Latest / Calibrated Taste / Eric Toda: Marketing Sicko
Transcript
- Shay Fan: Who are you? Can you introduce Eric Toda: I need to do that. Shay Fan: can you introduce yourself? Eric Toda: I think it I think if you've clicked into this and are listening, you probably already know who I am I'm Eric Toda. I'm I'm currently a retired marketing executive and Yeah, I've worked at amazing brands like Nike, Facebook, Airbnb, Snapchat, Gap Inc. etc. etcetera, et cetera. Shay Fan: Okay. Well, I'm I hope you're enjoying your retirement. so you are a visionary marketer, creative, as my favorite description of you as a marketing sicko, right? Eric Toda: Yeah. Shay Fan: Through through and through a marketing sicko. So yes, yes. Okay. So I'm curious for you, as a marketing sicko, Eric Toda: Uh-huh. Shay Fan: you have a lot of people who are like, Come market for us, Eric Toda. Eric Toda: Sure. Yep. Shay Fan: What to you is good marketing? Eric Toda: Well, I think the first thing if if someone's asking me that, like Eric, we want you in in this organization, the first thing I always look to assess is do they have the stomach to do actually good breakthrough work? And breakthrough work requires a lot of risk appetite. Breakthrough work requires a lot of cultural intuition. It's not chasing culture. It's not doing the standard operating playbook of that sector that that business is in. I look For an organization that wants to hit above its weight per se. I want an organization that is creatively ambitious. You know, they want to compete in the market, not just against their sector, but against the industry as a whole. And if they're talking to me, that means they're relatively serious. But I need to know that they're serious, that if they bring me in, it's not just to again to to say that they got me and then handcuffed me, it is to say we got him. You're about to see some magic happen. Shay Fan: Okay, so the reason I'm even doing this is because for me I've been thinking a lot about taste, right? And as a marketer, you even talked about it, like culture, taste, everything. And you you talk about breakthrough. So what to you I mean, it's interesting because there's so many different industries. There's so many different ways to breakthrough, positive and negative, right? So I am kind of curious, what what to you, I mean, what is a good breakthrough? What is a bad breakthrough? You have had so many amazing companies, you have so much experience doing this. how did you even tune your taste? how do you even assess that, right? what's what's the Eric Toda: No. Yeah. Shay Fan: inputs that like make you go, Yes, that's Eric Toda: I will say it started at Nike and it was because of the talent that I was around. that I was really young in my career. I was an executive very early with all these other young marketers that ultimately, if you just Google their names, that I was around, they all became CMOs. They all became the stars of marketing for this generation. But we were all in the same room. And I realized, again, coming from Facebook, where I started my career to to Nike, Nike was a different beast because you weren't just trying to compete against the other categories. So my category was the MLB, NFL, NCAA, and men's training. Everybody else had basketball or running or, you know, global soccer, which are like hit categories. And and I and so I was a bit on the back foot. But what I realized is we weren't just competing against each other, which I think is extremely healthy. we were also competing to see who Was cooler than each other. And that was incredibly intimidating to me because I was not cool. I was coming from tech, you know, I had, you know, standard like button up and whatnot. Everybody else was like so vibey and listening to music that I wasn't listening to, you know, smoking pot all the time. And and like they were just like they were they were the key target markets for exactly who you're marketing to. And I Shay Fan: Hm. Eric Toda: and I I was like, how do I become cooler? And I knew it was necessary because if I needed to compete against that with my own marketing and my own taste and my own culture, I needed to assess what how cool they were, what they were wearing, what they were listening to, what they were doing, because I realized all that is feeding into their taste. All that is feeding into them seeing an idea and saying, well, that's not cool or that is, right? And nine times out of 10, especially at that time in Nike, this was 2013, everything was a hit. And so like literally everything, every category was a hit. and and so I always looked at them as a bellwether of cool, of taste. And whether Shay Fan: Yeah. Hmm. Eric Toda: that's the candles that they had in their office, whether that Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: was the foods that that they were trying at different restaurants, it's like nothing was basic. Everything was curated and everything was very bespoke to them. And I needed to figure out what is my own cool. what is my own taste and what drives me. And so that's really where I first really started to build upon what my taste and aesthetic looks like, what I like, that then influences again the ideas and creative that I come forth with, with my with the brands that I work with, or just again, like how I lead teams. Shay Fan: Okay, so you taught that's great because you I love that your your way of honing it is looking at other people and being like, You're cool. Okay. It is it is a human Eric Toda: Yeah, I mean that's I mean that that that's that's a very human thing. That's a very human thing. Shay Fan: thing, but here's my question then. Wha how would you describe your taste now? Like your yeah, Eric Toda: Yeah. Shay Fan: how would you describe like if you see like a pair of shoes, right? Or art or whatever, what what makes you go, pfft yeah, that? Eric Toda: I think to me it's it's one what matches my eye, right? Like I think ever Shay Fan: Hmm, okay. Eric Toda: everybody has this. Everybody like looks at something, they're like, I like that. I like that. I don't know if it's cool or not, but I like it. Shay Fan: Mm-hmm. Eric Toda: it matches with how I view myself, it matches with how I want to per how I want other people to perceive me. And and so that was the first step, is like, okay, what what do I like? Like what do Shay Fan: Mm-hmm. Eric Toda: I like specifically? Like what colors do I like? Like what shapes Shay Fan: Mm-hmm. Eric Toda: and like different aesthetics, what kind of art do I like? And and that's when I started really honing in on again, like, okay, now how do I bring that into my personality per se? And and then how do I let that drive again decision making, whether it's the clothes I wear, the music I listen to, et cetera. I I remember it being like a competition of cool. It's just like, well, who's cool? And the references that they were spouting off. It's like I didn't know. And so I had to catch up. I had to catch up. I had to be more online. You know, which is w which was tough because I've already felt like I was like at the pinnacle. But I I Shay Fan: Yeah. Eric Toda: was like I had to I had to know and I had chase and like they were working with people who I didn't even know yet and that I had to go find, right? So I think it is all of those bits and pieces of that experience that built the foundation of my taste and aesthetic, which to me simple. I think it's very simple. I think it's it's it's very inspirational. I think it's I think it's also approachable. I think that's one of Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: the big things that I really like in in my taste is that is Shay Fan: Yeah. Eric Toda: it is it approachable, is it simple, and it and again, is it elevated to an extent that again, like it's not cheap. Like you you Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: don't look at it and you're like, that's cheap, right? And so and Shay Fan: Mm-hmm. Eric Toda: so I think like all those things are like really just foundational elements of that that how I built on it throughout the course of my career, but it all started with like those things. Shay Fan: Okay. So you would say that your taste now is simple, approachable, yet there is sort of this elevated elegance to that. Eric Toda: Yeah, like I I think there's a good trend right now of like quiet luxury. Like Shay Fan: Mm-hmm. Eric Toda: it's not like in your face, like logos everywhere. Shay Fan: Yeah. Eric Toda: which w which I think is you know, could be perceived as tacky. I like I I like the the the quiet confidence of taste, right? Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: It's like you know what you're wearing, you wear it really well. It doesn't matter if it's ten bucks or a hundred bucks, but you wear it well and that that quiet confidence to me is quiet luxury. And so When I look at a piece of creative, when I look at, you know, what I want to put out into the world, does it reflect that quiet confidence and does it reflect again like the the approachability that it's not like a perfume commercial where you're just like, this is some esoteric stuff? Like I don't even know what I'm looking at. Like this is like, this is like it's not approachable. Shay Fan: Wait, wait, wait. I do have I do have a question. say you as a marketing sicko, right, have to market that perfume. And Eric Toda: Ça Shay Fan: it's well, how would you, how do you calibrate and change your taste to understand that it might not be yours, but for your audience, that's what they want. How do you how do you get in that mindset? Eric Toda: No, I well, I think that I think what you're talking about is pattern disruption. I think we're Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: so accustomed to the celebrity soft music, like very strange like, you know, environment that they're around. You don't even say this stuff until the end, but they're like walking around saying some poems or something, and then it's like Shay Fan: Ha ha. Eric Toda: it's like boom, you know, perfume, right? Like that that we're just we're just that Framework, that format has been beaten into our heads over the past like 50 years since like Madison Avenue started to where we expect it, right? What I Shay Fan: Mm-hmm. Eric Toda: would look to do is is pattern disruption. It's like, how do you market Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: a perfume or a scent that is more realistic, but also that puts it in a way that that's more approachable? It's like, you know, I I stayed in this hotel once where it had La Labo, which is fantastic and a great scent. But that marketing right there is just like the product placement is right there. It's like this it's the soaps inside my inside inside my hotel room. Fantastic, right? But like Shay Fan: Mm-hmm. Eric Toda: I would want to see something more realistic like that. Or like use Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: use it in situation, right? It's like I just got through the workout, don't have time for a shower, like I'm just gonna spray this all over me and I'll be okay. Right. That that's Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: realistic stuff, but that's that's also in situation, so it is approachable. Versus like I'm never gonna be Scarlett Johansson like walking on a beach saying like poems and then boom, like Dior like that's that's not me, right? That's not me, that's as that's probably not most people. Shay Fan: That's interesting though, because do you not feel like okay, so one, I love what you're saying about pattern disruption. But but a challenge to that tote too is do you feel like there is an audience that clearly this is resonating so that that's why they keep making it? Eric Toda: It's not though. Like the num the numbers speak for themselves. Like you you you could look at the recall numbers on all those campaigns. Like they're the Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: recall numbers are not great because they all look exactly the same. You know, Shay Fan: Okay. Eric Toda: they all look exactly the same. Like the recall numbers, you can just Google it. Like the recall numbers Shay Fan: Yeah. Eric Toda: are there. It's like but because they've been doing this for so long, do they know any different? No. Like do they know how to operate like on in in today's I mean first and foremost, if if they think that still works, they gotta realize that people are fast-forwarding through that stuff on TV. Shay Fan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Okay, well, Eric Toda: Right. Shay Fan: here's another question then for you. I love that you were talking about pattern disruption because it's true, right? I YouTube once there was this whole thing about how they, as a test, ran like a 30-second ad that was just white noise. And they were Eric Toda: Yeah, it's great. Shay Fan: like, my God, it got so much reach and engagement because people are like, What is this? Eric Toda: It's great. Yeah. Shay Fan: So here's a question. How do you tell the difference between something that's genuinely good or just bold? Eric Toda: It's generally good changes it one changes how I view the experience that I'm in. Right? Like I think that static commercial, which I think it was was brilliant, like that stops you. You're like, what what's happening? this is just like a break, right? This is just a break. Like this is interesting because they're saying different is good. That's cool. Bold is like They take it to another level where it's just like so like liquid death is a great example of this. I think the way that they do what they don't look at pattern disruption, they just look at bold. Like what's the boldest Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: idea that we could come, you know, that we could come forward with? You know, the last thing that they did that I saw was like they wanted you to ship your own pee to them so then they could give it to data centers, right? Bold, super bold, it's fun, it's Shay Fan: Yeah. Yeah. Bold, very bold, yeah. Eric Toda: funny, it's cutting edge. I think it's I think it's great. But is that actually changing your experience like as you watch it or is that just another ad? Like again, like I to me, as someone who's like very obsessed with marketing, to me that's another ad. Very well done, very interesting. I'm going to remember it, but is it going to change my expectations of all the other ads that I see between it and and before and after it? No, probably not. And Shay Fan: Mm-hmm. Eric Toda: and I think the best, the best pattern disruption makes you rethink. what you're seeing is actually real. Shay Fan: Okay, okay. So you like you s we talked about being the marketing sicko, you know, having now like tuned your taste with what's cool and curating and all of this. Has there been a time when you've been wrong? Like you're like, yes, this is sick, this is gonna be amazing, and then you're like, ooh, whoops. Eric Toda: I mean you I mean you I mean you worked for me. I was wrong ninety percent of the time. y yeah, I'm wrong. I'm wrong a lot. But I'm not afraid Shay Fan: You gotta tell the people. You gotta tell the people. Eric Toda: of that though. Like I'm not afraid of that I think one of the worst things any executive or leader does is like I have to be right all the time because that's the that's the expectation, right? Shay Fan: You know, but to interrupt though, and I don't mean it, sorry, you're a guest. I shouldn't be interrupting. Sorry. what does does any Eric Toda: Okay. This is how you know you worked for me. Shay Fan: this is this is how I know. With I'm curious though, like has anything stuck out in your mind? You're like, man, I really did think Eric Toda: Yeah. Shay Fan: this would hit, but it didn't. Like what what what do you take? Did that adjust the way that you approach your eye, your lens, your intuition? Eric Toda: Yeah, I mean there's been a ton. There there's been a ton. But Shay Fan: What's what's one? What's one that sticks out? Eric Toda: I mean well, I'll give you an example, right? when we created MetaProsper, this is like a again a recent example, like not that recent, it's like four years ago. when we created MetaProsper, I had this idea of like, okay, let's just say it's time to prosper across is across like a video, but you do it in multiple different languages, right? I was like, this is How can you not like this? This is great, right? What I didn't expect was that the people I I was using to say these things, like in their own language, with their own passion, maybe their accents were different. Maybe it wouldn't land right. Maybe someone would comment and be like, well, that's a different dialect or whatever. And that actually happened and it didn't hit really well. And I was like, crap, like that's something I didn't I didn't expect. Because I thought on a broad basis, like, this would be a hit because everybody is saying this one line in their own language for this organization that represents literally what they look like. but to me, I wouldn't say it was a failure, I'd think it was a misstep because we didn't calibrate. But at the same time, I think it was interesting because it got people talking. Shay Fan: How would you calibrate from that moment then? Like f from then on? Is there anything that you Eric Toda: Mm, no, I wouldn't really I wouldn't really It was it Shay Fan: You're like, that'll calibrate on perfect. Eric Toda: was perfect. It was no, I I I I I would say are we okay? Are we okay with if this going out, like people will cr the people will have criticism. People will criticize, right? Are we Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: okay with that? And if we're okay with that, fantastic, then let's go, right? But I think I think the worst case scenario is if no one cares, if no one says anything. I mean Shay Fan: Hm. Eric Toda: to me that's devastating stuff, right? Like if they love it, fantastic. Like that's kind of like a great a great expectation. If they hate it, okay, well hopefully it's for a good reason. but at least it gets them talking. It g it gets a reaction, right? Shay Fan: So you so you believe any any PR is good PR? Eric Toda: I believe it it gets you talking and and and Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: I believe if it gets if it gets a reaction one way or another, because you're not gonna hit a hundred percent every time. Like that's just impossible. But if you Shay Fan: Mm-hmm. Eric Toda: hit sixty forty, that's pretty damn good. I'll take that. I'll take that all day, Shay Fan: Hmm. Yeah. Eric Toda: especially on the internet. Shay Fan: Yeah. This is true. it's okay. So I have to ask, what have you hated before? And then later on you're like, you know what? Actually, okay, fine. It's not for me. It's not my taste, but I I see this as great marketing. Eric Toda: I mean every single car commercial is just I mean yeah the the auto the Shay Fan: Wait, really? Like you so you hate it, but then you're like, this is good marketing. Eric Toda: auto industry I think is plagued the by the sameness of the past like forty to fifty, sixty years. They've always done the exact same thing. I understand why they do it. I understand how they do it. It's now like part of it's on one of my favorite like Like memes is just like you know, when you like have a have a Dodge Ram truck and it's like a Friday night, a cold beer. That's what it feels like driving a ram. Right? It's like Shay Fan: Sold. Eric Toda: I get it. I get it, right? I I I get it in a time where again, like I I grew up like just seeing the same car commercial over and over again. I know all the taglines, you know, I know December to remember, I know, Toyotaon or whatever. and I understand why they do it. I think what I've come around to is all right, I expect it, but they do it now in moments that I feel like are expected but also targeted. Like they do it like I understand it now. I think that's the only r way I can say it is like I didn't like it before because I just think it's the same. But now I understand how they're doing it, I understand when they're doing it, I understand why they're doing it, Shay Fan: Mm-hmm. Eric Toda: and it certainly moves units for sure. that's always the outcome. But I to me, I just I just wish it was more creatively stimulating, you know. It's just no I mean it would be great if Sydney Sweeney's like had that deep voice and you know Shay Fan: Sydney Sweeney and a board wanna put it. Eric Toda: and and she was up in the mic saying like Friday night a Friday Shay Fan: Cold. Eric Toda: night with your boys after a game. That's what it feels like driving a F-150. Shay Fan: But Sydney Sweeney's saying that. You just you just disrupted it. Eric Toda: Yeah, but say but Sidney Sidney saying that. I think that's interesting. I think that's interesting. Shay Fan: last question, because I love talking about taste, intuition, all the things that we absorb that then helps us with our taste. What's the last thing that you read, watched, whatever that made you rethink and change your taste and how you approach marketing advertising? Something that made you rethink, something that made you go, dang, like this is gonna change how I'm gonna approach and view a good campaign, good marketing, good this. Eric Toda: You know, I look at a good marketing as good storytelling, generally, right? Like good storytelling, like it has to be very, very clean. and I so I I watch a lot of things that have just have incredible stories. Like incredible stories. Shay Fan: Okay, tell tell us your favorite. Tell us your favorite. The one last time that you were you felt something in your heart. Eric Toda: I w I mean a week ago I watched the entire almost an entire series of DuckTales. Shay Fan: Wait, the old one or the new one? The new one is so good. You should watch the new one. Eric Toda: The older one, like the one from the the one the one from the early the one from like the early nineties, like with the theme song. It's like it's amazing. But I I watch it for the stories because they're just like so good. Like it never should Shay Fan: Wait. Eric Toda: it never should have been that good, but it was. I will tell you every episode, and this is where I think marketing is going. Every episode is essentially a marketing vehicle for DuckTales and Disney. That's just true. DuckTales the brand and Disney. But every episode, I what I was thinking about is like Dude, if you can make this into series into a series, which they have, but if this was made today, you would drop this on like five different platforms, all connected to each other. And that would force you to watch all five episodes across different platforms because you just want to know how it ends. And Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: it would be the greatest marketing for Disney and the DuckTales brand and the merch that comes with it. This is why I believe every single great brand is now moving. To entertainment and serialized content that will eventually be sold to studios. Like, that Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: is just like they're creating IP. They're creating Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: defensible IP that is uniquely theirs. You know, I know a ton of brands that are doing it right now. Google's obviously taking a big foray into their like soap opera doctor thing with Google Pixel. And I think I think I I watched the trailer and it was I that was really hilarious. but everybody's gonna do it because it's IP because the reality is two things are at play. One, SNL numbers are down year over year Shay Fan: Mm. Eric Toda: because people could find funnier stuff online. True story. the other thing is that when you go on your TV right now because everyone's internet connected, there is no difference between YouTube and Apple TV. There was truly no difference. I think there's certain shows that are on both, but Because you're not seeing it, you're not seeing YouTube as like social media, you're seeing YouTube as entertainment. I think more and Shay Fan: Yeah. Eric Toda: more brands are gonna play there and create actual series themselves that will be sold for IP. Shay Fan: Hm. Eric Toda: And I think that's what DuckTales showed me was I was like, man, like we need more ideas like this because this is crazy stuff. This is like amazing storytelling, amazing like it's you're emotionally involved and you just don't see entertainment like that anymore. And like it's it's why I watch a lot of old shows. It's why I watched Shay Fan: Hm. Eric Toda: Twilight Zone. It's why I watched DuckTales. I I think I watched Tailspin in the Summer. You know, I Shay Fan: Tailsman, yeah. Eric Toda: watched I watched all of it because I think that storytelling of that era doesn't really exist anymore. But I want to bring it back for the sake of brands. I wanna do Shay Fan: Yeah. Eric Toda: that for a brand because I think that's I think it's cool. I think it's interesting, and I think it's I think it also plays on like the millennial nostalgia piece that we're seeing right now. Shay Fan: Mm-hmm. Eric Toda: Like people want people want that. And so that's I would say it's not a book, it's not like a more modern thing, but I I look at the past to help me define how I want to approach the future. Shay Fan: I l I love that. I love how typically it's like look at history and instead you're watching nineties television. Eric Toda: I mean that's the that's the era I grew up in. Shay Fan: Okay. Well, thank you for the chat. Thanks for Eric Toda: Thanks for having me. Yes. Shay Fan: thanks for sharing your thoughts, your taste, and basically how decision makers like you, you know, see what's good and bad. Eric Toda: No, I love it. Thanks for having me. Everybody, if you're listening to this, smash that follow button. Go follow Shay. and go engage and comment. Stay out of my DMs. Thank you.