Latest / Newcomer Pod / Meta Commentary (w/Alex Heath)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome, Silicon Valley, hello again everybody Welcome to Dead
- 0:14cat Tom here with Eric, we've got Alex Heath here from The
- 0:19Verge. Alex is the social media
- 0:21reporting, Savant lunar. Can't we save under Kent?
- 0:26You're still young enough to be Thundercats.
- 0:28Sure, sure. Let's go with that.
- 0:30Okay, but former colleague of mine at the information, we used
- 0:34to be shit. Kickers together on the social
- 0:36media beat you scoop that Facebook was going to change its
- 0:40name. We talked about that on this
- 0:41podcast, so yeah, and I enjoyed that conversation.
- 0:45We hadn't talked to you about Heath in a while.
- 0:46So we're glad to we're glad to bring you want it to correct
- 0:49that but but I do as excited as I am to have Alex on, we have to
- 0:54temper some of that, enthusiasm at the fact that we are here
- 0:57today to memorialize something that we all lost last week.
- 1:01Something that was part of all of our Lives Mehta Nay Facebook
- 1:06died, last week. Wow.
- 1:09All right P. Yeah, the cause of death, Tim
- 1:12Cook. And, you know what just turned
- 1:1518, just turn legal and Dad. Wow.
- 1:18Wow. I didn't even think about that.
- 1:19Not even a full life as much as you can get these days.
- 1:23It's tragic, honestly, we're a little bit.
- 1:26Yeah. The company only brought in
- 1:27thirty three billion dollars in Revenue last quarter which is
- 1:30Frankie pathetic. That's super.
- 1:32Yeah, that's three. Yeah so but But let's let's
- 1:36acknowledge the fact that it's talk to drop 20 something
- 1:39percent over the last Coast like 25%, last five twenty, five
- 1:42percent. So setting a record that they
- 1:45previously set themselves in 2018, right?
- 1:48Yeah, value itself. What 300 billion of market cap?
- 1:51Or I mean, I think it was closer to 20 ish, but yeah, it was, it
- 1:55was the record from their drop in 2018, right, right.
- 1:58So beating their own record. So what, what to make of this
- 2:02Alex? I mean, it's, there's a lot to
- 2:05this. To digest here.
- 2:06And, you know, the impact that it had that sort of blast
- 2:10radius, both affected and didn't affect a lot of its competitors.
- 2:14But what is like your high-level takeaways to why things seem so
- 2:19extreme report? Like what was the most troubling
- 2:23thing to investors? That caused them to panic in the
- 2:26way they did? I mean there were a few things I
- 2:28think probably the thing that sent the market down the most
- 2:32was the forecast being lower than expected because the
- 2:34markets always Ways are about the future, not the past, but
- 2:39it's the Apple stuff you talked about, Tim Cook just laying down
- 2:44absolute vengeance upon the and the ad world.
- 2:49Did they give a specific number on how much the Apple change
- 2:52affected them? They said they were going to
- 2:55lose 10 billion this year is the rough estimate from the Apple
- 2:58change. And then they also said they
- 2:59were going to spend 10 billion on Meadow, right?
- 3:01That's been confused, they have other guests and more than that,
- 3:03they spent that last year, but it's going to be Right.
- 3:06So they spent more in Q4 on metaverse than all arv.
- 3:11Our startups raise combined last year, so yeah, it's kind of like
- 3:15a bet the farm thing. So on one side investors, see
- 3:18this bet the farm increasing Rd spend that a massive loss that
- 3:23doesn't look like it's going to reverse course anytime soon and
- 3:28then they see an ad business that is under threat from Apple
- 3:32regulators and then they see a slowing user base.
- 3:35This was the first time that the Blue app reported sequential
- 3:38Global da you decline in its history.
- 3:42So the the unending gross narrative finally came to a halt
- 3:46and we know that a lot of that. It's so the reporting on this is
- 3:48actually been a little incorrect.
- 3:50A lot of it was like and I haven't looked at this in mind
- 3:52so I'm partly to blame as like when you say reporter, you mean
- 3:54like the media? Not like analyst.
- 3:57I mean us the media. Yes.
- 3:58Okay name names, Alex, what did we get wrong Force?
- 4:02Just well. So This is I also I think got
- 4:07the tone of this wrong in my, in my earnings coverage.
- 4:10But the so if you actually pay attention to what the CFO of
- 4:14meta said, the reason they lost users was because of higher than
- 4:18expected data prices in India. But there's a narrative that,
- 4:24you know, it's about losing the teens, right?
- 4:26The teens are on Fortnight there on Roblox, their own Tick-Tock
- 4:30Tick-Tock is the reason for all this.
- 4:32When in reality they told investors it had.
- 4:35Some, it was some very out there like pricing thing in India so
- 4:39like it just shows how you can see the da use breakdown
- 4:41literally looking at ya right now so they'll also US and
- 4:44Canada went right? I know, 196 million to 195.
- 4:50I mean I can just imagine being at the company you know they
- 4:54miss their da, you buy 1 million, right?
- 4:58So they might there must be some engineer that was like
- 5:01frantically trying to get us to not be owned.
- 5:05There's one engineer, many, many Engineers, like just hacking.
- 5:09Whatever they can to try to. Yeah, enough push alerts.
- 5:12To keep it right lat. Well, there's a so it's easier
- 5:15to fake Mau. So that's very easy to do with
- 5:17some push alerts and like they have a whole playbook for this.
- 5:20Like at the end of every quarter, if they feel like
- 5:22they're not going to meet their targets, it's like all hands on
- 5:24deck. Let's get those in may use up,
- 5:26tau is a lot harder to fake, right?
- 5:29Because that's that's like consistent engagement and that's
- 5:32also like the that's the core health of the Is Tau.
- 5:36And so basically, they couldn't eke out an extra million in
- 5:39India because of data plan pricing.
- 5:41And so therefore, this 1 million loss in North America led to a
- 5:44global decline for the first time, which is like a number
- 5:47that isn't that big of a deal but to investors it's like this
- 5:50company is never not grown. So that's that's a problem,
- 5:53right? Well now we have Robin Hood's
- 5:56decreasing, we've got Facebook, all these, alleged growth,
- 5:59stocks are showing showing weakness, well, the other apps
- 6:03are still growing in the, in the meta.
- 6:05Family right on mean really know like the the Mau for Instagram
- 6:10and WhatsApp was up like by I think around 100 million which
- 6:14is a lot but like on their scale, not what they're used to
- 6:18but the da, you barely moved. I think like, Instagram and
- 6:20WhatsApp or kind of also at a stasis.
- 6:23Right. Right.
- 6:24So like collectively it's just hard to for analysts or
- 6:28investors to keep with the same story that they have been which
- 6:31is that you know even if the growth of the Blue app is going
- 6:34to be you know on Decline or flat you can you can look to
- 6:39these other apps and say like well you know, thank God we
- 6:41still have Instagram or thank God.
- 6:42We still have what you know what's that?
- 6:44Like that's just that train is just slowing down.
- 6:47They just don't have that anymore.
- 6:49And I mean, look, none of this is all that surprising.
- 6:51I mean like I remember writing about this like three years ago
- 6:54at the information that this that this day was coming.
- 6:56So I mean, obviously you can only do so you called it.
- 7:00You're saying you had a you had a low wish.
- 7:02I could say that wasn't brought along.
- 7:03Put you had a long put on this You just made a lot of money if
- 7:06I made it. I made a huge amount of money
- 7:08and I know exactly why it was orders are always - sometimes
- 7:11eventually something bad right happen and you can be
- 7:15Vindicated, right? We every reporter has a short
- 7:17position. The whole video explanation.
- 7:19Honestly has been the most mystifying to me, everybody's
- 7:23trying to reinterpret it. So as I Kerber, gives this
- 7:27speech right to employees saying they're going to focus on video
- 7:32is Right, am I getting that right?
- 7:34Yeah, they said that on their own.
- 7:35Is culture? Yeah.
- 7:35Okay. So what's what's the deal?
- 7:37Is it just like talk or? Yeah I mean like video is more
- 7:42engaging. I think it's also a generational
- 7:44thing. Like I think young people
- 7:47instead of like taking a photo of something or like a selfie
- 7:49it's almost like a quick video pan of their face.
- 7:52Like I just noticed this and my feeds and like younger people
- 7:56don't really take photos as much and yeah Tick Tock is a format
- 8:00is now. Ubiquitous it's like stories.
- 8:02It's the new stories and you know, even snap.
- 8:04I'm Only deleting an undulating, really talk.
- 8:08Oh, so they need a femoral Tick-Tock.
- 8:09See, they're just going to merge the two formats.
- 8:11No, I mean I delete the app uses.
- 8:13Yeah. It's about a say, it's more
- 8:14serious. Yeah.
- 8:15Oh, it's a little cumbersome system.
- 8:17Well, that's because you don't want Chinese spyware, right?
- 8:19Well, the other thing about Chinese spy, where they ask for
- 8:23my contacts, like every other day.
- 8:25And I'm causes every answer. It should be against apples
- 8:29rules. Like so if I accidentally you
- 8:31don't like it and say, yeah, but it just like pops up in
- 8:34unexpected. At times and there's no like
- 8:37double confirmation just like a Miss click away from handing the
- 8:41Chinese government essentially. So you want, you want to argue
- 8:44sure before you send it to the Chinese government.
- 8:47I just think if you asked somebody something three times
- 8:50about highly sensitive information and you say no apple
- 8:55should Eric, are you really just saying your address book is
- 8:57super lucrative? I feel like that's the that's
- 8:59what - I just like the fact. You think the Chinese don't
- 9:03already have it? I know.
- 9:04Well, Day where the Wall Street Journal, you know, said that it
- 9:07got hacked, and it seems like it's probably the Chinese
- 9:10government. There is a degree to, which
- 9:12like, we're all just hacked all the time.
- 9:14Some of us are just finding out about it, but I would at least
- 9:17like, I don't know. I yeah, I think apple is a good
- 9:21Steward of my iPhone and this is just a request.
- 9:24I thought I want to get to the to the push alert things in a
- 9:27second when we talk about snap because I have a lot of thoughts
- 9:29about that. But but yeah, I mean, do you
- 9:33reels, right? That's the tick.
- 9:34Tock Etre you know, push through Instagram, and they're trying to
- 9:38spin a pretty positive story about that which in the past you
- 9:41know reading yours and Other Stories.
- 9:43It sounds like reels was kind of a fiasco but maybe they've
- 9:46turned it around a bit like the it's actually getting some
- 9:48Traction in the way they need it to.
- 9:50So Facebook's Playbook any time. There's a new competitor is like
- 9:54we copy the format and we don't monetize it because we don't
- 9:57want people to be turned off by ads to start.
- 9:59We want them hooked on the experience and we fine-tuned and
- 10:02kind of like needle the experiment it.
- 10:05Variants with all the engagement numbers.
- 10:06We have to the degree that no other competitor does to make it
- 10:09a little bit better. And when we like also pay
- 10:12creators to try to get a flywheel going, they did this
- 10:14with stories, they're doing it again with reels but it's early
- 10:17and they're not monetizing real. So like all the attention is
- 10:19Shifting to Reels but they're not putting at.
- 10:22Is this happened with stories. It was the same thing.
- 10:25It was like, I think even around the 2018 drop was like a story
- 10:27Narrative of like stories were under monetized and they just
- 10:30like eventually shoved ads in that thing.
- 10:32So like, I'm not this kind of just reminds me of 20:18 like
- 10:36they have these like, kind of huge drops when they like have a
- 10:39rough. There had a rough juncture, I
- 10:41guess as a company. You're optimistic though.
- 10:44I mean, when I go to the Instagram version of tick-tock
- 10:46is that also called reels. What's that one called?
- 10:49That's, that's reels that do that Israel's?
- 10:51That's where it's not me. It's on, it's not good.
- 10:53It's not, it's terrible. It's embarrassing.
- 10:55It's like knockoff. It literally has like a game.
- 10:58I got a knockoff version. Yeah.
- 11:00It's we make. So the algorithm Chinese things,
- 11:03unlike, you know, Somali Bob. But sore, but like the reels is
- 11:08like the version of that of tick-tock we're like Tic Tacs.
- 11:12Giving me like the real shit and reels the real.
- 11:16Yeah, exactly getting that real. Yeah, no, it's reels is not
- 11:21great. They don't have good algorithms,
- 11:24relative to tick. Tock, they haven't.
- 11:25So the reason is like Facebook was, was they design like
- 11:28Facebook came up in the era of like algorithms designed based
- 11:31off of like the user telling it what it once and tick-tock.
- 11:35Invented A New Concept of like the algorithm telling you what
- 11:38it thinks you want. And without like you having to
- 11:40input like when you open up and talk, you don't need to like
- 11:42follow things. You don't need to like, a bunch
- 11:44of things. Follow a bunch of pages.
- 11:46That's how Facebook built profiles of us back in the day.
- 11:48And that's how their algorithms are trained.
- 11:50So they're having to like kind of unlearn.
- 11:51The way they train a feed and it's hard to do in a company
- 11:55that size where the people who built the stuff from 10 years
- 11:57ago or so in charge. And so, and they can't buy, you
- 12:00know, companies really to help them with this stuff.
- 12:02So it's going to be a problem for them.
- 12:04And that's Thing they called out was like, it's almost I think
- 12:07they're worried that the narrative has gotten.
- 12:09So ahead on the metaverse stuff and the spend that they've
- 12:11highlighted as gotten, I mean, I have one by one person to blame
- 12:15for that. I mean, no, no.
- 12:17I know I it's their fault, totally, but if you look hasten
- 12:19to earnings like they highlight, we actually expect spend be
- 12:24higher in the family of apps segment in terms of like our
- 12:27capex then then the rest of the company.
- 12:31So they're actually trying to like Point people back like hey
- 12:33we know there's a problem in the core business.
- 12:35We're actually going to spend more than we all call it
- 12:36Facebook, again, I feel like the media knows resisted calling it
- 12:41meta. Like it's just like I really
- 12:43learned. I'm so fascinated by this
- 12:45Viewpoint. Like so if ya like it's almost
- 12:48like you know, a company says, they have these earnings but we
- 12:51should resist it. We should say they actually I
- 12:53like what do you mean? No.
- 12:54They like this is like except reinforcing make up numbers.
- 12:58I'm just saying as long as your core product is still one thing.
- 13:03It's just like I mean everybody. Every consumer still knows.
- 13:06Alphabet is Google like but that is just a real about the
- 13:10alphabet Rebrand was about like accounting.
- 13:12It wasn't about In Like Larry and Sergey also being able to
- 13:15like disappear into the sunset. It wasn't, it wasn't like an
- 13:18actual pivot for the company. I mean it's definitely a brand
- 13:21thing like I'm not I totally get that but like Facebook is
- 13:25actually the least important asset even in the family of apps
- 13:28in terms of like their strategic growth like instead they should
- 13:31be called Instagram if you want to call it based on what it is
- 13:33and the whole company should be called in Degree Facebook and
- 13:36blue app. Still makes the most generous,
- 13:38it makes the new. Well actually I've seen they
- 13:41don't break that out. But there's been some reporting
- 13:43that suggests that they're already like approaching parity
- 13:47and I wouldn't be surprised if Instagram makes more in the near
- 13:49term. So yeah if you want to call it
- 13:51by what it is, we should call it the Instagram company.
- 13:54Do you think there's been this is anecdotal but I feel like I
- 13:58post this on Instagram just right now just because even
- 14:01though I'm living life and doing things in the pandemics, not it
- 14:05Just like I'm not out as much as pre-pandemic.
- 14:07So it's just like there isn't the same lifestyle to post and
- 14:11that yeah a true end of the pandemic would be helpful for
- 14:16Instagram on the posting side. Less on the consumption side.
- 14:20I don't know dude that's that's an interesting point because
- 14:22Evan Spiegel on snaps our earnings said that they've
- 14:26noticed that stories posting has stayed down throughout the whole
- 14:29pandemic and they expected it to rebound by now with like a lot
- 14:32of lockdowns easing up especially for young people
- 14:34young people People are generally, you know, out more
- 14:37like snaps user base. So, yeah, that is an interesting
- 14:40Behavior. I think people are really
- 14:41embracing The Tick-Tock format, and kind of like stories aren't
- 14:44as cool anymore and that's the story of social media is like
- 14:48there's a format that's cool for a while.
- 14:49Until there's I love covering social media because it's so
- 14:51generational like it changes based on kind of the behaviors
- 14:55and like desires of like the Next Generation.
- 14:58It's a snap was like gen Z or whatever.
- 15:01And now there's another generation.
- 15:03What is the next Generation called?
- 15:04I've gets Jenna. I think I think it's a blizzard
- 15:07and Z. Yeah, it's stupid.
- 15:08It's actually kind of terrifying.
- 15:10If you think about the implications of starting again,
- 15:12at Alpha, there are the alpha generation that my kid is an
- 15:16alpha alpha. So why is it that snap seems to
- 15:20have navigated this much better? I mean, you know, they I know
- 15:23that they have adopted a tick tock like, you know, section of
- 15:27the app that, you know, they basically have paid people to be
- 15:29there. Yeah.
- 15:30But you know, why is that not been as catastrophic for them as
- 15:34it seems to What for favorite answer that but the drug set up.
- 15:38Also the drama on Snap because I think part of what's fun about
- 15:41this story is just like just as Facebook was tanking, snap was
- 15:46going wild in the aftermarket. So like why swings are like part
- 15:50of what's so crazy about this? These are main stocks now.
- 15:53I mean they're like baby, basically like is that a coins
- 15:55or meme? Stocktake.
- 15:57I mean, literally on the last episode, I was like, oh,
- 15:59everything's index index funds are going to kill everything.
- 16:02And I literally the next week we Find out that actually like a
- 16:07Fang stock. Facebook can swing down 25%, in
- 16:11five days. It's like totally the sanctions
- 16:13that notion. No, the thing stocks, do because
- 16:16they're indexed, but snaps Wings, crazily, because it's too
- 16:18small. Like it, it went up, 60,
- 16:21something percent or fifty to sixty percent and in after hours
- 16:25and is up way. I saw Nikita beer who sold an
- 16:29app to Facebook their last social media acquisition.
- 16:31They were allowed to do before antitrust and he was like he's
- 16:35Gonna buy a private jet off his snap calls that he ordered like
- 16:37right before markets closed for earnings.
- 16:41There was a wild swing and two Tom's question.
- 16:44Like I think people this is the same.
- 16:47I remember when everyone was like stories are going to kill
- 16:49Snapchat. Like Snapchat is doomed because
- 16:51Instagram is adding stories and like Snap is continued to add
- 16:53more users and grow faster than any other public social media
- 16:58company since then. Well, but there was a period
- 17:01where it seemed very accurate. I mean that, you know, but
- 17:03that's because of the redesign Workers cleaning, like, we were
- 17:06concerned. I mean, you know, this time like
- 17:08everyone was like conflating the problems with Android, the
- 17:12problems with International growth and the redesign was
- 17:14stories, which is like not even the main reason people use snap,
- 17:17like Snap is a private, it's a private messaging which is
- 17:20always funny that it's like you know now become a very
- 17:22successful advertising medium because obviously messaging is
- 17:25like terrible to monetize and to be perfectly honest I'm still
- 17:29not quite sure exactly like what is the full like offering of
- 17:33advertisements these days? Jean snap.
- 17:36When it's a lot of a our ads they're pushing into where it's
- 17:39super early because it's a new format, but they're saying like
- 17:41insane Roi eyes on those limited spend, they have their, it's
- 17:45like, like the numbers are pretty nuts on like, try on
- 17:48stuff actually and, like, how it affects customer sentiment, but
- 17:53they're doing a lot. All the ads are in discover the
- 17:55she Discover, right? Which is the thing that people
- 17:56don't even really talk that much about.
- 17:58And yeah, I mean there's a great story probably still to be
- 18:01written on like who exactly is that discover audience than
- 18:03like, what is its cultural? Fact, it's millions and millions
- 18:06of like, people, they're younger than us.
- 18:08I mean, it has they have, like, HBO shows in there now?
- 18:10Like, it's, it's pretty wild. You never hear anyone talking
- 18:13about. This is my biggest, this is my
- 18:15biggest, and I've heard this on other episodes of this show.
- 18:19We as reporters have, got to stop saying, I've never heard
- 18:22someone has used this. Therefore, it must be a joke
- 18:24like like I've never like it's a joke.
- 18:27This is my culture dominates. Like we all talk about fucking
- 18:31on the hgo like, of course. Yeah, no but like Luckily
- 18:35culture, like, I think but Tick-Tock he's widely pot,
- 18:39right? I think that's orders under that
- 18:40argument is like, so, they're like his very clearly
- 18:43penetrated. Some, some section of what we
- 18:45describe as mainstream culture, and absolutely.
- 18:48I'm not saying there's anything up with it.
- 18:50I just don't understand like what is the broader cultural
- 18:53penetration? You want us to be talking about
- 18:55like young Sheldon or like what is the biggest fucking regular
- 18:59person TV show in the world right now?
- 19:01This is us and I live with someone who watches that.
- 19:04So Is it good or no? It's terrible.
- 19:07That's not show. See all my all.
- 19:10My Elite snobbery is justified by the poor quality of the
- 19:13television that the masks. Hold on, we're getting far
- 19:16afield here though. I'd it sporty you so.
- 19:19So so discoveries is there is there a money maker is what
- 19:21you're saying? Well, and adds in stories and
- 19:24ads and Spotlight and discover. Yeah.
- 19:26Which is the format. It's been like that for a couple
- 19:29years. It's good.
- 19:30But let's talk about Tick-Tock and and and that aspect of it,
- 19:33like why has The generational shift towards Tick-Tock not been
- 19:37that devastating for them because that's not.
- 19:40So like Tick-Tock is entertainment.
- 19:41Its passive like I'm on the toilet and I need to like, look
- 19:44at some funny videos. Snap is actually like an
- 19:47iMessage replacement. It's like a it's a communication
- 19:49medium that is way more sticky. There's built-in Network effects
- 19:53that are very difficult to undo. Its why Zuck offered one of his
- 19:56like, you know fuck you money multiples for SNAP multiple
- 20:00times to try to like by the company because once you hit
- 20:03escape velocity on these kind of Social networks that are built
- 20:06around day-to-day interaction. It's very hard to unwind that.
- 20:09So you have to, like, actually, like really destroy the product
- 20:12over time. And so that's their durability.
- 20:15Is that like that chat stuff and also on the ad side which like
- 20:19the revenue piece snaps way earlier in their their
- 20:22advertising Journey, they maybe have a few hundred thousand
- 20:25advertisers Max Facebook has over 10 million.
- 20:27They have this Facebook invented this long tail of like small D
- 20:31to C brand. Advertisers Snaps are mostly
- 20:34big. And still companies that can
- 20:36navigate like, ad targeting problems.
- 20:39And so they weren't hurt as bad because like, the people who are
- 20:42hurt are like the, you know, Mom and Pop like, DDC brand that
- 20:45like used to adjust their ad, spend on Facebook, like every
- 20:48hour to, like, reach the exact Mom.
- 20:51They're trying to reach in Des Moines.
- 20:53You know, like that? That's what got hurt by Apple.
- 20:55Not like, Coca-Cola, right moms in Des Moines, but what, I
- 20:59don't, what I find kind of disingenuous on snaps part and I
- 21:03did not listen to the Ernest. I do not cover this company
- 21:06more, but I saw their lot of Reve Jeremy Gorman who was asked
- 21:11reasonably by, you know, by analysts.
- 21:14Why was it that snap was not hurt as badly by the Apple,
- 21:17privacy changes as Facebook, and the response was something like,
- 21:20well, you know, we've optimized for privacy focused,
- 21:23advertising. It's like, no, that's bullshit,
- 21:25that's bullshit. That's not true at all.
- 21:27They just are earlier in their cycle and have a slightly
- 21:29different, you know, cohort of advertisers that are not as yes,
- 21:33they're not as tan tracking in order to prove, you know, value
- 21:37for their advertisement and they're just earlier in their
- 21:39stage. Like there's more to that bucket
- 21:41that can be filled. Whereas Facebook is probably
- 21:43maxed out and they have to just constantly prove to advertisers.
- 21:46Yes, keep spending at these, you know, humongous amounts because
- 21:50that's valuable to you whereas snap.
- 21:52There's just, it's just an easier argument to sell without
- 21:55the data to back it up. It's absolutely okay.
- 21:58I think that's fair. Yeah.
- 21:59Yeah. Can we talk about sort of the
- 22:01Apple change? I mean, obviously, you've been
- 22:02touching on it, but that Drove a lot of the Facebook drop and
- 22:08there's been a sort of narrative on Twitter.
- 22:09I think, Matt Stoller, you know, sort of anti monopolist guy.
- 22:14Google pays Apple, a bunch of money to appear in apple search.
- 22:20And so Apple likes Google in a way that they don't like
- 22:23Facebook and therefore, their tilting the change to help
- 22:29Google and hurt Facebook. I mean that's sort of, I don't
- 22:32think there's reporting on that nests.
- 22:35Necessarily, but I don't know. What do you take of that sort of
- 22:37line of argument and how plausible or implausible is?
- 22:40There's no evidence that this back room search deal, where,
- 22:44you know, Google pays Apple, on the order of 10 billion a year,
- 22:47which is Google's. Hey, more based on just don't
- 22:51scale so that we don't know. So, the details of the deal have
- 22:54never been publicly acknowledged by the two companies details of
- 22:57serviced and litigation, I think the epic games trial, so, you
- 23:01know, when one Fang is paying the other, you know, on the
- 23:04order of 10 billion. You're secretly and neither will
- 23:06discuss it. That's probably a good sign that
- 23:08there's something weird going on and it's also like 10 billion to
- 23:11Apple and the grand scheme of things is nothing right, but
- 23:14that's like free money. Essentially that's like a
- 23:16hundred percent margin so that actually flows down to their
- 23:19profit margin in a really powerful way.
- 23:21And if that were to disappear, it would definitely impact on
- 23:24earnings. So this is a meaningful
- 23:25relationship. These two companies have built
- 23:27over this, like, basically when you open Safari Google's, the
- 23:30people just forgot that like, because it's been this way
- 23:33forever since Steve Jobs, like, It's Google when you search in
- 23:36Safari, right? And so yeah, meta CFO.
- 23:39Dave, Winer on the earnings call, made a pretty unusual
- 23:42comment. I don't usually see like a
- 23:44company, this large their CFO like directly accusing.
- 23:47Their two largest distribution providers of colluding on an
- 23:50earnings call but that's basically what he did and he
- 23:52said, look like the way Apple has rolled out this app tracking
- 23:55stuff which Tom you and I covered it.
- 23:57The information and is like disrupted, a lot of things, not
- 24:01just meta, but he's but they were like the way it applies
- 24:04just to a Not browsers where it blocks tracking between apps but
- 24:08not like in a browser necessarily and also like favors
- 24:13first-party data. So Google has more first-party
- 24:15data than any other company on Earth.
- 24:17Arguably. Sure seems to preference Google
- 24:21and you can actually see a Divergence in like Google's
- 24:24earnings relative to all the app based advertising businesses and
- 24:28Google had a monster quarter in e-commerce and Retail meta had a
- 24:32terrible quarter in e-commerce and Retail.
- 24:34Well, and those are the two ones that rely the most on very
- 24:37granular like d2c brand type targeting.
- 24:40And if this preference is first-party data, it
- 24:44incentivizes companies to basically merge with each other,
- 24:46right? It could have impact that that's
- 24:48true. That game that's a downstream
- 24:50effect but I think more close to the Google issue.
- 24:52Is that there's a there's a reporting and measurement issue
- 24:55here where Apple broke the ability to see real time how
- 24:58these ads were performing an app.
- 25:00So like metas was showing people during Christmas like you used
- 25:03to like a lot of brands. Adjust their spend in the middle
- 25:06of the day during like the holidays because it's a very
- 25:08like big time and they're getting a lot of new customers.
- 25:11They had like a multi-day delay and like reporting, whereas
- 25:14Google still has perfect data, perfect Insight real-time
- 25:18reporting. And so of course, all that spend
- 25:19is going to shift into search. And so the CFO is basically
- 25:23saying he said as long as this policy exists, this default
- 25:26agreement that they've worked out where they're paying each
- 25:29other. Apple has no incentive to to
- 25:32apply this philosophy of tracking A fairly and their mind
- 25:36and fairly to them is like tracking is not just like
- 25:39tracking between an app. It's like, if a company builds a
- 25:41profile on you, without your explicit, like, consent or
- 25:45really knowledge of what that profile is, that's like against
- 25:48the ethos of what Apple says it supports.
- 25:51And so Google has that they have the probably the best profiles
- 25:55on because they know our intent right with search.
- 25:56It's just a different. So that was met as argument.
- 25:59I think it's an interesting argument.
- 26:00There's absolutely no evidence to support that.
- 26:02The reason Apple and Google did this is to fuck with me.
- 26:05Do I do in your heart of hearts? Believe that Apple just cares
- 26:09about privacy and is doing these things on a pure.
- 26:13What's best for privacy? I think there's, I think apple
- 26:17is so big that there are factions of Apple that view this
- 26:19differently. I think it's true that like, in
- 26:21the Tim Cook World, they do actually have a pretty high
- 26:25minded view of this. It's also like a very smart
- 26:27brand positioning because like all of other Big Tex getting
- 26:30pushed towards like abusing privacy.
- 26:32So it's very smart to position yourself as like the You know,
- 26:35we're in urine control brand, but there are other parts of the
- 26:39company that are feel a differently.
- 26:41And I think like the rollout of this app thing was a
- 26:44transparency. Tracking thing was a perfect
- 26:46example of like, I bet the App Store team didn't necessarily
- 26:49know that the product team was going to roll it out this way
- 26:51and if they had, they would have said, hold on.
- 26:52This is going to like fuck with our major, like portion of our
- 26:56developers who rely on this kind of targeting for app install
- 26:59ads. So I do think Apple just like is
- 27:02too big to necessarily like have a defined View of it, but
- 27:05there's a lot of like, self-serving in this positioning
- 27:08and like Tim Cook. Absolutely hates.
- 27:10Mark, Zuckerberg wants to destroy meta wishes that
- 27:13Facebook was never on the App Store.
- 27:15Why can't you are? Because I think they felt like
- 27:20the bad PR that Facebook has gone through kind of have bled
- 27:25to them a little bit. I don't know if that's
- 27:26necessarily fair but like since they're the phone that you get
- 27:30these apps on, they just don't want to be associated with
- 27:33learning. Potential like company helping
- 27:37Russia when an election or something like that.
- 27:39And I also think it's about what's coming next which is
- 27:42headsets and this like a rvr war and I do think met Aviva, Apple
- 27:48will be probably the most interesting like Tech business
- 27:50story of the next like 10 years and so mad about you.
- 27:53Tim Cook is mad about something that's not going to happen for
- 27:55like 10 to 15 years at the earliest.
- 27:57No, no, like this headset. I mean, apples headsets hitting
- 27:59very soon hitting. Maybe this year.
- 28:01At least, they're not announce it by the end of this year and
- 28:03that had say next, Cost of Fortune.
- 28:05It's knocking. I reported, they were looking at
- 28:07like a three thousand dollar price point.
- 28:09It's a talent War right now. So they're trying to hire the
- 28:12same people to work on the same problems like meta and apple,
- 28:16and if you can make the other company like sound and look so
- 28:19bad and like its stock tank. So that like, when you're at a
- 28:22cocktail party, you'd rather say you work at Apple than meta on a
- 28:25are they need to bring back with the Eric Schmidt, Steve Jobs
- 28:29days? I mean collusion is much better
- 28:31for business than common seems like they're already.
- 28:34I mean, And Google have this weird symbiotic relationship in
- 28:37so many ways. Like, Google cloud is the
- 28:40hosting provider for iCloud, backup.
- 28:42Your like listen, Eric, they are still colluding, we just don't
- 28:45know about it for another decade.
- 28:46Yeah. Google is just probably the most
- 28:49like, incredible business that's ever been built.
- 28:51Because I mean they can even just like when they're doing
- 28:54deals with oems. They can be like will give you a
- 28:56small percentage of search Revenue through your devices.
- 28:59And that's just like you can't. No other company.
- 29:02Has that leverage or that ability to give stuff like For
- 29:05Partnerships and I just yeah I mean, unless Google unless it
- 29:09gets broken up, Google is like going to keep running the world
- 29:11and definitely because they just have all the data.
- 29:13But Facebook saw this coming a long time ago.
- 29:16This idea that they were always going to be, you know, in a
- 29:18weaker position from an ad perspective because they don't
- 29:21have search. And you remember all the times a
- 29:23couple years ago, they were trying to build search
- 29:25functionality into like the Facebook search bar, which that
- 29:29was a lawyer over and over again, but they knew that
- 29:31there's something inherently more valuable to being.
- 29:34The service that takes you to the thing that you wanted, you
- 29:37know, that you want to learn more about like the lower intent
- 29:40or two higher intent lower down the funnel rather than just
- 29:43like, you know, obviously there's huge value and
- 29:45importance to your social life and you know, your information
- 29:49ecosystem, but it's still way, way way less important than
- 29:53literally here. Like, you know, knowledge, just,
- 29:57yeah, the entirety of your brain, which is what I mean,
- 30:00Google is just a reflection of your brain.
- 30:02It's the most brilliant. Add product ever invented.
- 30:05Yeah, so I don't know. I think the apple is the meta
- 30:08thing is real. I think it's only going to get
- 30:10worse from here because meta has the Strategic advantage that as
- 30:14long as the Wall Street allows them to do this.
- 30:16Like, Mark is kind of in a Bezos type mindset of like your margin
- 30:20is my opportunity with Apple. So he's intentionally pricing
- 30:24their Hardware like below costs like they're losing money so
- 30:29that, you know, Apple won't do that, they can't do that for
- 30:33their business model and their margins.
- 30:34And so, Like apple will have the high-end maybe and they'll be
- 30:38the Android. And so, it's actually a pretty
- 30:40smart strategy against Apple. But one that won't really be
- 30:43valuable for at least 10 years. No, no, no VR will be much.
- 30:47So like, yeah, but driving like impactful for its business, I
- 30:51mean, sure, you can ship a couple of units, but VR based on
- 30:54everything I read in here. I think we'll be hitting console
- 30:57level. It already sold more than the
- 31:00Xbox last year. The quest, I think their
- 31:03totality of VR will be selling On soul level, like Global
- 31:06shipments in the next 3, S years and probably approaching PC
- 31:09within five I think is like the general consensus.
- 31:12So that's you're talking tens igneous, to use VR regularly for
- 31:16to be valuable, right? I mean they don't want to they
- 31:18will they can't just make the money off, Hardware Sales, you
- 31:22need, you know, real yeah. Yeah yeah.
- 31:24I'm sure you talked about this in the Phil libin interview
- 31:27right where he was just like he buys them all and put some in a
- 31:31clothes suck right now. Yeah.
- 31:32But like what's coming is the mixed reality.
- 31:34Any idea where it's like passed through video.
- 31:37And so, we are sucks because it's isolating and the screens
- 31:41aren't very good and it's bulky and it doesn't feel good on your
- 31:44face and there's not good audio. All, that's changing.
- 31:46Like apple didn't you? Ask Jana Reeves about this?
- 31:48He was very skeptical. I thought, oh yeah, I asked he
- 31:52clowned on me about in ft's And so like when you think about the
- 31:57concept of digital scarcity and things that are, you know, they
- 32:02can't be copied that are easily reproduced.
- 32:06Well, they're not the same, right?
- 32:08It's not fake version of you. I wonder what our do.
- 32:10We get a cut of that? Oh no.
- 32:12I don't. Actually, I don't think we're in
- 32:13him. They probably did other people.
- 32:15You have to take that up with the studio?
- 32:16And yeah, man. I missed all of this.
- 32:20Oh yeah. Using see this Tom, no, he that
- 32:23was fun. It was like, kids face.
- 32:26Realize it was you, right? But he was like, you were sort
- 32:28of the mystery man on the other side of it.
- 32:31Yeah. In a viral moment.
- 32:32Yeah, yeah. He was like, you know, can the
- 32:35metaverse not be owned by Facebook.
- 32:37That's an old idea. Like that goes, way, way back
- 32:41and I asked her about NF T's. And he just, like, lay out this
- 32:44hyena, like laughs. It was like, right?
- 32:47But my point is, you're you're a bit of A True True Believer on,
- 32:51on the VR stuff. I mean, you're talking.
- 32:53I see where the hardware is going.
- 32:55I mean, I see where the Hardware and software is going and I
- 32:57think the trend of tech is that more immersive.
- 33:02Engaging technology always wins and that's what these headsets
- 33:05are going to be doing soon. So like who is not going to
- 33:08maybe want to try IMAX on their face like for like a really cool
- 33:12video game with like spatial audio and like maybe a social
- 33:15that's coming in the next year to two years because like Met
- 33:18has got their own version of that that will be high end.
- 33:20So that Tech will start high end at the price will come down over
- 33:23the next few years and then they are glasses will About probably
- 33:27five to eight the v1's of those and that's like more for outside
- 33:30these headsets are all inside, but they're going to be like a
- 33:33PC companion. / replacement in terms of like the quality very
- 33:37soon. Explain to me what the five
- 33:40years from now. A our experience is going to be
- 33:42like will have like these headsets in our homes that we
- 33:45want to use for like either resumes or maybe like working
- 33:49because there's already like pretty robust hand tracking and
- 33:51keyboard stuff and like they'll be armbands.
- 33:54Met has got one they're working on.
- 33:55On that, like, can do EMG like a rager kind of muscle signals to
- 34:00have like, Phantom limbs for like typing without even really
- 34:02moving. That's all that's all coming.
- 34:05Let's not get weird shit. Okay, yeah, Works yet.
- 34:08I mean all this starts, I'm always saying on this show to
- 34:11argue for the metaverse like replacing zoom and browsing
- 34:15guess. Huge like that's it's huge.
- 34:18And also like better gaming like when I interviewed Zach last
- 34:22year, I mean, he made the point that like they're like people
- 34:25We'll spend on average four to six hours a day.
- 34:29Watching television screens in their homes.
- 34:31And those are like these like to deeply panels way up on a wall.
- 34:34This is my Superior. So yeah, but like is it as big
- 34:38as dual 8K displays on your face?
- 34:40What's special audio, right? Like that's the thing like when
- 34:44you when you tried the stuff with eye tracking, which like
- 34:47makes it so that the it's not as hot.
- 34:48And like it renders way cleaner and you don't get a sick like
- 34:52this text already been about everything.
- 34:53I would say, that's my yeah. I mean, I probably sound
- 34:56ridiculous. I just like, based on like, were
- 34:59I see, I know everyone who comes on.
- 35:00Here is like, VR is a joke but like the tech is getting very
- 35:04good and we just haven't seen a mass consumer version of it yet,
- 35:07but it's coming. Very, what about your point is
- 35:09that the best consumer adoption will happen when the tech meets
- 35:12it? Which you think is going to
- 35:13happen and imminently like in the Apple V1?
- 35:16Yeah. Apple V1 will be probably
- 35:18shipped by next year, announced this year and then metas doing a
- 35:22tie in Cambria had set this year as well.
- 35:25But how RB is almost the counter-argument to this like
- 35:28Snap Facebook. Like they're all like second
- 35:31screen apps. Like part of the beauty of
- 35:33Television is that you can do something else, you can look
- 35:38over at your partner or significant know, you can like
- 35:41Beyond these headsets though. Like that's the idea is like you
- 35:45could do with anyone in the world.
- 35:46Like you like your avatar. Could pop in just looking over
- 35:48at your avatar. The second time happening
- 35:50basically, in, in the device itself.
- 35:53Well, I get this time, I get to cynicism, Awesome, but it is
- 35:56better than like me texting you next to me like you I would feel
- 36:00like you're more next to me. If it was an avatar then like I
- 36:04guess, I mean if you're still putting on a device and so
- 36:08you're already making a commitment beyond the sort of
- 36:09like passive, you know, moment of like oh let me see what Alex
- 36:13is up to let me text him versus like yeah, put on the fucking
- 36:16headset, right? It's like a cinema noticed every
- 36:18season is ugly outside. Oh, this is gonna be a long
- 36:21commitment where as well? That's good.
- 36:25Describe the process of getting on the handset of being
- 36:28cumbersome, phones used to suck like trying to navigate typing
- 36:31on a phone sucked. Like, before the I we just got
- 36:34you're saying the technology didn't change all that much.
- 36:36We just decided that it's Kris would be talking about
- 36:38multi-touch touchscreen, keyboards, like dictation.
- 36:41Like, we have so many more ways of texting now than we did 10
- 36:44years ago. Like, I mean, are pause where we
- 36:47can just say things to people over text.
- 36:48Like I'm just saying that you and I are pod guy, you're just
- 36:51walking around on the street, dictate all the time all the
- 36:54time. Where your soul is here on that.
- 36:58Yeah, I just I like to take the opposite view.
- 37:01He kills everyone in the deaf. I definitely blend in and so
- 37:04really. Yeah, I think, like, everyone in
- 37:06media loves to just, like, shed on this stuff and I get it.
- 37:10It's like very goofy right now. But like, if you actually study
- 37:13how good the hardware is getting and where the companies are
- 37:15making their bets, like, you must think that Tim Cook Mark
- 37:19Zuckerberg, Evan, Spiegel Satya Nadella, whatever the fuck
- 37:22Amazon's doing. Like, they're all stupid, they
- 37:24all don't like, They're all making the same bet.
- 37:27Like it's the only thing apple and meta agree on is that these
- 37:31headsets are important to be clear.
- 37:32I believe. I think it's a tight timeline
- 37:35question and yeah, you know, you can invest too early but I agree
- 37:39with you mostly well, giving you a, let's move on.
- 37:42Let's move off. Let's talk about the people.
- 37:43I mean you guys both have obsessed over Evan Spiegel
- 37:48unhealthily at times. Like what the I mean?
- 37:52Where does he still see? Himself is like the genius and
- 37:54he's been sort of, huh? Mumbled like he had these sort
- 37:57of like, you know, he tried to do spectacles, he's not a big
- 38:02player in this future. I don't know what sort of what's
- 38:05due talk. Why doesn't God Alex is closer
- 38:07to this than I am? It's been a couple of years.
- 38:09Yeah, that's good. Yeah, I've talked to him.
- 38:12I think there was a time where you could say oh he's like the
- 38:16next Steve Jobs and people wouldn't be like oh that's
- 38:18crazy. But I think he was trying to get
- 38:19that image rice, but that jobs, portrait is in his office.
- 38:24And here's the interesting thing about The outside you tell me
- 38:26how wrong I am about this? Alex has again, everything I'm
- 38:28saying is multiple multiple years out of date, what I find.
- 38:31So interesting about snap these days is that as a business, it's
- 38:34never been better. Write their cash flow positive.
- 38:36Something that I did not think was going to happen, it's
- 38:38possible. Yeah, you know, they are growing
- 38:43in India which is something that Evan had zero interest in doing
- 38:46a couple of years ago. Every fucking night.
- 38:49I get a push alert from snap telling me that so-and-so added,
- 38:53you know, to their new story which is something that Ian
- 38:55would have murdered an engineer for suggesting that they do on a
- 38:59regular can turn that off. I have that off by the way.
- 39:01Oh yeah. Well I, if I cared more I would
- 39:03I just like to be reminded that certain people back to their
- 39:06stories, but look, the level of push alerts.
- 39:09That snap is doing Snapchat. Whatever is like, leagues,
- 39:12beyond anything that Evan would have wanted to do.
- 39:14He's sold them as we were saying he gave up on the business.
- 39:17He built a business, he got two kids, and, yeah, he is
- 39:20fundamentally had to give up certain aspects of what he
- 39:23expected. This company to be in order to
- 39:25Build something that is more appealing to to the markets and
- 39:29I find it you know it good for him, he's built a business, he's
- 39:32built value for people but the certainly wasn't the company
- 39:35that I thought he wanted to have done back in like 2015.
- 39:39Do you think they were just going to be all like spectacles
- 39:42by now? Like this.
- 39:43Just like no snapshot of well. Okay, look, there's certain
- 39:46things that he had to give up like, you know, in-app purchases
- 39:48being book. You know, the core business
- 39:49rather than advertisements but like they're tracking people as
- 39:52much as anyone else can in order.
- 39:54Sure if, you know, Value with their advertisements, they need
- 39:57to hit their numbers. So they have to do push alerts
- 39:59to like Show, You Know, da you increases above 20%, you know,
- 40:02year over year. These are all things that like a
- 40:05boring ass, Silicon Valley tech company has to do in order to be
- 40:08a successful business. And listen, buddy, we all grow
- 40:12up one day. We all have to get there, but
- 40:13it's it's not the most inspiring thing.
- 40:16Well, he's very, you know, her with his billions of dollars.
- 40:19I think like, yeah, the notification thing you're
- 40:22harping on. I don't really get because the
- 40:24main thing is Which requires notifications to tell you if
- 40:27someone has responded to your message.
- 40:29So now that's what I'm talking about.
- 40:31Like just pure up like engagement juicing, which is
- 40:33what like a push alert saying so-and-so, a still think.
- 40:36Yeah. But you, I'd are doing it more
- 40:38than they used to. Wait.
- 40:39Wait, turn that off like I turned it off.
- 40:41You can turn them off at Facebook to.
- 40:43It doesn't mean that it isn't like a core part of their
- 40:45strategy now though. Sure.
- 40:46I just like yeah, they're doing things.
- 40:48They he didn't ever wanted to do.
- 40:50He didn't know he, you know this, he never wanted to be an
- 40:52advertising company. That was like something, he got
- 40:55kind of pushed him to Doing because there was no other way
- 40:56at the time, there was no crypto web.
- 40:58They wanted to be taxed like yeah.
- 41:00And they're put there doing this super app strategy.
- 41:03The problem I think with them and their perception, is that
- 41:06the user base is just so different from anyone who covers
- 41:09them and so you know people don't cover them like they do
- 41:13Twitter or matter or whatever but like I would I would argue
- 41:16that there's still in terms of like hits on the board.
- 41:20There's no other social media company that has invented so
- 41:23many formats and ideas that have been Keep Bic like ubiquitously
- 41:27copied like bitmoji, like Met has literally just now getting
- 41:30around to copying that snap. They copied with Ray-Ban, like,
- 41:34literally everything snap has done except maybe the map thing
- 41:38because that's special to them. And like the close friends
- 41:40aspect of it has been copied and so likewise that now, right?
- 41:44I mean it's sort of well they have find my right.
- 41:46Like if you do snap map it's way different.
- 41:49It has a bunch of like extra layers to it and social stuff
- 41:51that sort of like my doesn't he? And now look I'm not
- 41:54criticizing. Evans foresight and talent as a
- 41:58product Visionary. I'm just saying the business
- 42:00that he's ended up with, which is now a very good one.
- 42:03It is pretty much. Just a symbolism brings
- 42:05everybody to their heels, you know, like look at my cleavage.
- 42:09You have quarterly earnings. Yeah.
- 42:10Like sure. It's more like Facebook but it's
- 42:12also like a Better Business than Twitter and it's younger than
- 42:15Twitter and it's like already make.
- 42:17I mean like Global assets at least it's not Twitter.
- 42:20Like at least like it's growing and I don't know, the spectacles
- 42:24thing is the thing I'm Most bearish on honestly.
- 42:26Like, I think he maybe has aspirations to be a software
- 42:29layer and like, kind of advisor to a hardware company or an oem
- 42:33on the glasses, down the road. But do you get us have the, is
- 42:36he happy with where they are now?
- 42:37Or he's sort of like, the type of person?
- 42:40You know, I need to be a top ten company at some point, or, I'll
- 42:43know think he thinks in terms of market cap, clearly not in terms
- 42:46of like valuation, because he had multiple chances to sell
- 42:50astronomical valuations. He's very into this AR thing
- 42:54again. It's like when I look at Devon
- 42:56Zack cook that who are I would say the three maybe most like
- 43:01accomplished people still leading tech companies right
- 43:04now. In terms of like their strategy
- 43:06Minds You could argue snaps. Still has a lot to prove.
- 43:09But I think in terms of what we just talked about what they've
- 43:11invented, they think I had in there, right?
- 43:12A lot of the time, they all agree that like this are
- 43:15glasses, thing is coming and it's going to be huge and that's
- 43:18where he's spending a lot of his time as on the a our software
- 43:20and on Snap lab where I reported they are Tom do you remember the
- 43:24Drone thing? They were going to do.
- 43:25Sure, they've revived with the Drone.
- 43:28Drones are back as because they're finally making money.
- 43:31They want to, like, do a bunch of Hardware shed and I wouldn't
- 43:33be surprised if there's a watch and multiple glasses and like
- 43:37companion devices. Like he's got this Hardware
- 43:40strategy that they just do not have the resources to compete at
- 43:43scale with apple and metal on, they have good talent.
- 43:46They have creative people but like they don't, you know, it
- 43:49still has that Underdog feel to it as a company.
- 43:51I still think he views it as like we're here to like throw
- 43:54darts at meta. And like be the anti Meadow
- 43:57which in the stock market, they definitely were this week.
- 43:59Yeah, no I mean he's definitely if that's still a core tenet of
- 44:03his it's been a good week. Yeah it's good for recruiting,
- 44:06it's good for like you know, people recruiting people from
- 44:09Mehta who are disillusioned and you know there's a huge Talent
- 44:13we're going on for all this air of stuff.
- 44:15So like it's important to have your brand be like considered
- 44:17the kind of cool Underdog but I don't know.
- 44:19I tried the new spectacles, the I think you guys talked about, I
- 44:22think you made fun of my demo at one point on the show.
- 44:25Uh-huh. I like and how as you know
- 44:28positively I wrote about them but like it's more just like
- 44:31it's they're not good now, like they're not anything normal.
- 44:34People are going to wear and that's why they're not selling
- 44:36them to people. But like it's very easy to see
- 44:39that this is going to get good and like that they've got the
- 44:42pieces to make it good and like there's like a scan thing where
- 44:45like once the scanning Tech, it's good like you've got visual
- 44:48search on your face, like, all this stuff is going to be
- 44:51hitting. It's just like not it's early,
- 44:53it's early days, but it's, it's I can See where it's more than
- 44:56just like a magically come. Look at our Magic Box
- 45:00experiment. It's like it's actually starting
- 45:02to work in the real world. It's just not great yet.
- 45:05Do you want to spend a minute on Pinterest or should we should we
- 45:07respond? What do you, what do you think
- 45:09about Pinterest? Tom, because you covered, you
- 45:11covered Pinterest more over the years.
- 45:12I've dabbled in, and out, but it looks like there have lost.
- 45:15Like it reminds me of snapping. Like the Nick Bell leaving are
- 45:18alike, 2018 2017, when every week was like I was hearing that
- 45:23another exact was leaving snap and it seems like that's the
- 45:25case. With Pinterest right now.
- 45:26And we're talking, I was talking about this with Eric before we
- 45:28started, I'm always a little and I'm guilty of this myself.
- 45:31I do think reporters get a little over excited or maybe
- 45:35over index for executives or leaving company.
- 45:38Therefore, it's in complete turmoil.
- 45:40I think we're in a unique time now, where people don't really
- 45:43want to work at large companies and certainly not large social
- 45:46media companies. And so, you know, Pinterest
- 45:49social media over the fuck they are.
- 45:50You know, they're some sort of amalgam of a Silicon Valley ad
- 45:54tech company. That also Has like a social
- 45:56layer to it but yeah they've lost a couple of Executives.
- 45:59The information reported that I'm sure it messed things up for
- 46:02them, but I also think they lost like 9i.
- 46:05That's the thing, it's like it's a snap level, like clear the
- 46:08bench. Like what it signals to me
- 46:10whenever I read because there were MMA rumors about them with
- 46:13Michael, right? So that that's more damaging to
- 46:15me than anything because I yeah that yes that that should be me
- 46:20that says, because they had a corked of left.
- 46:22Like and so like that to me says that a lot of the senior Can
- 46:26file people. A lot of the senior people
- 46:28wanted to sell Ben Silverman didn't or they couldn't get a
- 46:30good deal done another all leaving and that right that's
- 46:33actually more than just like a couple execs leaving.
- 46:35I mean I think it's like nine at this point.
- 46:37Sure it's not great. Yeah I do think it's fair to
- 46:41countenance that with the fact that there are a lot of
- 46:43Executives leaving a lot of not particularly inspiring sure but
- 46:46he's these days. So you know you can you can make
- 46:50of that. What you want?
- 46:51I think Pinterest is an incredible advertising vehicle.
- 46:55If you just think about like the core product itself, it is very,
- 46:59you know, corporate or sorry. It's very product adjacent and
- 47:03so their ability to make money from.
- 47:05It is pretty huge. I think the problem that they
- 47:08have is that they're losing users and you know it, yeah, and
- 47:11and good talent, I mean that the app doesn't do you use the app?
- 47:15No, not the app. I use the service from time to
- 47:18time because I've been, you got some real operating on.
- 47:21Yeah, that's why. Yeah, you know, the times of
- 47:23people use it, which is like you did when you dip out like that.
- 47:25So, social media so much, my wife is an interior designer.
- 47:28She uses Pinterest all day everyday, like power user.
- 47:31She always is like this app sucks.
- 47:34Like every time she's like, it doesn't work.
- 47:36It just breaks. Like it doesn't make sense the
- 47:38way to navigate it. So that to me says like from
- 47:41someone who knows it really well that they just probably don't
- 47:43have like good engineering and like they're not hiring the best
- 47:45people and they can't build the best product because this stock
- 47:48is tanking and they don't have a business yet.
- 47:50So they're in this like kind of death trap, it seems like well
- 47:53the the stock is tanking thing is relatively new.
- 47:55I mean, if you look at this chart over the last year they
- 47:58actually were a huge winner during endemic true but you know
- 48:03better to be that than not and you know their value is a
- 48:07company went up substantially over the course of last year.
- 48:09It's obviously plummeted now and I agree with you there in kind
- 48:11of this nether region where even though they got a lift after it
- 48:15turned out their numbers weren't as bad as investors were
- 48:18expecting post meta, they didn't get the snap like bomb and so
- 48:22that is fundamentally. I think a better you know, it's
- 48:24a better app. And you know, a more sustainable
- 48:28future and it doesn't seem like they've evolved that much from a
- 48:31product standpoint. So I think they're probably this
- 48:34is so out of my league but like I think they're probably in a
- 48:36stage where they can make a bunch more money overseas, you
- 48:39know, they were barely monetizing outside of the US and
- 48:43so like you'll be able to see Revenue growth over the next,
- 48:46you know, year or two. But like the core question of
- 48:49like, is this app going to grow? Do they have, you know, some
- 48:52sort of a meta play or Something that can, you know give a clear
- 48:58indication as to the next, the next stage.
- 49:00I don't I don't see it myself and I think the fact that they
- 49:04probably came pretty close to selling to Microsoft, it's hard
- 49:08to get past that. I mean you could make an
- 49:10argument that Twitter even though the business is doing
- 49:12better now. Never really, you know, changed
- 49:15after that whole period in 2017 when they were going to sell to
- 49:19conditioning, I know I know Google tried to buy Pinterest
- 49:22to, I think it was before they listed Google has this ritual.
- 49:25Like the air before any hot like consumer or even really SAS, but
- 49:30definitely consumer like Network effects company, goes to public.
- 49:33They have a, you know, will give you like above your listing
- 49:36price like just come to Google anyway.
- 49:38They probably have stopped doing that because of antitrust but
- 49:41yeah, they they they definitely tried it with Pinterest.
- 49:43So I think that would perfect sense, right?
- 49:45If it's basically like a nice little like social layer on top
- 49:49of double-click. Yeah, yeah.
- 49:51So I don't know it's not, I wouldn't be too bullish on them.
- 49:55You know, we just were always obsessed with Mark Zuckerberg on
- 49:59this show. I mean, I can tell I've been
- 50:01trying to think over how to ask, I mean, I want to know what you
- 50:05what you think's up with him, who sort of in the mix.
- 50:08But I mean, I think, you know, when we first got to know, like,
- 50:12when I first came to Silicon Valley, like, you know, this
- 50:15sort of Facebook people, there is like an earnest You know,
- 50:20they love product, they do like talking about the future.
- 50:24And so, you know, if you read it just like knowing their
- 50:27personalities, there's a sense that the sort of meta push is
- 50:32sincere and that they like device is very sincere.
- 50:35And I feel like that's a part of the posture of reporting is
- 50:39like, you know, believing them to some degree on that.
- 50:42Whereas, whereas, like, I think a lot of, you know, sort of the,
- 50:46I don't know, Wall Street Journal, Bloomberg types.
- 50:48You know, you can just become Very focused on the quarterly
- 50:52earnings and then you see everything is a game or if
- 50:54you're obsessed with antitrust. You see it as like a messaging
- 50:58thing to get away from that. I don't know, that's sort of
- 51:02just a statement of purpose. But I mean am I right to say
- 51:05that you believe you take them seriously.
- 51:07When they, when they seemed excited about sort of the
- 51:10product piece of VR and, and sort of the meadow?
- 51:15Yeah, because it's more than just like words.
- 51:17It's like the people who are moving Owing to that division.
- 51:21The fact that it's like 15,000 people.
- 51:24The fact that they spend over 10 billion a year on it.
- 51:27The fact that it's like we're zacha spending his time, like
- 51:30legitimately like, of course, I take it.
- 51:32Seriously. I find reporters who.
- 51:33Don't take it seriously to be kind of.
- 51:37Unlike what do you, what is your job was?
- 51:39Like, why are you? Why are you like just assuming
- 51:41that this is like and like check and make sure, but you're just
- 51:45assuming that this is like a joke because you're cynical
- 51:47about the company. I think there's way too much.
- 51:49Cynicism about like their motives.
- 51:52And I'm not saying their motives are pure by any means but like
- 51:55yeah, no I do take it seriously. I'm like, I'm not a like text
- 51:59synthesis either. Like I think Tech is cool.
- 52:01I think it can be misused, but I think it's like also very cool.
- 52:04It's why I got into this job is because I'm a nerd and like but
- 52:07I also like do the like, you know, Facebook disbanded its
- 52:12Civic Integrity team. And here's why I type story,
- 52:14right? I do that.
- 52:15But like I do take this seriously and I think I think
- 52:19it's important that people do it.
- 52:20I mean, like, they may decide to give up, but I think it's kind
- 52:22of like no going back at this point.
- 52:24Is the vibe that I get like this is like, I was talking to
- 52:27someone and on the glasses, you know, Division and like they're
- 52:31like, this is I of Sauron, like Zuck on us.
- 52:34Like, this is like, this is like there.
- 52:37It's the most intense. This person had worked and
- 52:39Silicon Valley to bunch of big tech companies for a long time.
- 52:41It was like this is the most intense founder involvement in
- 52:45any like project I've ever seen. I mean, I got to take that
- 52:49seriously. The dude is like one of the most
- 52:50powerful people in the world so I don't know.
- 52:54I don't know. What do you Des if you think the
- 52:56media has become soft? What you got?
- 52:59Soft? No, I'm not calling you.
- 53:00So I do, I mean, I think part of this show is like, we think that
- 53:04reporter is got like to - I mean, there is like such a drum
- 53:08beat. There's just such a drumbeat
- 53:10against, you know, if you'll like the media does want to
- 53:13dislodge like Mark Zuckerberg. Yeah, no kidding.
- 53:18I mean like I guess the T. My thing is like I think it gets
- 53:21old, I think. People are sick of the same old
- 53:25like stories of like we found this Russia, you know, saying or
- 53:30the Macedonia teens on. I'm not saying those stories
- 53:33aren't important, like they should keep happening, but I
- 53:36think the overall tenor of the coverage.
- 53:39Yeah, is like, just de facto cynical de facto.
- 53:42This is a joke, like all the headlines this week are like,
- 53:44this is the end of Facebook and like, I don't know, I just don't
- 53:48know if readers. Like I think others are subsets
- 53:51of readers who definitely love that and you're obviously
- 53:53playing to that but I are like are you?
- 53:55I try to not think about like just one audience I'm like I
- 53:57want the people who also work at this company to read me and to
- 54:00feel like I'm critiquing the company and being harsh where I
- 54:03need to be. But also like I care about this
- 54:06stuff and I'm not just like de facto slamming it, you know,
- 54:10what I was gonna say, I also think there is a very poor, like
- 54:14one of the mistakes that reporters make in writing about
- 54:16Facebook is they conflate social problem.
- 54:19Eames. And the impact that a company's
- 54:21technology has on society with its business and you see that
- 54:24happening with Joe Rogan now. You know at Spotify they're like
- 54:27oh you know, after Neil Young announced that he was going to
- 54:30be pulling his catalog from Spotify, its stock fell 10%,
- 54:33it's like you fucking idiots, that is nothing.
- 54:35That's not the reason the stock fell and then it came up the
- 54:38next day like for fuck's sake. That's the other thing is like
- 54:41my stories, the reason Facebook declined 1% unless you got
- 54:44numbers that like a million, you know, like hackers have Straight
- 54:49like their infrastructure like and they haven't announced it
- 54:52yet, you're not moving the stock of a company that large like,
- 54:55that's, that's another pet peeve.
- 54:56I have anyway. Sorry.
- 54:57Right. But also, you know, in the case
- 54:58of Facebook, I really think there were a lot of reporters
- 55:01who got, you know, high on their supply that because they wrote
- 55:03so many great pieces about their, you know, social
- 55:07infrastructure team or or whatever whatever you call it.
- 55:09You know, the problems that they've had in in terms of
- 55:11moderating contents or name any Facebook, scan of the last five
- 55:15years. That that was really going to
- 55:16hurt its business. And it's like, you know, there
- 55:18was also a So, a long period of time that as a business
- 55:21reporter. You also could have explained.
- 55:22Look, these guys are running up against a wall in terms of user
- 55:25growth that you know, Apple's privacy changes are going to
- 55:27hurt them and you have done this I'm not blaming you specifically
- 55:30but I think a mistake the tech reporters have made is as
- 55:33they've seen the influence that technology has had Beyond just
- 55:36the industry itself. They've conflated that with the
- 55:38business and you, you mislead people into thinking that that
- 55:42is going to change a, that core aspect of their of their
- 55:46business. And again, you just do a
- 55:48disservice to readers. You can Both.
- 55:49But like, explain to people that there's a huge difference
- 55:52between these types of stories while it's also you just ignore
- 55:54the business like, alot of Facebook covers, just ignores
- 55:57the advertising business. Like, I like, how do they make
- 56:00money? Like, what is their actual
- 56:02vulnerability in their weakness? Exactly.
- 56:03Like it's people are. So this is, I think Facebook is
- 56:08a perfect example is like house in Industry.
- 56:10We kind of like can play to our peers more than we can to what I
- 56:14think an audience wants. And I honestly think a lot of
- 56:16The Joe Rogan coverage has gone into this realm as well.
- 56:19Wear it Like we love to like, sit here and be like, are there
- 56:22a publisher or are they a platform?
- 56:24Like, oh my gosh, and I wasn't speaking about this incessant
- 56:27like and Eric, like, I think that's an important debate for
- 56:30us to have and like, the media. My job licker insiders.
- 56:33So I don't even have. Yeah, 10.
- 56:34And like, I don't even for tends to speak for this podcast is
- 56:37where that conversation should be happening.
- 56:39But like, most people do not fucking care.
- 56:43And like that is the reality most people do not actually
- 56:46think they're like a lot of the That we just assume that
- 56:50everyone feels about Facebook like this.
- 56:53It's just like Facebook is seen very differently in other parts
- 56:55of the world and so, like you can't ignore that and I don't
- 56:59know. Anything like included, I mean,
- 57:01and politicians and like, potentially deservedly and
- 57:05tarnishing Facebook's reputation.
- 57:07So I mean they have moved it and I do want to serve it.
- 57:09I mean there is an argument that like if Mark Zuckerberg has done
- 57:13something Beyond like forgiveness or is not the person
- 57:16to run the company, or is causing started this global I'm
- 57:19which I think some people believe and there's like a
- 57:21credible argument for I don't think it's like reasonable to
- 57:25just like stop hitting that drum because it's like exhausting to
- 57:28be - I don't know. That's really a challenge
- 57:31journaling about, I mean, no, I agree.
- 57:33I agree with you. I don't think that you should
- 57:35stop. I think it's like, I think a lot
- 57:37of the coverage is ignored everything else or not, taking
- 57:39it seriously because it's how, he only thinks it's sort of
- 57:42like, okay, you need to represent this piece of it with
- 57:44this part of. Yeah, I mean, it's hard to be
- 57:46real. I mean, like, we know it gets
- 57:47Awards consideration, we know What like gets are pat on the
- 57:50back from our editor and our colleagues.
- 57:52And it's the it's not the like, it's not the stuff that isn't
- 57:56related to disinformation and fake news and these topics that
- 58:00we love to just act like have Universal definitions, but don't
- 58:03and yeah. So no.
- 58:06I mean there's a lot of I sound. I think I sound like an
- 58:09apologist for Facebook right now.
- 58:10But I think I'm more. I just want I want like more
- 58:13balanced coverage in general. I think I try to do that and I
- 58:17get slammed like I got slammed for The zuc interview as it
- 58:20being soft and it being like, why don't you ask him about how
- 58:23good and the one who is about, like the metaverse, the Rebrand.
- 58:26Yeah. And like, what the fuck is he
- 58:28going to say? Like, he really literally, like
- 58:30he just said it on an earnings call, he just said that it
- 58:32doesn't make sense her claims, like he was very blunt like way
- 58:36more blunt than like, Tim Cook has ever been about anything and
- 58:39like, what is he going to tell me in the 30 minutes I have with
- 58:42him to talk about like, a massive, like Rebrand of one of
- 58:47the largest companies in the world, like I'm going to go back
- 58:49through One still like Instagram for kids like and like when he's
- 58:52already talked about it and he's a CEO he's not going to say
- 58:55anything new and I was worried Ben.
- 58:57Thompson is talked about this challenge, some on his podcast
- 59:01ruined dinner and I think I mean it is hard.
- 59:03When you have these CEOs you want to, you have to have a
- 59:06productive discourse. I mean part of it is just
- 59:09obviously I prefer a world where you could, it's more like a
- 59:12deposition. You have like three hours
- 59:15really? Like, that would be a just world
- 59:17where you're really, you know, it's not performative in.
- 59:19Trying to really go through the stuff but given the reality that
- 59:22if it's like, yeah, especially 30 minutes, it is sort of like a
- 59:25performance and they're sort of kind of it terms because, you
- 59:29know, it's so short. Like, these interviews are all
- 59:31performances. Well, I also just have a
- 59:33fundamental, I have a fundamental disagreement.
- 59:35We talked about this in an earlier episode and Katie and I
- 59:37disagreed on this. I just don't there's no magic.
- 59:40You know, Elixir that our reporter has or like there may
- 59:43be able to wave a wand that because they asked the right
- 59:45question at the right time the Earth's, you know, shifted a
- 59:48couple degrees off of its access Like we're all there to ask the
- 59:51right questions and hopefully get an answer from it.
- 59:53But the true impact comes from the stories that investigate
- 59:56things of the co, you know, isn't going to talk about.
- 59:59And so, you know, I do think we have an obligation and you know,
- 1:00:03you can argue one way or the other whether you wish you had
- 1:00:06asked to do something to suck that you didn't you know, to ask
- 1:00:09a hard question. But fundamentally you know the
- 1:00:11real reporting that matters isn't going to come through that
- 1:00:14interview. It's performative.
- 1:00:16And so I feel for ni I haven't Been in a situation like you
- 1:00:20have where, you know, I'm speaking to a high-level CEO in
- 1:00:24an interview that's going to be scrutinized in that way, but I
- 1:00:27don't, I just don't blame the reporter in that particular case
- 1:00:31here. I think you can blame them if
- 1:00:32like the totality their work of, you know, elides on huge
- 1:00:35problems and you know, purposefully chooses not to
- 1:00:39cover them because they think it'll benefit their career long
- 1:00:42term or something weird like that.
- 1:00:44But I just don't think that. Yeah, the the core of reporting
- 1:00:48comes through the few times. You get to interview the person
- 1:00:50in power. And I just, I try to remind
- 1:00:52myself. There are things that people
- 1:00:54care about that. We don't always obsessed with in
- 1:00:56the media. Like there's like that matter at
- 1:00:58a company that scale like asking him, are you going to be Co in
- 1:01:01five years like, stuff like that, that I did ask him like is
- 1:01:04a little off the like it's not Facebook files but like it
- 1:01:08matters to be like these kind of question like if I get a chance
- 1:01:11to ask Zuckerberg, some things I want to also throw things in
- 1:01:14that like not just the crowd that loves to eat up the like
- 1:01:18Facebook is bad. No.
- 1:01:19Matter what stories will be interested in because I'm trying
- 1:01:22to like, reach a lot of people, right?
- 1:01:24I mean, I've been on both sides of this argument.
- 1:01:26I mean, there is a degree to which if you're a reporter
- 1:01:29trying to hammer a narrative, like, if you're really trying to
- 1:01:34focus attention on your reporting and you feel like it,
- 1:01:37it's reporting that if people paid attention to would have
- 1:01:40impact. But it's hard to keep the
- 1:01:42attention on there and the companies just doing everything
- 1:01:45they can to avoid it. Then you want to sort of have
- 1:01:49this Of tight-knit network of reporters that can sort of force
- 1:01:54the conversation that you think is societally important.
- 1:01:56And then it can be annoying when the company can try to find
- 1:02:00Pockets to scape that. But of course, that sort of
- 1:02:02argument that I make is what the vast majority of the public and
- 1:02:05companies hate about reporters. The idea that there could be
- 1:02:09sort of control of the message to such a degree that you force.
- 1:02:13Man, if you want to, man, if you want to talk about control the
- 1:02:17message, that that is Apple. All like meta is actually.
- 1:02:22It is one of the easiest companies to talk to and one of
- 1:02:25the most forthright I found and like Zuck actually actually
- 1:02:29subject. I thought the whole debate about
- 1:02:30like Zuck never does interviews with like, you know.
- 1:02:33So and so he's not open and like available, he does way more
- 1:02:37interviews with journalists in Tim Cook.
- 1:02:38Tim Cook, six down. He sits down with like a fucking
- 1:02:41YouTuber. That's like he's pressed for the
- 1:02:43year old still like be. Like I was just, you know, I
- 1:02:45totally different totally different standard.
- 1:02:47And they're, they're arguably way more influential.
- 1:02:49Unlike important. And so, yeah, no, I agree.
- 1:02:52It's like the standard thing is like, very interesting.
- 1:02:55It's like, remember when Jack Dorsey was sitting down with
- 1:02:57like, every third person that asked that there was like a
- 1:03:01three or four month period, we have is doing like he would he
- 1:03:03would have appeared on like the 200th most important podcast.
- 1:03:07Yeah. I've never interviewed Jack have
- 1:03:09you guys know? But he was sort of I had cost
- 1:03:12the firm that I accosted him at Sun Valley once a it was a
- 1:03:14little earlier, right? I mean, it was a little I was
- 1:03:17still new wish I forget. What years?
- 1:03:20I mean. Aaron's demos was like big on
- 1:03:21getting Jack. Super out there.
- 1:03:23I think for a period. Yeah.
- 1:03:25Jack's. A fun.
- 1:03:26One day interview. I feel like right now he'd be
- 1:03:27just like wild. Like I know.
- 1:03:29No, no Jack. Come on.
- 1:03:31Yeah. Yeah you want to show?
- 1:03:34I mean the whole like everyone's is ID number and reason for
- 1:03:37which you start Chris Dixon was going after Bobby, good lat.
- 1:03:40Like last night, I'm just like egregious, anyway.
- 1:03:43Not the biggest player in Silicon Valley is has Bitcoin
- 1:03:46investor, but it just I mean I've On complain that these
- 1:03:50people aren't sort of confrontational enough and like,
- 1:03:53like to keep all their fights and private.
- 1:03:55So I guess I happy to see anyway.
- 1:03:58Yeah, there's all starting to fight with each other on
- 1:04:00Twitter, which side, it's on Twitter, something real, like if
- 1:04:03you take it to another venue and I'll give it a little bit more
- 1:04:06time of day for right now, it just seems like entertainments
- 1:04:09rights Patty. They're not like writing like
- 1:04:11essays or like yeah and they're certainly not, I don't know.
- 1:04:15Do you think if like we weren't on Twitter all day like coverage
- 1:04:18of these companies would be way. A different.
- 1:04:20It's so you be so different. Yeah, it's so like it's such an
- 1:04:24echo chamber and it's just I for young reporters to like coming
- 1:04:27in till I covering these companies.
- 1:04:29They're looking at like more established people for cues of
- 1:04:32what to cover. I mean I did this and like it
- 1:04:34just has this like feedback Thing That Never Ends, right?
- 1:04:37I know we all like, need the like Steven Levy or like, or
- 1:04:41like this day. Max Max chaff kannur Brad.
- 1:04:44So, I mean, just any of these? Where they like are almost like
- 1:04:47disconnected from the beat reporter.
- 1:04:49In the be reporters, like myself would go all like pissed off
- 1:04:52that they're not like asking the questions that were obsessed
- 1:04:55with of the moment, but they like, do the long interview, I
- 1:04:58mean, Matt Matt Honan would do these with Google sometimes we I
- 1:05:02feel like those types of stories, I think it's partially.
- 1:05:05The companies haven't been cooperating because the media
- 1:05:08has been so negative. I don't know where of those
- 1:05:10stories. Gone are like it wasn't there.
- 1:05:13They've mostly. Yeah, disappeared.
- 1:05:15I mean Levy had is, you know, had some access to Facebook for
- 1:05:18a while. And that book and marks done
- 1:05:21some interviews wired wire, did a fairly long Zuck you know
- 1:05:24inside his world during kind of the Cambridge analytic.
- 1:05:28It's the one where he's beat up on the cover.
- 1:05:30Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:05:32And read the one that had all the comms department but that
- 1:05:34was like reporter e. That was very like interested in
- 1:05:39the things we care about that was that was a very specific
- 1:05:43Source space. Yes, and no people know who
- 1:05:48talked in that. Worried.
- 1:05:50But that was also not mark on the record, right?
- 1:05:52Like you know, like Isaac's got his Facebook book coming out and
- 1:05:57he's working on, maybe he'll get some access, I don't know like I
- 1:06:01think Mark is down to like talk to people but it's like I think
- 1:06:04a lot of the vibe is that a lot of the reporters who cover meta
- 1:06:07or like just like by default. Confrontational.
- 1:06:11Not even like I think it's a difference between like being
- 1:06:13quizzical and like a not assuming like something is
- 1:06:17correct or Has the right intentions and being like
- 1:06:20downright confrontational and there's honestly some of that
- 1:06:23vibe in like people sweets. Are you, are you you consider
- 1:06:26yourself a view from nowhere reporter?
- 1:06:30I don't know. I definitely have opinions, but
- 1:06:32I actually intentionally try to not fully form opinions so like
- 1:06:36I like I'm more motivated by Scoops and like uncovering
- 1:06:40things and not necessarily like connecting all the dots and so I
- 1:06:45think I like to hide behind the reporting a little bit.
- 1:06:47Like I actually don't want you to know.
- 1:06:49What I've you of meta is like a net good or net bad because I
- 1:06:53honestly don't know. And I think if you say, you know
- 1:06:56and you're an outsider, you're lying because like you like you
- 1:06:59there's no way of knowing like at scale like we don't have the
- 1:07:01data so it's like I don't know. Yeah I try to like hide behind
- 1:07:05it. I think it works for like
- 1:07:07sourcing as well because you know, like people at these
- 1:07:10companies if they feel like you're at least like are willing
- 1:07:13to hear them out and not like assume they're evil, then you
- 1:07:16know, they'll talk to you. So I think it's a more of a
- 1:07:19Long-term view honestly well, certain kind of sourcing, right?
- 1:07:21I mean I think one of the advantages that reporters have
- 1:07:23when they're so outspoken about their personal beliefs is that
- 1:07:26you can cultivate a certain perspective.
- 1:07:28Yeah. You cultivate one side.
- 1:07:30Yeah yeah yeah yeah. Which is not to name names but
- 1:07:33like you can definitely you know, he's turned effective.
- 1:07:37Yeah, if you're out there just like constantly tweeting about
- 1:07:40how absurd something that Facebook has done is.
- 1:07:43Well, it's like Ryan Mac going to war with like Tesla or
- 1:07:46whatever on your face. It's it's intentional and I
- 1:07:51think it's a great reporter and he is great, just like a good
- 1:07:55strategy. If you know your side, they know
- 1:07:58your side and then they go to you.
- 1:08:00I mean time have their strategy, I do not want to fight with him,
- 1:08:02will tweet it. Well, it's good to know the show
- 1:08:04to you mean, I know it's good to I, this is real shit that we're
- 1:08:07talking about. Like, yeah, I think it's good to
- 1:08:08have different strategies and I may be a little old school.
- 1:08:11I don't know like, or to a lot of people nowadays.
- 1:08:13I may just be soft but like, I think there's value and not
- 1:08:17everyone taking the same approach and I think There's
- 1:08:19value in Ryan's approach and I think there's value in mind and
- 1:08:21like, I'm not saying there's are bad, I'm just saying, like, we
- 1:08:24need a mix. We don't need to all be doing
- 1:08:26the exact same fucking thing because like some people have
- 1:08:29big newspapers, cover something a certain way like write a mix
- 1:08:31of like approaches to reporting. Now, we're back to, we spend too
- 1:08:35much time on Twitter. I, by the way, believe I've
- 1:08:38been, I've been limiting my Twitter, a little bit.
- 1:08:39The last couple of weeks, I swear to God sources.
- 1:08:42It's unrelated. I think there's something Cosmic
- 1:08:44that happens when you lean back on, like, time spent on Twitter
- 1:08:46and like sources will call me back They just know they're like
- 1:08:50this guy isn't tweeting. Yeah, I think it's like if
- 1:08:52anything was like, some sort of indication from a higher power
- 1:08:55that I shouldn't spend as much time on here.
- 1:08:56I literally have better days reporting in ways that have
- 1:08:59nothing to do with Twitter. When I spend less time on their
- 1:09:02Robin Hood, Twitter puts Okay order.
- 1:09:05Yeah. No.
- 1:09:06It's and that is interesting that like that's bigger expiry
- 1:09:08my tweeting effects Twitter stock then they have bigger
- 1:09:11problems. Yeah.
- 1:09:13Anyway Alex. This was great.
- 1:09:14Thank you so much for joining. Yeah.
- 1:09:17Well, we'll do this again. Yeah.
- 1:09:18This Thanks for having me, guys. Thank you, goodbye.
- 1:09:33Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:09:35Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:09:19Thanks for having me, guys. Thank you, goodbye.
- 1:09:33Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:09:35Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.