Latest / 9 Lives Horror Club / The Grudge (2004): Does the Nostalgia Hold Up? Trauma, Cycles, and the Remake Trap
Transcript
- 0:00OK, I think the Grudge has gotten way more hype than it
- 0:05ever deserved. And it is really just a poor
- 0:08American remake of what must be a better and more interesting
- 0:12film. Get your bingo cards ready and
- 0:17let's get scared. Hello club members and welcome
- 0:33to the 9 Lives Horror Club where we recap and analyze horror
- 0:36movies to break down the real life horrors that we're too
- 0:39scared to talk about. I'm Cheyenne and I bring the
- 0:41analysis and antagonize Ben. And I'm Ben and I bring overly
- 0:45passionate hot takes. Sometimes they are wrong, but I
- 0:49will defend them to my core. And today we are talking about
- 0:53The Grudge. But before we get into it, we
- 0:57have some spooky rants to handle.
- 0:59So if you want to skip ahead, the time stamps will be in the
- 1:02show notes. Hello.
- 1:04And with that, Ben, what do you and Rocknell have in your hearts
- 1:08today? I see a little tail.
- 1:09There's a little tail, there's there's a little girl next to
- 1:11me. You know what?
- 1:15I had something in mind, but actually going to change it.
- 1:17I wasn't talking about I've been sick lately, which sucks.
- 1:20Gross. And I got spring break coming up
- 1:23so I want the sickness to be gone.
- 1:24I want to feel great. But instead this is a little
- 1:28rant about myself. I am so influenced by whatever I
- 1:33am watching and lately I have been watching a streamer for the
- 1:39first time. I'm watching streamer for the
- 1:40first time and it's amazing. Called GH.
- 1:42Is it a gaming streamer? Yes, GH coffee and I already
- 1:46feel myself taking on the same like speaking tones and the same
- 1:54bits that they do. Do we have WS in the chat band?
- 1:58Well, he often does is a big part of they go Mama a blank
- 2:02behind you and it's like non-stop for the past like week.
- 2:06I keep going, Mama, a blank behind you.
- 2:10Just like insert anything. Yes, when you were like, there's
- 2:13a cat, I wanna go Mama, there's a cat behind you.
- 2:17I kind of like it. That's kind of good.
- 2:19We're. Watching Search Party and at one
- 2:23point I just basically to myself, go Mama, there's a
- 2:26parallel behind you and it's nice.
- 2:31Like I wish I could be my own person, but I'm just taking
- 2:35these little Nuggets from people.
- 2:36Same way I know a large portion of my comedy when it comes to me
- 2:43talking about things. I'm just I'm copying mannerisms
- 2:46from Mike's mic. OK.
- 2:49I do it all the time. I keep doing like a British
- 2:52voice all the time because Mike's Mike does a British voice
- 2:54every now and then and it OK. And famously, you're British is
- 2:57really good. It's good in it.
- 3:03Hey, what's that one character saying?
- 3:04Who has the little wand? The one and it's.
- 3:08Yeah, right. Does he want a long?
- 3:10Live the Queen. I will be killed.
- 3:14I'm going to get killed in England.
- 3:15I'm going to get killed. Thank God you're not there.
- 3:18The Queen's gonna come back and get your ass.
- 3:23OK, well, you know what? I think that's very normal.
- 3:25It's just. It's so much.
- 3:27Impressive. It's just like Nuggets from
- 3:30other ones that I like, and if you think about it, that just
- 3:33really highlights your individual personality and
- 3:35tastes. I mean consuming and replicating
- 3:40mannerisms of other people. Cool, cool.
- 3:43Yeah, yeah. When this stopped being ironic
- 3:46for me, that was a really hard one for me to.
- 3:50But guess what? Now I love.
- 3:51Doing it. Clock it.
- 3:52Clock it. My my podcast tonality.
- 3:59Sometimes I listen back and I go, that's not how I speak.
- 4:03You're being performed. That is that is, it's too scary.
- 4:07Didn't watch. It's something it's not me, but
- 4:11now it is, you know? So here we are, here we are.
- 4:15What is your? Is that the end of your spooky?
- 4:17Ramp. Is that the end of my ramp?
- 4:18This is a little mean coming to terms with who I am as a person.
- 4:21OK, naturally, as I always have two parts, I have two parts. 1
- 4:27is very quick. Just I'm yapping the girls.
- 4:32Yep, I just need to update everyone on my journey with
- 4:36Advantage team. We were successful as streamers
- 4:40would say. We have AW in the chat.
- 4:43Loan was deferred. As GH Coffey would say, Mama,
- 4:47there's a loan behind you. Not anymore.
- 4:49That bitch is deferred. Is my name changed in the
- 4:54system? No, no it's not.
- 4:57But the loan is deferred and I will take it.
- 5:00So that that brings me to my spooky rant.
- 5:02And it's not fully a spooky rant.
- 5:04It almost it like could have been it had the makings of a
- 5:07spooky rant. OK, so Ben, as you know, Katie
- 5:10and I, we're on our roller skating journey.
- 5:11You. Guys are and I'm really like
- 5:13bikini excluded from it. Well, I was going to ask you
- 5:16when your spring break goes because probably if you wanted,
- 5:18we could, we could go to the skate park.
- 5:22It is coming up. Yeah, we have to figure out some
- 5:26skates for you. Or we could go to the roller
- 5:28rink. The roller rink.
- 5:30Anyways, Katie and I discovered that there is a skate park in
- 5:34town, like ramps and rails for skateboarding.
- 5:38Skate Park. For like teens.
- 5:41No, you would think teens, but no.
- 5:45So we went on a Thursday, Friday night, something like that, and
- 5:52it was busy. And we got there and we were
- 5:54like, Oh no, there's lots of boys skateboarding.
- 5:57Wow. Oh my God, do you hear him?
- 5:59I do. Oh my God, OK, Lots of boys
- 6:02skateboarding and we park and Katie's like, Oh no, there's
- 6:06teenage boys here and I'm like, we are almost 30.
- 6:08We cannot let teenage boys on skateboard scare us.
- 6:11Though they're scary, they're scary.
- 6:13We can't. So we get over there and we're
- 6:16doing our little thing. Turns out that these skaters are
- 6:19between the ages of like 25 to 30.
- 6:24They are violently minding their own business.
- 6:26They are not bothering us at all.
- 6:28And then one of them started talking to us.
- 6:31And he was, he was from upper upstate New York, but his soul
- 6:37was from California, you know? I love that for him.
- 6:40And he's like. Asking us.
- 6:42About the skate rink that's like 20 minutes from our town, he's
- 6:48like, is that still open? I never see anybody there and
- 6:51he's talking to us about skating.
- 6:52He's like, I could never do that shit.
- 6:53You guys are so good for you to try and like.
- 6:55This Was there an underground skating community?
- 6:59He was a yapper. He was a yapper and they were
- 7:01all so chill and they did not get in our way or anything.
- 7:06And we had a, we had some joints being smoked in the vicinity.
- 7:11We had snacks offshore, I think there were some brewskies
- 7:16around. We were blasting Beastie Boys
- 7:19from somebody's car. It was about it was giving peak
- 7:24skater 2008 to to 2012 era. We had dads bringing their kids
- 7:31who definitely were skaters back in the day and now their little
- 7:33kids are like on ramps and shit. There's a whole underground
- 7:36world I'm unaware of there. Was one little kid fell and the
- 7:40all the 30 year old adult skater boys stopped.
- 7:43They went, you OK, little man? It was precious.
- 7:47And then a girl showed up on a skateboard and she did a, she
- 7:51did a ramp. And Katie and I looked at each
- 7:53other and we went, wow, that's. The same time.
- 7:56So we're taking a break and she comes over and she's like, hi, I
- 7:59like your skates. Our skates are bright pink
- 8:02glitter. This girl's skateboarding it all
- 8:05black. She looks cool as shit.
- 8:06She's like, I like your pink skates.
- 8:07Those are so fun. We're like, thank you.
- 8:10And we're telling her how we're like obsessed with her.
- 8:12And she goes, no, I get so excited when I see girls here,
- 8:15too. You guys are doing so good.
- 8:17And we're like, thank you. We don't really know how to
- 8:19skate. And she said you're trying and
- 8:20that's all that matters. Oh.
- 8:22My God. So it was like the opposite of a
- 8:26spooky rant, but it almost was. I was a little bit concerned.
- 8:29That's beautiful though. So the skating community is
- 8:33alive and well, guys. They're alive and well.
- 8:35They're wholesome. Yes, and we went this morning
- 8:39and he was dead. And then a girl with roller
- 8:41skates showed up and she was doing all kinds of shit.
- 8:44It was crazy. She was so.
- 8:46Nice. And then her boyfriend almost
- 8:48skated into me and he said Oh my God, I'm so sorry.
- 8:51Mama, there's a skater. Behind you, Mama, there's a
- 8:54skateboard. I'm gonna apologize right now
- 8:55because I will make this bit 1000 times this episode.
- 8:59OK, well, hey, that one's not on the bingo card, so.
- 9:01And I guarantee you it's going to work for this whole movie.
- 9:05Oh, you're so right. You're actually so right.
- 9:09And before we get into the movie though, I don't know about you,
- 9:13but I have a bevy on the pod. I also have a bevy on the pod.
- 9:16OK, well my bevy on the pod, bringing it back.
- 9:19Devil's Backbone. Still, I'm still with you.
- 9:21I bought another pack I locked into those.
- 9:24Those were pretty good. The watermelon one slapped.
- 9:28Shut up, you stupid freak. I don't like watermelon flavour.
- 9:32Shut up, you stupid freak. Well, I'm I.
- 9:35Don't like anything I'm. Drinking.
- 9:36I have two bevies I got myself a nice caps have as as probably
- 9:43the same model you. Come to caps have boy.
- 9:45I love me some caps I have. I love it.
- 9:48And the AC4 Jolly rancher watermelon flavor.
- 9:54You fucking could never. You could never.
- 9:57It's delicious. I love it.
- 9:58It's the best of the Jolly rancher flavors.
- 10:03I'm entering AC4 era. I'm loving it.
- 10:06I used to like those a lot, the C4 energy drinks, and then I
- 10:10realized that they make my head feel like my brain spinning
- 10:12around on the inside. They give me that ants in my
- 10:14skin feeling that I really like. Oh, I only get that from the
- 10:18powder on a good day, not the energy drink, but I love that
- 10:21for you. Well, with that Ben, yay, I have
- 10:25some factoids. Tell me about you.
- 10:27The grudge. The Grudge.
- 10:30OK team, this one was released in 2004 and to its credit, it
- 10:36was filmed in Japan. I will give them that.
- 10:40Spoiler alert, that's probably all I'm going to give them.
- 10:46Oh my goodness. So the director was to What's
- 10:52crazy then is I read these words and these names to myself when
- 10:56I'm writing these, and I have no problem.
- 10:58And then you put a mic in front of me and I can't say them
- 11:01anymore. I can look.
- 11:02Give me Takashi Shimizu. OK, so he's done so many horror
- 11:09movies that I haven't seen, but a lot of them did look cool.
- 11:13Like the posters alone looked dope.
- 11:16But also, I don't know if you know this game Ben, but he was
- 11:20heavily involved in Nightcry which I think is a horror video.
- 11:24Game I'm not heard of Nightcry. OK, I just thought it was cool
- 11:27that he's done a video game. Normally, I do not mention the
- 11:31producer. However, conveniently and
- 11:36coincidentally, the producer is Sam Raimi.
- 11:41As as blisters. If you missed last week's
- 11:44episode, we talked about Drag Me to Hell, which is directed by
- 11:47Sam Raimi. So he's back on accident.
- 11:51Our writers are Takashi Shimizu and Stephen Susko, who helped
- 11:58write the 2013 Texas Chainsaw and all of the grudge things.
- 12:04Of course, there's lots of grudge Japanese like the
- 12:08original Grudge and then American grudges and then spin
- 12:11offs and remakes and all kinds of shit.
- 12:15So it's another one that they really milked.
- 12:17Now. Our star's been, our star's
- 12:20been. I don't think we've had who I'm
- 12:22about to say on our pod before. Which is crazy, actually.
- 12:25It is crazy because she's everywhere, and that is Miss
- 12:28Sarah Michelle Gellar. SMG.
- 12:32I'm gonna, I'm gonna give the people a moment to applaud.
- 12:35They need a minute, as we know. Well, first of all, she plays
- 12:39Karen. Second of all, powerhouse.
- 12:42A queen of horror, if you will. And she isn't then.
- 12:46I don't know if you know this, but she isn't ready or not too.
- 12:48I do know this. I didn't, but I'm excited.
- 12:51About she's like the new matriarch, I think.
- 12:53I've not watched the trailers really because I want to watch
- 12:54and be surprised. Yeah, we need to figure out when
- 12:57we're doing that. Spring break's coming up.
- 12:59Oh, you're so right. Of course she's Buffy.
- 13:03Like the Buffy? She's yes the have you seen?
- 13:05The Vampire Slayer. You should watch Buffy the
- 13:11Vampire Slayer. It's so.
- 13:13Fun. I know I would love it.
- 13:14I know I would. I think I've seen clips growing
- 13:17up, you know? But I haven't like sat down and
- 13:18watched. That the remake got fucking
- 13:20cancelled and I'm upset by it. And so is Sam Michelle Keller.
- 13:25Also tractionally this week, Nicholas Brendan, one of the
- 13:27main cast, passed away as well. Was he Angel?
- 13:32No, that's David Boreana. Oh, OK.
- 13:35Xander. I was like, I know the guy's
- 13:36name. We were rewatching it not too
- 13:39long ago. No, I I know it's on my radar
- 13:44thanks to watchers. Haven't gone there yet.
- 13:46She also was on Of course I know what you did last summer 1st and
- 13:51the new one. She also was in Dexter and much,
- 13:56much more. And I, I, I, I don't know why
- 13:59you wouldn't mention scooby-doo. That's I'm sorry.
- 14:02You're so right. That's my, that's my Daphne.
- 14:05Please give. That is your Daphne, Mama
- 14:09Daphne's behind. Mom, there's a Daphne behind
- 14:10you. Give her the credit she
- 14:12deserves. I'm sorry, I just, I put our
- 14:15house and much, much more. So I felt like I covered my
- 14:18bases, but whatever. We also have Jason Bear as Doug,
- 14:23who fun fact was in one episode. Of Buffy and it's, I'm so glad
- 14:28you mentioned that 'cause I was watching to, I recognize this
- 14:31guy. Why do I recognize him, 'cause
- 14:34he is on, he's on. He's in Season 2 of Buffy.
- 14:37OK, OK. He is on Spike's intro episode I
- 14:40think. OK, he got one episode.
- 14:45He's in one episode, he shows up and it seems like he's made a
- 14:47love interest, but he's obsessed with vampires.
- 14:50Oh, because he's, like, dying of something.
- 14:51He's like, has some, like, terminal illness.
- 14:53He's like, I got to become a vampire for eternal life.
- 14:56And then Spike just kills him. Wow.
- 15:01So funny. Yeah, I saw him as he looks
- 15:03really familiar. He was on you.
- 15:07Remembered him from one episode, that's really impressive.
- 15:09Yeah, I'm really good at that. Yeah, you are.
- 15:12We also have William Mapother Mapother like Mother but with
- 15:17AP. Mapother.
- 15:20And he is Matthew. He was on a lot of TV shows.
- 15:25He's been on a lot of TV shows. None of them really stood out to
- 15:28me. I'm so sorry.
- 15:29We also have Why are we moving Kalia Duvall as Jennifer.
- 15:38She was in Handmaid's Tale, Better Call Saul, and American
- 15:43Horror Story Asylum. Do you remember the plot line
- 15:46about the lady? I thought she was Anne Frank.
- 15:48She Anne Frank, that was her. I thought she was the the
- 15:52lesbian girlfriend. I think she's the Anne Frank
- 15:57because I saw something. I'm.
- 16:00Almost, but I could be wrong. You famously.
- 16:02I'm not good at those. In my head, I'm thinking that
- 16:04she was the one who was dating the psychologist.
- 16:07Maybe I thought she was Anne Frank.
- 16:09What do I know? If my little I think very fucked
- 16:14up they make her play a straight woman in this movie 'cause she's
- 16:16famously gay if you've also she's in the faculty as a little
- 16:23as that's a horror movie that she was in.
- 16:26OK. Do you have?
- 16:28Flowers. She's a, well, she's a well
- 16:30known face. I would say so.
- 16:34We also have Tokako Fuji as the ghost of Kyoko Kyoko.
- 16:39I think it's Kyoko. Kyoko and she's been in all of
- 16:43the Grudge movies. So even like the Japanese ones?
- 16:46Yes. And.
- 16:49Some TV appearances as well. And then we have Yuya Ozekai as
- 16:54Toshio Saki. Saiki.
- 16:57Saiki, and he's the little ghost boy.
- 17:02Toshio. Yes, and he's also been in all
- 17:05of the Grudge things and nothing else.
- 17:08His his acting career is the Grudge Universe.
- 17:11I think he might just be a ghost boy for real.
- 17:13That's worth considering. They actually didn't do any
- 17:16special effects. His mouth just.
- 17:17Opened. He just can't do that.
- 17:20And we have Takashi Matsuyama as Taiko Saiki.
- 17:25Is that what you said? I think Saiki.
- 17:27Saiki and he also is in all of the grudge stuff.
- 17:33So lots of we have a grudge family here and they they're
- 17:36sticking to it. The budget for this bed.
- 17:42Famously our favorite part. The budget for this movie in
- 17:452004. 22 years. $10 million today, that would be a humble
- 17:54$17.2 million in the domestic. Oh my God, when you have a
- 18:03little tickle in your throat, guys, you know what you need.
- 18:06That's not sponsored, but like, please do anyways.
- 18:13Domestic opening weekend for this movie in 2004 is $110
- 18:20million. That's crazy.
- 18:25Today, then, that would be 189.4 million.
- 18:31Inflation pissed me off. And then lastly, the worldwide
- 18:36box office gross total was $187.3 million in 2004 and so
- 18:45today that would be worth $322.5 million.
- 18:51How does that make you even sense?
- 18:52I don't. I don't understand money 'cause
- 18:54that doesn't feel like it's equally.
- 18:57I don't take it up with Google. Not with me.
- 19:02I. Don't know, I don't understand
- 19:04how that that happened. That's, and I also gonna say it
- 19:08crazy little worldwide when like the other Grudge movies were not
- 19:12that old. Like the Japanese ones?
- 19:17Yeah, they're not that old, especially the the same little
- 19:19boy. That's such a good point.
- 19:22You're so right. Because he's not like a a grown
- 19:24boy in this. He's still a small child.
- 19:28He's the world's smartest man, that kid.
- 19:29Could not be older than 12. Yeah, he's tiny.
- 19:32He's tiny. I will.
- 19:33I'm one to believe he's like a small 11 year old at best.
- 19:38At best. At worst, the kids 9 so there's
- 19:41no way to The other Grudge movies are more than two years
- 19:43old. You're right, huh?
- 19:46Well, I have some more fun facts for you if you.
- 19:49Would like to. So before filming, the cast and
- 19:54crew went through a ceremony where they were all blessed so
- 19:58nothing bad could happen to them during filming.
- 20:04So they were taking this very seriously.
- 20:06I would not be in a movie about that.
- 20:08Like I, I would not, I'd go, oh, this is bad vibes.
- 20:11This is bad. If they're like, hey, we're
- 20:13gonna do a a blessing to make sure you don't get cursed for my
- 20:16movie. I'm not saying for that movie.
- 20:18I'm doing it for a movie. Really.
- 20:21I'm gonna, I'm gonna do like a Disney film at that point, like
- 20:23God. I mean, the Wizard of Oz
- 20:27famously was like super haunted, you know, So it doesn't really
- 20:30matter. Shit, you're right.
- 20:32Yeah, right. Yuya, Takako and Takashi, we're
- 20:38all So that's the the Japanese mom, the boy.
- 20:41Like Japanese characters, The father that's fucked.
- 20:44Up We're all in the original Japanese films that this is
- 20:47based on, so they all got to reprise their roles for the
- 20:49American remakes and continuations, which is cute.
- 20:54That's cute. They didn't.
- 20:55Replace them, easy paycheck. We're like we can.
- 20:59We're just doing it again. Excuse me.
- 21:02So the sequel, the American sequel, was greenlit on the
- 21:05Monday after the first weekend box office due to the surprise
- 21:10success of $39 million in one weekend, which that's kind of
- 21:15crazy. That's kind of crazy.
- 21:17They didn't do any planning. They just said, OK, we're doing
- 21:19it. Is this people like original or
- 21:22is it another like just a copy of I'm curious we.
- 21:26Didn't cover the sequel so I didn't look into it.
- 21:29You know, in Japanese folklore, owning a black cat brings good
- 21:34luck and fortune. Spoiler alert.
- 21:38We got Black Cats. We have Black Cats and spoiler
- 21:42alert, that's not what this movie is about.
- 21:44That actually made me the black cat of it all.
- 21:47It was upsetting, actually. I like the Black Hat.
- 21:50I love the Black Hat. He's surviving.
- 21:53But what happens to the Black Hat Cheyenne?
- 21:57I missed it. Oh, it's upsetting.
- 22:00Oh, OK, we'll talk about my journey with this in a minute.
- 22:04And then lastly, Takashi Shimizu directed the original Japanese
- 22:09films and all of the American remakes and apparently he was a
- 22:13silly, goofy goober on set and people had a lot of fun work.
- 22:18He's a. Silly guy, he's a.
- 22:19Silly guy. I Apparently he would come up
- 22:22behind people and like. Bitch, Oh my God, I'm throwing
- 22:26the hands. I'm going to throw hands.
- 22:27I would be so upset. I'd be so upset because I'm
- 22:30because I'm also really excited to share with you my journey
- 22:33with this. OK my journey is really short.
- 22:36Let me give you the trigger warnings first.
- 22:38So you're making me feel like I missed 1 so if I did, please add
- 22:42to my list here. I have domestic violence,
- 22:46suicide vibes, and family annihilation.
- 22:50I think it's worth adding animal abuse.
- 22:53OK and animal abuse. So with that, my journey with
- 22:57this movie, Ben, I think we had similar lead ups to the movie
- 23:02where I like I just this movie has been in my realm of
- 23:07understanding of knowledge for pretty much my entire life.
- 23:13And I had been under the impression and this was a very
- 23:19scary like this is an up there movie, you know, like this is
- 23:24one of the ones we build up to. We can't watch it just on a
- 23:26Willy nilly like it's scary. We got to be.
- 23:29Ready. Prepared.
- 23:31Fortified. Yep, Yep, I felt that.
- 23:33Right, right. So I watched it.
- 23:36So I watched it once for fun. I didn't want to like bother
- 23:38with taking notes or like really thinking about it.
- 23:40I just wanted to watch it. And then I then I tried to watch
- 23:43it again and my Internet, shocking everyone was not
- 23:49cooperating. And the Wi-Fi kept going out
- 23:51while I was watching it. And I said, you know what?
- 23:54I don't need to watch it again. I just don't need.
- 23:58To Oh my goodness. So you've only watched it The
- 24:00one? That's my journey.
- 24:02Well, I was gonna share. Yeah.
- 24:04And this really goes back to really my journey with horror in
- 24:08general. Oh, a journey, my journey,
- 24:11'cause I as a child my dad loved to scare me.
- 24:16I can't believe we haven't talked about this.
- 24:18Talk about this at all. Which is actually crazy.
- 24:20Like, yeah. And, you know, without getting
- 24:23too much detail, part of that was watching scary movies.
- 24:27And I was like, I don't want to watch scary.
- 24:28There's one point this stuck with me.
- 24:30We watched or he watched Hellraiser Bloodlines, and
- 24:35there's a scene where two security guards get their faces
- 24:38horribly twisted together. And I'm probably 7 years old and
- 24:43my dad called me, my twin brother, into the room.
- 24:45He said that's you guys. And it's like, that's so horror
- 24:50movies. For a long time was that where I
- 24:52would see a scene, a clip? I'd be terrified.
- 24:55This was a movie my whole family watched.
- 24:57And I said, no, that's too scary for me.
- 25:00I'm not gonna watch it. I'm gonna hang out in the
- 25:02computer room playing video games all night.
- 25:06But at one point I got up, I walked in during a specific
- 25:10scene of this movie. The specific scene I I walked
- 25:14in, I saw it and it was ingrained in my memory and I'm
- 25:18so excited to talk about it 'cause in all caps my nose.
- 25:20OK, This is the scene. The second got there.
- 25:22I was back in that moment of that terror.
- 25:26OK. Where I did your family.
- 25:28I did not sleep that night and I thought about that scene
- 25:32probably for the next 6 years of my life.
- 25:36Every time I was going to bed I would think without a scene.
- 25:39I have a scene like that but I don't know what movie it's from
- 25:42at all. Like and I made it Reddit.
- 25:45I OK so I have no idea what movie it was.
- 25:47I don't know I don't know anything about it.
- 25:49I just remember this one scene traumatized the shit out of me.
- 25:52Also science did but that's for another that's for another
- 25:55journey. This particular scene from a
- 25:57movie. I put this on Reddit and nobody
- 26:00could help me figure it out. It was like, I know that the
- 26:04context of the movie was like kind of Cloverfield esque where
- 26:07we have a group running around. Was it?
- 26:09Found footage. I don't remember Ben.
- 26:12This is like an. Early memory so it's so it's so
- 26:15base vibes. Gotcha.
- 26:16I gotcha. It is, this is an early memory
- 26:19and it traumatized me. So I I know that's like the
- 26:23context, but that's all the contacts I have.
- 26:25So then somebody or group or someone within the group is
- 26:29looking at ATV that is in a black and white.
- 26:32OK, so we're watching the TV and on the TV we're seeing someone
- 26:35watch a black and white TV. And on the black and white TV
- 26:39they, it's like a picture of trees.
- 26:43We're outside, there's trees and they're talking about this
- 26:46monster thing. And I think the monster thing is
- 26:50what the movie's about. Maybe, probably.
- 26:53But the monster thing in my memory, which this is probably
- 26:58just like blatantly not what it was, but in my memory this
- 27:00monster is woolly mammoth esque. OK.
- 27:06It's big, but it's up and it's got something.
- 27:09One could call it a trunk, but I don't know if that is actually a
- 27:11trunk. And it's just like I'm a no
- 27:14monstering around and it scared the fucking shit out of me and I
- 27:17have no idea what fucking I have.
- 27:21No idea, this could possibly be you.
- 27:23Have no idea so I put it on Reddit and a lot of people were
- 27:26like is it Cloverfield and in the post I said it's not
- 27:28Cloverfield so I have no idea. If you come across any woolly,
- 27:36you come across any black and white TV.
- 27:39Scenes. With the monster that makes you
- 27:42think fucked up. Woolly Hammed.
- 27:46Please let me know. I really.
- 27:48Listen, listeners, please. So that's my side tangent, Ben.
- 27:56All right, so now with our traumas out of the way.
- 28:00Yes, now that we've. Aired that out, I think it's
- 28:01time to talk about the movie. Yep, obviously.
- 28:09Anyways. So.
- 28:10Tell us about this hot fucking mess.
- 28:13I'm so excited about the Grudge. I do realize there was 1
- 28:16character we forgot to mention during the credits.
- 28:20Excuse me? Bingo cards, guys.
- 28:22You failed to mention Bill Pullman.
- 28:26Bill Pullman. I know that name.
- 28:28Very famous. His son's having a moment right
- 28:30now. Lewis Pullman, who was in, he
- 28:33was in like the new the the Thunderbolts movie.
- 28:38OK, Did you watch the Thunderbolt?
- 28:40He was the, I think the villain. I think he's the villain.
- 28:43Oh. Century.
- 28:46Love Florence Pia. I know nothing about that movie,
- 28:49I just know he's in it. Love Florence Pia.
- 28:52But yes, we start with Bill Pullman and it seems like he's
- 28:54in a hotel with his wife or a person, but that's his wife.
- 29:01He's just being really quiet. She, his wife wakes up.
- 29:04It's like Bill Pullman, what are you doing?
- 29:08He just looks at her and he just kind of topples off of a
- 29:11balcony. Cut to black.
- 29:16He's or no she I think should be see him dead but then cut to
- 29:18black. I thought that was William
- 29:21Moefer. No, no, Cheyenne, Cheyenne.
- 29:25I'm so I'm so glad you said that.
- 29:26I'm so glad you said that. Every fucking bitch in this
- 29:29movie, every, every man, every white man looks like Bill
- 29:32Pullman. So the point I kept erasing my
- 29:36notes because it wasn't Bill Pullman.
- 29:39Wait, so who's? That no Matthew.
- 29:41Matthew is not Bill Pullman's character.
- 29:44Matthew is not the guy who jumps off of the building at the
- 29:46beginning of the movie. Who the hell is that?
- 29:48Matthew comes later. Can you tell me when he gets?
- 29:52Sicker. We'll tell you when we get to
- 29:54Matthew. OK, Bill.
- 29:55Pullman already. I'm already lost.
- 29:57Bill Pullman, who's not the guy from later, It's a different
- 30:00white guy. We have Bill Pullman.
- 30:02He's just killed himself, guy. Really, Mama?
- 30:07There's a jumper behind you. Happens and we got to like this
- 30:12woman in I. I thought it was New York City
- 30:15for way too long. I don't know why.
- 30:18It's an American movie. I, I guess, and when we see this
- 30:21woman Yoko, who's biking around having a very like, you know,
- 30:27she's having a good day. She's going to take care of this
- 30:31woman whose name I believe is Emma, as we're not an old woman
- 30:36a lot, but she's taking, she's like the nurse, the home nurse
- 30:39for this woman Emma, who's got dementia, who's lethargic.
- 30:44So it's her job to like, clean all these things.
- 30:48And while she's there, she hears some kind of weird sounds in the
- 30:51attic. She goes to investigate and
- 30:55like, almost immediately she goes up there.
- 30:58She gets grudged. She.
- 31:00Like gets. Grudged she looks, we see a
- 31:04woman which is like hail. Black rings around her eyes.
- 31:09It's kind of like. And then oh.
- 31:12That didn't even work. Yes, you're thinking of some.
- 31:16Yeah, she got hair all over her face.
- 31:18Yeah, so her hair flipped over. And then she's she's yes, the
- 31:24sound dead and I'm already cut to black and I'm already
- 31:29confused at this point and said we got 2 cold opens to this
- 31:31movie and that's the and I will start now.
- 31:36That was the first little flaws I saw in this film.
- 31:38I was like OK we got 2 cold opens, cool cool.
- 31:45So that we cut. See what we're hoping is our
- 31:47actual main character now? Who's?
- 31:51To say, played by Sarah Michelle Gellar, this is Karen and her
- 31:57boyfriend is like getting up. He's getting ready.
- 32:00He's like, I go to class and she's like, no, you don't.
- 32:03I've changed your your clock. T he, he I'm so mischievous.
- 32:05We can hang out together. They go on a walk.
- 32:08We have like, I, I thought this was going to matter more, but
- 32:12she recognizes there's, she's like, oh, there's people doing a
- 32:14Buddhist practice over there where they're like lighting
- 32:17incense to help bring peace to the dead.
- 32:19And I was like, OK, that's gonna be relevant, hopefully.
- 32:24At this point, I still think it's New York City.
- 32:25So I'm just like, OK, I'm still confused.
- 32:29Hearing is like, gotta go to work, but also I gotta go to
- 32:32class. So I was lost a little bit.
- 32:35Maybe he's in a doctorate program and I really.
- 32:37Honestly humiliating because now I'm thinking about it, there
- 32:40were so many signs in Japanese everywhere they went and I went.
- 32:43That's New York City for you, baby.
- 32:45That's New York City for you. Maybe you thought they were in
- 32:48little China or something or. Chinatown, she goes to work and
- 32:51like all the files are in are in Japanese.
- 32:54I'm still not getting it. If I have like is she like some
- 32:58program to learn Japanese is like that's what's happening
- 33:00here. You could call it that.
- 33:04You could say that. And then we get our our first,
- 33:09is that Bill Pullman? No, it's not Ted Rainey playing.
- 33:14I don't know the guy's name, but it is Karen's.
- 33:18And he's like, oh, we got a case for you.
- 33:21And I'm thinking, oh, to help her learn Japanese 'cause I'm
- 33:24not getting it. No, Karen isn't a nursing
- 33:27program in Tokyo. Like, yeah, so this woman's
- 33:32nurse is not showing up today. We need you to go cover.
- 33:37You're ready for it. You can handle it.
- 33:39And how convenient is an English speaking home?
- 33:42Or like, oh. Love to see it.
- 33:43Convenient. How convenient.
- 33:45Love this for her. So it's easy for her at this
- 33:49point. I wrote down, oh, this is Tokyo.
- 33:55He caught it, got it, got it. Wait, Ben, I think you've ruined
- 33:58me. Because now I keep thinking,
- 34:00hey, Mama, there's a Tokyo. Hey.
- 34:02Mama, there's a Tokyo. Why have you done medicine?
- 34:06So stupid, but it works. Why have you done this?
- 34:11So now Karen goes to the creepy house where we saw Yokoa
- 34:15earlier. Yoko.
- 34:16She's taking care of this old woman.
- 34:19I don't think it's she's weirded out, but nothing too weird's
- 34:23happened so far. She's just like this scary vibes
- 34:26going on. And so she goes upstairs to the
- 34:29same room where we saw Yoko get got and there's a closet that is
- 34:33covered in tape and she's weirded out a little bit until
- 34:38she starts hearing a cat meow in there.
- 34:40It's like, oh, I gotta go see a cat.
- 34:43Fully thought that was a human baby crying.
- 34:46That was the most cat cry I've ever heard in my life.
- 34:49No, it sound like a human baby. It sound like a human.
- 34:52But to be fair, here's the thing.
- 34:54Here's the thing. Killian's cry to me also sounds
- 34:56like a human baby. That's that's your baby boy.
- 34:59He is my baby boy. And also, cats adapt their meows
- 35:03to sound like human babies because is that real people
- 35:06react? Yeah, humans react to it, more
- 35:09or less. They're manipulating me.
- 35:10Why? Urgently, yeah.
- 35:11Yeah, well, I recognize I was like, this is a cat meowing.
- 35:16And so she's like, I gotta go say this cat.
- 35:17She opens it up. There's more than a little black
- 35:20cat in this room. There's a little boy holding the
- 35:22cat and I don't think she calls the police.
- 35:27No, she calls her boss. She calls her boss, call the
- 35:31police 'cause that's insane. There's clearly an abused boy
- 35:36taped up in a closet, but she makes choices and she.
- 35:41We love when women make choices. When?
- 35:43She does a lot. Especially in the early 2000s.
- 35:50So she like, I think the boy's like, she leaves the boy to like
- 35:53arrest or something. While she's on the phone with
- 35:54her boss, she finds some photographs of a family who's
- 35:58not. First she finds a picture of who
- 36:02I believe was Bill Pullman, but it could have been any of our
- 36:04male characters in this movie. And then she finds a picture of
- 36:10a of a family, the little boy's one of them with the mom's face
- 36:14cut out. Creeping.
- 36:17And this is where we get the scene, which I famously know
- 36:20from Scary Movie, where the little boy's upstairs, he's like
- 36:25around the railing. And she's just like speaking in
- 36:29very basic Japanese kid and doesn't ask enough questions.
- 36:34She's like, what's your name? Because it's Yoshio or Toshio.
- 36:39And then like, that's really all she gets to say to him before
- 36:42the phone starts ringing. And it's the the daughter of the
- 36:46woman she's taking care of is calling to like, check in,
- 36:48right? And I might be wrong here, but
- 36:51I'm pretty sure that the phone at this point doesn't have
- 36:53power. I think that San Michelle Gellar
- 36:55looks at the phone and while it's talking, there is no power.
- 36:58The power light is off. The receiver is there and so
- 37:03it's like one of the ones you can pick up.
- 37:05Oh, that's what she said, and. Walk around the phone was gone
- 37:06cordless. Cordless, yes, so it's flashing
- 37:09but the phone is gone. So the receiver picked it up but
- 37:12she wouldn't be able to like. You.
- 37:14Know how you answer the phone like this?
- 37:16Yes, I got you. While she's like doing this.
- 37:21Uh oh. There's a scary silhouette in
- 37:22the background. So she like she follows it into
- 37:28the old woman's room and like we get like full on grudge here
- 37:33where the old woman is like spooked and scared literally
- 37:37like around her. Spooked.
- 37:39And scared, wrapped around her. It is like the Grudge with like
- 37:45flowing dark hair everywhere. Really just like kind of
- 37:48crawling. Luscious.
- 37:49We don't see her again like this, which is disappointing
- 37:51because I kind of like how I'm going to say like reptilian.
- 37:56She kind of looked. I get it.
- 37:58It's kind of snaky. She's kind of snaky.
- 38:00She's very fluid. But like luscious mane, it's
- 38:03giving Pantene commercial. Give her a job.
- 38:08Call her. Sam Michigan like looks up goes
- 38:11gasp. We cut to black and in my head I
- 38:14thought was this a third cold open is there We're getting a
- 38:19new character and we are and it's like for this and this
- 38:23character is Matthew, who is who you thought was the opening.
- 38:28We see like when the old woman first moves into the house when
- 38:32Emma first moved in, she was moved in by her son Matthew, his
- 38:39wife Jennifer, played by Clete Duvall.
- 38:44And then there is a a sister who's with them as well.
- 38:48So he moves them. He got a new job in Tokyo.
- 38:52His mom is not well. She needs home taken care of.
- 38:56So they're finding a home for for him, his wife and his mom.
- 39:00And of course they pick this speak spooky martyr house
- 39:03because why wouldn't you? Mom immediately is like drawn to
- 39:07the attic. There's like water in the tub
- 39:11that the realtor's trying to hide.
- 39:12I think he like digs in to get it out, ends up grabbing a a a
- 39:17dead body out or he pulls like a a woman's body out, but he's
- 39:21just a ghost. It's not real.
- 39:23She's disappears and he's got hair all over his hand.
- 39:25He doesn't really seem to matter.
- 39:27I think this should matter. I.
- 39:29Yeah. That's what we know later on
- 39:30we'll. Talk about it at the end, but
- 39:32like logically it doesn't make a lot of sense it.
- 39:34Feels like this house should have a lot more people aware
- 39:37what's going on with this. It's a secret.
- 39:42But yeah, so we got, we got our in our house.
- 39:44We have the mom, we got her son, we got Clea Duval, his wife.
- 39:50And Clea Duval is not having a good time.
- 39:53She's like, I don't know this place.
- 39:55I don't speak the language, really.
- 39:58I don't see why we have this family.
- 40:00I'm not afraid to say it. I didn't like this.
- 40:02This was the most boring part to me.
- 40:06Yeah. All it is is he's like, don't
- 40:08worry about baby girl. And she's like, OK, OK.
- 40:13And then, like, the next day, uh oh.
- 40:15There's spooky things going on. She sees a black cat again.
- 40:18She follows it. And we see some, like, ghostly
- 40:22hands pick up this cat. Klee Duval falls into a room.
- 40:26Door slams shut. We know she just got grudged.
- 40:30Matthew shows up and then like he's he finds his wife.
- 40:36She just seems like paralyzed in bed with fear.
- 40:39He tries to help her, but then the little ghost boy pops up out
- 40:42of nowhere and he's like meowing like a cat would.
- 40:46Or like a human baby. At her, Clete Duvall seems to
- 40:51pass away in this moment where she just fully is dead.
- 40:54Seems like she's scared to death and then not.
- 40:57Bill Pullman falls back. Little boy does hisses at him.
- 41:03Cut to black again. We don't get to see shit in this
- 41:05movie. There's so many.
- 41:06Cut to blacks. Wait, so this guy is not the
- 41:10guy? This guy is not the guy who
- 41:11jumps. So who's the jumper?
- 41:13The jumper comes later, so I mean we cut back I.
- 41:18Fully thought he was. No different.
- 41:21He's different because they because in the next bit.
- 41:23So we cut back to the president where Sam Rachel Geller had just
- 41:27been spooked by the grudge and her boss seems like come looking
- 41:32for her be like, what's going on?
- 41:33Like you even checked in all day.
- 41:37And he finds Karen in the corner kind of like hair lies with fear
- 41:42much the same way Cle Duval was. And he calls the police.
- 41:47I think the mom is dead. The mom, like died in her sleep.
- 41:53And the detectives are like, we can't find the like the son
- 41:58didn't call in to work today. His wife is missing.
- 42:00Like people are going missing now.
- 42:02And they're like, oh, Yoko the the nurse, she's also missing.
- 42:08She ain't show up for work. So texters are like, OK, we
- 42:10gotta check this out. They I think the phone leads
- 42:15them upstairs. OK.
- 42:18Right, that sounds right where she like I think.
- 42:21The end up. Upstairs, I think they're like,
- 42:22where's the phone at? Because like you said, it's not
- 42:24on the receiver. They do.
- 42:26They do like the find the phone thing.
- 42:27So the phone's ringing, OK, where they go up there, and this
- 42:33is where we find the bodies of Clea Duvall and her husband.
- 42:38So they're fully dead. You're right.
- 42:40They're fully dead and they see like on the floor is someone's
- 42:47jaw, someone's lower jaw. Yes, casually.
- 42:50And it's like, who does that belong to?
- 42:52Who's is this? Does someone leave this here?
- 42:56Who's is this? Who's that?
- 42:57No, no, it's a job. Who's?
- 43:01Who's mandible? They also determined it was like
- 43:04a suicide or like I think the police would go, it looks like
- 43:07the husband killed his wife and committed suicide where you
- 43:10know, because they're like, from what I understand, they've not
- 43:13been missing for very long, right?
- 43:15Because they just say, Oh yeah, the son didn't show up to work
- 43:18today, right? It might be a Monday, but it's
- 43:21I'm assuming he should have to work on Friday at least.
- 43:24Yeah, and also Yoko just went missing like.
- 43:27You ever missing the day before? So that one's like less.
- 43:29But like there's like, oh, we think he did.
- 43:30He did this. The bodies are already decaying.
- 43:34Like what world do you think they died like recently?
- 43:37Maybe it's really hard like at it.
- 43:39Maybe Karen, she's OK. She wakes up, She's just like,
- 43:46scared. She's talking to her boyfriend.
- 43:50The police were like, there's a sister.
- 43:52She lives in Tokyo too. Let's get a hold of her.
- 43:55We cut to the sister. At this point, I'm getting
- 43:57exhausted of all the characters. I'm tired of it but.
- 44:02I thought one guy was the same. You thought they were the same
- 44:04person. They're not.
- 44:05And this is the scene that I saw as a kid that scared the fuck
- 44:09out of me, 'cause Susan is like, she's leaving work.
- 44:15I don't know where she works at. It's not very clear.
- 44:17Some building and she's just getting kind of creeped out.
- 44:21She's the only one in this big building.
- 44:23The vibes are super, super weird.
- 44:27She's in a stairway and she gets a phone call from from Matthew,
- 44:32who we know is dead. So she answers it and it's that
- 44:37classic so scary. She's freaking out.
- 44:44She like hangs up above her. The lights are like flickering
- 44:47and like they're smashing sounds below her.
- 44:50She can strip, see like the ghost of a woman, like just kind
- 44:54of scratching around. So sorry the sickness is coming
- 45:00through me. Oh my God, he's choked out.
- 45:02So choked with fear. So she like runs and she does
- 45:05find a security guard and she's like, you have to check this
- 45:07out. There's something suspicious and
- 45:08weird going on. I'm scared.
- 45:11Security guard goes to check it out while she's watching from
- 45:15the cameras. We see him find nothing, but in
- 45:18the second he walks away from the stairway a little shadow
- 45:23starts to pour out her into the shape of a woman and start
- 45:27walking. And Susan, the sister is not
- 45:29having any of it fair. So she fucking dips.
- 45:33She runs out which? Leaves his ass to deal with it.
- 45:36Really. Like now they're fast, like Dan,
- 45:37he was out of his building, gets on a taxi to go back to her
- 45:44home. And while she's like on the
- 45:48elevator, Mama, there's a ghost boy behind you.
- 45:52Mama. Mama, every single floor there's
- 45:55a ghost boy behind you because she's got the elevator and we
- 45:57can see through the window. Little boys are staying there
- 45:59all ghostly up. As she's going up, she gets
- 46:04home, she gets a phone call from Matthew being like, hey, I'm
- 46:08outside, buzz me in. The second she buzzes, there's a
- 46:12knot and she looks and she does see Matthew through the little
- 46:15eye hole. She's like what the hell?
- 46:18Uh huh. The timing does not make sense.
- 46:19It can't be him. How do you do that?
- 46:21She opens the door. He's gone.
- 46:23And I did really like that part. I really like that.
- 46:25It was like, that is kind of scary.
- 46:27And this grown woman, now scared, runs into bed.
- 46:31She runs. She got to jump covers.
- 46:34And this is the moment I saw. This is the moment I saw.
- 46:37That stuck with me because she jumps in the bed.
- 46:39And the bed when you're a kid, is your safe space.
- 46:42Demons can't get you there. Oh.
- 46:45She gets into the bed. She's like hiding and then we
- 46:48see some like a lump form and start like railing towards her.
- 46:53There's something in the bed with her, she opens it up, it's
- 46:56the grudge going and then like within a second Susan is
- 47:03disappeared. Which also why sometimes the
- 47:06grudge disappear them and sometimes it kills them.
- 47:10She's a little variety in her life, her afterlife.
- 47:14RIP Susan. This also will say what the fuck
- 47:20was the point of any of that? Oh.
- 47:24OK, I have to. I meant to say something earlier
- 47:27but I forgot, but we'll talk about it later.
- 47:28Sorry anyways. Yeah, so that whole long
- 47:31sequence just to kill Susan, I'll tell you know, doesn't
- 47:33matter. Back to Karen, back to our main
- 47:38storyline. She's being interrogated by the
- 47:40police or asking questions. And she's like, yeah, I did find
- 47:43a journal when I found that little boy and then went, oh, he
- 47:48had a journal. She goes, no, it's a girl's.
- 47:52How do you know it looks feminine?
- 47:56Handwriting. Kind of handwriting
- 47:59scientifically. We've seen no we see that
- 48:01journal. We see that journal.
- 48:06I would not call that feminine handwriting.
- 48:08I don't remember it. We see all the crazy scrawlings
- 48:12in it. OK.
- 48:15There's I was like, that's a crazy thing to say.
- 48:20The police find out Susan is now missing as well.
- 48:24Susan and they drop a fun little nugget where they this go
- 48:29detective, that's the first family to live in that house
- 48:33since the thing three years ago, which like, yeah, they'd be
- 48:37obviously connected. And so Karen overhears this
- 48:41thing. She, I think she like, oh, she,
- 48:48she gets out of the hospital. She means her boyfriend doesn't
- 48:51really matter. I didn't care for her boyfriend
- 48:53all that much. He was way more interested in
- 48:55his one episode of Buffy. I'm not afraid to see it.
- 48:59He gave nothing. She goes home and we get this so
- 49:02we can tell like the demon is still with her, like she sees in
- 49:04a reflection, we see the grudge At one point she's washing her
- 49:08hair and there's just like a knuckle.
- 49:10I feel like it was someone's hand was like a.
- 49:12Hand Yeah. Would you say Mama, there's a
- 49:15demon behind? You, Mama, there's a demon in
- 49:17you like. Let your freak flag fly.
- 49:23While we're doing this, we see we're cut back to her boss,
- 49:26Karen's boss. He's at work, he's leaving super
- 49:28late, and now there's a creepy ghost or something creepy
- 49:33walking in and we go, oh, it's the Grudge.
- 49:36It's not the Grudge. It's Yoko that's Yoko, and she's
- 49:40dripping blood and he's just like Yoko.
- 49:42Bro, what's up? What's going on?
- 49:44Like are you OK? Good girl.
- 49:46She turns around and she says, Mama, I dropped my jaw.
- 49:52Direct quote. He says, Mama, I dropped my jaw.
- 49:57He's jaw. It was her jaw in the attic.
- 50:00The grudge took her jaw. You know, like wig snatched.
- 50:05Wig snatched. Jaw snatched.
- 50:07Mandible taken. Boss screams.
- 50:12I'm like, he's gonna. He's just killed here.
- 50:17Yeah, she needs his job. So now at home, Sir Mitchell go.
- 50:23She's like, OK, I know something else have in this house.
- 50:25I know this little boy was probably involved so I need to
- 50:27investigate it and she googles pretty fast.
- 50:30She finds little boy killed like there was a incident where a
- 50:36husband killed his family and then himself.
- 50:40And do you know what that's called?
- 50:42Family annihilation. Yes, I only like the triggers.
- 50:50And I do not understand how she makes the next leap in logic
- 50:54because she clicks on this article and then she scrolls
- 50:58down and we see Bill Pullman committed suicide as a different
- 51:06news article. And she goes, it's connected.
- 51:11And I don't know how she made that connection at all.
- 51:14She's Buffy the Vampire Slayer. She just scrolled.
- 51:18Down to a different story and went this is it.
- 51:21She just knows. The, oh, the, the we got the
- 51:29detective, he's just kind of investigating.
- 51:30We know he he's seeing like the ghosts happening.
- 51:34He doesn't. I wish the detective was more of
- 51:36a character in this because he doesn't do a lot except go uh oh
- 51:41the ghost is real. It's behind you, Mama.
- 51:45Mama goes behind you, say Michelle Gellar.
- 51:48She goes to she, she finds Bill Pullman's wife and she's like, I
- 51:52just want to know what happened. And she's the wife just showing
- 51:55pictures to Buffy. Yeah, we're having show and
- 51:59tell. She's like, like all these
- 52:00photos of my husband and like while San Francois was looking
- 52:06through him, she starts noticing in the background a woman who
- 52:10looks just like Toshio's mom, Kaiko.
- 52:15And she makes this connection and she looks in all of them.
- 52:18And there I, I will say this because it's the most fitting.
- 52:20Mama, a stalker behind you? Mama.
- 52:24Mama, there's a woman behind you because she's on every single
- 52:27photo. This, every single photo.
- 52:29Some of them like you should have seen that because it's you
- 52:32and your wife together and this woman's maybe 2 feet behind you
- 52:35in between you guys. In like every single time too.
- 52:39Like have you ever looked at the pictures?
- 52:40Like some of them I'm like, yeah, she's way in the corner.
- 52:42I wouldn't miss that. But she's right next to you, so
- 52:48we know. Like I don't even explored
- 52:52enough if like was she stalking him or was there an affair?
- 52:56I took it as a fair, but I. Don't know, I don't think it was
- 52:58an affair though, because now we get a flashback of or we used to
- 53:05get Bill Pullman sort of like because they love to jump around
- 53:07in this movie. It's for no reason.
- 53:09We're now at Bill Pullman's time where he's at work leaving and
- 53:14his bot or his Co workers like oh, you got another message from
- 53:17this woman and this this crazy woman.
- 53:20And he's like, yeah, she said we I taught her about remember who
- 53:23she is. And so I don't think I'm
- 53:28confused still. He then goes to the house, which
- 53:32I'm guessing must have been on the letters because he goes
- 53:37there and he finds Toshio clearly abused Is.
- 53:41Your mom. Around but I and it's maybe he
- 53:44was having an affair and he's looking for the mom because he's
- 53:48like that's our relationship, but it it seems like he doesn't
- 53:53really know who Toshio is. OK, OK.
- 54:00I I didn't, I just don't get it. He goes in the house and.
- 54:08You lost. Oh no, 'cause I'm like, what?
- 54:12I'm just like, 'cause it's so confusing.
- 54:13For no reason. He goes in the house, there's a
- 54:15it's all kind of a ruin. It's a mess.
- 54:17The little boy starts meowing and screeched like a cat.
- 54:21So at this point, you know what? We know he's.
- 54:23A. You know how every every middle
- 54:25school had the kid that thought they were a cat?
- 54:28Toshi was that like who he told you who they wishes they were?
- 54:33He's the one who's like you annoys them, you annoy them, and
- 54:35they like. So I'm assuming at this point
- 54:38I'm like, oh, he's already dead. Toshi was dead because he's
- 54:41meowing like a ghost. Cut to black again, because this
- 54:46movie loves to fucking do that. At this point.
- 54:50I thought he figured out what happened.
- 54:51I feel like you figured out what happened.
- 54:54But he likes to really tease it out and say, Mitchell Geller,
- 54:57now she's like, OK, the event that happened three years ago,
- 55:00that's still affecting what's ever happening now.
- 55:02She goes to the detective and she's like, she was like, they
- 55:06shared a relationship with this guy, or she knew this guy or was
- 55:09obsessed with him. And she's all these photos.
- 55:11What does this mean? He does.
- 55:12He reveals that when people are killed in extreme feelings of
- 55:18sadness or sorrow or anger, then that emotion stays behind and
- 55:25it's going to kill anyone who goes into that space.
- 55:29So now anyone who's been in the house is doomed to get killed.
- 55:36Which? Is blatantly not true.
- 55:39I just seems like you'd be really well aware of that.
- 55:41I feel like there's no way to hide like, because in anyone
- 55:46who's investigating this, like any like the, the this murder
- 55:48suicide, they're all going to die and then go, the house must
- 55:51be connected and they're going to start going there And it's
- 55:54like some people will be dead, some people will be dead.
- 55:56Realtors will be dead. Wait, the realtor is not dead
- 55:59and also the main detective is actively detective thing still
- 56:04despite detective? He wasn't the main detective on
- 56:06that case. But he's been in the house
- 56:09before, I think. This was his first time in the
- 56:11house. He was not on that case from the
- 56:16three years ago at all. His colleagues were, He said, I,
- 56:19we were three detectives on it. They all died.
- 56:23And he's kind of like, we're kind of fucked now.
- 56:25We're actually doomed to die. And there was A and the biggest
- 56:28part, there were so many people who showed the house when Sir
- 56:32Michelle Gellar called or when they called the police
- 56:34afterwards, she was there. So a lot of people who get
- 56:36killed who you go, that's really weird.
- 56:39It makes no sense to me. And he's just like, Yep, we're
- 56:45kind of in trouble. We're going to die.
- 56:48I'm sorry. Sucks to suck.
- 56:52She goes home, He goes to the house.
- 56:54He's going to set it on fire. But before he does, he starts
- 56:58boyfriend. No, sorry, not boyfriend, the
- 57:00detective. The detective's like, I'm going
- 57:01to burn this whole place down. He takes gasoline cans there.
- 57:05He's about to use them, but he starts hearing a boy crying.
- 57:08And like, why would you even fall for that?
- 57:10It's clearly the ghost and it's also reasonable question of to
- 57:13me at this point, is the boy boy entity different from the mom
- 57:18entity, different from the dad entity?
- 57:20Or they all the same thing in different forms?
- 57:28I think they're different because it seems like the boy
- 57:32and the mom kind of, I mean, just based on what we come to
- 57:35learn later. I just know they all are seem to
- 57:38have the same goal like we're going to kill you when it comes
- 57:40in here. Well so he's there, he hears the
- 57:45boy crying, he goes upstairs and he finds like the boy in the tub
- 57:51and then the dad ghost. His one and only appearance am
- 57:54I, if I can remember correctly. Yes.
- 57:56He comes charging and not pale. That pissed me off.
- 57:59I was like why is he not pale like everyone else?
- 58:02And he drowns. The detective in the Tub series
- 58:07rap on. The Oh, he makes one more
- 58:08appearance. He makes one more appearance.
- 58:10Oh yeah, but not as a ghost. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 58:14Sarah Michelle Gellar, Now that she's gone home, she gets a a
- 58:19phone call. She's told that Yoko's haven't
- 58:22been found dead. Her boss is dead, and her
- 58:24boyfriend's like, I'm really worried about you.
- 58:26Did you go back to the house? I'm going to come look for you.
- 58:28Uh oh. He's going back to the to the
- 58:30death house, which if you go into it, you're going to be
- 58:35killed. So seriously, girl is running
- 58:37there trying to save him. She shows up and like we see
- 58:42like earlier he was walking around in it and like there was
- 58:45some creepy stuff behind him. But she gets there, Mama behind
- 58:51him. Mama, there's a door creaking
- 58:53behind you. So stupid.
- 58:58She gets there. She can hear like him talking
- 59:01and like upstairs and she's like, Oh my God, I found you.
- 59:04Only it's not him. It's Bill Pullman talking to
- 59:09Toshio. Yes, yes.
- 59:12And again, I'm confused about his relationship with this mom.
- 59:16This so when he when we see Sarah Michelle Gellar question
- 59:22mark, I guess seeing all the pictures of the mom, the person
- 59:30in the other family pictures that combined with how dad is
- 59:34just like very comfortably hanging out in the kids room is
- 59:38why I thought affair. Because I didn't think he was I.
- 59:41To me it felt like he was the same.
- 59:44No, it must be an affair because it couldn't have been the same
- 59:46day as when he first went to investigate it because the kid
- 59:48was already dead at that point. I figured that she like.
- 59:52Worked for them is the same day because the mom's dead.
- 59:57I just in my mind she worked for them and they were having an
- 1:00:00affair and she was like jealous of.
- 1:00:03Wait, no, actually it's an affair and I know why and we'll
- 1:00:06talk about it later. It's an affair.
- 1:00:07OK, 'cause now? Now I'm thinking maybe it isn't
- 1:00:09affair. It's an affair.
- 1:00:12He's like, see, we see, like we just following him like as a
- 1:00:16flashback ghost for no reason at all.
- 1:00:18This could been done in the last flashback 'cause it isn't.
- 1:00:22In the drama. Where he drops the boy after the
- 1:00:25voice still scratched up and like bruised and all that he
- 1:00:27like you hang out here. Dad starts start dad.
- 1:00:31Bill Pullman's investigating around Moore and he finds a
- 1:00:36journal and he finds like all the photos with like the mom's
- 1:00:41face cut out. And so he finds a journal and
- 1:00:45inside of it is just like Peter, Peter, Peter, which is Bill
- 1:00:49Pullman's name, I think is my guess, a reasonable guess in my
- 1:00:53opinion. But one could assume.
- 1:00:57There's like his name everywhere and like, she's clearly obsessed
- 1:00:59with him and in love with him. He goes upstairs into the attic
- 1:01:04and the mom's body like drops down and we get a sudden like
- 1:01:08quick flash of like what LED up to that where the husband found
- 1:01:13this journal and this sent him on this rage where he killed his
- 1:01:19family. He drowned the cat in the tub.
- 1:01:21That's what the tub was. I think the we don't see if
- 1:01:26maybe the boy gets drowned in it too.
- 1:01:27We don't see what happens. Specifically, I thought the kid
- 1:01:29got drowned. The cat for sure gets drowned
- 1:01:34and then the mom is killed in the attic and this is like, so
- 1:01:39this is like the thing that's cursing this this house, which
- 1:01:42like, yeah, I got that. The second, the second he told
- 1:01:45me a man killed his wife and kid, I was like, oh, 'cause she
- 1:01:48was in love with somebody else. I didn't need you to tell me
- 1:01:50like this. It wasn't complicated.
- 1:01:54And Sarah Michelle Gellar's like, she's like, I now know
- 1:01:58everything. She finds Doug.
- 1:01:59Doug has been grudged. He's in that paralyzed beard,
- 1:02:04just kind of unable to move state and she's trying to drag
- 1:02:09him out. But now Kyoko's ghost is now
- 1:02:12coming after them. The ghost like touches Doug and
- 1:02:21Doug dies fully. He does dead.
- 1:02:24And I wish I cared. And I don't think Sarah Michelle
- 1:02:26Gellar counts that much either. She seemed like kind of.
- 1:02:29Irritated. Barely there.
- 1:02:30She felt like she was like, damn, I really wanted to keep
- 1:02:33him alive. Oh well, you know.
- 1:02:36Let's just get another floppy white hair boy or floppy hair
- 1:02:39white boy. The Corners movie.
- 1:02:41There's Americans everywhere in Japan, so.
- 1:02:45And they're all the same man. They're all the same, man.
- 1:02:49I hope you like, not Bill Pullman does everyone else.
- 1:02:55And she opens the door to leave. But then, like, the ghost is now
- 1:02:59also there. Kaiko's spirits have been moving
- 1:03:01around too fast for her. She seems like she's like, this
- 1:03:03is it for me, set the size of the house on fire.
- 1:03:06She pours the gasoline tanks. She gets a match.
- 1:03:10She's trying to light it. And the ghost is trying to stop
- 1:03:12her, like Kaiko's trying to stop her, but she can't really.
- 1:03:17I mean, she could do more. I really like I've seen you do
- 1:03:19more, but she goes no, don't do it.
- 1:03:23No, she like froze the match. While honestly Kyoko's like
- 1:03:26trying to make out with her. Like that's what she's doing.
- 1:03:28She's trying to like, I guess trying to suck her soul out of
- 1:03:31her head or something, but they're really just making out.
- 1:03:35Would you say she's trying to? I think she is a little bit.
- 1:03:41She's trying to make out. I mean, she throws the match Cut
- 1:03:47to black again. This movie is cut to blacks.
- 1:03:49Pissed me off. They pissed me off so much.
- 1:03:52And Sam Michelle was in the hospital and we're getting an
- 1:03:54exposition talk of the go. Yep, the boyfriend died, but
- 1:03:59this girl survived. We also saved the house too.
- 1:04:02So that's pretty awesome. And they're having her just go
- 1:04:05see the body. I guess I'm also so confused
- 1:04:08because they're Michelle Gellar at this point is like, she looks
- 1:04:11like she got the shit kicked out of her.
- 1:04:13Like she's got a black eye, she's got cuts, bruises
- 1:04:16everywhere. Like no burns.
- 1:04:20You don't look at your car, not like you were in a fire.
- 1:04:24There's a really aggressive making out session.
- 1:04:26Like that? Damn, like that's crazy.
- 1:04:30That's crazy. And we know what's going to
- 1:04:32happen. She's there to go see the body.
- 1:04:34But uh oh, the hand that flops out is not Doug's arm, it's the
- 1:04:38Grudge's arm. SMG gets spooked.
- 1:04:41And then behind her we see a a woman with long black hair.
- 1:04:46She turns around, It's a grudge, Mama, Mama, a grudge behind you.
- 1:04:54And roll credits. And that's the whole movie.
- 1:04:56That's the whole movie. And I was, yeah, I was
- 1:04:58disappointed. Yeah, we are on the same.
- 1:05:03Page this. Week.
- 1:05:04Buddy, that's what we did. That's it.
- 1:05:06I don't understand. I don't understand the I'm very
- 1:05:10curious what the original ones like because my I feel like they
- 1:05:14must have chosen to add more deaths.
- 1:05:20Hence why we have like the pointless like boss getting
- 1:05:25killed and like the what's their name?
- 1:05:32Like the like the son and the and his wife getting killed and
- 1:05:35the sister which really Oh my God caught her from the whole
- 1:05:38fucking movie. Who cares?
- 1:05:40Yeah, she didn't need to be there.
- 1:05:42I so then I am very confused on so I was tracking that we had
- 1:05:49floppy hair boyfriend, we had the Japanese dad.
- 1:05:55There are there are a total of you talking about the white male
- 1:05:58characters. There's four of them.
- 1:06:01Four. OK, wait.
- 1:06:03I'm counting. I'm counting boyfriend.
- 1:06:04There's Boyfriend. Boyfriend and boss I have we
- 1:06:07got. Those me because my my three, my
- 1:06:10three Bill Pullmans were Bill Pullman, boss and the son
- 1:06:16Matthew, I thought. So every time they popped up on
- 1:06:20screen, I said which one's that? Wait, so the sun jumped?
- 1:06:26The sun did not jump. The Sun was kidnapped by the
- 1:06:28little boy ghost with his wife. So this movie was so incredibly
- 1:06:39boring to me that I think I just checked out.
- 1:06:42It's not good. It's not good because.
- 1:06:47I thought we had three. I mean, I the boss is not like
- 1:06:51an important person in my mind. He's just like a shoe in.
- 1:06:54He's just. There.
- 1:06:55Yeah, he's just there for a deaf.
- 1:06:57So he's clear to me because he has such a limited little
- 1:07:00whatever. And then?
- 1:07:02Boyfriend. And Remy's brother.
- 1:07:05Boyfriend. I could tell the difference
- 1:07:07because he had floppy hair and the other ones.
- 1:07:09Didn't, yeah. But the other guy, Jumpy and
- 1:07:13Attic, I thought were the same person.
- 1:07:15Nope. And then until you said that,
- 1:07:17that didn't make sense. You know it didn't click, but
- 1:07:20they were not the same. Person.
- 1:07:21No, not the same person. OK, well here's the thing.
- 1:07:28This is not important, this is not relevant, this is not part
- 1:07:31of my analysis, but I meant to say it when we were at the scene
- 1:07:34and I just forgot immediately after, Karen and Emma see The
- 1:07:41Grudge together as a family. My viewing on Prime, You can
- 1:07:48watch this on Prime, by the way. Went to a commercial.
- 1:07:51Oh, same. Same.
- 1:07:53The commercial was Ozempic, except it was Justin Long.
- 1:07:57No, he's promoting, yes. And I was like, first of all,
- 1:08:04first of all, why is Justin Long talking about Ozempic?
- 1:08:08Because he's he's always been small.
- 1:08:12Like why him? What an odd do that I.
- 1:08:18So that was like really jarring. That was very confusing to me
- 1:08:24and it that holds more weight for me than this entire movie.
- 1:08:29And then you said I'm done watching, actually.
- 1:08:32I that's crazy. Well, the other thing I wanted
- 1:08:39to bring up is that similar to Late Night with the Devil, but
- 1:08:43not quite as dramatic, the opening brands where they do the
- 1:08:48little clip for each brand. I was like, oh, this one's a
- 1:08:50little bit locked, She's a little bit long.
- 1:08:53Going. They kept going.
- 1:08:55I'm not gonna lie, at that point I was playing Pokopia on my
- 1:09:00Switch too. Pretty sure I just started
- 1:09:03playing my little number game on my phone at some point.
- 1:09:06I. Was like, this is not it.
- 1:09:09OK, so let me tell you the back story, the lore that this movie
- 1:09:17is based on, and see if that helps us answer a question about
- 1:09:21the mother's relationship with white dude #2 I guess #3 I don't
- 1:09:28know. I would say white number one.
- 1:09:29He's the most famous. Number one, OK, so the back
- 1:09:34story that this movie is based on is reminiscent of the myth of
- 1:09:41Oiwa. OK OIWA, which is a traditional
- 1:09:47resentful Japanese ghost legend. So in the movie we have a
- 1:09:54housewife who is disfigured and brutally murdered by her
- 1:09:59unfaithful husband. Oh, that was like, so I don't
- 1:10:06that was like a classic giallo zoomin.
- 1:10:10There was a good one. It was like a little bit off.
- 1:10:12It was good. That's what John.
- 1:10:14Does I don't know where we learn that he's unfaithful?
- 1:10:19Wait, where'd you get that he was unfaithful?
- 1:10:22IMDb. What?
- 1:10:24Maybe it's one of the other movies or something.
- 1:10:25Because he was not. No, I it was 2004 so.
- 1:10:31That was not implied in this one.
- 1:10:33The actual. I believe the actual legend that
- 1:10:37it is based on is to. That's not true either.
- 1:10:42I think it's implied that he is abusive beyond like killing his
- 1:10:46family. Right, just in the day-to-day,
- 1:10:49Yeah, so I don't they said that, but basically regardless, even
- 1:10:55if you take that away, mom is disfigured and brutally murdered
- 1:10:59and also the child ended up are brutally murdered by this man.
- 1:11:04And then the now I'm very confused OK the way IMDb wrote
- 1:11:16this. I have to imagine IMDb is basing
- 1:11:19this as like whoever wrote that is basing it off of what might
- 1:11:21come from other movies that might get discovered later on or
- 1:11:25might be have been a revelation in one of the other like the
- 1:11:31Japanese movies. It's my only possible guess
- 1:11:35this. Is Britain like it happens in
- 1:11:39the movie, but it logically sounds more like what the legend
- 1:11:43would be based on. Yeah.
- 1:11:46So I'm just going to tell you what it said.
- 1:11:49So it it said again, mom, child murdered, disfigured, RIP.
- 1:11:55And then they come back. Specifically, the wife comes
- 1:11:59back and haunts the husband's lover.
- 1:12:04We didn't see any of that, which makes me feel like maybe that's
- 1:12:06a legend. That's got to be a legend
- 1:12:07because that doesn't happen here.
- 1:12:08And they just worded it poorly. Because in this one, it's the
- 1:12:12they they quite clearly say if you walk in the house, death
- 1:12:16will attach itself to you. So where that comes from, this
- 1:12:20one's easy is the legend. So the actual for sure part of
- 1:12:23this legend is that this type of vengeful ghost is it doesn't
- 1:12:30haunt a place or a person. It's every time you retell their
- 1:12:34story, they then haunt who heard it.
- 1:12:37Don't fucking tell me. Oh my God.
- 1:12:38I'd be so poor. I'd be so pissed.
- 1:12:41But also, if I knew, I'm telling everybody.
- 1:12:44So, but it's interesting, it's a, if you think about like how
- 1:12:49most legends and myths come to be, it's just to explain an
- 1:12:52unexplainable thing at the time. Yeah.
- 1:12:55And that one I like isn't the word, but it's interesting
- 1:13:00because it's a decent metaphorical explanation of
- 1:13:04cyclical trauma and abuse and how, you know, often the
- 1:13:08traumatized slash abused become the abuser or traumatizer.
- 1:13:14So basically this person who was murdered, their ghost is not
- 1:13:22traumatized. And now every time somebody
- 1:13:23tells that story, they traumatize the person who told
- 1:13:26the story. So it's it's a decent
- 1:13:28representation of that human psyche phenomena.
- 1:13:35So retelling spreads the curse, which we see at the end of the
- 1:13:40movie because now Sarah Michelle Gellar, even though she survived
- 1:13:42the house, she knows the story, which is why she's still
- 1:13:45haunted. And she does.
- 1:13:48I'm assuming. She We don't see anyone die.
- 1:13:52We have. Cigarettes too, we see.
- 1:13:53The grudge goes and they go and then we see the black every
- 1:13:58fucking time. And it's like a Rep itch when
- 1:14:05you don't deal with your anger and all of your feelings from
- 1:14:08those situations. That's how you're like cycle of
- 1:14:11trauma starts because you don't have anywhere to put those
- 1:14:14feelings. So you start taking it out on
- 1:14:15people, which having the tail be the thing that haunts you, I
- 1:14:20think is also a very interesting way to explain that.
- 1:14:25And it also shows the randomness of trauma.
- 1:14:28So these people don't that don't have anything to do with nothing
- 1:14:31are getting affected by this, which is how trauma works in the
- 1:14:35real world. And am I afraid to say it?
- 1:14:37It's fucking lame. They're all Americans.
- 1:14:40It it really feels like there was no reason to remake this
- 1:14:42movie. That's how I felt when I watched
- 1:14:44it. I don't know why it was remade,
- 1:14:48I think it got a lot of. I'm one of those.
- 1:14:51This was in a this was in a time period which I, I'm, I, we know
- 1:14:55the nozzles that we'll talk about it 'cause there's a few
- 1:14:57different movies from this time period that I'm aware of where
- 1:14:59we were just in America, loved remaking Japanese.
- 1:15:03Horror J Horror Yeah, I so this and The Ring apparently, are
- 1:15:08very. This, the this, the Ring and
- 1:15:10also one missed call. They're all from the same era of
- 1:15:16like horror. Genuinely, this was like, it's
- 1:15:19so much, so much the unborn. I think it's called.
- 1:15:22No, it's not the uninvited. There's so many different movies
- 1:15:26from this time period where the like the mid early 2000s where
- 1:15:31it was straight up we just are remaking a Japanese horror film
- 1:15:35because I think this is the, I think the 90s were just like a
- 1:15:37peak time for horror films in Japan.
- 1:15:41I feel like Americans are very begrudgeon when it comes to
- 1:15:46either listening to dub or reading Subtitle I.
- 1:15:50Think especially in the 2000s, Yeah, like even like people were
- 1:15:54it was like, no, we can't watch this unless you remake it with a
- 1:16:00with a blonde actress as our lead.
- 1:16:03Crazy. I Unfortunately, if the dub is
- 1:16:06really bad, I can't do it. I'm not I'm.
- 1:16:08Not watching a dub. I'm not watching.
- 1:16:09It I'll read it so I'll go dub over captions but if the dub is
- 1:16:14bad. If it's a if it's a live action,
- 1:16:17I got to watch it subbed. And I also, I can, I do think we
- 1:16:22should add to our list. I was going to bring this up.
- 1:16:26We should add one missed call because I do actually like one
- 1:16:28missed call and that is 1. I do think the American version
- 1:16:30is better. I've seen both of them.
- 1:16:31So I can tell you talk about both.
- 1:16:33And we should add, I just thought about it the uninvited
- 1:16:36because I like the uninvited a lot.
- 1:16:38You should put those on the spreadsheet.
- 1:16:39I'm going to put those on the spreadsheet on the pole for next
- 1:16:42week. I do want one missed call.
- 1:16:45One missed call. OK, I so the ring is another one
- 1:16:49that's been built up in my head. But because recently I've been
- 1:16:52seeing a lot of discourse of people saying it's one of the
- 1:16:54scariest things they've ever seen, and now I feel like we're
- 1:16:57being dramatic. That one, they are.
- 1:16:58I, I can say right now they definitely are.
- 1:17:00That one's not scary at all. It's it's very similar, just
- 1:17:04like this weird spooky thing and like AI think it's Nicole Kidman
- 1:17:10researching it. OK, love.
- 1:17:13It's just her like going to a place then going I'm going to be
- 1:17:16vague and ambiguous. It's not good.
- 1:17:19I don't like the ring. I don't like the ring.
- 1:17:21I don't like the ring. I don't think it's scary.
- 1:17:23Sounds boring but yeah the like the haunting happening through
- 1:17:28just retelling of the story just really embodies the randomness
- 1:17:31of trauma. There's.
- 1:17:33Just like no rhyme or reason. And again, how destructive anger
- 1:17:37can be when it's not dealt with. And with that, Ben, I think
- 1:17:41that's about as deep as this movie goes.
- 1:17:44I don't think it's very it's pretty like on the surface, like
- 1:17:47OK, we get it. It's there's trauma on dealt
- 1:17:51with and now it's re coming back coming back and.
- 1:17:55Yeah. And it's not gonna do anything
- 1:17:57to even like deal with that does go Yup, that's what's.
- 1:18:01Happened. That's it and.
- 1:18:02They all die. I like where does your
- 1:18:07disappointment fall in? Like what is your big let down
- 1:18:13on this? I think for me it was how just
- 1:18:15disjointed the whole thing was. The timeline jumping did not
- 1:18:20work. For me it doesn't.
- 1:18:20It doesn't. And the whole time, like because
- 1:18:23I am a person, it's not good for me.
- 1:18:26I will sit there and I'll if I'm like watching something, I'm
- 1:18:28thinking how can I make it better?
- 1:18:30Which is crazy because I definitely couldn't make it
- 1:18:32better, but like I'm sitting here going like I'm sitting here
- 1:18:36thinking like, OK, I I wish we started with a more clear
- 1:18:40protagonist. I think the detective should be
- 1:18:42that protagonist. I think we start with I think we
- 1:18:48have the cold open of Yoko getting snatched.
- 1:18:50That's the only cold open we don't see Bill Pullman.
- 1:18:53And then we have the detective kind of come in after Sarah
- 1:18:56Michelle Gellar has been spooked.
- 1:19:00And then so it's like, OK, now she's unconscious.
- 1:19:02He we know people are missing and like we learn through him.
- 1:19:06These things have happened, not these random.
- 1:19:09Here's a flashback showing you. I would have cut Susan entirely
- 1:19:13and done something else but kept the scares because that was a
- 1:19:16good scary scene. OK.
- 1:19:19And it is for me like it was just like have.
- 1:19:20The detective in the stairwell, he's been to the house.
- 1:19:22He would be haunted too. He does get get get haunted too.
- 1:19:29He dies, they kill him. I don't even remember it.
- 1:19:32He just gets drowned all of a sudden by the dad.
- 1:19:35And that's like where I think my disappointment comes from, where
- 1:19:37it's just I at no point cared about the story 'cause they did
- 1:19:43not lay it out as a story. They set it up as like, as
- 1:19:46though it'd be like a mystery. It'd be unraveled, but it's not
- 1:19:51unraveled. And it's not like the scares
- 1:19:55were getting progressively scarier.
- 1:19:58Yeah. Like a lot of characters get
- 1:20:01killed off screen and it's not like I'm like suspenseful, like
- 1:20:05oh God, what happened? I know what happened.
- 1:20:07We should have found the the bodies of the husband and wife
- 1:20:11before we actually saw what happened.
- 1:20:15Yeah, I my disappointment comes from a It's just like the scares
- 1:20:20aren't scary. I feel like they created this
- 1:20:25visually creepy character and then completely wasted it.
- 1:20:28Yeah, 'cause it is creepy to have a little, like she's moving
- 1:20:31wrong, her hair's backwards, she's making creepy noise, but
- 1:20:35then she just kind of like, exists and the boy doesn't do
- 1:20:38anything. Well, the boy's the boy does
- 1:20:41also just say that it's existing and that's why I'm also confused
- 1:20:43about what are they art 'cause he is also killing people.
- 1:20:48He kills the the husband and wife.
- 1:20:52I don't. It's not the mom.
- 1:20:54I don't get it. It's him and it's why I think
- 1:20:56it's the same entity doing it all.
- 1:21:00Just kidding, but that's not how ghosts work.
- 1:21:02I don't know, it's just very. Because they're not ghosts.
- 1:21:03They're the emotion of when they got killed, they said.
- 1:21:06It's the rage, the sorrow that lingers.
- 1:21:08It's not them, it's the the feeling of when they died.
- 1:21:14I feel like that doesn't make any sense because the feeling
- 1:21:16doesn't kill you. Well, in this case the feeling
- 1:21:19does. It's not I don't know which.
- 1:21:22Also, that I think plays into the beginning part where they're
- 1:21:24like, oh, they got to put the spirits to rest.
- 1:21:26That's never even wound up as a possibility to resolve this.
- 1:21:31It's. Why did Michelle, Sarah.
- 1:21:33Michelle. Miller just not go in there and
- 1:21:34do that. We got burn it down.
- 1:21:37That's not what they told the beginning.
- 1:21:39That's not the same thing as saging.
- 1:21:41It's instance burning, but yes. Sorry, I don't.
- 1:21:46I didn't like, I didn't like this.
- 1:21:47I didn't like it. I didn't like it.
- 1:21:49I don't really upset, yeah. Me either, I did see when I was
- 1:21:53looking for reviews I did see that a lot of people were saying
- 1:21:56the original 1 is way better. I'm willing to bet the original
- 1:21:591 is better and I'm willing to bet they added they.
- 1:22:03I'm hopeful that either they make the main girl more
- 1:22:08prevalent, have a bigger role 'cause I think they added more
- 1:22:11deaths. Yeah, that's my guess.
- 1:22:16I know American remakes like to add more deaths.
- 1:22:19It works well. It works well in one missed
- 1:22:23call. OK.
- 1:22:27God I love that movie. Hope it's still as good as I
- 1:22:29remember. We'll put it on the boat.
- 1:22:31When we talk about, we talk about next week, I'm gonna pitch
- 1:22:33it. I'm gonna explain why we should
- 1:22:34watch it and help people vote. OK.
- 1:22:37Well, with that it can be review time if you're.
- 1:22:39Ready I am ready. I'm right, I'm right Review.
- 1:22:41I'm right Review this. I'm gonna give it to me.
- 1:22:44I'm gonna give this movie 2 out of Nine lives.
- 1:22:48I wanna be a. Little you know what, Ben, I
- 1:22:51agree with you. I it's not, it's not the worst
- 1:22:53that we've ever seen in my life, right?
- 1:22:54Like and it did stick with me for a long time.
- 1:22:59Yeah. But it's still boring.
- 1:23:03It's boring and after having it built up it is a let down.
- 1:23:07So like for reference and I won't get into it too much
- 1:23:12because I want us to cover it at some point.
- 1:23:14The movie science traumatized the shit out of me when I was
- 1:23:16little and then finally in my mid 20s I watched it and while
- 1:23:22the part that traumatized me was it ended up being funny, the
- 1:23:25rest of the movie holds up. This is not that.
- 1:23:31This does not hold up at all, no, in my opinion.
- 1:23:36So I agree with that. What should our narrative?
- 1:23:41Oh, the review be. Review be.
- 1:23:43That's hard 'cause I 'cause I already did review it myself.
- 1:23:46Yeah. And I, well, I like my review
- 1:23:48says I thought they were all Bill Pullman.
- 1:23:55And I would love with you, you know, but I think it should say
- 1:23:58Mama, a grudge behind you. I like it.
- 1:24:04Mama, a grudge. Mama, there's a grudge behind
- 1:24:07you. Got it.
- 1:24:10That's a good one. I like it.
- 1:24:14And with that Ben, I have yet to create the little.
- 1:24:19You want the reverb, so let's see.
- 1:24:20What we have. Hold on.
- 1:24:24It's time for voices from the Boy I.
- 1:24:28Had a reverb on that I had a reverb.
- 1:24:31That one was topical. Now, Ben, I have to tell you,
- 1:24:36there were so many fucking weird reviews for.
- 1:24:39This. I've read none of them.
- 1:24:40I went into letterbox. I didn't even look at other
- 1:24:42reviews. Bro half of them were written
- 1:24:46like poetry. I swear to God there were like
- 1:24:49multiple haikus about this movie.
- 1:24:52I don't know why it took me so long so fine reviews to include
- 1:24:59no teen O'Shea to y'all, but you were being weird and dramatic as
- 1:25:02hell. It's so beautiful.
- 1:25:04It was weird but I finally found 2.
- 1:25:08So from single wait Famalian on letterbox who gave it a 2.5 we
- 1:25:17have? Did the real estate agent who
- 1:25:20showed the haunted house to Tom Cruise's cousin and his lesbian
- 1:25:23wife get grouched? Also the scariest thing about
- 1:25:27this is the man murdering his wife because domestic violence
- 1:25:29is literally the most frightening thing for real in my
- 1:25:34opinion. Yeah.
- 1:25:38Tom Cruise's cousin and his lesbian wife.
- 1:25:40Is that Tom Cruise's cousin though?
- 1:25:42I think it's a joke. It might because I mean it is
- 1:25:45his lesbian wife. Right what?
- 1:25:50But it's not excuse me, single white family and I'm so sorry.
- 1:25:56I paraphrase paraphrase. She actually said because
- 1:25:59domestic violence is literally the most frightening for real
- 1:26:02terrifying thing in the world in my opinion.
- 1:26:05We also have beg on letterbox who also gave it a 2.52 point 5
- 1:26:11was a very popular rating for this one.
- 1:26:13Is it his cousin? That is his actual cousin, yes.
- 1:26:17OK, cycle way from Alien. OK, research.
- 1:26:20They did the research. They did their research.
- 1:26:23Good beg on letterbox gave it 2.5 and they said so.
- 1:26:27This is what Daphne did during the split up from scooby-doo.
- 1:26:30This when? She learned those karate moves.
- 1:26:33Yes, that's what she did. So, Ben, it's time to discover.
- 1:26:41What we were. Talking about next week, so of
- 1:26:44course gotta give the reminder to the listeners every week you
- 1:26:47will see a poll probably Thursday or Friday on my
- 1:26:51personal Instagram and the podcast Instagram with three
- 1:26:55options to vote for what we will will cover next.
- 1:26:59Your options this week were Signs the movie that traumatized
- 1:27:03me, creep. I love creep.
- 1:27:06And Jeepers Creepers. What do you think?
- 1:27:13I think science warm. OK, so it was a landslide this
- 1:27:17time. For science, No, really.
- 1:27:22Oh wait, wait for creep or for? I think it's for creep.
- 1:27:29We're talking about Justin Long again.
- 1:27:30It's creepers. Creepers.
- 1:27:32That's crazy. The people want Justin.
- 1:27:37People long for and. His ozipic commercial.
- 1:27:39The yearn for Justin? That's crazy.
- 1:27:44I I to be honest, I couldn't decide if I wanted creeper
- 1:27:47signs. I wouldn't find Creep because I
- 1:27:50would love to talk about the Creep Tapes as well, which is
- 1:27:53the show which I love. OK, I haven't watched it.
- 1:27:56There's two scenes of it. Oh, I got Mars to watch creep
- 1:28:00and he was like oddly into it. I.
- 1:28:02Didn't. Know that you would mean no.
- 1:28:04He wasn't ready to do that right away, but I've been thinking
- 1:28:06about bringing it back on my station.
- 1:28:08I love creep. Yeah, we'll have to keep those
- 1:28:10back in the poll anyways. So Ben, so my, I was making
- 1:28:13clear my so my pick on the next poll is going to be for one
- 1:28:16missed call. I want to I want to pitch it.
- 1:28:18I want to explain why it's so good.
- 1:28:21The premise is basically you get a voicemail of your death and
- 1:28:28it's like, it's like, I think they do the math.
- 1:28:30It's like the voicemail comes in exactly like 3 days or two days
- 1:28:34or days, something like that. Somehow they can figure out when
- 1:28:37you're gonna die because of the voicemail, but you hear yourself
- 1:28:40die. And it's so good.
- 1:28:43The American remake as a third act that's not in the Japanese
- 1:28:47version, which really my thinking elevates the whole
- 1:28:50thing. It makes it a beautiful, tragic
- 1:28:52story instead of like, oh, it's so good, just scary.
- 1:28:55And I'm saying this. I haven't seen it since it came
- 1:28:57out in like 2010 or no, I mean, 2010.
- 1:29:00I watched it maybe in 2008. And I'm talking about it like I
- 1:29:04know it so well. We're on the 2000s kick right
- 1:29:08now. 2000s was a good time for horror.
- 1:29:11It was bad horror. It was a good time for horror.
- 1:29:13Uninvited. Also great one from the 2000s
- 1:29:16Emily Browning's in it. Oh my God.
- 1:29:19Also based on a Japanese movie, which name I'm blanking on.
- 1:29:25It's something about twins. So good.
- 1:29:29Best best. Never saw it coming.
- 1:29:30Love it. But yeah.
- 1:29:33So my P is 41. Missed call.
- 1:29:37You've given me an idea and we're speaking on the fly here,
- 1:29:40so I want to know what you think.
- 1:29:42I'm listening. Should we each week, instead of
- 1:29:45just like talking about the polls, should we pitch our next
- 1:29:47one? Well, I mean, I'm just going to,
- 1:29:49I'm going to pitch mine because mine never win.
- 1:29:52Well, do you want it to be like a thing now?
- 1:29:54Sure, because mine never. Win.
- 1:29:55OK, OK. It doesn't have to be ready for
- 1:29:59mine because I'm always last minute.
- 1:30:02Well, I I can come up with one last minute because I saw
- 1:30:05Undertone. So that is a podcast horror
- 1:30:09movie and it's not available right now.
- 1:30:12It's only in theaters. So I can't over explain the
- 1:30:15plot. And also there's it's all audio.
- 1:30:17There's not a lot of visual to over explain.
- 1:30:19So it wouldn't be terrible. Also, the movie is good.
- 1:30:23It's like if Blair Witch was good.
- 1:30:25You're gonna make me go to the theaters?
- 1:30:27Yeah, I went to the theaters system.
- 1:30:28You're gonna make me go to the theaters, though.
- 1:30:29No, you don't have to. You can just like show up if you
- 1:30:31want and I'll tell you about it. I guess that's true.
- 1:30:35Yeah, you don't have to watch it, but that's my pitch.
- 1:30:38It was super creepy. It's fun.
- 1:30:40It's a good one. I really, really liked it.
- 1:30:43Very fun, very new and well I guess not new and different
- 1:30:46because Hush is like the original sound based or I would
- 1:30:49say. I disagree with that, but OK.
- 1:30:53It's the one that I'm aware of. I disagree.
- 1:30:57I disagree with that as a sound based horror, but that's.
- 1:31:00Oh no, you're right, because it's the complete opposite.
- 1:31:03I'm dumb. The movie's called Hush.
- 1:31:07Why would it be? Scratch that, listeners.
- 1:31:10Anyways, Undertone. Creepy creepy, creepy, creepy,
- 1:31:14creepy. Blair Witch.
- 1:31:15Done well and good and right. OK, and with that, then, what
- 1:31:19should be our staple? What's a staple we haven't
- 1:31:26pitched yet? Oh, I mean, the staple's going
- 1:31:29to be, I think. I have no idea.
- 1:31:32That's why I said we kind of. We'll have it maybe more defined
- 1:31:35in the future, but right now they're my 2 picks.
- 1:31:38You have our 2 picks and then you'll see another one.
- 1:31:40And have a third pick, then maybe it would be better.
- 1:31:42Maybe you'll like it. Who's to say?
- 1:31:45All right, Ben. And with that, Mama.
- 1:31:55Mama. There's a grudge, there's
- 1:31:57there's a Jeeper creeper behind you and we're gonna talk about
- 1:31:59it next week. I can't.
- 1:31:59Wait. In the meantime, in between Time
- 1:32:03club, you can follow us and please do on Instagram, TikTok
- 1:32:09and Letterbox at 9 the number 9 LHC pop.
- 1:32:15You can also check us out on Facebook and YouTube at the
- 1:32:18number 9 Live's Horror Club. And if you want to keep the hot
- 1:32:22takes rolling, go ahead and join our subreddit at R/9, the number
- 1:32:279 Live's horror club. Our poll this week.
- 1:32:37Do you hate this movie? Yes or yes?
- 1:32:39Yes or yes? Should we watch the original?
- 1:32:45No, 'cause like I do want to watch the original now 'cause it
- 1:32:48has to be better. It has to.
- 1:32:52Do you want us to cover the original?
- 1:32:54And the post be Should there be American remakes of Japanese
- 1:32:58horror films? OK, I like that.
- 1:33:01I like that if you are listening because we have featured your
- 1:33:06review My Hair is Everywhere on a previous episode.
- 1:33:10Go ahead and drop some little ghost in the comments.
- 1:33:12Don't forget to comment Bingo somewhere.
- 1:33:15If you got it this week, you would be our first one.
- 1:33:19I don't. Think we've got?
- 1:33:21Have we done it? That's no way we've done bingo
- 1:33:23yet. Oh, I don't know, I didn't run
- 1:33:25the bingo card yet. Oh, I guess drag me to Hell
- 1:33:28could have a bingo card. Who's to say?
- 1:33:30Anyways, you will see us next week for Jeepers Creepers.
- 1:33:36I immediately forgot that was crazy.
- 1:33:38I'm excited. I'm so excited.
- 1:33:41We love Justin Long, unless he's in an Ozempic commercial.
- 1:33:44That was a little crazy. But Speaking of Justin Long in
- 1:33:48an Ozempic commercial, stay spooky and we will see you next
- 1:33:57time. Bye.