Latest / Beyond This by Zaheerah Bham Ismail / Episode 14 : Beyond This By ZBI - Reclaiming our identities
Transcript
- 0:15Assalam Molik Murakami Talahi Wabarakatuh Welcome back to
- 0:18another episode of Beyond This with me, Zahira Bomb Ismael.
- 0:22The one thing about being on a platform like this is that we
- 0:25don't just go with the flow. Everything has to be discussed,
- 0:29even the uncomfortable discussions that most likely are
- 0:32going to generate a little bit of negativity or comments around
- 0:36it. But this is what we hear for to
- 0:38be able to open these discussions and to have them.
- 0:41One of the topics that have come up repeatedly in many
- 0:44conversations was who we are as Muslim women and the narrative
- 0:48that we hold for ourselves as women.
- 0:50Our stories are often told by the media, by communities, by
- 0:53society, by everything around us.
- 0:56And more specifically, as Muslim women, our narrative is very
- 1:00often held by someone else's lens, and we so often fall into
- 1:04that. And when women are being told to
- 1:06find their identity, to hold their space, to hold their own,
- 1:11we don't even know where to start.
- 1:12Where do you begin? Because we've never been allowed
- 1:15or never been given the opportunity or the space to be
- 1:18able to find our own identities, to know the legacies that we
- 1:22come from. And I'm not talking about the
- 1:24cultural ideologies. I'm not talking about who we've
- 1:27been told we are or we should be as Muslim women.
- 1:30And being told about going to find out yourself, it comes back
- 1:33again to the first injunction of ICRA, which is read, go and find
- 1:37out who you are, going to find out the legacy of Muslim women
- 1:40that we come from. Because so often we told this is
- 1:42your place. And we can't question it.
- 1:44We can't discuss it. We can't open up any discussions
- 1:47around it because we've never taken the time to go and read
- 1:49about the amazingly strong Muslim women that we come from.
- 1:53So how do we actually navigate those discussions?
- 1:56So we sit back and we accept the lens from which we've been told
- 1:59that we supposed to be. So as Muslim women, when we
- 2:03discuss it, we often have so many places that have been given
- 2:07to us. So we see the media describing
- 2:08Muslim women as voiceless, as being oppressed, as needing
- 2:12saving. I have so many issues around
- 2:14this. We see it so often where these
- 2:17voices are coming up from people who have no idea, no link to
- 2:21Muslim women, to no link to a community involved in Islam,
- 2:25involved in our lives that they feel they need to come and save
- 2:29us because we look a different way, we carry ourselves in a
- 2:32different way that we voiceless really many of us have very,
- 2:35very strong voices. The last thing we ever need is
- 2:38saving. I think everyone else around us
- 2:40needs saving, not us. We good where we are.
- 2:42And then we've also got society that places these expectations
- 2:48of who we are as being a good girl.
- 2:50And I have this good girl thing comes from if you told the line,
- 2:55if you fall into the right boxes, if you're not too out
- 2:59there, if you know how to be quiet enough so you don't
- 3:03disrupt the status quo and you're a good girl.
- 3:05And then it puts it as too modern too, doing nothing, just
- 3:10being a housewife. Again, you've from previous
- 3:13episodes, you know, that's a huge issue for me when people
- 3:15are described, women who choose to be at home, who choose to be
- 3:20a caregiver, who choose to put their family at the forefront of
- 3:24everything and whose roles are so minimised and depleted and
- 3:29disregarded. So I have huge issues with that.
- 3:31Then we also have issues with two traditional 2 modern, all
- 3:35these words that are used to describe women except for woman
- 3:38who just being in their space. So when we talk about women who
- 3:43are different, who are out there for me, those are probably the
- 3:47women who don't fit into the boxes because they true to who
- 3:50they are. And here we are trying to put
- 3:53women into these boxes of too modern, too homely, good girl.
- 3:58It's tied into our communities and our families, tied into
- 4:02serving. You're good enough if you're
- 4:04serving other people. That again becomes an issue on
- 4:06its own because yes, we have obligations to people around us.
- 4:10We have obligations to our communities, but that's not only
- 4:13our role that we have, because when our identity is handed to
- 4:17us that you need to be this to be able to succeed in our
- 4:20community, then we shrink ourselves fit into those roles.
- 4:24And really we do because so seldom do we give ourselves an
- 4:27opportunity or a chance to be able to say what works for me,
- 4:31what guides these values for me. If you had to sit and think
- 4:36about it, what is your value system?
- 4:38We talk about, ohh, Islam gives us all these rights In August,
- 4:41we all talk about Women's Month and how great we are as women.
- 4:45And then the rest of the year, everything continues as is.
- 4:49We talk about the rights must Islam gives us.
- 4:51How often or how much of it do we actually know that empowers
- 4:55us enough to speak about it because we speak about it.
- 4:58But then we're still being told we are places are and other
- 5:01people controlling that narrative of who we are because
- 5:04we've not taken the time to be able to read about it.
- 5:07So we've got Islamophobia, we have hijab debates, we have
- 5:11headlines that frame us all the time and we not doing anything
- 5:16to change this narrative. We talk about it in these echo
- 5:19chambers, but we need to get out there and we need to be able to
- 5:22say it in a different way, to speak it in a different way.
- 5:26So people actually hear us. One of the things I heard
- 5:29earlier from our producer was, you know, whether you're going
- 5:32to do something or you're not going to do it, people are
- 5:34always going to have a comment. We, we hold ourselves back from
- 5:38being true to who we are because we are afraid of what those
- 5:40repercussions are. But again, if we understand
- 5:43where we are, if we understand our value system, if we link it
- 5:46back to our faith as our anchor, then don't worry about what
- 5:51people are going to say. They're going to say it anyway
- 5:53regardless. We've got our internal community
- 5:56pressure. So besides as Muslim women
- 5:58dealing with what everyone else thinks we are and how we are and
- 6:01how we should be and how we should be looking, we have our
- 6:04internal community pressures of being too religious or not
- 6:08religious enough. And I was saying this to
- 6:11somebody about why do we feel the need to comment on people's
- 6:14social media pages about how they're wearing the scarf, how
- 6:17they're not wearing it correctly, how they behaviour
- 6:19doesn't fit this or that. And someone said ohh.
- 6:23But you know, if you're putting it out there, then you are going
- 6:26to get the comments. So stay with me for a little bit
- 6:29on this. When we walking out into public,
- 6:33you wouldn't go up to a stranger and Give your opinion on them.
- 6:36You're seeing them walking past you.
- 6:38Social media is a digital footprint.
- 6:40If you don't like what you see walking past, you simply
- 6:43unfollow. And if you really do truly want
- 6:46to give Ness he had to somebody do it in a respectful way, in a
- 6:50way that maintains their dignity in a silent manner quietly
- 6:54directly to them. But we've become these keyboard
- 6:57cowards that get we feel gives us the right to comment on
- 7:00everything. We are never going to be 100%
- 7:03perfect. Not a single one of us is.
- 7:05We know this. The only perfect person was our
- 7:08prophet Sallallahu Ali was Salem.
- 7:09The rest of us, we fallible, we going to make mistakes, but to
- 7:14judge someone on it, to say, ohh, but they way hijab and they
- 7:17do this, you have to understand the rules are the same whether
- 7:20you wear a scarf, whether you wear hijab, whether you wear
- 7:22parada, whether you wear niqab. The rules are the same for
- 7:25someone who does and someone who doesn't.
- 7:27The rules in terms of how we navigate our lives should be the
- 7:31same. But we can't sit and hold people
- 7:33up to different value systems based on what they look like.
- 7:37And we can't be sitting there commenting on how we think
- 7:40somebody wears something or doesn't wear something.
- 7:43And I have to speak to the Muslim Brothers on this because
- 7:46you have no idea when you make those comments, how it actually
- 7:49moves somebody further away from Dean, further away from a sense
- 7:53of community, further away from a sense of belonging, rather
- 7:57than keeping them part of a community that she holds them
- 8:01while we falter and find our ways.
- 8:03The same for the Muslim men, if we are going to criticise every
- 8:06time someone walks into the Masjid in terms of how they
- 8:09dress because really not everyone is dressed the way they
- 8:13should be. Much the same as the way you
- 8:15comment about women, Muslim men are in exactly the same bracket.
- 8:18If you are wearing tight fitting clothes, those tight fitting
- 8:21jeans and you walk into the massage it understand that if we
- 8:24are commenting on that, what's going to happen?
- 8:26Those people are not going to come back into the massaging.
- 8:29So if you can create safe spaces for Muslim men to belong to a
- 8:32community where they finding their identity because you don't
- 8:35want to lose them and you want to make sure that they keep
- 8:38coming back so that they become strong forbearers for Islam,
- 8:42then why aren't you affording the same for the Muslim women
- 8:44and the young Muslim girls in our community as well?
- 8:47Because if we are going to sit and comment on everything that
- 8:50she looks like, how she speaks, what she does, what do you think
- 8:53she's going to do? She's going to walk away.
- 8:55And then we have to sit with the repercussions of that.
- 8:58So we need to really be providing safe spaces and
- 9:01networks for ourselves to understand that each one has a
- 9:05journey to walk on. Each one has their own journey.
- 9:08We can guide, we can be there when they fall, we can be there
- 9:11when they falter. But it's not our journey to
- 9:13walk. It's theirs weak.
- 9:16Ours is to provide those support systems so that no person feels
- 9:19isolated, no person feels alone and no person feels that this is
- 9:24something that they're struggling with.
- 9:26There are girls who are going to put on their scarf the next day,
- 9:29struggle with it the third day, put it back on.
- 9:32Our job is not to judge it. Our job is to make sure we they
- 9:35so that the days that she's got it on, she's got us strength of
- 9:38a sisterhood of a community that tells her that they're here to
- 9:42support her on this journey. When Muslim women have
- 9:46constantly been spoken about, we negotiating basically where we
- 9:52belong. We negotiating our authenticity
- 9:54and the respect that we get. And it should never be that we
- 9:58if we want to encourage growth and we want to encourage
- 10:00excellence and we want people to thrive as the best of Muslims.
- 10:04We don't keep them in these spaces that serve us the way we
- 10:09need it. We need to allow for growth.
- 10:10We need to allow for them to become the best versions of
- 10:13themselves. But they can only do this if
- 10:15they have a sense of belonging to something bigger.
- 10:18And then it comes back down to our personal responsibilities
- 10:21that we take to be able to go and read, to go and find out
- 10:25what these value systems are. To go and find those anchors in
- 10:27faith that allow us to be the best versions of who we are
- 10:31without being afraid of saying want to take the step, but what
- 10:34are people going to say? Our faith really does honour us,
- 10:39but society tries to flatten us into these one-dimensional
- 10:44projects that they can manage. If we truly understood or
- 10:49understand the strength that we have, the strength that we
- 10:52carry, the strength of the legacy we come from, we will
- 10:55never be apologetic about who we are.
- 10:58Which brings me into another whole conversation about being
- 11:00apologetic Muslims. And this is for the males and
- 11:03the females. Our need to try and fit in has
- 11:08basically done exactly what the medias wanted to do to separate
- 11:12us into good Muslims and the extremist Muslims.
- 11:16And there's no such thing in my head.
- 11:18You Muslim and you're Muslim, there's one thing in that.
- 11:22You come, you read the same Quran, you've got the same
- 11:24journey you want to walk on for inner tells Habboon, we all want
- 11:27to get to Jinnah. Our rules are the same.
- 11:30Don't try and be apologetic about who we are, about our
- 11:33identity. Again, this is coming from a
- 11:36place of not knowing who we are, not having read it, of talking
- 11:40about all these rights that Islam gives us.
- 11:42But if you're not reading about it, we are going to find
- 11:45ourselves on complete opposite ends.
- 11:48And the visa, Lawley Salim told us moderation is key.
- 11:51Find that middle Rd. But you can't find it if you
- 11:54have no idea who you are and you don't have any idea.
- 11:56It's because we're not even doing any reading.
- 11:58We taking what people are telling us we should be.
- 12:01We're taking what people are telling us should be the
- 12:04definition of a good woman, a good Muslim, and okay.
- 12:07This is the road I need to travel by so that nobody else
- 12:10has anything bad to say about me.
- 12:14Our identity is rooted first in who we are.
- 12:17We are servant of Allah and everything else flows from
- 12:21there. I'll be going to make mistakes.
- 12:23Absolutely. Does it mean that we are of a
- 12:27different religious level? People often say, ohh, you can't
- 12:30speak about Islam because you're not an alima or you're not a
- 12:33Muslim. I don't agree with it at all
- 12:36because they're very, very many people who are exceptionally
- 12:39passionate about their religion, about the legacy that we come
- 12:42from and who speak about it truly from their hearts.
- 12:45And you learn so much from them and their people who may look a
- 12:49certain way also, who may not necessarily link to the way you
- 12:53see a value system. So you have to find this journey
- 12:57and that responsibility is on you because if you are not
- 13:00taking the responsibility of educating yourself, then how are
- 13:04you going to be answerable for it?
- 13:05You can't say somebody else told you that.
- 13:08So when we speaking about our own story, just a simple thing
- 13:12about the legacy we come from has Arcadia already allowing her
- 13:16and I'm using the names that we know of was an entrepreneur, a
- 13:19leader, a wife, a mother hazard, Aisha radial law and her was the
- 13:23greatest scholar of her time, a teacher, a narrator of hadith.
- 13:27We still learning from her at this time.
- 13:30Maria Malay Salam, who was defined by devotion, not just by
- 13:34motherhood. So these are the we've got to go
- 13:36back. We've got to find who these
- 13:38women are. There are so many more names
- 13:40that have been reading about that we've never been told
- 13:42about. We've never read about.
- 13:44We have so such limited access to.
- 13:46But if we understand the legacy they carry, you understand how
- 13:51it easily it is to define yourself into that.
- 13:54One of the things I was doing with some friends recently is I
- 13:56said to them, find the qualities that define you most and let's
- 14:00link it back to one of the most remarkable woman that we come
- 14:04from and use that to be a basis also for who you are because so
- 14:07often we struggle with that and that will help guide it as well.
- 14:12So when we talk about it, I have to ask you, who has been writing
- 14:16your story? Is it time for you to take back
- 14:19their pin and write your own one?
- 14:22We have limited time. We're not coming back to do this
- 14:24again. You have one journey to live.
- 14:27You have one journey that you're answerable for.
- 14:29How you write that story is entirely up to you.
- 14:33Who you lend that pen to to write your narrative is entirely
- 14:37up to you. It's time to take it back.
- 14:39It's time to make it yours. And it's time for you to say I
- 14:43am based on your own anchors, based on your own value system.
- 14:47Not written by what the media says.
- 14:50Not written by what culture says.
- 14:52Not written by what society says.
- 14:54Written by what you say, what you are answerable for, and what
- 14:57you want to be want to leave behind.
- 15:01Our identities were never meant to be dictated by others.
- 15:05We are now faith, we embrace our complexity, and we own our
- 15:11stories with dignity. It's time to hold our own pins,
- 15:16because what comes next starts here.