Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Turn a Rival Into an Ally at Work
Transcript
- Lucas: You know that colleague who seems to be competing with you for every promotion, every high-visibility project, every chance to speak in the all-hands meeting? Luna: Oh, I have a face in mind. And I bet most listeners do too. Lucas: Right. Conventional advice says 'play nice' or 'ignore the competition.' But there's a third option that's way more powerful: turn that rival into an ally. Luna: That sounds easier said than done. How do you even start? Lucas: There's a playbook for it, and I want to ground this in a real case. At Spotify a couple of years ago, two senior product managers — let's call them Priya and Marco — were constantly stepping on each other's toes. Luna: I've heard of that dynamic — each trying to own the Spotify Music discovery roadmap. Lucas: Exactly. They were both strong, ambitious, and their portfolios overlapped. Priya led the 'Discover Weekly' algorithm improvements; Marco owned the 'Release Radar' personalization. Instead of collaborating, they'd hoard data, schedule conflicting meetings, and subtly undermine each other in cross-functional reviews. Luna: So a textbook rivalry. What changed? Lucas: A director pulled them aside and essentially forced them to co-present a consolidated vision for music personalization. That external pressure created a shared problem: if they looked disorganized, both their careers would suffer. So they started talking — really talking — about what each needed. Luna: And that's the first move? Exposing the common threat? Lucas: That's step one: surface a shared incentive. It doesn't have to be a director's mandate — could be a looming competitor, a budget cut, or a stakeholder who's losing patience. You find a reason why you both lose if the rivalry continues. Luna: What's step two? Lucas: Reframe the relationship from zero-sum to positive-sum. Priya and Marco realized that Discover Weekly and Release Radar actually served different user moments — discovery versus habit — and that combining their roadmaps could create a seamless experience that neither could build alone. Luna: So they identified complementary strengths instead of overlapping ones. Lucas: Right. Priya was better at deep-dive user research; Marco excelled at A/B testing at scale. They agreed to let each other lead in their zone of genius, and publicly credited each other. That built trust fast. Luna: I imagine the third step is actually delivering a win together. Lucas: Step three: co-create a visible win. They launched a combined feature called 'Your Weekly Mix' that blended both algorithms. It became Spotify's most engaged playlist within two months. Both got promoted the next cycle. And their bonus was tied to cross-team collaboration metrics — so the incentive structure reinforced the behavior. Luna: That's a great story. But what if you don't have a director forcing a meeting? How do you initiate the conversation with a rival without it feeling awkward or manipulative? Lucas: You lead with vulnerability. Walk over and say something like, 'Hey, I've noticed we keep tripping over each other, and I think it's hurting both of us. Could we spend twenty minutes figuring out a better way to work together?' The key is framing it as a joint problem, not an accusation. Luna: And if they say no? Or they're not interested? Lucas: Then you know where you stand. Not every rivalry is salvageable. If the other person is genuinely toxic — stealing credit, sabotaging your work, lying — then the alliance playbook doesn't apply. You need to build a coalition with others or escalate to management. Luna: So how do you tell the difference between a healthy rival and a toxic one? Lucas: Healthy rivals compete over ideas and outcomes, but they're still professional. They show up on time, they don't lie, they respect boundaries. Toxic rivals make it personal — they attack your character, not your work. If you offer an olive branch and they weaponize it, that's your answer. Luna: That's a hard lesson. But let's go back to the positive case. After Priya and Marco aligned, did they ever fall back into old habits? Lucas: They did, briefly. When a VP role opened up, both were candidates. Old instincts flared. But because they'd built a track record of success together, they were able to have an honest conversation — 'Look, whoever gets this, the other won't leave. Let's make sure the winner supports the other's next move.' That's the depth of the alliance. Luna: So the trust survived a direct competition. That's impressive. Lucas: It's because they'd reframed their identity from 'competitors' to 'partners in a larger mission.' That's the real psychological shift. And it's repeatable — I've seen it work in finance, tech, even law firms. Luna: I'm thinking about a listener who might be in a rivalry right now. What's one concrete move they can make this week? Lucas: Find one small piece of information that would genuinely help your rival succeed — a data point, a meeting invite, a heads-up about a policy change — and share it without expecting anything in return. Do it in a way that's visible but not performative. That's the opening move. Luna: I like that. It's generous but strategic. It signals that you're not threatened by their success. Lucas: Exactly. And if they reciprocate, you've got the start of a relationship. If they don't, you've lost nothing but gained information about their character. Luna: Before we wrap, I want to touch on something you mentioned earlier — the vulnerability piece. That feels risky. What if the rival interprets your openness as weakness? Lucas: It can happen, but in my experience, vulnerability is actually the highest-leverage tool in office politics when used correctly. You're not confessing a weakness; you're naming a shared problem. That requires confidence, not weakness. And it disarms people because they expect you to compete, not cooperate. Luna: So it's a power move disguised as a peace offering. Lucas: Exactly. And look, this is a topic where we've seen a lot of listeners ask for deeper guidance. It's one of those career skills that isn't taught in any MBA program. Luna: That's true. And it reminds me — if we've helped you think through a tricky workplace relationship or a career decision, we want you to know that this show stays ad-free and independent because of a small group of listeners who chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's not a big ask — just a way to keep the conversations honest and practical without any sponsor influence. Lucas: Yeah, and we're grateful for that support — it literally makes episodes like this possible. And speaking of practical, let's get back to one more tactic that pairs well with the alliance playbook. Luna: What's that? Lucas: The 'shadow ally' move. You don't always need a formal alliance. Sometimes you can quietly support a rival's project behind the scenes — offering a resource or a connection — without them ever knowing it was you. Later, when they succeed, you've got a silent debt you can call in. Luna: That's almost cloak and dagger. But I can see how it builds influence without triggering their defenses. Lucas: Right. It's the long game. Most people want quick resolution to rivalry, but the best outcomes take months. Priya and Marco's alliance took about six months to fully solidify. But the payoff was enormous — they both ended up in senior director roles. Luna: Alright, so recap: expose a shared threat, reframe as complementary, co-create a win, and sometimes play the long game with a shadow ally. Lucas: That's the framework. And if you're in a rivalry right now, pick one of those steps and try it this week. You might be surprised how often the other person is just waiting for an invitation to collaborate. Luna: I'm going to try the information-sharing move myself. I have someone in mind. Lucas: Let us know how it goes. We'd love to hear from listeners who try it — send us a note. Until next time.