Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Path to $1M Bitcoin with Vijay: The Bullish Case Revisited
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness, 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we're going to call this, it's all just the same
- 0:20thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell, hey. OK, I say when we sell.
- 0:33We just finished recording with DJ Boyapati, author of The
- 0:36Bullish Case for Bitcoin. I really enjoyed this one
- 0:38because his article in 2018 was one of the first pieces I came
- 0:42across that really started to help me understand Bitcoin, what
- 0:45it was, the history of money, and really the future of
- 0:48Bitcoin. He since published a book in
- 0:502021 diving into those ideas in more detail.
- 0:54And today on the last trade, we revisited something that I
- 0:58really wanted to was nation state adoption.
- 0:59He had mentioned that as kind of like one of the final points of
- 1:03the adoption curve for Bitcoin. So clearly there's a lot has
- 1:06changed since 2018 when he first published that article.
- 1:09We also talked about Bitcoin treasury companies and other hot
- 1:12topic there about B JS thoughts, which I thought were refreshing
- 1:15and balanced. And then we also talked about
- 1:18why he thinks Bitcoin adoption is still incredibly early from,
- 1:21you know, traditional finance and wealth advisors really not
- 1:23stepping in yet. Most people don't have any sort
- 1:26of material allocation. And then he also mentioned why
- 1:29Bitcoin is still incredibly attractive from a risk adjusted
- 1:34perspective, meaning a lot of the risks that people are
- 1:37concerned about 5 or 10 years ago no longer exist.
- 1:41But that said, one risk that does exist is custody and how
- 1:44you secure your Bitcoin. And So what we do here at On
- 1:47Ramp is we help investors like yourself, whether it's an
- 1:49individual or a business or institution to secure Bitcoin
- 1:53for the long term. We have inheritance built into
- 1:56that. We have insurance built in, we
- 1:57have Iras, loans, etcetera. There's a lot we can talk about.
- 2:01So if you want to learn more and how we can potentially help you,
- 2:04you can head to our website here.
- 2:06You can schedule a consultation and you speak with myself or
- 2:09someone else on the team. Hope you enjoy this episode with
- 2:11DJ as much as I enjoyed recording it.
- 2:14Welcome back to the last trade. We have a really exciting one.
- 2:17I'm I'm particularly excited for this one because we have Vijay
- 2:21Boyapati joining us and we have my Co host Brian Cabela's and
- 2:25Michael Tanguma. But Vijay, I know you have a
- 2:28busy summer. You have your hands full with
- 2:29the family. So thanks for carving out an
- 2:31hour here to sit down with us and chat everything that bullish
- 2:34that is happening in this space. It's great to be with you guys
- 2:38and I really like the format. I'm obviously a huge fan of the
- 2:42All In podcast, so it's a it's a cool format.
- 2:46Yeah, we're going to surpass them at some point.
- 2:48I can't put a prediction as to when that'll happen, but it
- 2:50could happen sometime. In the I think it's Bitcoin
- 2:52500,000. I think that's when you surpass
- 2:54them. You know, I think it'll be
- 2:55around the same. Time, yeah, it'll be around the
- 2:58same time they start understanding Bitcoin.
- 3:00I think that'll be the convergence.
- 3:01It'll yeah. Yeah, if we could only have
- 3:04Vijay here every week with us, we would be ahead of them in no
- 3:06time. But yeah, we want to start just
- 3:09really quickly. I want to at least acknowledge
- 3:11some new all time highs. This is the on ramp terminal.
- 3:14But we hit a, what was it, 123 or so earlier this week.
- 3:18Felt like a nice milestone, but we all know I think there's much
- 3:22more ahead of this cycle. But then also you're just
- 3:25looking ahead. We're really just getting
- 3:27started. And one of the things that we
- 3:29wanted to start with today was VJ.
- 3:32You know, you hold a special place in my heart, my friend,
- 3:34because in 2018, your article the bullish case for Bitcoin was
- 3:38really the first thing that kind of got me set on the right track
- 3:41here. And so the three of us ought to
- 3:43be a good idea to just revisit that quickly because you had in
- 3:47kind of the closing section of that piece that you published,
- 3:53you had I guess the best way to categorize it as the the final
- 3:56Gardner hype cycle. So if you want to just explain
- 3:59quickly what those hype cycles are, and then you mentioned the
- 4:02last one would be nation state adoption.
- 4:05And so we're finally at that breaking point here where we had
- 4:09El Salvador a few years ago. But now you have the US
- 4:11government getting involved and you have a lot of nations that
- 4:14are exploring Bitcoin as a strategic asset.
- 4:17So we'd love to just hear you revisit that.
- 4:19And it's probably pretty wild, seven years later, to be seen
- 4:22everything play out as you had written.
- 4:25Yeah, so the Gartner Hype Cycle is part of the process of
- 4:29monitor the monetization of Bitcoin and the cool thing about
- 4:32seeing the monetization of Bitcoin.
- 4:33And so we're we're watching this real time, like all of us are
- 4:36watching this happen. The process of monetization of
- 4:40gold took thousands of years and no one really had, you know, a
- 4:44complete sense of what it looked like.
- 4:46You'd you'd live your life. And the gold, the value of gold
- 4:49didn't fluctuate that that much. But with Bitcoin, it's going
- 4:53from being worth nothing to being worth trillions of dollars
- 4:55and becoming global money in the span of decades.
- 5:00And really no one has seen this before.
- 5:03And, and so it, it was kind of an open question like what does
- 5:06that monetization look like? Is it just linear?
- 5:09Is it just like adoption grows slowly but steadily over time?
- 5:14And what we've learned is that it happens in these cycles,
- 5:17which I, I call fractal patterns of increasing magnitude, which
- 5:21is you look at each of these cycles and you superimpose them
- 5:24on each other and they look pretty similar, right?
- 5:27You look at the cycle from 2017 and you overlay it on the cycle
- 5:31of 2013. It looks pretty similar.
- 5:34It's this kind of parabolic shape.
- 5:36Then you have this crash and then you have a plateau.
- 5:41And this is the shape of a classic Gardner hype cycle.
- 5:44So we've had, let's see, three or four of these.
- 5:49I'd say four of these Gardner hype cycles have happened so
- 5:53far. And what I posited in my article
- 5:58and then my book was that the last of these hype cycles would
- 6:02be nation states scrambling to get as much Bitcoin as possible.
- 6:08And one thing that I wrote, which I, I still think is true,
- 6:13is that it would be nation states with strong executive
- 6:18power that would be the first to adopt Bitcoin because it takes
- 6:23kind of a strong leader to come in and say, hey, we're just
- 6:26doing this. We're just going to buy Bitcoin.
- 6:29My view was that it would be some, a nation like North Korea
- 6:33that they, that their leader would say, hey, we need to get
- 6:37some kind of store value that we can transmit across the globe
- 6:41that can't be sanctioned by the US.
- 6:44So we are going to get it by stealing, by hacking, whatever
- 6:48means possible. It it turned out that the the
- 6:52the leader who really stepped forward first was Naib Buchelli
- 6:57from El Salvador. And while El Salvador is a
- 7:03democratic country, he has overwhelming support there, like
- 7:0790 plus percent support. So in practice, he has the power
- 7:12of a dictator. He has the power to do things
- 7:15that a very strong executive can do.
- 7:18And so he said, hey, we're just going to buy Bitcoin.
- 7:21And I don't care what anyone else thinks, we're going to go
- 7:24and do it because I think this is the right thing for our
- 7:26country. And I said I believed that
- 7:30Western democracies like the United States would actually be
- 7:33kind of later in line because it's really hard to build
- 7:37consensus in a democracy like the US, especially when you have
- 7:41so much polarization, right? When you have Democrats hating
- 7:46Republicans and you have these razor thin majorities in the
- 7:50House and the Senate, it's hard to get anything done.
- 7:54But it is interesting. I am a little surprised that the
- 7:57USI mean hasn't done anything really, but that the US said
- 8:02that it would establish A strategic Bitcoin reserve.
- 8:06And Trump seemed to be supportive of that.
- 8:09I think what that is, is a recognition that there's a very
- 8:13strong and crucial demographic in the US that are independent
- 8:19voters and that care a lot about Bitcoin.
- 8:23And, and for them, it might be their single issue, right?
- 8:27Like, I care a lot about Bitcoin.
- 8:29And if you were going to propose policy that is really
- 8:33antagonistic towards Bitcoin, hell no, I'm not going to vote
- 8:36for you. In fact, I'm going to go out of
- 8:38my way to try and make sure you can't get elected.
- 8:40And So what you've seen in this last election cycle is that
- 8:43there are all of these very powerful interests now that are
- 8:46having a big impact on the election and politicians are
- 8:49paying attention. And I'll give just one example
- 8:52of this. Sherrod Brown, who was a
- 8:55Democrat in Ohio, was the most powerful person on the Financial
- 8:59Services Committee. He was the chair of that
- 9:01committee and he was kicked off that committee.
- 9:03He was, he was voted out because the sort of Bitcoin slash crypto
- 9:09lobby went after him. And, and that was a very, very
- 9:14powerful signal. You better believe that people
- 9:16in the Democratic Party were paying attention to that, that
- 9:19this is now a very powerful lobby.
- 9:21And, and the, the, the last comment I'll make is this
- 9:24signals that Bitcoin has political capture now And for
- 9:28several years. I said the most important risk
- 9:30to Bitcoin is a nation state attack.
- 9:33And the only way to get around nation state attack is to get
- 9:36political capture. That is Bitcoin.
- 9:38There is enough adoption of Bitcoin that it becomes
- 9:41politically infeasible to attack it because the consequence of
- 9:44attacking it is you don't get into power.
- 9:47I think Trump coming to the Bitcoin conference, bending the
- 9:51knee and saying everything that Bitcoin, Bitcoin has wanted to
- 9:55hear from. I'm going to free Ross Ulbricht,
- 9:57I'm going to fire Gary Gensler. And he did these things, right?
- 10:00This is not empty promises. He did these things.
- 10:04That was the sign that we now have political capture.
- 10:06And I think the number one risk for Bitcoin is off the table.
- 10:11And so that is a very, very powerful thing.
- 10:14I think for this bull cycle and for future bull cycles we have
- 10:20instead of having this headwind against us, which is the
- 10:24political establishment being a headwind, it is now a tailwind
- 10:27for Bitcoin. So I think that's a very, very
- 10:30important sea change for the market.
- 10:33Yeah, One thing to call out from that prescience of, you know,
- 10:36referencing the adoption cycle in sovereigns, I think that was
- 10:41actually precisely right. They just weren't public because
- 10:43I was writing down like the Kingdom of Bhutan, you know,
- 10:45maybe didn't necessarily outright adopt or say they're
- 10:49gonna establish, but they've been leveraging their resources
- 10:51even before they became public. I think it like back ended into
- 10:53US finding out North Korea has been hacking everyone's wallets
- 10:57for a very long time. And I I was just saying that
- 11:00hacking Ethereum wallets then transferring it into Bitcoin
- 11:04because they recognize that Ethereum is an easier target to
- 11:07hack and that Bitcoin is the strongest, safest asset if you
- 11:11want to hold something liquid, easily transferable and not
- 11:15controllable by nation states. They wanted Bitcoin so the
- 11:19worst. This is another signal the the
- 11:21worst nation on earth recognizes that it's better to target
- 11:24Ethereum, but it's also better to save in Bitcoin.
- 11:28Exactly. And then Russia again with the
- 11:30sanctions and everything else going on.
- 11:32And then UAE, because it's understood that UAE has been
- 11:36stacking, whether it's via mining, via nuclear or just
- 11:41adopting, but behind closed doors.
- 11:42And these are all like effectively monarchies.
- 11:45And then Kazakhstan, I think this week it's it's interesting,
- 11:47it got to kind of swept under the rug, but they're potentially
- 11:49establishing a reserve a little out of a left field.
- 11:53Before we continue, I wanted to just ask, where do you, where
- 11:57does the, the first principle prescience or the first
- 12:00principles and some of the understanding of like this
- 12:03monetization phase come from? And the reason why I asked that
- 12:05is because like Jackson, you know, read the bullish case for
- 12:09Bitcoin very early. And then naturally, I've kind of
- 12:11looked at your, your Twitter for the, the signal and deep in the
- 12:14bear markets of like, you know, even now as we're coming back,
- 12:17it's, it's this is the adoption. This is where we're at.
- 12:19You know, there's a lot of questions have been around
- 12:21what's happening at 100K and is there paper Bitcoin.
- 12:23It's like, well, listen, people have been holding this for a
- 12:25long time. Feel like you've had a great
- 12:27handle on this phase more than a lot of people of what's
- 12:31happening in. And I know you've shared
- 12:33previously about your background father having to flee and carry
- 12:38gold and these stories, but you were also a Google engineer and
- 12:41lived the Silicon Valley life, which historically is like at
- 12:44polar office. It's a first principles
- 12:46thinking. I'm just curious, like, where
- 12:48does it come from? Because I think that'll help me
- 12:50personally. I understand how you develop
- 12:52this mindset, but also for the rest of the conversation where a
- 12:55lot of that comes from. Yeah, that's a good question,
- 12:57Michael. Actually, no one's ever asked me
- 12:58that. I think it comes from the fact I
- 13:02when I joined Google, I didn't really have any knowledge of
- 13:06politics or economics or anything like that.
- 13:08But then I came across some libertarians at Google and they
- 13:13introduced me to some thinkers, economic thinkers, who really
- 13:17changed my life, I would say. And yeah, people in the Austrian
- 13:22School of Economics, Ludwig von Mises, Friedrich Hayek, and they
- 13:29really provide a framework for thinking about economics and
- 13:32thinking about political economy.
- 13:35And I would say the book Human Action by Ludwig von Mises is
- 13:39just a life changing book. It's very, very difficult to
- 13:42read because it's, you know, someone who's a German speaker
- 13:45writing in English and writes these really long, verbose
- 13:49sentences which are incredibly dense.
- 13:53So it is, it's a difficult book to consume.
- 13:55There are other books that sort of introduce you to the same
- 13:59ideas in a more approachable way, but I'd say that's the
- 14:02background. Austrian economics, and in
- 14:05particular Ludwig von Mises, and that book Human Action really,
- 14:09really had a big impact on how I see the world.
- 14:12Love it. Yeah, one thing is well VJ that
- 14:15you mentioned that I thought was interesting that we talked on
- 14:18occasion on the show as well as you mentioned the political
- 14:21capital behind Bitcoin now and I would even expand that out to
- 14:25just broader incentives. And so now you really have
- 14:29everyone that has political power, financial power has the
- 14:33backing of Bitcoin, right? Because one of the things I like
- 14:36to follow that I can still cannot believe how little people
- 14:39are talking about it. But the fact that Blackrock's
- 14:42Bitcoin ETF is now in the top 20 largest ETFs in the world about
- 14:4718 months after a launch, right? And it's, I think the now the
- 14:51largest revenue driver for ETF products at BlackRock.
- 14:54So not only is it the political shift that we're seeing now, but
- 14:57it's also all of the largest pools of capital in the private
- 15:02sector have a ton of incentive for Bitcoin to be successful.
- 15:06And so I just, I'm curious to hear your thoughts how you think
- 15:08about that as on the private side in addition to the public
- 15:12sector? Yeah, there are two facts about
- 15:15that which I find absolutely incredible, that it's one of the
- 15:18biggest profit drivers at BlackRock.
- 15:20The fee structure on that ETF is incredibly low, incredibly low.
- 15:26So that tells you how how quickly it's grown and the
- 15:30assets under management in that ETF are enormous and growing
- 15:35very, very quickly. So despite the fact that the fee
- 15:37structure is so low, I think it's like oh point 2%, it's
- 15:42incredible like for this kind of esoteric product that they're
- 15:47offering. And just for context, the gold
- 15:50ETF is, oh point, 4% and the gold ETF has been around a lot
- 15:55longer. So the fact that they're making
- 15:59so much money on it is, is a testament to how quickly it's
- 16:04grown. The the other thing is that I
- 16:07find amazing is that people like Larry Fink and Jamie Diamond,
- 16:11they, they're not true believers.
- 16:13It's not like they really understood Bitcoin and like we
- 16:16need to figure out a Bitcoin strategy and like be forward
- 16:21thinking. And, and I, I will give credit
- 16:24to Fidelity. They, they were forward thinking
- 16:26and they built out a Bitcoin team very early on.
- 16:30The reason they got into Bitcoin was it was entirely bottom up.
- 16:35Their clients were coming to them saying, can you please give
- 16:38us a way to get exposure to Bitcoin And they were hearing
- 16:41this over and over and over again.
- 16:43Their big clients saying, please, family offices and high
- 16:46net worth individuals are coming to them and saying, we want a
- 16:49way to get exposure to Bitcoin. We're banking with you and we
- 16:52don't there's no product here. What do we do?
- 16:56And, you know, a lot of these folks, especially the older
- 16:59ones, they don't want to go out and buy Bitcoin directly and put
- 17:04it on a hardware wallet and then put it under their, you know,
- 17:08pillow. They don't know how to manage
- 17:11private keys. That stuff is scary as hell.
- 17:13So they wanted a trusted financial institution to give
- 17:17them access to bitcoin's price moves.
- 17:20And that's why Larry Fink launched the ETF.
- 17:22That's why Jamie Dimon is starting to think about offering
- 17:25products around Bitcoin. And it's it's a testament to
- 17:30this was there was a groundswell of demand for Bitcoin and this,
- 17:34the growth of this ETF, the fact that it's the fastest growing
- 17:37ETF in history is evidence of that, that underlying demand,
- 17:42that groundswell. And it it's not over by a, you
- 17:46know, a long shot like the gold ETF when it was launched caused
- 17:50a four or five year bull market in gold and, and gold, I think
- 17:54at 4 or 5X once the ETF was launched, you know, I think we
- 17:59could see a sustained bull market in Bitcoin.
- 18:03We may not see this cycle may be different to previous ones.
- 18:06It's entirely possible that we see a sustained bull market in
- 18:11Bitcoin that lasts 345 years based solely on the fact that
- 18:16there is so much underlying demand in the retail population
- 18:21to get Bitcoin. Yeah, Vijay, I was actually
- 18:23going to ask a question right along those lines of in your
- 18:28mind are are cycles different going forward?
- 18:30You know, obviously always cognizant of not saying that
- 18:33this time is different. But if you just, you know, take
- 18:36in context what we just spoke about in terms of institutional
- 18:39capital flows, even sovereign level flows, it does feel like,
- 18:43at least to me, like we've unlocked these higher rungs of
- 18:47pools of capital that now just fundamentally change the market
- 18:50dynamic. Like if there is some
- 18:52deleveraging event in the future, I just think there's
- 18:55going to be a massive bid from these larger pools of capital to
- 18:57step in with greater size. Where in the past, like you were
- 19:01reliant effectively on retail to, to, you know, step in in, in
- 19:06terms of, you know, that deleveraging event.
- 19:07And that could take time, right? Could take two years for retail
- 19:10to come back. So I just think the market
- 19:13structure is totally different now.
- 19:14What are your? Views on that just in terms of
- 19:16what cycles may look like going forward?
- 19:19Yeah, that's a great point. I will, I'm going to try and
- 19:23argue both sides of this and give you both perspectives.
- 19:27I think you're absolutely right, Brian.
- 19:29The market structure has completely changed and I think
- 19:31there are things now that dampen the movement of Bitcoin.
- 19:35One of the things is that we now have mutual funds which are
- 19:39allocating to Bitcoin and have a fixed percentage allocation,
- 19:43let's call it 3% or 4%. I think that'll grow and you're
- 19:45going to get more of these sort of retirement vehicles having a
- 19:50fixed allocation to Bitcoin. And the dampening effect there
- 19:53is they, let's say they allocate 5% and that turns out to be, I
- 19:57don't know, 500 million or it could be 5 billion depending on
- 20:00the size. Let's say Bitcoin has a Goodyear
- 20:03and it double S and now suddenly they've got a 10% allocation.
- 20:06They're going to sell that down. So they're going to try and get
- 20:09it back to their target allocation of 5%.
- 20:11So that's dampening. As Bitcoin goes up, they're
- 20:13going to dampen by selling it down.
- 20:15If it goes down, they're going to dampen in the other direction
- 20:18by let's say Bitcoin halves. Their allocation is now 2 1/2%
- 20:23and they're going to try and buy it back to 5%.
- 20:25So this is going to have a tendency to sort of stabilize
- 20:28the price of Bitcoin. The other part is the
- 20:32financialization of Bitcoin. That is, you now have options
- 20:37markets on Bitcoin, you now have futures markets on Bitcoin.
- 20:41Those things also tend to stabilize the price.
- 20:44They provide more liquidity and it means that you can you can
- 20:48make a sale in the Bitcoin market now without moving the
- 20:52price very much. And there's an example of a
- 20:54recent sale, very large sale of Bitcoin and it only moved the
- 20:59price a few percent, which I think is a remarkable testament
- 21:04to how liquid Bitcoin has become.
- 21:07So that's arguing one side. That's arguing the side, the
- 21:09point that you were making, Brian.
- 21:11The other side I will say is that human nature is still a
- 21:15thing. And and this madness of crowds
- 21:19phenomena, I think can still kick in.
- 21:22It's, it's not, it's not really possible to see something going
- 21:28up steadily in price and to not have people pile in like let's
- 21:32say Bitcoin goes up, you know, 20% a year.
- 21:35Every year people are going to say, why want some of that?
- 21:39And then more people will see, oh, well, it's actually going up
- 21:41more than 20%. It's going up 30% now.
- 21:44And that's what creates the parabolic move.
- 21:47I think that's still entirely possible that we do get a
- 21:51parabolic blow off top. And when that happens, I don't
- 21:56know, I could easily see this cycle being extended just
- 22:03because of the size of the capital that's involved.
- 22:05Now the last thing I'll say is this cycle already looks quite
- 22:08different from previous cycles where there was more of a kind
- 22:12of parabolic move where the price would kind of steadily,
- 22:17you could draw a parabola through it and there would be
- 22:19corrections, but it would go up, It would correct very quickly
- 22:22and just go up in kind of a parabola.
- 22:24This cycle looks more like a stair step where we go up like
- 22:2830% and then we plateau and just grind for eight months and, and
- 22:33people like, is that the end of the market?
- 22:35And then we'll go up another sort of 30 to 50% and grind.
- 22:38And this has happened like 3 times in this cycle.
- 22:41This already to me feels quite different to, to prior cycles
- 22:46because of that. So I don't know.
- 22:49I guess that the, the bottom line is I don't know how this is
- 22:52going to play out. My intuition is this plays out
- 22:55over a longer period of time, but eventually the madness of
- 23:00crowds will kick in and that you will get retail FOMO and people
- 23:04will start piling in and you will get a blow off top.
- 23:08And I could see that happening in 20/26/2027.
- 23:13And and the thing we've learned from prior cycles is the top
- 23:16always seems higher than most people predict at the beginning
- 23:19of the cycle. Yeah, I think that's exactly
- 23:21right. Just based on the it's extended,
- 23:26it does look different, a little muted for a number of reasons
- 23:28with the, the capital markets, specifically options to, to kind
- 23:31of like dull or smooth out the volatility, but also from behind
- 23:36the scenes. And I'm sure you, you see a lot
- 23:38of this as well. You there's a lot of liquidity
- 23:40and plumbing being set up, whether it's banks, stable coins
- 23:43coming live, other, you know, institutions that allowing for
- 23:47setting up ETFs, the sovereign adoption pub codes that there's
- 23:52still a lot more liquidity to come in before this natural blow
- 23:55off top. But then we're still all humans
- 23:58and the people still running these shops are humans and they
- 24:01will naturally get overextended. My mental model and part of the
- 24:05founding of this business was looking at 2022 and realizing,
- 24:09Oh my God, we're going to redo this again because it's the old
- 24:12legacy mental model of just pure trad fire, right?
- 24:14Like either self custody or third party custody.
- 24:17And they treat Bitcoin like every other asset and they're
- 24:19not familiar with 24/7 lending and all the things associated
- 24:22with it that we've kind of like lived through.
- 24:24And so tread fights going to come in and do it because you
- 24:26don't just like wake up and be a pub Co and say, I want 5 billion
- 24:29and understand what you've learned in the past 15 years,
- 24:31like it's impossible. And so those humans are
- 24:34naturally going to get outside of their insurance.
- 24:35And then there's also the notion of not every capital, long term
- 24:38capital. We saw with forget what the firm
- 24:40was in 21 that realized like 100% gain and sold.
- 24:44And, and, you know, it's still rallied another like, you know,
- 24:462X from there is people are going to realize their gain and
- 24:49sell off and that's going to, you know, participate in that
- 24:52volatility in the future. Yeah.
- 24:55I think, you know, everyone who comes into Bitcoin learns these
- 24:58lessons over time. Like they, they initially see it
- 25:01as a trading opportunity. There's this famous tweet from
- 25:052011 where someone bought Bitcoin for three cents and
- 25:08they, they sold it at $0.08. And it just keeps getting
- 25:12brought up every year. And, and I think that's going
- 25:16to, that's going to apply to a lot of these financial
- 25:18institutions too, that they don't, they don't understand
- 25:21what they have on their hands. I, I think.
- 25:24And, and that's, that's fair enough.
- 25:25You go back to the early days of Bitcoin, of the cypherpunks and,
- 25:29and the libertarians who are using it, A lot of them didn't
- 25:31understand what they had either. Like you look at the 2017 block
- 25:35size wars, there was this huge debate internally in the Bitcoin
- 25:39community, like what is Bitcoin? Is it digital gold?
- 25:43Or is it like a decentralized PayPal or Visa?
- 25:46Like is it a payment rail? And, and I think that debate was
- 25:51decisively answered. It's, it's much more akin to
- 25:53gold. It's much more akin to a reserve
- 25:55currency. But when, when you don't
- 25:59understand what Bitcoin is and what the opportunity is, you do
- 26:03see it as a, a short term trading opportunity.
- 26:05You're like, oh, this is great. I can make, you know, 50% in a
- 26:09year, or maybe I'm lucky and I get 100% in a year and I time it
- 26:13correctly. But then they're not zooming out
- 26:15and seeing like this is a generational opportunity.
- 26:19And this isn't me. This isn't my intuition coming
- 26:21from, you know, my understanding, the economics,
- 26:24this is my intuition having worked at Google.
- 26:26These things are very rare, these generational opportunities
- 26:29that change the world. And when you see them and when
- 26:32you understand them, what you want to do is just hold a core
- 26:35position, build a core position and just hold it forever.
- 26:40That that is how great wealth is always made.
- 26:42It's it's having a concentrated position in something that you
- 26:46have high conviction in. All of the, all of the
- 26:49wealthiest people on Earth became wealthy that way.
- 26:51It's not through diversification, it's not
- 26:53through day trading. It's having a concentrated
- 26:55position in something that's going to change the world, and
- 26:58that's what Bitcoin is. I love it.
- 27:01Yeah. No, Vijay, one thing too, we
- 27:03wanted to talk about ties into what you just said in the sense
- 27:07like I think the three of us, Brian, Michael, myself, we are,
- 27:12we're strongly advocating for people to buy and hold to your
- 27:14point, have a core position in Bitcoin and just kind of forget
- 27:18about it, right? Make sure the custody is up to
- 27:21snuff, however you want to do that and your family can access
- 27:24it. But you know, in this cycle,
- 27:27we've had a lot of people advocate for people selling
- 27:30their Bitcoin to buy a better form of Bitcoin, Bitcoin
- 27:34treasury companies. So I know it's something you
- 27:37wanted to talk about. Brian had it on his list as
- 27:39well. We wanted to talk about Bitcoin
- 27:41treasury companies. What your thoughts are in that
- 27:44space. I my personal before I hand it
- 27:46over to you, is that like if people want to invest in them,
- 27:49by all means, but you got to have the core position in
- 27:51Bitcoin. Like that's the most important
- 27:53thing here. But I also think it ties into
- 27:55what you said earlier about human psychology.
- 27:58And so I think that the Bitcoin treasury companies will likely
- 28:01play a part in a blow off top that inevitably happens whether
- 28:05it's this year or next. But want to hand it over to you
- 28:08and then certainly welcome the groups thoughts on this topic
- 28:10too. Because it's a it's a spicy one
- 28:12let's say. Yeah, I, I mean, there is kind
- 28:16of a religious fervor around these treasury companies and,
- 28:20and how, you know, they're great for accumulating Bitcoin.
- 28:24And there's this narrative that they're better than Bitcoin
- 28:27because they can, they can be a creative of Bitcoin per share.
- 28:31They can accumulate more Bitcoin per share through various, you
- 28:35know, financial engineering. I will observe that every cycle
- 28:41has had a bubble, something which kind of made it like
- 28:45people got really excited about it.
- 28:46Then it blew up and, and people lost their limbs from, from the
- 28:51bubble. And in 2017 it was Icos and in,
- 28:54in 2021 it was like NFTS and, and Defy.
- 29:01And also I will say GBTC. We can, we can talk about that
- 29:04later. And this cycle it's treasury
- 29:07companies. They are the big bubble and they
- 29:09will be, in my view, they will be the reason that this market
- 29:12blows up. And there will be a tail that
- 29:15will give you a big hint that the top of the cycle is in.
- 29:18Once the premium to NAV gets to one or drops below 1, you should
- 29:24be very, very careful about, you know, doing anything crazy in
- 29:28the market or putting in a huge purchase because that will be
- 29:31the signal for the top of the market.
- 29:34I am very skeptical of the idea that you can financial engineer
- 29:39your way to, you know, a huge holding of Bitcoin.
- 29:45I know it's happening with a couple of companies.
- 29:47And so they're a little bit of an anomaly like MicroStrategy
- 29:50and Metaplan. It's had some success, but
- 29:52you're going to get a flooding of companies doing this to the
- 29:55point where they're not able to be creative anymore and the
- 29:58premium to NAV gets down to 1 and they can't issue more
- 30:04shares. And I, I've always been
- 30:08supportive of the idea that companies have a real business
- 30:12and they save in Bitcoin. Mike, that's how MicroStrategy
- 30:15started, right? Remember, the first purchase of,
- 30:17of Bitcoin was MicroStrategy had $500 million that they had
- 30:22earned through their, their real business, their bricks and
- 30:25mortar business, which was a data analytics business.
- 30:28And they're like, what do we do with this $500 million?
- 30:30Let's buy Bitcoin. That's great.
- 30:33But this idea that you can kind of bootstrap your way up doesn't
- 30:39make much sense to me because there is nothing, there's no
- 30:45rational reason that they should have a premium to NAV.
- 30:48Let's say I create a treasury company that doesn't have an
- 30:51underlying business, that doesn't have any underlying cash
- 30:54flow and I have like 10 Bitcoin. Why should the value of the
- 30:59company trade higher than the 10 Bitcoin?
- 31:01There's no reason, There's no logical reason.
- 31:04It's just sort of irrational market sentiment.
- 31:11And eventually that market sentiment will be, I think,
- 31:15washed away and then you're going to get the hangover in the
- 31:18crash When, when that happens, I don't know.
- 31:21But I, I would be looking for the tail.
- 31:23If MicroStrategy trades at its asset value, then, you know, the
- 31:27bull market's about to end. I think that's really well said.
- 31:31And we've been I've personally been very loud about this,
- 31:34living through a lot of just building in this industry and
- 31:37seeing people lose their Bitcoin specifically like blocked by
- 31:39FTX. And part of our role when I
- 31:43think of outside of just custody and financial services and we
- 31:45like safeguarding. So all the things that you've
- 31:47learned, we've learned, we communicate that to clients and
- 31:49they can do whatever they want, but there's very little people
- 31:52just telling people to park and hold their Bitcoin.
- 31:53We'll take a nominal fee and then you go back to your life.
- 31:56And so just take pride in that. And I've done a lot of soul
- 32:00searching because I'm trying to figure out like, am I the lud
- 32:02out here? Am I crazy?
- 32:04And, and we've had to have these discussions you referenced.
- 32:07And I do think one big component you touched on it with the ET FS
- 32:12is and it, and this was something I was thinking about
- 32:14and that I was recently messing around with a single sig wallet.
- 32:18And it's like the proposition of all of us and what we did to get
- 32:21Bitcoin is actually kind of insane when you really think
- 32:23about it. Park material wealth, if not all
- 32:24of our wealth in this thing. And so many people globally have
- 32:28wanted exposure and there's so much capital out there that's
- 32:30underperforming. And so you see this, that's the,
- 32:33it's rational, irrational behavior of people just trying
- 32:37to get their proxy exposure through these vehicles.
- 32:39But to your point, this is just asymmetric misunderstanding of
- 32:43there's other ways to do it and there will increasingly be.
- 32:45And as people smarten up as everyone does because their
- 32:48wealth increases in whatever terms, well, there's Bitcoin per
- 32:50share of dollars. I'm like, well, what is this
- 32:52thing? And the rational move is to take
- 32:54it out and get the underlying with the least amount of
- 32:57counterparty risk. So, and that's just one angle.
- 33:00There's the first principles angle.
- 33:01What you're probably keen in on is you can't make more money off
- 33:03of money on a long enough time horizon.
- 33:05And so, yeah, it's, it's refreshing to hear you take have
- 33:09that take. But also I, I do see the concern
- 33:12of like, there's just so much capital out there and so much
- 33:14people, so many people that don't know.
- 33:16And we're in a mimetic world where there's a ticker for
- 33:18everything. And so it's like we're infusing
- 33:20Bitcoin into instead of crypto 2 point O we're going to get it's
- 33:23the the altcoin cycle, but it's in public duty traded stocks,
- 33:26which is where everyone 6040 is in by definition.
- 33:30So it's a click of a button to get your Bitcoin Treasury Co.
- 33:33And so it probably lasts a lot longer than we're expecting or
- 33:36hoping. Yeah, you're right, it could
- 33:39last a lot longer. I will say it's kind of the last
- 33:44stage of a risk on market where people really chasing that kind
- 33:48of performance because I think there are at the last stage of a
- 33:54bull market, there's just so much froth and so much
- 33:58speculation and people are trying to catch up in a way.
- 34:01Like they look back and they feel this sense of like lost,
- 34:05lost opportunity because they, they have friends or people they
- 34:09know who've made like, I don't know, 2X or 3X in Bitcoin and
- 34:13they haven't, they've come in really late and they're like,
- 34:15how do I catch up? And it's really just pure greed.
- 34:19You know, the market's driven by greed and fear.
- 34:21And at the end of a bull market, it's just pure greed.
- 34:25And that's when people are trying to look for leverage.
- 34:29I will say this reminds me a lot of before I was a Bitcoiner, I
- 34:33was a gold bug. And I, I used to talk about gold
- 34:37when I was an employee at, at Google and try and explain why
- 34:39gold was important to people. And they would always look at me
- 34:42funny, like, what is this useless rock?
- 34:44Why would you want to own this useless rock?
- 34:47And then I'd explain it and they would start understanding
- 34:50inflation and start understanding money and they'd
- 34:52be like, Oh yeah, actually gold makes sense.
- 34:54I should have some in My Portfolio.
- 34:56And the next thing that would happen was why don't I own a
- 34:59gold miner? Because they have more leverage.
- 35:02And if gold is going to do well, and now I start to believe the
- 35:05story that gold will do well, it's better to own gold miners.
- 35:09And I would always have to sit them down and say no, that
- 35:13that's a bad idea because there are all these other risks to
- 35:17gold miners that gold does not have this geopolitical risk.
- 35:20There's management risk, there's forex risk, there are all these
- 35:24other risks that you're not considering.
- 35:27What you're trying to get is leverage on gold.
- 35:29If you want more performance, if you're getting greedy and the
- 35:32gold is not giving you enough performance, just leverage on
- 35:35gold. And I make the same point about
- 35:37Bitcoin. If you feel like you need to
- 35:39catch up, don't go find a super speculative treasury company
- 35:43that you think is going to 10X. Just do leverage on Bitcoin.
- 35:47I mean, I think that's a bad idea too.
- 35:50You're going to get blown up that way too, but at least it's
- 35:53a pureplay and you're not taking on these risks that you don't
- 35:57understand. You were just taking on the risk
- 36:00of leveraging on Bitcoin. So yeah, it really is.
- 36:04I think it's greed. That's what what it comes down
- 36:08to. It's people are chasing
- 36:10performance that they feel like they've missed out on.
- 36:13And you won't. You know, as much as you speak
- 36:16to people, Michael, you're not going to be able to stop it,
- 36:18unfortunately, because there's just this herd mentality and
- 36:22people go crazy at the end of the cycle.
- 36:25And you just kind of have to stand back as someone who's seen
- 36:29it over and over again and say, crap, this is going to happen
- 36:34and people are going to get burned and people I care about
- 36:37are probably going to get burned, but there's nothing I
- 36:40can do about it. You're going to feel like
- 36:41Cassandra, that that's what it's going to feel like.
- 36:44It's the beauty of having a vehicle to express it in the
- 36:47which is our firm. And then the low time
- 36:50preference. Because I appreciate you sharing
- 36:52this because the guy like I have, we're all day long
- 36:54explaining what you're explaining.
- 36:56And I know they buy in, but they're a little younger and
- 36:58they haven't gone through like build it in this business.
- 37:00And I witnessed this first hand. I used to.
- 37:02I was that Unchained built that business and would compete
- 37:04against block Fi all day long. And our loans were more
- 37:07expensive and everyone would always like, you know, balk.
- 37:10They knew it was better. It's like, look, nominally it's
- 37:12more expensive. I remember the exact numbers
- 37:14because interest rates were lower was 7.9% to lend against
- 37:17your Bitcoin at block fine, 9.9 at unchanged, but it was risk
- 37:20adjusted much cheaper and then people lost their shirts.
- 37:23But then at the other end of that, that's when you build a,
- 37:26you know, generational business because all that capital flees
- 37:29not only to the people explaining it, but also the more
- 37:31transparent fault tolerant solutions.
- 37:33So that's the angle here is like we just keep talking about it
- 37:35and people will remember who was doing it the right way and then
- 37:38who was putting people in these like speculative products.
- 37:40Yeah, you're absolutely right. 2022 was a great example of
- 37:44this. Like all of the companies which
- 37:47had no risk management, which were being incredibly reckless
- 37:51with their lending, they all blew up Voyage of Block Fi, you
- 37:55know, Genesis all, they all blew up because they didn't have good
- 37:59lending practices and their management specifically
- 38:04prevented good lending practices because they were greedy.
- 38:08And, and, you know, to have good risk management and risk
- 38:12controls in place would mean that they wouldn't make as much
- 38:15money. And and, and unchanged is an
- 38:18example of a company that was, you know, very responsible and,
- 38:21and still exists, but probably left money on the table because
- 38:26of that. But in this space, that's the
- 38:30only way you survive. Like the ones that win in this
- 38:34space are the cockroaches, the ones that say, I just want to
- 38:37survive because every cycle there's something that will blow
- 38:40up a lot of businesses. And at the end of the day, it's
- 38:43the cockroaches which survive and become the most successful
- 38:47companies. And, and some examples of that
- 38:50like River and and Coinbase who, who've been fairly, you know,
- 38:56risk averse and haven't taken, you know, huge leverage or, and,
- 39:00and have had good risk control. So I think that's a good lesson
- 39:05to any business in this space is is to be a cockroach and
- 39:09survive. I hope you're enjoying this
- 39:11episode with DJ. I did tell you at the start of
- 39:13the show, it was a good one, so I hope it's delivering on that.
- 39:16Just a quick break. If you could leave a like a
- 39:18comment, subscribe rate, 5 stars, that really helps.
- 39:23We spend a lot of time making this a good use of your time
- 39:27from booking guests. I reach out to Vijay a number of
- 39:29times. He's busy and but I was really
- 39:31persistent wanting to have him on the show.
- 39:33I've always looked up to him. And so reaching out to guests,
- 39:36preparing for the episode, recording, editing, it all takes
- 39:40a lot of time. And so if you could just leave a
- 39:42like comment, I really appreciate it.
- 39:44Michael, Brian, the team, we really appreciate that.
- 39:46So thank you for being here tuning in.
- 39:49And if you could do that for us, that really helps.
- 39:51And then one other thing, if you haven't subscribed to our
- 39:54research, head to on ramp bitcoinresearch.com, check it
- 39:57out and then if it looks good to you, subscribe.
- 39:59I think Brian does a great job distilling his thoughts on the
- 40:03investment landscape on Bitcoin. Then we also share your product
- 40:07updates, launches, etcetera, partnership.
- 40:09So if you just want to stay up to date on what we're doing,
- 40:11that's a great place to hear from us.
- 40:13Enjoy the rest of the episode and thanks for being here.
- 40:15Bye. Well, one, one thought on that
- 40:18as a transition point is just curious your thoughts 'cause I
- 40:21don't like, let's say COIN base Black Rock, which is proxy.
- 40:26So ETF flows, pub codes, like where do you start to see a
- 40:31concern, if any, with the amount of assets getting pulled into
- 40:34these pulled vehicles? Because it's just been, I think
- 40:37it came out that as great as the ETFs have done, I think pub co's
- 40:41have accumulated half of those ETF assets and we're still early
- 40:44in this cycle. So just curious like if you, if
- 40:47you think about that at all of either the neutering, neutering
- 40:50or hollowing out of like the underlying into these vehicles
- 40:55and how that gets expressed from like what, what Bitcoin we think
- 40:57it will be as global money. Well, well, it'll be interesting
- 41:00when the cycle turns. Eventually it'll turn and
- 41:03sentiment will turn. That's that's inevitable.
- 41:07Some of the CEOs of these companies have said if we trade
- 41:13below NAV, we're going to sell the underlying and buy our
- 41:17shares. Now Michael sale is an excep
- 41:20exception to this. He said I'm never going to sell
- 41:24my Bitcoin. That's going to be very, very
- 41:27difficult, right? Like imagine you're a fiduciary
- 41:30for shareholders and suddenly you're trading at 50% of NAV and
- 41:35your shareholders are threatening to sue you.
- 41:37So my point is, it's not clear that the Bitcoin is going to
- 41:42stay with these companies. There's going to be an enormous
- 41:44amount of pressure if they trade below NAV to get rid of their
- 41:48bitcoins. And the bitcoins could flow out
- 41:50of these treasury companies just as easily because you're going
- 41:54to have some medium sized treasury company that no ones
- 41:58heard of. They're trading at 50% to NAV.
- 42:00The shareholders are suing the CEO and the CEO is like, oh
- 42:03shit, I'm going to have to sell my Bitcoin and buy shares.
- 42:07And those bitcoins are just going to flow right out of them
- 42:09and go to some stronger hands. So I wouldn't, don't worry too
- 42:15much. I, I do think at some point
- 42:17sentiment will shift and bitcoins will flow out of these
- 42:20treasury companies. But again, I don't know when
- 42:22when exactly that's going to be. Yeah.
- 42:25And so Vijay, you made a good point that I certainly agree
- 42:28with on the market perception and say the human and investor
- 42:35psychology around these is a lot of people feel like they not
- 42:40necessarily late. Like I think a lot of people in
- 42:42the Bitcoin space still recognize that it's early, but
- 42:45they look back a couple of years ago and the price is 10,000 if
- 42:49you look back a little bit further as 1000, right?
- 42:51And so it's still, I think there's a perception where many
- 42:56investors think that they've missed a lot of the upside,
- 42:58right? And so naturally, they go into
- 43:00riskier areas of the market to try to eventually, hopefully get
- 43:04more spot Bitcoin in their possession.
- 43:06But as you mentioned, that's very challenging feat to
- 43:08accomplish. So maybe you could just help
- 43:11paint a picture about where we are.
- 43:14Do you think we're finally at the exponential point of the S
- 43:17curve? Are we approaching it?
- 43:19We'd just love to hear your thoughts about kind of what lies
- 43:21ahead, you know, thinking, let's say, past this year, past next
- 43:25year, just in the next like 5 to 10 years.
- 43:27Because I think some people need to hear this still, right?
- 43:29Because otherwise they're going to end up in vehicles that they
- 43:31probably shouldn't own just because they're being greedy and
- 43:34they think that they are not going to be able to have enough
- 43:36Bitcoin. We're we're still definitely in
- 43:39the early adopter stage. I'd say global adoption is still
- 43:42single digit percentage call it 5% maybe of of the global
- 43:47population owns Bitcoin. So I think we we still are
- 43:51incredibly early. Sorry, can you repeat the last
- 43:57part of the the questioning and Jax and I missed the yes.
- 43:59Sure. So the last part would be, you
- 44:01know, so you said we're at the early adopter stage still.
- 44:05What do you think needs to happen for let's say this like
- 44:08exponential part of the S curve? Like when?
- 44:10When do you approximate that may happen?
- 44:12Or what should we look for to know that is happening outside
- 44:15of just the price exploding higher?
- 44:19The one thing I think is really important is that it's not the
- 44:24number of people who adopt Bitcoin that is really
- 44:26important, it's the total amount of capital.
- 44:28This is something I tweeted about recently.
- 44:32And most of the capital is concentrated in places like the
- 44:36US. So, you know, one point I made
- 44:39on Twitter is that the top .1% of capital in the US, like, you
- 44:44know, the billionaires in the US, they have more capital than
- 44:48the entire population of Africa. Oh yeah, this is the tweet.
- 44:53Thanks. So it is possible that this
- 45:00happens very quickly, right? What you need is for folks who
- 45:05are wealthy to suddenly get it and suddenly say, oh, I, you
- 45:11know, I'm so short Bitcoin, I don't have any Bitcoin and it is
- 45:15exploding. I need some exposure to Bitcoin
- 45:17that I think could happen within one cycle or maybe two cycles
- 45:21where you have these incredibly wealthy people who are thinking
- 45:26about their portfolios and say I need to get like Bill Gates.
- 45:29I my guess is he has near 0% allocation.
- 45:34Folks like that if they suddenly turn and realize that this is
- 45:37not going away, they need exposure.
- 45:39That could happen very quickly. The signs of that, you know, I
- 45:43think price will tell us, I think when Bitcoin, when Bitcoin
- 45:47goes from 100,000 to like a million, I think we'll know just
- 45:51by the fact that the to to to get to that price level, you
- 45:55have to have such an enormous amount of capital coming in.
- 45:58Like to to get Bitcoin to a 4 trillion market cap, you you
- 46:01need hundreds of billions of dollars of capital come to come
- 46:05in and for hundreds of billions of dollars of capital coming,
- 46:08you need to have these very high net worth individuals jumping
- 46:12into Bitcoin. So I think price is really the
- 46:14big signal. In that context, Vijay, I'm
- 46:17curious how, you know, how big of a factor is sort of the
- 46:22broader macro picture and the unsustainability of Fiat debt
- 46:26and deficits. Because to me, that's like that
- 46:29would be part of the turning point for that super high net
- 46:31worth individual who recognizes like the unsustainability of the
- 46:35debt. And it feels like for a while
- 46:37we've been sort of reaching that event horizon of people
- 46:40recognizing, you know, Elon getting loud on Twitter about it
- 46:42after his failed attempts at doge.
- 46:44Like it seems like it's more in the zeitgeist that the Fiat
- 46:47system is is unsustainable and we're just going to have to
- 46:50debase our way out of this. You know, how, how much weight
- 46:54do you put on that component of it as opposed to like someone
- 46:56just purely learning about Bitcoin, understanding Bitcoin
- 46:59versus understanding the rest of the world and the the sort of
- 47:02water that they've been swimming in?
- 47:04Yeah, that's a great question. I think Bitcoin has now become a
- 47:07macro asset. And what I mean by that is that
- 47:09macro factors affect the price of Bitcoin.
- 47:12And I think we saw that in the last cycle.
- 47:14My strong, my personal view is that the last cycle ended
- 47:20because of the Fed. And I think Bitcoin behaved in a
- 47:23way that gold would behave. Gold did behave in the 70s.
- 47:28It was the Fed that killed the gold rally.
- 47:29During the 70s, gold went exponential.
- 47:32And then in 1980, it went into a bear market because Paul Volcker
- 47:38came along and said I'm going to get inflation under control.
- 47:40And he raised interest rates to 20%. the Fed did something
- 47:45similar in 2022 where they at first they were like inflation
- 47:49transitory. We think it's going to go away.
- 47:52And then they got religion and thought, oh, this is starting to
- 47:55get out of control. We need to stop this.
- 47:58And so they raised interest rates very quickly and it had a
- 48:02big impact on Bitcoin, at least in my opinion.
- 48:05So I think Bitcoin is acting like a macro asset.
- 48:08When Bitcoin was much smaller, I don't think that would have
- 48:11mattered because it was just really an adoption story.
- 48:13And it's, it's kind of like, you know, like a penny stock or a
- 48:18startup or something like that. They're much more affected by
- 48:22adoption and user growth than they are by macro factors like
- 48:27Google, for instance, when I joined Google in 2022, it was
- 48:33like the depths ofthe.com bust, right?
- 48:36Companies were laying off people, there was a huge
- 48:39recession, but Google was growing like crazy because it
- 48:42there was an adoption story there.
- 48:45I think Bitcoin has now gotten to a size where it is affected
- 48:48by macro factors and the adoption story itself can't
- 48:53completely overcome them. So, yeah, I'm not sure if that
- 49:00answered your question, Brian. No, it definitely does.
- 49:03Go ahead, Mike. I.
- 49:04Was just saying, I think there's two components on both questions
- 49:07that Jackson brought up on. Like one of the aspects of
- 49:11adoption is that as the price rises, awareness happens.
- 49:14And then as awareness happens, more users by notion of holding
- 49:18and want to accept it. And I think that's will be a
- 49:20cat, not a catalyst, but it'll be a Canary where you start to
- 49:23see more people want to accept it for goods and services.
- 49:26And that'll be part of that like real kind of breakaway.
- 49:29But the other one that just rings out is I don't think
- 49:31people, not that they don't care, but the average person
- 49:34doesn't actually really care about macro or even the debt
- 49:38because the debt is like ephemeral at this point.
- 49:40You just hear about it and it just always gets, it continues
- 49:43to get raised. And the concern is the, you can
- 49:47start to see this with like real world assets and tokenizing like
- 49:50everyone's going to get rich in the next couple years in nominal
- 49:53terms. But in real terms, it's, it's
- 49:55that like waking up. And I don't know what happens
- 49:57where people realize the only way you can actually persist or
- 50:01outcome like stay ahead of, of real inflation is by holding
- 50:05this asset. And I think that's just a
- 50:08function of once you get that enough penetration that the
- 50:10market just realizes that's your cornerstone.
- 50:13Like we talk with banks all the time in the way I think about
- 50:16user adoption is, remember we used to have checking account or
- 50:18savings accounts and you would park your money from your
- 50:20checking and savings and put enough of your, you know, in
- 50:23your auto convert from direct deposit go out, and then you
- 50:27would move into saving to get some nominal yield.
- 50:29Like that's what it ends up looking at for from Americans or
- 50:31people globally. You're just naturally putting
- 50:33those assets and it'll have the local Fiat with BTC and that'll
- 50:37just become user behavior over time.
- 50:40And then that's when it just becomes it just, it's like,
- 50:41well, that's what I use. That's my cornerstone.
- 50:43I don't know how far we are, but that's how I kind of see it
- 50:45playing into the zeitgeist versus like people realizing the
- 50:49debts not going to be paid back. He's a proxy for the debt not
- 50:52being paid back is inflation, But they're, they're kind of
- 50:54different because you not being able to afford a stake because
- 50:57you're, you know, trading Solana is a little bit different than
- 51:01adopting Bitcoin because the government has too much debt and
- 51:03doge didn't work out. I do like, I really do like that
- 51:06mental model. Then, Mike, that Bitcoin will
- 51:09kind of become this like de facto savings account.
- 51:12And when you want to spend you, you might transfer some and sell
- 51:16to stable coins. And then you, you'd use the
- 51:18stable coins to spend. I do think that's going to be,
- 51:22you know, very transformative to the financial industry because
- 51:28you don't really need banks. I mean, banks, banks are this
- 51:31intermediary that that grew during the 19th century because
- 51:35it was inconvenient to store, store your own gold and to to
- 51:38pay with gold. So you put your money in a bank
- 51:41and they would give you these paper certificates.
- 51:44And then you could use these paper certificates to buy things
- 51:46that was more convenient. And then the bank made a yield
- 51:48by lending out the gold. That model I don't think needs
- 51:52to exist at all today. Like, and you know, one reason,
- 51:57I don't know if you guys paid attention to this one reason
- 52:01with the stable coin bill, the Genius Act, there's a provision
- 52:04which says that stable coin providers can't pay interest.
- 52:07Did you guys know that? Why is that there?
- 52:11That the reason that's there is because banks realize that if
- 52:15you could pay interest on stablecoins, it would kill the
- 52:18banks. It would instantly kill the
- 52:20banks. Like why do you need a bank to
- 52:22keep your money to to be able to transfer to businesses?
- 52:25You just don't need that and banks don't.
- 52:29Most banks don't pay any interest.
- 52:31So if I was able to keep my money in something that I could
- 52:34control and I get paid interest on it, then I would do that.
- 52:39I'd take all my money out of the bank and put it into a stable
- 52:41coin. And it is very interesting that
- 52:46there I always wondered like, why is it that stable coins
- 52:50aren't paying interest? Because naturally competition
- 52:53would drive them to do this, right?
- 52:55Like Tether is the big stable coin, but then you have these
- 52:58other competing products. How could they out compete
- 53:01Tether? They could say, well, Tether
- 53:02doesn't pay interest, we pay interest.
- 53:05What are they doing with the the money that they're holding these
- 53:08stablecoin companies, they're just parking it in treasuries
- 53:10and they're collecting interest. And This is why Tether is so
- 53:15profitable. They have like $150 billion of
- 53:19just dollars and that's all parked in U.S.
- 53:22Treasuries. So they're earning like 4/4 and
- 53:251/2 percent on, on U.S. Treasuries on $150 billion.
- 53:29So they're making $6 billion in pure profit every year.
- 53:34And you know, someone else's is margin is your opportunity as a
- 53:39business. You see they're making that $6
- 53:41billion and you say, well, I'll pay like 3% interest.
- 53:44I'll give most of the interest from the treasuries back to the
- 53:46user and I'll win market share from Tether.
- 53:49And eventually what you have is competition will drive people to
- 53:53give up most of their profit and pay most of the interest out.
- 53:57The only reason that's not happening is regulatory is that
- 54:01banks need to be protected. And the the Genius Act is really
- 54:06giving banks some runway to say, hey, you guys better start
- 54:10offering these products, too. If you don't offer these
- 54:12products, eventually they're going to pay interest and you
- 54:15guys are all going to get blown away.
- 54:16There won't be deposits in banks anymore.
- 54:18There'll just be people holding stable coins to spend at the
- 54:21grocery store or or the hairdresser or wherever people
- 54:24spend their money. Yeah.
- 54:26And I think you just walk through kind of the logical
- 54:28progression of how Bitcoin gets used as money.
- 54:31We talked about this like 2 years ago with Joel Rebel, who's
- 54:33up in Wyoming, thinking through the game theory around
- 54:36competition, if they're going to issue a stable coin, because it
- 54:38kind of just goes back to free banking, right?
- 54:40Like you're naturally going to have reputation, but also what
- 54:43is the competent competitive factors and issuing eventually
- 54:48interest. But then you saw Safe did a good
- 54:50talk about this two years later. It's the rational thing where
- 54:54you'll naturally have to back your stable coin with BTC.
- 54:57And then if you start to pass that through and then eventually
- 54:59just becomes inefficient to use the stable coin and transfer to
- 55:02BTC. And then you're naturally just
- 55:03using the thing that's backing it.
- 55:04And then you naturally use it as money.
- 55:07Since we have DJ on it, we're it's the bullish case.
- 55:10I don't ever give my price or my number, but I will share that
- 55:14after really looking deep into like what's happened in the US
- 55:17with stable coins, it really opened up how the possibility of
- 55:20$1,000,000 BTC could happen in this whatever next cycle.
- 55:23Simply because you're taking this small kind of exercise of
- 55:28what Tether meant for the Bitcoin market and bringing
- 55:30liquidity and you're digitizing basically the rest of the
- 55:33capital markets and just increasing that flow or that
- 55:37opportunity from that dollar or whatever that stable currency is
- 55:40into BTC. And you do that globally in the
- 55:44market that we're in. And now you can start to see the
- 55:46amount of capital flow and across the world into numbers
- 55:50that we haven't historically. So that's been my like case for
- 55:54how I think we can get up much higher than we expected because
- 55:57it just becomes normalized that there's a there's we're in a
- 55:59digital world and you're going to have digital currencies.
- 56:01And if you have a, you know, a dollar next to your eBay Amazon
- 56:06account and you can literally transfer within it or go back to
- 56:09your bank account and transfer to Bitcoin without having to
- 56:11send it to some shady exchange. That just opens up the amount of
- 56:16capital flow that can come in. Yeah.
- 56:18And that that infrastructure for making that happen is being
- 56:20built out now, like the ability for banks to custody Bitcoin and
- 56:25and for these financial institutions to hold Bitcoin.
- 56:28That's happening now. And there are other things that
- 56:30are happening that sort of in process like registered
- 56:33investment advisors being able to actually recommend Bitcoin
- 56:37and and for for financial institutions to sell it as a
- 56:40product. That's all happening.
- 56:42So this is going to play, this is a story that's going to play
- 56:45out over several years. There are so many like unseen,
- 56:48but very, very powerful catalysts that will sort of push
- 56:52this market forward. I will say one comment is that
- 56:55Bitcoins price has always been strongly correlated to the size
- 56:59and stability of the liquidity channels into Bitcoin.
- 57:03So in the earliest days like that, there weren't reliable
- 57:06liquidity channel so the price was effectively nothing.
- 57:09And then Mount Gox came along and it was the only real way to
- 57:13get Fiat into Bitcoin. But it's incredibly unreliable.
- 57:16It was run by this guy who was malfeasant and then went to jail
- 57:20and his business blew up. And then eventually there was
- 57:22Coin base and then you have these sort of bigger financial
- 57:25institutions coming in and now you have the ETFs.
- 57:28The size and, and reliability of the liquidity channels into
- 57:32Bitcoin are now enormous. And and you know, one thing that
- 57:37may not be fully appreciated is we now have a liquidity channel,
- 57:41not just from retail, the retail equity market, but from the bond
- 57:46market as well through Sailor offering convertible debt and
- 57:49allowing the bond market to get exposure to Bitcoin.
- 57:51So you have all these pools of capital now which are able to
- 57:55get exposure to Bitcoin. And as those become more
- 57:58developed over time, I think you're going to see much greater
- 58:01flow of money into Bitcoin and but that's going to take a few
- 58:05years to play out. Yeah, it's a, it's a fantastic
- 58:08point. And I, I won't hold you to a
- 58:11price prediction, Vijay, but I, I was curious, I did want to ask
- 58:14like if you, so you wrote the, the bullish case in 2018.
- 58:18If you were to, you know, write it again today fresh like, what
- 58:21would be the sort of most important net new addition to
- 58:25the bullish case in your mind knowing everything you know
- 58:27today? Well, I am actually working on
- 58:30the second edition, so this question is actually very
- 58:33relevant to me. I think the thing that's very
- 58:36different is the risk profile of Bitcoin is just completely
- 58:40different now like we talked about at the beginning of the
- 58:43show, I think that the biggest risk to Bitcoin is now off the
- 58:47table. And so that in terms of risk
- 58:52adjusted returns, I think Bitcoin is, is the best
- 58:56asymmetric bet on Earth. And I said that at the time, but
- 58:59I think, you know, 1000 X Bitcoin now is probably not
- 59:03possible. But it's, it's also important to
- 59:06realize that the risk profile of Bitcoin has dropped, you know,
- 59:09massively like 90% of the risk is out of Bitcoin.
- 59:14And I think Bitcoin still easily, easily has a 10X in it
- 59:18over the next, you know, few years, 100 XI think that that's
- 59:23over, you know, you know, a decade or maybe a couple of
- 59:27decades, but 100 X return over a couple of decades with the risk
- 59:32profile that Bitcoin has, I still think makes it the best
- 59:35asymmetric bet on earth. I will say there is one risk
- 59:40that should be considered by investors, despite the fact that
- 59:44the risk profile has dropped dramatically.
- 59:47I do think people need to think about quantum computing because
- 59:50it really is sort of an existential Black Swan type risk
- 59:55to Bitcoin, and it's worth keeping in your mind that that's
- 59:59still out there. There are solutions and I'm
- 1:00:03going to write about this in my book, but the real question is,
- 1:00:07can the Bitcoin community? Get consensus around the
- 1:00:11solution. Getting consensus in Bitcoin is
- 1:00:13very, very difficult thing to do because it's a very fractious
- 1:00:17community. It's hard to get people to agree
- 1:00:19on anything. You know, that is the story of
- 1:00:22the block size wars. It was really, really hard.
- 1:00:25People, All the most powerful companies tried to get consensus
- 1:00:28around increasing the block size.
- 1:00:30Thankfully they didn't and they didn't change Bitcoin The one
- 1:00:35time I think you do need to change Bitcoin and really need
- 1:00:38to get consensus is under the gravest extreme when the
- 1:00:42protocol itself could explode if you don't.
- 1:00:45And quantum computing provides that one risk.
- 1:00:49I think the the predictions of when quantum computing could be
- 1:00:54a risk to Bitcoin or exaggerated.
- 1:00:56I don't think it's like a three to five year risk.
- 1:00:58I do think it's a multi decade risk though.
- 1:01:03Do you wanna game that out? Do you wanna game that out a
- 1:01:04little bit? Because I know you had it on the
- 1:01:06list and it does come up with folks.
- 1:01:08I know we have a limited time, but I guess the question would
- 1:01:10be if that happens, there's a lot more economic capital.
- 1:01:13So there's a lot more weight behind.
- 1:01:15I guess it goes in both directions, more people, so more
- 1:01:17governance issues, but then also more economic weight to rational
- 1:01:21to come to rational decision. If it comes down to two, it
- 1:01:24would naturally be a fork and then wherever the hash rate
- 1:01:27would follow and that would be the adoption.
- 1:01:29Is that like a very simplistic version or how do you see that
- 1:01:32playing out? Hash rate will follow where
- 1:01:36owners of Bitcoin go. That was the big lesson from
- 1:01:392017. Like the miners in 2017
- 1:01:42threatened to starve the chain that the legacy chain say we're
- 1:01:46not going to mine that chain. We're going to mine this chain
- 1:01:49which has twice the block size. They wanted to change the block
- 1:01:52size and they threatened to only mine the chain which had greater
- 1:01:56block size. But what happened was owners
- 1:01:59said, I'm not going to buy that chain.
- 1:02:01I don't want to say I don't want that chain.
- 1:02:03And actually futures markets got created where you could trade
- 1:02:07the legacy chain against the the new chain, which had twice the
- 1:02:11block size. And the market overwhelmingly
- 1:02:14chose the legacy chain, the chain that didn't change.
- 1:02:18And that was a sign that, hey, you guys can mine that on the
- 1:02:21chain if you want, but it's not going to have any value and
- 1:02:24you're going to throw away all your resources mining a chain
- 1:02:27that people don't want to own. So it comes down to owners of
- 1:02:30Bitcoin. What will owners do?
- 1:02:32And owners need to find consensus on a solution.
- 1:02:36And it's difficult because the, if quantum computing becomes a
- 1:02:41thing, there will be Bitcoin addresses that become
- 1:02:45vulnerable, any Bitcoin address where the public key is being
- 1:02:48exposed. So the old address is Satoshi's
- 1:02:51coins, the public key is exposed, all of those coins can
- 1:02:54move. And that's really scary, right?
- 1:02:57Like if quantum computer can steal those bitcoins and move
- 1:03:01them and sell them, then suddenly you're unlocking
- 1:03:04millions of coins of supply that could get sold onto the market.
- 1:03:08So part of the consensus is do we burn those coins?
- 1:03:13Do we say that coins that have the public key exposed are dead?
- 1:03:17Do we come to a common agreement about that or do we give them a
- 1:03:21sort of a timeline time horizon? You got to move those coins and
- 1:03:24make them quantum resistant within two years, otherwise
- 1:03:27they're dead. That's going to be tough, tough
- 1:03:32debate and argument about what the solution is.
- 1:03:35And I will say that if quantum computing, it looks like it's
- 1:03:41going to be feasible on like a five year time horizon, that
- 1:03:45will be priced into the market today.
- 1:03:48So the price will start getting affected today.
- 1:03:51So this is something we need to think about years in advance and
- 1:03:54that's the one thing that I try to urge people, anyone who's
- 1:03:58thinking about building Bitcoin and working as a core developer,
- 1:04:03this should be by far the number one focus that you think about.
- 1:04:08What are we going to do about quantum computing?
- 1:04:10How do we solve this? How do we get consensus around
- 1:04:12this? Try and figure this out and
- 1:04:14start thinking about it right now.
- 1:04:16Once we get rid of, you know, this, quantum computing is a
- 1:04:19risk. I don't think there's anything
- 1:04:21that's going to stop Bitcoin, and I think we're on a clear
- 1:04:23shot to Bitcoin becoming the global reserve currency.
- 1:04:29Well, Vijay, I want to be respectful of your time.
- 1:04:32I know we have many other questions for you, but we could
- 1:04:34just tuck those away for a future episode.
- 1:04:39I know you mentioned before we hit record, you said you would
- 1:04:41only come back on the show if people liked the video and
- 1:04:44subscribed. But anyways, Vijay, I really
- 1:04:48appreciate your time. You're a legend into space.
- 1:04:51I owe a lot to you. For people who are not familiar
- 1:04:54with your work or want to hear of maybe early Access or however
- 1:04:59you're going to release the second edition of the Bullish
- 1:05:00case, how should they follow along?
- 1:05:03So Twitter is the best place to find me.
- 1:05:05Or I should say X. You know, I've been using X or
- 1:05:08Twitter for a long time, so I've got this old bad habit of
- 1:05:11calling it Twitter. But I am real under score VJ.
- 1:05:14So REAL under score Vijay at X and that's the best place to
- 1:05:21sort of follow along. And you know, when I launched
- 1:05:23the book, I'll announce it on Twitter and I may launch it like
- 1:05:26I did the first one, which was a Kickstarter, right?
- 1:05:28I launched it directly and and that went pretty well and and
- 1:05:31had a lot of success. So I think that's probably how
- 1:05:33it's going to come out. Yeah.
- 1:05:35Vijay is a great follow on X or Twitter and his fault who he
- 1:05:39follows. The one who he follows was one
- 1:05:42as a good nice Easter egg. You should look into what he's
- 1:05:45doing and the business he's building.
- 1:05:49Thank you so much, Vijay, really.
- 1:05:50Appreciate it. Thanks guys.
- 1:05:52Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:05:55If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:05:57episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:06:00app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:06:02today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:06:05Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:06:07for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 1:06:10nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:06:13Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:06:15to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com Contact
- 1:06:19to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:06:22advisors.