Latest / The Bitcoin Way Podcast / Matthew Kratter: Bitcoin Core is Compromised - Here's Why
Transcript
- 0:00This is the very sad state we're in in Bitcoin, where we have a compromised Bitcoin core.
- 0:04At least when someone is spinning up a new node, they actually have to pause and assess
- 0:09what is it that I want to run?
- 0:10Where do my values lie?
- 0:12Michael Saylor has become a shit coiner, spending years talking about Bitcoin as being ethical
- 0:16money and Ethereum as being garbage that he's now actually retweeting Ethereum garbage.
- 0:21My belief of Bitcoin is that you can buy as much Bitcoin as you want and you can even
- 0:25take it into self-custody and you are not a participant in the network unless you are
- 0:29also running a node. BIP 110 and Bitcoin knots people's messages, you cannot do that as devs.
- 0:34This is not how Bitcoin works. Bitcoin is decentralized. You need to get node runners
- 0:38permission. And so we're going to push back against you. Today on the show, I have Matt
- 0:53Cratter. Matt has been quite the controversial figure in the BIP 110 knots versus core debate,
- 0:58and he has a very strong opinion, walks through the history of core, why he thinks it's been
- 1:02corrupted. This is a fascinating episode. I think you're really going to learn a lot and enjoy the
- 1:06show. Hey, everyone. Like I said in the intro, I've got Matt here. Matt, welcome to the Bitcoin
- 1:10Way podcast. Good to be here, Michael. Thanks for having me on. I'm excited to chat. You have
- 1:15educated a lot of people on Bitcoin through Bitcoin University, and I think you've got a lot
- 1:19to share here. I told you before we clicked record, I'm going to sort of play devil's advocate
- 1:24against some of your points because I think it'll give you an opportunity to explain to the people
- 1:27who maybe have objections, aren't really clear what's going on. First, why don't you give a
- 1:32background, a brief background on spam on Bitcoin, what happened during sort of these node wars that
- 1:38continue to persist? And then maybe we can talk about why you think core devs are compromised and
- 1:44not merely misaligned with you. I think that's a good question. So I'll actually start with the
- 1:48second part of the question first, and then I'll tackle the first part. So it's always hard to know
- 1:54when people are compromised, they don't come right out and say, I'm compromised, obviously.
- 1:59And they're not like Dr. Evil. That's just in Hollywood and on TV. And so this is something
- 2:05that always needs to be inferred. And I think a good context, especially for your viewers and
- 2:11people who've lived through the last six years. And I may offend some people with this analogy,
- 2:18but I think a lot of the history is sort of becoming clear now. But what would be an example
- 2:23like Fauci at the beginning of COVID. And, you know, Fauci, who's here to worry about the health
- 2:29of the American people, et cetera. And I didn't even know who he was until 2020. And I thought
- 2:35he actually did want to save my grandmother or whatever, even though she passed away many decades
- 2:40ago. But then, so how do you know there's some weird stuff happening? Obviously, COVID was a rough
- 2:47time for many people, but it did kind of wake a lot of people up, which I think is interesting.
- 2:53And it opened people's eyes to the idea that the good guys, the smiling guys on TV sometimes can be malicious. And so it became clear to many of us that Fauci was somehow compromised. And why did we know that? Because the gaslighting, the changing narratives, masks don't work, masks do work. You should wear two masks.
- 3:16you should wear a mask when you're checking in at a restaurant. But once you get to your table,
- 3:22you can take the mask off, but you can't go to the beach even with a mask. You can go outside
- 3:28though without a mask if you're protesting certain political things. And then there's the safe and
- 3:33effective vaccine where it's safe and effective, but the unvaccinated are still a threat to the
- 3:39vaccinated, even though the vaccine is safe and effective. So this is obviously, I mean,
- 3:44It's a really blatant example.
- 3:45Then, of course, it came out that Fauci was indirectly funding the coronavirus lab in Wuhan,
- 3:50et cetera, and the Chinese and Americans were working together.
- 3:54And so I think that's a helpful template.
- 3:56And the whole time, I mean, Fauci was never a bad guy.
- 3:59He was always smiling on TV, and he's just this nice grandfatherly figure.
- 4:04And that's a good way to, you know, you don't put someone who looks like Dr. Evil to do
- 4:08the project.
- 4:08You have to do someone who's, you know, a serious scientist and has been around for decades,
- 4:12et cetera.
- 4:12And so I think in terms of answering this question about Bitcoin Core being compromised, there's similar clues because in the last 12 months, we've seen quite a bit of gaslighting, changing of narratives.
- 4:26And one way to understand that is to rewind back to the early days when Satoshi was still around at the project.
- 4:33And there's a famous exchange he had with Gavin Andreessen, who was the guy that Satoshi basically passed on the repo keys to.
- 4:40and Gavin was saying, my evil little mind imagines embedding Lady Gaga videos in the blockchain.
- 4:48And Satoshi basically said, we have transaction fees to fight that and then there's other stuff
- 4:51we can do if needed. So Satoshi, unlike modern Bitcoin core devs, he knew what spam was
- 4:56and he was willing to fight it. He obviously knew that Bitcoin was a monetary network. And so we
- 5:02have this history and this is why it's important always to study history. It's nice with Bitcoin
- 5:06because we're still very early in the history.
- 5:09It hasn't even been two decades.
- 5:12So you can go back, as I've done,
- 5:14and you can read early exchanges like that.
- 5:16And you can follow the history of spam
- 5:18or non-monetary data, arbitrary data,
- 5:21basically things that don't make Bitcoin better money
- 5:23and how are these things always treated.
- 5:26And so the first episode of the spam wars
- 5:28really took place in 2013, 2014,
- 5:31and kind of wrapped up in 2015.
- 5:34There are a number of projects,
- 5:35For example, Eric Voorhees, I believe it was, yeah, I think it was him.
- 5:38He had Satoshi Dice.
- 5:40And so basically this was like casino gambling on the blockchain and it was producing all
- 5:44these, all this Bitcoin dust, all this, these dust UTXOs.
- 5:48You had the counterparty guys, the colored coin guys, the Omni guys, all these people
- 5:52who thought it'd be cool to put shit coins on Bitcoin or to put, to put Wall Street assets
- 5:58to somehow real world assets on the blockchain.
- 6:02And the thing is in Bitcoin, one of the useful things about reading this history is you'll see these things get reintroduced 10 years later and everyone's like, so this is what happened with ordinals and inscriptions, which are basically Bitcoin NFTs and BRC20 tokens, which are shit coins on Bitcoin.
- 6:19these things all came back in 2023 and there's nothing new about them this had been attempted
- 6:24before but what happened in in 2014 is we still had we had a very cypherpunk group of people in
- 6:33bitcoin and certainly in bitcoin core and these were people who hadn't gotten into they weren't
- 6:38from wall street they weren't interested in getting rich most of them they were just they
- 6:43thought it was cool bitcoin was cool they wanted to buy drugs with it on the silk road and they
- 6:47were kind of hacker types. And many of these people never ended up getting rich from Bitcoin
- 6:53because they just used it as, you know, played around with it and used it as a medium of exchange,
- 6:58et cetera. You know, Bitcoin is, it is a threat to the system. And so the system has been attacking
- 7:04it since the very early days. In fact, the same Gavin Andreessen we were talking about decided
- 7:09one day for some reason just to go visit the CIA. And this really upset Satoshi. And Satoshi was
- 7:14basically on his way out at that point saying, I don't want part of this. So it's important to
- 7:19understand that Bitcoin is a very important project that Intel agencies, central bankers,
- 7:25politicians, deep state actors, all the bad guys in the world, and also all the good guys in the
- 7:31world know how important it is. So this is the battleground. We won the spam wars in 2013, 2014,
- 7:382015 because we had Bitcoin core devs and Bitcoin core is really just the, it's the ref, it's the
- 7:44node software that Bitcoiners run or that used to run. And now there people are sort of migrating
- 7:49away from it to Bitcoin knots because of the developments I'm about to tell you. But basically
- 7:54we had, we had Bitcoin core devs back then who understood that Bitcoin was money and were willing
- 7:59to defend it as such and willing to defend the blockchain. And one of the basic, one of the basic
- 8:04principles of Bitcoin culture is that this blockchain is immutable and it's going to be
- 8:09around forever. And when you, in future node runners, a hundred years from now, if you've
- 8:15ever spun up a node, and I know you guys help a lot of people spin up nodes, you know, you have
- 8:20to basically download the history from 2009 and your node validates everything and checks everything.
- 8:25And so the basic philosophy or the basic culture in Bitcoin always was, don't be an asshole. You
- 8:31You know, this is sort of the common, you've heard of tragedy of the commons.
- 8:35This is the common blockchain.
- 8:37And we want this to be around forever.
- 8:39And we want to separate money from state.
- 8:42And so people doing gambling, doing casino games on Bitcoin, this is frivolous.
- 8:46It's, you know, it's funny for like five seconds.
- 8:48But then when you realize that central bankers hate us and want to put us in a digital prison
- 8:53and all these things are coming and give us CBDCs, you realize that maybe we should really
- 8:57optimize Bitcoin for being the best money that's possible. And so these Bitcoin core devs fought
- 9:04spam. They basically drove. And one of the guys who wanted to do complex smart contracts,
- 9:11Turing complete stuff on Bitcoin was a guy named Vitalik Buterin, who started Bitcoin magazine.
- 9:17And he had actually already done a quantum scam at that point. So these quantum scams,
- 9:22you know, keep coming back. It's always a good way to scare people and make money.
- 9:25But he had this idea of putting smart contracts on Bitcoin and really, really bloating it. And the Bitcoin core devs and the Bitcoin community said, no way, not interested. And so we basically, the Bitcoin community filtered out, I like to say we filtered out Vitalik Buterin.
- 9:41And you can go find, I talk about his tweets in my videos. You can go see where he said, basically, I decided not to build on Bitcoin because of hostility from Bitcoin core devs. And so there's basically this place in Bitcoin that was established in 2014 called OpReturn. And it's a place to put a small amount of arbitrary data, for example, a hash of a larger document.
- 10:03You could hash the Declaration of Independence, for example, and stick it in there.
- 10:08And it's still just 40 bytes or it started off as 40 bytes and then went up to 80 bytes.
- 10:14But this has always been a place not for monetary stuff, but just for sort of proof of existence.
- 10:19So you can prove you have a legal document, you hash it, you put the hash in there and in a transaction.
- 10:26It only takes up 40, 80 bytes, a very small amount of data.
- 10:28does matthew matt was that a compromise that that was made amongst developers that hey let's
- 10:34we're going to experience some level of this let's create this small amount of arbitrary data
- 10:40this this opportune for that specific purpose well it was yeah i think that's a good way of
- 10:45putting it though i wouldn't say it was a compromise with spammers it was a compromise
- 10:48with ethical people who wanted to so for example you might want to um you know hash a business
- 10:56document or something to prove that it existed at a certain point in time. And then you stick it in
- 11:00the blockchain and everyone knows because a hash is basically a unique fingerprint of a document.
- 11:05So it sort of functions as proof of existence at a certain point in time. And because the Bitcoin
- 11:10blockchain can never be rewritten, it serves that purpose. So there was a small accommodation made.
- 11:17And this is a problem in criminal context as well. California did something like this that's
- 11:23quite notorious where it's like you're only allowed to shoplift a thousand dollars worth of
- 11:27goods and so if you give someone it start off as it start off as 40 bytes and then they raised it to
- 11:3380 bytes they moved it back and forth a couple times and um it basically it was his compromise
- 11:42but it wasn't big enough for vitalik and so he left and all his buddies left and they went and
- 11:47created an idiot container called Ethereum, where all the scams, all the shit coins,
- 11:52everything happened for about a decade. So it was very nice in Bitcoin because all those people
- 11:56who wanted to play games and they weren't serious about Bitcoin as money and separating money and
- 12:01state, they went over to Ethereum. So that was 2014, call it. And we had this almost a decade
- 12:08of peace. We had the block size wars, but there was no one that that was more debate about monetary
- 12:15transactions in the blockchain and how big the blocks would be. But that whole faction that
- 12:20wanted to do silly things on the blockchain and basically pollute the blockchain. Because again,
- 12:25this is stuff that some poor family is going to have to download 100 years from now. So
- 12:29it's actually not that funny and it makes it harder to run a node, more expensive to run a
- 12:35node. So we had this period of peace and inevitably there was turnover in Bitcoin core
- 12:42dev circles and a lot of the people just sort of aged out.
- 12:46A lot of the people, OG Bitcoiners, a lot of them, or a fair number, obviously got quite rich
- 12:52and you know didn want to have to you know had decided to move on with their lives and start families etc And it I imagine it quite stressful working on Bitcoin Core or Bitcoin Not Software because there a lot of money riding on it
- 13:06And it's a very important project.
- 13:09So there was dev turnover.
- 13:11And we began to see, really, in 2019, 2020, there was a push to replace some of these devs
- 13:19who had retired or moved on to other things.
- 13:21And as part of this, there was this idea, which started off as a good idea,
- 13:25like these things normally do, that we should fund Bitcoin core devs. And there was some funding
- 13:30before going back a few years, but there was a real push to get younger devs and to sort of grow
- 13:36the pipeline of new devs because it's such a niche thing. Like how many people in 2019 wanted to
- 13:43become Bitcoiners or even cared about Bitcoin? And then of that set, how many people wanted
- 13:48to work on the actual node software, which you don't get rich doing. It's very tedious. It's
- 13:53very stressful. And the other thing we had happening back then
- 13:56was Craig Wright, who's this fake Toshi, the scammer who
- 13:59pretend to be Satoshi, he was suing all the Bitcoin core devs.
- 14:02So it was a very stressful time. And that's one reason a bunch
- 14:06of them retired and moved on because it's like, why do why do
- 14:08we need this? So this this this push to bring in new devs started
- 14:14with good intentions. But unfortunately, it ended up
- 14:19recruiting a lot of very young devs who didn't have the same
- 14:21sort of cypherpunk ethos. And, and for obvious reasons, because
- 14:26some of them would just graduate from college, they didn't have
- 14:28any money, like none of us have that much money or any money.
- 14:30When we graduate from college, we usually just have debt
- 14:32instead. It's one thing if you go and volunteer and work on
- 14:36Bitcoin Core because you in 2014, because you have 5000 Bitcoin,
- 14:40and you're going to be you're gonna have a very different
- 14:41attitude to what happens with Bitcoin. You're not gonna be
- 14:44making jokes about it. And you know, joking about wallet while
- 14:47it's being deleted, it's and stuff. But if you're just fresh
- 14:50out of college, maybe this is just another programming job for you. And you can make,
- 14:54you know, 300, $400,000. And so it's sort of self it's selected for for a group of people who were
- 15:01fairly young, seem to seem to like living in blue cities had gone to fairly, fairly left wing
- 15:09universities, though, obviously, all the universities are fairly left wing right now.
- 15:14And so these people didn't have the same ethos. And they didn't have they didn't have their whole
- 15:19net worth in Bitcoin. Most of these people didn't even care about being paid in Bitcoin. They're
- 15:24being paid in fiat. And they were also living together in big blue cities, mainly San Francisco
- 15:31at the Presidio, New York City, Midtown, Manhattan, and London. And John Attack is a Bitcoin core dev
- 15:41who's talked about this. He's done some great interviews with Bob Burnett and Daniel Prince
- 15:46in Knut's Vaughn home. So basically they selected for a certain type of person, someone who's,
- 15:52who's fairly young, doesn't have a family yet, is fine with living in a box in a city,
- 15:58is willing to comply, for example, with the, the COVID vax, because obviously you can go work in an
- 16:03office in the early 2020s without having a vaccine passport. And so it, it unfortunately ended up
- 16:10selecting for, for people who didn't have the same ethos, the kind of people who just want to live in
- 16:16El Salvador, like out in the wilderness and are more hacker types and have slightly different
- 16:21politics. I really don't want to make this a left-right thing. Maybe the better way of looking
- 16:26at it is authoritarianism. And so, you know, if the left wants to inject you with things or the
- 16:31right wants to inject you with things, this is a problem on both sides. But anyway, so what
- 16:37happened is there was a recurrence of Bitcoin spam and it was basically brought back because
- 16:42all the shit coins were dying and the scammers needed something fresh to sell to crypto VCs and
- 16:49to sell to noobs who were like, who got wrecked on all these, these shit coins. And then they're
- 16:54like, I'm never going to buy a shit coin again. So the idea was, well, let's put shit coins on,
- 16:57on Bitcoin and sort of let it share the aura. And so the shit coins on Bitcoin were developed
- 17:03and Bitcoin NFTs, which had been very popular on Ethereum. And these basically began to hit the
- 17:09chain and interfere with monetary transactions and drive up my drive up transaction fees and it also
- 17:15brought a lot of shit coiners over to bitcoin just people with very bad cultural values who
- 17:19didn't care about the blockchain didn't care about separating money from state just wanted to
- 17:24do pump and dumps and scam people um and get rich and of course none of them got rich because they
- 17:30make a lot of money in one pump and dump but then they'd lose it so it's just this sort of casino
- 17:34mentality that we've been shielded from because everyone was on ethereum doing it but ethereum
- 17:39just kept like shooting itself in the foot so many times. And so we basically had these large
- 17:44spam attacks in 2023 and 2024. And anyone who's listening to this, who is trying to do transactions
- 17:50then remembers seeing that just the massive transaction fees. And these transaction fees
- 17:56were not because everyone was using Bitcoin as money and trying to transact on chain. It was
- 18:00because there were spammers and scammers attacking it. And many of these people were well-respected
- 18:05Bitcoiners who ran Bitcoin conferences and had Bitcoin magazines and were respected in the
- 18:10community. It had been around for a while. So it was a very confusing time for many of us,
- 18:15especially I'd only been in Bitcoin for about four years at that point. So I was trying to
- 18:18make heads or tails of it. And people were making arguments like, look how cool it is. We can put
- 18:23the Declaration of Independence on the blockchain. What's more freedom minded than that? Well,
- 18:27the problem is you can put the Declaration of Independence in BitTorrent or you can put it on
- 18:32a satellite and send it to the moon or something, put it on a rocket. There's no reason to put it on
- 18:37the Bitcoin blockchain. Or maybe you can put that, but then that was used to justify putting like
- 18:43pornographic cartoons and just total garbage and bad postmodern art and clip art and just garbage.
- 18:52But unfortunately, the ethos had changed at Bitcoin Core and because of this dev turnover
- 18:57that I was talking about. And we had sort of a group of people who are much more agnostic about
- 19:03what Bitcoin was for. They were hesitant to say this is for money. They didn't really, they had
- 19:07this sort of postmodern way of looking at the world that they had inherited from perhaps from
- 19:12their undergraduate studies. And so they weren't equipped to fight the spam in the same way.
- 19:18And they basically just laid down and let it happen. And they abandoned this tradition of
- 19:23fighting to keep the blockchain as lean and mean as possible. And many of these same characters who
- 19:30in 2014 and 2015, people like Greg Maxwell and Peter Wulla, who are sort of the senior respected
- 19:35devs, even they changed. And I had a quote from Greg Maxwell, I just wanted to read here from
- 19:432014. So he, Greg Maxwell has done a lot for Bitcoin. He's been a longtime contributor. He's
- 19:49one of the easily top three most respected Bitcoin devs living now. And so let me tell
- 19:58you his approach to operaturn and spam in 2014. This is from the Bitcoin repo discussion or Bitcoin
- 20:05talk. Basically, you can Google this, but he writes, I think operaturn, which is this place,
- 20:11you put arbitrary data that we were talking about. I think operaturn has shown itself to
- 20:14be seriously problematic. And we continue to have problems with people believing that storing
- 20:19non-Bitcoin related data in the chain, in the blockchain is an approved, correct,
- 20:25non-antisocial use of the system. We have people selling insane data storage services, etc.
- 20:30It's a bad place to be. So that's Greg Maxwell in 2014. But Greg Maxwell in 2023 to 2026,
- 20:37all of a sudden doesn't believe that protecting the Bitcoin blockchain is that important.
- 20:43and um and in fact he's been saying the opposite he's been saying like uh people who are on my side
- 20:50fighting for this sort of traditional stuff that you know we're the weirdos and we don't understand
- 20:54bitcoin and so there's this weird thing you can do where you can use greg maxwell's a genius he's
- 20:58a he's a very impressive guy who's done a lot for bitcoin but he can't really explain why he changed
- 21:03his view and so you can play this fun game of quoting greg maxwell in 2014 to refute him
- 21:08in 2026. And so there's this toxic combination among Bitcoin core devs where the senior devs
- 21:15like Greg Maxwell and Peter Woola sort of burned out, checked out, rich, and, you know,
- 21:21wanted to kind of work on their own things. And so they weren't pulling the younger devs into line.
- 21:26Younger devs, I've talked about Gloria Zao, who's no longer with the project, but she was
- 21:30a shit coiner undergrad at UC Berkeley. It was never really a hacker type. She studied CS,
- 21:36apparently in college and then went to work on Bitcoin. It's just another corporate job.
- 21:42So there's a whole, we probably don't have to go into it here, but there's a whole
- 21:46dating nepotism, DEI element to this as well. That's quite ugly where people who are founding
- 21:53and running them nonprofits and giving out money, we're also dating the female devs.
- 21:59And basically promoting people, these people were pushed up past their ability or past their level
- 22:05of wisdom. And so you had immature Bitcoin devs who, who, you know, I don't think they're bad
- 22:11people or anything. They're just young and they're being given everything on a silver platter and
- 22:15they're making hundreds of thousands of dollars a year out of college. And they're going to hang
- 22:20out with Greg Maxwell and Peter Willa. Like it's amazing. It's something that you kind of can make
- 22:24your head big if you, if at some point doing that. So the junior devs like Gloria just had no idea,
- 22:30they were shit coiners. They, like they, they actually were teaching how to do shit coin ICOs
- 22:35at Berkeley as part of their crypto club.
- 22:38They didn't understand that this was a spam attack and this was dangerous.
- 22:42Then for some reason, whether because they're checked out or because they're somehow compromised,
- 22:46the senior devs were not pulling them into line.
- 22:50Now we're dealing with a very young group of devs.
- 22:54There's kind of a core group, which are called the maintainers.
- 22:56These are people who have been given right access to the Bitcoin repo so they can actually
- 23:02make changes to the code. And theoretically, they're not supposed to make any changes that
- 23:07the community doesn't agree with. But I think one of the red flags is that there were changes made.
- 23:17And there's this metaphor that the Bitcoin core maintainers are like janitors. They're just
- 23:21basically cleaning up the code and making it compatible with new operating systems and fixing
- 23:25bugs but they became much more uh much more activist and in kind of a weird woke way so
- 23:32there's this all this discussion of bitcoin core like especially during the george floyd times that
- 23:36we we shouldn't use the word blacklist in our in our documentation and in our software documentation
- 23:41because that's somehow i don't know that's racist i guess calling it blacklist so they wanted to
- 23:47call it some other thing so yeah just give that as an example of the mentality like you know we're
- 23:51trying to destroy the central banks. And there are all types of people in Bitcoin. And Bitcoiners
- 23:59just get along with everyone. We're international. We're global. We don't care about skin color. We
- 24:04don't care about gender or politics or anything, as long as you're here to separate money from state.
- 24:10And so this weird stuff began to creep in. And this has happened with other open source projects
- 24:16like Linux and Tor. I'm not sure exactly why that is, but people have told me about this happening
- 24:22elsewhere. Part of it is just trying to capture these very important things. It's much easier to
- 24:27capture something in a sneaky way if it's open source and distributed and decentralized like
- 24:36Bitcoin aims to be. We had these spam attacks. The Bitcoin core devs just laid down. Basically,
- 24:43the blockchain got completely destroyed and got filled up with spam. Something called the UTXO set
- 24:50completely blew up from four gigabytes to 12 gigabytes. Now, UTXOs, these are chunks of
- 24:57unspent Bitcoin. They're very important because when a node sees a new transaction in order to
- 25:03avoid double spending, it has to go quickly check the UTXO set to say, oh, can this chunk of Bitcoin
- 25:10still be spent or is it already been spent? And so if you're running a Bitcoin node, and I would
- 25:15encourage everyone, run a Bitcoin Nots node because you'll learn a lot of this sounds abstract and
- 25:20complicated. When you run your own node, it's really easy to do. You just download the software.
- 25:23It's free. Go to BitcoinNots.org, I think it is, or get a Start9 server and run it on there.
- 25:30But this is something a lot of people have experienced over the last year when they try to
- 25:33spin up a new node and do that initial syncing process that we're talking about.
- 25:37It stalls out in 2023 and 2024 when these spam attacks happen.
- 25:42And that's because of the UTXO set bloat that happened then.
- 25:45And again, it wasn't because people were using Bitcoin as money.
- 25:47It was because of shit coins.
- 25:48It was mostly because of shit coins on Bitcoin.
- 25:51So there are people in the community who are actively Bitcoiners,
- 25:55quote unquote Bitcoiners who are actively scamming newcomers to the space trying to get them into shit coins on Bitcoin just so they could take their money And in the process it like peeing in the pool or leaving your needles all
- 26:07over the park, destroying the commons in the process. And so it's become much more difficult
- 26:11to run a node as a result of this. So basically, the UTXO set, which cannot be pruned, it needs to
- 26:18be held by every node runner, it bloated from four gigabytes to 12 gigabytes. So all of a sudden,
- 26:24if you're running a Raspberry Pi and it's four gigabytes, you can't use it anymore. You need to
- 26:31get some external drive for it and then it's slower to do the initial sync, the initial block
- 26:36download, et cetera. And so this is a real problem. And this is one way to attack Bitcoin,
- 26:43to make it more difficult to run a node because it's the node runners like you and me who basically
- 26:48secure the network and ensure that the 21 million cap is enforced. So unlike gold, which has these
- 26:54sort of atomic properties that make it what it is. Bitcoin is enforced by Bitcoiners running nodes.
- 27:00That's how Bitcoin works. And the miners are just employees, the exchanges, they just will trade
- 27:05your Bitcoin for fiat. But it's node runners like you and me who own Bitcoin and run nodes. We are
- 27:09the network and we are the immune system of Bitcoin. And so if you want to hurt Bitcoin,
- 27:14you hurt the node runners, you blow out the UTXO set. So I'm still, I'm still, I'm going to come
- 27:19back to the compromise piece. This is all, I'll lead up to that. So we basically had eight gigabytes
- 27:24of UTXO set blow. And again, this isn't a question of memory or storage or anything. It just makes it,
- 27:30it means it can take a lot longer to spin up a node. And in the modern world, when you download
- 27:35a new app on your phone, you know, people's patience is very, very short. If that thing
- 27:39doesn't install and download in like five seconds, you've already probably clicked away.
- 27:43And so running a node, it's already a pain now. It's become more expensive thanks to Bitcoin Core,
- 27:47you know, might cost you 800 or a thousand dollars. And then you have to plug it in and,
- 27:52And not everyone lives in the Presidio or Midtown Manhattan like Bitcoin Core devs and has high-speed internet and a $3,000 computer, etc.
- 28:00So there are people on my channel in the comment section, it'll take them 30 days to sync a node.
- 28:06And it syncs really well.
- 28:07And then in 2023 and 2024, it completely crawls to a halt.
- 28:11And so it's a very subtle attack on Bitcoin that a lot of people don't understand.
- 28:17And this whole thing goes against basically Bitcoin Core sat on their hands.
- 28:21They didn't do anything while this thing was bloating from four gigabytes to 12 gigabytes.
- 28:26And the whole point of Bitcoin Core is to make it easy to run a node and to help Bitcoiners run a node.
- 28:30That is what the project is.
- 28:34Luke Dasher, who's really the OG Bitcoin dev who's been around since, I believe, 2011.
- 28:42And he's an interesting person, too, because he's seen it all since 2011.
- 28:47And he has this vast memory and context for how things work.
- 28:52So he saw the spam attack for what it was, because he had been in Bitcoin for over 10 years at that point, over a decade.
- 28:58And he put in a pull request, in other words, a request to change the software to stop this from happening, because it's just a complete disaster for node runners.
- 29:07Bitcoin Core turned it down.
- 29:09They said, we're not going to do anything about it.
- 29:11We're not going to merge this PR.
- 29:12We're not going to come up with a new PR of our own.
- 29:15We're just not going to do anything.
- 29:17So again, that's really weird when you have 10 years and you saw the thing I just read
- 29:21from Greg Maxwell saying that this is antisocial.
- 29:24This is bad for the blockchain.
- 29:26This is a huge problem.
- 29:27All of a sudden, it's not a problem in 2023 and 2024.
- 29:31So that could be attributed to laziness or just some sort of ignorance of how Bitcoin
- 29:36arbitrary data has always been treated.
- 29:38but then the real mask off moment came in about a year ago in in 2025 and there was this very
- 29:46strong push from bitcoin core to blow open hop return so we talked about how it started off at
- 29:5140 bytes and then 80 bytes uh it's a little bit like the income tax you know it starts off at one
- 29:56percent and affects just uh just the super wealthy in 1913 and now of course no one's paying one
- 30:02percent and it affects everyone up and down the um the tax bracket chain so so what happened is
- 30:10basically they allowed the utxo set to bloat they did not let luke uh they didn't merge his his fix
- 30:17which was basically a filter that would have would have prevented all this from happening
- 30:20and the reason hl hl is one of the the maintainers uh gave for not merging it saying it was just too
- 30:28controversial. So fast forward to 2025, they decide to blow open another big hole that you can put spam
- 30:35in, which is OpReturn. So it had been at 40 bytes, raised to 80 bytes, and they decided to just blow
- 30:41it open all the way to 100,000 bytes. So they basically got rid of the cap. They did what's
- 30:45called uncapping data carrier size. And so that 100,000 byte limit, so 1,250 times bigger than 80
- 30:53bytes, that that limit was basically being enforced by other filters in Bitcoin. And what
- 30:59was the reason they gave for it? They gave a number of reasons. And I watched your interview
- 31:03with Chris Guido, which I'd encourage everyone to watch. It's a great, great interview. And he goes
- 31:08through some of the other reasons they gave in terms of mempool fee estimation and block
- 31:14propagation. But the really the big thing, the big smoking gun, in my opinion, and I imagine Chris
- 31:20would agree with this, is that the justification they gave in 2025 for blowing open Op return
- 31:26was that this would blow out the UTXO set. And this was done to accommodate a shitcoin,
- 31:33Bitcoin affinity scam startup called Citria. I like to call it shitria. And they basically,
- 31:40they needed, they told one of the Bitcoin core devs named Antoine Poinceau that they were going to,
- 31:45as part of their effort to turn Bitcoin into Ethereum, to give people the ability to scam
- 31:51on Bitcoin, as people did on Ethereum, they needed to do this sort of watchtower justice
- 31:57transaction where if something went wrong, they would post a small amount of data onto the chain.
- 32:04And they needed to post, I believe it was 144 bytes. And they wanted to put an operaturn,
- 32:09but Oppurtern was only 80 bytes. So they wanted to put the extra 64 bytes in the UTXO set in
- 32:17what's called fake pub keys. And so Antoine was, first of all, it's very strange that you have
- 32:23Bitcoin core devs talking to a shitcoin company that basically wants to turn Bitcoin into Ethereum.
- 32:27That's not who I want looking after my node software. They're having these social relationships
- 32:32and they're all hanging out in wherever it is in the Presidio or in Midtown Manhattan.
- 32:36and uh that's that's the other problem these sort of social clicks um so so basically they did that
- 32:44and um this was given as one of the reasons for blowing open opertern because they're saying they
- 32:50the the main stated reason was we don't want to contribute to utxo set bloat and chitria wants to
- 32:57put 64 bytes which was never going to happen anyway it or it could happen like once every once
- 33:03every five years. Not that Chitria is going to be around in five years from now. I can guarantee you
- 33:07that. So they didn't care about eight gigabytes of UTXO set blow, but they were willing to blow
- 33:13a giant hole into Bitcoin for 64 bytes. That would probably never happen. This is the Fauci moment
- 33:21where basically there's this huge contradiction. Masks don't work, but you have to wear a mask now.
- 33:27This is the same thing Bitcoin Core was saying throughout 2025. Filters don't work. Filters
- 33:31don't do anything. Oh, but by the way, we need to blow open this filter for Citria or they're
- 33:36going to blow up the UTXO set. And we really all of a sudden care about the UTXO set. We care about
- 33:4164 bytes of bloat when we didn't care about eight gigabytes and refuse to do anything.
- 33:47Now, remember I said HL refused to blow that open, refused Luke's PR to fix inscriptions in
- 33:522023 because HL said it was too controversial. So what happens in 2025? Bitcoin Core is
- 34:01willing to blast through this highly, highly contentious change. There's a lot of funny
- 34:06business involved. They were locking and unlocking the repo. They were banning people. They were
- 34:12having private conversations. And basically, this was sort of presented to the world as a fait
- 34:16accompli that this thing was done and we're going to blow up an opportune. And what happened last
- 34:22year as a result of this, 20% of the network left Bitcoin Core and started running much better
- 34:27software, which is Bitcoin knots. And so we talked about how you might know Fauci's compromised if
- 34:32you don't have that, that if the information hasn't come out somehow, that he was funding
- 34:37labs in Wuhan. Here's this thing where all of a sudden, they start worrying about UTXO set blow
- 34:43when they've been laying down on the job for three years, all of a sudden, it becomes so,
- 34:47so important. And so I would say this is a moment, this is a little bit like one of the
- 34:51covidian moments where where um we knew we knew bitcoin core was lying just like we knew fauci was
- 34:57lying and bitcoin core knew that we knew they were lying and they didn't care because like fauci
- 35:04they're in a position of power and it's just like f you we're going to push this through oh yeah we
- 35:08don't do contentious updates uh when they when they uh can help to stop the spam problem um but
- 35:14when it's going to increase more spam on the blockchain because obviously 100 000 bytes is a
- 35:18a lot more than 80 bytes. And when 20% of the network leaves, highly, highly contentious,
- 35:24we're still going to push it through. So I think that's really the mask off moment.
- 35:29And their technical justifications were so weak. And then their whole response to community pushback
- 35:35was, oh, the plebs, you guys aren't coders. You guys are idiots. It was just like COVID again.
- 35:42You need to trust the experts. And if you don't actually know how to code in C++,
- 35:45plus, you can't even have a conversation about it. This was their point of view. Whereas it was very
- 35:51clear with COVID, you didn't have to be a virologist to understand what was going on.
- 35:58You didn't have to understand. You could basically see the changing narratives, the gaslighting,
- 36:03the contradictions, just the absurdity of it all. And something similar has happened in Bitcoin.
- 36:08It all makes a lot of sense. So for anyone who isn't familiar,
- 36:11knots is you can think of it it's an alternative that you can run on your node and it stays it
- 36:18adheres more to the uh to like legacy bitcoin core pre pre some of these changes you're describing
- 36:24i would actually add to that that it's it's um it's actually a much more configurable software
- 36:30as well which is nice from sort of a freedom perspective so it actually doesn't it has more
- 36:35knobs and dials than um than bitcoin core so you you can actually run a bitcoin knots node
- 36:40and you can increase the spam if you want to.
- 36:43It basically, it's not paternalistic like Bitcoin Core.
- 36:46It actually lets you set more things.
- 36:48It'd be more flexible.
- 36:49Though you are correct, the people who run it,
- 36:51they're not running it because they want to create more spam.
- 36:54We've got Bitcoin Core to do that for us.
- 36:56Okay, so full disclosure, I do run Nots.
- 37:00The concerns I have with it are, first of all,
- 37:04I think one big one isn't necessarily the software itself.
- 37:07It's not a consensus change.
- 37:08It's a relay policy thing.
- 37:10It's what is your node actually?
- 37:12What transactions is it willing to relay on to others on the network?
- 37:16To what extent do you find it viable that Knott's reaches enough adoption that it's actually useful and not just a philosophical stance that you're taking, which candidly is more or less why I run Knott's?
- 37:28And then I think the second big concern is the lack of, not that obviously Core has its problems from a development perspective, but you've got more or less Luke is kind of the guy with Noughts and relatively fewer eyeballs on Noughts in addition to a lower number of developers.
- 37:45How do you address both the adoption concern and maybe like the technical concern that people might have with something like Noughts?
- 37:52Yeah, they're both good questions. So we can start by, for people who don't know, Bitcoin Knotts is actually a fork or a mod of Bitcoin Core. And so that's not like a soft fork or a hard fork. It basically means like a copy paste.
- 38:08And then you make some changes, as you said, to the memfo filters, which affect what gets relayed from node to node. Luke does have some discretion what he ports over as well. But they're basically consensus compatible. So it's the same Bitcoin. They enforce the same basic rules in terms of what can end up in a block.
- 38:31And so you have a situation where for the last decade, you had 99% of node runners running Bitcoin Core. And as I said, this has now shifted. So it's more 20, 80, 20% running nodes and 80% running Core.
- 38:48So the first sort of pushback I would make is that Bitcoin Core, the way it functions, you have many, many contributors.
- 38:56It's an open source project.
- 38:57There are probably 200 300 people who contribute who have contributed It might just be one line of code But then you have this really core group of maintainers who have right access to the repo
- 39:10and seem to be friends and in the same social clicks, et cetera. And so even though you have
- 39:16five, maybe you have six maintainers now, I'm trying to remember the exact number.
- 39:21There's a lot of group think going on, as we do know, and it kind of functions. They all protect
- 39:27each other. It's like this little inner cabal. So Bitcoin Core is fairly centralized. Bitcoin
- 39:33Nots is even more centralized because you only have one maintainer. But it's already an improvement
- 39:37for the network to have two separate implementations running because you have one sort of centralized
- 39:43implementation and then you have one really centralized implementation. But Luke is a real
- 39:48contrarian kind of someone who always speaks his mind, you know, whether no matter the social cost.
- 39:56And so just having two different implementations that still have the same consensus rules, I think there is an improvement in terms of robustness and antifragility there.
- 40:06So if there is a bug that takes down all the Bitcoin core nodes, now we have at least 20% are running not.
- 40:12So that does make the network more resilient.
- 40:16And then the great irony is the biggest bug that we've seen in the past 12 months, apart from the sort of malicious stuff that perhaps Bitcoin Core has done, the biggest bug we've seen shipped with this very controversial version of Bitcoin Core, Bitcoin Core version 30.
- 40:33And it basically, after all this talk, like Luke doesn't know what he's doing and, you know, there's just one maintainer, we can't trust him.
- 40:39After all of this, they weren't careful enough with Bitcoin Core 30. It basically shipped with a bug that they were basically changing wallet types, the wallet that comes with the node.
- 40:52As part of this migration, you had to migrate from the old wallet to the new wallet. There was a wallet migration bug.
- 40:59Someone was not paying attention. Bitcoin Core made the decision to delete.
- 41:06if there was a problem with the migration, Bitcoin Core would delete the old wallet
- 41:11rather than just saving it, saving it just to be safe. So this is a major bug. I've talked to
- 41:16Bitcoiners who lost money. Core has clearly shown malicious sort of compromised behavior,
- 41:21but they're also shipping buggy code. Very embarrassing. And so there seems to be something
- 41:25broken with their process as well, their sort of quality assurance. And this was a bug that
- 41:32that Luke did not because he's very careful when he adds new features or does this stuff.
- 41:37So this did not affect Bitcoin not's user user. So that's the first thing I would say,
- 41:42using the great irony, if you use a Bitcoin core this year, you might have had your wallet deleted,
- 41:46but the bug was not present in Bitcoin not's. Nevertheless, you are right, it's not good to
- 41:50have one guy in charge of something. And this is the very sad state we're in in Bitcoin, where we
- 41:56have a compromised Bitcoin core. And then we have this OG who for people who don't know who Luke
- 42:02Dasher is, he's literally saved Bitcoin two, arguably three different times. One of the times
- 42:08very early, I believe like 2013, there was this chain split and he was the guy who came up with
- 42:13the way of basically healing it. He literally saved Bitcoin. He also saved it again with the
- 42:18UASF in 2017. And we'd have big blocks. We'd basically look like Bcash or BSV if it weren't
- 42:26for Luke Dasher. And actually Bitcoin Mechanic was involved in that UASF as well.
- 42:32And so if you had to pick someone, Luke is a maverick.
- 42:35He's a contrarian.
- 42:36He's a difficult figure.
- 42:38And he's also a CS genius.
- 42:41He's an absolute genius.
- 42:43So it's not ideal to have one person.
- 42:46On the other hand, we are a decentralized project.
- 42:49No one controls Bitcoin.
- 42:51And we're in a really bad place where the reference implementation went wrong.
- 42:56And so once again, a lot is hanging on poor Luke's shoulders.
- 43:00and um he's he's as i understand it i don't want to put attribute something to him that he's not
- 43:06doing as i understand it he spends because ocean is pretty much built out now they're their mining
- 43:11pool company he spends he spends almost all of his time working on working on bitcoin knots
- 43:17and he's extremely careful he also um he contributes he still contributes to bitcoin
- 43:22core in terms of reporting bugs to them when he finds it i mean one way of looking at is you have
- 43:27Bitcoin core looking at all the code and then they create their version. And then Luke comes in
- 43:33and looks at it and decides if there's a wallet deletion bug, he probably is not going to move
- 43:39that over. And so Luke in some sense is almost like a sixth or seventh maintainer who looks at
- 43:44Bitcoin core. And then he doesn't change that much. It's mostly the same software. It's probably
- 43:4999% the same software. But we are in the weird situation where Luke has saved Bitcoin at least
- 43:56twice before. And he's now at the center of the two most important things happening in Bitcoin
- 44:01right now, the two essential things, which is diversifying ourselves away from having just
- 44:06one reference implementation with Bitcoin Core. So it's very good. And now that 20% of the network
- 44:11is running knots, that must be a huge weight on Luke's shoulders to have to... The stakes are so
- 44:20much higher. And he takes great pride in it. The thing I've noticed on Twitter as well is that he
- 44:25actually talks to node runners he talks to the plebs he's actually actively talking to plebs
- 44:30telling asking them to report bugs etc talking about their experience like he takes it very
- 44:34seriously he's a very serious guy and he doesn't he doesn't suffer fools idly and then on the on
- 44:40the bitcoin core side but we have a lot of very disinterested people who don't really want to hear
- 44:44they they don't want to be bothered they're software developers who don't want to hear from
- 44:47their users and so we've had situations i don't can't remember if chris guida talked about it on
- 44:52your show, but he used to work for Start9. He helped people spin up hundreds, if not thousands
- 44:57of nodes. And so when Bitcoin Core was talking about, you know, the node syncing speeds, etc.,
- 45:05Chris offered his input. They didn't want to talk to him. And then when Bitcoin Core is rolling out
- 45:10Bitcoin Core version 30, one of their justifications was mining pool centralization. So Bob Burnett,
- 45:16who runs Barefoot Mining and is a really kind of senior executive guy, he was the
- 45:21chief technical officer at Gateway. So he's like a real tech guy. He's not like an English major
- 45:28like me. He went to Bitcoin Core to offer his input and they didn't want to talk to him either.
- 45:33So this is another reason we know they're compromised because their justifications
- 45:37for doing what they do, they don't actually want to talk to real users. And so this is one thing
- 45:42that I really like about Bitcoin Nots. The good news though about Bitcoin Nots as well is
- 45:47as the adoption rises, the funding is now rising for it. And so there are things happening. It
- 45:54looks like some more devs are going to be going over there. There are already people, I believe,
- 45:58helping Luke part-time. But this is like anything else. This is like saying,
- 46:04who's going to run Bitcoin Core in 2011? Or how are we going to pay these people?
- 46:09And if there's demand for a software product, the funding comes. And a lot of people have seen how
- 46:15important it is now to have different clients to run. There's a third node implementation project
- 46:20that's being launched by Jimmy Song and Samson Mal called Production Ready. And so I think this
- 46:30will be good if they're able to, these things take time, but we'll move to the point where maybe
- 46:35there are three implementations. I think Bitcoin Core has a real branding and people problem. So
- 46:41maybe they just disappear or they have to change their name or something?
- 46:45My thought is I would love to reach a stage where there's no longer really a reference
- 46:50implementation, that the code base is forked as it was with Notts. Probably some derivative of the
- 46:58main code base will be what production ready is with, again, to what Notts has done. Minor
- 47:04adjustments, maybe more conservative than core has been. Maybe it's not quite as dogmatic as what
- 47:10knots is but at least when someone is spinning up a new node they actually have to pause and assess
- 47:15what is it that i want to run where do my values lie because today my concern with knots is because
- 47:21it's only 20 if i'm just a random guy off the street found bitcoin heard i should run a node
- 47:26decided to spin one up i'm going to say okay well what should i run probably the latest version of
- 47:31the thing that the most people run yeah right and then people are going to buy default opt into that
- 47:36And I'm not, it's not even like a philosophical claim that you should or shouldn't.
- 47:42It's more just to make people step back for a moment and say, okay, I'm going to do this thing.
- 47:48What's the thing that I, how should I approach this and have to go to a little bit of research, which maybe creates a bit of friction in getting people to run nodes.
- 47:57But at least they're more mindful about why am I here for Bitcoin?
- 48:01Am I here because I want BRC20 tokens?
- 48:04Am I here for ordinals?
- 48:05am I here for sound money? And they can make that judgment themselves.
- 48:11I think it's a situation that's going to heal itself too, because I heard similar,
- 48:16you know, this is good pushback, but I heard similar pushback when Bitcoin Nots was at 1%
- 48:21of the network last May. And people were mocking us and saying, who's going to run this? It's so
- 48:25small, et cetera. And now we're at 20% and we're still growing. And our software client, which we
- 48:31could talk about later is growing as well. And so I think people, first of all, most Bitcoiners don't
- 48:36run nodes. I didn't run a node for a couple of years. But I think the landscape is rapidly
- 48:43changing. The new adoption in Bitcoin nodes, it's all people running Bitcoin knots because no one
- 48:49in the space is advocating, or very few people, I know you guys do, but very few people are
- 48:53advocating for running a Bitcoin node. And even Bitcoin core devs, they don't seem to care about
- 48:59it. And there's been some evidence. Jeremy Rubin went on a podcast and basically said that
- 49:06Bitcoin core devs, none of them run nodes or most of them don't run nodes.
- 49:10That's wild.
- 49:11The point I was getting to is that Bitcoin nodes could be at 50% very soon. And when BIP110 wins,
- 49:19so we'll go into that later maybe, but Bitcoin core isn't even prepared for BIP110. So I think
- 49:25the landscape will be quite different. It's almost like saying, you know, if people are going to come
- 49:29to get a COVID shot, are they going to get the Pfizer or, you know, are they going to know that
- 49:33that one was slightly worse because it had, you know, turbo cancer in it than the Moderna one?
- 49:38Well, these things sort of solve themselves because when people start comparing notes and,
- 49:43you know, their uncle died because they got the Pfizer vax, they're not going to, we don't have
- 49:47to worry about people, you know, word will spread. And the same is true with Core. You know, the guy,
- 49:52The guys who had their wallets deleted by Core are not going to, you know, they'll be letting people know don't run Core.
- 49:59Yeah, that's probably true.
- 50:01And honestly, the attention that this battle has gained, it's, I think, going to bring more people online with nodes, which I think is fantastic.
- 50:11It's had a real silver lining that way.
- 50:12I agree.
- 50:13Yeah, yeah.
- 50:13Because people realize, oh, the network is only as resilient as its user base.
- 50:18Like the network is, to your point, the network is the people.
- 50:21It is the people.
- 50:21Yeah, like my belief of Bitcoin is that you can buy as much Bitcoin as you want, and you can even take it into self-custody, and you are not a participant in the network unless you are also running a node.
- 50:32You're still somewhat passively.
- 50:34Well, you don't even know that you have it if you're not running a node.
- 50:37You may think you have it in self-custody, but your hardware wallet maker or the software associated with may just be spoofing it.
- 50:46And how do you even, you can't even send it without a node.
- 50:49like you have to rely on someone else's node so if you ever want to spend it or move it around
- 50:53um you're really a second class citizen as you know if you don't if you don't run a node because
- 50:58you can't verify that it's real bitcoin you're not really a participant in the network enforcing
- 51:03the rules and if we ever run into a bad situation like who knows what's going to happen in 2028 in
- 51:07the u.s or wherever wherever people are um maybe you won't be able to access public nodes or it
- 51:13may become difficult um and then that's the other thing too if you don't want to leak privacy if you
- 51:17use someone else's node, they're noticing all your transactions. And, you know, we really don't
- 51:21want that. So they're good, selfish, self-interested reasons to run a Bitcoin node. And we want to,
- 51:27I was sort of guilty of this in my early videos, kind of attributing, and I think a lot of people
- 51:32make this mistake when they're new to Bitcoin, attributing to Bitcoin these magic qualities,
- 51:36like, you know, Satoshi created this perfect software that magically keeps everything at 21
- 51:42million. And, you know, Satoshi gave us a great gift, but this is not how Bitcoin works. Bitcoin
- 51:48is whatever Bitcoiners want it to be. And so this is one of the concerns with Shytria that they want
- 51:54to, you know, if Bitcoiners decide to turn Bitcoin into Ethereum, there's nothing that can stop that
- 52:00from happening. We can move to proof of stake just like Ethereum. It's the node runners that
- 52:04these things. And so if you have any significant portion of your net worth in Bitcoin,
- 52:09Bitcoin is always under attack and we need good Bitcoiners to run nodes,
- 52:13enforce the rules, fight spam. Because Bitcoin doesn't defend itself. It's not magic software.
- 52:23They're shit coins like Bcash and BSV that are very, very similar software because they're
- 52:27forks of Bitcoin. And they're absolutely terrible because the culture is different and it's used for
- 52:33different things. So there's nothing magical about software. Just Bitcoiners are special people.
- 52:39And they're also, when you have all your money in Bitcoin, like I do, you really take these
- 52:45things seriously. And if you're a Bitcoin core dev who just graduated from college and you don't
- 52:50have any Bitcoin and you don't run a node, that's pretty sad. You kind of be forgiven. You can
- 52:55understand why those people aren't terrified of what's been happening to Bitcoin. Let's touch on
- 53:00BIP 110 briefly here. Why don't you give just the quick overview of what it is? And then I think
- 53:06more importantly, what do you think the likelihood of it activating is? And if it doesn't, what's the
- 53:12fallout? So yeah, let me give the context for that. So we basically have had this escalation
- 53:17in fighting spam because, as I said, unlike in 2014, when we had the help of Bitcoin Core,
- 53:23we basically have a hostile Bitcoin Core implementation that just doesn't even want
- 53:28talk about these things and it's blocked everyone um and so the way we've escalated is we we first we
- 53:33kind of fought the social media battle uh with with bitcoin core and its supporters saying please
- 53:39don't do this please don't ship uh bitcoin core 30 because it has all these problems um and they
- 53:45went ahead and did it anyway and then they blocked everyone and just basically it was just like
- 53:51fauci like well you know you're going to take the shot whether you want it or not you know or if you
- 53:55if you want to work or get an airplane or go to a restaurant. And so what we did is, you know,
- 53:59many of us just deserted, dumped Bitcoin Core, started running Bitcoin knots and running better
- 54:05filters. So that's the first place that we fought the battle was that the level of mempool filters.
- 54:10And to be very clear, filters are not censorship. They've been around. Their filters were invented
- 54:14by Satoshi Nakamoto and have been around since 2019. So that's the other thing. The other reason
- 54:18you know, Bitcoin Core is compromised. All this gaslighting that filters is censorship.
- 54:22absolute nonsense it's it's it's no more censorship than gmail for example saying you
- 54:28can't upload an attachment more than 25 megabytes uh that's not that's not google censoring you
- 54:33that's just google telling you if you want to send a giant file use google drive or google storage or
- 54:39something don't use email for it and likewise with um likewise with mempool filters so we had
- 54:45this escalation at the at the social layer and then sort of at the mempool layer and yet uh but
- 54:51But the problem we have now is approximately 80% of the network is running Bitcoin Core
- 54:55version 30 or version 31 or one of these versions that has a large op return.
- 55:03And this is very dangerous for the Bitcoin network because there's this giant spot there
- 55:08now for arbitrary data, for non-monetary data.
- 55:13And you can imagine Bitcoin mechanic likes using this analogy, like who would just like
- 55:19spin up a server and open it up to the internet and let people fill it with whatever they want.
- 55:24You know, immediately if you did something like that, it'd be filled with just, you know,
- 55:28the stuff you see on 4chan or whatever, just be filled with, or much worse stuff.
- 55:35And the one thing we've focused on a little bit on my side is child sexual abuse material
- 55:39and the risks of this hitting Bitcoin. And when you create a large space for it,
- 55:44it becomes a much bigger risk. And there have been forks of Bitcoin like BSV that have been
- 55:48totally destroyed by people posting this horrific, horrific material. And that the problem with
- 55:58CSAM, child sexual abuse material on Bitcoin, is Bitcoin has an immutable blockchain. And so
- 56:04you can't really, if someone discovers it's there, there's no way to delete it.
- 56:09And so basically, the network has been exposed since October 10, since this thing shipped.
- 56:15And as there was adoption and people rolling over from Bitcoin core version 29 to 30, you basically have this huge new attack surface for Bitcoin. It's a CSAM attack surface. But there's other things people can put there. There are many different cultures in the world, many different types of people.
- 56:34and you could imagine putting something there that would upset the Chinese government or that
- 56:40would upset Muslims or Christians or whoever. I basically did not get in the game of Bitcoin to
- 56:49host whatever data people want me to put on my node. It's not something I'm willing to fight for.
- 56:55It's not something that's important. I sure as hell don't want anything like CSAM on my computer.
- 57:00So this is the real threat. And this is the reason that we've moved. Because Bitcoin Core refused to reverse course and back down. All they really need to do, and they could do it today, they can make this problem go away today. Just revert data carrier size, revert opportun from 100,000 back down to 80. You want to take the wind out of our sails? Just do that.
- 57:22you know then what are we gonna there's still the inscriptions problem there's still the problem
- 57:26that we don't trust bitcoin core but but um that would be that would be a great gesture and that's
- 57:31the bizarre thing about bitcoin core they're willing to fragment the network they're willing
- 57:34to cause a contentious chain split just because they're so stubborn um they pushed through this
- 57:40thing that was unpopular it's become much less popular since then and they're unwilling to revert
- 57:45the changes so that's that's what makes people think maybe there's there's an attack vector here
- 57:49that was planned. Basically, if a CSAM thing ended up in a Bitcoin op return, you have about 10 to 30
- 57:57minutes to try to reorg it out by mining on a different block, mining on the block before,
- 58:02and sort of make sure that block doesn't end up as part of the blockchain. It's very, very difficult
- 58:06to do. Once it's in the blockchain, it's there. It's basically there forever unless you do a manual
- 58:12intervention and basically hard code that block. The problem is if there's CSAM on the blockchain,
- 58:17Imagine a node runner, you know, 10 years from now, or just someone today, do you want to spit
- 58:22up a new node? And in the process, you have to download child sexual abuse material on your
- 58:26computer. It's like a non-starter. It's absolutely non-starter. It's not the fact that it's illegal.
- 58:31It's a fact that it's, it's inhuman and disgusting. And, you know, people who have kids and people
- 58:36who don't have kids, everyone's against that. And so what we've, what we've moved to do is to do
- 58:42BIP110, which aims to do many different things. It's not just a CSAM thing, but I thought I would
- 58:48bring that up because that's an important thing that we need to make sure that doesn't happen.
- 58:53And we've been very lucky that it hasn't happened since October 10th. But what BIP110 is,
- 59:00it's a temporary soft fork. So it's a temporary change in the rules that aims to basically roll
- 59:06things back and revert the changes that Bitcoin Core has made over the past two or three years,
- 59:13and basically rejecting their idea that Bitcoin is a file storage service that can just be used
- 59:18for anything. So it asserts that Bitcoin is money. It reverts OperaTurn back from 100,000 down to 80
- 59:25bytes at the consensus level. And so you won't be able to include large, nasty things in OperaTurns
- 59:32after this. And it also fixes the inscriptions bug, which Bitcoin Core, in spite of all their
- 59:38concern about UTXO set below, they somehow just let this happen. So it fixes that and closes that
- 59:43attack vector and basically reverts a lot of these bad changes that Core has made. The problem we have
- 59:50is the Bitcoin Core reference implementation for node software pushed through something unilaterally.
- 59:56And so Bit1.10 and Bitcoin knots people's messages, you cannot do that as devs. You're just like five
- 1:00:02five young people. You cannot do this to Bitcoin. This is not how Bitcoin works. Bitcoin is
- 1:00:07decentralized. You need to get NodeRunner's permission. And so we're going to push back
- 1:00:12against you. And we tried to do it nicely. We tried to do it with mempool filters. We tried
- 1:00:16to do it with Bitcoin knots, et cetera. But you've now exposed the network to really horrible things
- 1:00:21and done it basically to accommodate these crypto VCs and companies like Shatria. So it's very,
- 1:00:28It's disgusting what's happening.
- 1:00:30And it may just be financial interests or maybe an actual attack on Bitcoin in an effort
- 1:00:36to discourage node runners.
- 1:00:38So BIP-110 is a temporary soft fork.
- 1:00:40Why temporary?
- 1:00:41Real quick, why temporary?
- 1:00:42Or maybe you'll get to that.
- 1:00:44Yeah no it a good question So a soft fork is let first talk about what a fork is So a fork is just a change in the rules and so bip 110 is a very a change in the software rules or the consensus rules
- 1:00:57bip 110 is actually very simple it just basically reverts opera turn back fixes the inscriptions
- 1:01:02hack and closes a couple other attack surfaces um that luke is aware of this is this is an
- 1:01:09interesting insight he's aware of these things they're in the bip and they haven't been exploited
- 1:01:13yet. So we're trying to be proactive about these things as well. And we're trying to do it in a way
- 1:01:18where we don't let the spammers and scammers know about these attack surfaces. So it's a very
- 1:01:22delicate thing we're trying to do. You have a fork, which is a change in the consensus rules,
- 1:01:26where basically people start running different software on their nodes. And a soft fork narrows
- 1:01:32the rules. So it creates a subset of the existing rules, whereas a hard fork widens the rules.
- 1:01:38People may have heard of Bcash and Roger Ver and that whole thing.
- 1:01:42That was a hard fork because Ver, he widened the rules.
- 1:01:46The consensus rule was blocks can only be one megabyte or less.
- 1:01:51And so let's say you wanted to do a soft fork with that and narrow the rules.
- 1:01:56You could lower the max block size to 0.8 megabytes, for example, instead of one megabyte.
- 1:02:02That would be a soft fork because you're narrowing the rules.
- 1:02:04And the existing nodes would still accept that because the rule is the block has to be one megabytes or less and 0.8 megabytes is less.
- 1:02:12And so old nodes will still find those blocks valid.
- 1:02:17Hard forks are more difficult to do because you need to get everyone to upgrade their clients.
- 1:02:22And so what Roger Ver did is he changed the block size from one megabytes to, I can never remember if it's four megabytes, I think it's maybe eight megabytes.
- 1:02:30That's a hard fork that's widening the rules.
- 1:02:32and um so the the reason we're doing this as a soft fork say we we lower oper turn from 100 000
- 1:02:42down to 80 bytes and then there's some or we make some other change um and then there's there's
- 1:02:48people realize oh we actually needed 160 byte oper turns if you do a soft fork to narrow the
- 1:02:54rules and then you want to go back to where the rules were before and you want to take it back up
- 1:02:58from 80 bytes to 160 bytes for data carrier size, that would be a hard fork because you'd
- 1:03:04be widening the rules again.
- 1:03:06And the rule in Bitcoin is really just never do a hard fork.
- 1:03:09There's some edge cases in a real emergency.
- 1:03:12We could do a hard fork for various things.
- 1:03:15So that's one reason it's temporary.
- 1:03:16It's basically a cooling off period.
- 1:03:18You can imagine that in the lifespan of these crypto scam startups, a whole year of not being
- 1:03:23able to do their spams and scams is devastating to them.
- 1:03:27And it will lead to less funding of these scammy companies.
- 1:03:30They'll put the ones, you know, they're basically going to be handcuffed.
- 1:03:33And if they try to change and do other things, we can hit them with our mempool filters afterwards.
- 1:03:39So that's one reason it's temporary.
- 1:03:41It's temporary just to be very conservative, to make sure we don't break anything.
- 1:03:45And again, it's a very conservative soft fork.
- 1:03:47It doesn't add any new functionality.
- 1:03:50It doesn't cause, this is something we didn't really talk about,
- 1:03:52that the last software that was really driven by Bitcoin Core and arranged by Bitcoin Core with the
- 1:03:57miners turned out to be was Taproot. And that's really the source of a lot of the Bitcoin spam
- 1:04:02just because of the way they did it. And so we're doing something much more conservative than that,
- 1:04:07that this software will basically expire after 12 months. And it gives the community time to figure
- 1:04:12out a real solution to these problems and to sort of optimize like how big OpRaturn should be.
- 1:04:17There's another thing it does is it temporarily takes away what are called upgrade hooks.
- 1:04:22which are needed for future versions of SegWit and Taproot and other updates.
- 1:04:29And so you need upgrade hooks.
- 1:04:33And not taking them away would have made this software much more difficult
- 1:04:37and the code more difficult.
- 1:04:38So we basically take it away for 12 months.
- 1:04:40It's actually not measured in time.
- 1:04:41It's measured in blocks or block height.
- 1:04:45But this is a software that was developed by a NIMH named Dathan Ohm.
- 1:04:48And so this is, I think he tried to construct it in the most conservative way possible where it doesn't break any of the monetary use cases of Bitcoin, but it closes the attack surfaces, especially the CSAM thing is just awful and huge. It buys us some time.
- 1:05:05And it also just demonstrates community opposition to these people.
- 1:05:09And it pushes back on Bitcoin Core and says, look, you can't unilaterally change things.
- 1:05:14The network will fight you on this.
- 1:05:17You said you don't push through consensus changes.
- 1:05:19You did it anyway.
- 1:05:20Well, look, this is what happens.
- 1:05:21You refuse to back down and move it back down from 100,000 to 80 bytes.
- 1:05:24Well, we're going to soft fork you out.
- 1:05:26And no one wants what you did, except the people who are benefiting from the spam.
- 1:05:32So those are the basic reasons.
- 1:05:33It's a temporary soft fork.
- 1:05:34we've tried to do it in the most conservative way and it doesn't require a hard fork to undo
- 1:05:40so last question on all this subject because i want to do a sort of a lightning round with you
- 1:05:45on just a couple of other unrelated things if bip 110 doesn't activate if not doesn't gain
- 1:05:51oh i should yeah i didn't i didn't answer the second part of your question i'll answer that
- 1:05:55really quickly because okay yeah it's going to activate it is set up we are going to activate it
- 1:06:00it is going to happen, BIP-110. And this is one of the reasons I'm doing the podcast circuit,
- 1:06:05to tell people about this so that they're prepared, and especially the miners need to be prepared.
- 1:06:10So there are two ways that it activates. This software can be activated any day,
- 1:06:14any two-week period by the miners, these large mining pools, if they want to. So we're sort of
- 1:06:19giving them this as a courtesy. And then if they don't go ahead and do the right thing and activate
- 1:06:24it, because maybe they just like mining spam, they make a little bit of extra money from it,
- 1:06:28which itself is kind of an illusion because of the difficulty adjustment.
- 1:06:31That's its own rabbit hole.
- 1:06:32But if the miners don't go ahead and do it,
- 1:06:35first, it's important to note that the miners, the large mining pools,
- 1:06:38they're employees of the network.
- 1:06:39They basically need to do what the node runners like you and me tell them to do.
- 1:06:43So we're giving them a chance to make this a very smooth transition.
- 1:06:46They can activate it as what's called an MASF, a miner activated soft fork.
- 1:06:51If they do not activate it, we are going to be activating it.
- 1:06:54There are a couple of stages, but I think something like August 7th is the big date.
- 1:06:59You can go to bip110.org if you want to read about this.
- 1:07:03But on August 7th, this thing will activate as a user-activated soft fork.
- 1:07:07And the first step we're going to do is we will basically, malicious miners who don't
- 1:07:12seem to have a problem with spam or CSAM and want to keep producing these blocks, we're
- 1:07:17going to be throwing their blocks in the garbage starting August 7th.
- 1:07:21And the problem with throwing someone's blocks in the garbage is they spend $300,000 on electricity for the block and then they don't get paid for it.
- 1:07:31And so this is basically what happened in 2017.
- 1:07:35Luke Dasher was one of the leaders.
- 1:07:37Bitcoin Mechanic was one of the leaders as well.
- 1:07:40They were doing a very similar thing called BIP-148, which is UASF.
- 1:07:44And this is what got SegWit activated.
- 1:07:46And so this thing, we have people like Luke and Mechanic who have done this rodeo before. They're not new to it. Luke is the foremost expert in the world on soft forks and consensus changes. I can guarantee you that. He's a game theory master.
- 1:08:01and they've already done one successful soft fork led it in 2017 and they they were able to do with
- 1:08:09just 500 nodes out of 100 000 nodes and right now we're at something like 11 call it 10 or 11 000
- 1:08:15nodes so we're way ahead of where they were in in 2017 so this this thing will activate because
- 1:08:21the node runners will activate it and it's basically no one is against it there are a lot
- 1:08:28of apathetic people who don't really care one way or the other. And then there's a very, very small
- 1:08:32group who likes the status quo of Bitcoin Core being in charge and being able to put spam on
- 1:08:38the blockchain. The game theory around soft forks is very, very interesting. And it turns out in
- 1:08:43Bitcoin, you can have a small intolerant minority like us. So we're only 11, 12% of the network.
- 1:08:51I think that's enough to push through a change like this. It's a conservative change. It's a
- 1:08:54narrowing of the rules. And there's an excellent article your readers, your viewers can check out
- 1:08:59called, I believe it was published at Bitcoin Magazine in 2017. It's called UASF, User Activated
- 1:09:06Soft Forks and the Intolerant Minority. And it basically demonstrates that doing soft forks like
- 1:09:11this is much easier than people think. And the only way to stop something like this is to do
- 1:09:17what's called a URSF, a user resisted soft fork, which would be very awkward for the other side to
- 1:09:21do because they would basically be saying,
- 1:09:23we want CSAM and spam on our blockchain.
- 1:09:25So it's kind of an untenable position.
- 1:09:27It unclear who would support something like that And especially if miners tried to do it you can imagine large regulated miners saying we want child sexual abuse material on our side Like it seems unlikely that they would want something like that And most of the mining pools just want to go along to get along
- 1:09:43So this thing is going to activate and it's I think it's going to win.
- 1:09:47It's going to be successful because there's no one, you know, most most Bitcoin plebs like it.
- 1:09:53Like you can go in and you can go in your comment section.
- 1:09:55if this is posted on YouTube when we're done. Read what the plebs have to say.
- 1:10:01Go to the comment section of any Bitcoin mechanic video or Bitcoin University, which is where I post
- 1:10:09my videos. Look at the comment section. See all these Bitcoin plebs who are running Bitcoin knots
- 1:10:14and also running BIP 110 and signaling for this. And these are people who are committed,
- 1:10:20seem to be mostly committed family men, and they have a surprising amount of Bitcoin.
- 1:10:25I talked to many of these people and they're warriors.
- 1:10:30And you'd be surprised how many people have a few hundred Bitcoin or even a few thousand
- 1:10:34Bitcoin on our side.
- 1:10:35They're renting hash, they're mining for it.
- 1:10:39And so we have an army, basically, a BIP-110 army.
- 1:10:42And there's no one to oppose us on the other side because we're not trying to hurt Bitcoin.
- 1:10:46We're just trying to close attack surfaces.
- 1:10:48The people on the other side, especially the Bitcoin core devs, they're fairly weak, passive,
- 1:10:52people pleaser types, you know, kind of corporate types who just, just want to get paid a lot of
- 1:10:57money to do software. They're not like the cypherpunk army that we've assembled on our side.
- 1:11:02Okay. Interesting. So August, we'll, we'll have to stay tuned for that. Okay. I want to hit a few
- 1:11:07additional topics. I don't know that you've covered all, you've probably covered all of
- 1:11:12these at some point in time, but these are just all topics that I hear about all the,
- 1:11:16just every day. There's something, the clarity act, there's supposed to be all sorts of,
- 1:11:21I love government names. The Patriot Act, the Clarity Act.
- 1:11:26Yeah, there's always clarity. The U.S. government, they're always so honest with us. They always give us clarity. That's great.
- 1:11:31The marketing is always impressive when it comes from Congress. But I'm curious if you have any initial thoughts on the Clarity Act, what the likelihood of that passing is. Is it good, bad?
- 1:11:41I haven't dug that deeply in it because I basically don't care. I don't need permission from the U.S. government to run a node and use Bitcoin.
- 1:11:49um there there are some there's some interesting parts in there that you know having protection for
- 1:11:55for devs from the u.s government there's some good um some good self-custody protections but
- 1:12:02they're not really protections because um at least the versions that i've seen it's basically like you
- 1:12:06know americans have the right to run a bitcoin note just like thank you yes i i know that i knew
- 1:12:11that i had you know you don't give me that right i have that right um and and basically you know
- 1:12:18So the Clarity Act gives you the right to self-custody unless you're dealing with sanctioned transactions or doing something the government doesn't like.
- 1:12:26So it's like any law.
- 1:12:27And that's why I haven't been following it too closely.
- 1:12:29Obviously, there's a civil war going on.
- 1:12:31So there's been bigger things.
- 1:12:32But the U.S. government runs on the U.S. dollar.
- 1:12:34The U.S. government and the central bankers are our enemies.
- 1:12:38And they can pass whatever they want.
- 1:12:40But we all know how this is going to end.
- 1:12:43And laws can be changed.
- 1:12:45Executive orders can be reversed.
- 1:12:46and we need to win using cypherpunk principles. It's fine if people want to play the political
- 1:12:52game. I'm fairly cynical, especially seeing what's happened over the last 18 months.
- 1:12:58These systems are very robust. Even you can put someone like Bobby Kennedy in there who was very
- 1:13:03good on the COVID and the vaccine stuff. And it appears to me, at least, I haven't been following
- 1:13:08very closely, but he's been a good guy who obviously really believes these things. He's
- 1:13:12been sort of shut down and handcuffed. And he seems to have a lot of free time on his hand to
- 1:13:17go on podcasts, which is surprising that he's in government now. I think he has good intention. So
- 1:13:22it's the same thing. You send someone in there to fix big pharma and they either get co-opted or if
- 1:13:28they're a good guy like RFK Jr., they get their hands tied. So I don't expect many. I'm not waiting
- 1:13:35for the government to help me. Okay. I tend to agree with that. I could echo everything you just
- 1:13:41said, how about Michael Saylor? He had recently sold a little bit of Bitcoin. And I think you've
- 1:13:47been critical at times on and off of different people, certainly in the treasury company space.
- 1:13:52What's your general take on what's happening there? I've sort of stayed quiet about it until
- 1:13:56the last week or so, but Michael Saylor has become a shit coiner. He's, I mean, it's shocking to say
- 1:14:01this is, this is the depressing thing of the last 12 months. People going rogue, like Greg Maxwell
- 1:14:06and add them back.
- 1:14:09And Michael Saylor is actively promoting
- 1:14:11Ethereum DeFi protocols on his X.
- 1:14:14And he's doing it because people can lever up
- 1:14:17their stretch preferred shares from strategy,
- 1:14:20which he's using to buy Bitcoin.
- 1:14:24But basically he's made,
- 1:14:26he said he would never sell Bitcoin,
- 1:14:27then he sold it.
- 1:14:28I don't think that's a huge deal
- 1:14:29because there is some sort of treasury
- 1:14:31or cash management there.
- 1:14:33But I find the more disturbing things to be
- 1:14:35that he, after spending years talking about Bitcoin as being ethical money and Ethereum
- 1:14:42as being garbage, that he's now actually tweeting, retweeting Ethereum garbage.
- 1:14:47And he's also making posts like saying strategy, his company turns Bitcoin into money.
- 1:14:55As if we need Michael Saylor or strategy. I think Satoshi gave us money in 2009.
- 1:15:00The other thing I don't like about the Bitcoin treasury companies in general is there's sort of
- 1:15:05hype machines that the only reason to own the shares, the common shares, is because you want
- 1:15:09to outperform Bitcoin, which is always a fool's errand. This is what people, you know, I was late
- 1:15:13to Bitcoin. I heard about in 2011. I didn't get in, really start buying in Holly until 2019. We're
- 1:15:19all late to Bitcoin. We all wish we had more Bitcoin. There's only one way to catch up,
- 1:15:24which is like working really hard, producing goods and services that the world wants,
- 1:15:29getting paid in Bitcoin and stacking it. That's the only way to catch up.
- 1:15:33buying Bitcoin treasury company common shares. This does nothing for Bitcoin adoption. And if
- 1:15:39you think about it, it actually has a very dangerous side effect, which is it centralizes
- 1:15:43a huge amount of Bitcoin at these large US custodians, like Coinbase Custody and Fidelity,
- 1:15:49et cetera. So that's where all strategies Bitcoin is. It's not like Michael Saylor's keeping it on
- 1:15:55his seed signer. And the problem with this is these are huge attack vectors, large pools of
- 1:16:00Bitcoin. This was what happened in 1933 when President Roosevelt stole all Americans' gold.
- 1:16:06He didn't go door to door. He basically just took it out of the bank vaults. And this is going to
- 1:16:11happen to the large centralized custodians in the US. All that money is going to be hacked or lost
- 1:16:15or stolen by the deep state or by the federal government or by someone. And so I've been really
- 1:16:20pushing back and I've been getting a lot of hate for it. I don't think loading up Bitcoin plebs
- 1:16:25with preferred stock like Stretch and giving them some yield, I don't think that's how newcomers
- 1:16:30should be onboarded. I don't think they should be encouraged to use DeFi protocols. And stacking
- 1:16:34sats at Coinbase Custody does nothing for Bitcoin adoption. What does something for Bitcoin adoption
- 1:16:39is when Bitcoiners live on a Bitcoin standard, earn Bitcoin, spend Bitcoin, run a node,
- 1:16:44mine with Bitcoin, etc. So the whole thing, I find it disgusting. It's exploiting retail investors.
- 1:16:5080% of stretch shareholders are retail investors and they're being encouraged to use DeFi protocols.
- 1:16:55So I'm very disappointed in Sailor. He's a brilliant guy. I'm frankly just mystified why he would take a turn like this.
- 1:17:05Yeah. Kill your heroes. That's what we say. Okay. Last one. What's that?
- 1:17:12Kill them metaphorically, of course.
- 1:17:14Metaphorically. Metaphorically. Yes. Yes. This is a peaceful show.
- 1:17:17Last bit. This is, I'm going to call a little bit of an audible here.
- 1:17:19I would love to hear your thoughts though on, at the time of this recording, this won't air for a couple of weeks,
- 1:17:25But the prices sort of tanked the last few days, last four or five days, I guess.
- 1:17:30And would love to know what extent, and by the way, I'm asking you now a series of questions.
- 1:17:36I don't care about it all, but I know that people have curiosities about these things.
- 1:17:40Yeah, no, no.
- 1:17:40Do you have like a thesis on the price action?
- 1:17:43Like, why haven't we hit half a million dollars, Matthew?
- 1:17:46What's going on?
- 1:17:47Well, one very dark explanation.
- 1:17:49I mean, there's the obvious explanation, which is the node, the reference implementation went rogue, like we've been talking about.
- 1:17:57And the network's now exposed to CSAM threats and spam threats and large amounts of arbitrary data.
- 1:18:03So we have a serious Bitcoin governance problem and we're about to have a soft fork.
- 1:18:07So it could be that.
- 1:18:10There also the new Fed chair is a little bit more hawkish than maybe people thought So interest rates aren falling et cetera We also in a bear market we been in a bear market that started on october 10th when bitcoin core released bitcoin core version 30
- 1:18:26it might just be a coincidence but it's it's it's quite striking we're joking about it at the time
- 1:18:30and it turns out that was the top basically that day when this malware was released on the network
- 1:18:35and then but there's the darker explanation which i'm increasingly um contemplating which is that
- 1:18:42the BlackRock spot ETF, Bitcoin spot ETF, IBIT, MicroStrategy strategy, holding basically their
- 1:18:53ways of collecting a lot of Bitcoin at these centralized custodians, as we said.
- 1:18:59And Michael Saylor's refused to do proof of reserve, so no one really knows.
- 1:19:04We assume the Bitcoin's there. You know, America's not a total banana republic, at least not yet.
- 1:19:08But the problem with having these large pools and putting them in the hands of people like Brian Armstrong, who's a shit coiner and a lackey of the US government, or the hands of Larry Fink, I mean, I don't have to tell people about BlackRock, is that they may be using this Bitcoin that Saylor has so conveniently pooled for them, they may be rehypothecating it.
- 1:19:29Again, no proof of reserves.
- 1:19:31And they may be using it to manipulate the market price.
- 1:19:33And if you had told me that we'd be at, wherever we are, 60-something thousand in 2026 after a Bitcoin-friendly president like Trump or after the Bitcoin spot ETF or after a sailor buying whatever, $60 billion worth of Bitcoin, there's something wrong.
- 1:19:54There's something wrong because Bitcoin is very scarce.
- 1:19:57So I think we have a problem with paper Bitcoin.
- 1:19:59The best way your viewers can fight this is dump your strategy shares, sell your IBIT, buy real Bitcoin, hold it in self-custody, and please don't leave your Bitcoin on exchanges because it's going to get stolen.
- 1:20:13And it's also, it contributes to these large pools that are used, that may be being used, I should say, to being used to suppress Bitcoin's price.
- 1:20:22I feel like we are probably, we're being attacked in Bitcoin from so many different directions at this point.
- 1:20:29But fortunately, we are pushing back. But I think that those are explanations for the fiat price.
- 1:20:34Yeah, I would say I've grown increasingly cynical and I look at Bitcoin backed loans, treasury companies, Wall Street adoption.
- 1:20:41And my head just goes to that is their way of accumulating Bitcoin.
- 1:20:46Yeah.
- 1:20:46Other people paying for it. And we're going to have a lot of money.
- 1:20:50It's a bait and switch is what it is. It's just like the shitcoin bait and switch.
- 1:20:52You know, I love Bitcoin, buy my preferred stock.
- 1:20:54and let me let me interject one thing there because you meant really quickly because you
- 1:20:58mentioned bitcoin loans i really recommend against people taking bitcoin loans i used to advocate for
- 1:21:04them a little bit about three years ago the problem with bitcoin loans is you give your
- 1:21:08bitcoin to someone else um to the lender even if it's locked in a in a two of three multi-sig it's
- 1:21:13still risky i think there's i think one of the ways that um the financial complex will confiscate
- 1:21:20people's Bitcoin and good Bitcoiners Bitcoin is that it will engineer a price crash or a flash
- 1:21:26crash. And to the extent that you have all that Coinbase that sailors accumulated at Coinbase
- 1:21:31custody to enable them to do this, they'll crash the price. And I would ask people of loans,
- 1:21:36what are you going to, I think I asked this in my video this morning, what are you going to do if
- 1:21:39Bitcoin goes down to $5,000 and just spends 12 hours, 24 hours, 36 hours at $5,000? Do you have
- 1:21:48collateral to top up your Bitcoin loan or you're going to be liquidated. So I think Bitcoin loans
- 1:21:52are extremely dangerous. They're a way of people sort of living beyond their means and trying to
- 1:21:57have their cake and eat it too. There's probably 1% of the population that's financially sophisticated
- 1:22:02enough and disciplined enough. But even then, if you're doing a Bitcoin loan, do like 5% or
- 1:22:0810% of your Bitcoin and expect to have it confiscated in a flash crash because this is
- 1:22:13going to happen in the next five years. It's going to be a flash crash and a lot of people are going
- 1:22:17lose their Bitcoin. Bingo. You nailed it. And if anyone listening thinks that Matt sounds too
- 1:22:24cynical, it sounds crazy, doesn't it? I would argue that if you think he sounds crazy, you're
- 1:22:29probably not skeptical enough. What you just said, I think it's spot on. Wall Street for 30 years. So
- 1:22:35Wall Street is just, you know, these are the games they play all the time.
- 1:22:39Yes. Yeah. It's a big club and you ain't in it. Okay. So last question for you, Matt,
- 1:22:45What is an unpopular opinion that you have? Bonus points if you offend some Bitcoiners with it.
- 1:22:54I feel like I've done that a lot.
- 1:22:57You kind of told all your unpopular opinions.
- 1:23:00I think the big one is that Bitcoin's immune system is not as strong as it should be.
- 1:23:07and Bitcoiners, a lot of Bitcoiners talk a really big game and they say, slay your heroes and call
- 1:23:14out people. And yet they're too scared to call out Adam Back or Michael Saylor. Like it's nice to
- 1:23:20say slay your heroes, but I don't see anyone slaying their heroes. And the problem is a lot
- 1:23:24of people being paid by their heroes or somehow incentivized. You know, they're getting invited to
- 1:23:28the, uh, the sailor yacht parties or whatever. Um, but I, I think, I think Bitcoin's immune system
- 1:23:34is less strong than people think. And that's one of the things I'm working on strengthening it,
- 1:23:39just telling people about these problems. There's the classic thing with Bitcoin mining that all the
- 1:23:46mining rig operators will switch away if a pool gets too big. We just haven't seen that happening.
- 1:23:51And basically, Bitcoin's only as good as the Bitcoiners who defend it. And I think there's
- 1:23:57still a large enough number of Bitcoin plebs who are really the heart and soul of the network.
- 1:24:04who have rallied. If I hadn't seen this reaction from Bitcoin plebs, I probably would have gotten
- 1:24:11out of Bitcoin just because if the reference implementation or if miners can tell us what
- 1:24:17to do unilaterally, Bitcoin is not valuable. It's simply not valuable and it will get priced in
- 1:24:23eventually. And I'd like to get out before that happens because I basically have my life savings
- 1:24:28in Bitcoin apart from my house. And so that would be my unpopular thing that I would say to all the
- 1:24:34Bitcoiners who say, slay your heroes and be toxic, et cetera. Are you willing to slay Sailor when he
- 1:24:43starts shitcoining? That shouldn't be that hard. This guy's pushing ERC-20 tokens after talking
- 1:24:49them down for years. So that would be the most unpopular thing. I'd like to see more Bitcoiners
- 1:24:55waking up so we can make this thing work and we can end up separating money from state.
- 1:25:00Amen. I couldn't agree with that more. There have been so many, so many quote unquote heroes I've had to just rid myself of.
- 1:25:07It's really depressing and it's sad to see. It breaks my heart.
- 1:25:10It is. The good news is that there are, actually, I had Luke DeWolf on the podcast recently and he wrote an excellent book on defending Bitcoin and what we need to do as plubs to be resilient.
- 1:25:23Yeah. And so it's a fantastic read. Everyone should go check out the episode I had with them. And I think those are the sorts of things we need to be doing. So if you're listening to this episode, everyone, you aren't running a node, go run a node. We can help you at the Bitcoin way. But Matt, thank you so much for your time. It's been a pleasure. I'm glad we finally got to do this. I'm glad that you're out on the podcast circuit, making yourself known. So really appreciate that. Why don't you tell people where they can find you and Bitcoin University?
- 1:25:49Yeah, you can find my channel on YouTube is called Matthew Cratter's Bitcoin University. So if you just type in Bitcoin University in YouTube, that's probably the best place to find me. And I'm also on Twitter at Matt Cratter, M-A-T-T-K-R-A-T-T-E-R. And reach out and say hi, ask your questions or suggest future topics for videos because I love talking about stuff that people are interested in and have real questions about.
- 1:26:14Fantastic. Matt, thank you so much for your time today.
- 1:26:17Thank you, Michael.
- 1:26:18Cheers.
- 1:26:19And that's a wrap. Again, hope you enjoyed my conversation with Matt. Go be sure to check out
- 1:26:23Bitcoin University. Follow Matt on X. And of course, if you want to be a node runner, if you
- 1:26:28want to have a decision as to what code you run, go to thebitcoinway.com slash podcast. We can help
- 1:26:33you set up your node, take proper 100% self-custody of your Bitcoin. Also help with online privacy,
- 1:26:38setting up privacy phones. We have a great plan B residency option in Panama. Again, that's
- 1:26:43thebitcoinway.com slash podcast. You can follow us on x at thebitcoinway underscore. I'm there as
- 1:26:49well at the other mjordan. And until next time, stay safe, stay sovereign, and remember the yield
- 1:26:55on Bitcoin is freedom.