Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 242:8-14. Honoring Rabbis: Simple Halacha Vs. Involved Psak, From Books, Stopping Transgressors, Ready to Pasken
Transcript
- 0:00Say that good morning, we are filling in for the Asus.
- 0:07We are in the Reichman bays, some Reichman bays, SIF, SIF,
- 0:12khas fine lol. MI Gray high raw LO, it's not
- 0:24called high raw that he won't be able to do it.
- 0:27You know, from the front, you know, in the area of his of his
- 0:30of his rabbi, except for something that there's kiddish
- 0:35for the Shiloh. It's some there's some Shiloh.
- 0:41That's that's something which is the khodish of a hiroya dua
- 0:44sheep shooter. The call You're going nice in
- 0:48town of gun, something which is posher to everyone like nice in
- 0:52town of gun. The guy comes with the Shiloh,
- 0:54since I don't know, you know, the I I cook, I cook, I cook
- 0:58milk in the in the inflation pot and you know, and the the motor
- 1:03officer and the the guy, the robots.
- 1:05Well, you know the talent ass well, you know, when did you
- 1:09last use it? I used it two months ago.
- 1:11No, OK, they seen town have gone.
- 1:13That's how called the Hiro. Even if this guy doesn't know
- 1:15the halakha, but it's not a it's not nature of a Hiro.
- 1:20That would be a problem. Hiro would be something, you
- 1:22know, I'd say on a you know, Traifa that like how it used to
- 1:27be, you have to go to the rub of the Shiloh Traif or not or or
- 1:31Anita Shiloh or let's say it's something which is, you know,
- 1:35something which is not well known.
- 1:37Like I'd say it's a Shiloh about the you know, something with
- 1:40computers. I don't know, something which is
- 1:42not something which is you do affairs, you know, something
- 1:46like that. That would be the that would be
- 1:50the oh, Lovato, it's a machine or like, you know, if he's
- 1:55nothing, it's a machine or anything like that.
- 1:57He'll today the motor. That's that's not that's motor
- 2:00from the you know, that's motor for the for the Talmud to the
- 2:04Paskin test the HP Shikasa Shikala Costa Vaswari and Pisgay
- 2:11are going in Yahoo lawyers in a rabbit.
- 2:13If some say that anything which is written down from Pisgay
- 2:17going in now we're talking about, you know, this mana, it's
- 2:21a Pisgary shiny or you know, with a Kule that's he's allowed
- 2:30to he's allowed to, you know, say this thing, you know, but
- 2:34he'd pass. The Brewer says this.
- 2:36I don't know whatever it is roughly, you're a Dover me Libo.
- 2:40He can't if there's a complex Shiloh and I shouldn't something
- 2:44which is throwing me out. So he just, he should, he should
- 2:50go consult with his Rob with, with his Rebbe or the rub of
- 2:55the, if there's a rub of the city or let's say you know,
- 2:57he's, you know, he's in the shul and is the rabbi of the shul and
- 3:04you know, things like that, which you know, you know that,
- 3:09you know, someone is the bigger tomahawk and things like that.
- 3:11He shouldn't be passed. He shouldn't pass again
- 3:15according to his understanding. You're the HB should also the
- 3:22Hoffa, Mahathir, Dobber, Hatamua, Shanira, la Ravi and
- 3:26Shahidir as her author. It shouldn't.
- 3:29He shouldn't matter something which is seems like telling
- 3:35Tamua right? Everyone has to be careful.
- 3:38Not that you shouldn't. It's a stop.
- 3:40Nothing to do with pomade or Rao.
- 3:42This is a separate thing that this is based on the Gemara.
- 3:46Basically Kumar the in in one of the one of the Kumaras is the
- 3:49Bakarius says that Rav was an expert in he spent like 9 months
- 3:53learning moving from Bakarius. He's like spent nine months
- 3:56living in a as a shepherd or something to learn it.
- 4:00So and Ravi wouldn't let him pass him because he was such a
- 4:04Bucky in in moving. So even though something which
- 4:07everyone would say, Oh yeah, that's that's mumma over.
- 4:10That's, that's, that's a mum kavua.
- 4:11Sorry, it's a mumma over. That's not, that's not going to
- 4:15mat there. He was in on to mum Kavua
- 4:16because he knew the difference. And it's going to be Tamua to
- 4:19everyone. And the problem is, is that they
- 4:21make him come to go ahead and say, Oh, you see that?
- 4:24I can eat it before with the mum over.
- 4:27You see, Rob Baskin, The problem is, is that they're going to
- 4:29come to be mad here more than more than what's more than what?
- 4:35He's being mad. He's being mad here, Shaft says
- 4:39if he explains if he explains his reasoning, So that's going
- 4:43to be yeah, that that would be it.
- 4:47That would be OK. Or if he shows later, hey, look,
- 4:50see this, this is the difference.
- 4:52He explains what he's doing or explains to Tom Iser the time I
- 4:55had theirs and that that would be that would be fine.
- 4:58Then I I saw. But of course, it depends if the
- 5:03person who asked the Shiloh would understand what he's
- 5:06talking about. The guy with no clue, you know,
- 5:08start talking about, yeah, the, you know, you know, a woman
- 5:13calls and she, you know, you start giving you a host, a
- 5:16culture and it's not and you know, it's going to go over her
- 5:19head or anyone. So then that's that that
- 5:24doesn't, you know, that's not going to help.
- 5:25So first it has to be Nizar not to go ahead and just, you know,
- 5:29go, you know, to match, match or something, unless it's something
- 5:32I saw. If it's something which is let's
- 5:35say everyone started being knowing a certain way and he
- 5:38said no, no, no, no, no, that's insert.
- 5:41He said nobody. Why is it, officer, that they
- 5:43you know, this is not pusher, this is motor or whatever.
- 5:46I wish did that you know something, you know, something
- 5:48like that. That wouldn't be a a problem.
- 5:50The problem is something that people know and he might come,
- 5:52they might come to go ahead and to and and and and get confused
- 5:57and things like that. I mean there's no problem to be
- 6:01a Matthew. There's no problem for a person
- 6:03to be a Mako and the Matthew things it shouldn't be, you
- 6:08know, neural around being like, you know something, which is
- 6:11Finnish, you know, the olive la Fuchimii Surah.
- 6:14If someone's doing an Avera and he and the guy shall hey, don't
- 6:18do that right. Is that called?
- 6:21Is that called the hoirah would be also the thing Rabbi who
- 6:24should be sewer could go on Shabba ultimate show you dash
- 6:28you also. Let's say that phone's being
- 6:29over in a Vera again, he doesn't know such a thing as officer.
- 6:32Oh, if they reach Oh, sorry, or he knows, then he's doing it
- 6:35anyway. Mutter Allahafrisher.
- 6:38It's mutter to the Mafra Shamalomerlowshu also, which
- 6:43name Rabbi right. If he if it's stop him from
- 6:45doing it in a Vera, he's allowed to shout out.
- 6:47Hey, that's also and that's not called a hurry up.
- 6:51What's the name? Rabbi should have a whole muck
- 6:53of your Shiloh Hashem ain't holding cover the round.
- 6:56If there's going to be a Shiloh Hashem, then there's no hulking
- 6:59cover the round. There's no you know, don't don't
- 7:01defer you just you know you just do that like you.
- 7:04I can see like the pinhole. Sorry, he went to brochure of a
- 7:08new and and there he deferred to him.
- 7:10He's like canine pokeman bowl like just do.
- 7:13There's no asking child. Just do like you know, you got
- 7:16to stop what's going on. Just do you know so and so
- 7:21there's no pillow shell. The shy lay is if it's something
- 7:24you know, let's say it's not a pushing me.
- 7:26So let's say like you know, for example, in the shul, you know
- 7:30guy, the guy's Laney and he says the wrong Elaine's wrong.
- 7:34Are you allowed to be the person allowed to be to shout out?
- 7:37You know, the rob doesn't shout out.
- 7:39You know you know The thing is OK, besides the fact you revised
- 7:43the guy or not and the question is the person know if it's
- 7:47mocking or not. Yeah, of course, as I'm saying
- 7:51it does. It could be done.
- 7:53It could be done so posh it to make if the you know if the you
- 7:57know if the if the you know if the revolution's there and he
- 8:00doesn't catch it. I mean the mids of the middings
- 8:02event, if you want. What I'm pointing out is only a
- 8:05Fushimi Surah is is is trying trying shooting Michael kill a
- 8:09sham, but but you know other things.
- 8:12It's the things to be weighed your days in the base.
- 8:16So he show Tom, let's say you know, he's a Talmud and whatever
- 8:22and his wife passed him a Shiloh.
- 8:26Then you know how he wrote and he's Roy for a while, right?
- 8:29Michelle Lullo Lo, you're the other hand, Makkam Rabba.
- 8:32He should not be more. He should not be more than
- 8:35Makkam Rabba. Now this is a little bit Tabua
- 8:37because you know, the wife comes to him.
- 8:40You know, you know that. Can you?
- 8:43I, I, I dropped the milk spoon in the flash of pot.
- 8:46But what should you do? What should I do?
- 8:51Fine. Yeah.
- 8:51OK. Well, it needs to hurry up.
- 8:53Whatever. Let's say the whole complicated
- 8:54thing or whatever the case may be.
- 8:57Right. It's simple.
- 8:57Shiloh. He has to go call it.
- 8:59Wait. Well, I have to wait till the
- 9:00morning. Let's call the road.
- 9:03I can't. I can't be that.
- 9:04I mean, since the war. The question is like, I seem
- 9:07like our show. How?
- 9:08Like the drunk shooting, that basic Shiloh, then the hunger,
- 9:12the hunger, the home. And then he's very low.
- 9:14He can pass it for his family. The issue, the issue here is if
- 9:18he's making a like a complicated, you know, and and
- 9:25you know, and and it's something which is like the case they
- 9:27bring is, for example, like my street tonight.
- 9:30The case is cool and whatever they have to show the row of the
- 9:32street tonight, because that's that is cool.
- 9:36You know, so so something which he has to be more cover that
- 9:40like you shouldn't be more, you know, something like that, which
- 9:43is not like. So also something which is not,
- 9:44you know, that's not, you know, need to answer right now and
- 9:49he's worried to answer it. You know, he doesn't have to go
- 9:53wait to wait to, you know, speak to the rub in the morning.
- 9:56He could, you know, he can, he can't answer.
- 9:58It's just something which is, which is a much more complicated
- 10:01thing, which doesn't, you know, it's not in the whole, it's not
- 10:02something you know, that needs to be answered right now, even
- 10:07though it's they say he should wait and speak to his Rav.
- 10:11You know, the whole Nisha Mace Rabbi, local Misha Mace Rabbi
- 10:18multilay Chevy Lajores. Not everyone who's a pomade.
- 10:23If the if the if the if the Rav dies, they could just, you know,
- 10:27take over Ellie Wiki Hagil hai Rao whatever has to be he's
- 10:32Mukubil. It's Mukubil called that he is
- 10:35worried to be the I'd say the raw worried to, you know, to be
- 10:38the worried to be the raw. He doesn't just automatically
- 10:41get the get the position. You Gimmel Talvicha Hagil hai
- 10:47Rao Moira Hareza Shaita Russia Vegas Rua the all of Neymar
- 10:55Hirabi Khalol and Ipila someone who's he's not he Gila Iran.
- 11:00He starts being mad here, you know, being married or whatever.
- 11:05He's it's very strong language from mission.
- 11:10Other stories, you know, of, you know, people who work with Iran,
- 11:14they they you know, and they get Shilohs of, you know, hospital
- 11:19Shilohs. They get Shilohs, of course,
- 11:22nefesh and not and different. I don't live in things like
- 11:26these people. If they don't if they don't
- 11:28really know like you know it can because of Corbin, you know you
- 11:36know and of course I like I remember hearing you know, the
- 11:40you know they have the yeah, yeah, yeah, you have.
- 11:42We'll see you speak on a minute. We have the smeet hose with the
- 11:45you know, it's only gets smeet hose with the with the telephone
- 11:48of the well there like you know, the the smeet hose with the
- 11:53chapters number on the wall. You know that's not the great.
- 11:57The point is is that simple things he can mean more, but it
- 11:59starts then, you know, pass getting complicated child as he
- 12:03should. You know that's you know, you
- 12:04should be careful. I'll go up with Tamili Maktani
- 12:07Makwiksim. The the you know, the young guys
- 12:13who you know, always want to you know, you know, get covered and
- 12:17whatever these guy little thing on my arms Barbie Mahalikis,
- 12:21Mahreva Mahreva ruin everything. These are called and the every
- 12:33person should be careful not to give a hurrah and he's shustly
- 12:38doesn't mean shaker. Shaker is partial Shustly means
- 12:41that he drank he drank a reviews of ya and there are shakers that
- 12:46he like took a took a reviews of wine and drink it down.
- 12:51He shouldn't pass in until he's sure that doesn't sound effect.
- 12:55He did. No, it was either.
- 12:56He's a bigger guy review. It's not going to he's not going
- 12:58to do much, but he takes, you know, Shard volume, the Shakur
- 13:03him, you know, he goes to show him Zafar has a few too many
- 13:08shots. Whatever he shouldn't pass him a
- 13:10feel a little bit of a passion, even if it's the repulsion, like
- 13:13we said before, you know, even though she would have a borrow
- 13:16of a play scheme, The Who listen something which is like not much
- 13:22before in the place game. It's dry like, you know, this is
- 13:25what said this is not this is I don't know, whatever it is, it's
- 13:30something which is more a little more complicated.
- 13:32He shouldn't, you know, he shouldn't pass Canon and he has
- 13:37to wait until he feels that his that he that that the that the
- 13:42that the effects of the alcohol went away.
- 13:44The shaft brings the bringing some sheets as a whole that if
- 13:49it's poor him, he shouldn't be more poor him or other times he
- 13:53shouldn't be more the whole day. He shouldn't because maybe he'll
- 13:56come to drink. Now I see a lot of more in a
- 13:58row. Don't drink.
- 13:59I'm poor him, because a lot of people need to come and shy a
- 14:01lot of things, whatever, but the shack is not here.
- 14:05You know, obviously depend the person knows what he's doing.
- 14:07He doesn't drink. He doesn't have to be mapped,
- 14:09but the point is that maybe he'll come to drink.
- 14:11You know, nowadays either he'll drink where he won't.
- 14:13You know, it's not the you know, it's it's a little bit different
- 14:16than in the eye, and it was also much more common to drink to
- 14:18drink. So it's different.
- 14:21It is mutter the the the album, right.
- 14:26So the shaker is it is mutter for a shaker to give sheer.
- 14:30So you know, go to for Reagan, the sheer whatever, as long as
- 14:35he doesn't pass him for it's passing, you know he can and
- 14:39that that would be that would be okay.
- 14:42Are you darling call Hoffman Shahira, the anal Moira Sunny
- 14:48any who's McGill Torreira and he's not Myra Hariza Moneta
- 14:53Torreira. And now he said he stopped, he's
- 14:57stopping the Toyota and he's but all of them are assuming that
- 15:03the Islamic people, you know, it's a very strong trainers.
- 15:06On the other hand. Now what does this mean?
- 15:09Because I mean, a guy might be really raw, but you know, it's
- 15:12not always a stellar. It's not always a position for
- 15:14him to become a raw. You know, I just open a base or
- 15:19yeah, I'm passing it. Who's going to call?
- 15:21Like, you know, what does that mean nowadays?
- 15:23And I think it could be a means that the that they offered him a
- 15:26position. He's roaring for a position.
- 15:28I said, no, I want to keep on. I want to keep on learning, just
- 15:30learning quietly in the basement.
- 15:32That's whatever. Then that could be what we're
- 15:36talking about. He's worried and they offered
- 15:38him and whatever. So then that could be, you know,
- 15:40then, then, then, then he has to go ahead and and take the, you
- 15:44know, take the position a Gov Inian Inian has.
- 15:52Inian has mikos Shinagu bizman exactly she is the cola arm.
- 15:59She Gila Hira Smitha nowadays is in order that people should know
- 16:06that he's the Gila Hira. Now there was a whole the whole
- 16:09controversy in the in spas, the Shasta Vesuv that the Maribe Rav
- 16:17reinstituted Smitha Smitha, meaning Smitha like time of the
- 16:22of the Sanhedrin that they can they, they can pass in not so
- 16:28he's in pass in and and and different things.
- 16:32He he he had a Duke in the Rambam, which was Mashma that if
- 16:36all the all the hakami were to sell were masking to reinstate
- 16:41that I would work. And he was so much the the the
- 16:48alphabets. I don't remember the Maro Bach
- 16:56was the revolution and he wrote a very he was very curious
- 16:59against it, very curious Chuva against it and says Chad was
- 17:02wrong and whatever and he wrote at the end of the Chuva and
- 17:05according to you, you said of all the revolver to throw our
- 17:08mask is on the revolution. I'm not masking.
- 17:10So that ended that so upon him that the that the you see what
- 17:15the Ramas said. So the Mahavir he doesn't talk
- 17:19about the IT could be he's not a real sneaker Aquapon in the
- 17:23Ramon talks about sneaker in Europe sneaker nowadays is just
- 17:26to go ahead and and say he's a Gila Iran Mashamura who wishes
- 17:30Rabbi and that was he divorced wishes to Rabbi his son Koi.
- 17:35He takes takes a prize for him Rabbi if the if the rob if the
- 17:43rob of the stomach is is is was nifter in circles because he's
- 17:48he's worried worried Mukumarabo, he's worried.
- 17:51They say that I think Ron and Lakewood said that if you learn
- 17:54for a certain number of years, you don't need to become a
- 17:56rabbi. I mean, I don't know if you talk
- 17:57about sock. I don't know, but that's what
- 17:59you can call yourself a rabbi this week of that you need to
- 18:02you know, as a you put, you know, a degree.
- 18:05So whatever, you know, you can call yourself a rabbi after a
- 18:09certain point. Now this week also talking about
- 18:11here, the specific growth was giving him smika.
- 18:15You know, you're you're whatever it is not talking about.
- 18:17Let's say he goes to the revenue, the remnants not going
- 18:19to take and it takes a test to the revenue.
- 18:21They're not going to go ahead and take, you know, a prize for
- 18:25this guy like he used to, you know, unless he becomes rubber,
- 18:27you know, things like that. Like, you know, you're not going
- 18:30to take a cry just because he took the test.
- 18:31But you know, certain SWIFA tests it used to be as only
- 18:34Goldberg. That's all used to give the
- 18:36speaker test didn't anyway, unless someone came to him.
- 18:40You sure someone came to him and said I want to pass him.
- 18:42Then he mavish like grilled it like they just wanted to Smith.
- 18:47It wasn't you know, it wasn't it was different Asia and Moreno
- 18:55and someone who doesn't have a title title of of Moreno.
- 18:58Another thing Giti Mekhalitsais aim of ice of Klum.
- 19:01There are those who say that if he didn't get a sneak or for
- 19:04Giti Mekhalitsais, they don't they puzzle every single get
- 19:08that he wrote the Ishlakush, the Giti Mekhalitsa shenasan in the
- 19:13Shia duo, the culture move called the Rabin who that you
- 19:19have to be cautious for any get and get another get unless you
- 19:25know that he was he was really a Montreal ravage didn't have a
- 19:29didn't have a smearish whole came when we kill him.
- 19:31Some say our Mako the Malcolm Eagle when also on getting the
- 19:36Khalid they can't easily get and you know get another gather
- 19:40through another Khalid then Malcolm eagle and their Mako of
- 19:44a low bit there after giving hugs that the minute you sell
- 19:50Toyota is not to was is was to get Smeeta for this and it's a
- 19:55very and then it's very important.
- 19:57Can they really but only release your motor losses Moreno the
- 20:01actually Saudi get in. You're allowed to give the title
- 20:03of Moreno to someone who's been Saudi get in.
- 20:05I hope he should be Dean Smeeta. I should not be showing
- 20:09Lohavidina hockey, even though Smeeta used to be able to do
- 20:13with get that to do with, you know.
- 20:16You know, general, he's so many he's very low.
- 20:19You can give Smeek on the specific topic.
- 20:21I mean go Malcolm Ashram in all the tears for shoes, but I'm a
- 20:26bashari that he gets you can personally get Smeeka for
- 20:30Paschinane. I don't know soccer showers.
- 20:33I don't know whatever you can get Smeeka and every you know,
- 20:36and one fugitive one this, you know, whatever you can get the
- 20:41you can get Smeeka. It's very interesting.
- 20:43Finish off with it and we'll see interesting Pisgah Chuva brings
- 20:48in Mark Shaw that anyone who you know his in his time or just
- 20:55murder her. A lot of the show honor just
- 20:57straight from show honor he says and they don't know the
- 21:01reasoning behind it. They just they read the show
- 21:03honor and they go ahead and you know or the kids are sorry.
- 21:08That's another more, you know, be more apt nowadays.
- 21:11Person opens the Pisgah Chuvas and and he just starts being
- 21:14murdered. I don't mean just reading and
- 21:16say, OK, this Katuma says this start being Madonna Milsul, the
- 21:20Milsa and and say, well, he's been you know, he says this and
- 21:24he says this and whatever, and you know that.
- 21:27Then he said that's the he said that's not and and they weren't
- 21:31mashamish told me if it's calling me and told us Nofa or
- 21:33Rosa and you can't. And then Mabli and the part of
- 21:36Mabli can't. They can't.
- 21:38No, you can't. It can't be somewhat on these
- 21:42people. It has to be asked to be.
- 21:43They know Tom and Inion Piska Chu was his holic and he said
- 21:46that nowaday, nowadays, his time that we have the no say Kaley
- 21:50and they give the time a inion so you can pass them.
- 21:52So open the show and if you know if you go know the no say Kaley,
- 21:56that'll be fine. So like, for instance, someone
- 21:58who just listens to this year, the power just he would not be
- 22:00able to pass the shiles for everyone.
- 22:03He knows it's a Shiloh, but either unless you learn the
- 22:05whole doubt with you know, proper, you know properly.
- 22:09Shohan says, though a person doesn't have any Shibush and
- 22:12yes, and no, he doesn't. He doesn't know so years he
- 22:14doesn't know. I mean he is he doesn't have the
- 22:17EU doesn't know how to learn the EU and this is they're called
- 22:21the literature. Mahalo, so that that you know a
- 22:25person doesn't know. You see, whatever that if they
- 22:29don't know how to learn, learn even about the comma, learn even
- 22:35whatever, then they're not to also pass in.
- 22:42They have to have a certain amount of to pass in things
- 22:47other than Mahal came when it comes to you know, when I say
- 22:50passing for sure, I understand like Roger safe is very much
- 22:53into passing like Maran only only basis.
- 22:57But again, it's it's they also hold they also that learning the
- 23:01base, the Asif as well and passing Maran.
- 23:04He just like whatever he knew the base and passing and
- 23:09whatever there's the difference variety.
- 23:11Mahal the the did not only Maran and I'm saying I have a show
- 23:16different place before there's something different.
- 23:19You know, Mahalkim had a had a pass him, but it's not the
- 23:22Nahkopan him. It's not the you know the the
- 23:26you know, it's not just the opening kits.
- 23:28It's time and you know think you know halacha.
- 23:31You have to, you know, you have to really, you know, a person
- 23:35has to, have to, to be a place, you know, whatever you know, to
- 23:40look up and say, OK, just got you and said OK, fine.
- 23:44But anything beyond that is not the OK.