Latest / Boulder Valley Frequency / The People v. Boulder: City sued over use of Flock cameras
Transcript
- 0:00The frequency of frequently.
- 0:09Good morning, Boulder County.
- 0:11It's Wednesday, June 3rd.
- 0:14I'm your host, Shea Castle.
- 0:16And this is the Frequency.
- 0:19A weekly local podcast covering the news, events, and voices shaping the Boulder Valley.
- 0:25This episode is brought to you by the Regional Air Quality Council.
- 0:28This summer, go wild for front-range air quality.
- 0:32Take simple steps for better air, to help reduce ground-level ozone pollution and to protect your health.
- 0:38Taking public transit, carpooling, and combining trips, riding your bike, working from home, and going electric all help us breathe easier in the warm and sunny summer months.
- 0:49Know when it matters most by signing up for ozone alerts from the Regional Air Quality Council.
- 0:55Learn more at SimpleStepsbetterAir.org.
- 1:01We've got another all-headline edition for you today.
- 1:05On Friday, the Mountaineer's Tyler Hickman takes us to skate school in Netherland.
- 1:10You truly do not want to miss this.
- 1:12It is Tyler's best story so far.
- 1:15Next week, we're visiting an art class in a South Boulder community.
- 1:20I am so grateful to finally be featuring some youth voices on the podcast.
- 1:24Mark your calendars.
- 1:26It's a fun one.
- 1:27Let's get to it.
- 1:31A federal judge has temporarily blocked the transfer of NCAR's Supercomputing Center.
- 1:37The ruling comes as the Trump administration attempts to dismantle the crucial hub of climate monitoring and weather research based in Boulder.
- 1:44The National Center for Atmospheric Research has been in the crosshairs of the president for so-called climate alarmism.
- 1:51NCAR is under the purview of the National Science Foundation, or NSF.
- 1:56In February, NSF announced the Supercomputing Center would be transferred to new, unnamed operators.
- 2:02This week, senior U.S.
- 2:04District Judge R.
- 2:05Brooke Jackson granted a temporary injunction against the transfer.
- 2:10In the ruling, Judge Jackson noted the move may have been retaliatory for Colorado's detention of Tina Peters.
- 2:17Peters was imprisoned after tampering with voting machines in Mesa County.
- 2:21She was released from prison this week after Colorado Governor Jared Polis commuted her nine-year sentence.
- 2:27Jackson also noted the decision to move the supercomputing system seemed to ignore the NSF's own rules for public comment.
- 2:35Quote, NSF's flagrant disregard of its own mechanism for receiving and considering stakeholder and public feedback further illustrates the arbitrary and capricious nature of the agency's decision, Jackson wrote.
- 2:47Read more from Axios Boulder at the link in our show notes.
- 2:52Two Boulder residents are suing the city over its use of automatic license plate reader cameras, or ALPRs.
- 2:59Boulder employs 31 cameras across the city.
- 3:02The data is gathered and managed by Flock, a company that has drawn increasing scrutiny in recent years for its cooperation with federal immigration authorities.
- 3:12The cameras are continuously gathering images of cars and drivers.
- 3:16Every time a vehicle passes a camera, a photo is captured and fed into Flock's searchable database.
- 3:22That amounts to a warrantless search, the lawsuit alleges.
- 3:26Plaintiffs Will Freeman and Gwen Steele are being represented by Denver law firm Newman McNulty.
- 3:32They are seeking class action status, arguing that every resident and person who travels through Boulder is also being subjected to dragnet surveillance.
- 3:41The lawsuit also alleges Boulder's flot cameras capture data on individuals outside of motor vehicles, such as race and ethnicity, gender and clothing.
- 3:51That's something Andrew Gentry warned us about in his February interview with The Frequency.
- 3:56There's a massive amount of information being collected by these cameras, including facial recognition, including race recognition, including gauge recognition.
- 4:06There's a ton of information that most people don't know is being collected every single time you pass one of these cameras.
- 4:12Gentry is a cybersecurity professional based in Golden and founder of Eyes Off Colorado.
- 4:18Hear more from Gentry in our May 22nd re-release of that interview.
- 4:22Freeman is the founder of DeFlock, an open source project mapping the location of Flock cameras and advocating for stronger protections.
- 4:30Freeman is also suing for access to images of his own personal vehicle captured by Flock.
- 4:35The City of Boulder declined to release those records to him, the lawsuit alleges.
- 4:40Boulder is in the process of selecting a new provider of ALPR technology.
- 4:44A competitive bidding process was launched in March.
- 4:47A vendor is expected to be announced later this month.
- 4:51The City of Boulder could be facing a second lawsuit over an informal vote related to its airport.
- 4:57In April, Boulder City Council directed staff to keep accepting money from the Federal Aviation Administration for the maintenance and upkeep of Boulder Municipal Airport.
- 5:06The direction was given via an informal vote known as a nod of five.
- 5:11Nods of five are routinely used by City Council to communicate general policy direction to staff.
- 5:17Unlike formal roll call votes, they do not require a public hearing or advance notice, though such actions are often listed on an agenda released in advance of the meeting.
- 5:27In mid-May, a legal memo was released by Airport Neighborhood Campaign, a group of residents advocating for the airport to be redeveloped into housing and services.
- 5:36The group retained Denver law firm Ireland, Stapleton, Pryor, and PASCO to write the memo.
- 5:42The memo states the April Not of 5 may have violated Colorado's open meeting laws, which require official government action to be noticed in advance and occur at meetings open to the public.
- 5:53The NOT of 5 in question happened during a study session that was broadcast virtually, with no opportunity for public comment or in-person attendance.
- 6:02After the memo's release, Boulder City Council announced its intention to hold a public hearing on the matter.
- 6:08That hearing has not yet been scheduled.
- 6:10Read more from the Daily Camera and Boulder Reporting Lab at the links in our show notes.
- 6:16Lafayette is hosting an informational meeting about its cemetery, which has been closed to casket burials since November, after the discovery of unplotted human remains and controversy over unmarked graves.
- 6:27The meeting will be Wednesday, June 10th, from 6.30 to 8 p.m.
- 6:31at the Lafayette Public Library, 775 West Baseline Road.
- 6:36We've been reporting on this issue for months.
- 6:38Listen to our coverage at boulderfrequency.com.
- 6:42Boulder County has extended and expanded direct cash assistance for low-income families with young children.
- 6:48The commissioners spent$4.2 million on the program, which will give$600 per month to families to spend as they please.
- 6:56That is double the$300 they were receiving before the bump.
- 7:00Qualified families earn less than 30% of area median income and have children under the age of four.
- 7:06In 2026 in Boulder County, a family of four with a combined income under$45,000 would be considered eligible.
- 7:14The funds come from interest on federal COVID recovery dollars Boulder County received under the American Rescue Plan Act, or ARPA, according to a press release.
- 7:26NIWAT has been cleared to vote on incorporation this November.
- 7:30The vote will be the first in a process toward becoming a home rule municipality, giving NIWAT more authority to write its own laws and elect its own governing bodies.
- 7:39If approved, the incorporation vote would be followed by the drafting and adoption of a charter.
- 7:44Superior and Erie both became home rule municipalities in recent years, as they seek more control over budgets and local decision making.
- 7:53The Left Hand Valley Courier has been following the entire Naiwat process.
- 7:57The nonprofit community newspaper is truly your best source of information for this.
- 8:02Visit LHVC.com to learn more.
- 8:19Now, Erie is asking residents about a potential tax on lodging.
- 8:23If you live in Erie, take the survey at surveymonkey.com/slash r slash Erie Lodging or follow the link in our show notes.
- 8:33If you've driven through Boulders University Hill recently, you may have noticed a familiar sight that's been missing for a few years.
- 8:41A banner stretching across Broadway begging motorists not to honk.
- 8:45That sign heralds the return of the Colorado Shakespeare Festival.
- 8:49More specifically, the festival's return to its outdoor Mary Rapon Theater.
- 8:54The Rapon underwent a$105 million renovation that moved the Shakespearefest inside for two years.
- 9:01The festival opened last week and runs through August 2nd.
- 9:05Catch productions of Twelfth Night, Julius Caesar, Shakespeare in Love, and Friends Roman's Countrymen.
- 9:12Full details at cupresents.org/slash Shakespeare-Festival.
- 9:21As always, thanks for listening.
- 9:23Before you go, here's one more thing.
- 9:39Why'd you say that?
- 9:40It takes a lot of time, it takes a lot of practice.
- 9:42You need to get really good at an instrument or really good at a piece of production software.
- 9:46I think the majority of people don't enjoy the majority of the time they spend making music.
- 9:50Do you not think that's like running?
- 9:52It is hard to run, it is painful to run, you don't particularly enjoy it, but you love running.
- 9:57And you get good at it and you get better at it, and you speak to the runners, and they love running.
- 10:02Most people drop out of that pursuit because it was hard.
- 10:05I think that the people that you know that run, uh, this is a uh highly uh biased selection of the population that fell in love with it.