Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Bank Buys, CUSO Acquisitions, and Mergers of Equals: The 2026 Acquisition Landscape with Mike Bell & Justin Gingerich
Transcript
- 0:00Mark Treichel: Hey, everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trakel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm excited to be, uh, here today with Mike Bell of ⦠and
- 0:06Justin Gingrich of Honigman.
- 0:09Mike I've had you on the podcast twice before.
- 0:11Justin, you're new to the show.
- 0:13Guys, I'm excited to talk about bank acquisitions, branch acquisitions,
- 0:17all sorts of acquisitions in the credit union arena today.
- 0:21How you guys doing?
- 0:22Mike Bell: Very good, thank you.
- 0:23We're, we're ready to talk about the same.
- 0:25Mark Treichel: Very good.
- 0:26And, uh, for ⦠if you wanna give a little bit of your background.
- 0:29It's ⦠Uh, Mike, we were chatting pre-show, I thought I had you on last
- 0:33year, but it w- they went back to 2024.
- 0:34This is your third time on the show.
- 0:36But for people who might not know what, uh, who you are and, and what you do
- 0:40at Honigman, if you could kinda, uh, give your, your bios, if you would.
- 0:45Mike Bell: Yeah.
- 0:45Yeah, Mark, ha- happy to.
- 0:46So look, we're lawyers and we work at a law firm first to start.
- 0:50But in that space we really only represent credit unions, never
- 0:53represented a bank, and are known in the space for, first and foremost,
- 0:57helping credit unions acquire banks.
- 0:59We did the first ever, and when I say we, Mark, that's you included, my friend.
- 1:02You were the regional director a couple years ago.
- 1:06Mark Treichel: A couple years ago, yes.
- 1:07Mike Bell: Yeah, back when our hair wasn't gray, and we did the first
- 1:10ever credit union bank buy together.
- 1:12And since that time, you know, we've done 100 of those, and bank branch
- 1:16buys, uh, other business buys.
- 1:18And then we'll talk today hopefully a little bit about the latest
- 1:22and greatest with the credit union to credit union mergers.
- 1:25But when I say latest and greatest, I mean big credit union to big
- 1:28credit union, merger of equal type things that have really transformed
- 1:31the space in the last couple years.
- 1:34And then I'll, uh, kick it to my partner, Justin, who we've been
- 1:38connected at the hip for about 10 years.
- 1:40And, um, Justin and I do these all together.
- 1:44And I'll let him add.
- 1:45Justin Gingerich: Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:46No, th- thanks, Mike and, and Mark.
- 1:47Happy to, uh, ha- happy to join.
- 1:49But yeah, as, as Mike said, we're, uh, connected at the hip or as I
- 1:52like to say, you know, w- we're two arms of the same body, right?
- 1:55So the, the two of us together, right, are kind of, you know, creating a- and
- 1:58architecting these with, you know, our
- 2:00B- between ourselves, our clients, right, but then also, you know,
- 2:02kind of the remainder of our team.
- 2:04And so, so my role and function here is- You know, kind of making these
- 2:08things actually come to life, right?
- 2:09You know, so once we get sort of parties that are interested and get through sort
- 2:12of LOI stage, right, somebody's gotta kind of boil that down to paper, uh, and
- 2:17that paper ultimately getting signed.
- 2:18And so that's kind of my role and function of working through with sort
- 2:21of the management team, executive teams and, you know, and, and, and
- 2:23making those, come to life and, and being completed, if you will.
- 2:27And then it kicks over to the regulatory process, which we all know and love.
- 2:31Mark Treichel: Very good.
- 2:31Yeah, y- y- the way you framed how you guys work together, it
- 2:34reminded me what I used to say when I, when I was executive director.
- 2:37John Kutchey, the current regional director in, in the eastern region,
- 2:41was my deputy and, you know, we'd brief each other in the morning, we'd brief
- 2:44each other in the afternoon, and we could finish each- we could finish each
- 2:48other's sentences, uh, if we needed to.
- 2:50So, uh, it sounds like that's the, the work approach you guys have to this.
- 2:54So, so what's-- um, you know, the, politically volume-wise,
- 2:59let's just kind of start about, uh, banks into credit unions.
- 3:03What's the state of affairs as we chat here in July of twenty twenty-six?
- 3:08Mike Bell: Yeah, Mark, happy to.
- 3:10The known headline is that there have only been, I think, four or five
- 3:14announcements so far in twenty-six.
- 3:17And so everybody looking at that would think, "Oh boy, it's, these are down.
- 3:21There must be a reason.
- 3:22What's going on?"
- 3:24And I will admit that, one, that's accurate.
- 3:27Um, there have only been so many announcements.
- 3:29I'll tell you, I think there's one key reason why, and then
- 3:32I'll tell you what's coming.
- 3:34So on the reason why category, I have always said, always, and it's always been
- 3:39the case since the beginning of these, that credit unions are unsuccessful
- 3:44more than they're successful when it comes to being the winning bidder.
- 3:48And you'll never know that because it never is reported like
- 3:51so and so bid and lost, right?
- 3:52We only report the wins.
- 3:53That's just how the industry works.
- 3:55I'll tell you, this year there has been plenty of activity, plenty of
- 3:59opportunities, and plenty of great credit unions making great bids.
- 4:02That's not the problem.
- 4:04The problem is the banks are as, as active as they've ever been,
- 4:09and they're bidding higher than they've ever been, and we're losing.
- 4:14And we're losing more than we've lost in the past.
- 4:17I, I don't view this as bad, Mark.
- 4:19I view it actually as proof that half of what the ICBA says is absolutely untrue.
- 4:24This year is exhibit A to show that their claims about unfair
- 4:28competition and different things is completely false, right?
- 4:32So we have-- I can think of- Maybe almost 10 instances in the last three
- 4:38or four months where we have had a great client, a proven buyer with
- 4:43a great bid that got second place.
- 4:46Okay?
- 4:47Now, I'll tell you, I think that that certainly continues.
- 4:50Like, that hasn't disappeared, but because of the activity levels,
- 4:54because of the volume that we're seeing, we have some wins coming.
- 4:58So Justin and I have a shortlist here that, you know, it's not public yet,
- 5:02but absolutely before the year is out more of these are going to be announced.
- 5:07We're very close on a couple.
- 5:09There's more activity on more.
- 5:11So I do think this year ends with far more than have been announced to date,
- 5:16but there's absolutely reasons why these things are less than normal this year,
- 5:21and it's because the banks are aggressive.
- 5:22Mark Treichel: Got it.
- 5:23Justin, any thoughts on, on, uh, what Mike said there?
- 5:26Justin Gingerich: No, I think it's 100% right, and I think just the emphasis
- 5:28is, i- is worth, driving home again, is that we've historically lost a lot, and
- 5:34we're just historically ⦠We're, we're actually losing at a higher rate than
- 5:37the historical norm at this point, right?
- 5:40And so, you know, for, for those, you know, kind of anti-competitive, you
- 5:43know, types of claims or, you know, hey, credit unions are always able to pay
- 5:46more, they're, you know, they're, they're paying more premium than they ever should.
- 5:50If that were true, w- we're now losing significantly more than what
- 5:53we previously have, and so the, the, the free market, right, that we always
- 5:57advocate for, uh, must be working in the right way in order for that to happen.
- 6:01Mark Treichel: Yeah, and the free- so the free market working too, it's like,
- 6:03okay, so this is good for banks, right?
- 6:05'Cause, 'cause credit unions have, have got into the market.
- 6:09It's, it's like when you have three people bidding on a house, right?
- 6:12You get a little bit more concerned that you might not win, so you put
- 6:15an escalator in and you get it.
- 6:17That's good.
- 6:17That's good for the seller, and, and in this instance, it's
- 6:20good for the sellers of banks.
- 6:21So, so credit unions getting into the game has made the sale price of banks
- 6:27in total higher than it would've been if credit unions weren't in the game.
- 6:32Mike Bell: Yeah, Mark, that is 100% correct.
- 6:34It's what we've been saying.
- 6:36It's what all professionals in the space say, not just us, but the
- 6:39guys that sell these banks say it.
- 6:41And you can look in the states where these are prohibited or curtailed,
- 6:45the very few by the way, and you will see the pricing is lower.
- 6:49If you dig in, you're gonna see that banks in Tennessee are worth less-
- 6:54And Tennessee's a great economic state that we always hear about, right?
- 6:57Right.
- 6:57It's, it's on par with Florida where I live and, and where you
- 7:00spend time in your camper, right?
- 7:01But the banks in Tennessee are worth less because the law they passed.
- 7:05The banks in Washington State are now worth less because the law they passed.
- 7:09In other states, states like Illinois, uh, where there's a lot of activity,
- 7:14uh, and I can just think of, you know, a few instances this year where we've had
- 7:17amazing strong bids and the banks have sold for far more than they expected
- 7:21due to an aggressive bank bidder.
- 7:24Good for the state.
- 7:24Good for them, right?
- 7:25Good for them.
- 7:26Good
- 7:26Mark Treichel: for the free
- 7:26Mike Bell: market
- 7:26Mark Treichel: there.
- 7:26Yeah.
- 7:27That's right.
- 7:27And, uh, the Washington State, that's a whole newâ¦
- 7:30that all started and became a law, I think, since we last chatted,
- 7:33so- Yeah ⦠what, w- has thatâ¦
- 7:37What has that done i- in Washington?
- 7:38If any- if anything you can tell.
- 7:40I, I guess if, if there aren't any happening, it's curtailed banks
- 7:45and credit union from bidding, which is impacting the price?
- 7:48Mike Bell: Yeah, it is.
- 7:48And I, and I'll tell you, I do ⦠I think reasonable minds prevail there,
- 7:52and that law eventually changes.
- 7:53That law was interesting, Mark, in that it was a tax law.
- 7:56They were trying to find revenue from what I understand, and they thought,
- 7:59"All right, well, if a bank buys a, or a credit union buys a bank, we'll,
- 8:02we'll expose them to this tax," right?
- 8:05Well, no credit union's gonna agree to do that.
- 8:06So, so far that tax bill has raised zero dollars of revenue, and I'm
- 8:11gonna predict that not one penny will ever be paid of that tax.
- 8:15And what it has done indirectly, or perhaps an unintended consequence, is
- 8:21it's shut down the market of credit unions bidding on Washington State banks and
- 8:24the value of those banks has dropped.
- 8:26And we all know from the business we're in, there are some amazing, strong,
- 8:29great credit unions in Washington State.
- 8:31Always have been.
- 8:32Yeah.
- 8:32Absolutely.
- 8:32It's a great, strong credit union state.
- 8:34We have great clients there, and what we're helping them do today is merge
- 8:38with other credit unions, is look at acquiring things that are not banks in
- 8:43Washington, look at acquiring institutions that are outside the State of Washington.
- 8:48Like, we're finding our ⦠The pressure of wanting to grow, we're finding the
- 8:53pathways, 'cause they shut one down.
- 8:56But boy, it would be a lot easier and cleaner once they undo that bad tax
- 8:59law, which I think they eventually do.
- 9:01Yeah.
- 9:01It's raised zero revenue and it never will.
- 9:04Mark Treichel: Yeah, I remember ⦠I remember hearing some of the politics
- 9:06behind it and how it got approved, which was like politics, I guess.
- 9:10Yeah.
- 9:10Mike Bell: Yeah, a last-minute political thing, so.
- 9:12Mark Treichel: Right?
- 9:13Mike Bell: So be it.
- 9:13So be it.
- 9:14Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 9:14So be it.
- 9:15So be it.
- 9:16You know, last time we chatted, we talked about, and you kinda
- 9:18m- mentioned a little bit, there, there's, there's other acquisitions
- 9:22other than bank into credit unions.
- 9:24There's branch deals, there's title insurance companies, there's
- 9:29lenders that, that get acquired that become parts of CUSOs and things.
- 9:33What's going on in any or all of those these days?
- 9:38Mike Bell: Yeah, so on the branch side you know, the space remains active, and each
- 9:43year, uh, you know, we help more credit unions buy bank branches than anybody else
- 9:47year over year, and we'll keep doing that.
- 9:50You know, we have some great branch-buying clients that really specialize in
- 9:54that and have had massive success.
- 9:57A lot of those I'm seeing are in the Southeast or in the upper Midwest.
- 10:00I think that's random.
- 10:01I don't necessarily give you a scientific reason, but those
- 10:04opportunities keep coming, and we keep ⦠You know, we, we're one of
- 10:08the best buyers for those things.
- 10:09So I, I view that as absolutely an area of continuing focus, and really I think
- 10:16always will be I will point out though, for first-time viewers or considerers of
- 10:21this, in case you haven't heard either of us talk before, I think people need to
- 10:25understand that a branch deal will never happen on the big end of the spectrum.
- 10:31Chase, Wells, Bank of America, they never sell a branch, and they never will.
- 10:37Nor will it happen on the very, very bottom where we have, like, a three-branch
- 10:40community bank that, you know, either end of that pendulum, you'll never see it.
- 10:45So if you call me up and say, "Hey, there's this Wells branch
- 10:47I love," I'll say, "Sorry," like it, it will never happen.
- 10:51However, if there's a larger community bank, regional bank, or small
- 10:55regional bank, that's the sweet spot.
- 10:57Those are the kind of banks that sell branches, that have a reason
- 11:00to sell them, that benefit from selling them, and they're actually
- 11:04the kind of branches we wanna buy.
- 11:06They're the best for us, the way the business is done there.
- 11:09So it's just something for folks to keep in mind.
- 11:11And then I will add you know, these other businesses it's rather endless,
- 11:16whether it's investments, insurance, title insurance, real estate-related.
- 11:21We kind of do those all the time and, um, can really almost compromise anything.
- 11:27Credit unions between themselves and their CUSO powers, I think can
- 11:31virtually get into any business they want to, or they should.
- 11:34Let's be clear, I, I don't think we're gonna own junkyards, but why would we?
- 11:38But anything financial adjacent or financial related, I think
- 11:42the credit unions have the power to be in that business and do.
- 11:46And then one thing, Mark, I'm gonna tee up for Justin, and I'll tell you I think is,
- 11:51I would say new We have recently worked with some of our larger credit union
- 11:56clients, kind of the upper, upper echelon of size, and we have helped them actually
- 12:02acquire kind of current or existing CUSOs.
- 12:06So there's a bazillion CUSOs out there, and they do great work, but we are seeing
- 12:10a trend now where some of our bigger clients are gonna buy and bring those
- 12:14things in-house, which is interesting.
- 12:16J- Justin, I'll let you chime in on that concept.
- 12:18Justin Gingerich: Yeah.
- 12:19A- and so, yeah, it's a really good segue.
- 12:21And I think at the end of it, right, and, and for those of us that have,
- 12:24or for those of you that have heard myself or Mike speak on this, right,
- 12:27I mean, we view this in sort of the non-organic growth aspect, right?
- 12:31And, and, and non-organic growth is really triggered by not, uh, you-
- 12:37some of the detractors, right, would say, "Well, you're just growing
- 12:39for the sake of growing," right?
- 12:40And I think what we're really, what we really focus on and I think what
- 12:43we see a lot of our clients focus on, is they're really growing in
- 12:46the name of member service, right?
- 12:48What other features, what other functions can we provide to our membership to
- 12:52kind of make that relationship stickier?
- 12:55And what you find, and, and this is kind of where the, you know, the
- 12:58CUSO to CUSO trading, if you will, is going on, is that there is a lot of
- 13:04discussion on buy versus build, right?
- 13:07A lot of these larger institutions are able.
- 13:09Could they go out and start sort of their own insurance, you know,
- 13:12CUSO and, and build that out?
- 13:14Absolutely.
- 13:15But if another organization, or as we've seen the trend become a collection of
- 13:20organizations have basically, you know, funded and founded some sort of CUSO
- 13:24and they're looking to basically sort of trade that off, that becomes sort of the,
- 13:29an opportunity or a springboard, right, for You know, a, a larger institution to
- 13:33just say, "Look, let's just buy this," and, and in the name of member service
- 13:37and member stickiness, uh, versus, you know, having the investment, which at
- 13:41the end of the day is gonna be slower, probably more expensive, more rigorous
- 13:45from, you know, a regulatory perspective.
- 13:47Let somebody else who's already gone through all the hassles of building and
- 13:51getting approval and, you know, the, the learning curve, those, you know,
- 13:55that, that tuition, right, is already paid, go out then and just acquire
- 13:59that on sort of the secondary market.
- 14:01And, and that's a trend that we're seeing sort of more and more.
- 14:04Uh, and what's fascinating now is I think a lot of those early investments between
- 14:08multiple, uh, multiple institutions into a sp- particular CUSO are now sort
- 14:13of getting to maturity stage, right?
- 14:15Where the institutions are kind of looking and saying, like, "Look we've
- 14:18held this for three or five years.
- 14:20Uh, now it's maybe time to, you know, kind of move this off of our books
- 14:23or, or figure out a way to make this sort of bigger than what it is."
- 14:27By no means, right, do I wanna, call it sort of, you know, a
- 14:29private equity-like model, right?
- 14:31You know, these institutions are not, thinking in the private equity way.
- 14:34But some of these CUSO, conglomerates, right, or, or, or cooperatives, you
- 14:38know, not to confuse it with the credit union mission, uh, are kind
- 14:41of operating in that way, right?
- 14:42Of, you know, we made a collective investment, what do we now do with this?
- 14:46And, and larger institutions are probably a really good acquirer of those, uh,
- 14:50especially in the name of member service.
- 14:52Mark Treichel: Yeah, and if you've got a structure with, a, a good office
- 14:54space, a, a good board, good policies, good procedures clean books, and you've
- 15:00already got that regulatory approval, and you've kinda peaked, right?
- 15:03You've had your growth and maybe you've stabilized, maybe it's this bigger
- 15:07institution or a cl- conglomerate of bigger institutions that can say,
- 15:11hey, or big, bigger credit unions that can go, "Okay, they got it to here.
- 15:14We can make it bigger.
- 15:15We can utilize this.
- 15:17W- it a- it adds th- these couple of services we don't have."
- 15:21And then it a- it, A, it solves that piercing the corporate
- 15:23veil thing too, right?
- 15:24Because it came from ⦠Clearly is different, 'cause you acquired it over
- 15:28here and you didn't form it over here with the same exact board, uh, a- and people.
- 15:32So I, I could, I could see that, a- as a big, big positive.
- 15:36I had I hadn't thought of, of that as a, an area of growth for
- 15:40acquisitions, but it makes sense.
- 15:42Mike Bell: Yeah, and Mark, I think it's because we didn't chat last
- 15:44year, because I think it just
- 15:46Mark Treichel: started-
- 15:46Mike Bell: Like-
- 15:47Mark Treichel: There, there we go.
- 15:48Mike Bell: Yeah, this was a, this is a 2025 thing.
- 15:50Yeah.
- 15:50And literally last week I got a phone call from from our friends at Olden Lane
- 15:55saying, "Hey, you know, we have an idea.
- 15:57There's this CUSO, it's mature, right?"
- 16:00Like, and their instinct and my comment was, "Hey, there are big credit unions
- 16:05out there now acquiring these things."
- 16:08And so a lot of times, Justin mentioned a lot of the reasons, I'll add another.
- 16:11You know, there's a lot of times these CUSOs are beautiful,
- 16:13they're wonderful, they'reâ¦
- 16:15Nothing's wrong, but their management is aging, right?
- 16:17Right.
- 16:18Yeah.
- 16:18Right.
- 16:19Yeah.
- 16:19We're talking about this in a credit union
- 16:19Justin Gingerich: sense.
- 16:19Mike Bell: Yeah.
- 16:19And so here we are, we need to now invest in the next big management
- 16:23group, or is this the time maybe it's mature and we offload it?
- 16:27And a sophisticated credit union sit- they're saying, "Hey, we've spent a
- 16:30lot of time building an impressive management team that is deep.
- 16:34We want non-interest income, right?
- 16:37We wanna amp things up at this place.
- 16:39Let's buy this thing, buy that thing."
- 16:42And it all kind of comes under this umbrella and we need less maybe direct
- 16:47management because we now are in-house, and the sophisticated team has the
- 16:50bandwidth and wherewithal to support it.
- 16:53So this is new, Mark.
- 16:54Yeah.
- 16:54I think if we talk next year, this is something to kind of
- 16:56put a feather out there to say, "Hey, do more of these happen?"
- 16:59Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 16:59Mike Bell: Is this continuing?
- 17:00Because we're seeing it on the front li- front lines anyways.
- 17:03Mark Treichel: Fa- fascinating.
- 17:04So- You know, if I wanna, if I wanna buy a house or wanna just monitor a market,
- 17:10I look at Redfin or I look at Realtor.
- 17:12If I wanna buy concert tickets, I look at Ticketmaster or StubHub or SeatGeek.
- 17:16If I wanna buy branch deals, if I wanna buy title insurance companies specialty
- 17:21lenders or CUSOs, what, wh- where's theâ¦
- 17:24Uh, I mean, obviously people know you do it, so they call- Mm-hmm ⦠and say,
- 17:28"Hey, I'm looking to sell," or- Mm-hmm
- 17:29"I'm looking to buy."
- 17:30What's theâ¦
- 17:32How, how, how do those deals come together?
- 17:35Mike Bell: Yeah, so, so this is a, this is a fair question because I would not
- 17:38call this an efficient marketplace, right?
- 17:41There is not a StubHub, right?
- 17:43Right.
- 17:43There is not a Zillow.
- 17:45But what there is, though, is a small world.
- 17:47So though it's not the most efficient marketplace, I will tell you that
- 17:51there's probably 20 people, 25 people that you would speak to that are in
- 17:57that market, that, that are gonna move either on the buy or the sell side
- 18:02virtually everything that's out there.
- 18:04Are there exceptions?
- 18:04Sure.
- 18:05But o- really on one or two hands if you talk to ourselves, you know, various
- 18:12other folks in the business, you're gonna figure out really quick what's out there
- 18:15and what's not, or you're gonna learn who you need to speak to, uh, and where
- 18:19you need to put yourself so you're in the market and you're seeing deal flow.
- 18:22Mark Treichel: So-
- 18:22Mike Bell: Maybe someday this gets efficient.
- 18:24Yeah.
- 18:24I, I don't know how, though.
- 18:25It's more of a classic marketplace.
- 18:27I don't think, I don't think there's a way to make it any more efficient than it is.
- 18:30Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 18:31Sure.
- 18:31So said another way, if, if someone has a CUSO and they're listening or
- 18:35watching and they think, "Hey, maybe I wanna sell," or if someone's saying,
- 18:39"Hey, we're thinking about getting into one, I, I'm in that biggerâ¦
- 18:43Define big, but I'm in that bigger, uh, arena," first place to start is to call
- 18:47you guys and say, "Hey, I'm interested in buying," or, "I'm interested in selling,"
- 18:51'cause it sounds like you're connected to a lot a lot of these as it starts to grow.
- 18:55Mike Bell: Yeah, it's true, and I mean, this is, this si- this is not a, a sales
- 18:59pitch because I'll tell you, we spend a majority of our time just talking to
- 19:03people and talking to people for free.
- 19:04Yeah.
- 19:04Like, you don't, you don't sign- That's right ⦠engagement letters with us.
- 19:07You don't give us any of your money.
- 19:08We don't want it.
- 19:09We are spending most of the day talking to buyers and talking to
- 19:14possible sellers with no fees going anywhere and never going anywhere
- 19:19unless we actually do something.
- 19:20Yeah.
- 19:20That's just how this works.
- 19:22It's how it has to work, I think.
- 19:23I, I don't have a better model.
- 19:25And so, um, there's a short list of people, right?
- 19:28We're- Justin and I are on the phone all day long.
- 19:31I'm not gonna name the names of the credit union buyers.
- 19:32No, of
- 19:32Mark Treichel: course not.
- 19:33Mike Bell: But we're talking to the investment banks whether it's Hubdy or
- 19:37Olson Palmer or their uh, Sandler, right?
- 19:40And we're also talking to what I would call credit union
- 19:43industry partners or vendors.
- 19:45Olden Lane, ALM First, Dorme, Hugh.
- 19:49We're spending our time, and there's just a small group of us- Right
- 19:55⦠that are kind of space discussing what's there, what's not, who's looking
- 19:56for this, who's looking for that, and that's how things come together.
- 20:00It really is.
- 20:01I'll give you an example.
- 20:02If you're a credit union in, in, let's just say, the Southeast, Florida,
- 20:05Georgia, Alabama, and you called us up and said, "Hey, we wanna buy a bank or
- 20:10buy bank branches," I'm gonna say to you, "Great here's what we have today, right?
- 20:15I'll give you a listing of everything we're aware of, and
- 20:17here's the other two people, that's it, that you should speak with."
- 20:21Right?
- 20:22Between the three of us, you're gonna see everything you need to see.
- 20:25I say the same thing, it'd be two different people, but in the
- 20:27upper Midwest or in the Northwest.
- 20:29It, it's very simple, um, to distill down who's in the market
- 20:33and who's not, in my opinion.
- 20:37Mark Treichel: Very good.
- 20:38So c- the credit union to credit union, uh, mergers.
- 20:41Let's chat about what you've what you're seeing, uh, in that arena these days
- 20:47Mike Bell: Yeah.
- 20:47So, so for the entirety of my credit union career, which has been about
- 20:5223 years long, for 22 years, this was, did not occur or maybe occurred
- 20:59once, and that is kind of credit unions of significant size merging.
- 21:04We'll just call it merger of equals, or MOEs is the official term.
- 21:08However, starting a couple years ago, and continuing to this very
- 21:12day, there is MOE activity that has never occurred in our industry ever.
- 21:18We are, uh, by the week, talking with credit unions all over
- 21:23the country that are s- in some piece of a timeline of an MOE.
- 21:29Now, look, to be clear, some of these are, "Hey, Mike, I just
- 21:33had coffee with so-and-so."
- 21:35Right.
- 21:35"We think it might make sense.
- 21:36What do you think?"
- 21:37The very beginning.
- 21:38Some of these come to us and say, "Hey, you're not gonna believe this.
- 21:40We have a signed LOI."
- 21:42"We just put it together between the two of us.
- 21:44Here we go."
- 21:45Um, right, so that's on the other extreme end.
- 21:48If I get 10 phone calls about we just had coffee, maybe two or three
- 21:52of those come together, right?
- 21:54There's a high failure rate, be clear.
- 21:56But I'll tell you, I never got phone calls about the we had
- 21:59coffee or maybe once a year.
- 22:01Now I'm getting them every week, Mark.
- 22:03Mark Treichel: Thatâ¦
- 22:03Mike Bell: Yeah.
- 22:03And then I would say if we get the phone call about, "Hey, we have
- 22:06an LOI," I think eight out of 10 of those get home and get done.
- 22:10There is not a high failure rate after that point, but I cannot
- 22:14emphasize enough the activity level.
- 22:17So I was in a room, uh, the League of Southern Credit Unions, a great state
- 22:20league, by the way, one of our faves.
- 22:22I was at their CEO conference.
- 22:24I think there was 40 CEOs in the room.
- 22:28I think I could say to you there's 30 of them that I'm in the middle
- 22:31of conversations with about something, which is just unheard of-
- 22:36⦠In the past.
- 22:37Now, I will tell you that they're complicated and, and, you know,
- 22:42they're difficult, but we've had more success than we've ever had before
- 22:45and I'll kick it to Justin, you know, just for an opinion about perhaps
- 22:50why we're having success with these things and we weren't in the past.
- 22:53Because to be clear, these things were like the black swan.
- 22:57Now I'm gonna call them normal.
- 22:59Justin Gingerich: Yeah.
- 22:59Mike Bell: Which is a huge difference.
- 23:02Justin Gingerich: Yeah.
- 23:02And I think that normalization, right, just to kind of preview, I think, why
- 23:05we're seeing the, the bigger trend and, and why, if, if they get to LOI,
- 23:09right, kind of why they're, coming to fruition, uh, at a higher rate
- 23:14it's a lot of the things we've kind of talked about, right, in theâ¦
- 23:16You know, we just talked about on the CUSO side, right?
- 23:18It's succession planning.
- 23:20It's difficult to run an institution of size efficiently.
- 23:25And so if you have sort of two, $5 or $6 billion institutions, they both
- 23:30have extremely high technology costs.
- 23:32They have extremely high compliance costs.
- 23:35Th- there's actually sort of scale, economy of scale in combining
- 23:39those two institutions together.
- 23:40And if you get the side effect of, again, more member product, more member service,
- 23:45more member benefit, succession planning, and, operational efficiency, those
- 23:52things really, start to come together.
- 23:54But the, you know, a- as Mike was saying, you know, from a, a black swan event, I,
- 23:58I think the reason that we've had success is actually a result of the regulatory
- 24:03team that we have here at Honigman, you know, that Mike and I work with.
- 24:06Our, our partner Brandy is a savant it feels like, right, in sort of
- 24:12navigating sort of this, this process.
- 24:14And, itâ¦
- 24:15This deal is public, right, so I'm, I feel, fine to talk about it.
- 24:18But, you know, our firm was a part of the Wings and merger transaction.
- 24:22Uh, and that was one that was announced.
- 24:25It was one of kind of two that were going on about the same time, both
- 24:29going through the Western region.
- 24:31And it was, you know, creating an, an institution, you know, north of
- 24:34$10 billion, and that with it came a whole new regulatory landscape, right?
- 24:39It was a regulatory process that really never been done.
- 24:43Interestingly, it was going on, you know, in two, two separate transactions
- 24:46at the same time in the region.
- 24:48Uh, but we were able, I think, Very much so due to the efforts of obviously the
- 24:53internal teams, right, for both Wings and ENT, but with Brandi to navigate
- 24:57sort of that, uh, regulatory process.
- 24:59And we got approval on that deal to merge in four to five months, right?
- 25:03Which is, is unheard of.
- 25:05And so I think it really comes down to strategic planning, outside
- 25:08guidance, internal buy-in, right?
- 25:11Having sort of the subject matter experts inside the institution kind
- 25:14of, sort of create the most efficient regulatory application possible.
- 25:18Uh, and that's something that, you know, our team can kinda help guide with.
- 25:21But it's ⦠You're, you're kind of, at this point, especially with
- 25:25the large MOEs, you're, you're baking a cake, but the recipe is
- 25:29only kinda half written, right?
- 25:30Because everybody is sort of catching up on this, right, from a regulatory
- 25:34perspective and what do we need?
- 25:36How do we do it?
- 25:37Is that enough information?
- 25:39Is that too much information?
- 25:40And so it's a, it's a bit of building the plane while we're flying it, and
- 25:44that's something our team, I think historically has been really good at.
- 25:47And obviously we've got clients who we're able to kind of walk through that
- 25:50process and, you know, we've got some of the best clients out there, right?
- 25:53So they take guidance and, and info really well, and we were able to,
- 25:55have a successful outcome and that was one of what I think will be quite
- 26:00a few right in the very near future.
- 26:03Mark Treichel: The last exam I did as an examiner was Northwest Airlines,
- 26:06which was Wings back in Minneapolis.
- 26:08Yeah.
- 26:08There you go ⦠their CEO at the time was a guy named Fred Smith, who,
- 26:12uh, when I walked into his office, he handed me his business card and
- 26:15it said, "What, you here again?
- 26:17Another half-hour, shot to hell."
- 26:19So he was a very cool guy in the history of Wings.
- 26:23But you know, as you described that putting my regulator hat on building
- 26:27building it while you're flying a lot of times I'll get asked, "What's NCUA's
- 26:32position gonna be on this," right?
- 26:33'Cause big into big, you get into, gosh, is this
- 26:38Sh- should NCUA care, right?
- 26:40And the reality is, if it meets the regulatory requirement and the mem-
- 26:45and you disclose, your disclosures are great- It's the democratic process, and
- 26:51NCUA will honor the democratic process.
- 26:54And there's, so all of the angst that someone might have about, w-
- 26:57what's the regulator gonna think?
- 26:59They want you to follow the rules, they want you to notify the members, and then
- 27:02the chips fall where the chips fall.
- 27:04That is how NCUA looks at it.
- 27:06Now, the other thing is, as you're developing this expertise on
- 27:09these bigger ones you know, this, this kinda goes into almost every
- 27:12conversation I'm having these days.
- 27:14NCUA's down about 30% of their staff, right?
- 27:17And they, the people they lost were the ones who were eligible to retire,
- 27:22close to eligible r- to retire.
- 27:24Uh, so they lost a lot of corporate knowledge, which makes it hard
- 27:28sometimes when you go in saying, "Hell, we've done two of these."
- 27:31So ironically, when you're doing some of these and they the flow starts to
- 27:35increase you're kinda educating NCUA a little bit too, 'cause some of the
- 27:39people who might have approved some of them previously uh, don't reallyâ¦
- 27:43A- are gone, right?
- 27:44So it's this constant reeducation of NCUA at this juncture right now too, so.
- 27:50Mike Bell: Yeah, absolutely true.
- 27:51And that's why there's, like, a new normal, and I don't
- 27:54think it's bad though, Mark.
- 27:55No.
- 27:55Um, I think that everybody is finding their footing.
- 27:58I would say, as an outsider looking in, you know, with the big changes
- 28:02and the staff reduction, everything, I feel much differently now than
- 28:07I did middle of last year, right?
- 28:09I feel like there's been a settling, there's been a calming.
- 28:13That's good.
- 28:13Um, I feel like the agency, uh, credit to Kyle Hauptman, to, to
- 28:17be honest, has really tried to do better with what they have.
- 28:22And so new procedures, new guideposts, new whatever, these little things matter.
- 28:27And, you know, is it perfect?
- 28:29No, none of us will ever say that.
- 28:30But is it better?
- 28:32I think it's a heck of a lot better now than it was a year
- 28:34ago, um, even with the new staff.
- 28:36Well,
- 28:36Mark Treichel: peopleâ¦
- 28:37And people rise to the occasion, right?
- 28:38There's a lot of talented people at NCUA who are waiting for the opportunity
- 28:41for some re- retirements to happen, and so now it's kind of like an ex-
- 28:46an expansion baseball team, right?
- 28:47The guys the backup catcher gets the opportunity to prove that he, uh, is a,
- 28:51should be an everyday player, and that's what's happening at NCUA right now.
- 28:55Mike Bell: Yeah, true.
- 28:57Mark Treichel: The another musical reference.
- 28:59You talk about the black swan event.
- 29:00I always think of, uh, a line from a Suzanne Vega s- song.
- 29:05It's a one-time thing, it just happens a lot.
- 29:09So that's kind of what we're starting to see there.
- 29:11So- Yeah.
- 29:12Well, guys Iâ¦
- 29:13the things I had written down to, to chat about, I've kind
- 29:16of checked the boxes here.
- 29:17Is there any other topic you wanted to, uh, to discuss here today
- 29:21before we put a wrap on this?
- 29:23Mike Bell: Mark, no, but I, I would end just by saying what we've already said,
- 29:28but let's make a short little list, right?
- 29:29Yeah, perfect.
- 29:29And take from the list.
- 29:30Justin Gingerich: Yep.
- 29:31Mike Bell: And that is, you know, don'tâ¦
- 29:33the bank acquisition thing remains alive, remains exceptionally active.
- 29:37I would encourage people to pay attention.
- 29:40And then the bank branch, other businesses, sure.
- 29:43But we identified two kind of newer things that I think people should
- 29:47not miss out on or not think about.
- 29:49That's this idea in the CUSO space of some mature CUSOs, some aging CUSOs
- 29:54being acquired by single credit unions.
- 29:57And then what we just talked about- The CU2CU merger thing.
- 30:02Now, I'm gonna say this doesn't mean everybody should do it.
- 30:06I'm not saying if you're not having a conversation, you're wrong.
- 30:09But I would say that y- if you don't think this is happening,
- 30:13your eyes are closed, right?
- 30:16Everybody's talking to everybody.
- 30:18Again, not a reason to do it, it's just a reason to be aware of what's
- 30:21happening in your industry, and they're doing it at a level that it
- 30:25continues that I have never seen before.
- 30:29It's shockingly high.
- 30:30Mark Treichel: Yeah, sticking your head in the sand's not a
- 30:32good strategy for the long term.
- 30:33Correct.
- 30:33So paying attention- Correct ⦠is important.
- 30:35Justin, any last thoughts?
- 30:37Justin Gingerich: Yeah.
- 30:37I think at the end of the day, right, it's, it's, I'll, I'll kind of close
- 30:40with the same thing I, I close every talk that I give, right, which is strategic
- 30:45non-organic growth will continue to be a driver of success for institutions
- 30:50that are looking for growth, right?
- 30:52It's never a playbook, right, for those that aren't interested in
- 30:55sort of, you know, finding sort of that jumpstart to the balance
- 30:58sheet or, or to member services.
- 31:00But if you're sitting in boardrooms and strategic sessions, right, and as we
- 31:04know, a lot of our clients are getting ready for kind of that process, you know,
- 31:07despite that we're sitting in July, right?
- 31:09But those, tho- those meetings are being planned as 2027 strategy comes apart.
- 31:14If 2027 strategy says, "Look, how are we finding sort of more
- 31:17non-interest income, and how are we providing new members or how are we
- 31:21providing new services to members, or how are we getting new members?"
- 31:25Strategic non-organic growth is a really solid way to check a lot
- 31:29of those boxes on strategic plans.
- 31:31Mark Treichel: Nice.
- 31:32Nice.
- 31:32That's a great wrap, guys.
- 31:33Well, Mike, uh, Justin, thanks so much for your time.
- 31:36And listeners, uh, watchers, I hope you'll do the same again soon.
- 31:42It's been a lot of fun and, uh, we'll catch you next time.
- 31:44This is Mark Trakel signing off with flying colors