Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / #Channel-Who's Your Favourite Designer
Transcript
- 0:02This is hashtag Channel, a podcast about discord with Ben and Steve. Well,
- 0:09actually, a hashtag means it's a channel. So you sound like you're
- 0:17in prisoned, Steve, what happened? I'm in a kind of prison,
- 0:21Ben, You see? Is that the prison known as the workplace? Yes,
- 0:25yes, I'm joining you today live from the headquarters building of my company
- 0:30that I will not name. I'm inside of a lovely phone booth that they've
- 0:34provided for us to trap ourselves even further. So it's kind of want I've
- 0:38been looking at them within a prison. I've been looking at these on the
- 0:41internet. I want one, actually, but I mean they're really fucking expensive,
- 0:44so I'm not going to get mean. I mean, the thing about
- 0:46incarceration that they don't tell you is it's actually quite cozy. You don't have
- 0:50anything to worry about. All your needs are basically taken care of. You
- 0:53have limited space to keep tidy, You've got your toilet, you've got your
- 0:57caught. You know, meals are planned, and you're in your mid faulty
- 1:00seex isn't the thing anymore so well, you know, probably not the kind
- 1:03that you expect. Just be careful in the shower room, and sometimes they
- 1:07let us outside. So so let's go back, shall we to to New
- 1:15Jersey early eighties. You got a little I mean I didn't spend a lot
- 1:21of time in New Jersey in the early eighties. I mean this was like
- 1:23the state across the river from right. Sorry, sorry, I do apologize.
- 1:29Sorry. Let's go the scene, like the Lower East Side nineteen Baby,
- 1:34I'm walking here, I'm walking here, so so downtown Manhattan, Steve
- 1:42exactly. You know, you're you're thinking, you know, you're going to
- 1:48some sort of primary school. That's not what you call them there, but
- 1:52you know that's that's Can you play Saturday Night Fever like it beneath this?
- 1:56That's a few years before, but I guess you know, it's still a
- 1:57hit. Like walking to school. I've got a cool leather jacket with like
- 2:01metal studs and ship and you know the teachers, the teachers, they're going,
- 2:05you know, hey, hey, Steve, well you want the people
- 2:08You go up and you're like, I want to I want to change the
- 2:14world. Teacher, what was your what was your teacher your your elementary school
- 2:17teacher's name. My favorite teacher was my first grade teacher, Missus Sanosi.
- 2:23Missus Sanosi. Did you did you? Did you fancy her at the age
- 2:29of six? Yeah, I mean we're precocious in council the States. In
- 2:31Britain, I mean a certain amount to the girl at the six year old
- 2:37girls, I've got children at this point. Yeah, I suppose I fancied
- 2:40her in that sort of platonic, innocent way that a six year old child
- 2:45can Did you ever do that thing where the teacher says something to you when
- 2:47you turn around and you call her mom? No? Is that? No?
- 2:53It is the thing kids do it occasionally because you get you get mixed
- 2:57up, didn't you? And you go, oh, yeah, mom,
- 2:59I'm coming, And then all the class laughs because you called the teacher mum.
- 3:01No. No, I just really wanted to please her. So I
- 3:04was that guy that's like I'm raising my hand. I'm raising my hand.
- 3:06I'm raising anybody else? Would anybody else like to answer the question? That
- 3:09was me? You probably loved that person in your classes? Or were you
- 3:13that person? I was that person? Of course I was. Yeah.
- 3:15You seem like you would be that person anyway. And you want you want,
- 3:17you want everyone to know all the time how much you know? Y
- 3:23fucking random facts and shit about the world, like nobody gives a shit.
- 3:25It's just like you know it. They have to hear you demonstrating that you
- 3:30know it. And I only know this about you because you're like a mirror
- 3:31image of me. I got a big argument. I've got a big argument
- 3:35at work the other day because all of the people at work. Bear in
- 3:38mind, work is rehearsals for a play, just to put in context a
- 3:43kind of people that were in the room, and I had a big argument
- 3:46because they were all defending chakra meditation and alternative medicine, and they got really
- 3:54offended with me because I was like, no, it's a load of all
- 3:58bollocks, and they were like, no, no, no, it's been
- 4:00around for centuries. I was like, yeah, it was fucking small box
- 4:03and you know Christianity, But like, what do you what do you do?
- 4:08What does one do? What is a good strategy when you find yourself
- 4:10in that kind of situation? The problem is, right, I was too
- 4:13and I don't know what to say. So I'm sick right now and I
- 4:16was coming down with it right at the time. And so when you're just
- 4:20getting ill, you're a bit emotional, so you're not really very good at
- 4:25being rational. And also everyone else in the room, like five people in
- 4:30the room were all defending fucking alternative therapy. Yeah. I mean the rest
- 4:33of the time, when you're totally well, you're completely rational and well exactly
- 4:38exactly, And the problem is, it doesn't matter. It doesn't matter whether
- 4:42you've got right because I'm not a fucking scientist, so I don't have the
- 4:45facts to hand. And the problem is, right, especially when five people
- 4:50are just vociferously arguing against you, it doesn't matter whether you're right or not.
- 4:55You have no fucking chance. And they're not going no, no,
- 4:58no. And one girl was like, oh, so I was ill and
- 5:01I took something and it made me better. And I said, well,
- 5:04it could be a myriad of things. It could be that you've just got
- 5:08better. It could be that the drugs, the conventional drugs you were taking
- 5:12before, kicked in. It could be that, you know, correlation is
- 5:16not causation exactly. I mean, the thing is, the thing is,
- 5:19and of course you always have Esperitu Scallier, right, and for the people
- 5:27think the defining future of my life, and and so that the point is
- 5:30afterwards, I I what I should have said to them was I'm sorry,
- 5:38I can't take your anecdotes as prove. We have lived in a life with
- 5:42a scientific method, and we can only truly rely on these things as a
- 5:46general cause if they have been tested in blind controls and those tests have been
- 5:54replicable. Until then, we can't in good conscience say that they effective in
- 6:00any way, because you might be driving people away from effective therapist into things
- 6:06that don't work, or at least we don't know whether they work. That's
- 6:10what I should have said. What I did actually say was you're talking bullocks.
- 6:15It's all a load of bullocks, because that's what I'd like. You
- 6:18weren't feeling well, and you were kind of like you know, edgy,
- 6:21you were off your game. This is not like the Ben Maddox that we
- 6:25all know and like, yeah, I mean listen to me now, I
- 6:27mean rational, rational headed sober. You said sober twice? Should I?
- 6:35Yeah? What else did I say? Sober? I think sober? I
- 6:42don't know why you'd stress on that one, but anyway, So when you
- 6:45know you're at school and missus Samos is asking you can get her name off,
- 6:51fucking get mister Snowsi's name of come over there and kick your ass.
- 6:56You have no idea what that woman did for me. I wouldn't have made
- 6:58it through first grade with that, missus. Snow See, don't you fucking
- 7:00joke about this ever again? Don't you just get to go through first grade?
- 7:03Sorry about that? Sorry about that, Sorry about that. You just
- 7:06a little bit trigger, a little bit triggered. You just get to you
- 7:10just get to go through first grade, aren't you. It's not that easy,
- 7:13Ben, not not in fucking Miss Laura made happen anyway. So so
- 7:20I'm like, walking to school alone, I was a lapt key kid.
- 7:23I'm like, my fucking feet are crushing crack files as I fucking step over
- 7:27homeless people and the better Oh, Ronald, very good anyway. So when
- 7:31she said, what do you want to be? Did you think I want
- 7:34to be stuck in a cubicle in a corporate office? Even though I can
- 7:42see the cubicle here, even though they've put like it's of nice colors,
- 7:46it's basically a fucking I can only remember the German word that's depressing solitary confinement
- 7:53thing in the middle of the city. I'm pretty sure that a cubicle like
- 7:57a proper cubicle would be an upgrade from what I'm sitting in now. So
- 8:01this, this is meant to be like an enclosed space where you can get
- 8:05work done when you're when you need to be alone and focus. Cubicles,
- 8:09I think cubicles were the subject of much mockery in like the eighties and nineties
- 8:13culture. So the only thing worse that I can imagine than cubicles would be
- 8:18what we have now, which are like total like open plan offices, which
- 8:22you know, you've you've been here, you've seen it. It's just like
- 8:24we're all like on top of each other all the time. If you can
- 8:26hear everything everyone is saying, see everything everyone is doing. There's no privacy,
- 8:31there's no personal space. You're a team collaborating together all the time,
- 8:37wearing your while wearing your noise canceling headphones, so you fucking zone out as
- 8:41much as you can, oh truly, truly, and and you know,
- 8:46most of these jobs are just basically you're facilitating the flooding of the world with
- 8:54more consumer shit that people don't need. So you know, this is this
- 9:00different from podcasting? Hey Hey, depends on the podcast love. I don't
- 9:05know. Joe Rogan I'm not putting conspiracy theorist up on here. I'm only
- 9:09getting the fucking top notch people to speak sense and fucking help the world.
- 9:13Do you think there's like a little sort of six year old Ben Maddox right
- 9:18now, like in Tunbridge Wells going like mommy, mommy. When I written
- 9:22mommy in this case is the teacher mommy when I grow a pod luck to
- 9:24be a podcaster, roll would so much glamor. She's going to Ben.
- 9:30We didn't know no one when when we were sick. You didn't say I
- 9:31wanted to be a podcaster, because there was no such thing. She's like,
- 9:35Ben, you're from the estate at the top of the road. You'll
- 9:39be lucky if you're not in prison. And I didn't go to prison and
- 9:43fucking corporal punishment, right, they fucking wrap you across the knuckles with a
- 9:46ruler and shit like that. I did get my picture of your country is
- 9:52just like straight out of Oliver Twists. Yeah, yeah, No, I
- 9:54did get manhandled once by a teacher. Really yeah, because we were drawing
- 9:58pictures. We'll get onto the sub jeck to the minute. We were drawing
- 10:01pictures of the Bible at school. I know, you know, I know,
- 10:03I know this seems here, you know, terrible for an American because
- 10:07of separation church and state. But I went to a church school there.
- 10:11Everyone goes to a church school, right, And we were drawing pictures of
- 10:13the Bible. And I drew a picture of Adam and Eve and I was
- 10:18like eight or nine or something, and their fig leaves had fallen off,
- 10:24so they were stood there covering their bits, going oh, And I drew
- 10:26a picture of that because I thought it was funny, right, And I
- 10:28went to the teacher and I explained the picture of the teacher to the teacher
- 10:33and he went fucking mental and fucking grabbed me and slowly shaking me. And
- 10:37I was like, gloody, ell, it's a bit much, so much
- 10:39for your celebrated British irony, I know, but but you know it's led
- 10:45me on a life of comedy. And now look at me. I assume
- 10:50in these situations in your country, you do something wrong and the teacher beats
- 10:54you, and you go home and tell your parents and then they beat you
- 10:56too. Yeah, exactly what did you do to make the teacher angry?
- 10:58A little bastard? And then you're got a slap around the head. This
- 11:03is good. This is how we ended up that the sun never set on
- 11:09the British Empire, I'll have you know. It's how you and I ended
- 11:11up as the the happy, healthy, successful, well adjusted people. Right.
- 11:18Well, with that, let's go on too after all together. Too
- 11:22much consultation with the greatest minds in the world. Topics represent this, all
- 11:35right, Steve? So, what's what's the topic for this this? Sorry?
- 11:41Sorry, listeners, I'm ill so I can't get words out. What's
- 11:43the topic? I want to do this over again, Ben, No,
- 11:46they love it. They love it. It lets us it lets them into
- 11:50the real world, Steve, the real world behind the fuck is made exactly.
- 11:56So, So what's the topic of this week's hashtag channel? Stave?
- 12:01Fuck? I'm supposed to I'm supposed to look at the document right, Okay,
- 12:03okay, okay, I'm really bad at this. I the topic on
- 12:07the documentary. No, you didn't know you did, but you mentioned the
- 12:09topic to me. You mentioned the topic to me before we started recording,
- 12:13so you should know. I know that like broad strokes of the topic.
- 12:15I just wasn't sure like how you phrased it, Like if you had a
- 12:18very nice pithy title, but you don't. So the topic is we want
- 12:22to stop complaining because that's all we do on this fucking show. Yeah,
- 12:26we want to. We want to in the interest of being positive and introducing
- 12:30a note of levity to our otherwise dour serious topics. Talk about designers that
- 12:35we love. Actually the designers that are many dickheads on the Discord love exactly.
- 12:41We are getting some amazing engagement from these people's great missions, Like they
- 12:46don't need us anymore. So if you're listening to this, how did they
- 12:48join the Discord stage so they can get in get in on the getting on
- 12:52the shows. Okay, so I'm going to explain how to do it,
- 12:54but for right now, just for the next minute, just eliminate the concept
- 12:58of numbers from your mind. Anytime I say a number, instead think of
- 13:01how you would spell it out in letters. That's okay, Yeah, because
- 13:03I do writing, because I'm a fucking writer, all right, Yeah,
- 13:09I get it. Like, what long form do you think Shakespeare ever used
- 13:11numbers to give number? Probably not a thing. I don't think he knew
- 13:16how to count verily, that is five and twenty. Do you think he
- 13:18wrote five and twenty or do you reckon? He wrote to nine. I
- 13:22mean I think his editor probably added to the like tied it up the figures
- 13:28to make sure that they could reconcile. But do you know, as you
- 13:31artist, as you know, I'm the modern Shakespeare. So I just you
- 13:33know what's good enough for him, he's good enough for me. Carry on.
- 13:39I just, I just I just wanted there to be a nice heavy
- 13:43pause there after that statement. So www dot five games for doomsday dot com.
- 13:48And remember no numbers. And this is some kind of blog where you
- 13:54can pin posts. And there is a pinn post there is pinned to the
- 13:58very top of the page, and it's an invitation link to join the discord.
- 14:03And you know, we joke around a lot on this show, but
- 14:07I am not joking when I say that this is the coolest discord on the
- 14:11internet. Please join and jump in the conversation. It's we discuss movies and
- 14:15music and it sort of stuff. Yeah, it's been very good. I
- 14:20have all of our New Year's resolutions. This is the one that's really kicked
- 14:24off. Yeah, and you get to chat with me and Ben exactly anyway,
- 14:28So so steve the topic. Make sure if ben if Ben, Like
- 14:33Evince's an opinion, just like make sure you agree with him. He fucking
- 14:35gets annoyed. Yeah, I really people disagree? Does the problem is?
- 14:41I mean, I don't want to sign arrogant to you, but I'm the
- 14:43fucking cleverest person who's ever fucking lift you know all that. What's his name?
- 14:46What's his name? Fineman? Yeah, fucking bullshit man. Compared to
- 14:50me, fucking Einstein, fucking zero stones compared to what I mean, very
- 14:58good? Did you just come up now? I did? I did just
- 15:01come up with that. Now it's called witt Oppenheimer. Oppenheimer, I call
- 15:03him Nopenheimer. Yeah, fucking right. Compared to me, I could fucking
- 15:09I can't do equations though, so apart from that, who needs them anyway?
- 15:13So yeah, So the topic was who's your favorite designer? Because like,
- 15:18we did a couple of serious topics, and I thought, just let's
- 15:20let's revel in games for a bit, right. The summer's coming to an
- 15:24end. It's all very melancholy. The end of the year presages the end
- 15:28of our lives, and so I don't know, I mean, thanks to
- 15:31global warming, I think we probably have another month of summer. Yes,
- 15:33it's bloody boiling. I was supposed to go camping this weekend, but I'm
- 15:37ill, so I can't go, which fucking great, isn't it. Well
- 15:39you're not going with me, so I don't really care. Well, you're
- 15:43you're going on holidays, some funky five star results or some shit, aren't
- 15:46you. It's like a very cheap airbnb right anyway, So you didn't have
- 15:52an answer to this before we started recording, So I'm going to put I'm
- 15:56not allowed to participate in the hashtag. So firstly, I fucking didn't.
- 16:02Secondly, you've got to participate in the actual show when we record it.
- 16:04THO, wouldn't you like right now? You mean, yeah, yeah,
- 16:10But I thought like, let let the listeners have the conversation amongst themselves and
- 16:14leave my response my contribution for the show, right exactly. But you told
- 16:18me just before we started recording that you didn't have an answer to this,
- 16:22So why are you telling them that I told you that that wasn't you weren't
- 16:25meant to tell everyone who's listening to because why did you tell the person who's
- 16:29listening to this Derek is Derek is not just a listener Steve. He's also
- 16:36my friend. Yeah, no, I hadn't because it's hard. It's hard
- 16:41to come up who's my favorite designer? But I'm gonna come up with something.
- 16:44Do we do? We have to start with me or you? Yeah,
- 16:45we have to start with you. Okay, Well I'm gonna go.
- 16:51I'm gonna go a little bit off the reservation and I'm gonna say there are
- 16:56lots of designer groups. Can I pick a group? We'll pick a group
- 17:00and then it's not going to be splatter. It's not going to be splatter,
- 17:02So that is the answer. But pick a group, and then pick
- 17:06a group, and then talk about the characteristics of that group, and then
- 17:10a couple of notables within it. Well, I mean the group would be
- 17:12the Ragnar brothers. I don't even remember their names. I think one of
- 17:15them is Phil and Ed and Bob and Jackson. When I got into board
- 17:22I got into board games at first in the eighties, like this is the
- 17:25first phase where it was all Milton Bradley Parker brothers and I played Mystery Mansion
- 17:29and Screaming Eagles and mouse Trap, which I'm not sure is really a game.
- 17:33Stuff like that, and then eventually graduated through magically gathering to the church
- 17:38basement with the middle of the rich, those weird nonces in the church basement.
- 17:42Yeah, yeah, exactly. You go. You tend to go very
- 17:45quiet and sort of slightly fearful when you when you mentioned that that didn't happen,
- 17:52that you carry on. I mean, I mean the coincidence of this
- 17:56occurring in a church basement though, I mean, this is like my chef
- 17:59kiss for you to make some hay out of there, exactly. And not
- 18:02that we're saying religious organizations are just are just covers for fucking Roman gangs of
- 18:07pedes. We're not saying that. Steve, Well, this was a Congregationalist
- 18:12church, not a Catholic church, And I think the Congregationalists are sort of
- 18:17like as as close to atheists as you can be and yet still somehow be
- 18:22like vaguely Christian. Okay, I have no idea what I've no idea what
- 18:26they are. You've got too many crazy religions in America. Yeah, you
- 18:29can look it up on Wikipedia if you want. It's like, it's like
- 18:32very very very light Christianity anyway, if you want. Is carrying a lot
- 18:34of weight in that sentence anyway, carry on, you're talking about you're talking
- 18:37about getting getting molested in the church basement. Carry on, It's exactly what
- 18:41I was talking about. I really I can't wait for my own children to
- 18:45hear this recording someday when they like recover it from the fucking time capsule.
- 18:49It's going to end up in I first played this game here, Jemima.
- 18:55I found Jemima. I found these in the old abandoned city before the plague.
- 19:03What are they? Oh, they're computer discs bliemia. Oh well,
- 19:08we should listen to them if you've got that old computer. Yes, it's
- 19:12about to be some wisdom from the elders, isn't it? Jar Bible?
- 19:15Yes, believeaight, motherfucker comes this becomes the fucking founding text of the next
- 19:30era of humanity or X and Craig the Bennett Steve Show. Anyway, carry
- 19:33on, Yeah, so may I carry on? So we played. I
- 19:41first was exposed to this game History of the World, which I've talked about
- 19:44before, and it was an entirely new experience for me. I mean,
- 19:48a lot of these games they took I was gonna say, six hours,
- 19:51sorry, twelve hours, six players, twelve hours but I was, I
- 19:55was riveted, and I think this this just just like it's like it's stamped
- 19:59board games into my brain for life. And there are lots of other games
- 20:03at the time, but I've always come back to this. And it's not
- 20:07like I've played loads of Ragnar Brothers games. I actually have I think almost
- 20:12all of them on my shelf and we need to play them eventually. But
- 20:17you know, when you say favorite, it can mean a lot of things.
- 20:19It could mean like whose games do I go back to over and over
- 20:22again? And lately it's like such a melunch. I don't know that I
- 20:25do go back to anybody's games over and over again, even though there are
- 20:27a few notable designers, like I might say Splotter, But how often do
- 20:30I even play a Splotter game. It's all novelty all the time. But
- 20:34History of the World, I've just played so many more times than any other
- 20:38game, and I've introduced it to so many different audiences, even like non
- 20:41gamer groups who've quite liked it. Even you liked the the updated, like
- 20:48sort of watered down version by z Man Games, which I think is probably
- 20:51the only playable one now. It's a very, very hard to get anyone
- 20:52to play a twelve hour game in our group these days. So I want
- 20:59to say that the rag Our Brothers for me, I'm gonna, I'm gonna,
- 21:02I'm gonna say these are my favorites, not least because I got to
- 21:04meet them. You were there, you saw real time all week at again.
- 21:11Yes, And I got them to autograph my box, and I think
- 21:15that was and the Bold game. Yeah, oh I see, I see.
- 21:21I don't know what your boxes, but it's a body parts joke,
- 21:23joke, body part joke. Yeah, I know. I mean, I
- 21:26think it's pretty clear that you're making some kind of innuendo or or ente the
- 21:30dub exactly. But yeah, I got my I got my game autographed.
- 21:34I got to meet them. They tried to explain their new game to me,
- 21:37and you know how I am when you explain a game to me.
- 21:41I think they got a little impatient. And I think that was the last
- 21:44essen that they ever attended. That's right, That's right. So they're not
- 21:47your favorite, theo were they? That's just rank nostalgia, is it.
- 21:51You're not You're not you're not jones into play Ragnall Brothers games. You're not
- 21:56you know I am always ready to play History of the World at any moment
- 21:59I will play. Yeah, but that doesn't that doesn't mean they should be
- 22:02your favorite designers because one of their games you love. Right, So,
- 22:06for instance, I think Trade on the Tigers is fantastic. But I'm not
- 22:08saying Jeff Engelstein and Ryan Storm are my favorite game designers. You know what
- 22:11I mean? Well, you know if I had come to that game at
- 22:15a certain time of life and like, so favorite game designers implies what that
- 22:18I have. Like, I've played loads of their games, and I appreciate
- 22:22them as somehow artists, right, Yeah, even though I've only played this
- 22:26one game, or like at least I have actually played other Ragner Brothers games.
- 22:30But like, this is what I'm focusing on. I've played it so
- 22:33many more times. I've played History of the World more times than I've played
- 22:37like all Splatter games together. Why also so so basically for the listeners,
- 22:42fucking yours and your own right could draw a picture of Steve being molested by
- 22:51a horse and right across this top Steve is the biggest fucking prick who's ever
- 22:56existed. We hope he dies because he's the biggest twat I've ever known.
- 23:02Put it in a box, set it to Steve for a hundred quid and
- 23:06he would say it's the best game ever made. I don't know why you're
- 23:10so reluctant to talk about the Splotters as being clearly your favorite designers. Wait
- 23:15a minute, Wait a minute. They just post something about this to face.
- 23:18Wait are you wait? It's this is a joke, right, it's
- 23:22on the face, it's on the Facebook group. This is an actual game.
- 23:25I know they're coming out with a new game. They just a horseless
- 23:29carriage and now they're doing Steve's the count. How much is it? If
- 23:33it's only one hundred and fifty euros, I'm gonna order five copies. Yeah,
- 23:37yeah, it's it's one hundred and seventy five with postage. Fine,
- 23:41because you know eventually they get used out and you want to have a new
- 23:44one handy and I need that enough to get me through the rest of my
- 23:45life. Look, I can answer your fucking questions anyway I want. I
- 23:49know. I'm just curious, water guys, I'm just curious, that's all.
- 23:53Yeah. I'm always talking about Splotter, like in my in the contemporary
- 23:57phase of my game playing. I would say that I appreciate their designs the
- 24:03most, like they're very like offbeat, they're totally doing their own thing.
- 24:07But like I've I've We've had this conversation so many times, I don't have
- 24:11anything else to say about it. Like I live in anticipation of a new
- 24:18Splotter game. There will never again be a ragnar Brothers game. So they're
- 24:22they're part of like my formative experience and have even contributed to what I understand
- 24:27to be a favorite game. Like they they are constitutive of my taste as
- 24:33a gamer, which would even allow me to appreciate the Splotter boys. So
- 24:37how about how about that for an answer? Yes, so for me,
- 24:41it's difficult, right because and everything is difficult with you. Well, sorry,
- 24:49I was talking to a colleague. Was just walking by. Yeah,
- 24:52that's fine, I'll send the email later. Sorry about that. I thought
- 24:56it was a sign I opened the door crack. Okay, anyway, So
- 25:03what Oh, I was just telling about Kyleeague about my bath. I'm annoyed
- 25:07with him. Okay, anyway, So the thing is, I think there
- 25:12are a couple of designers out there that are clearly the I think there are
- 25:15two designers out there that are clearly the most talented game designers in the world,
- 25:21right, Okay, Jamie Stegmyer, Yeah, that's right, and would
- 25:26be the other one. Actually, I can't think of another designer that really
- 25:30grinds your gears as much as as Jamie. So so I think I think
- 25:34it's clear that Knitsia is just astonishing, and I think Lara chavattel Is I
- 25:41always say this about him. I think the most kind of naturally gifted game
- 25:45designer in the world in the sense that I think he thinks he speaks the
- 25:51language of games like no other game designer does. I mean, if you
- 25:53look at the achievement that is through the ages, it's quite astonishing, right,
- 25:57And he's able to design, He's able to design games across every genre
- 26:03and for them all to be breathtaking and surprising and bart fundamentally very good.
- 26:11Right. I don't think the Splotted guys. I think the Splotted guys are
- 26:15wonderful, but I don't think they're hugely consistent and bar I think are they
- 26:22my favorite game designers. It's it's easy to say knits yeah, But the
- 26:26thing is the guy I keep coming back to and the guy who just whenever
- 26:30I play any of his games, and they're light games usually, but they're
- 26:34all just so great and I get to the end of them and I feel
- 26:38that lovely sort of warmth that you get when you've played a good game,
- 26:44like when someone's peeing on you exactly exactly and he's got a new games.
- 26:48Why are you, by the way, why are you into that so much?
- 26:51Because it's great. I just couldn't do it. The thing is,
- 26:55I've got loads of untreated I wear loads of untreated leather. Yeah, so
- 27:00if I get people to piss on me, it's two birds with one stone,
- 27:03isn't it. Yeah, that makes sense, makes sense. I get
- 27:04I get to Ejacumla late and get my leather treated at the same time.
- 27:10It's great, you know. It's also it's also a sterilizing agent, so
- 27:12exactly. Yeah, maybe it could sort it out your cold. I mean
- 27:15to be honest, I was I was born during the year of Chernobyl,
- 27:19so I'm sterile anyway. But I'm pretty sure that your colleagues at the theater
- 27:23would agree that the best cure for a cold is to have a group of
- 27:26people piss on you. Yeah. I mean, that's a very theater thing
- 27:30anyway. Now everyone's boring in the theater. Everyone thinks everyone's so wild,
- 27:33they're not. Everyone's everyone's fucking That was that? Wasn't that? That?
- 27:37I was not alluding to, like wild sexual escapades in the dramatic world,
- 27:41more that they would believe in some kind of bullshit homeopathic remo. Oh yeah,
- 27:47fucking monkey piss monkey pissed crystals. Yeah. Anyway, So but I
- 27:52think I think the person who's games whenever they come out and I'm very excited,
- 27:56and they've got a new game coming out at Essen this year, and
- 27:59that Paolo Mori. His games are just so good and they're so grockable,
- 28:03and yet they feel so original. Libertalia it's such a brilliant original game.
- 28:10Blitzkrieg is so great, Dogs of War is so great, and Ethnos we
- 28:15played that a few weeks ago. It's just so great, and there's just
- 28:19something about the accessibility. If he designs, he's the game designer I maybe
- 28:23have played the most as well. I think he's a solid choice, especially
- 28:27for you. I mean, I appreciate Vava. I don't know how often
- 28:30I'm like desperate to play any at one of his games. But Polo Mori's
- 28:34games are are very palatable, and I think they're like exactly the kind of
- 28:37weight that you appreciate most having been exposed to your your game playing fashions over
- 28:45the years. And the thing is, the thing is this might change.
- 28:48So say Vlada Chivato comes out with a new he hasn't come out with a
- 28:52big game in years, and he comes out with a new game and it's
- 28:56just astonishing, and then he's undeniable, right, I mean so much of
- 29:00many of his games are great fun too. You know, Galaxy Truck is
- 29:03great, Space Ala is great and so. But but Palo Mari's just he
- 29:07might be the designer I've played the most. I've played a lot of games
- 29:11in Libertali. I've played a lot of games of Blitzkrieg. I've played a
- 29:14lot of games of Dogs of War, and they never get boring and introducing
- 29:18them to new people, they're incredibly fun, but they were crobably easy to
- 29:21explain. But that doesn't mean they don't have strategic depth. And I think
- 29:26I think he's an absolutely glorious How can we not picking up Via Rosenberg?
- 29:32It seems like you're always on the hunt for his game, like you will
- 29:33buy Ube Rosenberg games when they come out of ess and I don't hear you
- 29:37even seeing the same enthusiasm about I think Luve Rosenberg's great, but I only
- 29:42really truly love two of his games, Like I like a lot of his
- 29:45games, but I only truly loved to No Lahavre Bonanza. I love those
- 29:52two games, but the rest I like, but I don't love them in
- 29:56that way you always seem very excited when a new one. I think he's
- 30:00deeply, deeply consistent as a game designer in the way that I've played a
- 30:04few Splotter games, and I think I think there is I think with people
- 30:07that are that original design wise, that have artistically that original, you have
- 30:14dips, you have valleys and peaks, right, whereas with Rosenberg, apart
- 30:19from Hengist, you don't really have valleys. And Lahavrea is an incredible peak.
- 30:27But I think the rest of them are just very consistent, very solid
- 30:30eure games. Yeah, I mean I agree about Splatter. I mean how
- 30:33much does my opinion rest on just antiquity is brilliant. Food Chamber and it's
- 30:38brilliant. Horses Carriage is brilliant, but they're eighteen or eighteen blah blah blah.
- 30:44He's fine, it's not great, and there are other games I didn't
- 30:48get along with Great Zimbabwe, though people think it's brilliant, you know,
- 30:52I think. I think, because this is this is the thing of being
- 30:55bold and fresh and essentially having no editors, that you're capable of brilliance.
- 31:00But you're also capable of I know. I don't think they're ever bad,
- 31:03but sometimes just not as good. Right, well, let me let me
- 31:07let me give you another entry of Vladimir Succi. So I don't want to.
- 31:11He's not my favorite, but I really look forward to his new releases
- 31:15every year, Like if I'm going to buy a game at US and it's
- 31:17going to be whatever Vladimir Succi is doing. Me too. But I feel
- 31:21there's a creeping complexity coming into his designs that are making his designs less attractive.
- 31:26Yeah, it could be. I think Woodcraft felt to me overly fiddly.
- 31:30M Yeah, I mean it wasn't like entirely his game. So let's
- 31:33see if you can rebound this year with Evacuation. Evacuation, which is what
- 31:38I did this morning before we started recording. Anyway, Steve. Let's move
- 31:42on. Let's move on to the contrary. That's what they're here for.
- 31:45We've been talking for half an hour and we haven't got to the contributions of
- 31:49the discord. People really, people really like to hear their own names spoken
- 31:55by us on the podcast. Right, all right, So, Richard Norcle,
- 32:00he's from Australia, isn't he? I don't know, is he?
- 32:02I think he is. Yeah. I saw a picture of him with Martin
- 32:07Wallatt at some Australian games festival, So I think he's from Australia. Okay,
- 32:10I mean, is it is it relevant to mention where he's from?
- 32:13Is it? Is it interesting? I just gotta get into character before I
- 32:16read out his post, okay, So please inhabit Richard. And if I'm
- 32:23wearing a lot of sunblock, no ozone layers, the ozone layer go on?
- 32:30All right? So barefoot, remember your barefoot feel? I'm wearing thongs,
- 32:35actually thongs exactly right. That's what they call flip loops in Australia.
- 32:39All right, Sorry, made for me? It would have to be a
- 32:44leigxine. The feasta they just beade out of Wolf Gone Vosh and Vloratuvotel great
- 32:49Western trial made was probably the fust Hiva game that all I applied enough to
- 32:53fill on the steam deat and nadies without a fifty plas yet the dish honor
- 32:59he It's a great variety, from pro royal to almand goods as light of
- 33:02kild Games to Eireless Guy and Broom Service, lean onto GWT and Maracaibo which
- 33:08is shit. But but he has an Eckert providing what seems relatively do understeemed.
- 33:15You clearly lay as as deep as you played more mate, all right,
- 33:19what do you think? So we're probably not going to agree on this.
- 33:22No, you know how I feel about Alexander Fister, and you know
- 33:24how I feel about your opinion of Alexander Fister. So explain why, explain
- 33:28why you like him so much? As a designer, you know, when
- 33:32you play a game and you enjoy it, you can't always intellectualize why it
- 33:37is that you enjoy it. You're on a podcast, that's that's your job.
- 33:40Oh god, it's such a fucking ball leg to do. Though.
- 33:44I think that Richard Norkele captured my sentiments pretty well. I think he does
- 33:49have great variety. I think some of his games are quite whimsical. Some
- 33:53of them are like there they really fit the sort of like euro game mold
- 33:59that I appreh like Marichaibo. You don't like Maracaibo. I like Maracaibo.
- 34:02I like this mechanism that he does. It's a very great Western trail where
- 34:06you're and and also boon Lake has this where you sort of like you go
- 34:08around and around and you collect your sources and you do actually like this fucking
- 34:15merry go round that's endless, by the way, and the card the card
- 34:19oriented nature of the game, Like again, boon Lake does this Marcaibo.
- 34:22I think he's great with incorporating cards into his games, and I often find
- 34:29that I don't like games that are very card oriented. But in this case,
- 34:31you don't actually have to like know what all the cards are to be
- 34:35able to use them, So I think I like that part. I don't.
- 34:37I don't mind that there are sort of like different kinds of like tracks
- 34:40that you can follow to earn points. I just think that, you know,
- 34:44a lot of these games are really well constructed. There are lots of
- 34:47avenues that you could take for victory. No one is necessarily better than any
- 34:51other and they they just fit into like my like synapses somehow. I think,
- 34:58oh my, oh my Goods is like really brilliant at using the cards
- 35:04to like build buildings as well as serve as the currency of the game,
- 35:07the money broom service. I think this is we agree on broom service,
- 35:13so I don't have to think anything about that, And we also agree about
- 35:15Great Western Trail so at games of his I haven't played, so I think
- 35:17probably you and I will eventually find common ground here, just maybe not on
- 35:22Maracaibo specifically. So there are some writers I can't think of the names offhand,
- 35:27but there are some writers, and you read a book from them,
- 35:29and you pick up the book and you read it for a couple of chapters,
- 35:30and then you put it down, and while you're reading it, you're
- 35:32thinking, this is great, but when the thought of going back to pick
- 35:37up the book again, you're like, oh, y'alla really can't be asked
- 35:39to pick that book up again, right, This is Alexander Fist to me
- 35:44exactly. So this is Alexander Fister to me. Like I think Maracaibo was
- 35:49genuinely not finished as a game. I just don't think. I just don't
- 35:52think it went through the records of development. I think most of his solo
- 36:00games feel overly fiddly and unrefined. I think the I think. I think
- 36:06Boom Service is fantastic games, which the games I mean games that he designed
- 36:10on his own as opposed to with other people. But and this was the
- 36:15big thing. I played Great Western Trail late, and I understand the regard
- 36:20with which he's held now because Graceston Trail is brilliant. Graceston Trail is absolutely
- 36:24fantastic, like Great Western Trail is a game that has that quality of great
- 36:30designs that it's incredibly moorish. You play it and you want to play it
- 36:34again, and you see the box and you think, oh yeah, no,
- 36:36I definitely play that. None of his other games do that to me.
- 36:39Like I quite enjoyed playing Boon Lake. There is a battle report to
- 36:43testify to that fact. I quite enjoy playing Boon Lake, but I have
- 36:45no desire to go back to it. They're just so long and involved and
- 36:51fiddly, and that really bothers me, and I don't think so. I
- 36:54think the length of time the games take, it's just not value for money.
- 37:00And that's that's my fundamental issue, and I think Markaibo is just not
- 37:02a very good design. I mean, I think you could say this about
- 37:06a lot of euro games. But my, my, my issue with your
- 37:10of course you could say it a lot about a lot of euro games.
- 37:13Of course you can. That's the point, right, This is we're talking
- 37:16about cream of the crop, and I just don't think he is cream of
- 37:19the crop. Well. The thing so here's here's where I disagreement with you.
- 37:23Laes lies Lie laz one of them. It's one of those, you
- 37:28know, you know, you know, living in Germany, I'm losing my
- 37:30ability to speak English correctly. Yeah, because you speak German all the bloody
- 37:32time, don't I hear? I hear Germany. I hear Germans speaking English
- 37:38using German grammar all the time, or like unnecessary usage of participles? What
- 37:45was I going to say? I feel so your your opinions about any one
- 37:49game are like legitimate, right, Like there's no accounting for taste. You
- 37:52don't like Markaibo, you think it's unfinished. I mean, I'm not going
- 37:55to dispute that it's it's your impression, but to indict him as a designer
- 38:00based on only exposure to a few games. I think is unfair, especially
- 38:05since you admit to liking a number of them. So I'm not the online
- 38:08tight team as a designer. I just don't think you have. I think
- 38:10you have. I think there are games, there are games of his that
- 38:14I don't get along with, and as I see with a lot of designers,
- 38:17So I released my weather Report review on YouTube this week, and I
- 38:22see a problem with Fister, as I see a problem with Loserta. There
- 38:25is an ever creeping desire to become more and more complex and get away from
- 38:31the actual hub of what a fantastic game is. And so great Western Trail
- 38:37is wonderful, Broom Service is wonderful. Oh my Goods is great too.
- 38:40These were all published fucking years ago. I think that you have in the
- 38:45past made comments about him as a designer based on only a few games,
- 38:49and I think that you have much more standing to have that commentary on Loserta
- 38:53because you've played so many more of his games. You have now played more
- 38:57of Fisters games. I think you need to make a deal with me,
- 39:00okay, and I need to sit down and play Mombassa and then revisit your
- 39:04overall Yeah, I hear Mombassa is amazing as well. Anyway, So we'll
- 39:07move on to Matt GREENO two. He says he's English, so I'll do
- 39:13it in an English accent. Wait what kind of English accent? I mean
- 39:16English accent doesn't mean anything, right, You've got so many possibilities. Yeah,
- 39:21just just a general English accent. Okay, I mean that's your accent.
- 39:25Okay, yupe love three words, Rudiger fucking Dawn, No need to
- 39:34swear goa incredible Genoa, Genius, Jambo, the two player African shopping that
- 39:42will make your brain do gymnastics while riding a roller coaster of self doubt is
- 39:45Stambul brilliant? Is Stambul the dice game better? If anything? Las Vegas
- 39:51Ilvecio louis the full teenth Room Stones Relicate Snapshots, Kadia the Guy's a Legends
- 39:58is corp as a quality games She played incredible? What now, Matt.
- 40:04Matt Green is a dickhead. And by the way, when I say dickhead,
- 40:07that's not meant to be. Yeah, you are a member of the
- 40:12Discord, So I've I've come to really appreciate Matt's opinions, and I'm here
- 40:19for his game recommendations, So based on this post alone, well not,
- 40:22I don't know if it was this post or a previous one he had made
- 40:24about rudeger Dorn. I don't know if it's come up before. I just
- 40:28don't know his games that well. I think I've played one famous rudder Dorn
- 40:32game. Well, yes, I played a Stambul, which I think is
- 40:38great. I have even bought a copy of Louis the Fourteenth and the Essen
- 40:45No shipping auction on Matt Green's recommendation alone, right, because because I I
- 40:50think he's a designer that I need to get more exposure to, and I
- 40:52haven't. I haven't played like most of these games. I know about them.
- 40:55I know about Goa and Genoa. I think I've heard of Jambo.
- 41:00I know what. I think maybe I've played Las Vegas at some point,
- 41:02and I think you like Las Vegas, right, I think Las Vegas is
- 41:06fantastic. Yeah, yeah, it's brilliant. Yeah yeah, I think you've
- 41:08mentioned this before. So I really need to get to know ruddger Dorn and
- 41:13his oh more, he's one of those He's one of those sort of classic
- 41:16Golden age euro designers that no one really talks about even though he's been incredibly
- 41:22successful and there are loads of really good games. I thought Roomstones was good,
- 41:28not great. I think Las Vegas is brilliant, so simple, it's
- 41:31so clever. I enjoyed Istanbul. I hear Jambo is brilliant. I love
- 41:37sort of two player. Those two player games from the nineties or the two
- 41:43thousands from Cosmos are just absolutely fantastic, fantastic. He is a guy that
- 41:46I would love to do a deep dive. I would love to do a
- 41:50project whereas I take twelve designers for a year and just do a deep dive
- 41:54on their games every month. I have a month of this designer and that
- 41:59would be great. Okay the Bruce have you? Have you interviewed him?
- 42:02Really good? All? No, But I'm I'm hoping to line up a
- 42:07load of interview to Essen this year, so if he's there, I'll give
- 42:08him an ask. Well, he's still he's still publishing apparently? Yeah?
- 42:15Oh he did? Did he do a hombre? That's where I think I
- 42:16probably know him from. No, that was DRK Kenn, I believe,
- 42:20but did be wrong. It's it's listed on his Board Game Geek page.
- 42:24Ever, reason Yeah, maybe just for an expansion I don't know. Well,
- 42:29then then then it might be him. I don't know, Glenn.
- 42:34Why would he be listened on Glenmore two chronicles because maybe he designed maybe he
- 42:39designed a module for it or something. Yeah, okay, but I mean
- 42:43the Stanbul, I think obviously stands among the great classics. Have you played
- 42:46a Stanbul? Yeah? Okay, I haven't played the Stanbul dice game,
- 42:51though I assumed dice games are never as good as the originals. But maybe
- 42:54this is an exception. All right, So the Bruce, he says where
- 43:00he's from in the first sentence, So you've got to try and guess what
- 43:01accentime doing. Okay, I'm not gonna look. I recognize I'm a euro
- 43:08ludo philistine, but being American, I press on with my unyielding opinion anyway.
- 43:15As children, Yes, Scottish, Yeah, yeah, he's a one
- 43:19trick pony. But the gloom Haven core mechanic of chords are stamming, a
- 43:22low inflammation planning, a chaot resolution is gold. And as an old d
- 43:28day geek who no longer has a group to play with, it scratches the
- 43:31dungeon crawling itch. It's probably because you've got a lot of itches that no
- 43:36one's playing with you. I played hundreds of scenarios with a few different groups
- 43:39and the guy and continued to surprise him to Latmi. When I play with
- 43:43my wife, it's a wonderful bombing, experienced team work and strategy. When
- 43:46I play with my college friends, it's a back by the group of mercenaries
- 43:50knocking each other over. Get to the treasure. First. Things are not
- 43:53things that are not good, the Forgotten Circle's expansion and any of his games
- 43:59and gloom High. All right, so the Bruce is like a character from
- 44:04a from a World War two movie, like exactly naive, the naive dough
- 44:07boy from Alabama, exactly. So what do you think? So you've not
- 44:13played gloom Haven? Right? No, And I'm often I'm often like wondering
- 44:16aloud whether we are remissing our duties as a board game board game podcasting semi
- 44:23professionals that we haven't played it. And I think I think it is absolutely
- 44:29in my in my ludography, it is a error. It is an embarrassing
- 44:34and I think negligent error. To be honest. It's just so fucking expensive
- 44:37and it looks like it'll take three hours to this is to live a lifetime
- 44:42to play it. And it's a campaign game, right. So the thing
- 44:44is, I've played so he says that anything else that isn't gloom Haven by
- 44:47Isaac isn't very good. So I've played four Dwall, which was fine.
- 44:55You and I played Founders of bloom Haven find Is gloom Haven, which was
- 45:00okay. But I've not played anything by him that I thought was remarkable.
- 45:07People say gloom Haven is remarkable, and you know, Isaac's a nice guy
- 45:12and he's he's a very wealthy guy now on the back of this, and
- 45:17there has to be something there, I you know. But but the problem
- 45:22is with bloody gloom Haven. It's just so bloody intimidating, right. And
- 45:27I don't feel like playing Jewels of the Lion because I don't feel like playing
- 45:30the sort of half fat version. I want to play the full fat version.
- 45:35That's what I was gonna I was gonna suggest Jaws of the Lion might
- 45:37be like our entree into the world. So if people are listening to them
- 45:42to this, and if Jewels of the Line gives you a gloom Haven experience,
- 45:45like a like a full flavored gloom Haven experience and then then we'll we'll
- 45:49play Jewels of the Lion a bit. But oh, the thought of gloom
- 45:52Haven is a bit stressful. But glo Haven is gloom Haven so much of
- 45:57a legacy game that once you've played through it, it's of like unusable after
- 46:00that, I think, so, b it's it's it's a game that's like
- 46:04one hundred hours worth of place. So yeah, would you know, but
- 46:07we're not going to get like a used copy, I guess, I guess,
- 46:10I guess not. And like, would we would we start with gloom
- 46:14Haven? Would we go straight to frost Haven? Well, well, I
- 46:17think I think it's much of a muchness, right, But yeah, maybe
- 46:21we'll have a look anyway. So trog Dawson, where do you think truck
- 46:24Dawson's from? Do you know who? Trog Door is? No? Trog
- 46:30Door the Bernonader was a character from the Internet animated series Homestar Runner from the
- 46:37early or mid two thousands, and trog Door you have to get you have
- 46:44to like basically google it. Trog Door is like a dragon character, but
- 46:46a very poorly drawn dragon that goes around bernonading the countryside and all the peasants
- 46:53in their thatched roofed cottages. Excellent. I could actually sing the trog Door
- 47:00song. I know it's so well, Ben, yeah, sure should we
- 47:02avoid that drag? Or well a man? He was a dragon man?
- 47:09Alright, so dragon, alright, alright, fucking right now. By the
- 47:17way, even if you don't, right Trot Dawson, change your fucking name
- 47:23anyway. So where do you think he's from? How do you know trog
- 47:28Door is a he? Where do you think they're from? I think I
- 47:34think the United States because obviously we have a shared cultural context. All right,
- 47:38war lovely play aspirationally cool whirly. Now. The reason I put this
- 47:45in is because I want I want to grill you because you were very cold,
- 47:52whirly skeptical up until the other weekend when we went to Dustledorf and we
- 47:57played an Infamous Traffic how'd you feel about Cole Whirly now? Well, I
- 48:02don't know that. So again, I don't want to base my opinion about
- 48:06him as a designer on one game, even if it's for the better.
- 48:08I happen to think an Infamous Traffic was like a very interesting game, but
- 48:15it doesn't change the fact that I am not like a root lifestyle player.
- 48:20I really bounced hard off of Oath, we both did, and I people
- 48:27have been saying that they think Packs to Mere is like one of the greatest
- 48:30design games of all time. Maybe I have to play it again. I
- 48:31mean I have it. I didn't love it, to be honest, I
- 48:34think it's fine. I didn't love it, though. Yeah. And you
- 48:37you really like Bally who these games, don't you? Yeah? So I
- 48:40think I think what's interesting is I mean, sometimes, right, sometimes you're
- 48:46in a swimming pool and the swimming pool's nice, and then someone has a
- 48:52ship in the swimming pool, and even though you're not in the bit of
- 48:57the pool where the shit's floating, I don't want to stay in the pool
- 49:00right right, I'm trying to a picture of the image now, So what
- 49:07I'm trying to say is flooding there. Yeah, it's just floating there.
- 49:12And anyway, So the thing is Oath was such a gigantic turn in the
- 49:17Pool that I that it truly infected my view of his other games, unfortunately.
- 49:23But what made you think that he was so great before? Was it
- 49:27John Company First Edition? Was it past premiere? I mean no, I
- 49:30thought I well, because I played infamous Traffic in twenty nineteen, and I
- 49:34thought it was wonderful. Then I played Route, which I thought was really
- 49:38good, and it was just based on that really, But but I think
- 49:44I think the way he talks about games is fascinating. The way he approaches
- 49:49games is fascinating. And I realized, I think in the way that and
- 49:54this is I got an argue in an argument with cet new And on my
- 49:58podcast about this because he thought I was saying that the that the auteur is
- 50:05better than the craftsman, but actually it was the other way around. And
- 50:08I used Cole Whirly and Ryana Canitzier as examples. And so what I see
- 50:14in Col Worley's designs is a desire to be conceptually rigorous. He treats game
- 50:20design like an academic would treat game design. And what happens is you have
- 50:22a lot of nice ideas, and I think oath is the quintessence of this.
- 50:27You have lots of nice ideas. The names for actions are very sort
- 50:30of clever, and you know, there's this desire for it to be People
- 50:36want to like it because I think they think you're somehow intellectually rigorous. If
- 50:40you do. But there's why I assumed you liked him. But there zero
- 50:45fucking game there. His aspiration is to make something that's worthy and intelligent,
- 50:50whereas Ryana Canitzia has one aspiration make a good game. He doesn't always succeed,
- 50:54but he's a true craftsman as opposed to an artist, and I think
- 51:00crafts people make the best art, ironically and so but I still think Infamous
- 51:07Traffic is wonderful. It's it feels very unique, and it's very simple,
- 51:13but it promotes the kind of a cross table bally who that is just that
- 51:19is just absolutely fantastic, and I hope the second edition doesn't ruin it.
- 51:23Basically, you want to play a game designed by William Morris, not Pablo
- 51:28Picasso. I take it right, exactly exactly. So the point is I
- 51:34spoke in my weather Machine review that up on the YouTube channel. I talked
- 51:37about art and design and why games are designed, and I said, the
- 51:42reason games are designed is because they have they have to have an inherent utility
- 51:46in the way that art doesn't. Right. Art can be art can be
- 51:52impractical and weird. And the example I used was the Son of Man by
- 51:57mcgreet that he doesn't. He doesn't have to care whether that poor bloke can
- 52:00see anything with the apple in front of his face, because it's a piece
- 52:04of art. Whereas a game has to have a utility. Therefore it's designed
- 52:08as opposed to do created in a greater sense. And I think the minute
- 52:15you the minute you step away from this idea that you're creating a game and
- 52:21you're creating some gazamt kunstwerk, you're inevitably going to descend into self indulgence.
- 52:25And often self indulgence isn't very good, right, And speaking of self indulgence,
- 52:30how many like foreign words do we incorporate into every episode of this podcasts?
- 52:36It's truly incredible what we're capable of. Incredible. So I think that
- 52:40vital Lisserta might be going through a kind of Baroque period. Cole Whirly seems
- 52:46to only have had a Baroque period, But it doesn't mean that occasionally there's
- 52:52informos. Traffic feels very pure to me, A sure simple game design that
- 52:58does exactly what he wants it to just doesn't feel like anything else. It
- 53:01doesn't feel like anything else. There there is something like very uncanny about it.
- 53:06I still haven't really wrapped my head around it. I have to play
- 53:08it more than once, I think, but it just makes it very hard
- 53:13for me to judge Cole Worly, because I couldn't say, like, what
- 53:15is a classic COLVERLYE game? I probably could say, what is a classic
- 53:20you tell liserta game? I kind of wonder why Tragdor aspirationally would like well,
- 53:25I asked him on and he says the reason he used the word aspirational
- 53:29because he wants to play. He has an aspiration for Coleworly to be his
- 53:32favorite good game designer, but he doesn't get his games to the table enough
- 53:36to be able to convincingly say it. I think I think trog Door might
- 53:40be a woman. By the way, not completely not completely clear though,
- 53:46people need to tell us. I'm getting away from that anyway. So final
- 53:52one, Steve, and we should wrap this up with the most definitive statement
- 53:59of the of the week, and this is Ethan r. I think by
- 54:02default the answer should just be Ryana Kanitzia, the only one and true game
- 54:08designer. What do you think of that? I don't I don't know what
- 54:12only one and true game designer is supposed to mean. But Chrador also mentioned
- 54:16Ryan Kanitzia, and I kind of wonder, like why we wouldn't pick Ryan
- 54:20or Kanitzia. I think some of his games, many of his games,
- 54:23most of his they're almost too perfect. There's nothing that sort of stands out
- 54:29enough for me to say, like I can sort of identify with the personality
- 54:32quirks of this designer's art, because I don't know. Rhyner's games are kind
- 54:37of for everybody. He's a game designer for all seasons. So the point
- 54:42is, I think, I think what's interesting about Ranna Canitzia is you could
- 54:45play. So my favorite Rana Kanitzia game is Modern Art, which I think
- 54:47he's absolutely spectacular, and you play it and you go, this is great.
- 54:52But you only truly get to appreciate Ryana Kanitzia once you you get to
- 55:01the end of your or you get to a point in your Ryana Canitzia journey,
- 55:05and you go, oh, my god, I've just played Modern Art
- 55:07and ra and Tigers and Euphrates and Stevenson's Rocket and fucking Voodoo Prints and all
- 55:15of these games, and you go, my god. Though there are so
- 55:22many great games, you know, you play one and you go, this
- 55:24is great, and then but once you've played twenty great Ryana Canitzia game,
- 55:30my god, this guy is amazing. And I think I think the reason
- 55:34Kanitzia is so great and deserves every plaudit that he gets, and I think
- 55:38he is the greatest living game designer is that he has this unwavering a tesian
- 55:47to being as simple as possible. There has never been a baroque Ryana Kanitzia
- 55:55phase. He wants to get as much as he can out of the simplest
- 56:00rule set possible, and the magic that he fucking weeds with three or four
- 56:06rules is just astonishing. Right, So if I agree, But if he's
- 56:12the greatest, why would you not say he's your favorite? Is it for
- 56:15similar reasons that I wouldn't say he's my favorite? Yeah, because favorite and
- 56:20favorite and great are not the same thing. It's like, let me think,
- 56:28I don't know. I wouldn't say Shakespeare is my favorite writer, right.
- 56:31I think he's wonderful, I think he's spectacular. I think he's probably
- 56:35the greatest, but he's not my favorite, right, Shakespeare is not the
- 56:37one I returned to all the time. I would I think, I think
- 56:40I think I would rank because favorite is about enjoyment as well as sort of
- 56:46objective admiration, and I think I enjoy Evelyn war more than I do Shakespeare,
- 56:52right in the same way. You can like sort of appreciate Shakespeare aesthetically,
- 56:55but there's sometimes something unapproachable about that degree of sublimity. Yeah, and
- 57:02you know, Knitzia is Knitzia is clearly, I think the greatest living game
- 57:07design. It is he my favorite? Is he the one that I love
- 57:10the most? But the point is with Knitzia as well, because he's so
- 57:15good and it's so deep. I mean, I got on the Knnitzia train
- 57:19relatively late into my gaming career. Speak to me in two years time when
- 57:23I've played ten more Canizia games, and I might just go, well,
- 57:28yeah, it's clearly the best and my favorite because he brings so much joy
- 57:32to me. You know. Yeah, It's like, you know, the
- 57:35best decision that you can make is to go to the gym, but sometimes
- 57:37you'd rather go to the pub instead or exactly exam most of the time if
- 57:42it's you what m what? Oh? No. I had a colleague walk
- 57:46by asking if I wanted to go for a drink later, and I just
- 57:50I made a little joke about how they like to drink too much. And
- 57:52yeah, sorry about that. I didn't mean interrupt the podcast. No problem.
- 57:55Well, all right, and we'll we'll move on to in an act
- 58:00of willful competition, we present our all Right, Stevie, you're the judge,
- 58:08jury, and executioner. You've got to come up with who is?
- 58:14Can I pick uli You can't pick Ulie because he didn't post anything, Steve,
- 58:19but we just you can't pick everything. You can't doesn't matter. You
- 58:22can't pick Ulie every week. You've got to. You've got to pick someone.
- 58:27You've got to pick someone who you thought was great this week. I
- 58:30thought I thought Ulie was great this week you posted in the general channel.
- 58:35Yeah, but not only fucking hashtag channel channel. I want to pick Ulie.
- 58:38You can't pick Ulie. Pick someone else out of this week, fine,
- 58:44only the ones that we actually got to right yeah here, actually,
- 58:47shut up, shut up. Don't let people know I'm leaving them out.
- 58:54Do you think it's because you and I like yammer on too much? We
- 58:58can't actually definitely not everything that comes out of our mouths to solid gold.
- 59:01I'm gonna go with the Bruce this time, because he's giving us just that
- 59:06little bit of extra lift that we probably need to finally sit down and get
- 59:10get it the fuck over with and play Gloomhaven. All right, Well,
- 59:13congratulations to the Bruce. You are this buds poster of the mouth. That
- 59:21was good. That was our all right, Steve. So just to wrap
- 59:30up, I've got it on the on the show schedule what we need to
- 59:34say, So let's repeat it, Steve, how'd you join the discord?
- 59:38Hang on a second, Hang on a second, I'm going to Oh wait,
- 59:40I don't need to read this. I actually know. No, I'm
- 59:44prompting you. How did you join the discord? So you go to five
- 59:47games for doomsday dot com? Yeah, follow the link. Pin pinned,
- 59:52not pined, pin pined. You can pin us if you'll, he'll pin
- 59:57me. You're occasionally you send me that message. Occasionally you send me that
- 1:00:00message. Sound like a right fucking yuppy dikeet ya okay, pig Lata Okay,
- 1:00:07yeah, great, Pila. I'm adding I'm adding something to your document
- 1:00:13by the way. Yeah, I'm seeing in real time. Please uh give
- 1:00:19us five stars on oh yeah iTunes or wherever? What do you say,
- 1:00:27rate, Rate and Review. Yeah, we're on. We're on point one
- 1:00:30at the moment, so well, you won't let me finish point one.
- 1:00:32You have to interrupt me and fucking undercut me and insult me and humiliate me
- 1:00:37in front of our listener. Get on with it. I know Derek is
- 1:00:40your friend, but that doesn't mean that you have to use this podcast as
- 1:00:44an opportunity to make you to make yourself look better in front of me.
- 1:00:47Derek thinks I'm the cool one. Everybody likes you more than me. Anyway,
- 1:00:52it's like fucking you know, like stop hammering at home. I'm very
- 1:00:57vulnerable. Ben. Yeah, all right, just get go click click the
- 1:01:00link at the top of the page, the pin post and follow it and
- 1:01:04then you can go to discord and pining us to your heart's content. All
- 1:01:07right, Number two point two on the list. Steve just added please rate
- 1:01:12and review on iTunes or wherever it is people of rate and review podcasts.
- 1:01:15And Ben will not ask you to get five stars, but I will because
- 1:01:20it's a bit cringe asking to give five stars. But anyway, yeah,
- 1:01:22right, show rate whatever you want, but this is five star content,
- 1:01:24so I'm just trying to help. You don't even think about it. It's
- 1:01:27obviously five. All right, then number three, how's support the show?
- 1:01:32Why do I have to do all of these? Because you're good at it.
- 1:01:35You're like the organized one. I'm I'm like the cool I'm like the
- 1:01:37cool comedian, and you're like the boring sort of anal twat. Yeah,
- 1:01:42you're like you come across as this fucking like you know, out there extrovert.
- 1:01:45I'm Ben Maddex. I say whatever it is, whatever's on my mind,
- 1:01:47it comes out of my mouth, no filters. But then when it
- 1:01:51comes to asking people for support, you become all bashful and British and KG.
- 1:01:55Yeah, you can support the show by going to www dot patreon dot
- 1:02:05com slash. Now, remember the numbers, numbers are coming back. Numbers
- 1:02:07are back five g for d for some reason. And this this content that
- 1:02:14you're listening to right now, is this not for patrons? Remember you never
- 1:02:19bloody, remember no, this is on the main thing. This is coming
- 1:02:22out. I'm gonna just as we wouldn't we We wouldn't be asking for support
- 1:02:27if like they're already supporting us, right exactly, we might ask them to
- 1:02:31increase their support. So anyway, for five euros a month, you can
- 1:02:37enjoy even more of what you're experiencing right now, as well as original content
- 1:02:43developed and produced by ben Wayne Maddox himself indeed, and so finally, I'd
- 1:02:50just like to say thank you to everyone who contributed. Without you, the
- 1:02:53show wouldn't exist and what a tragedy that would be. And also if you
- 1:02:58want to suggest a topic, you know, because I'm not an endless fountain
- 1:03:04of creativity, if you want to suggest a topic, If you want to
- 1:03:07suggest a topic, you can go on the hashtag channel channel on the discord
- 1:03:14suggest a topic and maybe we'll do it for a show anyway. So that's
- 1:03:19all all we have to say is say thank you, Steve. Thank you,
- 1:03:22Steve. I'm going back to bed now because I'm six a dog.
- 1:03:35Without you, this show wouldn't exist, so really you're to blame, So
- 1:03:39thank you for listening, and oil up your ears for the next hashtag channel
- 1:04:00of the m