Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E030: Bitcoin ETFs and Shifting Macro Tides with Mark Connors
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that the last
- 0:03trade is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:14management platform built on multi institution custody.
- 0:17We serve high net worth individuals, institutional
- 0:20investors and financial intermediaries with the best in
- 0:23class suite of products which include multi institution
- 0:26custody, a spot Bitcoin fund, Onram Wealth for Rias and
- 0:32private wealth services for high net worth individuals.
- 0:35Leveraging our partnership with Bit Go and other industry
- 0:38leaders, Onram's Multi Institution Custody is a first
- 0:41of its kind institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:46institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:50unique permissions have been met.
- 0:52Our multi institution vaults utilize cold storage, key
- 0:55signing and authentication at the direction of the client to
- 0:59maximize security for client assets.
- 1:02This pioneering approach to custody is the foundation of On
- 1:05Ramp's financial products which reduce counterparty risk
- 1:09associated with trusting a single institution.
- 1:12To learn more about how On Ramp can help you secure a new or
- 1:16existing Bitcoin position, please visit our website at on
- 1:19rampbitcoin.com, where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:23connect directly with our team. What you're telling me is that
- 1:28music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:31the biggest bag of odorous extra ever assembled in the history of
- 1:37darkness, 1974198792972000. And whatever we want to call
- 1:44this. It's all just the same thing
- 1:46over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 1:49I say when we sell, hey, I say when we sell.
- 1:56And we're live, gentlemen, back for another week of the last
- 2:00trade, this week joined by Mark Connors, the Director of
- 2:04Research at 3 IQ. Mark, welcome to the show.
- 2:07Thank you. Thanks for having us here.
- 2:10It's a good it's a good foursome.
- 2:13Yeah, we were just saying we're all pros, so it's good to have a
- 2:16bunch of pros in the room discussing.
- 2:18There's no one else, and there's no one else here to refute it.
- 2:20Which I like that. I guess before we jump into an
- 2:26intro, are you comfortable riffing on what we were
- 2:28discussing before we had recorded on the ESG narrative
- 2:31what you're seeing there? Yes, yeah, sure.
- 2:33So we're just talking about you know what I was doing and I was
- 2:37I've been aggregating information on on the ESG and
- 2:42the whole idea is that Bitcoin in general is is complex and
- 2:46moving fast and most people are still looking at 2017 news
- 2:51stories or or even the technology.
- 2:54They're not really catching up to what it's doing now.
- 2:56And a perfect example is how Bitcoin mining is now even being
- 3:02recognized by the UN for helping solve global warming.
- 3:09Just to start with a big old nugget punch right there.
- 3:13And then what I was talking about was, is it Dan Batten I
- 3:18think is the as in chapter four. He runs a fund, he's I think
- 3:23he's an Australian or New Zealander and he's been
- 3:26migrating into the Bitcoin space because he is a environmental
- 3:31lead oriented investor. And the whole idea about Bitcoin
- 3:37mining is really the only option to help reduce methane flaring
- 3:41and how that has not only attracted ideas and people in
- 3:45the space, but investors. And I think you were just
- 3:50talking about how your firm was bought out by a an energy
- 3:57company that is engaged in that exact process.
- 4:00Is that right? That's Caruso.
- 4:02And it's funny. Cully from Caruso, their CEO,
- 4:05was on 60 Minutes this week telling the story.
- 4:07I'm not sure if you saw that clip.
- 4:09No, I didn't. Wow.
- 4:11Yeah, it's one of the few bright spots of mainstream media
- 4:14coverage of Bitcoin mining. And I mean it is the flare gas
- 4:17mitigation is probably one of the most ironclad narratives the
- 4:21mining industry has. It's a very visible problem
- 4:24quite literally with the the flame in the air and the fact
- 4:28that you can reduce that to nothing and get value out of it
- 4:32is it's really hard to combat say that that is not a a net
- 4:38benefit to humanity at the end of the day.
- 4:40And and isn't there a case? I don't have the raw data, but
- 4:44I've I've read recently that methane flaring got a bit of a
- 4:48pass by the either environmental but I don't know if it's a
- 4:55carbon emissions group or you have to buy offset that so they
- 4:58don't have to offset it as much for carbon emissions for for
- 5:01flaring. Flaring gets a pass, but if it's
- 5:04used for Bitcoin money, it actually becomes a cost.
- 5:09In other words, they don't account for the mitigation it
- 5:11provides. But actually it's again, Bitcoin
- 5:15so far has occurred that the regulators and the taxing
- 5:18authorities don't know how to deal with with certain aspects
- 5:21of it. So if you weren't aware of that,
- 5:23we can maybe put that in the notes after.
- 5:25I'll follow up on it. Yeah, it's it's different
- 5:29between depending on the jurisdiction.
- 5:31Up in Canada, you can't flare at all.
- 5:35They're not allowed to flare at all in Canada.
- 5:37That's why upstream data, this had a lot of success up in
- 5:41Canada. They're selling their their hash
- 5:43huts because the producers can't flare at all and so they're
- 5:47doing extraction of oil and gas. The associated gas needs to be
- 5:51taken care of. Bitcoin mining is a perfect
- 5:53example in the Bach and if I recall correctly it's been a
- 5:56couple of years since I was deeply involved with their
- 6:01operations of Great American Mining.
- 6:02But they have I believe like a 90 day flaring post initial
- 6:07drill. So you can drill and flare for
- 6:0990 days and after that you have to figure out mitigation.
- 6:12You start getting fined by the EPA.
- 6:14New Mexico has very strict flaring laws down here in Texas
- 6:17they're a bit more liberal with it.
- 6:19But yeah, there's inter jurisdictional differences
- 6:24between how much you can flare, how long you can flare, and
- 6:28whether or not you can flare at all.
- 6:31Yeah, I think the whole capital spec starts to change.
- 6:34I've been further removed from it.
- 6:35But I remember in 21 and 22 in Texas specifically when it came
- 6:39to mining on you know land and we think the capital structure
- 6:42of you have the landowner, you have the lease holder and then
- 6:45somebody that's going to leverage the natural resources
- 6:48and there's a certain like threshold of that's due.
- 6:51But then that starts to change with the economics of the price
- 6:54going up and those leases started, I think Marty's talked
- 6:56about those lease started like somebody they have certain like
- 6:59standards built in and now people are going back to rewrite
- 7:02them because you got to account for this asset that can just,
- 7:05you know, reflexively go up you know at such a fast pace
- 7:09compared to like what you've seen in oil and gas.
- 7:11Historically, yeah. What you're touching on there is
- 7:13the mineral rights owners and how the lease are written from
- 7:16them. So somebody owns the land, owns
- 7:17minerals beneath the land. They lease that out to an
- 7:20extractor and typically they get their royalties at midstream.
- 7:25So and that gas goes to midstream and then sold to the
- 7:28broader market and they get typically I believe 12, 1/2% of
- 7:32the revenue in royalties on those sales.
- 7:36And that's where Bitcoin mining strung a bit of a wrench in that
- 7:39set up because you do the extraction and the monetization
- 7:42of that gas upstream and not at the midstream.
- 7:45And so like you said, Michael, people are beginning to rewrite
- 7:49their leases to ensure that they're getting their royalties
- 7:53from the monetization upstream. Mark before we jump into the
- 7:58episode in your background, I was thinking I know for Marty
- 8:02and myself and I think majority on the Pod of you mentioned
- 8:06global warming and Bitcoin solving it, that there's this
- 8:08like, sweet irony in a lot of these tropes that have happened.
- 8:12And that it, I thought it made me think of when you're a child
- 8:15or younger and you're told not to lie and the reason you're
- 8:17told not to lie. There's lots of reasons.
- 8:19But once it always comes back, like you cannot like run from
- 8:21the lie long enough. And there's always like common
- 8:24things that are said and like, you just get trapped in your own
- 8:27kind of propaganda eventually. And it's like, wait, this is the
- 8:31thing that it was supposed to boil the oceans and end
- 8:34everything. And this is actually the thing
- 8:36solving what I I'm going and now you're just like stuck it up in
- 8:39a pretzel, like wondering what the hell am I talking about?
- 8:42Yeah, it it's almost too big a nugget to present.
- 8:45That's why I almost walked it down after I said, like, all
- 8:47right, let's just go into the details first before we throw
- 8:50out that little, you know, reversal of narrative that
- 8:55people are are not going to be ready to almost, you know, take
- 8:59in. It's almost like you want to
- 9:00sort of do incrementalism, just talk a little bit at a time
- 9:03because you're right. Yeah, it's a, it's A and I don't
- 9:08know how much was like a lie or was it just self-serving or fear
- 9:12or misunderstanding. It's just a bunch of you know to
- 9:16look at incentive structures about why the WAFF or others
- 9:19would would say it other than maybe they don't control it.
- 9:23It's the only thing I can think of.
- 9:27Yeah, they don't like that. They can't control it.
- 9:28It's it's scary. Brave new world.
- 9:33Sometimes you can't control everything.
- 9:35Become apparent. Find that out soon.
- 9:39Found that out last night, I was telling Jesse and Michael before
- 9:42you hopped on. We had a a midnight trip to
- 9:44urgent care for an asthma attack last night.
- 9:46Can't control that. Nope, can't control that.
- 9:51But I guess diving in, I just straight into Bitcoin mining,
- 9:55flare, mitigation, all that good stuff.
- 9:58But let's take a step back and allow you to introduce yourself,
- 10:00Mark, what you've been doing. I think your background, it was
- 10:04extremely fascinating, particularly coming from Credit
- 10:06Suisse to Three IQ, to focus on research and advice on how to
- 10:12allocate the Bitcoin. Yeah, you know, it's.
- 10:15I feel a little bit, little bit like Will Ferrell in old school
- 10:21where he says, you know, we're going to streak the squad, you
- 10:23know, or the quad. Come on, follow me like numb.
- 10:27No one, no one from from track by following me.
- 10:32I am like come on guys, the water's warm.
- 10:34Let's go. And there are some, you know, I
- 10:38got Pete Janney over at night dig and and a few others.
- 10:43But when I go back to you know meetings meet holiday parties,
- 10:48they kind of look at me with like a little bit of a, you
- 10:50know, we still like you. We're not going to call the
- 10:53authorities or have you in straight jackets.
- 10:55OK. We still like you.
- 10:57So I I mention that because yeah I spent 30 years in you know
- 11:01firms from you know Dean Witter, Smith Barney.
- 11:06I was at some smaller firms like CRT Capital that focus on
- 11:10distress debt which that process actually is most applicable to
- 11:16this investment thesis. I, I think we can touch that
- 11:19later. And then in the hedge fund
- 11:22community for about 15 years doing risk management across
- 11:25multi asset and then credit Swiss.
- 11:28And the reason why I came over is we would we would help our
- 11:34team helped hedge funds with alternative data whether it be
- 11:37positioning data and and the like.
- 11:39And then we would compare it to the market data and say oh here
- 11:43comes another market shock, be careful, it looks like
- 11:46positioning will change and you guys should you know deleverage.
- 11:50So we were communicating to, you know, the major funds and their
- 11:53and their PMS etcetera. But I noticed that a lot of them
- 11:58are going out of business and these were smart people, a lot
- 12:01of resources and they couldn't beat the S&P but the NASDAQ even
- 12:06on a risk adjusted basis, you know, only the larger ones like
- 12:09Citadel, you know, Millennium Bally's done a good job, you
- 12:13know, over the past five years changing their process and I
- 12:18wondered why. And then I'm like, Oh my God,
- 12:20the money. The Fed is becoming more
- 12:23centralized and they're becoming the volatility extinguishers and
- 12:28they're coming in with QE like they did and you know August of
- 12:319th of 19 and obviously in 2020. But the dead load was getting so
- 12:39big and the number of buyers of our debt so small, there used to
- 12:43be like 45 primary dealers managing the distribution of our
- 12:49auctions. Now they're 2425.
- 12:53They used to be all US. the Fed only dealt with US entities and
- 12:56now only a third number US. We had to spread it out because
- 12:59it became so big. So we have fewer people managing
- 13:03our debt load. We have more of it and now the
- 13:06Fed's buyer of last resort to its own auctions essentially.
- 13:11So I saw it from a macro standpoint and the effect was
- 13:15that these, these tremendously resource hedge funds couldn't
- 13:19beat the Fed because things change so quickly from a macro
- 13:25standpoint that he just had to just as I say, don't fight the
- 13:29Fed, but we'll go into how that's going to turn sideways.
- 13:33And then over a period, two years, I started to understand
- 13:37Bitcoin a little more and I'm like and it's funny, I just
- 13:42think they didn't until now I literally had the visual of
- 13:46people leaving treasuries and equities and stepping on at
- 13:50Bitcoin. So maybe, I don't know if that's
- 13:52how you got the name on ramp there folks.
- 13:54But that is literally I said maybe we don't have to go
- 13:57through a default if there can be a new asset kind of like when
- 14:00Nixon broke the peg in 71 and Citibank was bleeding losses in
- 14:05emerging markets, but they developed a brand new market
- 14:08that never existed which was foreign exchange and saved their
- 14:12ass. So maybe this is that new sort
- 14:16of punch to the new realm of opportunity, I believe so where,
- 14:21you know the burning fire behind you, you escape by stepping onto
- 14:25Bitcoin. So that's how I came here.
- 14:27That's my background. And so it's global macro, it's
- 14:30markets and now it's including digital assets.
- 14:33I mean, Bitcoin really as the main animal.
- 14:39That's so interesting. It's fascinating to hear your
- 14:42your journey there and that you know that's exactly how I view
- 14:45it too of we talk about as like the the lifeboat you know
- 14:50bitcoin's the lifeboat for for what's coming this this storm of
- 14:54sovereign debt and what the hell is gonna happen here and it is
- 14:58it's I share that hope of I think that this is what with bit
- 15:04without Bitcoin I think there's a much greater chance of like
- 15:06like global catastrophe in terms of like the Great Depression
- 15:13level of upheaval as the sovereign debt situation plays
- 15:17out. But with Bitcoin it it could be
- 15:20that that smooth lifeboat to for us to transition to and and the
- 15:28lifeboat builds and gets bigger and stronger over time and and
- 15:33turns into the the new boat. So I'm hoping that that's how it
- 15:37goes. Mark, if if we still have you
- 15:40there? Jesse, why don't we?
- 15:42Why don't you just rehash the last 10 seconds of your question
- 15:44there all? Right.
- 15:46We're going back, Mark. Thanks guys.
- 15:49Yeah, Mark, I don't know if how much of you caught it.
- 15:51I'll just roll into it here. Yeah, it's fascinating to hear
- 15:56about your, you know, suddenly becoming aware of bitcoin's
- 16:01actual value proposition. And I'm, I was just curious what
- 16:07were the pieces that you read about Bitcoin because if my if
- 16:12my timing is right there, Paul Tudor Jones would have been
- 16:15right around then coming out, you know with his bitcoin's
- 16:18going to be the fastest horse this decade his his May 2020 BVI
- 16:23letter. And there were a few other you
- 16:26know Bill Miller and and Stan Druckenmiller were starting to
- 16:29make comments around then. Is that right or am I totally
- 16:32off of my timing there? Yeah, that was it.
- 16:35And then it was it was a friend who I was speaking to who said,
- 16:40yeah, you're just supposed to own a little.
- 16:42I mean, that's how early it was. And so I bought a little and
- 16:47then I started reading. So I was that sort of live, you
- 16:50know, take action and then read, you know, small amount.
- 16:54And and one book I read, which I really like, 'cause I like
- 16:57getting the context was digital gold.
- 16:59I don't know if you guys have heard of that.
- 17:04Yeah, I I read it quite a while ago, and in my recollection of
- 17:10it is that it he recognizes that crypto currencies are digital,
- 17:17digital gold, right. OK, but.
- 17:20But is it specifically focused on Bitcoin?
- 17:22I might be, I might actually be misremembering which one this.
- 17:27It it is mostly on Bitcoin because it's it.
- 17:30It finishes in 2015 and what I liked about it is I love stuff.
- 17:36Frozen in time is what did they say back then?
- 17:40You know, That's why following The Economist's articles over 10
- 17:43years and as I said, it's going to die 1000 times and they were
- 17:46wrong. But I like about digital gold is
- 17:49it gave you a narrative and Popper doesn't even like
- 17:52Bitcoin. I think he's not a fan.
- 17:53No it. Wasn't allowed to buy.
- 17:56But yeah, I don't think he owns much, but it it gave me the
- 18:02background. I understood it.
- 18:03It was from a obviously a disinterested or an unbiased
- 18:07party because he's not a fan and everything that like is a guy.
- 18:14The Argentinian wensis. I thank the guy who had the.
- 18:17Cesarus. Yes, Cesarus Wensis or Wensis
- 18:21Cesarus. I forget how it goes.
- 18:23The latter. And and everything that they're
- 18:26talking about has happened. So I I love the historical
- 18:29perspective. It wasn't the tech that got me
- 18:31that came later on the understanding.
- 18:33I had to get the concept down and then the tech later, so so
- 18:39that was helpful for me. I had to read about it, and then
- 18:41we I went in deeper. Yeah, it so I I definitely did
- 18:45read that book, but that was this the beginning of my altcoin
- 18:49arc. So whatever it was about that
- 18:51book, like it didn't prevent me from taking that that idea of
- 18:56like, OK, these things are digital gold and then and then
- 18:58saying they can be an infinite number of them.
- 19:01So I guess it was missed, or maybe I just missed that part
- 19:05and I needed to learn the hard way.
- 19:07Mark, going back, I'm curious if you can share and it's probably
- 19:12pretty, there's a lot of info there.
- 19:14So you can, you know give us the short version or a longer
- 19:17version. But you referenced 4X being like
- 19:20this Valve and supporting from a crisis previously.
- 19:23Can you talk about where you see or like how you you see
- 19:26mechanically and structurally Bitcoin being able to support
- 19:30and like this kind of easing their transition to a different
- 19:33monetary base? Sure.
- 19:36So what? What when Nixon broke the peg,
- 19:39which is crazy, right? I mean, the fact that, you know,
- 19:42after World War, 243 countries agreed to put all their gold on
- 19:48ships and bring it over during the war down below Maiden Lane
- 19:52and then after Fort Knox is kind of bananas.
- 19:56But that meant that obviously we could rebuild faster.
- 19:59And then the global growth helped a lot and actually was.
- 20:02Beneficial because then we could chew through all our all our
- 20:04debt inflated away in a very efficient global coordination.
- 20:09So there was a purpose behind it.
- 20:10And that held true. When Nixon broke, that trade
- 20:14went crazy. Everyone.
- 20:15So then everyone's own currency started to float against the
- 20:19dollar, not against gold. So then in order to to do trade,
- 20:24you had to then get a relationship, had someone foster
- 20:28an exchange between A&B and I guess what I the, the reason
- 20:33it's relevant to today is that as we know with, you know,
- 20:36Russia invading Ukraine, what's happening in the Middle East,
- 20:40there are disruptions to trade. When trade gets disrupted,
- 20:44growth goes down and people get hurt.
- 20:46You just obviously as growth, as GDP declines, death rates go up.
- 20:53So what happened with the FX is that people found a way to
- 20:57foster trade and that's what I think Bitcoins doing.
- 21:01It's being faster settlements, it's it's serving a need that's
- 21:05slower money and less integral money is bringing to us.
- 21:09So it's it's it's a not a direct analogy, but technology has
- 21:14always provided a solution and Bitcoin was there, FX was the
- 21:19technology at the banks. This time it's not going to
- 21:22involve the banks as much. So that's that's one take away.
- 21:28No, that makes sense. There's a monetary base with
- 21:30integrity, basically that we all agree on.
- 21:32And so it's the intermediary between other currencies that
- 21:35are facilitating trade or economic activity and that we
- 21:38agree on. Yeah, and this is a fascinating
- 21:41framing I've never heard. Typically when bitcoiners talk
- 21:43about Nixon ripping us off the gold standard, Bitcoin's the
- 21:48solution to the problem that that started.
- 21:51But I've never heard like the parallel sort of narrative of
- 21:55oh, it's gonna do something similar to what happened after
- 21:59we got ripped off the gold standard, which is pretty
- 22:02unique. Perspective does paint a picture
- 22:05of optimism moving forward more. That and and and that's it.
- 22:09Because part of our narrative is that there's a problem and no
- 22:14one really wants to hear about, you know the debt problem and
- 22:17you know Lavish brings it up about the about the spiral.
- 22:20And he's not wrong. It's it could take longer and
- 22:24it's it is there we jumped a shark but you don't have to
- 22:27focus on it and and I I agree that we have too much fun out
- 22:31there. I got kids and you know this
- 22:34this whole negative narrative garbage is just creating a real
- 22:38mental health problem with kids in general just makes for a bad
- 22:44mood on the weekends. So I think you know, and and and
- 22:48we know that social media gets sad without getting too, too far
- 22:52afield. Just because mainstream has not
- 22:56adopted it doesn't mean people shouldn't get curious on their
- 22:59own. And that's basically what I
- 23:00think. What I like work with you guys
- 23:02is not everyone in our industry, you know, is sort of, as we
- 23:07found out trustworthy or worth listening to.
- 23:10So I'm trying to, you know, be not too far afield, have a
- 23:17sound, you know, argument or presentation to get people to
- 23:20just take a look because I I agree I think it's way
- 23:25constructive and can, but that's and part of it was, you know
- 23:30what I, as you saw from my publication last week, Jesse, I
- 23:34went front and center with your asset pile.
- 23:37I mean, that's just clear as, you know, rain just wonderful.
- 23:43Thank you. Yeah it it, it really is it.
- 23:48I I when we had some technical difficulties here I was
- 23:52beginning to talk about how you know it's the lifeboat analogy
- 23:58and but it but it's a funny sort of lifeboat analogy because
- 24:01Bitcoin continues to grow and develop and and as the adoption
- 24:04curve progresses more and more people fit in the lifeboat, but
- 24:07the lifeboat grows with it and into a point where it can it can
- 24:11grow into the ship itself, right.
- 24:13So we sort of have this ailing current system and this, this
- 24:19wonderful lifeboat that creates you know an opportunity for
- 24:22constructive growth and development and solution to many
- 24:28of the problems that we are facing with the traditional
- 24:31system at the moment. Such that it, you know it's it
- 24:34really is the only thing that's giving me optimism at this point
- 24:38in time about how things can play out fiscally, economically
- 24:43into the future. Because because that debt spiral
- 24:48is very scary if you don't have a way out.
- 24:53And and as a millennial without Bitcoin, I would not have any
- 24:58optimism about ever being able to retire for example.
- 25:03But with Bitcoin, I have that optimism because it it creates
- 25:07this tailwind for my finances and it allows me to plan for the
- 25:14future in a way that my peers are not.
- 25:17You know, I'm focused on building a family right now and
- 25:22most of my friends are not. And I think that that's just as
- 25:28an an outcome way downstream of having Bitcoin as my store of
- 25:34value currency versus the dollar.
- 25:39And and so you know, there's probably a better way to to
- 25:43encapsulate that that hope, that optimism, that relief that the
- 25:48Bitcoin lifeboat allows for and and and represents.
- 25:54But it's unmistakable that it it can.
- 25:59It has the ability to make a better future for us as
- 26:04individuals and collectively at a time when the math is starting
- 26:08to look a little scary, with the current ship starting to list a
- 26:12little in the water and taking on, you know, a little too much
- 26:16seawater. Yeah.
- 26:19Yeah, I think, I think what Jesse's alluding to is like
- 26:23there's two parts of Bitcoin in the sense of like you have the
- 26:25monetary for preservation of wealth, that obviously matters.
- 26:28But then there's also this lens that you start to to get on the
- 26:32world. And I'm sure you've seen Mark,
- 26:34you know, we discussed of like when you see that there's a
- 26:36like, there's these two parts and it comes up more and more.
- 26:40And you referenced it about pessimism, depression, all the
- 26:44stats that we know that are happening in the US and like
- 26:47globally. And it's one thing to like not
- 26:51know what the problem is because that's already disconcerning and
- 26:53like disorienting. But then even if you know what
- 26:55the problem is, then not having the solution is the second kind
- 27:00of like part of like where you just don't have the hope.
- 27:02And so being able to have both of those from like the
- 27:06Darwinistic, kind of like preservation of wealth and being
- 27:08able to build and and have children, all those things are
- 27:11irrelevant. But then it's also starting to
- 27:13see the the world for what it is in in the problems.
- 27:15Then you can actually diagnose. But then the other part where
- 27:21you're referencing Mark is like on, you know, this stuff's
- 27:24happening and being used now today.
- 27:27And so you made this reference point about 4X and how we can
- 27:29see this kind of like transition.
- 27:30And we've talked about it on previous podcasts on this like
- 27:33Oscillation that we think we'll see over the next decade between
- 27:36like gold, Bitcoin and then whatever the you know, digital
- 27:39currency is whether it's a dollar, CBDC or alternative you
- 27:43know other countries currency but there's all these other and
- 27:46that's already kind of happening Now when you have all these
- 27:48cryptocurrencies in this different trade, we see what
- 27:51happens with Forex or like remittances with Bitcoin.
- 27:54So you can kind of squint and already see the market structure
- 27:56happening and the utility that's being provided it's it's you
- 27:59know without goes without saying it's at a very micro scale.
- 28:03But it's to your point that like these concepts have been
- 28:05delivered for for years now by people that were came way before
- 28:09us and they're playing out. And so we're kind of right in
- 28:12the thick of it in the middle whether it's how we custody and
- 28:15these other things that we're talking about or doing these
- 28:16primitives we're we're building in the financial structure that
- 28:19you can kind of squint and see larger and larger cross country
- 28:25cross you know commodity bases on how you settle with Bitcoin.
- 28:32Yep, it it is there. And I still think the Bitcoin
- 28:36UI, which is what you guys are trying to solve for, is
- 28:40terrible. You know, there was this, I mean
- 28:43relative to to how easy Web Two makes things.
- 28:45And you know, there's this story about AOL back in the day that
- 28:52is early. And Steve Case is saying, you
- 28:55know, we have a problem, why isn't this happening?
- 28:56Why are we getting adoption? And this engineer actually
- 29:02relevant doesn't, But she said, she picked up the phone and said
- 29:07until we get this, until we get a dial tone on on demand, we
- 29:12will not have full scale adoption.
- 29:15I think it took 18 months and it involved connectivity.
- 29:20It involved getting more you know coax as opposed to dial up.
- 29:26So you know we we, we have this throughput, we just don't I
- 29:31think have a great UI which is why you need trusted partners in
- 29:35the beginning and that's why it's going to be, you know, we
- 29:37are a regulatory rapper and through ETS and funds you guys
- 29:44do the custodial work. And as we said in the other
- 29:47call, we support you know sovereign holdings but without
- 29:51going down that one, we need to be a better UI.
- 29:56That's why Bitcoin is only trading at a $780 billion market
- 30:00cap and not, you know, 20 or 100 trillion right now.
- 30:05Yeah, so that's it. It makes sense to me that it'll
- 30:09happen, but no one's thinking about why they need it until
- 30:14they see it. Right.
- 30:16I I like to talk about how there's there's two parts of the
- 30:21digital revolution. There's the digitization of
- 30:24information and there's the digitization of value.
- 30:26And we've lived through the the former that's the Internet and
- 30:30you know the the Internet was started in in the 70s, I think
- 30:35it was 79 like the first really true Internet.
- 30:40And so you know your AOL moment is 15 years into that you know
- 30:49and and we don't think about it that way retrospectively we we
- 30:52think about the Internet as starting in the 90s but that
- 30:55that's not true. It it was already 15 years in
- 30:58the making before AOL came along and that's really that hockey
- 31:02stick in the global adoption point that everyone remembers.
- 31:07So you know, where are we right now?
- 31:09We're 15 years into Bitcoin and and what was the 1st 15 years
- 31:14for the Internet? It was like super clunky, super
- 31:17technical, very hard to find information.
- 31:21You needed to be very technical to understand what the hell to
- 31:24do and you were troubleshooting a lot of it, your own and and
- 31:28eventually those those sticking points were obfuscated away,
- 31:33abstracted away as as we bet got better and better UI and and
- 31:39there therefore the UX improved to a point where you know
- 31:43eventually you you don't even have to click anything to log on
- 31:48to connect to the Internet. You just literally pick up your
- 31:50phone but you know that's way further down the road.
- 31:54But you know in the early 90s you were you were dealing with
- 31:57you you had your own dial up Internet and you had to be
- 32:01running some code on your computer to to connect to the
- 32:05Internet at night. You know, I remember watching my
- 32:07dad struggle with that stuff basically as as like an early
- 32:10Internet adopter and you know, in Bitcoin, we're 15 years in
- 32:17and we're still in that phase like and it's understandable
- 32:19that we are, it's still pretty technical.
- 32:23Things are getting better and better, the apps, the the
- 32:26services, the infrastructure is becoming better.
- 32:29And we're solving some of those problems that prevent mainstream
- 32:32adoption. And you know, at what point does
- 32:35that take off? Don't don't know.
- 32:38Don't know if it's you know external factors that that add
- 32:41up to to make the value proposition for Bitcoin suddenly
- 32:44clear to everybody. ETFs and the marketing that'll
- 32:48come from people like BlackRock saying that Bitcoin should be a
- 32:51part of your portfolio could definitely be a big part of
- 32:53that. But then it's the the technology
- 32:56and the services that keep getting better and and simpler
- 32:59and there's a going to be some sort of point where the majority
- 33:04of people can understand bitcoins value proposition and
- 33:09find it not as technically intimidating as it currently and
- 33:14and historically has been. And that's gonna be that hockey
- 33:17stick moment for Bitcoin adoption too.
- 33:21Well, this leads into a good point.
- 33:23I mean, Mark, you mentioned earlier that people need to get
- 33:25curious 1st and very interested to get your perspective on that
- 33:29and your work at 3 IQ. As you've been building out the
- 33:32research arm there, what are you seeing on your end?
- 33:35Are people getting more curious, so they asking better questions?
- 33:38Jesse mentioned the Black Rock ETF.
- 33:40Has that been a catalyst for increased curiosity?
- 33:44And I I would say it's it is very hard we've we've gone to
- 33:48what I call hand to hand combat where we're travelling more and
- 33:52we're doing shows or you know presentations with financial
- 33:58advisors companies etcetera. And I do believe I think
- 34:03pictures and stories help. I spoke to one advisor about, I
- 34:09said I was amazed at the at the performance distribution of
- 34:15Bitcoin. I didn't realize how much it
- 34:19punched far to the right. It's not a normally distributed
- 34:23performance pattern over any kind of weak months, year or
- 34:27quarter a year. And it's more logarithmic.
- 34:30And that is for a period in time Tesla had that type of
- 34:34distribution. But it it then became a little
- 34:37bit more normal. And I said that's why Black
- 34:41Rock's involved because Bitcoin and BlackRock thinks Bitcoin is
- 34:46going to survive. So that's that's what you know
- 34:49Larry Fink got orange filled by someone and so now they're
- 34:53saying well, it's going to survive and so now let's
- 34:55monetize its performance because the bonds are not providing
- 35:00downside support. So they're looking at it as a
- 35:03remedy to the 6040 among other reasons.
- 35:08And I bring it up because that was a huge utilitarian moment
- 35:13for me coming from the investment side.
- 35:15And when I relayed that to another RIA, they said no one
- 35:19said this, I never realized that.
- 35:21So there's still a lot of Nuggets and the question is
- 35:25always have a nugget around that someone can digest and then walk
- 35:30out from there, but just find out, you know, what they like to
- 35:32eat, what their diet is. So that's that's been a bit more
- 35:37again hand to hand, it's it's hard to do in a publication.
- 35:41It's a little bit easier with these types of podcast.
- 35:43So thanks for having me on. But face to face is still
- 35:48worthwhile because that's how unusual it is to get someone to
- 35:52invest. It really is a tough conversion.
- 35:55It's happening a little faster. We're getting inflows, but
- 35:59that's that's where I'm. As a solution to the the
- 36:04problems of the 6040 portfolio, you know that that resonates
- 36:09with me as like that really is what people should be locking
- 36:13onto with Bitcoin. But what are the other types of
- 36:16like? Depending on what a person likes
- 36:19to eat, you know what narratives they're worried about, or
- 36:22thinking about what are the like the other anecdotes or or facts
- 36:32or, you know, angles that resonate with the Wall Street
- 36:36crowd to wealth managers, various audiences you're
- 36:40speaking to. Making it look like a, you know,
- 36:45understanding technology stocks. So obviously we all know about
- 36:49the Magnificent 7 in the US we have a Canadian audience.
- 36:54So they look at the TSX and that's been you know, dead in
- 36:57the water, think up three and a half, 4% of the year.
- 37:01So they're looking for remedies and if you look at how tech
- 37:05stocks are valued, they have high book to high price to
- 37:10books. You know we we did a piece, we
- 37:12showed that the bank index is like called it 1.2 or .9 price
- 37:18to book, it's it, but it has assets, it's price trades around
- 37:23it. JP Morgan's at a premium and
- 37:25other banks that are at discount.
- 37:27And then you move up the curve to maybe like Visa, which is
- 37:30kind of like not, not not a bank.
- 37:31It's like moving up the curve of trying to dematerialize from the
- 37:35financial system that has a higher price to book.
- 37:39And then you go to NVIDIA and that's like a 40 price to book
- 37:45because you can't use it's book value to value it.
- 37:48Technology stocks are valued on how much, how well management
- 37:53can convert intelligence and strategy using hardware and
- 37:58software and it's a much faster and dynamic work industry.
- 38:06So also cash flow per share is very high for these companies.
- 38:14If you look at Bitcoin and you look at cash flow per token,
- 38:17very high. If you looked at price to book,
- 38:19even if you roll in and say the Bitcoin money network is 10
- 38:22billion, you have a pretty high price to book.
- 38:25So that's how we kind of convert people to say, I know where
- 38:29you're sitting, I know what you look at.
- 38:31Let me show you how I view the, you know, the Bitcoin protocol.
- 38:36It is a technology. It's odd because it's the
- 38:40Internet of money or it's a monetary Internet.
- 38:43You couldn't own the Internet. So let's say it's more like
- 38:46NVIDIA than it is like TCPIP. So that's one way, Jesse, that
- 38:50we've done as well. Yeah, yeah.
- 38:55Makes a lot of sense. It's sort of backwards from how
- 38:59I would have thought about it of like you.
- 39:01You want to. You want to.
- 39:02Focus on that before Jesse that I'm kind of back here, so don't,
- 39:05don't, don't worry about. It but it makes sense because
- 39:08it's just backwards like I I guess I I fall into the trap as
- 39:13as not you know I've I've never been a stocks person but I fall
- 39:18into the trap of thinking man PE ratios are just way too high.
- 39:24But it you're right that it's like kind of a different animal
- 39:26when you're talking about technology.
- 39:28And so a lot of that is warranted.
- 39:31And if it's warranted, it's great that Bitcoin happens to to
- 39:34be something like that, you know?
- 39:37So it's kind of a funny, a funny way of looking at it freshly.
- 39:41Yeah, basically they're the wrong metrics.
- 39:44People are still using some metrics.
- 39:47You know, we look at the Bohr models still, even though we're
- 39:49like, you know, maybe that's not exactly how that stuff flows
- 39:51around, but it's a good starting point for us to walk into, you
- 39:57know, the great structure. Yeah, that's the Is that the
- 40:01soup? The atomic soup one.
- 40:04No, no the the the the Bohr model is the Styrofoam ball with
- 40:08the toothpicks for the electrons flying around.
- 40:11Got it. OK.
- 40:12OK. Yeah, Yep.
- 40:14Yeah, yeah. I think all the things you just
- 40:17explained are important from just providing mental models for
- 40:19people to start to like anchor to something that doesn't you
- 40:22know you can't touch or feel but you you hit a point like
- 40:26business. It's always been relationship
- 40:28driven. You've always needed to meet
- 40:30individuals in in space and meet space to shake hands and look
- 40:34eyes. I feel like marking my
- 40:35experience and I think what you're alluding to it's it's
- 40:37it's pronounced or it's higher like there's higher conversion
- 40:44slash just trust building when it comes to this asset class and
- 40:49meeting because of there's just historically haven't been a
- 40:52trustworthy individuals like you referenced early.
- 40:54But then also the fact that like you're tying some component
- 40:57whether you're it's implicit or explicit like to this asset
- 41:01versus it just going online going to a Coinbase clicking a
- 41:03button and then you're hoping that it's still there when you
- 41:05look for it, it's like I'm looking at somebody in the face.
- 41:08I'm shaking hands. I'm understanding what's
- 41:09happening and that there's a a team of business behind this
- 41:14which makes sense that like it it probably and we think about
- 41:17our business and what you've been doing, it's probably be a
- 41:19heavy part of this for the next couple of years is anchoring to
- 41:22the real world something that doesn't have any kind of like
- 41:24tangible feel in it? Yeah, yeah.
- 41:28And that's why you know your model when you are trying to say
- 41:31you don't have to do it. You can get you know related
- 41:34parties to help. You know just like how you have
- 41:37a trust agreement. You meet with a lawyer and they
- 41:38hold it your you know last long testament or your your other
- 41:44documents. You know this is how we can do
- 41:45it here too. You know that someone calls it
- 41:49not someone. A few folks have highlighted the
- 41:51term skeuomorphic which if you're on you know Bloomberg or
- 41:56something they ring a bell when you use fancy language or
- 41:59something. No no.
- 42:01No jargon language. Yeah, but but it means it's it's
- 42:05like when the automobiles in the beginning had a horse head on
- 42:09them because they wanted people to be familiar.
- 42:12They're used to seeing horses on the streets, not cars.
- 42:15So they may not move out of the way because they don't know what
- 42:18it is. So I I I think that's kind of
- 42:21what we're doing here. Bitcoin doesn't need to be in an
- 42:24ETF, but there's behaviors that are going to be lagging the
- 42:28opportunity that have to be accommodated and that's that's
- 42:31where we are. Thanks for tuning in to the last
- 42:34trade. If you're enjoying the show and
- 42:37want to dive deeper, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com where
- 42:41you'll find a full suite of institutional grade research and
- 42:45analytics including our recently published white paper, Bitcoin's
- 42:49full potential valuation and our new tool, the On Ramp Terminal.
- 42:54Now back to the show. You mentioned bad actors in the
- 42:59space. Obviously last year came with
- 43:01Terra Luna, Celsius block 5 FTX 3 arrows go down the list.
- 43:06How much does a model like the multi institution, multi sig
- 43:10model that on Ramp's going after help people get over the fears
- 43:15of the bad actors in the space? Historically, this idea that you
- 43:18can distribute custody risk amongst multiple trusted
- 43:23institutions, is that a good selling point?
- 43:27Yeah. Well, let let's go back to what
- 43:29we wrote about last year and when when it was happening and
- 43:32you know I came into right at the like week after first rate
- 43:36cut and two months before Tara Luna.
- 43:41So our analyst and I were trying to sort through what was going
- 43:45on, see a pattern and we finally came up with soon unregulated
- 43:51centralized bad actors with bad business models.
- 43:58There's an asset liability mismatch and that last one was a
- 44:01biggie. You know, whether it be Terra
- 44:04Luna, you know with with their model, whether it be 3 arrows,
- 44:10certainly Machinsky, forget the fraud, the business model wasn't
- 44:17really sound Asset liability mismatches, you know, taking
- 44:20down a lot of firms. So that is a big one.
- 44:24Is there leverage involved? Is there an asset liability
- 44:26mismatch? Those are the two biggest.
- 44:28And then is there transparency, You know, it wasn't transparency
- 44:34into you know, 3 arrows. If you read those trustee
- 44:39reports on the emails between the prime brokers and three
- 44:42arrows, they're like, yeah, no problem, we got it.
- 44:45You sure you guys have enough you can make the margin call?
- 44:47Yeah, we'll, we'll do it. Never made.
- 44:51So I I I think having transparency onto it and then
- 44:55knowledge because here's a big one and I'd like to actually
- 44:58take this across the side I want to put it say put a pin in it
- 45:02because I'm I'm not sure I like that term but let's I'd like to
- 45:05focus on this one. FTXS movement of four plus
- 45:11billion out of the FTT deployer wallet in June to Alameda and
- 45:19then back to FTX in September was caught on ether scan.
- 45:23I know we're talking about Bitcoin here but that blockchain
- 45:26had transparency on it. No one looked at it.
- 45:30So I think part of it is the tools are there but no one it's
- 45:33it's too much too fast. So back to on ramp, if you guys
- 45:37can clarify it, provide the provide the transparency and you
- 45:41have that sound unlevered model then I think you know those are
- 45:45the boxes. I think differentiate what
- 45:47you're offering, then what the other bad actors, you know, how
- 45:52people were harmed in 2022. Yeah.
- 45:55I think I think it's important to to take it like to your
- 45:58point, the skeuomorphic don't know that term.
- 46:00But I'll, I'll go with your. I'll go with your.
- 46:07I'll trust your definition in that sense of like how do you
- 46:09anchor back to what people know And this idea of people know
- 46:14financial institutions they know banks but there's this natural
- 46:17aspect of Bitcoin that's different than other assets that
- 46:19you can split up that trust in in in movement.
- 46:23But to your point, Mark, it's like there has to be an
- 46:25education and this is really where you kind of like joke
- 46:28around it's like we're so early that you know it's obviously
- 46:31like maybe we have, but I I don't believe so and I think a
- 46:34lot of people this call would agree that we haven't really
- 46:37figured out custody. So we're so early that we
- 46:38haven't even figured out just like how to hold the asset long
- 46:40term and this idea of, you know, like how do you actually get
- 46:49somebody to earnestly look at the asset.
- 46:51And I generally will go as far as I say, it's like the
- 46:54education is almost secondary because people can't earnestly
- 46:57look at it because historically if you look at the long tail of
- 47:01firms that have existed in the space, they don't exist very
- 47:04long. So all people generally know is
- 47:06that if I buy it, I can only buy so much because it's there's a
- 47:09good chance that I won't get to have it or it won't be around
- 47:12and it's not my own. It doesn't have to be, they get
- 47:14hacked. It could just be like the the,
- 47:16you know, the third party that they're leveraging.
- 47:17And so I think by anchoring too and it doesn't have to be like
- 47:22on RAMPS model, it's more of this whole notion is really
- 47:25valid of like not your keys, not your coins hardware or things
- 47:30offline. Because at the end of the day
- 47:32and this is something we used previously, it's like the keys
- 47:34don't get up and walk away. So if you have a single hardware
- 47:38device the reason why it's it's lasted and been a A use case is
- 47:41because that that hardware device if you back it up and you
- 47:43put it somewhere it doesn't get up and walk away.
- 47:45Now there's things that can happen.
- 47:46You want redundancy built in as the the net value of your as the
- 47:50asset appreciates as a percentage of your net worth and
- 47:53that's where like multi say comes in And then those keys
- 47:55don't also walk away because you distribute them and there's
- 47:58obviously like trade-offs with that.
- 48:00And then you you pick that up into this like multi institution
- 48:03model where now there's different institutions that have
- 48:05those keys offline. They don't plug themselves in.
- 48:07They have like governance processes and controls in place
- 48:11and that's historically what financial institutions had and
- 48:15that they have processes and now you distribute that where if
- 48:18one's a bad actor you have this ability.
- 48:20So to your point, Mark, I think that like the skeuomorphic, like
- 48:23this idea of multiple institutions and the process
- 48:25starts to anchor back to the the old world and has a check on all
- 48:29the things you just referenced with FTX.
- 48:32But also to your point, there's a lot of education that goes
- 48:34into play and like why it's a standard, why it's not like
- 48:36proprietary to a certain firm, why it's you know the it's
- 48:39native to the protocol and all those things.
- 48:42But I think just like everything you start somewhere and then you
- 48:44start to build up and it ultimately with trust and
- 48:46reputation and other firms come in and doing this you start to
- 48:50build a standard in the industry and that's part partially where
- 48:52a lot of the folks on is calling on ramp believe it's like we're
- 48:55establishing kind of a standard and then others will will follow
- 48:58and it's generally like all things and technology.
- 49:00It's not like the coin bases of the world.
- 49:02It's a tier 3 exchange. It's a tier 3 fund or some other
- 49:06kind of family office that starts And then as others demand
- 49:09it, others start to look around and the game theory starts to
- 49:11dictate. Or you know like hey, are you
- 49:13going to do this or why aren't you doing this And then you see
- 49:15it establish. As you know it's the same thing
- 49:18with the banks right now and and BlackRock getting into Bitcoin.
- 49:20It was. It was starting to become too
- 49:22big to ignore. Yep, Yep.
- 49:25And it will take time. Yeah.
- 49:31And that, I mean that's the question is how much time, like
- 49:35how much do you think the macroeconomic tailwinds will
- 49:41force people to become more curious like the, I guess
- 49:45pivoting this back to the macro backdrop, do you think it's
- 49:50chaotic enough to force the issue on people learning about
- 49:54Bitcoin quicker? Not in the USIII think that.
- 49:58You know we people in our industry talk about the global S
- 50:02Argentina just let their peso go as not as promised but part of
- 50:08plan by 54% yesterday. Yeah, and and that's, I mean it,
- 50:15it is on our neighbours are on fire, so it is happening there.
- 50:20I think here it does have to be dressed up as a delectable
- 50:25delight that can maybe be passed on to your children and
- 50:30partially understood, but an amount that won't hurt you.
- 50:34If I had to be put my salesman hat on which I have one, we're a
- 50:37small firm and I do try to get people to buy it based on our
- 50:41research, is is exactly that. It's an investment vehicle.
- 50:48It's full blown When it metamorphosizes, metamorphizes
- 50:53for its when the metamorphosis happens and Bitcoin becomes what
- 50:58I think is a settlement layer and price, you know, transforms
- 51:01from being priced in Fiat to being the unit of measure that's
- 51:05that's not even worth talking about.
- 51:07People are already starting to text their phone on their phone
- 51:09by the time you bring up that topic.
- 51:11So I I do think the investment thesis is a big one for getting
- 51:17people involved now and the benefit of that for the longer
- 51:21plan. If you are a Bitcoin believer
- 51:23that it it's real services being fully distributed, you want to
- 51:28get as many people in now with 50 to 150 basis points of their
- 51:31portfolio. Don't have me even think about
- 51:33it being a unit of measure in 2010, 20-30 years.
- 51:37Just have them be in it now, yeah.
- 51:42Do you have a strong opinion on like you know how these ETFs
- 51:46manifest themselves in the long tail like risk associated where
- 51:49if you have to get you know sexy up your version not yours, but
- 51:53in general the market's version that people may hear you know,
- 51:58leverage or yield and all the things associated.
- 52:01And we kind of get orders of magnitude larger kind of carnage
- 52:05I guess for lack of better words that we saw in 22.
- 52:08But at the like institutional level, have you, have you
- 52:10thought anything about that? Do you?
- 52:11Do you you want to read your perspectives to see if the
- 52:16issuer or custodian can rehypothecate the coins?
- 52:20That's one. I I don't believe that's in
- 52:22there, in the ones. I haven't read all 13 by any
- 52:26stretch, but I know what our ours are in cold storage
- 52:31separate. When I read the BlackRock one,
- 52:36there wasn't any language at all about that and I sort of
- 52:40wondered if the lack of addressing that topic implies
- 52:44that they would potentially follow, you know, ETF normal
- 52:50practices and consider rehypothecating.
- 52:55I don't know the, the biggest discussion now and suggest
- 52:59that's something to go back. I mean definitely for me to go
- 53:01back and look at the, the part that is on the table now is
- 53:05whether or not the, I think the APS, the redemption creation
- 53:11folks, the broker dealers, whether they can do in kind or
- 53:15whether they have to do cash. And I think I believe a purist,
- 53:21we'd like to see it be in kind in order to reduce the potential
- 53:27for spoofing or more paper Bitcoin even temporarily for a
- 53:31day or two being on the books. So that's that's the biggest
- 53:36piece I I think Blackrock's going back to try to get it to
- 53:39be in kind. Yeah, that's right.
- 53:41They're they're one of two that's fighting for that, which
- 53:45sort of surprised me. Maybe Larry Fink really, really
- 53:48is more of a believer that I thought.
- 53:51It yeah, I I I agree. I agree.
- 53:55Well, while we're on this topic, obviously there's 13 ETF filings
- 54:00out there to assume that most of them will get approved at some
- 54:05point potentially in the next month or two.
- 54:09How do you see the competition amongst these ETS playing out?
- 54:13You see Pareto distribution of who gets the most AUM versus
- 54:17others. How?
- 54:17How vicious is this competition for AUM gonna be?
- 54:22And and and Mark maybe you want to tell everybody what you
- 54:26shared in the webinar of like your knowledge and and
- 54:30expectations about when and the likelihood of of approval?
- 54:36OK, so the the Ark investment isn't is the next firm up with a
- 54:47or Ark has a final deadline of January 10th and the SEC has the
- 54:53ability to pass twice. If they pass the third time on a
- 54:57application, which Ark did a while ago, they have to give a
- 55:00new reason and it'll be a final kill shot.
- 55:05We don't think that's going to happen because on August 29th,
- 55:11Judge Naomi Rao, who's the who's the Chief Justice in the the
- 55:18Washington DC Federal Second Circuit Court, said that the SE
- 55:25CS argument was arbitrary and capricious, a term she used
- 55:28eight times. And.
- 55:31And their argument was that yes, yes, the SEC approved a futures
- 55:36based ETF for Bitcoin in 2021. I think but that's very
- 55:44different because the CFTC overseas it, they understand,
- 55:48you know the eight or the 9:30 to 4:00 trading.
- 55:51So they surveil it well, they understand the futures of the
- 55:55underlying that underlines the ETF.
- 55:58But this spot market, holy moly, no one knows what's going on
- 56:01there. You got finance out, you know,
- 56:03without even a headquarters trading 70% of the market,
- 56:06there's no way we can know what's going on.
- 56:08And the judge in March when they, when the hearing happened
- 56:11said that's an arbitrary and capricious approach essentially,
- 56:17which she then used later. It's illogical because the
- 56:21future is based on the spot. How can you approve a future
- 56:24without a spot? And and we and we belabor that
- 56:27point because for the listeners out there think of that a future
- 56:31is based on a spot whether it's the E Minis in the S&P based on
- 56:37the S&P index or gold on the gold spot, they're based on the
- 56:42spot. If you don't trust the spot, why
- 56:45would you do a futures. It made no sense.
- 56:47So that's why in her 21 page opinion, her last word, she says
- 56:53what she felt and deemed their argument to be unlawful.
- 56:59Strongest words I've ever read in any court filing and I was
- 57:04involved in distress for about 10-12 years.
- 57:07So I think they heard her loud and clear and that's why they
- 57:11didn't appeal on October 13th. And if you look at your Bitcoin
- 57:15charts that's when Bitcoin started take off.
- 57:18So they're going to approve it or they're messing with a with
- 57:24censure and potential civil I don't think they knew criminal
- 57:28but but civil liability from the court.
- 57:31So generally and that was a big long segue because that's how
- 57:35strongly I feel it's going to happen and it's going to happen
- 57:39sometimes people think the 8th to the 10th.
- 57:43So that's when we think the approval will happen.
- 57:45The part I don't know fully well and maybe the other Jesse you
- 57:48whether can is whether or not BlackRock and others are can
- 57:53roll it out that day. I don't think that's clear.
- 57:57Yeah the the speculation I've I've seen from the the Bloomberg
- 58:03ETF guys is is their their base cases that the SEC just kind of
- 58:07quietly stamps them all at the same time so that nobody has
- 58:11like a leg up or gets to claim a win you know?
- 58:15Yeah. Yeah.
- 58:16And I've heard like ranges of approval to launch anywhere from
- 58:22days to 45 days. For some reason that 45 day
- 58:26figure has been out there, but I believe somebody was saying that
- 58:30futures Bitcoin ETF, when that was approved, it launched three
- 58:34to five days after. Who knows if there will be some
- 58:38different outcome for this, but that's what I've heard.
- 58:42And Mark, what do you what do you expect from your your
- 58:44previous colleagues and peers like are they finally gonna go
- 58:48streaking with you Like what What's your phone gonna be like
- 58:51what's what what's your phone gonna be like that week when
- 58:55that when you know it it finally does get approved.
- 58:59I will get some pings I think. I think there will, there will
- 59:01be some pings and and unfortunately it'll be at 6070
- 59:07thousand that's when you're going to get most of people
- 59:09buying I believe. Yeah, I I mean Marty's been
- 59:13through this a little, little longer than the rest of us, but
- 59:19in invariably it ends up being like well north of a new all
- 59:23time high. That's when that's when my
- 59:25friends start taking interest. And so if that was the play out
- 59:28again that we're talking 100K before people even start being
- 59:32like should I buy some now is now a good time, which will be
- 59:36very frustrating to see you again.
- 59:38It must be. It must be a nice world to be
- 59:40with the the big boys. When you think about you
- 59:42reference the October filing But then BlackRock had announced in
- 59:46the the summer. So like you know it's very, very
- 59:49nice alignment And then you know two days ago with Google
- 59:51relaxing the, you know the ad spend which they had put in like
- 59:562020 like oh it's so nice, so convenient going into 20 as
- 59:59these like everybody goes, you know crazy on spend to to market
- 1:00:03themselves like just it's nice, nice beautiful dance into the to
- 1:00:07the big ball. I I don't think we're prepared
- 1:00:10for for the marketing arms of these investment giants suddenly
- 1:00:16telling the world, telling every American with an investment
- 1:00:21portfolio at least you should really have some Bitcoin like
- 1:00:26that, that's gonna be a very different world to live in very
- 1:00:29soon. And what do you mean by that,
- 1:00:33Jesse, that they won't be able to do it or that the impact
- 1:00:36would be meaningful? Yeah, that that for the for
- 1:00:40bitcoin's entire life, all the media on it has been, you know,
- 1:00:47dubious at best. It has been this is a scam.
- 1:00:50This is Internet drug money. You know, it's used by
- 1:00:54criminals. And we're not we we've never
- 1:00:58lived in a world where BlackRock is saying hey this is a great
- 1:01:05product you should buy some you know and and not not just
- 1:01:09BlackRock but these thirteen other EDETF providers really
- 1:01:13like as soon as those ETFs go live all of Wall Street has an
- 1:01:16incentive to to then funnel money to these new products and
- 1:01:20take a cut along the way. That's going to be kind of a a a
- 1:01:25light switch I think in terms of what people are exposed to with
- 1:01:29regard to you know how they're shaping their perspective about
- 1:01:33what Bitcoin is and is it a good idea or a bad idea.
- 1:01:36So suddenly we're going to go from like, it's just kind of the
- 1:01:40sketchy thing that nobody really talked about.
- 1:01:41And there's occasionally a very negative news piece to, you
- 1:01:45know, investment marketing saying it's a good idea that's
- 1:01:50going to be pretty night and day.
- 1:01:53I agree. I agree.
- 1:01:54I mean, over the weekend, even people I talked to in the
- 1:01:59industry outside, they're like, Oh yeah, wasn't that, you know,
- 1:02:01they just talked about the SPF, you know, the guy was hugging
- 1:02:05Tom Brady's Super Bowl like that is that's going to have a bit of
- 1:02:09a tail in people's minds, unfortunately.
- 1:02:13And I, I agree with you about the impact.
- 1:02:17Wall Street loves transactions. You know, Bitcoin captures
- 1:02:21energy, Marty. You know, you've, you've lived
- 1:02:24it from the ground up, you know whether it's capturing it from
- 1:02:28sustainable or other energy and transferring and minting a coin,
- 1:02:33it captures energy. Wall Street does that in trades.
- 1:02:37They take in money. They have an idea, they have a
- 1:02:39bid, they've asked, they tell a story and they capture a a
- 1:02:44transaction in time and price and they take a Commission.
- 1:02:48So this is going to be big. They're going to say what I do
- 1:02:51something. It has 80 basis points on it.
- 1:02:53When the other ETFs are, you know, anywhere from a nickel to
- 1:02:5725 basis points, this is going to get attention.
- 1:03:02Well, and that also leads me to question too.
- 1:03:05Like Wall Street is vaunted as the experts of the financial
- 1:03:11world and trading and how to allocate money appropriately in
- 1:03:16size and at the right time. Like in we're talking about
- 1:03:20retail reaching out to us above an all time high.
- 1:03:23That's the one thing I'm wondering is like how many of
- 1:03:27these trading desks actually recognize the opportunity and
- 1:03:31will get the timing and sizing right at the beginning of this
- 1:03:37gun being shot to start the race with the ETF being approved?
- 1:03:40What? Do you think, Jess?
- 1:03:44I don't think, I think they're they're noobs.
- 1:03:46I think they're Bitcoin noobs and there's no way around it.
- 1:03:50And and you know I I write about this sometimes the the hubris of
- 1:03:55having having training in finance and business and you
- 1:04:00think you know and you think you know about money.
- 1:04:02You think you know about investing and you think you know
- 1:04:04assets. And so you're going to bring
- 1:04:05that hubris to this. And we're going to get a whole
- 1:04:09wave of that. And Bitcoin will, will welcome
- 1:04:13these newbies in and will some of them will make a lot of money
- 1:04:17and some of them will make a lot of the classic mistakes that
- 1:04:20that we made in 2017. And you know, the learning curve
- 1:04:25is going to begin for a lot of them at that point in time.
- 1:04:29And that's OK. You know, like as we're talking
- 1:04:32about this, a thought popped in my head of like, how's Marty,
- 1:04:36How's Marty feeling about the suits arriving here?
- 1:04:39And you know, the reality of it here is what we're talking about
- 1:04:43is the suits are here to pump your bags and and tell you that
- 1:04:46they're that you know that the big boys are here now.
- 1:04:50But yeah, which will be annoying, but it will also be
- 1:04:56Bitcoin growing up and Bitcoin succeeding and it comes with the
- 1:04:59territory. So I it's a whole, it's a whole
- 1:05:02mixed bag. It's going to be very annoying
- 1:05:04to have Wall Street telling everybody about, oh, we just
- 1:05:07discovered Bitcoin, but great, I'm glad that they're joining
- 1:05:12the party. Yeah.
- 1:05:14Well on that like this has come up from I don't know I think
- 1:05:18Larry talked about it Larry Leopard on on previous pod.
- 1:05:21But like because of the we're talking about the reflexivity of
- 1:05:23of the the asset and then like it go in no bid and and how can
- 1:05:27people facilitate the trades. Do you have any like take on
- 1:05:30that mark or like where you see that because again that's the
- 1:05:32thing that is not is so foreign to the market is there's a world
- 1:05:35where they can't find or source enough liquidity.
- 1:05:37And that's I think that things like the question that's going
- 1:05:40to be hanging out there across desks, whether a crypto native
- 1:05:43desk or in the traditional finance space.
- 1:05:47Yeah and and that is a big deal when the new, you know we just
- 1:05:52talked about transactions when you have an IPO, the issuer
- 1:05:55usually gives the the book running manager a green shoe,
- 1:05:59the ability to pull down more to satisfy or to short and then
- 1:06:03cover lower. So they there's a there's a
- 1:06:07creation mechanism beyond what is transparent as you said, you
- 1:06:12can't do that with with Bitcoin. In fact, going back to the
- 1:06:15specifics in that January 8th to 10th window where we expect it's
- 1:06:22the SEC to approve all 13. I think we're in agreement on
- 1:06:26that or at least that's it. I I agree with that and I think
- 1:06:29Marty said as well, when that happens, two things are going to
- 1:06:34happen. Folks like Grayscale may be able
- 1:06:35to convert their existing trust. Fidelity has a wise origin
- 1:06:41trust. They'll likely offer that
- 1:06:43conversion to their clients and should probably take it.
- 1:06:47And there might be a few other trusts so that'll be a
- 1:06:52conversion that might allow for some selling.
- 1:06:55But any new orders have to be bought on that day.
- 1:07:00There's no pre buying big. You know, I I don't believe, I
- 1:07:04don't know, I don't believe that they're pre buying this.
- 1:07:07So will there be a a gap in this, this, this absolutely
- 1:07:14there could be a gap. You know you don't have gold
- 1:07:16sitting you know at the London Stock Exchange they can you know
- 1:07:20this is very different. So that's why we we, that's why
- 1:07:25I did the piece with you Jesse last week is we started looking
- 1:07:29evaluation model because you have to talk price because it's
- 1:07:32going to move and it'll be volatile to just like we saw
- 1:07:36last week with the you know down 1015% move.
- 1:07:40This is very different. To answer your question Michael,
- 1:07:43this is new to Wall Street. They don't understand it.
- 1:07:45They like to control processes and they do not control supply
- 1:07:48on this. Perfectly said yeah, I, I, I I
- 1:07:53think that's a big a big question with these ETFs.
- 1:07:56And I think that it's something that that people are generally
- 1:08:00assuming incorrectly about how this will play out where like on
- 1:08:06the day that ETFs are approved doesn't.
- 1:08:10Does that mean there will be suddenly you know Blackrock's
- 1:08:13been waiting to deploy 2% of of their clients assets into
- 1:08:18Bitcoin and boom you know you suddenly rock it up to 100,000
- 1:08:23+. I I I don't think so because I
- 1:08:26think you know the mechanics you described there's there's a
- 1:08:29moment in time where suddenly it's possible for people to
- 1:08:32start allocating into Bitcoin and and and for these ETFs to
- 1:08:36start purchasing Bitcoin to enable that.
- 1:08:40But it's you know, I I don't think that there's like people
- 1:08:43sitting on the sideline just chomping at the bit waiting to
- 1:08:45get in who haven't, you know, already found a way to get
- 1:08:49exposure to Bitcoin. But what it does is it adds this
- 1:08:53this ability for capital to start flowing in in these new
- 1:08:58channels and continue flowing in.
- 1:09:00And so like that's one thing about the mechanics that I think
- 1:09:04people are like assuming incorrectly.
- 1:09:07It will suddenly skyrocket. I we could totally have a gap up
- 1:09:11because you know, if there is suddenly, you know, if there's
- 1:09:16some amount of excitement to buy on that day and the and the
- 1:09:21total shortage of interest and selling because suddenly there's
- 1:09:24an ETF and so why would you sell?
- 1:09:26We could, we could have a gap up.
- 1:09:27But I think that gap up is you know and Mark, I think you're
- 1:09:31thinking this is it, it could be maybe it's 10,000, but it's
- 1:09:35probably not going to be like suddenly we're at 200,000.
- 1:09:39I think, I think there's there's something worth like also it's
- 1:09:43anecdotal but like we can make the case that the existing stock
- 1:09:47of Bitcoin being held is being held by the most sophisticated
- 1:09:50Bitcoin holder in basically the past 15 years.
- 1:09:53And what I mean by that is you had the run up in 17, those were
- 1:09:57like, you know a lot of O GS people have their price points,
- 1:09:59the price sells or people sell the price you go.
- 1:10:04And we've oscillated you know back and forth from like 1718
- 1:10:08hovered in this like range but then going in 20 late 2020-2021,
- 1:10:14yeah, this new entrance into the market.
- 1:10:17But a lot of people were shaken out and what I mean
- 1:10:19sophisticated, I mean like shaken out from positions that
- 1:10:21they held on all the quote UN quote bad actors in the space.
- 1:10:26And we I think Marty mentioned and there's like the data behind
- 1:10:29kind of longest bear market. So you've kind of had it, you've
- 1:10:32had this chance to not only shake out people like
- 1:10:35unwillingly based on just they thought they held Bitcoin that
- 1:10:39doesn't exist and they're they're sitting in bankruptcy,
- 1:10:42you know court and everybody else was sitting in whether it's
- 1:10:45a better exchange or in in cold storage.
- 1:10:47But then we've been in this long bear market for people to
- 1:10:49fortify positions, increase positions where I think again
- 1:10:54making this case of like we've basically SAT roughly 25,000,
- 1:10:59you know give or take for five years, you ran to 20 and 17, we
- 1:11:03kind of ran up to 68. But we've like oscillated
- 1:11:05between on average in this in this area where this next leg
- 1:11:10up. There's a lot of people that
- 1:11:11aren't really their position for a longer term hold.
- 1:11:15And obviously this is like anecdotal, but you can start to
- 1:11:17make that case of who's holding Bitcoin is not the same holder
- 1:11:20that existed in a net you entered in 2020 and 2021 coupled
- 1:11:25with newer liquidity pools coming in.
- 1:11:27It just it's a it's ripe for, you know what we're talking
- 1:11:30about this like gap up or explosive setup.
- 1:11:35Yep. Yeah, and that's a look.
- 1:11:38And I put a chart that unchanged as posted earlier today just to
- 1:11:42quantify all this, Bitcoin's up what, 100 and more than 2 1/2 X
- 1:11:48this year? And only 12.9% of the coins have
- 1:11:51moved in the last three months. And So what you're describing,
- 1:11:54Michael, it's really playing out in these hotto waves.
- 1:11:56You see these peaks of the orange usually when the price
- 1:12:01goes up. But if you look at what's
- 1:12:02happening right now, despite the fact we're up well over 100%
- 1:12:07this year, it's it's not peaking.
- 1:12:08People are not moving. Yeah, and go actually, can you
- 1:12:13pull that, pull that back up where where, when that first
- 1:12:15time it hit 40K, where's the if you hover over I'm trying to
- 1:12:19look at. It's a tweet, so.
- 1:12:21I know I'm just but I'm just trying to think is that 21
- 1:12:25probably like 21 right there like that peak, that last circle
- 1:12:30that was roughly the the last kind of 40K run up the huddle
- 1:12:35the yeah. People are unfazed by by
- 1:12:39unimpressed by 40K right now. And you know I think this, this,
- 1:12:42this is goes back to there's a very good case to be made that
- 1:12:47right now the the spring is compressed for a variety of
- 1:12:52factors. And I, I think Michael's right
- 1:12:54that you know we've been in this zone for quite some time now,
- 1:12:59really five years is that's fair You know that that we've been in
- 1:13:03this sort of transitional phase for the last five years maybe
- 1:13:07even you could call it the last two bull markets of this asset
- 1:13:12is no longer just a a toy for crypto anarchists and it's now
- 1:13:17like becoming digital gold, but it's not quite there yet.
- 1:13:21And then looking forward, there's a pretty distinct new
- 1:13:24era on the horizon of like this is digital gold for the
- 1:13:29investment community like starting in a month, you know.
- 1:13:33So we've been in this compressed spring zone for five years of it
- 1:13:38being in this like stepping stone to to Bitcoin, graduating
- 1:13:42to the next stage of its life and and and you know, graduating
- 1:13:47into becoming a global store value asset and we're right on
- 1:13:52the cusp of that moment happening.
- 1:13:55So you know, I, I, I think I, I did some analysis earlier this
- 1:13:59year of like what's the, what's the probability that this next
- 1:14:05bull market is bigger than the previous one.
- 1:14:07And yeah, kind of impossible to say but but I I, I pegged pegged
- 1:14:13it ultimately at like 30 to 40% chance that next this bull
- 1:14:17market, the next two years is a bigger bull market than the one
- 1:14:22we saw in in 2020-2021. Specifically because in that era
- 1:14:28we had, we had the, you know the negative factors, the headwinds
- 1:14:34of the China mining ban and then the pivot from QE to QT by the
- 1:14:39end of 2021, which just kind of cut short the the mania that I
- 1:14:43think would have happened under normal conditions.
- 1:14:47So we had this, this very unfortunately timed headwinds
- 1:14:50occur in 2021 that caused it to I think be a less explosive bull
- 1:14:56market than it otherwise would have been.
- 1:14:58And right now we're in the in the opposite conditions of we
- 1:15:01are in QT. And I think it's probable that
- 1:15:05they'll be pivoting back to QE if they, you know, they sort of
- 1:15:09already have liquidity is already up into 2024 plus the
- 1:15:15ETFs plus, you know the sovereign debt crisis and and
- 1:15:21global macro things going on with Argentina and and
- 1:15:27elsewhere. And the case for Bitcoin is
- 1:15:29suddenly clear. All those are all those things
- 1:15:32are tailwinds that could mean that this next bull market ends
- 1:15:36up being more explosive for the first time ever, more explosive
- 1:15:40than the bull market before it. Not my base case, but the the
- 1:15:44the spring is compressed because we've been in this same price
- 1:15:47zone for so long despite all this development that's
- 1:15:50happened. And the fact of the matter is
- 1:15:52that a month from now, we're in a totally new era for Bitcoin.
- 1:15:58Yeah, the we, we haven't really touched on the on the whole
- 1:16:07digital gold part, but it's about I think for the viewers or
- 1:16:14listeners. If you look at the amount of our
- 1:16:18economy has gone online in the digital realm, no one's really
- 1:16:21looking to build warehouses to get people to get in the cars to
- 1:16:24visit them too often, you know baseball game, a concert
- 1:16:31etcetera. But with more the economy going
- 1:16:35online to have a monetary layer that settles every 10 minutes is
- 1:16:38a big deal. It's it's an odd concept but
- 1:16:40just it's been talked about for three decades and that's
- 1:16:43something that you know you can ask Jesse or myself or anyone on
- 1:16:46here for information we can give it to you.
- 1:16:49So yes it is digital gold, We are in a coiled spring.
- 1:16:54We are priced along with equities and bonds in a an
- 1:16:58environment that is QT ridden. So we're already pricing pretty
- 1:17:01bad things. We haven't priced in QE, we
- 1:17:04haven't priced in fully the ETF yet.
- 1:17:07And if you look at Bitcoin in particular versus stocks as we
- 1:17:12said, it punches to the right, it has such a positive skew
- 1:17:17because of events and adoption and it solves a a problem.
- 1:17:20So you're 30 to 30%, you know bigger bull market is, is is a
- 1:17:28fair to conservative in my opinion.
- 1:17:30I there's just a lot of data that supports.
- 1:17:34That it's just, yeah, go ahead. Chelsea was gonna say it's funny
- 1:17:38you mentioned potential quantitative easing coming.
- 1:17:41Funnily enough, as we're recording this, Jerome pal is
- 1:17:45going through his meeting and one of the headlines out of
- 1:17:49there is most Fed officials expect Rate cuts in 2024
- 1:17:52Bitcoins ripping interesting today.
- 1:17:58So, so they have, they have come out and said that now.
- 1:18:00So the the narrative they've they've rolled out the carpet in
- 1:18:04advance of that happening. That's what that says to me,
- 1:18:07right? Like they don't want anything to
- 1:18:09ever be a surprise to the market.
- 1:18:11So they're they're priming the market for that, eventually
- 1:18:14coming sometime soon now. We heard it from Marty first,
- 1:18:19folks. You heard it from Marty.
- 1:18:21Seriously, that's that's a big difference.
- 1:18:25Yeah, you all be hearing this on Friday.
- 1:18:27It'll be a couple days late, but we're, the, the pros in this
- 1:18:30talk are hearing it now from Marty.
- 1:18:34Yeah, Bitcoin approaching 43,000 again.
- 1:18:38Marty, are you are are they gonna start calling you Marty
- 1:18:41the Fed Whisperer? I hey, I'm not at Nick Tamaros.
- 1:18:46I'm not at his level yet. But if I keep keep my eyes on
- 1:18:50the tweet deck long enough, maybe I could be, you know, but
- 1:18:55I did. I know we got to wrap up here
- 1:18:57soon, but I did want to bring it back to the discussion about the
- 1:19:00immediate demand post ETF launch and particularly focused on
- 1:19:04BlackRock and that could be completely out of bounds with
- 1:19:10this idea. But is there the potential like
- 1:19:13once they launch the ETF, maybe they don't want to wait for
- 1:19:16demand for new customers to buy into the ETF?
- 1:19:20Could they put the ETF in a commodities basket?
- 1:19:22Because I'm looking at, look when you pull up the GSCI index
- 1:19:26that they have tracking commodities and if you look at
- 1:19:29historical performance, it's not doing great right now.
- 1:19:32And if they want it to bolster the returns in their commodities
- 1:19:35portfolios like Bitcoin has been deemed A commodity by the CFTC.
- 1:19:40Is that an Ave. they could go through?
- 1:19:41Or could they put get exposure to Bitcoin in these commodity
- 1:19:48portfolios via their own ETF product, something I'm
- 1:19:50completely ignorant to? I'll I'll give a a shot at that.
- 1:19:55I I know it's it's deemed an asset by the IRS.
- 1:20:00I think the SEC has stated on a publicly that it's a commodity.
- 1:20:06I do know that BlackRock has an unconstrained bond fund and they
- 1:20:09could change the allocation there or a molten up bond fund,
- 1:20:13a multi asset fund. So yes they could have captive
- 1:20:17funds where they control the allocation.
- 1:20:19So that could happen. Yeah, my my thinking there Marty
- 1:20:25is that they would probably surprise the holders of the
- 1:20:30existing holders of that fund, the commodities fund who most of
- 1:20:35those investors probably don't think that Bitcoin is a a valid
- 1:20:38commodity. And so they would be maybe
- 1:20:41pissed off to be like why, why are you changing, why are you
- 1:20:44putting Bitcoin in My Portfolio all of a sudden.
- 1:20:46So they, they may may not want to surprise their, you know
- 1:20:52their clients with that, but I think Mark's right they they
- 1:20:55could and if they really want to deliver performance that's what
- 1:21:00they should do. So who knows?
- 1:21:03Right, because even though I set a multi asset fund which has
- 1:21:05more latitude on on asset types, they would have to sign an asset
- 1:21:10and say it's a commodity or digital asset and maybe that's
- 1:21:14not you know in the original prospectus.
- 1:21:17So yeah, I got I got some homework to do to figure out if
- 1:21:21if an agency has deemed it to be a full commodity in writing, and
- 1:21:27I I don't know if that's the case.
- 1:21:28Maybe that's why this ETF matters.
- 1:21:32Yeah, no, I just had that that harebrained thought while you
- 1:21:36were talking earlier, Jesse. It's like, I mean they don't
- 1:21:38have to wait for the manage of their clients.
- 1:21:40They have a bunch of other funds that they could dump it into.
- 1:21:43Yeah, I so I'm hoping, I I do want to say I'm very
- 1:21:48constructive on the on this on this year and this first quarter
- 1:21:53and there's going to be volatility.
- 1:21:55Grayscale could see some redemptions.
- 1:21:57There could be a lag between the announcement when Amy shoots up
- 1:22:01to you know up 10K like Jesse said from today's levels and it
- 1:22:07could go back down when it's not met.
- 1:22:09There's going to be volatility no doubt, but we love the
- 1:22:13trajectory on on the year. Yeah, I I kind of have this, I
- 1:22:19have this bad feeling this it's probably pattern recognition at
- 1:22:22this point of like people are a little too excited as about the
- 1:22:26ETFs as like the saviour that's going to send the Bitcoin price
- 1:22:30soaring. And historically whenever those
- 1:22:34events happen or anything like this, it's very bullish in
- 1:22:39advance. It becomes a a buy the rumor,
- 1:22:41sell the news event, you know, where like very exciting Bitcoin
- 1:22:46suddenly up a bunch. Maybe it gaps up 1000 or 5000 or
- 1:22:5010,000 and then it turns out there's actually not like
- 1:22:55sustained demand created by this ETF yet.
- 1:23:00Possibly that's a possible scenario and then the bottom
- 1:23:04falls out and we go back towards where we were.
- 1:23:07But the reality is that that that new channel is now live and
- 1:23:12that demand keeps growing through those channels and that
- 1:23:18has a cumulative impact over time.
- 1:23:21So you know, whatever happens, the volatility will be there and
- 1:23:25and it'll be driven a lot in large part by speculators who
- 1:23:28are already in the market. I think trying to position in
- 1:23:31advance of it misjudging how much it changes demand day 2 and
- 1:23:38and but it and probably underestimating how much it
- 1:23:41changes demand for Bitcoin. You know Day 300.
- 1:23:45I know Jesse's playing devil's advocate, but just to, you know,
- 1:23:49the, the, the, the opposite side of that is what we reference
- 1:23:52like all the marketing push, it's like you can't give up,
- 1:23:55right? You can't like let up because of
- 1:23:57somebody else winning out the gate.
- 1:23:59So I if that's the idea, then they're going to be relentless
- 1:24:03with it so they don't end up in the back.
- 1:24:06And the one that we always forget about is fidelity.
- 1:24:08Like Fidelity's been involved, but I think everybody pretends
- 1:24:10like they don't support Bitcoin. It's like, Oh yeah, they're like
- 1:24:12abuse fidelity. They're so standard of trillions
- 1:24:14of dollars. Abbey, it's like, Oh yeah,
- 1:24:15they've just been playing around and so now it's Fidelity and
- 1:24:18BlackRock in that full push that would be like the counter to
- 1:24:20like they're just going to go and they're not going to stop
- 1:24:22because they're have to win out on like they're the de facto or
- 1:24:26one or top 2-3 asset managers that support have the technology
- 1:24:29and they just don't, they don't let up.
- 1:24:32No, I mean we tell you Fidelity has the biggest team in the US
- 1:24:36far not. They have 200 people.
- 1:24:38They're they're dedicated and yeah, and you and you and you
- 1:24:41throw some high margin product out there, they're gonna be
- 1:24:44getting it. And as I said you know in Canada
- 1:24:46we, we've seen inflows in November, some of the biggest
- 1:24:50posts the FTX. So people are front running
- 1:24:53Black Rock in Canada. God bless the Northern.
- 1:24:58And we we should give a shout out Fidelity like we we kind of
- 1:25:01talked a little bit you know BlackRock and us not being you
- 1:25:03know whether it's their their interests in the space, their
- 1:25:06technology, their parties was chatting with some folks that
- 1:25:10are closer to fidelity and they've like made a very
- 1:25:12concerted effort to like transform their business to like
- 1:25:14appreciate this asset class invested in the technology.
- 1:25:17I think they're the only ETF provider that is leveraging
- 1:25:19their own infrastructure when it comes to multi signature custody
- 1:25:23And so they're in it for the long haul.
- 1:25:25So it's nice to see that there's, you know, actual
- 1:25:27incumbent that's appreciating it from like a vertical integration
- 1:25:30perspective and doing things the right way.
- 1:25:33Yep. And to your point, there are
- 1:25:36people who have been there and I think that's this is not new
- 1:25:39Cathy Wood, obviously he's been owning Bitcoin person for a long
- 1:25:43time. She's been a holder.
- 1:25:45You know, I won't talk about her holding, but they're public and
- 1:25:49they're in the digital asset space.
- 1:25:50So you know, don't get get curious folks.
- 1:25:55Give us a call. I was going to ask what are what
- 1:26:00are your final thoughts to wrap up this conversation, but I
- 1:26:03think it's a call to action. Get curious?
- 1:26:05Get, get just read our stuff. Jesse's report on the on the
- 1:26:09valuation is just is a you know from salad to dessert has got it
- 1:26:15all and just eat it. And we we have some information
- 1:26:20on our website as well. Yeah, Mark, what was the what's
- 1:26:25that report, What's the report that you guys have of answering
- 1:26:30all the questions that like a wealth manager would have?
- 1:26:33So we'll make that available to wealth managers and it's called
- 1:26:36the advisor care kit because you're going to get a call about
- 1:26:41Bitcoin. And if you do not, if you cannot
- 1:26:44answer these questions, you will not get the order and they're
- 1:26:47going to sell stock in your account and buy Bitcoin away.
- 1:26:50So we actually saw that happen in the last run where advisors.
- 1:26:56We know this because we lived it.
- 1:26:58As a reference for advisors who say give me some information
- 1:27:01because I'm losing 5 to 10% of my assets people are throwing on
- 1:27:05Coinbase. That's exactly right.
- 1:27:07And we have this other thought that those assets that they
- 1:27:10moved over that sit outside when the price because it's 1%, they
- 1:27:13don't care when it's 5 to 10%, they're like, hey, can you bring
- 1:27:16them back? We have a solution for it.
- 1:27:17So that's a whole other pool of capital that we haven't really
- 1:27:20touched on. And back to what the question
- 1:27:23you asked, and it isn't on an unregulated exchange held in an
- 1:27:27omnibus account. You guys do it a little
- 1:27:28differently there at the Hunt ramp.
- 1:27:31So all all the more reason. Yeah, Mark, thanks for for
- 1:27:35coming on. We'll get an e-mail from you to
- 1:27:38any links that you want to include.
- 1:27:40And I'd be remiss to say we've talked about on this call out a
- 1:27:43a report, it was Jesse, maybe you want to plug the full
- 1:27:46potential evaluation and what happened last week because we've
- 1:27:48talked about it multiple times, we haven't announced like where
- 1:27:50it is and how they can find it. Yeah.
- 1:27:53So I put together, I turned my full potential evaluation
- 1:27:58article into a full report that we put out through on ramp and
- 1:28:03that's available on our on our website.
- 1:28:05If you go to on rampbitcoin.com/FPV full
- 1:28:09potential evaluation, there's a link there to download the
- 1:28:13report and and you can take a look through that.
- 1:28:16The idea there is for it to be you know like a a high quality
- 1:28:20piece of of educational material that packs a lot in and is very
- 1:28:27accessible and readable that makes a case for you know where
- 1:28:30Bitcoin is going, what's, what is the full potential valuation
- 1:28:32for Bitcoin, how high could this thing go.
- 1:28:35And the hope there is that people can, you know, use it as
- 1:28:38part of their own education. But I think it's particularly
- 1:28:41valuable to have to in order to give to your friends and
- 1:28:44colleagues to help them, you know, wake up and and see the
- 1:28:49potential of his assets. So go check that out on
- 1:28:51rampbitcoin.com/FPV. And last week we did, we did a
- 1:28:56webinar session walking folks through.
- 1:28:59We had like 200 joined for that and and we walked through the
- 1:29:05report and what it meant and then had a great conversation
- 1:29:07with Mark, myself and and and Brian from on RAMP where we
- 1:29:12talked through bitcoins full potential valuation various
- 1:29:17approaches to valuing Bitcoin and then had a a great Q&A from
- 1:29:20the audience that was our first webinar.
- 1:29:22We're we're planning to do that on a on a regular basis going
- 1:29:25forward. So if you want to be aware of
- 1:29:28those events going forward, the best way to to find out about
- 1:29:33them is to either follow us on Twitter at On RAMP Bitcoin or
- 1:29:37get on our our e-mail list and get our our weekly market
- 1:29:43updates and news from On Ramp about upcoming events, which you
- 1:29:47can find on our website. Awesome pros.
- 1:29:53It's been a pleasure. Mark, thank you so much for
- 1:29:56joining us. Thank you, Marty.
- 1:29:59Michael, Jesse, always a pleasure.
- 1:30:01Thanks, Jess. Yeah, it was great, Mark.
- 1:30:04All right. This is the last trade, but
- 1:30:07we'll be back. Next week was another episode of
- 1:30:10The Last Train.