Latest / Five-Minute Crime / Episode 43- The Stranger on the Bridge: The Murder of Cara Knott
Transcript
- Ronan Wolfe: This is Five-Minute Crime. I’m Ronan Wolfe. Tonight’s case begins with flashing lights in a rearview mirror—something most of us have seen and forgotten. But for Cara Knott, that moment became her last. Ronan Wolfe: On December 27th, 1986, Cara Knott was driving home from her boyfriend’s house in San Diego. Around midnight, she was pulled over by a California Highway Patrol officer for a minor traffic issue. That officer was 43-year-old Craig Peyer. Ronan Wolfe: According to trial testimony, Peyer directed Cara to follow him to a darker, more secluded area near a bridge under construction. What happened next wasn’t fully witnessed—but investigators would later piece it together through physical evidence. Ronan Wolfe: Cara was sexually assaulted and strangled. Her body was thrown off the bridge, landing 125 feet below. It was discovered hours later. Ronan Wolfe: Peyer initially denied any wrongdoing. But detectives quickly uncovered inconsistencies in his story. Fibers from Cara’s clothing were found in his patrol car. Tire tracks matched his cruiser. Witnesses came forward saying they’d seen Peyer behave inappropriately toward female drivers before. Ronan Wolfe: During the trial, prosecutors revealed that Peyer had a disturbing pattern of targeting young women during traffic stops—often asking them personal questions, sometimes detaining them longer than necessary. Ronan Wolfe: In 1988, Craig Peyer was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to 25 years to life in prison. Ronan Wolfe: The case rocked Southern California. It forced departments to re-examine oversight, body camera policies, and how officers interact during late-night stops. The betrayal of trust cut deep. Ronan Wolfe: A badge is meant to symbolize protection. But in this case, it became a weapon. Ronan Wolfe: That’s all for this episode of Five-Minute Crime. Until next time—stay curious, stay sharp, and watch your back.