Latest / Politics with Paul / How to Encourage and Incentivize People to Depolarize w/ Phelosha Collaros (DepolarWise) | Politics with Paul #77
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08And as you can see here, we've got another great guest on tap for you today.
- 0:12But for such episodes, I always add a disclaimer that I do not take a stance for or
- 0:16against a guest's political views or groups they support.
- 0:19But, of course, as always, our topics are things that are relevant to people across the
- 0:23political spectrum.
- 0:25One of the primary goals of this show is to bridge political divides, and that involves
- 0:29giving practical tips on how to depolarize American politics.
- 0:34In fact, discussions with several of my guests on here have focused specifically on the
- 0:39endeavor of depolarizing.
- 0:41But while it's all well and good to talk about how to be less polarizing, more empathetic,
- 0:46have how to have better conversations, and so on, we have to truly want to depolarize and
- 0:53make our political culture less toxic.
- 0:55So how do we encourage and incentivize depolarization and show that toxicity is not
- 1:01beneficial to anyone?
- 1:03Well, that's what today's guest, Falocia Kolaros is here to talk about.
- 1:07Falocia is the founder of DepolarWise, which strives to depolarize and build bridges in
- 1:12America through means such as educational tools, connecting people into a supportive
- 1:16community and promoting the values of empathy, civil dialogue and our common humanity.
- 1:21She also gave a TED talk titled, We Need to Talk About Everyday Partisan Violence and is
- 1:26currently the vice president for board governance and strategic outcomes at St.
- 1:30John's College.
- 1:31So now let's welcome our guests and let's get her insights into encouraging depolarization
- 1:38and her work with depolarize.
- 1:39Please welcome Felicia Kolaros.
- 1:41Felicia, thanks for coming on.
- 1:43How are you?
- 1:44Oh, I'm great, Paul.
- 1:45I'm delighted to be here.
- 1:46Thank you so much for inviting me to this conversation.
- 1:50Absolutely.
- 1:50Thank you for being here.
- 1:52So I like to start off with guests getting into the whys of what my guest does and their
- 1:59relation to the topic in general.
- 2:01So before all this public speaking and depolarizing all the stuff that you're doing
- 2:05now, what got you so interested in depolarization efforts in the first place?
- 2:11And what were some early experiences with polarization?
- 2:14Yes.
- 2:14Well, I'd actually have to say that my earliest experience with depolarization was in my DNA.
- 2:20It was a secret code, though.
- 2:22I didn't know the history of my family that my mother, a Colombian, born, now American
- 2:28citizen, was carrying with her until relatively recently when she started to see some of the
- 2:33markers, from her country, the signposts start to come about in our country around
- 2:40polarization and partisan violence.
- 2:43So my grandparents, her parents were actually in a mixed political marriage in Colombia when
- 2:50La Vialencia occurred, which was a partisan civil war between the Liberales and the
- 2:55Conservadores that ultimately claimed the lives of 200,000 citizens and burned the capital of
- 3:01Bogota to the ground.
- 3:03This was a a family history of ours that, you see, as many immigrants come to this country,
- 3:09they don't look back at those past tragedies, from the country they they left.
- 3:14But as the signposts in this country started to come about, seeing the kind of collapse of the
- 3:20continuity of of, viewpoints and of ideological diversity and of the tolerance of each other in
- 3:28this country.
- 3:29My mother started to reveal this hidden history, and I became so fascinated by it.
- 3:35So I would ask her a lot of questions about the experience of herself and her her parents.
- 3:41Some of her earlier memories were, people shooting at their home because my grandfather
- 3:46was not in the same political party as that town.
- 3:50So she had experienced La Vie Valencia.
- 3:53She knew it had happened, but she didn't really understand it as an adult would, as somebody
- 3:58who had researched it would.
- 4:00We just started going back to Colombia.
- 4:02We made several trips where we visited libraries and archives.
- 4:07We spoke to historical societies, and we had the privilege of interviewing some of the last
- 4:12living survivors of La Via Valencia who were at the generation who truly saw the entire thing
- 4:18unfold.
- 4:19And that really, it was really eye opening to me, and I'll say the similarities between
- 4:25Colombia and The United States in this juncture are very salient.
- 4:30Colombia used to be called the Athens of South America.
- 4:34So I really wanted to understand how that stable of a democracy could turn into a place
- 4:42of everyday partisan violence and, and really become the type of society that still struggles
- 4:48with the haunting of that violence to this day.
- 4:51I remember reading a little bit on the depolarized website, you talking about your
- 4:56mother's and your grandparents' experience in Colombia.
- 4:59It's it's it's very sometimes it's hard for those of us like I I I'm born in The United
- 5:04States.
- 5:04I've never even been outside the country, and it can be hard for us to realize just how much
- 5:11worse things can get.
- 5:12I mean, as as bad as things are now, we can look to all sorts of different historical
- 5:17points and throughout the rest of the world, but people already don't know enough about The
- 5:25US's history and especially the history of polarization and, you know, let alone the rest
- 5:29of the world.
- 5:30But I think it's it's still you know, just because it's another country, like you said,
- 5:34it's still very relevant to what's happening today for The US, and it is something that I
- 5:41think it's also hard for people to appreciate and think, well, you know what?
- 5:44That's that kind of thing is never gonna happen over here.
- 5:47It's like but if you treat it like it's never going to happen, it will happen at some point.
- 5:52And it is Exactly.
- 5:54Just, yeah, it's something obviously we've got to be careful about.
- 5:59Oh, you got something to add?
- 6:01Yeah.
- 6:01Yeah.
- 6:02I was just gonna add that, you know, one of the ways in which we dismiss in this country the
- 6:07polarization and violence experienced in other countries is to is to say, oh, well, that was a
- 6:12religious conflict.
- 6:13Right?
- 6:13Oh, that was an ethnic conflict or a racial conflict.
- 6:17But in Colombia, you know, the vast majority of the people were Catholic and the vast majority
- 6:21of the people were some kind of mixed Hispanic ethnicity.
- 6:26So really at the heart of the framework of the conflict was the liberal conservative divide.
- 6:31And I think that combined with the fact that The US and Columbia have very similar
- 6:36histories, their founders were really inspired by the enlightenment to create these democratic
- 6:42republics.
- 6:43They had that initial conflict within those two worldviews.
- 6:47Right?
- 6:48The the radical enlightenment and the modern enlightenment.
- 6:51Colombia looked to The United States in terms of its revolution to build its society.
- 6:55So there's just so many historical synergies.
- 6:58And then there's also that present day synergy, which is we, we are, not fractured by other
- 7:06identities primarily, but we're fractured by this partisan polarization.
- 7:11We're stacking these other identities on top of it to widen the divide.
- 7:15But for us, that framework is very salient and very disturbing when we see how that played
- 7:19out, in Colombia.
- 7:22Oh, we were talking about those enlightenment.
- 7:27It's actually funny enough, my very first guest I had on this podcast, Seth David Radwell, he
- 7:31actually wrote a book about those two enlightenments and how they have affected
- 7:37American history throughout or America throughout its history.
- 7:42I Excellent book.
- 7:43American Schism.
- 7:44Correct?
- 7:44Yes.
- 7:45Yeah.
- 7:46Know what you're talking about.
- 7:47It's really a phenomenal book in terms of drawing out that that very that very history.
- 7:53Yeah.
- 7:53Kind of a full circle moment, I guess, for the podcast there.
- 7:56Definitely.
- 7:57And you you guys can check out that that episode as well.
- 8:00I believe it's episode seven.
- 8:02So it was very early on in this podcast history.
- 8:05But wanna move on a little bit to the work that you're doing now with DepolarWise.
- 8:10And I I briefly described DepolarWise in the intro, but, obviously, I wanted you to talk
- 8:16about it in your own words since it is your organization or one of your organizations.
- 8:21So when and why did you establish DepolarWise?
- 8:24Was there some gap that you wanted to fill in a depolarization movement that you didn't think
- 8:29was filled?
- 8:30And how does DepolarWise contribute to depolarization?
- 8:35Yes.
- 8:36Thank you.
- 8:36So I would say that the genesis of depolarwise.com is really this journey that I
- 8:42was on personally to try to understand polarization and then what can be done about
- 8:47it.
- 8:48So as I was on that journey, I had the privilege of encountering so many people who
- 8:53were working in different ways as authors like we just talked about, founding organizations,
- 9:00and podcasts like we're doing.
- 9:02Just so many ways in which they were building a community and furthering this movement of
- 9:07bridge building and depolarization.
- 9:09So the the heart of the project really founding DepolarWise was to say, look, there's this
- 9:16community here that is growing and wants to welcome you.
- 9:21Of course, when you talk about a country that has kind of pushed people very much to the
- 9:26binary and that binary has become a deep identity with people, it can be very scary to
- 9:32step off of the binary and just not know what is in in in the, the third way there and who's
- 9:39gonna meet you there.
- 9:41So as I was in discussions with people and understanding their fear and trepidation of
- 9:45stepping off that binary, not understanding that there was a community here that was
- 9:50working on these issues, and that it, that it was accessible to them.
- 9:54That was the heart of the mission for Depolarize, to try to create a space where
- 10:00people could find this community and start their own personal journey on, how they could
- 10:05interact with, engage with depolarization and bridge building.
- 10:09So the way the site is set up, is to help people on their own journey and and meet them
- 10:14with what's accessible to them.
- 10:17Right?
- 10:17So if you're a big fan of podcasts, there are so many podcasts that you can check out in this
- 10:21space.
- 10:21If you want to read more about it, there are books and there are also, news source
- 10:27recommendations of people who are making efforts to have nonpartisan, news sources.
- 10:33You can find, organizations to join once you're at that level and you're ready to jump in in a
- 10:39more active way and other resources to explore that will really help catalyze and further you
- 10:45on the journey of becoming part of this community.
- 10:48I think there's for citizens in general who are sick of the division and the polarization and
- 10:55the false binaries, I think it's hard for them sometimes to appreciate that there are a lot of
- 11:00people doing this work in depolarization like you, for example, and it's good to see or be
- 11:07able to demonstrate, no, there are those people out there, and not only me, but there's all
- 11:11these other resources you can use, all these other people that are involved as well that you
- 11:16direct them to as well.
- 11:17It's great to not have just, hey, come to our website.
- 11:20We've got a lot of content, but then you also can direct them to all these other resources
- 11:25that they can use as well.
- 11:26And especially because sometimes I think I think a lot of times, for lack of a better
- 11:31term, depolarization can sometimes feel very woo woo and touchy feely when really there is a
- 11:37lot of actionable practical ways that you can depolarize that don't have to get all what
- 11:43somebody might call touchy feely.
- 11:47You guys That's absolutely right.
- 11:48People like you
- 11:49That's a criticism leveled against the field, right?
- 11:52Which is just that, you know, it's not doing anything.
- 11:55It's not taking a position.
- 11:57Right?
- 11:58Kind of like an antithetical to actually being in the world either politically or civically.
- 12:03And that is not the case.
- 12:05You know, it is it is an actual third way, and it's active and growing and addressing the
- 12:12beliefs and needs of people.
- 12:14Right?
- 12:14We have depolarized say, you know, be passionate about your beliefs and needs, but
- 12:18without partisan purity.
- 12:19And so helping people understand that they can find a third way without letting go of what's
- 12:25important to them and actively work on what's important to them within the polarization and
- 12:29bridge building context is really important.
- 12:32You know, the last thing I'll say you did ask, like, when when was Depolarized founded or
- 12:35launched?
- 12:36Coincidentally, it was launched just within the few months that Merriam Webster had, announced
- 12:42that polarization was the word of the year early last year.
- 12:45Right?
- 12:45And and how do we you know, how do they pick the word of the year?
- 12:49They look at these surges in searches for a term.
- 12:53So people were actually, like, hungry and searching for answers of what was happening to
- 12:59this country.
- 13:00And that is, I think, the very start of this journey that people are saying, what is this?
- 13:04What what does it mean?
- 13:06What what's happening here?
- 13:08And so to provide that resource for people that are hungry to not just understand it more from
- 13:13a practical level.
- 13:14Right?
- 13:14So we explain the difference between political and effective polarization, for example.
- 13:18We kind of give content of basic knowledge, but to say there are next steps.
- 13:22Once you know about this, there's something you can do to engage with it in a constructive way
- 13:27was the gap we were trying to fill.
- 13:29Right.
- 13:30And the point you just brought up about, you know, teaching people that they don't have to
- 13:36go against their values.
- 13:38I think that's a very important thing too, that we don't necessarily do as good of a job as we
- 13:42could about demonstrating as as in the depolarization movement as a whole, because
- 13:45sometimes people think, so I have to go against my morals.
- 13:48And a lot of times they have that moralized attitude that leads them to that extreme view.
- 13:54Here for us depolarized, it's like, no, it's not about that.
- 13:58It's just not having purity for the sake of having purity and for being able to at least
- 14:03understand why other people come from where they come from.
- 14:08There's there's nothing wrong with having an opinion.
- 14:11It's just opinion, but it's just when you assert some sort of moral superiority and think
- 14:18that other people are stupid or evil for having that different opinion, that's where we draw
- 14:23the line.
- 14:23But there's nothing wrong with having opinions, exactly.
- 14:27But speaking of trying to get these people to depolarize, there is some debate about how many
- 14:35people can be persuaded or broken out of their echo chambers, these echo chambers being a huge
- 14:40reason why polarization gets to fester more and more.
- 14:44And certainly, there are some people that are just never gonna be convinced of something that
- 14:48goes against what they believe.
- 14:49Even if it's just a tiny little bit, they just won't budge.
- 14:52But in your opinion, do you think that there's like a rough estimate of the number or
- 14:58percentage of people that you think can potentially be successfully encouraged to be
- 15:02less polarized?
- 15:03Or do you not really quite think of it in those terms?
- 15:06No.
- 15:07I I think that's an important question because, you know, we wanna put the effort and time and
- 15:11energy into, receptive ears.
- 15:15Right?
- 15:15And we know that it can be kind of a fool's errand to keep hitting your head against the
- 15:21most extreme cases and feeling like you're not making progress.
- 15:24So at DepolarWise, we do track, you know, pay attention to different polls and data that are
- 15:30coming out of organizations like Pew Research or More in Common.
- 15:36So that some of the ones that we found, and then we post, in a when we agree post on our
- 15:43social media so that we can see some kind of transparency on where the majority of Americans
- 15:48really are on things.
- 15:50Some of the recent ones have been like, you know, eight in 10 of us believe that civility
- 15:57in piddle political dialogue is actually necessary for the functioning of our democratic
- 16:02republic.
- 16:0371% feel that we have more in common as citizens than we have that divides us.
- 16:09About the same amount feel, you know, personal responsibility to connect with diverse
- 16:15viewpoints of people on the other side.
- 16:19And over 80% say that protecting our democracy actually requires working across divides.
- 16:26So I think what we see is this around 70% marker of people who are willing have this kind
- 16:32of mindset, this latent mindset there, and therefore are willing to engage in this type of
- 16:37work.
- 16:38That's a very hopeful thing for me, and that's that that that 70%, I think we should we should
- 16:43be concentrating on.
- 16:44But I will say that 30% ish that is not included in the numbers we were just talking
- 16:50about, it makes me wonder if that's pretty equivalent to the base of both parties.
- 16:55And, and we know that the base of the parties has a real outsized impact on our political
- 17:01process and the media that undergirds that medical, that political process.
- 17:05And I know with your background election research and everything, that 30%, I wonder how
- 17:09that resonates with you of like just kind of the base and the most polarized among us and
- 17:14how they impact the way we see what has prominence in this country.
- 17:19Yeah.
- 17:19It's it's something around well, I mean, it depends on who you ask, but some people say 30
- 17:23or 40.
- 17:24Some people say that there's really not anybody persuadable, which I don't believe in.
- 17:29But it it it is to your point about the election research background.
- 17:34It is a lot like how elections in general are when you're trying to win a campaign for a
- 17:40candidate where some voters there's no point in trying to reach out to them because they are
- 17:46never gonna step across the aisle.
- 17:48They are dead set on voting for your opposition.
- 17:52But, also, there's not really you gotta be careful not to reach out too much to the people
- 17:56who are already gonna vote for you because they're already there.
- 18:00You have finite resources to reach those other people that are persuadable.
- 18:04So I think sometimes we also have to be careful as depolarizers where when we are, I mean, I
- 18:12think the depolarization movement is picking up steam, don't get me wrong, but I think
- 18:15sometimes when we talk about depolarization, we highlight people who are already depolarized or
- 18:23at least are less prone to polarization, whereas we're still we need to reach more of
- 18:27those people we haven't reached before.
- 18:30I don't know if that quite
- 18:31That's the next point.
- 18:32Makes sense.
- 18:33Yeah.
- 18:34Okay.
- 18:34Good.
- 18:35Because I wasn't quite sure if I was getting the the point the point across, but it it is
- 18:40Yes.
- 18:40So we don't want to kinda burn resources on the people that just it's too fundamentally part of
- 18:48their worldview that there's this good and evil binary in our politics too.
- 18:52But we wanna create spaces for the people who are already the exhausted majority or open and
- 18:57receptive to this.
- 18:58And and then, you know, sometimes when the majority moves to a new mindset and a new
- 19:02position, it brings the stragglers along with it, you know, when that movement is very,
- 19:08apparent, and, motivating for others to maybe take a second look.
- 19:13Yeah.
- 19:13And every once in a while, you do get those people who were super obstinate and they come
- 19:17over.
- 19:18And hopefully, you know, that's what happens now, but we at least give them the resources to
- 19:24pick up on it and then they can decide for themselves.
- 19:27But human beings and and try not to say this in a cynical way because this doesn't have to be
- 19:32anything selfish, but human beings are often driven by motivations and incentives, just
- 19:38whatever they by whatever it's they think something is right or or or there's doesn't
- 19:43have to necessarily have to be some sort of selfish game.
- 19:46But clearly, people find polarization and toxicity appealing.
- 19:50They revel in it.
- 19:52So what are two to three of the biggest reasons why you think some people want to be polarizing
- 19:57even if they don't think they are?
- 19:59Right.
- 20:00So I mean, I think unfortunately, fundamentally it comes down to brain science.
- 20:05So we have evolved to have our framework, our evolutionary mental framework be what supports
- 20:16being in an in group because at a certain time, you know, our very survival was about being
- 20:22consistent and embraced by the tribe.
- 20:25Right?
- 20:25So we have evolution of how our brain actually functions that supports and promotes and pushes
- 20:32us toward in group thinking and to tribal acceptance.
- 20:36So for example, when we get, confirmation bias, right, when we thought something and then we
- 20:42see something that validates that confirmation bias, we get a little dopamine hit in our
- 20:47brains.
- 20:48You know, motivated reasoning.
- 20:49Right?
- 20:50So we see something that doesn't support our confirmation bias, but then we are able to kind
- 20:56of twist those facts to a point where we get that, alignment with our original thinking.
- 21:02We get another dopamine hit, and people have done research, on functional MRIs to see how
- 21:07our brain responds to us validating our preexisting beliefs.
- 21:11So that's a difficult thing to overcome.
- 21:13And we can talk, you know, kind of solutions later.
- 21:15But I would say that that fundamental biology, we're actually up against that and that in in
- 21:20group tribal kind of brain science reward system that just kind of naturally pulls people
- 21:31into a polarizing mindset.
- 21:33And we've seen that really accelerate with social media.
- 21:38Right?
- 21:38So we've ported all this brain science from our small tribal communities into this massive
- 21:44social media and media complex.
- 21:46So we're still looking for that in group validation.
- 21:49We're still looking for those dopamine hits.
- 21:51So how, attractive is it if something's toxic and you share it and you get all this feedback,
- 21:57right?
- 21:57This positive feedback.
- 21:58When you share something polarizing and you get all these likes because you're in that
- 22:01community that's validating that, that conflict.
- 22:05And I think in the worst extremes, what we're seeing people who are motivated by money.
- 22:09Right?
- 22:10We've monetized social media, and, they're finding that this kind of clickbait or what you
- 22:16would call rage bait.
- 22:17Right?
- 22:18It sells, and it brings an attention economy your way that has its own rewards.
- 22:23So those incentives are very, very attractive.
- 22:28And and also I will say incidentally, also signpost to what we saw in Columbia.
- 22:32Far before we did, they had bifurcated media, you know, partisan radio and partisan
- 22:38newspapers.
- 22:39So they were in these kind of echo chambers validating their own, community narrative and
- 22:45that then that that builds on itself.
- 22:47Right?
- 22:47I think the last thing is what I would call the efficacy illusion.
- 22:52Right?
- 22:53So we have this idea that if we win and if we have like total control and over the systems,
- 23:02right, the judicial systems and electoral systems and the, you know, the presidential,
- 23:06the White House and the congress, that that we need that to get anything done in this country.
- 23:12So that efficacy illusion is we we need, you know, it's it's war and we've gotta win it
- 23:18unequivocally so we could get what we want done.
- 23:21Right?
- 23:21So we can get our beliefs and our needs met.
- 23:23Unfortunately, it is ultimately illusion because in a in a society where you have this
- 23:28binary, where you have this switching back and forth between parties, the other party comes in
- 23:34and spends all of its time undoing what the last party did.
- 23:38So you might have this moment where you think, oh, look look what we did, how effective it
- 23:42was.
- 23:42And then four years, eight years later, it's all unraveled.
- 23:46I mean, it makes me think, you know, from my Saint John's background of Penelope and the
- 23:50audio odyssey.
- 23:51Right?
- 23:51She's she's making the tapestry during the day and she's unraveling it during the night.
- 23:56And so this this illusion of echo efficacy of building something tricks us into thinking that
- 24:01we're making durable change on issues that are really important to this country.
- 24:05When in fact, we're not.
- 24:06It's just a temporary moment that's gonna be undone because we haven't created consensus
- 24:11change that's actually gonna stay, that's gonna last, and that's gonna prevent blowback in the
- 24:18next cycle of power.
- 24:19All great points to bring up.
- 24:22And and maybe not so much on the efficacy part, but on the the the whole tribalism and and
- 24:28general brain science with the in groups and out groups.
- 24:30Unfortunately, you know, that's that's something that can happen to us as depolarizers
- 24:34too if we're we're not careful.
- 24:35I mean, it it can it can happen to anybody.
- 24:38I every once in a while, I'll think of a time where I I fell into that.
- 24:41I I'm a big sports fan, so I I get into that all the time where I see a fan base of a team I
- 24:46hate, and I I just get all these these are such annoying stupid people, blah blah blah.
- 24:52I I sometimes do that about my own fan base, but, you know, and I I can I can sometimes
- 24:57display the same behavior too, and I have to obviously be more self aware and careful about
- 25:02that?
- 25:02But yeah, it it is obviously, you know, a lot of it goes to being self aware about that.
- 25:08Right?
- 25:08I think a lot of depolarizer are a lot more self aware about that in group out group
- 25:14tendency, whereas polarizers even if the polarizers are, they don't really care.
- 25:18They're just like, well, my in group is is is right about everything, of course.
- 25:21And then with the with the efficacy part, you know, just that whole all or nothing prospect.
- 25:27And even when you I think sometimes even when you tell polarized people that they they're
- 25:32still convinced that eventually they're just going to just keep the ball rolling in
- 25:37perpetuity and that, oh, the the other side's not gonna win.
- 25:39We're we're gonna be able to keep this train rolling, and we're gonna be able to just
- 25:43dictate everything that happens.
- 25:44So sometimes I think they don't really, yeah, they don't really think that the ball is going
- 25:49swing the other way even though it inevitably does.
- 25:52So now how do we take those reasons that you just described for being polarized and how do
- 25:57we turn them around?
- 25:58So in other ways, in other words, what are two to three ways we can reverse those reasons for
- 26:04being polarized and encourage and incentivize those people to be less polarizing and to start
- 26:08building bridges across political divisions?
- 26:12Yeah.
- 26:12Very important question.
- 26:13So I I think that we are not at the point in our evolution where we can just expect people
- 26:18to opt out of brain science.
- 26:19Right?
- 26:19Like, we know this exists.
- 26:20We know this framework exists.
- 26:22We know how this is how we it works.
- 26:23So my personal opinion is, like, if you can't beat it, join it.
- 26:27Right?
- 26:27And how can we leverage that brain science for the positive, directionality of bridge building
- 26:33and depolarization?
- 26:34So let's just take, again, social media as as a micro example.
- 26:38So you we do have a choice, and it's kind of like a low effort choice, which is like, am I
- 26:42gonna follow, like, promote, amplify conflict entrepreneurs and toxic dialogues?
- 26:47Or am I gonna find another in group that is amplifying bridge building narratives, you you
- 26:53know, unity, but not monolith narratives.
- 26:56Right?
- 26:56We're like, again, because it's not about everybody thinking alike and every and hegemony
- 27:00and winning the the the worldview.
- 27:02This is about saying, you know, I think we can actually be different and and work together.
- 27:07Actually, that's a strength and not a weakness.
- 27:09Right?
- 27:09So you find find find a social media accounts, find media accounts that are, are amplifying
- 27:16this bridge building and depolarization, depolarization dialogue and get your dopamine
- 27:20hits by sharing and liking and engaging with a new in group.
- 27:24You know, this this in group is real and it's growing.
- 27:27I'll give you a couple examples.
- 27:28You know, of course, you're, everyone is is really welcome and encouraged to connect with
- 27:32to Polarwise on social media, but just seeing the growth in this last year.
- 27:37Right?
- 27:37Bridge USA, just on Instagram, is up to over 70,000 followers.
- 27:42Builders Oh, nice.
- 27:43Just in this year is up to over 360,000 followers.
- 27:46Yeah.
- 27:47So there's community there of people that are gonna be interested and and forming this in
- 27:52group for your likes and your shares in your amplification of this worldview.
- 27:57And I say, yeah, again, if that's important to you, if you need that, if you just, you know,
- 28:02it's just like coffee to you and you get, ah, I got that like, I got that share.
- 28:06Just change the in group that you're part of to a constructive one that's actually working to
- 28:11fix this, you know, the problems that we have in this country.
- 28:15The second thing I'll say, and it's, you know, it's more high effort, but it's directly
- 28:19engaging and working on achieving superordinate goals across unlikely coalitions.
- 28:26Right?
- 28:27So there's a video on Depolar Wise that I really, I encourage people to watch and it's in
- 28:34like our what to watch section.
- 28:35So if you like video content, it's there for you.
- 28:37It's from Kara McGee Mellon researchers on this, topic.
- 28:40And they talk about, you know, the, which goes back to what you were saying earlier, the kind
- 28:45of initial thinking around depolarization was like, how can you make efforts to just make
- 28:49people get along better, like be nicer to each other and, you know, and, and just kind of
- 28:53kumbaya or these like the soft woo woo stuff you were talking about.
- 28:57And what the research is really showing, especially from other countries is that doesn't
- 29:02fix it.
- 29:02What fixes it is getting unlikely coalitions, people that you wouldn't think agree with each
- 29:08other and giving them a goal that's bigger than the, the, the, micro goals that these
- 29:16communities have.
- 29:17So superordinate goal that everybody goes, yeah, I want to solve that.
- 29:21Maybe my beliefs and needs around it are different than your beliefs and needs around
- 29:25it, but we want to get at that and we need to fix it.
- 29:27So just give a concrete example.
- 29:29Maybe I'm invested in immigration reform because I have family here who are
- 29:35undocumented.
- 29:36They are kids.
- 29:36They grew up here and I wanna give them a path to citizenship to be productive members of the
- 29:41society going forward.
- 29:43Maybe someone else is interested in immigration reform because they want safety in their
- 29:47community.
- 29:47They don't want human trafficking or drug trafficking.
- 29:50And they were like, we gotta get at this because there's dangers.
- 29:52So both of those are valid beliefs and needs.
- 29:54Right?
- 29:55But both when you get to that sub superordinate goal, we're both talking about like good, solid
- 30:00immigration reform and, and, you know, protecting our borders while also giving people
- 30:05opportunity.
- 30:06Like, can find those points of commonality as we work towards solving that problem together.
- 30:13And you know, surprisingly, we've been very close to that in the past, but we just haven't
- 30:17been able to land the plane on it because we've been going in the wrong direction with
- 30:20polarization.
- 30:21Americans in general have very similar kind of policy, because we're for a practical nation.
- 30:27Right?
- 30:27We're just like, yeah.
- 30:28Like, I think every I think people should have the right to bear arms.
- 30:31I also think there should be some restrictions around stuff that's a little beyond the pale so
- 30:36we can get to, and Tennessee 11 is another, video or movie, documentary I would encourage.
- 30:42We can get to some common solutions.
- 30:44It doesn't mean everybody gets everything they want, but it means that we can move forward on
- 30:51positive change that isn't going to have that blowback and that yo yo effect because we've
- 30:57made something that's more durable with more voices, more ideas incorporated in that, in
- 31:04that policy solution.
- 31:06So nothing works on depolarization like working toward common goals and solving problems.
- 31:12And when you work towards those common goals, sometimes you find your seemingly completely
- 31:17disparate policy views really aren't so mutually exclusive.
- 31:21You can actually potentially work towards at least achieving somewhat of both sides'
- 31:26interests in that regard.
- 31:28But, obviously, like you said, we can't none of us can get everything that we want.
- 31:32It's just it's just not how politics works, at least not if you wanted to move forward.
- 31:37The thing you said about unity not a monolith, I wish I had come up with that specific way to
- 31:44put it because I really like putting it that way because sometimes people do, especially
- 31:49polarized people think unity has unity within our specific worldview.
- 31:56And then you you got some even hardcore Republicans, hardcore Democrats that complain
- 32:01about their party not being conservative enough if it's Republican or a liberal enough if it's
- 32:06Democrat, and then you've got those supposed rhinos and dinos that people like to use as
- 32:12pejorative terms for those.
- 32:14So I think also it is important to show that depolarization is not about being a monolith.
- 32:23It's just general unified purpose of, hey, we don't need to be at each other's throats all
- 32:28the time.
- 32:29And in fact, a lot of us don't have the same views on what is the best policy, but we do
- 32:35have a common purpose that is unifying us as which is to at least try an earnest attempt to
- 32:43find the best policy and to actually incorporate everybody's views so they at least
- 32:48feel like they are they've been heard.
- 32:50And so Yes.
- 32:52I I've I talked before, you know, shifting gears a little bit more to you've talked before
- 33:00in a TED Talk and in other forms and then, of course, just now on the podcast about your
- 33:05mother's experience in Colombia during La Viellencia, at their civil war.
- 33:10And, unfortunately, political violence and the threat of it has become more commonplace in
- 33:16American society way, like, with the assassinations of Melissa, Hartman and and
- 33:22Charlie Kirk and the intense assassinations of Donald Trump and Josh Shapiro and and countless
- 33:26other instances similar to those.
- 33:29But not every polar polarized person goes quite that far.
- 33:32Some of them just stick to yelling on the on the Internet.
- 33:36So what do you think ultimately gets people to cross that line into supporting or even
- 33:41engaging in political violence, and how do we more effectively discourage or push it back
- 33:46against that specifically?
- 33:48Yes.
- 33:49I I think this is to me personally, it's it's it's a question we need to be seriously asking
- 33:55ourselves and, actively working on because it is getting more real here.
- 34:03And it's to me, it's like a genie out of a bottle type of Pandora box or you're too about
- 34:10of a toothpaste situation.
- 34:12You can cross a threshold where it becomes so normalized, you can't go back.
- 34:16Right?
- 34:16So to try to disrupt political violence now, is so important.
- 34:21You know, you were just talking about, the the the people that we're seeing right now subject
- 34:26to partisan violence are typically media personalities or or politicians in some way.
- 34:32They have some very public persona.
- 34:33But I will guarantee you just from the historical framework that, that doesn't stop
- 34:39there.
- 34:40So eventually, it moves on to everyday partisan violence, citizen against citizen on the street
- 34:47violence.
- 34:48And so that doesn't wake us up.
- 34:50We think, well, you know, this this tall poppy syndrome, this person shouldn't have stuck
- 34:54their head out.
- 34:54They wouldn't have, you know, someone wouldn't have tragic shot at it.
- 34:57It's like, no.
- 34:58Is the beginning of something that really can be, will affect all of our lives if we do not,
- 35:05actively shut it down.
- 35:06So the three, I think it's a recipe.
- 35:08So you have this collapsing of of the continuity of political viewpoint and identity
- 35:15into the binary extremes.
- 35:17Now you add three things.
- 35:18One, it's the threat narrative.
- 35:21So we've talked a little bit about conflict entrepreneurs and how they monetize this
- 35:26toxicity and polarization.
- 35:27Key to that is this threat narrative that is, creating a worldview that the other side is
- 35:33dangerous to you.
- 35:34Right?
- 35:35So they're not just annoying.
- 35:36They're not just misguided.
- 35:37They're not just, you know, dumb.
- 35:39They're actually going to destroy the country.
- 35:41They're, going to destroy your kids' futures.
- 35:45So we create this threat narrative and, and unfortunately sometimes there's a, there's a,
- 35:50there's a reality.
- 35:50Something real happens, you know, say in Columbia, there was an attack at the, the
- 35:55pulse.
- 35:55Okay.
- 35:56So that really happened.
- 35:57And then what that turns into from the conflict entrepreneur framework is, liberals are coming
- 36:03to kill you.
- 36:04Conservatives are coming to kill you.
- 36:05We get that threat narrative escalated to the point where, you're, you're seeing the other
- 36:11side as an active threat to your livelihood or your life, then your mindset becomes one of
- 36:17self defense.
- 36:18And I, I feel strongly in the, and I believe the research supports this, that no one who
- 36:23takes their act of political violence thinks that they're an initiator.
- 36:27They don't think they're making the first strike.
- 36:29They think they're responding.
- 36:31Right?
- 36:31They have a mindset of self defense and what they're doing is a response.
- 36:35You see that type of escalation in this country too.
- 36:38We, label speech as violence, and then there's act of violence as a response.
- 36:43They don't think that they're they're initiating that act of violence.
- 36:47They think it's a response to other violence they've experienced.
- 36:49So that's why that vicious cycle of the threat narrative is so dangerous, because people are
- 36:55in a self defense mindset, which has its own moral authority.
- 36:58Right?
- 36:59The second part of the recipe is dehumanization.
- 37:02And, you know, you you recently had a guest on about pluralism who talked very articulately
- 37:07about that too.
- 37:08It cannot be overstated that when, people who are different than you aren't just different
- 37:14than you, but they're evil.
- 37:16They're traitors.
- 37:19Right?
- 37:20Subhuman.
- 37:21Exactly.
- 37:21They're vermin.
- 37:22They're bugs, animals.
- 37:23Like we see this in other conflicts around the world that human beings, their dignity is taken
- 37:29away and then they're labeled as something that is subhuman.
- 37:32Exactly the right word.
- 37:34And what that does is it shuts down it actually talking about brain signs again, it shuts down
- 37:38the empathy centers in your brain when you're not talking about another person as a, as a
- 37:43wife, a mother, a daughter, but you're talking about them as a traitor, an enemy, and, you
- 37:49know, a cockroach, then your your empathy centers have have have broke down.
- 37:53You don't have a human to human relationship with that.
- 37:56So that dehumanization is key.
- 37:57It allows us to turn the other way when we see political violence, and it is a tipping point
- 38:02to allowing something perpetuated.
- 38:04Then the third part of the recipe is really lack of faith in our institutions.
- 38:08And when you are seeing signs where you don't think you have the efficacy to improve,
- 38:16problems in judicial systems and electoral systems, you know, and you think there's no
- 38:22path there.
- 38:22There's no path to solving societal problems in our institutions anymore.
- 38:27Then what really does prevent you from going out into the street and trying to achieve the
- 38:30society you want?
- 38:32In hand to hand combat.
- 38:33Right?
- 38:34There needs to be, if not faith in the institutions as there are, there has to be
- 38:39faith in the institutions as we can change them for the better.
- 38:43Right?
- 38:44It the we have to have faith in in the voter booth.
- 38:47I'll tell you what what really there was a partisan violence in rural areas in Colombia,
- 38:51but real what really blew the lid off was a presidential candidate was assassinated.
- 38:56That people had invested a lot of hopes in resolving issues in the country like, the
- 39:00disparity between the wealth, between the wealthy and the poor.
- 39:03And so when they saw that, they said, you know, forget it.
- 39:05Electoral system is not gonna help us.
- 39:07You know, judicial system's not gonna help us.
- 39:09There's no institution that's gonna actually improve our lives.
- 39:12So we're going to the streets with it in a very violent way.
- 39:16Okay.
- 39:16How do we, how do we stop that?
- 39:18I mean, that, those are very big issues.
- 39:21I will say that in terms of the threat narrative, opting out of perpetuate the
- 39:26conflict entrepreneur and taking situations as isolated, terrible things have happened.
- 39:31Terrible things will happen, but not putting that as part of like a whole in group intention
- 39:37of violence to another in group.
- 39:39Right?
- 39:40Secondly, with the dehumanization, we feature the dignity index on depolarwise.
- 39:45That is a really important way to understand and moderate our own language and to vet how
- 39:51other people's language is removing the humanity of people or granting them humanity.
- 39:56We are gonna be disagreeing in this country, hopefully, for the rest of the time that we we,
- 40:02you know, are before until the sun explodes.
- 40:04Right?
- 40:04This is gonna be a country that has conflict and that needs to embrace conflict because it's
- 40:08a strength for how we improve ourselves.
- 40:10But how we express ourselves in that conflict, whether we're saying, you know, you, you have
- 40:16no human dignity or whether we're granted human dignity in that disagreement, there's some very
- 40:20tactical specific things you can do in language to make sure that's happening.
- 40:24The dignity index just just nails it.
- 40:26And then I I think the last thing is we have to have zero tolerance to political violence.
- 40:31We cannot brush it away or excuse it when it's happening from our side.
- 40:35It has to be as abhorrent to us whether our side is perpetuating it or whether the other
- 40:41side is perpetuating it.
- 40:42We start cutting ourselves slack there.
- 40:45We're just opening a door we can't close.
- 40:47You you could have an entire conversation on each one of those points you just brought up,
- 40:51but the the ones I specifically focus on, the one you just talked about and then the whole
- 40:55threat narrative is that, you know, I when Melissa Hartman was assassinated, there's
- 41:00there's so much talk about, look how violent conservatives are, and then Charlie Kirk got
- 41:04assassinated.
- 41:05And then it's like, look how violent liberals are.
- 41:07And with complete lack of self awareness and sincerity and no sarcasm at all, they really
- 41:14thought it was just, it's always that side that's starting it.
- 41:18Never them.
- 41:18Yes.
- 41:19They are always the ones that are, like you said at the very beginning, they are the ones
- 41:23who are reacting like, it's not me.
- 41:25Look, I'm just doing what I have to do.
- 41:27And, you know, that's that's a hard thing to break people from, you do have to kind of lead
- 41:32them to understanding that, no, this is how you're viewing things.
- 41:35We need to be able to recognize that this is a problem that all of us are contributing to.
- 41:45When you talked about how we need to recognize our side, not just their side, that's one of my
- 41:53big things I try to stress too, is accountability.
- 41:56There's no real accountability unless you're actually holding your side to those same
- 42:01standards.
- 42:02It's not accountability when you're
- 42:03So well said.
- 42:04Only yelling at other people.
- 42:05Yeah.
- 42:06It's because you're just yelling at them because they have different viewpoints, not
- 42:10because they actually did something wrong.
- 42:12And until we lot more people are willing to hold their sides accountable, we're not gonna
- 42:16have real accountability, and you're gonna have more and more politicians and activists try to
- 42:22toe the line, try to step over that line because they don't think anybody's gonna push
- 42:26back on them, at least not anybody in their camps.
- 42:30And something I emphasize in my work is how every one of us can improve how we engage with
- 42:36each other politically.
- 42:37We're all human.
- 42:37We all make mistakes.
- 42:39And I think there are still some people who really wanna bring down toxicity in politics.
- 42:44And I'm not gonna say that I haven't made these mistakes because I have, and to build bridges,
- 42:48but we can still accidentally be polarizing.
- 42:52We accidentally inflame polarization when we mean to tamp it down.
- 42:56So what are your thoughts about that?
- 42:58And how do you think we can encourage depolarizers and bridge builders to be more
- 43:03self aware to make sure they are making healthy contributions to political discourse.
- 43:09That's so important because, you know, for better, for worse, you are a model.
- 43:15Like you're gonna be held to a different standard if you're proclaiming that you're
- 43:18doing this work.
- 43:18So you have to walk the talk, right?
- 43:21I mean, before we get into, like, how we can improve our our own practice, I I do have to
- 43:26say though that I am the biggest fan of people working in bridge building and depolarization
- 43:30and civic education and civic renaissance work.
- 43:34I I, you know, my respect and my gratitude for for this group of professionals and volunteers
- 43:44is boundless.
- 43:45They are, they're doing incredibly important work.
- 43:48They're doing incredibly timely work.
- 43:51They're they're leading us into uncharted territory.
- 43:55Right?
- 43:55And they are building a plane while they're flying it.
- 43:58So those are my people, you know, to to the extent that, even that depolar Wise is is
- 44:04starting to pivot now into how we can help, professionals and high level volunteers do
- 44:10continue to do the work they do and, support them.
- 44:13Right?
- 44:14So we've recently created a group on LinkedIn called the Bridging and Civic Solutions
- 44:20Exchange.
- 44:21And our our the gap we're trying to fill, right, is that depolarization bridge building,
- 44:25it's not a field.
- 44:26It's not a sector.
- 44:28Right?
- 44:28LinkedIn does not recognize it as a separate entity.
- 44:30And we're kind of fractured ironically into, are you a media person in this space?
- 44:37Are you an education in this space?
- 44:39Are you doing membership organization?
- 44:41You know, are you in a nonprofit?
- 44:43So so there's really not like a a center point for this group.
- 44:47So we're trying to fill the gap of helping people find each other easier in LinkedIn,
- 44:52providing job postings for the sector, providing, conferences, amplifying conferences,
- 44:58amplifying conventions that are happening and, announcing funding opportunities for this
- 45:03space.
- 45:03So there's a real, opportunity, I think, for us all to connect.
- 45:07The group is now I'm I'm gonna call it small but mighty.
- 45:09You know?
- 45:10It's really new.
- 45:11We're we're, we're pushing forward, but we have leaders from some of the top organizations
- 45:16there already, you know, more in common, braver angels, just, you know, builders.
- 45:22So we're having people there that I'm hoping can start to trade their expertise with each
- 45:27other and support and amplify this as a profession.
- 45:31Because ultimately, what's my dream?
- 45:33That we're able to attract the best and brightest into this sector, into this emerging
- 45:37field, because we're gonna need those minds working as passionately on this problem as they
- 45:43have been working as passionately on the divide.
- 45:46Right?
- 45:46So let's take those best and brightest and put them in a different place and incentivize that
- 45:51and show that there's a sector of field and an opportunity to be part of a community and make
- 45:56a livelihood with it.
- 45:57Right?
- 45:57So, okay, that's all my gushing about bid bid builders and to polarizers because I I love
- 46:02them.
- 46:03So how can we improve our practice?
- 46:05I think that there's two there's there's two there's two things that pop out to me most,
- 46:11pressingly, I think, again, in terms of modeling and and walking the talk.
- 46:15I think we first, we need to remember that this is a journey.
- 46:18Right?
- 46:18Like and we're really far down in the journey, you know, and we're we're looking back and now
- 46:23everything's clear.
- 46:24Right?
- 46:24Hindsight's 2020.
- 46:25Like, this is so obvious to us.
- 46:27You know, why would anybody be supporting toxicity?
- 46:29Why would anybody be supporting partisan?
- 46:31Is it like it's just we we've already but we've given ourselves the time to pass through that
- 46:36journey and learn how we learned to get to this point.
- 46:39Right?
- 46:40So we wanna go back and we just wanna pluck people for the beginning of the journey and
- 46:44plot them down at the end of the journey.
- 46:46And that is not realistic be and it's not respectful.
- 46:49Right?
- 46:50So having a lot of patience and respect for people's, uncomfortability, like their
- 46:57hesitation or trepidation engaging with the other side.
- 47:00You know, having patience and respect for people maybe not being ready right away or or
- 47:06kind of not understanding that they can still get their beliefs and needs met in this
- 47:09movement.
- 47:10Just trying to, have patience with their discomfort and, and their feelings as they move
- 47:18through this journey.
- 47:19Right?
- 47:19Because that is a process that takes time.
- 47:21And what we can do is is hold their hands through it and provide them resources through
- 47:26it.
- 47:26But to have any type of intolerance, that they're not where we are right now, it's not
- 47:31helpful.
- 47:33I would say that that's pretty similar to to having to to forwarding how do I wanna say
- 47:40this?
- 47:42Civic engagement or civil dialogue, civil discourse as a ends and not as a means.
- 47:48Right?
- 47:48And so so folks that aren't very wedded like, invested in this movement, when they hear us
- 47:56saying, you know, just, you know, be more polite, have more subtle discourse, have more
- 47:59subtle like, they hear, you're not doing anything, are you?
- 48:02Like, you just want us to get along better.
- 48:04This is not gonna meet my this is not gonna solve my problems.
- 48:07It's not so I think we need to be very, very clear that things like the dignity index,
- 48:13things like civil dialogue, civil discourse, this kind of my this kind of aspect of
- 48:19depolarization and bridge builders that's trying to be welcoming and tolerant is not a
- 48:25excuse not to work on the hard issues and not to solve the hard problems.
- 48:29And I think, for us centering solving the hard problems is the end and the kind of way in
- 48:37which we do the work as the means also can help build credibility in the space and bring more
- 48:42people into it.
- 48:43I will also vouch for the LinkedIn group that Falocia just highlighted there.
- 48:49I'm actually in that group as well.
- 48:52And it is a point that I think needs to be made more, and I should be making the point more
- 48:59often too, is having this depolarization space be treated as its own separate thing, and it
- 49:05would also help to really legitimize the space even in the minds of people who might not be
- 49:11quite as given to depolarizing, they start to see that it's starting to gain more legitimacy,
- 49:17they might start to see, Oh, you know what?
- 49:19Maybe I should go check it out.
- 49:21I think also something that we oh, I was just going to shamelessly plug my I have a five day
- 49:27educational email course that actually talks a little bit about this kind of thing.
- 49:31Now a lot of what Felicia talked about, I touch on a little bit in the EEC, but it's basically
- 49:37just about some of the mistakes we make as depolarizers that can actually accidentally
- 49:41inflame polarization and how we can actually fix those ways that we go about.
- 49:47But, like, oh, oh, because you were talking about how we can be intolerant of people not,
- 49:54you know, not moving along as fast as we would we want them to.
- 49:57Yes, ironically, right?
- 49:58Yeah, exactly.
- 50:00It's just like we're being intolerant of the people that we're trying to get out of
- 50:03intolerance.
- 50:04And I kinda think about because I I coach at my local local YMCA on the side, and it's and I do
- 50:10various sports, basketball and flag football in particular because those are the ones that I'm
- 50:16most skilled at myself.
- 50:17But, you know, if you're, you know, trying to teach a kid how to dribble a basketball and how
- 50:21to shoot and and how to defend somebody, some people will get that stuff a lot quicker than
- 50:27other people.
- 50:27Some just have innately more of a talent to understand and some other people you gotta work
- 50:32with a little bit longer.
- 50:33Not everybody's journey is the same.
- 50:34So basically just like what you had said about bringing people along that journey.
- 50:39So I think that's a really neat way to put it.
- 50:42There's something else that I think bridge builders and depolarizers don't account for
- 50:47enough, is we don't really effectively show polarized people or people that are at major
- 50:52risk of being polarized why polarization actually hurts them in the long run.
- 50:56They a lot of times just see it as, well, I'm just benefiting somebody else.
- 51:00This doesn't benefit me.
- 51:01So what are two to three ways or methods that you think we can use to discourage and
- 51:06disincentivize people from being polarized by showing them that it doesn't actually benefit
- 51:10them as much as they think?
- 51:12Right, right.
- 51:14So, I mean, what that always just pops out to me, I've said this before, it's
- 51:19like
- 51:19these, you know, the these, partisan politicians and these, you know, kind of toxic
- 51:29conflict entrepreneurs that, that you follow, they're not gonna be there at your bedside when
- 51:34you're sick.
- 51:35Right?
- 51:36And we have seen real intangible loss of relationship, people letting go of not just
- 51:43friends, but family due to their devotion to these people on the on the partisan divide.
- 51:50And that to me is is heartbreaking, you know?
- 51:53You know, Monica Guzman, and this is a book we feature on, on Depolar Wise as well.
- 51:57I never thought about that way talks about, her relationship with her very, you know, she's
- 52:02living in Portland, very liberal.
- 52:04Her parents are immigrants, very conservative.
- 52:08And, and, you know, people actually told her, like, why do you still talk to your parents?
- 52:12And that to me is such a it's mind blowing.
- 52:16Right?
- 52:16Like, we've gotten to a point of this political identity, yeah, supersedes our families.
- 52:22Right?
- 52:22And that that's a real intangible harm to people.
- 52:26And it and it may, you know, when you're young and you're healthy and you're moving around the
- 52:31country, you may say, but get older, you know, and find out who's very valuable in your life
- 52:37and who's actually gonna be there for you.
- 52:39That is a sacrifice that is just really not, it's not worth making.
- 52:44Right.
- 52:44I think the second thing I would point out is what I'm going to call like a cortisol tax.
- 52:49Right.
- 52:49So when we're constantly engaged in outreach, like, that's gonna that's that's gonna affect
- 52:56your body.
- 52:56Right?
- 52:56That's your your insomnia and your anxiety and all this stuff that has tangible harms to your
- 53:03health for no trade off.
- 53:05Right?
- 53:05Like, we're not actually accomplishing anything.
- 53:07So, you know, if if you were spending all this cortisol to get yourself out of a burning
- 53:11building, good job.
- 53:13You know?
- 53:13But we're spending all this cortisol to just be outraged.
- 53:16And I I just don't think that we're gonna see positive outcomes from a societal perspective
- 53:22from that, and I think we're gonna see a lot of negative outcomes from a health perspective of
- 53:26this.
- 53:26And there have been some studies, linking, polarization tox and toxicity to, to
- 53:32psychological health.
- 53:33I you know?
- 53:34And I think physical health is not far behind.
- 53:38The last thing I'll just kind of point back to this, like, yo yo of change in the efficacy
- 53:41illusion.
- 53:42Right?
- 53:42Like like, has this really solved problems that you care about in this country?
- 53:45Has it really addressed if you are worried about, you know, the gap, the the lack of
- 53:50opportunity now, the lack of the American dream or the gap between wealth and the poor and like
- 53:53how it's harder for your children to have a better life than you did?
- 53:56Like, has it made tangible gains?
- 53:58Has this approach actually improved your life?
- 54:00And I would go a little bit further that and tap on it and say, who's benefiting from this?
- 54:06Right?
- 54:06If you really look at your personal individual life, are you benefiting from it?
- 54:10Is it increasing your health and your wealth and your opportunities?
- 54:13Or is it actually a real interesting tool for people who want to capture the attention
- 54:20economy, for people who want to garner votes, for people who wanna distract us from maybe
- 54:26issues like economic disparities in this country.
- 54:28Like, who is it benefiting?
- 54:30Follow the money.
- 54:31And I think, if you're not making money off of it, who is?
- 54:35And I hope that that really opens people eyes to, the, you know, the deficits of this kind
- 54:42of, mindset, mentality, or lifestyle.
- 54:45Cortisol tax is another phrase I wish I had come up with.
- 54:48I and if I ever if I ever use that, I'm gonna credit you for that because I don't I don't
- 54:53wanna take credit for that.
- 54:54But to to the big the beginning of of of what you were saying there, the whole, yes,
- 55:02separating yourself from friends and family because of politics.
- 55:06I think about even back when I was really young and I was very obnoxious, very opinionated
- 55:10about politics, even then, I had quite a few friends that were not of the same political
- 55:17persuasion as me, and then we'd get into stupid Facebook arguments.
- 55:21I was just, Ugh, why did we waste our time with those?
- 55:23But never once did I think about saying, You know what?
- 55:27Screw this person.
- 55:28I'm just I'm not even going to communicate with them at all anymore.
- 55:33That that just even at my most obnoxious, I I couldn't fathom about how somebody could do
- 55:42that, especially when you have such a strong relationship.
- 55:47It's and again, it goes back to it's fine to be passionate about politics.
- 55:52In fact, you should.
- 55:53You should have some core values that are your guiding principles, but when it comes to a
- 56:00point where that overtakes your identity and it leads you to dehumanize people that don't share
- 56:06those same values, that's where we've gotta step back a little bit and reevaluate things.
- 56:13Absolutely.
- 56:13Yeah,
- 56:15and one of the best antidotes, I think, to polarization, including those points that you
- 56:20had just made, is civic education for and engagement by a wider variety of people.
- 56:25We see plenty of studies that have linked civic education to less polarized views and being
- 56:32able to think about nuance and details, but improving civic engagement can be a very
- 56:39difficult task.
- 56:40Actually, my guest I just had before you talked about improving civic engagement.
- 56:44We talked about how it can be such a difficult, arduous task.
- 56:48And some people don't want to or are afraid of getting politically or involved politically for
- 56:54various reasons, whether they feel like they're personally gonna be threatened, for example.
- 56:59What are two to three ways that we could encourage and motivate more people to be more
- 57:04civically involved and therefore beat back polarization?
- 57:08Yes.
- 57:09And I think the phrasing you're using is so important.
- 57:11Right?
- 57:11Like, being civically involved is there's a lot of daylight between that and being political,
- 57:16right, and engaging in politics.
- 57:17And for this exhausted majority, it's like, I don't want like but if we start to further this
- 57:21idea of, like, civic engagement, like, that to me feels accessible.
- 57:25And that to me feels like some stuff that you could do without getting in any type of
- 57:29political phrase.
- 57:30So I would say the first two things, like, go local.
- 57:33Right?
- 57:34The more national we get, I think the more we're, like, subjected and also prone to more
- 57:40of this outreach machine and less of the actual getting things done.
- 57:43Absolutely.
- 57:44So the more local you can be, you know, I think your your your pluralism guess that you
- 57:48recently had, made such a compelling case for mutual aid.
- 57:52Right?
- 57:52So like when you're working on mutual aid, nobody's checking your voter card at the door.
- 57:57If you're at the food pantry giving out food, if you're helping clean up after a fire, that's
- 58:01like apolitical.
- 58:03Work locally on matters that provide mutual aid, improve your neighborhood, improve your
- 58:08community.
- 58:08That doesn't have to be about winning or losing a political battle.
- 58:13And then, like, similarly, just, like, lower the stakes.
- 58:15Right?
- 58:16So our local Brave War Angels group here in in in New Mexico, they have a documentary night.
- 58:22You just watch a film and talk about it.
- 58:24Right?
- 58:24Other people are having potlucks.
- 58:26You know?
- 58:26You could have a just a a food event between two different churches or a church at a
- 58:30synagogue or a mosque and just just eat together.
- 58:33You don't have to talk about any of the serious issues.
- 58:35Just get to know each other.
- 58:37So I think lowering the stakes is really important.
- 58:40I'll I'll do a shameless plug now for my for my, day job organization.
- 58:44So St.
- 58:45John's College, does a a summer classics ics event every year where people come around from
- 58:50the country, adult learners.
- 58:51They're not in degree programs, and they spend a week or more either in person or online
- 58:56talking about, great work that they're very interested to get to know.
- 59:00And I think this year, to your question, we have a great opportunity with the two hundred
- 59:05and fiftieth anniversary of the declaration to spend some time in company and reflection of
- 59:10the great works that have shaped America, either critic because of critic good, positive
- 59:15criticism that we needed or to try to reach our aspirational ideals.
- 59:20So, you know, you can come find us at sjc.edu/classics.
- 59:24Read the foundational texts with other people who are interested in it.
- 59:27Read great American novels and see how that shaped this country.
- 59:30Engage with the soul of black folk or native American films when you want that alternative
- 59:35perspective of the experience of this country.
- 59:38And, just really, spend time with other people in this, we're gonna, you know, we call our
- 59:47theme this year, the pursuit of happiness, right?
- 59:49Like really appreciating the opportunity of this country and our own kind of journey within
- 59:56it, by being part of this continuity of people who have criticized it, loved it, written about
- 1:00:02it, made films about it, and just be part of that conversation that's ongoing and will, you
- 1:00:08know, outlast us.
- 1:00:10And even just doing those things will be mean at least a little bit more civic engagement,
- 1:00:14but it is that is a very important distinction that you made there.
- 1:00:18Civic engagement does not mean being political.
- 1:00:21I mean, there's nothing inherently wrong with getting political, but you can still be
- 1:00:27civically involved without having to support a specific issue or support a specific candidate
- 1:00:35for office, just getting people to try to think more about these things, just informing them
- 1:00:40about what's going on and why people think one way and why people think another way.
- 1:00:45All forms of civic engagement, or at least you trying to understand why people might think
- 1:00:50differently than you without trying to come with a predisposed way of thinking of why they
- 1:00:57believe what they believe, which I mean, But, can happen to all of but very salient point
- 1:01:04that you made there.
- 1:01:05We're running a little low on time, so I'm gonna give one more question before the random
- 1:01:10question of the day that I like to end interviews with.
- 1:01:13But on your website, I found an interesting list of signature talks and topics on
- 1:01:19DepolarWise that you have given previously.
- 1:01:21And one of those was bridge building as a daily meditative practice.
- 1:01:25Now, obviously, I don't want you to give away all those secrets.
- 1:01:28I want you to be actually able to give that whole thing there if if if somebody comes to
- 1:01:33look for that talk.
- 1:01:34But what are two to three tips from that that you can share so that people can build up a
- 1:01:39habit of bridge building and depolarizing?
- 1:01:42Yes.
- 1:01:43Thank you.
- 1:01:43Thank you.
- 1:01:44I I think it's so important, especially as, you know, when you're working in the field as
- 1:01:47professionals and you're human and you're like, oh, this is this is hard.
- 1:01:51I think breath work is a fundamental part of our toolkit.
- 1:01:54You know?
- 1:01:55Just just taking one breath between stimulus and response as Viktor Frankl would say.
- 1:02:01Right?
- 1:02:02Just one breath between those two things is so helpful for, for grounding ourselves in our
- 1:02:09intentions and in the way that we wanna execute on this work.
- 1:02:13So I highly advocate breath work and and just taking that breath when you're feeling those
- 1:02:17those, you know, very human, very natural emotions.
- 1:02:20The other thing I'll say about meditation is it's about, right, self observation.
- 1:02:25Right?
- 1:02:25And self observation, we've talked about this this whole conversation.
- 1:02:29Right?
- 1:02:29Like how do we look at ourselves both as citizens?
- 1:02:32How do we look at ourselves as professionals in brick building and depolarization?
- 1:02:36And taking that time to just, like, observe your thoughts before you act on them.
- 1:02:43Right?
- 1:02:43Observe your emotions, you know, before you believe them, you know, as truth.
- 1:02:49And, you know, observe your, your beliefs before you, defend them.
- 1:02:55Right?
- 1:02:56And so that practice of self observation and that little bit of distance between what is
- 1:03:02feels feels initially natural to you, but creating that space for something else, even in
- 1:03:09yourself, I think that meditative practice of self observation can be a really helpful tool
- 1:03:15for us in this field.
- 1:03:17Breath work is something I am very bad about not doing.
- 1:03:20I definitely need to do that much more often in particular.
- 1:03:23Not even just with politics, just with stuff in general.
- 1:03:27I fell off the meditation wagon a while ago.
- 1:03:31I really need to get back on it, so I will definitely
- 1:03:34It's hard.
- 1:03:35It's really hard.
- 1:03:36That's why I like things like breath work because I like my brain can go somewhere.
- 1:03:40It's like you are just breathing.
- 1:03:41You're not trying to clear your mind.
- 1:03:42Forget it.
- 1:03:43It's impossible, but you can focus on breathing.
- 1:03:46And that is helpful.
- 1:03:48Yeah.
- 1:03:48You're letting the thoughts come and acknowledging them, but you're not trying to do
- 1:03:52anything specific with them.
- 1:03:53Just, oh, that's there.
- 1:03:55Okay.
- 1:03:56Then next thought
- 1:03:57comes And it gives out you compassion for other people, right?
- 1:03:59Because you're like, that's how their brain's working too.
- 1:04:01You know, sometimes stuff's just coming in it and they're gonna say that stuff and, know,
- 1:04:05have some compassion that maybe that's just passing through.
- 1:04:09Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:04:10I really wanna thank you for your time, for giving all your insights about this, Falocia.
- 1:04:15So we're gonna go ahead and wrap things up now because I like to always end interviews with a
- 1:04:22random question of the day.
- 1:04:23For those of you who are new to the podcast, it's just a fun, random, nonpolitical, or if it
- 1:04:29is political, it's not gonna be anything, like, controversial or anything like that.
- 1:04:35I I just like to get a different side of the guest and just showcase a different side and
- 1:04:40humanize them a little bit like we've been talking about in this in this discussion.
- 1:04:45And also, some of this stuff can be a little bit harrowing, so let's add some levity to it.
- 1:04:51Felocia, for you, the random question of the day is, if your safety and return to earth were
- 1:04:58guaranteed, what planet would you visit and why?
- 1:05:01Oh, what planet would I visit and why?
- 1:05:04Oh god.
- 1:05:06You know, I just feel like everyone's so focused on Mars.
- 1:05:10We we we need to think about a different, a different, star here that we wanna we wanna
- 1:05:18shed some light on.
- 1:05:19You know, I think if my safety was guaranteed, I would wanna check out Jupiter because you
- 1:05:30think you see that storm in the middle of that planet and you just think
- 1:05:36this
- 1:05:36planet has a soul.
- 1:05:38You know?
- 1:05:38It's something's going on.
- 1:05:40There's turmoil there.
- 1:05:41There's just the it's just so dynamic.
- 1:05:44Right?
- 1:05:44And and I think that, plus that and the gravity.
- 1:05:47Right?
- 1:05:47Like, what is what is that experience like, in a in a planet that is just, plus, you know, in
- 1:05:55in all the Greek and Roman mythology.
- 1:05:56Right?
- 1:05:56That's that's Zeus.
- 1:05:58That's the big guy.
- 1:05:58You know?
- 1:05:59That's the that's, that's the one that's that's the one that's, really, holding our
- 1:06:04gravitational system together.
- 1:06:06So let's give some let's give some respect to Yeah.
- 1:06:10To our, to our big planet in our solar system.
- 1:06:14Yeah.
- 1:06:14The great red spot is is is an astounding fact about the solar system.
- 1:06:19I believe it's bigger than Earth, and it's just this giant, like, 200 mile per hour windstorm.
- 1:06:24And then really freaky thing about planets like Jupiter is there's no solid surface to land on.
- 1:06:29It's all gas.
- 1:06:30I'd love to go see every planet if my safety was guaranteed as Yes.
- 1:06:34Freaky as some of it would be.
- 1:06:35But for me, if we're just gonna keep it in the solar system, because there's some exoplanets
- 1:06:40that are just super wild that that we've we've studied from afar, of course.
- 1:06:45But if we're just gonna stick in the solar system, it would be Venus.
- 1:06:49So Venus is a I I was a big astronomy nerd as a
- 1:06:52astronaut.
- 1:06:53Yeah.
- 1:06:54No.
- 1:06:54So Venus well, Venus is covered in noxious gases, but it it is a terrestrial plan.
- 1:07:01Once you get past yeah.
- 1:07:03Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, yes, Neptune, those are the gas those are the gas planets.
- 1:07:11Then
- 1:07:11Gas giants?
- 1:07:12Wow.
- 1:07:13Or gas yeah.
- 1:07:14Gas giants.
- 1:07:14So those are those are the gas giants, and then Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars.
- 1:07:18And then if you're still obstinate about Pluto, we actually, the my pluralist guest, you
- 1:07:24brought you you talked about Liz Vogel.
- 1:07:26We actually had a little discussion about Pluto.
- 1:07:30But if you still consider Pluto a planet, which I do too, those are the terrestrial planets.
- 1:07:36So those are the ones that actually have a surface.
- 1:07:37But I picked Venus because I think Venus is just a really most interesting because it is so
- 1:07:42because it is so covered in noxious gases and because the pressure there is really high, It's
- 1:07:49we've had very limited ability to actually scan the surface.
- 1:07:53I believe it's the Soviets that were the first to actually break through, and they got a probe
- 1:07:58there.
- 1:07:58So we do actually have a few photos from the surface from whichever probe it was that they
- 1:08:04sent there.
- 1:08:04It's just because of that level of mystery.
- 1:08:07I just really wanna see it.
- 1:08:08And then just just to get a sense of what that's like.
- 1:08:11But, of course, you know, that I love that.
- 1:08:13Even though even though every planet would be, you know, dangerous to live on, that'd be may
- 1:08:16one of the most dangerous.
- 1:08:18Well, I mean, of course, the gas giants, you don't have anywhere to land on.
- 1:08:21But, yeah, Venus and then also just there's just very interesting other aspects about
- 1:08:27Venus.
- 1:08:28Like, for one, it rotates the exact opposite way that all the other planets do.
- 1:08:32I think think Uranus does as well.
- 1:08:36The day the day on Venus is also longer than its year because it rotates slower than it
- 1:08:43revolves around the sun.
- 1:08:45So rotation Okay.
- 1:08:46That's crazy.
- 1:08:47Day.
- 1:08:48Yeah.
- 1:08:48That's that's crazy.
- 1:08:50Yeah.
- 1:08:50It's it it it rotates slower than it revolves around the sun.
- 1:08:54It's it's a really fascinating planet.
- 1:08:57So Wow.
- 1:08:58No.
- 1:08:59I I appreciate getting to geek out about space because I was a big space nerd when I was a
- 1:09:03kid.
- 1:09:04So really appreciate all your insights about depolarization.
- 1:09:09Thank you for humoring me with the with the quest the random question of the day.
- 1:09:13My pleasure.
- 1:09:14But we, yeah, but we are gonna have to wrap things up as much as I'd like to keep going on.
- 1:09:19So thank you so much, Felicia.
- 1:09:21Before we go, any, obviously I will link depolar wise on this episode when it comes out
- 1:09:28and as well as your TED talk.
- 1:09:30Is there any other things that you want me to Any other links you wanna share?
- 1:09:36No.
- 1:09:36I would just say come join us on social media, come fill out our forms on Depolarize and let
- 1:09:42us know what you're thinking.
- 1:09:43And if you're working in the space, come join us on LinkedIn at the Bridging and Civic
- 1:09:47Solutions Exchange group.
- 1:09:48We would love to have you.
- 1:09:49And thanks for your time and for your listeners' engagement.
- 1:09:53I am so grateful we had this conversation.
- 1:09:55I always find it so energizing to do so.
- 1:09:58Yeah.
- 1:09:58Absolutely.
- 1:09:59And I really thank you for being on there.
- 1:10:00So, yeah, I will also link that LinkedIn group as well.
- 1:10:04So my my links, my my LinkedIn profile, I post on there quite frequently.
- 1:10:10My Facebook page, Paul Raider author and speaker.
- 1:10:14My five day educational email course that I brought up about in in this talk about how we
- 1:10:19can more effectively depolarize politics and and correct some of the mistakes we make when
- 1:10:24we try to depolarize that can sometimes accidentally inflame tension.
- 1:10:28My email, Paul Raider writes at Gmail dot org.
- 1:10:31My website, paulraider.org.
- 1:10:33And I also have a book on Amazon.
- 1:10:36I realized I forgot to highlight that the last couple of episodes, but I have a book on Amazon
- 1:10:41about political independence and why they struggle so much with elections and how they
- 1:10:45could possibly mitigate those obstacles that you can buy on Amazon.
- 1:10:50It's not arguing for or against independence, but it just talks a little bit more about that
- 1:10:55from an impartial standpoint.
- 1:10:56So we are going to end this episode here now.
- 1:11:00So thank you again so much for all of you listening.
- 1:11:02Please like, comment, subscribe, and share the episode on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple
- 1:11:07Podcasts, and we'll see you next time.