1:32:28just kind of wandering around asking PRUEI and like hoping to find it. So
- 1:32:32now the episode I allowed to be fucking pruey as fuck. So sorry,
- 1:32:38little too, a little too pruey, yeah, prey little too now,
- 1:32:42but so yeah, I just I feel like sometimes and granted, now,
- 1:32:45of course we said it was going to be a short almost two hours.
- 1:32:48Yeah, whatever, it doesn't mean. But you know, now this has
- 1:32:50become an interesting reflection of the effect of art on ourselves and other people well,
- 1:32:55which is kind of the whole point of like this particular, not the
- 1:32:58chapter, but the meta analysis we're doing of the author's approach to the response
- 1:33:03to this chapter, which is free, is the kind of which is honestly
- 1:33:08fucking relatable, because sometimes I also want to be like, go fuck yourself.
- 1:33:11Yes, that's right, Like, yeah, of course I've even kind
- 1:33:14of maybe not told you to go fuck yourself, but maybe not in so
- 1:33:17many words, but I've been very angry with you because of how you've responded
- 1:33:21to some of my work, which is fair normal, but yeah, but
- 1:33:26it's those moments in this way, I said to her. I was like,
- 1:33:28it's the moments where like we get to make people feel seen and we
- 1:33:32get to feel seen by those people. That is what is worth it.
- 1:33:38We make people feel a little less alone for a second. Yeah, it's
- 1:33:41a goal. And I was like, and isn't that enough? Isn't that
- 1:33:45what we're all trying to do at the end of the day, Like,
- 1:33:48what are we really doing this for? Why are we really here? It's
- 1:33:50to have the and what really makes life meaningful? Right? It's not I
- 1:33:55have achieved plenty of things, and I have realized that they don't necessarily fix
- 1:34:00anything. And that's what I thought would fix things. It's the relationships that
- 1:34:04I think, the connections that I built with people. And I was like,
- 1:34:08and that is what makes art with it And I'm like and so,
- 1:34:12so it makes a lot of sense. When you're standable, you you reach
- 1:34:15really fucking hard at something that you hope will evoke a certain feeling and your
- 1:34:18readers and it doesn't. And that hurts. That hurts because then you feel
- 1:34:23alone because you've you've opened up a very squishiest part of yourself and handed it
- 1:34:26to others and they've gone as fuck as that because you feel alone. And
- 1:34:30I get that, I totally get that, but but I think it was
- 1:34:35because it was squishy for him. But he didn't invite us into the squishiness
- 1:34:42as much as he needed to. And that's what's hard, is because that
- 1:34:46takes fucking And I'm not saying he doesn't have courage, because obviously he's a
- 1:34:50metic enormous courage. It takes a lot. It takes a lot, and
- 1:34:56and because it's you and you're close to your squishy parts, you're like,
- 1:35:00of course they're going to see this. And really, he just had to
- 1:35:03dig a smidge deeper. I think you didn't. He didn't. I mean,
- 1:35:08we're not saying you had to make it the sea Folk. I just
- 1:35:09think he had to spend a little more time with the amy, you know,
- 1:35:11I think I think, yeah, we had to have them know them
- 1:35:14them more, We had to know them. Yeah. So but that that
- 1:35:18is hard to do. It is, it's extraordinarily hard to do. And
- 1:35:21now we're also advocating for adding more words to the middle books of The Wheel
- 1:35:24of Time. I know, but that's why I offered up the Sea Folk,
- 1:35:29and obviously, being like, I don't want him to do that because
- 1:35:30of course the implications are awful, of like in a different way. Yeah,
- 1:35:36but I was like, I think we needed just to know them well
- 1:35:42enough, you know. I so they were a potential you know thing where
- 1:35:48I you know, a potential comparison. Yeah. But yeah, all respect
- 1:35:55and love to Robert Jordan's always of course listen, we've we've flamed the man
- 1:35:59every again, but we wouldn't be here without him. Yeah. I think
- 1:36:03I think writing is hard, really how I want to end it, and
- 1:36:08I think that if people take anything away from this podcast, it's that creation
- 1:36:14is hard. Yes, being a human is hard. Let's all be gentler
- 1:36:17with each other. Please, Yes, good shit, good shit. I
- 1:36:23feel like that's a good place to end on anyway. At the end of
- 1:36:25the chapter in Logain is like, I don't give a shit. We gotta
- 1:36:28go water taxi little two little too. And that's the end of chapter twenty
- 1:36:31two. Yeah, Logan being the example of maybe what we don't do in
- 1:36:34response to other people's pain. Yeah, yeah, yeah, well you know
- 1:36:39that. At the same time, Tarman Guidan is coming yeah right, so
- 1:36:43well this is this is kind of the thing about being alive, right,
- 1:36:45is that like horrible things happen, but the world continues yep, And it's
- 1:36:49like how do we and all how do we find connection? When that's true,
- 1:36:54all the people who are not on the blogosphere and background Wheel of Time
- 1:36:58stuff are like, why the fuck is there to our thirty minute episode about
- 1:37:01these ship? What the fuck is this? So there you go, maybe
- 1:37:04joining us to join us on that journey, and maybe it wasn't, and
- 1:37:09you know what that is. That is your prerogative. Thanks for listening everyone.
- 1:37:27We have social media if you want to know what we've got going on,
- 1:37:30it's linked down below. We also have a Patreon if you want to
- 1:37:31support us that way. It's patreon dot com. Slash Wheel takes and you
- 1:37:34can always leave us a rating and interview, which helps an awful lot other
- 1:37:36than that anything else. Allly, I knew you were gonna do that.
- 1:37:40Thanks for listening everyone, Bye bye,