Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / The Attempt at Approval and Connection
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.metagroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.n ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:21This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:22It is Thursday, February 26th, 2026 at 7:35 PM Pacific Standard
- 0:29Time and I am going to talk about authenticity over
- 0:33approval, the path from pretense to presence from the attachment
- 0:40frame in, and maybe even talk about the conditioning that
- 0:49leads to that. That attempt at approval maybe,
- 0:56or the attempt at connection. Or you might frame it as the
- 1:04anticipation of rejection and thwarting that in the way that
- 1:08you think about the world and connecting to people.
- 1:15In secure family systems, of course, the infant is received
- 1:19by caregivers who are capable of taking care of them in a way
- 1:23that's meaningful to the child and reliably enough that they
- 1:28don't worry about whether or not the care will be there.
- 1:31That's essentially the foundation of a secure
- 1:35attachment, that somebody takes care of you and the care is
- 1:42reliable or you don't worry about it.
- 1:44And in insecure and disorganized attachment, that isn't what
- 1:48happens. And so you develop different
- 1:51strategies for coping with that. There's a strong survival desire
- 1:57in the children, unless it's so hopeless, then they fail to
- 2:04thrive and and can even shut themselves down completely into
- 2:10death. But for most of us, it's well
- 2:13certainly if you're here, you survived well enough that you
- 2:18didn't have to to do that. The research that Mary Ainsworth
- 2:27did in proving John Balby's conjecture of attachment. 10s of
- 2:36thousands of hours in the homes of people that they did the
- 2:39strange situation with concluded that in order to reach a
- 2:45security, a child needs to have their needs met 30% of the time
- 2:51or more. And I like to say what that is,
- 2:58is an astonishingly low bar for security.
- 3:04But that also means is that if you didn't have native security
- 3:07growing up, the circumstances of your childhood were difficult
- 3:11less than 30% of the time your needs were met.
- 3:16And so we begin to look at the ways in which needs aren't met
- 3:19and how that shapes the perception of the world, the
- 3:24perception of self. If we put this in a Buddhist
- 3:30frame, you know, sometimes in the West Buddhism is described
- 3:39as a, a pathway out of suffering, that you might say
- 3:45the first noble truth, life is suffering.
- 3:49But actually Dan Brown would argue that in in a way that was
- 3:56convincing, I thought that actually suffering is a poor
- 3:59translation, that the a better translation would be that life
- 4:05is reactivity. We live in this human body which
- 4:09has these sense gates, which has mind.
- 4:12In the West we have the five senses, touching, seeing,
- 4:16hearing, tasting, smelling. And in Buddhism there's the
- 4:19sixth one, which is the mind. And the mind is the thing that
- 4:25provides meaning or maybe definition.
- 4:30So you react and then the mind provides a definition for the
- 4:34reaction. So we we live in this marvelous
- 4:40experience of the eternity of the present moment is what I
- 4:45like to call it, which is incredibly fleeting.
- 4:48So it's this combination of of only existing in the present
- 4:52moment which is constantly changing.
- 4:55How do you come into a place of safety, a place of security when
- 5:01the whole setup is to be 1 of constant fluctuation, constant
- 5:06changing, and yet the perspective stays the same,
- 5:10right? When you think of yourself now,
- 5:16do you have continuity in the sense of you being the same you
- 5:21that was the child that you were?
- 5:24And does that magic of the way that the human mind conceives of
- 5:29things make it relatable that that child self and that adult
- 5:33self are relatable in some way? Even though the body that we're
- 5:38in is different, the the circumstances we're in is
- 5:41different and our our cognitive mind is completely different
- 5:45from the adult point of view from the child.
- 5:48But do you, can you remember your child's perspective on self
- 5:54in world even, or do you imagine it from the adult point of view,
- 6:03what it must have been? I remember one day my sister
- 6:15rode off on her tricycle. She was probably, I don't know,
- 6:19three years old or around 4 years old, something like that.
- 6:23And we all looked for her in the neighborhood and didn't find
- 6:26her. And finally, my parents called
- 6:28the police. And toward the end of the day, a
- 6:31squad car pulled up into the driveway.
- 6:34And my sister was sitting in the back of the squad car.
- 6:38And the cop took her tricycle out of the trunk and opened the
- 6:42door. And when she stepped out of the
- 6:44squad car she looked at me and said I could have got away.
- 6:59Which gives you a sense of the kind of chaos that we, we, we
- 7:03lived in, in the house I grew up.
- 7:14So then what we do is we look at these patterns of conditioning
- 7:16that we go through. And you know, the one of the
- 7:20things that about attachment theory is like, say, it's not,
- 7:23it's not rocket science, it's attachment theory because it's,
- 7:27it in some sense simple. The things that happen to a
- 7:30child lead in these ways to the creation of these working models
- 7:39of who we are and what we're capable of and actually what the
- 7:42world has to offer us. And in that way that we make
- 7:45conceptual reality, we can easily, in low mentalizing
- 7:51states, believe that the construction of reality that we
- 7:54create in every moment is actually what's happening.
- 8:00And the deep inside the Buddhist insight is that it's actually a
- 8:04construction. We've constructed something.
- 8:08It isn't actually what's happening.
- 8:10And that we've constructed the meaning of the present moment
- 8:13based on our conditioning. And that because everybody's
- 8:16conditioning is different, everybody is creating a
- 8:19different construction of the reality that we're in.
- 8:22And that actually the, the, the thing that connects us, the
- 8:26thing that allows intimacy between people is that you're
- 8:30willing to authentically describe your reality, your
- 8:37conceptual realities, and other people are willing to
- 8:42authentically describe their experience of reality and so
- 8:47that you can see them and they can see you and you can
- 8:50understand each other. So in that mentalizing frame, we
- 8:55would say you understand how you've defined the experience of
- 9:01the present moment. That is to say, you have a
- 9:05capacity to sense and you have an object that can be sensed.
- 9:08So yeah, the ear here is sound waves, the eye sees photons, the
- 9:14body tracks temperature and pressure tasting, smelling very
- 9:21closely linked. You know, there's more than one
- 9:26perfume. That alone should be an
- 9:30indication that we aren't all the same.
- 9:41Aristotle and I, I completely blame him and, and actually I
- 9:45think this is unforgivable in in many ways thought that we, we do
- 9:52a uniform survey of everything that's around us through our
- 9:55five sense gates. And then we create internally a
- 9:58working model of the world that is largely accurate because we
- 10:02take him enough of a survey of the world and perceive it
- 10:07accurately that when we assign meaning to it, it's a, it's a
- 10:11universal meaning. Everybody experiences the same
- 10:15thing, which allows you to infer other people's intentions by
- 10:20your interpretation of their actions.
- 10:27This has never really correspond corresponded to my experience
- 10:31about how the world unfolds. In Buddhism, we have mind, and
- 10:37what mind does is this highly curated selection of things that
- 10:41we enjoy, that we value, that we want, and it leaves everything
- 10:46else out. And so we live in these
- 10:48constructions of reality which are really attuned to our sense
- 10:54of what matters. So we're drawn toward the things
- 10:59that we like and we leave out the things that we don't like.
- 11:04Is that making sense now when we grow up and we're engaged in
- 11:15interactions with the caregivers and we need to be responsive to
- 11:19the caregivers, to elicit from them the things that we need to
- 11:22survive, Food, clothing, shelter, medicine, nurturing
- 11:28some kind. We adapt.
- 11:37Did you have a sensitive caregiver who was interested in
- 11:40who you were and what your preferences were?
- 11:43And did they attempt to meet those preferences?
- 11:47Did they pay attention to what you were drawn to and what you
- 11:50weren't interested in? Did they pay attention to your
- 11:54innate abilities, your innate, innate sensibilities?
- 11:58And did they foster them? Did they encourage them?
- 12:02Did they support them? Or were they so caught up in, in
- 12:07the, the, the chaos of their own making that they didn't have the
- 12:13bandwidth for that? That that I think is really the
- 12:16the main explanation of that this is not true for people who
- 12:23are sadistically abused, where the the caregiver derives some
- 12:29some satisfaction or pleasure out of the harm that they do.
- 12:34I think most people are hapless in the miscare that they provide
- 12:40and that their intention is to actually be good at it and to
- 12:44provide well. I think that that is my
- 12:47experience. For most people, you have an 85%
- 12:55chance of inheriting the attachment strategy of your
- 12:58primary caregiver, which means that the person that you choose
- 13:03to be that primary caregiver for you, you learn from them who you
- 13:09are and you learn from them what to expect from the world.
- 13:13That's really what conditioning is.
- 13:17So that in each moment when you make the reality that you create
- 13:21the conceptual reality and the meanings.
- 13:24It's that early construction of of self and world that really
- 13:33forms everything. It's one of the things about the
- 13:36human babies is that they're born with an intact brain stem,
- 13:42a partially formed right hemisphere and not very well
- 13:44formed left hemisphere. And we grow up in and create a
- 13:50brain, a living structure of the brain, which is reflective of
- 13:54the environment that we grew up in.
- 13:58Secure people have this marvelous dance between
- 14:01sympathetic, the sympathetic nervous system and the
- 14:04parasympathetic nervous system. So the sympathetic nervous
- 14:07system is activating and the parasympathetic nervous system
- 14:11is settling and in that marvelous stance of activation,
- 14:18checking whether you need to be activated and then the
- 14:22parasympathetic nervous system settling things down are so that
- 14:27you can be effective in responding doesn't happen in in
- 14:32the other attachment strategy. So you would say that you have a
- 14:36natively secure brain or you have a natively dismissing brain
- 14:40or a natively preoccupied brain or a natively disorganized
- 14:45brain. So what we're really talking
- 14:47about in in working toward authenticity, if you don't have
- 14:54that as a a natural state, is retraining the brain so that it
- 15:04can actually do that. Is that making sense?
- 15:10One of the things that you'll notice about insecure and
- 15:12disorganized people is that they learned the capacity for
- 15:16inauthenticity and they learned the the capacity to abandoned
- 15:25and adopt themselves so that they can get the approval, which
- 15:30we might read as care from the caregiver.
- 15:35And that the drive for survival, the drive to stay alive is so
- 15:39great that all children essentially fold and, and learn
- 15:46the bitterness of inauthenticity.
- 15:52And, you know, to abandon oneself and to abandon what's
- 15:59interesting and meaningful so that you can survive.
- 16:03And the family system is bitter. It's bitter for all of us who
- 16:08had to do that. It was bitter for our parents
- 16:12when they learned to do it, and often so bitter that they never
- 16:17reflected on it so that they just handed it off to us.
- 16:22Some of us had the perception, for instance, that we would do
- 16:25differently. We, we recognized the bitterness
- 16:28of it and when we had kids, I don't have them.
- 16:33I'm observing from sidelines like I do a lot of life and I've
- 16:43heard how many zeros at the end of time.
- 16:49The times I've heard this, that I, I, I, I just didn't want to
- 16:54raise my kids the way I was raised over and over again.
- 16:58And then does it interfere with the transmission of the
- 17:02attachment strategy at all, right.
- 17:04They still have this, the 85% chance of this.
- 17:07I'm saying this so you can let yourself off the hook if you're
- 17:11still on the hook, right? Why is that?
- 17:17Why does that happen? Well, when you get stressed, of
- 17:22course, the cognitive mind goes offline and you're left just
- 17:26with the the database, the rote database of what happened.
- 17:30And particularly with the first child, something is happening
- 17:35and the the body mind is attempting to make meaning of
- 17:38it. And if there's no entry in the
- 17:43database where you're the caregiver and your child is the
- 17:47child, but there's one close enough where you are the child
- 17:52receiving the care from the caregiver, the mind simply
- 17:55inverts them and you, the child becomes the caregiver and your
- 18:00child becomes you. And then you transmit the
- 18:04attachment conditioning. And anybody who's been around
- 18:09small kids or who's attempted to raise kids will understand how
- 18:13difficult that is and how challenged that is and how often
- 18:17you're exhausted and and stressed and how that has an
- 18:22effect on your cognitive mind. And you may even recognize it
- 18:28and make amends to the kid. All of us as small children, one
- 18:43of the central features of life is that we can have an effect on
- 18:50someone else, that somebody else tunes into us.
- 18:53They pay attention to us, they understand our communication,
- 18:58and our communication has an effect on them that we can see.
- 19:04And so often in the insecure and disorganized family systems, the
- 19:09child is overlooked and has to go into these enhanced
- 19:19demonstrations. Let's call them to get attention
- 19:22from from the from within the chaos of the family system.
- 19:31And this is the cauldron in which we begin to learn our
- 19:36inauthenticity, our our need for approval.
- 19:43I think need for approval is, is a common phrase that we use in
- 19:46English, but I wonder if we could also look at as as a
- 19:55strategy for connection, which I think is probably more accurate.
- 20:01The approval that we want is that somebody sees us and
- 20:04acknowledges us and that we have an effect on them.
- 20:08That's what we mean by a need for approval that we have the
- 20:13potential of getting our needs met by by our caregivers in the
- 20:21childhood of somebody who's dismissing so the.
- 20:25Child category for that is anxious avoidant.
- 20:29The defining characteristic of that is neglect.
- 20:36So that and we define neglect as a caregiver who's present but
- 20:41not available. How do you get the attention of
- 20:45a caregiver who's not available to you?
- 20:49And the way you do that is by becoming the person that they
- 20:53want you to be so that you'll get their attention, their
- 20:59interest, which means that you have to excel at the things that
- 21:02they value, whether it's of interest to you or not.
- 21:07Because the things that are interest interesting to you,
- 21:11they don't line up with the values of or the activities that
- 21:16are of interest to the carrier or you don't.
- 21:18They don't register, they don't have an effect, they don't get a
- 21:23response. So in the comments is behave
- 21:33immaculately or rebel? Yes indeed it has to be pretty
- 21:40bad. The conditions have to be pretty
- 21:42bad for a child to rebel in childhood, mid childhood.
- 21:51Most of the time the rebellion comes in adolescence and what
- 21:56happens there is as your cognitive mind improves, you
- 22:02know the child's brain is just this war on of axons that aren't
- 22:06connected to anything. So the child's brain can just
- 22:08SOP up so much information so quickly.
- 22:13One of my friends 20 month old has 3000 words.
- 22:21Can you imagine learning what that was like for you when you
- 22:25learned your first 3000 words? Well, tantrums I I, I think the
- 22:38terrible 234 fives. How old?
- 22:41How long did it take you to negotiate your deals in early
- 22:45childhood is something different than I would say rebellion,
- 22:49tantrums. You're negotiating how your life
- 22:57in the family is going to be and usually once, once the the
- 23:01negotiation period settle settles, you comply with the
- 23:05agreements you make throughout the childhood.
- 23:10It's when the the child's brain in puberty begins to be pruned
- 23:15back to the already connected axons and all the unconnected
- 23:20ones are pruned out that your cognitive mind shoots way up.
- 23:24Your capacity to think and reason shoots way up.
- 23:28And it's at that moment that you're able to reflect on the
- 23:31deals that you made in the tantrum phase.
- 23:37I mean, you know, tantruming is a hardcore negotiation strategy.
- 23:42It's not necessary if you have willingly collaborative partners
- 23:49to negotiate with, right? You reflect on the deals that
- 23:57they made, and if you make a decision that they were actually
- 24:00thoughtful and in your interest, you're able to transition out of
- 24:05that authoritative, controlling, protective caregiver into the
- 24:10coach, mentor caregiver. And then you can use them as a
- 24:15way of helping you negotiate your entry into the adult world.
- 24:20But if you look back at the deals that were made for you and
- 24:24your childhood and you realize that they were made in your
- 24:28caregiver's interest and they disregarded your interest, then
- 24:32it breaks the epistemic trust. And that's when you rebel and
- 24:37the rebellion, actually, because the cognitive mind is capable of
- 24:41really reflecting on this is from all adult authority really.
- 24:50Now, that doesn't mean you become isolated socially.
- 24:54What it means is you withdraw from adults, you are withdraw
- 24:59from the peer group that still is able to manage relationships
- 25:03with adults, and you turn toward your peer group that has also
- 25:08sever severed their relationships with adults, which
- 25:11is really the reservoir of probably the worst advice you've
- 25:16ever received in your entire life and all of the just
- 25:25boneheaded moves that you made as a result of that.
- 25:32Fair enough. The when the once the epistemic
- 25:39trust is broken, it's very difficult to form secure
- 25:43relationships or even reliable relationships because you simply
- 25:47don't believe what anybody is telling you.
- 25:50And it's very hard to form a relationship without trust,
- 25:56which I, I used to say when I was that age, it's not that I
- 25:59don't trust people. I trust them to fuck me over.
- 26:07I'm convinced that's actually what's happening.
- 26:15So we learn in our family systems, you know, preoccupied
- 26:19people. So in dismissing adults, really
- 26:23the main negotiating relationship system is called
- 26:27idealization, where you form these idealized view, you strip
- 26:31out anything negative and there's a belief that the
- 26:38presentation of the idealized view is the thing and not
- 26:44actually delivering on what's idealized in the view.
- 26:47Because in the family system there was no delivery required
- 26:51really. There was simply the
- 26:52presentation in preoccupied people.
- 26:58So that's anxious, ambivalent as a child because it's so chaotic
- 27:05in the environment that they grow up in.
- 27:08They don't learn that you ask for something that you need in a
- 27:12particular way and then, then, then you get it.
- 27:16There's no any of that there. There's just pectrum.
- 27:19There's just demanding. There's just asking, and the
- 27:22skill that you learn is to just keep asking.
- 27:25That's the skill, this dogged, demanding thing, but it looks
- 27:30like in adult life is a hectoring, demanding, nitpicking
- 27:37criticism, and that's how you get what you need from it.
- 27:48Whereas people who grow up to be dismissing are neglected.
- 27:52People who will grow up to be preoccupied become enmeshed in
- 27:56the mind states of their caregiver, then their role
- 27:59reversed. So they're involved in the
- 28:02maintenance of the mind States and emotional life of their
- 28:06caregiver and responsible for regulating the caregiver.
- 28:11And the child learns quite early, if they don't take that
- 28:14on, the caregiver becomes so dysregulated that it feels
- 28:19unsafe to be in the family system.
- 28:22And so they feel a kind of compelling energy toward taking
- 28:32taking on that. So what you notice about that is
- 28:45that the abandonment of yourself, the direction of focus
- 28:54in some ways on what other people demand of you and
- 28:58creating this persona, this false sense of self to engage in
- 29:07eliciting care from your caregivers and actually
- 29:12developing this false self. So it's pretty competent, right,
- 29:17of the two of the authentic real self versus the false self.
- 29:21The false self is much more developed, much more competent
- 29:25for participating in the negotiations of the family
- 29:28system that the the authentic self.
- 29:34And because the authentic self, when presented is is in some
- 29:39sense rejected or ignored, there's a lot of strong negative
- 29:47emotion associated with the activation.
- 29:51The true self Mudit. Hey, George.
- 29:58Hi, I was. Going to ask if to no false
- 30:03versus true self. As a false self, I was wondering
- 30:08if knowing what mindset you're in as if you want something from
- 30:13somebody or is that a good indicator that I want attention
- 30:20for example? So the I want attention, and I'm
- 30:27going to ask for attention in the way that I wanted as an
- 30:31authentic expression. I want attention, so I'm going
- 30:37to promise the world or I want attention, so I'm going to
- 30:42pretend to be the thing that you want that you would give
- 30:45attention to. That's the question.
- 30:51So how far down the rabbit hole of inauthenticity are you right?
- 30:59You can get so far down the rabbit hole of inauthenticity
- 31:02that you don't know the difference between the
- 31:06inauthentic self and the OR the false self and the true self.
- 31:11You've lost track of the true self or, or dismissing people
- 31:18tend to keep it secret. So they they have a hidden side
- 31:21to themselves that you might say that they don't reveal to
- 31:25anyone. And so it's, it's private.
- 31:29One of the things about that is it's, they're usually the
- 31:32formulations of those experiences are so young that
- 31:37they're never normalized in terms of what's reasonable in,
- 31:42in in the adult world. And so part of this process of
- 31:47authenticity is normalizing all of that stuff that you've kept
- 31:52hidden. And you know, it can be stunning
- 32:03how you grew up in a family system and were were treated
- 32:09terribly around things that are completely normal.
- 32:14I'll give you an example. When I was four, I was playing
- 32:20with my neighbor and we, we were walking down the street and we
- 32:24saw that this big kitchen knife had been left out on the, the
- 32:29front sidewalk of, on the front lawn of one of our neighbors
- 32:33houses. And so we got the brilliant idea
- 32:36that we would use it to cut a checkerboard into the lawn of
- 32:40the our, our neighbor. And so we, we very diligently
- 32:44cut a checkerboard out of the lawn.
- 32:47So grass, no grass, grass, no grass.
- 32:51And then we cut the the the divots that we took out and made
- 32:55checkers and then we played checkers and then got bored and
- 33:00went home. Anyway, when the neighbor got
- 33:02home from work, this old front lawless got up into a A to a
- 33:12checkerboard and he called our parents after he found out which
- 33:16were the kids who did it. So my friend's mother gave him a
- 33:20doughnut and said that it was not a good thing to do and
- 33:23please don't do it again. And I was severely beaten and
- 33:27sent to to bed with no dinner. Right.
- 33:31That's an example of how the different strategies of
- 33:36families. I can tell you that the doughnut
- 33:40was much more effective in convincing the kid right 'cause
- 33:47he got a sense of right and wrong out of it.
- 33:50I didn't get that out of that. Does that make sense?
- 33:55What happened to you and how did it change the way that you
- 34:02perceive things right when we move?
- 34:10So let's say you do recognize what's authentic and it arises
- 34:14in the mind. But because you have all of
- 34:19these associations from your early experiences of expressing
- 34:22yourself authentically, what happens next is there's an
- 34:25immediate spike of abandonment. And if it exceeds the window of
- 34:30tolerance, the mind immediately turns on the strategies that it
- 34:33uses to regulate the emotional experience that exceeds the
- 34:36window of tolerance. And the inauthentic thing you
- 34:39could say is dead arises in the mind and there you are,
- 34:46authentic, inauthentic. That's the choice.
- 34:50If you can mentalize it, right, as you were saying, if you can
- 34:54mentalize it, that's what happens.
- 34:57If you push into the authentic expression, which I am
- 35:00advocating that you do, the spike of abandonment terror is
- 35:04just going to go through the, the roof and all of that.
- 35:08And then if you can actually make the expression and hold the
- 35:11space, it will dissolve. And then this wave of terrible
- 35:15sadness of around the impacting of that inability to be
- 35:21authentic is going to sideswipe you.
- 35:24And it's going to be all of the times in the past that you you
- 35:28abandoned yourself and went with the inauthentic expression,
- 35:32which of course immediately relieved the abandonment here.
- 35:36That's the delusion, right? I make the inauthentic
- 35:39expression. It believes the abandonment
- 35:42here. So I think that I'm supporting
- 35:44the relationship, but it you're not actually supporting the
- 35:50relationship because you have the anxiety that if they
- 35:53actually discover what really is true, the the real real, as
- 35:58Lacan would say, what's really happening, right?
- 36:06They would leave you. So you never feel safe in the
- 36:08relationship. It's a great expense that we
- 36:11pretend to be someone else, right?
- 36:14We do hope, I think deeply, there's this deep hope that
- 36:19people will 3 see through the whole valence that we put up and
- 36:23see our true selves and want that that doesn't happen so
- 36:29much. You got a follow up question.
- 36:33I was going to say it's not always easy to know authentic
- 36:39versus inauthentic as a mindset, but it's easier to know how
- 36:44you're relating like that. You were saying am I acting to
- 36:48get something or you know, is an authentic way to get something
- 36:52or is an inauthentic way? Am I pretending so that I can
- 36:55get attention that's easier versus knowing if I'm simply
- 37:00being authentic versus inauthentic?
- 37:03Well, one way to tell, particularly in the beginning,
- 37:05is if you're authentic and it increases the abandonment tear,
- 37:08and then you're sideswiped by the terrible sadness, whereas if
- 37:11you're inauthentic, it relieves the abandonment tear.
- 37:15There's no terrible sadness that follows.
- 37:18But then, of course, what does follow is a sense of deprivation
- 37:22that you haven't actually asked for what you wanted and have
- 37:25haven't, in most cases gotten what you want.
- 37:32Now there is this mechanism around authenticity.
- 37:37This to be authentic does not mean that you're unguarded with
- 37:41everyone and that they have complete access to your psyche.
- 37:45That is not what authenticity means.
- 37:49What it means is that you are aware of the agreements of
- 37:53intimacy, that you have the consent, that you have both the
- 37:56consent to what you would like and feel safe somebody knowing
- 38:00about you and the consent that they've given to you to know
- 38:04that about you. And that you just limit the the
- 38:08way the the expression so that it falls within that rather than
- 38:11shifting into an inauthentic strategy where you're providing
- 38:16essentially false information that makes sense.
- 38:23Secure people think of themselves as capable of getting
- 38:26their needs met, and they think of the world as a place that
- 38:28will meet their needs. Insecure people, depending on
- 38:34which kind of insecurity. Dismissing people think that
- 38:39there's nothing that they can really do to get people to take
- 38:42care of them. It's always going to be some
- 38:45kind of transaction. And so they're they like to
- 38:50transact care. I do this for you, you do that
- 38:55for me. And it's one off agreements.
- 39:00They tend to find that that's a terribly sad and unbearable
- 39:06sadness that that's the nature of the world.
- 39:08And so they inflate themselves and one of the things that they
- 39:13need is this psychic energy to keep the inflation up.
- 39:18I'm the greatest, I'm the best. We have a whole culture around
- 39:23that. I think it's called a goat.
- 39:26I'm a goat, the greatest of all time.
- 39:36And at the core of that is this, this terrible feeling that
- 39:39there's nothing I can do to get people to take care of me.
- 39:41I have to transact the care. I have to pay for it, which
- 39:46means I have to gather the resources to be able to pay for
- 39:49it or I won't be taken care of. Preoccupied people pretend, and
- 39:56the way their consolation works is at the heart of it.
- 39:59They think that there's something wrong with them.
- 40:03That they're, they're incapable of providing for themselves.
- 40:07And So what they have to do is get someone else to provide for
- 40:10them so that they engage with other people and attempt to get
- 40:14other people to take care of them.
- 40:17And that's how they get through the trauma line falls down.
- 40:21And then when you get into disorganization, that the level
- 40:24of fearfulness is amplified. So secure people are afraid of
- 40:31being abandoned, insecure people are afraid of being humiliated,
- 40:39and disorganized people are afraid of being killed.
- 40:42It's levels or multiples of fearfulness that come from the
- 40:50experiences of that early relationship.
- 40:57In some sense, we, we understand the world from that infant's
- 41:01point of view. And then we just go out as if
- 41:03that's how it still is. What put it in fact it is.
- 41:06It's still like that, right? So the authenticity dilemma for
- 41:18disorganized people is the, the level of risk that they imagine
- 41:24they're undertaking. And so they actually have the
- 41:27most elaborate forms of inauthenticity.
- 41:31They these, I like to call it rococo or they these rococo
- 41:38methods of language in describing what their needs
- 41:43might be so that at any moment they can pivot out of an
- 41:47authentic expression so that they'll be safe.
- 41:55We did. So George, did you say the
- 41:58authentic self is more childlike?
- 42:01Well, the the the framework for that.
- 42:09We set up these original models in infancy and then we go out
- 42:14into the world using these models.
- 42:19I, I'm, I'm thinking of a, a quote by Pablo Picasso.
- 42:24Do you know the, the painter, the 20th century painter?
- 42:32He said it took me 4 years to learn to paint like Raphael and
- 42:38the rest of my life to learn to paint as a child, right.
- 42:43So that that authentic spontaneity without filtering it
- 42:49just being that freedom to just be without everything being
- 42:56calculated. So secure people, it's a
- 42:59balance, this dance spontaneity versus monitoring and this
- 43:04movement between them, you know, totally spontaneous at the same
- 43:09time monitoring enough that you can correct.
- 43:12And if you see that some expression, some gesture you've
- 43:15made hasn't landed in the way that you anticipated, you
- 43:19immediately can move in to understand why it didn't land
- 43:23and to correct it. But what you notice in
- 43:26dismissing people is that they over monitor and in over
- 43:31monitoring they they suppress spontaneity.
- 43:35Everything is rehearsed, everything is presented,
- 43:38everything is performed, everything is manicured.
- 43:41And if you get really skillful at that, it's a, it's a
- 43:44marvelous experience to behold, but it isn't free and it's not
- 43:50spontaneous. It's calculated and manicured.
- 43:54Preoccupied people, it's the opposite.
- 43:56They're, they're just completely spontaneous and they don't
- 43:59monitor anything. The manicured presentation was
- 44:06the thing that got dismissing people a response from their
- 44:09caregiver. And so they understand it as a
- 44:13skillful means of being in life. You're really, you get really
- 44:17good at it and then you can get what you want from people.
- 44:21That's the trade, that's the transaction.
- 44:24That's actually how relationships are meant to
- 44:27operate. Preoccupied people, it's too
- 44:30chaotic. There isn't a pattern that they
- 44:32can learn, so there's no value in monitoring.
- 44:36It's just iterating over and over again what you want in that
- 44:45framework for a secure mentalizing.
- 44:48You understand the meaning that you're giving to things.
- 44:51You understand why you're associating the meaning that
- 44:54you're associating because you can mentalize the definitions
- 44:58that you're using to define the present moment.
- 45:02You understand what about that you want to express.
- 45:05That's that managing the level of authentic intimacy, matching
- 45:11the consents that you have. You're not compelled to
- 45:15overshare or to just iterate. Then you express it to somebody
- 45:22and you make sure that you understand that they've
- 45:26understood you and you make sure that you understand their
- 45:28response, and then you modify your understanding of the
- 45:33relationship as it's unfolding. That would be an adequate amount
- 45:38of mentalizing. But if you look at, say, the way
- 45:41a preoccupied person mentalizes, they understand what they want
- 45:49and they make an expression, and then they monitor whether they
- 45:52get what they want or not. And if they don't get what they
- 45:56want, they simply make another expression to try and get what
- 45:59they want. They're not mentalizing how they
- 46:02would have to ask for the other person to give it to them.
- 46:06They're not mentalizing their response and they're not
- 46:10adapting their understanding of the relationship.
- 46:13They're simply, this is what I want, this is how I'm asking, do
- 46:17I get it? It's a whole different, much
- 46:21more primitive system of mentalizing.
- 46:24Is that making sense? I was under the impression this
- 46:34was only like in romantic personal relationships, but I
- 46:37just realized I I just actually know a Co worker who does this
- 46:41and I just just made immediate sense.
- 46:45Yeah. It's everywhere.
- 46:46It's all relationships, really. I thought that, you know, it's
- 46:50almost like I would say that oh, she's less intelligent.
- 46:54That was how my mind saw it. But I now I realize it's just, I
- 46:59mean, it just feels like it's almost like I can't blame her
- 47:02because it's almost like she's, I don't want to say dumb, but it
- 47:06just feels like she's just operating at a lower
- 47:08intelligence. It just feels like this.
- 47:10It's not a lower intelligence necessarily.
- 47:13Intelligence is a broad word. It's a lower mentalizing level,
- 47:19lower metacognition. But metacognition is totally
- 47:23trainable. In fact, the absence of
- 47:26mentalizing is the absence of training.
- 47:29It's not a suggestion necessarily of an inherent
- 47:35problem. In fact, you could be a great
- 47:37mentalizer and not intelligent in another way.
- 47:42I'm the proof. Thank you for volunteering.
- 47:58In order to be authentic, you have to risk abandonment.
- 48:02In order to be completely authentic, you have to risk
- 48:05abandonment. Now here's the here's another
- 48:11hook. If you're authentic from the
- 48:15beginning, the people that are interested in you and are drawn
- 48:18to you are interested in your, in the expression that you make.
- 48:22Everybody assumes that everybody else is being authentic, unless
- 48:25they're so lacking in skills that it's completely obvious
- 48:29that you're being manipulated, right?
- 48:34If you just express yourself the way that you are, and then what
- 48:42you'll notice is the people that are drawn to you are interested
- 48:45in that. You still have to be really
- 48:46picky about who you allow in, but at least they want you,
- 48:51right? You show them who you are and
- 48:53they want that, that that's an easier set up.
- 48:57If you're idealizing, you're presenting this very polished
- 49:01image of yourself, which is leaving out most of the negative
- 49:04stuff. And when people are drawn to
- 49:08you, that's what they want and they assume it's authentic.
- 49:12If you're preoccupied, you are just iterating whatever you
- 49:17think that they want. And if you land on what they
- 49:20want, they're drawn to you, right?
- 49:25The dilemma there is that over a period of time, you feel unseen.
- 49:31You feel that you have no effect on on on them and and it leads
- 49:37to a hollowness and a loneliness in relationship with someone
- 49:42else. And at a certain point, you want
- 49:46to fling off the cloak of inauthenticity and present
- 49:50yourself to them. But if who you said you were and
- 49:54who you actually are is too far apart, they may not want that.
- 49:56In fact, it's quite ordinary that they don't.
- 50:00And then what do you do? You're abandoned because you you
- 50:04weren't who you said you were, and because of your anxiety,
- 50:10your fearfulness of being abandoned, you couldn't tell
- 50:14them in the beginning who you were.
- 50:18So in order to move from that that conditioned inauthenticity
- 50:24into capacity for authentic expression, you're going to have
- 50:29to tolerate the abandonment terror and you're going to have
- 50:33to tolerate the terrible sadness.
- 50:35And in fact, it's a good signal that you're being authentic.
- 50:38In the beginning of this change into authenticity, if you say
- 50:43something and you immediately feel no abandonment anxiety at
- 50:47all, you know that you've just lied.
- 50:51And if you present yourself and you're stricken with abandonment
- 50:56here and crushed by the terrible sadness, you know that you've
- 51:00made an authentic expression. Makes sense.
- 51:05I'm, I'm Uberizing it slightly, but you get the gist that to be
- 51:12authentic means you're going to have to tolerate the
- 51:15abandonment. The other thing we probably
- 51:18don't do very well is ask for reassurance that we're not going
- 51:22to be abandoned, which secure people do.
- 51:26They don't have a issue with it so much that in the same way
- 51:30that insecure and disorganized people do.
- 51:36How do you ask? What?
- 51:39How do you ask? I just can't imagine guys asking
- 51:42other guys. Anything.
- 51:47What's the score? That I'm not going to.
- 51:52Get abandoned from from you. Oh, let's see, A common phrase
- 52:00would be we're good, right? Or we've bonded, right?
- 52:09Those kinds of things. Bring it in.
- 52:15What else? It is, I think, a terrible
- 52:35sadness the way that the way that homophobia has created
- 52:40these strictures in, in the heterosexual male community.
- 52:47But you know, it also has it's a effect in in the gay community
- 52:53as well. None of us have really escaped
- 52:57it. None of us had.
- 53:00You know, as I like to say, your gender training began the moment
- 53:04you popped out and they held you up and clocked whether you were
- 53:07male or female. It began right then, unless they
- 53:12did a scan and they identified you earlier and then it began
- 53:16while you were still in the womb.
- 53:21And you know the interesting thing, gender, I would say
- 53:25gender and orientation are, are different, but the, and so we're
- 53:29really mainly talking about gender here is the vocabulary of
- 53:35what what's male and the vocabulary of what's female.
- 53:45And how well you do in, in, in that, right.
- 53:48And when I was growing up, the the thing that made you the most
- 53:51masked and was that you were good at ball sports.
- 53:56I like to call them, you know, hand eye coordination and the
- 54:00ball coming in some game, right. And if you couldn't play sports,
- 54:08it didn't matter what your presentation were.
- 54:10You just weren't as masculine as the kids who could play sports.
- 54:15Now on the on the female side, if you were too good at sports,
- 54:19then you were too masculine, right?
- 54:22And in our culture, often men or what it is to be masculine is
- 54:29defined as not feminine. And that then requires the
- 54:36female side to reject anything that's masculine but competency
- 54:44and assertion and all of those things that are then dubbed as
- 54:49masculine and then are of course things that are not allowed for
- 54:54females. So, but it has nothing to do
- 54:58with the inherent qualities of either, right?
- 55:02And in fact, it's arbitrary even what what's designated as a male
- 55:10skill and a female skill. I grew up in an era of woodshop
- 55:17and home EC, and you could not take home action.
- 55:24You weren't female. You could not take woodshop if
- 55:27you were not male. That was how I mean everywhere
- 55:31along the way. When actually what would be
- 55:34important is everybody takes home EC because everybody's
- 55:39going to have to run a household in some way.
- 55:44Everybody takes basic finances. All of these things would be
- 55:48better in that way. Then you grow up, of course, and
- 55:53you are rewarded or penalized based on your capacity to meet
- 56:01these. Also not consistent, right?
- 56:05What was in elementary school, the demands were not the same in
- 56:10middle school. It's certainly not the same in
- 56:13high school and then later, right?
- 56:24So in that male sign, that masculine sign, not needing
- 56:33emotional help is often one of the things that is described as
- 56:39masculine. But this is simply inhuman,
- 56:45right? It's not how it is.
- 56:49One of the main things about Buddhism, of course, is how is
- 56:52it actually what's actually happening here?
- 56:57And that it's, it's, you know, terrible, a terrible burden.
- 57:09Now what happens? You can comfortably force
- 57:18yourself into the gender box that's prescribed for you and
- 57:21you can sit there and it's not that terrible for you.
- 57:25So you go along with it. And for those of us that don't
- 57:30fit so well into that box, it's terrible.
- 57:32We can't sit in there and so we do something else.
- 57:35But the penalties for that are are pretty enormous still, even
- 57:41at the the basic level of being safe, walking down the street is
- 57:44a problem, right? So we should, we should not
- 57:54allow that to be true. Now I remember my God, kids, one
- 58:00day they burst out of the house. They were both wearing witch
- 58:04hats. It's clearly feminine female
- 58:08orientation. They were both wearing football
- 58:12jerseys. One's one's a little boy, one's
- 58:14a little girl, clearly male. They were both wearing tutus,
- 58:22clearly female. But Can you imagine 2 adorable
- 58:25children, witch hats, football jerseys, tutus, and then the
- 58:33environment they grew up in. That was fine.
- 58:37It was everyone thought it was darling.
- 58:39That was the reaction that they got.
- 58:44I I imagine that that would could not happen in in the
- 58:48household I grew up in just could not.
- 58:53So some progress, but we need more.
- 59:00All right, We've talked way too long and I could blame myself
- 59:06for that. I won't.
- 59:11But why don't we do a little bit of loving kindness practice?
- 59:15What do you say? All right, let's go ahead and
- 59:17settle in. OK, Let go of the meditation.
- 59:22Comments or questions on that? Good.
- 59:34So let's see here tomorrow I think is Kaleidoscope, which is
- 59:43our monthly meeting of the Sangha, which is at 11 Pacific
- 59:49Time. On Saturday is the third day of
- 59:54the addiction Level 1. We're going to talk about the
- 59:59third module and the fourth module.
- 1:00:04On the 7th is a meditation and attachment level 1 starting.
- 1:00:11We're in the beginning of the new level 2, which is on at
- 1:00:17meeting at 10:30 to 12:30 on Fridays.
- 1:00:22If you want to join it, it will close after the 6th.
- 1:00:27What else? I'm speaking in person if you're
- 1:00:32LA at Open Door Dharma on Sunday the 1st and that's at noon to
- 1:00:371:30 in Silver Lake. And I think that's about it.
- 1:00:48That's coming up. Oh, on the 28th of March, we're
- 1:00:55going to do an exploration day long week.
- 1:00:58I like to do them, I like to call it intermediate
- 1:01:02exploration. And then we'll at some point do
- 1:01:05an advanced. So what we're looking at there,
- 1:01:08it's really a mentalizing strategies.
- 1:01:11We we talk a lot about basic mentalizing strategies or
- 1:01:15metacognition and the there there's a set that Dan Brown
- 1:01:21developed with the integral guy. Come on mind spit it out.
- 1:01:33Anyway, it's late. Let's see Ken Wilber yes, thank
- 1:01:43you and angler. Anyway, we'll cover the middle
- 1:01:51set in the workshop on the 28th that takes us into May.
- 1:02:06We're going to do our workshop in May, actually on the well,
- 1:02:09actually on April, the 1st of April.
- 1:02:15Anyway, it it'll be up on the website soon, if it's not
- 1:02:18already. Take a look at it.
- 1:02:19If something sounds like you want to jump on, please do.
- 1:02:23It'd be good to see you and to practice with you and good to
- 1:02:26see you here tonight. Appreciate it.
- 1:02:30Ioffer the teaching freely and I do hope if you can, you'll make
- 1:02:35a donation. There's a link on the website to
- 1:02:37do it. Any amount it's helpful, help
- 1:02:38supports me and also the work that Medigroup is doing and I
- 1:02:43hope to see you soon somewhere along the path.
- 1:02:47Bye now.