Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Rex Heuermann Challenges The Buccal Swab Request
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome back to the program. When
- 0:05Rex Youwerman was arrested, the authorities were relying on a
- 0:09discarded pizza box that contained a pizza crust that had
- 0:14rex Ewerman's DNA on it. But now they want to
- 0:18get a more stable sample of DNA from Rex Youwerman,
- 0:23and to do that they were hoping to get a
- 0:26bugle swab. Now, a bugle swab is a cheek swab.
- 0:30And for those of you who have been following along
- 0:32up in Idaho, you know that when Brian Kohberger was
- 0:35arrested in Pennsylvania, that was all part of the warrant.
- 0:40They hit his ass with the bugle swab right there
- 0:43on the spot when they arrested him. In New York, however,
- 0:46the process is a little bit different, and every single
- 0:50state you go to, you're going to find the process,
- 0:53the judicial process a little bit different. Now, the basic
- 0:57overall tenants that's always going to apply, but the way
- 1:01they go about things in each state each district is
- 1:04certainly up to the statutes of that state. So what
- 1:08is true in Idaho might not be true in a
- 1:11place like New York. So when you're talking about somebody
- 1:15like Rex Ewerman and the government trying to get that
- 1:18bugle swab. They have a few more hoops that they
- 1:21have to jump through to do that. And now that's
- 1:25exactly what the government's trying to do. They want a
- 1:28stronger DNA sample right from Rex Youwerman to strengthen their case.
- 1:33And of course Rex Ywerman and his legal team, they
- 1:36don't want to give up that bugle swab. They know
- 1:39what it's going to reveal. If he was innocent, don't
- 1:42you think they'd be out here talking about sure, take
- 1:45whatever samples you want. You want a sample of my liver,
- 1:48go for it. If it's gonna get me off from
- 1:51being the Long Island serial killer. I'm willing to jump
- 1:53through whatever kind of hoops you put in front of me.
- 1:56But instead we have Rex Ewerman and his legal team
- 2:00trying to avoid a process that would help him along
- 2:04the way to prove his innocence. If it's not you
- 2:07and you weren't there and it's not your DNA, don't
- 2:10you think you'd be a little bit more forthcoming. I mean,
- 2:12I would think that you're trying to do anything in
- 2:14the world to prove that you're innocent. I know that
- 2:17the burden of proof obviously is on the state. But
- 2:20if you're truly an innocent man, then you'd be falling
- 2:23all over yourself to give up that DNA to prove
- 2:26that you're innocent. Today's article is from the Daily Mail
- 2:31and headline Gilgo Beach serial killer suspect rex Yherman refuses
- 2:36to give DNA swab as lawyer cast out on pizza
- 2:39crust used to link him to the murder. Yeah, that
- 2:43wasn't his pizza crust. It was somebody else's, Just like
- 2:46that wasn't his DNA found on the girls or his
- 2:49wife's hair found in the burlab. But we're not gonna
- 2:52prove that. Instead, we're gonna try and challenge this request
- 2:56for a DNA swab. This article was off third by
- 3:00James Collery. Serial killer suspect Direct Hwerman has refused to
- 3:06give a DNA swab as his lawyer cast doubt on
- 3:10the pizza crust used to link him to one of
- 3:12three murders he stands accused of. Huerman fifty nine, is
- 3:18accused of killing Megan Waterman, Melissa Bartholemy and Amberlin Costello,
- 3:23whose bodies were discovered near Long Islands. Gilgo Beach in
- 3:27December of twenty ten. The bodies of the three women
- 3:32had been bound with belts or red tape and wrapped
- 3:36in burlap. Huerman has pleaded not guilty to first degree
- 3:40and second degree murder. He is also considered a prime
- 3:44suspect in the killing of Maureen Brainerd Barnes twenty five,
- 3:48whose remains were located near Gilgo Beach. And I don't
- 3:52think it's going to be long before they slapped that
- 3:54one on him too. I know I said that at
- 3:57the very beginning that I expected it even quicker. But
- 4:01there's no doubt that they have the goods on rex
- 4:03Ewerman as far as the prosecution's concerned to tag him
- 4:08with this murder. But they want to make sure that
- 4:10all of their ducks are in a row. They don't
- 4:12want to have any kind of issue. They don't want
- 4:15to have any sort of technicality or loophole that rex
- 4:18Ewerman is able to navigate to get himself off here.
- 4:22So they want to make sure that they're going through
- 4:24the process, they have probable cause and then from there
- 4:28they go to the judge and they get the charges
- 4:31that they're looking for, and with him in custody on
- 4:34three other murder charges already. I expect them to be meticulous.
- 4:39They already have a reason to hold them. He's off
- 4:42the street, so they can take their time now in
- 4:45processing the evidence that they do have to try and
- 4:48make sure that they have a very very strong case.
- 4:51Huerman was linked to one of the Gruesome murders through
- 4:54mitochondrial DNA profile from a pizza crust and to use
- 4:59napkin that he discarded from his Midtown Manhattan office. Prosecutors
- 5:04have said, and this is why they're fighting against the
- 5:06buckle swab. They don't feel like the evidence that's been
- 5:10collected off of the napkin, off of the pizza crust
- 5:13is strong enough to convict Rex Hwerman. So they're going
- 5:17to argue that there's not enough there probable cause wise
- 5:21for a judge to order a bugle swab. But I
- 5:24don't think that's going to work out so well for
- 5:26Rex Youwermen and his team. Once you're in the custody
- 5:30of the state the way that Rex Hwerman is, there's
- 5:33a lot of things that change for you as far
- 5:36as what you're gonna get away with rights wise, and
- 5:40what you're not gonna get away with. If you think
- 5:42you're not going to give up a DNA sample, and
- 5:45you're somebody who suspected in these kinds of killings, well
- 5:50you have another thing coming. The court is going to
- 5:53compel you to give up this sample. And that's exactly
- 5:56the outcome that I expect here. Huerman was arrested on
- 6:00July thirteenth and remains in jail ahead of his trial.
- 6:04Huerman's legal team is battling a request from Suffolk County
- 6:08prosecutors to gain a cheek swab for DNA testing. Danielle Koisch,
- 6:14who is representing Huerman, argued the Suffolk County District Attorney's
- 6:18office is a far cry from the legal benchmark needed
- 6:22to force the architect to give the swab. Newsday reported
- 6:26on Tuesday, citing court documents. So their position is there's
- 6:32not enough evidence here to force or compel rex Ewerman
- 6:36to give over this cheek swab, and now it's going
- 6:40to be up to the judge to figure out, one
- 6:42way or the other what happens from here. The exchange
- 6:47between prosecutors and the defense concentrated on authorities evidence of
- 6:52discarded pizza crust and to use napkin. They alleged linked
- 6:56Hewerman to one of the three killings. The assertions contained
- 7:01and the people's moving papers might be construed as rising
- 7:05to the level of a reasonable suspicion, but that is
- 7:08a far cry from the standard of probable cause that
- 7:12is required to justify granting the order sought by the people,
- 7:16Kois wrote in a response to Suffolk County prosecutors, as
- 7:21reported by Newsday, and Newsday has been getting a ton
- 7:24of scoops when it comes to this story. They're getting
- 7:27all kinds of interviews with people involved, and they've been
- 7:31all over it. So they've had a lot of good
- 7:33coverage over at Newsday, and they've had a ton of
- 7:36good scoops as well a lot of exclusive stuff. The
- 7:40response came after prosecutors filed a motion to obtain a
- 7:43cheek swab from youermen. The state prosecutors. They're seeking further
- 7:47DNA testing to continue adding weight to their case against
- 7:52you weer men, and they should be doing that every
- 7:55single avenue that they can travel down to score a conviction. Here,
- 8:00it has to be explored and if they have to
- 8:02get more testing, then so be it. And from Rex
- 8:05Hwerman's perspective, like I said earlier. If you're an innocent man,
- 8:09what are you doing here? Why are you trying to
- 8:12avoid giving up this DNA to prove your innocence. Assistant
- 8:16Suffolk County District Attorney Michelle Hadad asked the court last
- 8:20week to sign off on the cheek swab because the
- 8:23pizza crust and napkin can only be referred to as
- 8:27purported to be touched or used by you were men,
- 8:30according to the court documents. Newsday reported, I wish that
- 8:34New York had a site for us to take a
- 8:36look at the court documents the same way we do
- 8:39up in Idaho. I was looking at the docket over
- 8:43at Suffolk County and there's like nothing there as far
- 8:46as court documents go. It just gives you an update
- 8:49on when the next hearing is and stuff like that,
- 8:52whereas over in Idaho you have access to every single
- 8:56document that's been filed. So I wish they had a
- 9:00resource like that for Suffolk County as well, but I
- 9:03haven't been able to find one. So if anyone out
- 9:05there has a link to something like that, shoot me
- 9:07an email with it. That way we can dive into
- 9:09these court documents as well. Because I've been looking at them,
- 9:13but only in a piecemel fashion. There hasn't been a
- 9:17gigantic dump, and certainly not the access that we see
- 9:21over to the docket in Moscow. Had Dad noted in
- 9:25court papers that if Huerman's DNA from the swabs does
- 9:29not match the DNA profile from the napkin and pizza crust,
- 9:33the defense would be presented with a potential trial defense
- 9:37one hundred percent, not even a defense. I'm talking a
- 9:41full on dismissal. If I was the judge and the
- 9:44prosecution came to me and said, look, the napkin and
- 9:48the pizza don't match up with the buckle swab, I
- 9:51would let rex Ewerman go free. So I don't know
- 9:54why rex Ewerman's team is so adamant not to give
- 9:58up this sample, unless, of course, they have something to hide. Thus,
- 10:02there is clear indication that material and relevant evidence will
- 10:06be found and is crucial for the trials. She wrote
- 10:09in her filing this week, Quois insisted authorities essentially concede
- 10:15they don't have evidence to prove Hewerman actually ever came
- 10:18into contact with the pizza crust or use the napkin.
- 10:22The newspaper reported thus by the people's own admission, the
- 10:26nexus between the partially eaten pizza crust and used napkin
- 10:30and the defendant, Rex A. Huerman is at best a
- 10:33matter of conjecture and assumption, not fact. Sounds strong, right, Well,
- 10:39this is all easily cleared up. Give up that DNA
- 10:43sample and let's see what's what. And the longer they
- 10:46fight giving up that sample, the worse it looks for
- 10:50Rex Hewermen. And I have no doubt that the judge
- 10:53is going to end up giving them the go ahead
- 10:56to get this buckle swap. So all of this is posturing.
- 11:00This is what his legal team should be doing. And
- 11:02this is exactly what I expected. Loopholes and technicalities, and
- 11:07I would expect a whole lot more of that as
- 11:10the case against Rex ewer Men continues to evolve. All right, folks,
- 11:15that's gonna do it for this one. All of the
- 11:17information that goes with this episode can be found in
- 11:20the description box